“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes paper - example 3.pdf · “Aquashield”...
Transcript of “Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes paper - example 3.pdf · “Aquashield”...
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
1 | P a g e
IGEM Young Persons Paper Competition 2017
“Aquashield”
to Mitigate Water Ingress
of Gas Pipes
Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
Assistant Engineer
Technical Development Section, Distribution Operation Department
The Hong Kong and China Gas Company Limited
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
2 | P a g e
Abstract
Water ingress in gas pipe can cause interruption of gas supply to a considerable amount
of customers. Due to congested underground condition, extraction of water from gas pipe
could be very difficult and sluggish. For conventional practice, water ingress incident is
not notified until customer reports gas supply interruption to the utility. There is a lapse
of time between start of water ingress and first report of supply interruption and
subsequent isolation by operatives. The longer the lapse time, the greater the extent of gas
network is affected by water ingress. It is time consuming to locate the water ingress
point and hence difficult to confine the affected area to minimal. In such situation it is
crucial to compete with time to avoid water spread out in the gas network and to save the
resources for subsequent de-watering and gas resumption.
To address the above concern, an automatic shut off device “Aquashield” is designed to
safeguard the gas network by confining the water ingress, if happened, automatically.
This paper introduces the design features, working principle, functional verifications and
the application in Hong Kong of Aquashield which ensures a more reliable gas supply to
the society.
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
3 | P a g e
1. Introduction
1.1 Causes of Water Ingress in Hong Kong
Hong Kong is a busy and densely populated city. Apart from the road surface where
buildings and traffic are congested, the underground is also suffocated with utility
pipework.
Due to the congested condition in underground, every utility will try their best to squeeze
out any possible space available to accommodate their pipes. Gas mains and water mains
are always neighbor to each other as their buried depths are similar.
To avoid water ingression to gas mains, there is a requirement of at least 300mm
clearance between the two types of pipe, but in reality, sometimes the pipes have less
clearance due to space limitation. The close proximity of pipes and vigorous excavation
activities becomes one of the main reasons why gas pipe may suffer from water ingress
due to leaking water pipe.
When there is water pipe burst near gas main, the high pressure from water jet (usually 6-
8bars) together with sand and rock create grinding effect which will damage the nearby
gas pipe over time. The water jet will then entered the eroded gas pipe and cause gas
supply interruption to considerable amount of customers.
Fig. 1 Small clearance of water pipe and other utilities
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
4 | P a g e
1.2 Current Challenges of Handling Water Ingress of Gas Pipe in Hong Kong
1.2.1 Time Lapse Between Gas Interruption Report Time and Actual Water Ingress
Actual time of water ingress is usually unpredictable. Water ingress usually is
noticed until customer reported gas interruption and it shows that water ingress to
gas pipe already affect certain amount of customers before any action taken. The
longer the lapse time, the greater the extent of gas network is affected by water
ingress. Minimizing the lapse time between the actual water ingress and the
incident report time on gas interruption is very crucial to contain the incident, as
well as arrange resources for de-watering and gas resumption.
1.2.2 Action to Contain the Affected Area
Due to the quick spread out of water ingress to gas network, for current practice,
huge amount of work force and time are required to locate the exact water ingress
point. Immediately upon arrival on site, the emergency team has to determine the
extent of the affected area by checking the syhons, saddles, risers and governor
along the affected area. The team will check site environment as well as the time
and location of customer report as hints. Once the situation is uncontrollable, gas
valves and risers will be closed to confine the affected area which may cause gas
interruption to customer.
1.3.3 Locating Water Ingress Point and Follow-up Actions
Gas Pipe
Water Pipe
Fig. 2 Photo of gas pipe damaged by water jet from adjacent leaking water
pipes
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
5 | P a g e
The possible location of water ingress has to be identified through checking the
nearby governors and syphons, if any. Besides, the ground conditions and speed
of ingress water may provide hints for identifying the water ingress nature and
location. It usually takes time to identify the exact location of water ingress if the
water leak is too small to be detected. Once identify the ingress point, dewatering
and repairing of gas pipe and subsequence gas resumption also require huge
amount of resources and time which depends on the pipe material and area
affected.
