Advances in Reactor Concepts: Generation IV Reactors

Research Workshop Future Opportunities in Nuclear Power

October 16-17, 2014 Purdue University

Prof. Won Sik Yang Purdue University

2

Nuclear energy is a significant contributor to U.S. and international electricity production – 15% world, 20% U.S., 74% France

Status of Nuclear Power Production

3

Nuclear energy and hydropower are the only two major established base-load low-carbon energy sources.

Efforts to reduce CO2 emissions are thus a major factor in the renewed interest in nuclear energy that has become apparent in recent years.

Status of Nuclear Power Production

IEA/NEA, Nuclear Energy Technology Roadmap (2010)

World Electricity Generation (2009)

Total: 20130 TWh

4

Future Use of Nuclear Energy

Extended lifetime and optimized operation of existing plants Construction of new plants (evolutionary designs in near term) Closure of fuel cycle to improve waste management

– Strengthened international safeguards regime Sustainable generation of electricity, hydrogen and other energy

products

5

Generations of Nuclear Reactors

6

Generation IV Systems: Technology Goals

Sustainability – Sustainable energy generation through long-term availability of

systems and effective fuel utilization – Minimize and manage nuclear waste and reduce the stewardship

burden in the future Safety & Reliability

– Very low likelihood and degree of reactor core damage – Eliminate the need for offsite emergency response

Economics – Life-cycle cost advantage over other energy sources – Level of financial risk comparable to other energy projects

Proliferation Resistance & Physical Protection – Unattractive materials diversion pathway – Enhanced physical protection against terrorism

7

System

Neutron Spectrum

Fuel /Fuel Cycle

Coolant Temp. (C)

Power (MWe)

Plant Effici. (%)

Applications

Sodium Cooled Fast Reactor (SFR)

Fast MOX, Metal /Closed

500 - 550 50 300-600 1500

42 Electricity, Actinide Recycle

Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR)

Thermal Coated particles /Open

900 -1000 250 > 47 Electricity, Hydrogen Production, Process Heat

Gas-Cooled Fast Reactor (GFR)

Fast Carbides /Closed

850 200-1200

45 - 48 Electricity, Hydrogen Production, Actinide Recycle

Supercritical Water Reactor (SCWR)

Thermal, Fast

UOX, MOX /Open; Closed

510 - 625 1500 Max. 50 Electricity

Lead-Cooled Fast Reactor (LFR)

Fast Nitrides; MOX /Closed

480 - 570 50-150 300-600 1200

42 - 44 Electricity, Hydrogen Production

Molten Salt Reactor (MSR)

Thermal, Fast

Fluorides salts /Closed

700 - 800 1000 Max. 45 Electricity, Hydrogen Production, Actinide Recycle

Overview of Generation IV Systems

A Technology Roadmap for Generation IV Nuclear Energy Systems, December 2002 GIF R&D Outlook for Generation IV Nuclear Energy Systems, August 2009

8

Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactor (SFR)

KALIMER

ESFR

JSFR SMFR

Features fast spectrum and closed fuel cycle – Can either burn actinides or breed fissile material

High level of safety can be achieved through inherent and passive means

R&D focus – Analyses and experiments that demonstrate safety

approaches – High-burnup, minor actinide bearing fuels – Develop advanced components and energy conversion

systems

9

In the US, innovative fast reactor designs are being developed – Advanced burner sodium-cooled fast reactor (ABR) for waste management – Breed and burn nuclear systems for improved fuel utilization – Small modular reactors for near-term deployment in remote locations and

other countries China has constructed CEFR, which achieved the initial criticality on

July 21, 2010. Developing CFR-600 with oxide fuel, but will be converted to metallic fuel.

In India, the 500 MWe DFBR is expected to be online soon; they plan to construct 4 more 500 MWe units by 2020, and then 1000 MWe plants

Russia has constructed a BN-800 reactor, which achieved the initial criticality on June 27, 2014, and is developing the BN-1200 design

Japan envisions commercial fast reactors by 2050, and plans to construct a demo plant by 2025 (JSFR)

France envisions commercial fast reactors by ~2045, and plans a demo plant by 2020 (ASTRID)

Korea is developing the 150 MWe PGSFR design for demonstrating TRU transmutation

Designs Being Developed

10

Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR)

High temperature, helium cooled, graphite moderated reactor – High temperature enables non-electric applications

