Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5....

45
Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and other Colored Glasses Christoph U. Keller [email protected]

Transcript of Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5....

Page 1: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017

Lecture12:PinkandotherColoredGlasses

[email protected]

Page 2: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

Content1. Broadband Filters 2. Plastic Filters 3. Colored Glass Filters 4.  Interference Filters 5. UBVRI Photometry 6. Precision Photometry 7. Extreme Photometry

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 2

Page 3: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

Imaging•  2Dfield:starcluster,galaxy,protoplanetarydisk•  photometry•  astrometry•  filterstorestrictwavelengthrange

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 3

Page 4: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

BroadbandColorFilters•  DyedgelaKn(KodakWraNen)

–  advantages:thin,cheap,largesizes–  disadvantages:limitedopKcalquality,heat-sensiKve

•  Coloredglass(SchoN,Corning)–  advantages:stable,rugged,hightransmission–  disadvantages:limitedbandpasses,limitedsizes

•  Interferencefilters–  advantages:verynarrowfilters,almostarbitrarybandpassshapeandwavelength

–  disadvantages:expensive,verylimitedsizes,temperature-sensiKve,humidity-sensiKve,aging

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 4

Page 5: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

WraEenFilters

•  coloredplasKcsheets•  namedaUerFrederickWraNen,manufacturedbyKodakforabout100years

•  recently:WraNen2•  upto100mmby300mm•  canbeusedforexperiments•  improvedperformancewhenputbetweenglassplates

www.edmundopKcs.com/onlinecatalog/displayproduct.cfm?producKd=1326

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 5

Page 6: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

TypicalWraEenFilters

www.edmundopKcs.com/onlinecatalog/displayproduct.cfm?producKd=1326

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 6

Page 7: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

ColoredGlassFilters•  absorbspecificwavelengths•  madebyaddingsubstancestoglassduringglassmanufacturing

•  typicallyusefulfrom200-1200nm–  allglassesabsorbsignificantlybelow200nm

•  importantmanufacturers:–  SchoN–  Corning– Hoya

•  canalsobeusedfororderselecKoninspectroscopykeller@strw.leidenuniv.nl AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 7

Page 8: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

SchoEColoredGlass•  UG:Blackandblueglasses,UVtransmi_ng•  BG:Blue,blue-green,andmulK-bandglasses•  VG:Greenglass•  GG:Nearlycolorlesstoyellowglasses,IRtransmi_ng•  OG:Orangeglasses,IRtransmi_ng•  RG:Redandblackglasses,IRtransmi_ng•  NG:NeutraldensityglasseswithuniformaNenuaKoninthevisiblerange

•  N-WG:ColorlessglasseswithdifferentcutoffsintheUV,transmi_nginthevisiblerangeandtheIR

•  KG:VirtuallycolorlessglasseswithhightransmissioninthevisibleandeffecKveabsorpKonintheIR(heatprotecKonfilters)

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 8

Page 9: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

SchoEColoredGlass1

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 9

Page 10: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

SchoEColoredGlass2

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 10

Page 11: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

SchoEColoredGlass3

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 11

Page 12: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

SchoEColoredGlass4

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 12

Page 13: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

SchoEColoredGlass5

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 13

Page 14: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

UBVRI

•  UBVbyJohnsonandMorgan(1953)•  VRIJKLMNQ(infrared)byJohnson(1960)•  (combinaKonsof)glassfilters•  inventedtoclassifystarswithphotomulKpliers•  zeropointofB-VandU-BcolorindicesdefinedtobezeroforA0Vstars

www.sbig.com/products/filters.htm

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 14

Page 15: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

(Old)UBVRI

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 15

Page 16: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

LimitaTonsofUBVRIPhotometry•  limitedspectralresoluKon•  effecKvecentralwavelengthchangeswithcolorofstar•  star'smagnitudesandcolordependonthestar'scolor•  short-wavelengthsideofUfilterextendsbelowatmospherictransmissioncutoff

•  properKesofskydefinewidthofbandpass,notfilter•  nocleanseparaKonofinformaKonfromdifferentfilters•  differentdetectorshavedifferentsensiKviKes•  today:BesselorCron/CousinsUBVRIwithCCDs

