ABL Mark-Up of Newland Hercules Industries v Sebelius [Preliminary Injunction Order]

7/31/2019 ABL Mark-Up of Newland Hercules Industries v Sebelius [Preliminary Injunction Order]

1/19

8

MO TBJ ZOMTJD UTHTJU DMUT^MET EAZ^TCA^ TBJ DMUT^MET AC EAIA^HDA

Kzdgj Kabo I/ Lhoj

Emsmi Hetmao Oa/ 8;8>-es-88>5-KIL

WMIIMH@ OJWIHOD4 Utht/ 88= ">686-) moutmtztjd h sh~mjt} ac bjhitbeh~j ~jca~`u/

Ehuj 8;8>-es-688>5-KIL Daez`jot 56 Cmijd 67!>7!8> ZUDE Eaia~hda Vhgj 8 ac 82


2/19

8 Mo h ~jejot djemumao) tbj Uzv~j`j Eaz~t zvbjid tbj eaoutmtztmaohimt} ac tbj uaehiijdmodmsmdzhi `hodhtj) nzt moshimdhtjd tbj va~tmao ac tbj Hcca~dhnij Eh~j Het tb~jhtjomog iauu acjrmutmog @jdmehmd czodmog mc h uthtj djeimoju ta jrvhod mtu @jdmehmd v~ag~hù/ Ohti Cjdo acModjv/ Nzu/ s/ Ujnjimzu) QQ Z/U/ QQ< 825 I/ Jd/ >d 4:6 "Kzoj >2) >68>-/

> Tj~`jd tbj Vhtmjotu Nmii ac ^mgbtu tbjuj v~asmumaou ~jxzm~j bjhitb vihou ta; v~asmdjeasj~hgj ta vj~uaou wmtb v~jjrmutmog eaodmtmaou) v~atjet h vhtmjotu ebamej ac daeta~u) hiiawhdzitu zodj~ tbj hgj ac twjot}umr ta `hmothmo easj~hgj zodj~ tbjm~ vh~jotu bjhitb viho) v~abmnmthoozhi hod imcjtm`j im`mtu ao àut bjhitbeh~j njojcmtu) hod jod v~jjrmutmog eaodmtmao jreizumaouca~ ebmid~jo zodj~ tbj hgj ac omojtjjo/ Ujj Vhtmjotu Nmii ac ^mgbtu hshmihnij ht

bttv;!!www/bjhitbeh~j/gas!ihw!cjhtz~ju!~mgbtu!nmiiac~mgbtu!modjr/btì "ihut smjwjd ao Kzi} >7)>68>-/ Hu dmuezuujd moc~h ht o/4) oat hii bjhitb vihou h~j ~jxzm~jd ta `jjt tbjuj eaodmtmaou/

5 Tbj HEH dmd oat) bawjsj~) uvjemcmehii} djim`mt tbj eaotaz~u ac v~jsjotmsj eh~j/Moutjhd) mt djijghtjd tbht ~juvaoumnmimt} ta tbj Bjhitb ^juaz~eju hod Uj~smeju Hd`momut~htmao"BÛH-/ Ao Hzgzut 8) >688) BÛH hdavtjd ^jxzm~jd Bjhitb Viho Easj~hgj Gzmdjimoju tbhtdjcmojd tbj ueavj ac wa`jou v~jsjotmsj uj~smeju ca~ vz~vauju ac tbj HEH easj~hgj `hodhtj/Ujj BÛH) Wa`jou V~jsjotmsj Uj~smeju; ^jxzm~jd Bjhitb Viho Easj~hgj Gzmdjimoju hshmihnijhtbttv;!!www/b~uh/gas!wa`jougzmdjimoju! "ihut smumtjd Kzi} >7) >68>-/ Tbj BÛH gzmdjimojumoeizdj) hàog atbj~ tbmogu) tbj czii ~hogj ac Caad hod D~zg Hd`momut~htmaohvv~asjdeaot~hejvtmsj `jtbadu) utj~mim{htmao v~aejdz~ju) hod vhtmjot jdzehtmao hod eazoujimog ca~ wa`jo

wmtb ~jv~adzetmsj ehvhemt}/ Md/4 Oz`j~azu v~asmumaou ac tbj HEH hvvi} ta g~hodchtbj~jd bjhitb vihou; tbj v~abmnmtmao

ao v~jjrmutmog eaodmtmao jreizumaou "g~azv bjhitb vihou aoi}-) tbj v~abmnmtmao ao jrejuumsj

whmtmog vj~madu "natb g~azv hod modmsmdzhi bjhitb vihou-) tbj v~abmnmtmao ao imcjtm`j "natb- hodhoozhi "g~azv aoi}- njojcmt im`mtu) tbj v~abmnmtmao ao ~juemuumaou "natb-) hod tbj jrtjoumao acdjvjodjot eh~j easj~hgj "natb- ta oh`j h cjw/ 7: Cjd/ ^jg/ ht 54:4>/ Ca~ h ea`v~jbjoumsj

>

Hàog mtu `ho} v~asmumaou) mt ~jxzm~ju àut Z/U/ emtm{jou hod ijghi ~jumdjotu ta bhsj bjhitb

mouz~hoej) e~jhtju uthtjnhujd bjhitb mouz~hoej jrebhogju) hod ~jxzm~ju j`via}j~u wmtb cmct} a~

à~j cziitm`j j`via}jju ta accj~ bjhitb mouz~hoej/8 Md/ Tbj HEH hiua m`vij`jotjd h uj~mju ac

v~asmumaou hm`jd ht mouz~mog `mom`z` ijsjiu ac bjhitb eh~j easj~hgj/> @aut ~jijshot ta tbj

mouthot uzmt) tbj HEH ~jxzm~ju g~azv bjhitb vihou ta v~asmdj oaeaut easj~hgj ca~ v~jsjotmsj eh~j

hod ue~jjomog ca~ wa`jo/ 4> Z/U/E/ 566gg85"h-"4-/5

Zoimlj ua`j atbj~ v~asmumaou ac tbj HEH) bawjsj~) tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj

`hodhtj daju oat hvvi} ta ej~thmo bjhitbeh~j vihou jrmutmog ao @h~eb >5) >686/4 Ujj Motj~m`

Ehuj 8;8>-es-688>5-KIL Daez`jot 56 Cmijd 67!>7!8> ZUDE Eaia~hda Vhgj > ac 82


3/19

uz``h~} ac tbj hvvimehnmimt} ac HEH v~asmumaou ta g~hodchtbj~jd bjhitb vihou) ujj Hvvimehtmaoac tbj Ojw Bjhitb ^jca~` V~asmumaou ac Vh~t H ac Tmtij RRSMM ac tbj VBU Het ta G~hodchtbj~jdVihou) hshmihnij htbttv;!!www/dai/gas!jnuh!vdc!g~hodchtbj~~jgthnij/vdc/ "ihut smumtjd Kzi} >3)>68>-/

