A SAc PERSPECTIVE OF PARTICIPATORY PERFORMANCE … · promoting SAc in Extractive Industry A...

www.ansawww.ansa--eap.neteap.netAffiliated Network for Social Accountability In East Asia and the Pacific… connecting citizens to improve governance

Buzz session…• Each team will have a 10-minute buzz session

(like buzzing bees and other insects)• Answer the following:

– Write at least 3 thoughts about the News Reports.– What are the factors that facilitated your project?– What are the factors that hindered/posed as

challenges in your project?

• Write your answers on metacards. Keep in mindthe metacard rules.

• Post the metacard on the board.

17-18 JULY 2012A REGIONAL CASE CONFERENCE ON THE CSC: MAINSTREAMING SAC IN EI

• Each team will have a 10-minute buzz session(like buzzing bees and other insects)

• Answer the following:– Write at least 3 thoughts about the News Reports.– What are the factors that facilitated your project?– What are the factors that hindered/posed as

challenges in your project?

• Write your answers on metacards. Keep in mindthe metacard rules.

• Post the metacard on the board.

1


PRESENTATION OF CASE STUDIES


PRESENTATION OF CASE STUDIES(Per Component of the CSC)

2


Objectives of the Presentation• To share and listen to participants’

experiences in implementing the CSC,– Community entitlement

– Community scoring

– Interface meeting

• To assess the viability of CSC as a tool inpromoting SAc in Extractive Industry


• To share and listen to participants’experiences in implementing the CSC,– Community entitlement

– Community scoring

– Interface meeting

• To assess the viability of CSC as a tool inpromoting SAc in Extractive Industry

3


Instructions• Participants will be asked to share their experiences in

implementing CSC

• There will be three sets of presentation, highlighting a CSCcomponent/phase

• Ms. Baigal of Mongolia will present Mongolia’s currentinitiatives in promoting transparency and accountability in EI

• Each country team will be asked to present their cases within10-15 minutes

• Five minutes will be allotted for Q&A after each presentation

• Presentations will be guided by questions


• Participants will be asked to share their experiences inimplementing CSC

• There will be three sets of presentation, highlighting a CSCcomponent/phase

• Ms. Baigal of Mongolia will present Mongolia’s currentinitiatives in promoting transparency and accountability in EI

• Each country team will be asked to present their cases within10-15 minutes

• Five minutes will be allotted for Q&A after each presentation

• Presentations will be guided by questions

4


COMMUNITY ENTITLEMENTS

• How were the indicators (for scoring) arrived at?

• What do your country policies/laws provide in terms oftransparency of information, participation, andaccountability?

• How did you use the EI Global Standards?

• Based on your experience what strategies have youfound effective in informing/educating communitieson EI entitlements?

Lessons learned in informing or educating communities of their rightsand entitlements as provided by global and national standards.


• How were the indicators (for scoring) arrived at?

• What do your country policies/laws provide in terms oftransparency of information, participation, andaccountability?

• How did you use the EI Global Standards?

• Based on your experience what strategies have youfound effective in informing/educating communitieson EI entitlements?

5


COMMUNITY ENTITLEMENTS

• CRRT and CCIM (VOD) in Cambodia– Rights Education, Initializing Community Access to

Information

• MaCEC (Marinduque Council for EnvironmentalConcerns– Policy Education and the Community’s Right to Veto Mining

Projects

PRESENTERS:


• CRRT and CCIM (VOD) in Cambodia– Rights Education, Initializing Community Access to

Information

• MaCEC (Marinduque Council for EnvironmentalConcerns– Policy Education and the Community’s Right to Veto Mining

Projects

6


GENERATING COMMUNITY SCORING

• Indicators may point to the very issues that areperceived by the community or citizens– to be important to them– would benefit from the EI operation when services are

effectively provided by the regulating institutions and theextractive company

Lessons learned from generating and defining the INDICATORS by theCOMMUNITY.


