Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali...

49
8°UK NEQAS LI Italian Users Meeting Bologna, 7 Aprile 2016 Bruno Brando e Arianna Gatti Servizi Trasfusionali e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: [email protected] Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia Linfatica Cronica B e nel Mieloma

Transcript of Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali...

Page 1: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

8°UK NEQAS LI Italian Users Meeting Bologna, 7 Aprile 2016

Bruno Brando e Arianna Gatti Servizi Trasfusionalie Laboratori di Ematologia AziendaliASST Ovest MilaneseOspedale di Legnano (MI)

e-mail: [email protected]

Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua

nella Leucemia Linfatica Cronica B e nel Mieloma

Page 2: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Why the Study of Minimal Residual Disease is so Important:The Case of B-CLL & Multiple Myeloma

• New treatment strategies need more sensitive approaches to defineMRD at VERY LOW LEVELS (i.e. 10-4 / 10-5), to compare the efficacy of different therapeutic regimens.

• Better indicators to guide the therapy on an individual patient basisare needed, to avoid over- or under-treatment.

• The definition of clinical response (by PFS, RFS, CR, OS etc.) has remained basically the same during the last 20 years, and some indicators are now inadequate.

• Namely, the quality of Complete Remission (CR) varies largely amongdifferent regimens and fails to identify patients that may relapse.

• There is the need to define reliable Surrogate End-Point Indicatorsthat can be used in the SHORT TERM, whereas the disease course isnow typically 5-10 years long.

Page 3: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

MRD Predice Assenza di Progressione nella LLC-B

Prog

ress

ion-

Fre

e S

urvi

val

(Interim Staging)

Marcata

differenza del

potere predittivo

di MRD <10-2

rispetto a < 10-4

Böttcher S. J Clin Oncol 2012; 30(9): 980-988

Page 4: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

FDA POLICY ON INNOVATIVE BIOMARKERS(Applicable to the current B-CLL & MM-MRD studies)

Gormley NJ. Cytometry Part B 2016; 90B: 73-80.

Page 5: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Wood B. ICSH/ICCS. Cytometry Part B 2013; 84B: 315-323.

• Lower Limit of Blank (LOB):The highest signal in theabsence of the measurand.(Mean Blank + SD x 1.65).95% of negative values arebelow this limit.

• Lower Limit of Detection (LOD):(Mean Blank + SDlow x 1.65).95% of negative values areabove this limit.5% false negatives and 5% false positives are assumed

• Lower Limit of Quantitation (LOQ):The lowest level of measurandthat can be reliably quantitatedat a predefined criterion forprecision and accuracy (clinicalutility value). Never lower thanLOD.

Mean Blank

L O B

Mean Low Signal

Mean High Signal

95% NegativeValues

Such concepts derive from clinical chemistry and can be directly applied to Flow Cytometry for INTENSITYmeasurements only.

Level of theAnalyte

0

Page 6: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

LOB= 1 event MRD Events= 156

In FCM MRD studies, the LOB / LOD / LOQconcepts must be appropriately translated:

LOB = < 10 Events in normal samplesLOD = > 30 Events detected (> 0.001% or >10-5)LOQ = > 50 Events quantitated (> 0.001% or 10-5)

[30 and 50 events derive from statistical estimations]

Consensus on MRD Detection in B-CLL and Multiple Myeloma

Page 7: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

FCM MRD Studies: Estimated LOD & LOQ

According to the Total Number of Acquired Cells

Courtesy of Maria Arroz, 2015, modified

Total Number of

Acquired Cells(Excluding Erythroid)

LOD %≥ 30 Events

LOQ %≥ 50 Events

200,000 0.015 0.026

500,000 0.006 0.01

1,000,000 0.003 0.005

2,000,000 0.0015 0.0025

3,000,000 ~ 0.001 ~ 0.0017

5,000,000 ~ 0.0006 ~ 0.001

In each report, the LOD specific for the total amount ofacquired cells should be specified.

