Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities...

39
Sponsored by: Live Webinar June 14 2PM EST Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies

Transcript of Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities...

Page 1: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Sponsored by:

Live Webinar June 14 2PM EST

Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies

Page 2: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Sponsored by:

Today’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta

Mebane Faber Chief Investment Office Cambria

• How To Evaluate Sectors • How To Evaluate Sector ETFs

Matt Hougan President, ETF Analytics Global Head of Editorial IndexUniverse

David Botset Senior V.P., ETFs Guggenheim

Page 3: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Combining Momentum Strategies

• “A Quantitative Approach to Tactical Asset Allocation” published in the Spring 2007 issue of The Journal of Wealth Management. •“Relative Strength Strategies for Investing”, April 2010.

Page 4: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Combining Momentum Strategies

1. Trendfollowing

2. Relative Strength

3. Combining the Two

Page 5: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Risk Management

"The first rule is not to lose. The second rule is not to forget the first rule.”

-Warren Buffett

Page 6: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

I can calculate the motion of heavenly bodies…but not the madness of men

6 Source: Marc Faber, Gloom Boom Doom

Page 7: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Trendfollowing Hypothetical Buy & Sell Signals

Source: Global Financial Data

Page 8: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Trendfollowing 1928 - 2009

Source: Global Financial Data

• 10-month simple moving average.

• Rebalances monthly.

• Moves to cash (T-Bills) when out of the market.

• 10 US Sectors

Page 9: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Trendfollowing, 1928-2009

Page 10: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Relative Strength 1928 - 2009

Source: Global Financial Data

• 1,3,6,9,12 month relative strength (total return).

• Rebalances monthly.

• 3 – 6 % outperformance per year.

Page 11: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Relative Strength, 1928-2009

Page 12: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Combining Relative Strength & Trend 1928 - 2009

Source: Global Financial Data

• Rank by 1,3,6,9,12 month relative strength (total return).

• Moves to cash if below long term moving average.

• Rebalances monthly.

Page 13: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Where Are We Now?

Source: Global Financial Data

1.Energy

2.Healthcare

3.Real Estate

Page 14: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Improvements

Source: Global Financial Data

1.More asset classes.

2.Granularity within asset class.

3.Multiple time frames.

4.Other factors, Value, Economic.

Page 15: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Sector Beta:

Understanding Classifications & Evaluating ETFs

Matt Hougan President, ETF Analytics Global Head of Editorial IndexUniverse

Page 16: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

The Jellybean Problem

Page 17: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Introduction to Sector Strategies GICS vs ICB

GICS ICB

Level 1 10 Sectors 10 Industries

Level 2 24 Industry Groups 19 Supersectors

Level 3 68 Industries 41 Sectors

Level 4 154 Subindustries 114 Subsectors

Different Names, Similar Structures

Page 18: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Sectors vs Industries

GICS Sectors ICB Industries

Consumer Discretionary Consumer Services

Consumer Staples Consumer Goods

Energy Oil & Gas

Financials Financial

Health Care Health Care

Industrials Industrial

Information Technology Technology

Materials Basic Materials

Telecommunication Services Telecommunications

Utilities Utilities

Page 19: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Thomson Reuters Business Classification (TRBC)

Page 20: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI
Page 21: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

GICS vs ICB Breakdown of S&P 500

0% 5% 10% 15% 20%

Con Discret/Services

Con Staples/Goods

Energy/Oil & Gas

Financials

Health Care

Industrials

IT/Tech

Materials

Telecom

Utilities

GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY

ICB SPY

GICS SPY

Page 22: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI EAFE

0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25%

Con Discret/Services

Con Staples/Goods

Energy/Oil & Gas

Financials

Health Care

Industrials

IT/Tech

Materials

Telecom

Utilities

GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI EAFE

ICB EFA

GICS EFA

Page 23: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

GICS vs. ICB Performance: Consumer Splits

-60

-40

-20

0

20

40

60

80

Pe

rce

nt

Ret

urn

Consumer Sector ETFs TRR

IYC IYK XLP XLY

Page 24: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Sector Correlations

Page 25: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

GICS vs. ICB Performance: Energy

-30

-20

-10

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

Pe

rce

nt

Ret

urn

Energy Sector ETFs TRR

IYE XLE

Page 26: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

GICS vs. ICB Performance: Financials

-100

-80

-60

-40

-20

0

20

40

Pe

rce

nt

Ret

urn

Financial Sector ETFs TRR

IYF XLF

Page 27: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Industry Breakdown: SPY through the Lens of TRBC

