Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

78
PREPRINT 2001–08 Adaptive finite element computation of 3D magnetostatic problems in potential formulation Marzia Fontana Chalmers Finite Element Center CHALMERS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY oteborg Sweden 2001

Transcript of Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

Page 1: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

PREPRINT 2001–08

Adaptive finite element computation of 3Dmagnetostatic problems in potential formulation

Marzia Fontana

Chalmers Finite Element CenterCHALMERS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGYGoteborg Sweden 2001

Page 2: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...
Page 3: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

Preprint 2001–08

Adaptive finite element computation of 3Dmagnetostatic problems in potential formulation

Marzia Fontana

Chalmers Finite Element CenterChalmers University of Technology

SE–412 96 Goteborg SwedenGoteborg, April 2001

Page 4: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

Adaptive finite element computation of 3Dmagnetostatic problems in potential formulationMarzia FontanaNO 2001–08ISSN 1404–4382

Chalmers Finite Element CenterChalmers University of TechnologySE–412 96 GoteborgSwedenTelephone: +46 (0)31 772 1000Fax: +46 (0)31 772 3595

Printed in SwedenChalmers University of TechnologyGoteborg, Sweden 2001

Page 5: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

!"$#&%('*)+ ,$-.!/01+2/30 -456* 7#8$29: 0!

;=<>?A@B<DCE!FGH<F<JI

K6LNMPO8QSRUTVOWYXHZ.[]\^_^a`]^ab^aZc\dVZUdV`]egf0[hf[hfjiUklVilmf0^anpoqlVk\0rU^6f\0ds\0[ut6vsw:xydSzg!^a`h`|~f^acUds\0[hlmZUfoqlVk

b_dsmZA^P\0[htX.^a`hnUfa!HdVf^anlmZdpnUlmA.`]^ilV\^aZc\0[hdV`oqlVkbU`hds\0[]lmZ\0rUds\`]^adVnUf_\l&dV^aZA^PkdV`[]P^anNlm[hf0flmZ6blgnA^a`.[]\0rn.[hf0tlmZc\0[hZcUlmUfn.[.f0[]lmZ_dVZUnZAlmZArAlmblVV^aZA^PlmUf*w[]k[htrU`h^P\dVZUn ^a.b_dVZUZ[hZc\^Pk0oBdVt^dVZUnlm.ZUnUdsk0e6tlmZUnU[]\0[]lmZ.fPrA^XZU[]\^^a`]^ab^aZc\$b^P\0rUlnytlmZUf0[hf\0flVodi.[h^at^P$[hf^`u[hZA^adskdV`h^Pk0[uZpnU[hftk0^P\0[]ads\0[]lmZplmZpd\^P\kdVrA^anAkdV`!b^af0r/Z\0rU^blgnA^a`h`h[uZAi.rUdVf^Vc\0rA^tlmbi.A\0ds\0[]lmZlVo/\0rA^ ![hlV\¢¡gda£sdsk0\(`hda¤[hf¥i^Pk0oqlVkb^ance+XZU[]\^£Vlm`h.b^$[hZc\^PVkdS\0[]lmZ_[hZtPdVf^$lVo9tlmbiH`]^zcfrUdsi^antPAk0k0^aZc\tPdsk0k0eg[hZAjV^Plmb_^P\k[]^afPlVkb_[]z^an_f0^ab_[ZUb^Pk[htPdV`dVZUn¦dVZUdV`]e\0[htPdV`§kdVZAsdska|~foqlVkb.`hdVf[hZ¦tPdVf^lVo(tlm[h`NV^Plmb^P\k[]^afPWZ¦dVnUdsiU\0[]£V^_tk[]\^Pk[]lmZlVob^af0r¨k^XHZA^ab^aZc\[hf\0rU^aZdsiUi.`u[]^an/¥.dVf0^an¨lmZdpilmf\^Pk[]lVk[(^af0\0[hb_ds\0[]lmZlVo\0rU^XHZU[]\^^a`]^ab^aZc\*^Pk0k0lVk[hZ6^aZA^PkVeZAlVkb Ub_^Pk[htPdV`^zgdVb_i.`]^af(lmZflmb^jbdsmZA^P\lmf\0ds\0[htjtPdVf0^af$dsk0^iUk0^af^aZc\^anoqlVk$d_tlmbiHdsk[hflmZ[]\0rlV\0rA^Pk$dVnUdsi.\0[]£V^XHZU[h\^^a`h^ab^aZ©\$\^atrUZU[ucA^afa

ª«¬­®V¯°S± $²,[hZU[]\^^a`]^ab_^aZ©\b_^P\0rAln.fP³dilmf\^Pk[]lVk[,^Pk0k0lVka³dVn.dsiU\0[]£V^b^afr¦k0^XHZA^ab_^aZ©\Pb_dsmZA^P\lmf\0ds\0[utjiUk0lVH`]^ab_fPA ([]lV\¢¡gd8£Sdsk0\`hda

´0µ/¶B·¸a¹»ºU¸8¼m¼V½¢¾¿¢¿ÀNÁÂPÃÅÄÆuÂmÇNÁÂPÈhÉmÊ]ËÉmÂaÌ~ÁÍ0ÃÎÊÏÎÍ0ÐÁÂPÃÅÄÆuÂVÇ,Æ]ÑgÂPÁÍÊ]ËÒPÁÓÕÔ ¸8ºÏ·¾½¿Ö¹Ïש¹ÙØ¢¾µ9º»¾·¾×SØ Ó ¾×SØž½ÐmÚ¾Ûc¸a½ÅØÅ·¾×SØ¥ÜaÝ/Þ_¸aØ Ô ¾·¸aØŹ߿РÓÕÔ ¸aº»·¾½¿à¥×m¹»á8¾½¢¿Å¹ÏØãâÜaÝ/ä.¾åß Ô ×mÜ8º»Ü8æçâè ¶Bé©êëaì8íîïÜaØ¢¾ðÜ8½¢æ©Ð èsñ ¾¼V¾×Uòó Ü8½¢ô¿õ©ÛmÛcÜç½Ø¢¾¼ðsâ ÓNö÷ ½¢¾¿Å¾¸8½¢ß Ô Ýh¾ºÏº»Ü ñ ¿ Ô ¹ÏÛëaøçùmò ømêçòûúaømÐ Ó Ü8ש¿Å¹ÏæçºÏ¹»Ü ö ¸aü¹ÏÜçש¸aº»¾*¼V¾º»º»¾ ÷ ¹»ß¾½ß Ô ¾8ÐVýBظaº»âþSÿçÿ8ÿ ÂPÈhÉmÍÁÂaÈ ÆuË0ÎÍË0ÈÌÏÂÎÎÆ ÕËÂPÈqÆuÒPÑ !ùsëmÐSí ö ù8ømÐVí ö 8ømЩúùçø

Page 6: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...
Page 7: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

!#"$%'&)(*"$+,".-0/".2143 5)6 7 &8/&:93'&;9<"=,&)9 6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 A)6 B C/-&8DE9<".,&:9 6@6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 F

G HI+&:-+J".K<.&:L".-M&:NO'"$9PQE&)-&:(R"=3&S+9T( SUV$6 !#"$WOXY&:-+-[Z\9]&:NO'"$L9 6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 T^V$6 _ "$`E".aQ&82bc".,&d,eL9 6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 fV$6gV B ,"=-+"=".JDL&:C<CT&)+"=-Q9 6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 hV$6i^ B ,"=-+"=<.&:L".-Q9Ybc(R"=3&S9jT"$+k<C/-&:(l9 6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6

U mn%'&o(R'&:-[p@'&Sqre+J"=Jqe&s&)-&:(R&:Lt".'".-e`'9T+9 C^=6 mn%'&u"=/9j".v(R'&:- 6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 ,w^=6 x "=2+"$+'".-ybc2(;-+"$+ 6>6>6?6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 ,w^=6gV HIQe&s&:-&:(R&:LP+9T,&SzS"$L 6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 h^=6i^ (*"=3&S9j")Q|</-&)( 6?6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 V,F

~&:9j+(R"$".K".'"=<'D` GC w)6 m`<&:9PCb&82C 6?6@6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 V

w)6 <9jT&:2C&82C&)9Q(*"$L 6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 V^w)6gV "$<eD&d(R&:9T%E2&Sq&:(R&:L 6?6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 ^

(*<-&:(R&:L"$E+9T9T'&:9 ULf$6 mn%'&u".-3CCe%( 6?6@6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 ^Sff$6 /Oj&)jC2+&:LT&)E<C3C2"=(l(l+3 6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 ^SAf$6gV -+".99&:9tbcqrT&u&:-+&:(R&:LP(*&8%9 6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 wF

<<-+Q,"$+9Y".a4(R&82+,".-M&SW".(*<-&:9 CG 6 C/-+&:( 6>6>6?6@6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 wV 6 C/-+&:( 6>6>6?6@6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6@6?6>6>6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6@6?6>6?6>6>6?6>6?6 wA

LS-+9T9]".Kb'2&sXYC1 C

V

Page 8: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

^

Page 9: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

! #"!$!"%&!'!&(()*+,-*/.0 12*** ' 0 3&!",)),-!!!45#6 4718:9;%<%=>8:9?@>BAB" CEDEFG3(D!H/I

J K |MLONQPQRMSP

TVU1WXZYG[\U]W^3_Ua`b[dceZYG`3`%^3fZgihE`!Ukj l\UafmYllYfnW^!Ua`pocq`%Yr^3fsl_G^3YfE_YiU1fZetYGfZgq^3fEYYo^3fZg 6tu fv[dcqlW_kU1lYlGwyx>cqozUeEYYh|ZfZeZYGolWUafZeZ^%fZgicax~hZXnj l^3_Ua`hZXZYfEcq[YGfUU1fZeWcOfZeUafZlYolWcYfEgq^3fZYGYo*^3fEg\hZocqZ`3YG[lGw(^%W^3lpfZY_GYllUaojVWcgqc\YGjacqfZeQYhYo^3[dYfnWlU1fZeXZYG|Zo^%lW^3_[dYGWXZc eZlU1fZeioU]WXZYGox>cq`%`3cUOWXZYGcqoYW^%_kUa`UahZhEocnUa_Xx>ocq[UacqY1wCWXEocq|ZgaXUx>cao[Ua`BoYGhZoYGlYfnWU1W^%cqf^3fWYGo[dlcaxUdada/a\ 6 TUafnjhZocqZ`3YG[lp_kU1fi Y¡[dceZYG`3`%Ye¢jl£jl£WYG[l¤c1xMx>|ZfZ_W^3cafUa`$Y¥¢|U1W^3cqfEl¦^%WXga^%qYGfcq|ZfZeZUaojUafZe§1cqo¨^3fZ^W^3Ua`y_GcqfZeZ^W^3cafZl 6u f[dcqlW¡_kU1lYlGwMl|E_Xx>|ZfZ_GW^3cqfZUa`BY¥¢|U1W^3cqfElUaoYzhU1oW^3Ua`cqopcqoeE^3fUao£jreZ^©-YGoYfnW^!Ua`YG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfZlwlcdWXU]WYqcq`%|EW^%cqfV[dc eZY`%lU1oY¡oYhEoYlYfnWYGe¢j^3fE^%W^3Ua`cq|ZfZeU1oj\1Ua`%|ZYhEocqZ`%Y[dlUafEel£WU1W^3cqfZUaojd[dceZYG`3l¢j\ ca|ZfZeUao£j1Ua`%|ZY¤hZocqZ`%Y[dlw caWX`3^%fZYkU1o¨UafZefEcqf`%^3fZYUao«ª A1¬Q6O­ fZ`%jihZ|ZoYdeZ^©-YGoYfnW^!Ua`B[dceEY`3`%^3fZg\^3l¨fZcaWwCXZcYGaYowBl|E®d_^%YfnWzWcYhZ`3Ua^3fVWXZY¯_Gcq[dhZ`3Y+E^WjcaxUa`3`$hZXnj l^%_kUa`y YGXUk^%cq|Zol°¦^3filcq[dYY`%eZlc1x±hZXnjl^3_GlzU1fZeiYfEgq^3fZYGYo*^3fEgZwB^3fxUa_Wkw±hZXZYGfZcq[dYfUUafEeshEocqhYo£W^3YGl¯fZYGYe²Wc Yx>cqo[¯|E`!U1WYe³njeZ^©-YGoYGfZ_Y1w^%f¢WYgqoUa`~cao^3fnWYgqoc1eZ^©-YGoYGf¢W^!Ua`-Y¥¢|U1W^3cqfZl 6p­ fZ_Y¨WXZYz[\U]WXZYG[\U1W^3_Ua`)[dceZYG`XUalp YGYfx>cao[¯|Z`3U1WYGeO^3fl|Z_XU¤Ukj¯WXU1W^%WMXUal±Ulcq`%|EW^%cqf)waWXZY¦^3fnWYGoYGlW^3lMWXZYf´Wc¨lcq`%aYp^W 6Mµ ^3fZ_GYqYGoj«lYG`3eZca[UafdUafU1`%j¢W^%_kUa`lca`3|EW^3cqfQ^%lcqEWU1^3fUaE`3Yaw-f |E[YGo^3_Ua`B[dYGWXEceZl¤WUa¶aY«cqYGoU1fUa`%j¢W^3_kU1`ycqfZYGlx>ocq[·ga^% ^3fZgOU1hZhZock^[U1WY1w ]¸¹/nº3 lcq`3|W^3cafZl 6C» XZY¦UafUa`j l^3ly^3lM_Uaoo^3Ye«cq|WBhUall^3fEg¨WXZoca|ZgqX¯WXEYx>cq`3`%c¦^%fZgZUal^%_lWUagqYGl°~¼ ½±¾ a¸ ¾ aº3 wZ¼ q½ dada/a¢\ wZ¼ Vn½ a3¿ ¾ ~\ w¼ ^n½±À ¹ \ ¾ /a¢¿]Á¹ / À.6» XZYd_cq[dhZ|EWYelca`3|EW^3cqfQ^%l¨WX¢|ZlWXZYdUahZhEock^3[U1W^%cqfQcaxWXZY«^3fnaYlW^3gnU]WYeÂhZXnj l^%_kUa`BhZocqhYoW^3YGl^3frWXZY¨oYkU1`)hZocaZ`3YG[Ã|ZfZeZYGo¦_cqfZl^3eZYGoU1W^3cqf 6

ÄY«XZYoY«h cq^%fnWcq|EWWXZY¯WYGo[ ¸n¸ ¾ GÅqda/ À °fZcOY¥¢|U1W^3cqfZl¨eZYGl_Go^3Y«hZXnj l^3_Ua`BoYUa`3^WjY+¢Ua_W`%jawMfUa[dY`jWXZY_cq[dhZ|EWYe³lca`3|EW^3cqf^3ll|Z ÆYG_GW´Wc ¾¾ ¾6 ÄÇXU]W¯~Y\_kUa`%`YGoocao^3lUa_GW|Ua`%`%jWXEYl|E[Ècax±lYGaYoU1`M^3fZeEYhYfZeZYGfnW_cqfnWo^3E|EW^%cqfZleE|ZYzWc\WXZYlYGaYoUa`yhZXZUalYGlcaxB[dceZYG`3`%^3fZgZweE^3l£_oYGW^3ÉkU]W^3cafzU1fZe_Gcq[hE|EWU1W^3cqf 6CÊ YgqUaoeZ^%fZgbWXZ^%lw1Uaf¡^3fnWYGoYl£W^%fZgeZYqYG`3cqhZ[dYfnWC^3fË~cq[dhZ|EWU]W^3cafUa`TU1WXZY[U1W^3_lb^%lbWc«[YUal|EoYWXZY¡lYqYGoUa`$_caf¢Wo^%Z|EW^%cqfZlbcaxCWXZY¨YGoocaow^3fOcqoeZYobWcYGlW^%[\U]WY¤WXEYUa_G_|ZoUa_Gj´c1x WXZY¦f |E[YGo^3_Ua`Elcq`3|W^3caf«UafZe«l|ZgagqYl£W_Go^WYo^!UWc¡^%[hEocqYb^W 6CÌ U]WYo±cqf´Yb¦^3`3` W|ZofUa_¶ÍWc´WXZ^%lb^3[dh cqo£WUafnW¦U1lhY_GW 6

u fvWXZ^3ldgqYGfZYoUa`cq|W`3^%fZYcax¨[\U]WXZYG[\U1W^3_Ua`b[c eZYG`3`3^%fZgZwBYQXZYoYx>c_G|Zl\caf 3 ¾ ]dÎ À /\ #¿ ª f w h¬c6ÐÏ aU1lWVUa[dcq|ZfnWcaxhEocqZ`%Y[dlOUafZeÑeZYG ^3_GYlVUaoca|ZfZeÒ|ZlUaoYYhZ`3Ua^3fEYeÒ¢jY`%Y_Woca[\UagafZYGW^3_rWXZYGcqo^%YlG°_kU]WXZc eZYÓoUkjscql_G^3`%`3cql_cqhYlGwWYG`3Y^%l^%cqfmoY_GYhEW^3cqf)w~oUaeU1owlU1WYG`3`3^WY_ca[[¯|EfZ^3_U1W^%cqf)w)[d^3_GocUkaYeZY ^3_YGlwÔ[caZ^3`%Y¯_cq[d[¯|ZfE^3_kU]W^3caf)w)cqhEW^3_Ua`yYo¨_ca[[¯|EfZ^3_U1W^%cqf)woYG[c1WYMlYfZl^3fZgZw]oU1eZ^3cbU1lWocqfZcq[zjqwZoU1^3fl_UafZfZYGolGwaY`%Y_Woca[\UagafZYGW^3_ylXZ^3YG`3eZ^%fZgZwhU1oW^%_`%YMUa_G_Y`%Yo*U1WcqolGw T Êpu lj lWY[dlw Y`%Y_GWocq[UagqfEYGW^%__ca[hU]W^3E^3`3^Wj¡UalhY_WlGw hEocqZ`%Y[dlBcax Y`3YG_GWoc1Ó[YG_XUafZ^%_kUa`YfEYog1j_caf¢aYol^3caf)wUafZelcQcqf 6QÏ l¶ fEc¦f-wWXZY\x>|ZfZeZUa[YGfnWUa`Y¥¢|U1W^3cqfEl¯^3fhEX¢j l^3_l´gacaYof

w

Page 10: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

^3fEgÍUa`%`Ô[Ua_Gocql_cqhZ^%_zYG`3YG_GWocq[UagqfZYW^3_¨hZXEYfZcq[dYfZUÍUaoY kÅ~ ¿«¹Ea/ À ¿ wYhZoYllYenjUafXnj h YGocq`3^%_l£j lWYG[ caxol£WÍcqoeZYodeZ^©-YGoYfnW^!Ua`¦Y¥¢|U]W^3cafZl 6 » XZYV[\U1^3f²WUal¶³cax[U1WXZYG[\U]W^3_Ua`[dceZYG`3`%^3fZg«^3fY`3YG_GWocq[UagqfZYW^%_UafZUa`%j l^%l^%lWXEYfQWXZYhZocqE`3Y[ cax±lcq`% ^%fZgOTU] Y`%`l¤Y¥¢|U1W^3cqfEl|ZfZeEYo¤gq^qYGfi ca|ZfZeUao£jiU1fZei^3fE^%W^3Ua`_cafZeZ^%W^3cqfEl 6pÏ fUa`j¢W^3_Ua`$lcq`%|EW^%cqfZlpcaxTU] Y`%`l¤Y¥¢|U1W^3cqfEleZczY^3l£W^3f«xUa_Wkw cqEWU1^3fZYGe[Ua^3fE`%j´njdlYGhUaoU]W^3cafcax-aU1o^!U1Z`3YGlU1fZecq|Zo^3YGoU1fZe Ì UahZ`3Ua_YbWoUafZl*x>cqo[ [YWXZc eZlwCZ|EWzWXZYjU1oY\ZUalYGecqfl^3[dhZ`3Y«_GccqoeZ^3fZU1WYdlj lWY[dlz¦^WXoYgq|E`!Uao¡cqo¡^3fEfE^%WYcq|ZfZeU1o^3YGl 6iµ |Z_X²UafU1`%j¢W^%_kUa`±[dYGWXEceZlzoYG¥ |E^3oYWc clWo^%_GW´U1ll|E[hEW^3cqfElcqfWXZY\gaYcq[dYGWojÂcaxWXEY¯[\U]WYo^!Ua`$oYgq^%cqfZl¤U1fZe)w-lcq[dYXZc¨w-WccÍ^%eZYkU1`CXnj h c1WXZYGlYlWXU1W¤_UafZfZc1W[\U]W_XWXZY¯_ca[hZ`%YlXZUah YGlMcax(YG`3Y_Wocq[\U1gqfZYGW^3_eZYG ^%_YlMUafZe´eZcq[Ua^%fZlCYGfZ_ca|ZfnWYoYe«^3foYkU1``%^%x>YUafZe¯^%fZeZ|Zl£Wo^3Ua` UahZhZ`%^_kU]W^3cafZl 6 ÄY¨oYkU1`3^3ÉGYawEWXZYoYGx>cqoYawZWXZY¨^3[dh cqo£WUafE_Y¤caxCf¢|Z[dYo^%_kUa` Wc cq`3ll^3fZ_GY¡UafUa`j W^3_Ua`-[dYGWXZceEleZc«fZcaWpY+E^%lWp^3fO[dcqlW¦c1xCWXZY¨_kUalYlpcaxy^%fnWYoYl£W 6

Ï ly^WyXU1hZh YGfZly^%fcaWXZYoÔYfEgq^3fZYGYo^3fZgpY`%eZlw]aU1o^3ca|ZlCf¢|Z[dYo^3_Ua`¢[YWXZc eZlÔ_kUaf¯Y~|ElYezWc¤lcq`%aYeZ^©-YGoYfnW^!Ua`Z[dc eZY`%lB^3f«Y`%Y_GWocq[UagqfEYGW^%l[ 6C» j hZ^3_Ua`3`jqw À 3\ À w À ¤a ¤ ¾ À w ¿¸ ¾ aUafZe º]¹ À n ¾ 3\ À \]¿ UaoY¨|ZlYe)wcqo¦[d^YeVUahZhZocnUa_XZYGeU1lYecqfU«_ca[¯Z^3fZU1W^%cqfrcaxWXEYlY¨WYG_XZfZ^%¥ |EYlª V ¬c6 ^3eZYGf¢W`%jaw caWXrWXZYGcqoYW^3_Ua`UafEeVhZoUa_GW^3_Ua`)oYUalcafZlU1o^3lY^3frWXEY¡_XEcq^3_GYcaxÔWXZYzUahZhEocqhZo^!U1WYf¢|Z[YGo^%_kUa`-WY_XZfE^3¥¢|ZYaw(eZYGh YGfZeZ^%fZg\cqfrWXZYzfZU1W|ZoY¨caxCWXZY¨hZocaZ`3YG[¼Y 6 g 6 WXEYeZcq[Ua^%fVgqYGcq[dYGWo£jqw(hcqll^3Z`%YUdhZo^%cqo^¶¢fZc¦fQhZocqh YGoW^3YlpcaxMWXZY¡lcq`%|EW^%cqf)wUafZeVlcÍcqf ½ w(Z|EW¤Ua`3lccqfiWXZY«UkaU1^3`!U1Z`3Y¡oYGlcq|Zo_YGl¡^%fWYGo[dl¤cax±W^%[YUafZeQ[dYkUafEl 6µ cq[dYGW^%[YGlw lW^%`3`ÔfZc¨w_cqfElWoUa^3fnWlcaxC`3cÑ_cq[dhZ|EWU1W^%cqfUa`W^3[dYUafEe_GcqlWp_Uafx>cao_YWcd|ElY¨l^%[hZ`%YoeE^3l_GoYW^3ÉU1W^%cqfrl_XEY[dYlU1W¦`3ccqoeZYoz¼Y 6 g 6 fE^%WY¨eZ^©-YGoYGfZ_Y¡[YWXZc eZl ½6 YGaYo£WXZYG`3YllwhZocaZ`3YG[l¦cqf_cq[dhZ`%Y¢lXUahYeeZYG ^3_GYlGwcqooYG¥ |E^3o^%fZg¡XZ^3gqXhZoYG_^%l^3caf)wEU1eZeZoYGllWcU1oeZl[dcqoYocqZ|Zl£WUafEerUa__G|ZoU]WYf¢|Z[dYo^3_Ua`([YWXZc eZl 6Ï [dcqfZg¡WXZYG[Vw¢WXEYfZ^WYpY`3YG[YGfnW[dYGWXEcei¼ T ½ XUal~oY_GYfnW`j\Y_Gcq[YUlWUafZeU1oeÍ_Gcq[hE|EWU]W^%cqfrWYG_XZfZ^3¥¢|ZYª V,F w wF¬c6

» XEY¯ol£WfZ^WY¯YG`3YG[YGf¢W[YWXZc eZlp~YGoY´^3fnWoc eZ|Z_YGeQnj Ê@6 Ë~ca|ZoUafnW^%f A^,V w eEYGqYG`3cqhYe^%fWXEYzl|Z__GYll^%aYjqYUaolpx>cqo¦lWo|Z_GW|ZoU1`CU1fUa`%j l^3lpUahZhZ`%^3_U1W^%cqfZl^%fUa^%o_GoU1xW¦eZYGl^%gqf¼>Y`3UalW^3_^WjrY¥¢|UW^%cqfZlGw hE`!U1WYYG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfZlw YGW_ 6#½6BÏ lcq`%^3e«[\U]WXZYG[\U1W^3_Ua`ZUa_¶¢gqocq|ZfZeÍ~UaleZYGaY`3cah YGeÍ^3fdWXZY A,f,F lx>cqoMYG`3`%^3hEW^3_hZocqE`3Y[dlw1WXZYGfdY+ WYfEeZYedWchUaoUacq`3^%_UafZe«Xnj h YGocq`3^%_hZocqZ`3YG[ly`!U1WYo 6 ocq[ WXEYfcqf)w¦^WXWXZY«_ca[^%fZgrcax~Ua|EWca[\U1W^3_¯_Gcq[dhZ|EWU]W^3caf)w)WXZ^%l[YWXZc eÂXUal¨XUaeUͦ^3eZY«eZ^©-|Zl^3cqf^%f[UafnjiYfEgq^3fZYGYo^3fZgOUahEhZ`3^%_kU1W^3cqfZlG°¦lWo|Z_GW|ZoU1`±UafZeQlca`3^3eQl£WU1WY´[YG_XUafZ^%_lGw|Z^3eQejfZUa[^%_lGwf | _`%YkUaopYfEgq^3fZYGYo^3fZgZw(XZYU1W_cqfZeE|Z_GW^3cqf)w_caf¢aY_W^3cafeZ^©-|El^3cafhZoc_GYllYlGw)h YWocq`3YG|Z[ YfZga^3fZYGYo^%fZgZwoYUa_GW^3cqf eZ^©-|Zl^3cqf«hZoc_GYllYlGwEYG`3Y_Wocq[\U1gqfZYGW^3l[Vwq~UkqY¤hZocqhUagqU1W^%cqf)wn^3fnWYgqoU1W^%cqf«_^3o_|Z^WlGwU1fZelccqf 6 Ë~cqfE_YofZ^3fEgY`%Y_Woca[\UagafZYGW^3_¯[dceEY`3lGw)fZ^WY«Y`%Y[dYfnW¨[YWXZc eZl¡UaoYd_G|ZooYfnW`j|EW^%`3^%ÉYex>cqopUd1Ual£W¤U1[cq|Ef¢WpcaxMlWU]W^3_1w(¥ |ZUal^ lWU1W^%_¡UafZeVW^3[dYeZYhYfEeZYfnWhZocqZ`%Y[dlw(oUafEgq^3fZg´x>ocq[ XZ^3gaXx>oYG¥¢|ZYfZ_j[^%_oc~UkqYlp|ZlYei^%f[dcqZ^%`3Y¤_Gcq[d[¯|ZfZ^%_kU1W^3cqfÍWcd`%c x>oYG¥¢|ZYfZ_jc_G_|Zoo^3fEg^%fhc~YGoYfEYog1jª A w V^ w ^ w ^8w]¬Q6

~Ual^%_kUa`%`%jqwW~ceZ^%© YoYfnW¤U1hZhZocqUa_XZYl_kUafV Y¡|ZlYe)° À na fZ^WY¡Y`%Y[dYfnWlGw(Wj hZ^%_kUa`c1xBl_Ua`!Uaox>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3cafZlwUalY`%`pUal Î fZ^WYY`%Y[dYfnWl 6Ñ» XZYx>cqo[dYo«XUkaYi YGYfv[Ua^%fZ`%j³|ElYet|ZfnW^3`fZc 6B» XZY¤`3U1WWYoª A1¬ YoY^3fnWoceE|Z_YGeÍnj 6 ÄÇXZ^WfZYj\^%fWXZY ASwF lw Z|EW~cqfZ`%jd^%f\oYG_YGf¢WbjaYkUaollca[Y¤YGeZgqYZfZ^%WY¤Y`%Y[dYfnWWXEYcqo^3Yl¼ 6 Ë 6 YGeZY`%Y_aw Ïn6 cqllU ^WkwUafEercaWXZYGol ½ XUkqY¨oYG_YG^%qYGeUaf^3fE_oYUal^%fZgiU]WWYGfnW^3cafx>cqo¨qYG_GWcaozx>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3cafZl 6ÍÏ f³UaeE1UafnWUagqY\c1xbYeZgaY\Y`%Y[dYfnWlz^3fUqYG_GWcqo

f

Page 11: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

x>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3cafcax$YG`3YG_GWocq[UagqfZYW^3_phZocqZ`3YG[l^3lWXU]WWXZYj\_Uafr[dceZYG` eE^3l_GcqfnW^%f |E^%W^%YlcaxWXEYY`%e1Uao^3UaZ`%Yl¦^3fOWXZY¨WoUafZl^%W^%cqfVUa_ocqllpeZ^%© YoYfnW¤[U1WYo^3Ua`)eZca[\Ua^%fZlwZ¦^WXUaZo|EhEW_XZUafZgqYGl^3fY`%Y_+Wo^3__GcqfZeZ|Z_W^^WjqwhYo[^WW^ ^%Wjcqo¦[\UagafZYGW^3_¤hYo[YUaZ^3`%^%Wj 6M» XZY¡fZceZUa`$UahZhZocnUa_X)wXEcYGaYoGw ^%llW^3`%`-hZoYGx>YooYGeVx>cqobl_kUa`3Uaobh c1WYfnW^!Ua`-x>cao[¯|Z`3U1W^%cqfZl¤¼Ual¦^3frca|Zo¦_kUalY ½6

Ë~cafZ_YGofZ^%fZg¯WXZYlXUahYcax$Y`%Y[dYfnWlb|ElYeO^%fÍlhU1_YeZ^%l_oYGW^3ÉkU]W^3caf)w[dcql£WbcaxWXEYYkUao`3^3YGoZfZ^%WYY`%Y[dYfnW`3^%WYoU1W|ZoY¦XUaeÍYYGfÍeZYGaY`%cqh YGe\x>cqooYG_GWU1fZgq`3YGl~^%fdWc¯eZ^%[YGfZl^%cqfZlUafZe\Eo^3_¶¢l^%fdWXZoYGYeZ^%[YGfZl^%cqfZl 6 lh YG_^3Ua`3`jÍx>cqo¦Y`%Y_GWocq[UagqfEYGW^%_¡UahZhZ`%^3_kU]W^3cafZlwZXEcYGaYoGw-WXZYGoYzXUalp YGYfioY_YGfnW`%jUaf³^%fZ_oYkUal^3fZgQ^%f¢WYoYlW´WcUaoeZl´Wo^!UafZga|Z`!UaozUafZe³WYGWoUaXZYGeZoUa`~[YGlXZYGlwUal¯WXZYjXU1fZeZ`3YrYGWWYGo_caofZYGolUafZeOYeZgaYlpc_G_|Zoo^3fEgd^%frWXZY¨_ca[hZ`%YÍlXUahYl¦caxCY`%Y_Woca[\UagafZYGW^3_eZY^%_YGl 6

|Zo£WXZYGo[dcqoY1wUaf²UaoYUQcaxp^3fZ_GoYkU1l^3fEgQ^3fnWYGoYl£W«^3l´gq^qYGfsnj nn¸a ZfZ^%WYÍY`%Y[dYfnW«[YWXc eZl¯ª V w w w w h w V w V,V w ^,A]¬Q6 ^©-YGoYGf¢W`%jÍx>ocq[ _`3Uall^3_Ua`WY_XEfZ^3¥¢|ZYGlw)^%fUaeZUahEW^qYz[YWXZc eZlUaf^3[dhZocaY[dYfnW¡caxWXZYdlcq`%|EW^%cqfUa_G_|ZoUa_GjÂ^3loYkUa_XEYenjÂUO`3c _kUa`CoYGZfZY[dYfnW¯c1xWXZY[dYlX)w$cqo¡U`3c _kU1`Ô^%fZ_oYkUalY¯caxBWXZYhcq`%j fZca[^3Ua`cqoeEYoc1xBWXZYZfZ^%WYY`%Y[dYfnW¤lcq`3|W^3caf)w hYo£x>cqo[dYeVcqfZ`jVcafQUlYG`3YG_GW^%cqfcqf[YGlXYG`3Y[dYfnWl¯XUk ^3fZgi`3UaogaYYGoocao^3fEeZ^3_U1Wcqol 6µ |Z_X²^3fEeZ^3_U1Wcqol¡UaoYÍ_Gcq[dhZ|EWYGenjl|Z^WUaE`3Y «¸¿ ¾ / ¾ Yoocqo¨YGlW^%[\U]WYlc1x~WXEY«ZfZ^%WY´Y`3YG[YGfnWzlcq`3|W^3cafQcqEWU1^3fZYGeUa_G_cqoeZ^3fEgWcVeZ^%© YoYfnW¯_Go^WYo^!UEwÔUafEe[YUal|EoYe¢j¶¢fZc¦f³¥¢|UafnW^W^%YlwC`3^%¶aY´WXZYf¢|Z[YGo^%_kUa`±lca`3|EW^3cqf)w$WXEYeU1WUOUafZeWXZY«[dYlXÂl^%ÉY 6dÏ fU1eUahEW^%qYdUahEhZocnU1_XUa`%`3c¦lWcoYeZ|E_Yd^3fÂUl^3gqfE^%_UafnWUkjQWXEY_ca[hZ|WU1W^3cqfU1`-_calWUafZeOW^%[Y¤c1xCWXZYfZ^%WYY`%Y[dYfnWp_kUa`%_|Z`3U1W^%cqfÍcqfrWXEY¡[dc eZY` 6

cq`%`3c¦^3fEgdWXZYlY´gq|Z^3eEY`3^%fZYlGwWXZY¯hZ|EohcqlY´caxBWXZ^3lp~cao¶^%lWcÍlW|ZeEjWXZY¯Y®_G^3YGfZ_GjcaxUaeUahW^qY´fZ^WY«Y`%Y[dYfnW¡[YWXZc eZl¨cqfÂlcq[dY´WXZoYY+eZ^%[YGfZl^%cqfUa`M[UagqfEYGWcalWU]W^3_´hEocqZ`%Y[dlcqEWUa^3fZYGex>oca[ UeZcq|EZ`3Y¡h c1WYfnW^!Ua`x>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3cafrcaxBlWU1W^%_¯TVU] ~YG`3`lYG¥¢|U1W^%cqfZlGw¦^WXiUdh calWYGo^%cqo^YGoocaoYl£W^%[\U1W^3cqf 6y» XZY^%eZYkU^%l_kU1oo^%YeÍca|EWWXEocq|ZgaXOUafOUafUa`j l^3lU1W[dcqoY`3YGaY`%lw¦XE^3_XO^3fnqca`%qY caWX[dceZYG`3`%^3fZgVUafZe²_ca[hZ|WU1W^3cqf³U1lhY_GWl 6 Ë~cafZ_YGofZ^%fZgQWXZYr[dceEY`3`%^3fZghZXU1lYawUil^%gqfZ^_kUafnW«U1fZe_o|Z_^3Ua`±WUal¶^%lzWXEY\^3fnWYgqoU1W^%cqfcax~WXZY ^3caW£ µ Uk1UaoWz`!Ukx>caozWXEYÍYl£W^3[U1W^3cqfÂcaxbWXEY\[UagqfZYW^3_YG`3eOeZ|ZY¨Wc«lca|Zo_GY¡_G|ZooYfnWl 6

» XEYzoYhcqoW¦^%lbcqognU1fZ^3ÉGYeUalbx>cq`3`%c¦l 6

u f Ë~XZUahEWYGo WXEY³[\U1WXZY[U1W^3_kU1`Ua_¶¢gqoca|ZfZe ^3lVhZoYGlYfnWYe)w¯¦^WX UtlXZcqoWicaYo£^%YG caxÌ YYlgq|ZY´UafEe µ cqcq`3YOlhU1_Yl|ZlYGeQ^3fVWXZYz1Uao^!U1W^3cqfZUa`-x>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3cafVU1fZefZ^WY¡Y`%Y[dYfnWUafZUa`j l^%lpc1xCWXZY¨[\UagafZYGWcqlWU1W^%_¤[c eZYG`3lblW|ZeZ^%Ye^3frWXZY¨hZoYlYfnWcqo¶ 6

Ë~XZUahEWYGo V hZoYGlYGf¢WlbUaf^3fnWoceZ|E_GWcaoj´l_YfZUao^%ccqfdx>|ZfZeUa[dYfnWUa`([\U1WXZY[U1W^3_kU1`E[dceZYG`3l±|ZlYe^3fdY`%Y_Woca[\UagafZYGW^3_¦hZocaZ`3YG[lGw eEYo^qYGex>oca[ÐTU] ~YG`3`lY¥¢|U1W^3cqfEl 6B» c¯eZ^%© YoYfnW[\U1WXZY[U1W^_kU1`-[dceZYG`3`%^3fZg¡UahZhEocnUa_XEYlbUaoY¤eZ^%l_|EllYGe)° x>cqo[|Z`!U1W^3cqfElw¢UalYercqfÍaY_GWcqo~YG`3eZl wQwUafZe _ w)cao ¸]* À a x>cqo[|Z`!U1W^3cqfElw^3fnWoceZ|E_^3fEgrl_kU1`!UaoU1fZeiqYG_GWcao¡hcaWYfnW^3Ua`3lGw-`3^%¶aY«w w m w w(UafZerWXEY¡_Gcq[¯Z^%fU1W^3cqf ZǼ_GcqfZl^%eZYoYe^3frWXEY¡hEoYlYfnWp~cqo¶ ½6

Ë~XZUahEWYGo ^ eZYGl_Go^3Yl$WXEYgaYfZYGoUa`¢_`3Uall$caxcq|ZfZeU1oj¤1Ua`%|ZYBhZocaZ`3YG[lWcb¦XZ^%_Xz[UagqfEYGWcalWU]W^3_[dceZYG`3l¡^3fshcaWYfnW^3Ua`x>cao[¯|Z`3U1W^%cqf YG`3cqfEg 6i» XZYrU1ZlWoUa_W´[c eZYG`^%l¯UafYG`3`%^3hEW^3_«hZocaZ`3YG[Vw

Page 12: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

_cafZl^%lW^%fZgÍcaxU\gaYfZYGoUa`%^3ÉYGeCca^3llcqfY¥¢|U1W^3cqfV¦^%WXQ[d^YGeifZcqfÓXZcq[dcqgqYGfZYcq|El¤ ca|ZfZeUao£jiU1fZe^3fnWYoxU1_Y´_cafZeZ^%W^3cqfElcax ^%o^%_XZ`3YWUafZe Y|Z[UafZfQWj h Y 6«» XZY´aU1o^!U]W^3cafUa`$x>cqo[¯|E`!U1W^3cqfV^3l¤WXEYfeZ^%l_|EllYGe)wUafZe´Y^%lWYGfZ_YpUafEed|EfZ^3¥¢|ZYGfZYllcax(WXZY~YUa¶lcq`3|W^3caf¯^3lMhEocqYGenj¯WXZY Ì U]¢£TV^%`3gqoUa[WXEYcqoY[w-¦^%WXQl|Z_G_Yll^qY«fZ^%WY¯Y`%Y[dYfnWeZ^%l_GoYGW^3ÉU1W^%cqfnj¨Ua`%Yo¶¢^%fi[YWXZc eicqfQWYGWoUaXZYGeZoUa`[dYlX 6

Ï x>cao[Ua`yYGoocao¨UafUa`jl^3l¤^%l¤WXZYGfhEoYlYfnWYGe^%fÂË~XUahEWYo w)6 TVc eZYG`3`3^%fZgÍU1fZe_Gcq[dhZ|EWU]W^3cafUa`YoocqoldUaoYreZ^%l_G|ZllYevU1fZe)w±x>c_G|Zl^%fZgcqf³WXZYO_ca[hZ|WU1W^3cqfU1`YGoocao´eZ|ZYrWcQWXEYOZfZ^%WYrY`3YG[YGfnWeZ^%l_oYGW^3ÉkU]W^3caf)w-UhZo^%cqo^CUafZeQUÍhcql£WYo^3cqo^ÔUahZhZocnUa_XZYGl¨UaoY¯Y+hZ`!Ua^%fZYe 6¤Ï hcqlWYo^3cqo^CYGoocao¤Yl£W^[U1WYGlU1oYWXZYGfVhEocqYGei^3fOYfEYog1jOfZcqo[wUal¦¥¢|UafnW^%WU]W^%aY¨^3fZeZ^%_kU1Wcqolbc1xMUa_G_|ZoUa_GjOc1xyWXEY¨ZfZ^%WYY`%Y[dYfnW¦lca`3|EW^3cqf 6 ¨YGcq[YWo^3_WY_XZfZ^%¥¢|ZYlcaxyYG`3YG[YGf¢W¦l|ZeZ^% ^3l^3cqfÍx>cao¦UafUaeUahEW^%aY¡oYGfEY[dYfnWcaxÔWXZY¨[dYlX)wUalYecafOWXZYlYzYGoocqob^3fZeE^3_kU]WcqolwUaoY¤WXZYGfeZ^%l_G|ZllYe 6

Ï lhY_WlrUacq|EW^3[dhZ`%Y[dYfnWU1W^3cqfsUaoYV^%fnqYl£W^%gnU1WYGev^3fvË~XUahEWYo f$6ÑÏ gqYGfZYoUa`eEYl_Go^%hEW^%cqfcaxWXZYUa`3gqcao^%WXZ[ ^%l¡ZolWzhZoc ^%eZYe 6O» XZYl|Z_G_YGll^qYrlY_GW^3cqfEl¯UaoYdWXZYfeEYeZ^%_kU1WYeWcY+EhE`!Ua^%fhcqll^3Z`%YUaeaU1f¢WUagqYGlcaxBca ÆY_Wcao^3YGfnWYehZocqgaoUa[d[^%fZg´x>cqo¦fZ^%WYzYG`3YG[YGf¢W_cq[dhZ|EWU1W^%cqfZlb¦^%WXlca[Y¡YEUa[dhZ`3YGlcaxyfZ^%WYzYG`3YG[YGf¢W_`3UallYlGw)UalpWXZYjXUkaYYYfQ|ElYe^3fVWXZY^%[hE`3Y[dYfnWU1W^%cqfrcaxcq|Zo¦U1`3gqcqo^%WXZ[ 6

