Achieving Performance Excellence - MNASQ.org 101_MNASQ_02-12-13.… · Achieving Performance...
Transcript of Achieving Performance Excellence - MNASQ.org 101_MNASQ_02-12-13.… · Achieving Performance...
1
Achieving Performance Excellence
Baldrige 101 WorkshopASQ Professional Development Summit
Today’s DiscussionIntroduce the Baldrige frameworkValue and Benefits of BaldrigegRegional Program – MN, ND & SDNational ProgramClass discussion and exercises on the Criteria for Performance ExcellenceExplore assessment options
2www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Testimonials from local organizationsOptions for next steps; additional resources
2
Where Do You Start?
Improve HR selection
Improve compliance
Improve support processes
Improve reward & recognition
I
Improve cycle time
3www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Improve planning
Improve accuracy
Why Use Baldrige?Baldrige is a framework
Not regulatory; not accreditation (it’s flexible)System that any organization can choose to use (scalable)Criteria identifies what needs to be done, not explicitly how to do thingsRepresents “leading edge of validated management practice”
Self-evaluationR i h t lf i ti
4www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Requires honest self-examinationHelps build a common language
Outside EvaluationState/regional program, National program
3
Benefits of Using BaldrigeIdentifies strengths
foundation for continuous improvementp
Identifies improvement opportunitiespain or problem areas
Facilitates and guides improvement Promotes organizational alignment and integrationA i t i d li f l t t k h ld
5www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Assists in delivery of value to stakeholdersFacilitates personal & organizational learningMonitors (measures) progress over time
…Economic Value Added to the US…2001 Study
207:1 economic return$25B in economic benefits at $119M in total cost
2011 Study820:1 in terms of economic returnCost savings, customer satisfaction, financial gain (rev)
Larry Potterfield, CEO, MidwayUSA (2009 recipient)– http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zG8FjjctVhE&feature=plcp
6www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Source: Albert N. Link and John T. Scott. NIST Planning Report 11-2: Economic Evaluation of the Baldrige Performance Excellence Program, December 2011
4
The Baldrige AwardGiven by the President of the United States to:
businesses, manufacturing and service, small and large, g , geducation (K-12 and higher)health care organizationsnon-profits
Applicants judged to be outstanding in seven areasProgram objectives:
Share best management practices
7www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Share best management practicesHelp organizations achieve world-class performance levelsIdentify and recognize role-model organizations
Baldrige (National) Facts93 Baldrige Award winners since 1987Number of applicants:Number of applicants:
Manufacturing – 354Service – 187Small business – 361Education – 151 (since 1999)Healthcare – 288 (since 1999)
40 out of 69 applicants in 2011 were healthcare
8www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
40 out of 69 applicants in 2011 were healthcareNon-profit – 47 (since 2006)Estimated number of state applicants – 10,279
there are 33 state quality award programs
5
Language DifferencesBusiness, Health Care, & EducationCustomers, students and stakeholders, & patients and familiesProduct offerings, educational programs, health care servicesWork Processes
Product & process design BusinessProgram, service, and process design Education
9
Service & process design Health Care
Results - product, student (budgetary), & health care
Local National Baldrige Recipients3M Dental Products Division (St. Paul)BI (Eden Prairie)BI (Eden Prairie)Cargill Corn Milling North America, (Wayzata)Cargill Kitchen Solutions (Monticello) (2 time recipient)Custom Research Inc., (Minneapolis)IBM Rochester, (Rochester)
10www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Zytec Corporation, (Eden Prairie)
6
Regional Program – MN, ND, SDProgram is developmental, not just recognizing the bestFour levels of Award
Excellence (top level)( p )AchievementAdvancementCommitment
List of the organizations that received these awards:www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
To help organizations get started regional program
11www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
To help organizations get started regional program offers:
self-assessmentsalternative assessmentsBaldrige 101
12www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
7
Focusing Energy & Resources
Visi
on
Alignment
Mission
Visi
on
Mission
13www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Baldrige
Lean
ISO The Joint Commission
FDA
State & Federal Requirements
DMAIC
FMEA
Balanced Scorecard
Six Sigma
8
Understanding the Baldrige CriteriaBaldrige Defines Excellence
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Organizational Profile – sets the context for the way an
Profile & Seven Categories
sets the context for the way an organization operates
Categories 1 – 6 – define processes that make up the work of
the organizationCategory 7 Results
16
Category 7 – Results – a composite of process, financial, and
other outcomes
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
9
P lWorkforce
Organizational Profile: Environment, Relationships, and Challenges
People Focus
Process Focus
WorkforceFocus
OperationsFocus
Work Core
Leadership
StrategicPlanning
Customer Focus
Driver Triad
Results
17Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Management
which bring about improvement here
Changes here guide changes here
Starting point for: self-assessment
iti li ti
Organizational Profile
writing an application
Describes what is importantdrives measurement choices, strategic plan
Describes operating environment & key relationships with customers, students, patients, suppliers partners & stakeholders
18
suppliers, partners, & stakeholders. Evaluators & judges use it to review/understand the organization
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
10
Organizational Profile Activity
What is your next area for improvement?