: Mo a~dj~ ta xzhimc} hu h ~jimgmazu j`via}j~ jimgmnij ca~ tbmu jrj`vtmao) ho j`via}j~`zut `jjt tbj caiiawmog e~mtj~mh;

"8- Tbj moeziehtmao ac ~jimgmazu shizju mu tbj vz~vauj ac tbj a~ghom{htmao/">- Tbj a~ghom{htmao v~m`h~mi} j`via}u vj~uaou wba ubh~j tbj ~jimgmazu

tjojtu ac tbj a~ghom{htmao/"5- Tbj a~ghom{htmao uj~sju v~m`h~mi} vj~uaou wba ubh~j tbj ~jimgmazu

tjojtu ac tbj a~ghom{htmao/"4- Tbj a~ghom{htmao mu h oaov~acmt a~ghom{htmao hu djue~mnjd mo ujetmao

3655"h-"8- hod ujetmao 3655"h-"5-"H-"m- a~ "mmm- ac tbj Motj~ohi ^jsjozj Eadj ac

8=23) hu h`jodjd/

73 Cjd/ ^jg/ 433>8) 433>3 "Hzg/ 5) >688-< Ujj 77 Cjd/ ^jg/ 27>: "Cjn/ 8:) >68>-/

5

Cmohi ^ziju ca~ G~azv Bjhitb Vihou hod Bjhitb Mouz~hoej Easj~hgj ^jihtmog ta Uthtzu hu h

G~hodchtbj~jd Bjhitb Viho Zodj~ tbj Vhtmjot V~atjetmao hod Hcca~dhnij Eh~j Het) 7: Cjd/ ^jg/

54:52)54:46 "Kzoj 87) >686-/ Tbmu ghv mo tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj mu umgomcmehot/

Heea~dmog ta gasj~o`jot jutm`htju) 8=8 `miimao H`j~mehou njiaog ta vihou wbmeb `h} nj

g~hodchtbj~jd zodj~ tbj HEH/Md/ ht 54::6/ Hitbazgb tbj~j h~j ho} ~jxzm~j`jotu ca~

`hmothmomog g~hodchtbj~jd uthtzu)ujj >3 E/C/^/ :4/=28:8>:8T"g-) mc tbauj ~jxzm~j`jotu h~j

`jt h viho `h} nj g~hodchtbj~jd ca~ ho modjcmomtj vj~mad ac tm`j/

Mo hddmtmao ta g~hodchtbj~mog zodj~ tbj HEH) tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j gzmdjimoju jrj`vt

ej~thmo ~jimgmazu j`via}j~u c~a` ho} ~jxzm~j`jot ta easj~ eaot~hejvtmsj uj~smeju/:

Ujj Motj~m`

Cmohi ^ziju ca~ G~azv Bjhitb Vihou hod Bjhitb Mouz~hoej Muuzj~u ^jihtmog ta Easj~hgj ac

V~jsjotmsj Uj~smeju Zodj~ tbj Vhtmjot V~atjetmao hod Hcca~dhnij Eh~j Het) 73 Cjd/ ^jg/ 433>8

"Hzg/ 5) >688-/ Tbj gzmdjimoju hiua eaothmo h tj`va~h~} joca~ej`jot uhcjbh~na~ ca~ vihou

uvaoua~jd n} ej~thmo oaov~acmt a~ghom{htmaou wmtb ~jimgmazu ankjetmaou ta eaot~hejvtmsj easj~hgj



4/19


5/19

:

umgomcmehot hàzotu ac àoj} ta Ehtbaime a~ghom{htmaou hod ehzuju/ Md/ ht 5:/

Heea~dmog ta Vihmotmccu) Bj~eziju `hmothmou h ujicmouz~jd g~azv viho ca~ mtu j`via}jju

\hPu vh~t ac czicmiimog tbjm~ a~ghom{htmaohi `muumao hod Ehtbaime njimjcu hod ea``mt`jotu/ Md/ ht

57/ Umgomcmehoti}) njehzuj tbj Ehtbaime ebz~eb eaodjòu tbj zuj ac eaot~hejvtmao) Bj~eziju

ujicmouz~jd viho daju oat easj~ hna~tmchejot d~zgu) eaot~hejvtmao) a~ utj~mim{htmao/ Md/ ht 48/

Bj~eziju bjhitb mouz~hoej viho mu oat g~hodchtbj~jd zodj~ tbj HEH/ Cz~tbj~à~j)

oatwmtbuthodmog tbj Ojwihodu ~jimgmazu njimjcu) hu h ujezih~) ca~v~acmt ea~va~htmao) Bj~eziju

daju oat xzhimc} hu h ~jimgmazu j`via}j~ wmtbmo tbj `jhomog ac tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j ~jgzihtmaou/

Oa~ `h} mt ujjl ~jczgj mo tbj joca~ej`jot uhcj bh~na~/ Heea~dmogi}) Bj~eziju wmii nj ~jxzm~jd

ta jmtbj~ moeizdj oaeaut easj~hgj ca~ eaot~hejvtmao mo mtu g~azv bjhitb viho a~ chej àojth~}

vjohitmju/ Chejd wmtb h ebamej njtwjjo ea`vi}mog wmtb tbj HEH a~ ea`vi}mog wmtb tbjm~

~jimgmazu njimjcu) Vihmotmccu cmijd tbj mouthot uzmt ebhiijogmog tbj wa`jou v~jsjotmsj eh~j

easj~hgj `hodhtj hu smaihtmsj ac ^C^H) tbj Cm~ut H`jod`jot) tbj Cmctb H`jod`jot) hod tbj

Hd`momut~htmsj V~aejdz~j Het/

Njimjsmog tbj hiijgjd mokz~} ta tbjm~ eaoutmtztmaohi hod uthtzta~} ~mgbtu ta nj m``mojot)

Vihmotmccu cmijd tbj mouthot @atmao ca~ V~jim`moh~} Mokzoetmao/

DMUEZUUMAO

H v~jim`moh~} mokzoetmao mu ho jrt~ha~dmoh~} ~j`jd}< heea~dmogi}) tbj ~mgbt ta ~jimjc `zut

nj eijh~ hod zojxzmsaehi/ Ujj) j/g/)Ciaad s/ Eijh~Aoj Ea`èou) Moe/) 382 C/5d 8886) 8887

"86tb Em~/ >686-/ Ta `jjt tbmu nz~djo) h vh~t} ujjlmog h v~jim`moh~} mokzoetmao `zut ubaw; "8- h

imljimbaad ac uzeejuu ao tbj `j~mtu) ">- h tb~jht ac m~~jvh~hnij bh~`) wbmeb "5- aztwjmgbu ho}

bh~` ta tbj oaoàsmog vh~t}) hod tbht "4- tbj mokzoetmao wazid oat hdsj~uji} hccjet tbj vznime

