Cultural Spaces for New Audiences Amy Kaufman, Lord Cultural Resources.
Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
Transcript of Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
1/49
AB314 CULTURAL STUDIES 3
SEMESTER 2: COURSEWORK 2
WHAT MAKES A GOOD PUBLIC SPACE?
Before I come into facts and arguments about what exactly has made some of the public
spaces in Rome amazing and astoundingly breathtaking, lets firstly make clarity of the
title on what does it mean by good on its own? The word good can be define in a
variety of meaning, depending on ones opinion but here let me clear it up with the
dictionary. Good here comes to term with to be desired or approved of, having the
required qualities; of a high standard, giving pleasure; enjoyable or satisfying. (Oxford
dictionary, 2011).On the other hand, Public space here means B:AH B:LAH BLAH.
Thats one definition
Pertaining to the definitions given, of what I have closely come to understand and know
how a public space is good and enjoyable, that would be of Buchanan Street on its own.
There are two places that I was very excited to see, not just because of the fame,
But it has been highly regarded as places you must see if you are in ROME, and in as well
as places to be before you die.
The Piazza is just lapping in all the delicious beauty. For me in first glance it was not
what I had in mind: Huge space, Should have a rather grand entrance into it, but as I
emerge closer to the centre of the piazza, sitting down at a bench nearing one of the
fountain that was called the fountains of four gods, I began to feel the sparkling majesty
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
2/49
of the place . with its explosion of joyous curves. It wasnt just the fountains that made
the place alive; there were little happenings around the square that adds flavor into the
cornucopia of excitement. As I was sitting there wondering why there is so much
commodity about being here, trying to see exactly what makes this place the place to be?
There were people walking in and out of the place via corners of the piazza, there were
7 accesses in and out of the piazza. One can find tourists, intellectuals, kids playing,
freaks and elegant signori, painters and artists selling their works right in the square.
This Piazza has been a circus for nineteen centuries and, as a pedestrian island filled
with churning crowds licking their ice cream cones and having their caricatures sketched;
it continues the "Roman Holiday".
Much of what is seen today in the Piazza Navona is a result of one family: the Pamphilis.
In the 1600s, the Pamphili family gave Piazza Navona a major remodel.
-
Piazza Navona
History:
FIRST READING
Designed for the athletic contest of the nude Greek contest, the stadium was
inaugurated by the emperor Domitian, sometimes before AD 86, when the first game of
the new games in honor of Jupiter capitolinus. The Piazza Navona square was built
exactly on the area of emperor Domitians stadium (81-96 AD), and retains the
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
3/49
stadiums oblong shape with a rounded north end. It was the largest in ancient Rome,
larger than the Coliseum, and could seat 50,000 spectators.
The name of the stadium was Circus Agonalis (competition arena), which became
corrupted to nAgona, and eventually Navona. Thanks to hydraulic engineering,
naval battles engaging up to 3,000 antagonists were performed (they were called
naumachiae).The stadium later became a baroque jewel, with masterpieces of Bernini
(the Fountain of the Four Rivers and the Fountain of the Moor), Calderari (the Fountain
of Neptune) and Borromini (the Church of SantAgnese in Agone).
Ruins of the ancient stadium can still be seen under the palaces (please see the bottom
photo). Today the Piazza strikes visitors for its harmony and colours, combined with its
elegance and charm. Varied people stroll or attend the piazza. One can find tourists,
intellectuals, kids playing, freaks and elegant signori, painters and artists selling their
works right in the square.
The kaleidoscopic, lively, cosmopolitan atmosphere blending history, art, and love for
life, i.e. the peculiar Roman character, reaches possibly its highest level, making the
Eternal City such a magical place.
Piazza Navona has been for long used as a place for meeting and processions. During
daytime life seems to be revolving around the open-air cafes, and around the artists
stands (you can have your caricature or painting at a modest cost). Like all Romes
squares and streets, the piazza changes aspect at night, when the atmosphere becomes
imaginative, people seem to be mesmerized, and enjoying themselves more than
daytime.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
4/49
In December, until Epiphany, a season market is held. Traditionally, parents come here
to buy toys for their children.
Of the 3 fountains of the Piazza, fed by the Aqua Virgo aqueduct, the most renowned is
the Fontana dei Quattro Fiumi (Fountain of Four Rivers 1651 AD), by a mature
Bernini, following the decision of Pope Innocent X.
An obelisk from the Circus Maxentius was erected over a rocky grotto, from which a lion
and a horse emerge.
The obelisk appears to be resting on an open cavity. The large figures represent the
main rivers of the four continents known at that time: the Danube, the River Plate, the
Ganges, and the Nile (with a veiled head to indicate that its source was still unknown at
that time). The church of SantAgnese in Agone (1652 1670) according to tradition,
stands on the site of prostitution where St. Agnes, stripped naked, was saved by
dishonour by the miraculous growth of hair. Many architects worked on it (Rainaldi,
who gave it the Greek cross design, Borromini, Bernini, Pietro da Cortona), although the
concave facade, the dome, and the two belfries all having dynamic unity are primarily
the work of Borromini.
http://www.piazzanavona-rome.com/2008/06/20/history-piazza-navona-navona-
square/
Second reading
Piazza Navona
Little is square about this beautiful square-with its
explosion of joyous curves. And little is otherworldly
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
5/49
about this Papal creation. Sensuous Piazza Navona typifies Baroque Rome, with
masterpieces by Bernini and Borromini. And like all the great Italian Piazzas, it has
served for centuries as a glorious outdoor theater for enjoying the drama and the
comedy of life.
Typically Roman is the super-position of a Baroque pleasure area exactly over an ancient
Roman monument. The 17th Century Pope, like the 1st Century Emperor, created a
place of private glory as well as mob entertainment. This Piazza has been a circus for
nineteen centuries and, as a pedestrian island filled with churning crowds licking their
ice cream cones and having their caricatures sketched; it continues the "Roman
Holiday".
The name Navona is a Medieval corruption of the Latin word for gymnastic contest:
"agon "which also explains why the great Baroque church in this Piazza is called St.
Agnese in Agone. If you walk out of the single exit at the North (curved) end of the
piazza, and turn left, you will soon see on your left a glass-enclosed section of Emperor
Domitian's original stadium (16, Piazza Tor Sanguina), and notice how much lower the
ground level was in those days.
In the 17C Queen Christina of Sweden, after abdicating and becoming a Catholic (but
certainly not a nun), paraded around this piazza in a highly ornate carriage - of the kind
you can see in paintings at the Museum of Rome in the adjacent Palazzo Braschi.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
6/49
In its earliest days, the arena could be flooded for staging mock sea battles. And a
century ago it would still be covered with water in August so that the ornate carriages of
the great papal families could circle around, providing a cool respite for Roman nobles
and prelates who had not escaped to their country villas.
Nowadays, the Christmas season transforms this piazza into a rowdy marketplace, filled
with booths, including shooting galleries and shops selling figurines for Nativity Scenes:
miniature mangers with donkeys, babes and Wiseman.
Piazza Navona
History
86 AD. Emperor Domitian built a long U-shaped stadium here; an arena for athletic
contests, surrounded by a 15,000-seat stone grandstand, in a sparsely inhabited
suburb of Rome called Campus Martius.
