ORIDA SUPREME COURT

BOBBY A LaTULIP Appellant

vs Case No SC13-1866

STATE OF FLORIDA Appellee

APPELLANTS JURISDICTIONAL BRIEF

on review from the district court of appeal Fifth District

State of FLORIDA

TABLE OF COMTEt4T S

P$e Ntildeo^

TA6LE oE cJegts t

TAE LE_ OF alT A31c t45 t i

ST A-tEmran of cASE foslashb EAcatildes 1 -Q

TuP45~0cmorfrac14L STA1F_tAEtAz 3

QUEST1otugraveS PRESEr4xE-6 Ouml~Ntilde

ARGAMErax VoA QuEsto A oAE A -b

ARGutAs FaA QuEsxxord wo (o-B

APGQMEraquocurren EoR QuasxroA frac12REAElig S-lO

CoAc_LAsto A to

C-E_A~EFlc A3F_ OE SEAcircfrac14Tc

Awso

(G

TABLE OV CHAmon$

Coe Cited P e

AMusoufrac14Soslashslaquo 70 A b1(Eh-bxbcA 20ot) 9

basfrac14s 4middotpara15 A (Gkfrac14ktcAxo$ 6

scesSwxesen etc(Ebsk ecAmA 1 (frac14xw 4-frac12ve 33 SoA 1As (Ehfrac14bCA frac14ol 6

(WC$ frac12xe th 4degtCRa3A txAMR) T

blaquoees oslashvxte19Asa(acs anecALcuo3 5

G5agravetSwestsSoAn(Rastkbc

Fowe t 52z74 Co3A l(Ebhx tcA Jeu)

cord 4Swe (co bu t3amplEfrac14sthbcA3e 6

kowis 4STlaquoR 6 53A 34 (Efrac14 AograveCA iW McLees v swe amppara5o agraveq-to541(FwtsvbcA a

ffrac14 4SgtxosxqYI Sa A94 (Ra-KD 9

ox 4Sxwxg i SsM LOEacuteRAsu DCA D-oO odelo frac14Sve43Ecirc G lfbdot

uad (Sate7 M GTI(RaaA bcA Ms) 1 e$ 4Caacutevxe 13 Ra_Aeefrac14 624(fllaquoAth Bc e C oss 9 Swxe 26As5CEfrac14 bcA acne)

Ptgtac_K4 Stoxe45 Sou Asgt CEfrac14M DC A 2GiA) 6 o

Sefrac14frac14 frac145xcqparaT153A)lF(asA bcA peo

m (SaxeqmoA7sg(Eg7cmN amp

5xepheAsoA frac14frac12te14d1o(Ra3cc

5xoyenlts Gwxe 101 Sod sto (Ras DcA 3et Co eaxaacute SSrcne1s kAca (Ra sh

olaquo Awwti1(es cugravee RaACvaacutef 3350

Ra-LCrugrave ampSDCAN A O EkA AampE (4(bY2)(b) S O

Eh P Aoslash P 9o523oCQG4 3 Aex3(63356 c x_(moN

(J Ocirc

STATEMENT OF CASE AND FACTS

After the circuit judge Merritt Sr denied all seven 3850 grounds (without

a hearing) attaching four pages of the record for grounds 5 and 7 Appellant

appealed to the Fifth District on August 28 2012

On May 16 2013 Mr LaTulip mailedfiled his 3850 initial brief raising all

seven grounds that was denied on July 19 2013 with a written opinion (no

attachments or hearing)

A timely rehearing was taken denied on August 20 2013 The mandate

soon followed September 4th

Then a timely Notice to Invoke Discretionary Jurisdiction was filed by the

clerk of the lower tribunal on September 18 2013 after LaTulip timely mailed it

Now with the clock ticking and having never prepared one of these briefs

the Appellant requested an Enlargement of Time mailedfiled here on September

27th

Then the Supreme Court finally responded with an Acknowledgement of

New Case dated October 8th reCeived October 14 with a Case No SCl3shy

1866 but no response on the Enlargement of Time pleading

On October 22 2013 Mr LaTulip mailed off a Notice of Inquiry about

his brief that is due soon Asking the Clerks Office of the Supreme Court to

advice him the date on which to mail said brief

1

CO CO_ a$ Setlr5 0

cnh s dom xo rAe o +e pe o o E e

e s taxergke Ge1 camek te no1cw amp o

Dee eAec xa10 e nes one(

SuMMAtw of AAGAWA

e + bsmc colaquocxs 343s nyes efrac12aA xkx is

hd aampM((A9coAcs atm e4ecy ksntagravex ccutxa4 maA

a amp slaquopem colaquoet cces os(2timestlaquow pxaacutes cfrac14e reclaquoch

ekse ceQ elaquocg laquoA eraquoet i a uso muca)~frac14s

etaugraveeeeAx tanuaAt xo ck nasLAumla c claquose lawJs xwsiacutes

t hisx Qlaquoesua preseaeck heteaa

e sus opara5e secowh Qlaquoesuoa agrave howe Fi Disit

ouen TA o wa ecAhcxs oAringxfrac14 wt ksita cou(xescep

Eoutu Deacuterict tow(xoinhe salaquoe ax 04 laquoaxha1 regaices 5e

rid cout vwusx axwch ugraveose specAtildeagrave microxiooslashs oNtilde ue recxamp ucircax

comlaquosa3 1ampte elaquock uso dlaquougrave(laquoog w3e coutugrave suportshy

a acmea claquonealaquoe ampc each cfrac14 a4 ugravedCeexaacuteess

e sumxty lt4+e ugraveamp Qwesxas is taxeJ4$ oiquestatildes

eoaCVcts 45 oumlgxaxepCramicrok NySwxegdcembrx

Ates wewecugraves ad frac12xtlaquocheese cefrac12ltweax frac14 each

5sso egravelaquoeacute o( agraveeparaetxweness

TABLE OF COMTEt4T S

P$e Ntildeo^

TA6LE oE cJegts t

TAE LE_ OF alT A31c t45 t i

ST A-tEmran of cASE foslashb EAcatildes 1 -Q

TuP45~0cmorfrac14L STA1F_tAEtAz 3

QUEST1otugraveS PRESEr4xE-6 Ouml~Ntilde

ARGAMErax VoA QuEsto A oAE A -b

ARGutAs FaA QuEsxxord wo (o-B

APGQMEraquocurren EoR QuasxroA frac12REAElig S-lO

CoAc_LAsto A to

C-E_A~EFlc A3F_ OE SEAcircfrac14Tc

Awso

(G

TABLE OV CHAmon$

Coe Cited P e

AMusoufrac14Soslashslaquo 70 A b1(Eh-bxbcA 20ot) 9

basfrac14s 4middotpara15 A (Gkfrac14ktcAxo$ 6

scesSwxesen etc(Ebsk ecAmA 1 (frac14xw 4-frac12ve 33 SoA 1As (Ehfrac14bCA frac14ol 6

(WC$ frac12xe th 4degtCRa3A txAMR) T

blaquoees oslashvxte19Asa(acs anecALcuo3 5

G5agravetSwestsSoAn(Rastkbc

Fowe t 52z74 Co3A l(Ebhx tcA Jeu)

cord 4Swe (co bu t3amplEfrac14sthbcA3e 6

kowis 4STlaquoR 6 53A 34 (Efrac14 AograveCA iW McLees v swe amppara5o agraveq-to541(FwtsvbcA a

ffrac14 4SgtxosxqYI Sa A94 (Ra-KD 9

ox 4Sxwxg i SsM LOEacuteRAsu DCA D-oO odelo frac14Sve43Ecirc G lfbdot

uad (Sate7 M GTI(RaaA bcA Ms) 1 e$ 4Caacutevxe 13 Ra_Aeefrac14 624(fllaquoAth Bc e C oss 9 Swxe 26As5CEfrac14 bcA acne)

Ptgtac_K4 Stoxe45 Sou Asgt CEfrac14M DC A 2GiA) 6 o

Sefrac14frac14 frac145xcqparaT153A)lF(asA bcA peo

m (SaxeqmoA7sg(Eg7cmN amp

5xepheAsoA frac14frac12te14d1o(Ra3cc

5xoyenlts Gwxe 101 Sod sto (Ras DcA 3et Co eaxaacute SSrcne1s kAca (Ra sh

olaquo Awwti1(es cugravee RaACvaacutef 3350

Ra-LCrugrave ampSDCAN A O EkA AampE (4(bY2)(b) S O

Eh P Aoslash P 9o523oCQG4 3 Aex3(63356 c x_(moN

(J Ocirc

STATEMENT OF CASE AND FACTS

After the circuit judge Merritt Sr denied all seven 3850 grounds (without

a hearing) attaching four pages of the record for grounds 5 and 7 Appellant

appealed to the Fifth District on August 28 2012

On May 16 2013 Mr LaTulip mailedfiled his 3850 initial brief raising all

seven grounds that was denied on July 19 2013 with a written opinion (no

attachments or hearing)

A timely rehearing was taken denied on August 20 2013 The mandate

soon followed September 4th

Then a timely Notice to Invoke Discretionary Jurisdiction was filed by the

clerk of the lower tribunal on September 18 2013 after LaTulip timely mailed it

Now with the clock ticking and having never prepared one of these briefs

the Appellant requested an Enlargement of Time mailedfiled here on September

27th

Then the Supreme Court finally responded with an Acknowledgement of

New Case dated October 8th reCeived October 14 with a Case No SCl3shy

1866 but no response on the Enlargement of Time pleading

On October 22 2013 Mr LaTulip mailed off a Notice of Inquiry about

his brief that is due soon Asking the Clerks Office of the Supreme Court to

advice him the date on which to mail said brief

1

CO CO_ a$ Setlr5 0

cnh s dom xo rAe o +e pe o o E e

e s taxergke Ge1 camek te no1cw amp o

Dee eAec xa10 e nes one(

SuMMAtw of AAGAWA

e + bsmc colaquocxs 343s nyes efrac12aA xkx is

hd aampM((A9coAcs atm e4ecy ksntagravex ccutxa4 maA

a amp slaquopem colaquoet cces os(2timestlaquow pxaacutes cfrac14e reclaquoch

ekse ceQ elaquocg laquoA eraquoet i a uso muca)~frac14s

etaugraveeeeAx tanuaAt xo ck nasLAumla c claquose lawJs xwsiacutes

t hisx Qlaquoesua preseaeck heteaa

e sus opara5e secowh Qlaquoesuoa agrave howe Fi Disit

ouen TA o wa ecAhcxs oAringxfrac14 wt ksita cou(xescep

Eoutu Deacuterict tow(xoinhe salaquoe ax 04 laquoaxha1 regaices 5e

rid cout vwusx axwch ugraveose specAtildeagrave microxiooslashs oNtilde ue recxamp ucircax

comlaquosa3 1ampte elaquock uso dlaquougrave(laquoog w3e coutugrave suportshy

a acmea claquonealaquoe ampc each cfrac14 a4 ugravedCeexaacuteess

e sumxty lt4+e ugraveamp Qwesxas is taxeJ4$ oiquestatildes

eoaCVcts 45 oumlgxaxepCramicrok NySwxegdcembrx

Ates wewecugraves ad frac12xtlaquocheese cefrac12ltweax frac14 each

5sso egravelaquoeacute o( agraveeparaetxweness

TABLE OV CHAmon$

Coe Cited P e

AMusoufrac14Soslashslaquo 70 A b1(Eh-bxbcA 20ot) 9

basfrac14s 4middotpara15 A (Gkfrac14ktcAxo$ 6

scesSwxesen etc(Ebsk ecAmA 1 (frac14xw 4-frac12ve 33 SoA 1As (Ehfrac14bCA frac14ol 6