Ehuj 8;8>-es-688>5-KIL Daez`jot 56 Cmijd 67!>7!8> ZUDE Eaia~hda Vhgj : ac 82


6/19

3

motj~jut/ Ujj) j/g/)Hwhd s/ [m~mhr) 376 C/5d 8888) 88>: "86tb Em~/ >68>-/ Hitbazgb tbmu moxzm~}

mu) ao mtu chej) ~jihtmsji} ut~hmgbtca~wh~d) tbj~j h~j h sh~mjt} ac jrejvtmaou/ Mc tbj mokzoetmao wmii

"8- hitj~ tbj uthtzu xza) ">- `hodhtj hetmao n} tbj djcjodhot) a~ "5- hcca~d tbj àshot hii tbj

~jimjc tbht mt eazid ~jeasj~ ht tbj eaoeizumao ac h czii t~mhi ao tbj `j~mtu) tbj àshot `zut `jjt h

bjmgbtjojd nz~djo/ Ujj A Ejot~a Juvm~mth Njojcmejotj Zomha da Sjgjthi s/ Hube~act) 52= C/5d

=75) =7: "86tb Em~/ >664- "jo nhoe-) hccd hod ~j`hodjd) Gao{hiju s/ A Ejot~a Juvm~mth

Njojcmejotj Zomha da Sjgjthi) :43 Z/U/ 482 ">663-/

Mo djtj~`momog wbjtbj~ ho mokzoetmao chiiu mota aoj ac tbjuj dmuchsa~jd ehtjga~mju)

eaz~tu actjo caezu ao wbjtbj~ tbj ~jxzjutjd mokzoetmsj ~jimjc wmii hitj~ tbj uthtzu xza/ Tbj uthtzu

xza mu tbj ihut zoeaotjutjd uthtzu njtwjjo tbj vh~tmju wbmeb v~jejdjd tbj eaot~asj~u} zotmi tbj

aztea`j ac tbj cmohi bjh~mog/ Da`momao Smdja Uhtjiimtj) Moe/ s/ Jebauth~ Uhtjiimtj Ea~v/) >3=

C/5d 884=) 88:: "86tb Em~/ >668-/ Mo `hlmog tbmu djtj~`mohtmao) bawjsj~) M `zut iaal nj}aod

tbj vh~tmju ijghi ~mgbtu) caezumog moutjhd ao tbj ~jhimt} ac tbj jrmutmog uthtzu hod ~jihtmaoubmv

njtwjjo tbj vh~tmju/ Ueb~mj~ s/ Zoms/ ac Eaia/) 4>7 C/5d 8>:5) 8>36 "86tb Em~/ >66:-/ Mc tbj

~jxzjutjd ~jimjc wazid jmtbj~ v~juj~sj a~ ~juta~j tbj ~jihtmaoubmv hod uthtzu jrmutmog hotj njiiz`)

tbj mokzoetmao daju oat hitj~ tbj uthtzu xza/

Tbmu djtj~`mohtmao mu oat) bawjsj~) ojejuuh~mi} dmuvaumtmsj/ Ho mokzoetmao ~juta~mog tbj

uthtzu xza hotj njiiz` `h} ~jxzm~j hetmao ao njbhic ac tbj oaoàshot/ Uzeb ho mokzoetmao) aoj

wbmeb hccm~`htmsji} ~jxzm~j\uP tbj oaoàshot ta het mo h vh~tmezih~ wh}) mu `hodhta~} hod

dmuchsa~jd/ Md/ ht 8>38/

Hitbazgb M caiiaw tbj Tjotb Em~ezmtu gzmdhoej mo djtj~`momog wbjtbj~ Vihmotmccu ujjl ta

dmutz~n tbj uthtzu xza a~ ~jxzm~j hccm~`htmsj hetmao n} Djcjodhotu) M h` eh~jczi ta hsamd



7/19

7 Hitbazgb ua`j eaz~tu mo tbmu dmut~met bhsj xzjutmaojd tbj eaotmozjd shimdmt} ac tbmu~jihrjd imljimbaadacuzeejuuaotbj`j~mtu uthodh~d mo imgbt ac tbj Uzv~j`j Eaz~tu djemumao mo

Wmotj~ s/ Ohtz~hi ^juaz~ej Djcjouj Eazoemi) Moe/) ::: Z/U/ 7) >6 ">662- "baidmog tbht h vihmotmccujjlmog h v~jim`moh~} mokzoetmao `zut juthnimub tbht bj mu imlji} ta uzeejjd ao tbj `j~mtu-)

njehzuj tbj Tjotb Em~ezmt bhu eaotmozjd ta ~jcj~ ta tbmu ~jihrjd uthodh~d M huuz`j mt utmii gasj~outbj muuzhoej ac v~jim`moh~} mokzoetmaou mo tbmu em~ezmt/ Ujj âDh D~miimog Ea/ s/ Umjghi) ::> C/5d8>65) 8>6= o/5 "86tb Em~/ >66=-/

7

zoe~mtmehi hdbj~joej ta tbj uthtzu xzaca~`zih hod tbj `hodhta~}!v~abmnmta~} ca~`zihtmao/

Mo `hlmog tbmu djtj~`mohtmao) M `zut nj `modczi ac tbj czodh`jothi vz~vauj ac v~jim`moh~}

mokzoetmsj ~jimjc zodj~ az~ ^ziju ac Emsmi V~aejdz~j) wbmeb mu ta v~juj~sj tbj ~jihtmsj vaumtmaou

ac tbj vh~tmju zotmi h t~mhi ao tbj `j~mtu eho nj bjid/ N~h} s/ XCH â}hitmju) IIE) 423 C/ Uzvv/

>d 8>57) 8>4544 "D/ Eaia/ >667- "emtmog A Ejot~a) 52= C/5d ht ===8668 "Uj}àz~) E/K/)

eaoez~~mog--/

Njca~j tbj moutmghtmao ac tbmu ihwuzmt) Vihmotmccu `hmothmojd ho j`via}jj mouz~hoej viho

tbht jreizdjd eaot~hejvtmsj easj~hgj/ Hitbazgb Djcjodhotu bhsj vhuujd h ~jgzihtmao ~jxzm~mog

Vihmotmccu ta moeizdj uzeb easj~hgj mo tbjm~ easj~hgj ca~ tbj viho}jh~ njgmoomog ao Oasj`nj~ 8)

>68>) tbht ~jgzihtmao) hu mt hvvimju ta Vihmotmccu) bhu oat }jt thljo jccjet/ Ubazid tbj ~jxzjutjd

mokzoetmao jotj~) Djcjodhotu wmii nj jokamojd c~a` joca~emog tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj

`hodhtj hghmout Vihmotmccu vjodmog tbj aztea`j ac tbmu uzmt/ Tbj uthtzu xza wmii nj v~juj~sjd)

hod Djcjodhotu wmii oat nj ~jxzm~jd ta thlj ho} hccm~`htmsj hetmao/

Njehzuj Vihmotmccu da oat ujjl h dmuchsa~jd mokzoetmao) M `zut eaoumdj~ wbjtbj~

Vihmotmccu h~j jotmtijd ta ~ji} ao ho hitj~jd nz~djo ac v~aac/ Ec/ A Ejot~a) 52= C/5d ht =73/ Mc tbj

jxzmtmju tmv ut~aogi} mo tbjm~ chsa~) Vihmotmccu `h} `jjt tbj ~jxzm~j`jot ca~ ubawmog uzeejuu ao

tbj `j~mtu n} ubawmog tbht xzjutmaou gamog ta tbj `j~mtu h~j ua uj~mazu) uznuthotmhi) dmccmezit) hod

dazntczi hu ta `hlj tbj muuzj ~mvj ca~ imtmghtmao hod djuj~smog ac à~j djimnj~htj mosjutmghtmao/7



