AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

93
Feasibility Study: Private Equity Investment Opportunities in the African Telecom Sector For AlCazar Capital Partners, Dubai-UAE By Apurva Chiranewala Manoj Balaji Monita Anand Sunitha Suresh S.P. Jain Center of Management 18 Nov 2007

Transcript of AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

Page 1: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

Feasibility Study: Private Equity

Investment Opportunities in the African

Telecom Sector

For

AlCazar Capital Partners, Dubai-UAE

By

Apurva Chiranewala

Manoj Balaji

Monita Anand

Sunitha Suresh

S.P. Jain Center of Management 18 Nov 2007

Page 2: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

2 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

CERTIFICATE

This is to certify that the project titled “Feasibility Study of private equity investments in

telecom sector in Africa” submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirement for the award of

degree Global Masters in Business Administration is a record of the candidate‟s own work

carried out by him/her under my/our supervision. The method embodied in the thesis is

original and has not been submitted for the award of any other degree.

Date: November 18, 2007

Page 3: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

3 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

DECLARATION

This is to certify that the project titled “Feasibility Study of private equity investments in

telecom sector in Africa” submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirement for the award of

degree Global Masters in Business Administration is a record of the candidate‟s own work

carried out by him/her under my/our supervision. The method embodied in the thesis is

original and has not been submitted for the award of any other degree.

Date: November 18, 2007

APURVA CHIRANEWALA (GMBA07E087)

MANOJ BALAJI (GMBA07H125)

MONITA ANAND (GMBA07A117)

SUNITHA SURESH (GMBA07A141)

Page 4: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

4 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Acknowledgement

We would like to take this opportunity to thank AlCazar Capital Partners, Dubai for giving

us a chance to work on a project assessing the private equity investment opportunities in

Africa. Working on the project gave us insights into unexplored business opportunities and

potential sectors for investments.

We would like to thank our organization mentor Mr Dinesh Tiwari who actively guided us

through this project giving us valuable inputs and our college mentor Mr Sanjay Sircar, who

helped us with methods and models for analysis of data.

We thank Mr Ramkumar Kakani and Mr Naveen Bhatia for helping us with linking the

classroom concepts with the project and real time requirements.

We also thank Dr. Shilpa Dalvi for her guidance during every stage of the project and for her

efforts to maintain timely updates.

We would also like to acknowledge Mr Bocar, Vice President SAMENA Council, who gave

us considerable first hand information about telecom revolution in Africa.

We also express our sincere thanks to the respondents of our survey for taking out

time from their busy schedule without whose inputs the project would not have been a

success.

We extend our gratitude to the administrative staff and fellow students of S.P. Jain Center of

Management for their guidance through the course of our memorable journey.

Page 5: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

5 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Executive Summary

Africa has a total population of 900 million with a mobile penetration of 20%. Sub Sahara

Africa has a total population of 700 million with a mobile penetration of mere 12%. With

high population and low mobile penetration it is being considered a gold mine of

opportunities. Recently, the telecom sector has seen tremendous growth indicating investors

the plethora of underlying opportunities.

AlCazar Capital Partners is a private equity firm focused in investments in emerging

markets. With Africa‟s booming telecom and growth potential, the need to assess the market

opportunities is evident. This report focuses on the study and assessment of the investment

opportunities in African telecom sector and identification of attractive investment

opportunities. South Africa has been considered out of scope for the study.

The study was a step by step by process wherein firstly data collection was carried out

for each of these countries on various parameters such as economic indicators, political

indicators, infrastructure developments, population and demographics and telecom indicators

(penetration, revenues etc). The parameters were quantified and given weights based on the

primary findings of the research. Further, clusters were created for the regions on the basis of

common parameters so that the clusters can be studied individually. The individual clusters

were “North Africa” and “Sub Saharan Africa”. The clusters were then further studied where

each country was assessed using 3 different methods. Each of the methods had advantages

and disadvantages of its own. Method I assessed the countries by grouping them into “Good”,

“Bad” and “Average”. The groups were given a certain score and a final score for each of the

countries was calculated. Method II assessed the countries by calculating percentile for each

of them and a final score was arrived at for each of them. The 3rd

method was the qualitative

analysis of the data collected through our primary research. The output of each of these

methods was combined and a final list of countries was arrived at. The list of countries were

North Africa – Algeria, Egypt, Morocco and Tunisia

Sub Sahara – Ghana, Mozambique, Kenya, Nigeria, Tanzania and Zambia

The analysis shows that investment in the cellular telephony is more profitable than the fixed

line telephony with the penetration levels growing by leaps and bounds. Countries that fell

Page 6: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

6 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

short of few parameters in one of the models were Angola, DRC, Sudan and Senegal. These

countries are the possible future drivers in the telecom sector.

Future telecom growth trends in few countries selected were estimated on the basis of

a proxy country. The proxy country selected was Pakistan because of the similarities

portrayed by the telecom growth in the country with few regions in Africa.

The corollary of the study clearly outlines the underlying telecom opportunities in

African region. Africa is booming in telecom and it is an attractive investment option to

invest now.

Page 7: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

7 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

TABLE OF CONTENTS

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ....................................................................................................... 4

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ..................................................................................................... 5

TABLE OF CONTENTS ........................................................................................................ 7

1.0 INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................. 9

1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE RESEARCH/ STUDY ......................................................... 9

1.2 INFORMATION ABOUT THE ORGANIZATION: .................................................... 11

1.3 NEED FOR THE STUDY ............................................................................................. 11

1.4 OBJECTIVE................................................................................................................... 11

1.5 SCOPE OF THE PROJECT ........................................................................................... 12

1.6 BRIEF METHODOLOGY ............................................................................................ 12

1.7 LIMITATIONS .............................................................................................................. 13

2.0 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY: ............................................................................. 14

2.1 RESEARCH OBJECTIVE ............................................................................................. 14

2.2 RESEARCH DESIGN ................................................................................................... 14

2.3 DATA COLLECTION ................................................................................................... 15

2.3.1 DATA COLLECTION SOURCES ......................................................................... 15

2.3.2DATA COLLECTION METHODS ......................................................................... 15

2.4 DATA ANALYSIS ........................................................................................................ 18

2.4.1DATA ANALYSIS TOOLS: ................................................................................... 20

2.5 QUALITATIVE METHOD I & II ................................................................................. 25

3.0 FINDING AND ANALYSIS ........................................................................................... 25

3.1 METHOD I .................................................................................................................... 26

3.2 METHOD 2 .................................................................................................................... 27

3.3 PRIMARY RESEARCH ................................................................................................ 30

Page 8: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

8 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

3.4 FINAL LIST OF COUNTRIES ..................................................................................... 34

3.4.1 NORTH AFRICA .................................................................................................... 36

3.4.2 SUB SAHARAN AFRICA......................................................................................49

3.4.2.1 GOOD PROSPECTS.......................................................................................49

3.4.2.2 FUTURE POSSIBLE DRIVERS.....................................................................61

3.4.3 PROXY COUNTRY ANALYSIS .......................................................................... 62

3.4.3.1 PAKISTAN : BENCHMARK COUNTRY.....................................................63

3.4.3.2 CORRELATION ............................................................................................. 64

3.5 INVESTORS PERCEPTIONS ...................................................................................... 66

3.6 MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS..............................................................................67

4.0 EMERGING TRENDS .................................................................................................... 68

5.0 CONCLUSION.................................................................................................................70

APPENDIX A:........................................................................................................................79

APPENDIX B:........................................................................................................................78

APPENDIX C:........................................................................................................................79

APPENDIX D:.......................................................................................................................82

APPENDIXE:.........................................................................................................................88

APPENDIX F:........................................................................................................................89

LIST OF TABLES/ LIST OF EXHIBITS ........................................................................... 90

GLOSSARY............................................................................................................................92

BIBLIOGRAPHY..................................................................................................................94

Page 9: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

9 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

1.0 Introduction

1.1 Background of the research/ study

The telecommunication sector has been steadily growing in most African countries. The fixed

line telecommunication systems has developed at a slower pace whereas the development of

wireless and mobile communication technologies has been phenomenal. Africa currently has

over 900 million people and a mobile penetration of just about 20%. Mobile

telecommunication was introduced in some of the African countries in 1992, after an intial

steady growth period mobile communication growth exploded around 1999 and has been

growing since. Recent investments made in the telecommunications space has tremendously

contributed to the the growth in this sector.

Private Equity is defined as any equity investment in any financial asset that is not registered

for public trading. Private equity can be used for the following purpose:

– Expand operations through capital investment

– Develop new products and technologies

– Resolve ownership and management issues

Private Equity Business Model can be easily understood by the following diagram:

Figure 1

Private equity investors seek opportunities in companies with the following attributes:

– High minimum rates of return – 25% - 35%.

Page 10: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

10 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

– Well-structured management.

– Consistent earnings.

– Excellent industry reputation.

– Ability to meet specified operational milestones.

Historically, the bulk of African private equity activity has been concentrated on a few

countries in Southern and Northern Africa, such as South Africa, Egypt and Morocco. The

lack of private equity investments in the region stems from a number of factors. Many of the

systems and institutions that typically facilitate the private equity investment process, from

deal flow to exit, are absent in the region. The small size and fragmentation of most West

African economies, their poorly developed financial markets, poor corporate governance

practices, and political instability are a few of the challenges an investor might face. In West

Africa in particular, nations such as Liberia, Ivory Coast, Togo and Sierra Leone have

experienced recent unrest which negatively impacted their economic growth. [1]

Most recently, following years of mismanagement by state-owned monopolies,

countries are increasingly adopting sector reform policies that are driving the demand for

investments in infrastructure related projects. The high returns in African equity markets over

the last five years continue to attract foreign investments in the region. And private equity

firms with regional familiarity can take advantage of the improved macroeconomic

environment in certain countries, and the prevalence of undervalued companies in the region.

These positive trends coupled with Africa‟s low correlation to world markets make

investment in the region an attractive portfolio diversification.

A final critical factor in the growth of private equity investment in the region is that

developed nations are becoming less attractive destinations for private equity. As the amount

of available capital in the US and Western Europe continues to grow, the competition for

good deals heightens, and fund managers are increasingly looking for alternative investment

destinations.

[1]

The climate for private sector development in Africa – International Finance Corporation

Page 11: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

11 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

1.2 Information about the organization:

Al-Cazar Capital is a private equity firm headquartered in Dubai which is predominantly

focused on investments in emerging markets. Agility Logistics is the sponsor for their

investments. It is a $300 million fund managed by three partners, one of them being our

mentor Mr Dinesh Tiwari. AlCazar Capital Partners diversifies its risk by investing in various

projects across industries by limiting their investments within $10-20 million. With Africa

being an emerging economy, AlCazar Capital Partners is assessing the feasibility of

investment in the African Telecom sector.

1.3 Need for the study

Africa is the first continent in the world in which cellular telephony has outnumbered the

fixed line network. There has been rapid telecom development in certain parts of Africa in the

recent past. The government of the African countries have carried out significant economic

reforms and programmes to hasten the process of economic development of their respective

countries, which in turn fuels the telecom industry. Thus, such an emerging economy is

slowly becoming the focus of the investors. Investors perceive huge potential in this market

in terms of info-communication development. In order to achieve universal access, and full

inter-country connectivity the telecom sector requires huge investment. This symbiosis calls

for a detailed research to identify precisely where the immediate opportunities exist.