(WC$ frac12xe th 4degtCRa3A txAMR) T

blaquoees oslashvxte19Asa(acs anecALcuo3 5

G5agravetSwestsSoAn(Rastkbc

Fowe t 52z74 Co3A l(Ebhx tcA Jeu)

cord 4Swe (co bu t3amplEfrac14sthbcA3e 6

kowis 4STlaquoR 6 53A 34 (Efrac14 AograveCA iW McLees v swe amppara5o agraveq-to541(FwtsvbcA a

ffrac14 4SgtxosxqYI Sa A94 (Ra-KD 9

ox 4Sxwxg i SsM LOEacuteRAsu DCA D-oO odelo frac14Sve43Ecirc G lfbdot

uad (Sate7 M GTI(RaaA bcA Ms) 1 e$ 4Caacutevxe 13 Ra_Aeefrac14 624(fllaquoAth Bc e C oss 9 Swxe 26As5CEfrac14 bcA acne)

Ptgtac_K4 Stoxe45 Sou Asgt CEfrac14M DC A 2GiA) 6 o

Sefrac14frac14 frac145xcqparaT153A)lF(asA bcA peo

m (SaxeqmoA7sg(Eg7cmN amp

5xepheAsoA frac14frac12te14d1o(Ra3cc

5xoyenlts Gwxe 101 Sod sto (Ras DcA 3et Co eaxaacute SSrcne1s kAca (Ra sh

olaquo Awwti1(es cugravee RaACvaacutef 3350

Ra-LCrugrave ampSDCAN A O EkA AampE (4(bY2)(b) S O

Eh P Aoslash P 9o523oCQG4 3 Aex3(63356 c x_(moN

(J Ocirc

STATEMENT OF CASE AND FACTS

After the circuit judge Merritt Sr denied all seven 3850 grounds (without

a hearing) attaching four pages of the record for grounds 5 and 7 Appellant

appealed to the Fifth District on August 28 2012

On May 16 2013 Mr LaTulip mailedfiled his 3850 initial brief raising all

seven grounds that was denied on July 19 2013 with a written opinion (no

attachments or hearing)

A timely rehearing was taken denied on August 20 2013 The mandate

soon followed September 4th

Then a timely Notice to Invoke Discretionary Jurisdiction was filed by the

clerk of the lower tribunal on September 18 2013 after LaTulip timely mailed it

Now with the clock ticking and having never prepared one of these briefs

the Appellant requested an Enlargement of Time mailedfiled here on September

27th

Then the Supreme Court finally responded with an Acknowledgement of

New Case dated October 8th reCeived October 14 with a Case No SCl3shy

1866 but no response on the Enlargement of Time pleading

On October 22 2013 Mr LaTulip mailed off a Notice of Inquiry about

his brief that is due soon Asking the Clerks Office of the Supreme Court to

advice him the date on which to mail said brief

1

CO CO_ a$ Setlr5 0

cnh s dom xo rAe o +e pe o o E e

e s taxergke Ge1 camek te no1cw amp o

Dee eAec xa10 e nes one(

SuMMAtw of AAGAWA

e + bsmc colaquocxs 343s nyes efrac12aA xkx is

hd aampM((A9coAcs atm e4ecy ksntagravex ccutxa4 maA

a amp slaquopem colaquoet cces os(2timestlaquow pxaacutes cfrac14e reclaquoch

ekse ceQ elaquocg laquoA eraquoet i a uso muca)~frac14s

etaugraveeeeAx tanuaAt xo ck nasLAumla c claquose lawJs xwsiacutes

t hisx Qlaquoesua preseaeck heteaa

e sus opara5e secowh Qlaquoesuoa agrave howe Fi Disit

ouen TA o wa ecAhcxs oAringxfrac14 wt ksita cou(xescep

Eoutu Deacuterict tow(xoinhe salaquoe ax 04 laquoaxha1 regaices 5e

rid cout vwusx axwch ugraveose specAtildeagrave microxiooslashs oNtilde ue recxamp ucircax

comlaquosa3 1ampte elaquock uso dlaquougrave(laquoog w3e coutugrave suportshy

a acmea claquonealaquoe ampc each cfrac14 a4 ugravedCeexaacuteess

e sumxty lt4+e ugraveamp Qwesxas is taxeJ4$ oiquestatildes

eoaCVcts 45 oumlgxaxepCramicrok NySwxegdcembrx

Ates wewecugraves ad frac12xtlaquocheese cefrac12ltweax frac14 each

5sso egravelaquoeacute o( agraveeparaetxweness

STATEMENT OF CASE AND FACTS

After the circuit judge Merritt Sr denied all seven 3850 grounds (without

a hearing) attaching four pages of the record for grounds 5 and 7 Appellant

appealed to the Fifth District on August 28 2012

On May 16 2013 Mr LaTulip mailedfiled his 3850 initial brief raising all

seven grounds that was denied on July 19 2013 with a written opinion (no

attachments or hearing)

A timely rehearing was taken denied on August 20 2013 The mandate

soon followed September 4th

Then a timely Notice to Invoke Discretionary Jurisdiction was filed by the

clerk of the lower tribunal on September 18 2013 after LaTulip timely mailed it

Now with the clock ticking and having never prepared one of these briefs

the Appellant requested an Enlargement of Time mailedfiled here on September

27th

Then the Supreme Court finally responded with an Acknowledgement of

New Case dated October 8th reCeived October 14 with a Case No SCl3shy

1866 but no response on the Enlargement of Time pleading

On October 22 2013 Mr LaTulip mailed off a Notice of Inquiry about

his brief that is due soon Asking the Clerks Office of the Supreme Court to

advice him the date on which to mail said brief

1

CO CO_ a$ Setlr5 0

cnh s dom xo rAe o +e pe o o E e

e s taxergke Ge1 camek te no1cw amp o

Dee eAec xa10 e nes one(

SuMMAtw of AAGAWA

e + bsmc colaquocxs 343s nyes efrac12aA xkx is

hd aampM((A9coAcs atm e4ecy ksntagravex ccutxa4 maA

a amp slaquopem colaquoet cces os(2timestlaquow pxaacutes cfrac14e reclaquoch

ekse ceQ elaquocg laquoA eraquoet i a uso muca)~frac14s

etaugraveeeeAx tanuaAt xo ck nasLAumla c claquose lawJs xwsiacutes

t hisx Qlaquoesua preseaeck heteaa

e sus opara5e secowh Qlaquoesuoa agrave howe Fi Disit

ouen TA o wa ecAhcxs oAringxfrac14 wt ksita cou(xescep

Eoutu Deacuterict tow(xoinhe salaquoe ax 04 laquoaxha1 regaices 5e

rid cout vwusx axwch ugraveose specAtildeagrave microxiooslashs oNtilde ue recxamp ucircax

comlaquosa3 1ampte elaquock uso dlaquougrave(laquoog w3e coutugrave suportshy

a acmea claquonealaquoe ampc each cfrac14 a4 ugravedCeexaacuteess

e sumxty lt4+e ugraveamp Qwesxas is taxeJ4$ oiquestatildes

eoaCVcts 45 oumlgxaxepCramicrok NySwxegdcembrx

Ates wewecugraves ad frac12xtlaquocheese cefrac12ltweax frac14 each

5sso egravelaquoeacute o( agraveeparaetxweness

CO CO_ a$ Setlr5 0

cnh s dom xo rAe o +e pe o o E e

e s taxergke Ge1 camek te no1cw amp o

Dee eAec xa10 e nes one(

SuMMAtw of AAGAWA

e + bsmc colaquocxs 343s nyes efrac12aA xkx is

hd aampM((A9coAcs atm e4ecy ksntagravex ccutxa4 maA

a amp slaquopem colaquoet cces os(2timestlaquow pxaacutes cfrac14e reclaquoch

ekse ceQ elaquocg laquoA eraquoet i a uso muca)~frac14s

etaugraveeeeAx tanuaAt xo ck nasLAumla c claquose lawJs xwsiacutes

t hisx Qlaquoesua preseaeck heteaa

e sus opara5e secowh Qlaquoesuoa agrave howe Fi Disit

ouen TA o wa ecAhcxs oAringxfrac14 wt ksita cou(xescep

Eoutu Deacuterict tow(xoinhe salaquoe ax 04 laquoaxha1 regaices 5e

rid cout vwusx axwch ugraveose specAtildeagrave microxiooslashs oNtilde ue recxamp ucircax

comlaquosa3 1ampte elaquock uso dlaquougrave(laquoog w3e coutugrave suportshy

a acmea claquonealaquoe ampc each cfrac14 a4 ugravedCeexaacuteess

e sumxty lt4+e ugraveamp Qwesxas is taxeJ4$ oiquestatildes

eoaCVcts 45 oumlgxaxepCramicrok NySwxegdcembrx

Ates wewecugraves ad frac12xtlaquocheese cefrac12ltweax frac14 each

5sso egravelaquoeacute o( agraveeparaetxweness

s c kscce uteampcuoao e

chec oC ltx ksxc cco ak sfrac14xx eyes 9

6 s a de_cauacute4 eQ supltaelig Coucx or ohwer C t Cltraquocx

ea e s u2 ccedilbt x oS cuA 9e Ac l E3 $(bfrac14frac14x 5 o aA

m opesme s tfrac14 amp C s ec

e c outxs musx atxach s c c_ Fxu S o I e Ct o

e u eQlaquose each to 4 accochace wlaquoh Rh timesC

a eudeaxig$ heaG

secvh pwa weet n claquocmx ch

s ee es ions oNtilde xhe secorAring xhxx coAcAgraveaSNEAgrave CeNtildeIgrave e

e en Aohe pa(ch olog aacutexw aacutes ceaa 6

a e eas hean

Thehhich guestio eacutes ampexfrac14at ugravee ciccutt coatx QufS To

( Ae -to Me tt4(Q(e cawsoQadltt degravertcaacutex colaquot541ccedilucsuast

o e- gcocektah ce uiceseAx oQ aeligtuchg PCxfrac145 oUcirc the CeogttA

a cocusaacuteel sefuse each 3350 cfuae4M deg 0degCTS

sai e adAtesseA we eecus oQ each $cowoslashcQux bC adel To

5 e reQgtxt e4e( cou9Agrave v o9agrave seMc couex he cu4

3

et3xt04 edfla Of caA ad O R

APGAMEAT FoA CoouAo ont

w cecoslashrch Go r s orAet) au cueA woe agrave owpxxfrac14h

eces oQ ppc Cx xagraveo A pgdassfrac14 seea ltkus o4 ugraveeampseshy

ess ampc $touds s laquoAt reeowec m axxoaring~sxs do sex posm49

eNtildem M A eAring Ntildexs sex Ntildegtrxfrac14 aacutese_xue c As Foc efrac14paraAacute

cou4 Sa aos Aegegraveagrave becausea extoc oA scoresfrac14currenx es brdess

where cx agrave teaagraveosegraves semeace ltuea e res4x d hegrave segoxioxed fem