• List what are your key organizational characteristics
19
characteristics• What is your organization’s strategic
situation?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
P lWorkforce
Organizational Profile: Environment, Relationships, and Challenges
People Focus
Process Focus
WorkforceFocus
OperationsFocus
Work Core
Leadership
StrategicPlanning
Customer Focus
Driver Triad
Results
20Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Management
which bring about improvement here
Changes here guide changes here
11
Category 1 – Leadership1.1 – Senior Leadership
– Vision, Values, and Mission• How do leaders set these?• How do leaders demonstrate commitment to
legal and ethical behavior?• How do leaders create a sustainable
organization?– Communication & Organizational Performance
• How do leaders communicate with
21
workforce?• How do senior leaders create a focus on
action to accomplish objectives?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Category 1 – Leadership1.2 – Governance and Societal Responsibility
– Governance• How does your governance system keep• How does your governance system keep
leaders accountable and transparent?– Legal and ethical behavior
• How do you ensure legal and ethical behavior including meeting regulatory requirements?
S i t l ibiliti d t f k
22
– Societal responsibilities and support of key communities
• How do you ensure societal well-being and community support?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
12
Category 1 Activity - Leadership
What is your next area for improvement?
• How do your senior leaders lead?
23
• How do you govern and fulfill your societal responsibilities?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
P lWorkforce
Organizational Profile: Environment, Relationships, and Challenges
People Focus
Process Focus
WorkforceFocus
OperationsFocus
Work Core
Leadership
StrategicPlanning
Customer Focus
Driver Triad
Results
24Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Management
which bring about improvement here
Changes here guide changes here
13
Category 2 - Strategic Planning
2.1 – Strategy Development– Strategy development process
• How do you conduct strategic development process?
• Who participates?
25
p p• What are your work systems?
– Strategic Objectives• What are they?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Category 2 - Strategic Planning
2.2 – Strategy Implementation– Action plan development & deployment
• How do you develop and implement action plans?
• How do you modify action plans if needed?
26
• What are your key performance measures?– Performance projections
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
14
Category 2 ActivityStrategic Planning
What is your next area for improvement?
• How do you develop your strategy?
27
• How do you implement your strategy?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
P lWorkforce
Organizational Profile: Environment, Relationships, and Challenges
People Focus
Process Focus
WorkforceFocus
OperationsFocus
Work Core
Leadership
StrategicPlanning
Customer Focus
Driver Triad
Results
28Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Management
which bring about improvement here
Changes here guide changes here
15
Category 3 – Customer Focus3.1 – Voice of the Customer
– Customers and stakeholder listening• How do you listen to customers including
potential customers and customers of competitors?
– Determination of customers and stakeholder satisfaction and engagement
• How do you determine customer satisfaction
29
How do you determine customer satisfaction and engagement?
• How do you determine customer satisfaction relative to competitors?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Category 3 – Customer Focus3.2 – Customer Engagement
– Customer Service offerings and stakeholder support
• How do you determine customer and market requirements for product and service offerings?