1.4 Objective

With rapid developments in the telecom sector, huge investments are flowing into the African

economy. AlCazar Capital Partners, a UAE based private equity firm, is interested in the

assessment of the telecom market in Africa. The feasibility of investments considering that

most of the countries in Africa had been marred by poor social and economical conditions in

the past becomes one of the vital factors for an investor.

AlCazar Capital Partners gave us the opportunity to assess the telecom opportunities in

African countries. The objective of the study is to analyze African countries based on various

parameters like key economic indicators, political indicators, telecom infrastructure, telecom

revenues and telecom penetration, investment viability and population and demography. The

outcome of the study should be the recommended list of countries for investments and the

timeline for investment.

Page 12: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

12 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

1.5 Scope of the project

The following is the scope of the project:

a) Study and analysis of telecom opportunities in African countries.

b) The study would include the following:

i) Economic and Political Indicators

ii) Regulations and Liberalization

iii) Telecom Indicators

iv) Competitive Landscape

c) Collection of relevant data from primary sources e.g. interview, questionnaire etc. and

secondary sources e.g. electronic resources, reports and journals etc.

d) Recommend list of countries for investment.

e) Recommend telecom sector for investment.

f) Study of South Africa is out of scope.

1.6 Brief methodology

Firstly data collection was carried out for each of these countries on various parameters such

as economic indicators, political indicators, infrastructure developments, population and

demographics and telecom indicators (penetration, revenues etc). The parameter were

quantified and given weights based on the primary findings of the research. Further, clusters

were created for the regions on the basis of common parameters so that the clusters can be

studied individually. The individual clusters were “North Africa” and “Sub Saharan Africa”.

The clusters were then further studied where each country was assessed using 3 different

methods. Each of the methods had advantages and disadvantages of its own. Method I

assessed the countries by grouping them into “Good”, “Bad” and “Average”. The groups

were given a certain score and a final score for each of the countries was calculated. Method

II assessed the countries by calculating percentile for each of them and a final score was

calculated for each of them. The 3rd

method was the qualitative analysis of the data collected

through our primary research. The output of each of these methods was combined and a final

list of countries was arrived at.

Page 13: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

13 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 2

1.7 Limitations

Lack of first hand accessibility to African market: Since it wasn‟t feasible to go to

Africa, we couldn‟t get first hand information from African telecom players and

investors.

Data scarcity: Some of the data available from the secondary sources were obsolete.

Hence, it was difficult to assess the present trends of the telecom sector in Africa.

Too many assumptions in the Mathematical Model: To assess the telecom

opportunities in terms of telecom growth, licensing costs, subscriber acquisition costs etc

with a quantitative model, data wasn‟t readily available which plugged in innumerable

assumptions into the model. As a result a concrete mathematical model couldn‟t be built

to substantiate the analysis.

Limited target audience: Since the target audience was limited to investment banks,

telecom players and equity research houses who invest in the African telecom sector, it

was difficult for us to get in touch with all of them to gather information.

Page 14: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

14 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

2.0 Research Methodology:

2.1 Research Objective

The objective of this Special Group Project is to identify those African countries which

would prove to be the most profitable for Private Equity Investments in the African telecom

sector. The objective of the research therefore is to collect the relevant data required for this

study, provide an appropriate method to aid in the analysis and arrive at a final conclusion.

2.2 Research Design

The design incorporates carrying out a descriptive study to assess the feasibility of investing

in these countries based on the following parameters:

Key Economic Indicators

o GDP, real GDP growth rate & per capita GDP

o Population, Population growth rate & Demography

o Inflation

Political Indicators

o Stability

o Govt. Efficiency

o Regulation Quality

o Corruption Index

Teledensity

o Fixed Line Penetration

o Mobile Penetration

o Internet Penetration

Infrastructure

Competitive Landscape

o Operators

o Market Share

o Revenue

FDI Inflows

o Quantity

o Quality

o Trade ties with other countries

Page 15: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

15 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Licensing, Liberalization & Regulation

Investment Viability

2.3 Data Collection

2.3.1 Data Collection Sources

Secondary data sources:

o Electronic resources (world wide web)

o Reports

o Newspapers

o Magazines and journals

o Bloomberg

Primary data sources:

o Interview

Bocar A. BA, Senior Vice - President, SAMENA Telecommunications

Council.

Izhar Ahmad, Senior Manager – Market Research, SAMENA

Telecommunications Council.

Bhaskar Peruri, Sales Director - Middle East, Pakistan & Egypt Proxim

Wireless Europe B.V

Nikhil Iyer, Associate Vice President, Kotak Mahindra Limited

Andrew Brierly, Associate – Investment Management, Ernst & Young

2.3.2Data Collection Methods

Cross Sectional Data Sheet

An Excel spreadsheet was formatted to comprehensively capture the data that was collected

for all the countries. The spreadsheet had the list of all the countries and the parameters they

are measured against for the purpose of this study.

The Cross Reference File helps in easy comparison of countries against each other, which is

the main reason why this particular method of Data Collation was chosen.

Page 16: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

16 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Snapshot of the Spreadsheet

Figure 3

Listed below are the various heads under which data was collected to help in the research:

Headings Sources

Telecom Characteristic Internet

Liberalization/Licensing & Industry

Activity Internet

Economic Characteristics Internet

Page 17: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

17 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

GDP (US$ billion) World bank

Real GDP Growth (%) World bank

Population World bank

Population Growth (historical avg) World bank

Per Capita GDP World bank

Inflation World bank

FDI inflows (% of GDP) World bank

Leading Countries with trade ties Internet

Main telephone lines ICT,ITU,Internet

Mobile subscribers ICT,ITU,Internet

Internet users ICT,ITU,Internet

% of main Telephone Lines ICT,ITU,Internet

% of Mobile Subscribers

ICT, ITU,

Internet

% of Internet Users

ICT, ITU,

Internet

Political Characteristics Internet

Political Stability Score World bank

Government Efficiency Score World bank

Regulation Quality Score World bank

Penetration World bank

Table 1

Questionnaire

Page 18: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

18 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

An exhaustive questionnaire was prepared bearing in mind the target audience. Considering

the nature of this study, Primary research needed to be an active interaction with specialists in

the field rather than a questionnaire.

Therefore, the focus was on scheduling interviews. The questionnaire was intended to collect

information from those resources that couldn‟t spare the time for an interview.

Salient Features of the Questionnaire:

o Brief & Exhaustive

o Simple & Self Explanatory

o Close Ended Questions

o Multiple Choice/Selection type questions

o Questions framed in a logical order

Please refer to Appendix C for the questionnaire.

2.4 Data Analysis

Analysis of Parameters

The data collected and collated in the cross reference sheet based on the parameters selected

needed to be weighed in order of importance from the point of view of a Telecom investment.

The parameters were consolidated to the following six:

Table 2

* it is important to note that Political Environment was a calculated average of the scores

assigned by the World bank on Government Efficiency, Political Stability & regulatory

Quality.

Assigning weights:

Page 19: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

19 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Primary research helped in ranking the above parameters in their order of importance.

Once these parameters were in order, it was required for this ordinal data to be converted into

a quantitative scale to be able to rate the countries based on the respective parameters and

calculate an overall score (process explained later). For this purpose we assigned weights to

these parameters based on certain logic.

Since it was difficult to quantify how important each one of these parameters was, we

decided the weights would have equal intervals.

We then tried assigning simple weights of 1, 2,3,4,5 & 6

Table 3

Since the interval between these weights was 1 unit, the total score for quite a few countries

were the same or at least within a small range because they had almost fared equally among

some of the parameters and the differences in the other parameters were set off.

Due to this deficiency in demarcation, we decided to increase the interval between the

weights to 2.

The new weights assigned were 1, 3,5,7,9 & 11

Page 20: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

20 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

On studying the overall scores, the interval seemed fair enough. Although there still exists

countries which have the same overall scores, this is mainly due to the reason that the

countries have similar characteristics and have fared equally rather than a deficiency in the

weights assigned.

These weights were later used to multiply with the parameter score, calculated under the

average & percentile method (explained later in this document) to arrive at a total score used

for comparison.

2.4.1Data Analysis Tools:

From data analysis point of view, it is important to note that we have divided the African

Countries as:

1) South Africa (out of scope of this study)

2) North African Countries (Algeria, Egypt, Libya, Morocco & Tunisia)

3) Sub Saharan African Countries (Comprises of a list of 48 countries)

This preliminary classification is based on the level of economic development. South Africa

is the most developed country in the continent with a highly mature telecom market. The

North African Countries have a similar telecom history and belong to that stage of

development which is slowly evolving into a mature market with a high growth potential in

the very near future.

Sub Saharan Africa consists of those countries with relatively low levels of penetration and

telecom development. This is the segment where most of the investors are currently focussing

on due to the high returns in a relatively short span of time. As a result of which, the focus of

our study has also predominantly been in this segment without ignoring the North African

Countries.

Page 21: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

21 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 4

Simple Average Quantitative Method I

This is a method we devised to classify the countries on a 3 point scale depending on how

good the country is on each parameter as against the average of the cluster.

Here the 3 point scale being:

Good Avg Bad

3 2 1

Good (3): A country would be classified as good against a certain parameter if it is

significantly above the average.

E.g. Algeria, Population of 33.4 Million as against an average of 30.4 Million as the range

subjectively decided was +/- 1Million.

Average (2): If the country measures a score in the average range of the cluster, it would be

rated 2. The range, however, would subjectively vary from parameter to parameter.

E.g. Algeria, Penetration of 62.5% as against an average of 55.2%. Here again the range was

subjectively decided to be +/- 10%.

Page 22: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

22 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Note: Penetration & Inflation are those parameters which are better if they are lower.

Therefore when the range below average are considered good and the range above average is

considered bad for the sake of Penetration.

Bad (1): Quite simply, the measure lying below average is considered bad. In certain cases

this is looked at subjectively on a case to case basis.

E.g. Both Burundi & Zimbabwe is rated Bad as far as Inflation is considered for the exact

opposite reasons. Burundi faces a deflation of -8.4% and Zimbabwe is facing Hyper Inflation

of 1016%. Cases such as these would be looked at subjectively.

Scores

Once these countries are rated as per the priorities in the above manner, these ratings are

multiplied with the weights (explained in a section earlier) and summed to get the final score

for the country.

Table 4

We have then taken the top 25% of the countries into consideration based on these scores.

Advantages of this method:

Simple & Easy: This method of calculation is fairly simple as the only quantitative

method it uses is the simple average. It is therefore easy to band the countries into

Good, Bad & Average

Middle Value: As it calculates the average and compares the same against other

countries, we have an average basket to classify some of the countries and this is

important from the point of view that these parameters often do not clearly fit into

Good or Bad.

Page 23: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

23 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Thin Line of Demarcation: The reason we could not use a 4 point scale, namely

Very Good, Good, Average & Bad is because a) it is often difficult to distinguish

between Good & Very Good under these parameters and b) from telecom investment

point of view, it does not matter if it is good or great, for e.g. If you consider Political

Stability, it does not matter if it is very good or good as from a telecom investment

point of view, all that matters is that there is political stability based on World bank

Definition.