e (cnomew onxAN quex Cpuumlh aacutefrac14so ochec bj e

beaie b enxx sc lbweuer teA ssa wasfrac14w oxtoltaq uas

weR4ecxwe_ aveA net Ao sec576uA cocCecx aAh accMaxe Auker o

c Gaoa$ coanxasme sxasefrac34 frac14s sceneex hoamp sclaquoeunupaacute

sugrave egccaeligock co44egravecions (d Moni x were Act hh Ak e4 of er

ctamp scoreswees twe axoslashtg seacute QampA v cocteex enrlaquo

rofrac14oer a kaAcopa adgcadMet efrac14c$e IA Scxe ortoc040

h4 cxx seae (Augusx 5MNtildefa accacocte accust opara Aggteuca

ooc cecocA Gon a bot ueb su daxech(IApposlashN brlaquomsawg

odd Lc3A ko Aa oc coq oQucircox scaacutet aux oA c seraquoieAcshy

s eAR as we as ahcee agraveccucone scoceshee we

on o ewA AoxeAate Aga x 3ltm cose e s e

e e a esx sec ss an se elaquoe av s 4

haue bes (As oo) nosigs ox(c sgs) go 3 ampgtx grAz x hare4e

etcoc See (pagnu3opound Nc Laumlfrac14040sMso Taugraveud 6tagrave4

Coud se4edthe_9 e qe_ crcCochm eutatilded shy

stetuvoa Ockcaoes oslashplusmn ampcqs a4 s

Th ts5m deAs oacute couasts iquestq To wwem we

e el da es owicuns xtucfrac14 agrave Sax zwe e a e

at e elec cdoay ccA scwagraveccedil A3 e

o a quesxw

sxlaquoxe axxachd sicxltoes o4+e cecocA

e ehte rouaeths see cxtuckeamp0 As a

ou eJfrac14cent Tfrac12Ase4JAtcuag axtoc A

TT Te+ To su(040042CT oacauer 1frac12A ce bres eku

te xaacuted coun sfrac14okk eriwec ccAcx ga eoslashdesiaacutecy weasu oc e

owv wthosx A hem i(570oSex tecocA axxoampweais e

dosagraveepe(570uvehees a agraves colaquoe wec cou

e$ecwe osrstar-te LLo15GA

N botew ue iswe ckstcugrave ec

evak aveJe ccedillaquo ot +ree yagravecys o e A e o i u s

AteAct GA To Sca+e er oQ frac14timese Decicircs s ccedillaquo- e

aa$ oslashses eneamp heteaacutemicroc The xwo ecoceAwc4 cAe 3ece

oxfrac14 coutts deccedilorxeA Gon meswA ce ce og to we

ofrac14d roceAurah (523parace-ests teC coudoQ eoseks enc

5

otTTCC CCTtcAs Oslash para 254(254Cocirct_

hch ltkTGcx couct awh+s Gousx usuoh e

o hea c=tts frac14xo attlaquocvv ptxwraquos oR+e e

daacute3 Axe elaquoch $colaquoMoa te e ps

si et+ec amoch gx=s oR+ e 11mse

cekuve cd3k2 c3oms oc hoM oa e e c7 koor e o

Afrac14frac12sA ltraquodlar PA4(epoundcurreno See eoy wocchdo S e so

drus(alaquo7exsproslashfrac12laquognsods47sydaagteed s

slaquow vo soAsmsswa(m3xAnMeugsse2 so 4 ssshy

sUnaacobsee Aw wewsogm(ands1ea 3e y es

svxxe ta kugravempfrac14(Ra(stcA De frac14omsistlaquost 7 oa

(RaraquochkA 7e3 ucircom4Sexe 1frac12 (As(BagtA tcApo

Sme cfrac12ugraveAsqwdaaAumlktcAge gossgsxlaquoepss

bcA Xol 4 e Ccedila LugraveeeY frac34(Ra AthtcAfefrac14 o Dea s

4 SxagM9utXamp(RoAtcA aeaQz 5o1s 4 Suxepol Sod so s

(tskbcA De$z Lewoatfrac12xerco sg 6L(RasikecA ae

ampnve7tuvogu(RasecA aeoipwh6ttaumls e sn

(Ra-sAccA mece m g o+et claquoses tatilde4p wA

Nfrac14uwA FOR quEstrectWo

n toex conexs le ccedil e e ecsA

a s Ceh each tco 4 o ovoq cwk s o e

6

6

o e e A see e Awkcsoa v Scie70 Sod bAbs(Ro A

nlaquoaws gpssoA subnMaa ocAgtoos04 se

ah colaquovx a a a Aeaagraves+ese daaacutea ssx asxach 5cse syec

ek xbe secocA teG chas d wh Se xtah co s9(

claquoticaegraveez 64t(040Sisemicrosouma5413s(gatcx3as As AagraveecteA e twl

ecuct cukk on ampgtttis wovoasers o txfrac14 ntildes comoede ad att

microwas o4 amp tecotamp agrave devesebeA adfrac14stwey9seamp+ox cutg was evt

eaxah to laquoq teiektoce SSvtejsoagravernp(Roshc8xmfrac12cause

taeligt o Ae_c beaokdoaguaacute recotagrave attacheeetssuspistiah eclaquovegraves

espee xe xea c( chss we oNcus aso Scse ssues phshy

oux Qusc cfrac14eussioA ifrac14wo we te4eeseA sumar$ deSAring efrac14ootugrave Ocs

araquoh temd aA e+vhesuat$ heoAacute A oA x cha oampNLAear ae

eva541sogtAcamaskocAaxparaesltU ccutxd10 consiAec awk

aampesuekaacutes ches ax glaquoiquest eeas gelaquoxe tlaquoagravew

e outx Oa telaquoadA cout +caamp4e oMg c eoch efrac14+ax agrave

is ectfrac14ec baAg agraveucirck auk svose ltdce4 teocow Sted Qorr agrave s

comEacutee$ teampek k reedmicrotock$ P oss o4 recotAoc

o$ laquosgec4aacute te4eceace mo+e oxtackelth ahoeffrac12x hooduSme

(lu So4 frac14AgravesMot)ltktcA Pntildequcx edSitlaquoxeJSo h C(

(no s rA ocR

63 frac14 vo ampw -themog elaquoses Folt Quesuoaacute -the (040wea

ose c4 Wavachoslashegx cegnte eaxaaampfrac34 ev=fes ahem auml

1

s aA coutx awamp M Efrac14 Dsxact C=sx (oatildeel o

gerax a eeasu kAacute cqgtAh tegagravew Got Ah Colaquotz Sa Ace_ agrave agrave uw

Asquxelda cowxs nues ox10ucirc tekew psaacutevas amp Se seco(ampxo

tehve each gro d ffrac14Aring )efrac12 aacute ograveow tkagrave Ograveutx (oc ox

easxtfrac14eJos ( eolaquos frac14raquo1frac14t Secod Daumlxcagrave1 Cod frac14s oxxachel

xfrac14_ recocA Roc encfrac14o$coud aoagrave bas aso goat a tecod Sc each

c cowds k

t vaak coutx mos arco-cho cts ocograveec 50se

otxions 0Ntilde+e Cecatamp wfrac14ch coachtsmey eswahish

at ogeaax s emraea to wo ttegraveNtilde e zoSe

dans oMawceA a eh agraves teasons 4x so cok

a leepusis

Lersaacuteufrac12e (JuSoakwyGHoamptcAfm

Ta cose axd5e koet coarx ga4e4 Ceasooslashsamp Ae4

seuea oudgfrac14t Aamp sax attacfrac14 as recotA3fg tauoamps ove xkro w

4o4 odsh iAgraveesce aarhc caMugravec s beeA iiusxtonehkx scaQ be

tevfrac14el snee Goux aux cR Gee Amucc coutxs (agravehxhoxfrac34xook cow

wusx cnzoch se specc_ ptvows a4 tecccograve teCux a frac14te_ams

(a u tcnicode4cr b | each groud coms suiquesty254vg

A9cmm troA quesnoa mu

Eocns atyeest Accedilpeass was aa$auxobd o452

case od oraquoe frac14iumlXaNcasG1box codes aacutech frac14frac34frac34 8JegopAcircwa

ougrave oamphe ue veCagravescopy aMomacheess requugraveeeerax

Mies case is M 5uguoca)e Me a ocagraveecs a541

smaacuteb de p his Me 3s37e maacute uns deaacuteeograve oae s

CeRelaquo a o e coaxean oQ Ws ph ogteeeea-s( eucx s

o 6a hoMp)oaewer(x ampamp aax axxlaquoch o e o e

a ee e x oc an oxfrac14c microagas ofrac14 tecA zo coachsisve ce

e3 IA xfrac14 svraquocurren eoaelig$e qea ogeeeem(oamp+cee

s3 ue e anonefrac14c goud Gabuxg1agrave asgeoaks

ehwe gachlaquox rlaquoecxeak e slaquopyx e

cs pagcqh o570theAtoyeax frac14lt Ques 04 thorn elose

renovhamp 6etimesvA eux agraveecAes xo A e e

es ixs gtecause we cheCeakam claquoagraves are eoslashacksm$ teh

tecocagrave cout sfrac14Ah laquovtlaquochk egcognoxe- poco as oC+e reco

xo te ocagraveeEcircDe- o+ec cce is Sekenfrac14eKn4k(Rashtr

ofrac34)3(3goo a040d cSehaacute issusq oA tesi mah cowx sougrave e

et$ec c to4x Se souA oc growle_5e_ comgde_ c e

M oxxacheeAc o CecoCEcirclt040x3groas

seyesx is w+ommetugrave)

A otAlaquo Mch sumoih$ deaies a o c

laquoMd e de-oasxtne laquoe co t eowa e e e o

Muagrave laquovaaringg e pxas 09 tecocAgrave ok ch cowlus dero shy

sxcom e AeSeAax aacute emaacuteeampo as tamp en M L s e

ongss-sdRaxovuAcxeacutepound uns(AadRaMpppounddegu4(bYMe (quexg Vdlaquoc$tcQ) cm$ xh wese middotwo scoeedud cubes

oampxfrac14e courts aampwtte m decom oPSxose becisd

Cot4CL10t4

Seth e toraquoet -etisA ce cs eccek wfrac14 a deacuteh sx coAshy

ekwaeg tepoundlaquoe A lt4 Ly s ssaelig teuds wxw tecltxA oweend

s ooslashe caA peraquoaq seeltomtke costs agravefrac14ahnh RochS em

Coutx laquoeA cagrave bcsx Cowxs kJ assurel us FA SW4

|ac 94MNMb570AringNtildeh EcircAringweh a8Aacute cho ceAringed us 1x

ea xyenese Quks are sv Qoonel because oboc 3 teasma58 cet

gte recoscleh (oc enfrac14er ow eade x he oc oiker opcoshy

aclaquoe oews

Ia smsd cowx erlteh ad xfrac14gt Asz( cousx eAfrac14aaeel

eic middoteccot whea no (dow Meme 570cdeck k e4

noce Dectss as Aenoslashssraxek meiwa

frac14keAvsogg Agelaquoax ampys x kaos pesamkcee gch

ou quewoes xh Mvh acyeass v xfrac14s uasaye Coutx Aamp1kcea

oesua s are (eodnoamp cecoch laquoxaakm cefrac12temamp pace

emce d eteax (m oraquoe a aAe k ace syxel case ausfrac14ax

eges owAgrave dlaquoecq cowUcirccas AgeEgraveads atttreA c w

s ecCuil s

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY the original was sent to Florida Supreme Court at 500 S

