AAAM 2020 - 157 Development of main spectral profiles database … · 2020. 3. 31. · trail’s...

1
Development of main spectral profiles database for MALDI- identification of common aspergillosis causative agents from the colonies obtained in liquid medium Results in graphic view (in BactoSCREEN-ID software) Background Materials and methods MALDI-TOF-mass-spectrometry of the cell extract has been successfully used to identify clinical isolates of micromycetes, including Aspergillus spp. Modern databases of main spectral profiles (MSPs) are intended mainly for working with cultures in «pellets» that are grown in a liquid medium on a rotator. Working with «pellets» is associated with some inconveniences, in this regard many microbiologists prefer to work with membranous cultures obtained on liquid medium without rotation. № 157 N.V. Vasilyeva, I.A. Riabinin, L.V. Alieva, Y.V. Mikhaylova, Y.V. Borzova, T.V. Bogdanova, A.Y. Alexeyev, N.P. Remnyeva, V.M. Kaschuba, O.A. Schurpitskaya, T.S. Bogomolova, G.A. Chilina North-Western State Medical University n.a. I.I Mechnikov Kashkin Research Institute of Medical Mycology; Faculty of Preventive Medicine; Department of Medical Microbiology Purpose Study was performed using the Laser ToF LT2Plus MALDI-TOF- mass-spectrometer (SAI, UK) and BactoSCREEN software (Lytech, Russia). In order to create the MSP-database strains of A. fumigatus, A. flavus, A. niger-complex (A. niger & A. awamori) and A. nidulans identified by the target DNA-sequencing of ITS and β-tubulin loci according to the CLSI MM18 standard (2nd Ed.) were obtained from the Russian collection of pathogenic fungi. Only the most detailed mass-spectra with low noise levels were selected. The MSP- database design was carried out according to the instructions of the software manufacturer. 166 Aspergillus spp. of 5 species were processed for a positive identification control, 199 fungal cultures of 37 species and 117 bacterial cultures of 85 species were included in the trial for negative control (specificity control). All of the strains used in the study were isolated from human biomaterials. The processing of mycelial fungi cultures was carried out as described previously [Riabinin I.A. et al., AAA-2014], bacterial and yeast cultures were prepared by direct deposition and acid etching on MALDI-target. As a trail’s resume the effectiveness parameters were calculated for the created MSP-database relative to the main commercial MSP- database of software manufacturer. Conclusion The study allowed us to create the MSP-database suitable for the cultural diagnosis of aspergillosis using MALDI-TOF-mass- spectrometry. In the future, it is advisable to expand the range of species of the database, taking into account the more rare but actual causative agents of aspergillosis (e.g. A. sydowii, A. ochraceus, A. candidus, A. calidoustus and others). The purpose of the study is to compose the MSP-database of Aspergillus spp. the most common causative agents of invasive aspergillosis to identify their cultures grown in liquid nutrient medium without mechanical agitation. The «AMPSL» (Aspergillosis Main Pathogens Spectral Library) database was created, which included high-quality MSP of 47 Aspergillus spp. cultures. Compared to the manufacturer’s main MSP- base, AMPSL was more sensitive (100% vs 79.8%), although slightly less specific (98.2% vs 100%). False positive identification using the AMPSL-database was detected for individual isolates of Penicillium sp., P. digitatum, Purpureocillium lilacinum and Scopulariopsis brevicaulis. These micromycetes are closely related to Aspergillus spp. and have very similar composition of MALDI-mass-spectra, which explains their inaccurate identification. However, the conventional microbiological methods (stereomicroscopy of colonies, microscopy of a preparation from a culture) such problem strains are easy to determine correctly. In general, the created «AMPSL» base showed greater diagnostic efficiency compared to the standard MSP- base of mass-spectrometer (98.5% vs 96.7%). A distinctive feature of the AMPSL utilization is the more successful identification of A. flavus and A. terreus isolates. «Positive» control (Sensitivity control) on Aspergillus spp. isolates Standard Database «AMPSL» Results «Negative» control (Specificity control) on non-Aspergillus reference microbial isolates («AMPSL» database) «Spectrum» indicator is 0.8 - 1.0. Reliable identification to species level. Color scale for interpreting of identification results (in the right parts of MS-target positions) «Spectrum» indicator is 0.6 - 0.8. Reliable identification only to the genus level. «Spectrum» indicator is 0.0 - 0.6. Identification is unreliable. MMRL microbial cultures collection of Medical Microbiology Research Laboratory. SC subculture . Nonlipophilic Yeasts Malassezia spp. Procaryota and nonlipophilic yeasts Mycelial fungi (Dikarya) Procaryota (selection) Examples of identification results of Aspergillus spp. clinical isolates Standard Database «AMPSL» Database

Transcript of AAAM 2020 - 157 Development of main spectral profiles database … · 2020. 3. 31. · trail’s...