Page 8: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

The acceptable level of cytometric error in the evaluation of MRD(in this case B-CLL) greatly influences the classification of the patient’s status (i.e. MRD+ or MRD-), and therefore its correlation with the clinical outcome.

Courtesy of Andy Rawstron, 2015.

B-CLL

Page 9: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Riassumendo 10 Anni di Evoluzione Tecnica nelloStudio Citometrico della MRD nella B-CLL

• 4 Colori sono meglio di 3 MRD 1%

• 5 Colori sono meglio di 4 MRD 0,1%

• 6 Colori sono meglio di 5 MRD 0,01%

• 6 o 8 Colori vanno bene MRD 0,001%

• Moreton P. J Clin Oncol 2005; 23: 2971-2979.• Böttcher S. J Clin Oncol 2012; 30: 980-988.• Strati P. Blood 2014; 123: 3727-3732.• Santacruz R. Haematologica 2014; 99: 873-880.• Rawstron AC. Leukemia 29 Jan 2016; doi:10.1038/leu.2015.313

L’identificazione citometrica di MRD al disopra dello 0.01% (>10-4) è unindicatore indipendente predittivo per ‘Progression-Free Survival’ e‘Overall Survival’ nei pz con B-CLL trattati con chemio/immunoterapia.

4 Tubi

2 Tubi

1 Tubo

Page 10: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

FCM ANALYSIS OF B-CLL - MRD: Technical Options (1)

V450 FITC PE PE cy7 APC APC-H7

CD5 x CD81 CD79b x CD19 CD43 CD20

• ERIC One-Tube CORE 6 Color Panel: Good in >95% Classical B-CLL Cases

• Can be used with any analysis software, provided the HMDS-ERIC gatingstrategy is applied.

V450 BV510 FITC PE PerCP-cy5.5 PE cy7 APC APC-H7

CD5 CD22 CD81 CD79b CD3 CD19 CD43 CD20

• ERIC One-Tube 8 Colors: CD3 & CD22 added to CORE Panel to prevent stainingartifacts (but they are important if CD43 and CD81 are absent on B-CLL cells).

• Especially useful if a Pre-Treatment sample demonstrates an atypical phenotype(CD20 & CD22 to discriminate normal B Cells from B-CLL Cells).

Page 11: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

6-Color CORE Panel and gate syntax provide sufficient internal controls to validate the analysis independently of the chose clones and fluorochromes.

Harmonized approach toB-CLL MRD Analysis

Capture gateB-CLL CD19+

B-CLLCD43+ CD81-/dim

B-CLLCD5+ CD79b-/dim

B-CLLCD5+ CD20-/dim

Besides CD5 and CD43 (‘positive’ in B-CLL), the Eric approach is more based on ‘negative’ B-CLL markers (CD22- CD79b- CD81-)

Page 12: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Aggiustamento dei gate nell’approccio ERIC - CORE Panel a 6 colori

Page 13: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

B Cell Progenitors & Plasmablasts: CD5- CD20- CD43+++ CD81++

Contaminant T Cells: CD5+ CD20- CD43+++ CD79b- CD81++

6-Color Panel and gating can discriminate contaminants

Page 14: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

B-CLL MRD Analysis by 6-Color Core Panel vs High-Throughput Sequencing (HTS - ClonoSEQ)

Rawstron AC. Leukemia 29 Jan 2016; doi:10.1038/leu.2015.313

Page 15: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Rawstron AC. Leukemia 29 Jan 2016; doi:10.1038/leu.2015.313

8-C

olo

r vs 6

-Co

lor

Spiking 1 Tube 8-Color

<LOD >LOD & <LOQ >LOQ

Bland-Altman

6-Color Core vs 8-Color Panel: Overlapping results in typical B-CLL MRD studies (in a Operator- and Platform-Independent fashion)

• CD3 is not required in all cases, but it is necessary when high accuracy is needed (i.e. in the 0.001 - 0.01% range and if FACSDiva is used).