Duval Street Tallahassee 32399 and one true copy sent to the Attorney Generals

Office The Capitol PL-01 Tallahassee 32399-1050 all of which which hand-

delivered to a Lake CI mailroom staff for mailing on this (o A day of

Dee_gc 2013

Sincerel

Add Bobby A LaTulip 253688 Lake Correctional Institution 19225 Hwy 27 Clermont FL 34715-9025

bltub 40 xc inmates file

114 Cut fLo91DA 549AEtAE CouRT

09 A Mfrac34LW

Agelam

Ms Cose Ntildeo S Ndo

51mt of ELo9ao A

THORNqgteee_

AWELLEgrave A9PEt4bK

APPEMOI Eth1

O tAC

G

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

et3xt04 edfla Of caA ad O R

APGAMEAT FoA CoouAo ont

w cecoslashrch Go r s orAet) au cueA woe agrave owpxxfrac14h

eces oQ ppc Cx xagraveo A pgdassfrac14 seea ltkus o4 ugraveeampseshy

ess ampc $touds s laquoAt reeowec m axxoaring~sxs do sex posm49

eNtildem M A eAring Ntildexs sex Ntildegtrxfrac14 aacutese_xue c As Foc efrac14paraAacute

cou4 Sa aos Aegegraveagrave becausea extoc oA scoresfrac14currenx es brdess

where cx agrave teaagraveosegraves semeace ltuea e res4x d hegrave segoxioxed fem

e (cnomew onxAN quex Cpuumlh aacutefrac14so ochec bj e

beaie b enxx sc lbweuer teA ssa wasfrac14w oxtoltaq uas

weR4ecxwe_ aveA net Ao sec576uA cocCecx aAh accMaxe Auker o

c Gaoa$ coanxasme sxasefrac34 frac14s sceneex hoamp sclaquoeunupaacute

sugrave egccaeligock co44egravecions (d Moni x were Act hh Ak e4 of er

ctamp scoreswees twe axoslashtg seacute QampA v cocteex enrlaquo

rofrac14oer a kaAcopa adgcadMet efrac14c$e IA Scxe ortoc040

h4 cxx seae (Augusx 5MNtildefa accacocte accust opara Aggteuca

ooc cecocA Gon a bot ueb su daxech(IApposlashN brlaquomsawg

odd Lc3A ko Aa oc coq oQucircox scaacutet aux oA c seraquoieAcshy

s eAR as we as ahcee agraveccucone scoceshee we

on o ewA AoxeAate Aga x 3ltm cose e s e

e e a esx sec ss an se elaquoe av s 4

haue bes (As oo) nosigs ox(c sgs) go 3 ampgtx grAz x hare4e

etcoc See (pagnu3opound Nc Laumlfrac14040sMso Taugraveud 6tagrave4

Coud se4edthe_9 e qe_ crcCochm eutatilded shy

stetuvoa Ockcaoes oslashplusmn ampcqs a4 s

Th ts5m deAs oacute couasts iquestq To wwem we

e el da es owicuns xtucfrac14 agrave Sax zwe e a e

at e elec cdoay ccA scwagraveccedil A3 e

o a quesxw

sxlaquoxe axxachd sicxltoes o4+e cecocA

e ehte rouaeths see cxtuckeamp0 As a

ou eJfrac14cent Tfrac12Ase4JAtcuag axtoc A

TT Te+ To su(040042CT oacauer 1frac12A ce bres eku

te xaacuted coun sfrac14okk eriwec ccAcx ga eoslashdesiaacutecy weasu oc e

owv wthosx A hem i(570oSex tecocA axxoampweais e

dosagraveepe(570uvehees a agraves colaquoe wec cou

e$ecwe osrstar-te LLo15GA

N botew ue iswe ckstcugrave ec

evak aveJe ccedillaquo ot +ree yagravecys o e A e o i u s

AteAct GA To Sca+e er oQ frac14timese Decicircs s ccedillaquo- e

aa$ oslashses eneamp heteaacutemicroc The xwo ecoceAwc4 cAe 3ece

oxfrac14 coutts deccedilorxeA Gon meswA ce ce og to we

ofrac14d roceAurah (523parace-ests teC coudoQ eoseks enc

5

otTTCC CCTtcAs Oslash para 254(254Cocirct_

hch ltkTGcx couct awh+s Gousx usuoh e

o hea c=tts frac14xo attlaquocvv ptxwraquos oR+e e

daacute3 Axe elaquoch $colaquoMoa te e ps

si et+ec amoch gx=s oR+ e 11mse

cekuve cd3k2 c3oms oc hoM oa e e c7 koor e o

Afrac14frac12sA ltraquodlar PA4(epoundcurreno See eoy wocchdo S e so

drus(alaquo7exsproslashfrac12laquognsods47sydaagteed s

slaquow vo soAsmsswa(m3xAnMeugsse2 so 4 ssshy

sUnaacobsee Aw wewsogm(ands1ea 3e y es

svxxe ta kugravempfrac14(Ra(stcA De frac14omsistlaquost 7 oa

(RaraquochkA 7e3 ucircom4Sexe 1frac12 (As(BagtA tcApo

Sme cfrac12ugraveAsqwdaaAumlktcAge gossgsxlaquoepss

bcA Xol 4 e Ccedila LugraveeeY frac34(Ra AthtcAfefrac14 o Dea s

4 SxagM9utXamp(RoAtcA aeaQz 5o1s 4 Suxepol Sod so s

(tskbcA De$z Lewoatfrac12xerco sg 6L(RasikecA ae

ampnve7tuvogu(RasecA aeoipwh6ttaumls e sn

(Ra-sAccA mece m g o+et claquoses tatilde4p wA

Nfrac14uwA FOR quEstrectWo

n toex conexs le ccedil e e ecsA

a s Ceh each tco 4 o ovoq cwk s o e

6

6

o e e A see e Awkcsoa v Scie70 Sod bAbs(Ro A

nlaquoaws gpssoA subnMaa ocAgtoos04 se

ah colaquovx a a a Aeaagraves+ese daaacutea ssx asxach 5cse syec

ek xbe secocA teG chas d wh Se xtah co s9(

claquoticaegraveez 64t(040Sisemicrosouma5413s(gatcx3as As AagraveecteA e twl

ecuct cukk on ampgtttis wovoasers o txfrac14 ntildes comoede ad att

microwas o4 amp tecotamp agrave devesebeA adfrac14stwey9seamp+ox cutg was evt

eaxah to laquoq teiektoce SSvtejsoagravernp(Roshc8xmfrac12cause

taeligt o Ae_c beaokdoaguaacute recotagrave attacheeetssuspistiah eclaquovegraves

espee xe xea c( chss we oNcus aso Scse ssues phshy

oux Qusc cfrac14eussioA ifrac14wo we te4eeseA sumar$ deSAring efrac14ootugrave Ocs

araquoh temd aA e+vhesuat$ heoAacute A oA x cha oampNLAear ae

eva541sogtAcamaskocAaxparaesltU ccutxd10 consiAec awk

aampesuekaacutes ches ax glaquoiquest eeas gelaquoxe tlaquoagravew

e outx Oa telaquoadA cout +caamp4e oMg c eoch efrac14+ax agrave

is ectfrac14ec baAg agraveucirck auk svose ltdce4 teocow Sted Qorr agrave s

comEacutee$ teampek k reedmicrotock$ P oss o4 recotAoc

o$ laquosgec4aacute te4eceace mo+e oxtackelth ahoeffrac12x hooduSme

(lu So4 frac14AgravesMot)ltktcA Pntildequcx edSitlaquoxeJSo h C(

(no s rA ocR

63 frac14 vo ampw -themog elaquoses Folt Quesuoaacute -the (040wea

ose c4 Wavachoslashegx cegnte eaxaaampfrac34 ev=fes ahem auml

1

s aA coutx awamp M Efrac14 Dsxact C=sx (oatildeel o

gerax a eeasu kAacute cqgtAh tegagravew Got Ah Colaquotz Sa Ace_ agrave agrave uw

Asquxelda cowxs nues ox10ucirc tekew psaacutevas amp Se seco(ampxo

tehve each gro d ffrac14Aring )efrac12 aacute ograveow tkagrave Ograveutx (oc ox

easxtfrac14eJos ( eolaquos frac14raquo1frac14t Secod Daumlxcagrave1 Cod frac14s oxxachel

xfrac14_ recocA Roc encfrac14o$coud aoagrave bas aso goat a tecod Sc each

c cowds k

t vaak coutx mos arco-cho cts ocograveec 50se

otxions 0Ntilde+e Cecatamp wfrac14ch coachtsmey eswahish

at ogeaax s emraea to wo ttegraveNtilde e zoSe

dans oMawceA a eh agraves teasons 4x so cok

a leepusis

Lersaacuteufrac12e (JuSoakwyGHoamptcAfm

Ta cose axd5e koet coarx ga4e4 Ceasooslashsamp Ae4

seuea oudgfrac14t Aamp sax attacfrac14 as recotA3fg tauoamps ove xkro w

4o4 odsh iAgraveesce aarhc caMugravec s beeA iiusxtonehkx scaQ be

tevfrac14el snee Goux aux cR Gee Amucc coutxs (agravehxhoxfrac34xook cow

wusx cnzoch se specc_ ptvows a4 tecccograve teCux a frac14te_ams

(a u tcnicode4cr b | each groud coms suiquesty254vg

A9cmm troA quesnoa mu

Eocns atyeest Accedilpeass was aa$auxobd o452

case od oraquoe frac14iumlXaNcasG1box codes aacutech frac14frac34frac34 8JegopAcircwa

ougrave oamphe ue veCagravescopy aMomacheess requugraveeeerax

Mies case is M 5uguoca)e Me a ocagraveecs a541

smaacuteb de p his Me 3s37e maacute uns deaacuteeograve oae s

CeRelaquo a o e coaxean oQ Ws ph ogteeeea-s( eucx s

o 6a hoMp)oaewer(x ampamp aax axxlaquoch o e o e

a ee e x oc an oxfrac14c microagas ofrac14 tecA zo coachsisve ce

e3 IA xfrac14 svraquocurren eoaelig$e qea ogeeeem(oamp+cee

s3 ue e anonefrac14c goud Gabuxg1agrave asgeoaks

ehwe gachlaquox rlaquoecxeak e slaquopyx e

cs pagcqh o570theAtoyeax frac14lt Ques 04 thorn elose

renovhamp 6etimesvA eux agraveecAes xo A e e

es ixs gtecause we cheCeakam claquoagraves are eoslashacksm$ teh

tecocagrave cout sfrac14Ah laquovtlaquochk egcognoxe- poco as oC+e reco

xo te ocagraveeEcircDe- o+ec cce is Sekenfrac14eKn4k(Rashtr

ofrac34)3(3goo a040d cSehaacute issusq oA tesi mah cowx sougrave e

et$ec c to4x Se souA oc growle_5e_ comgde_ c e

M oxxacheeAc o CecoCEcirclt040x3groas

seyesx is w+ommetugrave)