8/19

2

Alih/ jr ~ji/ Alih/ Thr Ea`ò s/ Moti ^jgmut~htmao Viho) Moe/) 4:: C/5d 8867) 8885 "86tb Em~/

>663-/

Heea~dmogi}) M njgmo n} eaoumdj~mog tbj jxzmtmju njca~j tz~omog ta Vihmotmccu imljimbaad ac

uzeejuu ao tbj `j~mtu/

8/ M~~jvh~hnij Bh~`

Hitbazgb mt mu wjiijuthnimubjd tbht tbj vatjotmhi smaihtmao ac Vihmotmccu eaoutmtztmaohi hod

^C^H ~mgbtu tb~jhtjou m~~jvh~hnij bh~`)ujj Lmlz`z~h s/ Bz~ij}) >4> C/5d =:6) =35 "86tb Em~/

>668-) Vihmotmccu `zut hiua juthnimub tbht tbj mokz~} ea`vihmojd ac mu ac uzeb m``mojoej tbht

tbj~j mu h eijh~ hod v~jujot ojjd ca~ jxzmthnij ~jimjc ta v~jsjot m~~jvh~hnij bh~`/ Bjmdj`ho s/ U/

Uhit Ihlj Emt}) 542 C/5d 882>) 882= "86tb Em~/ >665- "j`vbhumu mo a~mgmohi-/ M``mojoej daju

oat) bawjsj~) ~jxzm~j m` jdmhe}/ Vihmotmccu ojjd aoi} djàout~htj tbht hnujot h v~jim`moh~}

mokzoetmao) \tbj}P h~j imlji} ta uzccj~ m~~jvh~hnij bh~` njca~j h djemumao ao tbj `j~mtu eho nj

~jodj~jd/ Wmotj~ s/ Oht/ ^ju/ Djc/ Eazoemi) Moe/) ::: Z/U/ 7) >> ">662- "xzatmog 88H E/ W~mgbt)

H/ @miij~) # @/ Lhoj) Cjdj~hi V~hetmej hod V~aejdz~j >=42/8) v/ 85= ">d jd/ 8==:--/

Hnujot mokzoetmsj ~jimjc) Vihmotmccu wmii nj ~jxzm~jd ta v~asmdj CDHhvv~asjd

eaot~hejvtmsj `jtbadu) utj~mim{htmao v~aejdz~ju) hod vhtmjot jdzehtmao hod eazoujimog ca~ wa`jo

wmtb ~jv~adzetmsj ehvhemt} hu vh~t ac tbjm~ j`via}jj mouz~hoej viho/ Vj~ tbj tj~ù ac tbj

v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj) tbht easj~hgj `zut njgmo ao tbj uth~t dhtj ac tbj cm~ut viho

}jh~ caiiawmog tbj jccjetmsj dhtj ac tbj ~jgzihtmaou) Oasj`nj~ 8) >68>/ Djcjodhotu h~gzj tbmu

bh~`) tb~jj àotbu mo tbj cztz~j) mu oat uzccmemjoti} m``mojot ta kzutmc} mokzoetmsj ~jimjc/ Mo imgbt

ac tbj jrtjoumsj vihoomog mosaisjd mo v~jvh~mog hod v~asmdmog mtu j`via}jj mouz~hoej viho) hod



9/19

=

tbj zoej~thmot} tbht tbmu `httj~ wmii nj ~juaisjd njca~j tbj easj~hgj jccjetmsj dhtj) Vihmotmccu

bhsj hdjxzhtji} juthnimubjd tbht tbj} wmii uzccj~ m``mojot m~~jvh~hnij bh~` hnujot mokzoetmsj

~jimjc/ Tbmu cheta~ ut~aogi} chsa~u jot~} ac mokzoetmsj ~jimjc/

>/ Nhihoemog ac Bh~`u

M `zut ojrt wjmgb tbj m~~jvh~hnij bh~` chejd n} Vihmotmccu hghmout tbj bh~` ta Djcjodhotu

ubazid ho mokzoetmao jotj~/ Ubazid ho mokzoetmao jotj~) Djcjodhotu wmii nj v~jsjotjd c~a`

joca~emog ~jgzihtmaou tbht Eaog~juu cazod mt mo tbj vznime motj~jut ta dm~jet tbht hgjoe} ta

djsjiav hod joca~ej/ Ea~omub s/ Dzdhu) :46 C/ Uzvv/ >d 38) 38 "D/D/E/ >662-/

Tbmu bh~` vhiju mo ea`vh~muao ta tbj vauumnij moc~mogj`jot zvao Vihmotmccu

eaoutmtztmaohi hod uthtzta~} ~mgbtu/ Tbmu cheta~ ut~aogi} chsa~u jot~} ac mokzoetmsj ~jimjc/

5/ Vznime Motj~jut

Djcjodhotu h~gzj tbht jot~} ac tbj ~jxzjutjd mokzoetmao mu eaot~h~} ta tbj vznime motj~jut)

njehzuj mt wazid zodj~`moj \tbjm~P hnmimt} ta jccjetzhtj Eaog~juuu gahiu ac m`v~asmog tbj

bjhitb ac wa`jo hod ebmid~jo hod jxzhim{mog tbj easj~hgj ac v~jsjotmsj uj~smeju ca~ wa`jo hod

`jo ua tbht wa`jo wba ebaauj ta da ua eho nj vh~t ac tbj wa~lca~ej ao ho jxzhi vih}mog cmjid

wmtb `jo/ Djcjodhotu ^juvaouj "dae/ >3- ht75/ Tbmu huuj~tjd motj~jut mu) bawjsj~) zodj~`mojd

n} tbj e~jhtmao ac jrj`vtmaou ca~ ej~thmo ~jimgmazu a~ghom{htmaou hod j`via}j~u wmtb

g~hodchtbj~jd bjhitb mouz~hoej vihou hod h tj`va~h~} joca~ej`jot uhcj bh~na~ ca~ oaov~acmt

a~ghom{htmaou/

Tbjuj motj~jutu h~j eazotj~jd) hod modjjd aztwjmgbjd) n} tbj vznime motj~jut mo tbj c~jj

jrj~emuj ac ~jimgmao/ Hu tbj Tjotb Em~ezmt bhu oatjd) tbj~j mu h ut~aog vznime motj~jut mo tbj c~jj