Middle Ages. The stadium, some of whose arcades had become brothels, was
adjacent to the route successive Popes took when traveling from their residence in
the Lateran Palace to St. Peter's, Christendom's most important church. The original
seats remained in use till the 15th Century, when sport-loving Romans came to watch
jousts between brightly caparisoned knights.
1644. This was the site of a small building owned by the Pamphili family when one of
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
7/49
its sons became Pope Innocent X. Self-glorification inspired him to transform the
stadium into a beautiful square dominated by three Baroque masterpieces: Bernini's
most glorious Four Rivers Fountain in the center, the highly original Sant'Agnese in
Agone church he commissioned Borromini to complete as a family chapel, and the
vast new Palazzo Pamphili where he installed his lady friend and sister-in-law.
Fontana dei Quattro Fiumi
(Fountain of the Four Rivers). Along with the Trevi Fountain,
this is one of Rome's most glorious designs for decorating the
piazzas with the sprinkle and tinkle of water.
Here Bernini built up a sculptural wonderland of gigantic figures in the diverse
environments of four of the world's great rivers, and topped it with an Egyptian obelisk.
Notice that directly under the figures is an empty grotto, a mannerist architectural trick,
which makes the enormously heavy obelisk appear to be floating in air.
The Nile, the Danube, the Ganges and the Plate represent the four corners of the world.
The immense cost of this complicated design, involving four other sculptors who did the
individual river gods, (Claude Poussin sculpted Ganges) prompted Innocent X to levy a
tax on bread; so, for the rest of his life he was reviled with slogans and street signs
attacking him and Olympia (whose name was distorted into "Olim Pia" the slang
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
8/49
equivalent of "she was virtuous").
In 1651 Pope Innocent X held a contest to choose the sculptor who should crown his
great piazza with a central monument. Originally, a much less elaborate fountain was to
be created by the Pope's protg, Borromini. But his arch-rival Bernini managed to steal
the commission away, by getting Innocent X's not-so-innocent favorite and sister-in-law,
Olympia Maidalchini, to dangle a solid silver model of this fountain before the eyes of
the Pope - and then give it to him.
Fontana del Moro
(Fountain of The Moor) At the South end of the Piazza, opposite Palazzo Pamphili,
Bernini added (1653) the central figure of an African cuddling a dolphin to the 1575
fountain designed by Giacomo Della Porta.
Bernini was an indefatigable designer who usually had his sketches realized by
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
9/49
assistants. At the North end of the Piazza, the third fountain was redesigned in the 19C
to match the Moro Fountain.
St. Agnese in Agone
Look carefully at the front of this church to appreciate Borromini's inventive use of
rippling in-and-out curves that give depth to the thin facade he transformed (1657) into
a grandiose Papal monument.
Borromini's plans always call for sober, basically white interiors, so you will be surprised
by the somewhat overpowering richness you find inside. Bernini's use of warm-colored
marble predominates, and he ordered the frescoes in the dome (1670-90, Ciro Ferri)
and pendentives (1662-72, Baciccio).
The church's monumentality is Borromini's, its flamboyancy Bernini's. The square just
lapping in all the delicious beauty.
St. Agnese in Agone
History
304 AD. Wellborn 13-year old Agnes was made to
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
10/49
strip for the clients of a whorehouse near Domitian's Arena. Thanks to her faith in
Christ, Agnes' hair immediately grew long enough to hide her embarrassment. When
attempts to torch her body failed, she was stabbed to death. The Church later
rewarded her piety with canonization (see also St. Agnese Fuori le Mura).
1652. Pope Innocent X Pamphili commissioned Girolamo Rainaldi and his son Carlo to
make him a glorified family chapel incorporating St. Agnes' much revered shrine.
Perhaps he thought little Agnes' innocence would also cover up the reputation of his
favorite, Olympia Maidalchini.
1653. Innocent replaced the Rainaldis with Borromini, who pulled down their front
wall and designed the complex plasticity you see in the facade. He also lightened the
cramped interior.
1657. A commission including Bernini took over, but did not modify the unity of
Borromini's masterpiece except by gilding and sculpting and using colored marble.
Piazza Navona (Map F 5)
http://web.tiscalinet.it/romaonlineguide/Pages/eng/rbarocca/sBMy4.htm
3rd
reading
Piazza Navona and Bernini's Four Rivers Fountain
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
11/49
Nina Miller
Honors in Rome - Summer 2005
I. Introduction
Piazza Navona has been Romes most popular secular assembly space for generations. It
is built on the spot of Emperor Domitians stadium that was constructed in 86 A.D. Over
the years, the long, nearly oval piazza has been the site of diversions of all kinds from
mock sea battles to medieval jousts. From 1477 to 1869, the piazza was used as a
marketplace, and from the 1600s to as recent as the 1800s, it was flooded every
weekend in August for the entertainment of the Roman citizens. Much of what is seen
today in the Piazza Navona is a result of one family: the Pamphilis. In the 1600s, the
Pamphili family gave Piazza Navona a major remodel.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
12/49
The Pamphili family had been a presence in Rome for a long time. They moved to Rome
from Gubbio in the 1400s. Over the years, family members had begun to buy property in
the area surrounding the Piazza Navona. In autumn of 1644, the nephew and sister-in-
law of Cardinal Giambattisa Pamphili (who would later become Pope Innocent X) bought
land next to the cardinals house with the idea of combining their properties into one
large palace that fronted the Piazza Navona. They felt that this would be the perfect
showcase to house one of the leading families in Rome in what was then the largest
civic space in the city.
As the Palazzo Pamphili began to take shape, Pope Innocent realized that the character
of the Piazza was changing. It was no longer merely a market and gathering place, but
rather one of the citys most important squares and home to the first family of Rome. As
the buildings around the piazza were being built and refurbished, it became clear that a
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
13/49
single unifying focal point was needed. Innocent decided upon incorporating an ancient
obelisk that had just been found at the Circus of Maxentius into a fountain to serve as
the centerpiece of his piazza. Now all that was needed was someone to design the
fountain.
Gianlorenzo Bernini was one of the most well-known, talented sculptors of the time.
One might assume, therefore, that he would have been the obvious first choice to
design such a grand piece of art. As it turns out, however, this was not the case. During
the reign of Innocents predecessor, Urban XIII, Bernini enjoyed the position of the
popes preferred architect. He lost this position, however, when Innocent became pope.
Urban XIII led an unpopular regime and spent a lot of the churchs money on personal
items and family expenses. Because of this, Innocent decided that he did not want
anything to do with Urban, including, therefore, Bernini. Fortunately, however, the
fountain that stands today is indeed Berninis work; thus it can be assumed that he
found a way around Innocents initial exclusion.
History tells two stories of how Bernini accomplished winning the commission for the
Four Rivers Fountain. In one story, the popes nephew encouraged Bernini to create a
model. He then placed Berninis model strategically in the Pamphili Palace so that the
pope would have to walk around it. After seeing the model, Innocent was completely
won over and claimed, If one does not want to carry out [Berninis] designs, one must
not see them. In a second story, it is said that while other sculptors were making
models out of clay and wax, Bernini made his out of silver. He then presented this model
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
14/49
to the popes sister-in-law, Donna Olimpia, who was amply impressed and managed to
persuade the pope to accept Berninis design. In either case, what is known for sure is
that Bernini got the commission and created what stands today as a masterful work of
art.