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
6 | P a g e
2.Aquashield
1st Generation (Metal Iron Body)
2nd
Generation (PE Body)
Counter Rods
Guide Rod (Stainless Steel)
PE Cross Fitting
Metal Seat (Magnetized Steel)
Cantilever
Fig. 3 Internal Structure of Aquashield
Shut-off Plate
Buoy
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
7 | P a g e
To mitigate the effect of water ingress to gas pipe and solve the above challenges,
Aquashield is designed as an automatic shut-off device which blocks water ingress in gas
pipe at the very first place, far earlier than customer report.
The main purpose of Aquashield is to block the flow of the water in pipe wherever the
water flows from automatically. It can effectively confine the affected area by water
ingression before anyone noticed so the interruption brought to customer can be
minimized. Moreover, since affected gas network is reduced, the workforce and time for
following actions like de-watering and gas resumption can be further reduced.
There are two types of Aquashield, the metal one as an earlier version while the PE one is
the latest design with a few improvement features.
Simpe is the best! The design of Aquashield consists of all mechanical parts housing in a
PE cross fitting, which include the counter rods, shut-off plate, cantilever, metal seat, PE
adaptor, guide rod and buoy. It creates a self-triggerred water blocking mechanism by
buoyancy principle, lever system and magnatic force.
2.1 Working Principle of Aquashield
2.1.1 Aquashield is designed to be installed in low pressure distribution network.
Its PE spigot ends making it able to be fused on the PE pipe directly. At
normal circumstance, Aquashield is fully opened to allow gas flow.
2.1.2 Assuming water ingress from either side of the gas pipe and the water
enters the Aquashield, the water blocking mechanism will be triggered
automatically by the buoyancy force of ingress water exerting to the buoy.
Fig. 4 Aquashield Mechanism
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
8 | P a g e
2.1.3 As water level in Aquashield increases, the buoy keeps rising. The guide
rods ensure the buoy moving in a vertical upward displacement.
2.1.4 Once the buoy rises up to certain position, the systems hit on the counter
rods and push the shut-off plates laterally to the metal seats in parallel.
2.1.5 When the shut-off plates are closed to the metal seats, the permanent
magnets embedded in the plates will be attracted to the metal seats made of
magnetized steel which closes the Aquashield and water flow into the
downstream.
2.1.6 Before reset the Aquashield back to the open position, a suction tube is
inserted into the Aquashield to extract water from the Aquashield cavity.
Then a rod is inserted to push the buoy down to the original position. The
Fig.5 Aquashield Shut-Off Mechanism
Fig. 6 Aquashield Re-opened
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
9 | P a g e
shut-off plates will be separated from the metal seats and open the pathway
for gas resumption.
2.2 Design Considerations
2.2.1 Material Selection
The self-triggered shut off device is initiated by the buoyancy force exert on the buoy
once water accumulate in the Aquashield cavity.
Therefore, the components that lifted up by buoyancy force were made of light-weight
materials. The floating element itself was good in buoyancy properties, which is made of
expanded Polystyrene foam. Apart from the metal seats made of steel due to its
magnetized properties, other components are made of light weight plastic materials like
POM, PC, as well as Aluminium.
Besides, the materials are rigid to be able to withstand water and gas pressure, as well as
good in corrosion prevention.
2.2.2 2-way Blockage of Water
Direction and location of water ingress are unpredictable, hence the Aquashield is
designed to block the water flow no matter which direction it comes from. The two shut-
off plates in symmetrical design allow the tight shut –off against water ingress from both
directions.
2.2.3 Easy to Install and Operate
Aquashield can be installed in existing gas network. It should be able to be installed
easily without the modification need of existing gas supply. The operation of Aquashield
should be simple and reliable. Its internal parts are maintenance free and easy to be reset.
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
10 | P a g e
2.3 Special Features of Aquashield
2.3.1 PE Cross Fitting embedded with Metal Seats
In order to avoid special made fitting and reduce on-site fabrication, a PE cross fitting
which is prefabricated with mechanical parts in factory for ready connection to existing
PE network simply by electrofusion.
A pair of metal seats made of magnetized steel is embedded in the PE cross by
interference fit which acts as a valve seat to the shut-off plate. Once the magnets in the
plate brought to the metal plates, a strong magnetic force attract both together to block
the water flow from either direction.
