Analysis of Financial Assets of Council of Ministers of ...adrindia.org/sites/default/files/Analysis...
Transcript of Analysis of Financial Assets of Council of Ministers of ...adrindia.org/sites/default/files/Analysis...
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 1 of 20
Analysis of Financial Assets of Council of Ministers of Rajasthan (based on
the annual declarations made in 2012) Summary and Highlights:
A Letter dated 17th December, 2009 from the Union Home Ministry was sent to the Rajasthan Government that asked for the introduction of a mechanism for annual declaration of assets by the Council of Ministers.
The Rajasthan Government agreed to the communication from the Union Home Ministry dated 21st January, 2010 regarding the Code of Conduct of Ministers. According to this letter from the Home Ministry, Ministers are now supposed to disclose particulars of all immovable properties and the total approximate value of (1) shares and debentures, (2) cash holdings and(3)jewellery pertaining to themselves and their family members.
As per Para 1 of the Code of Conduct for Ministers, Ministers are required to furnish a Statement of Assets and Liabilities, and business interests of himself and his family members, immediately after entering office, and in any case within a period of two months from the date of assumption of office.This applies to Ministers of State Government and Union Territories also. As per Para 2(a) of the Code of Conduct for Ministers, “a Minister shall furnish annually by the 31st of August to the Prime Minister ,or the Chief Minister, as the case may be, a declaration regarding his assets and liabilities for the previous Financial Year.”
National Election Watch (NEW) has analyzed asset declarations of all those 23 Ministers of Rajasthan who made asset declarations in 2012. (Asset declarations of 4 Council of Ministers for 2012 are unavailable namely Brij Kishore
Sharma, Bharat Singh, Mangeelal Garasia and Rajendra Singh Guda)
From our analysis of the annual Asset Declarations of the Rajasthan Council of Ministers, 3 points have stood out:
There is no standard format (similar to the ECI’s format for affidavits to be submitted by contesting candiates at the time of nominations for elections) according to which annual asset declarations are made by Ministers. This provides the opportunity to a Minister to use his own discretion in declaring assets. For example, most of the Ministers have not been declaring the assets belonging to their spouse and dependents.
Even the assets that the Ministers do declare in their annual declarations, the rupee value for lots of these assets (eg. Plots of land, building, shops, and vehicles) are not declared specifically.
In some cases Assets that have been declared by the Ministers 2008 are altogether missing from their latest declarations.
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 2 of 20
Crorepati Ministers
Prima facie almost all the Ministers, for whom the self-declared information regarding assets has been analyzed, appear crorepatis. It is difficult to assess the current value (in Rupees) of the assets possessed by these Ministers because they have not declared the Rupee Value of the many assets like landholdings, buildings, vehicles etc.
Liabilities
Only 6 out of the 23 Ministers analyzed have declared that they have liabilities. The 17 other Ministers have not declared any liabilities.
Ministers who have declared liabilities
The top three Ministers with highest declared liabilities are (in decreasing order): Babu Lal Nagar, (MOS(Independent) for Khadi and dairy)who has declared the highest liabilities worth Rs. 1.18 Crores ,followed by Mahendrajeet Singh Malviya (Minister of Tribal Area Development and Rural Development) with liabilities of Rs. 44.32 Lakhs and Aimaduddin Ahmad (Minister of Medical and Health, Family Welfare) with liabilities of Rs. 38.29 Lakhs.
Ministers displaying higher degree of transparency
Out of the 23 Council of Ministers analyzed, 5 Ministers have even declared their income by making their Income Tax Retuns document public. They are, Murali Lal Meena (MOS(Independent) for Technical Education and PWD), who declared his income to be Rs. 6.58 Lakh, Dr. Rajkumar Sharma (MOS(Independent) for Science and Technology) who declared his income to be Rs. 5.08 Lakhs, Rajendra Pareek (Minister of Industry) who declared his income to be Rs. 4.82 Lakh, Hema Ram Chaudhury (Minister of Revenue) who declared his income to be Rs. 3.02 Lakhs, and Virendra Beniwal (MOS for Home and Transport(Independent)) who declared his income to be Rs. 2.04 Lakhs.
Toll-free Helpline (1-800-110-440) to help voters to choose honest candidates and SMS MYNETA <Pincode> to 9246556070 or MYNETA <Constituency name> to 9246556070.
Jaipur, March 21st, 2013: Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) and Rajasthan Election Watch (REW), the Rajasthan chapter of National Election Watch (NEW), a nationwide campaign comprising of more than 1200 NGOs and other citizen led organizations, has been working on electoral reforms, improving democracy and governance in India. Rajasthan Election Watch (REW) has analyzed asset declarations of 23 Council of Ministers in 2012. This report is based on the analysis of these asset declarations.