C^3fUa`%`%jawbf |E[YGo^3_Ua`oYl|Z`%WlVU1oYQoYGh caoWYGeÇ^3fÒË~XUahWYo 6 » ~c²WYGlWO_UalYGlVU1oYQhZocqh calYe-wUalYercqf_cqfnaYOU1fZeÍfZcqf _caf¢aYÍgqYcq[dYGWo^%Ylw ^3fnacq`% ^3fEgz[UagqfZYW^%_plcaxW[U1WYo^3Ua`3lB¦^WX\eE^%© Yo£YfnW¦[UagqfZYW^%_hYo[YUaZ^3`%^%W^3Yl 6yÊ Yl|Z`%Wl¦UaoYeZ^3l_|ZllYerx>cqoU¯_cq[dhUao^3lcaf\¦^%WX\WXZYcafZYlbU1`3oYUaeEjcqEWUa^3fEYe\njdfZ^WYYG`3YG[YGf¢W[dYGWXEceZlx>cqo±WXZYlWU]W^3_¤TU] Y`3`lY¥¢|U1W^3cqfEl~^3fdY`%e\x>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3caf)wY 6 g¨WXZY¦`3YUalW£l¥ |ZUaoYGlfE^%WYbYG`3YG[YGf¢W[dYGWXZce-w¢U¨eE|Ua`Zx>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3caf¯¶¢fZc¦fÍUal±[dYGWXEce)w¢U1fZeUzaY_GWcqobhcaWYGf¢W^!Ua`(x>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3cafnjÍ|El^3fEg¯fZc eUa`-cao~YeEgqYY`%Y[dYfnWl 6B» XZYlY[YWXZc eZlXUkaY YGYfWYGlWYedU1W±Ë~XZUa`3[dYol y^%fZ^%WY `3YG[YGfnWË~YfnWYGow Uaf¯^%fnWYoeZ^3l_^%hZ`3^%fUaoj¨|EfZ^%Wycax Ë~XUa`%[YGolpfZ^%aYol^%Wjcax » YG_XZfZcq`%cqgajr^%f caWYcqogEw µ YeZYGf)w(^3fO_c cqhYoU]W^3cafͦ^%WX Ï Ë~caohcqoU1WY Ê YGlYkU1o_X 6

h

Page 13: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

d MSkR R dLPoQNu f WXZ^%lrlY_W^%cqf ~Y^3fnWoc eZ|Z_YQfEcaWU1W^3cqfElrUafZeÇeZYfZ^%W^3cqfElrUacq|EW Ì YYlgq|ZYÂUafZe µ ca cq`%YG

lhZUa_YGl±¦^WX«UlXEcqoWB[dYfnW^3cqf¯Wclcq[dYbUal^3_hZocqhYoW^3YGl±UafZe´^3fEY¥¢|Ua`%^%W^%YlC|ZlYGe^%f¯WXZYx>cq`%`3c¦^3fEg 6 ]Óa/ À» XZocq|EgqXZcq|EW´WXZ^3leZc_G|Z[dYfnWkwBWXEYrlj [¯cq`3lbw UafZe eZYfZc1WYrWXZYrlYGW«caxp_Gcq[«hZ`%Y woYUa`$UafZefU1W|ZoUa`B¼ F ^3fZ_G`3|ZeZYGe ½ f¢|Z[¯Yolw(oYGlhY_GW^%aY`%j 6 ^%lboYGlYo£qYGex>cqo¦U«oYkU1`h cql^%W^%qY_cafZlWUafnWkwEeE^%© YoYGfnWU1WYkU1_XÍc_G_|ZooYGfZ_Y 6 cqoUafnjdeZcq[Ua^%fm^3fWXZY |E_`3^%eZYkU1f\lhZUa_Y-wfEcaWU]W^%cqfZl ¤w ²UafZe"!³eZYGfZcaWYWXZYcq|ZfEeUaojawqWXZY~_`3cal|ZoYbUafZe¯WXZYb^3fnWYGo^%cqoChZUaoWBc1x¤wnoYlh YG_GW^%qYG`%j 6#%$'& ( 3 -H) + -+* ¥-

Ì YGW%v YUafÍcah YGf Ì YYlgq|ZY¤[dYkUal|ZoU1Z`3YpeZcq[Ua^3fd^3f)* 6Mu x+v^%lcq|ZfZeEYe)w ~YUall|Z[YpWXU]W^%Wlcq|ZfZeU1oj,-Ò^3l.l|E®d_^%YfnW`j0/´oYgq|E`!UaoGwE^ 6 Y 6±Ì ^%hZl_XZ^Wɤ_GcqfnW^%f |Ecq|Zl 6 cqobU1f¢j\oYUa`2143 wEYeZYGfZcaWYnj6587 ¼9 ½ WXZY4: º¿Îa¹´¿¸E <;Í ¾ ¾ ¸ wC^ 6 Y 6 WXZY UafU1_XlhU1_Y\c1x¦Ua`3`BYG¥¢|Z^%1Ua`%YfZ_GY_`3UallYl´cax¦oYkUa`cqo_Gcq[dhZ`3Y+ /1Ua`3|ZYGex>|ZfE_GW^%cqfZl= Ì YYlgq|ZYr^%f¢WYgqoUaZ`%Y\cqf>¤wB^%f¦XZ^%_XWXZY1EhcYolBcax@?A=B?kU1oY Ì YG YGlgq|ZYb^%fnWYgaoUaZ`%Y~cqf 6 YfEcaW^%fZg¤njC WED CGF I CGF-H+IJIJIKCGF waWXEYlWUafZeUaoefZcqo[Ã^3f4587 ¼L ½ ^%lbeZYGZfZYeQU1l

M = MONQP 5SR I DUT V R ?W=X? 7 C WZY IL[ 7]\ ^ =_`587 ¼L ½ I ¼ )6 ½

|ZfZ_W^3cafZl^%f>587VU1oYÍfZc1W¯_caf¢W^3f¢|Zcq|El¯^3fgaYfZYGoUa`Z|EWkwBEocnUaeE`%jÂlhYkUa¶¢^%fZgZwMWXEYGj³U1oYÍUilcqoWcax.£YkUa¶a/UahZhZoc^%[\U1W^3cqfcax_GcqfnW^%f |Ecq|Zl«x>|ZfZ_GW^3cqfEl 6²» XZ^3l´x>cq`%`3c¦lx>ocq[ WXEYOxU1_GW«WXU]W´WXZYOlYW ¼ ½ ^3lbeZYGfZlY¡^3f4587 ¼L ½6Ï [cafZgWXZY Ì YG YGlgq|ZYlhU1_YlGwB^%W¡^3l¡¶¢fZc¦fWXZU1W5@H]¼9 ½ ^%lUaf ^%`3YoW¨lhUa_GYawMnjÂ_XZc cql^%fZg

WXEY¡^%fZfZYGobhZoc eZ|Z_W

¼9= \Kb ½ Ndc 5eR I D V R = b C W \ ^ = \Kb _5*H]¼9 ½ \ ¼ )6 a½

¦XZcqlY\^%fZeZ|Z_GYefZcao[_cq^%fZ_^%eZYl¨¦^%WXWXZY Ì YG YGlgq|ZY\fZcqo[ ¼ )6½ x>cao1 D )6ru f_UalYÍc1xoYUa`1Ua`3|EYex>|EfZ_GW^3cqfZlGwMeZYfZ^%W^3cqfv¼ )6 q½ UafZel^3[d^3`3UaocqfZYGl´UaoYgq^%aYfnjÂlYWW^3fZg

b^%fhZ`3Ua_YdcaxbWXEY

_caf]Æ|ZgnU1WYb6» XEY¨Y`%`Ó¶ fEc¦fgf a¹ ihkj ¾ mlz À ¹ZaÁ XEcq`3eZlGwZWXU]W¦^3l

?£¼9= \Kb ½ NGc 5SR I ?Sn M = M Ndc 5eR I M b M Ndc 5eR I \ ^ = \Kb _`5@H]¼L ½ I ¼ )6 Vq½

Ê Y`!U]W^3cafi¼ )6 Vq½ _Uafr YlYGYfOUalbU¡hUao£W^3_G|Z`!U1o_UalY1wx>cqo+1 DpoBD w caxqsr] ¾ ¿ À ¹EaÁ w ¦XE^3_XUallYo£Wl¨WXU]Wx>cqo¨Ua`3`13 w o 3 l|Z_XÂWXU]W ut 1)v ut owD w^%x=x_y587 ¼L ½ \Kb _y5@z¼9 ½ wWXEYf= b _`5 I ¼L ½ UafEe M = b M N| 5SR I n M = M NQP 5eR I M b M Ni 5eR I I ¼ )6g^n½

A

Page 14: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

ÄYU1`3lcs^3fnWoc eZ|Z_Y 5 ¼L ½ UalWXZY ~UafUa_X lhUa_GYcax«U1`3`Y¥¢|Z^1Ua`3YGfZ_Y_`!U1llYGlcax¯oYkU1`¡cao_ca[hZ`%Y¢Ó1Ua`%|ZYeÍx>|EfZ_GW^3cqfZl= Ì YYlgq|ZY¡^3fnWYGgqoUaE`3Y¤cqf4¤wZYGllYfnW^3Ua`3`j¼^ 6 Y 6 aÁ\¿~ a ¾ y ¾ ½cq|ZfZeZYGeVcafE 6±» XZY¨_caooYGlhcqfZeZ^%fZgdfZcqo[ ^3l¦eZYfZYeUal

M = M N 5eR I D l|Zh R ?A=X? D ^%fEx _E °?W=y¼ W ½ ?Sn U 6 Y 6 ^%f4 aI ¼ )6 wa½

c1W^3_GYÍWXU]W¯WXZYOfZc1WU1W^3cqf>5 ¼L ½ ^%lpÆ|Zl£W^%ZYe²nj²UQ`3^3[d^%WzhZocqh YGoWj°Íx>cqo´UQgq^qYGf²x>|EfZ_GW^3cqf>=Ì YYlgq|ZY¨^3fnWYGgqoU1Z`3Ycqf ¤wZ^%xÔU¯oYkUa` o 3 Y^3l£Wlbl|Z_XWXU1W M = M N 5eR I v WXZYf M = M N P 5eR IM = M N 5SR I U1l 1 6» XZYÍ^%fZ_`%|Zl^%cqf 5*zk¼L ½ 587 ¼L ½ x>cqo n 1yn o XZcq`%eZlwÔx>ocq[ ca`3eZYGo l^3fEY¥¢|Ua`%^%WjqwyUalzY`%`Ual 587 ¼L ½ 5 ¼9 ½ x>cqoUafnj 13 ,6 TVcqoYGcqYoGwBWXZYGoY\Y+^3lWl´U_GcqfZlWUafnWKF l|Z_XVWXU1W M = M NQP 5SR I n M = M Ni 5eR I \ ^ =E_`5@z¼L ½ I ¼ )6 fq½

cqo¦U´[dcqoYY+ WYfEeZYeil|ZoaYGjOcax Ì YYlgq|ZY¡lhUa_GYlGw lYYª ^,F1¬c6

#%$ # 30 -+* -

Ï fZ^WYdY`3YG[YGfnW¯UafZUa`%j l^%lzoY¥¢|Z^%oYlUOx>|EoWXEYo¯U1ll|E[hEW^3cqfcaxoYgq|E`!Uao^%WjQcqf 5*H£Óx>|ZfZ_W^%cqfZl 6Ê YgnUaoeZ^3fEg¯WXZ^%lwZx>cqobYUa_X _¦w~Y¡eZYGZfZYWXZY j aº]3 z¿¸E ¿¯<;¯ ¾ ¾ Ual

¼L ½ D u= _ 5*H¼L ½ ° d=E_`5@H]¼L ½ \ ^ ! °? ! ?en"# ¼ )6 ½

x>cqo¦Uafnjr[|Z`%W^^%fZeZY+ ! D ¼ ! I\! H \ IJIJI ! ½ _` ¦^%WX>? ! ? D$ %'&

I ! % wZ¦XEYoY¨WXEY¡eEYo^1U1W^qYl

d= D )( ( = F I c F-H IJI IK +* F ¼ )6 hq½

UaoY¯^3fnWYGfZeZYGeÂ^%fWXEY´lYfElY«cax a3¿ ¾ º¹ / À ¿ ª ]¬c6 ¼9 ½ ^3l¤U1f ^3`% YGoWlhUa_GY¯¦^%WXiWXZY¯^%fZfZYGohZoceZ|E_GW

¼ = \Kb ½-,/. 5SR I D 0( ( 1

V R G=2 b C W \ ^ = \Kb _#¼L ½ \ ¼ )6 Aq½

¦XZcqlYz^%fZeZ|Z_GYefZcqo[Ã^3l

M = M ,/. 5SR I D T 0( ( 1

M G= M HNGc 5eR I Y IL[ H \ ^ = _3¼L ½ I ¼ )6Fn½

|ZoWXZYoGw(UafO^3[dh caoWU1f¢WlY[d^3fEcqo[ ^3lbeZYfZYeUal

F

Page 15: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

? = ? ,/. 5SR I D T 0( ( &

M G= M HNdc 5eR I Y IL[ HQ\ ^ =_ ¼L ½ I ¼ )6½

u [d[YGeZ^!U1WY`jY¨XUkqY ¼L ½ I¼L ½ x>cqo D \

\ IJIJIwZ¦^%WXM = M ,/. 5SR I n M = M ,/. 5eR I \ ^ =_ ¼L ½ I ¼ )6 q½

Ë~cafZ_YGofZ^%fZg¤_caf¢W^3f¢|Z^WjzhEocqhYo£W^3YGlw]~Y~ZolWyeZYfEcaWY¢j ¼ ½ WXZY~lhUa_Y~caxoYUa` cqoC_Gcq[dhZ`3Y+ 1Ua`3|EYe¤x>|ZfZ_W^%cqfZlcqf Q¦XZcqlY±_G`!Uall^3_Ua`aeEYo^1U1W^qYl|Eh¨WcbcqoeEYo UaoYB_GcqfnW^3f¢|Zca|Zl$UafZe¨cq|ZfZeZYGe 6» XZ^%lp^%l¦UUafUa_XlhZUa_Y1wYG¥¢|Z^3hZhYeO¦^%WXWXZY¨fZcqo[

M = M . 5 R I D 0

( ( 1 l|Zh R ? G=C¼ W ½ ?

\ ^ =E_ ¼ ½ I ¼ )6Vn½

» XZYGf)wa^%fZ_`%|Zl^%cqf ¼ ½ ¼9 ½ XZcq`3eEl)x>cqo$Ua`3` D F\\

\ IJIJI 6M­ fWXZY±caWXZYo$XU1fZe)wx>|ZfZ_GW^3cqfEl^3f ¼9 ½ U1oYfZcaWp_GcqfnW^3f¢|Zca|Zl¦^3fOgqYfEYoU1` 6 jÍWXZY¨lc1Ó_kUa`%`3YGe j aº]3 dºna À Îd ¾ ^%Wb^%lhcqll^3Z`%YzWc\hZocqY1wfZYGaYo£WXZYG`3Yllw$WXU]W .gqc c e /\hZocqhYoW^3YGl¤cax±oYGgq|Z`3Uao^WjU1oY¯lU1W^%lYGei¦XZYf3^3ll|E®d_G^3YfnW`%jXZ^3gqX 6yu frhUao£W^%_|Z`3Uaow¢^3fcqfZY¤eE^3[dYfZl^3cqfUa`3` I/Óx>|ZfZ_W^%cqfZlU1oY_GcqfnW^%f |Ecq|ZlE^3fWcUafZeWXZoYY¡eZ^3[dYfEl^3cafZl H Óx>|EfZ_GW^3cqfZlpUaoY¨_cqfnW^%f¢|Zcq|ZlGw¦XZ^%`3Y I /x>|ZfZ_W^3cafZlpUaoY¨fZcaW^3fOgqYGfZYoUa` 6BoYG_^3lY`jqw^%x/ 8t WXZYf ¼L ½ ¼ ½ UafZeOWXZYGoY¨Y^%lWlpU«_cqfElWU1f¢W JF l|Z_XWXU1W

M = M 5 R I n M = M , . 5SR I \ ^ =_ ¼9 ½ I ¼ )6T^¢½

TVcqoY¨gqYfZYGoUa`%`%jawZ^%x,_ UafZe 8t vÍWXEYfOWXZYGoY¨Y^3l£WlU´_cqfZl£WUafnW KF l|E_XVWXZU1W

M G= M N 5SR I n M = M , . 5SR I \ ^ =_ ¤¼9 ½ \ ¼ )6wq½

x>cqo¦Ua`%` ! _ ´l|Z_XWXU]W ? ! ?en 6cqoCUpZfZ^%WY~Y`%Y[dYfnWÔx>cqo[¯|E`!U1W^3cqf¨caxlY_GcqfZe´cqoeZYoC cq|EfZeUao£j¡1Ua`%|ZYhZocqE`3Y[dlwaUaly^%fzca|Zoy_UalY1w

U`.£YkU1¶|/«oYgq|Z`3Uao^Wj«cqf\WXZYolW¦eZYGo^%1U1W^%aYcaxWXZYx>|ZfZ_W^%cqfZl~^%l~oY¥¢|Z^3oYernjrU1hZhZ`%j ^%fZg oYGYflWXEYcqoY[ª V ¬Q6±» X |Elw I ¼9 ½ W|ZofElpca|EWbWc«Y¨WXZYx>|ZfZeU1[YGf¢WUa`lYWW^3fZg´x>cqobcq|EophEocqZ`%Y[dl 6µ |ZhZhcqlYVfZcÃWXU]WdWXZYeZcq[Ua^3fx ^%ldcq|ZfEeZYe 6 ^©-YGoYGf¢W`%jx>ocq[ 5@H/x>|ZfZ_GW^3cqfElwx>caoU1f¢j

-ÐWXEYoYl£Wo^%_GW^3cqf= D =@? cax¤Uix>|ZfE_GW^%cqf>= _ I ¼9 ½ ^3l¯Y`%`eEYGfZYGe)w±^3f³WXEYrlYfElY^3fnWYfZeZYGe¢jVWXZY¯Y`%`Ó¶ fEc¦f ¾ ´ ¾ ª ]¬Q6¡» XEY¯x>|ZfZ_GW^3cqf=Â YG`3cqfEgqlWc5*H]¼ ½ UafZeQ^%l_kU1`3`3YGeWXZY ¾ cax=Qcqf 6bÊ YGgnUaoeZ^3fZg«WXE^3lwWXZY[dcqlWp_G`!Uall^3_Ua` ¾ z À ¹EaÁ UallYGoWlpWXU]WWXEYoY¨Y+E^%lWlU´_cafZlWUafnW KF eEYhYfZeZ^%fZgdcqfZ`%j\cqf4Ñl|Z_XVWXU1W

M = M Ndc 5 I n M = M , 5SR I \ ^ =E_# I ¼L ½ \ ¼ )6fn½

Page 16: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

¦XZYGoY¨WXZYeZYfZ^W^3cafrcaxCWXZY¨lhU1_Yl 587 ¼ ½ ¦^WXr_caooYGlhcqfZeZ^%fZg«fZcqo[l M M NuP 5 I ^3lbgq^qYGfUafZUa`cqgqca|Zl`j\WcV¼ )6 ½ wZ|Zl^3fZg U1lp^%fnWYgaoU1W^3cqfreZca[\Ua^%f 6

ÄY¦eZYfEcaWY¦njV¼L ½ WXZYblhZUa_Ypcax^3fEZfZ^%WY`%jzeZ^©-YGoYfnW^!UaZ`%Y~x>|ZfZ_W^%cqfZlM¦^%WX«_cq[dhUa_W±l|ZhZhcqo£W^3fx¤w^ 6 Y 6 Uall|Z[d^3fEgQfZcqfÓÉYocÂ1Ua`%|ZYl´cafZ`%jcqf²lcq[dYO_cq[dhUa_W«l|ZZlYGWcax 6³Ï fs^3[dh cqo£WUafnWl|EZlhU1_Y¤^%f¨IG¼L ½ ^3lBWXEYf I ¼L ½ wn¦XZ^%_X\^%leZYfZYGerUalBWXZYp_`%cql|EoYpcaxV¼9 ½ ^%f I¼L ½6yu W~_UafY¡lXZc¦fVWXU1W

I ¼L ½ D u= _ I ¼9 ½ °)=@? R D F aI ¼ )6 ½

I ¼9 ½ W|ZofZl¨cq|EW¨Wc Y´WXZY«fU1W|EoUa`MlhUa_GY\Uallc _^3U1WYGeÂWcOZfZ^%WYdYG`3YG[YGf¢W¡lcq`3|EW^3cqfEl¤caxlY_GcqfZecqoeZYoBcq|ZfZeZUaoj¯1Ua`%|ZYhZocqZ`%Y[dly¦^%WXdcq|ZfEeUaoj_cqfEeZ^%W^3cqfZlMUa`3`cax ^%o^%_XZ`3YWCWj hY 6 Ë~cqXZYGoYGf¢W`%jawWXEY¡lhUa_GY

I ¼L ½ D u= _3 I ¼L ½ °)=@? D F ¼ )6hn½

_kU1fY^3fnWoc eZ|Z_YGerx>cqo -¤wUal¦U¯fU1W|ZoU1`)lYWW^%fZg¯¦XZYGfVcaWX ^%o^3_XE`3YGWUafZe Y|Z[UafZf¼caoÊ cqZ^3f ½ cq|ZfZeU1oji_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqfZl¤U1oY¯hZoYlYfnWkwWXEY¯x>cqo[dYogq^%aYfcqf 6 caWY¯WXU1W¤^3f I ¼L ½ WXEYlYG[^%fZcqo[ M = M , 5SR I D M = M NGc 5eR I wEcqEWUa^3fEYe\x>ocq[·¼ )6½ x>cao D wE^%lbUfZcao[ÐY¥¢|Z^%1Ua`%YfnW~WcWXEY µ cqcq`3YfZcao[ ¼ )6Fn½ ¼UafZeUafU1`3cqgqca|Zl`jx>cao I ¼L ½½6 cqo[l M M , 5SR I UafZe M M NGc UaoYoYG`!U1WYeiWcYUa_XcaWXEYo¤WXEocq|ZgaXWXZY¯x>cq`%`3c¦^3fZg ] À ¾ ¿ À ¹ZaÁ °¤^%x ^3lcq|ZfEeZYe)w)WXZYoYY^%lWlpU«_cqfElWU1f¢W JF eZYGh YGfZeZ^%fZg«cqfEÒl|Z_XWXU]W

M = MONGc 5SR I n M = M Ndc 5eR I \ ^ =_ I ¼9 ½ I ¼ )6An½

u [d[YGeZ^!U1WY`jqwMU1f^3fZYG¥¢|Ua`3^WjÂUafUa`%cqgqcq|ElzWc³¼ )6An½ XZcq`3eEl¯UagnU1^3f¦XEYf²_cqfEl^3eEYo^%fZgQU1WzWXZY\`3YGxWXUafEeVl^3eZY M = M , 5SR I ^3fZl£WYkU1eVcax M = M NGc 5SR I 6u frcq|ZfEeUaoj«1Ua`%|ZYhZocqZ`%Y[dlx>|ZfE_GW^%cqfZlXZUaYWc YUall^3gqfZYGeOUal~eZU1WUcaYohU1oWl~cax$eZcq[Ua^3f

cq|ZfZeU1o^3YGl 6B» X¢|ZlGw ^Wb[\U1¶aYl¦lYfZlYzWc«^%f¢Woc eZ|Z_GY¤WXZY¨lhZUa_Y

IL[ H ¼ ½ D b ° ¼cqo ½ °2=_# I ¼L ½ °)= ? D b \ ¼ )6 Fn½

Y`3cafZgq^3fEgpWc¤U[dcqoYgqYGfZYoUa`xU1[^%`%j¤c1x µ cqcq`3Y¨lhU1_Yl ¼9 ½ x>cqo_EpwZ¦XZ^%_X¯_kUaf YeZYGfEYenj cq|Eo^3YGopWoUafElx>cqo[ ª ]¬ w-_GcqfZl^%lWYfnW`jV¦^WXieZYfZ^W^3caf³¼ :6 ½ ¦XZYf D _ 6 IL[ H ¼ ½ ^%lUaf ^%`3Yo£WblhU1_Yaw(YGfZeZc~YGe¦^%WXrWXZY¨fZcqo[M b M , 9c 5 I D ^3fEx

"! #"$&%

M = M , 5SR I \ ^ b _ IL[ H ¼ ½ I ¼ )6 ½

ÄÇXEYficqo¶¢^3fEgͦ^%WXVlhU1_Yl ¼L ½ XUk ^3fZgÍoYkUa`CcqoeEYo' w)U1fi|ZlYx>|Z`M^%fZY¥¢|Ua`%^%WjO^%lgq^qYf¢jWXEYx>cq`%`3c¦^3fZg À ¾ ¸]a/ À > ¾ °M^%x8Ç^%lcq|ZfEeZYeOUafEe I

\ HbUaoYoYUa` f¢|Z[ YGoll|Z_XÍWXU]W

I JHkwZWXZYfOWXEYoY¨Y+E^%lWlU«_cafZlWUafnW JF l|Z_XVWXU1W

Page 17: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

M = M , 5SR I n M = M I , 5SR I M = M , c 5eR I \ ^ b _ c ¼9 ½ ¼ )6 q½

¦XZYGoY D ¼ a½ I v HkwZx>cqo¦Uafnj F n n ,6

|Zo£WXZYGorgqYfEYoU1`3^3ÉU1W^%cqfZld_kUafÇYieZcqfEY 6 C^3ol£Wkw¦l^%[^%`!Uao`%jWc³eZYGZfZ^%W^3cqf ¼ )6 ½ w Î À ¾ aÁ l]j aº]3 V¿¸E ¿i<;i ¾ ¾ weZYGfZcaWYevnj 7 ¼9 ½ w_UaftY^3fnWoceZ|E_Yem^3fs_cqfEfZY_W^3cafm¦^%WXlhZUa_YGl587 ¼L ½6 7 ¼L ½ UaoYUafZUa_XlhUa_YGly^%f¡¦XZ^%_XYG`3Y[dYfnWlCU1oY 5Z7/x>|ZfZ_W^3cafZl)¦XZcqlY~eZYGo^%1U]W^qYGlp|EhWcdcaoeZYGo UaoYB587/x>|ZfZ_GW^3cqfElwlc´WXU1W ¼L ½ D H ¼L ½6µ W^3`%`$_cqfZl^3eZYGo^%fZgWXZY¯_kU1lY 1 D w¦XZYGfQeZ^%© YoYfnW^3Ua`Ô[c eZY`%l^%fnqcq`qYfEcaW¤l_kUa`3UaoE|EW¤qYG_GWcqo

x>|ZfZ_W^%cqfZl¡XUk^%fZg`Ci_Gcq[hcqfZYGfnWlwClhU1_Yl ¼L ½ cqo ¼L K ½ _kUafYdfU1W|EoUa`%`%jQ^%f¢Woc1eZ|Z_GYevWceZYGl_o^3YiU oYGgq|Z`3Uao^Wjx>cqodYkUa_Xv_Gcq[dh cqfEYfnW 6 ~Yl^3eZYGlwx>cqo«qYG_GWcqoÍeZ^©-YGoYfnW^!Ua`Y¥¢|U]W^3cafZl|Zl^%fZgOeZ^%aYogqYfZ_GY«cax~_G|Zo`ycqh YGoU1WcqolGwlhU1_Yl¡`3^%¶aY ¼LC b O ½ wcqo ³¼ = O ½ _kUafÂY|ZlYe)woY¥¢|Z^3o^3fZg«U 5@HÓoYga|Z`!Uao^%WjdcqfrWXEYeZ^%aYogaYfZ_GY¡cao~WXZY_G|Zo`c1xÔWXZY¤x>|ZfZ_W^%cqfZlwEoYlh YG_GW^%qYG`%j 6u f\WXZYx>oU1[Y~cqo¶«cax$Y`%Y_GWocq[UagqfEYGW^%_¦[c eZY`%lw¢x>cqo~^%fZlWUafZ_GYawWXZY`3UalWW~czW|Zofrcq|EW~WcY¤l|E^%WUaZ`%YÍlYWW^3fZgqlzx>cqoWXEYÍfZ^%WYrY`%Y[dYfnW´lca`3|EW^3cqfc1xhEocqZ`%Y[dleZYfZYGemnjsTUY`%`l´Y¥¢|U1W^3cqfEl¦XZYGfiU¯Y`%erx>cqo[¯|E`!U1W^3cqfÍ^%lb|ZlYGe³¼>lYYË~XUahWYo Vn½6

|Zo£WXZYGo[dcqoY1w1x>|ZfE_GW^%cqfUa` lhZUa_YGlMx>cqoÔW^3[dYeEYhYfZeZYGfnWBx>|ZfZ_GW^3cqfElM_cq|E`3eY^%f¢Woc eZ|Z_GYe´UalyfU1W|ZoUa`(lYGWW^%fZgqlx>caofE^%WYpY`%Y[dYfnW[YWXZc eZl~lcq`% ^%fZgz^%fZ^%W^!Ua`E cq|EfZeUao£j´aU1`3|ZYphZocaZ`3YG[l 6BÌ YGW¨ª F

\ ¬

YzWXEYW^%[Y¡^3fnWYGo1Ua`CUafZei`%YGW \¼L ½ eZYfZc1WY´Udl|Z^WUaZ`%Y U1fUa_XQcqo ^%`3YoWlhZUa_Y¯c1xBx>|ZfZ_GW^3cqfEleZYfZYeOU1`3[dcqlWYGaYo£j ¦XEYoY¨cqfw UafZeÍl|E®d_^%YfnW`j\oYgq|Z`3Uao¼^%fÍU¡YkU1¶lYfZlY ½6» XZYGf)wE^W~_UafÍY_caf¢aYfZ^%YfnW¤Wc^%f¢Woc eZ|Z_GYzlhUa_YGl¤`3^%¶aY ¼ª F \ ¬ \¼9 ½½ woYG¥¢|Z^3o^3fZgd_cqfnW^3f¢|Z^%WjOcafV1Uao^3UaZ`%Y+wcao.£YkUa¶1Yo'/ilhU1_Yl¡`3^%¶aY´WXEY \\ ¸ À À : º¿Îa¹(´¿¸E 5@H]¼ F \ d¼L ½½ UafZeWXEY \ h¸ À À j aº]3 ¯¿¸E IG¼ F \ d¼L ½½ wUafZeiUafUa`%cqgqcq|Zl`%j ¼ F \ ¼L ½½6» XZYlhUa_GYͼ9 ½_kU1fVYawZx>cqob^%fZlWUafZ_GYaw-5@H]¼L ½ cqo I ¼L ½6u fª w V,h]¬ U«eZYGWUa^3`%YeVUafUa`jl^3l¦cqf µ cqcq`3YrlhU1_YlUafZeWXZYG^3o¦gqYfEYoU1`3^3ÉU1W^%cqfZlb^%lhZoYlYfnWYGe)w

WcagqYGWXZYo\¦^WX U1fvY WYGfZeZYGeÒl|ZoaYGj c1x¨[\U1WXZY[U1W^3_kU1`WcqhZ^%_loY`3U1WYGevWchZUaoW^!Ua`¦eZ^©-YGoYfnW^!Ua`Y¥¢|U]W^3cafZl 6BÏ gaYfZYGoUa`)caYo ^%YGÑcaxÔlYGaYoUa`[YWXZc eZl~x>caoWXEYf |E[YGo^3_Ua`-lcq`3|W^3caf\caxÔeZ^©-YGoYfnW^!Ua`hZocqZ`3YG[lC_kUaf«Y~x>cq|ZfEed^%fOª V ¬Q6 y^%fZ^%WY~Y`%Y[dYfnWB[dYGWXZceElMcqf«U¤`!U1ogqY_`!U1llBcax(hZocqZ`%Y[dlBUaoY~hZoY+lYGfnWYe^3fª VF]¬Q6Ï lp_GcqfZ_GYofElpfE^%WY¨YG`3Y[dYfnWp[dYGWXEceZlx>caopYG`3`%^3hEW^3_hEocqZ`%Y[dlwZ_GcqfZl^3eZYGoYe^3fOWXEYhZoYlYGfnW¤~cao¶(wU_G`!Uall^%_kUa`$oYx>YoYfZ_GY´^3lª ¬c6pu fihUao£W^%_|Z`3UaowZfE^%WYzY`%Y[dYfnW[dc eZY`%`3^3fEg«x>c _|El^3fEgcqfdY`%Y_GWocq[UagqfEYGW^%_bhZocaZ`3YG[lB^%lhEoYlYfnWYGeÍ^3fVª A w ^ w ^8w¬ UafEe)wnx>ocq[ U¨o^%gqcqocq|ZlB[U1WXZYG[\U]W^3_Ua`hcq^3fnW¦caxÔ ^3YG¨w^%fª V^]¬c6

V

Page 18: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

Sj N QN R]rBS rP BSjo ST RML PdBST % $'& ¤ ã-4 +!/0+-» XZY¡x>|ZfZeU1[YGf¢WUa`ÔY¥¢|U1W^3cqfZleZYl_o^3Z^%fZg\YG`3Y_Wocq[\U1gqfZYGW^3_¨hZXZYGfZcq[dYfUUaoY¡WXZY¡~YG`3` ¶¢fZc¦f

kÅ~ ¿¯¹Za/ À ¿ 6 cqobUa`%`)lhU1_Y¡h cq^%fnWlwE^3frWXZY¨gqYGfZYoUa`W^%[Y¤eEYhYfZeZYGfnW¤_kU1lYWXZYjO_kUafY¦o^WWYfUal

v _ D F ¼ V$6½

D \ ¼ V$6 q½

_kU1`3`3YGe ¾ nn h q À¾ ¿ UafZe kÅ~ h ¸ ¾ ¿¤ oYGlhY_W^%aY`jqwZWcagqYGWXZYob¦^%WX

D ¼ V$6gVn½ _ D F

\¼ V$6i^¢½

_kU1`3`3YGe a¹n¿¿ ¿ UafZe dÎ À / a¹¢¿¿ ¿ w ¦XEYoY ^3lpWXZY¯YG`3YG_GWo^3_¡Y`%ei^3fnWYGfZl^Wjqw ^%lWXEYY`%Y_Wo^%_ |OeZYGfZl^Wjqw ·^3lbWXEY¡[UagqfEYGW^%_¤Y`%eV^%fnWYfEl^%Wjaw _ ^%l¦WXZY¡[\UagafZYGW^3_ | eZYfZl^%Wjaw ^%lWXEYY`%Y_GWo^%_~_|EooYGfnW±eZYfZl^%Wjaw¢UafZe ^3lÔWXZYYG`3YG_GWo^3__XUaogaY~qcq`%|Z[dY~eZYGfZl^Wj 6Mu f¯WXZY^3fnWYofZU1W^%cqfUa`lj l£WY[ µu WXZY¡x>cq`3`%c¦^3fZgd[YUal|EoY|EfZ^%Wl¤UaoY|ZlYe)°ª ¬ D qca`%Wl§1[dYGWYGowyª ¬ D _cq|Z`%cq[¯Zl§1[dYGWYGo H wª ¬ D U1[hYoYl§][YWYoGw)ª _¬ D YYol§1[dYGWYo H w-ª ¬ D U1[hYoYl§][YWYo H UafZeQª ¬ D _cq|Z`%cq[¯Zl§1[dYGWYGo 6TVU] ~YG`3`l¦Y¥¢|U1W^3cqfElp_UafVUa`3lc´ Y¦o^WWYf^3fr^3fnWYgqoUa`-x>cqo[VwU1l

C D V! _ C#" D F ¼ V$6 wa½ C D V !%$ v '& C#" D F ¼ V$6 fq½

R C#" D V R C ¼ V$6 ½ R _ C#" D F ¼ V$6 hq½

x>cqodUafnj²cqhYfsl|Zo£xUa_Y(" *) ¦^%WXmcq|ZfEeUaoj_|Zo£qY+" D ÔwUafEemx>cqo«Uafnj²cqhYfmeZcq[Ua^3f ,) XUk ^3fZgV cq|EfZeUao£jl|ZoxU1_Y- 6 ¥¢|U]W^3cafZlr¼ V$6 wa½ U1fZeǼ V)6 fn½ XUkqY\ YGYfcqWUa^%fZYe¢j^3fnWYgqoU1W^%cqfrcqYo-"ÒcaxÔWXZY¡_|Zo`Y¥¢|U1W^3cqfEl¼ V$6½ UafZe¼ V$6 q½ |Zl^3fZg µ Wca¶aY l¦WXZYGcqoYG[VwZ¦XZ^%`3Yd¼ V$6 ½UafZe¼ V)6 hn½ x>cq`%`3cÒx>ocq[ WXZY¨eZ^%aYogqYfZ_GYYG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfZl¼ V$6gVn½ UafZe¼ V$6i^¢½ njOqcq`%|Z[dY^3fnWYGgqoU1W^3cqfOcqYGo¤w)U1hZhZ`%j ^%fZgWXZYeZ^qYGogqYGfZ_YWXZYcaoY[ 6pu f²¼ V$6 ½ WXZYz_cqfnWo^3Z|W^3caf/. D10 R C oYhZoYlYfnWlWXEYWc1WUa`_XUaogqYlWcqoYGer^3f, 6±u fÍWXEYx>cq`3`%c¦^3fZg¨~YeEYkUa`-¦^WXOTVU] ~YG`3`lYG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfZlb^3fWXZYG^3o~eE^%© Yo£YfnW^!Ua`-x>cao[ 6

T^

Page 19: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

YfEYoU1`3`%jawÔTU] Y`3`l¡Y¥¢|U]W^3cafZlU1oY«_cqfEl^3eEYoYGeWcqgqYGWXZYo¦^WXWXZY«x>|ZfZeU1[YGf¢WUa`BoYG`!U1W^3cqf¼ ¹Ea/ À <;¯ À À ¹ E½

v D F\

¼ V$6 Aq½

¦XZ^%_XrlhY_^YlWXZY¤_GcqfZlYGo1U1W^3cqfÍc1x$_XUaogaY 6­ fZ`%j«WXEoYYcaxWXZYZqYYG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfZl¨¼ V$6 ½ ¼ V$6i^¢½ U1fZe¼ V)6 An½ UaoY¯^%fZeZYGh YGfZeZYfnW 6 YfZYGoUa`%`%jOWXEYGjQU1oY´Uall|Z[dYeQWcr Y (UaoUaeUkjn pYfZo£j l`!Uk¨w$TVU] ~YG`3`Ï [dhYoY l`3Uk U1fZeQWXZY´YG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfQcax_cqfnW^3f¢|Z^%Wjawl^%fZ_Y ¨Ua|Zll )l`3U caWXQ^%fiWXZY´YG`3YG_GWo^3_´U1fZe^3frWXZY¨[\UagafZYGW^3_x>cqo[ _UafVY¨eZYo^%aYeOx>ocq[ WXZY[ 6

TVU] ~YG`3`l¤YG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfZlY_ca[YUÍeZYGfE^%WYlj lWY[·cax±YG¥¢|U1W^%cqfZl¦XEYf À ¿¹a ¾ a/ À ¿eZYGl_o^3Z^%fZgWXZY~[Ua_Gocql_cqhZ^%_hEocqhYo£W^3YGlCc1xZWXZY[\U]WYo^!Ua`%l$UaoY_cafZl^%eZYoYe 6 cqoCUl^3[dhZ`3Y±[dYeZ^%|Z[WXEYGjOUaoY D4 v ¼ V$6Fn½

D ¼ V$6½_ D \ ¼ V$6 q½

¦XZYGoY ^%lWXEYi^3[dh calYemlcq|Eo_Y_|ZooYfnWreEYfZl^%Wjqw ^%ldWXZYiY`%Y_Wo^%__GcqfZeZ|Z_W^^Wjqw ^%lWXEYY`%Y_Wo^%_¨h YGo[d^%WW^% ^%WjÍUafZe ^3l¦WXEYz[UagqfZYW^%_¡hYo[YUaZ^%`3^%Wj\caxyWXZY[dYeE^3|Z[ 6~» XZYz_cqfElW^W|EW^%aYhUaoUa[dYGWYGol

\ UafZe UaoY\WYfZlcqol¯x>cao¯UafZ^%lcaWocqhE^3_\[dYeE^!UEwCl_kU1`!Uaolx>cqo^%lcaWocqhE^3_d[YGeZ^!UiU1fZe

WXEYGjUaoY«x>|ZfZ_W^%cqfZlc1xblhU1_Yx>caoz^%fZXZcq[dcqgqYGfZYcq|El¡[dYeE^!U 6 ~YGl^%eZYlGwyx>cqo¨`3cqlljÂ[dYeZ^3UOWXZYGjUaoY_ca[hZ`%Y¢Ó1Ua`%|ZYe 6

YGh YGfZeZ^%fZg´cqfÍWXEY¤hZocah YGoW^%Ylc1xÔWXZY¤_GcqfZl^%eZYoYeO[U1WYGo^!U1`/wnWXZYh YGo[dYkUaZ^%`3^Wj ^3fÍYG¥ |ZU1W^%cqf¼ V)6 a½ _kUafUa`3lcdY¨x>|ZfZ_GW^3cqfOcax 6u xMfZc1Wkw^ 6 Y 6M_ U1fZe UaoY¨`3^3fEYkUao`%joY`3U1WYGe)wZWXEYz[U1WYGo^3Ua`-^%l_kU1`3`3YGe Á À ¾6 (caobh YGo[UafZYfnWp[UagqfZYWlbY¥¢|U]W^3caf¼ V$6 q½ Uall|Z[dYl¦WXZY¨[dceE^%YGeÍx>cqo[

_ D ¼ ½\

¼ V$6Vn½

¦XZYGoY C^%lBWXZY ¾ a ´ À À ¿ ¼^ 6 Y 6 WXZY¦oYGqYGolY¤[\U1gqfZYGW^3_YG`3ed^3fnWYGfZl^Wj´WXU]WXZUalWcY¤UahZhE`3^3YGeWc¯oYGeZ|Z_Y[\UagafZYGW^3ÉkU]W^3caf«Wc¯ÉYGoc ½6Bu fÍ[dcqlW~_kUalYlwE^%W^3lUall|Z[YGeÍWXU]WWXZY¤oYG`!U1W^3cqfYGWYYf _ UafZe ^%l¤`3^%fZYkUaoYGaYfx>cqoUÍhYo[UafZYGfnW¨[\UagafZYGW 6 YfEYoU1`3`%jaw-eZYfZ^W^3cafZl D UafZe D U1oY|ZlYe)wq¦^WX¯oYGx>YGoYfE_YWcWXZY_GcqooYlh cqfEeZ^3fZghYo[YUaZ^%`3^%Wj D ^ F t ¼XEYfZo£jZ§][YWYo ½ UafZeÂh YGo[d^%WW^% ^%Wj D ut ¼ H ½ F t ¼ V,fÔ½t ¼>xUaoUae(§1[dYGWYoGw)¦XZYoY ^3lWXZYlh YGYec1x`3^%gqXnW ½ ^%fx>oYYdlhU1_Y 6 U1fZe UaoYeE^3[dYfZl^3cqfZ`%Yll¤aU1`3|ZYGlUallc _^3U1WYGeÂWcVWXEY[U1WYGo^!U1`/w _kUa`%`3Ye ¾ aab¸ ¾ ´ UafZe ¾ aab¸ ¾ \nºÁ 6

-&:L9"$+$(R"=3&S9jT"$+v,".9&ÄÇXEYfWXZY´YG`3e¥¢|UafnW^W^3YGl¨eZcOfZcaW1Uaoj¦^%WXQW^3[dYaw)YG`3Y_Wo^3_«UafZe[UagqfZYW^%_´hZocqhYo£W^%YleZY+

_ca|ZhZ`3Y¤x>ocq[ÃYUa_XVc1WXZYGolpUafZeTU] Y`3`l¦YG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfZl¦oYGeZ|Z_Y¨Wc´Wc^%fZeZYGh YGfZeZYfnWlj lWY[dl°

w

Page 20: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

D F ¼ V$6T^¢½ D \

^3frWXZY¨Y`3YG_GWocql£WU1W^3__kU1lYaw(U1fZe D ¼ V$6wq½ _ D F

\^3frWXZY¨[\UagafZYGWcqlWU1W^%_¤_kUalY 6±» XZY¡lWU1W^%_Y¥¢|U1W^3cqfOcaxC_cqfnW^3f¢|Z^%Wj

D F ¼ V$6fn½^3l~UafÍ^%[[dYeZ^3U1WY¦_GcqfZlYG¥¢|ZYfZ_GY¨caxWXZYol£WboYG`!U1W^3cqf^3fQ¼ V$6wq½6yu fÍWXZY¤hEoYlYfnWbcqo¶dlcq[dY¤[Uag1fZYWcql£WU1W^3_hZocqZ`3YG[lbeEYo^qYGeVx>oca[ ¼ V)6 wa½ ¦^3`3` Y¨l£W|ZeZ^%Ye 6