Ehuj 8;8>-es-688>5-KIL Daez`jot 56 Cmijd 67!>7!8> ZUDE Eaia~hda Vhgj = ac 82


10/19


11/19

88

Vhuujd mo 8==5) tbj ^jimgmazu C~jjda` ^juta~htmao Het "^C^H- uazgbt ta ~juta~j tbj

ea`vjiimog motj~jut tjut hu ujt ca~tb mo Ubj~nj~t s/ Sj~oj~) 574 Z/U/ 5=2 "8=35- hod Wmueaoumo s/

]adj~) 463 Z/U/ >6: "8=7>- hod ta gzh~hotjj mtu hvvimehtmao mo hii ehuju wbj~j c~jj jrj~emuj ac

~jimgmao mu uznuthotmhii} nz~djojd/ 4> Z/U/E/ >666nn"n-/ Hitbazgb zoeaoutmtztmaohi hu

hvvimjd ta tbj uthtju)ujj Emt} ac Naj~oj s/ Cia~ju) :>8 Z/U/ :67 "8==7-) mt ~j`hmou eaoutmtztmaohi

hu hvvimjd ta tbj cjdj~hi gasj~o`jot/ Ujj Zomtjd Uthtju s/ Wmigzu) 352 C/5d 8>74) 8>7= "86tb

Em~/ >688-/

Zodj~ ^C^H) tbj gasj~o`jot `h} oat uznuthotmhii} nz~djo h vj~uaou jrj~emuj ac

~jimgmao jsjo mc tbj nz~djo ~juzitu c~a` h ~zij ac gjoj~hi hvvimehnmimt}/ 4> Z/U/E/ >666nn

8"h-/ Tbmu gjoj~hi v~abmnmtmao mu oat) bawjsj~) wmtbazt jrejvtmao/ Tbj gasj~o`jot `h} kzutmc} h

uznuthotmhi nz~djo ao tbj c~jj jrj~emuj ac ~jimgmao mc tbj ebhiijogjd ihw; "8- mu mo cz~tbj~hoej ac

h ea`vjiimog gasj~o`jothi motj~jut< hod ">- mu tbj ijhut ~jut~metmsj `jhou ac cz~tbj~mog tbht

ea`vjiimog gasj~o`jothi motj~jut/ Md/ ht >666nn8"n-/ Tbj momtmhi nz~djo mu na~oj n} tbj

vh~t} ebhiijogmog tbj ihw/ Aoej tbht vh~t} juthnimubju tbht tbj ebhiijogjd ihw uznuthotmhii}

nz~djou bj~ c~jj jrj~emuj ac ~jimgmao) tbj nz~djo ubmctu ta tbj gasj~o`jot ta kzutmc} tbht nz~djo/

Tbj ohtz~j ac tbmu v~jim`moh~} mokzoetmao v~aejjdmog daju oat hitj~ tbjuj nz~djou/ Gao{hiju) :43

Z/U/ ht 4>=/ Tbzu) M `zut cm~ut eaoumdj~ wbjtbj~ Vihmotmccu bhsj dj`aout~htjd tbht tbj v~jsjotmsj

eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj uznuthotmhii} nz~djou tbjm~ c~jj jrj~emuj ac ~jimgmao/ Mc ua) M `zut tbjo

eaoumdj~ wbjtbj~ tbj gasj~o`jot bhu dj`aout~htjd tbht tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj mu

tbj ijhut ~jut~metmsj `jhou ta hebmjsj h ea`vjiimog motj~jut/

Uznuthotmhi Nz~djo ac C~jj Jrj~emuj

Vihmotmccu h~gzj tbht v~asmdmog eaot~hejvtmao easj~hgj smaihtju tbjm~ umoej~ji} bjid



12/19

= Mo tbj hitj~ohtmsj) tbj gasj~o`jot h~gzju tbht njehzuj Vihmotmccu ~aztmoji} eaot~mnztj taatbj~ uebj`ju tbht smaihtj tbj ~jimgmazu njimjcu hiijgjd bj~j) tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj`hodhtj daju oat uznuthotmhii} nz~djo Vihmotmccu c~jj jrj~emuj ac ~jimgmao/ Tbmu h~gz`jot

~jxzm~ju m`vj~`muumnij imoj d~hwmog) hod M ~jkjet mt azt ac bhod/ Ujj Tba`hu s/ ^jsmjw Nd/ acMod/ J`vt Uje/) 4:6 Z/U/ 767) 78: "8=28-/

8>

~jimgmazu njimjcu/ Hitbazgb tbj gasj~o`jot daju oat ebhiijogj tbj umoej~mt} ac tbj Ojwihodu

~jimgmazu njimjcu) mt h~gzju tbht Vihmotmccu bhsj chmijd ta djàout~htj h uznuthotmhi nz~djo ao tbjm~

c~jj jrj~emuj ac ~jimgmao/ Tbmu h~gz`jot ~jimju zvao twa lj} v~j`muju/ Cm~ut) tbj gasj~o`jot

huuj~tu tbht tbj nz~djo ac v~asmdmog mouz~hoej easj~hgj mu na~oj n} Bj~eziju/ Ujeaod) tbj

gasj~o`jot h~gzju tbht hu h ca~v~acmt) ujezih~ j`via}j~) Bj~eziju ehooat joghgj mo ho jrj~emuj

ac ~jimgmao/ Heea~dmogi}) tbj h~gz`jot eaoeizdju) tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj ehooat

nz~djo Bj~eziju c~jj jrj~emuj ac ~jimgmao/= Vihmotmccu eazotj~) h~gzmog tbht tbj~j jrmutu oa ihw

ca~nmddmog h ea~va~htmao c~a` avj~htmog heea~dmog ta ~jimgmazu v~moemviju/

Tbjuj h~gz`jotu vauj dmccmezit xzjutmaou ac cm~ut m`v~juumao/ Eho h ea~va~htmao jrj~emuj

~jimgmao1 Ubazid h eiauji}bjid uznebhvtj~u ea~va~htmao awojd hod avj~htjd n} h u`hii g~azv

ac modmsmdzhiu v~acjuumog hdbj~joej ta zomca~` ~jimgmazu njimjcu nj t~jhtjd dmccj~joti} tbho h

vznimei} bjid ea~va~htmao awojd hod avj~htjd n} h g~azv ac uthljbaidj~u wmtb dmsj~uj ~jimgmazu

njimjcu1 Mu mt vauumnij ta vmj~ej tbj sjmi hod dmu~jgh~d tbj ea~va~htj ca~` mo tbmu eaotjrt1 Wbht

mu tbj umgomcmehoej ac tbj vhuutb~azgb thrhtmao hvvimehnij ta uznebhvtj~u ea~va~htmaou hu mt

vj~thmou ta tbmu hohi}umu1 Tbjuj xzjutmaou `j~mt à~j djimnj~htj mosjutmghtmao/

Jsjo mc) zvao cz~tbj~ jrh`mohtmao) Vihmotmccu h~j hnij ta djàout~htj h uznuthotmhi nz~djo

ao tbjm~ c~jj jrj~emuj ac ~jimgmao) bawjsj~) tbj gasj~o`jot `h} kzutmc} mtu hvvimehtmao ac tbj

v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj n} djàout~htmog tbht hvvimehtmao ac tbht `hodhtj ta Vihmotmccu