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 3 of 20
Table of Contents ANALYSIS BASED ON ASSETS ...................................................................................................... 3
DECLARATION OF ASSETS BY MINISTERS ...............................................................................................................................3
TOP 5 MINISTERS WITH HIGH ASSETS IN 2008 AND THEIR ASSETS IN 2012. ...................................................................................4
TOP 5 MINISTERS WITH LOWEST ASSETS IN 2008 AND THEIR ASSETS IN 2012. ................................... ERROR! BOOKMARK NOT DEFINED.
MINISTERS WHO HAVE DECLARED LIABILITIES .........................................................................................................................9
MINISTERS WHO HAVE MADE THEIR INCOME TAX RETURNS PUBLIC .............................................................................................9
MINISTERS WHO HAVE NOT MADE ASSET DECLARATIONS IN 2012 ............................................................................................ 10
FULL ASSET DETAILS OF RAJASTHAN COUNCIL OF MINISTERS (AS PER 2012 DECLARATION) .. 11
Analysis based on assets
Declaration of Assets by Ministers
The table below provides details of the years for which the asset declarations made by Ministers are
available.
S.No. Name Ministry Declaration in 2009 Declaration in
2010 Declaration in
2011 Declaration in
2012
1 Sh. Ashok Gehlot
Chief Minister, Minister of
Finance,Planning,Civil Aviation
✖ ✓ ✓ ✓
2 Sh. Aimaduddin
Ahmad Minister of Medical and Health, Family Welfare
✖ ✓ ✓ ✓
3 Bina Kak Minister of Tourism ✖ ✓ ✓ ✓
4 Dr. Jitendra
Singh Minister of Energy ✖ ✓ ✓ ✓
5 Sh. Brij Kishore
Sharma
Minister of Primary Education and
Secondary Education ✓ ✓ ✓ ✖
6 Sh. Harji Ram
Burdak Minister of Agriculture ✖ ✓ ✓ ✓
7 Sh. Hema Ram
Chaudhary Minister of Revenue ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
8 Sh.
Mahendrajeet Singh Malviya
Minister of Tribal Area Development and Rural
Development ✖ ✓ ✓ ✓
9 Sh. Parsadi Lal
Meena Minister of
Cooperatives ✖ ✓ ✓ ✓
10 Sh. Rajendra
Pareek Minister of Industry ✖ ✓ ✖ ✓
11 Sh. Shanti Kumar
Dhariwal Minister of Urban
Development ✖ ✓ ✓ ✓
12 Sh.Bharat Singh Minister of Public
Works Department ✓ ✓ ✓ ✖
13 Sh. Ashok Bairwa Minister for Social
Justice and Empowerment
✖ ✓ ✓ ✓
14 Smt. Naseem Akhtar Insaf
MOS for Education ✖ ✖ ✓ ✓
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 4 of 20
S.No. Name Ministry Declaration in 2009 Declaration in
2010 Declaration in
2011 Declaration in
2012
15 Smt. Manju Devi MOS for Women and Child Development
✖ ✖ ✓ ✓
16 Sh. Dayaram
Parmar MOS(Independent) for
Higher Education ✖ ✖ ✓ ✓
17 Sh Vinod Kumar
Lilawali MOS for Rural Development
✖ ✖ ✓ ✓
18 Sh. Babu Lal
Nagar MOS(Independent) for
Khadi and dairy ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
19 Sh. Brijendra
Singh Ola
Minister of Irrigated Regional Development
and Disaster ✖ ✖ ✓ ✓
20 Dr. Rajkumar
Sharma MOS(Independent) for
Science and Technology ✖ ✓ ✓ ✓
21 Gurmeet Singh
Kunnar
MOS(Independent) for Agricultural Marketing and Water Resources
✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
22 Sh.Mangeelal
Garasia
MOS(Independent) for Labour and
Employment ✓ ✓ ✓ ✖
23 Sh. Murari Lal
Meena
MOS(Independent) for Technical Education
and PWD ✓ ✓ ✓ ✓
24 Sh Rajendra Singh Guda
MOS(Independent) for Civil Defense
✖ ✓ ✖ ✖
25 Sh. Ramkishore
Saini MOS(Independent) for
Prisons ✖ ✓ ✓ ✓
26 Sh. Virendra
Beniwal MOS for Home and
Transport(Independent) ✖ ✖ ✓ ✓
27 Sh. Ameen Khan MOS for Minority
Mamlat ✖ ✖ ✓ ✓
Table 1:-Details of the years for which asset declarations of Ministers are available
✓ Stands for availability of Declaration ✖ Stands for unavailability of declaration
Top 5 Ministers who were richest Ministers in 2008 and their asset declaration in 2012.
The table-2 below provides details of latest annual asset declaration of 5 Ministers who ranked highest
among Rajasthan Ministers according to the assets declared by them in their self sworn affidavits, which
they submitted with the ECI, in the 2008 Rajasthan Assembly Elections.