'".9T 9"$+s,"=9&u fWXZY¨W^%[YeZYhYfZeEYfnW_kU1lYaw(^xCWXZY¡W^3[dY¤1Uao^3U1W^%cqfr^3l¦l|®_G^3YGf¢W`%jOl`3c Y_UafVfEYgq`%Y_GWpWXEY

a3¿¸ \ À ¹ ¾+¾ À t ¡^3fv¼ V$6 q½6r» XZ^3lzX¢j hcaWXEYl^%l`%YkUaeZl¨WcWXZYlc1Ó_kUa`%`3YGe ¹E]¿ h ¿Óa/¸n¸ ¾ GÅqda/ À.6 ^%© YoYfnW`j¯x>oca[ WXEYl£WU1W^3_b_kU1lYaw fZYqYo£WXZYG`3YGllwWXZYb1Uao^3U1W^%cqf´cax WXZY¦[UagqfZYW^3_|³eZYfZl^%Wj _ ^3l´fZc1W«fZYgq`%^3gq^%Z`3YUafZe (UaoU1eUkj¢ YGfZoj ldYG¥¢|U1W^%cqfѼ V$6½ oY[Ua^3fZl|ZfZ_XUafEgqYeUalz^3fWXZYgqYfZYGoUa`±W^%[Y+eZYGh YGfZeZYGf¢Wz_kU1lY 6Ï fZUa`3cqgacq|Zl`jiWclWU]W^3_«l^%W|ZU1W^%cqfZlwCY¥¢|U1W^3cqfv¼ V$6fn½XZcq`%eZl 6» XEY´¥ |ZUal^ lWU1W^%_¯Uall|Z[dhEW^3cqfQ^%l1Ua`3^%ex>cqohZocqE`3Y[dl^%fi¦XZ^3_Xix>oY¥¢|ZYGfZ_^%Yl¡UaoY`3c cqow[dcqoYhZoY_G^3lYG`%jawZ¦XZYfWXZY¡l^%ÉY¨caxÔWXZY¡lWo|Z_W|ZoYz^%lbl[Ua`3`)_Gcq[dhUaoYGe¦^WXrWXEY¡YG`3YG_GWocq[UagqfZYW^3_~UaY`%YfZgaWXiUallc _^3U1WYGeOWcdWXZY¨XZ^3gaXZYl£Wbx>oY¥¢|ZYGfZ_Gj_Gcq[hcqfZYGfnWc __G|Zoo^3fZg´^%frWXZY¨hZocqZ`3YG[ 6

% $ # +*2 + ¥2/#a* :+_0+-

TU] Y`3`l±YG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfZlMx>cqo[Ulj lWY[ caxhU1oW^3Ua`EeE^%© YoYGfnW^!U1`EY¥¢|U]W^3cafZlM¦^%WXd[Uafnj¯lcq`3|W^3cafZl 6u frcqoeZYoWcfEeÍWXZYU1_GW|ZUa` lcq`3|W^3caf\caxWXZY¤hZocqZ`3YG[ |ZfZeZYGo_cqfEl^3eEYoU]W^3caf)w YXUkqYWc´lhY_G^%xjcq|ZfZeU1oj¨_cafZeZ^%W^3cqfEl$Uallc_G^!U1WYe¨Wc¦WXZYlhU1_Y~eEcq[\U1^3f)wkWcqgqYGWXZYo$¦^%WXz^%fZ^%W^!Ua`]1Ua`3|ZYGl$^3f¨WXZYBW^%[YeZYGh YGfZeZYfnWb_UalY 6Bu frUaeZeE^%W^%cqf)wn^%f¢WYo£xUa_Yp_cqfEeZ^%W^3cqfZl±YGWYYGfr[\U1WYo^!Ua`%lBXUkqYWcY_GcqfZl^3eZYGoYe-weZYGl_o^3Z^%fZgWXZYWoUafZl[^%ll^%cqfÍcaxZY`3eEl~x>ocq[ cqfEY¤[\U]WYo^!Ua`WcWXZYcaWXZYGo 6 ^%aYfÍWc´_cqfnW^%gq|Zcq|El[dYeZ^3U ¦UafZew_cqooYlh cafZeZ^3fEgOWcrWXZY´eZ^%l>Æcq^%fnWeZcq[Ua^3fEl % UafZeswÔl|Z_XWXU1WX- % - D % D wWXZYWoUafZl[^%ll^%cqfr_cafZeZ^%W^3cqfEl¦U1W % _kU1fVY¨YhZoYGllYeQUal

¼ % ½ D F ¼ V$6 ½ ¼ % ½ D ¼ V$6hn½ ¼ % ½ D ¼ V$6An½ ¼ _ % _ ½ D F

\¼ V$6 Fn½

¦XZYGoY ^3l±WXZY¤|EfZ^%WqYG_GWcaofZcqo[\Ua`Wc % phcq^%f¢W^3fZg¨x>oca[ ¦^3fnWc % wUafZeÍWXZY¥¢|UafnW^%W^%Yl UafZe UaoY«WXZYdl|Zo£xUa_Yd_XUaogqYeEYfZl^%WjUafZeWXZYdl|EoxUa_GY\Y`%Y_Wo^%_«_|ZooYfnWzeZYfEl^%WjawyoYlhY_+W^qYG`%j 6r» XEYolWWc_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqfZl¡gq^%aY^%fEx>cqo[U1W^3cqfUacq|EW¨WXZY / À Î À a _cq[dh cafZYfnWzcaxWXEY

f

Page 21: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

YG`3eZl UafZe°«WXEY\x>cqo[dYoz^3lz_cqfnW^%f¢|Zcq|ZlGw±WXZYÍ`3U1WWYo^%l¯eZ^%l_caf¢W^3f¢|Zcq|El¯^%x¦l|ZoxUa_GYÍ_|EooYGfnWlY^%lW 6«» XZY«`3UalWWcV_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqfZleZYGl_o^3Y´WXZY À ¾ da _Gcq[dh cqfEYfnW¨cax UafZe _ w$oYGlhY_GW^%aY`%jeZ^%l_caf¢W^3f¢|Zcq|Elp^xÔl|Zo£xUa_Y¡_XUaogqYlpY^3l£Wkw(UafEe_GcqfnW^%f |Ecq|Zl 6

­ xMWXZYlYzx>cq|Eop_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqfZl¦cqfZ`jrW~c\UaoY¡^3fZeEYhYfZeZYGfnWkw x>caop^%fZlWUafZ_GYͼ V$6 ½ UafZe³¼ V$6hn½6~» XZY_cafZeZ^%W^3cqf¼ V)6 ½ x>cao±WXZY¦WUafZgaYfnW^3Ua`(_cq[dh cafZYfnWcax ^3l±Y¥¢|Z^aU1`3YfnWWc¨WXZY_cqfEeZ^%W^3cqfV¼ V)6 Fq½ x>caoWXEY¤fZcqo[\Ua`_ca[hcqfZYGf¢W~cax _ w¦XE^3`3YpWXZY_cqfZeE^%W^%cqfQ¼ V$6hn½ x>caoWXEYWUafEgqYfnW^3Ua`_cq[dh cafZYfnWc1x _caooYGlhcqfZeZlpWci¼ V$6An½ x>cqobWXZYzfZcqo[\Ua`_Gcq[dh cqfEYfnWc1x 6bu fVWXEY¥¢|Ual^l£WU1W^3_¡UahZhEock^3[U1W^%cqf)w¦XZYGoY 4D F wUa`%lc´WXEY¡_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqf

¼ % ½ D F ¼ V$6 ½

XUalzWcQYÍ_cqfEl^3eEYoYGe)w±eZYl_o^3Z^%fZgiWXZY\_cqfnW^%f¢|Z^%Wjcax¦WXZY\fZcqo[Ua`_cq[dhcqfZYfnW´c1xbWXZYr_G|ZooYfnWeZYGfZl^WjU1WbWXZY¨^%f¢WYo£xUa_Y % 6µ cq[dYlhY_G^!Ua`_UalYGl_UafVY¨_cqfEl^3eEYoYGe 6 jL&8b ".,&u/&SXY&8&:JXYR-+9T9T-&:9T9t(R&:"u fQWXZ^3l_UalY´fZcOl|ZoxUa_GY«_|ZooYfnWlzU1fZefZcrx>oYY´l|ZoxU1_Y´_XUaogqYl¨Y+E^%lW¡U1WWXZY´^3fnWYoxU1_Yaw$U1fZe

_cafZeZ^%W^3cqfElb YG_cq[dYXZcq[dcqgqYGfZYcq|El° ¼ % ½ D F ¼ V$6 q½ ¼ % ½ D F ¼ V$6 Vn½ ¼ % ½ D F ¼ V$6 ^¢½ ¼ _ % _ ½ D F

\¼ V$6 ,wq½

eZYGl_o^3Z^%fZg«_cqfnW^3f¢|Z^%WjrU1W % x>cqo¦Ua`%`-WXEY¡_Gcq[dh cqfEYfnWl*w *w UafZe 6 jL&8b ".,&u/&SXY&8&:K"*&:-+&:2+v". " <&8b &:v,C» XEYU1 cqYQ_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqfZlÍ_UafÇ YQoYeZ|Z_GYeÇWcsUlhY_G^!Ua`_kUalY¦XEYfÇcqfZYQcax¡WXEYiW~c²[dYeZ^3U

UahZhEock^3[U1WYGl~UhYo£x>Y_W_cafZeZ|Z_WcqoGwE^ 6 Y 6 XZUal~_GcqfZeZ|Z_W^^Wj 6±µ ^%fZ_Y^3fWXZYW^3[dY/aU1oj ^3fZg_kU1lYOUQh YGox>YG_GW«_cafZeZ|Z_Wcqo´_UafZfZcaW¯l|Zl£WUa^%fmU1f¢jY`%e³^3f³^Wl À ¾ / ¾ wBYG¥¢|U1W^%cqfZl¼ V$6 ½ +¼ V$6 Fn½Y_ca[Y

D F ¼ V$6 fn½ D ¼ V$6 ½ D ¼ V$6 hn½ _ D F

\¼ V$6 An½

¦XZYGoY w Âw UafZe _ UaoYdWXZY´Y`%eZl¡Y WYGo^3cao¨WcWXZY«_cqfEeZ|Z_GWcqozUafZe ^%lWXZY«fZcqo[\U1`B|ZfZ^%WqYG_GWcqohcq^%f¢W^3fZg¯U~Ukjrx>ocq[ WXZY¨_cafZeZ|Z_Wcqo 6

Page 22: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

_ '"=`K,eL9^%aYfUcq|ZfEeZYe[\U1WYo^!Ua`MeEcq[\U1^3f ¤wÔ_cqfZeE^%W^%cqfZl¨U1W¨WXZYcq|ZfEeUaoj D - XUkaYWcY

[dceZYG`3`%Ye¡_cqfZl^3eZYGo^%fZgWXU1WÔ¦XU1WM^%lC[U1WXZY[U1W^%_kUa`%`%jU,.cq|ZfZeZUaoj|/^%lyfZc1WXZ^%fZgE|EWBUaf^3fnWYGoxUa_GY¦^%WX\U1f Åq ¾+À a [dYeZ^%|Z[ ¦XZcalYpY`3YG_GWocq[UagqfZYW^%_blWU]W|Zl±^3lUa`%oYUaeEj´¶¢fZc¦f 6B» XZ^%l±[YUafZlBWXU]WYG`3eZlÍcao\WXZYG^3ofZcqo[Ua`pcqoWUafZgqYGfnW^!U1`_ca[hcqfZYGf¢WlrUaoYigq^%aYf eU]WUcqftWXZYQlYqYGoUa`¤hZUaoWlÍcax 6 cq|ZfZeU1oj³eU]WUiXUkqY1wc1x_Gcq|ZolYaw±WcQYOUall^3gafZYe²^3f²Ui_GcqfZl^3lWYfnW«UkjlcQWXU]W¯WXZYj²UaoY_ca[hU]W^3E`3YO¦^%WX YUa_XÇcaWXEYo 6 Ï _XEcq^3_GYawp_cqXZYGoYGf¢W`%jm¦^%WX ¼ V$6 ½ ¼ V)6 Fq½ wb^3ldWc²Uall|Z[dYiWXEYx>cq`%`3c¦^3fZg¥ |ZUafnW^%W^3YGl¦Ual¦¶ fEc¦f-°

cqo _ cqf I ¼ V$6gV,Fn½ cqo cqf ZH \ ¼ V$6gV ½

¦XZYGoY I tUafZe 8H sUaoY´l|Z_XÂWXU1W I 8H D Bw)Y 6 g 6 ¢jgq^% ^%fZgÍY¥¢|U]W^3caft¼ V$6 fn½ cao¼ V)6 Aq½ caf I wUafZe¼ V$6 ½ cqo¼ V$6 hn½ cqf 8H 6yu f\_kU1lYpcax)|Zf¢cq|ZfZeEYeÍeZca[\Ua^%fZlw¢Ux>cqo[\Ua`(U1hZhZocqUa_Xcq|Z`3eV Y¡Wc_cqfZl^3eZYGo`%^3[d^%Wb_GcqfZeZ^W^3cafZlpU1W^%fEfZ^WY¡eZ^3l£WUafE_YlGw-fZYqYGoWXEY`3YGllU1f¢jV[dceZYG`3`%^3fZgx>cao_ca[hZ|WU1W^3cqfU1`ÔhE|ZohcqlYGld¼Y 6 g 6 fE^%WYzY`%Y[dYfnW[dYGWXEceZl ½ oYG¥¢|Z^3oYl¤fZYG_YGllU1o^3`jQUafU1hZhZock^3[U]W^%cqfc1xBWXZY¯^%fEfZ^WYzgqYcq[dYGWojO¦^%WXQUfE^%WYcqfZYaw nj^%f¢Woc eZ|Z_W^3caficaxB_W^%W^3cq|Elcq|ZfZeZUao^%Yl¤U]W.l|E®d_^3YGfnW`%j|/dZ^3g´eE^3lWUafZ_GYl 6% $ % *2+ ¥N$26* /00-

fnW^3`fZc¨wBY`3YG_GWocq[UagqfZYW^%_YG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfZlXZUaYr YGYf³_GcqfZl^%eZYoYe²^3fÂWXZYx>cqo[caxbolW´caoeZYGoeZ^©-YGoYfnW^!Ua`bYG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfZl«^3fnqca`% ^3fZgWXEYaY_GWcqol w Âw U1fZe _6 ÄÇXZYftUafmYG`3YG_GWocq[UagqfZYW^3_hZocqZ`3YG[ ^%l¤eZYl_o^3Ye¢jWXZYGlY´qYG_GWcao¨ZY`3eElw$^%W^%l¤lU1^3eQWXU]W¨U B;k ¾ ´¹a/ À ^%l|ZlYGe 6´u fYG`3etx>cqo[¯|Z`3U1W^%cqfZlwWXZYi_GcqfZl£W^%W|EW^qYioY`3U1W^%cqfZl¼ V$6Fn½ ¼ V)6 Vq½ Ua`%`3cÃWcYhZoYllOYG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfZlÍ^%fWYGo[dl¦caxycafZ`%jW~c«Y`%eO¥ |ZUafnW^%W^3YGlwY 6 g 6 UafZe _ wZcqo UafZe 6

Ï eZ^%© YoYfnW¡UahZhZocnUa_X_kU1fQ Y¯Wcr_cqfnqYGoWzU\olWcqoeZYoeE^%© YoYGfnW^!U1`ChZocqZ`%Y[ ^3fnqcq` ^3fZg\WcYG`3ed¥ |ZUafnW^%W^3YGl^%fnWczU¡lY_cafZeÍcqoeZYohZocaZ`3YG[^3fnqca`% ^3fZg¨cqfE`%j´cqfEYpYG`3ed¥¢|UafnW^Wj 6B» XZ^%l^%l±[\UaeEYhcqll^3Z`%Y¢jÍ^3fnWoceZ|E_^3fEgdhEocqhYobl_kUa`3UaobcqoqYG_GWcqohcaWYfnW^3Ua`3l 6Mu fVl|Z_XiU«_kU1lYaw^W¦^3lblUa^3erWXZU1WpU¸] À a|;k ¾ ´¹ a/ À ^3l|ZlYGe 6´µ YGqYGoUa`Cx>cqo[¯|E`!U1W^3cqfZlp_kU1fQ Y´gq^qYGf)w)^3fV¦XZ^3_XhcaWYGf¢W^!Ua`%l_UafYpeEYGfZYGeÍlYGhUaoU1WYG`%j´cqo±_Gcq[¯Z^%fZYe«WcqgaYGWXEYo^3f«eZ^%© YoYfnWoYGgq^3cqfElc1x-WXEYpeEcq[\U1^3f)w¢Ua_G_cqoeZ^3fEg¨WcWXEY¯fU1W|ZoYzcaxBWXZYzhZocaZ`3YG[ÈU1fZeWXEYWcqhcq`%cqgq^3_Ua`)hZocqhYoW^3YGlcax±l|Z_XQoYGgq^3cqfEl 6µ cq[Yzh c1WYfnW^!Ua`x>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3cafZlUaoY¨[YGf¢W^3cqfEYeO^3frWXEY¨x>ca`3`3c¦^%fZg 6

B ,".-+"$v&:-+&:2+<.&:L".-M".KD&)T(R"=3'&SQk<.&:L".-­ ¦^3fZgOWcOWXEYd[UagqfEYGW^%_ ¡U1|Zll l¡`!Uk¨w$WXZY´qYG_GWcqozYG`3e _ ^%l¡lcq`3YGfZcq^%eUa`¦¼>ÉYocVeE^%qYGogqYGfZ_Y ½ ^%fWXEY¦XZcq`%Y\l^3[dhZ`%j_GcqfZfZYG_GWYGe²lhUa_GY 6iu W^3l¨WXZYGf³h call^%Z`3YdWcVYhZoYGll«^%Wz^3fÂWYGo[dlcax¦U a* ¾dÎ À /¸]* À a wZ^ 6 Y 6 U«eE^%© YoYGfnW^!U1Z`3Y¤aY_GWcqobx>|ZfZ_W^3caf l|Z_XWXU]W

_ D I ¼ V$6gV q½

h

Page 23: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

» XZYGf)wx>ocq[ U1oUaeUkj lp`3Uk UafEeVeZYfZ^W^3caf¼ V$6gV q½ wZ^%Wbx>cq`%`3c¦l~WXU1W

$c v & D F\

¼ V$6gV,Vn½

UagnU1^3f«_cqfEl^3eEYoYGeÍ^3f«WXEYp¦XZca`3Y¦lhU1_Y 6µ ^3fZ_GY^%ooc1WU1W^3cqfU1`YG`3eZlcqf\l^3[dhZ`%j_cqfEfZY_WYe\eZcq[Ua^3fZlUaoY¡_GcqfZlYo1U1W^%aYawZYz_UafV^%fnWoc eZ|Z_GY¨U ¿a ¾ 3 ¾ /¸] À a dweZYfZYeUal

D v \ ¼ V$6gV^¢½

¦XZ^%_Xv^3l«WXZYVgqYfEYoU1`3^3ÉU1W^%cqf²cax¤WXZY_G`!Uall^3_Ua`¦oYG`!U1W^3cqf D |ZlYe ^3fsWXZYVlWU1W^%_V_UalY 6 `3YG_GWocqlWU1W^%_¦hZocqE`3Y[dl±_kUafdWXZYGfÍYl£W|ZeZ^%Ye¢jdlcq`% ^3fEg ^3f«WXZY 3 ¾ / ]3¿¿ À ¿¹Ea/ À

¼ ½ D \ ¼ V$6gVSwq½

eZYGo^%aYeOx>ocq[ ¡Ua|Ell l¦`!UkÒ¦XZYfUahZhZ`j^%fZg¯WXEY¡l£WU1W^3_¨eZYfZ^%W^3cqfrc1x 6

u f\gqYfZYGoUa`wfEY^%WXZYo fZcao U1oYp|ZfZ^3¥¢|ZYG`%jdeZYfZYe 6u W~^3l¶¢fZc¦fÍx>ocq[ pY`3[dXZcaWÉ lWXZYcaoY[WXZU1WCWXZYeZYGfE^%W^%cqf¡caxZcqfEYaY_GWcqoyoY¥¢|Z^%oYlÔWXZYlhY_G^%_U1W^%cqfc1xZcaWXz^%Wl$_G|Zo` UafZez^%WlCeZ^qYGogqYGfZ_Y1wWXEYoYx>cqoYUrx>|ZoWXZYo¡_cqfEeZ^%W^3cqfcqfÂWXZY«eZ^qYogqYfE_Y\c1x XZUal¡WcVYd^3[dh cqlYet¼ Îna¹aÎa À Î ½6d» XZ^%lgnUa|EgqYV_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqfm^%l\_XZcalYf lcWXU1WÍhEocqhYo«WYGo[dl1UafZ^%lXt^%fmWXZYVx>cqo[¯|Z`3U1W^%cqf³cax¡TUY`%`lY¥¢|U]W^3cafZl¯njWXZYÍqYG_GWcao´h caWYfnW^3Ua` d6 cqozlWU1W^%_\hZocqZ`3YG[lGwMWXZY\l^3[dhZ`%YlW_cqfEeZ^%W^3cqf^%lWXEYlc]_kU1`3`3YGef ]¹3]dºÎna¹qÎ

D F\

¼ V$6gV,fn½

¦XZ^%_X [\U1¶aYl UafEe Y`%`ÓeZYGfEYe |EhÑWctUaf U1eZeZ^%W^%aYÂ_GcqfZl£WUafnW 6 Ê YG¦o^%W^%fZg²WXZYÂlWU1W^%_TU] Y`%` Ï [hYoY l~YG¥ |ZU1W^%cqfÍnj\eEYGfZ^W^%cqfQ¼ V$6 V q½ w UafZe\|Zl^%fZg¯gnUa|EgqY´¼ V$6 Vfn½ w¢~YgqYGWWXZY a* ¾ ]3¿¿ À ¿¯¹Ea/ À

H D ¼ V$6gV ½

x>cqoB[UagqfZYWcql£WU1W^3_bhZocqZ`%Y[dl 6 cqoMW^3[dYeZYGh YGfZeZYfnW~hZocqE`3Y[dlw¢U[dcqoY¦_GcqfnqYfE^3YfnW_XZcq^%_Y¦^3lBWXEYlc]_kU1`3`3YGeE: ¾ À mlÎna¹aÎ YhZoYGllYeinj

D \ ¼ V$6gV,hn½

¦XZ^%_XioYGeZ|Z_YGlWcWXEY´Ë~cq|Z`%cq[¯gnUa|ZgaY¡x>cqobWXZYl£WU1W^3_¨_kUalY 6µ YGYrª f]¬ cqozª ^^a¬ x>cqo¦eZYGWUa^3`%lU1 cq|WgnUa|Egq^3fZgUafZeVWXZY¯_GcqooYlh cqfEeZ^3fZg\YhZoYGll^3cqfZlcaxBWXZY¡W^%[Y¨eZYGh YGfZeZYfnWzTUY`%`l¤Y¥¢|U]W^3cafZl^%fWYGo[dl$caxEhcaWYfnW^3Ua`3l UafZe 6ÔÏ x>cao[¯|Z`3U1W^%cqf¤nj¤WXZYaY_Wcqo ^%l$UahZhZocqhZo^!U1WYMx>cqo hEocqZ`%Y[dlwY_kU1|ZlY ^%lycqo£WXZcagqcqfUa`nWcWXEYeZcq[Ua^3f-w1Y 6 g 6 D x>caoChZocqZ`%Y[dlCeZYfZYGedcafWXZYF¢ÓhZ`!U1fZY 6

A

Page 24: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

x &:C&:-&)T+<.&:L".-M"=a9T,"=-+"=(R"=3&S+|<.&:L".-Ï l±Ua`%WYofU1W^qY~Wc¤WXZY Òx>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3caf)w1^%f¯WXZYb¥¢|U1l^ÓlWU1W^%__kUalYb^%WB^%lMhcqll^3Z`%Y~Wc^%f¢Woc eZ|Z_GY

caWXZYol_kU1`!Uao~UafZe\aY_GWcqohcaWYGfnW^!U1`3l 6Bµ ^3fZ_GYWXZY_G|ZooYfnW¦eZYfEl^%Wj ^%llcq`3YGfZcq^%eUa`(^3flhUa_GYawEWXZYoYY^%lWl¦^%fOxU1_GWU¯qY_Wcqo m w_kUa`%`3Ye a ¾ 3 ¾ /b¸] À a wEl|Z_XWXU1W

D m I ¼ V$6gV,An½

» XZYGoYGx>caoYaw(l|ZZlW^%W|EW^%fZgV¼ V$6gV,An½ ^%fTU] ~YG`3` Ï [dhYoY l¦`3U¨w~Y¡XUkqY

¼ m ½ D F\

¼ V$6i^SFn½

lc«WXZU1WpU ¿a ¾ dÎ À /¸] À a _UafVY^3fnWoc eZ|Z_YGe¦^WXOeZYfZ^%W^3cqf

D m I ¼ V$6i^ ½

y^%Y`3eVY¥¢|U1W^3cqfEl¤_kUafiWXZYfQY¯Y+EhEoYllYGe^%fWYGo[dl¤cax m nj_cqfZl^3eZYGo^%fZg (UaoU1eUkj¢ YGfZoj l¤`!UkUafZe³WXZYO[\UagafZYGW^3_ ¨Ua|Zll ld`3Uk¨wWXZYO_cqfZl£W^W|EW^%qYroY`3U1W^%cqfZl UafZe _ wUafZe²eZYfZ^%W^3cqfEl¼ V)6 V,Aq½ UafZe¼ V$6i^ ½6BÏ lpU«oYl|Z`%WwEYzgqYW

¼ m ½ v ¼ m ½ D $ & ¼ V$6i^ q½UafZe

¼ m ½ D F I ¼ V$6i^SVn½

c1WY\WXU1W m UafZe UaoYfZcaW´|ZfE^3¥¢|ZYrUafEe)w±UafUa`%cqgqcq|El`%jQWc wBUgnU1|ZgqYÍ_GcqfZeZ^W^3cafXUalzWcQYlhY_G^%YGe 6 Ccall^%Z`3YgnUa|ZgqYGlx>cqo m UaoYWXZY´Ë~cq|Z`3ca[¯gnU1|ZgqYaw-oY¥¢|Z^%o^%fZg\ÉGYocreE^%qYGogqYGfZ_Y¯x>cao m wcqoWXZY Ì caoYfnWÉzgnU1|ZgqY

m D \ ¼ V$6i^,^¢½cqoWXZY¨_cqfZeE^%W^%cqf

m D F\

¼ V$6i^8wq½

¦XZYGoY ^3l¦UafUaoZ^%WoUao£j\qYG_GWcqobY`%eWXU1W¦eZc Yl¦fZcaWpXUkaY¡_G`3cqlYeOY`%eV`%^3fZYGl¨ª ^8w]¬Q6

u f c1WX´WXZY UafEe m x>cao[¯|Z`3U1W^%cqfZlGwq ca|ZfZeUao£j«UafZe^3fnWYGoxUa_GY¦_cqfZeE^%W^%cqfZlp¼ V$6 VFn½ +¼ V$6gV ½UafZe¼ V)6 ½ ¼ V$6 Fn½ XZUaY¡Wc« Y¨YhZoYllYeQ^%fÍWYGo[dlpc1xCWXZY¨l_kU1`!Uao¦UafEeaY_GWcqo¦h c1WYfnW^!Ua`%l¡ª ^,^]¬c6

|Zo£WXZYGox>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3cafZl¦caxTU] Y`3`lY¥¢|U1W^3cqfZl_cq|E`3eiY¯^3fnWoc eZ|Z_YGeQ^3fWYo[lcax±h c1WYfnW^!Ua`¥¢|UafnW^W^%YlUafZe[d^YGeUahEhZocnU1_XZYl_cq|Z`%eYz_GcqfZl^3eZYGoYe^3feZ^%© YoYfnWhZUaoWlcaxCWXZYzeZcq[Ua^3f 6u fWXEYpfEY WlY_W^%cqf)wqYhZoYlYfnWU1fU1`%WYGofU]W^%aY~x>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3caf¯UalYedcqf´WXZY¦fZcaW^3cqf´c1x WczeE^%© YoYGfnWl_Ua`!U1o¡[UagqfEYGW^%_¯hcaWYGf¢W^!Ua`%lwÔUal¨^%W¨XZUalzYYGf|ZlYe^3fWXZY«hZoYlYGfnWcqo¶iWcVeZYGl_Go^3Ydlcq[dY V [UagqfZYWcql£WU1W^3_¤[dceEY`3l 6

F

Page 25: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

% $ *26* 0-D#a$2*)+ ,$-.!/0 +2/30 -

u fWXZoYYÓeZ^3[dYfEl^3cafUa`Ml£WU1W^3_dhZocqE`3Y[dlw U1fZe m hZoYGlYGf¢W´UOx>|Z`%`MqYG_GWcaozx>cqo[·WXU1Wz^3l¨fZc1WqYGojÂYG®d_G^3YfnW^3fÂ[cql£W¡_kUalYl 6Vµ ^%[^%`!Uao`%jrWcVWXEYYG`3Y_WocqlWU1W^%_d_UalYd¦XZYoYÍU ¨Óx>cao[¯|Z`3U1W^%cqfi^%lgqYGfZYoUa`3`j|ElYeOx>cqo V [c eZY`%lw^3fÍ[UagqfZYWcql£WU1W^3_hZocqE`3Y[dl^W^3l~_cqfnqYGfZ^3YGfnWpWc´^3fnWoceE|Z_YWcl|E^%WU1Z`3Y¨l_Ua`!U1o[UagqfZYW^%_¡hcaWYfnW^3Ua`3lmU1fZe $w(¦XE^3_XQUaoYzeEYGfZYGeQlYGhUaoU]WY`jO^3fW~cÍeE^%© YoYGfnWoYGgq^3cafZlbcaxÔWXZY¨eZcq[Ua^%f)wEeZYGh YGfZeZ^%fZgd¦XEYGWXEYopoYga^3cqfZlb_GcqfnWUa^%fO_|ZooYfnWlcqo¦fZc1W 6

ocq[ pY`3[dXZcaWÉ lWXZYGcqoYG[ÃWXZY¨[UagqfZYW^%_Y`%eO^3fnWYGfZl^Wj ·_kUafYzU1`%~Uj l¦hUao£W^W^3cafZYeOUal

D v \

¼ V$6i^Sfn½

¦XZYGoY ^3l±lcq`%YfZca^3eUa`(U1fZe\oYhZoYlYGfnWlWXEY[UagqfZYW^%_¦ZY`3e^3fnWYGfZl^WjdeZ|ZY¦WchEoYl_o^3YeÍlcq|Zo_GY_|EooYGfnWlw¢¦XZ^%`3Y ^3lM^%oocaWU1W^3cqfZUa`EU1fZe«eZYl_o^% YGlWXZYb[UagqfZYW^3_Y`%ed^%fnWYfEl^%Wj¯eZ|ZYbWc^%fZeZ|Z_GYe[UagqfZYW^3ÉU1W^%cqf´^3f«[U1WYGo^3Ua`3l 6Cu W^3lBhcqll^3Z`%YbWXZYGfWc¡eZYfZY¤U¨l_Ua`!U1oBh caWYfnW^3Ua` w¢_kU1`3`3YGe ¾ a¹dÎ À /¸]* À a wZl|Z_XVWXU1W

D v \

¼ V$6i^ ½

^3fV¦XZ^3_XiWXZY¯lca|Zo_GYY`%e _kU1fQ Y¯_Gcq[dhZ|EWYGeQ|Zl^%fZg\WXZY /] hkj ] ¾ 6 ^%aYfU\lcq|Zo_GY_|EooYGfnW¨eZYfZl^%Wj eZYGZfZYecqfQUÍ_GcqfZeZ|E_GWcao¤eZcq[Ua^3f w _kUa`%`3YGe ¿]¹ ¾ ¾ /Îa/ À w l|Z_X`!Uk WYG`3`3lWXZU1WbWXZY¨oYl|E`%W^%fZg´Y`%e @D ¼ ½ ^3lbgq^qYfOnj

@D

^ V R $ ? ? & C ¼ V$6i^Shn½

cqoGwZY¥¢|Z^aU1`3YfnW`%jqw

¼ ½ D

^ V R ? ? C \ ¼ V$6i^SAn½

¦XZYGoY ^3lpUafVUaoE^%WoUaoj\h ca^3fnW¦^3fOlhZUa_Y\¼_Ua`3`%Ye ¡¸] À ½ U1fZe ^3lpUafnjrhcq^%f¢Wp^%f ¼>_kUa`%`3YGe¿]¹ ¾ ¸] À ½6¯Ï fcqYGo ^3Y cax±1Uao^%cq|Zl¤WY_XZfZ^%¥¢|ZYl¨x>cqoWXZY«_cq[dhZ|EWU1W^%cqficaxWXZY ~^%caW µ Uk1UaoW`!Uk ^%lhZoYlYfnWYGes^%f ª ^,^1¬Q6 (caozl^3[dhZ`3Yd_|ZooYGf¢W£_Uaoo£j^%fZgigqYGcq[dYGWo^3YGlz`%^3¶aYdUaol¯UafEe_cq^%`3l¦^%WXhcq`%j gqcqfZUa`_ocqlldlYG_GW^3cqf)wYGW_ 6 wbUafUa`j¢W^3_Ua`~Y+hZoYGll^%cqfZlXUkqYYYGfteZYGo^qYemnj Ì6 6 poUafE¶1U1oª ^Sf w ^ w ^,h1¬c6Bµ cq[dYpc1x-WXEYlYf¢|Z[YGo^%_kUa`cqo±lY[d^*U1fUa`%j¢W^3_kU1`WYG_XZfZ^%¥ |EYl~XZUaYYYGf\^3[dhZ`%Y[dYfnWYGecqfrWYGlW_kUalYlplW|ZeZ^3YGeV^%fË~XUahEWYo 6µ YGY¡eEYGWU1^3`3lb^%fª ¬c6

pfZeZYGoWXZYGlY´hZoY[d^3lYlw-_cqfZl^3eZYGo^%fZgWXZY¯[UagqfZYW^3_ ¡U1|Zll l¤`3Uk UafZeiWXEY¯_cqfElW^W|EW^%aYoYG`!U]W^%cqfZl¡¼ V$6 q½ UafZe¼ V)6 Vq½ wEWXZYx>cq`3`%c¦^%fZg dÎ À / ]3¿¿ À ¿¯¹Ea/ À x>cq`%`3c¦l

¼ ½ D v \

¼ V$6 wFn½

Page 26: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

^3fr¦XZ^%_XU1`3lc«hYo[\UafEYfnW¦[\U1gqfZYGWlb¦^%WXO_GcYGo_^qYYG`3e XUkqY¡ YGYfV[c eZY`%`3YGe 6

cqolWU1W^%_UafZer¥¢|Ual^ÓlWU]W^3_hZocqE`3Y[dlw^%W~^3l~hcqll^3E`3YWc´^3fnWoceZ|E_YUafEcaWXZYGol_Ua`!U1oh c1WYfnW^!Ua`cqfl^%[hE`%jV_cqfZfEY_GWYeÂeZcq[Ua^3fEl¦XZYoY«fZcOlcq|Zo_Y«oYGgq^3cafZlB UaoY´hZoYGlYfnW 6dµ ^3fZ_GY * D FcqfOl|E_XieZcq[Ua^3fElwZU´l_kUa`3Uaobh c1WYfnW^!Ua` _Uaf Y¨^3fnWoc eZ|Z_YGeVl|Z_XVWXU1W

D \

¼ V$6 w ½

_kU1`3`3YGe *]/adÎ À /~¸] À a 6­ fOoYGgq^3cqfEl¦^%WXrfEcdlcq|Zo_Y¨_|ZooYGf¢WlwY¡gaYGWbWXEYfOWXZY¨Y¥¢|UW^%cqf

¼ ½ D \

¼ V$6 w q½

¦XZ^%_XVoYeZ|Z_GYl¦Wc Ì UahZ`!U1_Y lbY¥¢|U]W^3caf¦XZYGfWXZYoYU1oYfZcdh YGo[UafZYGf¢W¦[UagqfEYGWl 6

^%aYf\U¡eZca[\Ua^%fws¦^%WXdlca|Zo_GYoYGgq^3cafZl ¤w ^3fElWYUaedcax_cafZl^%eZYo^3fZg¡cqfZ`j¯WXZYh c1WYfnW^!Ua`wU1fU1`%WYGofU]W^%aY¯UahEhZocnU1_XÂ_Gcq|Z`%eQ YWcr|ZlY«caWX UafZe 6¡u x±WXZY¯Wcqh ca`3cqgajcax±WXZY´eZcq[Ua^3f[Ua¶aYGld^W´hcqll^3Z`%YawBWXZYO^%eZYkUQ^3lzWchUao£W^%W^3cqf ^3f³WchZUaoWl°OUQl|ZeZcq[Ua^%f l|Z_XsWXU]W wZ¦XEYoY¨WXEY¡oYeZ|E_Yeh caWYfnW^3Ua` ³UafZeOWXEYf³¼ V$6 wFn½ ¦^3`%`-Y¨|ZlYGe)wUafZeVUdl^3[dhZ`%j_cqf fZYG_GWYGe\l|Z eEcq[\U1^3f)

£wn¦XZYoYpWXZYbWcaWUa`ZhcaWYGf¢W^!Ua` OU1fZei¼ V$6 w q½ ¦^3`%`ZYp|ElYe 6Bu fdWXZ^3l±lYG_GW^3cqf)w

x>cqo¨ZoYG ^%Wjaw ~^3l¨_kU1`3`3YGeQWXZY ]Óa ]da À UafEe6 WXZY ¾ a¹i ]da À.6«» XZYUaeE1UafnWUagaYcax±l|Z_X ]¹Zº3p¸]* À a0;k ¾ ´¹ a/ À weZ^©-YGoYfnW`%jx>ocq[ U\_Gcq[hE`3YGWYzx>cqo[¯|Z`3U1W^%cqfV^%f w `3^3YGl^%f

WXEYoYeZ|Z_W^%cqfcaxlcq[dY«_kUafZ_GY`%`!U1W^3cqfYoocqol¡WXU1W¡~ca|Z`3ec_G_|Zo¡^3fWXZYdoYGeZ|Z_GYe³eZcq[Ua^%f¦XEYf_ca[hZ|W^3fEg¯WXZYWc1WUa`-ZY`3e ·nj¼ V)6g^ ½ wZYGlhY_^3Ua`3`j\x>cqob`3UaogaY¤h YGo[dYkUaE^3`3^W^%Yl 6

cq|ZfZeU1ojdUafZe^3fnWYGoxUa_GY_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqfZlBXUkqYpWXZYGf\Wc¡YY+EhEoYllYGer^3f«WYo[lcax WXZY¦W~czh c1WYf W^3Ua`3l UafZe 6 jÍ_GcqfnqY_W^%cqf)wEYol£WpUall|Z[YWXU1Wh cqll^%Z`3Y¤hYo[\U1fZYfnW¦[UagqfZYWoYGgq^3cafZlbUaoY_caf¢WUa^3fEYe«^3f¯WXZYWcaWUa`EeEcq[\U1^3f 6CÌ YGW D - ) YWXZYb^3fnWYGoxUa_GYb YW~YGYfdWXZYboYeZ|Z_GYeUafZeVWXZYWcaWU1`CeZca[\Ua^%f 6 ocq[ ¼ V)6 Fq½ w|Zl^%fZg\WXEYeZYfZ^%W^3cqfElcax ÂUafZe tU1fZeWXEY¯_cqfElW^W|EW^%aYoYG`!U1W^3cqfEl YW~YGYf _ UafZe w~Y¡gqYGWbWXZYol£W¦WcaWUa`§1oYeZ|E_Ye^3fnWYoxU1_Y_cafZeZ^%W^3cqf

¼ ½ D ¼ v ½ caf \

¼ V$6 wVn½

¦XZYGoY ^%lzWXZYÍfZcqo[\U1`|EfZ^%WzqY_Wcqo«U]W wy¦XZcqlYreZ^3oY_W^3caf_kUaf YrU1oZ^WoU1o^3`jQ_XZcqlYf 6» ccqEWUa^3fÍWXZY¨lYG_cqfZeV^3fnWYGoxUa_GY¨_cqfZeE^%W^%cqf)w ~Y¡oY¦o^%WYd¼ V$6hn½ ^%frWYo[l¦cax iUafZe ³UafZeXUkqY

ª ¼ ½ ¬ D F\

¼ V$6 w^¢½XZYGfZ_Y

¼ ½ D cqf \

¼ V$6 w,wq½

¦XZYGoY ^%lMWXZYp|ZfZ^WBWUafZgaYfnWaY_WcqoU1W 6 ÄYpolWUall|Z[dYpWXU1W ^%l±_cqfZfEY_GWYe 6±» XZYGf)w¢EYeUaoZ^%WoUao^3`%jrU\h ca^3fnW _ w-~Y^3fnWYGgqoU1WYcqYGo¨UafnjhE^3Y_GYG¦^%lY´oYGgq|Z`3UaohZU1WXyª \ ¬ ¤x>caoUafnjrhcq^3fnW _ w(UafZegqYGWbWXZY¨lY_GcqfZeWcaWUa`§1oYeZ|E_Ye^3fnWYoxU1_Y_cafZeZ^%W^3cqf

Page 27: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

C¼ ½ D ~¼ ½ V

C cqf

\¼ V$6 wfn½

¦XZYGoY^%W«^3l«U1ll|E[YGe C¼ ½ D ¼ ½6 Ë~cqfEeZ^%W^3cqfѼ V)6 wfq½ eZYl_o^% YGldUÍÆ|Z[dh²caxeZ^3l_cqfnW^%f¢|Z^%WjYGWYYfmWcaWUa`bUafZesoYGeZ|Z_GYethcaWYfnW^3Ua`~1Ua`3|EYldU1W´WXEYV^%f¢WYo£xUa_Y1weZ|EYWcWXZYOlcq|Eo_YOYG`3e 6²u x\^%l´eZ^3l_cqfZfEY_GWYe)wUÂ_GcqfZeZ^W^3caf³`3^3¶1Y¼ V$6 wfn½ XU1l«WcYOoYGh YU1WYGetcqfsYkUa_Xsl^%fZgq`%Yr_cqfZfEY_GWYe_ca[hcqfZYGf¢W 6

ÄÇXEYfQhYo[UafZYGfnW¤[UagqfZYWlUaoYz_cqfZl^3eZYGoYGeQ^3fVWXZYzWcaWU1`CeZca[\Ua^%f)w^3fnWYoxU1_Y_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqfZlp Y+WYYfdhYo[UafZYGfnW±UafZe«lc1xWB[\U]WYo^!Ua`%lCXZUaY¦Ua`3lcWcY^%fZ_`%|ZeZYe 6yu x I

^3lMU¤lcaxWB[U1WYo^3Ua`

¦^%WX\hYo[YUaZ^3`%^%Wj I Uae]ÆU1_YfnWWc¯Uzh YGo[UafZYfnW[\U1gqfZYGW %H ¦^%WXh YGo[dYkUaE^3`3^Wj HwWXEY

^3fnWYoxU1_Y¨_cqfEeZ^%W^3cqfZl~ YG_cq[dY

¼ I H ½ D H ¼ V$6 w ½ 5 I I D 5 H I \ cqf I H \ ¼ V$6 whn½

¦^%WX I H D - I -%Hw¦XEYoY 5 I I UafZe 5 H I eZYGfZcaWY¡WXZYz1Ua`%|ZYl¼cqo¦`%^3[d^%W1Ua`%|ZYl ½ c1x icqf I Hx>oca[WXZY\l^3eZYGl¯cax I U1fZe>%H´oYGlhY_W^%aY`j 6iu fWXZY\l^3[dhZ`3YGo¡_UalY\^3f¦XZ^%_XcaWX> I U1fZe>%HUaoYdlcaxWz[\U1WYo^!Ua`%lw)oY`!U]W^3cafZll^%[^%`!UaopWc³¼ V$6 w ½ UafZev¼ V$6 whn½ XEcq`3e)w$fZc¦^WX D F wÔlcOWXU]WUa`%lc\WXZY¯ol£W¨_cqfEeZ^%W^3cqfiY_Gcq[dYlXZcq[dcqgqYGfZYca|Zl 6 Ccqll^%Z`3Y¯^%fnWYo£xUa_Y_cqfZeE^%W^%cqfZl¤YGWYYGfÂWclc1xWM[U1WYGo^!U1`3l$^3fWXZYoYeZ|Z_GYe«eZcq[Ua^%fUaoYYhZoYllYed^3f¯UafUa`%cqgqcq|Zl$~Ujawnnj_XU1fZgq^3fEg «¦^WX 6

u fUVl^3[d^3`!U1o~UjawMcq|ZfZeU1oj_cafZeZ^%W^3cqfElzU1oYdcqEWU1^3fZYGe 6 ÄY_Ua`3` UafZe ÇWXZYdhUao£Wl¡cax D -Ðcqf¦XZ^3_X-woYlh YG_GW^qYG`%jqw±WXEYrfZcqo[Ua`~UafZeWU1fZgqYfnW^!Ua`_cq[dh cafZYfnWl´c1xpWXZYr[UagqfZYW^3_YG`3edUaoY¦U1ll^%gqfZYGei¼>cqfZYbcaxWXZYWc¡_kUafd YbYG[hWj ½ UafEedl|ZhZhcqlY¦WXZU1WBWXZYboYeZ|E_YeeZcq[Ua^3f ^3fnWYolY_Wl¦WXZY¨cq|ZfZeU1oj 6±» XZYGf)w~Y¨gqYW¦WXZY¨fZcqf XZcq[dcqgqYGfZYca|Zl YG|Z[\U1fZfV_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqf

D cqf \

¼ V$6 wAn½

¦XZYGoY D - w¦XZYfÒ^%Wr^%lrfZcqfÓY[dhEWj 6 Yl^%eZYlGw^%x D ^%lfZcqf Y[dhEWjOU1fZeO_cqfZfEY_GWYe)w(Y¡gaYGW¦WXZY¨fZcafXZca[cqgaYfZYGcq|Zl ^3o^3_XZ`%YGWb_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqf

¼ ½ D V

C \ ¼ ½ D F cqf ¼ V$6gf,Fn½

¦XZYGoY _ ^3lzUhcq^3fnW¡EYe²UaoZ^%WoUao^3`%j 6ru x ^%lzeE^3l_GcqfZfZYG_GWYe)wUV_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqf`%^3¶aY¼ V)6 f,Fq½ XZUalWczYpgq^%aYf\cafYUa_XÍl^%fZgq`%Yp_GcqfZfZYG_GWYeÍ_Gcq[hcqfZYGfnW 6±µ ^%[^%`!Uao`%jaw1Y_GcqfZl^%eZYofZc WXEYWc1WUa`eZca[\Ua^%f

-¦XZYGf\^W±^3fnWYGolYG_GWlWXEYcq|ZfZeZUaoj 6M» XZY Y|E[\UafEf_GcqfZeZ^W^3caf«WUa¶aYGlWXZYbx>cqo[

D

cqf

\¼ V$6gf ½

¦^%WX D - wÔ¦XZYGf^%W¡^%l¡fEcqfYG[hWj 6\u x D

Ç^3l¨fZcafYG[hEWjÂU1fZe

_cafZfZY_WYGe)wM~YgqYGW¯UVfZcafXZca[cqgaYfZYGcq|Zl¡_cqfZl£WUafnW ^%o^%_XZ`3YW¨_cqfZeE^%W^%cqf 6ru fhUaoW^3_G|Z`!UaoGwÔ¦XEYf

V

Page 28: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

N,redΓ

=0SJ Ω red

totΩΓN,tot

ΓD,tot

ΓD,red Γ12

ΓIr0

rA

ϕ

φ φ

Ω1 Ω2

y^%gq|ZoY ° Ï W~c]eZ^%[YGfZl^%cqfUa`)eEcq[\U1^3f\¦^WXOWcaWUa`UafZeOoYeZ|Z_GYeVoYga^3cqfZl

^3l_GcqfZfZYG_GWYeiU1fZeO_cqfZeE^%W^%cqf¼ V$6 fFn½ ^3lb^%[hcqlYercqf wEx>cqo_GcqfZl^%lWYfZ_jYzXUkaY¡Wc«rWXZY¨_GcqfZeZ^W^3caf

y¼ ½ D V

C cqf <I ¼ V$6gf q½

u fOWXZY¨caWXZYo¦_kU1lYlGw(cqfZY¨[\Ukj\lhY_^xj

C¼ ½ D C¼ ½ caf \

¼ V$6gf,Vn½

¦XZYGoY ^%l¯Uihcq^3fnWzEYesUaoE^%WoUao^%`%jQ^%f *w±Uall|Z[d^3fZgVx>cqo¯^3fElWU1fZ_Y C¼ ½ D F)6µ YYr^%fy^%gq|ZoY Uhcqll^3Z`%Y l_XZYG[\U1W^3_VoYhEoYlYfnWU]W^3caf caxWXZYeZcq[Ua^3f)w~^3ftWXZYil^%[hE`3Yo«_UalYQ^%f¦XZ^%_XVcaWX UafZe ²UaoY¨_cafZfZY_WYGe 6

µ Y_GW^3cqf ^=6i^ hEoYlYfnWlWXZYÂ_ca[hZ`%YGWYUafUa`j W^3_Ua`x>cqo[ cax´U V ca|ZfZeUao£j 1Ua`3|ZYQhEocqZ`%Y[cqEWUa^3fEYeQx>ocq[ WXZYdUacqY«eZcq|EZ`3Y´hcaWYGfnW^!U1`Cx>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3caf)w WceEYl_Go^% Y«[UagqfZYWcql£WU1W^3_¯[dceEY`3l_ca[hcqlYGercax$lc1xWb[\U1gqfZYGW^3_[\U1WYo^!Ua`%l¦^WXÍ^%[hcqlYGeÍ_|EooYGfnWl 6 cqoUz[cqoY¤eZYWUa^%`3YecqYo£ ^3YGcaxCY`%Y_GWocq[UagqfEYGW^%_YG`3eZlpUafZehcaWYGf¢W^!Ua`%lwlYY\ª f w h]¬ UafZeª ^^ w ^8w]¬Q6

^

Page 29: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

d ONd Nd QSjMSP QN QSjr ~| yST $'& 3+-.2/*N4j

Ì YW¡|Zlol£Wz^%fnWoc eZ|Z_GY«^3fQ^%Wl¨UaZl£WoU1_GW¨x>oUa[dYGcqo¶WXZY«_G`!Uall¡c1x~cq|ZfZeZUaoji1Ua`%|ZY´hZocqZ`3YG[llW|ZeZ^%Ye^3frWXZY¨hZoYlYfnWhZUah YGo 6

Ì YWw I *) ÍUafZeg%H ) YrWc ¸ À weZ^3lÆcq^3fnWkwcq|ZfZeZYGevUafEem_GcqfZfZYG_GWYGeveZcq[Ua^%fZlwÌ YYlgq|ZYp[YUal|ZoUaZ`%Y¦^%WX Ì ^3hZl_XZ^%Wɦ_cqfnW^%f¢|Zcq|Zl±cq|ZfZeU1o^3YGl I UafZe%H 6 ÄYUall|Z[dY¦WXZYGjUaoY nG À wZ^ 6 Y 6 WXZYlYGW D I -%H^3l¦U´fZcqfÓY[dhEWjÍl|ZoxU1_Y¼_Ua`3`%Ye À ¾ ;G ½6±Ì YW¦|ZleZYGfZcaWY«nj D ! I %H¨WXEYdcah YGfgq`%cqUa`CeZcq[Ua^3f 6 ÄYdXEYoY«_GcqfZl^%eZYo¤WXZY´x>cq`3`%c¦^3fZgÍ_G`!UallcaxlYG_cqfEecqoeZYo¦cq|ZfZeU1ojn^%f¢WYo£xUa_Y¤1Ua`%|ZYhZocaZ`3YG[lG°

¼ ! = ½ D ^%f4= I D =-H vgC caf ! I = I I v ! H =-H H D 1 caf = D = caf ! = D o caf

\ ¼ ^=6 ½

¦XZYGoY U1fZe UaoY¡hZUaoWlbcaxCWXZY¨ ca|ZfZeUao£j D -¤w(l|E_XVWXZU1W D 6BocqZ`3YG[ ¼ ^$6 ½ ^%lzUOgqYGfZYoUa`3^%ÉYe Ôcq^3llcqf[c eZY`C¦^%WXÂ[d^YeÂfZcqfÓXZcq[dcqgqYGfZYcq|El ^%o^%_XZ`3YW

YG|Z[UafZftcq|ZfEeUaojsU1fZet^%f¢WYo£xUa_Y_cqfEeZ^%W^3cqfZl«^%fsWXZY|ZfE¶ fEc¦fy= D =C¼AF \ \ ½6 % UafZe eZYGfZcaWY¡WXZYzfZcqo[\Ua`$|ZfE^%WpqY_WcqolU1W ¨UafZehcq^3fnW^3fZg«Wc~UaoeZlWXZYzY WYGo^3caocaxyWXZYzeZcq[Ua^3fZl % w D

\ wUafZe` oYGlhY_W^%aY`jqw ¦XE^3`3YX= % UafEe ! % eZYfEcaWYWXZYz1Ua`%|ZYl¯¼cqop`3^%[^Wb1Ua`3|ZYGl ½ cqf

caxWXZY¯x>|EfZ_GW^3cqfZl=UafZe ! x>oca[ÈWXEYdl^3eZYGlcaxYkUa_X % w D \

:6¯» XZYV¼oYkUa` Ó1Ua`3|EYe ½ x>|ZfZ_GW^3cqfEl! D ! ¼ F \ \ ½ UafZe D ¼AF \ \ ½ eEYGfZYGemcaf¤w C D C¼ F \ \ ½ UafZe1 D 1$¼ F \ \ ½ caf woBD o ¼ F \ \ ½ cqf U1fZe = D = b¼AF \ \ ½ cqf ²UaoY¨gq^%aYfOeU1WU«lU1W^%lxj ^3fEgd_GYo£WUa^%foYgq|E`!Uao^%WjhZocqh YGoW^3Yl 6 cqo¯WXZYÍx>ca`3`3c¦^%fZgZwMYVU1ll|E[YrWXZU1W´WXZYOeZ^©-|El^3caf³_c YG®d_^%YfnW ! D ! ¼AF \ \ ½ ^%lUhcql^W^qYd cq|EfZeZYex>|EfZ_GW^3cqfcqf>¤w Ì ^3hZl_XZ^%WÉ\_GcqfnW^3f¢|Zca|ZlcqYGo´YkUa_X % wMlcVWXU1WzWXZY\`3^3fEYkUaoCca^3llcqfrcqhYoU1Wcqo %= D ¼ ! = ½ ^%fQ¼ ^=6 ½ ^3l|ZfZ^x>cqo[d`%j«YG`3`3^%hEW^%_bcqf 6 |ZoWXZYoGwYUall|Z[dYWXZU1Wz¼ ^=6½ XU1lU«|ZfZ^%¥¢|ZY¨lcq`%|EW^%cqf 6

­ |Zo¨^%f¢WYfnW^%cqf)w^%fWXZ^3l¡Ë~XZUahEWYGowÔ^3lWcOeZYGo^qYdUO1Uao^!U1W^3cqfZUa`Ôx>cao[¯|Z`3U1W^%cqficaxhZocqZ`3YG[ ¼ ^=6 ½x>cqoUdfE^%WYzY`%Y[dYfnW¤U1fUa`%j l^3lwWcÍ YzUahZhE`3^3YGeVWc\lca[Y V [UagqfZYWcql£WU1W^3_¨[dceZYG`3l¦WXU]W_UafiY ^3Y~YGeiUal¦hUao£W^%_|Z`3Uao~_UalYGlcax¼ ^$6 ½6

$ # *29!+ #a$29: 0!/0

fEeZYo ~ _cafZeZ^%W^3cqfEl~caxÔoYGgq|Z`3Uao^Wj´x>cqo \ C \ 1 \ o UafZe,= w ~YeZYGo^qY¨U1Uao^3U1W^%cqfUa`Zx>cao[¯|`!U]W^3cafQcax[dceEY`¦¼ ^=6 ½6Ì YW|ElzU1ll|E[Y _ 5@H]¼L ½ w-1x_ 5@H¼ ½ w o _5*H¼ ½ w Cs_ IL[ H ¼ ½UafZe,= >_3IL[ H ¼ ½6 ÄY¤cqEWUa^3fWXZYGfOWXZY¤YkUa¶dx>cqo[Ðcax~¼ ^=6½ ¢jÍUx>cqo[Ua`hZoc _YGeZ|ZoYl^3[d^3`3Uao

,w

Page 30: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

Wc´WXZYzcafZY¡UahZhZ`%^3YeÍWcdWXZY¨_`3Uall^3_kU1` Ccq^%llcqfV[dc eZY`-¦^WXfZc«^3fnWYGoxUa_GYlzª V ¬ w_cqfZl^3eZYGo^%fZg« caWXeZcq[Ua^%fZl I UafZe %H 6z» X |Elw~Y«[¯|E`%W^%hZ`%jrWXZY´eZ^©-YGoYfnW^!Ua`CY¥¢|U1W^3cqfQ^%fs¼ ^=6½ njQU1fU1oZ^WoU1ojb _# ¼L ½ UafZeO^%f¢WYgqoU1WYcaYo¦YkU1_XE % w D

\)6B» XEYf)wZY¡UahZhZ`j oYYGflWXZYGcqoYG[ Wc´WXEY

Wc´^3fnWYGgqoUa`(YG¥ |ZUa`3^W^3YGlUafZeÍlhZ`3^WWXZY_GcqooYlhcqfZeE^3fZg¯l|ZoxU1_Y¤^%f¢WYgqoUa`3lcqYGo%- % ^3fdWXZYlYGaYoUa`hUao£Wl¦cax~w UafZe eZYfZYGenjrWXZY¨oY`!U]W^3caf

- % D ¼9- % ½ ¼L- % ½ ¼L- % ½ \ D \

I ¼ ^=6 a½

y^%fUa`3`jqw|Zl^3fZg YG|Z[\U1fZfi_cafZeZ^%W^3cqfElpcaWXQU1WpWXZYz^3fnWYGoxUa_GY¯UafZeVWXZYz cq|EfZeUao£jU1fZeil|E[[d^3fZg|ZhOWXZYWcYG¥¢|Ua`3^W^%Ylw~Y¨gqYWpWXZYx>cq`3`%c¦^3fZgYkU1¶Íx>cqo[Ðx>cqobhZocaZ`3YG[ ¼ ^$6 ½ °

D$"=2+"$+'".-~b C2( -"$L À = D =C¼ F \ \ ½ _ 5@H]¼L ½ y ¾ = ? R D = % _ I ¼9 % ½ ;k ¾ D

\ ¿¹(r>Ea

V R ! = b C WED V R b C W v V o b C#"sv V 1 b C#" \ ^ b _ I ¼9 ½ \ ¼ ^=6 Vq½

À «¿¹>Ea = D = À À = I D =-H vxC À d¼ À ¤¿ À ¿¯<;¨ ¾ ½ u fÂWXZ^%l¨[c eZY`M¦^WXÂ^3fnWYGoxUa_GYlGwÔWXZYlcq`3|W^3cafs= D =C¼ F \ \ ½ Y`%cqfZgqlWcE5@H]¼L ½ Z|WfZc1W¡Wc I ¼9 ½ w YG_kUa|ZlY¯caxBWXZYhZoYlYfZ_GYdc1x±U\fZcqf ÉYGoc¡Æ|E[hx>|EfZ_GW^3cqfECOcaf^3fVWXZYzZolW¤^3fnWYGoxUa_GY

_cafZeZ^%W^3cqfmcaxd¼ ^=6 ½6Ò» X |ElwUalÍUfZU1W|ZoUa`plYGWW^%fZgx>cqodcq|Zod~YUa¶mlcq`3|W^3caft^%W[Ua¶aYGl\lYGfZlYiWc^3fnWoc eZ|Z_YWXZYx>cq`3`%c¦^%fZg ¸/ B3¿ µ cqcq`3YÍlhZUa_Y

I ¼9 I \ %H ½ D _`5@H]¼L ½ ° ? R _ I ¼9 % ½ \ D \

aI ¼ ^=6g^n½

YfEcaW^%fZgnj % D >? R wx>cqo D \

wZWXZYz_cq[dh cafZYfnWpx>|ZfZ_GW^3cqfElcaxMUafnj _ I ¼9 I \ %H ½ w(WXEYeZYfZ^%W^3cqf M M , 5SR R c I D M I M , 5eR I v M H M , 5eR c I ¼ ^=6 wa½

_kU1fYWXZYf¯_XEcqlYGf´UalCUfU1W|ZoU1` fEcqo[ 6 Ë~caXZYoYfnW`jqw1Y~^%fnWoc eZ|Z_GYWXZYl|ZZlhUa_GY I ¼L I \ %H ½caxx>|ZfZ_W^3cafZl _ I ¼L I \ %H ½ ¦XZcqlY«WoUa_Y cqf vaU1fZ^3lXZYl 6\µ ^3[d^3`!U1o`%jrWcOlhUa_GYl I ¼9 ½UafZeI ¼9 ½ wZx>cqobYUa_X _ ¨I ¼L I \ %H ½ ^W¦^3lbYkU1ljÍWchZocqYWXU]WpWXZY¨eZYGZfZ^%W^3cqfM M , # 5SR R c I D M I M , # 5eR I v M H M , # 5eR c I ¼ ^=6 fq½

^3lUafZc1WXZYGofZcqo[ x>cqo I ¼9 I \ %H ½ WcqgqYWXZYGo¦^WXVWXZY^%fZeZ|Z_GYeQfZcao[Ãx>oca[ ¼ ^=6 wq½ w(¦^%WX % U1l_ca[hcqfZYGf¢W¦x>|ZfE_GW^%cqfZlbcax cqf % w D

\)6

u fÒ¼ ^=6gVn½ wMeE^%© YoYGfnW`%jÂx>oca[WXZYrlca`3|EW^3cqf = _ I ¼L I \ %H ½ wMWXZY\WYGlW¯x>|EfZ_GW^3cqfZl b Y`%cqfZgVWcI ¼9 ½ I¼L ½ wElc«WXU1WbWXZY^%o~WoUa_Y b ^%l~Y`3` eZYfZYGeV^%f UafZe 6µ ^3[d^3`3Uao`j¯Wc«[dceEY`3lf

Page 31: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

¦^%WXZcq|EW¤Uafnj^%fnWYo£xUa_Yz_cqfEeZ^%W^3cqfZlGw ^W_UafQYlXEc¦f^%[[dYeZ^3U1WYG`%jWXU1W´¼ ^=6gVn½ ^3lpY¥¢|Z^%1Ua`%YfnWWcWXEYpYkUa¶´x>cqo[¯|Z`3U1W^%cqf¯cax)U¡[dceEY`Z¦^%WX ^%o^%_XZ`3YW± cq|EfZeUao£j´_cqfEeZ^%W^3cqfZlBWXU1WUaoY ]\Î À ]¹n¿cqf ÑUafEel|E_XWXU]W À +¹ ¸¿ÍÅq3¿ad À * ¾ ;G 6Ê YGgnUaoeE^3fZgOWXZ^%lw$`3YW¡|Zlz_GcqfZl^3eZYGoWXEY¡l|ZZl£W^%W|EW^%cqf = D= v = \ ¼ ^=6 ½

¦XZYGoY = ^3l\Uaf Y WYfZl^3cqf caxX= cqf l|Z_XÇWXU1W = _ I ¼L I \ %H ½ UafZevWXZYi_Gcq[hcqfZYGfnWx>|ZfZ_W^%cqfZl = I cafE I UafZe = Hpcqf4%HlU1W^%lxjÍWXZY¡_cqfZeE^%W^%cqf = I D= H+vgC\cqf 6» XEYf)w(^%WoYGl|Z`Wl =E_#I ¼L ½6 c ~Y¨^%f¢Woc eZ|Z_GY¨WXZY¨Z^3`%^3fZYUaox>cao[

¼ \Kb½ D V R !

b C W ^\ b _3 I ¼9 ½ \ ¼ ^=6 hq½

UafZe-w]x>cqoÔUbEYex>|EfZ_GW^3cqf Ì YYlgq|ZY[YUal|ZoUaZ`%YcafU¦l|Zo£xUa_Y " -¤waWXZY±x>cq`%`3c¦^3fZg~fZcaWU]W^3cafcaxC`3^%fZYkUaox>|ZfZ_GW^3cqfZUa`

\ ! D V! C#" ^ b _ I ¼L ½ I ¼ ^=6 Aq½

» XZYGf)wEeZYGfZcaW^3fZg¯nj¼ \ ½ R WXEY|Zl|Ua` 5*HÓl_Ua`!UaohZoceZ|E_GWcqf,¤wx>ocq[ ¼ ^$6 Vn½ Y¤gqYGWWXZYpx>cq`3`%c¦^3fZg

&:NOD$".-&)]D="=2"$L'".-yb C(;-+")+ À = _ I ¼L ½ ¿¹(Ea ¼ = \ b ½ D ¼ b ½ ^ b _# I ¼L ½ \ ¼ ^=6Fn½

y ¾ z\3¿Îaa À º ¼ ^=6ghn½ À

¼b½ D ¼ \Kb ½ R ¼ ! = \ b ½ R v o \Kb v 1 \Kb \ ¼ ^=6½

B o \ À 1 \ Îaa À º ¼ ^=6 Aq½6» XZY\UaeE1UafnWUagaYcax~WXZ^%lzYG¥ |E^%1Ua`3YGfnWzx>cqo[¯|Z`3U1W^%cqfQ^3l¨WXU]WfZc WXZYlcq|ZgqXnWz~YUa¶lcq`3|W^3caf1Uaf ^3lXZYl¦cqf ³`3^3¶1Y¤WXZYWYlW¦x>|ZfE_GW^%cqfZl

bwUafZe^%Wlb_cq[dhcqfZYfnW¦x>|ZfZ_W^%cqfZl = % lU1W^3lxjWXZY¨_GcqfZeZ^W^3caf

= I D=-Hpcaf 6±» XZY¨fZcqf ÉYGoc´1Ua`3|EY¨U1WWXEY ^%o^%_XZ`3YWcq|ZfZeU1ojOUafEeOWXZY¨eZ^3l_cqfnW^3f¢|Z^%WjÍU1WbWXEY^3fnWYoxU1_Y¨XUkqY¡ YGYfOWoUafZlx>YGooYeOWcdUd¶¢fZc¦fx>|ZfZ_GW^3cqf = 6c cerhZocqhYoW^3YGlpXEcq`3erx>cqo UafZe 6 y^%ol£Wkw ^3lblj [d[YWo^3_¨UafZe_caf¢W^3f¢|Zcq|Elw^ 6 Y 6

? ¼ \Kb ½ ?Sn I M M , # 5eR I M b M , # 5SR I ^\Kb _# I ¼L ½ \ ¼ ^=6 q½

Ual¤^Wx>ca`3`3c¦l¦x>ocq[ WXZY«ËUa|Z_Xnjn µ _X¢~Uao£WÉd^3fZYG¥ |ZUa`3^Wjqw¢jWU1¶ ^%fZg I D M ! M N ¼>XZYoYaw)YG¥¢|Ua`CWc[U] R ! ½6B» XZYGf)w(eZ|ZYWc«WXEY¡|EfZ^%x>cqo[ YG`3`%^3hEW^3_^Wjqw¢~Y¡XUkqY

Page 32: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

¼b-\Kb

½ 3 H M b M H , # 5SR I ^ b _ I ¼L ½ ¼ ^=6Vn½

¦^%WX H D [^%f R ! ¼>^3fl|Z_XU_UalY1w)^%Wp^%llU1^3eVWXU1W ^3l ¾ a cqf I ¼L ½½6 Yl^%eZYlGw-WXEY`3^%fZYkU1ocqhYoU]Wcqo ^%lb_cqfnW^3f¢|Zcq|ZlGw^ 6 Y 6

? ¼ b ½ ?en M b M , # 5SR I ^ b _# I ¼L ½ \ ¼ ^=6T^¢½

Uali^WVx>ca`3`3c¦lx>ocq[ WXEY ca|ZfZeZYGeZfZYllhZocqhYo£Wj cax´WXZYx>|ZfE_GW^%cqfUa`%l¼ \Kb ½ R wͼ ! = \ b ½ R w o \Kb U1fZe 1 \ b wE|Zl^%fZgËUa|Z_Xnjn µ _Xn~UaoWÉ´UafZe Cca^3fZ_UaoY l¦^3fEY¥¢|Ua`%^%W^%YlGw ¦^WX JFeZYGh YGfZeZ^3fEgVcqf ! w w-1)w o w = ~w+ I U1fZe6%H 6«» X¢|ZlGwÔx>ocq[ WXEY Ì U]¢*TV^3`%gqoUa[ WXZYcqoY[ ª w V ¬ wWXEYoY¨Y+E^%lWlU´|ZfZ^%¥¢|ZY~YUa¶rlcq`%|EW^%cqfÍx>cqoWXZYaU1o^!U]W^3cafUa`hZocqE`3Y[·¼ ^=6Fn½ wUalbY`3`$U1l¼ ^=6gVn½6

» c_GcqfZ_G`3|ZeZY1wyhZocqhYoWjt¼ ^=6 TVn½ gq|UaoUafnWYYGlWXZU1W ¼b-\Kb

½ 3 F wÔx>cqo¨YkUa_Xb _ I ¼L ½ ¼>WXEYhZocqh YGoWjXEcq`3eZl$U1`3lc¦^%f¨Up`3UaogqYGo)lhZUa_Y1w1`%^3¶aY I ¼L ½½6 ÄY±_kU1f¡WXZYoYGx>cqoY^%fnWoc eZ|Z_GYMWXZY±YG¥ |E^%1Ua`3YGfnW

fZcqo[ M b M R D ¼ b-\Kb ½ D T V R ! b b C W Y IL[ HQ\ ¼ ^=6wq½

¦XZ^%_X¦^%`3`-Y¨|ZlYGe[Uafnj\W^3[dYlb^3frWXZYx>cq`3`%c¦^%fZgZw _kUa`%`3YGe À ¾ Î dÀ ¾ 6

$ % 1 0 4_0-2/ ,/!cqo¤U\fE^%WYY`3YG[YGfnW¨eZ^3l_oYW^%ÉkU1W^3cqfVcax±WXZY¯1Uao^!U1W^3cqfU1`ÔYG¥¢|U1W^%cqfs¼ ^$6 Vn½ w)`3YW D Y´U

À ;k ¾ da V Wo^3UafZgq|Z`3U1W^%cqfQcax¤wM^ 6 Y 6 UhUao£W^%W^3cqfcax^%fcqhYfWo^3UafZgq|E`!Uaol|Z eEcq[\U1^3fZlhUa^%o¦^%lYeZ^3lÆcq^3fnWCcqoyXUk ^3fEg¤Y^WXZYGoMUaYoWY w¢Uaf¯YGeZgqYcaoMUxUa_GY~^%f_ca[[dcqf)w1l|Z_X¯WXU1W D 6Ì YGW¦|Zl¦l|ZhZhcqlY¨WXU]W ¡^3l¦Ua`%lc À ¿ ¾ a À U]WbWXZY¨^3fnWYoxU1_Y wZ^ 6 Y 6 YUa_XY`3YG[YGfnW¦^3lbeZ^%l>Æcq^%f¢Wx>oca[ cao´XUaldUiqYo£WY+-wUaf²YeZgqYOcqo«UixUa_GYO`%j ^3fZgQcafs^W 6» XEYV^%fZeZY)w_Ua`3`%Ye \¿¿ l] w[dYkUal|ZoYGl¤WXZY´hcq^3fnW¦^%lYl^3ÉGY´cax±WXZY¯YG`3YG[YGf¢Wl^3fWXZY¯Wo^!UafEgq|Z`!U]W^3caf)w(UafZeXUalWcrlU]W^3l£xjlcq[dYoYGgq|Z`3Uao^WjhZocqhYo£W^%Yl 6» jhE^3_kU1`3`%jaw^3l¡eZYfZYesUal¡WXZYhZ^3YG_Y¦^3lY_cqfElWU1f¢W¯h cql^%W^%qY«x>|ZfZ_W^%cqfl|E_XWXU]W? D eZ^!U1[¼ ½ x>cqo¡UafnjY`%Y[dYfnW-wy^ 6 Y 6 ^%W¡YG¥ |ZUa`3l¨WXZYd`3cafZgqYl£WYGeZgqYdcax 6 ÄYUa¶aYGoUall|Z[dhEW^%cqfZl~x>caor_kUafrXZcYGaYo¦ Yl|ZgqgaYlWYe 6 cqo^3fZl£WUafZ_GYaweZYGfE^3fZg D eZ^3Ua[V¼ ½ x>cqo~YUa_X4_ nwË 6 acqXZfZlcqfU1fZe 6 o^3¶¢llcqfoY¥¢|Z^3oY¨^3fª ¬ WXZU1Wk°

½ _ I ¼ ½ w^Wb^3lbhcql^%W^qY¨UafEeWXZYoY¡Y+^3lWl KF l|Z_XVWXU1W

? $¼ W ½ ?en \ ^ FE_ ¼ ^=6fn½

a½ WXZYGoY¡Y^3l£WlpU´_cqfZl£WUafnW I KF l|E_XVWXZU1W

I n V C W \ ^ _ ¼ ^=6 ½

Vq½ WXZYGoY¡Y^3l£WlpU´_cqfZl£WUafnW H KF l|E_XVWXZU1W

h

Page 33: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

H Xn $¼ W ½ n \ ^ F_ \ ^ _ ]I ¼ ^=6hn½

jO[dYkUafElpc1xCWXZYlYz_GcqfZeZ^W^3cafZlb^%W¦^%lpoY¥¢|Z^%oYeOWcdXUkqYzU«l|E®d_^%YfnW`jg.gqc ce2/´[YGlX)wWXZU1W¦^3lG° ½l|®_G^3YGf¢W`%j\|ZfZ^%x>cao[ ¦^%WXU¯fZc1WWc c´`!UaogqY1Uao^!U1W^3cqf^3frl^%ÉY¨Ua[dcqfZgzWXZYYG`3Y[dYfnWlw q½ ¦^WXrfZc1WWc clXUaohUafEgq`3YGl¡^%fQWXZYdY`%Y[dYfnWlGwMUafZe Vn½ ¦XZcqlY\YG`3Y[dYfnW¡lXZUah YGl¯UaoY«fZcaW¡Wc cOxU1o¨x>ocq[·WXEYY¥¢|Z^%`!U1WYoUa`ycqfEY 6´u ftª ¬ UafZemª w]¬ ^W^3lY+EhE`!Ua^%fZYeXZc WXZY´¥¢|Ua`%^%Wjic1xWXZY´Y`%Y[dYfnW¨lXU1h YGlz^%fWXEY¨Wo^3UafZgq|Z`3U1W^%cqf\_UafVU1©-YG_GW¦WXEY¡_GcqfnqYGogqYGfZ_YzcaxCZfZ^%WY¡YG`3YG[YGf¢W¦lcq`3|W^3cafZl 6

ÄY¯_UafQfZc W|ZofiWc\WXEY´eZ^3l_oYW^%ÉkU1W^3cqfVcax¼ ^=6Fn½ w-nji|El^3fEgrU À À ¹]¹n¿ a3 ¾ ] À ZfZ^%WYY`%Y[dYfnW¨[dYGWXEce 6Ì YGW I ¼9 ½ Y¯WXZY´fZ^%WYÓeZ^3[dYfZl^3cqfZUa`ClhUa_GYdc1x_GcqfnW^%f |Ecq|Zlx>|ZfZ_+W^%cqfZlhE^3Y_GYG¦^%lY¨eZYGZfZYeVcqf4¤wE1UafZ^3lXZ^3fEg´cqf wEWXU]WpUaoY_GcqfnW^3f¢|Zca|Zl¦h cq`j fZcq[d^!Ua`%lcaxÔcqoeZYo cqYGoYUa_XVYG`3YG[YGf¢W¦^%f 6±» XZYGf)wnjOeZYGfE^%W^%cqf)wEWXZY ¡U1`3Yo¶¢^3fÍfZ^WYYG`3Y[dYfnW¦lcq`3|EW^3cqfrlU1W^%lYGlWXEY1Uao^3U1W^%cqfUa`Cx>cqo[ ¼ ^=6 TFn½ x>cao¡WYlWzx>|ZfZ_W^3cafZl_GcqfZl^%eZYoYe^%fWXZ^3l¨fZ^WYÓeZ^3[dYfEl^3cafUa`BlhZUa_Y1w^ 6 Y 6 WXZYx>cq`3`%c¦^3fZg¯hEocqZ`%Y[°

Q9,2&S&kD="$"$"=-Mb C2(;-"$ À = _ ¿¹O>Ea ¼ = \ b ½ D ¼ b ½ ^ b

_ \

¼ ^=6An½

y ¾ Â À ¾ À º ¼ ^$6 hn½ À ¼ ^$6 ½6

» XEYeZ^%l_oYGWY[dceZYG` ~ D / ^%l«WXZYfteZYo^%qYGev^3fmUl^3[d^3`3Uao¯[UafZfZYGodWc[dceEY`3l´¦^WXZcq|W^3fnWYoxU1_Y 6u W¡^3l¨l|E®d_G^3YfnW¡Wc^3[dh calY¯WXEYeZ^%l_GoYGWY_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqfs¼ ^=6An½ cqfWYGlW¡x>|ZfZ_W^3cafZl

b Y+

`3cafZgq^3fEgWc¯WXZY¨lUa[dYfZ^WY+eZ^%[YGfZl^%cqfUa`Ual^3lb^3f |ZlYGex>caoWXZY¤fE^%WYoYhEoYlYfnWU]W^3cafVcaxÔWXEYeZ^%l_oYGWYlca`3|EW^3cqf 6C» XZY¤U1l^3lx>|ZfZ_W^3cafZl~U1oY_XEcqlYGfrlcWXU1WbU¡`3c _kUa`(_Gcq[hZUa_GWl|ZhEh cqo£WhZocqhYoWjXZcq`%eZl\¼Y 6 g 6 ^%fÂWXZYdhZ^3YG_YG¦^%lY`3^3fEYkUao_UalY1wCWXEYY`3` ¶¢fZc¦f Ea h ;+¹ À / À ¿ _kU1fY|ZlYe ½6r» c]gqYWXZYGo¨¦^WXQWXEYd^%fnWYo^3cqolcq|Zo_YlzUafZeWXEYdcq|ZfEeUaoji_cqfZeE^%W^%cqfZlGw^3fcq|Zo_UalYUr_cqfnWo^3Z|W^3cafx>oca[ÈWXEYd^%fnWYo£xUa_Y«_GcqfZeZ^W^3cafZl¤XUalWcY«^3fZ_G`3|ZeEYe^3fQWXEYdo^3gqXnW¨XU1fZel^3eEY / 6«u xUrhZ^%Y_GYG¦^3lY`3^%fZYkU1o ¨Ua`%Yo¶¢^%f[dYGWXEceV^3l¤U1hZhZ`3^%Ye)wx>cqop^3fElWU1fZ_Y1w WXEY¯f¢|Z[¯Yoc1x±eZYgqoYYGl¤caxMx>oYYeEcq[ x>caoWXEY`3^%fZYkU1ozl£jl£WYG[ ^3l¡WXZYÍf¢|Z[ YGo caxbWXZYÍ^%f¢WYo^3cqoUafZe Y|Z[UafZf³cq|ZfZeZUaojfZc eZYl¯eEYGfZYGe²¢jWXEYdWo^!U1fZgq|Z`3U1W^%cqf nwC¦^%WX^%fnWYo£xUa_YdfZc eZYl¡^3fE_`3|EeZYet¼_Ua`3`%Ye ; ¾ À ¿ ½6u fWXEYeZYfZ^W^3cafcaxbWXZYÍeZ^%l_oYGWYÍ[c eZYG`/wCWXZYÍ^%f¢WYo£xUa_YÍ_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqf6= I D =-H v CQ^3lz^3fZlYo£WYe³^%fnWcWXZYÍlWo|Z_W|ZoYcaxBWXZY´`3^%fZYkUaoplj l£WY[w^3fcqoeZYGoWc\_cq[dhZ|EWY¯eZ^3oY_W`%jOWXZYfZ^WY¯YG`3YG[YGf¢WUahZhZoc^%[\U1W^3cqf4= ´caxWXEY\lca`3|EW^3cqf =ÔwC^3fZl£WYUaecax = 6u fWXEYÍ|ZfZ¶¢fZc¦fqYG_GWcqo D ¼ = I \ =-H \ \ = ½ wCWXZYgqYfZYGo^%__ca[hcqfZYGf¢W = % D = ¢¼ F % \ % \ % ½ oYhZoYlYfnWl¨WXZYzaU1`3|ZY¯c1xWXZY¯fZ^WY¯YG`3YG[YGf¢W¤lcq`%|EW^%cqf= dU1W¤WXEY /WXOx>oYGYzfZc eZY¨cax 6» XZY¡_cq[dh cafZYfnWl¦cax cqffZceEYlp YG`3cqfZga^3fZg¯Wc ¤U1oY¡Uallc_G^!U1WYeY^WXZYGoWcWXZYbx>|ZfZ_GW^3cqf= I cqoMWcB=-HkwnnjdUaoE^%WoUaojz_caf¢aYfnW^%cqf)wUalBWXZYb1Ua`%|ZYbcaxWXZY¦caWXZYoBcqfEYp^%lBeZYo^%aYe^3[d[dYeZ^3U1WYG`%j´x>oca[ WXZY¨¶¢fZc¦`3YGeZgqY¨caxÔWXZY~Æ|Z[dh4C 6­ ¦^%fZgzWczWXEY|ZfZ^x>cqo[ YG`3`%^3hEW^3_^Wj¯cax-WXZYpx>cqo[ ¼9= \Kb ½ w¢WXZYl£W^©-fZYGll[U1Wo^´^3lfZcqfÓl^3fEgq|Z`!U1ow

lj [d[YWo^3_awh cal^%W^%aYreZYGfE^%WYVUafZe-weZ|ZYOWcWXZY`3c _kU1`l|ZhEh cqo£W\hEocqhYo£WjqwlhUaolY 6 » XZYGoYx>cqoY1wWXEYz`%^3fZYUaolj l£WY[ ^%lpgaYfZYGoUa`%`%jÍlcq`%aYeV¢jO^WYGoU1W^%qY[dYGWXZc eZlwY 6 g 6 oj `3crl|ZZlhZUa_Yz[YWXZc eZl 6µ |Z^WUaE`3YÍhZoY_GcqfZeZ^W^3cafZYol _ _UafmYUahZhZ`%^3YGe³^3f³cqoeZYo´WcoYeZ|Z_GYx>ocq[$¼ O½ Wc$¼ _]r½ WXEY

A

Page 34: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

NΓ ,1NΓ ,2

,2Γ ,1

rAro

Ω 2Ω 1

Ω S

ΓI

D

y^3gq|EoY ° Ï Wc1eZ^%[YGfZl^%cqfUa` hZocÆY_GW^3cqfOcaxÔWXEY¡[dc eZY`)eEcq[\U1^3f

_cafZeZ^%W^3cqf³f¢|Z[ YGo´caxWXZYOlW^%© fZYlld[U1Wo^ wM¦XZ^%_Xscq|Z`%e²caWXZYGo¦^%lYOgqoc Ual´WXZYr[dYlXml^3ÉGYY_ca[YGlfZYGo 6Ñu f ª V¬n6 ËU1^UafEe 6µ U1[¯|ZY`%llcqfvl|EgqgqYl£Wrlca[YV[YWXZc eZlw~`3^3¶1YiUaeEeZ^%W^%qYµ _Xn~UaoWɯ[YWXZc eZlUafZe[¯|Z`W^3gao^3eÍWY_XZfE^3¥¢|ZYlGw WXU1W_kUafV Y¡|ZlYGeQUalph call^%Z`3Y¨hZoY_GcqfZeZ^W^3cafZYolx>cqo±WXZYlW^%© fZYll~[U1Wo^ 6yÏ lhY_GWlUacq|EWWXEY^3[dhZ`%Y[dYfnWU1W^3cqf´c1x)WXZYeZ^3l_oYGWY[c eZYG`Ô¼ ^=6An½ w^%fcq|Zoblh YG_^_U1hZhZ`3^%_kU1W^3cqfElx>cqob[UagqfZYWcql£WU1W^3_¤hEocqZ`%Y[dlwE¦^%`3`)YeZYGl_o^3YeV^3fVË~XUahEWYo f$6

$ *)+ $-.!/0:+2/30

» XEYzYG`3Y_Wocq[\U1gqfZYGW^3_[dceEY`lW|ZeZ^%Ye^%fWXZY¡hZoYGlYfnW~cqo¶r^3lpU«hUaoW^3_G|Z`!Uaob_UalY¡caxCWXZY¡gqYf YoUa`-cq|ZfEeUaoj1Ua`3|ZYhZocaZ`3YG[·¼ ^=6 ½ x>cqolh YG_^!U1` 1Ua`3|EYlcax$WXZY¤eU1WUx>|ZfZ_W^3cafZl \ C \ 1 \ o UafZe,= oYG`!U1WYerWc«[UagqfZYW^%_hZocqhYo£W^%Yl 6

u f¯WXZYx>ca`3`3c¦^%fZgZw¦XZYf«cq[d^%WWYGe)w1^Wy^%lMUa`Ukj ly^%fnWYfEeZYe¯WXU1WBU1`3`¢[\U]WYo^!Ua`¢oYgq^%cqfZlwaUa`3`¢cq|ZfZe Uao^3Yl~UafZeÍ^%fnWYo£xUa_YGl~lU1W^%lxj«WXZY .gqc ce2/hZocqh YGoW^3Ylcax$oYGgq|Z`3Uao^Wj«lhY_^Yer^%f µ YG_GW^3cqf ^$6 ,6y» XZY^3fnWYfnW^%cqf ^3lÍfEc Wc³^%fnqYl£W^%gnU1WYVWXZYQYXUk ^3ca|Zorcax¡[\U1gqfZYGW^3_Y`%eZlr^3fvl£WU1W^3_i_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqfZlÍ^%fUQoYGgq^3cqf³c1xlhUa_GY_GcqfnWUa^%fZ^3fEgQhZoYGl_o^3Yes_|ZooYGf¢Wl 6²Ì YGW) ) YÍWXZYOoYGgq^3caf³caxp^3fnWYGoYl£W¦^%WXO cq|EfZeUao£j BwZ_cq[dhcqlYGeVcaxC[U1WYGo^!U1`3lWXU1WpUaoYlcaxWp[dYeZ^3UEwZU1`3`-`%^3fZYUaowXZcq[dcqgqYGfZYcq|ElU1fZe^3lcaWocqhZ^%_awqlc¡WXU1WBWXEYp[UagqfEYGW^%_bh YGo[dYkUaE^3`3^Wj ^%l±U¡hE^3Y_GYG¦^%lY¦_cqfElWU1f¢Whcql^W^qYx>|ZfZ_W^%cqf)wn^ 6 Y 6_cafZlWUafnW¨cqfQYkUa_X[U1WYGo^3Ua` 6Ì YW|Zll|ZhZhcqlY¯WXU1W¤WXZYoY¯Y^3l£Wl¨UÍ_GcqfZeZ|Z_WcqoeEcq[\U1^3f ¦XZYGoYOUi_|EooYGfnW c¦l¯¦^%WX³eZYfZl^%Wj 6Ì YGW´|Zl´hZUaoW^%W^%cqfWXZYreZca[\Ua^%f^%fW~cQ[U1WYo^3Ua`±oY+gq^%cqfZl I UafEey%Hl|Z_XtWXU1W%H\_GcqfnWUa^%fZl) UafZey I ^3l´l^3[dhZ`%j_cqfEfZY_WYe-w¦UafZeseZYfZc1WY¢j D - I -%HWXZY¨^3fnWYGoxUa_GYzYGWYYGfWXEY[ 6 Ua_XVcaxyWXZY¨eZcq[Ua^3fZl % _kU1fY¡_Gcq[dh cqlYecaxlYqYGoUa`$[U1WYGo^!U1`3l 6

Ï __GcqoeZ^%fZgWcWXZYeZcq|ZZ`%YOh caWYfnW^3Ua`x>cqo[¯|Z`!U]W^3caf³hZoYGlYfnWYev^%f µ YG_GW^3cqf V$6g^ wYV_UaftfZc¦o^WYdTUY`%`l¨Y¥¢|U1W^3cqfZl¨^%fWYo[l¨cax~UÍWcaWUa`B[\U1gqfZYGW^3_¯hcaWYfnW^3Ua` cqf I U1fZeUroYeZ|Z_GYe

V,F

Page 35: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

hcaWYGf¢W^!Ua` tcqf %Hw)oY`3U1WYGeWcÍWXZY¯[UagqfZYW^3_¡Y`%eQnj³¼ V$6 w ½ UafZes¼ V$6i^ ½6» XZY´gqcqYGofZ^%fZgreZ^%x!x>YoYfnW^3Ua`-YG¥¢|U1W^%cqfZlbU1oYWX |El Ccq^%llcaflbYG¥¢|U1W^%cqfZl¨¼ V$6 w q½ UafEe¼ V$6 wFn½ x>cqo caf I U1fZe cqf %HoYGlhY_W^%aY`jqw(^3fͦXZ^%_X ±1UafE^3lXEYlpl^3fE_YWXZYGoY¡UaoYfZchYo[\U1fZYfnWp[\U1gqfZYGWl 6