2.3.2 Shut-off Plates
The plates are made of polycarbonate embedded with 20 permanent magnets evenly
distributed at the outer ring of the plate to create a magnetic force to the metal seats.
Fig. 7 Aquashield PE Cross Fitting with a pair of metal seats
Fig. 8 Shut –off Plate Assembly
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
11 | P a g e
Polycarbonate is chosen as the material because of its high Impact Strength. By stress
analysis simulation with gas and water pressures exert to the plate, the results show that
the plate is able to withstand the forces without failure and deformation.
The permanent magnet is made of Neodymium N35. The adhesive force of each magnet
is about 4.6N and the total magnetic force of the plate is around 92N.
2.3.3 Cantilever System and Counter Rods
The back of Shut-off plate is attached to a cantilever system which ensures the plates
move in vertical direction. The cantilever is made of Polyoxymethylene (POM) with light
weight, high stiffness, low friction, and excellent dimensional stability.
The counter rod hits on the cantilever and pushes the plate outward. No matter water
ingress from either side of Aquashield, the plate can effectively block the water ingress to
the downstream of gas network.
Counter Rods
Fig. 9 Stress Analysis of Shut-off Plate
Fig. 10 Cantilever and Counter rods
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
12 | P a g e
2.3.4 Buoy and Guide Rods
The buoy is made of Expanded Polystyrene (EPS) which has strong
floating property due to its low density and weight; the buoyancy
force is able to lift up the moving mechanical components of
Aquashield.
The buoy is used to lift up and trigger Aquashield once there is water
accumulates in the Aquashield. To ensure it floats up in a vertical
direction, a pair of guiding rods is used as the guide.
Fig.11 Buoy and Guide Rod
Buoy
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
13 | P a g e
3.Functional Test
Aquashield is fabricated and pre-assembled in factory, the mechanism is proofed by in-
house test which simulating water ingress from either side of the network. The test result
shows that Aquashield can be triggered immediately when water accumulates and
successfully blocks the pathway of water into gas network.
Water Ingress in one
side of Aquashield
The buoy rises
gradually and brings
the shut-off plates to
the metal seats
The shut-off plates
block the water
flowing to the other
side effectively
Fig. 12 Aquashield Fabrication
Fig. 13 Aquashield In-house Testing
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
14 | P a g e
4.Conclusion
Maintaining a reliable gas supply to customers is always our mission. We try all
possibilities to reduce any chance of gas interruption.
The design of Aquashield is an innovative product that can immediate react to water
ingress in the first place, hence reduce the impact of gas interruption by blocking
ingress water spread out to the gas network and quickly confining the incident area to
minimal. Its simple mechanism ensures the reliability throughout its design life.
At the moment the new generation Aquashield is undergoing type tests to ensure a 50
years design life. It will be available to the industry soon this year.
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
15 | P a g e
Appendix
Testing Requirements of Aquashield
To ensure the quality of Aquashield, it is tested to conform to EN1555 Part3, as well as
the following additional tests would be conducted:
• External Leak Tightness
• Operability
• Shut-off Strength
Calculations
Force of Gas Pressure exerted on the Shut-off plate:
Area of Shut-off Plate x Gas Pressure = 84.8N
Total Magnetic Force of Shut-off Plate:
Magnetic Force x No. of Magnet = 92.6N
Safety Factor = Force of Gas Pressure/ Total Magnetic Force = 1.1
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
16 | P a g e
Lever Force
Required Lever Force for Both Sides (F) = M (L1/L2) (g) (2)
= 8.77N
Aquashield Moving Mass = 1.45kg
Gravity Force = 14.20N
Total Lift-up Force = 22.98N
“Aquashield” to Mitigate Water Ingress of Gas Pipes Chiu Wai Ting, Rita
17 | P a g e
Buoyancy Force
Buoy Volume = 3873249.1 mm3
Buoyancy Force (FB) = 38N
Net Buoyancy Force = 15.02N
Safety Factor = 1.65
Volume % = Cavity Volume/ Bouy Volume
= 2.91%
Push Force when Full Water = 15.02N
Push Force = (L2/ L3) (Net Buoyancy Force/ 2)
= 4.04N
-END-