Gurmeet Singh Kunnar: Gurmeet Singh Kunnar declared the highest assets among Ministers in the
2008 Assembly Elections, worth Rs 8.78 Crore. However, in 2012, Gurmeet Singh hasn’t declared
details of Cash, bank deposits, NSS and Jewellery which were part of his declaration in 2008.
Shanti Kumar Dhariwal: Shanti Kumar Dhariwal declared assets worth Rs 5.51 Crore in 2008.
However, In his declaration in 2012 he has not included Values of 2 Insurance Policies and 1 Vehicle.
Aimaduddin Ahmad: Aimaduddin Ahmad declared assets worth Rs 3.67 Crore in 2008. However,
Aimaduddin Ahmad in his declaration in 2012 has not given values of multiple assets including Bonds,
Debentures, Shares, 3 Vehicles, 5 plots of agricultural land and 2 Commercial buildings.
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 5 of 20
Hema Ram Chaudhary: Hema Ram Chaudhary declared assets worth Rs 2.69 Crore in 2008. However
in 2012 Hema Ram Chaudhary has not declared details of some properties that he had declared in
2008. Moreover, he has also not provided value of 1 Vehicle.
Dr.Jitendra Singh: Dr. Jitendra Singh declared assets worth Rs 2.22 Crore in 2008. However, Jitendra
Singh has not declared details of Jewellery in 2012 which he had declared in 2008. Moreover, he has
not provided values of commercial buildings, declared by him in 2012.
The table below provides details of movable and immovable components of assets declared by the above
Ministers in 2012. The table also shows their assets that they declared in 2012. The table also tabulates the
assets declared by the Ministers for which rupee value has not been provided:
S. No. Name of the Minister
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
1 Gurmeet Singh
Kunnar
8,78,12,862
8 Crore+
99,34,775 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Bonds, Debentures and
Shares : Rs 99,34,775
2,36,46,751 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land:
Rs 11,65,500
Non Agricultural Land:
Rs 70,47,776
Commercial Buildings: Rs 14,00,705
Residential Buildings:
Rs 1,40,32,770
2 Sh. Shanti Kumar
Dhariwal
5,51,35,433
5 Crore+
96,75,441 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 3,00,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 59,37,941
Bonds, Debentures and Shares : Rs 5,000
Jewellery: Rs 34,32,500
6,31,00,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Non Agricultural Land:
Rs 14,00,000
Commercial Buildings: Rs 6,17,00,000
LIC or other insurance Policies: ⇒Value not given for LIC,Annual
Premium 10046/-
⇒Value not given for LIC,Annual Premium 9795/-
Vehicles: ⇒Value not given for Scorda 2010
3 Sh. Aimaduddin
Ahmad
3,67,24,606
3 Crore+
35,19,131 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 33,000
43,92,962 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Residential
Bonds, Debentures and Shares : ⇒Value not given for ONGC Share 90
⇒Value not given for JSW Steel Ltd.
New Quantity-4
⇒Value not given for Once Eq ISIN
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 6 of 20
S. No. Name of the Minister
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 30,92,449
Bonds, Debentures and Shares :
Rs 13,72,000
LIC or other insurance Policies: Rs 2,09,713
Personal loans/advance given:
Rs 38,29,522
Jewellery: Rs 2,06,075
Buildings: Rs 43,92,962
No Quantity-90
⇒Value not given for Oriental Bank Quantity 100
⇒Value not given for Reliance Power
Ltd. Quantity-27 Vehicles:
⇒Value not given for Scorpio
⇒Value not given for Maruti Van
⇒Value not given for Jeep
Agricultural Land: ⇒Value not given for Tehsil Jaipur Rajsaw Village Lalrpura Khasra No
194 Equal Share of Daughter
⇒Value not given for Alavar Teh. Tijara Khasra Ni 816 Share of Wife
⇒Value not given for Teh. Jaypur Vill.
Gokulpura Khasra NI 67
⇒Value not given for Tehsil Jaipur,Village Lalarpura
⇒Value not given for Tehsil
Tijara,Village Khohrikala Commercial Buildings:
⇒Value not given for Luharu House Civil Line Jaipur Share Of Wife &
Daughter
⇒Value not given for Nuh Road Tapukada Jila Alavar Khasra Ni 817,
816, 813 Share of Wife
4 Sh. Hema Ram
Chaudhary
2,69,91,224
2 Crore+
33,95,529 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 20,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 26,90,529
LIC or other insurance Policies: Rs 3,10,000
Jewellery: Rs 3,75,000
2,72,00,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 2,28,00,000
Non Agricultural
Land: Rs 15,00,000
Residential Buildings: Rs 29,00,000
Vehicles: ⇒Value not given for Jeep, Mahindra
& Mahindra
5 Dr. Jitendra Singh
2,22,92,390
2 Crore+
59,82,112 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
32,10,178 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 7 of 20
S. No. Name of the Minister
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
Cash:
Rs 1,94,752
Deposits in Banks: Rs 37,91,868
Bonds, Debentures and
Shares : Rs 7,048
NSS, Postal Savings etc:
Rs 1,10,481
LIC or other insurance
Policies: Rs 20,000
Personal loans/advance given:
Rs 13,55,720
Vehicles: Rs 2,96,977
Other assets:
Rs 2,05,266
Agricultural Land: Rs 69,500
Commercial Buildings:
Rs 22,35,000
Residential Buildings: Rs 9,05,678
Table 2: 2012 Annual declarations of 5 Ministers who had highest assets (among Ministers) in 2008 declarations
Top 5 Ministers who had lowest assets among Ministers in 2008 and their asset
declaration in 2012.