» crlYW¨ ca|ZfZeUao£ji_GcqfZeZ^W^3cafZlw~Y´hU1oW^W^%cqf²^3fWc¼Uall|Z[dYe_GcqfZfZYG_GWYGe ½ hUao£Wl U1fZe l|Z_X²WXZU1W D ±w±eZYGh YGfZeZ^%fZgQcqf¦XZYGoYOfZcqo[\Ua`UafZe³WUafZgqYGf¢W^!Ua`_cq[dhcqfZYfnWl¯caxWXEY[UagqfZYW^3_rYG`3etUaoY¶¢fZc¦f 6 ÄY^3fnWoceZ|E_YVWXZYhUaoW^!Ua`bcq|ZfEeUao^%Yl I D - I w I D - I U1fZe H D -%Hw H D %H\cqfm¦XZ^%_X ¼ V$6gf ½ +¼ V$6gf q½ U1fZe¼ V)6 wAq½ ¼ V$6gf,Fn½ UaoYoYlhY_W^qY`jU1ll^%gqfZYGe 6 Ë~cqfZl^3eZYGo^3fEg^3f WXZYd^3fnWYoxU1_Yd_cqfZeE^%W^%cqfZl\¼ V$6 wVn½UafZe¼ V)6 wfq½ wEY¨XUkqY¨fUa`%`%jdWXZYx>cq`%`3c¦^3fZgeZ^%© YoYfnW^3Ua`)cq|ZfZeU1ojÍ1Ua`%|ZYhZocaZ`3YG[ cqf ¤°

¼ I ½ D F cqf4 I ¼ H ½ D ¼ H ½ cqf4%HC¼ ½ D ~¼ ½ 0

C \ y¼ ½ D ¼ ½ cqf

I I v H H D H H cqf C¼ ½ D 0

C cqf I

~¼ ½ D 0 C \ ¼ ½ D F cqf H I D F cqf I H D H cqf H

¼ ^=6 Fn½

^3fsWXZYV|ZfZ¶¢fZc¦fZl ÒUafZe cqfmWXZY^%ooYlh YG_GW^qYieEcq[\U1^3fZl I UafZe%Hkw¦XZYoY _ OU1fZe _ HzUaoY«EYGeUaoZ^%WoUao^3`j 6 C^3gq|ZoY lXZc¦l¯Url_XZY[U1W^%_ aYol^3cafcaxWXZY«[dceEY`BeZc1[Ua^3f 6±u f¼ ^=6 Fn½ oYhEoYlYfnWlWXZY¡lcq|Eo_Y¡[UagqfZYW^3_¤ZY`3e^3fnWYfZl^%WjOeZ|ZY¨Wc wZ¦XZ^%_X_kU1fY_ca[hZ|WYe|Zl^3fZg´WXEY ^3caW£ µ Uk1UaoW`!Uk ¼ V$6i^Shn½ wZUal¦eZYl_o^% YGeV^%fª ¬c6

µ ^3fZ_GY¤hZocaZ`3YG[·¼ ^=6 Fn½ Y`%cqfZgqlWc¯WXEY¤_`3Uall¨¼ ^=6½ ¦^WXÍeU]WU \ C \ 1 \ o UafZe= oYG`!U1WYe\Wc nj\eE^%© YoYGfnW^!U]W^3cafcqo`3^%fZY^%fnWYgaoU1W^3cqf)wnY¤_kU1f\WXZYGoYx>cqoY¤|ElYWXZYYkUa¶«x>cqo[|Z`!U1W^3cqfV¼ ^=6 Vq½ x>cqoUfZ^WYYG`3Y[dYfnWplca`3|EW^3cqfrnj ¨Ua`3YGo¶¢^3freE^3l_GoYW^3ÉU1W^%cqf)wEUa__GcqoeZ^%fZg´Wc«WXZY¨eZ^%l_GoYGWYx>cqo[·¼ ^=6An½6

­ fZ_GYWXEYQh caWYfnW^3Ua`3l ÑU1fZe XUkqYiYYGfÇ_cq[dhZ|EWYe njtlcq`3|W^3caftcax¡[dceZYG`¯¼ ^=6 Fn½ w¦U1fZe_cafZlYG¥ |EYfnW`jQWXZY¯YG`3eZl UafZe _ UaoY´¶¢fZc¦f)w$gq`%cqUa`Ô¥¢|UafnW^W^%Yl¤caxhZXnj l^%_kUa`B^%fnWYoYl£W¨_kUafYWXEYfÇYl£W^3[U1WYe)wbx>cqoYEUa[dhZ`3YWXZY dÎ À / À ¾ Î 26 ¨^qYGfÇU[\U1WYo^!Ua`¦eZcq[Ua^%f ) wUall|Z[d^3fZg´WXU1W _ ^3lb`3^%fZYkU1o`%jdoY`!U]WYeOWc ÂwEWXZYWcaWUa`-[\UagafZYGW^3_¤YGfZYogajrlWcqoYGeV^%f eZ|EY¨Wc ^3l

D

V

_ C WED

V

H C W I ¼ ^=6 ½

u f²Ë~XU1hEWYGo wM[dc eZY`p¼ ^=6 Fn½ ¦^%`3`±Y\UahEhZ`3^%YeWclcq[YdWYGlW¯_UalYGl´UafZe[\UagafZYGW^3_«YfZYGogq^%Ylzcqf[U1WYGo^!U1`ZeZcq[Ua^3fElM¦^3`3`Y¦WXZYpoYx>YoYGfZ_Ygq`3caUa`¥¢|UafnW^W^%Yl±_cq[dhZ|EWYedx>ocq[ cq|Eo T lcq`%|EW^%cqf)w^3frcaoeZYGo~Wc´_Gcq[hZUaoYWXZY^%o~1Ua`3|EYl~¦^WXÍWXEYcqfZYlbYGlW^3[U1WYGer¢j\caWXEYofZ^WY¤YG`3YG[YGf¢W[YWXZc eZl 6

V

Page 36: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

L±LdL MSJ MSP QN N uBSSj %$'& 6 ¥-=$#p ¥2/2/$2

~ocqUaeZ`%jslh YUa¶¢^3fZgZwpeZ^©-YGoYfnW^!Ua`[c eZY`%l\_UafÇ Y¦o^%WWYfÇ^%ftWXZYQgaYfZYGoUa`x>cao[ ¼9= ½ D w¦XZYGoY ^%lU a ¤ ¾ À a$¸ ¾ a ¾ w oYhEoYlYfnWl na/ UafEe,=^%lWXZY ¿]Á¹ / À.6Bu fÍWXZY¤oYGhZoYGlYGfWU]W^3caficax~UÍhZXnjl^3_Ua`BhZocaZ`3YG[ÈnjU ]¸¹ Ónº3 [\U1WXZY[U1W^3_kU1`$x>cao[ÈY«^3fnWoceE|Z_Y1w)XZc~YqYGowhYoW|ZoZU1W^%cqfZlzUafZeU1hZhZock^3[U1W^3cqfZl 6 YfZYGoUa`%`%jaw$WXZY\cah YGoU1Wcqo ^%l¡[dc eZY`%`3Yenj U1fZeWXEYeU1W|Z[ ^%lUahZhEock^3[U1WYGeinj 6¨» XZYoYGx>cqoYaw^x =^%lWXZY´YEUa_Wlcq`%|EW^%cqficaxBWXZY«UahZhEock^3[U1WYGe[dceZYG` ¼ = ½ D WXZYeZ^%© YoYfZ_GY D = =voYGhZoYGlYGf¢Wl¦XU]WYV_Uaft_Ua`3`WXZY \ Á À Î ¾+¾ ¾6b» XEYf)w eZYhYfZeE^3fZgcqfVWXZYeZ^%l_GoYGW^3ÉU1W^%cqfO[YWXZc eiUafEeVWXEY_ca[hZ|WU1W^3cqfUa`%gqcqo^WXZ[wEYUa`%lcOXUkqY«WcrWU1¶aYd^3fnWcO_cafZl^%eZYoU1W^%cqfQWXZY ]¸¹ Óa/ À a ¾+¾ ¾ ,D = ¦XZYGoY ^3lWXEYUahZhEock^3[U1WYGerlcq`%|EW^%cqfÍcax ¼ = ½ D 6B» XZYWcaWUa`-YGoocqo^3lWX¢|ZlWXZYl|Z[ÃcaxÔcaWXÍWXZY[dceZYG`3`%^3fZgUafZe_ca[hZ|WU1W^3cqfU1`-Yoocqol°

D = D ¼ = = ½ v ¼ =v ¤½ D v I ¼ w)6 ½

u fWXZ^3l¡~cao¶(wB~YÍ^%fnWYfEeWci^%f¢aYl£W^3gqU1WY\WXZYÍ_Gcq[hE|EWU1W^3cqfZUa`BYoocqoGwBeZcq[d^3fUafnWzhUao£W¯cax¦WXEYYoocqo¡¦XZYfWXZY_cq[dhZ|EWU1W^%cqfUa`B[dceEY` ¼ = ½ D ^3lzU .l|®_G^3YGf¢W`%j|/gacc eUahEhZock^3[U1W^%cqfcaxWXEY¡Y+EUa_GWp[dceZYG` ¼ = ½ D 6 YGoYawWXZY¡UahZhZoc^%[\U1WYerlcq`3|EW^3cqf ^3lb^3fnWYfZeZYGeVWcdY¤WXEY¨ZfZ^%WYY`%Y[dYfnW´lcq`3|EW^3cqf6= Ocax¦WXZYÍ1Uao^3U1W^%cqfUa`Bx>cqo[ ¼ ^$6 Vn½ wBcqEWUa^3fZYGe³nj³lcq` ^3fZgWXZYreZ^%l_oYGWYÍx>cqo[¼ ^$6 Aq½6³Ï x>|EW|EoYrWUal¶x>cqo«UQgq`3caUa`YGoocao«UafUa`jl^3l¯¦^%`3`YrWXZYGfsWcÂ^%fnqYl£W^%gnU1WYOcaWXZYo«YGoocao_caf¢Wo^%Z|EW^%cqfZl 6u fcq|Zo[dceEY`/w ¦XZ^3_X^3fnacq`%aYl¨lYqYoUa`±lWYhZl¨cax[c eZYG`3`3^%fZgUafZe_cq[dhZ|EWU1W^%cqf)wWXEYblcq|Zo_YGlc1x .h YGoW|ZoU]W^3caf /¨Uao^%lY^3f¯xUa_WB^3f´[dceEY`3`%^3fZgpcaxeU1WU¤U1WB[dcqoY`3YqY`%lp¼_Gcq[hE|EWU1W^3cqfcax weZ^3l_oYW^%ÉkU1W^3cqfÍc1x x>cqoWXZY YG|Z[UafZfr_cafZeZ^%W^3cqfElw ¥ |ZUaeZoU]W|ZoYcax 0 C x>cqo~WXEY ^3o^3_XZ`%YGW_cqfEeZ^%W^3cqfZl ½ Ual~YG`3`)U1lf¢|Z[YGo^%_kUa` _cq[dhZ|EWU1W^%cqfQ¼ ¡Ua`%Yo¶ ^%ffE^%WYY`3YG[YGfnWbeZ^3l_oYGW^%ÉkU]W^%cqf)wZ`%^3fZYUaol£jl£WYG[ lcq`%|EW^%cqf ½6

Ë~cafZl^%eZYo¦fZc WXZY À *´3\ À ¾+¾ ¾

D = = \ ¼ w)6 a½

¦XZYGoY=\^3lMWXZYpYEUa_GWlcq`3|EW^3cqf´c1xU_YGoWU1^3f«[c eZYG`UafZe)= ^%l±WXZYbfZ^WYbY`%Y[dYfnWlcq`%|EW^%cqf 6 oocaoYl£W^%[\U1WYl´cax¯¼ w:6 q½ hZoc ^3eZYUQ[dYkUal|ZoYrcaxpWXEYVU1__|EoUa_j²UafZe²lWUaZ^%`3^%WjcaxpWXZYÍZfZ^%WYrY`3YG[YGfnWlca`3|EW^3cqf 6y» XZYGjO_UafVY¨gq^%aYfO^3frWcdx>cao[dlwUal ¡¸ ¾ / ¾ U1fZe ¸¿* ¾ / ¾ ~¿da¿ 6

Ï hEo^3cao^yYGoocqoYl£W^3[U1WYl¤x>cqod¼ w)6 a½ UaoY´Y+hZoYGllYGe^3fQWYo[dlcax±WXEYdY+EUa_GW¡lca`3|EW^3cqf)w-lcrWXU]WWXEYGjV_kUafiga^%qYz^3fEx>cao[U1W^%cqfUa ca|EWoYgq|E`!Uao^%WjOhZocqh YGoW^3YlcaxMWXZYY+ZU1_GWlcq`3|EW^3cqfVUafZeVWXZY¯caoeZYGocax±_GcqfnqYogqYfE_Y«caxMWXZYfZ^WYzY`3YG[YGfnW¤[dYGWXEce 6 ^%© YoYfnW`jrx>ocq[ WXEYzx>cqo[YGow U\h calWYGo^%cqo^ÔYl*W^%[\U]WYl~UaoYY+hZoYGllYGe^%fÍWYo[l~caxÔeU1WUwE[dYlXOl^3ÉY¨U1fZeÍfZ^WY¤YG`3Y[dYfnW¦lcq`3|EW^3cqf-w^ 6 Y 6 WXZYjrUaoYeZYfZYeQnjV¥¢|UafnW^W^3YGlWXU1WUaoYUa`3` ]¸¹ Ónº3 6¦» XZY¯`3U1WWYo¦W|Zoficq|EWpWc\ Yz|ZlYx>|Z`CWc\l|EgqgqYl£WcqhYoU1W^qYr_o^%WYo^3UVWc^%[hZocqY\WXZYOlcq`%|EW^%cqf³Ua_G_|ZoUa_Gj³nj³l|Z__GYll^%aYl£WYhEldc1xpZfZ^%WYrY`3YG[YGfnW_kU1`3_|E`!U1W^3cqf^3frU ;k h º hZoc_GYll¦oYlcaoW^%fZgWc´¶ fEc¦fcqohEoYG ^%cq|Zl`j\_Gcq[dhZ|EWYGeO^3fEx>cqo[\U]W^3caf 6

V

Page 37: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

u fOWXZ^%lb_kUalYaw(fZcdU´hZo^%cqo^)^%fEx>cqo[\U1W^3cqfcaxyWXZY¨YEUa_Wlcq`3|W^3cafOUaoY¨oYG¥¢|Z^3oYe 6

u fÇU1f nn¸a fZ^WYVY`3YG[YGfnWÍ[dYGWXEce)w¦Uhcql£WYo^3cqo^¦Yoocqo\YGlW^3[U1WYGlrUaoYV|ZlYGe ^3fZl^3eZYU_ca[hZ|WU1W^3cqfU1` hEoc _YeE|ZoYWXU1WM_GcqfZl£Wo|E_GWl±UZfZ^%WY~Y`%Y[dYfnWBeZ^%l_GoYGW^3ÉU1W^%cqfzx>cqoyUgq^qYf´hEocqZ`%Y[Ua_G_cqoeZ^3fZg´Wc«WcdUal^%_¨cq ÆY_W^qYlª ¬ °¼U ½ WXZY¨YoocqobcaxÔWXZY¡UahEhZock^3[U1WYlcq`3|W^3cafr`3^3YGl¦^%WXZ^3fOU´gq^qYfOWca`3YoUafZ_GY ¼ ½ WXZYdZfZ^%WYYG`3Y[dYfnW¡lca`3|EW^3cqfÂ^3l¨cqEWUa^3fEYe¢jU¼fZYUao`j ½ [d^3fZ^%[\U1`yf¢|Z[¯Yo¡caxeEYgqoYYlzcax

x>oYYeEcq[ 6j«_GcqfZeZ^W^3cafi¼U ½ ~YoY¥¢|Z^%oY¦WXU]WWXZY[dYGWXZc e^%l ¾ Ánº3 w¢UafZenj_GcqfZeZ^W^%cqfV¼ ½ WXU]W~^W^%lUa`3lc !"#$%#&%%'()%+*#(","-."#/(0%,132%4(-56(723,,298:#1 <; 7= 13,23%,

>'?23@(AB42%4+B442%4C"D(-E(AFG,2H8IB4C(A%#JK13)%"#L(A23,"4%#"MN(AO*#(PB,B-EB#Q(GD23,RS(A2%#."2%#"4D"%B"R4(AUT%#V(AW%,13234X(A-YD(23'[Z ]\ ("4@8:M,2^%,B44D234E#(234.%4D"2%-E'RS(A">23#K-."D>"#/(AX(AB$T_B,"-."#/("M`#2^"BMa2%4 "13B[bc7_""AZd7234 LeD,2S"%,f&-.'42H)3B-EB#/(2%76(gD23,RS(A2%#h%B"R4%Bij/iP4B*#"-."#/(kbc"234D4"(A23#U2%7:D",BB("UB#Q(("l23#h8:[h(gB442%4#"(A234.4BR,X(Am,%41% on "1/4#1h(A"M8pF%#D(#1%RDq"DB#Q(r%,,i>(A4"F4DB*#"-."#/(%''42/%[""s

tGu^vxw y`zg MB"4"%2%7|(A","-."#/(:~"t!vxw y`zg MS#"4D%Dl27|(234D"46#m(A'!23,XiS#23-E%,4B'4B"#/(A(A23#G2%7<(2%,R(23#t&wkvxw y`zg M-E2H)3B-EB#/(kbB2344D"B(23#G2%7<#2^'?2%(23#

\ #".(AE4*#"-."#/( '42^""R4E%d!"B#U'!"4D72%4-."h2%#j(Ag-."zM&DR"B"D)%G%#U-.234%B"R4(Ad*#(","-."#/(+D23,R(23#&(AB#PB23-.'R(ABFR#1g(#8*#X(A2%#2%7( "1%4"B2%7<74"B23- I; #$(Al'4BB#Q(N'%'!"4:8Il"%,8:(A t 4DB*#B-EB#/(0("[#QR"#&#W^"B(23# 8pl8:,,z"B4?2H8(BiGH)%!"B#'',"m(2.*#(AB,B-EB#Q(:-."D" &%#/iC%R(234DT ;[ %RcMS Nn "-!23,("M nl #M hBD"4"M \ N "#^B8:"~%M

N 2%#2%#M n! B4D7R4@(AM ,%B4D(xi3M?%#FD23-.d2%("4D[Z0)% D(ARBF%%'S(A)%d*#X(A", t"-."#/(d-E(A2^""2%4#1&(2F'!23D("4234`B442%4d#"(A234D"D(-E(ABh/ij?"4D"#/(B4("4Dr SBE4DB7"4D"#B"m M|^M|^MH M|¡¢M|¡S%M 3M ¡^M % M£/¤c¥a#M¦7234$-.234D "23-.',(A,D("M(A23#BQR2%("$#j§ M!¡ M£3¤c¥ 0-E2%#1C(A23#Bl%?2H)%E-."#/(A23#BM(A*4DD(C'?23@(AB42%4=B442%4"D(-E(A2%4%?B"#PR1 t13BD(ABh/i Rc$%# %#W#F(AE %¢ ; #P(("%(AB442%4+86%l"2%-E'RS(A"F74D23-¨(A

2%,R(23#&2%7`f3'!"4D(R4!"fm,2^%,)%4Dr(23#,'423,"-."M!8:"4D4BR%,<^R%#/(A(B+%''!4"O(Ah7234m(AF"44D234C-.2SB, C"U%G?B"#LRD"©4"B"#/(A,Xiª7234m@([(WB,BB(A4D23-E%13#(A-.2SB,#ª¡^M=¡3H¥M=%#h7234l"iP"R4D4"#/( '423,"-.#«¡ ¥ &¬ ?"4B#/(A,iF74D23- %Rc «"M# 23#23#«''423%[hB442%4lBD(-E(ABd%4D'42H)^BU%lR''!"4l!23R#l2%76(."44D234#P'42%'?B4#234D-EdTk­®p­k¯3°M`­®p­±²kMa­®p­[³M!B( ZMz4D",(AB&(A2E4BR%,|^R%#/(A(B02^"BR44D#1g(0(d#/(A"4D234%#m(!23R#4DiE2%7¦(AB,"-."#/("MR'm(2 '42%'?B46"23#D([#Q( a %D"%,,Xi.("D"4D42346BD(-E(AB%4D23(A%#B/iWR#1g(Ad234D(231323#%,X(xiC'42%'?B4D(A"+27(A´%,"4Q#-.B(A2S(2313(AB408:(

3

Page 38: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

D(A%#4g*#(A","-."#/(p#/(AB4'!23,r(23# BD(-E(AB"MS%#E(Bi.4D"QR4D+%#E"@(A-E(23#2%7@([%,X(xi7_%(A234D"M8:[&"%#&!23(A%#"G/iG23,X)S#1 !w 2^"(ABC(A2 (A#(r%,!23# 0"B234#1(A2(ABl13R",#"BM#C(A# ^(ND"B(23#G8p S("#23-.l%413R-EB#Q(:'423'!23D"

# H Mp¡S"¥:7234",%D"%,<232%#q'4D23,B-EBMp(2h'4D29)%D23-E&j'!23@(A"4D234D"@(A-E(".2%7T ¡%Z7234(A*#(.B,B-EB#Q(lD23,R(23#F276-.2SB,:T_£ ¡%¢3Z N-E#1G((A"M8pEB23#"4(gD(4A%(74A-E8I234Dm'4D"B#/(A"&# %'S(A"4£

! "! #$%%&'( *),+- ./00#B4+(A/i^'?2(AB"%#P#2%(A(A23#+#/(A42^RB"O#jSBB(23#O£ ¡SM8p.H)%"B#j(((A

-.2SB,'4D23,B- T£ HZ %#.%,X86i^`?%D2^"rc(A" (2+)%4Dr(23#,^7234D- T£ ¢/Z<8:((A:,#%47234D-21E%#m(A,#%4a7R#B(23#%,43:B*#"$#PT£ 3ZI%#PT£ %9ZM^8:[GI"QR)%,"#/(6(2$T_£ Z 5B(+("4DB7234D76O?(A %B(D23,RS(A2%#2%70T£ ZMz2%([%#"&7423- (A23,R(A23#986O2%70T£ H¢/Z0#4B,r(23#T_£ 3Z S-E,r%4D,i3M%,B(6!:?(A0D"4DB(AN23,R(A23#MQ"23-.'R("g74D23- (A´l%,"4D^#.*#(","-."#/(:2%,R(23#;86!:l2%7T£ H¤/Z6%#G(AlB*#X(A23#

6!:=<>86!:?@86BADC :E T Z

8:B4F86GADC :E(AE'42IHD"B(23#P2%7J86GAL#O(A.*#X(A t -."#2%#%, D'%BLKNM:OC PRQTS>UWV TYX V EXZZ+2%77R#(A23#I((:%4D"23#/(#QR23R2%#[X V #[XZHM'""8:DB*#"$'?23,Xi^#23-.r%,a27<2%4B4\d2H)3B4[W","-."#/(N#]B: N04B1/%4^6F#_6!:d#$(d234D13#%,?-E2^","M8pdRD(A%-El,#%47234D-,1%aB*#"C#T_£ /ZkM^%#g#/(A42^RBl7R#(A23#%,` 2%([%#"742%-,36#T_£ 39Z=R[g(Ac(

`zTYaSZb< TdcGEeaSZ"fG?hg#ijEea&klPImn?ogNpqEraklPOQRE sBaut U Vv C POw TdX:Zyx T £/Z

iCB23#@(A4RB(A23#M8pQ#2H8J(A(6&A(D*"T_£ ZkM 1?Tz6EeaSZ<|`zTYaSZyE sBat U Vv C PIw TYX:ZyE T %Z

(A2%13B("48:( (A:#23# t 23-.2313B#"2%R ¬ 4D[,B(=B23#X(A23#=23#T~AO%#T~HMQ#T6!::Ac(A@*"`(A"4DB(72%4-1!TY6!:Eea:cZ<`zTYa:9ZyE sBa:tK M: x T Z

00#"4(A"l'4D"-.B"M74D23- T %Z6%#hT ZI(72%,,2H8:Bs

NI!BzIzG&# u y` x g wkwecw T ¡%Z y6 u cw u%r( Y! !we[ w Y1!T®Era:cZ<J¢jE sBa:tK M: x T %Z

; #X©8pl#2H8]#/(42^R"+(723,,2H8:#1 w

£

Page 39: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

\N<^T#6?Z;c!E T 3Z

%D2^"rc(A"C(2.(7R#B(23#%,

gT\IEea&k^< 1!TY6!: EeaSZ©TdcGEeaSZ"fogTi(Eea&k POmogNp4EeaklPOQ T ¤3Z

7234"%[ aTt U Vv C PIw TdX:Z "#

4 cw %aTt UWVv C PIw TdX:Z$a:NtWK M: u% g#\Erak^<^1!T®EeaSZ Eg#\Era:k^<J¢E T H¢/Zg#\Erak^<7gT\IEeaFa:k x

weO *4DD(l23# 723,,2H8:-.-EBrc(A",XiG7423- (A.,#%4D(xi&2%7 1M¦(A.D"B23#h2%# 7423-T Z6#$((A4G23#0 B23423,,r%4@i3MSR(A2(A,#"%4X(xiE27g#\Eek ´)%"#W((A4Dr%#1%R,r(23#[]B:J<"!$#&%QM,B((' !d(A DB(2%77_""27I,,|",B-EB#/(A# tF] : l; #

(A723,,2H8:#1MS72340%#/iG7_%"c t)' ?(x8IB"#O.(B(4A%B42%#*#,+- #X(A%H%B"#/(.#0/- M!%#W#Qi1 t2 Z T #,+-43 #5/- ZkM!8pB#2%(d/i 1 +- %# 1 /- (A,-EX(6)%,RBN2%7 1 23#_cP742%- (Al(x8I2mDB2%76# +- %#7# /- M4D"'!"(AX)3",Xi3M%#$/iF 1 ¥ - (AHDR-E'C27 1 %"4D23c#m(A4BB(A23#m2%7|(AR#()3BB(234 j#234-E%,z(2Tc<MB*#"&Qi

1 +- < ,-8:9 v; 1 T=<??>.<ZyE 1 /- < ,-8:9 vA@ 1 TB<C>.<ZyE s0< tcGE 1 ¥ - < 1 +- 1 /- x T 39Z

D02H8(:'!23D,+(A2B-E2%#D(4A((723,,2H8:#1 '!23D("4D234D"4D4234BD(A-gc(A+7234lT ¡%Zs

EGF !H I4J% u hz wd > cw u LK wM jy` xU gg wkwecw T ¡3Z ] u N w !we T_£ Z y6N u R PO 0!w[ w YQ u w lSR3z UT k¢ RcwO u u

­S®­ ³C fCV T ­ 8W,X ­ ¯%°SY fZ E T 9¡3Z

O u w 8W < 8W T=[?Z7 X < X T=[?Z w u z_ [[ O H y`z h u g # u u

8W]\ ^ < W_^ T ZX4\ ^ < \ .`^TaJ6!:9Z;c \ ? W / Vb Z^ &9T=#Z / Vb Z]c ^ E

O u Wd^ <Lr%-&TB#ZM$

Page 40: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

c ^ <ª­ ^ TD #6!: I¦¥,_pZ+­ ¯3°SY ^ POQ Z T £QZ? ­ ^ #6!:(R¦¥­ ¯%°SY ^ YPOPOQAZ:Z ?o­ #6!: I Fim­ ¯3° Y ^ PImZ E

O u w ! ^ % ^ :% BN% w w E u% HO n u O g u ¢ g ^ gJRcw _#t ]B: O u ^ ? ^ < # #u w [_

weO .B-E23#D(A4(A23#F"P23#O(AB,"-."#/(x8:."B23-E'!23D(A23#F2%7a(A#Q("134%,*##1u1E%#[`m/im(A(4%#13R,(A23#u]B: ` 4DD("M8I8:4D(A

g pqEea&klPOQ <- - PRQ pa!#" E T 93Z

*#

1 ^ TY6EeaSZb< ^ #6 P#a$! <bE sBaTt U Vv C PIw TdX:Z E T Z

%#$"2%#"4(AlDB(B"23-.'?2%(23#

% #L<T % #'& ~AZ 3 T % #(& ~*)pZ 3 T % #(&~qZ 3 T % #'+lTd~ 3 ~qZZyx T 93Z

B#M8I)3

gT\IEea&k|< ^,, - 1 ^ Tz6G:EeaSZLT c!EeaSZ ^ 'g#ijEea&k ^ PIm/.

- , gNpqErak - POQ<0

^,, - T^T#6!:9Zc!EeaSZ ^ ?|g % 6!:21 %43 i(Eeak ^ PIm?g % 6!:1 %43 Eea&k ^ P .

- g pqEea&k - POQ<0

^,, - T^T#6!:9Zc!EeaSZ ^ ?|g #6!:(R FijErak ^ PIm . T H /Z

? - , - g #6!: I¦¥ - pqEea&k - POQ ?g #6!: I¦¥ - Eea&k - YPOPOQ Z .

<0^,, - T^T#6!:9Zc!EeaSZ ^ ?|g #6!:(R FijErak ^ PIm?g5 ^ TD #6!: I¦¥d_p!ZyEea&k ^ POQ ?|g6 ^ aJ6G: I¥ Erak ^ YPIPRQSZ . E

8:B4]! ^ % ^ , DB(`2%7!8IB13/(a[23B#ED2((a¢ g ^ gJ7234`%,, #t ] :/MQ#7 ^8 ?9 ^ < 7_#,!%# #:p%4I%H%B"#/( 23#"4D#1N#2H8 (6(A44B,r(23##GT ¢/ZMc(A R[/i t S[/864D(A~#"QR%,(xiC#C(A-.23#2%(23#/im'4D23'?B4D(xiC7234#/(A"1%4A%,"MS8pl23([#

Page 41: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

\ g#\Erak \ V ^ ­0^T a#6!:9Z cK­ ¯%°SY ^ Z ­(a a:­ ¯3°SY ^ Z? ­ #6!: O Fip­ ¯%°SY ^ P m Z ­(a a:­ ¯3°Y ^ Z T H¤/Z? ­ ^ T aJ6!:I¥,_p!Z­ ¯3° Y ^ PRQSZ ­(aG a:­ ¯3°SY ^ Z? ­ ^ a#6!: I¥%­ ¯ ° Y ^ YPIPRQSZ:Z ­jaG a:­ ¯ ° Y ^ Z x

68p27R#%-."#/(A%,?#"QR,(BaH)%N(A"#g(2?0RBC23#mB,"-."#/( #C#g(A"4p?2%R#%4@iT_B H M£ ¥rZ E*4DD(23#.l&,2S"%, )%"4D23#h2%7I( w [E z Y T¡ Zsl13)%"#UC7R#(A23# t UWV TB#ZI(AB4ySD(A0 "23#D([#Q( T ^ C v kª¢R[$(Ac(

­ ­ ¯3°SY ^ Z V T ^ C v - W5/ Vb Z^ ­ ­ ¯3°SY ^ Z ? W Vb Z^ ­ ­ ¯3° Y ^ Z . x T ¡%¢/Z

E"B23#U2%#El&",%D"%,4BR,X(74D23- #/(AB4'!23,rc(A2%#W(AB234Di!sd"#2%("U/i X ^ (AER#2%#2%7`(A.B,23DR4 27pB,B-EB#Q(%H%B"#/((A2$%#/i",B-EB#/(]#M7234%#/i&7R#B(23# t U V TdX ^ Z("4DySD(A"23#D([#Q( T ^ C V kª¢72348:[

­ YaZ T !: Z0­ ¯ ° Y ^ ZaV T ^ C V W / ^ ­ Y Z ­ ¯ ° Yf Z E T ¡S9Z

7234 < ¢jEE#< Ek¡^M68:"4D!: .(AW#2S,0#Q("4D'?23,%#/(m2%7 c(m#2^"g2%7NX ^ M68:( Y v Z < %# Y V Z < =; #&'%4D("R,r%4BM(72%,,2H8:­ aG!:Oa&­ ¯3°Y ^ Z V T ^ C V Wd^ ­ Ja&­ ¯3°SYf Z T ¡3¡3Z­ &TYa !:aSZ0­ ¯%° Y ^ ZaV T ^ C V ­ Ja&­ ¯3°Y f Z EB#"­a !:Oa$­ ¯3°SY ^ Z V T ^ C Z W Vb Z^ ­ #a$­ ¯3° Yf Z T ¡ Z

8:( T ^ C Z <]¡ T ^ C v T ^ C V hRD((ARS(A0(:*4@(I#"QR%,(xi 27`T ¡3¡%Z`#FT ¡ Z=#T H¤/ZkMS#4BR-.l%,,?(A"2%#D(A%#/(A:(A223(A%#

\ g#\IEeak \ V T Y v Z ^,, W_^ ­0 T#6!:9Z 7cl­ ¯3° Y ^ Z ? W Vb Z^ - ­ ^ #6!:, ¥%­ ¯%°SY ^ YPOPOQ Z Z

? ­ ^ T aJ6G:_ ¦¥d_p!Z!­ ¯3°Y ^ POQ Z ? ­ #6!:d * ia­ ¯3°SY ^ PIm&Z . ­_#a:­ ¯3°SYf Z T ¡£QZ

7234F"2%#D(A%#/( T Y v Z k ¢ "#Ma8I$"2%#"4(G-E23#2%(A23#/ih'423'!"4@(xiU7234(G#/(AB134A(23#23-E%#lX ^ S X+M(AR''!"4:!23R#

V 1# V V 1 Z Vb

ZE s 1#L¢E D< Ek¡(ERxRxRxyE 3 E T ¡33Z

Page 42: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

8:[C23,I7234ID23-.+"23#D([#Q( kª¢M%I8p",,z%I(+!23R# 1 Z ? 3 Z V Td1 ? 3Z Z V ¡1 Z ?q¡3 Z72340%,,1%E!3 ©¢ 7 (AB40D23-El4"%44%#13B-EB#/(M!Qi$#Q(42^R(A2%#&2%7 (Al13,2%%,#2%(A(A23#dT Z%#hT £/ZM8p13B(

\ g#\IEea&k \ V T Y V Z ­ 8W X ­ ¯%°SY fZ ­dJa­ ¯3°SYf Z T ¡ Z

72346("23#@([%#/( T Y V Z < ¡ T Y v Z "#zM8pl[2S2% aJ<J®%#GRDl("QR%,(xi

\ g#\EA®k \ <5­S®=­ Z³C f E T ¡33Z

23(A%#"+742%-J(A=*4@(<BQR(A23##.T H¢/Z |2B23#B,RMH8I`"2%#"4(`"QR)%,"#B?(x8IB"##234D-E­S®=­ ³C f %#>­_E®=­ ¯3°SYfZ ; #$'%4@(A"R,%4"M^7423-

/ ­_E®=­ Z¯ ° YfZV ­S®­ Z³C f T ¡% /Z

8p13((AR''?B4!23R#&#C2Z t #234-

­_E®=­ ¯3°Y fZ V 8T ­ 8W,X ­ ¯3°SYfZ T ¡%¤/Z

8:( 8T < T Y V Z 1 a\ #$(2%(AB4:%#M74D23- ­_E®=­ Z¯ ° YfZ ­S®­ Z³C f T ¢/Z

4B,r(23#PT 9¡3Za*#%,,Xim23,"MQiG[2S23D#1 T < T Y V Z 1 %!29)%dBD(A-gc(A2%#&23# X]2H8:N((0(A"#B41%i&#234D- 2%7(Al*#X(Al",B-EB#/(NB442%4N t'!"#`23# (:4"DR%,((#/(AB4234=2%7!","-."#/(ABMQ#'42%'?234@(A23#%,Q86i (2+(A:-."D~" W_^ M

%8IB,,|%0(l4"DR%, c(0(d#Q("4 t ","-."#/(bHDR-.'2%7=(l#234-E%,¦B4)()%2%7 (Al23,R(A23#M#$ '4D23'?2%4D(A23#%,!86iC(2 W Vb Z^

234:(A#QR-."4D,|B23-.'R([c(A2%#&2%7:T 9¡3Z6(x8I2g-.'?234@([%#/(%D'?BB(+)3l(A2g!dB23#DB4" a*4@( 23#pB23#"B4#|(A`8p"1%Q( ^ %''?"%4#1:#(Ap'%4@8:DaB23#/(A4DR(23#<"42%|",B-EB#/(7_%B" N,X(A23R13W%##*#(Al#QR-!"402%7)%,RB0"%#W! %D1%#"(2E("-$M?X(NNB23#/)3"#"#/(+(2*#0("-5#EDR[C86i(Ac(p(0B2344D"D'?23##1l(AB4-.a#.(NR''?B4p!23R#FT 9¡%Z!"B23-.%+D-g,,<%+'!23D, D-.',BD(N[23B(A2m(A%%( ^ < 13¡SM? (2C"23#DB4%# v w _ 2%7(A+"4D42346B23#/(A4DR(23#ER+(2HDR-.'62%7(+#234D-g,?B4X)%c(A)% J?((AB46[23"M2H8pB)3B4"M|N(2CB*#.m?"4D"#/(8IB13/(74D23- B,B-EB#Q((2C","-."#/(M(A%Q#1m#/(A2G%B"23R#/((A13B23-E(A4@iW2%7p(A'4D23,B-¨2%-g%#Mz('?23D, B23#/(A#QRX(xiW2%7p(AXzR2%#F"2^ .""#/(G%B423D",B-EB#/(A"M%N8p",, %+,2S"%,<!"H)^23R4N2%7`(Ad*#(","-."#/(2%,R(23#UT_ 1 134%B#/(A"MB( Z .n "1/%4D#1m(A"M¦C'?2%, #23# t R#7234D- B*#X(A23#F2%7a(A 8p"1%Q( ^ DR1313BD(ABh#(A72%,,2H8:#1 B234B- ¡

Page 43: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

D""2%#>T_B4RBr%,rZ6%'!"(N(A2.'42H)^l%#&%''423'4Dr("D(-E(A23#C2%7<(A"2%#D(A%#/(A T%# 8T '4D2S2%7a2%7` "234D"- DR1313BD(A2H8 (A2mB23-.'R(A("-$Mz/iW("4N4D",rc(A2%#&8:((A+"23#D([#Q(%''!4#1d#E(A(A4A"%#m#/(AB4'!23,rc(A2%#E#"QR%,("0T ¡¢/Za#PT ¡S9Z D0) t"4@(AB,B"M<R[h"D(-E(AB8I23R,P? (A2^2$,r%4D13 54'!"4l"D(-E(A23#W(A%#T H¡3ZN4Ac(AB423(A%#">/i>"'%4A(#1O(A$B23#/(A4DR(23# 2%7N(G#/(AB42%44BR%,.%# (HDR-E'.27N(A#234D-g,IB4)()%G%"4D23 (A$B,B-EB#Q( 7_"" 8:X(A>#/(A4D2SRB(23#K2%7(x8p2jXzB4B#Q(B23#@([%#/(ABM#D(A"%$2%7 2%#%M4D"2%4D(A#1 (A2 7B8-E2^X*(23#I#C('4)S23R:B-E23#D(A4(A23# <%Q#1 #/(A2 ""2%R#/((AB+(x8p2.'4A%(A"%,z ."R,X(A""MSd*#B4"4D42346BD(-E(A23#gp(A"#GR1 t13BD(AB/iC-.2S*"(A23#m2%7|(A13,23%,?13"#"4A,R''!"4:?2%R#hT 9¡3ZkM%723,,2H8: EGF !H I4 u hz wd > cw u LK wM jy` xU gg wkwecw T ¡3Z ] u

N w !w T_£ Z _y6 u R PO !we[ w Y N u w SR3a O (T V kq¢ T Zk¢ Rcw O u u­I®.­ Z³C f <5­ Vb Z &TY6 6G:cZ­ Z¯3° YfZ T 9Z

V ^ T V ­_ / Vb Z W_^ T .^T#6!:9ZcZ­ Z¯3° Y ^ Z

? T Z - - Y ^ YPOPOQAZ:Z ­zT+#?L/?Z/ Vb Z W Vb Z- aJ6!:I¥ - ­

Z¯%°SY - Z

? - Y ^ POQ Z ­zT + ?L / Z / Vb Z W Vb Z- T a#6!: I¥ - _p!Z!­ Z¯ ° Y - Z

? - Y ^ P m Z ­+T / Vb Z W Vb Z- TaJ6!:IC i3Z!­ Z¯3°SY - Z . E

O u w Wd^ W - xE u $ g [#c y`z W_^ < r-TB#ZT W - <%-$T cZ Rcw u] [ c #5 Rcw #t ]B: O u w + G / x u N ¦ u [ c # kwe I x w cw SR3x w cwpw [_BN% q [ cw T %9Z weO FB-E23#D(A4(A23#g-.,%4(A2U(AF23#F2%7 "2%4"- F7R#%-."#/([%,

XzB4"#""23#@(A#G('!"B*"(A23#G2%7¦(A8p"13/(A ^ %#$#G ?"4D"#/(:B*#(23#C2%7|(A"2%#D(A%#/( 7_%B(234 N13%#M=8pC"2%-E'RS(Ang \IEea k P; #K(AC,%D(41%Q(%#>m2%7B^R(A23#T H 3Z8pC%#>X)Sm#K-R,X(A',iO/i4 Vb Z (C%"#.4DB7B44BU(A2 # %# % # & ~*)0M`#-R,X(A',i$%#F)^d/i W Vb Z^ (A%B#47"44D"F(A2 % #7&~*):M % #5&n~q# % #5+Td~ 3 ~qZ B#M8I*#(A8p"1%Q( ^ #/(A4D2SR"B&#$ "234D"- 2(A(

^ \ - < + + ? / E T ¡3Z

7234.%[V7_%" c©2%7N","-."#/( # L; 7+8I&',(#V(x8p2h7_%B(234(A&B23#/(A4R(23#.2%7 ^ /i>(ARD((ARS(A2%#

¤

Page 44: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

^ < ^ + T 3 Z

8:(9 ^ \ - < + 1T + ?L / ZkM"QRc(A2%#UT ¤/Za([%":(Al-.2^*BC7234-

\ gT\IEea&k \ V ^,, ­ Vb Z TYa a:cZ!­ ¯%°SY ^ Z ­ / Vb Z T .`^T#6!:9Z;cZ0­ ¯%° Y ^ Z

? ­ Vb Z W / Vb Z^ TzaG a:cZ!­ ¯%° Y ^ Z - ­ / Vb Z W Vb Z^ T#6!: I* i3Z­ ¯3° Y ^ POm&Z T £QZ?Y­ ^ W Vb Z^ TD #6!: I¦¥ p!Z!­ ¯ ° Y ^ POQ Z ?Y­ ^ W Vb Z^ aJ6!:I¥%­ ¯ ° Y ^ YPOPOQSZ Z . x

423- T ¡3¡3Z6#UT ¡ Za8p2%([%#m(A#"QR%,("

­ Vb Z TYaG !:OaSZ+­ ¯%° Y ^ ZaV 8T ^ C V W_^ ­ #a&­ ¯%°SY f Z T 3Z­ Vb Z W / Vb Z^ TYa !:OaZN­ ¯%° Y ^ ZaV 8T ^ C Z­ #a$­ ¯3° Yf Z E

8:B4 8T ^ C V < T ^ C V VbZ

C ^ %# 8T ^ C Z < T ^ C Z Vb Z

C ^ M8:(*

C ^ -gS-R- ?R23#C)%,R23# # jl#298"23#"4(AR''?B4!23R#

+ + ?L / g

+ ? / E T Z

%#$',((?2%R#%4@iC"2%#Q(4R(A23#23#$[","-."#/(0%,2%#1(AD#13,+7_%"B a; 7 8p"#2%(/i W - <©%-&T cZ (0D~B02%7%[.7_%" c<MQ7234a%#/i (AB(4A%"4D23# #t ]B:N(AB4yS@(AIlB23#D(A%#/( ^ k©¢"'!"##1.23#$(Al13"2%-E(A4Dim2%7 (l(B(4A%B42%#R[(Ac( W_^ V ^PW - 7234%#/i$7_"c2%7U# ^R"MR-E-E%4~"#1d,,","-."#/([%,!"2%#D(A%#/(A 8T ^ C V %# ^ #Cd1%,23, 8T V M%I8p",,z 8T ^ C Z%# ^ #$ 8T ZM8p23S([%#

\ gT\IEea&k \ V ^ 8T V ­_ / Vb Z W_^ T^T#6!:9Z;cZ­ ¯3°SY ^ Z T 3Z

? 8T Z - - Y ^ YPIPRQAZ:Z ­T + ? / Z / Vb Z W Vb Z- aJ6G: I¥ - ­ ¯ ° Y - Z

? - Y ^ POQ Z ­zT + ?L / Z / Vb Z W Vb Z- TD #6!: I¦¥ - p!Z!­ ¯ ° Y - Z

? - Y ^ PImZ ­+T / Vb Z W Vb Z- T aJ6G: I* i%Z!­ ¯%°SY - Z . ­_Ja­ ¯ ° Y f Z E

%&-.2S*"(A23#F2%7lT ¡c£QZ 01/%#M|8pg[2S23Dua< ®3M %'',XiF"QR,(xiVT ¡33Z%#UB23#DB4!23R#&T ¡ /Z%#T ¢/Z ^#1P"4D>­6®E­ Z³C f #D(A"% 2%7E­6®E­[³C fV%# RD#1O#"QR%,(xiT ¡3%ZM38p*#%,,Xi23(A%# BD(-E(A23#$T 9Z<72%4RX([%,"23#D([#Q( T V k¢%# T Zk¢4",(AB