II. Description
The basic design of the fountain is a travertine rock surrounded by four river gods,
topped with a large Egyptian obelisk. The four river gods represent the four major
continents of the world, as they were known in the 1600s. One surprising element of
this fountain is the posture of the river gods. Traditionally, river gods were depicted in a
lounging-position; they were hardly ever seen doing anything. In Berninis fountain,
however, their twists, turns, and muscular contractions simulate the motions of the
rivers they personify.
The river god on the northwest corner of the fountain is
for the Rio de la Plata and represents the Americas. A bag of coins spilling out under the
gods feet symbolizes the riches of the New World. The river god is depicted as a black
man, which reflects the fact that, at the time, very little was known about the Americas.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
15/49
To the left of the Rio de la Plata god is the god of the
Danube River representing Europe. This statue has one of the most energetic poses of
all the river gods. His body is twisted to the right and his arms are stretched out in order
to support the large papal coat of arms at the base of the obelisk. Between the Danube
and Rio de la Plata gods is a large horse. The horse was known to be native to both
Europe and the Americas, thus representing a connection between the two continents.
The Ganges River, representing Asia, is seen on the other side of the Danube. This river
god straddles an oar to represent the navigability of the river through India.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
16/49
On the other side of this god is the god of the Nile River representing the fourth
continent known at the time, Africa. The face of this god is covered with a cloth to
symbolize the fact that the source of the Nile was unknown at the time the fountain was
made. In between the Nile and Ganges gods is a lion and palm tree, known to be native
to both Asia and Africa. The lion crouches down toward the water ready to drink, and
the palm tree sways in the wind. The four gods are situated around a large travertine
rock that serves as the base of the obelisk.
The travertine rock was carved to look like the quarry that the stone for the obelisk
came from. In order to make the fountain more dramatic and astonish viewers to this
day, Bernini carved out the center of the travertine so that a space through both sides of
the base is open. The obelisk that rests on top of the travertine base was carved in Egypt
and brought to Rome by Emperor Domitian. Domitian had a stonesman carve
hieroglyphics that refer to Domian as Eternal pharaoh and Vespasian and Titus as gods.
Resting on top of the obelisk is a dove, representative of both the Pamphili family and
also the Holy Spirit.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
17/49
III. Function
The Four Rivers Fountain has an amazing ability to manipulate its viewers movement.
Its massive size demands the attention of any visitor coming to the Piazza Navona. Once
the viewer is drawn in, the fountain then seems to draw the viewer in a circular motion.
There is not one single position that offers a satisfactory view of the entire fountain. In
order to see all four river gods, or to find the front of the lion whose rear can be seen on
one side, an onlooker must continue moving around the fountain. The idea of a circular
motion is especially fitting for the position of the Four Rivers Fountain. It is placed in the
center of an oval piazza; thus, by circling the fountain, one in turn ends up circling the
entire piazza.
The movement of the viewer is not the only effect this fountain imposes on its visitors.
Bernini carved the base of the fountain such that one is left to wonder how the giant
obelisk is supported at all. He hollowed out the travertine base so that you can actually
see through the sculpture from one side to the other. The sense of disbelief that this
wonder inflicts adds to the dramatic effect of the fountain. At the time the fountain was
complete, many contemporary critics insisted that the base was not stable enough to
support the obelisk and thought that it would come toppling down at any moment.
Bernini decided to face his critics head-on in order to stop their disapproval once and for
all. He came to the Piazza Navona a couple days after a large storm in which everyone
was sure the obelisk would fall and pretended to make an hour-long inspection of the
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
18/49
fountain. After this inspection, Bernini took four strings that were nailed to the tops of
buildings around the piazza and tied them to the top of the obelisk, and then, with a
look of satisfaction, drove off in his carriage.
IV. Patron
As noted earlier, Pope Innocent commissioned the Four Rivers Fountain as a way to add
a unifying focal point to the middle of his piazza. The significance of the fountain goes
far beyond a simple piece of aesthetic decoration, however. Innocent was deliberate in
his rejection of his predecessors regime. He wanted nothing to do with Urban XIII, and
he used this fountain as one way of showing that. The aqueduct that feeds the fountains
of the Piazza Navona also goes on to feed the Trevi Fountain -- a fountain that Urban XIII
championed during his reign. Innocent, therefore, decided to divert the water away
from the Trevi Fountain to be used in his own piazza. The Four Rivers Fountain served as
a perfect outlet for such a diversion of water.
The symbolism behind the fountain also served as a propagandistic tool for Pope
Innocent. In a single piece of art, the four continents of the world were united under
one giant obelisk. In essence, Pope Innocent was bringing the whole world to the center
of his piazza and topping it with an obelisk that carried his family emblem, the dove. The
dove also symbolizes the Holy Spirit, so its presence on top of the obelisk additionally
serves to exorcise the pagan implication of the obelisk and place Christianity above all.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
19/49
The message transmitted by this fountain is one of power and triumph of the church
under Pope Innocent.
The idea of triumph was a particularly important message to be sent. At the time this
fountain was being made, there was a widespread feeling of defeatism throughout the
Catholic community. During the Thirty Years War that ended in 1648 there was a series
of religious and territorial battles between Protestants and Catholics. The treaty that put
an end to this war demanded that the Catholic Church sacrifice important bishoprics in
the north in order to keep Austria and Bohemia under its control. This sacrifice was seen
as a major loss to the Church and left an air of defeatism over the Catholic community.
Innocents fountain helped to improve the image of strength of the Church and papacy.
V. Personal Observations
In researching the Piazza Navona and Four Rivers Fountain, I was especially interested in
both the sheer skill of Bernini and also the amount of symbolism that was worked into
the fountain. When I walked up to the fountain for the first time, I was struck with awe
and admiration. Life-like movement was extracted from the marble and captured in
nearly every element of the fountain. The lion crouched in a position about to drink
water while the Ganges River God straddled an oar between his hands. All four river
gods were frozen in very energetic poses adding an element of life to the fountain. The
talent required to design and create such a work of art is beyond my understanding.
Bernini carved the finishing touches on the travertine base, the lion, horse, and palm
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
20/49
tree on site. This is an amazing feat considering the cramped, constricted space he had
to work in.
The most enjoyable aspect of researching the Four Rivers Fountain was discovering the
symbolism behind each figure carved on the fountain. From the covered Nile River
Gods head to the lion and palm tree, every aspect of the fountain had a meaning
behind it. To see the fountain as more than just aesthetically pleasing decoration and to
know its symbols, meanings, and intentions proved to be the most rewarding part of my
studies.
VI. Bibliography
Angelini, Alessandro. Bernini. Milano: Jaca book, 1999.
Briggs, Martin S. The Genius of Bernini. The Burlington Magazine for Connoisseurs
26.143 (1915). http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0951-
0788%28191502%2926%3C197%3ATGOB%3E2.0.CO%3B2-4
Fehrenbach, Frank. Berninis Light. Art History 28.1 (2005): 17-20.
