80°Little Rock

Search ArkansasOnline

FOLLOW US:

1

Comment (1) Font Size

Home / News / Arkansas /

UA raises immunity in Title IX suit filingBy Jaime AdameThis article was published February 4, 2017 at 3:38 a.m.

PHOTO BY ANDY SHUPEA crowd walks Saturday, Feb. 13, 2016, past Old Main and the University of Arkansas campus in Fayetteville.

FAYETTEVILLE -- An appellate court filing by the University of Arkansas seeks to undercut the basis

for lawsuits seeking monetary damages in Title IX lawsuits like one filed against the university last

year.

A former student claimed the university acted with "deliberate indifference" when she reported

being raped by another student in 2014. The student's lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court in

Fayetteville, states that UA violated Title IX, the federal law that prohibits sex-based

discrimination at schools that receive federal funding.

Other schools have been sued by students alleging Title IX violations related to how schools respond

to reports of sexual assault. Some cases resulted in high-profile settlements, like when Florida

State University in 2016 announced a $950,000 settlement in a case filed by a former student.

The suit against UA-Fayetteville and the university system's board of trustees alleges that the

university improperly handled a campus disciplinary process, failed to properly train a disciplinary

panel hearing the case and did not implement policies to clearly set out "the procedure for

trainers, coaches and student-athletes to follow when a student-athlete is the victim of sexual

assault."

The lawsuit asked for damages, punitive damages, attorneys' and expert fees and "other relief of

which this Court deems just and proper."

[EMAIL UPDATES: Get free breaking news updates and daily newsletters with top headlines

delivered to your inbox]

ADVERTISEMENT

Tuesday, February 07, 2017, 1:50 p.m.

Epaper

ADVERTISEMENT

'Walking Dead' star thanks Arkansas police officerfor helping stranded mom - Mobile

Arkansas store clerk charged in lottery-fraud case

Little Rock teenager robbed of $20,000 in parkinglot, she tells police

Little Rock's 1st killing of '17 probed asgang-related

MOST POPULAR

Viewed Commented

SHOPPING

Arkansas Daily Deal2017 Spring Tennis Classes forKids 8 and Under!Up to $120 off

Crime Right2Know Traffic Projects Archives News Tip Whole Hog Sports Arkansas Life Place an Ad Arkansas Daily Deal

Today's Mortgage Rates

3.74% APRARM

Home News Obituaries Business Entertainment Sports Photos Videos Features Events Classifieds Jobs Homes Autos

30-Year Fixed 3.88% 3.92% APR

UA raises immunity in Title IX suit filing http://www.arkansasonline.com/news/2017/feb/04/ua-raises-i...

1 of 4 2/7/17, 1:50 PM

ADVERTISEMENT

Cotton apologizes in call to Arkansan; senato...

State treasurer, ex-aide cleared in firing, d...

Judge blocks changes in Arkansas plaintiffs' ...

Dental benefits manager selected for Arkansas...

UA raises immunity in Title IX suit filing

Arkansas deputy cleared in fatal shooting

Bail set at $150,000 for Arkansas suspect in ...

Man found fit for trial in Fort Smith slaying

Bicycle clog ahead: Pass by the rules

More Arkansas stories >

Attorneys for UA sought to have the case dismissed by U.S. District Judge P.K. Holmes III, but he

ruled in November that "dismissal is inappropriate at this stage," with the university then taking its

argument to the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

In a brief filed Jan. 30, university attorneys cited a 2011 U.S. Supreme Court ruling and the legal

concept of sovereign immunity to argue for dismissal of the former student's case.

Questions of sovereign immunity involve, in part, whether governments and government employees

should be shielded from lawsuits. While the U.S. Congress can override states' immunity or induce

states to waive immunity voluntarily, this must be done via a "clear statement," attorneys for the

university argued.

"No court has, to our knowledge, ever performed the requisite clear-statement analysis in a lawsuit

involving a Title IX claim for monetary damages against a State institution. Under such an analysis,

dismissal of this civil action is compelled," UA states in the filing.

A ruling in a 2011 Supreme Court case called Sossamon v. Texas -- which did not involve Title IX but

a Texas inmate's lawsuit under what's known as the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons

Act -- bolsters their argument, UA states in the court document.

Erin Buzuvis, a law professor at Western New England University School of Law and co-founder of

Title IX Blog, said in an email that the U.S. Supreme Court found in the Sossamon case that a state

taking federal money did not constitute a waiver of sovereign immunity as it relates to the

Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act.

This "could be relevant in the Title IX context as well," Buzuvis wrote. While in the past there have

been several examples of courts rejecting state university arguments of sovereign immunity in Title

IX cases, "it's hard to find many examples" after the 2011 Supreme Court ruling, she said.

But another legal issue involves the relationship between Title IX and the 14th Amendment, Buzuvis

said. Federal lawmakers have the power to revoke a state's sovereign immunity, or abrogate it, to

protect rights under the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, according to legal theory,

Buzuvis said. The 14th Amendment, which protects the rights to liberty and equal protection under

the law, was ratified after the Civil War.

"This is not universally held, but some courts have recognized Congress's abrogation of state's

sovereign immunity in Title IX cases on the grounds the Congress essentially used its 14th

[Amendment] power along with its spending clause power when it passed Title IX," she wrote,

calling the UA case "one to watch."

Doriane Lambelet Coleman, a law professor at Duke Law School, said the question of sovereign

immunity "could be fact-specific and state-specific," adding that a state may have waived its

immunity in various ways. But the case could end up setting a legal precedent, she said.