A otAlaquo Mch sumoih$ deaies a o c

laquoMd e de-oasxtne laquoe co t eowa e e e o

Muagrave laquovaaringg e pxas 09 tecocAgrave ok ch cowlus dero shy

sxcom e AeSeAax aacute emaacuteeampo as tamp en M L s e

ongss-sdRaxovuAcxeacutepound uns(AadRaMpppounddegu4(bYMe (quexg Vdlaquoc$tcQ) cm$ xh wese middotwo scoeedud cubes

oampxfrac14e courts aampwtte m decom oPSxose becisd

Cot4CL10t4

Seth e toraquoet -etisA ce cs eccek wfrac14 a deacuteh sx coAshy

ekwaeg tepoundlaquoe A lt4 Ly s ssaelig teuds wxw tecltxA oweend

s ooslashe caA peraquoaq seeltomtke costs agravefrac14ahnh RochS em

Coutx laquoeA cagrave bcsx Cowxs kJ assurel us FA SW4

|ac 94MNMb570AringNtildeh EcircAringweh a8Aacute cho ceAringed us 1x

ea xyenese Quks are sv Qoonel because oboc 3 teasma58 cet

gte recoscleh (oc enfrac14er ow eade x he oc oiker opcoshy

aclaquoe oews

Ia smsd cowx erlteh ad xfrac14gt Asz( cousx eAfrac14aaeel

eic middoteccot whea no (dow Meme 570cdeck k e4

noce Dectss as Aenoslashssraxek meiwa

frac14keAvsogg Agelaquoax ampys x kaos pesamkcee gch

ou quewoes xh Mvh acyeass v xfrac14s uasaye Coutx Aamp1kcea

oesua s are (eodnoamp cecoch laquoxaakm cefrac12temamp pace

emce d eteax (m oraquoe a aAe k ace syxel case ausfrac14ax

eges owAgrave dlaquoecq cowUcirccas AgeEgraveads atttreA c w

s ecCuil s

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY the original was sent to Florida Supreme Court at 500 S

Duval Street Tallahassee 32399 and one true copy sent to the Attorney Generals

Office The Capitol PL-01 Tallahassee 32399-1050 all of which which hand-

delivered to a Lake CI mailroom staff for mailing on this (o A day of

Dee_gc 2013

Sincerel

Add Bobby A LaTulip 253688 Lake Correctional Institution 19225 Hwy 27 Clermont FL 34715-9025

bltub 40 xc inmates file

114 Cut fLo91DA 549AEtAE CouRT

09 A Mfrac34LW

Agelam

Ms Cose Ntildeo S Ndo

51mt of ELo9ao A

THORNqgteee_

AWELLEgrave A9PEt4bK

APPEMOI Eth1

O tAC

G

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

haue bes (As oo) nosigs ox(c sgs) go 3 ampgtx grAz x hare4e

etcoc See (pagnu3opound Nc Laumlfrac14040sMso Taugraveud 6tagrave4

Coud se4edthe_9 e qe_ crcCochm eutatilded shy

stetuvoa Ockcaoes oslashplusmn ampcqs a4 s

Th ts5m deAs oacute couasts iquestq To wwem we

e el da es owicuns xtucfrac14 agrave Sax zwe e a e

at e elec cdoay ccA scwagraveccedil A3 e

o a quesxw

sxlaquoxe axxachd sicxltoes o4+e cecocA

e ehte rouaeths see cxtuckeamp0 As a

ou eJfrac14cent Tfrac12Ase4JAtcuag axtoc A

TT Te+ To su(040042CT oacauer 1frac12A ce bres eku

te xaacuted coun sfrac14okk eriwec ccAcx ga eoslashdesiaacutecy weasu oc e

owv wthosx A hem i(570oSex tecocA axxoampweais e

dosagraveepe(570uvehees a agraves colaquoe wec cou

e$ecwe osrstar-te LLo15GA

N botew ue iswe ckstcugrave ec

evak aveJe ccedillaquo ot +ree yagravecys o e A e o i u s

AteAct GA To Sca+e er oQ frac14timese Decicircs s ccedillaquo- e

aa$ oslashses eneamp heteaacutemicroc The xwo ecoceAwc4 cAe 3ece

oxfrac14 coutts deccedilorxeA Gon meswA ce ce og to we

ofrac14d roceAurah (523parace-ests teC coudoQ eoseks enc

5

otTTCC CCTtcAs Oslash para 254(254Cocirct_

hch ltkTGcx couct awh+s Gousx usuoh e

o hea c=tts frac14xo attlaquocvv ptxwraquos oR+e e

daacute3 Axe elaquoch $colaquoMoa te e ps

si et+ec amoch gx=s oR+ e 11mse

cekuve cd3k2 c3oms oc hoM oa e e c7 koor e o

Afrac14frac12sA ltraquodlar PA4(epoundcurreno See eoy wocchdo S e so

drus(alaquo7exsproslashfrac12laquognsods47sydaagteed s

slaquow vo soAsmsswa(m3xAnMeugsse2 so 4 ssshy

sUnaacobsee Aw wewsogm(ands1ea 3e y es

svxxe ta kugravempfrac14(Ra(stcA De frac14omsistlaquost 7 oa

(RaraquochkA 7e3 ucircom4Sexe 1frac12 (As(BagtA tcApo

Sme cfrac12ugraveAsqwdaaAumlktcAge gossgsxlaquoepss

bcA Xol 4 e Ccedila LugraveeeY frac34(Ra AthtcAfefrac14 o Dea s

4 SxagM9utXamp(RoAtcA aeaQz 5o1s 4 Suxepol Sod so s

(tskbcA De$z Lewoatfrac12xerco sg 6L(RasikecA ae

ampnve7tuvogu(RasecA aeoipwh6ttaumls e sn

(Ra-sAccA mece m g o+et claquoses tatilde4p wA

Nfrac14uwA FOR quEstrectWo

n toex conexs le ccedil e e ecsA

a s Ceh each tco 4 o ovoq cwk s o e

6

6

o e e A see e Awkcsoa v Scie70 Sod bAbs(Ro A

nlaquoaws gpssoA subnMaa ocAgtoos04 se

ah colaquovx a a a Aeaagraves+ese daaacutea ssx asxach 5cse syec

ek xbe secocA teG chas d wh Se xtah co s9(

claquoticaegraveez 64t(040Sisemicrosouma5413s(gatcx3as As AagraveecteA e twl

ecuct cukk on ampgtttis wovoasers o txfrac14 ntildes comoede ad att

microwas o4 amp tecotamp agrave devesebeA adfrac14stwey9seamp+ox cutg was evt

eaxah to laquoq teiektoce SSvtejsoagravernp(Roshc8xmfrac12cause

taeligt o Ae_c beaokdoaguaacute recotagrave attacheeetssuspistiah eclaquovegraves

espee xe xea c( chss we oNcus aso Scse ssues phshy

oux Qusc cfrac14eussioA ifrac14wo we te4eeseA sumar$ deSAring efrac14ootugrave Ocs

araquoh temd aA e+vhesuat$ heoAacute A oA x cha oampNLAear ae

eva541sogtAcamaskocAaxparaesltU ccutxd10 consiAec awk

aampesuekaacutes ches ax glaquoiquest eeas gelaquoxe tlaquoagravew

e outx Oa telaquoadA cout +caamp4e oMg c eoch efrac14+ax agrave

is ectfrac14ec baAg agraveucirck auk svose ltdce4 teocow Sted Qorr agrave s

comEacutee$ teampek k reedmicrotock$ P oss o4 recotAoc

o$ laquosgec4aacute te4eceace mo+e oxtackelth ahoeffrac12x hooduSme

(lu So4 frac14AgravesMot)ltktcA Pntildequcx edSitlaquoxeJSo h C(

(no s rA ocR

63 frac14 vo ampw -themog elaquoses Folt Quesuoaacute -the (040wea

ose c4 Wavachoslashegx cegnte eaxaaampfrac34 ev=fes ahem auml

1

s aA coutx awamp M Efrac14 Dsxact C=sx (oatildeel o

gerax a eeasu kAacute cqgtAh tegagravew Got Ah Colaquotz Sa Ace_ agrave agrave uw

Asquxelda cowxs nues ox10ucirc tekew psaacutevas amp Se seco(ampxo

tehve each gro d ffrac14Aring )efrac12 aacute ograveow tkagrave Ograveutx (oc ox

easxtfrac14eJos ( eolaquos frac14raquo1frac14t Secod Daumlxcagrave1 Cod frac14s oxxachel

xfrac14_ recocA Roc encfrac14o$coud aoagrave bas aso goat a tecod Sc each

c cowds k

t vaak coutx mos arco-cho cts ocograveec 50se

otxions 0Ntilde+e Cecatamp wfrac14ch coachtsmey eswahish

at ogeaax s emraea to wo ttegraveNtilde e zoSe

dans oMawceA a eh agraves teasons 4x so cok

a leepusis

Lersaacuteufrac12e (JuSoakwyGHoamptcAfm

Ta cose axd5e koet coarx ga4e4 Ceasooslashsamp Ae4

seuea oudgfrac14t Aamp sax attacfrac14 as recotA3fg tauoamps ove xkro w

4o4 odsh iAgraveesce aarhc caMugravec s beeA iiusxtonehkx scaQ be

tevfrac14el snee Goux aux cR Gee Amucc coutxs (agravehxhoxfrac34xook cow

wusx cnzoch se specc_ ptvows a4 tecccograve teCux a frac14te_ams

(a u tcnicode4cr b | each groud coms suiquesty254vg

A9cmm troA quesnoa mu

Eocns atyeest Accedilpeass was aa$auxobd o452

case od oraquoe frac14iumlXaNcasG1box codes aacutech frac14frac34frac34 8JegopAcircwa

ougrave oamphe ue veCagravescopy aMomacheess requugraveeeerax

Mies case is M 5uguoca)e Me a ocagraveecs a541

smaacuteb de p his Me 3s37e maacute uns deaacuteeograve oae s

CeRelaquo a o e coaxean oQ Ws ph ogteeeea-s( eucx s

o 6a hoMp)oaewer(x ampamp aax axxlaquoch o e o e

a ee e x oc an oxfrac14c microagas ofrac14 tecA zo coachsisve ce

e3 IA xfrac14 svraquocurren eoaelig$e qea ogeeeem(oamp+cee

s3 ue e anonefrac14c goud Gabuxg1agrave asgeoaks

ehwe gachlaquox rlaquoecxeak e slaquopyx e

cs pagcqh o570theAtoyeax frac14lt Ques 04 thorn elose

renovhamp 6etimesvA eux agraveecAes xo A e e

es ixs gtecause we cheCeakam claquoagraves are eoslashacksm$ teh

tecocagrave cout sfrac14Ah laquovtlaquochk egcognoxe- poco as oC+e reco

xo te ocagraveeEcircDe- o+ec cce is Sekenfrac14eKn4k(Rashtr

ofrac34)3(3goo a040d cSehaacute issusq oA tesi mah cowx sougrave e

et$ec c to4x Se souA oc growle_5e_ comgde_ c e

M oxxacheeAc o CecoCEcirclt040x3groas

seyesx is w+ommetugrave)