Marder, T.A. Bernini and the Art of Architecture. New York: Abbeville Press, 1998.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
21/49
Morrissey, Jake. The Genius in the Design: Bernini, Borromini, and the rivalry that
transformed Rome. New York: William Morrow, 2005.
Petersson, Robert. Bernini and the Excesses of Art. Florence, Italy: M & M, Maschietto &
Ditore, 2002.
Wittkower, Rudolf. Bernini: the sculptor of the Roman Baroque. London: Phaidon Press,
1997.
http://honorsaharchive.blogspot.com/2005/09/ppiazza-navona-and-berninis-four-
rivers.html
4th
the fourth reading:
"Piazza" can be translated to mean public square. But the piazzas of Rome are unique
from other famous cities because they are genuine places for lovers of outdoor art to
gather and enjoy such beauty together.
There is no better place to admire the fountain work of the famous artist Bernini than
at the Piazza Navona, where the Fontana dei Fiumi or the "Fountain of the Four Rivers"
was built in 1651. Here in the public square Bernini's students executed four immense
sculptures around an artistic obelisk sitting on top of a central rocky pedestal. One of
those students was Claude Poussin who executed "the Ganges" as part of this fountain
and who later went on to fame and renown himself.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
22/49
The Fountain of the Four Rivers is a classic Roman fountain that seems alive with a rich
diversity of life from a cactus to palm trees to sea monsters and dozens of wonderful
pieces all mixed together artfully around the unifying column in the middle.
The story goes that to rise the funds for this expensive fountain, taxes were actually
placed on bread which infuriated the citizens of Rome, from the poorest to the
wealthiest. That bit of history now is a fun part of the background of the fountain to
discuss over a relaxing cup of coffee as you watch the busy city go by.
Just across the piazza is another magnificent fountain that has the sea god Triton riding
a dolphin as its centerpiece. The "Fountain of the Moor" is a great place to relax and
take in the activity in the public square, catch some warm sun on your face or discuss
with your travel mates what site to see next in the Piazza Navona. The piazza is full of
things to see, do and taste that will enhance your experience just as much as the
wonderful and artistic fountains outdoors.
Along the rows of cafe's, restaurants and shops in the piazza, you will find dozens of
stalls where merchants offer their wares and services. Here you can stop and have your
portrait skilfully sketched by the many artists who populate this public gathering place.
There is plenty to do in the piazza once the sun goes down. The nightlife is active with
tourists mingling with natives, beggars, mimes and artists all milling around in the
crowded oval piazza. This active public space was built on an ancient circus, which was
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
23/49
not a place where trapeze artists and elephants performed. Rather it is a circular public
area where many streets come to a common intersection.
postscript to our post on the sewer zeppelins and artificial lakes of Rome.
*
Every weekend during the sweltering month of August, from 1652 until 1866, the drains
of the Fontana dei Quattro Fiumi were blocked so that the waters would overflow and
flood much of Piazza Navona, a sort of aqueous reincarnation of thenaumachiae, or
mock naval battles, that were once staged on the same site more than a thousand years
ago. Or perhaps this aberrant hydrology was an attempt to mimic the floodplains of the
real Quattro Fiumi. It could even be described as the temporary, theatrical reemergence
of the marshy landscape on which the Eternal City was built.
In any case, it was one of the most popular midsummer festivals in Rome, the merriest
of them all, according to the poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. Members of the
nobility and gentry came in droves in their carriages. Watched by gazers crowding the
shores of this artificial lake or looking out from the windows of the palaces
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
24/49
surrounding the piazza, princes and nobles would parade side by side with peasants
and farmers around and around the water's shallow periphery or crisscross across
deeper parts. It probably didn't take long until the water became just a dirty puddle,
but one could still churn up microgusts of cooling breezes. On the dry portions of the
piazza, entertainments were set up, as well as booths for refreshments.
This urban hydro-spectacle would go on all day, until sunset, sometimes even into the
night. Then the piazza was drained, and the water once again contained in its Baroque
basin.
Experiences:
Its an ocher coloured gem, unspoiled by the new buildings nor the traffic. Four fountains,
plenty of perimeter cafe seating, no car in sight, complete enclosure, a slight slope north
to south, not one tree, a lively ring of facades, and plenty of surrounding pedestrian
friendly lanes and alleys. Stone paved, perfect for mimes, sword swallowers and artists
to strut their stuff. Good late PM shade. Feels like a big room. (Tom Paine, Wellesley MA)
dodging street vendors selling strange blinking toys, slow-moving packs of tourists, and
the restaurateurs who can tell in an instant that Im a foreignerGood evening, Miss.
Full Meal, fifteen eurosNo thanks.
Piazza Navonaholds one of the finest examples ofBerninis fountain work: the Fontana
dei Quattro Fiumi(Fountain of the Four Rivers), built in 1651 .
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
25/49
The four gods on the corners of the fountain represent the four major rivers of the
world known at the time as the Danube, the Ganges, the Nile and the River Plate.
Arranged around the central rocky mass supporting the almost-obligatoryobelisk are
four large sculptures executed by his students. One of them, the Ganges, was sculpted
by Claude Poussin who would later become a master under his own name.
The fountain is a tour de force with a sea monster, a lion, cacti, palm tree and a dozen
other pieces woven together around the central column. The funding was so large for
the piece that taxes were levied on bread, prompting outcries from Roman citizens both
poor and rich. But with the controversy now a part of history, visitors like us can simply
enjoy it for its beauty and artistic merits.
The Fountain of the Moor, at the other end of Piazza Navona, features a Triton - one of
the many gods of the sea riding a dolphin. From this vantage point, there is ample
opportunity for people watching, enjoying the warm Roman sunshine or planning your
next stop around the Piazza Navona and its environs.
As a newly minted Roman, Ive already traversed Piazza Navona more times than I can
count. My trips around the city are like small orbits around and through this piazza,
since most major sites,popular restaurants and nightlife spots are at most a fifteen-
minute walk. Many times, I rush past the piazza,
There are dozens of merchant stalls, interspersed among the many cafes and
restaurants. You could stop near one and have your portrait sketched by one of the
numerous artists dotting the piazza. They may not be grandmasters, but some of them
are really talented.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
26/49
The Fontana dei Calderai (Fountain of the Coppersmiths), later renamed the Fountain
of Neptune is also here. Decorated with sea figures, Neptune slaying an octopus, sea
horses, dolphins and Nerieds (sea nymphs) it carries Romes fountain-sea creature
theme to the ultimate peak. The fountain is made of the same Portasanta rose marble
used for St. Peters doorjambs.
ANOTHER:
The Church ofSantAgnese in Agone is one of the grandest structures on the piazza.
According to religious traditions, it stands on the site of the beheading of St. Agnes, a
young virgin persecuted by rebuffed suitors. The church now houses her severed skull,
called theSacra Testa (holy head), in its sacristy. I recommend to all to check out the
interior of the Church, as well as its headlining (and somewhat bafflinggo visit and
youll understand why) relic.
