Auditing Page Definition of Auditing Auditing is the Process By
Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
Transcript of Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
1/24
Program
QA/QC
Internal Quality Audits at HDR
The Evolution of a Quality Management System
American Society for Quality
The 33rd National Energy & Environmental Conference
Tucson, Arizona
August 2!3", 2""#
Dan Domalik, PE, !QA
East Region "ead Auditor
HDR Engineering, In#
Session T$%& A#hieving Quality in Auditing ' E(e#uting Pro)e#ts in
*lo+al and S-only Environments
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
2/24
Program
QA/QC
QA/QC
$ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit ProgramSummary
$ntroductionPur.ose of Presentation
My BackgroundHDRQuality OfficeQA/QC Program
Audit ProgramSummary /ho am I0
and
/hy am I here0
1. ntroduce HDR
!.Our Quality Program
".Quality Auditing
at HDR
How does a consulting engineering
firm ensure design quality?
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
3/24
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
4/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroduction
()* Quality Office
QA/QC Program Audit ProgramSummary
ntroduction
()*
Quality Office
QA/QC Program Audit ProgramSummary
Servi#es
Stati$tic$Pro0ect$
Aard$2rot*
QA/QC
HDR is an ar#hite#tural,
engineering and #onsulting
firm that e(#els at managing#om.le( .ro)e#ts and solving
#hallenges for #lients
.*drinc.com
Trans+ortationTrans+ortation
Environmental Environmental
Architecture Architecture
o-er & Energy o-er & Energy
.ater/.aste-ater .ater/.aste-ater
rogram 0anagement rogram 0anagement
lanning lanning
Consulting Consulting Security Security
ConstructionConstruction
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
5/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroduction
()* Quality Office
QA/QC ProgramRegional/-ocal
Audit ProgramSummary
ntroduction
()*
Quality OfficeQA/QC Program
Audit ProgramSummary
Ser(ice$Statisti#s
Pro0ect$ Aard$2rot*
QA/QC
3 4ounded in 1516
3 More t*an 78!'' em#loyee oner$
3 O(er 1"' location$ orldide
3 96"' million in fee$ +!''7,
3 Head:uarter$; Oma*a8
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
6/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroduction
()* Quality Office
QA/QC ProgramRegional/-ocal
Audit ProgramSummary
ntroduction
()*
Quality OfficeQA/QC Program
Audit ProgramSummary
Ser(ice$Stati$tic$Pro)e#ts
Aard$2rot*
QA/QC
!oo.er River 1ridge
Hoover Dam 1y.ass
!ity of "as 2egas
/ater Pollution !ontrol
3a#ility E(.ansion
1ir#k
4anote#hnology
!enter
2entana Medi#al
Systems
!or.orate
Head5uarters
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
7/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroduction
()* Quality Office
QA/QC ProgramRegional/-ocal
Audit ProgramSummary
ntroduction
()*
Quality OfficeQA/QC Program
Audit ProgramSummary
Ser(ice$Stati$tic$Pro0ect$A6ards
2rot*
QA/QC
%ngineering Record Ranking$7 %8 - Design 3irm ? ! > Healt* Care? ! > Solid @a$te
? 7 > Dam$ Re$er(oir$? 6 > Correctional 4acilitie$? 6 > Hig*ay$? > Bridge$? 5 > )reatment De$alination
? 1' > Seerage Solid @a$te? 1' > )ran$#ortation? 1' > @ater Su##ly
? 11 > Ma$$ )ran$it Rail? 1" > @a$teater )reatment? 17 > 2eneral Building? 1 > 4o$$il 4uel? 1 > )ran$mi$$ion -ine$ A:ueduct$
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
8/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroduction
()*
Quality OfficeQA/QC Program
Audit ProgramSummary
Ser(ice$Stati$tic$Pro0ect$
Aard$*ro6th
Quality OfficeQA/QC Program
Audit ProgramSummary
ntroduction
()*
QA/QC QA/QC
consulting engineering firm
ensure design quality?
gro-ing How does acontinuously i m+rove
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
9/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDR
Quality %ffice
QA/QC Program Audit ProgramSummary
ntroductionHDR
Quality %ffice
QA/QC Program Audit ProgramSummary
$99: Strategi# PlanQMS/%SS
QA/QC
The HDR Quality ;ffi#e&
"eading Management
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
10/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDR
Quality %ffice
QA/QC Program Audit ProgramSummary
!'' Strategic PlanQMS>ESS
QA/QC Program Audit ProgramSummary
ntroductionHDR
Quality %ffice
QA/QC QA/QC
Quality Management Servi#es ?QMS@3 QA/QC Procedure$3 nternal Audit Program
3 Be$t Practice$3 Peer Re(ie$3 Client Re#ort Card$
Engineering Su..ort Servi#es ?ESS@3 nternet/ntranet3 Document control tool$3 Softare $u##ort3 Standardiation3 Pro0ect Management )ool$/)raining3 Con$truction Admini$tration
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
11/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC rogram Audit ProgramSummary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC rogram Audit ProgramSummary