The table-3 below provide details of latest annual asset declaration of 5 Ministers who ranked lowest
among Rajasthan Ministers according to the assets declared by them in their self sworn affidavits, which
they submitted with the ECI, in the 2008 Rajasthan Assembly Elections.
Dr Rajkumar Sharma: Rajkumar Sharma declared the lowest assets among Ministers, worth Rs 4.04
Lakhs in 2008. However ,in 2012 he has not given values of 1 Vehicle
Ramkishore Saini: Ram Kishore Saini declared assets worth Rs 7.90 Lakhs in 2008. However, in 2012
he has not given details of Cash, Insurance Policies, Jewellery and commercial buildings which he had
in his declaration in 2008. Saini has also not provided values for 1 Vehicle, 2 pieces of non agricultural
land and 2 residential buildings.
Ameen Khan: Ameen Khan declared assets worth Rs 11.88 Lakhs in 2008. However, in 2012 he has
not given details of Cash, Insurance Policies, Jewellery and commercial buildings which he had in his
declaration in 2008.
Rajendra Pareek: Rajendra Pareek declared assets worth Rs 19.69 Lakhs in 2008. However, Rajendra
Pareek in 2012 has made new declarations of assets such as Cash, NSS, Jewellery, Non agricultural
land and Commercial buildings now in 2012 which he didn’t declare in 2008.
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 8 of 20
Ashok Bairwa: Ashok Bairwa declared assets worth Rs 29.44 Lakhs in 2008.
The table below provides details of movable and immovable components of assets declared by these
Ministers in 2012. The table also shows their assets that they declared in 2012. The table also tabulates the
assets declared by the Ministers for which rupee value has not been provided:
S. No. Name of the Minister
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012
1 Dr. Rajkumar Sharma
4,04,372 4 Lacs+
2,85,481 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 1,00,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 5,481
Jewellery: Rs 1,80,000
0
Vehicles: ⇒Value not given for HERO HONDA
CD100
2 Sh. Ramkishore Saini
7,90,749 7 Lacs+
14,15,504 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Deposits in Banks: Rs 13,30,504
NSS, Postal Savings etc:
Rs 85,000
0 Vehicles: ⇒Value not given for Scooter Bajaj
Chetak 01 Non Agricultural Land:
⇒Value not given for BANDIKUI 01
⇒Value not given for Jaipur 01 Residential Buildings:
⇒Value not given for Bandikui 1 inhrted
⇒Value not given for Bandikui 01
3 Sh. Ameen Khan 11,88,285 11 Lacs+
13,92,891 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Deposits in Banks: Rs 5,42,891
Vehicles: Rs 8,50,000
14,00,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 6,00,000
Commercial Buildings: Rs 5,00,000
Residential Buildings: Rs 3,00,000
4 Sh. Rajendra Pareek 19,69,376 19 Lacs+
59,92,000 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Deposits in Banks: Rs 4,02,000
Personal loans/advance
21,00,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 5,00,000
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 9 of 20
S. No. Name of the Minister
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012
given: Rs 30,90,000
Other assets:
Rs 25,00,000
Residential Buildings:
Rs 3,00,000
Others: Rs 13,00,000
5 Sh. Ashok Bairwa 29,44,990 29 Lacs+
24,69,885 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 2,70,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 1,23,885
LIC or other insurance Policies: Rs 6,00,000
Vehicles: Rs 6,10,000
Jewellery: Rs 10,06,000
84,02,123 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 25,75,000
Non Agricultural
Land: Rs 15,20,000
Commercial Buildings:
Rs 15,00,000
Residential Buildings: Rs 27,66,323
Others: Rs 40,800
Table 3: 2012 Annual declaration of 5 Ministers who had lowest assets (among Ministers) in 2008 declarations
Ministers who have declared liabilities
The table below provides a list of Rajasthan Ministers who have declared liabilities in their 2012 asset declaration
S. No. Name Ministry Liabilities declared in 2012 (Rs)
1 Sh. Babu Lal Nagar MOS(Independent) for Khadi and dairy 1,18,46,338
1 Crore+
2 Sh. Mahendrajeet Singh
Malviya
Minister of Tribal Area Development and Rural Development
44,32,284 44 Lacs+
3 Sh. Aimaduddin Ahmad
Minister of Medical and Health, Family Welfare
38,29,522 38 Lacs+
4 Sh. Murari Lal Meena
MOS(Independent) for Technical Education and PWD
15,00,000 15 Lacs+
5 Sh. Ashok Bairwa
Minister for Social Justice and Empowerment
14,45,514 14 Lacs+
6 Sh. Virendra Beniwal
MOS for Home and Transport(Independent)
8,62,586 8 Lacs+
Table 4: Ministers who declared liabilities
Ministers who have made their Income Tax Returns public
The table below provides a list of Ministers who have also, declared their Income by making their Income
Tax Returns document public
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 10 of 20
S. No. Name Ministry Total Asset as
declared in 2012