Subjective Input: In this study it is extremely important to have some subjective

input in deciding the range of the parameters. The parameters are such that it requires

a judgemental approach. For e.g. Deciding on a range of +/- 1 Million for Population

etc has been the subjective aspect of it. Also in parameters such as Inflation &

Penetration, where it initially seems like the lower the better, we obviously know that

very low levels of Inflation can impede growth and extremely low penetration could

indicate something about the technology in the country.

Limitations of this method:

No Standard Range across all parameters: This is the adverse effect of having an

analysis tool which is in part subjective. It could be influenced by various biases and

imprecision when such a call is made by one person. Therefore we have discussed

each parameter as a team and then have finally concluded the analyses to do away

with this limitation of the study.

Percentile Quantitative Method II

In this method, the actual scores are converted into Percentiles to find out where the

country stands among other countries when measured for a particular parameter. This

method brings about a standard across all the parameters measured, the standard being

the percentiles. For certain parameters where the lower was better, we have calculated

the inverse percentiles (i.e. 1- percentile) eg. Inflation,Penetration etc.

Scores

Page 24: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

24 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

These percentiles are then multiplied with the weights (explained earlier in section) and

summed to get the final score for the country.

Advantages of this method:

Each country is comparable: In the percentile method the overall scores would be

way different and each country would be ranked in an order. Therefore the countries

are comparable against each other, asa against method one where they are classified in

three major categories – Good, Bad & Average.

Standard maintained across: This method is better than the simple average method

in the sense that it maintains a standard across all the parameters and does not have

differing ranges as in Method 1. The standard here being the data is completely

converted to percentiles.

No Subjectivity: Since this method is purely quantitative, there is no judgement

required and gives no room for such human errors and bias.

Limitations of this method:

Inverse Percentile Calculation: While the Simple Average method is fairly simple,

this is not all that straightforward. Certain parameters are such that they cannot be

measured like any other because of the nature of the parameter. i.e. For Inflation &

penetration, the inverse percentile needed to be calculated as unlike the other

parameters, the lower these measures are the better.

Page 25: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

25 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Qualitative validation Required: This limitation also arises due to the parameters

such as inflation & Penetration being part of the data. While the lower these measures

are the better, this does not hold good after a certain point. This means that both these

parameters are such that if it gets really low, it turns into a negative instead of a

positive attribute. Eg. While really low Inflation/Deflation impedes growth, Deflation

& extremely low levels of Penetration could mean the country isn‟t technologically

sound. This could be a possible reason why the telecom development is not up to the

mark thereby having very low penetration. Qualitative Analysis is required to point

out these aspects which this method does not allow.

2.5 Qualitative Method I & II

Primary Research & Secondary Research

For the sake of Analysis we have used Primary & Secondary Research as the qualitative

aspect of the study to back up the results found from the Quantitative methods.

Our Primary Research resources were asked to list countries based on the following factors:

Lucrative Investment

Risk Involved

Telecom Infrastructure

Technology

Liberalisation

Regulation

It is worth noticing that most of these factors are those characteristics which form the

qualitative aspect of the study and expert opinions are extremely important for this reason as

there is no readily available information for the same.

3.0 Finding and Analysis

The output of the 3 different methods used for analysis were a little different from each other

because of the underlying differences in the base of the model.

Page 26: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

26 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

From the list of all sub saharan countries the first quartile was chosen and ranked in

descending order. The first quartile was chosen to limit the number of investment option and

because 25% of the population was considered an appropriate size for selection.

For North Africa, the top 3 countries were chosen on the same grounds.

3.1 Method I

The following outlines the output list for Method – I with their respective scores:

North Africa Score

Egypt 100

Morocco 98

Algeria 89

Tunisia 78

Libya 53

Table 5

Sub Saharan Africa Score

Angola 96

Benin 86

Ghana 75

Tanzania 75

Uganda 75

Nigeria 73

Burkina Faso 71

Cameroon 70

Namibia 70

Sudan 70

Senegal 70

Mozambique 70

Table 6

The following is a pictorial snapshot of list of countries from Method I.

Page 27: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

27 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 5

3.2 Method 2

The following outlines the output list for Method – II with their respective scores:

North Africa Score

Tunisia 21.41

Algeria 19.75

Libya 18.75

Egypt 16.75

Morocco 13.00

Page 28: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

28 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Sub Saharan Africa Score

Ethiopia 25.74

Niger 23.85

Sudan 22.76

Cameroon 22.43

Mail 21.77

Burkina Faso 21.67

Guinea 21.42

Angola 21.40

Madagascar 21.10

Tanzania 20.24

Mozambique 19.93

Chad 19.90

Table 7

The following is a pictorial snapshot of list of countries from Method II.

Page 29: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

29 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 6

Page 30: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

30 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

3.3 Primary Research

Findings from Primary Research:

Interview with Mr. Bocar A. BA (Senior Vice - President, SAMENA

Telecommunications Council) gave us first hand information about the telecom sector and

its prospects in Africa. He has been working in the telecommunication sector for over 7 years

and has great expertise in this field, he is very optimistic about the growth in the African

telecom sector especially in the sub Saharan region.

Algeria, Egypt, Kenya, Mozambique and Morocco is considered to have good telecom

infrastructure according to Mr. Bocar. However he does not feel that the existing telecom

infrastructure will play a significant role in deciding the future of telecom growth in African

countries.

“If there is potential, Infrastructure will follow! Its opportunity that drives investments in

infrastructure and not the other way round” says Mr. Bocar.

“Three P`s” that are the most important factors for a telecom investor: Population,

Penetration, Policy.

“Most African countries are liberalizing their telecom sector and therefore the policies are

framed keeping the interests of the investors in mind, so policies are not that worry us

anymore” quoted Mr. Bocar.

He cites that Egypt, Tanzania, Ghana and Zambia has favourable regulatory conditions for a

telecom investments thereby improving the chances of higher returns for a private equity

investor as well. Political instability and corruption plays on the minds of investors but does

not hold enough weight age to deter investors from investing in a particular economy.

Mr. Bocar feels Democratic Republic of Congo, Kenya, Mozambique, Nigeria, Gabon and

Ghana are some countries which should yield a high return on investment in the near future.

The low telecom penetration levels, fairly high population coupled with flow of grants and

funds from foreign countries make them attractive investment destination. When asked about

UAE investors perception on the African markets he said “Etisalat has always been interested

in Africa and it has special interests in Egypt, the perception of investors is slowly changing

Page 31: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

31 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

in UAE and they have started looking beyond Europe and America to park their funds”.

Mr.Bocar highlighted the importance of several emerging trends and technologies, he

mentioned MVNO (Mobile Virtual Network Operator) as an emerging trend.

He also mentioned China`s role in the development of African telecom sector. China is one of

the many countries which has started investing in a big way in some of the sub-Saharan

countries and Chinese companies are increasingly providing technology and infrastructure

development services to most of the sub-Saharan and North African countries.

Mr. Izhar Ahmad (Senior Manager Market Research, SAMENA Telecommunications

Council) was kind enough to share some of his insights about the booming

telecommunication sector in Africa. He says Algeria, Egypt, Ghana, Kenya, Mozambique,

Morocco and Mauritius are witnessing improvement in telecommunication infrastructure. Mr.

Ahmed feels demand for value added services will grow and therefore bring about newer

opportunities in some of the more mature telecom markets like Tunisia, Botswana etc.

“Broad band internet and 3G mobile services are getting up the popularity charts and most

telecom companies are responding” said Mr. Ahmed.

According to Mr. Ahmed countries such as DRC, Kenya, Morocco, Nigeria, Ghana, Zambia,

Tanzania and Senegal will be place to watch out for if one is looking for high return on

investments form the telecom perspective. On the one hand He considers political

exploitation, high unemployment rates and shortage of skilled man power as factors which

could impede the telecom growth and on the other hand he feels lower handset costs,

international aid through subsidies and increased demand for telecom services will help drive

the telecom sector to new heights in most of the African regions.

Interview with Mr. Bhaskar Peruri (Sales Director Middle East, Pakistan & Egypt,

Proxim Wireless Europe B.V) gave us an insight on the prevailing technology in the

telecom sector. He specializes in the North African and Middle eastern region. He believes

that Egypt and Morocco are perceived to be the next big markets in the African continent.

Mr. Peruri is of the opinion that technological changes are similar to human evolution and

Africa has jumped an evolutionary step and therefore will be blessed with technologies like

Wi-Max (Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave access) and VSAT without going

through the pain of installing basic telephone or broadband infrastructure.

Page 32: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

32 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

According to Mr. Peruri Algeria and Egypt are two countries which will have higher returns

in the near future. The aggressive liberalization measures and new foreign investments make

these two countries attractive destinations in the North African region.

He echoes the sentiments of other investors by saying “Political instability, corruption and

religious hard lining may be present in the North African countries but have no relation with

the aggressive growth in the telecom industry, whatever the political state of a particular

country people will always need to communicate and that‟s where we come in…”.

In an interview with Mr. Nikhil Iyer (Associate Vice President, Kotak Mahindra

Limited) we discussed about the UAE investors perception of the telecom story in Africa.

Mr. Iyer was bullish on the African growth story and felt telecom, infrastructure development

along with healthcare will drive the investment wave in most African nations for the next

decade. Mr. Iyer spoke about the Mo Ibrahim foundation and how it helps to have initiatives

to attract foreign investments into Africa.

Mr. Iyer cited several examples such as that of Ghana looks set to achieve middle-income

country status by 2015 already Ghanaians access to electricity is the highest in Sub-Saharan

Africa outside South Africa, In Algeria foreign investors benefit from tax incentives,

including five-year tax relief for companies investing in new projects, in Tanzania the mining

sector, particularly gold mining, should pick up as new projects come on stream in late 2007

and output increases. He said European investors look at Africa as a hedge against the

standard risks existing in the world markets as African markets do not follow any patters

similar to other market.

He would put his money on Ghana, Algeria, Kenya and Nigeria when it came to returns in

the next 3 – 5 years time frame. He also pointed out that political instability does not have a

big impact on investors mindset as they already know about the political situation and their

returns weigh much higher than the perceived risks.

Page 33: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

33 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Key findings from the questionnaire

Population, telecom penetration, economic conditions and foreign direct investments

are four of the most important criteria‟s investors look out for when investing in the

telecom sector of a particular country.

Political conditions have limited influence on the telecom investors‟ sentiments.

Certain countries in Africa is perceived to be low risk and high return proposition,

however there are countries which are also perceived to be High Risk and Low Return

proposition.

Nigeria , Kenya and DRC are looked upon as great prospects for telecom investments.

UAE investors are positive about the African telecom markets and are looking at

these investments in the near future.

Primary research data was collected from experts in the relevant field wherein their

preferences were asked about the countries for investment.