A otAlaquo Mch sumoih$ deaies a o c

laquoMd e de-oasxtne laquoe co t eowa e e e o

Muagrave laquovaaringg e pxas 09 tecocAgrave ok ch cowlus dero shy

sxcom e AeSeAax aacute emaacuteeampo as tamp en M L s e

ongss-sdRaxovuAcxeacutepound uns(AadRaMpppounddegu4(bYMe (quexg Vdlaquoc$tcQ) cm$ xh wese middotwo scoeedud cubes

oampxfrac14e courts aampwtte m decom oPSxose becisd

Cot4CL10t4

Seth e toraquoet -etisA ce cs eccek wfrac14 a deacuteh sx coAshy

ekwaeg tepoundlaquoe A lt4 Ly s ssaelig teuds wxw tecltxA oweend

s ooslashe caA peraquoaq seeltomtke costs agravefrac14ahnh RochS em

Coutx laquoeA cagrave bcsx Cowxs kJ assurel us FA SW4

|ac 94MNMb570AringNtildeh EcircAringweh a8Aacute cho ceAringed us 1x

ea xyenese Quks are sv Qoonel because oboc 3 teasma58 cet

gte recoscleh (oc enfrac14er ow eade x he oc oiker opcoshy

aclaquoe oews

Ia smsd cowx erlteh ad xfrac14gt Asz( cousx eAfrac14aaeel

eic middoteccot whea no (dow Meme 570cdeck k e4

noce Dectss as Aenoslashssraxek meiwa

frac14keAvsogg Agelaquoax ampys x kaos pesamkcee gch

ou quewoes xh Mvh acyeass v xfrac14s uasaye Coutx Aamp1kcea

oesua s are (eodnoamp cecoch laquoxaakm cefrac12temamp pace

emce d eteax (m oraquoe a aAe k ace syxel case ausfrac14ax

eges owAgrave dlaquoecq cowUcirccas AgeEgraveads atttreA c w

s ecCuil s

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY the original was sent to Florida Supreme Court at 500 S

Duval Street Tallahassee 32399 and one true copy sent to the Attorney Generals

Office The Capitol PL-01 Tallahassee 32399-1050 all of which which hand-

delivered to a Lake CI mailroom staff for mailing on this (o A day of

Dee_gc 2013

Sincerel

Add Bobby A LaTulip 253688 Lake Correctional Institution 19225 Hwy 27 Clermont FL 34715-9025

bltub 40 xc inmates file

114 Cut fLo91DA 549AEtAE CouRT

09 A Mfrac34LW

Agelam

Ms Cose Ntildeo S Ndo

51mt of ELo9ao A

THORNqgteee_

AWELLEgrave A9PEt4bK

APPEMOI Eth1

O tAC

G

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

otTTCC CCTtcAs Oslash para 254(254Cocirct_

hch ltkTGcx couct awh+s Gousx usuoh e

o hea c=tts frac14xo attlaquocvv ptxwraquos oR+e e

daacute3 Axe elaquoch $colaquoMoa te e ps

si et+ec amoch gx=s oR+ e 11mse

cekuve cd3k2 c3oms oc hoM oa e e c7 koor e o

Afrac14frac12sA ltraquodlar PA4(epoundcurreno See eoy wocchdo S e so

drus(alaquo7exsproslashfrac12laquognsods47sydaagteed s

slaquow vo soAsmsswa(m3xAnMeugsse2 so 4 ssshy

sUnaacobsee Aw wewsogm(ands1ea 3e y es

svxxe ta kugravempfrac14(Ra(stcA De frac14omsistlaquost 7 oa

(RaraquochkA 7e3 ucircom4Sexe 1frac12 (As(BagtA tcApo

Sme cfrac12ugraveAsqwdaaAumlktcAge gossgsxlaquoepss

bcA Xol 4 e Ccedila LugraveeeY frac34(Ra AthtcAfefrac14 o Dea s

4 SxagM9utXamp(RoAtcA aeaQz 5o1s 4 Suxepol Sod so s

(tskbcA De$z Lewoatfrac12xerco sg 6L(RasikecA ae

ampnve7tuvogu(RasecA aeoipwh6ttaumls e sn

(Ra-sAccA mece m g o+et claquoses tatilde4p wA

Nfrac14uwA FOR quEstrectWo

n toex conexs le ccedil e e ecsA

a s Ceh each tco 4 o ovoq cwk s o e

6

6

o e e A see e Awkcsoa v Scie70 Sod bAbs(Ro A

nlaquoaws gpssoA subnMaa ocAgtoos04 se

ah colaquovx a a a Aeaagraves+ese daaacutea ssx asxach 5cse syec

ek xbe secocA teG chas d wh Se xtah co s9(

claquoticaegraveez 64t(040Sisemicrosouma5413s(gatcx3as As AagraveecteA e twl

ecuct cukk on ampgtttis wovoasers o txfrac14 ntildes comoede ad att

microwas o4 amp tecotamp agrave devesebeA adfrac14stwey9seamp+ox cutg was evt

eaxah to laquoq teiektoce SSvtejsoagravernp(Roshc8xmfrac12cause

taeligt o Ae_c beaokdoaguaacute recotagrave attacheeetssuspistiah eclaquovegraves

espee xe xea c( chss we oNcus aso Scse ssues phshy

oux Qusc cfrac14eussioA ifrac14wo we te4eeseA sumar$ deSAring efrac14ootugrave Ocs

araquoh temd aA e+vhesuat$ heoAacute A oA x cha oampNLAear ae

eva541sogtAcamaskocAaxparaesltU ccutxd10 consiAec awk

aampesuekaacutes ches ax glaquoiquest eeas gelaquoxe tlaquoagravew

e outx Oa telaquoadA cout +caamp4e oMg c eoch efrac14+ax agrave

is ectfrac14ec baAg agraveucirck auk svose ltdce4 teocow Sted Qorr agrave s

comEacutee$ teampek k reedmicrotock$ P oss o4 recotAoc

o$ laquosgec4aacute te4eceace mo+e oxtackelth ahoeffrac12x hooduSme

(lu So4 frac14AgravesMot)ltktcA Pntildequcx edSitlaquoxeJSo h C(

(no s rA ocR

63 frac14 vo ampw -themog elaquoses Folt Quesuoaacute -the (040wea

ose c4 Wavachoslashegx cegnte eaxaaampfrac34 ev=fes ahem auml

1

s aA coutx awamp M Efrac14 Dsxact C=sx (oatildeel o

gerax a eeasu kAacute cqgtAh tegagravew Got Ah Colaquotz Sa Ace_ agrave agrave uw

Asquxelda cowxs nues ox10ucirc tekew psaacutevas amp Se seco(ampxo

tehve each gro d ffrac14Aring )efrac12 aacute ograveow tkagrave Ograveutx (oc ox

easxtfrac14eJos ( eolaquos frac14raquo1frac14t Secod Daumlxcagrave1 Cod frac14s oxxachel

xfrac14_ recocA Roc encfrac14o$coud aoagrave bas aso goat a tecod Sc each

c cowds k

t vaak coutx mos arco-cho cts ocograveec 50se

otxions 0Ntilde+e Cecatamp wfrac14ch coachtsmey eswahish

at ogeaax s emraea to wo ttegraveNtilde e zoSe

dans oMawceA a eh agraves teasons 4x so cok

a leepusis

Lersaacuteufrac12e (JuSoakwyGHoamptcAfm

Ta cose axd5e koet coarx ga4e4 Ceasooslashsamp Ae4

seuea oudgfrac14t Aamp sax attacfrac14 as recotA3fg tauoamps ove xkro w

4o4 odsh iAgraveesce aarhc caMugravec s beeA iiusxtonehkx scaQ be

tevfrac14el snee Goux aux cR Gee Amucc coutxs (agravehxhoxfrac34xook cow

wusx cnzoch se specc_ ptvows a4 tecccograve teCux a frac14te_ams

(a u tcnicode4cr b | each groud coms suiquesty254vg

A9cmm troA quesnoa mu

Eocns atyeest Accedilpeass was aa$auxobd o452

case od oraquoe frac14iumlXaNcasG1box codes aacutech frac14frac34frac34 8JegopAcircwa

ougrave oamphe ue veCagravescopy aMomacheess requugraveeeerax

Mies case is M 5uguoca)e Me a ocagraveecs a541

smaacuteb de p his Me 3s37e maacute uns deaacuteeograve oae s

CeRelaquo a o e coaxean oQ Ws ph ogteeeea-s( eucx s

o 6a hoMp)oaewer(x ampamp aax axxlaquoch o e o e

a ee e x oc an oxfrac14c microagas ofrac14 tecA zo coachsisve ce

e3 IA xfrac14 svraquocurren eoaelig$e qea ogeeeem(oamp+cee

s3 ue e anonefrac14c goud Gabuxg1agrave asgeoaks

ehwe gachlaquox rlaquoecxeak e slaquopyx e

cs pagcqh o570theAtoyeax frac14lt Ques 04 thorn elose

renovhamp 6etimesvA eux agraveecAes xo A e e

es ixs gtecause we cheCeakam claquoagraves are eoslashacksm$ teh

tecocagrave cout sfrac14Ah laquovtlaquochk egcognoxe- poco as oC+e reco

xo te ocagraveeEcircDe- o+ec cce is Sekenfrac14eKn4k(Rashtr

ofrac34)3(3goo a040d cSehaacute issusq oA tesi mah cowx sougrave e

et$ec c to4x Se souA oc growle_5e_ comgde_ c e

M oxxacheeAc o CecoCEcirclt040x3groas

seyesx is w+ommetugrave)

A otAlaquo Mch sumoih$ deaies a o c

laquoMd e de-oasxtne laquoe co t eowa e e e o

Muagrave laquovaaringg e pxas 09 tecocAgrave ok ch cowlus dero shy

sxcom e AeSeAax aacute emaacuteeampo as tamp en M L s e

ongss-sdRaxovuAcxeacutepound uns(AadRaMpppounddegu4(bYMe (quexg Vdlaquoc$tcQ) cm$ xh wese middotwo scoeedud cubes

oampxfrac14e courts aampwtte m decom oPSxose becisd

Cot4CL10t4

Seth e toraquoet -etisA ce cs eccek wfrac14 a deacuteh sx coAshy

ekwaeg tepoundlaquoe A lt4 Ly s ssaelig teuds wxw tecltxA oweend

s ooslashe caA peraquoaq seeltomtke costs agravefrac14ahnh RochS em

Coutx laquoeA cagrave bcsx Cowxs kJ assurel us FA SW4

|ac 94MNMb570AringNtildeh EcircAringweh a8Aacute cho ceAringed us 1x

ea xyenese Quks are sv Qoonel because oboc 3 teasma58 cet

gte recoscleh (oc enfrac14er ow eade x he oc oiker opcoshy

aclaquoe oews

Ia smsd cowx erlteh ad xfrac14gt Asz( cousx eAfrac14aaeel

eic middoteccot whea no (dow Meme 570cdeck k e4

noce Dectss as Aenoslashssraxek meiwa

frac14keAvsogg Agelaquoax ampys x kaos pesamkcee gch

ou quewoes xh Mvh acyeass v xfrac14s uasaye Coutx Aamp1kcea

oesua s are (eodnoamp cecoch laquoxaakm cefrac12temamp pace

emce d eteax (m oraquoe a aAe k ace syxel case ausfrac14ax

eges owAgrave dlaquoecq cowUcirccas AgeEgraveads atttreA c w

s ecCuil s

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY the original was sent to Florida Supreme Court at 500 S