The financial year for which income tax return has been
declared
Total income shown by Minister in ITR (Self+Spouse+Dependent)
1 Sh. Murari Lal
Meena
MOS(Independent) for Technical Education and
PWD
3,06,21,893 3 Crore+
2011-2012 6,58,310 6 Lacs+
2 Dr. Rajkumar
Sharma
MOS(Independent) for Science and Technology
2,85,481 2 Lacs+
2010-2011 5,08,063 5 Lacs+
3 Sh.Rajendra
Pareek Minister of Industry
80,92,000 80 Lacs+
2009-2010 4,82,755 4 Lacs+
4
Sh.Hema Ram
Chaudhury Minister of Revenue
3,05,95,529 3 Crore+
2010-2011 3,02,413 3 Lacs+
5 Sh. Virendra
Beniwal
MOS for Home and Transport(Independent)
1,67,33,906 1 Crore+
2011-2012 2,04,144 2 Lacs+
Table 5:-Ministers who have declared their incomes through Income Tax Return document
Ministers who have not made Asset Declarations in 2012
The table below provides asset details of 4 Ministers who have not made Asset Declarations in 2012. Out of these 4 Ministers who have made declarations in 2012, 3 have made declarations in 2011, while 1 has made a declaration in 2010.
S.
No. Name Ministry Year of Declaration
1 Sh. Rajendra Singh
Gudha MOS(Independent) for Civil Defense
2011 Affidavit Not Available - this is 2010 data
2 Sh. Mangi Lal Garasia MOS(Independent) for Labour and
Employment ( 2011 data)
3 Sh. Brijkishore
Sharma Minister of Primary Education and Secondary
Education ( 2011 data)
4 Sh. Bharat Singh Minister of Public Works Department ( 2011 data) Table 6:- Ministers who have not made Asset Declarations in 2012
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 11 of 20
Full Asset details of Rajasthan Council of Ministers (as per 2012 declaration)
S. No. Name
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
1 Sh. Shanti Kumar
Dhariwal
5,51,35,433 5 Crore+
96,75,441 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 3,00,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 59,37,941
Bonds, Debentures and Shares : Rs 5,000
Jewellery: Rs 34,32,500
6,31,00,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Non Agricultural Land:
Rs 14,00,000
Commercial Buildings: Rs 6,17,00,000
LIC or other insurance Policies: ⇒Value not given for LIC,Annual
Premium 10046/-
⇒Value not given for LIC,Annual Premium 9795/-
Vehicles: ⇒Value not given for Scorda 2010
2 Gurmeet Singh
Kunnar
8,78,12,862 8 Crore+
99,34,775 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Bonds, Debentures and Shares :
Rs 99,34,775
2,36,46,751 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 11,65,500
Non Agricultural
Land: Rs 70,47,776
Commercial Buildings: Rs 14,00,705
Residential Buildings:
Rs 1,40,32,770
3 Sh. Murari Lal Meena
2,15,25,253 2 Crore+
22,88,511 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 4,72,592
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 1,57,804
LIC or other insurance Policies: Rs 4,28,148
2,83,33,382 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 50,43,302
Commercial Buildings:
Rs 21,00,000
Residential Buildings: Rs 2,00,60,080
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 12 of 20
S. No. Name
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
Vehicles: Rs 2,50,400
Jewellery: Rs 9,34,565
Other assets:
Rs 45,000
Others:
Rs 11,30,000
4 Sh. Hema Ram
Chaudhary
2,69,91,224 2 Crore+
33,95,529 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 20,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 26,90,529
LIC or other insurance Policies: Rs 3,10,000
Jewellery: Rs 3,75,000
2,72,00,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 2,28,00,000
Non Agricultural
Land: Rs 15,00,000
Residential Buildings:
Rs 29,00,000
Vehicles: ⇒Value not given for Jeep,Mhindra &
Mahindra
5 Sh. Brijendra Singh
Ola
1,73,21,199 1 Crore+
2,08,51,937 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 1,00,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 4,24,575
NSS, Postal Savings etc: Rs 16,28,310
Jewellery: Rs 1,80,000
Other assets: Rs 1,88,64,271
0
Vehicles:
⇒Value not given for Santro car Jewellery:
⇒Value not given for Gold Jeweler 50gm
⇒Value not given for Gold Jeweler
600gm
⇒Value not given for Gold Jeweler 500gm
Agricultural Land: ⇒Value not given for Vill. Ardawata
Teh. Chidawa Dist Jhujhunu Khasra Ni 162 & 108 Total Area
⇒Value not given for Murbba No
34/389 Vill. 10 N.S.W Teh. Pilibanga Dist Hanumangard
⇒Value not given for Khasra Ni 133
Vill. Sinchana Teh. Buhana Dist Jhujhunu
Commercial Buildings: ⇒Value not given for E- 3/9 Mlana
Vill. Dist Bhilwada 1/4 Share Residential Buildings:
⇒Value not given for Plot Ni 96-97 Nagar Sivil Line Jaypur
6 Sh. Mahendrajeet
Singh Malviya
91,27,702 91 Lacs+
36,08,502 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
1,52,55,859 (Total declared Rupee
Value
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 13 of 20
S. No. Name
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
Cash: Rs 1,83,318
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 19,52,879
Personal loans/advance given:
Rs 27,44,249
Vehicles: Rs 8,35,000
Jewellery: Rs 6,37,305
Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 68,66,660
Commercial Buildings: Rs 31,40,000
Residential Buildings: Rs 25,04,950
Others:
Rs 52,94,249
7 Sh. Babu Lal Nagar
1,37,51,590 1 Crore+
9,47,481 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 38,939
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 1,41,982
Vehicles: Rs 7,16,560
Jewellery:
Rs 50,000
1,64,01,772 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 24,98,215
Residential Buildings:
Rs 1,45,21,657
8 Sh. Virendra Beniwal
78,01,546 78 Lacs+
38,82,638 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 1,24,752
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 16,92,353
Bonds, Debentures and Shares : Rs 50,000
NSS, Postal Savings etc:
Rs 12,40,631
Vehicles: Rs 85,200
Jewellery: Rs 6,89,700
1,28,51,268 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 28,40,000
Non Agricultural
Land: Rs 66,50,000
Residential Buildings:
Rs 33,61,268
LIC or other insurance Policies: ⇒Value not given for LIC,Annual
Premium 71145/-
⇒Value not given for LIC,Annual Premium 38621/-
9 Sh. Ashok Bairwa 29,44,990 24,69,885 84,02,123
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 14 of 20
S. No. Name
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
29 Lacs+ (Total declared Rupee Value Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 2,70,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 1,23,885
LIC or other insurance Policies: Rs 6,00,000
Vehicles: Rs 6,10,000
Jewellery: Rs 10,06,000
(Total declared Rupee Value
Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 25,75,000
Non Agricultural
Land: Rs 15,20,000
Commercial Buildings:
Rs 15,00,000
Residential Buildings: Rs 27,66,323
Others: Rs 40,800
10 Smt. Naseem Akhtar
Insaf
47,66,101 47 Lacs+
16,92,683 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 5,61,760
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 6,45,923
Bonds, Debentures and Shares :
LIC or other insurance Policies: Rs 1,25,000
Jewellery: Rs 3,60,000
85,60,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 8,10,000
Commercial Buildings: Rs 75,00,000
Residential Buildings: Rs 32,50,000
11 Sh. Dayaram Parmar
56,24,776 56 Lacs+
45,53,342 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 28,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 50,02,564
LIC or other insurance Policies: Rs 2,50,000
Jewellery: Rs 2,76,000
47,93,500 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 13,93,500
Non Agricultural
Land: Rs 3,00,000
Residential Buildings:
Rs 31,00,000
Vehicles: ⇒Value not given for Jeep, Rg. No.RJ-
12-722
⇒Value not given for Bollero Diesel Car-Reg. No. Rj-27-UA-4311
⇒Value not given for Bollero Diesel
Car-Reg. No. Rj-27-UA-4311 Jewellery:
⇒Value not given for Gold Chain (Wt. 15 Gms)
⇒Value not given for Gold Braslet,
(Wt.4.50 Gram)
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 15 of 20
S. No. Name
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
12 Dr. Jitendra Singh
2,22,92,390 2 Crore+
59,82,112 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 1,94,752
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 37,91,868
Bonds, Debentures and Shares : Rs 7,048
NSS, Postal Savings etc:
Rs 1,10,481
LIC or other insurance Policies: Rs 20,000
Personal loans/advance
given: Rs 13,55,720
Vehicles: Rs 2,96,977
Other assets:
Rs 2,05,266
32,10,178 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 69,500
Commercial Buildings:
Rs 22,35,000
Residential Buildings: Rs 9,05,678
13 Sh. Rajendra Pareek
19,69,376 19 Lacs+
59,92,000 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Deposits in Banks: Rs 4,02,000
Personal loans/advance
given: Rs 30,90,000
Other assets:
Rs 25,00,000
21,00,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 5,00,000
Residential Buildings:
Rs 3,00,000
Others: Rs 13,00,000
14 Sh. Parsadi Lal Meena
45,15,000 45 Lacs+
14,27,059 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 25,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 7,12,058
Jewellery: Rs 6,90,000
65,00,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 25,00,000
Non Agricultural
Land: Rs 5,00,000
Residential Buildings:
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 16 of 20
S. No. Name
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
Rs 35,00,000
15 Sh. Aimaduddin
Ahmad
3,67,24,606 3 Crore+
35,19,131 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 33,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 30,92,449
Bonds, Debentures and Shares :
Rs 13,72,000
LIC or other insurance Policies: Rs 2,09,713
Personal loans/advance
given: Rs 38,29,522
Jewellery: Rs 2,06,075
43,92,962 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Residential Buildings: Rs 43,92,962
Bonds, Debentures and Shares : ⇒Value not given for OAGC Share 90
⇒Value not given for JSW Steel Ltd.
