A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

17
A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker

Transcript of A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

Page 1: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

A resilience approach to the future

Brian Walker

Page 2: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

looming threats

- climate change- peak oil, energy prices

- food shortages and prices- water shortages and wars (Tibet / China)- new and old diseases, pandemics- social unrest /terrorism- increasing connectedness (globalisation, financial risk correlation)- increasing numbers of people with increasing aspirations

Page 3: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

“Rising Above The Gathering Storm” (USA Academies 2008)

- the need for investment in science and innovation

Page 4: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

less and less room to manoeuvre

more and more need for ability to absorb shocks – for resilience

Page 5: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

Resilience “the ability of a system to absorb disturbance and re-organise so as to retain the same structure, function, feedbacks and identity”

Page 6: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

resilience places an emphasis on the limits to change

it puts a focus on thresholds (tipping points) between alternate states, or ‘regimes’, of a system

Page 7: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.
Page 8: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

the water table rises as trees are cleared

a threshold occurs at a depth of 2m

Page 9: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

bio

ph

ysic

al

Water table depth

Area salinized Riverine ecosystem condition

Native veg cover and biodiversity

eco

no

mic

Farm financial viability Size of dairy & fruit

processing sectors

Water infrastructure state

soci

al

Values (e.g. environment vs. agriculture) – water allocations

Farm/ landscape Landscape/catchment Region/ nation Shocks and slow drivers

climate change

long run energy cost

technology

markets

population (demand)

diseases

governance

Tree cover and water table equilibrium (E/T)

9 thresholds in the Goulburn-Broken catchment

Page 10: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

- the cost of maintaining resilience vs. the cost of not maintaining it

resilience vs. efficiency

- ‘specified’ (targeted) resilience, vs. ‘general’ resilience

Applying a resilience approach

- resilience is maintained by probing its boundaries

Page 11: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

what determines resilience?

- diversity - modularity- tightness of feedbacks- openness – immigration, inflows, outflows- reserves and other reservoirs (memory,

seedbanks, nutrient pools)- overlapping governance/institutions

Page 12: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

The Longford gas explosion

in Shepparton:25 million litres of milk poured away- no alternate power source for pasteurisation machinery (no “response diversity”)

Page 13: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

“resilience” –

“adaptability” – capacity to manage resilience; avoid thresholds(leadership, trust, ‘social capital’, governance)

Page 14: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

if a shift into a “bad” state has happened, or is inevitable, the only option is transformation

“transformability” - capacity to transform into a different kind of system; a new way of living, and making a living

(the first rule of holes!)

Page 15: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

determinants of transformability

- preparedness to change - capacity to change- options for change

Page 16: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

Where do we need to enhance resilience of existing systems?

Where do we need to transform?

Page 17: A resilience approach to the future Brian Walker.

A resilience approach to the future

- don’t aim for some “optimal” state- learn about thresholds and aim to avoid them- let the system self-organise within the range of acceptable states (‘command-and-control’ doesn’t work for very long)- maintain general resilience and embrace change- promote and sustain diversity, of all kinds- restrict control of environmental and ecological variability- be ready for and capable of transformational change- encourage learning, innovation and experiments- beware of partial solutions!