A summary of operators opinionson the proposed MOSS system

30 July 2010

Question : Should SSM be ScrappedAgainst 54 77.14%For 11 15.71%No Answer 5   7.14%  

What do you think is wrong with SSM? Nothing 12 17%Not Much 11 15.71%Inconsistent 11 15.71Costs 7 10.00%Too Complex 6 8.57%Paperwork 10 14.29%Costs 7 10.00%Control 3 4.29%No Answer 3 4.29%

Do you think that SSM is confusing & unduly complex for industry? Yes 30 42.86%No 36 51.43%No Answer 4 5.71%

Does MNZ have effective oversight of safety under SSM? Yes 30 42.86%No 36 51.43%No Answer 4 5.71%

Does the Marine industry have a mediocre safety record under SSM? Yes 14 20.00%No 49 70.00%No Answer 7 10.00%

Do you think MOSS will be a better system than SSM? Yes 13 18.57%No 45 64.29%Don’t Know 7 10.00%No Answer 5 7.14%

Do you want to leave your SSM company.Yes 13 18.57%No 48 68.57%Don’t Know 0 0.00% No Answer 9 12.86%

Do you think survey costs will increase or decrease under MOSS? Increase 52 74.29%Decrease 6 8.57%No Answer 12 17.14%

Do you support MNZ conducting auditing under MOSS? Yes 27 38.57%No 31 44.29%No Answer 12 17.14%

Do you believe that the audit process will be consistent? Yes 17 24.29%No 36 51.43%Don’t Know 6 8.57%No Answer 11 15.71%

Do you think audit costs will stay the same, increase or decrease if conducted by MNZ? Increase 52 74.29%Decrease 6 8.57%Stay the same 2 2.86%

% No Answer 10 14.29

Are you happy with the consultation undertaken so far by MNZ in developing MOSS? Yes 16 22.86%No 34 48.57%No Answer 20 28.57%

Would you like the opportunity for industry workshops to be conducted with MNZ to investigate alternative models for SSM? Yes 50 71.43%No 10 14.29%No Answer 10 14.29%

Are you happy with paying for exemptions and applications for private use?

Yes 7 10.00%No 48 68.57% No Answer 15 21.43%

Summary of Questionnaire respondents

Fishing Boats 17 175 Meters Total Vessels 105Charter Boats 36 510 Meters Total Length

1892 mFerries 16 369 Meters Total Operators

70Vehicle Ferries 7 264 MetersWorkboats11 376 MetersBare Boats 13 144 MetersAquaculture 2 24 MetersJet Boat 1 10 MetersSail Trainer 1 10 MetersWater Taxi 1 10 Meters