Goal – reach 1000 °C, with near term focus on 700 - 950 °C Reference configurations are the prismatic and the pebble bed

11

Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR)

R&D focus on materials and fuels – Shared irradiation

• Confirmed excellent performance of UO2 TRISO fuel

– Develop a worldwide material handbook – Benchmarking of computer codes

Japanese HTTR (30 MWt) is in operation – 50 days continuous operation at 950 °C

completed March 2010 Chinese HTR-PM demonstration plant is

under construction – Pebble bed core, 750 °C outlet temperature,

steam cycle, 40% efficiency – Two 250 MWt NSSS modules for 210 MWe

electricity – First concrete poured in Dec. 2012 – Plant operation expected around end of 2017

HTR-PM

12

Gas-Cooled Fast Reactor (GFR)

Decay heat removal (LOCA) is a challenge – High power density – Low thermal inertia

High temperature, helium cooled fast reactor with closed fuel cycle – Fast spectrum enables efficient

use of uranium resources and waste minimization

– High temperature enables non-electric applications

– Non-reactive coolant eliminates material corrosion

Very advanced system – Requires advanced materials

and fuels Key R&D focus

– SiC clad carbide fuel – High temperature components

and materials

13

Supercritical-Water-Cooled Reactor (SCWR)

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

250 350 450 550Temperature (C)

Pres

sure

(MPa

)

SCWR

PWR

BWR

superheated vapor

supercritical fluid

vapor

liquid

compressible liquid Merges Gen-III+ reactor technology with advanced supercritical water technology used in coal plants

Operates above the thermodynamic critical point (374 °C, 22.1 MPa) of water

Fast and thermal spectrum options Pressure tube or pressure vessel

options Key R&D focus

– Materials, water chemistry, and radiolysis – Thermal-hydraulics and safety to address

gaps in SCWR heat transfer and critical flow databases

– Fuel qualification

14

Lead-Cooled Fast Reactor (LFR)

ELFR

– 1500 MWt / 600 MWe – MOX fuel – Coolant temp., 400/480C – Max. clad temp., 550C – Efficiency: ~42% – Breeding ratio: ~1

Lead is not chemically reactive with air or water – Highly corrosive and erosive

Fast spectrum and closed fuel cycle Three design thrusts

– European Lead Cooled Fast Reactor (Large, central station)

– Russian BREST-OD-300 (Medium size)

– US SSTAR (Small transportable system)

R&D focus – Materials corrosion – High burnup, MA-bearing fuels – Safety

15

LFR Concepts Being Studied

BREST-OD-300 – 700 MWt / 300 MWe – UN+PuN fuel – Coolant temp: 420/540C – Max. cladding temp., 650C – Efficiency: 42% – Breeding ratio: ~1

SSTAR – SSTAR is a small natural

circulation fast reactor of 20 MWe/45 MWt, that can be scaled up to 180 MWe/400 MWt.

– Uranium nitride fuel with 15-20 year lifetime

16

Molten Salt Reactor (MSR)

MSFR – Since 2005, European R&D interest

has focused on Molten Salt Fast neutron Reactor (MSFR) as a long term alternative to solid fueled fast neutrons reactors

High temperature system Design options

– Fuel dissolved in molten salt coolant • Traditional MSF concept • On-line waste management

– Solid fuel with molten salt coolant • VHTR + molten salt coolant

Key R&D focus – Neutronics – Materials and components – Safety and safety systems – Liquid salt chemistry and properties – Salt processing

17

Two reactors concepts using molten salt are studied in the GIF MSR – Molten salt reactors, in which the salt is both the fuel and the coolant

• France and Euratom work on MSFR • Russia works on MOSART (Molten Salt Actinide Recycler & Transmuter)

– Reactors with solid fuel cooled by molten salt • USA and China work on FHR (fluoride salt-cooled

|high-temperature reactor) concepts

MSR Concepts Studied

18

Summary

Generation-IV systems are being developed worldwide – Gen-IV International Forum was established in 2001 and provides

an international framework for development of Gen-IV systems – Collaborative projects started with significant R&D investment

worldwide – Prototype demonstration reactors are being designed and/or built

• SFR (France and Russia) • VHTR (China)

Much still needs to be done before Gen-IV systems become a reality – Continue R&D on Gen-IV systems – Develop advanced research facilities – Engage industry on the design of Gen-IV systems – Develop the workforce for the future