• CD20 & CD22 together are redundant if ≥ 2 typical CLL markers (CD5, CD43, CD79b and CD81) are expressed and if Infinicyt is used.

Page 16: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

The Problem With Clonality Assessment by theKappa / Lambda Ratio: Poor Specificity

B-C

LL c

ells

as

% o

f Leuc

ocyt

es

• > 40% of ‘Polyclonal’ conditions are in fact MRD Positive• > 5% of ‘Monoclonal’ conditions are in fact MRD Negative

Rawstron AC. Leukemia 2013; 27: 142-149

B-CLL

Page 17: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Rawstron AC. Leukemia 29 Jan 2016; doi:10.1038/leu.2015.313

B-CLL MRD Detection using the ERIC Harmonized Approach (FCM vs HTS)

• Applicable to >95% of typical B-CLL cases.

• A pre-treatment sample is not essential, if the B-CLL phenotype is typical.

• Applicable both in BM and PB samples in all therapeutic trials.

• Plenty of internal controls for a robust gating setup and adjustment.

• Easy to perform and relatively operator-independent.

• Platform-independent reagents can be used, with wider applicability.

• High-Throughput Sequencing (HTS) is more sensitive than Sanger sequencing.

• HTS shows a good concordance with FCM down to 10-4 (0.01%).

• HTS can be applied to stored DNA.

(FCR=Fludarabine,Cyclophosphamide,Rituximab)

Page 18: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Rawstron ACLeukemia 2013; 27: 142–149

Standard Template to evaluate Minimal Residual Disease in Classic B-CLL withone 8-color tube

CD3+ CD19+Artifacts

Page 19: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

1-tube, 8 Colors, plusDoublet discrimination,exclusion of CD19+ CD3+ artifacts and final FSC/SSC Backgating

Minimal Residual Disease in Classic B-CLL :One tube cantell you all.

Page 20: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

FCM ANALYSIS OF B-CLL - MRD: Technical Options (2)

V450 V500 FITC PE PerCP-cy5.5 PE cy7 APC APC-H7

CD20 CD45 CD23 CD10 CD79b CD19 CD200 CD43

• EUROFLOW Approach: LST Tube for screening and B-CLPD Tube for bettercharacterization of B-Cell lymphoproliferative disorder and MRD study.

• Merging of 2 Tubes of 2 Million cell events each + Infinicyt analysis is therecommended technique.

V450 V500 FITC PE PerCP-cy5.5 PE cy7 APC APC-H7

CD20 CD45 CD8 CD56 CD5 CD19 CD3 CD38CD4 Lambda Kappa TCR

Backbone Markers for File Merging

LST Tube

B-CLPD Tube

Page 21: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Reference image (blue contours) indicates the position of the B-CLL cells at onset. Red dots: MRD 0.03%, 1.5 Million cells acquired.

Reference Images and Database options establish objective and reproducible frames for comparison.

Classic B-CLLFollow-up

Page 22: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

8-color, 1 Tube, CD43 / CD79b / CD19 / CD3 / CD5 / CD38 / CD20 / CD45B-CLL MRD (blue dots): 0.01% on 2 Million cells, single tube.Reference image (red contour) indicates the position of the B-CLL cells at onset.

Normal B Cells

Residual B-CLL

Page 23: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

8-color, 1 Tube, CD43 / CD79b / CD19 / CD3 / CD5 / CD38 / CD20 / CD45

B-CLL MRD (blue dots): 0.01% on 2 Million cells, single tube.

APS is based on the statistical function known as ‘Principal Component Analysis’.

Use of APS - Automatic Population Separator

Reference Image

Page 24: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Mantle Cell Lymphoma at Onset

2nd B-CLPD Euroflow Tube: CD20/ CD45/ CD23/ CD10/ CD79b/ CD19/ CD200/ CD43

MCL phenotype is directly comparedto the expected classic B-CLL pattern obtained with the same B-CLPD tube.

