Ahp Analysis

download Ahp Analysis

of 20

Transcript of Ahp Analysis

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    1/20

    risk preferences

    risk analysis of uk oil companies

    Alternatives

    risk avoidanceavoid the risk

    risk reductionreduce risk

    risk mitigationremove risk

    Criteria

    risk preference

    uncertain energy policy

    access to reserve

    operationl

    cost control

    environmental

    management

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    2/20

    Preferences and priorities

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    3/20

    Preferences in context of: risk preference

    operationl vs. uncertain energy policy

    7 : 1

    access to reserve vs. uncertain energy policy

    4 : 1

    operationl vs. access to reserve

    2 : 1

    uncertain energy policy vs. cost control

    6 : 1

    uncertain energy policy vs. management

    1 : 1

    environmental vs. uncertain energy policy

    5 : 1

    cost control vs. operationl

    6 : 1

    cost control vs. management

    4 : 1

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    4/20

    environmental vs. cost control

    9 : 1

    cost control vs. access to reserve

    6 : 1

    operationl vs. management

    1 : 1

    operationl vs. environmental

    1 : 1

    environmental vs. management

    6 : 1

    management vs. access to reserve

    7 : 1

    access to reserve vs. environmental

    5 : 1

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    5/20

    Criterion

    Weight

    uncertain energy pol

    11.72

    access to reserve

    16.25

    operationl

    13.17

    cost control

    19.35

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    6/20

    environmental

    27.11

    management

    12.39

    Preferences in context of: uncertain energy policy

    risk avoidance

    8

    risk mitigation

    9

    risk reduction

    4

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    7/20

    Alternative

    uncertain energy pol

    n

    88.89

    risk reduction

    44.44

    risk mitigation

    100

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    8/20

    Preferences in context of: access to reserve

    risk avoidance

    6

    risk mitigation

    9

    risk reduction

    5

    Alternative

    access to reserve

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    9/20

    n

    66.67

    risk reduction

    55.56

    risk mitigation

    100

    Preferences in context of: operationl

    risk avoidance

    6

    risk mitigation

    8

    risk reduction

    9

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    10/20

    Alternative

    operationl

    n

    66.67

    risk reduction

    100

    risk mitigation

    88.89

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    11/20

    Preferences in context of: cost control

    risk avoidance

    5

    risk mitigation

    8

    risk reduction

    6

    Alternative

    cost control

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    12/20

    n

    62.5

    risk reduction

    75

    risk mitigation

    100

    Preferences in context of: environmental

    risk avoidance

    5

    risk mitigation

    7

    risk reduction

    8

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    13/20

    Alternative

    environmental

    n

    62.5

    risk reduction

    100

    risk mitigation

    87.5

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    14/20

    Preferences in context of: management

    risk avoidance

    2

    risk mitigation

    8

    risk reduction

    6

    Alternative

    management

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    15/20

    n

    25

    risk reduction

    75

    risk mitigation

    100

    Criterion

    Global weight [%]

    Local weight [%]

    risk preference

    100

    100

    environmental

    27.11

    27.11

    cost control

    19.35

    19.35

    access to reserve

    16.25

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    16/20

    16.25

    operationl

    13.17

    13.17

    management

    12.39

    12.39

    uncertain energy policy

    11.72

    11.72

    Ranking in context of: risk preference

    Alternative

    Total

    uncertain energy pol

    access to reserve

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    17/20

    operationl

    cost control

    environmental

    management

    n

    62.17

    10.42

    10.83

    8.78

    12.1

    16.94

    3.1

    risk reduction

    78.33

    5.21

    9.03

    13.17

    14.51

    27.11

    9.29

    risk mitigation

    95.15

    11.72

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    18/20

    16.25

    11.71

    19.35

    23.72

    12.39

    Comparison in context of: risk preference

    Criterion

    n

    risk reduction

    risk mitigation

    uncertain energy pol

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    19/20

    88.89

    44.44

    100

    access to reserve

    66.67

    55.56

    100

    operationl

    66.67

    100

    88.89

    cost control

    62.5

    75

    100

    environmental

    62.5

    100

    87.5

    management

    25

  • 8/3/2019 Ahp Analysis

    20/20

    75

    100