New Quantity-4
⇒Value not given for Once Eq ISIN No Quantity-90
⇒Value not given for Oriental Bank
Quantity 100
⇒Value not given for Reliance Power Ltd. Quantity-27
Vehicles: ⇒Value not given for Scorpio
⇒Value not given for Maruti Van
⇒Value not given for Jeep
Agricultural Land:
⇒Value not given for Tehsil Jaypur Rajsaw Village Lalrpura Khasra No
194 Equal Share of Doughtier
⇒Value not given for Alavar Teh. Tijara Khasra Ni 816 Share of Wife
⇒Value not given for Teh. Jaypur Vill.
Gokulpura Khasra NI 67
⇒Value not given for Tehsil Jaipur,Village Lalarpura
⇒Value not given for Tehsil
Tijara,Village Khohrikala Commercial Buildings:
⇒Value not given for Luharu House Sivil Line Jaypur Share Of Wife &
Doughtier
⇒Value not given for Nuh Road Tapukada Jila Alavar Khasra Ni 817,
816, 813 Share of Wife
16 Sh Vinod Kumar
Lilawali
1,93,72,728 1 Crore+
55,85,979 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 6,00,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 34,10,979
Other assets: Rs 15,75,000
0
Vehicles: ⇒Value not given for Toyota Inova
Model 2010 Jewellery:
⇒Value not given for 92 TOLA JEWELLREY
Agricultural Land: ⇒Value not given for 59 1/2 Bigha,se
15lakh /year earning
⇒Value not given for 3 bigha ,se 75 thosand earning /year
⇒Value not given for Sangria
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 17 of 20
S. No. Name
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
Hanumangarh
⇒Value not given for Hanumangarh chak 17HMH
⇒Value not given for chak 51NGC
Hanumangarh
⇒Value not given for 2LLW Hanumangarh Sangria Non Agricultural Land:
⇒Value not given for Lilawali Sangria
⇒Value not given for Lilawali Sangria
⇒Value not given for Lilawali Sangria
⇒Value not given for 51 NGC Hanumangarh JC.sangria rd.
Commercial Buildings: ⇒Value not given for Hanuman garh
sHOP NO.1
⇒Value not given for SHOP 61a
⇒Value not given for SHOP 61B
⇒Value not given for New Dhanmandi Hanumangarh Jc. 122
1/2shere
⇒Value not given for New Dhanmandi Hanumangarh Jc. 121
Residential Buildings: ⇒Value not given for Lilawali Th
sangria
⇒Value not given for Sawan Colony Ward no 37,
⇒Value not given for RHB Biwadi
⇒Value not given for Sawan Colony
Ward no 37 ,Hanumangarh
17 Bina Kak
1,35,31,000 1 Crore+
33,69,267 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 1,45,000
Vehicles: Rs 2,01,500
Jewellery: Rs 30,22,767
21,30,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 14,15,000
Non Agricultural
Land: Rs 18,00,000
Residential Buildings:
Rs 3,30,000
18 Sh. Ashok Gehlot
1,07,50,647 1 Crore+
54,75,318 (Total declared Rupee Value
0
Agricultural Land: ⇒Value not given for 23Bigha
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 18 of 20
S. No. Name
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 43,43,616
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 43,43,616
Jewellery: Rs 22,11,544
Mandor Jodhpur
⇒Value not given for 19Bigha Mandor Jodhpur
Non Agricultural Land: ⇒Value not given for Vacant Plot Yds
Mundwa Nagpur Rajsthan
⇒Value not given for One Plot 50x50ft Kot Jodhpur
Residential Buildings: ⇒Value not given for Brahmpuri
Mahmandir Jodhpur
⇒Value not given for 1 kachha House Mandor Jodhpur
⇒Value not given for 1 House in
Mansarover Area Jaipur Of rajsthan housing Board (MLA Quota )
⇒Value not given for 1 Flat IN Sansad
Vihar Cop.Group.Housing Society New Delhi MP LOksabha Quota
19 Smt. Manju Devi
49,51,722 49 Lacs+
20,98,138 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 17,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 3,50,956
Vehicles: Rs 15,45,182
Jewellery: Rs 1,85,000
33,65,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 11,10,000
Commercial Buildings:
Rs 2,70,000
Residential Buildings: Rs 19,85,000
LIC or other insurance Policies: ⇒Value not given for LIC 71468/Year
⇒Value not given for
GPF,SI,LIC,34908/- Annual Others:
⇒Value not given for Rent KH.NO 1606 (lease pe IOC KO )215X12
2580/YEAR RENT
20 Sh. Harji Ram Burdak
1,19,24,210 1 Crore+
33,85,369 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 3,05,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 30,61,069
Bonds, Debentures and Shares : Rs 19,300
0
Jewellery: ⇒Value not given for 170gm Gold
⇒Value not given for 360gm gold
⇒Value not given for 2kg Silver
Agricultural Land: ⇒Value not given for 73.5 Bigha
Bharnawa
⇒Value not given for Hudaas
⇒Value not given for Ladaun
⇒Value not given for 88.5 bigha village jharuya
Non Agricultural Land: ⇒Value not given for Vidhansbha
Nagar Jaipur
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 19 of 20
S. No. Name
Assets of Rajasthan
Ministers declared in 2008 Assembly
Elections (Rs.)
