Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

29
+ LESSONS FROM GREATER MSP www.centralcorridoranchorpartnership.org UEDA Annual Summit: September 30, 2014

description

The panel will highlight colleges and universities engaged in formal collaboration initiatives aimed at place-based development that include a diverse set of partners. The discussion will be placed in the context of the anchor strategic framework developed by ICIC and Michael Porter. Representatives from successful collaboration initiatives in Minneapolis and Syracuse will share insights from their experience with this approach including the challenges associated with effectively managing and aligning multiple partners.

Transcript of Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Page 2: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Overview

• Background & Context• Structure & Process• Goals & Progress to Date• Lessons and Discussion

Page 3: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Background – Regional Context$1 billion Central Corridor (GREEN LINE) investment in new LRT Line between MPLS and ST. Paul.

Center Corridor Funders Collaborative Corridors of Opportunity Cedar Riverside Partnership Living Cities Integration Initiative

Page 4: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler
Page 5: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Anchor Economic & Development Opportunities

9 “Meds”, 7 “Eds” 111,500 students enrolled 32,000 anchor Ed jobs 35,000 anchor Med jobs $ 2 Billion annual spend 100+ major capital projects $5B+ capital investment

Environmental Scan (2011)

5

Page 6: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

6

Page 7: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

7

Page 8: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

8

Page 9: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Goals & Progress

• Five Original Focus Areas:                      Personnel Procurement Last Mile/ Transit           

         Live-Work Engaged Scholarship

• Current Focus Areas: Personnel Procurement Transit/Last

Mile

Page 10: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Organized Around Principle of Shared Value

Benefit for both anchor institutions and Central Corridor communities, especially low income residents

Page 11: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Augsburg CollegeBethel College

Fairview Health Services/U of M Medical CenterHamline University

Metropolitan State UniversityMinneapolis Community & Technical College

Regions Hospital/HealthPartnersSt. Paul College

United Hospital/AllinaUniversity of Minnesota

University of St. CatherineUniversity of St. Thomas

Central Corridor Funders Collaborative

Page 12: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Partnership Organization – August 2012

Memorandum of Understanding 13 Partners Committed• Executive

Leader• Senior Staff

Work Groups• Financial

ContributionsFinancial Support• McKnight• CCFC• Partners

Central Corridor Anchor Partnership

Executive Committee

Coordinating Team

Workforce Work Group

Procurement Work Group

Smith Partners &

Civic Source

Page 13: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Goal:  Grow more representative local workforce

Achieve a workforce among anchor institutions that is more representative of local communities along the Central Corridor in order to contribute to better local health outcomes, improved educational achievement, and increased household incomes.

Page 14: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Indicators of Progress

1. Increase anchor institution employment from Central Corridor zip codes by 5% (1,545 jobs) in 5 years

2. Achieve racial diversity goals across all job categories among Central Corridor anchor institutions in 5 years

3. Reduce the racial employment gap in the Central Corridor zip codes by 4% in 5 years

Page 15: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Health Careers Pathways Matrix

Page 16: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Workforce Strategies

Scrubs Camp Central Corridor Fellows Incumbent Workers – next up Live–Work

Page 17: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Scrubs Camp

2013-2014 St. Paul College

Augsburg

Number of Campers 68 128Students of Color 68% 66%

Page 18: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Central Corridor Fellows

• Part time positions for MCTC and SPC healthcare students

• Hospitals, clinics, and long-term care

• Goal of 50 Fellows in 2013 & 200 by end of 2014

• Mentoring seminars

Page 19: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Live-Work

• Promoting Central Corridor residence for anchor employees Reduces household

(Housing + Transportation) costs

Existing program incentives in place

Home Ownership training Location-efficient mortgage

exploration

Page 20: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Goal: Grow Local Purchasing

Create wealth in communities adjacent to the Central Corridor by focusing and aggregating the demand from the Anchor institutions to local suppliers that employ and invest in the community.

Page 21: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Indicators of Success

• Baseline: $293M in Corridor vendors 2012

• Increase anchor purchasing from Corridor vendors by 5% ($18M) in 5 years

• Provide cost savings to anchors

Page 22: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Procurement Initiatives 2013

2013 2014

Appliances Contract $100,000 $250,000

Window Cleaning Contract

$130,000-$150,000

$200,000-250,000

Snow Removal Contract $600,000-$1.0M $1.8M-$2.4M

Total $1.25M $2.9M

Page 24: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Goal: Increase anchor employee and student transit ridership 5% in 5 years

• Kick-off Campaign: 1700 deeply discounted GO TO cards for opening of Green Line (June 2014) and Start of School year 2014.

• Discount Fare Program – Students• Metro transit use by employees low (only 10%)• College Pass - $175 per semester• U-Pass - $97 per sem.

• Last Mile Connections• Wayfinding• Institution Infrastructure

Page 25: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Early Learnings & Practice

Presidents Involvement & buy-in Champions at the “worker” level “Glue and Grease $” - Centrality of mission Early wins with an eye toward systems change Value represented in self-funding commitments Shared Resolutions among CEO’s Building a positive narrative of behaviors,

actions, and outcomes. Build from actions and strengths

Page 27: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler
Page 28: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Background - History

Living Cities Symposium on Anchor Institutions

Staff Working Group• Corridors of

Opportunity • CCFC• McKnight• Augsburg• Itasca• U of M• Health

PartnersFocus on "3 Ps"• Personnel• Procurement • Placemaking

McKnight Funds Environmental Scan“Anchor Activities and Plans re: 3 Ps "Phase 1""

CCAP Inaugural Meeting Aug 29, 2012

Paul Pribbenow, Mary Brainerd, Kate Wolford Host Half Day Session of Executive Leaders of 18 Anchors Nov 2, 2011

Personnel and Procurement Work Groups Convened to Explore Viability of Anchor Collaboration

Report Confirms Viability & Recommends Anchor Partnership Formation "Phase II"

Jun 2011

Nov 2011

Mar 2012

Jun 2012

Dec 2013

CCAP Meeting Nov 26, 2012

CCAP Meeting Apr 2, 2013

CCAP Meeting Jul 22, 2013

CCAP Meeting Oct 31, 2013

Joint Meeting CCAP & CCFC Dec 12, 2013

CCFC Hosts Anchor Learning Session Nov 3, 2011

Page 29: Anchor Collaboration Models for Collective Impact - Eric Muschler

Dashboard