Duval Street Tallahassee 32399 and one true copy sent to the Attorney Generals

Office The Capitol PL-01 Tallahassee 32399-1050 all of which which hand-

delivered to a Lake CI mailroom staff for mailing on this (o A day of

Dee_gc 2013

Sincerel

Add Bobby A LaTulip 253688 Lake Correctional Institution 19225 Hwy 27 Clermont FL 34715-9025

bltub 40 xc inmates file

114 Cut fLo91DA 549AEtAE CouRT

09 A Mfrac34LW

Agelam

Ms Cose Ntildeo S Ndo

51mt of ELo9ao A

THORNqgteee_

AWELLEgrave A9PEt4bK

APPEMOI Eth1

O tAC

G

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

6

o e e A see e Awkcsoa v Scie70 Sod bAbs(Ro A

nlaquoaws gpssoA subnMaa ocAgtoos04 se

ah colaquovx a a a Aeaagraves+ese daaacutea ssx asxach 5cse syec

ek xbe secocA teG chas d wh Se xtah co s9(

claquoticaegraveez 64t(040Sisemicrosouma5413s(gatcx3as As AagraveecteA e twl

ecuct cukk on ampgtttis wovoasers o txfrac14 ntildes comoede ad att

microwas o4 amp tecotamp agrave devesebeA adfrac14stwey9seamp+ox cutg was evt

eaxah to laquoq teiektoce SSvtejsoagravernp(Roshc8xmfrac12cause

taeligt o Ae_c beaokdoaguaacute recotagrave attacheeetssuspistiah eclaquovegraves

espee xe xea c( chss we oNcus aso Scse ssues phshy

oux Qusc cfrac14eussioA ifrac14wo we te4eeseA sumar$ deSAring efrac14ootugrave Ocs

araquoh temd aA e+vhesuat$ heoAacute A oA x cha oampNLAear ae

eva541sogtAcamaskocAaxparaesltU ccutxd10 consiAec awk

aampesuekaacutes ches ax glaquoiquest eeas gelaquoxe tlaquoagravew

e outx Oa telaquoadA cout +caamp4e oMg c eoch efrac14+ax agrave

is ectfrac14ec baAg agraveucirck auk svose ltdce4 teocow Sted Qorr agrave s

comEacutee$ teampek k reedmicrotock$ P oss o4 recotAoc

o$ laquosgec4aacute te4eceace mo+e oxtackelth ahoeffrac12x hooduSme

(lu So4 frac14AgravesMot)ltktcA Pntildequcx edSitlaquoxeJSo h C(

(no s rA ocR

63 frac14 vo ampw -themog elaquoses Folt Quesuoaacute -the (040wea

ose c4 Wavachoslashegx cegnte eaxaaampfrac34 ev=fes ahem auml

1

s aA coutx awamp M Efrac14 Dsxact C=sx (oatildeel o

gerax a eeasu kAacute cqgtAh tegagravew Got Ah Colaquotz Sa Ace_ agrave agrave uw

Asquxelda cowxs nues ox10ucirc tekew psaacutevas amp Se seco(ampxo

tehve each gro d ffrac14Aring )efrac12 aacute ograveow tkagrave Ograveutx (oc ox

easxtfrac14eJos ( eolaquos frac14raquo1frac14t Secod Daumlxcagrave1 Cod frac14s oxxachel

xfrac14_ recocA Roc encfrac14o$coud aoagrave bas aso goat a tecod Sc each

c cowds k

t vaak coutx mos arco-cho cts ocograveec 50se

otxions 0Ntilde+e Cecatamp wfrac14ch coachtsmey eswahish

at ogeaax s emraea to wo ttegraveNtilde e zoSe

dans oMawceA a eh agraves teasons 4x so cok

a leepusis

Lersaacuteufrac12e (JuSoakwyGHoamptcAfm

Ta cose axd5e koet coarx ga4e4 Ceasooslashsamp Ae4

seuea oudgfrac14t Aamp sax attacfrac14 as recotA3fg tauoamps ove xkro w

4o4 odsh iAgraveesce aarhc caMugravec s beeA iiusxtonehkx scaQ be

tevfrac14el snee Goux aux cR Gee Amucc coutxs (agravehxhoxfrac34xook cow

wusx cnzoch se specc_ ptvows a4 tecccograve teCux a frac14te_ams

(a u tcnicode4cr b | each groud coms suiquesty254vg

A9cmm troA quesnoa mu

Eocns atyeest Accedilpeass was aa$auxobd o452

case od oraquoe frac14iumlXaNcasG1box codes aacutech frac14frac34frac34 8JegopAcircwa

ougrave oamphe ue veCagravescopy aMomacheess requugraveeeerax

Mies case is M 5uguoca)e Me a ocagraveecs a541

smaacuteb de p his Me 3s37e maacute uns deaacuteeograve oae s

CeRelaquo a o e coaxean oQ Ws ph ogteeeea-s( eucx s

o 6a hoMp)oaewer(x ampamp aax axxlaquoch o e o e

a ee e x oc an oxfrac14c microagas ofrac14 tecA zo coachsisve ce

e3 IA xfrac14 svraquocurren eoaelig$e qea ogeeeem(oamp+cee

s3 ue e anonefrac14c goud Gabuxg1agrave asgeoaks

ehwe gachlaquox rlaquoecxeak e slaquopyx e

cs pagcqh o570theAtoyeax frac14lt Ques 04 thorn elose

renovhamp 6etimesvA eux agraveecAes xo A e e

es ixs gtecause we cheCeakam claquoagraves are eoslashacksm$ teh

tecocagrave cout sfrac14Ah laquovtlaquochk egcognoxe- poco as oC+e reco

xo te ocagraveeEcircDe- o+ec cce is Sekenfrac14eKn4k(Rashtr

ofrac34)3(3goo a040d cSehaacute issusq oA tesi mah cowx sougrave e

et$ec c to4x Se souA oc growle_5e_ comgde_ c e

M oxxacheeAc o CecoCEcirclt040x3groas

seyesx is w+ommetugrave)

A otAlaquo Mch sumoih$ deaies a o c

laquoMd e de-oasxtne laquoe co t eowa e e e o

Muagrave laquovaaringg e pxas 09 tecocAgrave ok ch cowlus dero shy

sxcom e AeSeAax aacute emaacuteeampo as tamp en M L s e

ongss-sdRaxovuAcxeacutepound uns(AadRaMpppounddegu4(bYMe (quexg Vdlaquoc$tcQ) cm$ xh wese middotwo scoeedud cubes

oampxfrac14e courts aampwtte m decom oPSxose becisd

Cot4CL10t4

Seth e toraquoet -etisA ce cs eccek wfrac14 a deacuteh sx coAshy

ekwaeg tepoundlaquoe A lt4 Ly s ssaelig teuds wxw tecltxA oweend

s ooslashe caA peraquoaq seeltomtke costs agravefrac14ahnh RochS em

Coutx laquoeA cagrave bcsx Cowxs kJ assurel us FA SW4

|ac 94MNMb570AringNtildeh EcircAringweh a8Aacute cho ceAringed us 1x

ea xyenese Quks are sv Qoonel because oboc 3 teasma58 cet

gte recoscleh (oc enfrac14er ow eade x he oc oiker opcoshy

aclaquoe oews

Ia smsd cowx erlteh ad xfrac14gt Asz( cousx eAfrac14aaeel

eic middoteccot whea no (dow Meme 570cdeck k e4

noce Dectss as Aenoslashssraxek meiwa

frac14keAvsogg Agelaquoax ampys x kaos pesamkcee gch

ou quewoes xh Mvh acyeass v xfrac14s uasaye Coutx Aamp1kcea

oesua s are (eodnoamp cecoch laquoxaakm cefrac12temamp pace

emce d eteax (m oraquoe a aAe k ace syxel case ausfrac14ax

eges owAgrave dlaquoecq cowUcirccas AgeEgraveads atttreA c w

s ecCuil s

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY the original was sent to Florida Supreme Court at 500 S

Duval Street Tallahassee 32399 and one true copy sent to the Attorney Generals

Office The Capitol PL-01 Tallahassee 32399-1050 all of which which hand-

delivered to a Lake CI mailroom staff for mailing on this (o A day of

Dee_gc 2013

Sincerel

Add Bobby A LaTulip 253688 Lake Correctional Institution 19225 Hwy 27 Clermont FL 34715-9025

bltub 40 xc inmates file

114 Cut fLo91DA 549AEtAE CouRT

09 A Mfrac34LW

Agelam

Ms Cose Ntildeo S Ndo

51mt of ELo9ao A

THORNqgteee_

AWELLEgrave A9PEt4bK

APPEMOI Eth1

O tAC

G

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

s aA coutx awamp M Efrac14 Dsxact C=sx (oatildeel o

gerax a eeasu kAacute cqgtAh tegagravew Got Ah Colaquotz Sa Ace_ agrave agrave uw

Asquxelda cowxs nues ox10ucirc tekew psaacutevas amp Se seco(ampxo

tehve each gro d ffrac14Aring )efrac12 aacute ograveow tkagrave Ograveutx (oc ox

easxtfrac14eJos ( eolaquos frac14raquo1frac14t Secod Daumlxcagrave1 Cod frac14s oxxachel

xfrac14_ recocA Roc encfrac14o$coud aoagrave bas aso goat a tecod Sc each

c cowds k

t vaak coutx mos arco-cho cts ocograveec 50se

otxions 0Ntilde+e Cecatamp wfrac14ch coachtsmey eswahish

at ogeaax s emraea to wo ttegraveNtilde e zoSe

dans oMawceA a eh agraves teasons 4x so cok

a leepusis

Lersaacuteufrac12e (JuSoakwyGHoamptcAfm

Ta cose axd5e koet coarx ga4e4 Ceasooslashsamp Ae4

seuea oudgfrac14t Aamp sax attacfrac14 as recotA3fg tauoamps ove xkro w

4o4 odsh iAgraveesce aarhc caMugravec s beeA iiusxtonehkx scaQ be

tevfrac14el snee Goux aux cR Gee Amucc coutxs (agravehxhoxfrac34xook cow

wusx cnzoch se specc_ ptvows a4 tecccograve teCux a frac14te_ams

(a u tcnicode4cr b | each groud coms suiquesty254vg

A9cmm troA quesnoa mu

Eocns atyeest Accedilpeass was aa$auxobd o452

case od oraquoe frac14iumlXaNcasG1box codes aacutech frac14frac34frac34 8JegopAcircwa

ougrave oamphe ue veCagravescopy aMomacheess requugraveeeerax

Mies case is M 5uguoca)e Me a ocagraveecs a541

smaacuteb de p his Me 3s37e maacute uns deaacuteeograve oae s

CeRelaquo a o e coaxean oQ Ws ph ogteeeea-s( eucx s

o 6a hoMp)oaewer(x ampamp aax axxlaquoch o e o e

a ee e x oc an oxfrac14c microagas ofrac14 tecA zo coachsisve ce

e3 IA xfrac14 svraquocurren eoaelig$e qea ogeeeem(oamp+cee

s3 ue e anonefrac14c goud Gabuxg1agrave asgeoaks

ehwe gachlaquox rlaquoecxeak e slaquopyx e

cs pagcqh o570theAtoyeax frac14lt Ques 04 thorn elose

renovhamp 6etimesvA eux agraveecAes xo A e e

es ixs gtecause we cheCeakam claquoagraves are eoslashacksm$ teh

tecocagrave cout sfrac14Ah laquovtlaquochk egcognoxe- poco as oC+e reco

xo te ocagraveeEcircDe- o+ec cce is Sekenfrac14eKn4k(Rashtr

ofrac34)3(3goo a040d cSehaacute issusq oA tesi mah cowx sougrave e

et$ec c to4x Se souA oc growle_5e_ comgde_ c e

M oxxacheeAc o CecoCEcirclt040x3groas

seyesx is w+ommetugrave)