Reference Images to rapidly compare a cell phenotype toan expected pattern (Mantle Cell Lymphoma vs B-CLL)

MCL

B-CLLReference

Page 25: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Reference Images to rapidly compare a cell phenotype toan expected pattern (Mantle Cell Lymphoma-MRD)

MCLReference

MCL MRD21 Events

NormalB Cells

21 MRD Events /500.000 TotalMRD Detected but not quantitated

Page 26: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Studio Citometrico della MRD nella B-CLLLe Relazioni tra Marcatori Diagnostici e Schemi Terapeutici

• L’uso di certi marcatori va armonizzato al tipo di terapia che il paziente sta seguendo (conoscere la patologia!).

• In pazienti sotto Rituximab (anti-CD20) non sono piùdimostrabili cellule B normali in circolo, per cui il CD20perde il suo potere discriminatorio tra cellule B-CLL ecellule B normali.

• In questi pazienti è quindi indifferente usare CD20 o CD22.

• Il pannello ‘Core’ a 6 colori è stato validato prospettivamentesu periferico e midollo in vari trial controllati (ADMIRE, ARCTIC,

COSMIC, FLAIR, GALACTIC) ed è applicabile anche in studi cheimpiegano Venetoclax, Ofatumumab e Ibrutinib.

• Böttcher S. Leukemia 2009; 23: 2007-2017.• Rawstron AC. Leukemia 29 Jan 2016; doi:10.1038/leu.2015.313

Page 27: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Fludarabine+Cyclophosphamide+Ofatumumab(COSMIC). NormalB Cells reappear afterdiscontinuation ofMoAb therapy

BM BM BM

PB PB PB

Examples of B-CLLpatients underIbrutinib monotherapy

Courtesy ofA.C. Rawstron, 2016

CD5 tends to bedown-regulatedunder Ibrutinib

Page 28: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

0

20

40

60

80

100

0 20 40 60 80 100

Ibrutinib Therapy: Equivalent Disease Levels in PB & BM

In 56 samples after 1–6 Months of Ibrutinib, the BM MRD level is

basically the same as PB (But PB may disclose higher MRD values!)

PBC

LL %

of

leuc

ocyt

es

BM CLL % of leucocytes

Trephine biopsy in 6/19 cases

after 6 months of Ibrutinib

treatment indicate

substantially lower level of

infiltration than indicated by

the Aspirate CLL %

Courtesy of A.C. Rawstron, 2015, modified

Page 29: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Studio Citometrico della MRD nella B-CLLOpportunità, Problemi Aperti e Controversie

• La citometria sta consolidando un ruolo centrale nella B-CLL,sia nella diagnosi che nell’analisi della malattia residua.

• Validità dell’analisi citometrica del sangue periferico in qualsiasi regime terapeutico.

• Bulk Lysis SI (Rawstron & Stetler-Stevenson) oBulk Lysis NO (Orfao-Euroflow)?

• Più COLORI (in studio pannelli monotubo a 10 colori !) oPiù EVENTI (2x6 colori, 2 Mil. di eventi/tubo + Infinicyt)?

Page 30: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

New Programme s

Pilot Minima l Residual Disease in CLL/ Pilot Minimal Residual Disease in AML

The Minimal Residual Disease programmes will issue up to four send outs per financial year.

Each send out will include two follow up samples of a known CLL/AML case post treatment at

different time points. The AML programme will also include a reference sample to assist with

antibody selection. Participants will be asked to quantify the level of residual disease in these

samples.

B-CLL MRD: Partenza ~ metà 2016

AML MRD: Partenza ~ fine 2016

In corso discussioni tecniche per avviareun programma di MRD per il MIELOMA

Page 31: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Flow Cytometric Analysis

of Minimal Residual Disease

in Multiple Myeloma

Conventional 8-color Flow-MRD

vs

Next Generation Flow-MRD

Page 32: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

• Increasing evidence is accumulating on the power of FCM assays forMM-MRD Assessment (on sCR, OS, PFS and prognosis).