Name Ticker GICS ICB Industry TRBC Sector

Aetna Inc New AET Health Care Health Care FINANCIALS

Cigna Corp CI Health Care Health Care FINANCIALS

Humana Inc HUM Health Care Health Care FINANCIALS

Wellpoint Inc WLP Health Care Health Care FINANCIALS

Mastercard Inc MA IT Financials FINANCIALS

Visa Inc V IT Financials FINANCIALS

Fidelity Natl Information FIS IT Industrials FINANCIALS

Dun & Bradstreet Corp Del N DNB Industrials Consumer Services FINANCIALS

Page 28: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

SPY TRBC vs GICS: Non-Financials

Name Ticker GICS TRBC Sector

Plum Creek Timber Co Inc PCL Financials BASIC MATERIALS

Weyerhaeuser Co WY Financials BASIC MATERIALS

Host Hotels & Resorts Inc HST Financials CYCLICAL CONSUMER

Health Care Reit Inc HCN Financials HEALTHCARE

Hcp Inc HCP Financials HEALTHCARE

Ventas Inc VTR Financials HEALTHCARE

Moodys Corp MCO Financials INDUSTRIALS

Public Storage PSA Financials INDUSTRIALS

Leucadia Natl Corp LUK Financials INDUSTRIALS

Page 29: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

SPY TRBC vs ICB: Non-Financials

Name Ticker ICB TRBC Sector

Plum Creek Timber Co Inc PCL Financials BASIC MATERIALS

Weyerhaeuser Co WY Financials BASIC MATERIALS

Host Hotels & Resorts Inc HST Financials CYCLICAL CONSUMER

Health Care Reit Inc HCN Financials HEALTHCARE

Hcp Inc HCP Financials HEALTHCARE

Ventas Inc VTR Financials HEALTHCARE

Moodys Corp MCO Financials INDUSTRIALS

Public Storage PSA Financials INDUSTRIALS

Western Un Co WU Financials INDUSTRIALS

Page 30: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Financial ETFs: Performance

-50

-25

0

25

50

75

2009 2010 2011

Pe

rce

nt

Ret

urn

IYF XLF VFH FXO RYF PFI

Page 31: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Financial ETFs: Performance in a Bear Market

-90

-80

-70

-60

-50

-40

-30

-20

-10

0

10

Oct-07 Apr-08 Oct-08

Pe

rce

nt

Ret

urn

10/10/07 - 3/9/2009

IYF XLF VFH FXO RYF PFI

Page 32: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

The Difference? Holdings RYF PFI

ACE LIMITED 1.39% ACE Ltd. 2.53%

AMERICAN EXPRESS COMPANY

1.39% Ameriprise Financial Inc. 2.46%

AVALONBAY COMMUNITIES INC

1.43% CB Richard Ellis Group Inc. (Cl A)

2.46%

BOSTON PROPERTIES INC 1.43% CNA Financial Corp. 2.52%

CHUBB CORPORATION 1.41% Discover Financial Services 2.49%

EQUITY RESIDENTIAL 1.41% Franklin Resources Inc. 2.53%

MOODY'S CORPORATION 1.64% Moody's Corp. 2.79%

SIMON PROPERTY GROUP INC.

1.39% NYSE Euronext 2.52%

SLM CORPORATION 1.37% Prudential Financial Inc. 2.47%

VORNADO REALTY TRUST 1.38% Travelers Cos. Inc. 2.57%

Page 33: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Variety of Performance Stats: Financial ETFs

1 yr Perf Max

Return Min Return Sharpe Ratio Volatility

Max Drawdown

IYF 7.00 7.09 -7.20 0.61 19.12 -10.04

XLF 4.47 7.32 -7.62 0.49 20.32 -10.88

VFH 7.17 7.15 -7.52 0.62 19.49 -10.46

RYF 15.35 5.69 -7.86 1.01 18.80 -10.20

RWW 2.68 6.77 -7.58 0.35 20.58 -12.85

PFI 15.75 5.91 -5.47 1.13 16.42 -8.14

FXO 18.38 5.68 -5.82 1.33 15.98 -8.08

Page 34: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Biotech Performance

-50

-25

0

25

50

75

100

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Pe

rce

nt

Ret

urn

IBB BBH PBE XBI FBT

Page 35: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Sector Choices: Biotech Performance

Ticker Name

Bull Market 3/9/2009 - 5/31/2011

Bear Market 10/10/2007 -

3/9/2009

BBH Biotech HOLDRS 39.33% -3.35%

IBB iShares Nasdaq Biotechnology 86.28% -32.28%

PBE PowerShares Dynamic Biotech & Genome Portfolio 111.84% -44.76%

XBI SPDR S&P Biotech 72.02% -26.59%

FBT First Trust NYSE Arca Biotechnology 169.20% -36.64%

Page 36: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Theme Investing: Wind

-80

-70

-60

-50

-40

-30

-20

-10

0

Jul-08 Jan-09 Jul-09 Jan-10 Jul-10 Jan-11

Pe

rce

nt

Ret

urn

FAN PWND

Page 37: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Sector Choices: Thematic Benchmarks: What Is Wind? Purity of Benchmark Rules

Page 38: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Sponsored by:

Any Questions?

Mebane Faber Chief Investment Office Cambria

Matt Hougan President, ETF Analytics Global Head of Editorial IndexUniverse

David Botset Senior V.P., ETFs Guggenheim

Page 39: Alpha/Beta Series: Sector Strategies - ETF.comToday’s Webinar: Alpha/Beta ... Telecom Utilities GICS, ICB & TRBC Breakdown of SPY ICB SPY GICS SPY. GICS vs ICB Breakdown of MSCI

Thank You

For more information: www.IndexUniverse.com www.cambriainvestments.com

www.mebanefaber.com

www.guggenheimfunds.com