£/¢

Page 45: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

(A2 8T ZV # 8T ZZ 4"D'?BB()3B,i G´)^#1FW-.234EB(A%,"K#S7234-E(A23#O(A%#U(C13B#"4%,6!23R#JT 9¡%ZM=BD(A-gc(A2%#LT 9Z

298:(Ac((l",B-EB#/([%,B23#/(A4R(23#G2%7<(A"4D4234:Rl(2.(#/(A"4D2344D"DR,:#/)3B4D",i'4D23'?2%4D(A23#%,`(A2 Vb Z %# '423'!234D(23#%,a(2F(ACB,"-."#/(D~"M8:,g(AG,2S"%,IB23#/(A4R(23#23#G(Al","-."#/(0?23R#%4@iC([%#Q(2g""2%R#/(0(B23#/(A#^R(xiC2%7 ?RD23#&%"4D23:(Al7_%B"BM#/)%"4D",Xi'4D23'?2%4D(A23#%,/(2.T + ?L / Z Vb Z %# '4D23'?2%4D(A23#%,/(2+(A6DQR%44D2S2(=2%7(AI7_%"I~B" ; #P(A.'%4@(A"R,%4+E8:X(A2%R(l%#/iO#/(AB4D7_%B"BMT HZB23#""8:(P(EB44D234"D(-E(A

#/(42^R"Bh/i < %a%# %-R",D23#j#V ¥ 4D"'4D"B#/(Ad(E#(234+(Ac(d!""#>RD">#j(Am'4"D"#/( 8p234P7234%%'(AX)3m4DB*#"-."#/('R4D'?23D"BMaD#BG#QR-."4%,p"@(A t-E(A23#F2%7I(."23#@([%#/( T V %# T Zd%l%,4"%iF!"B#hB4)%"U#V§ ¥`?2%(j#P(E¡ ¬ #3¬ "% "D$BD(-E(ABd4BR,X( #P7_%B(%4D'?B4d(A%#U(Ag,r%4D13EB23#@([%#/(A 2%([%#"j7423-(Al(4A%B#&#/(A"4D'?2%,r(23#C#"QR%,(" lR131%"D(")%,R"%4D T V <]¢xX3M T Z <]¢xH72%4(A4Dr%#13,B:%# T V <]¢x¢/SM T Z<]¢x %72%4:(B(4A%B4AT_RD"&"4DHZ p; #&(#y^(+D"(A2%#$8pl8:,,B"4D!(Al%,13234X(A- 2%7 %%'S(A)% W t 4*#B-EB#Q(N%'',Bm(A223R4:-.2S", |2."23#B,R%M%,X(AB4#()%%''4D2/%[B02%7 '?2%D(AB4234?"44D234:"@(A-E(23#mB23R,$!'4D23'?2%"zM

B'?B##1&23#O8:[hQR%#/(AX(xiOB23#"4D"P7234-E"%R4D#1C("44D23423#P( "4M|8pgH)%72^"RD"-g#,Xi2%#(A'R4"4D4234 2%7(A'!2%(AB#/(Ar,M%# 234"4 (2B)%,R(A64BB(,il(A:%B"R4%Bi2%7(A´l%,"4D^#d*#X(AB,"-."#/(D23,RS(A2%#2%7!(AB4B(67234- T_£ H¤/Z|%D2SBr(" (A2-.2^",T_£ 9Z N#&%,X(A"4D#()3B4X(A"4D23#CB23R,$!(A2"@(A-g(+(AB442%423#$(&eD"#"41iSf.*#"&/i

< \ J6 \ Z ! < \ #6!: \ Z !Q< T /Z

234BM?(("4:#G23R4"%8:(G?R23# <=M/i

< \ #6 \ Z !Q< \ J6G: \ Z ! <bE T ¤/Z

7234+B"4@([%#P23-g# S "2%#Q(A%#"O#X 234 X$xM < Ek¡SM4D",(ABW(A2G'/i^"%,=-E(AB4%,2%7<(Al-E2^B, I; #$(Al-E%13#(A23@([('42%,B- T_£ ¡%¢/ZkM#G7_%B("M(A,r(D(A"4B*#X(A23#&:4",(AB(A2ªeD'Qi^D,f$^R%#/(A(xi%M= (g-E%13#B(A "#B41%iªT_£ ¡SHZM|QiP-.%#2%76B*#(A23#gT £Q3Z%# T S9Z %''42/[W8I23R,F! .""#/(72340-E2^",NB4X)3"O/i*",&7234-R,r(23#BMz(:%:?B"#G(A"@(AB#j MH¢c¥ N:B23#"B4#"%,r4'?2%("#/(A%,z7234D-R,(A23#"MQ(Al#B8o*#X(A2%#2%7B44D2340D"B-EN%''4D23'4(A723423-E%#8:"4D23#,Xi '!2%(AB#Q(r%,%4l#/(A4D2SR"BM?,#","(A42%D([c(Aa-.2SB,BM%234<#d-E%13#B(A2%D([c(Aa-.2SB,|)^#1+'!"4D-g#"#/(=-E%13#B(A<R( D23R4B"R44B#/(A a; #$23R4:%D%M("44D234 2SB#2%(:"23#""2%-E',B(",iE8:(G(B?"(A)%B44D2342%7(Ad'/i^%,|-g13#B(l"#B41%i$!""%Rd2%7`_ '?2%("#/(A%,7234-dR,r(23#m((N%N4D"B23R4D#B""DA%4D,XiW(A2$ w [ O'?2(A"#/(r%,#OC'%4D(27p(23-E%#WB23#/([%##1C"R4D4"#/( ; #F(A%M#7_%(M%,2g( "2%#Q(4R(A23#W2%7`(2%R4B*",0%N(A2C!d(A%%B#P#/(A2G%B"23R#/(#(AlBD(-E(A23#m2%7<(A-E%13#(AN"#B41%i

£

Page 46: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

+^ @)> %N/=$),$/ <2GB23#D(4R(%#P%%'()%*#( ","-."#/(23,R(A23#W"P23#O4*#B-EB#Q(l2%7`(-EBM8p

)3C(2F'!""X7 iKF"4D("423#U2%7D",BB(23#K2%7:(C-EB>"#/((A"d(2O?m4DB*#"Ma(A2313(AB4d8:(G13"23-.B(4(A"[#QRE2%764DB*#B-EB#/( C 4@(M(A'4D2344D"QR4D"-."#/(l(A(%#UG'?2%D(AB4234"@(A-g(23#d2%7(A*#X(AB,"-."#/(B44D234%`!""#'4D2H)S".#DR(A%,I#234- ­.­9M/B'?B##123# (A'423,"-%# (A6*#(6","-."#/(7234D-R,rc(A2%# "#M^%QR#Q((A(AX)3#S7234-E(A23#7423-8:[$(2.1%"#B4A(l(l%%'()%'42^"BR4M8I#&B23#"4BsT3Z$ 13,23%,?4",(AX)3B442%4#(234"M^(A2?-.%DR4B&2%#G(2H)3"4%,,23-g#T_ZG,2S"%,%D23,RS(A"44D234a"D(-E(AB`#.#234-$M/(A2l?"2%-E'RS(A".7234a%[E",B-EB#/(I2%7?(A0-EB 13,23%,#c(A234T3Z:0B23-E'R(AB&742%- ,2^%,c([WTZM!23#B(d#2%4- 2%7=(*#(B, t-."#/(a23,R(A23#%a?B"#gBD(-E(AB =¬ B'?B##123#(A0-E%13#X(AR2%7?(,2^%,23,R(A:B442%4)%,R""M8pl("#&"B8:(AB40(AlD23,RS(A2%#$:"#23R13W%B"R4(Al234%#&%%'S(A)%4DB*#"-."#/('4D2SB"R4D%6(A2!%'',BC23#m(A-."D$B#/(A(B67234 RB"BX)3%#G-.234%B"R4(A+*#(","-."#/(:2%,R(23#C23#G(Al4DB*#"-."D

2342%R4'423,"- T_£ ¡%¢/ZkM8I."23#"4(A.G'?2%D(AB4234=B44D234"D(-E(A23# T HZN#O"#B41%i#234D- ´X)3"#gl*#(A","-."#/(a(A4%#13R,r(23#7]B:/M^8p%DR-.0%I,2S"%,%D23,R(0B44D234pBD(-E(AB[m2%7(N"#%''!4#1d(a(A04D13/(p%#EN2%7T 9ZkM^#E(72%,,2H8:#1"#2(A"gQi Z:RC ^ 7234"%[C#t ]B: ^R"M(AQR%#/((xi

< ^ Z:OC ^­ 6!:­ f T £/¢/Z

%DR-EB % W*#(23#K2701%,23,p4D",rc(A)%gB442%4#c(A23423#X+M8:"4D6!:Gl(Am*#(","-."#/(D23,R(23#&23#_]B:E#ª­0"­ f "#2(A"+(B#"4D1%iW#2%4- 23#X "#MX70T £/¢/Z:+,2H8IB4(A%#hG'4D"B4?Bj(A2%,"4%#B%M(A *#(AB,"-."#/(l2%,R(23#OB23#DB4"]e%B"R4(ABf%#j(A%,13234X(A-5@(A23' p\ ("4@8:D%M!%#$%%'S(A)%4*#"-."#/(0'42^"BR4Dl%,,BMB23#D(#12%7 BNH "'!"##1.23#C(Al-E%13#(AR+2%7|(A,2S"%,"4D4234#(234 234D-g,,i%MS#C234"4(A2B" O u u B,B-EB#Q(#"B&(2.!4*#"%# u%PO u M 2H8-E%#/iU"13".#K(A$B,B-EB#Q(H)%$(2O?G',("M=8IG*4DD(."23#"4 (AG-ES-R-Y,2S"%,IB442%4

#"(A234 Z <©-E^ ! Z:RC ^ %x T £9Z

B#M*S"jg)%,R.R[O(A(l¢g[g 3M"%,," cwT w y`zg M!8IDB((A ?L¡,)3B,

3 v <J¢ 3 < ) + V / Z E D< Ek¡(ERxRxRxyE>?©E T £Q¡3Z

8:B4 :(A#^R-?B4N2%7="13B T 1 < M!#$2%7 (AB(4A%"4/Z B#"ME4DB*#"-."#/("4D("423#C#&!(A723,,2H8:#1s

£Q¡

Page 47: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

1

2

2

3

4

11

23

(a) edge bisection (c) Bank bisection(b) centroid

13R4D s ,r%,z4B*#"-."#/((A"[#QRB72346(4%#13,"

1

1

2

3

456

7

81

2 3

4 12

32

(b) centroid(a) edge bisection (c) Bank bisection (d) face bisection

13R4D+£s ,r%,z4B*#"-."#/(:(AB[#QRB072346(B(4A%B4A

s0# t] :sc 3 !Tt!c¢jEERxRxxyE )%R6 W > W 1Q>3 =g Z:RC ^ V 3 + V rp > > W ®d® ® G® 3 > #1 3 `m® !`®x

; #G(A'42^"BR4M(A","-."#/(A #$)^#1 Z^ V 3 V 4#2%(B23#"4D"G72344*#B-EB#Q( ^',X((A#1O%# "1%&-.%#E#1jO#8 #2S&c(.(G-E'!23#/( 2%70(A$"13 L"#q%#

","-."#/(l#"B(2&!.4B*#"h%"B234#1G(A2G(AE%,1%234X(A-$M?8:X(APR!)^2%#P27W"13"BM<(A GB13B%4D',X( L"# k d-E234D(%#F23#86iW"%#W(A"#FySD(+(2m13"#"4Ac(A(AB4)%" B,"-."#/(<742%-](Ap#X(Ar,323#M3"23#"4#10(6" #2SB 6[23"I%?2%R(<8:[7_%B"l13"#B4A(.(."4D)3Bh(A(A4%"4AUT 2H8 %Bh#2^BB23##BB(2%,P%#j#B8 #2SB#&(A 234D13#%,(B(A4%B423#ZNN23# #R[jE8IHi(A(0(AB4+D%'! 0%"'S(&eD",23Bfm(A2m(A"QR,r("4%,13B23-E(A4@i3M"23#@(AB#Q(,iC8:X(AG(Al'?lQR%,X(xiC2%7 23,C(A(A4%"423# 2%#

£

Page 48: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

#g234B4p(2 )323m"1%"#B4A(23#I#gB,B-EB#Q(I'?B6(A(I"23R,m#2(613R4A%#/(ABNB23#/)3"4D13"#"2%7(A6*#(6","-."#/(D23,R(23# <; # (A%D < 3M%(x8p2(AB(4A%"4%413B#"4(AB 7423- 23#TR#1(Ad",%D"%, H[_ Og u% %M!%02H8:#F# 13R4D£ /ZkM!8:,#$(A%D T< "13/((A(A4%"4Ag4d1%"#B4A("&74D23- 23#mT_ 1 2%([%#"&/i$(l2 t %,,"^ Mu H[_ Og u% %M%l2H8:#U# 13R4D £ Z C; #P(AE4B*#"-."#/(27I(AEB,"-."#/("M -.234D"2H)3B4"M<7R4D(A"4(4A%#(23#","-."#/(A"2%R,G#B"(2.!l4B*#"&#$234B4(A2.13R%4%#/(A"(A(:(A#8 -EB$ 3 c \ [1 l'42^"BR4D2%7 -EB&4B*#"-."#/(0%:?B"#&B)%",2%'?BW/i S%-RB,D23#&( %,-."4D t#X(A ,B-EB#/( "#/(AB4l27 ,-."4=00#X)3"4DX(xiF2%7a <B[#23,231%i 234m([%,"F"B4'(A23#F2%7%-dR",2%#:4DB*#B-EB#/(0("[#QR%MBm M£B¥

13R4D" #£>2H8 B)%"4%,",%D,N4*#B-EB#Q(C("[#QR"$RD"L#L%%'(AX)3*#(","-."#/(-E(A2^7234¡ ¬ %# 3¬ (4r#13R,(A23# E"&2%7I-E(A2^l%BU23#j"13E tBB(23#]T 13R4B j%#q£ /Z %# %#KBB(23#T 13R4D" &#q£ HZkMp7234#D(A%#"MI)3B4DiF'!23'R,r%4 NgD234@(-EB#Q(23#2%7a%,("4D#(AX)3DR!)^D23#&"4D(AB4Mz#(A.¡ ¬ %D$T 3¬ M4B'!"(A)%",XiZ [ we g u% jT 13R4D" M234:£ &72%4:( 3¬ "%Z:B23R,$!d%'',"M#8:[W(A4D"GT 723R4"M?4B'!"B()%",iZNB,"-."#/(+%4D"4D)%"W742%- (d234D13#%,¦23#/iW"2%##"(A23#2%7I(A)%"4D(B"8:(AP(A4Di^"B#Q("427p(.*13R4 C 234 3¬ -EBB"M -.234D"2H)3B4"M<(2 t %,,B [ H[_ mg u% $T 1%R46£ Z B23R, ?B23#"4D"M/8:X(A13"#"4Ac(A2%# 2%7(A4D"(A(A4A"4742%- 23#.QiOB23##BB(23#j2%76(A.)%"4D(B"8:X(AO(A.%4@i^""#/("42%7p(AE,r%4D13"@(7_%" g,%D((x8p2&-.B(2S%#M298pB)%"4BM ,"%W(A2GD%'! "13B#"4(A23#l%#O13B#"4%,,Xi4D"QR4(AB[#^R"2%7I-EBh4D"13R,r%4D~c(A2%#M,% [7 O / M & w j _ M 234-.2H)3"-."#/(2%7#2^".T 1 n O u ZkMz#234B4N(A2CB2344D"((AD%'! 2%7(A #B8 ","-."#/(A#-E%%(6",2%"4(2("QR,r("4A,23# ^"E§Hc¥7234:-E2%4y^("#B2H)3B4D)^8o2%7|(AB(AB[ t#^R""M2%4d 3M!¡3^M ¤c¥

£3£

Page 49: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

For each element: compute elemental stiffness matrix; compute elemental RHS due to source field; compute (possible) elemental RHS due to interface

Compute source fieldby Urankar’s method

Read toleranceRead refinement factor

Global FE assembly

Do Neumann nodes exist?

Compute source fieldby Gaussian integration

Compute line integrals on Dirichlet nodesSubstitute Dirichlet values at RHS

List all boundary Dirichlet nodesList all boundary Neumann nodesList all interface nodes

Is conductor a coil withpolygonal cross section?

Compute line integrals on interface nodes

Do Dirichlet nodes exist?

Write nodal potential of reduced domain on fileWrite nodal potential of total domain on file

Solve FE linear system

number of refinements?Is iteration j less than max

For each element: compute local error indicator Adaptive method?

Write nodal field of reduced domain on file Write nodal field of total domain on file

Compute normal source field on Neumann nodesAdd Neumann condition to RHS

START

Is union of total materialssimply connected?

Choose uniform/adaptiverefinement method

For each boundary surface: set Dirichlet/Neumann type

For each material domain: set total/reduced type

Adaptive method?

Does union of reduced materialscontain all conductor regions?

j = j+1 j = 0 Read max number of mesh refinements Read order of Gaussian quadrature

Compute global error estimator

For each element: mark refinement level

STOP

Error less thantolerance?

Refine marked elements according to levelDefine new mesh

Refine all elements uniformlyDefine new mesh

Compute magnetic field on total/reduced domainCompute magnetic energies on materials

Compute gradients of total/reduced potential

Read geometryRead physical dataRead mesh

YES

YES

NO

NO

YES

NO

NO

YES

YES

YES

NO

YES YES

NO

NO

NO

NO

YES

1%R4^s ,2H8 t [4D(2%7|(Al-E%#G%,132%4(-

£Q

Page 50: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

l =o+ &&! ) F2%,R(23#ª27l(F!23R#4Diq)%,R'423,"- T_£ ¡%¢/Z%C!""#L-E',"-."#/(ABª# ? ?

,r#13R%1%023#m00# mSR# t S23,%4p',(72%4- S2%-EN%)%#/([%1%"I#E(+R(,~(23# 27|%#m23(HDBB( t234D"#/(" "2^I72%4 -E(AB-gc(A"%,Q'42%134A%-.-.#1M9B'!""%,,Xi7234<*#(AI",B-EB#/(`%'',"(A23#"M%4DyS',%#"F#FS"(A2%# ¡ D(4R(AR4D 2%7(A -g%#W%,13234D(A- %#F!4D"'4D"B#/(A"j/i(A! 2H8 t [%4D(B'(A"&# 13R4Dl `; #$(D"B(23#zM8I4D ! iC"23-.-."#/((A-E%#C'%4D(27 (A'4D23134A-

NP $I#"Q (RRY%$

; #G(Al#(r%,!'%M13B23-E(A4@i3M D(A%4D(#1&T (AB(4A%"4%, ZI-."D%#$'Qi^D,|'%4A%-.B("4D2%7`(A.'423,"-¨%4 DB( 2%7 (x8I%4#42/b D+´ ; D ``n %!""#ORD"h% ¬ (A2^23,<72%4(AC"23#@(A4DRB(23#>2%7:(AC23-E%#U1%"23-.B(4DijQiU'%4A-E(A4gBR4D)%".%#>R4D7_%B"#?D^0 n 4B'4BB#Q(A(A23#M0yS'?2%4D(A#1>-E2^B,g# ; ´ q7234D-g( ; #(O'4B'42^"B#1>'%D%MN(xi^'%,*#X(AB,"-."#/(#S7234-E(A23#m4D(234Bs

&J Rcw _ s#QR-d?B427 #2^B"M13,2%%,z#2S#QR-!"4DN#G"234D4"D'?2%##1 %4@(A tDr%#G"2^234D#c(A"B& g< Rcw _ s #QR-!"4a2%7B,"-."#/("M^#^R-?B4I2%7?)3B4D(A"B6'?B4pB,B-EB#Q(+T_#E"%02%7-. S"FB,B-EB#Q([ZkM13,2%%,|",B-EB#/(#^R-?B4BM"23##"B()^(xi-gc(A4 &",B-EB#/( t ,2S"%,¦#2^"BM(xi^'!l27 -E(AB4%,&J x w Rcw s<'Qi^D,!'%4A%-.B("4D`%D2SBr(" (A2(A-E("4%,6T_# 23R4-.2SB,sD23R4BgBR44D"#/( B#X(xi3M=4D",rc(A)%-g%1%#B('?B4-.%,X(A""M¦#U'!23D,.B2SB4B)3.*",#Q("#D(xim8:"#$'?B4-E%#"#/(-E%13#(A:yS@(kZ

¬ 4D[,B(N%# D0BR-E%##F!23R#4DiWDR4D7_""l%4D '!"B*BM¦%+8p",, %+(A B*#(A23#W2%7`(2%([%,234:4BRB"'!2%("#/(A%,23#G(Al)3"4%,¦-gc(A"4Dr%,z23-E%# &"D#S7234-E(A23#C%4D"23##"B("(2(AGD^0 n C13"23-.B(4Di ' #(6 *)+)Yd$ -,^/.$0"Q 1( 4@(M(l%,1%234X(A- 4B^R4B(A"@(A-g(23#C27 QR%#/((A":%''?"%4#1.%:([ #$'423,"-

T_£ ¡%¢3Z ; #G(A723,,2H8:#1M^8p234@(A,XiC"D"4D!(-g#C-.2SB,,#1D(AB' &32 _ u Iy6 7 54 _ _ v76 N w 98 %w 68p2XzB4B#Q(l(AB[#^R" %4DgRD"M "'!"##1&23#U%'?E'42%'?B4D(A"l2%76D23R4D"m4D"1323#"M| BR44D"#/( t %4D4Di^#1d"23#RB(234 ` 2%4pB23-E',y.1%"23-.B(4B"M^l*#()%23,R-.0%''4D2OS-g(23#m"23#"4BM+/i[2^23D#1 %m)%23,R-."m(W*#X(AFB,"-."#/(C,2^("L#ª(F"R4D4B#Q( t"%44@iS#1G"23#RB(234 ("[#QR4"QR4Bm(4r#13R,(A23#&((B23#@(A4A#BO(2(m%'?C27(C"2%#R(A234D "23-.'!23X(A %¬ ´%RD t 5¦B13"#4CQR%4A(R4C(A"#%'',"8:(J#%''423'4rc(AF234D"4G23#©%[©"2%#R(A234G)323,R-. L"#©(AOD23R4B

£

Page 51: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

4D"1323#0%4l"4"R,r%4:"2%,8:X(A4D"([%#1%R,r%4:B423D+BB(A23#M!ED"-. t %#%,Xi^("%,'4D2SB"R4D"%#F?RBO#@(AMz"F2%#W-E2^X*"n04A%#4 «07234D-R,r £Qc¥Mz '4"DBj#(AB4-.2%7<","-."#/([4Dig7R#B(23#BM %"2%r%#CB,,'(07R#B(23#:#&B,,'(#/(AB134A%,2%7|(A+*4DD("MD""2%# %#K(A4UQ#©§%MI9¡SM 9¥ P; #U(AC,%D(d-E(A2^M=(Am#QR-EB4%,p"23#/(A4DRS(A2%#B23#D(2%7I",,'S(Ad#/(AB134A%, "D(-E(A23#BM|"4.'!"4D72%4-."PQi 4,D23#«d,13234D(- £M ¥MQ# QR%4(AR4D2%7!23# t -EB#23#%,j004%#c%4 «=#Q("134%,|8:"#'!23#/(%4#'!"Br%,,-.(p'?23D(23#I23#C8:[ %4,23# :%,13234D(A- "%##2(0!%'',B ¬ ([%,%!23R(("D("[#QR"0%4BB4!"$#j«¡3c¥

& _ N Rcw u V _ SR[P(AC%4 "%,i23([#BFQiB23-E'R([(23#G2%7<(Al)%4(A23#%,?yS'4BD23#F2^"(AB&(2.(#234-E%,B4)()%l27 23#j%,,=(A.R4@7_%"7_%B"l2%7I(E#/(A"4@7_%"E%#P(A D0BR-E%##P?23R#%4@i D2S,=)%,RB%4D+(AB#&2%([%#"C/iCDR-.-g(23#g2%7<(+)%423RB23#/(A4R(23#I23#C(AR4D7_%B7_""6(28:[&"%[$#2Sl!",23#13

& _ N Rcw u w u = SR[)%,RB%4D23([#B Qi#^R-EB4 t"%,SBD(-E(A23#2%7,#`#/(AB134A, P ! 62%# %,,3(I#2SB 2%7(ApR4@7_%"B(|(Ap#/(AB4D7_%B%#P( ¬ 4[,(?2%R#%4@i .#/(AB134A(23#O,#B%4.%''42RS-E(ABj/iO'!23,i^1323#%,B23-E'!23D".2%7zD"13-."#/(+T"13B`2%7?(B(4A%B4A3Z2%4p4"0T'42HDBB("g2%#Q(2R4@7_%"Ba74D23-(AB13"AZ2%#O(#/(AB4D7_%B234+(A ¬ 4[,B(+?23R#%4@i T_"%,," w [ Z .¬ "'!"##1G23#O(AD%'!d"2%-E',yS(xi$2%7=R[OR4D7_%B""Mz#^R-EB4"%,¦,##/(A"1%4A(23#$:(AB#F23#/iKT_/Zl t'!23#/(`QR%4A(R4:4R,2H)3B4p"%[gB13%MQ234TZ=1%"4234D"4p´%RD t 5B13"#4#/(AB134A(23#2H)3B40"%[$"13234'42HDBB(ABW%4D

; #G-.234N13"#B4A%,z-E2^","M^(AB23#/(A4R(23# 3T @ZI%''!%4D#1c(6(A4D13/(#G+2%7<2%D23#«NB^R(A23#0(A2E?l"2%#"4D"W#23-g#8:(4D"RB"W'!2%("#/(A%,¦B*#(A23# ; #G23R4:%DR-.'(23#BM(AI("4- )%#D":D#B-g("4Dr%,p)%lB23#@([%#/(-g13#B(0'?B4-.%, t(xim%# I23,"#2%%,

lYD $ *)= (B($d"H I IzG 'B"8:d,#%40´%,B4Q#&D"4(A~(23#$"D"4D!"F#WS"(A23#W£ %0?B"#O%'',"

L(C4B'!"B((2 ",%D,4<2%D23#C-.2SB,BMB4+8p)3(A2 B23#"46%#G%X(A23#%,!D("'s(A(A4D(-EB#/(E270(G"23#(A23#K2%70'?2(A"#/(r%,$HDR-E' ((A$#/(A"4@7_%"C!B(x8p"B#ª23-E%# #U(2%([%,'!2%(AB#Q(r%,%#$23-E%#I#G4BR"B'!2%(AB#/(Ar,

0"B234#1g(2g23R4023R,l'?2%("#/(A%,7234-dR,r(23#zM(0(d#/(A"4@7_%"?(x8IB"#O4B132%#0277 t7"4D"#/(+'!2%("#/(A%,8Il)3l(A2EB(0"X(AB4N 234 w [ &B*#(23#C7234:(Al'!2%(AB#Q(r%, 6\ #B*S"F(0"23#/)3B#/(A2%#MR4D#1E(A,2^23'2H)3B4%,,¦B,"-."#/(N#&(A1%,23, B-,Xi'%M#2^%,'!2%(AB#/(Ar,R#Q#2H8:#N(:(A#/("4D7_"%M8:2%l",B-EB#/(A:)3.B*#X(A23#jT_4BRB"M(A2 t([, Z<(A(I [/% (2(A023#0[2%"#m(`(A#/(AB4D7_%B%M^)3(A2l?48:4(D(AB#g#(AB4-.`2%7(A,rc((AB4 "47234M#2S":2%7|R[&#/(AB4D7_%B","-."#/(A)%d%#G S(4A "2%#Q(4R(A23#G((41%Q(%#2%7 (D"4DB(Al-.2SB,M"4X)3B&742%- (A%D2^"rc(A"$'!2%(AB#Q(r%,jHDR-E'M1%)3B#&/iG(A"2%44B'!23##1.,#+#/(AB134A, ! d-R,X(A',"m/im("234D4"D'?2%##1E@(A?#B"2^ .""#/(A

£Q

Page 52: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

¬ ?"4D"#/(A,XiF7423- (E72%4-."4"M|#2F(23#%,="2%#Q(4R(A23#hRE(2'!2%(AB#Q(r%, HDR-.'h%(2!%"G(6(+4D13/(6%#CN7234a(AN",B-EB#/(A,2^c(A"g#m4D"1323#p8:23'!2%(AB#/(Ar,?*#X(A2%#6(A%-.l%6(Al2%#B(0(:(#/(AB4D7_%B

234-E',"-."#/(A(A23#g'R4'!23B"M#G234D"46(2.4D"R"(A"4D4234'!"4@(AR4D(23#M(R131%"D("(A2[2^23DN%`'!2%(AB#/(Ar,B*#(23#.(`(A#/(A"4@7_%"(:A%-.:RBE#.(:23-E%# )^#1# wd wXzRD23#VT 13B44",(AX)3-E%13#(A'!"4D-E"%,(xiZ ; #jR[KC8IHi%M<(E,2H8IB4XzR2%#"2^ .B"#/(+2%7(A%H""#/(-E("4%,:13X)34A%(A2m,298p"4N%-.',X*(23#C7_%(A234DN#&(A-E2^ t",,#1"4D4234:R(2,#+#/(AB134A,"23-.'R(A(A23#

)+.qIYG;/, F )Yd6 T $ 0N ,#"%423,X)3B4:72%4:('4M?'!23D(AX)3*#X(Al%#$Di^-.-E(A4 = Di^@(A"-$M(A5

-.2SR,d74D23- (# SE2%7 (x8I%4D.'%[c%13&T)%"4D23#h¡ ¢ ¡% M7423- N4D1323## D0(A23#%,-5|?2 t4Ac(A234@iZN%?B"#hRS(A,~B" S.G#QR-EB4%,=,4%4Di$(xi^'"%,,XiR"P7234,#4%,1%"442%R(A#"BM(pp"D13#"m(A2d?+'%4D("R,r%4D,i EBB#Q(6#mDR''!234D(#1'%4A%,,B,"23-.'R(A(A23#6##",R"l&@(A234%13 7234D-g(72%4lD'%4Dg-E(4B"E £%¥ gB7_%R,X(l-E(A2^j2762%,R(23#O#O(A5 %B4#B, Nm´l n -.B(2^&8:(F%#&#B23-E',B( ; 50 7_%B(234~(23#MRS(+-E%#/i&2(AB44Di^,2H)GDR'%"X(AB4A()3-.B(2SN%4D'42H)^BM? 1 "23#HDR1/(Al134%B#/(0D23,)%"4D"M?(2313(AB48:(C)%42%R'4B"23#(23##1 -.B(A2S

0 .q$OYG -, )+(D %%( $G6 O " ( $G ( 4D23-(AN2%,R(23# )3BB(234I13X)^#1#2^%,#7234-E(23#%!23R(a'!2%(AB#/(Ar,"M^#2^%,4B'4B"#/(A t(A23# 2%7!(A*B, "%,i2%([%#"RD#1*#X(A2%#T £Q3Z<%#T S9ZkM38:(A '4)^23RD,i

"2%-E'RS(A"23#(A#2^"+#&(23-E%#$8:X(AW4D"RB"O'!2%(AB#Q(r%, S#Bd'"BB8:D,#40B, t-."#/(A)%!"B#ER"zMSN8p"13/(ABg)3B4A%1%#12%7("23-.'R("'!2%(AB#Q(r%,S134AB#Q("M/'"BB8:D"2%#D(A%#/(M!23#l23##"1%^!23R4","-."#/(A %13#B(AB#"4D13BN)%(A"#W!"B#W"23-.'R("&Qi#QR-."4%,z#/(AB134A(23#C27T£ ¡^9ZM2%#$"%[27<(-g("4Dr%,?23-E%#I2%7<(-E2^B,

=II! ( I OYG ( (6I5 P - (B %"BR4ABim27(AN*#(N","-."#/(6D23,RS(A2%#gp-.'42H)%"m/imDR"B"D)%(AB4A(23#p2%7¦-."D

4*#B-EB#Q( h¬ B'?B##1W23#KRD"4 #(r%,[2%"M(Am4DB*#"-."#/(%#K!6 3 c I\ FM %,,","-."#/(A%4D4*#"zM!2%4^1 !1Rpd> a^®3M 23#,igB,"(AB&B,"-."#/(044*#" ; #j(Ag%%'()%g%''42/[h(AE[23".2%768:[U","-."#/(A)3g(2!E4DB*#BKl23#E% t"2%4#1g(A2.(Ag'?2%D(AB4234|"4D42340"D(-E(Al#"#B41%i&#234D- 1%)3B#F#UT 9ZkMz"2%-E'RS(A"&7423-

(Al*#(AB,"-."#/(2%,R(23#G23#G(Al"R44B#/(N-."DM([.%#$","-."#/(kb97_%"~"B ,B-EB#/(A:2%7(A-."D$8:X(A$,r%4D13"4D4234:#"(A234D:%4("#&-g%4D%B&72344DB*#B-EB#/(M?%"B234#1(A2."4X(AB4r%#$R?X)^23#m(AB[#^R"N"B4?B&#^"B(23#&

^#Bl8p%4Dl8p234D^#1E8:X(A$"R4@)3BF13"23-.B(4""M!2%(#G(Ad%%'(AX)3%#&#G(AR#72%4-

£/

Page 53: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

1%R4 s4D2HD"(A2%#$27 #2^B023#/(2.BR4D)%"

4*#B-EB#Q("MI8:B#ª","-."#/(A2%70(A$23,>134D>)3$7_%"B[bB13Bg23# ?2%R#%4DB.2%4.#/(A"4@7_%"B(l#B""DA%4@ih(2'!"4D72%4- '42IHD"B(23#(A(d-.2H)3.(AE#B8 #2^"23#/(A2(gBR4D)%"K!23R# t%4D"Ab#/("4D7_"" ` 2346(A(x8p2 t -."#D23#,%D%MD" 13R4

l ( &! "D/ =% %+)>)> */

I%S)%#Q(A%13`2%7R#1N#23HD"B( t 234DB#Q("'4231%4A%-.-E#16,%#13R13%M9 1 = ?N?Mc,"-E%#,Xi#.(AN'?23D,(xi 2%78p234D^#1d8:X(A H MS%IB23-.', g2%(HD"(A6)^#1 %#C%RS(A23#2%-E23RI#/("4 t#%,4D"'4D"D"#/([(23#$2%7<(A.#$7R#B(23#l ¥ B23#D"QR"#"N27!(`''423%[Qi",rB` ( w dc '!"Br%,,il8:"#."23-.',yd'423 t,B-E04B^R4(A2m!%#,BFQi&-E',"4R'42%,B-EBM234N#""F(2m?dy^(AB#"zM'%4D(+2%7`(A

"2^GT-E2^R,"AZ#F?d8:4D(D(A"#FD"'4A(",i&/iDB)%"4A,'4231%4A%-.-EB4BM?'!23D,XiB)3B,23'!"Oc(O13"4,)3",27+13B#"4%,X(xi "D-.2SR," "%# ?G(AB#V"%,iK1%423R'!">(A2%13B("4.#DFR#^R$B2Sm7234(AG'R4'!23BE2%7:(G'!""X*G'42%,B- R#"4"23#"4Ac(A2%# |2jRD$%##D([#" 2%7a#P SD(#1g",r#m"2^M8:(N4"QR4BW(A2m(A '4231%4A%-.-EB4NN-E',i(A2FQ#2H8 (Ac((Ag",r g 2 D(%#U(A( %W""4@([%#K'R,E234'4D)(A.7R# t(A23#Wx 1G® 6 3 > 3 Tzaj1 \^Eea(1 \3¡(E $$4Eea(1 \ Z6"4@)^#1g72%40."B4D([#$'R4'!23D D02EQ#2H8:,"13%!23R(p(A#Q("4D#%,!4"'4"D"#/([c(A2%#$27(AB,r%D6p4"QR4B a\ #"B",%4BG%#C*#"G#m(-."-!"4+([C%#O7R#B(23#+%#"'!"#B#/(-.2^R,R"M?( ",%!"B23-."m#8 13W,)3B,(xi^'?l)%,%,N(A2 (Al'423134%-.-EB4I8p234Q#1E2%#$D'?B"X*'423,"-.

$234B29)%"4BM6#K(AG74%-.B8p234j2%7+'4D23134%-E-.#1&7234 -E(A"-E(A%,p'R4'!23D""Ma(AG,B)3B,2%7%@(A4%B(23#W2723(HDBB( t 234"#/(ABF,r%#13R%13BN,,2H8::(A2m%#,d"QRc(A2%#+%#WDi^-!23,B#/(A(B/i>W7234-E%,p'42^"BE%# F"2^G4"'4"D"#/([c(A2%# ((.%''!4 )3B4Di>-E,r%4(A2F(G-g( t-E(A%,7234-E%,~c(A2%# Ny%-.',""M^8I"%#C"23#"4#CX(AD(4A%(A2%#C#@([%#B"2%7<B,r%D _ M¦%8p",,=%23(HD"(A2%7a(xi^'? < z 2%4 z 7234"23-.'R(A(A23#+# R","%#

£/¤

Page 54: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

13B23-E(A4@i3MS%,13B4AD(A4DRB(R4B62%7(xi^'! K we MQB(A M´l%R%#g#/(A"1%4A(23#.-E(A2^pQi+",% K w w #8:[(#QR-!"42%7!#2^B[bc8p"13/(A`=D'?B"X*".%`+'4A%-.B("4"M%#$223#

l "+jy& N/ o%.$),$/|)>4 = '!"Br%,,iC7234:*#X(Al","-."#/(N-.B(2^"M!(A23(HD"( t 234"#/(ABW',23D23'/iGB"-.0(A2g?'%4 t(A"R,%4,Xi$ .""#/(8:"#P-g#'R,r(#1."#/(AX(A"%XzB4B#Q(r%,<"QR(23##W(A"40)%4rc(A2%#%,

7234D-&Mz%+8IB,,-EBB"M","-."#/(ABM%D+7R#(A23#"MzB(A S)3B4A%,'!23D,X(AB0#W(A [23B2%7("D.B,r%DB%4 "4D%Mz8p72SBR23#W(%N((N)3?B"#FRD"P#W2%R4+-.2SB, #(6*#X(A","-."#/(23,R(A23#

) R (, G . jIYG$ 4@(Mc(A6"4D#",S2%7(AI-E2^",Q,"<#l(AI)%4Dr(23#%,%7234D- 27!N'%4@(Ar,^2%4 234D#4DiXzB4"# t(A%,!"QR(23# -E2^B,T_£ 9ZkM#m(AB47234.T£ ¡¢/ZMS"23-."I74D23- (A1%"#B4A%,~"BL<2%D23#«

"QRc(A2%# .^T#6?Z< c723468:[$(-E',"@(8I"%m7234-dR,r(23#E

#6 P#a !Q< < 6T % 6 % a l? % 6 % a&? % 6 % aZ!Q<n< cGa$!Q< T HZ

#$l2%7=2%-E231%"#B23R ¬ 4D[,B(!23R#%4DiGB23#X(A2%#"M8:X(A23RS(N#QiG#/(A"4@7_%"B I 2%4-. SB!23R#4Dib#/("4D7_""2%#(23#"M8p)3l"B#&#&S"(A2%#$£ ¡d2H8R4@7_%"#/("134%,`T %¬ "%Z234¦,##/("134%,aT¡ ¬ "%Z¦H)%a(20!a%BM3""2%4#1(2T_£ Z jp"%#l("4DB7234Dp-E',"-."#/(dB,r%D ?M!#E8:[G7R#B(A23#m4DB(AR4#I(+B,"-."#/(A%,?,B7 (p%#g+2%7aT HZ#C(7234-

"!$#%'&)(*#,+!-.&/(0#,+12&)30#,+!'&)30#,+415'&)67#,+!-2&)60#,+8+:9

%#&7R#(A2%#$4DB(R4#:(Al4D13/(%#$l#C(A7234D-

; !<-79

8:( %# )S"#/(`4D"B-,%#"p(A2+(A%!29)%Di^-!23,a72%4-E%,~(23# 6)%4(A23#%,/B^R(A23#B23-.'R(ABO23#O%[j",B-EB#/(2%7`(A-."zM¦("4DB7234D(-E%%B"#(A2GB*#.%#hD(4A%(R'?B4",%=55&(A2E"23##"(N(Ad'!"B*l"QRc(A2%#KT_"4M5ZN8:X(A"%[","-."#/(g%#q(B2344D"'!23##1j%E7R#B(A23# \ D"4@)3W(A(E(-."-d?B4.7R#B(A23#.2%75>%4DE)%,P72%4d%,,(AE-E2^","M|8:,.(g'!"BR,%47234- 2%76(mB^R(A23#h-E', t-."#/(AB#GD'?B"*DR?B,r%DB B4X)3"$7423- (M 1 5F#G23R4

) R (, G $!+($ PB,r%DB$%#,#1 -."D"G23#©%4D(4A%4@iq2%-g%#gH)%O?B"#©-.',B-EB#Q("c(

Page 55: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

%,-EB4 #X(A ,"-."#/( "#/(AB4:Qi %-R",D23#jT"l^"B(23#& ZkM%#GX(%!"B#$'!23 t,a(A2"%,il"#"%'DR,r(I(A"-#d(A6'!"B*B2Sp8:4(D(AB#7234 23R4%'',"(A23# 0""2%4#1(A2%-dR",2%#"M<$-."Dh#h!ED""#U%d#h#D([#"O2%76%#U%D(A4%B(",% 8:B4%M!%%#G -E',%M7R#B(23#:,%

.& #,+ &:#,+; #, 411+<( & 0#, 9 +!3" &5# 4!3"# +$

4(AR4D# (>#QR-!"4 L2%7E","-."#/(ABMd(A>#QR-!"4 L2%7E#2^"BM(A>B2S234D#(AB# (%&*9 ((')*9 (%*& +>2%7(AW#2^8:23DF13,2%%,:#QR-!"4m M0%#ª(AW-gc(A"4Dr%,:"# t(AX*"4!3"g2%7<(AB,"-."#/( M4D"'!"(AX)3",Xi L"# W-EBKd(A2F!m"2%#"4D">#DgWB4A%4D[/iU2%7:DB)3B4A%,-."D" 2%#U(Am%-.