• How do you segment customers?– Building customer and stakeholder relationships
30
Building customer and stakeholder relationships• How do you build relationships with
customers?• How do you manage customer complaints?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
16
Category 3 ActivityCustomer Focus
What is your next area for improvement?
• How do you obtain information from your customers?
31
• How do you engage customers to serve their needs and build relationships?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
P lWorkforce
Organizational Profile: Environment, Relationships, and Challenges
People Focus
Process Focus
WorkforceFocus
OperationsFocus
Work Core
Leadership
StrategicPlanning
Customer Focus
Driver Triad
Results
32Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Management
which bring about improvement here
Changes here guide changes here
17
Category 4 - Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Management
4.1 – Measurement, Analysis, and Improvement of Organizational Performanceg– Performance measurement
• How do you select, collect, align, and integrate data and information for tracking performance?
– Performance analysis and review
33
Performance analysis and review• How and when do you review data?
– Performance Improvement
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Category 4 - Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Mgmt
4.2 – Knowledge Management, Information, and Information Technology– Knowledge management
• How do you collect, transfer, and appropriately share knowledge both inside and outside the organization?
– Data, Information and information technology • How do you ensure hardware and software are
34
• How do you ensure hardware and software are reliable, etc?
• How do you make data available as needed?• How do you make sure data is available in case
of emergency?www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
18
Category 4 Activity – Measurement, Analysis, & Knowledge Mgmt.
What is your next area for improvement?
• How do you measure, analyze, and then improve organizational performance?
35
• How do you manage your information, organizational knowledge, & information technology?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
P lWorkforce
Organizational Profile: Environment, Relationships, and Challenges
People Focus
WorkforceFocus
OperationsFocus
Work Core
Leadership
StrategicPlanning
Customer Focus
Driver Triad
Results
36Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Management
which bring about improvement here
Changes here guide changes here
19
Category 5 – Workforce Focus
5.1 – Workforce Environment– Workforce capability and capacity
• How do you ensure the workforce has the capability and capacity to get the work done?
• How do you organize the workforce to get the work done?
– Workforce climate
37
– Workforce climate• How do you address environmental factors?• How do you support your workforce?• What benefits do you offer?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Category 5 – Workforce Focus
5.2 – Workforce Engagement– Workforce performance
• How do you determine the factors that affect workforce engagement?
– Assessment of workforce engagement• How do you assess engagement?• How do you relate this to results?
38
• How do you relate this to results?– Workforce and leader development
• How do your learning and development systems mesh with what is important to your organization?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
20
Category 5 ActivityWorkforce Focus
What is your next area for improvement?
• How do you build an effective and supportive workforce environment?
39
• How do you engage your workforce to achieve organizational and personal success?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Workforce
Organizational Profile: Environment, Relationships, and Challenges
Process Focus
WorkforceFocus
OperationsFocus
Work Core
Leadership
StrategicPlanning
Customer Focus
Driver Triad
Results
40Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Management
which bring about improvement here
Changes here guide changes here
21
Category 6 – Operations Focus6.1 – Work Processes
– Product and process design• How do you design products and work• How do you design products and work
processes to meet key requirements?• How do you determine these
requirements?– Process management
• How do you manage and improve
41
processes?• How do you determine key support
processes?• How do you improve work processes?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Category 6 – Operations Focus
6.2 – Operational Effectiveness– Cost control
H d t l t d• How do you control costs and incorporate efficiency and effectiveness measures?
– Supply chain management• How do you select and manage
suppliers?
42
– Safety & emergency preparedness– Innovation management
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
22
Category 6 ActivityOperations Focus
What is your next area for improvement?What is your next area for improvement?
• How do you figure out how to design your products and processes?
43
• How do you figure out if your operations are effective and efficient?