• Several studies have demonstrated the value of FCM MM-MRD assaysin individual patients, IRRESPECTIVE OF THE THERAPY RECEIVED.

• Allele-Specific Oligonucleotide PCR (ASO-PCR) is considered thevalidated golden standard for MM-MRD assessment, because it issensitive at 10-5 and is a stable indicator throughout the clinical course.

• But ASO-PCR suffers from several limitations:

CONCEPTUAL AND TECHNICAL PREREQUISITES OF MM-MRD STUDIES

Landgren O. Cytometry Part B 2016; 90B: 14-20.

• Requires patient-specific primers.• Not easily accessible.• Costly and long to develop (3-4 weeks).• Applicable to 60-70% of patients only.• Same problems related to patchy disease distribution in the BM.

Page 33: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

BCSH Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Management of Multiple Myeloma(Bird JM. www.bcshguidelines.com/documents/myeloma_guideline_feb_2014_for_bcsh.pdf)

Table 6, page n. 78:

Immunohistochemistry forabnormal PC detection in BMis defined as UNRELIABLE

(0.26 - 1.65)

(at which level?)

Page 34: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

78726660544842363024181260

1,0

,9

,8

,7

,6

,5

,4

,3

,2

,1

0,0

Relapse-Free Survival of MM: Impact of immunophenotyping at 3 months post-ASCT

Rela

pse

-F

ree

Sur

viva

l

— <0.01% MM-PC

— ≥ 1% MM-PC

Months from immunophenotypical analysis(3 months post-ASCT)

RFS According to % of Residual Abnormal PC

p=0.0001

40m

23m

— 0.01% to 1% MM-PC

NR

Paiva B. Blood 2008; 112: 4017- 4023

(n=200 patients)

Page 35: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

• Landgren O. Cytometry Part B 2016; 90B: 14-20.• Rawstron AC. J Clin Oncol 2013; 31: 2540 - 2547.• Paiva B. Blood 2012; 119: 687- 691.

Cytogenetic Risk

FCM MRD Status

Progression-Free Survival (Months)

p =

MRD+ 33.7

Standard 0.014

MRD- 44.2

MRD+ 8.7

High 0.09

MRD- 15.7

Pivotal Studies on FCM MM-MRD by British and Spanish Groups

• Universal applicability and clinical significance of FCM MM-MRD.

• According to current guidelines, it is now contradictory to labela patient as in sCR when he/she is found to be FCM MRD+.

• Need for strict laboratory standardization.

Page 36: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Defining a Sample as UNSUITABLE for MRD Analysis

• When an excess peripheral blood contamination is observed(i.e. if CD16+ mature myeloid cells are >20%).

• When red cell precursors are overall < 10-15 %.

• When B-Lymphoid progenitors are absent or < 1-2%.

• When normal PCs are undetectable.

• Whenever a reduced representation of Bone Marrow-nativecell populations can be demonstrated, namely:

It is always advisable to classify a sample as unsuitable for MRD analysis rather than reporting an inaccurately quantitated MRD level due to peripheral blood contamination. It is however possibleto report ‘MRD Detected but not quantitated’ in selected cases.

• Aged samples (older than 48 hours).

• Visible clots are present.

• When sample deterioration has occurred:

Page 37: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Setting the Cutoff: Reporting a Sample as MRD - Negative

• If MRD cells are NOT DETECTED in a sufficient number,then the minimum requirement for reporting is the level ofabnormal PC collected in relation to the adopted LOD.

• Anyway it is good practice to report the Total number ofacquired events along with the number of PC events.

• LOD and LOQ levels adopted by the lab for that specificnumber of acquired events should be clearly included in the report, for comparison.

• As an example of MRD-Negative test:

Abnormal PC events collected = 15 events (positive: if>30)Total leucocyte events acquired = 5,000,000 cellsPercentage of abnormal PC = 0.000003 % (MRD-Negative)Or better: Abnormal PC = < 0.0006 % (MRD-Negative) (Reference Values: LOD ≥ 0.0006 %; LOQ ≥ 0.0001 %)

Page 38: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Setting the Cutoff: Reporting a Sample as MRD POSITIVE

• Sample prerequisites must be met.