23-E%#MQ%`(`a4D"QR4".7234`-EB.4*#"-."#/(ID(A4(AB13B"MQ(``R7R,(A2l"4D)30+ ,&-&23(HDBB(.%WR!",%27. g'R4'!23DC2%7:(AdR?B,r%D (2F%B"'>(A4A[j2%7:(m4B,r t(A23#D'+%-E2%#1C"#/(AX(A"47"4D4"F(2&m1%4 T 1 B,"-."#/("M7_%B""M¦B13"BM¦#2S"[Z%#P2(AB4"#/((A"<"234D4"D'?2%##1+(A2%#2%(AB4=#D([#"627134"4D)%" 7423-o(I7234D-EB4 /id4DB*#"-."#/(`234"M)^B6)3"4DAM/74D23- 8:[ (A672%4-."4=="4D)%" =; #23R4=%D%M/(AR#72%4- 4*#"-."#/(a'4D2SB"R4D(A2!l%'',"m(2g#$#D(A%#B+ ,G27 "4%4[",%/ , - &GD-.',iE,,BGQi

,.& ; 01 ; 43*#325"&4 ,79 )#0 +9

8:,+(A%'()3'42^""R4l"%,,"C/i,.& ; 0#%25"&4 ,79 -5#&6& +$&

; #.?2%( (A:4*#B-EB#Q(p'4D2SB"R4D"`(A#B8-."DE0 4 ,!MS1%"#B4A("7423- (A:234D13#%,-."7 , ; #m(+R#X7234-5'4D2SB"R4%M(+'4A%-.B("4 )#" m6%#C"#/(*B4I(Ac(6'!" t*"8:[UDR!)^D23#O(AB[#^Rg%(A2&?."2%#"4D"U#gG,D(l2%76)%4D23Rl4DB*#"-."#/(-.B(A2S-.',"-."#/(AB$72340¡ ¬ %# %¬ -EBB :; #&(%'()3l4*#B-EB#Q(N423RS(A#%M(Al# t7234D-g(23#E%!23R(a8:[CB,B-EB#Q(64*#M%#m298©-R[C%[C23#%MpB23#/([%#"C#E(N)3BB(234-5#&6 SR[O)3"(A234%D2^"rc(A"(2$"%[P13,23%, #QR-!"42%7p","-."#/(l#8 ,O(A#QR-!"4p2%7¦"1%"I((6H)%N(A2d?0',(M^%B"234D#1d(A2l(AN("[#QR+BB4!"C#CSBB(23#G ¨",r9 : ; 5& ! 45 555om%,2hB23#DB4"(2U"23##"(C-EB#7234-E(23#

8:(F(A.13"2%-E(A4Di%M¦ (A D^0 n OBR4D)%"d%#PR4@7_%"B4D"'4D"B#/(A#1!23R#4B%#P# t(AB4D7_%B"2%7(+-.2S", =\ #"+BD(A%,BCR[GB23##BB(A23#M%#/ig4DB*#B-EB#/(:'42^"BR408:,,!!'!"4D72%4-."d#%B"234D%#Bp8:X(A(IBR4D)%" D%'!62%7!23R#%4"<%##Q("4@7_%"B"M%/i'42IHD"B(23#2%7p(A.#2^",2^("P23#P(.?23R#%4@ibc#/(AB4D7_%BEB13"2347_%"B23#/(2R[U"R4@)3B[bDR4D7_%B"TD2H8:#'4DB)^2%R,Xi3M# 13R4D Z |2P"23#B,RG8:X(A>-.">#7234-E(23#M=OB,r%D;5 <, *#"zM6"23#/(A%##1F#S7234 t-E(A23#K%!23R(.%IH%"B#""2%70"#/(AX(AB #K(A$-."DMa 8:[q4C(ACB,B-EB#Q()S#1P

S

Page 56: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

#2^g#jB23-.-E23#zM|(gB,"-."#/(d%IH%"B#Q((A2%#U","-."#/(234l(g#2SB%IH%"B#Q((A2&#2^ #%,,Xi3MS",% , 5$%,,2H8:613B23-.B(A4D+2%'?B4A(23#2%#$B,B-EB#Q("M(4%#13,"%#$(B(A4%B4AM,%B23-E'R([(23#C27 ,"#1%("M4"M)32%,R-."BM#234D-g%,"MS%4Di^B"#/(AB4"M!B(

) R (, G ) (BI aB,B-EB#Q(%#!B"#%#@([%#""276B,r%D &04*#/ 5 9), 5 5+QM

8:B4. %# ,5 5 5l4"'4"D"#/(`(AI#^R-?B4=2%7)3B4D("BT 72%4 (A4Dr%#1%,"BM%£N72%4(A(A4%"4A/Z`%#.(A#QR-!"4a2%7%D7R#(A23#NT 234 7234a,#%42%4aQR4A(:(A4Dr%#1%,"BM/£2%4H¢7234:,#%4234QR%4(Al(B(4A%B4ASMz%#2E23#ZkM!4D"D'?BB(AX)3B,i B*#(23#$2%7=(%7R#(A23#6#g(A+%,"R,(A23#2%7(A"4`*4DD(B4X)%c(A)%T_%I4D"QR4"m72%4a(N8p%7234-52%7" t23#&234"4N?"4B#/(Ar,'423,"-.[Z#!d-.',"-."#/(AB&NRDB7R,|-EB-!"4:7R#B(23#0*##1(AE#c(AR4DE2%7I"4D)%"UB,r%D"BM ,% & 4!5 U74D23- &04*#*9 +QM &04!&742%- &04*#*9 '+QM^%#%#%,231323R,i07234¦(A4%#13,"BMc2%4¦72%4<13B4|2%4B4|*#(A`B,"-."#/(<-E(A t2^

¬ R4#1j(AW,2^23' 29)%"4G%,,:",B-EB#/(Ag#q(A13,23%,*#X(A&",B-EB#/(C%D"-d,i%M:(WBR44D"#/(#y &2%7|","-."#/(:%*4DD(:(A2!%D2SBr("C(A2.%# & 4C(AB-E',r(%M#GRB""DX)3",Xi(::13"23-.B(4%,,i.,2^("G#GX(A:'"l'?23D(23#C/iG-.%#:2%7=.-E%''#174D23- (Al4DB7B4"#"","-."#/(M"D"4?B/im(723,,298:#1B2Ss

2& #,.9 +$"& & 4 &0 5 # *9 +$&

B4 4"& %#d#@([%#BI2%7(Ap",r #4"&l((='!"4@7234-.¦(Ap"2^234#(`(4A%#D7234D-g(23#742%- (Al47"4B#"d",B-EB#/(02%#Q(2E(dBR44D"#/(+B,"-."#/( (xi^'!d2%7`´l%R%#$#/(AB134A(23#G'!"B*B&/i$%#G#D(A%#" &C2%7<(",%/4 4 ^23-E:-.234:#"'!"#"#/(6B,r%DBp"%#g!0B23#DB4".72347R4D("4a#S7234-E(A23# | 234`#@([%#"%M

5< -d# 5&< :4 ; 5 d%#!6"D13#"(A2'!"4@7234- 13B23-.B(A4Dp23'?B4A(23# 23# BR4D)%"%#ER4@7_%"BI*#BCQi D^0 n E'4A%-.B(44D"'4D"D"#/([(23#zMS8:,lB,r%D :4&& `RD"g(2%#,-E(A4DB")^#1.'4@(A4RB(AR4

; #W(# ^( %'("4BMz8I*#%,,XiG"23#",R23R40D"RD23#W8:((A%#%,XiSD2%7`#QR-."4%,4BR,X(A:23(A%#"G23#$23-.-g13#B(23D(A(A+"

Page 57: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

0.20

0.20 2.00

0.05

0.301.00

1.00

Iron

Copper

Air

13R4DlSsSr,BB(A23#$2%7<(23-E%#C#[423,"- ET-."#D23##G-E(AB4[Z

5

% "D)

0*4@('42%,B- 6#[email protected](A4D:-.2SB,(A(I"D"4D!l(xi^'%,!","B(423-E%13#B( -.2SB,"23#@(A.2%7N(4B-E(AB4%,I2%-g%# Bi^,#4%,B234$2%707"44D23-E%13#(AC-E("4%,T_ 1 4D23#Z#D"4@(A"O#OC(2342%%,|"2%''?B48:##1g8:X(AP%~"-R(%,<8:(AP¡ q#O4"([%# t13R,%4"4D23BB(23# 7"4D423-E%13#(A-EBR- %#G(Al"2%,%4D-.-EB4BG#&i^,#4%,!2Oh"2%#Q(A%##1&%48:(U'!"4D7BB(,ij"23#RB(#1WDR4D7_"" ´"23-.B(4Dij%#K-EB#23#l2%7(A-E(AB4r,64"D"4D!"$# 1%R4l

0([W7234(G'42%,B-&M8p&13#>(AC4D",rc(A)%C-g13#B(m'!"4D-E"%,(B M C - < H¢HM M C < M C M < .72347"4D423-E%13#(A -g("4Dr%,M"23,`%#j%4BM¦4"D'?BB()3B,i B23#@([%#/(D([ t(A23#%4@iBR44D"#/( ! 298:`#("23,S8:(E"#D(xi -E%13#X(AR < H¢%¢ 1 Z MQ (A2([%,#Q("#D(xi

Page 58: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

13R4D s ; 2%'?2%("#/(A%,,#B#C(A(2%([%,%#$4"R"B23-E%#62%7-423,"-

; #G23R4623R,+'!2%(AB#/(Ar,?*#X(A2%#MS(+"%,r46'?2(A"#/(r%,!R-EBG(2 ?0(A2%(A%,z#N(A4D23# "2%4%M/8:[E-E',XidB23##BB("MS%#4BRB"g#.%4##D6("23, S#"(A:-E%1 t#(A '!"4D-E"%,(xi$-R[P13"4#4D23#M(A.'!2%("#/(A%, l!"B#jB*#Bj(2%([%,<23#O(!23R#4DiWT_#/("4D7_"+7234a(A-.2S", Z D"R-E%##CB23#X(A23#m%I?B"#G-.'?2%"g23#m(A2%R(AB4!23R#4Di3M^'!"B7 i^#1d)%,R:2%7z'?2(A"#/(r%,c(p2%#0'!23#Q(a#.2%4B4a(213R%4A%#/(":(AR#^R"#B2%7<23,R(A23#

,#C#/("134%,:"23-.'R(A(A23# )3&?B"#ª'!"4@7234-." /i "23#DB4#1MI'!23#Q(./i '?2%#/(M(A )3"4%13 2%7`BD(-E(ABN2H)3B4+(A4B"+1%"#B4A("F/iW#(r%,'!23#/(N,2^c(A"#@i^-E-.B(4'?2% t(A23#0%#FDR ."B#/(A,i$D(A%#/(N742%- "%[F2%("4D ^#BdB4d(d7"4D423-E%13#B(A-EBR- W-E',."23#/)3 '?M`(m#Q("134(A23#U,#Bd#K?CD-.',iP%''42RS-E(ABK/iU'!23,i^1323#%,"2%-E'!23BE27","-."#/(a"1%"I,Xi^#123#(A#/("4D7_"%#(A!23R#4Di&T_X7 ¬ 4[,("23#(23#%4DC'!""X*"Z \ )3B4."%[ "13$K t '?23#/( QR%4(AR4DG4R,m%# !G%''," N '!"(ABM(AC-EB>QR%,X(xih%.zBB("K(AG'4D"B23#K2%7:(AC,#m#/(AB134A,I"2%-E'RS([(23#BM?B"23-.#1(A0-.2340%B"R4(A0%p(:(A4%#13R,r(23# !"B23-EBa*#"4BM#"/i.-EBm4DB*#B-EB#/(6'!23,i^1323#%,"2%#Q)%"4D13(298I%4D0BR4D)%"02%7 (#/(AB4D7_%B#&(ET_'!23D,HZ ¬ 4D[,B(!23R#%4Di I 234 7R4 t(A"4a-.'42H)3B-EB#/(p#.(0%"BR4A%i.2%7,#:#/("134%,"23-.'R(A(A23#BMQ%,D213B4a2%4B4p-.B(2S)3$!""#>B23#"4D"Mp 1 F"2%-E'!23X(Am2%# t -."#D23#%,´%RD t 5B13"#4GQR%4(AR4DG23#

£

Page 59: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

13R4D¤sa%1%#B(*",GD(A4D%-.,#"I#423,"-

[&B13%M/iCRD#1E¡ t £ t ´%RD%#G'?23#/(A[b98IB13/(A <BD(A)3l!""#$"2%-E',B("G/iC"23# t"4D#1%4B6#@(A"%m2%7¦D"13-."#/(ABM(A423R1%C'42HDBB(23#m27¦"13B623#/(A2(+BR4D)%"GR4@7_%"B2%7(A#/("4D7_"l%#C(Al'!23D, ¬ 4D[,B(!23R#%4Di

13R4Dd .2H8:N(23'!2%(AB#/(Ar,"(A23#W,#"0%,23#1E%#/i&',r%#l"2%#Q(A%##1.(ADi^-E-.B(4DiSBM/4B'!"B()%",i7234 (6(A2%(A%,# (A4D"RB".'?2(A"#/(r%, 13R4D6¤2H8:(AD(A4D%-.,#"<2%7(A-g%1%#B(N*B,C#Q("#D(xi D02(ABN(A+([%#1%"#/(A%,"2%#Q(#QRX(xig2%7¦(+*",GD(A4D%-.,#"(G(AP#/(A"4@7_%"O!B(x8p"B#]7"44D23-E%13#(A-g("4Dr%,N%#]4"MRO(A2 -E%13#(A~"(A23#B?"(A &23@(2%7:(AC-E%13#B(A ! R(Kd"23#B"#/(A4(ABq423R#>(m7"4D423-E%13#B(Ag-."R-$M 8:,g(A! RjC"#D(xiG#&466723R#G(A2!)%"4@iG,2H8 <%,04B'?234@(Aa(A"@(A-E("E)%,R"a2%7(N-E%13#B(A:"#B41%i.23#g%4BM^423#zM^B23,!%#g13,23%,

23-E%#M=%B"234D#1(A2WB*#X(A23#LT_£ ¡SHZ %,R"d%4g13)%"#U#U"23-.'%4DD23#h8:(h(Am"#B41%i

3

Page 60: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

= n B7"4D"#B 5| ´ A 13 ´ D02^%, ! "$# %& !'())+* %& !'()) -, t).

,-E %¢3.^H¢ ¤/%¢. 3¤/mH¢ 3¡ % / M ¤jx¢3 %¤ H¢ /$0 x¤ & ¢ /$0 jx¤%£/& H¢ /$0 ¤x¢/¡3& H¢ /$0 ¤xXH¢3¢ ¢ /$0/ - £x , H¢ / V v £x 3 /& ¢ / V v £x & H¢ / V v £x , H¢ / V v £x ¢ / V v/ 21 x "£U H¢ /-3 x 33 ¢ /-3 x£/¤£U H¢ /-3 x33& H¢ /-3 x3% ¢ /-3/ 8 8 ¤jx£Q%& H¢ /$0 ¤x ¢/& ¢ /$0 ¤jx ¢S, H¢ /$0 ¤x 3¤ H¢ /$0 ¤x«£ ¡& ¢ /$0

4<5, 63s 87 ,R96;:2%7 - 7 13#<6B(=?>@6BA96B41C=?6B:D= A425, 6B-¨ET=?A 2%R, 6Z

6B:@(=- 7 (E6B:D>"2%-E'RS(6BFG5/i&2(H96B4 (6;>(H9A9=QR96;:"M5QiI>B2CA9:E=?F96"4&= A1J= A 7 ,,K> 7 :&6B: 7 '9=?6B>B68D= :&6,?= A t6 7 4LF9=?:E>"4&6B(E=~ 7 (=2AKM \ R44E6B:DR,(E:"MN5/i 7 F 7 '(E=)C6m´ 7 , 6"4DO= Aj*9A9=(E6P6",?6"-J6BA/(Q:D23,RS(=2AR= Aj(6"4D-S:2%7'!2%(6;AQ(E= 7 ,?:UT pM 7 ''6 7 4V=?Am(H96, 7 :D(U>B23,R-SAKMW4UH96+) 7 ,R96;:UH96"4&64E6B'?234@(6;FIH 7 )6X56;6BAG2C5( 7 = A96;F5/iY>(H2^2C:E=?A1 ;Z7<,)<J¢x 7 :`4&6B*[A96B-S6;A/(I7 7 >(A234&:a2AE(H<6\>B2C=, 7 A<F.(EH96 7 =4[b]=42A 4E6"1=2CAT> 7 ,,?6BFM7234U54&6B)-=(xi%M^ ^ v w_(` 4&6"1C=2CAZI4&6B:Eab6B>+c=edC6",XiCM

\:+4E6B1 7 4&F9:\cEH962cEH96"4fc6B>(H<A9=QR96;:"MK>B23,R-JAhd2%7g4 7 5, 6.4E6;a?2%4&c:\cH964E6B7h6B4E6;A9>B6Qd 7 ,R96B:\a42 td-= F96;Fi5/iK 6 234Ea!234 7 c6 n 6;:E6 7 4E>(HMa7423-j:23,R<c=2CAK2%7fcH96k6"QR9=ed 7 , 6;AOcg¡ ¬ a4D2C5, 6B-jFR<6kc27 $= 7 ,:@iS-.-J6;cA4@i3M^8DH9=,?6\d 7 ,R<6B:64&6Ba!234&cE6BFl= AP>"23,R-SA<:¡SM Q7 A9FC£ 7 4E6m>B23-SaR<c6;FC4E6B:&a6;>;cE=?dC6B,iP5QiR9:&= A1-J6;cH2$F9:T 7 ZM¦Th5Z 7 A9FjT>ZM[F96;:E>B4E= 5b6BFI= AlcEH96723,,298D=?A1sT 7 ZG,?6 7 :nc t :DQR 7 4E6;:6*[A9=ec6m6B, 6"-J6BAocU:D23,R$c=2Ap5/im*[6",?Fm7234-dR, 7 cE=2CAJ= ApcE6"4D-S:627qd6B>+cA234fr « SM¤¥T5ZC*[A<=?c6f6",?6"-J6BAocs:23,R<c=2CAtd$= 7 cEH96\ -J6;cEH2$FzM$=M6uMW5/i 7 e&FR 7 ,f7234-dR, 7 cE=2CAY=?AJcE6"4-52%7 7

d6B>;c234svOM-:R<>(HPcH 7 cr@<xwy vFM^7234 7 :Di^-.-S6+cA4E=?>Ua?2:E=?cE=?d6fF<6B*[A9=ec6D5!23R9A9F96;Fm2Cab6"4 7 cA234w 7 A9F 7 A 7 FHD2C=?Aoc:2Ca6B4 7 c234U 7 :&:2->B= 7 c6BFkcA2tcEH96*[6",?FI6BQR 7 c=2CA9: H¢¥

T>Z&´ 7 , 6B4O= A.*[A9=ec6z6B, 6B-S6;AOc:23,R<c=2CAP5/iSa?2uc6BAocE= 7 ,7234-dR, 7 cE=2CAY=?APc6B4-J:I2%7d6B>;c234DWM^R9:E=?A16;F1C6X6",?6"-J6BAoc: ¤¥M

G6+cH2-F9:&T 7 Z 7 A9FJT>HZ 7 4&6l>", 7 :E:&= > 7 ,I*[A9=ec6l6",?6"-J6BAoc 7 a9a42 7 >(H<6B: 86B,, t OA2H8DA 74D23-|cEH96C, =ec6B4 7 tcAR4E6%M?8DH9=,?6d-J6;cH2$F>Th5Z\=?: 7 -.234E64E6B>;6BAoc@c6;>(H9A9=^R<6%M8DH2C:&6 7 a9a,?= > 7 c=2CAIc2p:&c 7 c=?> 7 S8s6",,:6"QR 7 c=2A9:t= :Q>BR44&6BAocA,Xi~5b6B= A1:&cAR<F9= 6;F5/i M ´tMb5 7 4&:2CAM tM 7 -R96",?:E:D2CA 7 A9F n M 6"4D1C:&c423-7 c H 7 ,-J6"4&: =?A9=?cE6 ,?6"-J6BAoc 6;AOcE6"4;M4UH<6B:E6 -J6;cEH2-F9:mH 7 dC6L56;6BA 7 >B>B23-Ja 7 A9=?6BF5/i 7 F 7 a<cE=?d6c6;>(H9A9=^R<6B:62%7z-S6;:EHm4&6B*[A<6"-J6BAocMQ8D=?cEHP>"4&=?cE6"4E= 7 5 7 :E6;Fg2CAS6B:&cE=- 7 c=2CA2%7:DR9=?c 7 5, 6:4&6B:E=?FR 7 ,QR 7 A tc=ec=?6B:234g6"4D4234N5!23R9A<F9:+Th:E6;6\F96+c 7 =, :N=?A H 7 a<c6B46¡2%7=«¤c¥M 7 A9F H 7 a$c6"4 2%7 H¢¥rZ+M N-.2CA1@cH96B-&M8s6la?2C=?Aoc23R<cLcH96 7 a!2C:nc6"4&=234&=s6B44D234L6;:&c=- 7 c=2AR= AcH96 7 F 7 a<c=edC6SV -J6;cH2$FMN5 7 :E6;FK2CA 7F96B4E=?d 7 cE=2CAj2%7Da4D2Ca6B4dR9a<a6B4Q5?2%R9A9F9:7234cH96E*[A9=?cE6P6B, 6"-J6BAocL6"44D234d27fv =?A6BA96B41%iA234D-&MW5Qi-J6 7 A9:27=?AOcE6"4&=234+4&6B:&= FR 7 , : 7 A9F=?AOcE6"4 t 6",?6"-J6BAoc ! Rj$6;:BME$=-J=, 7 4,XipcA2G23R4 7 a9a4D2 7 >(HM 7 7234- 7 ,7 4D13R-J6BAoc:2%76", 6B-S6;Aocx8D= :E6XF96;>"23-Ja!2C:E=ec=2AlH 7 :D56;6BA$R9:E6;FMH96"4&6l72%4 7 F<=6"4E6;Aoc72%4-R, 7 c=2CAKM

87 ,R96;:N>"2CA*4-cH<6U56+cEc6B4g>"2CAodC6B41C6;A9>B6M7234WcEH96D: 7 -J6:234EF<6"42%7a?2%,i-A23-J= 7 , 7 a9a42R$=- 7 c=2CAM2%7cH96d´ 7 , 6"4DO= Al:2%,R<cE=2CAk= A$23R4DF2%R95, 6Xa!2c6;Aoc= 7 ,z7234-dR, 7 cE=2CAm8D=ecH$4E6;:Eab6B>;cfcA2 7 :23,R<c=2CAk5QicH<6E,?6 7 :nc t :DQR 7 4E6;:d-J6;cEH2$FzM<234XcH<6PV -J6;cH2$FKM ; AcH9=?:-.2-F96",NH 7 d-= A1 7 :&=-Ja, 6 16"23-J6;c4Di3M

Page 61: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4

x 105

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0.35

0.4

Number of elements

Rel

ativ

e er

ror

in m

agne

tic e

nerg

y

Air Iron Coil Total

=13R4E6dH¢s 2CAodC6B41C6;A9>B6d2%7cEH96- 7 1CA96;cE= >m6;A96"4D1%ik= A425, 6B-¨ET 7 F 7 a<c=edC64E6*[A96B-S6;AOc[Z

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

x 106

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0.35

Number of elements

Rel

ativ

e er

ror

in m

agne

tic e

nerg

y

Air, unif. Iron, unif. Coil, unif. Air, adapt. Iron, adapt.Coil, adapt.

=13R4E63%s 2CAodC6B41C6;A9>B62%7 cH960- 7 1A96;cE= >D6BA96B41%iS= AT42C5, 6"- T_R9A9=X7234-d-:;M 7 F 7 a<cE=?d604&6B*[A96 t-J6BAockZ 3

Page 62: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

D MA2-F96;: D ME6",-J: / M / M / / 8 8 39 £/¡ £ ¢<M¢/¡3¢ ¢<MX9¡ £ ¢<M 3 ¤ ¢<M¢S ¡H¢/¡%¤ /3 ¢<M¢£/¡ ¢<M¢3 3¢S ¢<M¡%¢/S ¢<M¢%¢/% H /S9 H¢3¢33%¤ ¢<M¢3¢/% ¢<M¢/¡% ¢<MXH¢3 / ¢<M¢%¢ 3 93¡%¡£Q ¢<M¢3¢ ¤ ¢<M¢H¤ ¢<M¢ ¤%£ ¢<M¢%¢/¡3¡ S %¢3%¢/ ¢<M¢3¢/¡%¡ ¢<M¢3¢/ ¢<M¢/¡3£ ¢<M¢%¢9¡ /¡3£3£ £Q£%£Q¡S ¢<M¢3¢ ¢<M¢3¢H ¢<M¢ ¢<M¢%¢3

4 7 5,?6l¡Ss 87 ,R<6B::2%7<4E6", 7 c=edC6@6B442%4E:D= AG- 7 1CA96+c= >z6BA96B41%iPTh>B74;M =13R4&6 H¢/Z

d 7 ,R<6B:4E6;:R,ec6;dC6;AR:D, =1HOc,iG56+cEcE6"4@cH 7 AcEH962CA96;:l25<c 7 =?A96BFF74D23- 7 ´ 7 , 6"4DO= A:2%,R<cE=2CAF2%78cH<6a4D2C5, 6B- = A d6B>+cA234 a!2cE6BAoc= 7 ,/7234-R, 7 cE=2CAR9:&= A10, = A<6 7 4q6BF166",?6"-J6BAoc:;M 6;:E=?F96B:BM 7 7 7 =4 7 >;>"R4 7 >Bi= A23R4<-S6+cH2-FL=?:<4&6 7 >(H96;F 7 c 7 :R J>;= 6BAoc,i,2H8~AQR-Q5b6"4<2%7[F96B134E6;6B:2%774&6B6;F23-IM<\: 7 AL6 7 -Sa, 6%M=7a8s6J>(H2S2C:&6E4&6B*[A<6"-J6BAoc7 7 >;cA2%4E: BZ< ¢x k7 A9F ) < ¢xl=?A:23R4&>B6 7 A9FA2CA t :23R4E>B64&6"1C=2CA9:"M4E6;:Eab6B>+c=?d6",Xi3MVcH<6&723,,2H8D= A1F- 7 1CA<6;c=?>k6BA96B41%id 7 ,R96;: 7 4E6$2C5<c 7 = A96;Fs/ M <Y¤x¢/kH¢ /$0 =M/ - <¨£x%¤3¢ [H¢ / V v MU/h1< x 6[H¢ /-3 =M`8D=?cEH 7 cA2uc 7 ,V6;A96"4D1%i/ 8 8 < ¤x«£ a[H¢ /$0 =M>"2%44E6;:Ea!2CA9F9=?A1tcA2 7 -S6;:EHI>"23-Ja?2:E6BFG2%73S9¤QA2$F<6B: 7 A9F$£9% £/¤Q6",?6"-J6BAoc:;M

=13R4&6+H¢@F96;:E>"4&= 5b6B:NcH<6U56;H 7 d$=23R42%7bcH<64E6", 7 c=edC6V6B44D234N= AQcEH96:- 7 1A96;cE= >V6;A96"4D1C= 6;:"Mo:&c42CA13,iF96;>"4E6 7 :E=?A1 7 :fcH96 A^R-Q56B4+2%7N6B, 6B-S6;AOcE:m= A<>"4E6 7 :E6;:"M?R9:E=?A1PcH<6Lc6;>(H9A9=QR96d2%7 7 F 7 a$c=?d6d-J6B:&HW4E6 t*[A96B-S6;AoczF96;:E>B4E= 5b6BF= A H 7 a<cE6"4N$M4UH<6L>"2%44E6;:Ea!2CA9F9=?A1J6"44D234Dd 7 ,R96;: 7 4E64E6;a?234nc6;F= AI4 7 5, 6¡$M 6B4E6M/4E6B*9A96"-J6BAoc7 7 >+cA234&: BZ7< );<©¢x H 7 dC6U5b6B6BAY>B2CA9:E=?F96"4&6BFt=?AQ5?2ucHt:2%R4E>;6 7 A9FtA2A t :D23R4E>;64E6B1C=2A9:BM =13R4&63\:&H2H8D:scEH96z:D,2H86B4sF<6B>"4&6 7 :&6+2%7z4E6", 7 c=edC6D6"4D4234&:a8DH<6BA 7 AER9A9=X7234- 4&6B*[A<6"-J6BAoc= : 7 a9a, =?6BFM= A9:nc6 7 FE2%7?23R4 7 F 7 a<cE=?dC6D:&>(H96"-J6%M/8D=?cEHS:DR9ab6"4Ea!2C:&=?c=2CAt= AY:&> 7 ,?62%7cEH96D>"234D4E6;:Ea!2CA9F9=?A14E6B, 7 cE=?d6S6B442%4 >BR4&d6B:t6B:nc=- 7 cE6BF5Qi 7 F 7 a<c=edC6.4E6B*9A96"-J6BAoc MG4UH96p>B2CAodC6"4D1C6BA<>B6C2%7VcEH96P:D23,R$c=2A= : 7 >;>"23-Ja 7 A9=?6BF5Qi 7 -.2CA2ucA2CA9=?>tF96B>B4E6 7 :E6C2%7cH96E4E6", 7 c=edC6 7 a!2C:&cE6"4&=234&=86B44D234mT$M«£/¢/Z 7 cL6 7 >(H:R<>B>B6;:E:&=?dC64E6*[A96"-J6BAoc\=?cE6"4 7 c=2AKM

4UH<6 7 F 7 a<cE=?d64E6*[A96"-J6BAocXa4D2$>;6BFR4E6%M8DH<6BA 7 a9a,?= 6;FMz,?6 7 F9:\cA2 7 :ncA42A1C6"44&6B*[A<6"-J6BAocXA96 7 4cH<6 =?AOcE6"4@7 7 >B6Mb6;:Eab6B>;= 7 ,,il>B,2C:&6c2ScH<6 >B234EA96B4E:02%7WcEH96l7h6B44D23- 7 1CA96;cE= >-J6BF9=R-$M 7 :\=ecf= :D6;d-= F<6BAoc742%- =1%R4E6O9¡SMa8DH9= >(Hi:EH2H8D: 7 F96+c 7 =,2%7zcEH96G=?A9=?cE= 7 , 7 A9FcH96$4E6*[A96BFq-S6;:EH 7 cJcEH96kcA2Ca 2%7=4D2CAKMD4UH96Q:&6B>B2CA9FF-J6B:EH2%7 =13R4E6.9¡YH 7 :m5b6B6;AW2C5<c 7 = A96;F 7 72cE6"40£g4E6*[A96B-S6;AOcm=?c6B4 7 cE=2CA<:"M>"2CA t:E=?F96"4&= A1fcH96: 7 -J6I4&6B*[A96B-S6;Aoc=7 7 >;c234E:>"234D4E6;:Ea!2CA9F9=?A1zcA2\cH96s6"44D234c4E6;A9FtF96Ba<= >;cE6BFt=?A =13R4E6H¢<M

n 6B:DR,?cE:U:EH2H8xcH 7 cUcEH96@>"2AOd6"4D1C6BA9>;6 =?ApcH96X>BR44&6BAoc t > 7 4D4Di-= A1Y>B2CA9FR9>+cA234U=?:V:,2H86B4DcEH 7 AlcH<62CA96X=?A 7 =46234D= A<:E= F<6mcH967h6"4D423- 7 1CA96+c=?>m>"234&6Ms4UH9= :D= :UFR96c2 7 >B2CAocA4E=?5R<cE=2CAG2%7cH96-.2$F96B,,?= A16"4D4234BM2H8D= A1pc2kcEH96t>"2%-SaR$c 7 cE=2CAW-J6;cEH2-FF2%7gcH96 =2c t 7 d 7 4&c+, 7 8XMSR<>(H6B442%4@>"2CAocA4&= 5R$c=2AH 7 :\56;6BAa4D2dC6BFc2P5b6d, 7 41C6B4\=?A4E6B1C=2A9:z=?A9:E=?F962%4zA96 7 4\cEH96Q>"2A9FR9>+cA234;M$6;6Q= AU¡39¥WH2H8 cH<6a 7 4nc=?>"R, 7 4s>(H2C= >;6+2%7 cH96z= Aoc6B134 7 cE=2CAE-S6+cH2-FC2%7cEH96 =2uc t 7 d 7 4ncI, 7 8 > 7 A 7 6B>+c 7 >B>BR4 7 >Bi 7 A9F>"2%-SaR$c 7 cE=2CA 7 ,8cE=-J6P= AcEH96k6;d 7 ,R 7 c=2CAU2%7 7 A9FzMgcEH96"4&6B7234&6%Ma2%7DcH96C- 7 1CA<6;c=?>p6BA<6"41id 7 , tR96;:BMN4UH96DF 7 c 7 4E6Ba!234nc6BFJH96B4E6DH 7 dC6f56;6BAS>"23-JaR<cE6BFY5/i4E6B:D234&cE= A1@c204 7 A 7 4 :8:&6"-J= t 7 A 7 ,Xi-cE= > 7 ,

%

Page 63: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

=1%R4E6 9¡^s ¬ 6;c 7 =,z27W=?A9=?cE= 7 , 7 A9F 7 F 7 a$c=?d6",Xim4E6*[A96;F-J6B:EH 7 cUcEH96X= Aoc6B4D7 7 >;6.Td42C5, 6"-¨9Z

-J6;cH2$FM 7 :8=ec:4&6B:R,?c: 7 4&6lT6;:Eab6B>B= 7 ,,XiQ>B,2C:&6VcA2@cH96D>B2C=,rZ<1C6BA<6"4 7 ,,i-.234E6 7 >;>"R4 7 c6UcEH 7 A 7 *9A9=?cE6d32%,R-J6 =?Aoc6"1%4 7 cE=2CA 7 A9FzM 7 5!2dC6 7 ,,M9a 7 4nc= >BR, 7 4,iE7 7 :&cBM 2CA9>B6B4EA9=?A1E*9A9=?cE6d%23,R-J6= Aoc6B134 7 cE=2CAc6;>(H9A9=^R<6B:"Mqc6;:&cH 7 dC6S56;6BAF2CA96Y5/i>"2CA<:E= F<6"4E=?A1 7 >B23-Ja?2C:&=?cE6´ 7 R9:E: t 56"1C6;A9F4&6EQR 7 F4 7 cR4E6M7 a9a, = 6;FcA2I6 7 >(Hc6;c4 7 H<6BF4D2CAR=?A9:E=?F96tcH96J>"2C=,M>(H2^2C:&= A1O t £ t 9¡pa!2C= Aoc4DR, 6;:2CA6 7 >(HR6",?6"-J6BAoc M; AlcH9=?:V> 7 :E6%M<=?cUH 7 :V56;6BA$2C59:&6"4&d6BFkcH 7 c 7 >B>BR4 7 >Bil=?:6-E2%4E6z:&6BA9:&=?cE=?dC6mc2QcH96@:&=~;62%7q= Aoc6B134 7 cE=2CAd32%,R-J6B:VcEH 7 AkcA2tcH96QR 7 F4 7 cR4E6l234EF<6"4 7 a9a, = 6;FlcA2Y6 7 >(Hkd32%,R-J6M

% "D) 4UH96G:&6B>B2CA9F a42C5,?6"-|= : 7 A 7 $= :@iS-.-J6;cA4&= >m-.2-F96",M 7 :Y= A~cH96ka4&6;d-=2%R9:Y> 7 :&6%M5R<c 7 -.234E6

>"2%-Sa,?6y?M A2CA t >"2CAod6yj1C6"2%-S6+cA4Di = :@a4D2 d-=?F96BFKMS4UH96.- 7 cE6"4&= 7 ,>"2CA*13R4 7 c=2A>B2CA9:&= :&cE:27 7 7h6"4 t42%- 7 1A96;cE= >-J6BF9=R- H 7 d-= A1 7 cxi-a9=?> 7 ,¦4E6+d323,edC6;F t :EH 7 a68DH2C:&6L>;6BAocA4 7 ,qc4R9AI=?:\:DR44D23R9A9F<6BF5/icH96J: 7 -S6YcA234D2C= F 7 , >"2a9a6B4 >B2C=, 7 : =?A 4D2C5, 6B- 3Mq=-.-S6B4E:&6BF= AcH96J: 7 -S6Y>Bi^,?= A9F4&= > 7 ,N5?2R2%7 7 =4H 7 d$=?A1Ya6B4D7h6;>;cA,Xil>"2A9FR9>+c= A1J5!23R9A<F 7 4E=?6B:;MI´@6"2%-S6+cA4Di 7 A9FkF9=-S6;A9:E=2CA9: 7 4&6@F96B:&>"4E=?56;F=?A =13R4E6 M

4UH<6Ja42C5,?6"- H 7 :@5b6B6;A:D23,?d6BF5/i >"2A9:E=?F96"4&= A1pcx8p2GF<=6"4E6;Aoc4 7 cE=2C:\56+cx86;6BAcEH96tF9=XzR9:&=?d6

Page 64: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

2.001.00

1.00

0.05

0.100.300.20

0.01

0.20

0.200.30

Copper

AirIron

=13R4E6d s$= 7 ,K:E6;>;cE=2CA$2%7qcH96XF23- 7 =?Al= A42C5,?6"- ¡&ThF9=-J6BA9:&=2CA<:V= AG-J6;c6B4E:AZ

>"2-6 J>;= 6BAocE:BM 2348cEH9607h6B44D23- 7 1CA96;cE= >:-J6BF9=R-&MO=ecH 7 :5b6B6BA 7 :E:DR-S6;F M C - < ¢3¢234 M C - < ¢7 A9FzM`72%4Q>"2C=, 7 A<F 7 =4"M M C < M C M <YMj01 7 = AzM=86k>"2A9:E=?F96"4 7 :nc 7 cE=2CA 7 4Di>"R4D4E6BAoc8D=?cEH>"2A9:&c 7 Aoc\F<6BA9:&=?cxiG- 7 1CA9=ecAR9F96 < H¢%¢ 1 Z M =13R4&6£ :&H2H8D:cH<6*[6B, FJ:&c4E6 7 -E,?= A96;:8=?AJcEH96f> 7 :&6 M C - < ¢3¢<MW4UH<= :8>"2CA*13R4 7 c=2AMQ, =u6 7 ,,

t :&H 7 ab6BFP1C6"2%-S6+cA4E=?6B:BM= :m>(H 7 4 7 >+c6"4&=~;6BF5Qi 7 :&=1CA<=*[> 7 AocXa?2cE6BAoc= 7 ,WF<=6"4E6;A9>B6Y=?AcEH96 7 =4+1 7 aM=M6M cEH96@>(H 7 A<A96",:&6Ba 7 4 7 c=?A1 7h6"4D423- 7 1CA96+c=?>z>"2%-Sa!2CA96;AOcE:"M9cEH96@H9=1H96"4U=ecV= :VcEH96mcH<= A9A96B4VcH961 7 a= :BM 7 A9FcEH96pH9=1CH96"4 cH96g7h6B44D23- 7 1CA96;cE= >Sa6B4-J6 7 59=, =ecxi= :BM)D2c=?>B6p=?A =13R4E6&£ cH<6p>"R4nd 7 cAR4&6= A ! 6B>+c=2A 27zcH<6G*96", F:&c4E6 7 -E,?= A96;:t= A cH96 7 =4 4E6B1C=2CA 5b6;cx8s6B6;A cH96I>"2=, 7 A<FicH<6$1 7 aV27zcH<67h6"4D423- 7 1CA<6;c=?>+-J6BF9=R-GM

; AcEH9= :L> 7 :&6%MNFR96pc2cH<6pA2CA t >"2CAod6y>1C6B23-J6;cA4@iP2%7DcH96g7h6B44D23- 7 1CA96;cE= >JF23- 7 = AzMW6"QR9=?a9ab6BF8D=?cEH>"234&A96"4&: 7 A9F6BF16B:"M 7 a 7 4nc=?>"R, 7 4z> 7 4E6t=?:+4E6B^R<=4E6;F=?A cH96t>B23-JaR<c 7 c=2AW2%78cH96 ,?= A96Q=?Aoc6 t134 7 , :qF96B*9A9= A1fcH96qHDR-Ja9:5b6;cx8s6B6;AYa?2cE6BAoc= 7 , : 7 cqcH<6= AocE6"4D7 7 >B6%M%234qd 7 ,R96B:|2%7 7 a?2:E:E=?5, 6 ¬ =4&= >(H,?6;c5!23R9A9F 7 4Di>"2CA9F<=?c=2CAKMG a!2C:&:E= 5, 6E8 7 ic2 = A<>"4E6 7 :E6ScH96 7 >B>BR4 7 >ih27D:R9>(H>, =?A96J= Aoc6B134 7 ,g>B23- taR<c 7 c=2CA9:m=?:mcA2^2 7 d32C=?FJencA2^2C,2CA13fPcA4&6B6;:"M 7 :@=?cN8I23R, FF2->B>"R4=?A cH9=?:m> 7 :E6Mdz=-J= A1 7 c@cEH9= :BM 7

¢

Page 65: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

=13R4E6d£sa 7 1A96;cE= >*[6",?Fk:&cA4&6 7 -., =?A96B:= A42C5,?6"- ¡GTh> 7 :&6 M C - < H¢3¢/Z

a 7 4nc=ec=2A2%7[cEH96V=?AOcE6"4@7 7 >B6s= AL:&6;d6"4 7 ,9:R4@7 7 >B6I4E6"1=2CA9:H 7 : 5b6B6;At>"2CA<:E= F<6"4E6;FKM 4UHQR9:BM/, = A<6s=?AOcE6"134 7 , :H 7 dC6 56;6BAG>"23-JaR<cE6BF$2CA6 7 >(Ha 7 4&cM8D=ecHI6B:&cE=- 7 c=2CAC2%7cH96;=4Ud 7 ,R96;: 7 ,2CA1Ja 7 cH9:f>"2A9A96B>+c=?A17 :&c 7 4&cE= A1La?2C=?AocU= Am2A964E6B1C=2CAE8D=?cH 7 A2cH<6"4V=?A 7 :R9>;>B6B:&:E=edC6l4E6"1=2CAKM = A 7 ,,i%MOa 7 4&cE= 7 ,cA4&6B6;:2CA:E=?A13,?604&6"1C=2CA9:8H 7 dC6@5b6B6BA 7 :E:&6"-Q5,?6BFl=?AOc2d13,2C5 7 ,[c4E6B6;:>B2 d6"4&= A1QcEH96N2dC6B4 7 ,,=?Aoc6"4@7 7 >B6M<A2-F96\5QiA2-F96Ma-=-J=, 7 4Na42->B6;FR4E6;: 7 4&6m:R1%1C6B:nc6BFm72%4>"2%-Sa,?6y t :&H 7 ab6BFm-.2-F96",?:"M 7 :scEH96Bi 7 4E674E6"QR96;AocA,i6BA<>"23R9AocE6"4E6;F = AG4&6 7 ,K6B, 6;>;cA4D23- 7 1CA96+c= >@F<6;d-= >;6B:BMaz:D=?A4D2C5, 6B-¨3M[=?Aoc6"1%4 7 cE=2CAC,?= A96;: 7 4E6@a!23,i^1 t2CA 7 , : 7 ,2CA1ta, 7 A96;:"M234R<A9=2CA<:2%7q6", 6B-S6;Aoc 7 4@i 7 4&>B:D5/il6BF16@a42H&6;>;cE=2CA 7 ,2CA1t>"R4&dC6;F:DR4D7 7 >;6B:;M4UH96;AM 7 AQR-J6"4E=?> 7 ,= Aoc6B134 7 c=2APH 7 :U5b6B6;Aka6B4D7234D-S6;Fm2dC6"4D6 7 >(Hk:E6"1%-S6;AOc[b 7 4&>m5/imR9:&= A1 7 ¡ t £ t a!2C= Aoc:, =?A96 7 4[bu>BR4&d-=,?= A96 7 4I´ 7 R<:E: t 56"1C6;A9F4E6lQR 7 F4 7 cAR4E6M

4 7 5,?6B: t7 A<F$£ 4&6Ba!234&cV6B:&cE=- 7 c6;:2%7 cH96- 7 1CA<6;c=?>z6;A96"4D1C= 6;:U= A 7 =4"MQ7h6"44D23- 7 1CA96+c= >0-S6;F9=R-&M>"2=, 7 A9F&13,2C5 7 ,F23- 7 = AzM[= AGcEH96 cx8p2p> 7 :E6;: M C - < H¢3¢ 7 A9F M C - < H¢ 4E6B:&a6;>;cE=?dC6B,iM n 6B:DR,?cE:

Page 66: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

x 105

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

0.2

Number of elements

Rel

ativ

e er

ror

in m

agne

tic e

nerg

y

Air Iron Coil Total

=1%R4E6 9^s 2CAodC6"4D1C6BA<>B6d27cEH96- 7 1A96;cE= >m6;A96"4D1%ik= A42C5, 6"- ¡&Th> 7 :&6 M C - < H¢3¢3Z

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

x 105

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

0.14

0.16

0.18

Number of elements

Rel

ativ

e er

ror

in m

agne

tic e

nerg

y

Air Iron Coil Total

=1%R4E6 s 2CAodC6B41C6;A9>B627cEH96- 7 1A96;cE= >m6;A96"4D1%ik= A42C5, 6"- ¡GT> 7 :E6 M C - < H¢ Z ¡

Page 67: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

n 67h6"4&6BA9>;6 ´YM F1C6 ´YMD02-F 7 , ´tM D02-F 7 ,V K %& !'())+* %E !'( (* %& '( -, / .

,-S: H¤¤/¡%¡ ¤/%¤.¡ H¢ ¡/ M x¢/¡%& H¢ / x¢/¡3& H¢ / x3"£U H¢ / x¢SH¤ H¢ / / - x £U H¢ / xS9& H¢ / ¡(x % 3& H¢ / x ¤, H¢ / /21 x %¤ H¢ /-3 x3¡%¤ H¢ /-3 £x¢/¤ H¢ /-3 x £U H¢ /-3/ 8 8 £x ¡%& H¢ / £x33& H¢ / x¤%£3¢ H¢ / £x £ H¢ /

4 7 5,?6 s 87 ,R<6B::2%7<- 7 1A96;cE= >m6;A96"4D1C= 6;:f=?A`4D2C5,?6"- ¡GT> 7 :E6 M C - < H¢3¢/Z

= n 6B7h6B4E6;A9>B6 ´tM F1C6 ´tM D02-F 7 , ´YM D2$F 7 , %& '( +* %& !'()) * %E !'( ) <, / .

