A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is...

24
A PhD Story: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly. Pablo Vidales and Frank Stajano

Transcript of A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is...

Page 1: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

A PhD Story:The Good, The Bad and The Ugly.

Pablo Vidales and Frank Stajano

Page 2: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 1

Outline.

Before & after

PhD summary

Lessons

Advice

Conclusion

Questions

Page 3: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 2

Before & after.What changed?

•PhD finished in exactly 43 months

•Sixteen peer-reviewed publications

•Over 20 talks

•Collaborated with with UC3M, CMI, UPC, and CL-SRG

•Many other experiences

BEFORE AFTER

Page 4: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 3

PhD summary.Introduction.

•The dissertation was concerned with the design and implementation of a practical solution to support seamless mobility in future integrated heterogeneous networks.

Page 5: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 4

PhD summary.Thesis.

•Transparent migration of ongoing data flows between two access points belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, and tools and mechanisms for supporting this type of mobility should be placed within the next generation networking architectures.

Correspondent node

UMTS

hotspot

Mobile node

Page 6: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 5

PhD summary.Contributions.

•The design and deployment of an integration architecture that enables vertical handovers between the most popular wireless andwired technologies.

•A suite of Mobile IPv6 optimisation mechanisms.

•The design and implementation of a software solution to enable complete mobility support for nomadic users in 4G communication systems.

Page 7: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 6

PhD summary.Contributions.

•The design and deployment of an integration architecture that enables vertical handovers between the most popular wireless andwired technologies.

•A suite of Mobile IPv6 optimisation mechanisms.

•The design and implementation of a software solution to enable complete mobility support for nomadic users in 4G communication systems.

Page 8: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 7

PhD summary.Contributions.

•The design and deployment of an integration architecture that enables vertical handovers between the most popular wireless andwired technologies.

•A suite of Mobile IPv6 optimisation mechanisms.

•The design and implementation of a software solution to enable complete mobility support for nomadic users in 4G communication systems.

Page 9: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 8

PhD summary.Experimental Testbed.

4G system The Sentient Car

Page 10: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 9

PhD summary.Experimental Testbed.

Page 11: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 10

PhD summary.Basic MIPv6 protocol.

Page 12: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 11

PhD summary.MIPv6 optimisations.

•RA frequency

•RA caching

•BU simulcasting

•Soft-handover

Page 13: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 12

PhD summary.MIPv6 optimisations.

RA frequency

Discovery time is reduced, but there is a limit for each technology

RA Caching

Discovery time reduced to zero, but needs ubiquitous upper layer

BU simulcasting

Registration time reduced to 1.5 * RTT of fastest network, but requires anticipation

Soft handover

Packet losses reduced to ~ zero, but needs overlapping networks

It is the best option for Overlay Networks, but there are some details to be solved

Page 14: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 13

PhD summary.MIPv6 optimisations.

RA frequency

Discovery time is reduced, but there is a limit for each technology

RA Caching

Discovery time reduced to zero, but needs ubiquitous upper layer

BU simulcasting

Registration time reduced to 1.5 * RTT of fastest network, but requires anticipation

Soft handover

Packet losses reduced to ~ zero, but needs overlapping networks

It is the best option for Overlay Networks, but there are some details to be solved

Page 15: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 14

PhD summary.MIPv6 optimisations.

RA frequency

Discovery time is reduced, but there is a limit for each technology

RA Caching

Discovery time reduced to zero, but needs ubiquitous upper layer

BU simulcasting

Registration time reduced to 1.5 * RTT of fastest network, but requires anticipation

Soft handover

Packet losses reduced to ~ zero, but needs overlapping networks

It is the best option for Overlay Networks, but there are some details to be solved

Page 16: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 15

PhD summary.MIPv6 optimisations.

RA frequency

Discovery time is reduced, but there is a limit for each technology

RA Caching

Discovery time reduced to zero, but needs ubiquitous upper layer

BU simulcasting

Registration time reduced to 1.5 * RTT of fastest network, but requires anticipation

Soft handover

Packet losses reduced to ~ zero, but needs overlapping networks

It is the best option for Overlay Networks, but there are some details to be solved

Page 17: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 16

PhD summary.Autonomic solution.

Bringing together all relevant factors for handover decision-making, enabling “smart” context-aware roaming.

CONTEXTPolicy system

abstraction+Handling “BUTs”

Page 18: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 17

PhD summary.PROTON.

Network side Host side

Page 19: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 18

Lessons.The Good, the Bad and the Ugly.

•Very interesting learning process

•Publications (including conference trip)

•Development of self-motivation

•Nice to be called “Doctor”

Page 20: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 19

Lessons.The Good, the Bad and the Ugly.

•Working alone

•Too high personal expectations

•Lack of discussion

•Collaborations can go wrong

Page 21: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 20

Lessons.The Good, the Bad and the Ugly.

•When you don’t meet your supervisor for more than three consecutive months

•Skipping lab for more than five days without knowing why

•First paper rejected… no worries

•Second paper rejected… keep going

•Running out of funds… finish on time!

Page 22: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 21

Advice.Do and Don’t.

•Don’t disappear from the lab

•Don’t believe you know everything

•Don’t assume you have 4 years to finish your PhD

•Do look for discussion with your supervisor and peers

•Do try to meet your supervisor on a regular basis

•Do publish and try hard to do so

•Do look for fruitful collaborations, two heads are better than one (most of the time)

•Do build your personal network!

Page 23: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 22

Conclusion.

The PhD program is a long self-motivated process worth to pursuit. Sometimes you don’t think so. However, there are many rewards along the road to keep you going – just be careful to look for them and enjoy it.

Page 24: A PhD Story - University of Cambridge · belonging to independent heterogeneous technologies is achievable, ... the next generation networking architectures. ... •Don’t disappear

Konzernentwicklung · talk_lce2005_final.ppt 23

Questions.

Thank you

Please contact me if you want to do an internship

Email: Pablo.Vidales[at]telekom.de