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
P lWorkforce
Organizational Profile: Environment, Relationships, and Challenges
People Focus
Process Focus
WorkforceFocus
OperationsFocus
Work Core
Leadership
StrategicPlanning
Customer Focus
Driver Triad
Results
44Measurement, Analysis, and Knowledge Management
which bring about improvement here
Changes here guide changes here
23
Category 7 – ResultsResults item Related to Process item7 1 P d t & P O t 67.1 – Product & Process Outcomes 67.2 – Customer-Focused Outcomes 37.3 – Workforce-Focused Outcomes 57.4 – Leadership and Governance Results 1 & 27.5 – Financial and Market Results 4
45www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Category 7 – ResultsResults enable you to look at your organization’s key performance and improvementskey performance and improvementsThey help you make decisions about how your organization is doing.They mainly come from three areas:
Baldrige criteria requirementsRegulatory requirements
46
Regulatory requirements
Areas deemed important to your organization’s successUsually identified in the organizational profile
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
24
Category 7 Results Example
47
Category 7 Activity - Results
Consider what results your organization reviewsConsider what results your organization reviews to stay on track? How do you know if these are the right results?
• Product & process performance• Customer-focused performance
W kf f d f
48
• Workforce-focused performance• Senior leadership & governance• Financial & market performance
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
25
Assessing Performance with the Criteria
Three assessment options available:
Comprehensive State Quality Award
Alternative Assessment (consultant-facilitated)
49
Self-Assessment
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Assessment 1: State Excellence Award
Initial Evaluation Review Reach C d t C d t I t
Prepare
Conduct Site/IP SessionPrepare for Site Visit
Prepare FullEvaluation ReviewIndependently
ReachConsensus
ConductSite Visit
Conduct Imprmnt.Plng Session
Prepare Full App or BEX
Prepare application (narrative or Baldrige Express survey)
Uses teams of 10-12 trained Evaluator volunteers
3-4 months to complete (once application is submitted)
50
Includes site visit, which improves feedback accuracy and accelerates organizational learning
Most comprehensive, most thorough, most valuable (but also most resource-intensive)
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
26
Narrative vs ExpressNarrative is 50 page document (max) that describes how the organization meets criteria
I l d C t 7 ltIncludes Category 7 resultsOrg profile is additional 5 pages
Express is survey that asks criteria-based questionsAdministered on-line to statistical sampling of peoplePeople choose response that best characterizes the organizationScores determined by responses to survey
51
Scores determined by responses to surveyPeople have opportunity to write comments on the answers they chooseRequires expanded org profile (10 pages)Includes Category 7 results
Scoring – Indicator of Maturity
Each item has a point valueEach item is given a score as a percentage which g p grepresents the organization’s maturity on the journey to perfectionPercentage times point value provides item scoreTotal item scores creates total score450 of possible 1000 points are in Category 7Ri i ti t i t it
52
Rising scores over time represent growing maturity of organization
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
27
Assessment 2: Alternative AssessmentPrepare Prelim. Data
GatheringSite Visit Data
GatheringImprovement
Planning
Entry-level evaluation (not eligible for Award)Intended for organizations that want the benefit of the Baldrige Criteria, but not the rigor of the full-blown assessmentQuicker than Award process: 4 phases; ~2 month cycle timeConsultant-led process (with sector/functional experts as an
ti ) lt t j i tl l t d b i ti /N t k
53
option); consultant jointly selected by organization/NetworkSeries of three facilitated sessions:
½ day to talk about environment1 day for “mini” site visit½ day for presentation of findings and prioritization of improvement opportunities
Requires Baldrige Express survey for key leaders plus business results
Assessment 3: Self AssessmentPrepare Baldrige
Express Debrief
One hour primer with senior leaders
Deploy Baldrige Express survey with 25-50 leaders/ professionals
54
One hour debrief with senior leaders
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
28
• Most thorough, comprehensive and rigorous of the three.
• Evaluates the entire organization as a system.
• Less thorough, rigorous and comprehensive as Award process.
• Evaluates entire organization, but only at a basic level (deployment, learning, integration not as
• A less rigorous, high level overview of organization as a system.
• Evaluates entire organization, but only by considering workforce perception; uses a web-based,
Organizational Assessment ComparisonsPerf Excellence Award Assessment Alternative Assessment Self Assessment
• Typically, involves between 200-400 employees, increasing accuracy and promoting workforce involvement, learning, and cultural change.
