An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

13
An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies Bengt Gustafsson Dept of Astronomy and Astrophysics Uppsala University

description

An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies. Bengt Gustafsson Dept of Astronomy and Astrophysics Uppsala University. Solar Twins. M67. VandenBerg et al. Weiss. M67-1194. Pasquini et al. (2008) Solar-twin candidates in M67. M67-1194. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

Page 1: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

Bengt Gustafsson

Dept of Astronomy and Astrophysics

Uppsala University

Page 2: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

Solar Twins

Page 3: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

M67

Page 4: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

VandenBerg et al.

Page 5: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

Weiss

Page 6: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

M67-1194

Page 7: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

M67-1194

Pasquini et al. (2008)Solar-twin candidates in M67

Page 8: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

M67-1194 Sun diff

(Å)

Page 9: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

• Excitation of Fe I + H => 5780 ± 20 K • Fe I/Fe II + MgIb => log g = 4.44 ± 0.05 (cgs) t = 0.95 km/s• [Fe/H] = 0.023 ± 0.015

Page 10: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies
Page 11: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

Age• Isochrones (Teff vs log g) by VandenBerg (2010): 4.2 ± 0.3 Gyr

If Y is different by 0.01 => 0.2 Gyr

• C.f. photometry,Yadav et al. (2008):3.5 - 4.8 Gyr

Page 12: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

+ Meléndez et al. (2009)

• M67-1194

Page 13: An unusually solar-like twin, and the virtue of differential spectroscopy in Galactic studies

+ Meléndez et al. (2009)

• M67-1194

< 6% chance!