• Neoplastic AND normal PCs must be detectable.

• Neoplastic PC are detected ABOVE THE LOQ %

• As an example of MRD-POSITIVE test:

Abnormal PC events collected = 1000 events Total leucocyte events acquired = 2,000,000 cellsPercentage of abnormal PC = 0.05 % (MRD Positive)

(Reference Values: LOD ≥ 0.0006 %; LOQ ≥ 0.0001 %)

Page 39: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Multicolor Flow Cytometry to Study MRD in MM

• The quantitative assessment of tumor load at 10-5 level has provedMORE INFORMATIVE than the clinical categorization ofpositive / negative CR.

• Highly sensitive Multicolor FCM (10-5) is likely to improve theprediction of MM patients outcome, at a level comparable tomore complex and costly molecular assays.

• Previous MM-MRD studies, defining MRD at 10-4 level, are OBSOLETE.

• Multicolor approach is mandatory for the required accuracy (≥ 8 colors)and FCM should be appropriately set to collect the necessary highcell numbers (Millions of cells!).

• Applicable to virtually 100% of patients without requiring patient-specific profiles or pre-treatment samples for comparison.

• Intra-assay QC to assess sample suitability and to evaluate thepresence of other cell types.

Page 40: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Backbone Markers for File Merging

FCM ANALYSIS OF MM-MRD: State-of-the-Art

H450 H500 FITC PE PerCP-cy5.5 PE cy7 APC APC-H7

CD45 CD138 CD38 CD56 β2micro CD19 cyKappa cyLambda

CD45 CD138 CD38 CD28 CD27 CD19 CD81 CD117

Two 8-Color Tubes According to EuroFlow - Version 6

1

2

• The two tubes are necessary for a complete assessment of PC features.

• For the Infinicyt File Merging option, the Fix/Perm procedure is needed also for Tube n.2, despite the absence of intracellular stainings.

• At lest 2-3 Million cell events must be collected with each tube.

• The two EuroFlow lyotubes will be commercially available in 2016.

Flores-Montero J. Leukemia 2012; 26: 1925-1929.

Page 41: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Backbone Markers for File Merging

H450 H500 FITC PE PerCP-cy5.5 PE cy7 APC APC-H7

CD20 CD45 cyKappa cyLambda CD138 CD56 CD38 CD19

CD28 CD45 CD81 CD117 CD138 CD27 CD38 CD19

1

2

FCM ANALYSIS OF MM-MRD: Alternative Technical Options

• Tube 1 can be used for SCREENING, whereas Tube 2 is added for follow-upand MRD studies. File Merging requires Fix/Perm of both tubes anyway.

• Tube 2 ALONE can be used for MRD studies (no need for cyLight Chains).

• β2-Micro is replaced by CD20 because the latter remains stable even afterchemotherapy and can give clues on the presence of a t(11;14) translocation.

• Addition of CD20 is also useful in the simultaneous analysis of otherlymphoproliferative disorders and Waldenström macroglobulinemia.

• Some fluorochrome choices are aimed at minimizing the number of conjugatesto be purchased.

Page 42: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

V450 BV510 FITC PE PerCP-cy5.5 PE cy7 APC APC-H7

CD56 CD27 CD81 CD117 CD19 CD38 CD138 CD45

CD56 CD27 cyKappa cyLambda CD19 CD38 CD138 CD45

1

2

FCM ANALYSIS OF MM-MRD: Alternative Technical Options

• The HMDS - Leeds (Andy Rawstron’s) approach.

• Tube 1 can be used alone both for diagnosis and for MRD study.

• Tube 2 is optional, and the cytoplasmic Light Chains are placed at FITC/PEjust because they are the commonest conjugates.

• Emphasis is given to the internal negative control gating syntax, to clearlyassess the positive/negative judgement.