George Rozzell, an attorney for the former student, said a response is being prepared and will be

filed with the appellate court.

Metro on 02/04/2017

Print Headline: UA raises immunity in Title IX suit filing

Autos

2016 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium$24,898; 2326Subaru of Little RockSearch more vehicles

Real Estate

803 Shamrock Drive North LittleRock, $114,0001372 square feetView more homes

Calendar (http://arkansasonline.com/eventcalendar/)

TUE7

The Beatles!Clinton Presidenti... | Little Rock, AR

(http://arkansasonline.com/eventcalendar/#/details/THE-BEATLES/2758173/2017-02-07T00)

Paint Your Own Masterpiece at PinPinot's Palette Li... | Little Rock, AR

...

FEB23

TOBYMAC HITS DEEP TOURVerizon Arena | North Little Rock, AR

(http://arkansasonline.com/eventcalendar/#/details/TOBYMAC-HITS-DEEP-TOUR/2787290/2017-02-23T19)

More Arkansas

See more Deals

RNs, Physical Therapist - Multiple PositionsST VINCENT-NORTH REHAB HOSP02.05.17 Little Rock, AR

Fleet MechanicHILAND DAIRY/LR02.05.17 Little Rock, AR

Activity DirectorSHERWOOD NURSING & REHAB CTR02.04.17 Sherwood, AR

Research Interviewer

FEATURED JOBS

Central Arkansas Auto SalesCentral Arkansas BankingCentral Arkansas Beauty CareCentral Arkansas DentistsCentral Arkansas FloristsCentral Arkansas InsuranceCentral Arkansas LawyersCentral Arkansas MoversCentral Arkansas PhysiciansCentral Arkansas RestaurantsCentral Arkansas Real Estate

Tweet 0 One person likes this. Be the first ofyour friends.

Like Share Search Local Businesses

UA raises immunity in Title IX suit filing http://www.arkansasonline.com/news/2017/feb/04/ua-raises-i...

2 of 4 2/7/17, 1:50 PM

You must login to make comments.

February 4, 2017 at 2:44 p.m.

PAGE 1

Comment on: UA raises immunity in Title IX suit filingTo report abuse or misuse of this area please hit the "Suggest Removal" link in the comment to alert our onlinemanagers. Read our Terms of Use policy.

Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 total comment

DoubleBlind says...It will be a travesty if UA gets away with this. They do anything to protect their precious athletesand coaches but everyone else is on his/her own. They must be made to understand they have aresponsibility to act when someone reports being raped on campus. The only way to do that isthrough financial penalties. I hope this young woman prevails and UA is made to pay the price ofturning their backs.

( permalink | suggest removal )

To report abuse or misuse of this area please hit the "Suggest Removal" link in the comment to alert our onlinemanagers. Read our Terms of Use policy.

NEWS

Today's NewspaperArkansasObituariesOpinion / LettersNationalPoliticsElectionsWorldReligionOffbeatSister PapersWeatherPrint Edition

BUSINESS

BusinessBusiness wireTech wireArkansas stocksMarkets

SPORTS

Arkansas SportsWhole Hog - RazorbacksPrepsRecruiting Guy BlogLR MarathonCollege sports galleriesPreps sports galleriesAP SportsCollege FootballNFLNBAMLBPGANASCARTennis

FEATURES

Events CalendarEvent Photos

FEATURES cont.

StyleMusicFamilyFoodDining OutFind a RestaurantTelevisionTravelHigh ProfileWeddings/Engagements

WEB EXTRAS

E-mail UpdatesRight2KnowDatabasesDocuments

WEB EXTRAS cont.

ArchivesVideosPhoto GalleriesFixIt Pothole MapWar CasualtiesDemocrat-GazetteHistoryArkansas LinksSupport GroupsBlogsFacebookTwitter

CONTACT

FAQ/Contact UsForgotten Password?Subscriber HelpNewspaper DeliveryCorporate

CONTACT cont.

AdvertisingNewspaper StaffWebsite StaffInternshipsTerms of Use

SUBMIT

News TipEvent or MeetingLetter to the EditorHonor/AchievementWedding/Anniversary

PROMOTIONS

Democrat-Gazette StoreBridal ShowCapture ArkansasSpelling Bee

PUBLICATIONS

Tri LakesThree RiversRiver Valley & OzarkArkansas LifeSpecial SectionsWhere We Live

CLASSIFIEDS

ClassifiedsJobsReal EstateAutoJobs with Us

ADVERTISING

Advertise with us

Home News Obituaries Business Entertainment Photos Videos Features Events Classifieds Jobs Real Estate Autos Daily Deal

Copyright © 2017, Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, Inc.All rights reserved.This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, Inc.

Material from the Associated Press is Copyright © 2017, Associated Press and may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Associated Press text, photo, graphic, audio and/or video material shall not be published, broadcast,rewritten for broadcast or publication or redistributed directly or indirectly in any medium. Neither these AP materials nor any portion thereof may be stored in a computer except for personal and noncommercial use. The AP will not beheld liable for any delays, inaccuracies, errors or omissions therefrom or in the transmission or delivery of all or any part thereof or for any damages arising from any of the foregoing. All rights reserved.

ADVERTISEMENT

UA raises immunity in Title IX suit filing http://www.arkansasonline.com/news/2017/feb/04/ua-raises-i...

3 of 4 2/7/17, 1:50 PM

UA raises immunity in Title IX suit filing http://www.arkansasonline.com/news/2017/feb/04/ua-raises-i...

4 of 4 2/7/17, 1:50 PM