Page 34: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

34 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

The following is a pictorial snapshot of list of countries from primary research:

Figure 7

3.4 Final List of countries

The final list of countries was selected based on:

a) The common countries under all three methods

b) Strong reasons given by primary resources

After the analysis was performed, the following final list of countries was chosen for

recommendation for investment now:

Page 35: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

35 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 8

There are a few countries that fell short of certain parameters in one of the models but were

weighed just below the scale of the good prospect investment options. These countries will be

the possible future drivers in the telecom sector. The list of countries are:

Page 36: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

36 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 9

3.4.1 North Africa

Egypt

Egypt is a self sufficient country with abundant energy resources e.g petroleum, coal and

natural gas. The country‟s GDP in the year 2006 was 107.5 billion which has grown at a rate

of 6.8% jumping from constant 3% for the last one decade. The country has undergone

significant economic reforms incuding the few listed as follows:

1. Tariff reductions and customs reforms: Tariff reductions have been done to attract

foreign investments to fuel growth in the economy.

2. Tax rates cut to 20% in fiscal year 2005: To encourage more money circulation in

the economy to inject growth.

Page 37: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

37 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

3. Revisited and revived privatization: The focus of the government is gradually

shifting towards economic development through privatization.

Telecom Market

The following are the telecom industry highlights:

• Average mobile spending as percentage of GDP is estimated at 1.7%.

• Etisalat of UAE recently won the 3rd GSM license with 3G entitlement for US$ 2.9

billion and launched operations in May 2007.1

• Telecom Egypt owns 45% stake in Vodafone Egypt.1

Egypt has adopted a liberalized attitude towards granting entry to private players. The

following are the findings on the regulations front:

• ECMS operates a GSM license which is due to expire in 2013

• Regulators introduced number portability in 2007

Competitive Landscape

The telecom sector in Egypt has the following players:

Figure 10

Page 38: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

38 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Mobinil is a telecom subsidiary of Orascom operating in Egypt. The revenue growth of

Mobinil for 3 years has been:

Figure 11

Mobinil revenues grew at a CAGR of 43.42% from 2005 to 2007.

1

Telecom Opportunities

Egypt has total mobile penetration of 24% and the total population of 75.4 millions.

People who cannot afford basic ammenities constitute 5% of the population. An

untapped market of about 71% is attractive for investment.

Egypt is a developed market in terms of infrastructure developments and setup. For

telecom players, developed infrastructure decreases their fixed cost or setup cost

leading to low entry load.

Egypt‟s liberal moves to make it a diverse country in terms of economic development

will open up doors for private equity and foreign investors. It is unlikely that the

government's commitment to economic reform will change even in the event of a

government reshuffle which may occur towards the end of the year.

1 The telecom developments have been cited from the Orascom-Mobinil annual report 2006

Page 39: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

39 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

The listed companies in Egypt follow Egyptian accounting standrads adhering to

IFRS indicating tranparent and credible financial reports.

Egypt has made the fastest climb to the top of the list in ease of doing business. Doing

Business 2008 has forecasted that large emerging markets are reforming faster and

Egypt has similar potential.

The Doing Business report shows “equity returns are highest in countries that are

reforming the most," said Michael Klein, World Bank/IFC Vice President for

Financial and Private Sector Development. This should give an upside edge to Egypt

in terms of expected returns while exiting the private equity investment.2

Algeria

Algeria is the second largest country in the African continent. GDP in the year 2006 was

$113.2 billion which has grown at a rate of 3%. The country has had significant economic

reforms incuding the few below:

Strong fiscal surpluses are partly redistributed by investing extensively in

infrastructure, expanding the civil services and raising public-sector wages.

The government is beginning to liberalise in certain areas of the economy. Algeria's

state-owned banks was privatised in 2007. Large amounts of foreign investment have

been drawn into the telecommunications, housing, power and water sectors in this

year.

There exists tax incentives for foreign investors. e.g: Five-year tax relief for

companies investing in new projects.

Telecom Market

Algeria‟s mobile market grew at the rate of 200% exceeding all expectations.

The country‟s fixed-line market is behind the other relatively developed North

African markets, but accelerated developments in this sector is expected from 2007

2 Doing Business 2008--the fifth in an annual series issued by the World Bank and IFC

Page 40: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

40 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

onwards resulting from the upcoming privatisation of the country‟s incumbent

telecom.

Improved fixed-line and wireless infrastructure will also stimulate the country‟s

underdeveloped Internet market. The introduction of Third Generation (3G) mobile

technology is currently being implemented.

3

Competitive Landscape

The telecom sector in Algeria has the following players:

Figure 12

Djezzy is a telecom subsidiary of Orascom operating in Algeria. The revenue growth for

Djezzy for past 3 years has been:

3 GDP forecast has been cited from Economist

Page 41: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

41 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 13

The revenues grew at a CAGR of 26.51%

Telecom Opportunities

Telecom opportunities lie in Algeria because of investments in infrastructure and

increasing active reforms for economic development.

The current penetration in Algeria is about 60% with a population of 33.34 million.

Untapped market is high due to high population. Per capita GDP stands at $3393.

A fairly developed market in terms of infrastructure leading to lower fixed cost for

new players.

The accounting standards in Algeria can be concluded to be credible. It follows

Egyptian accounting standrads and is in adherence to IFRS.

Morocco

Morocco is one of the rare Arab countries in the Middle East & African region, which does

not have significant oil and gas resources. Morocco‟s economy is fairly stable with

continuous growth over the past 30 odd years, but is still considered one of the poorest

countries in the North African region with people having low spending power. The country is

considered to have attractive investments and good infrastructure.

Page 42: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

42 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

The country has had the following economic reforms:

Foreign nationals can invest freely in all the sectors without any screening or

preliminary authorization.The constraint to receiving high level of investments is

the prevalent bureaucracy in the country. The country's complicated tax system

and relatively high tax rates have long been identified as major constraints on

business.

According to the Index of Economic Freedom, 2007 Assessment, Morocco's

economy is 57.4 percent free, which is considered high when compared to the

other countries in the Middle East.4

http://www.heritage.org/research/features/index/country.cfm?id=Morocco

Figure 14

Competitive Landscape

Morocco has 2 mobile players and 2 fixed line operators. Their incumbent, Maroc Telecom,

provides land line phones, mobile phone lines, and internet access. Maroc telecom started its

privatisation back in 2004 by selling 34% of its stake. It then sold another 16% of its stake in

2005 because of the immediate need to fund major economic and social reforms. The

company is listed in both Casablanca Stock Exchange and Euronext Paris.

The telecom sector in Morocco has the following players:

4 http://www.heritage.org/research/features/index/country.cfm?id=Morocco

Page 43: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

43 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 15

The revenue growth for Maroc Telecom for 2 years has been:

Figure 16

Morocco has certain characteristics typical of developing countries:

Restraining government spending

Reducing constraints on private activity and foreign trade

Check on inflation to keep it within manageable bounds.

Page 44: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

44 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Telecom Opportunities

The government of Morocco has announced a tender for "custom-made new

generation" telecommunications licenses that will allow both fixed and mobile

services. The licenses are "open" in terms of what a bidding company or consortium

proposes to provide in technology, services, use of existing or new infrastructure, and

coverage targets.” 5

The Moroccan market has strong growth potential. Projected growth over the next 5

to 10 years is 3 million new fixed subscribers, 9 million new mobile subscribers and

500,000 to 1 million new Internet subscribers.

There is a steady low inflation rate of 2.7%. The inflation is constantly kept in check.

Tunisia

Tunisia has the most competitive economy in Africa and the Arab world. It moved seven

places up to 30th

position according to the latest Global Competitiveness Report 2006-07

released by the world economic forum in terms of global competitiveness. This is primarily

due to the way economy is successfully diversified, openness to the external world with

exports a catalyst for growth, sound and effective management of resources. Its varied range

of exports accounts for 50% of GDP.

Tunisia had a sustained growth rate with average GDP growth rate in the last five

years had been around 5.2% and the forecasted GDP growth for the next four years is about

6.1%.

Tunisia‟s legislation and regulations is transparent across all levels:

Privatization and contract procurements are done through bids

To make sure there is transparency in commercial transactions, the competition and

price law which is applicable since 1991 is followed.

The accounting methodology followed is the one used in OECD countries.

For first ten years of operations related to agricultural projects, regional development

projects, there is total tax exemption on profits and after 11th

year it‟s at the rate of

10%.

5 An article from http://pulse.tiaonline.org/article.cfm?id=2170

Page 45: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

45 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Freedom to Invest

Nationals and foreigners have the freedom to invest in various sectors in Tunisia.

Foreign investors do not need any formal authorisation and can keep up to 100%

capital in a particular project in most sectors.

Tunisia has received top investment grades from financial institution and rating

agencies. American agencies (BBB and Baa2), European Agency (BBB) and Japanese

agency (A-) have awarded Tunisia with this distinction which shows the tremendous

confidence the international financial community has on Tunisia.6

Telecom Sector

Tunisia‟s telecom sector is one of the most dynamic sectors which have experienced

tremendous growth rates. There had been huge investments in the establishment of

telecom infrastructure which has resulted in a fully digitized national network, 6500

kilometres of optic fibre highway, national and regional loops using SDH technology,

service network architecture moved to large-band multi service architecture,

information freeways and data, strong international network.

In 2006, partial privatization (35%) of Tunisie Telecom took place to Dubai‟s Tecom-

Dig for US$ 2.24 billion.

Estimated average mobile spend as percentage of GDP is 2.5%

Telecom Players

Tunisia is a two player market with Orascom Telecom Tunisie - Limited Company

Tunisiana having a market share of 47% as of June, 2007 and Tunisie Telecom

which is the incumbent and telecommunication and service provider in Tunisia and

has a market share of 53%

6 The ratings have been cited from the Orascom-Mobinil annual report 2006

Page 46: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

46 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 17

Tunisiana, a subsidiary of Orascom telecom in Tunisia has witnessed growth in revenues over

the last 3 years. The following are the revenue indicators in Tunisia

Figure 18

License and Regulations:

Tunisiana was granted a license in May 2002. The licence is due to expire in 2017 and

renewable for a five year period. Using this licence, they are free to operate

international gateway.

“Instance Nationale des Telecommunications,” is the local authority for telecom

regulation in Tunisia.

Page 47: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

47 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Telecom Opportunities

Tunisia‟s telecom sector has experienced tremendous growth rates and has one of the

most developed infrastructures in North Africa which shows that there is a huge

potential in this sector which can be exploited

Various networks are available in Tunisia and communication can be established from

almost anywhere in the world.

Improved technical and financial conditions for the acquisition of powerful telephone

systems are meant and bound to attract foreign investors.

Sound regulatory framework makes it an attractive option for the investors.