• Organization is eligible for recognition (MN Quality Award).
• Benefit of trained, diverse, expert team of Evaluators who contribute over 1,000 hours collectively.
• Benefit of site visit, which promotes accuracy/organizational learning
thoroughly considered).• Consultant performs interviews and
collects data. Fewer employees involved (typically 15-20, and usually only at senior leader level).
• Not eligible for recognition.
• Benefit of expert Baldrige consultant, but only one perspective (not a diverse team).
• Benefit of “mini” site visit, but not as accurate or as deep/rich in learning
behaviorally anchored survey.• Survey administered up to 25
employees , categorized by organizational demographics.
• Not eligible for recognition.
• Minimal external analysis; relies on internal expertise to draw conclusions and identify action.
• No site visit or chance to corroborate findings
55
accuracy/organizational learning.• Requires completion of narrative
application or Baldrige Express survey with a large sample, which both are fairly time intensive.
• Requires hosting a site visit; involves more staff time at all organizational levels.
accurate or as deep/rich in learning.• Less resource intensive and more
prescriptive.
• Saves organizational time, but higher fee.
corroborate findings.
• Minimally resource intensive.• Self-assessment free for members
(in a promotion). • A good place to start for
organizations new to Baldrige or desiring a quick “dip stick” on their journey to excellence.
In Today’s Environment,You Don’t Have a Choice…
Must focus on your people – your staff, key partners, and other stakeholders – their needs, their capabilities, their satisfaction & engagement& engagement
Must use data to make decisions, to systematically improve key processes
Must quickly adapt to changes in your environment and maintain agility, innovation
Must constantly improve the way you do things – your core processes, but also your support processes
56www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
processes, but also your support processes
Must rely on strong leadership – communication, transparency, vision, and constancy of purpose
Must focus on all aspects of your organization – the system
29
Testimonials
57www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Impact of Baldrige on Local Organizations“The Baldrige framework is a foundation and a benchmark for us as we work to integrate Mayo Clinic in the Midwest. The domains provide us with a focus to understand and address our challenges as we work to transform health care systems and the delivery of care”.
Dr. Rob Nesse CEO Mayo Clinic Health System
"Continuous improvement is a core value of the Byron School District. Over the last decade, our position of excellence has been achieved through the deployment, alignment and evaluation of continuous improvement processes.
58
p y , g p pOur PDSA plans and district goals are central to improving student learning and student achievement."
Dr. Wendy ShannonSuperintendent Byron Public Schools
30
"Throughout my 40 year career I have been passionate about improvement both personally and within whatever organization I have been associated with. Every organization wants to improve. The use of the Baldrige criteria has enabled o r organi ation to get better faster period! I ish I had
Impact of Baldrige on Local Organizations
has enabled our organization to get better, faster... period! I wish I had ‘discovered’ Baldrige a couple decades earlier.“
Jack PriggenPresident Cardinal of Minnesota, Ltd.
“Rochester Community and Technical College aspires to continuously learn and innovate; always seeking new and better ways to improve and better serve; for nearly two decades the Baldrige framework has been vital to our
59
serve; for nearly two decades the Baldrige framework has been vital to our enduring journey to performance excellence.”
Dave WeberChief Student Affairs and Strategic Operations Officer
Learning & Resources Baldrige 101: Sessions held quarterly, or upon request in individual organizationsB l tBecome an evaluatorReview materials at the Network’s web site
3 assessment processes: self-assessment, alternative assessment, quality award
Baldrige NationalUse online assessments - NIST Web site (www.nist.gov)
Baldrige Criteria workbook for deeper understanding
60
For more details on these event or any of the Network’s events visit www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
31
Next Steps Activity
• Identify 3 organizational changes that you want to see happen in the tnext year
1. ________________________________________________2. ________________________________________________3. ________________________________________________• Select one of the items listed above and list 3 things you will
personally do to promote its completion1. ________________________________________________2. ________________________________________________
61
3. ________________________________________________
• Identify one key individual or team that you can communicate with about these goals_________________________________________________
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
Good Luck
Contact information:
62
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org
www.performanceexcellencenetwork.org