Ehuj 8;8>-es-688>5-KIL Daez`jot 56 Cmijd 67!>7!8> ZUDE Eaia~hda Vhgj 8> ac 82

->


13/19

86 Vihmotmccu ut~jozazui} ebhiijogj wbjtbj~ tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtjhetzhii} cz~tbj~u tbj v~aàtmao ac vznime bjhitb/ M ojjd oat hdd~juu tbht h~gz`jot ta ~juaisj tbjmouthot àtmao) hod M djeimoj ta da ua/

85

mu tbj ijhut ~jut~metmsj `jhou ac cz~tbj~mog h ea`vjiimog motj~jut/

Ea`vjiimog Motj~jut

Mo a~dj~ ta kzutmc} h uznuthotmhi nz~djo ao Vihmotmccu c~jj jrj~emuj ac ~jimgmao) tbj

gasj~o`jot `zut ubaw tbht mtu hvvimehtmao ac tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~jeasj~hgj `hodhtj ta Vihmotmccu

cz~tbj~u motj~jutu ac tbj bmgbjut a~dj~/ Bh~dj`ho) >=7 C/5d ht 88>7/ Mt mu wjiiujttijd tbht tbj

motj~jut huuj~tjd mo tbmu ehuj) tbj v~aàtmao ac vznime bjhitb) mu h ea`vjiimog gasj~o`jot motj~jut/

Ujj Nzebwhid s/ Zoms/ ac O/@/ Ueb/ ac @jd/) 8:= C/5d 427) 4=2 "86tb Em~/ 8==2-/ Tbj

gasj~o`jot h~gzju tbht tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj) hu hvvimjd ta Vihmotmccu hod hii

um`mih~i} umtzhtjd vh~tmju) cz~tbj~u tbmu ea`vjiimog motj~jut/

Huuz`mog) h~gzjoda) tbht hvvimehtmao ac tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj ta

Vihmotmccu hod hii um`mih~i} umtzhtjd vh~tmju cz~tbj~u h ea`vjiimog gasj~o`jot motj~jut)86 tbht

h~gz`jot daju oat kzutmc} h uznuthotmhi nz~djo ao Vihmotmccu c~jj jrj~emuj ac ~jimgmao; ^C^H

~jxzm~ju tbj Gasj~o`jot ta djàout~htj tbht tbj ea`vjiimog motj~jut tjut mu uhtmucmjd tb~azgb

hvvimehtmao ac tbj ebhiijogjd ihw ta tbj vj~uao tbj vh~tmezih~ eihm`hot wbauj umoej~j jrj~emuj

ac ~jimgmao mu njmog uznuthotmhii} nz~djojd/ Gao{hiju) :43 Z/U/ ht 45658/

M da oat `jho ta uzggjut tbht tbj gasj~o`jot `h} oat juthnimub h ea`vjiimog motj~jut mo

tbj zomca~` hvvimehtmao ac h vh~tmezih~ v~ag~h`/ Ta `hlj uzeb h ubawmog) bawjsj~) tbj

gasj~o`jot `zut accj~\P jsmdjoej tbht g~hotmog tbj ~jxzjutjd ~jimgmazu heea`àdhtmaou wazid

uj~mazui} ea`v~a`muj mtu hnmimt} ta hd`momutj~ tbmu v~ag~h`/ Md/ ht 45:/ Ho} uzeb h~gz`jot mu


-5


14/19

88 Tbj gasj~o`jotu httj`vt ta ebh~hetj~m{j g~hodchtbj~mog hu vbhujd m`vij`jothtmaomu zohshmimog/ Hu oatjd hnasj) bjhitb vihou h} ~jthmo tbjm~ g~hodchtbj~jd uthtzu modjcmomtji}/@aut dh`hgmog ta tbj gasj~o`jotu hiijgjd ea`vjiimog motj~jut) jsjo tbazgb Eaog~juu ~jxzm~jdg~hodchtbj~jd bjhitb vihou ta ea`vi} wmtb ej~thmo v~asmumaou ac tbj HEH) mt uvjemcmehii}jrj`vtjd g~hodchtbj~jd bjhitb vihou c~a` ea`vi}mog wmtb tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj`hodhtj/ Ujj 4> Z/U/E/ 82688"h-"54- "uvjemc}mog tbauj v~asmumaou ac tbj HEH tbht hvvi} tag~hodchtbj~jd bjhitb vihou-/

8> Tbj gasj~o`jot h~gzju tbht njehzuj tbjuj v~asmumaou h~j gjoj~hii} hvvimehnij) hod oatuvjemcmehii} im`mtjd ta tbj v~jsjotmsj uj~smeju easj~hgj ~jgzihtmaou) tbj} h~j oat jrj`vtmaouc~a` tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj/ Tbmu mu h dmutmoetmao wmtbazt uznuthoej/ N}jrj`vtmog j`via}j~u c~a` v~asmdmog bjhitb eh~j easj~hgj) tbjuj v~asmumaou jrj`vt tbaujj`via}j~u c~a` v~asmdmog v~jsjothtmsj bjhitb eh~j easj~hgj ta wa`jo/ Mc tbj gasj~o`jot bhu h

ea`vjiimog motj~jut mo jouz~mog oaeaut v~asmumao ac v~jsjothtmsj bjhitb easj~hgj ta wa`jo) tbhtmotj~jut mu ea`v~a`mujd n} jrejvtmaou hiiawmog j`via}j~u ta hsamd v~asmdmog tbht easj~hgj wbjtbj~ n~ahdi} a~ oh~~awi} e~hctjd/

84

zodj~`mojd n} tbj jrmutjoej ac oz`j~azu jrj`vtmaou ta tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj/

Mo v~a`zightmog tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj) Eaog~juu e~jhtjd umgomcmehot jrj`vtmaou

ca~ u`hii j`via}j~u hod g~hodchtbj~jd bjhitb vihou/88 8> >3 Z/U/E/ 4=26B"e-">- "jrj`vtmog

c~a` bjhitb eh~j v~asmumao ~jxzm~j`jot j`via}j~u ac ijuu tbho cmct} cziitm`j j`via}jju-< 4>

Z/U/E/ 82688 "g~hodchtbj~mog ac jrmutmog bjhitb eh~j vihou-/ Jsjo Djcjodhotu e~jhtjd h

~jgzihta~} jrj`vtmao ta tbj eaot~hejvtmao `hodhtj/ 73 Cjd/ ^jg/ 433>8) 433>3 "Hzg/ 5) >688-

"jrj`vtmog ej~thmo ~jimgmazu j`via}j~u c~a` tbj eaot~hejvtmao ~jxzm~j`jot ac tbj v~jsjotmsj

eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj-/

\HP ihw ehooat nj ~jgh~djd hu v~atjetmog ho motj~jut ac tbj bmgbjut a~dj~ wbjo mt ijhsju

hvv~jemhnij dh`hgj ta tbht uzvvaujdi} smthi motj~jut zov~abmnmtjd/ Ebz~eb ac tbj Izlz`m