Page 1: AAAM 2020 - 157 Development of main spectral profiles database … · 2020. 3. 31. · trail’s resume the effectiveness parameters were calculated for the created MSP-database relative

Development of main spectral profiles database for MALDI-

identification of common aspergillosis causative agents

from the colonies obtained in liquid medium

Weakly virulent strains

Weakly virulent strains

Results in graphic view (in BactoSCREEN-ID software) Background

Materials and methods

MALDI-TOF-mass-spectrometry of the cell extract has been

successfully used to identify clinical isolates of micromycetes,

including Aspergillus spp. Modern databases of

main spectral profiles (MSPs) are intended mainly for working with

cultures in «pellets» that are grown in a liquid medium on a rotator.

Working with «pellets» is associated with some inconveniences, in

this regard many microbiologists prefer to work with membranous

cultures obtained on liquid medium without rotation.

№ 157

N.V. Vasilyeva, I.A. Riabinin, L.V. Alieva, Y.V. Mikhaylova, Y.V.

Borzova, T.V. Bogdanova, A.Y. Alexeyev, N.P. Remnyeva, V.M.

Kaschuba, O.A. Schurpitskaya, T.S. Bogomolova, G.A. Chilina

North-Western

State Medical University

n.a. I.I Mechnikov

Kashkin Research Institute of Medical Mycology; Faculty of Preventive Medicine; Department of Medical Microbiology

Purpose

Study was performed using the Laser ToF LT2Plus MALDI-TOF-

mass-spectrometer (SAI, UK) and BactoSCREEN software (Lytech,

Russia). In order to create the MSP-database strains of A. fumigatus,

A. flavus, A. niger-complex (A. niger & A. awamori) and A.

nidulans identified by the target DNA-sequencing of ITS and β-tubulin

loci according to the CLSI MM18 standard (2nd Ed.) were obtained

from the Russian collection of pathogenic fungi. Only the most

detailed mass-spectra with low noise levels were selected. The MSP-

database design was carried out according to the instructions of the

software manufacturer. 166 Aspergillus spp. of 5 species were

processed for a positive identification control, 199 fungal cultures of

37 species and 117 bacterial cultures of 85 species were included in

the trial for negative control (specificity control). All of the strains used

in the study were isolated from human biomaterials. The processing

of mycelial fungi cultures was carried out as described previously

[Riabinin I.A. et al., AAA-2014], bacterial and yeast cultures were

prepared by direct deposition and acid etching on MALDI-target. As a

trail’s resume the effectiveness parameters were calculated for the

created MSP-database relative to the main commercial MSP-

database of software manufacturer.

Conclusion

The study allowed us to create the MSP-database suitable for the

cultural diagnosis of aspergillosis using MALDI-TOF-mass-

spectrometry. In the future, it is advisable to expand the range of

species of the database, taking into account the more rare but

actual causative agents of aspergillosis (e.g. A. sydowii, A.

ochraceus, A. candidus, A. calidoustus and others).

The purpose of the study is to compose the MSP-database of

Aspergillus spp. – the most common causative agents of invasive

aspergillosis – to identify their cultures grown in liquid nutrient

medium without mechanical agitation.

The «AMPSL» (Aspergillosis Main Pathogens Spectral Library)

database was created, which included high-quality MSP of 47

Aspergillus spp. cultures. Compared to the manufacturer’s main MSP-

base, AMPSL was more sensitive (100% vs 79.8%), although slightly

less specific (98.2% vs 100%). False positive identification using the

AMPSL-database was detected for individual isolates of Penicillium

sp., P. digitatum, Purpureocillium lilacinum and Scopulariopsis

brevicaulis. These micromycetes are closely related to Aspergillus

spp. and have very similar composition of MALDI-mass-spectra,

which explains their inaccurate identification. However, the

conventional microbiological methods (stereomicroscopy of colonies,

microscopy of a preparation from a culture) such problem strains are

easy to determine correctly. In general, the created «AMPSL» base

showed greater diagnostic efficiency compared to the standard MSP-

base of mass-spectrometer (98.5% vs 96.7%). A distinctive feature of

the AMPSL utilization is the more successful identification of A. flavus

and A. terreus isolates.

«Positive» control (Sensitivity control) on Aspergillus spp. isolates

Standard Database «AMPSL»

Results

«Negative» control (Specificity control) on non-Aspergillus reference microbial isolates

(«AMPSL» database)

«Spectrum» indicator is 0.8 -

1.0. Reliable identification to

species level.

Color scale for interpreting of identification results (in the right parts of MS-target positions)

«Spectrum» indicator is 0.6

- 0.8. Reliable identification

only to the genus level.

«Spectrum» indicator is

0.0 - 0.6. Identification is

unreliable.

MMRL – microbial cultures collection of Medical Microbiology Research Laboratory. SC – subculture №.

Nonlipophilic Yeasts Malassezia spp.

Procaryota and

nonlipophilic yeasts

Mycelial fungi (Dikarya)

Procaryota (selection) Examples of identification results

of Aspergillus spp. clinical isolates

Standard Database «AMPSL» Database