,-J: ¤ 3 H 3¤ 3 / Y,Z 3¡%¢£ / M ¡jx ¢3¤ H¢ / ¡(x 3 H¢ / ¡jx £Q& ¢ / ¡jx 3& ¢ // - x3¡£U H¢ / x 3¡%& H¢ / x¡3%¢ ¢ / x%¢ ¢ / /h1 x%¢3¢ H¢ /-3 x , H¢ /-3 x3¡3¡& ¢ /-3 x & ¢ /-3/ 8 8 ¡jx H¢ / ¡(x SH& H¢ / ¡jx3%¤ ¢ / ¡jx 9¡& ¢ /

4 7 5,?6£s 87 ,R<6B:2%7 - 7 1A96;cE= >m6;A96"4D1C= 6;:f=?A`4D2C5,?6"- ¡$T> 7 :E6 M C - < H¢kZ

2C5<c 7 = A<6BFQ5/i2%R4NT 7234-dR, 7 cE=2CA 7 4&6F96;:E>"4&= 5b6BFY= A cH966, 7 :&cW>"23,R-JAKM4UH<6Vd 7 ,R96;:WcH 7 c 7 a9ab6 7 4= A cEH96d*4&:&c@c 7 5, 6LH 7 dC6Y56;6BA>"2%-SaR$c6BF5/i>(H2S2C:&= A1 ;Z[< ¢x 7 A9F ) < ¢x 7 :4&6B*[A<6"-J6BAoc7 7 >+cA234&:=?AcEH96Y:23R4E>B6 7 A9FA2CA t :23R4E>B64&6"1C=2CA9:"M¦8DH9=, 67 7 >+cA234&: ;Z_< ¢x 7 A9F )o< ¢xSSH 7 d65b6B6BA>"2A9:E=?F96"4&6BF= A cH<6J:&6B>B2CA9Fc 7 5,?6M01 7 =?AM4E6;:R,ec: 7 4&61C=?d6BA= A>B23-Sa 7 4E=?:2CAW8D=ecH6BA96B41%i6B:nc=- 7 cE6B:D>"2%-SaR$c6BFG5/i&2ucH96B4*[A<=?c6X6B, 6"-J6BAocfc6;>(H9A9=QR96;:BM =4E:&c"M[>"23,R-JAP4E6;a?234nc:DcH96l4E67h6"4 t6BA<>B6td 7 ,R96;:7423- 6 234&a?234 7 c6 n 6B:&6 7 4&>(HKM 23,R-SA9:¡C4&6Ba!234&cE:4E6B:DR,?cE:2C5<c 7 = A96;FF7423- 7 A7 F 7 a<c=edC6N´ 7 ,?6"4D-=?A.*9A9=?cE6\6B, 6"-J6BAocs:23,R<c=2CAJ= ASd6B>+cA234sa?2cE6BAoc= 7 ,7234D-R, 7 c=2AM/R9:E=?A1d,?= A96 7 4N6BF1C66",?6"-J6BAoc:;MzA 7 F 7 a<cE=?d6´ 7 , 6B4O= Ak:D23,R<cE=2CAkH 7 :\5b6B6;AWR9:E6;F 7 ,?:2YcA2J6B:&cE=- 7 c6@d 7 ,R96B:f= AI>"23,R-JA MN:nc=,,s=?AdC6;>;cA2%4ta?2cE6BAoc= 7 ,p72%4-R, 7 c=2CAMq5R<cY=?ARcH9=?:Q> 7 :E6lA2-F 7 ,s6", 6B-S6;Aoc:tH 7 dC6k5b6B6;A R<:E6BFzM, =?A96 7 4V= Ak> 7 :E6 M C - < H¢%¢M 7 A9FGQR 7 F4 7 cE= >X= Al> 7 :E6 M C - < ¢M

¬ 6+c 7 =, : 7 5!23R<ca4&6B:R,?c:a2C5<c 7 = A<6BF7423- cEH96DdC6B>+cA2348a!2c6;AOcE= 7 ,72%4-R, 7 c=2CAQd-= 7 6BF16 7 A<FSA2-F 7 ,6",?6"-J6BAoc:BMNcA231C6+cH96B4d8D=?cEHU7R4&cEH96"4 c 7 5,?6B:BM 7 4E6m4&6Ba!234&cE6BF = A«¤¥M ¬ =6"4&6BAocA,XiP74D23- 4 7 5, 6Wg72%442C5, 6"- 3MDd 7 ,R96;:m2C5<c 7 = A<6BFª742%- ,?6 7 :nc t :DQR 7 4E6;:m*[A9=ec6 6B, 6"-J6BAocl:D23,R$c=2A 7 4E6A2cG4E6;a?2%4&c6;FH96B4E6%M:E= A<>B6kcH96iiF2A2ucg4&6B:R,?cJ6BA2%R1CH 7 >B>"R4 7 cE6$7234tcEH9= :J>"23-Ja,?6y t :&H 7 ab6BF 1C6"23-J6;c4Di%M6;d6BA8DH96;A~>"2CA9:&= F96B4E=?A1WQR 7 F4 7 c=?>P6B, 6"-J6BAocE:BM4UH<6pV -J6;cEH2-F= :>"R4D4E6;AOc,ijR9A9F96B4Q= Aod6B:&cE=1 7 c=2A7234fcH9=?:fcxi-ab62%7gA2CA t >"2AOd6y >"2CA*13R4 7 c=2AM 7 A9FW4E6;:R,ec: 7 4E6 A2cNi6;c 7 d 7 =, 7 5,?6M H96;A 7 H9=1H7h6"4D423- 7 1CA<6;c=?>zab6"4D-S6 7 59=,?=?cxiY=?:V>"2CA<:E= F<6"4E6;FM[6M«19M M C - < H¢HM 7 c, 6 7 :&c 7 QR 7 F4 7 cE= > 7 a9a42R$=- 7 tc=2CAl= :4&6"QR9=4E6BFI= A 7 d6B>;c234Da?2uc6BAocE= 7 ,z72%4-R, 7 c=2CAP:D23,?d6BFI5/ilA2-F 7 ,K6B, 6"-J6BAocE:"M9cA2 4&6 7 >(H 7 7 7 =47 >;>"R4 7 >BiMFz:Q>B2CA9>B6B4EA9: 2%R4LF2%R95, 6S:E> 7 , 7 4 a?2uc6BAocE= 7 ,`7234-dR, 7 cE=2CAzMq6+dC6;Ai=?AcH<= :L> 7 :E6C4&6B:DR,?cE:>"2A*4- 7 132^2$F 7 >;>"R4 7 >Bi%Mb>B23-Ja 7 4 7 5, 6@cA2YcH<62CA<6l4&6 7 >(H<6BF 5/iI6BF16 6B, 6"-J6BAocE:"M86B,, t OA2H8DAIc2

3

Page 68: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

5b6a 7 4&cE= >"R, 7 4D,iJ6 J>B=?6BAoc7234VdC6;>;cA2%4:72%4-R, 7 c=2CA9:;M

=13R4&6B::9 7 A9F F96;a9= >+cscEH96fF96B>B4E6 7 :E= A1 cA4&6BA9Fg2%7 cEH9604&6", 7 c=edC6D6"4D42348= AYcH96- 7 1CA96+c= >D6;A96"4 t1C=?6B: 7234 7 At= A9>B4E6 7 :E=?A1@AQR-Q5b6"42%7b6",?6"-J6BAoc:<8DH96BA.-S6;:EH 4&6B*[A96B-S6;Aocp2->B>BR4E:N=?A 7 F 7 a$c=?d6I8 7 iM ; A =13R4E609SM/4&6B*[A96B-S6;Aoc7 7 >;c234E: ;Z7<¢x 7 A9F ,)<J¢x mH 7 dC6D5b6B6BAY>B2CA9:E=?F96"4&6BFJ= ALcEH96U:2%R4E>;6 7 A9FA2CA t :2%R4E>;6 4E6"1=2CA9:BM?8DH9=, 6 = A =13R4E6E 4&6B:Eab6B>+c=edC6",Xi7 7 >+cA234&: BZ[< ¢x 7 A9F )<¢x3¡3PH 7 d65b6B6BA.R9:&6BFKM D2c=?>B6VcEH 7 cN=?AQcH96;:E6D6y 7 -Ja, 6;: 7 :EH 7 4Eab6"4`4E6*[A96"-J6BAocgH 7 :85b6B6;A4E6"QR9=4E6;FJ=?A9:E=?F96VcH<6:2%R4E>;6t>"2CA9FR9>;c234BMN,ecH2%R1CH 7 :D- 7 ,,¦4E6B*9A96"-J6BAoc7 7 >+cA234 ;ZlH 7 :mcH<64E6B, 7 cE=?dC6 6"4D4234mF<6B>"4&6 7 :&6BFdC6B4Di.7 7 :&c,iY=?A9:E=?F96UcH96\:23R4&>B6+4&6"1C=2CAM/8s6N2C59:&6"4ndC6m=?A 7 ,,[> 7 :&6B: 7 ,2H86B4 7 >B>"R4 7 >ig2%7K6"44D234gd 7 ,R96;:= A<:E= F<6QcH96t>B2C=, 8D=ecHO4E6;:Eab6B>+cc2ld 7 ,R96;:=?A 7 =4 7 A9F= A9:&= F96QcEH96 7h6"4D423- 7 1CA96+c=?>- 7 c6"4&= 7 ,M?2H8D=?A1cA2tcEH96 7 5?2d6-J6BAoc=2CA96;F$-.2-F96",, = A1L6"4D4234U=?AlcH96X>"2%-SaR$c 7 cE=2CAC2%7qcH<6 =2c t 7 d 7 4&c6, 7 8XM

£

Page 69: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

1

zA 7 F 7 a<c=edC6[A9=ec6m6 6S6;AOcV: <c=CA 7 > 7 :E: cEHE6;6 t F<=J6BA9:&=CA 7 7 A96+cC:nc 7 cE= >\aC5 t 6S:IH 7 :56;6BA aCa:E6BFC5<c 7 = A<6BF 7 :E> 7 7 a!c6;AOcE= 7 LT " # 7 c=CA$t:&c 7 c=?> 7 &%s6: 6"' 7 cE=CA<:BM 4UH96&6B:?cE= A 5! 9A<F 7 Did 7 <6Va5 6 =?: 7 6;A96 7 =~B6BF7(C=?:E:A))-F96%D=?cEH#J= $6BF ACA t H ) 6BA<6 9:q5! 9A9F 7 Di 7 A9FQ=?AOcE6* 7 >B6s>CA9F<=?c=CA9:+ ¬ =E= >(H, 6;c 7 A<F D\6 7 A9Acxi-a6uML4UH96#9A9=?cE6Q6?6J6BAoc@F9=?:E>&6;cE=~ 7 c=A >CA<:E= :nc:- 7 a9=?6B>;6%D= :&6. =?A96 7 +´ 7 6DO= A/J6;cEH-F0CAc6+c 7 H96BF, 7 S6;:EH21 H 7 a<c66£'3 M a!C:&cE6E= E=b6B:nc= 7 cE6B:4cH965[A9=?cE6m6?6J6BAocV6 H 7 d6@56;6BAa d6BF =?AG6;A96 iIA 69cSad$=?F96>E=ec6E= 7 7 A 7 F 7 a$c=?d6 :nc 7 c6 i7 W t E69A96J6BAoc5 cH<6J6B:EH81 H 7 a<c60 3+M

n 6B:?cE:1 H 7 a<cE66 39CAScE6B:&cs> 7 :E6B: 7 A9FS> Ja 7 &= :A9::%D=?cH)cEH96;[A9=ec6D6?6J6BAocscE6B>(H9A<='96B::EH,<% 7 A H9= H<6 7 >B> 7 >i=$> 7 F 7 a<cE=?d66[A9=ec6G6 6S6;AocP: <cE=CAd-= 7 T] ? # 7 c=A@%D=?cEHAE6B:&a6;>;c8c 7 F 7 a<c=edC6[A9=ec6U6?6J6BAocS6+cH-F9:N5 7 :E6BFBCA. 7 cE=CA<:W5/i.[6?F9:516uM MC 6 7 :&c t:' 7 E6B:qc6;>(H9A9='96;:D3E F 7 Cd6B>+c &:16uM MqcEH96gV S6+cH-FF3GH cEH96g: 7 J6; EF96I9a! i-AS= 7 7 a9a,R$= 7 c=CAKM 6;:E= F<6B:$ 7 F 7 a<c=edC68:E>(H96S68a-F9>;6B:+BE6 7 >B> 7 c6E6B:?cE:cH 7 A 7 A 7 F 7 a tc=edC6´ 7 6O= Al: <cE=CApd-= 7 d6B>+c Da!c6;AOcE= 7 #, 7 cE=CA<:E= A ^ q6?6J6BAoc: VcH<6: 7 J6 &F96;M = A 7 i[cH96' 7 =?cxi7$4&6B:?cE:m= :\> Ja 7 7 5 6XcScH96#A96#E6;:ec=?A 7 A 7 F 7 a<cE=?d6´ 7 6O= A: <cE=CA=?AdC6B>+c a!c6;AOcE= 7 + 7 cE=CA6%DH96BA ` -` 6?6J6BAoc: 7 &6J>CA9:&= F96E6BFI cH<6J: 7 J6# EF<6cEH96B:&6) 7 cEcE6m5b6B=?A %6 t OAH%DA0 mcH96;=m6 J>B= 6;A9>Bi=?AJ[A9=ec6t6?6J6BAoc@dC6;>;c :<cE=CA9:;M

K <A9F 7 J6BAoc 7 )$F96?= A 7 :Eab6B>+cD= :cEH96@6B:nc= 7 cE=CAB cH96- 7 A<6;c=?>5[6 FlF<6mct=Ja!C:E6;F>,E6;Aoc:g5/i> Ja<c 7 c=CAL$UcH96 =c t 7 d 7 &cM 7 %N%DH,C:E6 7 >B>, 7 >i 7 6B>+c:Qa 7 &c=?> 7 Xi cH<6[A 7 7 >;> 7 >Bi =?AOE6;:ec:;M p>C= 6 S6+c&= 6B:UcH96 =c t 7 d 7 &cB 7 % H 7 :l5b6B6;A > Ja<c6;FE6;: nc=?A c_05 7 A 7 :Q:E6S= t 7 A 7 iOc=?> 7 :J6;cEH-F@C%D=?cEH6B:nc= 7 cE=CALD6 =?a<c=?>t= Aoc6 7 ?:BM >Sa?6y t :&H 7 ab6BFk>,E6;Aoc t > 7 @i-= A E6 =CA<: 7 [A<=?c6md ,S6@=?AOcE6 7 c=CApH 7 :f5b6B6;AG>CA9:&= F96E6BF>A9:E=?:&c=?A 7 >Sa!C:E=ec6.´ 7 9:&: t 56 6BA9F,E6.& 7 F 7 c&6BdC6 7 6 6J6BAocE:=?A9:E=?F96QcH<6S: E>;6>A9F9>+c &:BM 6;:E= F<6B:KcEH96 7 >;> 7 >Bi6E6;:ec:\= : 7 ?:S= A ! <6BA9>;6BF5/iGcEH96 7 >;> 7 >Bi/NcH96LA& tJ6E=?> 7 g=?AOcE6 7 c=CA:E>(H96S6P9:&6BFQ >Sa$c= A =?A96J= Aoc6 7 ?: F<6[A9=?A d 7 96B:R ¬ =&= >(H?6;c5! 9A9F 7 Dik>A9F9=?cE=CA<: -HSa<:5WF9= :&>CAocE= A'9=?cxi 7 cDcH96= Aoc6 7 >;6X56+cS%6;6BAa!c6;AOcE= 7 ?:9F,96ccH<6: &>B6M 7 A96;cE= >T[6 FKM

4UH<6@:E6;d6 7 7 :&a6;>;c:$IB-F96 =?A L7 A9Fp>Sa$c 7 cE=CAp=?Aod edC6BFl=?APcH<6maE6;:E6;AOc%4 DP: 6B:nc 7 A/iQc 7 :DO:4 9 <cE6U%4 M CA9>;6&A9= A > Ja<c 7 c=CA@CH<= H96; EF96p´ 7 ?6D-=?A.[A9=?cE6D6 6S6;AocJ6;cH,$F9:g:&H ?FP5b6f>CA9:&= F96E6BF Ma6?cE= &= Ftc6;>BA9='96B:8> , FJ56 7 a9a?= 6;F 7 :ga&6B>CA9F9=ec=A96&:; cH<6)[A<=?c6Y6 6J6BAoc : <c=CA@5/i29:E=?A cH96JH9= 6 7 &>(H/iL$VA96;:&c6;FQE6G[A96;F &= F9:;M CA9>;6&A9= A 7a!C:&cE6E= E= 6 7 A 7 i-:E=?:b:E= A<>B6L6;:&cE= 7 c6;:zH96E6QH 7 d6Q56;6BA F<6[A96;F0 fcEH96Q65NcEH96R9A9=?cE66?6J6BAocp: $c=A@=M6uM 7 cSauc6BAocE= 7 V 6+dC6WV=?c 7 a9ab6 7 E:p=?AOcE6&6B:&cE= A R7 : 7 :9>;>B6B:&:E=edC6:&c 7 6GcJ6 7 :E6mcEH96@6 7 :&:->B= 7 c6;FkcQcH96@6;A96 ilAX$cEH96@auc6BAocE= 7 W$:&= A9>;6=ecV=?:E6 7 c6;FpctcH<6 7 A96+c= >@6;A96 iCM 6B:&= F96;:F 7 ) E6X> Sa, 6;cE6X6 7 A 7 Xi-:E= :[6B:nc= 7 cE6B:U VcH96M)$F96?= A 6 N:&H ?FS5b6U>A9:E=?F96&6BF@& 7 = AXicEH96D6 NF<6Dc@cH96D>Sa$c 7 cE=CA.bcH<6 =c t 7 d 7 &cC 7 %7 A9F cEH96t6B:nc= 7 cE=CA6; =?A96L=?Aoc6 7 ?:TCA ¬ =E= >(H, 6;c\:, 7 >;6B:BMY9>(HZ)$F96?= A 6 m>CAoc&= 5 t

Page 70: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

c=CA9:m> ?F56Qc 7 6;A=?Aoc 7 >;> 9Aoc c 6+cH96T%D=?cEH cH96 7 a!C:&cE6E= E=I[A9=ec6t6 6J6BAoc@6 7 B-F9= [6BFl:nc 7 c6 i7CJ6B:&H7E69A96J6BAoc 7 =S=?A t7 c 7 AI=Sa,dC6S6;AOcU$C&6B:,?c:D6;:Eab6B>B= 7 Xip=?AE6 =A9:U>C:E6@cY>C=M

= A 7 i' 7 A 7 A 7 Xi$:&= : $ 7 > Sa, 6;cE6 7 A96+cC:nc 7 cE= >z> 7 :E6$ 7. 6BA96 7 ?=~ 7 c=CA ( )-F96:EH, Fl5b6m>CA9:E=?F96&6BFP%D=?cEHp= Aoc-F9>;cE=CA a6 7 A96;AOc 7 A96;cE:<:tcH 7 cscH96@>CAoc&= 5<cE=CABcH<6>$6E>;=?dC6-[6 F g= : 7 ?:Qc 7 6;A= Aoc 7 >B>9Aoc M

Page 71: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

" )= *($ (BI

:%D=?:EHpc cH 7 APa 7 nc=?> 7 XiJ: M 7 6B: H9A9:A VH9=?: 7 7 5?6zHC:&a9=?c 7 =ecxi 7 c H 7 J6&: =?A9=?cE6 6S6;Aoc 6BAoc6U H 7 S6E:l0fA9=?d6E:&=?cxi 46;>(H9A iP= AG´Jc6;5 &%6;F96BA M:%D= :&Hcl6 $aE6;:E:XclH9= diGF96;6Ba 7 A9F:E=?A9>B6E6 7 c=ec9F<6R mH<= :m:&>B= 6;Aoc=9> 7 A9FZB 7 q:9a<a nc :S6@a&6B>;= 9:U&6 7 O: 7 2c6E6 7 F9= A iPE6;a nc 7 A9F7 U5&=?= 7 Aoc-=?A9:Ea<=E=?A >AOd6&: 7 cE=CA9:;M

7 7 cE6 c 7 8cH96lab6Ca, 6PfcH96k>;6BAoc6 7 A9F~cH96 ¬ 6Ba 7 &cS6;AOcA$ 7 cH96 7 cE= >;:# H 7 S6E:-0\A9=edC6&:E=ecxi 7 A<F´Suc6B5! 0\A<=?dC6E:&=?cxi >CAoc&= 5$c= A t %D=ecHQH<6 auc6 7 >(H9=?A &6B:E>;6B:7 A9FGO= A<F9A96B:&: t c 7 dC6@ila?6 7 : 7 Aoc% DO= A 6BAod-=CAJ6BAoc M`5BCA cH966s6y$a&6B:E:Vdi 7 cE= tc<F96ga 7 &cE= > 7 ifc- 7 :| 7 #96 :E:CA@< H9=?:aE6;>B=9:c6 7 >(H9= A \7 A9FH96 aX= A'96B:nc=CA9:qF96 7 ?= A %D=?cEH ? ? >$F<6, 9=ec bF9=?>9:&:E=A9: CAl: S6zA&,S6E= > 7 7 :Eab6B>+c: 7 A9F VH<= : 7 F<d-= >B6 7 2c6E6 7 F9=?A iZE6Ba! nc MH%s6 7 c=ec9F<6Yc n = >[ 7 &F 6 :nc 7 A9FD\=' 7 : &= >;:E:A@( @cEH96B=H96 a 7 A9F a 7 cE= 6;A9>B6I= A 7 A9:%s6&= A 7 VcEH96GcE=J6B:Adi>'96B:nc=CA9: 7 5! <c ? ? >-F96 7 A9F90fA9= :Di-:nc6J: 7 A<F VcEH96> 7 AQiP5&3O:UcH96i7 6;AOcUJ6M

A9>B6EA9=?A cH<66[A9=ec6I6?6J6BAocp:2cS% 7 E6ab6* J6BFi= AcH9=?:B&6B:E6 7 E>(H a,H&6;>;c #%D=?:EHiccH 7 A- 7 : sH<= :>$F<6 7 5! <c8cH96 E=?FP> 7 :E:&6B:$c 6;cEH96%D=?cH n =?>[ 7 EFB%DH,C:E6@>$F96\H 7 :s56;6BA9:&6BF5/iPJ6 7 : 7 AI= A9=ec= 7 5 7 :E=?: U=Ja 6S6;Aoc 7 cE=CAKM

= A 7 i 7 7 : 7 cE6 c&5 6B:&: 7 A<F V7 :&c 7 A9=?A9=:I 6 n =?>B6E> 7 =?AUG= 7 A,c 7 Xi N= 6 = =+TcEc- cEH96 ¬ 6Ba 7 &cJ6BAoc; 6B>+c&= > 7 A = A<6B6&= A =?Ag´@6BA, d 7 0\A9=edC6E:E=ecxi c 7 Xi zA<FE6 7 6ncCA9=q46;>(H9AQ&2cU:BM 7 M:BMg= AC´X6;Ad 7 7 A9F[ 7 6EA 7 A9F96;:cH96:&c=ec<cQab6 7 7 cE6 7 c=?> 7 za<a =?> 7 c 7 @& t D n = A&´@6BAd 7 UcH<6B=UH<6 acEH96B=U: 6B:nc=A9: 7 A9F7 UcH<6= A<=?c= 7 b= A9:&a9= 7 c=CA 7 5! <cUcEH96X:95(H&6;>;c5WcEH96XaE6;:E6;AOcV%4 M

4UH<= :T%4 GH 7 :@5b6B6;AJ[A 7 A9>;= 7 iI:<a9a&c6;F5QiIcH<6 D 7 cE=CA 7 n 6B:&6 7 &>(H 9A9>B=1 D n 35c 7 i $cH H7E6;:E6 7 E>(H/h6<%D:&H9= a<: 7 AocDAKMp¡%¢ M¢CM%¢ 7 cH96 7 c= > 7 ->B= 6;A9>B6;:BM

Page 72: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...
Page 73: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

"¥dM \5 7 BH%D=?c~ (M M-cE6 9A ^G yO$M u[` _ 4-^ _ ^ ¬ dC6 :95 =?> 7 tc=CA9:dD\6% 01@H¤ 3

«¡c¥M<TucEc, LM V7 :&c 7 A9=?A9= bM´@=&F9= A<=DM 6EA 7 A<F96B: pwkwecwG` ^ ^G N ` ` u 2^ 2^ ` `(_ w _ ^G ^ ` _=!we ` `` 4+ 7 A9:;MQ 7 AKM £ ¡ ¢ t ¡ 3 1 H¤3¤3 3

¥ (M V7 59:D 7 + M M n 6B=L59H ?F<c % `w cw `wkwecw` ` Rcw u[` y ^ `~` ` ` ^ ` u% AOcBM M,D5,GM!G6+cHKM A M9¡Y9¤/ t 9P1@¤/% 3

£%¥dM V7 7 i 9 M ¬ Mc´-Ca<a@5NM MG> A9A<6B: M McYS=ecH@Q 6K_ `w ^% u4q6B>(H9A<= > 7 E6;a nc:D^5 t ¤/3bS% t n 6+d$=?:E=CA&¡$M¢$M ¡% YT CA9A96D 7 c=CA 7 5 7 5 7 cDiZ1¡%¢3¢3¢ 3«c¥ n M M V7 A!LM"6B=?:E6 64 ` % `w cw `wwecwU` cw RcwV` _¦ w Y( `w` ^Y

` ^ 7 cHKM Ja<cBM£3£¡% x ¢)1@¤3 / 3 ¥ M M V7 &cCA@!5NMM,D 7 >[' 7 A@ 6K_ ` ^ y _ ^G ` ^ 2^ `(`w 2^ 2 \F9F9= :CA R6;: 6! 21@¤3¤/ 3«c¥"M 6;>[6#M 7 A<A 7 >(H96# `(` v. _ M /!we _[u L`wwecwz_ ^ we $2^ y ^ `m` ` ` ^ ` u^v

_ ^G O ^G ` R ` 87 :&c R6;:&c M D5IM 7 cH$£¡ ¡ £ 1 H¤3¤ 3 ¥"M 6 :&c ` v w` 6y ^ `p` ` ` ^ ` u% RcwP` `(_ w ^ ` _ / _ ^ 5= >Mo4UH<6B:E=?: ¬ 6;a<c MS 7 cH96 7 cE= >;: H 7 J6&: 0fA9=?d6&:E=?c% )K46;>(H9A ´Suc6B5! 1¡%¢3¢3¢ 3 ¤¥"M 6 :nc6SLM CA9F96;:CA M CH9A<:CA@M ´tMj5 7 E:A@#QM5=@tM 7 #96?:E:CA@ !v

N ` y ^ `` ` ` ^ ` u% 2^ ` `(_ w ^ ` _ N4q6B>(H9A9=?> 7 &6Ba! &cE¡&4 &%s6BF9=?:EHA9:&cE=?c<c6-<za<a =?6BF& 7 cEH96 7 c=?>B:M1 H¤3¤3¤ 3

H¢¥"M 6 :&c !M!5 7 E:CA@ tM! 7 #96 :&:CA@ u[` y ^ `J` ` ` ^ ` u% L^G j v%w Y Rcw u[` ^ ` _ !we ` H 7 J6&: =?A9=?cE6 6S6;Aoc 6BAoc6:E6Ba,E= Aoca¡¢3¢ ¢/¡Y H 7 S6E: 0\A<=?dC6E:&=?c% P4q6B>(H9A !´Suc6B5! 1¡%¢3¢H3

3"¥dM 6EA@ ¬ M a9a9:&cE6B=?A@ ` u -` ^ `w ^^G [ & w Y^ j ^ = A 2 '2^ 2^ _ Y ` ^ K ` ` w ¬ M M ¬ @ M % 7 A 6BF<:BM L F&$>B=?6BAoc= [>¡ ¤%¢71@H¤3¤3¡ 3

9¡c¥M M &EFQM ¬ M &= 6;F 7 A@( ^G yO$M _&) ^ ` %w Rcw ^ 2^ `(`w ^G 6K_ ` ^ $a&= A 6,Df6% Z1 H¤/SH3 ¥ QM V7 = tMa 7 #96 :&:CA@ w ` ( ` N ` ` u% O u N ^ $^ w _ Y w`

%w Y Ja<c M = : 7 M$>;=M 3 "£ 1¡%¢%¢3¢ 3 £%¥ M M V7 :CA@ 2 #2^ J` _ 2^ ` %w _ ^ DVIM^ 7 cH M % 1 H¤/%¤ 3 9c¥lLM V7 :&c 7 A9=?A9= pwkwcwJ` ^ ^G ` u ^* `(_[u ^ ` Rcw y ^ `S` ` ` ^

` u% DNHKM ¬ Mq4UH<6B:E=?: ¬ =?aKMA 6 A96&= 7& ?6;c&cE=?> 7 D0\A<=?dC6E:&=?c 7 qF<6 ?=IOc9F9=gF9=I´@6BAd 71@H¤%¤3 3

¤

Page 74: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

¥ ¬ M tM H<6BA & ` ^G N ` `(_ we ^ ` _ zF9F9=?:CA 6B:?6 21 H¤3 3 9c¥M´YM = 7 6+c u[` 2^ ` ` ` ^ ` u% Rcw _ we ` _DV &cEH 7 A9F@^TJ:

c6EF 7 1@H¤/ 3 H ¥ tM E=O:E:A@ ¬ M :nc6BaM \7 A9:E5! M CH9A9:CA@ ) ^ we _ ^ N ` ` u% Rcw `w` ^Y ` ^ z>+c 7 D5J6&= > 7 £,H¢/ 9% 71 H¤3¤/ 3 H¤¥ tM &=O:E:CA@ ¬ M :&cE6Ba@M z7 A9:&5, M CH9A9:CA@ 2 # ^G `w` ^Y ^

V7 Q5&= F 6 0\A9=edC6E:E=ec% :E6B:&:#1 H¤3¤ 3«¡%¢¥ tM E=-:&:CA M CH<A9:CA(z^# N ` y ^ `U` ` ` ^ ` u% Rcw 2^ ` w` _!we ` 7 cEHKM Ja<cBM!%¢, 1@H¤3 % 3«¡S"¥ tM E=O:&:CA@ M CH9A9:CA@ N ` y ^ `Q` ` ` ^ ` u% RcwI w y _p!we ` ) 2^ ` w ` !we ` x+ M,DVIMzAKM!¡% Y£ 3P1@H¤%¤<3«¡3¡c¥5NM M d 7 A9:U w Y `w` ^Y ^ [=?A K w ` 6 d ` 2^ u[` _ M

H¤,5S6E=?> 7 A$ 7 cH96 7 cE= > 7 ¦Y->B=?6;c% [:d-= F<6BA9>;6"DH-F96 : 7 A9FL1@H¤%¤3 3«¡ ¥M 6&A 7 A9F96;:=M CAoc 7 A 7 ^ N ` y ^ `I` ` ` ^ ^G O ` `x[` ^G ` ^

` _ wkw` ^ !w ` l w ) 2^ `S` ` ` ^ ` ^G _ `wwecwP` ^ @&f6;a&c0¡Y A9:E= = D 7 ~;=CA 7 6mF<6?6 f=?>B6E>(H96$ c 7 Z1@¤3¤3 3

«¡£%¥M 6EA 7 A<F96B:M´X=EF9=?A9= ^ N ` y ^ ` ` ` ` ^N^G O _ ^G ` `t` `(_ w ^ ` _I!we ` AocBM M D5IMG6+cHKM A M£/Y!¡S9 ¡£ 1 H¤3¤3¤ 3

«¡3c¥M 6&A 7 A9F<6B:Mc´@=&F9= A<=9´tM96 = A 7 E=W `(_[u ^ ` =u^vxw` y ^ ` ` ^ 2^# N ` ` u 2^ (cw u 5 Aoc M M JaKM6 7 cH M ?6B>+cE=?> 6;>;cCA9=?> A M ¡%¤ 3 £1@H¤%¤%£'3

«¡ ¥dM CAoc 7 A 7 R [`w ` ^ _(` ^G Y ` ^| N ` y ^ `` ` ` ^ ` u% 2 u `w 2^ ` ` ` ^ 2 ` ^ `w q4q6B>(H9A9=?> 7 DVc6$ H 7 S6E: =?A9=?cE6 ?6J6BAoc 6BAoc6 H 7 J6&:0\A9=edC6E:E=ec% P46;>(H9A !´ScE6B5! 1 H¤3¤3¤ 3

«¡3c¥dM CAoc 7 A 7 ) ^ ` %w ^ ` u% Rcw u[`_ _ ( ^ u[` ^ ` _ y ` ; ` _ H 7 S6E: = A9=ec6 6J6BAoc 6;Aoc6#:E6;aE=?Aoc.¡%¢3¢ ¢/Y H 7 S6E: 0fA9=?d6E:&=?c% L46;>(H9A !´ScE6B5! 1¡%¢3¢H3

«¡% ¥ M M z7 Oc ^ 2^ `(`w 2^ `(_ w ^ ` _ G>´> 7 % =91@H¤3 3 3«¡%¤¥ M = A u[` 2^ ` ` ` ^ ` u% 2^ `(_ we ^ ` _ M =?6 7 A9F&YCA9:1@H¤%¤ 3 ¢¥ M CH9A<:CA@ `w _ 64 # ^ w Y `w` ^Y ^ u[` 2^ ` ` ` ^

` u% -c9F96;AOc =ecEc6 7 cM1@¤3 / 3 "¥ M H9A9:A@ ^ N ` y ^ `I` ` ` ^ ` u% Rcw ^ ^G _ ^ N `(_ ^ !we `

JaKMG6+cHKM\a9aKM!G6;>(HKM A M /¡Y ¢S ¡%¡1@H¤%¤3¢ 3

Page 75: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

¡c¥ ¬ M« M @6 MMsF96PMM6´ 7$ M M = 6;AO= 6%D=?>"~$ % `w cw `wwecw ^G I ^G N `p!we_(` ` 2^ u[` y ^ `Q` ` ` ^ ` u% w )v pwkwecw ^G I AOcBM M,DVGMG6;cEHKM A MH¤Y9%¤ ¤P1@H¤% 3

3 ¥ ¬ M« M @6 MMsF96PMM6´ 7$ M M = 6;AO= 6%D=?>"~$ % `w cw `wwecw ^G I ^G N `a!we_(` ` 2^ u[` y ^ ` ` ` ` ^ ` u% l w ) )Nv ^ N ` ` umw` y ^ ` ` ^ Aoc M M,DVGM!I6;cH M A MH¤, ¡S 1 H¤3 3

£%¥dM -E=~;6"F(MD\6;=?c&c 7C7 A, 7 O=W u[` _ B^G `w _ ` 2^ 2^ `(_ w _ ^ v 2^ `(`w 2^ - %s6:z> 7 F96J= > :95, = :&H96&:R1@H¤3¤ 3

c¥ M M D\6;d-= 6$ _ Y^ _ 4-^ _ ^ Y EF 7 &6BA9F,CA :&6B:E:1@¤/S<3 ¥ M M!:E6B:&:?M«LM[4q6$ :D M4@M 6+cEc6?= A MqM 7 A9A96 `w _ w`(_ [` 2^ 2

V7 Q5&= F 6 0\A9=edC6E:E=ec% :E6B:&:#1 H¤3¤/¡3

c¥lLM 7 &c6CA<= LM 87 =W `w _ /!we R ^ E w Y `w` ^Y ` ^ $a&= A 6 6 7 1 H¤3¤%£'3

¥dM(D6BA 7 EF$ M M(U 6E: z^ ) ^ we _ ^ w Y `w` ^Y ^ Q$a&= A 6 6 7 1 H¤3¤ 3

¤¥dM M f=ed 7 7 $ (cw u Rcww` y ^2^ w Y^ j w%w Y = # ` Rcw N ` ^G j v%w Y `(_[u ^ ` Aoc M M DVIMG6;cEHKM A M!¡%¢,£Q 3 1 H¤3 %£'3

£/¢¥ MU9F9= A ` $^G _ ` R ^G O G>H´- 7 % =:1 H¤3 / 3

£"¥ tM6 7 #96?:E:CA@ N ` (cw u Rcw y ^ `` ` ` ^ ` u% /!we R 2^ POe ` NHKM ¬ M[4UH96B:&= : U 7 A<:&c=ec<cE6>W4q6B>(H<A ?-c$>[OH 1 H¤3¤ 3

£Q¡c¥MM$=edC6B:nc6 XM5gM 6 7 &= , 2^ ` ` ` ^ R `(_ _ ^ 2^ `(` V7 L5E=?F 6=0fA9= dC6E:E=ec% [:E6;:E:.1 H¤3 3

£ ¥ Mt4UHS6;6MJ5 7 E:&:CA@) Y `(` ^Y ^ O ` _ ` H 7 S6E: 0\A<=?dC6E:&=?c% P4q6B>(H9A !´Suc6B5! 1 H¤3¤3¤ 3

£3£%¥dM[4+ 7 L56 `(` ` ^ ^G y ^ `t` ` ` ^ _ ' ^ Q` _ (` ^ 2^ y ^ _ ^ _ #2^ ` gH M ¬ M94UH<6B:E=?: ¬ 6Ba$c M 6;>;cE= > +H%6 A =?A96B6E=?A H 7 J6&:0\A9=edC6E:E=ec% P46;>(H9A !´ScE6B5! 1 H¤3¤3 3

£Qc¥ M« Mq4+H%D5E=?F 6$ z^ ) ^ e _ ^ 2 # ` Y ` `(_ e ^ ` _ z^G O M =?6 7 A9FYCA9:R1@¤3¤/¡ 3

£ ¥5NM0M05 7 A 7 `(_ +% ` ^Y&^G ^ ` _ y ` p_ ` ^ E_ 2^ y ^ ` _ ` ` ^2^^G _ R ) ) #2^ `(` ^ / R ^ `` 4+ 7 A9:;M¦ 7 AKM=H ,¤3 ¤91 H¤3 /¡3

S

Page 76: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

£Qc¥5NM0M05 7 A 7 `(_ +% ` ^Y&^G ^ ` _ y ` p_ ` ^ E_ 2^ y ^ ` _ ` ` ^2^|^G _ R l ) ) ) R _ _ # ^ R (`(_ ^ ( _ T `(_ ^ `a 4( 7 A9:BM? 7$ AKMH YH ¢ H 1@H¤3 3¡ 3

£/ ¥5NM0M05 7 A 7 `(_ +% ` ^Y&^G ^ ` _ y ` p_ ` ^ E_ 2^ y ^ ` _ ` ` ^&2^ ^G _ R ( ^ _e ^ `(_ ^ `a 4+ 7 A9:;M 7$ AKM¡ !39S 3H 3¢71 H¤3¤3¢ 3

£/¤¥"M 6* &cEH@ ` N ` O % ` `eJ` ^ ^G N ` ` ` y ^ ` ` ^ `(_ -^ ` = 6 4q6959A<6R1@H¤%¤ 3

«%¢¥ M M =?6BAO=?6%D= >B~= ` 2^ ` ` ` ^ ` 2^ ^ 2^ `(` 2^ 6K_ ` ^ _(` ¦G>´> 7 % =1@H¤3S<3

Page 77: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

F ) ( lYD $ ) (B (B (TH $YBI

"!#"%$&')(+*,-.'*0/(213+-45687#$&"96:"<; ->="?8@*8-A6BCD0EGFHB0IKJLD0E

K M$N?OPQRQ GSUTVWR5XK*8P"/Y EZO[]\_^>`Baa

b $2?OcRQ_ KQ8/4/d*0/Lef*0/d*86.'*8/gSUT%-Y EZO[]\_^>`Baa

h Ti780!j@kleU*8!H ?O8@*8K8mX?n5o0/4@L$p*,"coNq `mrts'[]EvudrtD8ud[xwWC[]^dry^zA6BCD0EGFHB0IKJLD0E

K |-4R5XK="?8/d'-LN "!#"j$&')(+*,-x.'*8/GW k'/d*8!L"o"@kN Kc@k8@*8+-&q `mr ~s"["EvudrtD8u_[wWC+[]^dry^zrys8D0\Z%[]\dav^u_\,B6J

Tit-"k*8?*0?-i8 "/d0p$&')(+*,-f.'*8/'k*8!H /d'--4@n' j8Kxi8/4P7'k*8!H /d'--4@n' W -4@k'7Gn"7iQ-'k(+; -$&')(+*,["ud[]\WFD0E^dBgD0EZpD8u^`D\_^dBE

K Txt-"k*8?OQ?*8?-#>0 "/d8$&')(+*,H.'*0/x)(+W 8>='?0Q@*0["ud[]\WFD0E^dBgD0EZpD8u^`D\_^dBE

eU*0+-"'/488@*8g/d* +"/4@4-.'*0/(xeU*0?*8?-H0VTxt-"k*8Q?*8?->0 "/d8G$&')(R*,-&D8u_^`D0\^dBEGDEZ Y A6BED6^>ryyD6^d^dBE

Tit-"k*8?*0?-V0 '/d0p8Kx)(+ie/d*8?6,"P9R@8,@8/4U" '!L"% 6 c@k8@*8N*i" -4R@k"Q7["ud[]\WFD0E^dBgD0EZpD8u^`D\_^dBE

fO *8:ft-"H>*-4'/4@*0/4/4/_*8/WK8c7-4t-.'*0/V0g 'K8c7 "!L'$&"(*].'*8/)(+lSn4-4k" /d*n" "!BED0tZ Y +\_["EsC¡¢vudryaL`D\_^dBED0EZN>rts"D\_ZOB#FxBOsC+['ududB

f W *6n80|*,k8ct-"£>*-4'/4@*0/4W/4/d*0/j0c7-4t-#¤(#$&"96!?O!¥j*8/4!¦.'*8/5 "!#"U% 6 /d*]96!#0Q@*0+-j*.x&eU*8k"Q@*0R@Ti §>?-4@*8NW/d*n" "!&D8u_^>B6J#DE

f+ M>*8-"/4@*8/4U/4/d*8/x0c7-4t-i¨(j$p]96!j?O!£j*8/4!©.'*8/LL>'K8c7#5xy'R!L"U$&"(*].'*8/i(Gª!#"R@T5 'K"Sn4-4k" /d*n" "!&D8u_^>B6J#DE

fOb ¥>*8-45"/4@*8/4H/4/d*0/LK8c7-4t-l«)(+G$&]9!?O!¬i*0/4!£.'*8/gg "!#"% R K/d*"96!L8@*8-j*.xª!L'R@T +"6'VeU*08_k"@*8R@Ti §>?-4@*82/d*6n' "!&D8u_^>B6J#DE

0 MX!H i*0k*8,.'*8/4!voL­c8/ "!#"K.'*8/)(+ 8-@k"Q7W/d*n" "!["ud[]\WFD0E^dBgD0EZpD8u^`D\_^dBE

0K ªK(>®®>¯iW '!L"f$&"(*]g0$2?OcPo/4@>.'*8/)(+V$&]o0K'*-48@k/d*6n'y'!rys8D0\Z%[]\dav^u_\,B6JN¡vpD0u_^H`D0\^dBEm¡OD0EZG°tD^¢ODJi±+[]y^_^dBE

²

Page 78: Adaptive nite element computation of 3D magnetostatic ...

0b ªK(*],6'/4RQy8k&S +"/d8*8/i8-i8N-478! K5*0Q@k|!%2t-"*8/d* @ki$&_0@pBCDJJLD6Z Y ^dD6Z]D6ZO["C

0h >*-4'/4@*0/4/4/_*8/%-4!#0Q@*0 *<.Gm?Ok"Q@*08c-N«c KQ@k&W/d*n" "!i-" f9' '/4R!L"Q-&D8u_^`D0\^dBEGDEZ Y A6BED6^>ryyD6^d^dBE

0K i*05*8 K'/o07 eU*0+-"'/488@*82.'*0/i0!jP5*0@8 X7-"!i- 1-o¤ef*0?*0?-ª!LU5 "!L'@-["ud[]\WFD0E^dB

0 X50Q@*00/472|'8"WXK"$p")(+*,g.'*8/G$&*]6'Pvo XO(8/ ''/).'6k_'-G©W/d*0?O0:8'/ *0:D0C+rtZOCp¢CD\dr3DEZNryy^<~U\_r «ry[]\da

0K '5o0/d0Q@*0p!L')(+*,-.'*0/(jk8yk'?O 0Q@*0 *<.)(+i!#]o0K'*-48@k' G8?i5*Gk*8 -&D0\"rtDj BEvu_DED

0 U" '!L"%k*8!H ?O8@*8p*<.,TM!#]o0K'*-48@k% /_*n" '!j- *8"@8.'*0/4!j?Oy8@*8&D0\"rtDj BEvu_DED

4UH96;:E6aE6;aE=?Aoc:D> 7 AI5b6M5<c 7 =?A96BFP

444.& & 5 0& 4"