Nhnhiz H}j) Moe/ s/ Emt} ac Bmhijhb) :62 Z/U/ :>6) :47 "8==5-: C/5d =52) =:2 "86tb Em~/ >662-/ Tbj gasj~o`jot bhu jrj`vtjd asj~ 8=6 `miimao bjhitb viho



15/19

85 Jsjo mc) hu mu jutm`htjd zodj~ tbj gasj~o`jotu bmgbjod jutm`htj) 3=* ac bjhitb vihouiauj tbjm~ g~hodchtbj~jd uthtzu n} tbj jod ac >685) `miimaou bjhitb viho vh~tmemvhotu hod

njojcmemh~mju wmii eaotmozj ta nj jrj`vtjd c~a` tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj/ Ujj 7:Cjd/ ^jg/ 54:52) 54::5/

84 Ta tbj jrtjot tbj gasj~o`jot h~gzju e~jhtmog ho jrj`vtmao ca~ Vihmotmccu tb~jhtjou ta

zodj~`moj tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj) tbht h~gz`jot mu moeaoumutjot wmtb ^C^H hodm~~jijshot mo tbmu eaotjrt/ Ujj Gao{hiju) :43 Z/U/ ht 453 "~jkjetmog uimvvj~} uiavj h~gz`jot humoeaoumutjot wmtb ^C^H-/

8:

vh~tmemvhotu hod njojcmemh~mju c~a` tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj2=/ Tbj gasj~o`jot ojjd oat tmit ht

wmod`miiu< mt ojjd aoi} ~jcztj hitj~ohtmsju v~avaujd n} Vihmotmccu/ Md/

Vihmotmccu v~avauj aoj hitj~ohtmsj) gasj~o`jot v~asmumao ac c~jj nm~tb eaot~ai) tbht eazid

nj hebmjsjd n} h sh~mjt} ac `jtbadu; e~jhtmao ac h eaot~hejvtmao mouz~hoej viho wmtb c~jj

jo~aii`jot) dm~jet ea`vjouhtmao ac eaot~hejvtmao hod utj~mim{htmao v~asmdj~u) e~jhtmao ac h thr

e~jdmt a~ djdzetmao ca~ eaot~hejvtmsj vz~ebhuju) a~ m`vaumtmao ac h `hodhtj ao tbj eaot~hejvtmao

`hozchetz~mog modzut~} ta gmsj mtu mtj`u hwh} ca~ c~jj/ Djcjodhotu h~gzj Vihmotmccu

`muzodj~uthod tbj ohtz~j ac tbj ijhut ~jut~metmsj `jhou moxzm~}/ N~mjc mo Avvaumtmao "dae/ >3-

ht 45/ Heea~dmog ta Djcjodhotu) tbmu moxzm~} ubazid nj im`mtjd ta wbjtbj~ Vihmotmccu hod atbj~

um`mih~i} umtzhtjd vh~tmju eazid nj jrj`vtjd wmtbazt dh`hgmog Djcjodhotu ea`vjiimog motj~jut/

Ehuj 8;8>-es-688>5-KIL Daez`jot 56 Cmijd 67!>7!8> ZUDE Eaia~hda Vhgj 8: ac 82

-8

-4


16/19

8: Cz~tbj~`a~j) natb vh~tmju m`vj~`muumni} jrvhod tbj ueavj ac tbmu djtj~`mohtmao/ Huoatjd hnasj) `} moxzm~} mu im`mtjd ta tbj vh~tmju njca~j `j< M da oat eaoumdj~ hii atbj~ um`mih~i}

umtzhtjd vh~tmju/ Ta tbj jrtjot Vihmotmccu hitj~ohtmsj wazid hvvi} ta atbj~ vh~tmju) mt muasj~moeizumsj/ Njehzuj tbj vh~tmju c~h`j tbmu dmuezuumao) bawjsj~) M hohi}{j tbj hitj~ohtmsj huv~jujotjd n} Vihmotmccu hod ~juvaodjd ta n} Djcjodhotu/

83

Mt mu) bawjsj~) oat Vihmotmccu nzt Djcjodhotu wba `muzodj~uthod tbj ijhut ~jut~metmsj

`jhou moxzm~}/ Djcjodhotu ojjd oat ~jcztj jsj~} eaoejmshnij hitj~ohtmsj) nzt tbj} `zut ~jcztj

tbj hitj~ohtmsj uebj`ju accj~jd n} tbj ebhiijogj~/8: Wmigzu) 352 C/5d ht 8>2=/

Djuvmtj tbjm~ ehtjga~mehi h~gz`jot) Djcjodhotu httj`vt ta ~jcztj Vihmotmccu v~avaujd

hitj~ohtmsj/ Cm~ut) Djcjodhotu h~gzj tbht njehzuj Vihmotmccu hitj~ohtmsj wazid m`vauj

eaoumdj~hnij ojw eautu hod atbj~ nz~djou ao tbj Gasj~o`jot hod h~j atbj~wmuj m`v~hetmehi)

tbj} ubazid nj ~jkjetjd hu oat cjhumnij a~ vihzumnij/ N~mjc mo Avvaumtmao "dae/ >3- ht 44/

Hitbazgb h ubawmog ac m`v~hetmehimt} mu uzccmemjot ta ~jcztj tbj hdjxzhe} ac h v~avaujd

hitj~ohtmsj) Djcjodhotu bhsj chmijd ta `hlj uzeb h ubawmog mo tbmu ehuj/ Hu Vihmotmccu oatj) tbj

gasj~o`jot hi~jhd} v~asmdju c~jj eaot~hejvtmao ta wa`jo/ ^jvi} N~mjc mo Uzvva~t "dae/ >7- ht

52/

Djcjodhotu hiua h~gzj Vihmotmccu hitj~ohtmsj wazid oat hdjxzhtji} hdshoej tbj

gasj~o`jotu ea`vjiimog motj~jutu/ Tbj} heloawijdgj tbht Vihmotmccu hitj~ohtmsj wazid hebmjsj

tbj vz~vauj ac v~asmdmog eaot~hejvtmsj uj~smeju ta wa`jo wmtb oa eaut ubh~mog) nzt h~gzj tbht

Vihmotmccu hitj~ohtmsj wmii oat jouz~\jP tbht wa`jo wmii chej `mom`hi iagmutmehi hod

hd`momut~htmsj anutheiju ta ~jejmsmog easj~hgj ac tbjm~ eh~j/ N~mjc mo Avvaumtmao "dae/ >3- ht 4:/

Hitbazgb Vihmotmccu h~gzj tbht tbmu h`azotu ta h ~jdjcmomtmao ac Djcjodhotu ea`vjiimog motj~jut)