Economic Snapshot

2006 2007 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 in Million %age USD %age

(% of

GDP)

Algeria 113.2 125.3 5.3 3 4.8 5.3 5.9 6.2 33.4 1.5 3393 2.3 2.6

Egypt 107.9 - 4.5 6.8 - - - - 74.2 1.8 1454 6.2

5400

Mn

(2005)

Morocco 57.3 59.08 1.7 7.3 3.1 5.1 5.6 4.9 30.9 1.1 1988 2.7

1600

Mn

(2005)

Tunisia 30.3 32.12 4.2 5.2 6 5.6 5.1 5.8 10.2 1.1 2959 3.1

4.3

723

Mn

(2005)

Table 8

Penetration Overview

Page 48: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

48 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

NORTH

AFRICA Population

Main telephone

lines

Mobile

subscribers Internet users

% of

main

Telephone

Lines

% of

Mobile

Subscribers

% of

Internet

Users

000s 000s p. 100 000s p. 100 000s p. 100

Algeria 33354 2841.3 8.52 20998 62.5 2460 7.38 8.52% 62.95% 7.38%

Egypt 75437 10808 14.33 18001.1 23.86 6000 7.95 14.33% 23.86% 7.95%

Morocco 30735 1266.1 4.12 16004.7 52.07 6100 19.85 4.12% 5207.32% 1984.71%

Tunisia 10210 1268.5 12.42 7339.1 71.88 1294.9 12.68 12.42% 7188.15% 1268.27%

Table 9

3.4.2 Sub Saharan Africa

3.4.2.1 Good Prospects

Ghana

Ghana is one of the potential emerging economies in Africa. Ghana has brought down

poverty levels by improving policies and institutions. Ghanaians access to electricity is the

highest in Sub-Saharan Africa outside South Africa.

It has invested in infrastructure and basic services to improve economy and living conditions.

Ghana looks set to achieve middle-income country status by 2015. The country‟s GDP in

2006 is 12.9 billion which has grown at a rate of 6.2%.

The telecom market in Ghana has the following most recent developments:

First GSM operator acquired in 1998 with partner France Telecom.3

11.9 m subscribers by June 2007.3

Third license awarded to Etisalat telecom for US$ 2.9 bn.3

Telecom penetration in Ghana in is 23.09% and the population that cannot afford basic

amenities constitute 44.8% of the population. The untapped market comrises of 33.71%.

Competitive Landscape

Milicom Ghana holds a major market share in Ghana telecom sector. Milicom Ghana‟s

revenue growth for the last year was:

Page 49: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

49 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 19

Milicom has grown with a CAGR of 79.7% in 1 year.7

Telecom Opportunities

Good Infrastructure and big available markat are 2 big factors for opportunities to

enter Ghana telecom market.

Active mergers and acquisitions in Ghana in the telecom sector in the past years

indicates liberalized and well regulated telecom sector.

Untapped market cose to 40%.

Global accounting standards e.g. IFRS 7 and IAS 23 are being followed by the listed

telecom companies. It indicates tranparency and credibility in revenue reporting.

Kenya

Kenya is a populous country with a population of 35 million. Country‟s GDP in the year

2006 is $21.2 billion. The telecom penetration in the country stands at 19% which is very

low. The political stability in the Kenya is very volatile and acts as the only deterrance to

foreign investments. However, the liberalized market looks very attarctive for emerging

sectors like telecom.

7 Telecom developments cited from Millicom annual report 2006

Page 50: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

50 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Kenya has seen tremendous telecom investments in the last one year and the economy is

expected to get boosted by telecommunications, infrastructure development and financial

services sectors.

Kenya is looked at as an attractive investment opportunity for the following features:

The estimated total population of the region is 35 million provides an impressive

consumer base. If the huge popoulation is added to the highly skilled human resource

capital and the availability of international transportation infrastructure with a

regional business hub.

It‟s membership of the Common Market for East and Southern Africa (COMESA).

Kenya is a member of the East African Community (EAC), where trade is expected

to flow freely by 2013.

The Communication Commission of Kenya (CCK) director general, Eng John

Waweru, said "We were used to fixed lines, and history has it that fixed lines have not

solved our developmental issues.Telkom Kenya only managed to connect 300,000

subscribers, while mobile phones have added nine million more, this is a clear

indication that the future is wireless".

Competitive Landscape

The following are the existing telecom players in Kenya:

Figure 20

Page 51: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

51 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Safaricom is a partnered entity of Vodafone operating in kenya. The following are the

revenue indicators of safaricom for 3 years:

Figure 21

Safaricom revenues have grown at a CAGR of 58.56%.

Telecom Opportunities

Attractive investments into the country for infrastructure developments.

Confidence in Kenya's capital markets are at an all time high according to a Business

Leadership Confidence Index prepared by the Steadman Group. The survey places

Kenyan CEOs confidence in the Kenyan atock market at 68% promising good

prospects for private equity exit strategies.

High Population and low penetration leave a huge untapped market.

Nigeria

Nigeria is one of most populous African country with its population standing at 134 million.

The country‟s GDP in 2006 is $114.7 billion which has grown at the rate of 5.9%. Nigeria is

Africa‟s one of the biggest and fastest growing telecom markets. It attracts huge amounts of

foreign investment, and market penetration is 24% which is still at low levels.

The telecom market in Nigeria has the following most recent developments:

Page 52: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

52 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Over 200 companies are providing virtually all kinds of telecom and value-added

services. The mobile sector has seen triple-digit growth rates five years in a row since

competition was introduced.

A fifth GSM operator and four 3G mobile networks were licensed in early 2007.

A new unified licensing regime designed to increase competition between fixed and

mobile network operators is expected to also give a boost to the Internet sector.

Competitive Landscape

The following are the existing telecom players in Nigeria:

Figure 22

The following are the revenue growth trends of MTN Nigeria:

Page 53: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

53 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 23

MTN revenue grew with a CAGR of 49%

Telecom Opportunities

Nigeria attracts huge foreign investments as it portrays tremendous potential in the

telecom sector. Investors are with the perception that Nigeria‟s potential will be

unbeatable if the 134 million population can be trained and used to the economy‟s

benefit.

Telecom Infrastructue is a development focus area for the government. Although the

political instability has had a toll over the country‟s economic development, the

country realizes that sectoral development is the key to harmonic economy.

Huge population and low penetration

Projected liberalization is an added attraction

Zambia

Zambia is a country in South Central Africa which shares borders with eight countries. The

population of Zambia is around 11.4 Million growing at the rate of 1.7%. Copper wealth has

made Zambia one of the most urbanized countries in Africa. It is known for its political and

social stability.

Page 54: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

54 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Economic Conditions:

Zambia‟s GDP growth rate is around 6% is expected to reach 7% or more by the end

of 2007 due to new investments in mining, agriculture, tourism and other sectors.

Despite progress in privatization and budgetary reform, Zambia's economic growth

remains somewhat below the 6%-7% needed to reduce poverty significantly.

Inflation had been a cause of concern in Zambia. However, the rate of inflation has

dropped considerably since 2006 (first time in single digits).

Zambian economy primarily reliable on the copper industry. Copper accounts for

more than 80% of the foreign exchange.

The Zambian Government is undertaking an economic diversification program to

reduce the economy's reliance on the copper industry. This initiative is to exploit

other sectors like agriculture, tourism, gemstone mining, and hydro power.

Competitive Landscape

Zambia has an independently regulated telecoms sector with three competing mobile

networks and a monopoly fixed-line operator, Zamtel. The three telecom players offering

cellular services in Zambia are: Celtel, Telecel and Zamtel. Of the three, Celtel is the

dominant player in the country holding up to 79% of the market share. It has 1.6 Million

customers till now. Its revenue has grown over the last few years. Last two years revenue

growth is shown in the below graph:

Figure 24

Page 55: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

55 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Telecom Opportunities

For a population of 11.8 million the mobile penetration is just 16%, so there is huge untapped

market.

With three mobile operators already there, growth in the market is expected fuelled by

increase in competition.

The infrastructure is developing fast with the rapid growth in the telecommunications sector.

To accelerate the telecommunication infrastructure in this region, The Development Bank of

Southern Africa (DBSA) has agreed to contribute $13.5-million to support a large-scale

network infrastructure development project to be undertaken by Celtel Zambia. Liberalization

of internet service and ease of an Internet service provider (ISP) to operate its own

international data gateway is bound to encourage investors.

The country‟s political stability, access to international markets, an educated workforce and

relatively good governance gives opportunities for foreign operators to invest in the Zambia‟s

telecom sector.

Tanzania

Tanzania with a population of around 39 million is heavily dependent on agriculture which

accounts for half of GDP, provides 85% of exports, and employs 90% of the workforce. It

has had a steady GDP growth of around 6.7 %.

The communications sector plays and will continue to play a major role in contributing to the

social and economic development of Tanzania. Telecommunication facilities are widely

available across the country and are linked to the world through the country‟s commercial

capital, Dar es Salaam.

Recent developments in Tanzania’s telecom sector

Tanzania becomes only the second country in Africa after South Africa to get the 3G

technology after the 3G HSDPA network by Vodafone Tanzania

Etisalat had raised its stake in Tanzania‟s fourth operator Zantel to 51%

Page 56: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

56 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

The Tanzania Communications Regulatory Authority made a pioneer move in Africa, by

approving in 2005 a Converged Licensing Framework (CLF).

Liberalization and Regulation

The information and communication sector in Tanzania is completely liberalised. The

regulation in Tanzania is governed by Tanzania Communications Regulatory Authority

(TCRA) and its objective is to regulate telecommunications, broadcasting and postal matters

in Tanzania.

Competitive Landscape

There are currently four licensed operators in Tanzania in addition to the government owned

fixed line company which is in the process of privatization. The mobile penetration as of now

is meager 16% but it‟s expected to grow leaps and bounds. The five operators are:

Figure 25

The revenue growth of Vodacom in the last three years is as shown below:

Page 57: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

57 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 26

Telecom opportunities

Huge population of around 39 million the mobile penetration is only around 16%. With

increase in the number of operators and competition this penetration can increase to a large

extent.

After the convergence in licensing, Tanzania‟s telecom sector has become more appealing to

the Foreign Direct Investments (FDI) and domestic capital.

Infrastructure is developing with the increase in the spread of wireless technologies and

introduction of fibre optic cable fuelling the telecommunication growth

Increasing income per head will increase the demand for communication services.

Mozambique

Mozambique is characterized as a dual economy because of the large divide between the

capital-intensive sector and traditional sector, Mozambique‟s economy is today relatively

diversified. All sectors make an important contribution. Mozambique‟s economy is closely

integrated with those of southern and South Africa.

Agriculture in Mozambique employs about 80% of its population; therefore it is the main

focus of efforts to reduce poverty.

IMF and World bank has supported Mozambique‟s debt on several occasions.

Page 58: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

58 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Mozambique is part of the HIP (Heavily Indebted Poor) Countries. Total debt service relief

under the HIPC Initiative will amount to amount US$3.8bn, reducing total external debt by

some 73 %, and debt-service as a percentage of government revenue from 23 % to around 10

% over 2000-2010 and 7% from 2011-2020. Resources made available by debt relief will be

allocated to anti-poverty programmes.

Telecom Industry

There is a high disparity in Connectivity between the cities and the underdeveloped rural

areas in Mozambique. 64% of all lines are concentrated in the capital city, Maputo, and the

second and third largest cities in the country have 11% and 7% of all lines, respectively.

The Telecommunication Development Bureau (TDB) of the International

Telecommunication Union has launched its first Telemedicine project in Mozambique.

Telemedicine refers to the provision of medical services and health care via existing

telecommunications systems. The range of services includes medical consultation, pathology

diagnosis, education and emergency services.8

The cost of mobile telecommunications dropped dramatically after competition was

introduced and a second operator entered the market in 2003. Total teledensity went from 8

subscribers per 1,000 inhabitants in 2004 to 55 per 1,000 the following year.