Of course, Piazza Navonas centerpiece, BerninisFontana dei Quattro Fiume (Fountain
of the Four Rivers), never fails to dazzle visitors with its strange combination of styles
faux ancient Egyptian obelisk and neoclassical sculptureand charactersfour
contorted behemoths plus some animals and an imagined armadillo. I can say that there
is nothing quite like standing besides the Fontana dei Quattro Fiume late at night, in
the rare moment when the Piazza is empty and silent, and watching the bright blue
reflections of water dancing across the bodies of the river gods.
A THEORY
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
27/49
y a supposition or a system of ideas intended to explain something, especially one
based on general principles independent of the thing to be explained:Darwin's theory of
evolution
y a set of principles on which the practice of an activity is based: a theory of
education[mass noun] :music theory
y an idea used to account for a situation or justify a course of action: my theory
would be that the place has been seriously mismanaged
After walking through cramped, narrow streets in Romes center, Piazza Navona is a
revelation. The visitors gaze is forced up from the cobblestones and out across the
grand piazza. Before them, a vast expanse of open space, lined with Baroque facades
and dotted with iconic fountains, pulsates with life at all hours of the day and night. In
fact, since its creation, Piazza Navona has been a hub of spectacle. In ancient times, it
was a circus in the literal sense. These days, its a spectacle of Roman city life, of art, of
commerce, and of socializing.
SO WHAT MAKES IT SUCCESFUL?
1`.Access & Linkages
2. (Monumentality, Centrality and the Articulation of Places and Flows in the
Informational City)
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
28/49
3. The Localisation ofFlows
4.Comfort & Image
5. Virtual Cities
6. Uses & Activities
7. VI. The New Urban Signification
8. The Dissociation between Space of Identity and Functional Space
9. ( the new urban signification)
Public space in the information society
Manuel Castells, 1994
[Ingls] [Castellano]
Published in Ciutat real, ciutat ideal: significat i funci a l'espai urb modern. Barcelona:
Centre de Cultura Contempornia de Barcelona, 1998 (Urbanitats; 7)
I. Spatial Change, Historical Change and Cultural Identity
The transformation of time and space is the material expression of historical structural
change. In this sense, the information society is no exception. The information
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
29/49
technology revolution, consolidated in the 1970s and disseminated throughout the
planet in every sphere of activity over the last two decades of the past millennium, has
involved and accompanied far-reaching changes in spatial processes and forms.
However, these changes do not confirm the prophecies of futurologists, or simplistic
extrapolations from the characteristics of technology. In particular, the prediction that
cities could disappear because of the spatial diffusion brought about by
telecommunications has been refuted by empirical observation.
The city is not disappearing and far from it. I insist on this point because of the media
impact of such books as the recent The Death of Distance. According to this ideology, it
is not only the death of distance we are faced with, but of everything with any kind of
spatial specificity because we are now inhabiting a computerised universe and are living
within an organisation of networks that are linked by telecommunication. This was also
essentially the idea of Marshall McLuhan, the concept of the global village, where all
culture is encompassed within a system of communication that goes beyond local
specificities, particularities, identities, and so on. It is verging on the idea of a world
government in which everything disappears for we are all brothers and sisters and, from
now on, cultures will melt together into some kind of undifferentiated universe. This is a
deep-rooted idea that has its present technological expression firmly entrenched in the
old rationalist tradition, both liberal and enlightenment (citizens of the world), and
Marxist (proletarians of the world). In other words, it is the idea of classes, and on the
basis of classes, a view of humanity as an undifferentiated mass. The essential idea of
rationalism, both liberal and Marxist, is to supersede cultures and therefore places. The
present technological instrument seems to enable the realisation of this prophecy as the
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
30/49
selfsame instrument that is at last able to free capitalism (and indeed it does) from its
institutional ties and the different forms of state control. However, cultures, places and
spaces, are much more resistant, and have much more density so are thus not so easily
abolished. Indeed, they are more and more organised. It can be demonstrated
empirically that people's experience is increasingly local. The mechanisms of political
and social control are also increasingly local. In the book that Jordi Borja and I have just
published, Local y global (Local and Global, Taurus, 1997), we emphasise this, stressing
that the global does not do away with the local but, on the contrary, creates the
possibility for a much more active, much more decisive role for what is local. In strictly
cultural terms the local, and places, are increasingly becoming the last ditches of
identity. With the general dissolving of identities in the instrumental world of the space
of flows (see my book, La sociedad red (The Network Society) Alianza Editorial, 1997),
the space of places is taking shape as an expression of identity, of what I am, of what I
experience, of what I know, and of how I organise my life around it.
II. The Dissociation between Space of Identity and Functional Space
The public re-launching of working-class residential spaces in many parts of the world,
but very specifically in Barcelona, is contributing to this idea of consolidating the identity
of what is local, and the identity of cultural expression. Yet there is a problem, which is
that if we limit ourselves to this verification, which is the importance of the local, the
importance of place, the identity of places, and if besides we reinforce, as we should,
the expression of these identities through urban planning operations that highlight the
significance of residential spaces, including working-class areas, what can appear, and
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
31/49
what is appearing, is the danger of an increasing dissociation between the space of
instrumentality and the space of identity. On the one hand is the space of a global,
cosmopolitan culture and, on the other, the space of what is local as a space that is so
dominated that it essentially becomes the space of the neighbourhood's identity, of the
identity of a specific place and it therefore not only loses its connection with the
instrumental space, but also communication between each of the identities. If each
identity becomes specific and the bridges of connection go through an instrumentality
that is global and cut off from what is expressive, we will then have at once a world of
global instruments with an ahistorical cosmopolitan culture and a fragmentation into
local tribes. From this we may deduce the importance of two old issues of urban
planning: monumentality and centrality. Monumentality, with its capacity for emitting a
generalising symbolic message, establishes, or can establish, a symbolic bridge of
meaning between different localities and between the localities and the instruments of
power with which they must coexist, negotiate, interact and struggle. Struggling is a
relation. The danger today is not conflict (which is socially healthy and aesthetically
creative), but the separation between the local and the global, creating thus the
possibility of constructing global instruments that are disconnected from local societies.
With the significant dissociation of monumentality, re-edification of urban centrality is
being considered. Centrality, from the urban planning perspective, does not mean being
a single centre: it can be multinuclear. This then raises the idea that the city is not just a
few central symbolic elements, to which are added residential spaces that become
significant, but rather that centrality means the diffusion of this monumentality into
different centres that would articulate meaning and function in the territory as a whole.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
32/49
III. Monumentality, Centrality and the Articulation of Places and Flows in the
Informational City
So, what elements, what attempts of articulation are occurring between the space of
places and the space of flows as an attempt to create systems of communication? I
would say that there are two observable kinds of attempts, one that is more incipient
and more exotic, on the basis of the space of flows, while the other is more traditional,
more diversified, more complex, on the basis of the space of places.
Starting out from the space of flows, there are attempts being made to create a public
cyberspace. These efforts are much more developed than what people usually believe
and, in particular, they have enormous potential in terms of their future manifestations.