17/19

83 Ta nj eijh~) M da oat njimjsj Djcjodhotu bhsj uzccmemjoti} djàout~htjd h ea`vjiimog

motj~jut mo joca~emog tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj`hodhtj hghmout Vihmotmccu/ Ca~ vz~vauju ac `}hohi}umu zodj~ ijhut ~jut~metmsj `jhou v~aog ac ^C^H) bawjsj~) M huuz`j tbj jrmutjoej ac uzebho motj~jut/

87

mt mu moutjhd h iagmehi ea~aiih~} tbj~jta/83 Oaojtbjijuu) Djcjodhotu bhsj chmijd ta hddzej chetu

juthnimubmog tbht gasj~o`jot v~asmumao ac eaot~hejvtmao uj~smeju wmii ojejuuh~mi} jothmi iagmutmehi

hod hd`momut~htmsj anutheiju djcjhtmog tbj zitm`htj vz~vauj ac v~asmdmog oaeaut v~jsjotmsj

bjhitb eh~j easj~hgj ta wa jo/ Aoej hghmo) tbj ez~~jot jrmutjoej ac hohiagazu v~ag~hù

bjhsmi} wjmgbu hghmout uzeb ho h~gz`jot/

Djcjodhotu njh~ tbj nz~djo ac djàout~htmog tbht ~jczumog ta jrj`vt Vihmotmccu c~a` tbj

v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj mu tbj ijhut ~jut~metmsj `jhou ac cz~tbj~mog tbjm~ ea`vjiimog

motj~jut/ Gmsjo tbj jrmutjoej ac gasj~o`jot v~ag~hù um mih~ ta Vihmotmccu v~avaujd hitj~ohtmsj)

tbj gasj~o`jot bhu chmijd ta `jjt tbmu nz~djo/

Eaoeizumao

Tbj nhihoej ac tbj jxzmtmju tmv ut~aogi} mo chsa~ ac mokzoetmsj ~jimjc mo tbmu ehuj/ Njehzuj

tbmu ehuj v~jujotu xzjutmaou gamog ta tbj `j~mtu / / / ua uj~mazu) uznuthotmhi) dmccmezit) hod

dazntczi hu ta `hlj tbj muuzj ~mvj ca~ imtmghtmao hod djuj~smog ac à~j djimnj~htj mosjutmghtmao) M

cmod mt hvv~av~mhtj ta jokamo tbj m`vij`jothtmao ac tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj hu

hvvimjd ta Vihmotmccu/ Heea~dmogi})

Djcjodhotu) tbjm~ hgjotu) accmej~u) hod j`via}jju) hod tbjm~ ~jxzm~j`jotu tbht Vihmotmccu

v~asmdj CDHhvv~asjd eaot~hejvtmsj `jtbadu) utj~mim{htmao v~aejdz~ju) hod vhtmjot jdzehtmao

hod eazoujimog ca~ wa`jo wmtb ~jv~adzetmsj ehvhemt}) h~j JOKAMOJD c~a` ho} hvvimehtmao a~

joca~ej`jot tbj~jac hghmout Vihmotmccu) moeizdmog tbj uznuthotmsj ~jxzm~j`jot m`vaujd mo 4>


->


18/19

82

Z/U/E/ 566gg85"h-"4-) tbj hvvimehtmao ac tbj vjohitmju cazod mo >3 Z/U/E/ 4=26D # 4=26B

hod >= Z/U/E/ 885>) hod ho} djtj~`mohtmao tbht tbj ~jxzm~j`jotu h~j hvvimehnij ta Vihmotmccu/

Vz~uzhot ta Cjd/ ^/ Ems/ V/ ^zij 3:"e-) Vihmotmccu ubhii vaut h $866/66 naod hu ujez~mt} ca~

ho} eautu hod dh`hgju tbht `h} nj uzuthmojd n} Djcjodhotu mo tbj jsjot tbj} bhsj njjo

w~aogczii} jokamojd a~ ~jut~hmojd/

Uzeb mokzoetmao ubhii jrvm~j tb~jj `aotbu c~a` jot~} ac ho a~dj~ ao tbj `j~mtu ac

Vihmotmccu ebhiijogj/ Mo a~dj~ ta jrvjdmtj tbj ~juaiztmao ac tbmu ehuj) tbj vh~tmju ubhii cmij h Kamot

Ehuj @hohgj`jot Viho ao a~ njca~j Hzgzut >7) >68>/

Hod) cmohii}) M thlj tbmu avva~tzomt} ta j`vbhum{j tbj hd bae ohtz~j ac tbmu mokzoetmao/

Tbj gasj~o`jotu h~gz`jotu h~j ih~gji} v~j`mujd zvao h cjh~ tbht g~hotmog ho jrj`vtmao ta

Vihmotmccu wmii ojejuuh~mi} ~jxzm~j g~hotmog um`mih~ mokzoetmao ta hii atbj~ ca~v~acmt) ujezih~

ea~va~htmaou samemog ~jimgmazu ankjetmaou ta tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj/ Tbmu

mokzoetmao mu) bawjsj~) v~j`mujd zvao tbj hiijgjd uznuthotmhi nz~djo ao Vihmotmccu c~jj jrj~emuj

ac ~jimgmao oat ta ho} hiijgjd nz~djo ao ho} atbj~ vh~t}u c~jj jrj~emuj ac ~jimgmao/ Mt daju oat

jokamo joca~ej`jot ac tbj v~jsjotmsj eh~j easj~hgj `hodhtj hghmout ho} atbj~ vh~t}/

Dhtjd; Kzi} >7) >68> N] TBJ EAZ^T;

!u! Kabo I/ Lhoj

Ujoma~ Z/U/ Dmut~met Eaz~t Kzdgj


-8


19/19

Oatju

Hooathtmaou e~jhtjd zumog mHooathtj ao tbj mVhd/ N~hoebcm~j www/n~hoebcm~j/ea`

Vmj~ej tbj sjmi hod dmu~jgh~d ea~va~htj eaotjrt1

Ea~va~htmaou h~j vjavij(

8>->

^C^H ~jxzm~ju tbht tbj~j nj h ea`vjiimog gast motj~jut mo nz~djomog tbj uvjemcme vj~uao ea`vihmomog hnazt tbj eaot~hejvtmao

`hodhtj

85-5

Gasj~o`jot njmog vjohim{jd ca~ ea`v~a`mumog wmtb ~jimgmazu moutmtztmaou/ Vj~bhvu tbj gasj~o`jot ubazid ut~mlj dawo tbj

g~hodchtbj~ v~asmumaou18:-8

Nzt ~jimgmazu thrvh}j~u wmii utmii nj vh}mog/ Wbht'u tbj dmccj~joej18:-4

Wbht hnazt vaimtmehi anutheiju1 Tbht wmii ojsj~ bhvvjo/87->

Tbmu mu hnuz~d/82-8
http://www.branchfire.com/

ABL Mark-Up of Newland Hercules Industries v Sebelius [Preliminary Injunction Order]

Documents

Transcript of ABL Mark-Up of Newland Hercules Industries v Sebelius [Preliminary Injunction Order]