• Indicators may point to the very issues that areperceived by the community or citizens– to be important to them– would benefit from the EI operation when services are

effectively provided by the regulating institutions and theextractive company

7



Luta Hamutuk

• provides services and projects to Timorcommunities impacted by oil extraction

• focuses on the agreements between governmentand oil company to provide the ‘local content’, i.e.,– provision of projects for alternative livelihood

– transfer of technology

– infrastructure

PRESENTER:


Luta Hamutuk

• provides services and projects to Timorcommunities impacted by oil extraction

• focuses on the agreements between governmentand oil company to provide the ‘local content’, i.e.,– provision of projects for alternative livelihood

– transfer of technology

– infrastructure

8


INTERFACE MEETING

• Platform for constructive engagement andcollaborative problem-solving

• Lessons learned, insights gained, suggestions forimproving and sustaining engagement will be shared

Bringing the results of the 3-cornered evaluation or audit to the tablefor constructive engagement, to build consensus on concretemeasures to address the findings.


• Platform for constructive engagement andcollaborative problem-solving

• Lessons learned, insights gained, suggestions forimproving and sustaining engagement will be shared

9



How was the interaction between stakeholders group duringthe interface meeting? Were messages clearly communicatedand/or discussed?

What are the key agreements that the group arrived at duringthe interface meeting? How consensus was built betweendifferent stakeholders?

Did the group come up with an action plan to outline nextsteps after the interface meeting? How can engagement besustained after the CSC?

Bringing the results of the 3-cornered evaluation or audit to the tablefor constructive engagement, to build consensus on concretemeasures to address the findings.


How was the interaction between stakeholders group duringthe interface meeting? Were messages clearly communicatedand/or discussed?

What are the key agreements that the group arrived at duringthe interface meeting? How consensus was built betweendifferent stakeholders?

Did the group come up with an action plan to outline nextsteps after the interface meeting? How can engagement besustained after the CSC?

10



PATTIRO and Bojo Negoro Institute

• Collaborated on the conduct of the CSC in BojoNegoro in Western Java

• Will share the lessons in moderating the InterfaceMeeting– surfacing areas for improvement or reform and in

discussing how the identified governance issues will beaddressed by government and the PetroChina.

• Discuss with the local government and theTransparency Mechanism on the possibleinstitutionalization of CSC

Presenters:


PATTIRO and Bojo Negoro Institute

• Collaborated on the conduct of the CSC in BojoNegoro in Western Java

• Will share the lessons in moderating the InterfaceMeeting– surfacing areas for improvement or reform and in

discussing how the identified governance issues will beaddressed by government and the PetroChina.

• Discuss with the local government and theTransparency Mechanism on the possibleinstitutionalization of CSC

11



Cordillera Volunteer Missioners (CVM)

• Engages the indigenous Kankanaey community thathosts Philex Mining Corporation’s mining project

• Examines the implementation of the SocialDevelopment Management Program and Provisionof IP Royalties

Presenters:


Cordillera Volunteer Missioners (CVM)

• Engages the indigenous Kankanaey community thathosts Philex Mining Corporation’s mining project

• Examines the implementation of the SocialDevelopment Management Program and Provisionof IP Royalties

12



MONGOLIA: THE EI SITUATION

13


Talking points…• Description of responsible mining initiatives in

Mongolia; how and where it works

• Description of Mongolia Human Development Fundand where it is now

• Reflections on the CSC case presentation:– What initiatives shared by the other presenters can be

applicable to Mongolia

– What initiatives in Mongolia does she think can bereplicable/applicable in other countries in the region


• Description of responsible mining initiatives inMongolia; how and where it works

• Description of Mongolia Human Development Fundand where it is now

• Reflections on the CSC case presentation:– What initiatives shared by the other presenters can be

applicable to Mongolia

– What initiatives in Mongolia does she think can bereplicable/applicable in other countries in the region

14

A SAc PERSPECTIVE OF PARTICIPATORY PERFORMANCE … · promoting SAc in Extractive Industry A...

Documents

Transcript of A SAc PERSPECTIVE OF PARTICIPATORY PERFORMANCE … · promoting SAc in Extractive Industry A...