Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche...

35
Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth

Transcript of Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche...

Page 1: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR- Still room for ebM?

Thomas Neumuth

Page 2: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Innovation Center Computer Assisted Surgery (ICCAS)

• Affiliated to Medical School of Universität Leipzig • ~85 engineering and computer science researchers

Page 3: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Medicine Biomedical and informationtechnology

PersonalizedPredictivePreventiveParticatory

Hood and Friend 2011

4P m

edic

ine

Technology is integral part of medicine

Page 4: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Technology has a different evolution speed

• Information retrieval from distant monitors and devices• Vendor dependent device operation• Technical obstacles for advanced workflow management • Limited flexibility in the selection and combination of systems

4

[Quelle: Bulitta, 2006]

Page 5: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

5

acquire

analyze

act

Page 6: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

6

acquire

analyze

act

Page 7: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Robotic systems for surgery

• Master-slave systems

7

• (Semi-) autonomous systems

© Intuitive, Transenterix, Avatera, Stryker, Smith & Nephews

Page 8: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Current evidence for robotic systems

• Operation times• Operative costs

• Blood loss• Complication rates• Hospital stay length• Transfusion rate

8

FDA, Feb 28, 2019

Page 9: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Imaging and cooperative robots

9

© Siemens Artis Zeego

Page 10: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Imaging and cooperative robots

10

Bieck et al. 2017

Page 11: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

11

acquire

analyze

act

Page 12: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

FDA-approved AI-algorithms

12https://medicalfuturist.com/

Page 13: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Current research areas

• Anaesthesia management• Risk for postoperative pain, nausea, and respiratory depression• Predict hypotension, hypoxemia

• Surgery• Prediction of procedure times and anticipation of risk situations• Decrease human-technology interaction, Automatic documentation

• Administration• Decrease non-value-adding activities• Provide KPIs

13

Page 14: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Situation aware biomedical technologies

14Neumuth et al. 2009, Franke et al. 2015

Page 15: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Situation aware biomedical technologies

15Neumuth 2012

Page 16: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

SDC – Service oriented device connectivity

Navigation

© Aesculap

HIS, PACS

© Ch. Toulon

Dokumentation

© Oehm & Rehbein

3D-Rekonstruktion

© Medstation

© OrthoMit

US-Regis-trierung

Planung

© Aesculap © SurgiTAIX

Tools Displays MMI

© Philips© Maquet

OP-Tisch

© Trumpf

Tracking

© NDI

Roboter

© meditec HIA

SDCOne Language

ISO/IEEE 11073-10207IEEE 11073-20701

ISO/IEEE 11073-20702Medical device interoperability

Page 17: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

17

acquire

analyze

act

Page 18: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Hyperspectral Imaging

18

Page 19: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Hyperspectral imagung for tissue perfusion

19

Pathological bowel

Perfusion state ?

anastomosis

Perfusion state ?

a) Patient with postop. perfusion insufficiency

b) and c) Patients without postop. perfusion insufficiency

Jansen-Winkeln et al. Chirurg 2018

© Universitätsklinikum Leipzig AöR (2009): Thema, Autor

Page 20: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Total number of spectra: nthyroid = 3128, nparathyroid = 383

HSI-based discrimination of thyroid and parathyroid

Barberio et al. 2018

Page 21: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

But surgery is just one option …

21

acquire

analyze

act

Page 22: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Digital patient models for decision-making

22

ENT-Tumorboard at the University Hospital Leipzig, Germany Cypko et al. 2017

Page 23: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Prediction and clinical decision support

Page 24: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR- Still room for ebM?

Page 25: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

The digital footprint

25

acquire

analyze

act

Page 26: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

The digital footprint

26

acquire

analyze

act

Page 27: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Numeric vs. symbolic process models

27

SurgicalWorkflow

Numericalmodels

(digital footprint)

Symbolicmodels

Page 28: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Model generalization

T. Neumuth: Process modeling strategies

A B A C

A B C

A B C DD

START

END

A

B

C

Single cases Merged model

Page 29: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Model analysis: workflow assessment

29

END

paracentesisparacentesis knife

cornea

injecthealon

chamber ant

capsulorhexisrhexis cannulacapsula lentis

cutlancet clear cut

cornea

excision materialutrata‘s tweezers

capsula lentis

100% 93% 81%

92%

94%

10%

86%

START

Preparation Capsulorhexis Lens Removal LensImplantation

Removal of Healon Completion

(model filtered with threshold 5%)

Neumuth et al. 2011

Page 30: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Model analysis: workflow assessment

30

END

paracentesisparacentesis knife

cornea

injecthealon

chamber ant

capsulorhexisrhexis cannulacapsula lentis

cutlancet clear cut

cornea

excision materialutrata‘s tweezers

capsula lentis

injectvision blue

chamber ant

irrigatesauter cannulachamber ant

100%

100%

19%

93%

51%

81%

83%

5%

84%

99%

94%

12%

18%

34%

6%

92%

94%

10%

86%

START

Phase Capsulorhexis or Cataract interventions: Generic process models

for outpatient (n=51) and inpatient cases (n=54)

(model filtered with threshold 5%)

Preparation Capsulorhexis Lens Removal LensImplantation

Removal of Healon Completion

Neumuth et al. 2011

Page 31: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Model analysis: resource impact estimation

Nissen fundoplication, animal studylaparoscopic cases vs. telemanipulator-assisted cases (each n=12)

31Krauss et al. 2012

Page 32: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Model analysis: technology requirements

Opening ofthe skin

Preparation of muscle tissue

Bone removal Removal of intervertebral disc

Completion

Neumuth et al. 2009 32

n=14 Unit AVG Min Max SDEV

Time Frame hh:mm:ss 00:45:08 00:22:23 01:13:43 00:13:08

Iterations activity 15.2 7 27 6.3

Cumulated Duration hh:mm:ss 00:19:55 00:12:40 00:32:11 00:06:52

Page 33: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Objective: Development of an eco system for data acquisition and AI-based analysis for post market surveillance of medical devices

33

Page 34: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

Summary

• Robots have arrived in ORs• AI in the OR has not yet arrived

• Technologies have digital footprints that enable continuous ebMwithout cognitive biases

If you can't measure it, you can't improve it.(Peter F. Drucker)

34

Page 35: Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room ... 19_Neumuth_Künstliche Intellige… · Artificial intelligence and robots in the OR - Still room for ebM? Thomas Neumuth.

35

Prof. Dr. Thomas NeumuthInnovation Center Computer Assisted Surgery (ICCAS)[email protected], Twitter: @iccasLeipzig

CCL Advisory Board Meeting, Mar 12 2019

Thank you.