Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie...

20
Climate Sensitivities of ENSO Bridging theory, observations, and modeling Andrew Wittenberg GFDL/NOAA, Princeton, New Jersey, USA Thanks to: Gabriel Vecchi, Qian Song, and Anthony Rosati

Transcript of Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie...

Page 1: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

Climate Sensitivities of ENSO

Bridging theory, observations, and modeling

Andrew WittenbergGFDL/NOAA, Princeton, New Jersey, USA

Thanks to: Gabriel Vecchi, Qian Song, and Anthony Rosati

Page 2: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

“Other worlds”  in CGCMs

Page 3: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

Mixed layer temperature anomaly tendency equation

Key to understanding impact of background state on ENSO.

Page 4: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

Mixed layer temperature anomaly tendency equation

Key to understanding impact of background state on ENSO.

Page 5: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

ICM Control Run

Page 6: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

ICM: Impact of trade wind strength

Page 7: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

Blocking the Indonesian Throughflow:

Change in mean SST (degC)

Page 8: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

Blocking the Indonesian Throughflow:

Anomaly patterns (regressed on NINO3)

Page 9: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

Observed SST forcing

Stochastic forcing: A role for the Indian Ocean

Daily west­Pacific zonal stress from 10 AM2 runs

Page 10: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

Observed SST forcing Warm East Indian

Stochastic forcing: A role for the Indian Ocean

Daily west­Pacific zonal stress from 10 AM2 runs

Page 11: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

Summary

1) CGCMs: “Other Worlds”

2) Mixed layer heat budget & “f requency budget”

3) ICM: perturbations seed feedbacks, which alter ENSO

4) CM2: flux anomaly patterns sensitive to background

5) WWBs, nonlinearity, and a role for the Indian Ocean

Page 12: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

CM2 greenhouse response

Page 13: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

Equatorial adjustment to off­equatorial stress

Page 14: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

ICM: Different climate perturbations, similar effects

Page 15: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

CM2 anomaly patterns: Wind stress

Page 16: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

CM2 anomaly patterns: Surface heat flux

Page 17: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

A wide variety of products

Page 18: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

ICM: Mixed layer heat budget

Page 19: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

Hybrid CGCM mixed layer heat budget

Page 20: Andrew Wittenberg - GFDL Extranetatw/yr/2005/clim_enso.pdf · 3.1 yr 3.3yr wmtp flux Tx=O.1 barie 5.5yr wmtp wptm *mtp flux 140t 1800 100'W ... -10 -20 IOO NIT F Precip (mm/day/C)

Impact of weakening equatorial zonal stress