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 16

Page 17: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

UBVRI

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 17

Page 18: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

OtherFilterSystems•  havelessoverlapand/orhighertransmission

•  Johnsonsystemforstars

•  Thuan-GunnfiltersforfaintgalaxyobservaKons

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 18

Page 19: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

OtherFilterSystems•  SloanDigitalSkySurvey(SDSS)forfaintgalaxyclassificaKon

•  StromgrenforbeNersensiKvitytostellarproperKes(metallicity,temperature,surfacegravity)

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 19

Page 20: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

Fabry-PerotEtalon•  2parallelplateswithadjustableplateseparaKon•  highlyreflecKvecoaKngsoninsidesurfaces•  periodictransmissionpeaksduetoconstrucKveinterferenceof

successivelyreflectedbeams•  transmissionpeaklocaKonchangeslinearlywithplate

separaKon

ChristophU.Keller,[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniquesCrashCourse2016Part3 20

Page 21: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

•  intensityreflecKvityr(transmissiont=1-r)•  transmissionasfuncKonofwavelengthk:m/2λ,m:orderofinterferometer,λ:wavelengthd:plateseparaKoni:angleofincidencen:indexofrefracKonofmaterialbetweenplates

•  ReflecKveFinessethehigherthebeNer

•  FreeSpectralRange:FSR=λ2/2nd•  SpectralResoluKon:R=λ/Δλ=λF/FSR=mF,R≈100-100’000

Fabry-PerotEtalon

( ) ( )1

22

2

0 cos2sin141

1

⎥⎦

⎤⎢⎣

⎡−

+⎟⎠⎞⎜

⎝⎛

−= idk

rr

rrII π

rrF

−=1π

ChristophU.Keller,[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniquesCrashCourse2016Part3 21

Page 22: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

ThinFilm

•  layerwiththickness≤λ•  extendsin2otherdim.>>λ•  materialwithdifferentindexofrefracKononthicksubstrate

•  maximumtransmissionwhenreflectedraysinterferedestrucKvely

•  maximumreflecKvitywhenreflectedraysinterfereconstrucKvely

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 22

Page 23: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

InterferenceFilters•  stackofthinfilms•  canbetailoredtoalmostanyspecificaKons

•  sensiKvetotemperature,humidity,angleofincidence

•  tuneinwavelengthwithtemperature,angleofincidence

•  spectralresoluKonR~3–1000

:

ns

n1, d1

n2, d2

nL, dL

n3, d3

nm

90º

!0

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 23

Page 24: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

Fabry-PerotTunableFilter•  mainingredientisFabry-PerotwithtunableplateseparaKon

•  stabilityofcavityspacingiscriKcal

•  oUencombinetwoormoretunableelements

•  alwaysneedinterferenceprefilter

www.arcetri.astro.it/science/solare/IBISphoto.jpeg

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 24

Page 25: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

Photometry•  goal:determinefluxofanastronomicalobjectinwell-definedwavelengthrange

•  problems:–  seeing–  exKncKon–  skybackground–  telescope,instrument,detector

•  calibraKonwith(standard)stars•  all-skyphotometry:compareobjectsalloverthesky•  differenKalphotometry:compareobjectsonsameCCDexposure

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 25

Page 26: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 26

SkyoverLaPalma

Page 27: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

Atmosphere•  photometricnight=uniform,stableskycondiKons

•  thincloudsandcirrusarehardtoseeatnight•  bright,greyanddarkobservingKme•  seeingdefinessizeofstellarimageforlargetelescopes

•  image=convoluKonofsourceandPoint-SpreadFuncKon(PSF)

•  [email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 27

Page 28: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

AirMass•  exKncKonduetoatmospherealongline-of-sight

•  airmass=amountofaironelooksthrough

•  atzenith(z=0):airmassX=1.0

•  atzenithdistancez,airmassX≈secz=1/cosz

•  X(z=60°)≈[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 28

Page 29: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

AirMass•  absorpKoncoefficientK=2.5log(f(z)/f(z=0)),wheref(z)ismeasuredfluxasfuncKonofzenithdistancez

•  KΔX=ΔmchangeinmagnitudeisabsorpKoncoefficientKmeschangeinairmass

•  measuremagnitudefordifferentairmassesandextrapolatetozeroairmass(noatmosphere!)

