Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub...

29
Army cutworms (Euxoa auxiliaris ) consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Transcript of Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub...

Page 1: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Army cutworms (Euxoa auxiliaris) consume winter annual plants and

shrub foliage

Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science

February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Page 2: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Why do we care about army cutworms?

Page 3: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Why do we care about army cutworms?

Page 4: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Mike Zielenski

In June 2003, the BLM noticed missing cheatgrass near Winnemucca, NV

Page 5: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Cindy Salo

I saw missing cheatgrass when I visited; I asked at a ranch

Page 6: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Jim Christison

Rancher photographed army cutwormsfeeding near Winnemucca in January 2003

Page 7: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

F.B. Peairs

Euxoa auxiliarisLarvae up to 1.5 inches

Page 8: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

J.W. Hagadorn

Adults are miller moths 1.5-2.0 inch wingspan

Page 9: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Grizzly Bear Study Team

Grizzly bears eat miller moths in mountain talus slopes in summer

Page 10: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Bob Hammon

In 2003, army cutworms ate crops in western Colorado

Page 11: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Bob Hammon

Army cutworms ate rangeland plants, too

Page 12: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Why so many army cutworms in 2003?

Manymothslaid eggs

Year of dry weather created many egg-laying sites

Heavy rain Ag-Se germinated many winter annuals

Dry Oct.-Jan. letmany larvae survive

Page 13: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Chemtica

Cindy Salo

Ten years later, many moths trapped at Boise, ID in fall 2013

Page 14: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Sept. 2013 precip 7.4 x avg

Oct.–Jan. 2014 precip 0.6 avg

September precip 9.8 x avg

Oct.–Jan. 2014 precip 0.7 avg

Same pattern as 2003: Year of dry weather followed by rain, then more dry weather

Two weather stations in southwest Idaho

Page 15: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Area most affected by army cutworms in 2014

Page 16: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Four research sites within army cutworm outbreak

Page 17: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Same soil

Army cutworms

No army cutworms

Sugar Valley research site: Paired transects on affected/unaffected sites on same soil

Page 18: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Cindy SaloMarch 1, 2014

Army cutworms on cheatgrass die-off

Page 19: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

All, Cindy Salo

Army cutworms feeding on native shrubs

March 1 and 4, 2014

Page 20: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

All, Cindy SaloApril 19, 2014

Army cutworm damage to native shrubs

Page 21: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Cindy SaloApril 19, 2014

Rob McChesney

Cheatgrass regrew on some die-offs later the same spring

Army cutworms pupated in May

Page 22: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

All, Cindy SaloJune 2, 2014July 21, 2014

Chenopod shrubs produced new leaves later the same spring

Sagebrush flowered on branches with surviving leaves

Page 23: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

April 26, 2014July 21, 2014

Grand View research site:Chenopod shrubs recovered later the same spring Cheatgrass had not recovered two years later

Page 24: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

April 26, 2014 July 21, 2014

Grand View research site:Chenopod shrubs recovered later the same spring Cheatgrass had not recovered two years later

Page 25: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

February 15, 2015 Cindy SaloJune 19, 2015 Cindy Salo

Sugar Valley research site:Sagebrush and cheatgrass recovered by the following year

Page 26: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Earlier cheatgrass die-offs followed same pattern: Heavy late summer precipDry Oct.-Jan.

Page 27: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Earlier cheatgrass die-offs followed same pattern: Heavy late summer precipDry Oct.-Jan.

Page 28: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

El Nino winters tend to be dry in PNW, army cutworm outbreaks more likely

La Nina winters tend to be wet in PNW, better time to reseed cheatgrass die-offs

Page 29: Army cutworms (Euxoaauxiliaris consume winter annual ... · consume winter annual plants and shrub foliage Cindy Salo Sage Ecosystem Science February 2, 2017 Society for Range Mgt.

Army cutworms (Euxoa auxiliaris) consume winter annual plants and

shrub foliage

Cindy [email protected]