Movable Assets Declared in 2012
Immovable Assets Declared in 2012
Assets for which rupee value not provided in 2012 declaration
⇒Value not given for HIG PLOT Housing Board Jodhpur Vidhyak Kota
Residential Buildings: ⇒Value not given for Station Rd
Ladanu
⇒Value not given for Bharnawan
⇒Value not given for C-10 IMLIWALA Fatak Jiapur
21 Sh. Ameen Khan
11,88,285 11 Lacs+
13,92,891 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Deposits in Banks: Rs 5,42,891
Vehicles: Rs 8,50,000
14,00,000 (Total declared Rupee
Value Of Immovable Asset)
Agricultural Land: Rs 6,00,000
Commercial Buildings:
Rs 5,00,000
Residential Buildings: Rs 3,00,000
22 Sh. Ramkishore Saini
7,90,749 7 Lacs+
14,15,504 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Deposits in Banks: Rs 13,30,504
NSS, Postal Savings etc:
Rs 85,000
0
Vehicles: ⇒Value not given for Scooter Bjaj
Chetak 01 Non Agricultural Land:
⇒Value not given for BANDIKUI 01
⇒Value not given for Jaipur 01 Residential Buildings:
⇒Value not given for Bandikui 1 inhrted
⇒Value not given for Bandikui 01self
23 Dr. Rajkumar Sharma
4,04,372 4 Lacs+
2,85,481 (Total declared Rupee Value
Of Movable Asset)
Cash: Rs 1,00,000
Deposits in Banks:
Rs 5,481
Jewellery: Rs 1,80,000
0
Vehicles: ⇒Value not given for HERO HONDA
CD100
Table 7: Full assets details Rajasthan Council of Ministers, 2012
Data in this Kit is presented in good faith, with an intention to inform voters. Ministers’ asset declaration is the source of this analysis. www.adrindia.org, http://www.myneta.info, [email protected], http://www.twitter.com/adrspeaks,
http://www.facebook.com/adr.new Page 20 of 20
Contact Details
Rajasthan Election Watch (REW):
Mr. Nikhil Dey +91 9414001389
Email: [email protected]
Ms. Renuka Pamecha +91 9314503785
Email:[email protected]
Mr. Kamal Tank +91 9413457292
Email: [email protected]
National Election Watch/Association for Democratic Reforms:
Media & Journalist Helpline
+91 80103 94248
Mr. Anil Bairwal, National Coordinator
National Election Watch,
Association for Democratic Reforms
+91 80103 94248 +91 9999310100
[email protected], [email protected]
Prof Trilochan Sastry IIM Bangalore
Founder Member,
National Election Watch, Association for Democratic
Reforms
+91 9448353285,
Prof Jagdeep Chhokar IIM Ahmedabad (Retd.)
Founder Member
National Election Watch, Association for Democratic
Reforms
+91 9999620944
DISCLAIMER
All information about Ministers, in this report has been taken from the asset declarations filed by Ministers. Copies of these asset declarations were obtained from the Website of the Chief Ministers Office,Rajasthan (http://gad.rajasthan.gov.in/property_return.htm). While all efforts have been made to ensure that the information is in keeping with what is mentioned in the declarations, in case of discrepancy between information in this report and that given in the declarations, the information reported in the declarations by the Ministers should be treated as correct. Association for Democratic Reforms, Rajasthan Election Watch and their volunteers are not responsible or liable for any damage arising directly or indirectly from the publication of this report.