Now, in 1997, there are 2,000 virtual cities, where what we understand by "virtual
cities" (a somewhat grandiose term) is urban pages on the worldwide web, on internet,
more or less permanent urban pages. Great efforts are being made by thinkers and
analysts, including urban planners, in the face of the loss of public space and the decline
or urban culture, to look at cyberspace as a new form of public space in which people
can meet up again in the electronic agora. I refer, for example, to Michael Benedict, or
to the ideas of Howard Rheingold in The Virtual Community, where cyberspace is seen
as a new space of sociability. Then, on the one hand, we would have the instrumental
space of flows while, on the other, would be the almost undifferentiated space of
individual habitat with some places to go out to eat from time to time, while the space
of real sociability, beyond the dangers posed by the city, would be the electronic agora.
This could have more success than we think here in Barcelona because not all spaces
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
33/49
have the power and constitution of Barcelona. If we are thinking, for example, about the
mega-cities of Asia where there are small centres and then enormous constellations of
totally poor and run-down, densely-populated neighbourhoods, the idea that
reconstructing a virtual space instead of constructing physical spaces, apart from the
enormous interest this might have from the standpoint of the electronics industry, is
one that is sufficiently attractive for people who like to apply technological solutions to
social problems.
IV. Virtual Cities
Let us look, in some detail, at two examples of virtual cities because I believe that this is
a matter that should not be taken lightly and it might, on the contrary, have the
interesting virtue of articulation with other processes. To be schematic, there are two
kinds of virtual cities. First we have those without physical existence or, in other words,
that do not correspond to a specific city but rather to the idea that the city is a
metaphor for acceding to different services on the global network of internet. These are,
in general, commercial services and, in this city of X, in such-and-such a cityscape, or
whatever, there is a bank or a shop, or a service that offers commercial products or, in
some cases, political propaganda. What I find interesting about these virtual cities is
that the graphics always or almost always show small cities or towns, and they even
have an almost childlike architecture like the kind of urban naf we see in Walt Disney
films.
The other virtual cities, the more important ones, in my view, are the real cities that
organise their virtual existence on the Web as a system offering information to their
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
34/49
citizens. Then there would be a third kind to which I shall refer in more detail below. The
second type includes the new network of European cities that are linked up in the on-
line project of the Eurocities network. At present, most are essentially administrative
databanks and information about services. In the case of Barcelona, it is an intelligent,
well-informed and efficient interactive service. These on-line pages also function as a
publicity catalogue in colour, with photos and texts that aim at attracting tourists and
investment, while also promoting the government team of the day. I believe it could be
a very interesting project in the near future but, for the moment, most the real cities
that go on to the Web do so in the form of advertising operations and services offering
information to citizens.
There are also more limited attempts but they are interesting to highlight, and these are
the real cities that construct a participative system of the virtual city. Rather than
speaking in general terms, let me give two examples for which we have some data and
that are among the most developed cases in Europe: the digital city of Amsterdam and
the Iperbole programme of Bologna. Both have been studied in some detail in the work
of Stephen Graham of the Centre for Urban Technology of the University of Newcastle,
so we have some material about them, in particular what I was able to obtain from my
own real visit to the virtual city of Amsterdam. Both were founded in 1994. The digital
city of Amsterdam is not under the auspices of the City Council but is financed by a
private, non-lucrative foundation and is organised as a city into thematic sections, each
with a square that appears physically, dealing with housing, municipal financing, local
culture, work and environment. In the centre of these thematic squares, there is
information about the related organisations, and around it are buildings, the houses
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
35/49
where people who are registered in this virtual city (35,000 in the case of Amsterdam)
can lodge their own information free of charge. Interaction is thereby structured
between the people of these buildings and the information offered by the organisations
in the square. Besides, there is a text programme called Metro, which enables direct
interaction between citizens who can even and they do get married virtually, have
families, choose the virtual mayor of the city, talk about their problems and relate the
problems of the real city with those of the virtual city. Moreover, a special effort has
been made in Amsterdam to create public terminals through which people can enter
this virtual city, and organisations of socially-excluded groups have received special
training and programmes to that they can join in the interaction. In some cafes and
public places there are also computers that are especially designed for children. Public
space? Yes and no. It is a public space that is obviously biased in the construction of the
programme and although, as I insist, the NGOs have received help so that they can
connect, it must be noted that, of the 35,000 residents of the virtual city, 85% are males,
75% are university graduates, and 58% are under thirty years of age. Again, financing
problems have ensured that, now The Digital City of Amsterdam is a success, the
foundation is selling space in the virtual city for commercial and advertising purposes
and here, it is interesting to note, the problems of physical public spaces are reproduced
because when something works it is commercialised.
Again, there is another problem, a basic one for anyone who wants to develop the idea
of an electronic agora along the lines of the development of a real city and this is that,
although the text is Dutch, since it is on internet, anyone can enter, from any part of the
world. As happens with a real city. Well, yes and no. Not everyone takes a plane from
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
36/49
Jakarta to Amsterdam every day, of course, but it is true that the real city is also open to
any kind of visitor and the so-called floating population of the real city is one of the
most important issues for urban planners, but this is not global on-line access as can
occur with the virtual city. In fact, from the statistics we have available, 50% of the
virtual city users are not registered in the virtual city because it is necessary to provide
an Amsterdam address in order to register, but this is not required in order to enter
because there is no way to connect up entry. Besides, the local Chamber of Commerce
and the Amsterdam City Council are using this digital city as an international lure to
attract people to Amsterdam and are therefore sending out images on internet with the
result that the proportion of real non-residents is rising and it might, in fact, become a
global public space around a virtual Amsterdam, which is how it is tending at present.
Another example that might illustrate our analysis is Bologna's Iperbole programme,
which was also created in 1994 by the Bologna City Council. In this programme, in
principle, the information is something that issues from the City Council and the city's
civic and union organisations, with which the citizens can interact but without being
able to add their own information. It is a more asymmetrical system. It is divided into
three departments, each of which offers a wide range of services, and these
departments arise from the different kinds of organisations that are managed by each
one. There are thirty-three groups of subject areas with Usenet-type conversation
groups about them. Participation in Iperbole is free of charge and is funded by the City
Council in terms of training projects at neighbourhood level and also at the level of civic
organisations so that people can use it and, in this sense, Iperbole has managed to
achieve almost exclusively local participation. Almost 90% of the people who enter into
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
37/49
the Iperbole programme are local, largely because the problems it deals with are very
local ones, as the City Council and local organisations propose. By 1996 it seemed that,
once the programme was underway, advertising space was being rented out to small
local enterprises. However, a selection is made of these enterprises and not just anyone
can advertise, but only those companies that the City Council thinks should be helped in
the local sphere. The City Council also wanted to use the Iperbole system to organise
referendums that might give some indications about specific problems of municipal
administration but, for the moment, technical problems of organisation have prevented
it. The technical problems, it seems and this is not official information from the City
Council consist in how to organise a referendum on a local issue when anybody from
any other city or any other part of the world can access the referendum and vote. This is
a complex problem that has not yet been resolved. I believe that it could be resolved
but, in the specific case of Bologna, it has not yet happened.
The problems raised, then, by virtual cities is that they are still very excluding, highly
commercialised, and many of them are networks of individuals who do the same as they
would do in their personal relations, but they do it in cyberspace, and the studies even
show that these networks of individuals tend to replace the urban life they once had
with life in this electronic agora.