A otAlaquo Mch sumoih$ deaies a o c

laquoMd e de-oasxtne laquoe co t eowa e e e o

Muagrave laquovaaringg e pxas 09 tecocAgrave ok ch cowlus dero shy

sxcom e AeSeAax aacute emaacuteeampo as tamp en M L s e

ongss-sdRaxovuAcxeacutepound uns(AadRaMpppounddegu4(bYMe (quexg Vdlaquoc$tcQ) cm$ xh wese middotwo scoeedud cubes

oampxfrac14e courts aampwtte m decom oPSxose becisd

Cot4CL10t4

Seth e toraquoet -etisA ce cs eccek wfrac14 a deacuteh sx coAshy

ekwaeg tepoundlaquoe A lt4 Ly s ssaelig teuds wxw tecltxA oweend

s ooslashe caA peraquoaq seeltomtke costs agravefrac14ahnh RochS em

Coutx laquoeA cagrave bcsx Cowxs kJ assurel us FA SW4

|ac 94MNMb570AringNtildeh EcircAringweh a8Aacute cho ceAringed us 1x

ea xyenese Quks are sv Qoonel because oboc 3 teasma58 cet

gte recoscleh (oc enfrac14er ow eade x he oc oiker opcoshy

aclaquoe oews

Ia smsd cowx erlteh ad xfrac14gt Asz( cousx eAfrac14aaeel

eic middoteccot whea no (dow Meme 570cdeck k e4

noce Dectss as Aenoslashssraxek meiwa

frac14keAvsogg Agelaquoax ampys x kaos pesamkcee gch

ou quewoes xh Mvh acyeass v xfrac14s uasaye Coutx Aamp1kcea

oesua s are (eodnoamp cecoch laquoxaakm cefrac12temamp pace

emce d eteax (m oraquoe a aAe k ace syxel case ausfrac14ax

eges owAgrave dlaquoecq cowUcirccas AgeEgraveads atttreA c w

s ecCuil s

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY the original was sent to Florida Supreme Court at 500 S

Duval Street Tallahassee 32399 and one true copy sent to the Attorney Generals

Office The Capitol PL-01 Tallahassee 32399-1050 all of which which hand-

delivered to a Lake CI mailroom staff for mailing on this (o A day of

Dee_gc 2013

Sincerel

Add Bobby A LaTulip 253688 Lake Correctional Institution 19225 Hwy 27 Clermont FL 34715-9025

bltub 40 xc inmates file

114 Cut fLo91DA 549AEtAE CouRT

09 A Mfrac34LW

Agelam

Ms Cose Ntildeo S Ndo

51mt of ELo9ao A

THORNqgteee_

AWELLEgrave A9PEt4bK

APPEMOI Eth1

O tAC

G

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

ougrave oamphe ue veCagravescopy aMomacheess requugraveeeerax

Mies case is M 5uguoca)e Me a ocagraveecs a541

smaacuteb de p his Me 3s37e maacute uns deaacuteeograve oae s

CeRelaquo a o e coaxean oQ Ws ph ogteeeea-s( eucx s

o 6a hoMp)oaewer(x ampamp aax axxlaquoch o e o e

a ee e x oc an oxfrac14c microagas ofrac14 tecA zo coachsisve ce

e3 IA xfrac14 svraquocurren eoaelig$e qea ogeeeem(oamp+cee

s3 ue e anonefrac14c goud Gabuxg1agrave asgeoaks

ehwe gachlaquox rlaquoecxeak e slaquopyx e

cs pagcqh o570theAtoyeax frac14lt Ques 04 thorn elose

renovhamp 6etimesvA eux agraveecAes xo A e e

es ixs gtecause we cheCeakam claquoagraves are eoslashacksm$ teh

tecocagrave cout sfrac14Ah laquovtlaquochk egcognoxe- poco as oC+e reco

xo te ocagraveeEcircDe- o+ec cce is Sekenfrac14eKn4k(Rashtr

ofrac34)3(3goo a040d cSehaacute issusq oA tesi mah cowx sougrave e

et$ec c to4x Se souA oc growle_5e_ comgde_ c e

M oxxacheeAc o CecoCEcirclt040x3groas

seyesx is w+ommetugrave)

A otAlaquo Mch sumoih$ deaies a o c

laquoMd e de-oasxtne laquoe co t eowa e e e o

Muagrave laquovaaringg e pxas 09 tecocAgrave ok ch cowlus dero shy

sxcom e AeSeAax aacute emaacuteeampo as tamp en M L s e

ongss-sdRaxovuAcxeacutepound uns(AadRaMpppounddegu4(bYMe (quexg Vdlaquoc$tcQ) cm$ xh wese middotwo scoeedud cubes

oampxfrac14e courts aampwtte m decom oPSxose becisd

Cot4CL10t4

Seth e toraquoet -etisA ce cs eccek wfrac14 a deacuteh sx coAshy

ekwaeg tepoundlaquoe A lt4 Ly s ssaelig teuds wxw tecltxA oweend

s ooslashe caA peraquoaq seeltomtke costs agravefrac14ahnh RochS em

Coutx laquoeA cagrave bcsx Cowxs kJ assurel us FA SW4

|ac 94MNMb570AringNtildeh EcircAringweh a8Aacute cho ceAringed us 1x

ea xyenese Quks are sv Qoonel because oboc 3 teasma58 cet

gte recoscleh (oc enfrac14er ow eade x he oc oiker opcoshy

aclaquoe oews

Ia smsd cowx erlteh ad xfrac14gt Asz( cousx eAfrac14aaeel

eic middoteccot whea no (dow Meme 570cdeck k e4

noce Dectss as Aenoslashssraxek meiwa

frac14keAvsogg Agelaquoax ampys x kaos pesamkcee gch

ou quewoes xh Mvh acyeass v xfrac14s uasaye Coutx Aamp1kcea

oesua s are (eodnoamp cecoch laquoxaakm cefrac12temamp pace

emce d eteax (m oraquoe a aAe k ace syxel case ausfrac14ax

eges owAgrave dlaquoecq cowUcirccas AgeEgraveads atttreA c w

s ecCuil s

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY the original was sent to Florida Supreme Court at 500 S

Duval Street Tallahassee 32399 and one true copy sent to the Attorney Generals

Office The Capitol PL-01 Tallahassee 32399-1050 all of which which hand-

delivered to a Lake CI mailroom staff for mailing on this (o A day of

Dee_gc 2013

Sincerel

Add Bobby A LaTulip 253688 Lake Correctional Institution 19225 Hwy 27 Clermont FL 34715-9025

bltub 40 xc inmates file

114 Cut fLo91DA 549AEtAE CouRT

09 A Mfrac34LW

Agelam

Ms Cose Ntildeo S Ndo

51mt of ELo9ao A

THORNqgteee_

AWELLEgrave A9PEt4bK

APPEMOI Eth1

O tAC

G

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

ongss-sdRaxovuAcxeacutepound uns(AadRaMpppounddegu4(bYMe (quexg Vdlaquoc$tcQ) cm$ xh wese middotwo scoeedud cubes

oampxfrac14e courts aampwtte m decom oPSxose becisd

Cot4CL10t4

Seth e toraquoet -etisA ce cs eccek wfrac14 a deacuteh sx coAshy

ekwaeg tepoundlaquoe A lt4 Ly s ssaelig teuds wxw tecltxA oweend

s ooslashe caA peraquoaq seeltomtke costs agravefrac14ahnh RochS em

Coutx laquoeA cagrave bcsx Cowxs kJ assurel us FA SW4

|ac 94MNMb570AringNtildeh EcircAringweh a8Aacute cho ceAringed us 1x

ea xyenese Quks are sv Qoonel because oboc 3 teasma58 cet

gte recoscleh (oc enfrac14er ow eade x he oc oiker opcoshy

aclaquoe oews

Ia smsd cowx erlteh ad xfrac14gt Asz( cousx eAfrac14aaeel

eic middoteccot whea no (dow Meme 570cdeck k e4

noce Dectss as Aenoslashssraxek meiwa

frac14keAvsogg Agelaquoax ampys x kaos pesamkcee gch

ou quewoes xh Mvh acyeass v xfrac14s uasaye Coutx Aamp1kcea

oesua s are (eodnoamp cecoch laquoxaakm cefrac12temamp pace

emce d eteax (m oraquoe a aAe k ace syxel case ausfrac14ax

eges owAgrave dlaquoecq cowUcirccas AgeEgraveads atttreA c w

s ecCuil s

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY the original was sent to Florida Supreme Court at 500 S

Duval Street Tallahassee 32399 and one true copy sent to the Attorney Generals

Office The Capitol PL-01 Tallahassee 32399-1050 all of which which hand-

delivered to a Lake CI mailroom staff for mailing on this (o A day of

Dee_gc 2013

Sincerel

Add Bobby A LaTulip 253688 Lake Correctional Institution 19225 Hwy 27 Clermont FL 34715-9025

bltub 40 xc inmates file

114 Cut fLo91DA 549AEtAE CouRT

09 A Mfrac34LW

Agelam

Ms Cose Ntildeo S Ndo

51mt of ELo9ao A

THORNqgteee_

AWELLEgrave A9PEt4bK

APPEMOI Eth1

O tAC

G

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY the original was sent to Florida Supreme Court at 500 S

Duval Street Tallahassee 32399 and one true copy sent to the Attorney Generals

Office The Capitol PL-01 Tallahassee 32399-1050 all of which which hand-

delivered to a Lake CI mailroom staff for mailing on this (o A day of

Dee_gc 2013

Sincerel

Add Bobby A LaTulip 253688 Lake Correctional Institution 19225 Hwy 27 Clermont FL 34715-9025

bltub 40 xc inmates file

114 Cut fLo91DA 549AEtAE CouRT

09 A Mfrac34LW

Agelam

Ms Cose Ntildeo S Ndo

51mt of ELo9ao A

THORNqgteee_

AWELLEgrave A9PEt4bK

APPEMOI Eth1

O tAC

G

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

114 Cut fLo91DA 549AEtAE CouRT

09 A Mfrac34LW

Agelam

Ms Cose Ntildeo S Ndo

51mt of ELo9ao A

THORNqgteee_

AWELLEgrave A9PEt4bK

APPEMOI Eth1

O tAC

G

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

APPEMOI Eth1

O tAC

G

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA FIFTH DISTRICT JULY TERM 2013

NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPlRES TO FILE MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DISPOSITION THEREOF IF FILED

BOBBY A LATULIP

Appellant

v Case No 5D13-430

STATE OF FLORIDA

Appellee

Opinion filed July 19 2013

3850 Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hernando County Daniel B Merritt Sr Judge

Bobby A Latulip Clermont pro se

Pamela Jo Bondi Attorney General Tallahassee and Lori N Hagan Assistant Attorney General Daytona Beach for Appellee

PER CURIAM

Bobby A LaTulip appeals from the(summary denial)of his seven-issue Rule

3850 Motion for Postconviction Relief filed after LaTulip entered what appears to have

been a favorable negotiated plea to charges in two separate cases In denying relief

the trial court described most of the claims as(facially insufficient)which could lead a

reader to conclude that the trial court simply identified pleading deficiencies such that

LaTulip should have been given an opportunity to amend his postconviction motion

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2

1 So 2d 754 (Fla 2007) However the denial order identified no

pleading deficiencies Rather e trial court addressed the of each claim

explaining why LaTulip was not legally entitled to relief as to each The trial court was

correct in its analysis and denial of LaTulips claims on the g e ts and we affirm)-- Ntildeo

AFFIRMED

ORFINGER LAWSON and BERGER JJ concur

2