Telecom reforms saw cell-phone users in Mozambique grow from 51,000 in 2001 to close to

2 million in August „07.Worldbank

Competitive Landscape

Mozambique has 3 Telecom Players. The Incumbent Telecomunicações Móveis de

Moçambique, Lda operates both in the Fixed Line and Mobile space.

VM Sarl & Vodacom are the other two Players who together own less than 45% of the

market share.

The mobile teledensity with 3 players is 11.6%

8 http://www.uneca.org/aisi/NICI/country_profiles/Mozambique/mozaminfra.htm

Page 59: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

59 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Telecom Opportunities

• The Mozambique Government is privatising its Incumbent Telecom Network in a

big way

• Heavy Liberalisation and issue of new licenses to Foreign Investors

• Mozambique‟s Tourism Industry is developing at a fast rate. The Chinese

government has declared Mozambique as an official tourist destination for its citizens.

The government is taking steps to reduce the cost of doing business in Mozambique through

decentralisation, streamlining of licensing procedures, addressing the rigidities in the labour

market, and improving basic infrastructure, such as energy, roads and telecommunications.

• Steady GDP growth at 7%

• High scope for Telecom growth with current mobile penetration at 11.6%

Economic Snapshot

Sub

Saharan

Africa

GDP (US$

bn)

(Market

Exchange)

Real GDP Growth (%) Populat

ion

Population

Growth

(historical

avg)

Per

Capita

GDP

(Market

Ex)

Inflatio

n

2006 2007 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 in

Million %age USD %age

Ghana 12.9 - 5.9 6.2 - - - - 22.5 1.9 573.3333 14.6

Kenya 21.19 22.36 5.8 6.1 5.5 5.2 - - 35.1 2.6 603.7037 -0.4

Mozambiqu

e 7.6 8.17 6.2 8.5 7.5 7.2 - - 20.16 0.024 376.9841 13.2

Nigeria 114.7 121 6.1 5.9 5.5 7.8 6 6.2 144 2.1 810 10.8

Tanzania 12.78 13.64 6.8 5.9 6.7 7.2 - - 39.03 2.6 327.4404 6.3

Zambia 10.9 11.55 5.2 6 6 6 - - 11.86 0.0211 919.0556 14.3

Page 60: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

60 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Table 10

Penetration Overview

Sub Saharan

Africa Population

Main

telephone lines

Mobile

subscribers Internet users % of

main

Telephone

Lines

% of

Mobile

Subscribers

% of

Internet

Users

000s 000s p.

100 000s p. 100 000s p. 100

Ghana 22556 356.4 1.58 5207.2 23.09 609.8 2.7 1.58% 23.09% 2.70%

Kenya 35106 293.4 0.84 6484.8 18.47 2770.3 7.89 0.84% 18.47% 7.89%

Mozambique 20158 67 0.33 2339.3 11.6 178 0.9 0.33% 11.60% 0.88%

Nigeria 134375 1688 1.26 32322.2 24.05 8000 5.95 1.26% 24.05% 5.95%

Tanzania 39025 147.9 0.38 6240.8 15.99 384.3 1 0.38% 15.99% 0.98%

ZambiaTab 11861 94.7 0.81 949.6 8.14 334.8 2.87 0.80% 8.01% 2.82%

Table 11

3.4.2.2 Future Possible Drivers

A few countries in Africa can be vouched for potential future investment destinations. Their

present conditions have marred them from being an attractive option now, but with

developing trends they are definitely to be watched out for. Four such countries are Angola,

Democratic Republic of Congo, Sudan and Senegal.

Angola

Angola, with a population of 16.4 million, has a very low mobile penetration of 14.33%. This

gives the investors opportunity to exploit the untapped market and reap rewards considering

the tremendous growth in the telecom sector. Angola‟s economy is on the rise with both the

oil and non-oil economy performing considerably well.

There are two players operating in the market namely, Angola Telecom and Unitel. The

infrastructure has shown tremendous signs of improvement with nationwide fibre optics

network being implemented. With the privatizing and licensing of third mobile operator

Page 61: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

61 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

being on the cards, Angola seems to have a good infrastructure to fuel the telecom sector

growth.

However, Angola had been marred by bad social and political conditions especially because

of the civil war conflict which lasted for about 27 years and finally ended in 2002. Since then,

there had been measures taken to bring stability to political conditions. The GDP had been

falling and had shown unsteady trends over the years. These factors don‟t make Angola a

good country to invest in presently. However, with better political and economical stability

and with the growth of telecom in the country, Angola can be seen as an attractive investment

option.

Democratic Republic Of Congo (DRC)

Democratic Republic of Congo is one of the poorest nations in the world with a huge

population of 59.4 Million. The mobile penetration is extremely low at 4.63% despite the fact

that there are five players operating in the market. This may be attributed to highly unstable

political conditions and corruption. Also the income rates had been quite low. The quality of

regulation had been poor as well.

However there had been a reshuffle intended to inject some dynamism into seemingly

aimless government and it intends to modernize its telecom system with the rise of mobile

telephony and wireless technologies. As a result several regional and international telecom

players have started showing interest in the market. The GDP also has shown steady trends.

With further improvement in government‟s policies and telecom growth, DRC seems to be a

bright option for future investments.

Senegal

Senegal with a population of 11.94 Million had been beset by energy crisis that caused

widespread blackouts in 2006 and it relies heavily on external assistance. Also it had been

one of those countries in Africa which wasn‟t given much attention in terms of growth and

development. One of the reasons is the fact the country had been relatively slow in

implementing liberalization and regulatory policies.

Page 62: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

62 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Despite these unfavourable factors, Senegal has shown considerable development in the

telecom sector with increase in mobile telephony. However the mobile penetration is quite

low at 24.5%. With increase in competition, development in the infrastructure – already the

quality of the network in terms of fibre optical backbone, digitisation is quite good - it seems

to have to good potential to reach higher levels of penetration levels.

Sudan

Sudan telecommunication sector is still considered to be in its nascent stage and huge

investment opportunities exist with the realization of peace and stability in the country. With

a population of 39.4 million and a low penetration of 12.66%, like other countries Sudan also

has huge untapped market. The ease in liberalization and privatization policies has fostered

the growth of modern and fully digital infrastructure in the country.

However, Sudan still faces formidable economic problems starting from the low level of per

capita output. Also, Sudan is still an oil dependent economy and other sectors are in the

developing phase.

3.4.3 Proxy Country Analysis

3.4.3.1 Pakistan : Benchmark Country

Due to political, social and economic similarities we consider pakistan as the benchmark

market for projection of growth in the Telecom sector in key African economies.

Some key political, economic and telecom sectoral factors:

GDP of US$ 145 billion with an annual real GDP growth of about 7%.

Population of 165.4 million growing at 2.1% per annum.

An emerging economy like most other African economies.

40.5% Teledensity (mobile, WLL) much above most African countries.

6 major players in the Telecom sector.

Page 63: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

63 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Source : Pakistan Telecom Association

Figure 27

Like most African nations Pakistan has had an unstable political history with millitary

dominating the political landscpe.

Pakistan has primary Trade relations with US , Germany, China , Middle Eastern

Countries.

Pakistan is an Islamic republic which makes it similar to most African countries in

terms of religious demographics and culture.

Our analysis shows Kenya , Ghana and Nigeria to be economically and politically

strikingly similar to Pakistan. All these countries have their per capita GDP within the

range of USD 575 and USD 850. The telecom penetration are relatively low and all of

these countries are fairly high in terms of popuplation.

The Sub Saharan and North African (shortlisted countries) weighted average mobile

penetration currently stands at about 28.61 % as oppose to Pakistan`s mobile telecom

penetration of 40.5%.

The following histogram shows the projected growth in Mobile penetration(%) in Ghana,

Kenya, Nigeria and Pakistan. Pakistan‟s mobile penetration growth is assumed between a

conservative range of 5% to 10% YOY with a modest CAGR of 8.9%. Our analysis projects

Page 64: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

64 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

that Kenya‟s subscribers base would grow from 9 million subscribers to 14 million

subscribers by 2012 ,Ghana‟s subscriber base will grow from 4.8 million to 11.1 million by

2012 and Nigeria is projected to add 23 million new subscribers by 2012. Pakistan with its

phenomenal growth in telecom is projected to over shoot 55% mobile penetration by 2012.9

Source : Pakistan Telecom Association | Morgan Stanley Research

Figure 28

3.4.3.2 Correlation

Any non cyclical industry in an economy grows in tandem with the nominal GDP. This fact

has been proven time and again by emerging and non emerging economies. To substantiate

the correlation between telecom growth and GDP growth the following exercise was carried

out where the folowing results were found:

9 Pakistan Telecom Association

Page 65: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

65 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Table 12

The telecom revenue growth and GDP growth trend analysis reveals the following trend:

Figure 28

Page 66: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

66 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

3.5 Investors Perceptions

Investors in Nigeria Telecom

Political risk and business risk are not necessarily correlated. You can have a thriving

telecom‟s business in a place where political risk is pretty high. Other investments will

expose us to the way Nigeria goes. Our view is that democratic reforms are entrenched, now

the economic reforms are as well. There may be some slowing in the pace of development

but we don‟t think it‟s going to go backwards.10

3.6 Mergers and Acquisitions

As part of the analysis, mergers and acquisitions in the African region were studied to

understand the openness of the African market. The following are the significance of M&A

activities: 11

MEA is considered largest potential markets for improved communications

M&A activities show the degree of openness of the market and also provides with

possible exit opportunities for a private equity investor

Renewed interest in M&A activity can be attributed to two factors:

Strong consumer demand for telecom

Govt‟s encouragement for private investment

Privatization seen as the strategic option to source additional revenue to sustain

spending and economic growth

MEA is one of the world‟s largest potential markets for improved communications,

but much of that potential has remained untapped especially in Africa in some new

types of services and technologies, namely, 3G, NGN, implementation and

broadband IP infrastructure.

10

Business Week article

11 Teletimes International

Page 67: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

67 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

This new competition arena is heavily favoured by a strong wave of telecom

liberalization in the region to attract significant investments in the telecom industry,

to attract new entrant

Mergers and Acquisition schemes are increasingly being seen as the means to meet

the burgeoning demand for telecommunications need.

One of the facets of M&A motivation was to address the need for massive growth by

capturing an existing market with a low penetration rate and then boosting it by

expanding the service through telecom network management expertise and

investment.

M&A moves are driven by focus on bringing synergies among the various regional

opportunities they lead. Those will have a bright future in the telecom landscape

across the region as they increasingly accumulate and sustain a competitive

advantage

M&A is an ultimate form of survival tactic for the growing and the ambitious operator

and market venture.

The M&A trend in telecommunications has already started emanating from all

directions within the MEA region

Page 68: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

68 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

4.0 Emerging Trends

MVNO

A Mobile Virtual Network Operator (MVNO) is a mobile operator that does not own its own

spectrum and usually does not have its own network infrastructure. It‟s an efficient entry

point for licensees whereby they purchase existing capacity from network operators, add their

own brand name, customer service, and billing systems and then sell this package to their

customers.12

A variety of companies, ranging from retailers to food producers, intend to become mobile

virtual network operators (MVNOs) in Africa. Becoming a MVNO can contribute significant

revenue to firms with well-established brand names at the same time allowing network

owners to sell capacity for little commercial and marketing cost.