History
Com#onent$Procedure$)raining
QA/QC
Do#umenting our
a..roa#h to delivering
Quality
1.or .ell )one4
3 15'E$ & Created
QA/QC Program
3 2radually ignored
3 155 & Ree$ta=li$*edQA/QC Program
3 F#dated !''!>!''
3 !''7 & %$ta=li$*ed QualityOffice and Audit Program
3 Regional Quality Director$
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
12/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC rogramRegional/-ocal Audit ProgramSummary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC rogram
Audit ProgramSummary
Hi$tory!om.onents
Procedure$)raining
QA/QC
3 Program Document$3 Quality A$$urance Procedure$3 Quality Control Procedure$
3 )ec*nical Procedure$3 Steering Committee
3 Regional -eader$3 )ec*nical -eader$3 Marketing
3 Con$truction3 Ad Hoc
3 Program m#lementation Re$#on$i=ilitie$3 Define$ role$ and re$#on$i=ilitie$3 4rom t*e Pre$ident to all em#loyee$
3 nternal Audit$3 %(aluate com#liance it* QA/QC Program3 dentify o##ortunitie$ for im#ro(ement3 S*are =e$t #ractice$
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
13/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC rogramRegional/-ocal Audit ProgramSummary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC rogram
Audit ProgramSummary
Hi$toryCom#onent$Pro#edures
)raining
QA/QC
3 Policy Definition$Establishes basis for authority
Creates a common language
3 Pro0ect 2uide$Project Management tool
3 Pro0ect Communication$Originating and maintaining correspondence
3 Pro0ect 4ilingPaper and electronic files
3 Pro0ect Re(ie$Inform management mitigate ris!s
3 Drafting Standard$"tandardi#e computer drawing production
3 Quality Control Re(ie$"enior independent re$iewers
%erify quality of deli$erables
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
14/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC rogram
Audit ProgramSummary
Hi$toryCom#onent$Procedure$Training
Audit ProgramSummary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC rogram
QA/QC QA/QC
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
15/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit rogramSummary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit rogramSummaryHistory
Role$Proce$$Re$ult$$$ue$
QA/QC
The missing .ie#e
of the .uleB
Accounta5ility
Audit Program *ite #a#er
Quality Office and Audit Program launc*ed-ead Auditor$ $elected
Draft audit #roce$$e$ de(elo#ed
7 #ilot audit$ conducted
Audit #roce$$e$ finalied
4ormal Audit Program rollout
Gear>end re#ort$ de(elo#ed
4ir$t re#eat audit$ conducted
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
16/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC ProgramRegional/-ocal
Audit rogramSummary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit rogram
Summary
Hi$toryRoles
Proce$$Re$ult$$$ue$
QA/QC
Quality Office Director &eports to President
'e$elops coordinates monitors
QA/QC Program Director Establish implement maintain
Promote awareness
Audit Admini$trator O$erall logistical support to (udit Program
-ead Auditor$ +%a$t8 Central8 @e$t,Coordinates and leads quality audits
Auditor$Part)time * + or , audits per year
Regional Quality Director$ (udit follow)up root cause analysis'e$elopment of action plan
Office QA/QC Program Coordinator$On)site logistical support for audits
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
17/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC ProgramRegional/-ocal
Audit rogramSummary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit rogram
Summary
Hi$toryRole$Pro#ess
Re$ult$$$ue$
QA/QC
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
18/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC ProgramRegional/-ocal
Audit rogramSummary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit rogram
Summary
Hi$toryRole$Pro#ess
Re$ult$$$ue$
QA/QC
@e revie- indi(idual #ro0ect$@e re+ort on a =u$ine$$ grou# and office le(el
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
19/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC ProgramRegional/-ocal
Audit rogramSummary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit rogram
Summary
Hi$toryRole$Pro#ess
Re$ult$$$ue$
QA/QC
;+servations C 3indings C Areas for Im.rovement
3a#ts C !on#lusions C Issues to /ork ;n
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
20/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC ProgramRegional/-ocal
Audit rogramSummary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit rogram
Summary
Hi$toryRole$Pro#ess
Re$ult$$$ue$
QA/QC
Post-audit A#tion Item "ist ?PAI"@
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
21/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC ProgramRegional/-ocal
Audit rogramSummary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit rogram
Summary
Hi$toryRole$Proce$$Results
$$ue$
QA/QC
une $99 ' une $99F
3 ! audit$ conducted
3 "!6 #ro0ect$ +917' million in fee$,
3 ! auditor$ #artici#ated
3 @ell>documented audit #roce$$e$
3 #rocedure training module$
;ut#omes
3 ncrea$ed aarene$$ focu$
3 2reater #roce$$ formaliation3 S*ared =e$t #ractice$
3 More feed=ack
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
22/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit rogram
Summary
Hi$toryRole$Proce$$Re$ult$Issues
Summary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit rogram
QA/QC QA/QC
!hallenges 3a#ed +y Audit Program
3 Audit #re#aration & IgamingJ t*e $y$tem
3 Small office$3 Selecting #ro0ect$ for re(ie
3 Con$i$tency among3 Auditor$
3 Audit$3 Region$
3 Culture c*ange & acce#tance
3 Auditor$ Ioning t*e #ro=lemJ
3 Standardiation ($. entre#reneur$*i#
3 Kee#ing audit #rogram Ifre$*J
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
23/24
Program
QA/QC
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit Program
Summary
ntroductionHDRQuality Office
QA/QC Program Audit Program
Summary
QA/QC
/hat did 6e learn0
/here are 6e going0
=ou im+rove 6hat you measure
Strengths
3 Culture of :uality & I@ork ell doneJ
3 Quality Control Re(ie$
3 Pro0ect file$
3 Pro0ect management
Areas for Im.rovement
3 QA/QC training
3 'L Re(ie$3 Management Re(ie$
3 QC Plan$
-
8/9/2019 Achieving Quality in Auditing Executing Projects in Global and Us Only Environments
24/24
Program
QA/QC
Internal Quality Audits at HDR
The Evolution of a Quality Management System
American Society for Quality
The 33rd National Energy & Environmental Conference
Tucson, Arizona
August 2!3", 2""#
Dan Domalik, PE, !QA
East Region "ead Auditor
HDR Engineering, In#
Session T$%& A#hieving Quality in Auditing ' E(e#uting Pro)e#ts in
*lo+al and S-only Environments