•  linearextrapolaKondoesnotworkintheinfraredduetosaturated/overlappingmolecularlines

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 29

Page 30: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

SimulatedNear-InfraredAbsorpTon

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 30

fromTokunagaetal.2002,adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2002PASP..114..180T

Page 31: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 31

DarkSkyinAlps

Page 32: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 32

BrightSkyintheNetherlands

Page 33: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

PhotometricObservaTons(1)•  observeobjectandstandardstarswithdifferentcolors

•  observestandardstarsatlowandhighairmasstodeterminetheir(color-dependent)exKncKoncoefficients

•  reduceimageswithbias,dark,flatfield•  measurefluxeswithaperturephotometry•  calculateinstrumentalmagnitudes:minst=-2.5log(fi/texp)

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 33

Page 34: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

PhotometricObservaTons(2)•  calibrateinstrumentalmagnitudeforzeroairmass:m0=minst-Ksecz

•  zeropointfromstandardstars:mzp=mstd-mstd,inst•  removezeropoint:m=mzp+minst•  absolutephotometry:determineactualmagnitudeswithcalibraKonsderivedfromstandardstars

•  differenKalphotometry:doesnotrequirecalibraKons

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 34

Page 35: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

SkyBackground•  useannulusaroundstar

•  usemedianinsteadofmeantoneglectcosmicrays

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 35

Page 36: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

AperturePhotometry

•  determinelocaKonofstarbyfi_ng2-DGaussianorMoffatPSFmodel

•  determineandremoveskybackground

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 36

Page 37: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

AperturePhotometry(conTnued)•  bestaperturesizedependsonbrightnessofstar•  trade-offbetweencapturingmorestarlightandaddingnoisefromskybackground,detectoretc.

•  plotresultasfuncKonofincreasingapertureandesKmateasymptoKcvalue

•  forvariabilitymeasurements(e.g.exoplanettransit)withdifferenKalphotometry(standardstarinsameimage):–  usefixedandidenKcalaperturesfortargetandreferencestar(s)

–  opKmumapertureminimizesscaNerinconstantpartsofmtarget-mstd

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 37

Page 38: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

ColorCorrecTon•  exKncKondependsstronglyonwavelength(color)

•  measuredfluxthroughbroadfilterdependsonstellarspectrum

•  addiKonalcorrecKon m=m0+Ksecz+k2CseczwhereCiscolorindex(e.g.C=B-V)

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 38

Page 39: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

ExtremePhotometry

keplerscience.arc.nasa.gov/PyKEprimerWalkthroughC.shtml90-daylong-cadenceKeplerSAPlightcurveofKIC3749404.keller@strw.leidenuniv.nl AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 39

Page 40: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

SubtleInstrumentalEffects•  ThermalchangesinopKcs,electronics•  Smallguidingerrorscoupledwithsub-pixelgainvariaKons

•  CotrendingBasisVectors(CBV):Instrumentalparametersthathavebeenshowntocorrelatewithphotometryofstandardstars

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 40

Page 41: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

16KeplerLightCurves

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 41

keplerscience.arc.nasa.gov/images/PyKE/PyKEprimerFig4.png

Page 42: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

CotrendingBasisVectors

[email protected] AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 42

keplerscience.arc.nasa.gov/images/PyKE/PyKEprimerFig3.png

Page 43: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

SubtracTonof2CBVs

keplerscience.arc.nasa.gov/PyKEprimerWalkthroughC.shtml90-daylong-cadenceKeplerSAPlightcurveofKIC3749404.keller@strw.leidenuniv.nl AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 43

Page 44: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

SubtracTonof8CBVs

keplerscience.arc.nasa.gov/PyKEprimerWalkthroughC.shtml90-daylong-cadenceKeplerSAPlightcurveofKIC3749404.keller@strw.leidenuniv.nl AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 44

Page 45: Astronomical Observing Techniques 2017 Lecture 12: Pink and …keller/Teaching/AOT... · 2017. 5. 9. · • no clean separaon of informaon from different filters • different

NoCBVFi]ngDuringEclipses

keplerscience.arc.nasa.gov/PyKEprimerWalkthroughC.shtml90-daylong-cadenceKeplerSAPlightcurveofKIC3749404.keller@strw.leidenuniv.nl AstronomicalObservingTechniques2017:Imaging 45