• Conventional logical gating. No β2-Micro nor Backbone markers are used.

Page 43: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Conventional Flow-MRD Assay: MRD Positive Case

Abnormal PC

Normal PC

CD27 CD117CD28

• MRD Study - 1 Tube, Conventional Analysis• 1 Million BM cells acquired (Erythroid removed)• LOD = 0.003% LOQ = 0.005 %

• 147 Abnormal PCs collected (0.014%)• MRD Positive

CD19 CD81

Page 44: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Conventional Flow-MRD Assay: MRD - Negative Case

0.026

0.00008

• MRD Study - 1 Tube, Conventional Analysis• 2.725 M BM cells acquired & erythroid removed• LOD = 0.0012%

• 2 Abnormal PCs collected (0.00008%)• MRD Negative

Consensus on a standardized,robust MM-MRD gating protocolwith conventional FCM analysis softwares is still lacking.

Page 45: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

• Post-ABMTx BM analysis.• 2.6 Million BM cells (Erythroid removed)

• LOD = 0.0012% LOQ = 0.002 %

• 236 Abnormal PC collected (0.009%)• MRD Positive

Next Generation Flow-MRD Assay: 2 EuroFlow Tubes Merged (a)

Abnormal PC

CD81

CD81

CD27

CD56 Kappa

Lambda

Page 46: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

CD38

CD45

Abnormal PCContourat Onset

CD81

CD19

ResidualAbnormal PCs22 Events

CD27 CD81

CD28

Normal PCs158 Events

CD138

• MRD Study (2 EuroFlow tubes merged)• 3.0 Million BM cells acquired (Erythroid removed)• LOD = 0.001% LOQ = 0.0017%

• 22 Abnormal PCs collected (0.0007%)• MRD Detected but not Quantitated

Next Generation Flow-MRD Assay: 2 EuroFlow Tubes Merged (c)

Page 47: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Flores-Montero J. Cytometry Part B 2016; 90B: 61-72.

Next Generation Flow MRD in MM: Infinicyt by merging the two 8-color EuroFlow tubes with 5+5 Million Bone Marrow cells: 10-5 sensitivity.

Normal Polyclonal PC

0.002% ClonalResidual PC (226 events)10 Million

BM Cells

Erythroid removed?

Page 48: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

* Proven polyclonal by CyIg staining

% A

bno

rmal PC

inf

iltr

ation

rou

tine

(con

vent

iona

l 8-co

lor

flow

MRD)

% Abnormal PC infiltration Tube 1(Next Generation Flow MRD)

10-5

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

Neg

10-6

Neg 10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1

2/54 (4%)

27/54 (50%)

9/54 (17%)

16/54 (30%)

*

Next Generation Flow MRD vs Conventional 8-color Flow MRD

Courtesy ofAlberto Orfao, 2015

Page 49: Analisi della Malattia Minima Residua nella Leucemia ... · e Laboratori di Ematologia Aziendali ASST Ovest Milanese Ospedale di Legnano (MI) e-mail: bruno.brando@asst-ovestmi.it

Conventional 8-Color Flow MRD vs Next Generation Flow MRD

CONVENTIONAL 8-Color NEXT GENERATION FCM

• Bulky cell files (1-5 Mi.) requirebulky cell preparations or multipletubes to be sequentially accruedusing the ‘append’ function

• The required bulky cell files (1-5 Mi.) are created with the‘File Merge’ function, by puttingtogether various smaller files.

• The conventional files retain thedecided MoAb composition. Moreinformation can be inferred byadding other (separate) tubes.

• The addition of multiple tubeswith the same backbone markersgenerates additional informationwithin the same merged file.

• Conventional analysis softwaressuffer very bulky files: everysmall adjustment in regionsrequires lenghty display refreshes.

• Merged files are managed in atotally different manner, so theanalysis is quick and smooth.

• Limited spectrum of statisticaloptions.

• Extended statistical andanalytical options (APS, Compass)