Nonetheless, there are possibilities for articulation, a chance for localities in the space of
flows, so that, for example, virtual communities can be created where transit between
flows and places can happen. One example is San Francisco where there is an Iperbole-
type programme called Citysearch in which people can chat about different matters and,
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
38/49
on this basis, establish personal, physical interaction and also receive information about
the kinds of activities that they can engage in within the real city of San Francisco, etc.. It
functions, first, then as a channel for electronic conversation and then as a system for
connecting to the local services of which they can avail themselves.
However, I must stress that the efforts of connection in cyberspace are presently limited
to interactive networks of groups from a fairly high social level, or they are essentially
administrative spaces, without either of the two being able to re-create public spaces,
neither in the sense in which we know them historically speaking nor, as I tried to point
out above, as spaces of integration, and spaces where integration enables the creation
of social synergy.
V. The Localisation ofFlows
Is it possible to reconstruct meaning and establish bridges between the space of flows
and the space of places, and from the places? Here we have a whole series of attempts
where the design of architecture and urban design are playing an evermore basic role in
an overall society in which, and I insist on this, people and societies resist disappearing
into the global non-differentiation of the space of flows.
There are several ways to create this new monumentality and this new centrality. The
first and simplest would be symbolic uses for the new instrumentalities of culturally
identifiable places that have historic and cultural sense. To put it clearly, the Casa de la
Caritat in Barcelona is a good example. It represents the project of using buildings
whose cultural value, identifying value and historic value, is maintained, reinforced and
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
39/49
highlighted in order to articulate these values with an instrumentality that is open to
information flows or, in different cases, to other types of flow. Banks, as we know, are
trying to absorb historic buildings and give them instrumentality. This might be criticised
from another point of view although I don't criticise it but there is an effort to
connect what was the physical identity of a place to a projection of the new
instrumentality. Public institutions and, in particular, the branches of the administration
in the autonomous regions all over Spain, are reusing a good part of their artistic and
architectural heritage for their offices and headquarters. I do not know if they could use
them for other purposes but at least there is some connection of historic identity,
physical culture and the new instrumentality. There is another example that might
appear ridiculous, but it seems significant to me, and this is what McDonald's does.
McDonald's, from a superficial standpoint, has become the symbol of global culture, of
the massacre of cultural forms, always with its yellow born-in-the-USA arches. But what
McDonalds is doing all over Europe is to reuse culturally significant buildings in each city.
Wherever they can engage in symbolic marketing of something but not in all cases
because there are too many McDonalds they do so. They also do it in Japan, of course.
Then, the attempt at a cultural leap is what, very primitively, is considered in connection
with symbolic uses that people can identify with new instrumental uses. But this is too
specific. The problem, as I suggested above, is how to extend the public sphere of
meaning.
VI. The New Urban Signification
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
40/49
I shall begin with what is not working. What is not working is the attempt at bringing the
new instrumental spaces under control by trying to give them new symbolic meaning
through privatisation of public uses. To be precise, examples inBarcelona are the L'illa
shopping mall and the Nova Icria Centre. In other words, this is the idea of creating
spaces that reproduce the functions of urban centrality, spaces that aim to reconstruct,
and they do reconstruct, sometimes quite successfully, the density of urban life, but
they privatise it. And in privatising, they definitively introduce bias into the uses of the
space and the perception of the space because it is dominated by the commercial
function. There is nothing wrong with the commercial function, which is as legitimate as
any other in society. However, the issue at hand is symbolic structuring when there is
excessive predominance of this function.
More excessive cases appear with the attempt to introduce into discrete spaces the
logic of the space of flows. In the space of flows, just like extraterrestrial beings, shops
like Planet Hollywood are organising landing systems. What is Planet Hollywood? It
means bringing Hollywood to any part of the world and installing it in a space where you
suddenly enter into the culture of Hollywood. Or, for those who have rather more
money and ambitions, there are places like Fashion Caf, which conveys the idea that if
you go there some day you might meet up with the co-proprietor, Claudia Schiffer, and
have a coffee with her.
From a more creative standpoint, we can see the attempt to go beyond privatisation
and to try to achieve articulation between flows and places. In brief, there are different
types of initiatives. This articulation between flows and places can occur when either
flows or places are dominant. When flows are dominant, we find, first of all, attempts to
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
41/49
articulate a new monumentality of the instrumental by way of technological design. One
example is the work of the engineer-architect Calatrava. The bridges of Calatrava, the
communications tower of Calatrava, etc., and the idea that what is technologically
advanced, what is the instrument of connection, let's say a bridge (if there was a river)
could be significant and monumental, while also instrumental. The articulation of
significance and instrumentality, places and flows, is at the basis of a huge effort in
architecture and urban planning with regard to places of interchange of flows: airports,
stations, highways. It is what I call the Changi model after the Singapore airport, which is
really a city that has been totally designed from within to make the wait very agreeable.
In a place and space where people are edgy because they find themselves suspended in
the space of flows, a cosy space has been constructed, which includes piano concerts of
classical music in the vestibule and all kinds of other activities. Although Changi is highly
commercialised, it is designed to make you feel you are in your living room at home. A
much more uncompromising model, but one that I think is a lot more interesting from
the design point of view, is the Barcelona airport, where we have the idea of dealing
with a space of interchange by bestowing significance on it, along with commercial
elements to which is added an aesthetic dimension of the relation between culture and
instrumentality. Then there is what Moneo has done with the AVE station in Madrid,
which is a brilliant genuflection to this, though I don't know whether it has been noticed.
The AVE station is in fact two stations, the old Atocha Station that, with a wonderful
rehabilitated design with the trees and birds of the surroundings, is a park and not a
station. Then, next to that is the crummy thing that is the new station for the AVE that
goes between Madrid and Seville, and that is all. Obviously, then, the idea, or the
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
42/49
oblique reference, is that the former could not be a station but a park, while this AVE
("bird" in Spanish) is there fortuitously because somebody got the bright idea of having
an AVE that goes from Madrid to Seville. Another significant example is Koolhaus's
design for the transport modal interchange system in Lille. The treatment given to the
centrality of the Gran Palais and to the organisation around the modal interchange
points for European transport once again combines instrumentality, expression and a
strong cultural component. To sum up, the attempt to turn crowded places of transit
into public spaces and not just places of fast connection is an idea that at least has the
strength of trying to integrate what is expressive into what is functional. I reiterate,
however, that the space of flows is still predominant.
As for the attempts to articulate spaces when places are predominant, we have, on the
one hand, an idea of prolonging what is historic, or the idea of maintaining and
developing public places, as we see happening in Barcelona. The Rambla continues to be
a historic place. In a book written by one of the great American urban planners, Alan
Jakobs, and published by MIT last year, we have the great cities with all the major
streets of the world, and he designates the best and second-best streets in the world.
The best, for him, is the Rambla, followed by the Passeig de Grcia, both of them in
Barcelona. This may be a qualitative analysis, but it is also an authoritative opinion.