Supermarket operator Carrefour in France is now offering mobile services. British MVNO

Virgin Mobile launched in South Africa. Analysis from Frost and Sullivan reveals that

revenues in the virtual operator space in the US totalled US$ 2.48 billion in 2004 and could

reach upto US$ 9.35 billion by 2011.

MNVOs operate in countries with some degree of telecom market liberalization. As the

liberalization of African mobile markets spreads, so too should attempts to develop the

MVNO business model in Africa.

"In West Africa there are about two to three companies per country that want to be an

MVNO within the next two years” – Mr. Bocar, (Sr. Vice President Global Operations,

SAMENA) on MVNO as a trend.

12 Electronic source: mobilein.com

Page 69: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

69 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

5.0 Conclusion

Africa has not grown at the same pace with the world market. However, the opportunities in

Africa are huge since risk and return of the African markets move differently with the world

market, investment in Africa is being considered as an attractive investment diversification.

There had been increased support in the regulation and political environment front so as to

improve the governance of various countries. One of the foundations which are working

towards this is the Mo Ibrahim Foundation, founded by the African telecommunications giant

Mo Ibrahim which aims to provide good governance in Africa to make the political and

economic conditions better. The Foundation awarded an annual prize of $5 million over 10

years followed by an additional $200,000 for life to the former president of Mozambique who

has shunned corrupt practices in favour of legal and ethical conduct.

Private equity investments serve as an impetus to economic growth in Africa. Private Equity

investors don‟t become part of the management of the companies they invest in; rather they

invest in various companies, reap the rewards and exit through various exit opportunities like

exiting through an IPO or break up and sale of subsidiary.

Perceptions of investors, found as part of our primary research, have affirmatively established

that Africa is a “goldmine” as far as telecom investments are considered.

Page 70: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

70 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Appendix

Appendix A: Secondary Data, Economic indicator, Teledensity, Political

indicators

Page 71: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

71 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Page 72: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

72 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Page 73: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

73 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Page 74: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

74 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Page 75: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

75 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Page 76: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

76 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Page 77: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

77 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Appendix B: Regulatory Quality and Political stability

Page 78: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

78 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Appendix C: Questionnaire

Name:

Organization:

Designation:

Questionnaire

1. How is Africa looked at as an Investment option in terms of ROI in the telecom

sector?

a. Good Prospect

b. Medium

c. Insignificant

2. Does Africa seem open to Private Equity Investments?

a. Yes

b. No

3. What is the risk level involved with investments in Africa?

a. Very High

b. Medium

c. Low

4. What kind of risks is involved from among the following? Please rank them in order

of priority.

a. Political Instability___

b. Unfriendly Regulations___

c. Expropriation Without Refund___

d. Corruption___

e. Unskilled Labour___

If any other please specify: ____________________________________

Page 79: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

79 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

5. From telecom investor‟s viewpoint, please rate the following in the order of

importance :

a. GDP ___

b. Population ___

c. Inflation ___

d. FDI Inflows ___

e. Telecom Penetration ___

f. Political and Regulatory Environment ___

6. Which of the following regions in Africa are lucrative in ROI terms?

a. North Africa

b. South Africa

c. Sub Saharan Africa

7. From the Sub Saharan countries which of the following are lucrative investment?

(please choose multiple, if needed)

a. Kenya

b. Nigeria

c. Ghana

d. Dominic Republic, Congo

e. Sudan

f. Eritrea

g. Somalia

h. All the above

i. None of the above

If any other please specify: ____________________________________

8. Which are the countries that invest heavily in Africa telecom?

Response: ___________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________

9. How is Sub-Saharan Africa looked at in terms of telecom liberalization?

a. Liberal

b. Conservative

Page 80: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

80 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

10. How would the telecom industry in Africa look 4 years down the line in terms of

investment?

a. High Margin , High Risk

b. High Margin , Low Risk

c. Low Margin , Low Risk

d. Low Margin , High Risk

If any other please specify: ____________________________________

11. What is the perception of an UAE investor about African Telecom Sector?

Response: ___________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________

Page 81: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

81 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Appendix D: Market players in different countries

Telecom Operator Primary Activity Website

Algeria . . Algérie Telecom Fixed www.algerietelecom.dz

Algérie Telecom Mobile www.mobilis.dz

Orascom Telecom Algérie Mobile www.otelecom.com

Wataniya Telecom Algerie Mobile www.nedjma.dz/watweb

Angola . .

Angola Telecom Mobile www.moviecel.net

Angola Telecom Mobile www.angolatelecom.com

Angola Telecom Fixed www.angolatelecom.com

Jembas Assistência Técnica Lda. VSAT .

Mercury Serviços de

Telecomunicações Sarl. VSAT www.mstelecom.com

MultiTel Serviços de

Telecomunicações Lda. VSAT/ISP www.multitel.co.ao

Unitel Mobile www.unitel.co.ao

Wezacom VSAT .

Benin . .

Areeba Mobile www.areeba.com.bj

Bell Benin Communications Mobile www.bellbenin.bj

Benin Telecoms Fixed www.benintelecoms.bj

Commodity Corporation Mobile www.libercom.bj

Spacetel-Benin Mobile www.spacetelbenin.com

Télécel Benin Mobile www.telecel-benin.com

Botswana . .

Botswana Telecommunications

Corp. Fixed www.btc.bw

Mascom Wireless Mobile www.mascom.bw

Orange Botswana (ex-Vista Wireless) Mobile www.orange.co.bw

Burkina Faso . .

Celtel Burkina Mobile www.bf.celtel.com

Onatel (Office National des

Télécommunications) Mobile http://www.telmob.bf/

Onatel (Office National des

Télécommunications) Fixed www.onatel.bf/pageshtml/accueil.htm

Telecel Faso Mobile http://www.telecelfaso.bf

Burundi . .

Africell S.A. Mobile www.africell.bi/index_en.htm

Office National des Télécommunications Mobile .

Spacetel Burundi S.A. Mobile www.spacetel.bi/

Telecel-Burundi Mobile www.stcellular.bi

Cameroon . .

Cameroon Telecommunications

Corporation Fixed www.camnet.cm

Camtel Mobile www.camtel.cm

MTN Cameroon Mobile www.mtncameroon.net/

Page 82: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

82 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Societe Camerounaise de Mobiles

(SCM). Mobile www.orange.cm

Cape Verde . .

Cabo Verde Telecom Mobile www.nave.cv/cvtelecom

Central African Republic . .

A-Cell Mobile www.acell-rca.net

NationLink Telecom RCA Mobile .

Société Centrafricaine des

Télécommunications Fixed .

Telecel Centrafrique

Mobile www.telecel.com Orsacom

Chad . .

Sotel Chad Fixed www.sotel.td

Celtel Tchad Mobile www.td.celtel.com/fr/index.html

Millicom Chad Mobile www.millicom.com/index4.htm

Comoros . .

Comoros Telecom Fixed ww.comorestelecom.km/

Huri Mobile .

Congo . .

MSI Cellular Investments Mobile www.cg.celtel.com/fr/index.html

Orascom Telecom Mobile .

Société des Télécommunications

du Congo S.A.U Fixed .

Cote d'Ivoire . .

Côte d'Ivoire Télécom Fixed www.citelecom.ci

MTN Cote d'Ivoire (was Loteny) Mobile www.telecel.ci

Orange Côte d'Ivoire S.A (was SIM) Mobile www.orange.ci

Democratic Republic of the

Congo . .

Celtel Congo Mobile www.cd.celtel.com/fr/index.html

Congo Chine Telecom Mobile .

Congolese Wireless Network sprl Mobile www.africanwireless.com

Office Congolais des Postes et

Télécommunications Fixed .

S.A.I.T. Télécom Mobile .

SuperCell Mobile .

Dijbouti . .

Djibouti Télécom S.A. Mobile www.djibouti-telecom.dj

Equatorial Guinea . .

Guinea Ecuatorial de

Telecomunicaciones S.A. Mobile .

Eritrea . .

Eritrea Telecommunications

Services Corp. (Eritel) Mobile .

Telecommunication Service of

Eritrea Fixed .

Ethiopia . .

Ethiopian Telecoms Authority Mobile www.telecom.net.et

Ethiopian Telecoms Authority Fixed

www.telecom.net.et

Gabon . .

Page 83: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

83 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Celtel Gabon SA Mobile www.ga.celtel.com/fr/index.html

Gabon Telecom Fixed www.gabontelecom.ga

Libertis S.A. Mobile .

Telecel Gabon Mobile www.telecel.co.ga

Gambia, The . .

Africell Gambia Ltd. Mobile www.africell.gm

Gambia Telecommunications

Company Ltd. Mobile www.gamtel.gm

Gambia Telecommunications

Company Ltd. (Gamtel) Fixed .

Ghana . .

Ghana Telecom Mobile www.onetouch.com.gh

Ghana Telecommunications

Company Fixed www.ghanatelecom.com.gh

Kasapa Mobile .

Millicom Ghana Mobile .

ScanCom Ltd. - Areeba Mobile www.spacefon.com

Guinea Republic . .

Intercel Guinée Mobile .

Investcom Mobile .

Société des Télécommunications de Guinée Mobile .

Guinea-Bissau . .

Ministry of Telecommunications Regulator www.icgb.org

Guinetel Mobile www.gtelecom.gw

Spacetel Guinee-Bissau SA Mobile .

Kenya . .

Celtel Mobile www.ke.celtel.com/en/index.html

Safaricom Mobile www.safaricom.co.ke

Telkom Kenya Limited Fixed www.telkom.co.ke

Lesotho . .

Econet - Ezi-Cel (Pty) Ltd. Mobile www.econetwireless.com

Tele-Com Lesotho (Pty) Ltd. Fixed www.telecom.co.ls

Vodacom Lesotho Pty. Mobile www.vodacom.co.ls

Liberia . .

Atlantic Wireless (Liberia) Inc Mobile www.libercell.info

Celcom Telecommunications Inc Mobile www.cellcomgsm.com

Comium Services BVI (Liberia) Mobile www.comium.com.lr

Lonestar Cell Mobile www.lonestarcell.com

Libya . .

Al Madar Telecom Company Mobile www.almadar.ly

General Post &

Telecommunication Company Fixed .

Libyana Mobile Phone Mobile www.libyana.ly

Madagascar . .

Madacom SA Mobile www.madacom.com

Orange Madagascar Mobile www.orange.mg

Telecom Malagasy S.A. Fixed www.telma.net

Malawi . .

Page 84: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

84 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

CelTel Malawi Limited Mobile www.mw.celtel.com/en/index.html

Malawi Telecommunications Limited Fixed www.mtlonline.net

Telekom Networks Malawi Limited Mobile www.telekommalawi.com

Mali . .

Ikatel S.A. Mobile www.ikatel.net

Sotel Fixed

www.mali.viky.com/sotelma/cgi-

bin/index.pl

Malitel S.A. Mobile .

Mauritania . .

Mauritano-Tunisienne des

Télécommunications Mobile www.mattel.mr

Société Mauritanienne des

Télécommunications Mobile www.mauritel.mr

Mauritius . .