Nonetheless, the idea of prolonging what is historic, as might be the case of the Piazza
Navona in Rome, is one that conserves the space of places but is unable to organise the
counter-offensive in the space of flows. To clarify this point, the Rambla only becomes a
flow when Bara wins a match or, in other words, it vibrates then as a media event and
it is there that it articulates to enter into another space beyond the place itself.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
43/49
Otherwise it continues to be a very local space, very much Barcelona and its tourists. So
the idea of historical prolongation and the endurance of highly significant places, while
it permits the survival of local cultures and identities, does not organise the counter-
attack of significance in the space of flows. What is difficult, then, is to articulate
physical monumentality, which has memory, with information flows as activities, and
with spaces of urban life as an element of articulation between memory and activity.
In my view, this is the frontier between urban planning and architecture in the
informational city. It is the idea of connecting activity with memory, of connecting flows
with places. Are things being done in this sense? Well, yes. I think that here, the idea of
museum activity that has existed still has some value and that, in part, the connection
comes in here, though it is limited to cultural elements and some activities. The model
of the Pompidou Centre in Paris, for example, (even though I find the design quite
horrible), but let's say the cultural model and its relation with the city, its revivifying of
the neighbourhood of Les Halles, etcetera, does work. However, what is sometimes
called the French model has not always worked. For example, the Gare d'Orsay is a
catastrophe as an element of revitalisation in its urban setting and La Villette is
somewhere between the two models. However, the idea of a powerful stimulus of flows
of activities, of all sorts of information initiatives, these flows being tied to cultural
expressiveness and integrated into an urban space that is being reactivated if not
directly through these activities then at least because of the presence of the project, is a
truly interesting phenomenon.
There are similar elements in the United States. I shall only cite one case so as not to
exceed my time. This is the effort that was made in Santa Monica, Los Angeles, to
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
44/49
articulate collective memory by rehabilitating buildings and so on, along with cultural
expressions through the interplay of images generated from the experience of California
itself. California, too, has its culture and history, a history of only fifty years, but a very
intense one, so intense that it is part of our everyday imaginary, and not just Hollywood,
but surf, skateboards, video-clips, etc.. All of this forms the Californian identity and
culture, just as the Baroque might have represented Italian culture and identity in other
centuries. Santa Monica, then, has organized urban life with a multitude of oblique
references in its public spaces to motifs pertaining to Hollywood, surf, skateboarding
and so on, and these references articulate this urban life.
The set of activities carried out here in the Centre de Cultura Contempornea de
Barcelona, in the Casa de Caritat building, next to the Contemporary Art Museum, in the
Raval neighbourhood, near the Rambla, in Barcelona, Catalonia all these connections
are the type of links that can really begin to construct bridges. The problem with this
kind of connection is that the initiatives are still too limited to relatively elite cultural
activities, but the idea of connecting information flows with historical significance, and
this being integrated into urban space, and this idea being generalised to other
neighbourhoods, to other sorts of activities and cultural expression, seems to be one of
the ways to go about reconstructing an articulation of places and flows.
Experimenting thus with a new information-based design of what is material and a new
material-based design of what pertains to information seems to be the new frontier of
urban planning. How to make a city of the information city. In other words, a producer
of culture on the basis of the interaction between work, everyday life and the imaginary.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
45/49
It is the articulation between the new capacity to create and the renewed art of
dreaming in time and space.
ACCESS
1GOOD ACCESS
LINKAGES & FLOW
2GREAT LINKAGES, FAIRLY ACCEPTABLE FLOW LOCALISATION OF FLOW
The articulation of significance and instrumentality, places and flows, is at the basis of a
huge effort in architecture and urban planning with regard to places of interchange of
flows: airports, stations, highways. It is what I call the Changi model after the Singapore
airport, which is really a city that has been totally designed from within to make the wait
very agreeable. In a place and space where people are edgy because they find
themselves suspended in the space of flows, a cosy space has been constructed, which
includes piano concerts of classical music in the vestibule and all kinds of other activities.
Although Changi is highly commercialised, it is designed to make you feel you are in your
living room at home.
USES AND SPACE
3EXISTING FUNCTIONAL SPACES FOR PUBLIC ( THERE ARE ACTIVITIES THAT PEOPLE CAN
EASILY, AND FREELY ENGAGED IN) thomass idea of wifi.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
46/49
SENCE OF BELONGING
4COMFORT/safety.
REPUTATION AND IMAGE
5POSITVE REPUTATION OR A GOOD IMAGE
-legends on trevi: n 19 B.C. Marco Vespasiano Agrippa decides to construct a
long canal to feed the springs he developed near the Pantheon.The legend states
that soldiers were sent to research the water springs closest to Rome, who, while
on assignment, met a young girl that led them to the pure springs. It is from
this legend that the water is gets its name the "Virgin Water".
During antiquity, a glass of the fresh, thirst quenching water from the Trevi
Fountain was said to ensure good fortune and a fast return to Rome.Over the
course of time, this practice was replaced with the tossing of a coin in the
fountain. The precise tradition calls for one to throw the coin over one's left
shoulder while standing with one's back to the Trevi Fountain.
The Trevi Fountain today, contains a wide collection of international coins tossed
by those travellers wishing to return to this distinctly romantic and wonderful
place in Rome.There is second romantic ritual associated with the Trevi Fountain.
This legend pertains to the miniature fountain of the left side, known as "the
small fountain of lovers". According to the legend, couples that drink from
the mini fountain will forever be faithful to their partner.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
47/49
http://www.travelermania.com/europe/trevi-fountain-in-rome/
Legends on piazza navona
SIGNIFICANCE
-HISTORICALLY
-URBAN
6THERE IS AN EXISITNG SIGNIFICANCE ABOUT THE PLACE/ FAME DUE TO HISTORY
7NEW URBAN SIGNIFICANCE
Definitions from Oxford dictionary
ACCESS:
y 1 [mass noun] (often access to) the means or opportunity to approach or enter a
place:the staircase gives access to the top floorwheelchair access
LINKAGES:
y the action of linking or the state of being linked.
y [count noun] a system of links:a complex linkage of nerves
FLOW:
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
48/49
2 [with adverbial of direction] go from one place to another in a steady stream, typically
in large numbers:peopleflowed into the huge courtyard
SPACES:
y 1 a continuous area or expanse which is free , available, or unoccupied:a table
took up much of the space[count noun] :we shall all be living together in a small spacehe
reversed out of the parking space
y [count noun] an area of land which is not occupied by buildings:she had a love of
open spaces
REPUTATION
y the beliefs or opinions that are generally held about someone or something:his
reputation was tarnished by allegations of bribery
y a widespread belief that someone or something has a particular
characteristic:his knowledge of his subject earned him a reputation as an expert
IMAGE
y 1 a representation of the external form of a person or thing in art.
y 2 the general impression that a person, organization, or product presents to the
public:she strives to project an image of youth
SIGNIFICANCE
y 1 the quality of being worthy of attention; importance:adolescent education was
felt to be a social issue of some significance
y 2 (also statistical significance) the extent to which a result deviates from that
expected to arise simply from random variation or errors in sampling.
-
8/6/2019 Ab314 Cultural Studies 3 What Makes a Good Public Spaces
49/49