Emtel Ltd. Mobile www.emtel-ltd.com

Emtel Ltd. Mobile .

Mauritius Telecom Ltd. Fixed www.mauritiustelecom.com

Mauritius Telecom/Cellplus

Mobile Communications Ltd. Mobile www.cellplus.mu

Morocco . .

Maroc Telecom Fixed www.iam.net.ma

Itissalat Al-Maghrib S.A Mobile www.onpt.net.ma

Medi Telecom Mobile www.meditelecom.ma

Office National des Postes et

Telecom. Fixed .

Mozambique . .

Telecomunicações de

Moçambique E.E. Fixed www.tdm.mz

Telecomunicações Móveis de

Moçambique, Lda. Mobile www.mcel.co.mz

VM SARL Mobile .

Vodacom Mobile www.vodacom.co.mz

Namibia . .

Mobile Telecommunications Co.

Ltd. Mobile www.mtc.com.na

Telecom Namibia Ltd. Fixed www.telecom.na

Niger . .

Sontel Fixed www.intnet.ne

Celtel Niger Mobile www.ne.celtel.com/fr/index.html

Sahel-Com Mobile .

Telecel-Niger S.A. Mobile .

Nigeria . .

Globacom Ltd Mobile www.gloworld.com

MTN Nigeria Ltd. Mobile www.mtnonline.com

Nigeria Mobile

Telecommunicarions Limited Mobile www.mtelnigeria.com/

Nigeria Mobile

Telecommunicarions Limited Mobile .

Celtel Mobile www.ng.celtel.com

Reunion . .

France Caraibe Mobiles Mobile .

Page 85: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

85 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Societe Francaise du

Radiotelephon Mobile www.srr.fr/

Rwanda . .

MTN RwandaCell s.a.r.l Mobile www.mtnrwandacell.co.rw

RwandaTel S.A. Fixed www.rwandatel.rw

Terracom Mobile www.terracom.rw

Sao Tome and Principe . .

Companhia Santomense de

Telecomunicações s.a.r.l. Mobile www.cstome.net

Senegal . .

SenTel GSM Mobile www.sentelnet.com

Société Nationale des

Télécommunications du Sénégal Mobile www.sonatel.sn

Tigo - Accueil Mobile www.tigo.sn

Seychelles . .

Air Tel Seychelles Mobile www.airtel.sc

Cable & Wireless (Seychelles)

Ltd. Mobile www.cw.com/seychelles/

Sierra Leone . .

Celtel Sierra Leone Ltd. Mobile www.sl.celtel.com/en/index.html

Comium Sierra Leone INC Mobile www.comium.com.sl

Datatel GSM Mobile .

Millicom Sierra Leone Ltd. Mobile www.buzzsl.com

Sierra Leone Telecommunications

Company Fixed .

Somalia . .

Hormuud Telecom Somalia Inc Mobile www.hortel.net

Nation Link Somalia Inc. Mobile www.nationlinktelecom.com/

SOMAFONE FZ LLC Mobile www.somafone.com

STC Mobile .

Telecom Somalia Mobile www.telcom-somalia.com/

Telesom Mobile Somalia Mobile www.telesom.net

South Africa . .

Cell C (Pty) Ltd Mobile www.cellc.net

Mobile Telephone Networks Mobile www.mtn.co.za

Mobile Telephone Networks Mobile www.mtn.co.za

Telkom S.A. Ltd. Fixed www.telkom.co.za

Virgin Mobile South Africa MVNO www.virginmobile.co.za

Vodacom (Pty) Ltd. Mobile www.vodacom.co.za

Vodacom (Pty) Ltd. Mobile www.vodacom.co.za

Sudan . .

Bashair Telecom Co Ltd Mobile www.areeba.com.sd

Bashair Telecom Co Ltd Mobile www.areeba.com.sd

Sudan Mobile Telephone

Company Mobile www.sdn-mobitel.com

Sudan Telecommunication Corporation Fixed

www.sudatel.net`

Swaziland . .

MTN Swaziland Mobile www.mtn.co.za

Swaziland Posts and

Telecommunications Corporation Fixed www.sptc.co.sz

Page 86: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

86 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Tanzania . .

MIC Tanzania Ltd. Mobile www.mobitel.co.tz

MIC Tanzania Ltd. Mobile www.mobitel.co.tz

Tanzania Telecommunications

Company Ltd. Mobile www.tz.celtel.com/en/index.html

Tanzania Telecommunications

Company Ltd. Fixed www.ttcl.co.tz/

Vodacom Tanzania Mobile www.vodacom.co.tz

Zanzibar Telecom Mobile .

Togo . .

Société des Télécommunications

du Togo Fixed www.togotel.net.tg

Telecel Togo SA Mobile www.telecel.tg

Togo Cellulaire Mobile www.togocel.tg

Tunisia . .

Orascom Tunisie Telecom Mobile www.tunisiana.com

Société Nationale des

Télécommunications Mobile .

Société Nationale des

Télécommunications Mobile .

Société Nationale des

Télécommunications Fixed www.tunisietelecom.tn

Uganda . .

Clovergem Celtel Ltd. Mobile www.ug.celtel.com/en/index.html

MTN Uganda Mobile www.mtn.co.ug

Uganda Telecom Limited Fixed www.utl.co.ug

UTL Telecel Mobile www.utl.co.ug/telecel

Uganda Communications

Commission Regulator www.ucc.co.ug/

Zambia . .

Celtel Zambia Ltd. Mobile www.zm.celtel.com/en/index.html

Telecel-Zambia (Zamcell) Mobile www.telecel.co.zm

Zambia Telecommunications

Company Limited Fixed www.zamtel.zm

Zamtel Mobile www.zamtel.zm

Zimbabwe . .

Econet Wireless Mobile www.econet.co.zw

Net.One Mobile www.netone.co.zw

Telecel Zimbabwe (PVT) Ltd Mobile www.telecel.co.zw

TelOne Mobile www.telone.co.zw/

Zimbabwe Posts &

Telecommunications Corporation

(Zimbabwe PTC) Fixed .

Page 87: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

87 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Appendix E: List of countries in North Africa and Sub Saharan Africa

List of North African Countries

Algeria

Egypt

Libya

Morocco

Tunisia

List of Sub – Saharan Countries

Congo Kenya SAO TOME AND PRINCIPE

COTE D'IVOIRE Lesotho Senegal

Congo, Dem. Rep. Liberia Seychelles

Djibouti Madagascar Sierra Leone

EQUATORIAL GUINEA Malawi Somalia

Eritrea Mali Sudan

Ethiopia Mauritania Swaziland

Gabon Mauritius Tanzania

Gambia

Mozambique Togo

Ghana Namibia Uganda

Guinea Niger Yemen

Guinea-Bissau Rwanda Zambia

Zimbabwe

Page 88: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

88 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Appendix F: SAMENA Council

Established: April, 2006

Headquartered Dubai, United Arab Emirates

With a network of members that extends beyond continental borders, SAMENA

Telecommunications Council, a multi-continent telecom consortium, aims to be the ultimate

promoter of telecom innovations in its member regions and a facilitator for collaboration and

knowledge-sharing between regional telecom entities. Such collaboration and knowledge-

sharing between operators, vendors, manufacturers, entrepreneurs, educators, R&D experts,

and regulators, aids effective resolutions to technical, economical, and legal issues in regions

where tough economical and regulatory environments prevail.

Page 89: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

89 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

List of Tables/ List of Exhibits

Figure 1- Private equity business Model

Figure 2- Brief Methodology

Figure 3- Snapshot of the spreadsheet

Figure 4- Quantitative and Qualitative Classification of the methods

Figure 5- Snapshot of countries from Method 1

Figure 6- Snapshot of Countries from Method 2

Figure 7- Snapshot of Countries from Primary research

Figure 8- Snapshot of final list of countries

Figure 9- Possible Drivers in the Future

Figure 10- Egypt Mobile market Players

Figure 11- Mobinil Revenue growth

Figure 12-Algeria Competitive landscape

Figure 13- Djezzy revenue growth

Figure 14- Morocco's ten economic freedoms

Figure 15- Morocco Competitive landscape

Figure 16- Maroc Telecom Revenues

Figure 17- Tunisia Competitive Landscape

Figure 18- Tunisiana Revenue growth

Figure 19- Millicom Revenue growth

Figure 20- Kenya Competitive Landscape

Figure 21- Safaricom revenue growth

Figure 22- Nigeria Competitive landscape

Page 90: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

90 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

Figure 23- MTN revenue growth

Figure 24- Zambia-Celtel Revenue growth

Figure 25-Tanzania competitive landscape

Figure 26- Vodacom Revenue growth

Figure 27- Mobile Market Share of Pakistan

Figure 28- Trend Analysis between GDP and telecom revenue growth

Figure 29- Telecom Penetration Comparison

Table 1 - Data sources

Table 2 - Parameters List

Table 3 - Parameters Ranking List

Table 4 - Scores of the Countries

Table 5 - List of North African countries

Table 6 - List of Sub Saharan Countries

Table 7 - Output List for Method - II

Table 8 - Economic Snapshot North Africa

Table 9 - Penetration Overview

Table 10- Economic snapshot Sub Saharan Africa

Table 11- Penetration Overview Sub Saharan

Table 12 Correlation between GDP and telecom revenue growth

Page 91: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

91 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

GLOSSARY

SAMENA - South Asia, Middle East and North Africa Telecommunications Council

DRC - Democratic Republic Of Congo

PE - Private Equity

UAE - United Arab Emirates

GDP - Gross Demostic Product

SAVCA - South African Venture Capitalist & Private Equity Association

FDI - Foreign Direct Investments

ICT - Information and Communications Technology

ITU - International Telecommunications Union

MVNO - Mobile Virtual Network Operator

VSAT - Very Small Aperture Terminal

GSM - Global System For Mobile Communications

CAGR - Compounded Annual Growth Rate

IFC - International Finance Corporation

IFRS - International Financial Reporting Standards

OECD - Organisation For Economic Co-operation and Development

COMESA - Common Market For Eastern and Southern Africa

IAS - International Accounting Standards

EAC - East African Community

CCK - The Communication Commission of Kenya

Page 92: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

92 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

DBSA - Development Bank Of Southern Africa

ISP - Internet Service Provider

TCRA - Tanzania Communication Regulatory Authority

HIP - Heavily INdebted Poor

IMF - International Monetary Fund

TDB - Technology Development Board

WLL - Wireless Local Loop

MEA - Middle East and Africa

M&A - Mergers and Aquistion

IP - Internet Protocol

NGN - Next Generation Networking

Page 93: AlCazar Capital Partners - Africa Telecom Report

93 | P a g e S p e c i a l G r o u p P r o j e c t

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Articles from AltAssets http://www.altassets.com/index.php

Articles from ITU http://www.itu.int/net/home/index.aspx

Research by NMC Communication http://www.nmscommunications.com

World Bank Data http://web.worldbank.org

Economist http://www.economist.com

MTN http://annualreport.mtn.com

Telegeogrphy http://www.telegeography.com

Pakistan Telecommunication Authority website

Bloomberg Terminal at SP Jain Center of Management , Dubai Campus

Reports:

Morgan Stanley Report