A NEW CRITICISM STUDY ON PERSONIFICATION METAPHOR, … · 2019. 5. 17. · poetry. Poetry is the...
Transcript of A NEW CRITICISM STUDY ON PERSONIFICATION METAPHOR, … · 2019. 5. 17. · poetry. Poetry is the...
-
AMETA
A NEW CAPHOR, A
Prese
D
CRITICISAND SIM
AN UN
ented as Parfor the
USWStud
EPARTMEFAC
UNIVERS
SM STUDMILE IN S
NDERGRA
rtial Fulfilme Degree of S
in English
ByWATUN KHent Number
ENT OF ENCULTY OFSITAS SANYOGYAK
2019
Y ON PESMITH’S
ADUATE T
ment of the RSarjana SasLetters
HASANAHr: 15421410
NGLISH LF LETTERSNATA DHA
KARTA 9
ERSONIFS “YONOS
THESIS
Requirementstra
H 04
LETTERS S ARMA
ICATIONSA HOUS
ts
N, SE”
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
A NMETA
NEW CRAPHOR, A
Prese
D
RITICISMAND SIM
AN UN
ented as Parfor the
USWStud
EPARTMEFAC
UNIVERS
M STUDY MILE IN S
NDERGRA
rtial Fulfilme Degree of S
in English
By
WATUN KHent Number
ENT OF ENCULTY OFSITAS SANYOGYAK
2019
ii
ON PERSMITH’S
ADUATE T
ment of the RSarjana SasLetters
HASANAHr: 15421410
NGLISH LF LETTERSNATA DHA
KARTA 9
RSONIFICS “YONOS
THESIS
Requirementstra
H 04
LETTERSS ARMA
CATION, SA HOUS
ts
SE”
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
A NMETA
A.B. Sri MAdvisor
Drs. HirmaCo-Adviso
NEW CRAPHOR, A
Mulyani, M.A
awan Wijanor
A Sarjana
RITICISMAND SIM
USWStud
A., Ph.D.
narka, M.Hu
a Sastra Und
M STUDY MILE IN S
ByWATUN KHent Number
Approve
um.
iii
dergraduate
ON PERSMITH’S
HASANAHr: 15421410
ed by
Thesis
RSONIFICS “YONOS
H 04
CATION, SA HOUS
April 4
April 4
SE”
4, 2019
4, 2019
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
A NMETA
NEW CRAPHOR, A
A Sarjana
RITICISMAND SIM
USWStud
a Sastra Und
M STUDY MILE IN S
ByWATUN KHent Number
iv
dergraduate
ON PERSMITH’S
HASANAHr: 15421410
Thesis
RSONIFICS “YONOS
H 04
CATION, SA HOUS
SE”
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
I certify th
submitted
my knowle
any other p
thesis
April 3, 20
Uswatun K
hat this unde
for the awa
edge, this u
person exce
019
Khasanah
STATEM
ergraduate th
ard of any ot
undergradua
ept where du
MENT OF
hesis contain
ther degree
ate thesis co
ue reference
v
ORIGINAL
ns no mater
at any univ
ontains no m
e is made in
LITY
rial which h
versity, and
material pre
n the text of
has been prev
that, to the
viously wri
f the underg
viously
best of
itten by
raduate
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
LEMBA
Yang berta
NamNo
Demi penUniversita
A N
META
beserta pekepada Perdalam bemendistribuntuk kepmemberikapenulis.
Demikian
Dibuat di YPada tangg
Yang meny
Uswatun K
AR PERNYU
anda tangan
ma mor Mahas
ngembangans Sanata Dh
NEW CRAPHOR, A
rangkat yanrpustakaan Uentuk medbusikan secapentingan aan royalti k
pernyataan
Yogyakarta gal 3 April 2
yatakan,
Khasanah
YATAAN PEUNTUK K
n di bawah in
iswa
n ilmu penharma karya
RITICISMAND SIM
ng diperlukUniversitas dia lain, ara terbatas, akademis tkepada say
ini saya bua
2019
v
ERSETUJUKEPENTING
ni, saya mah
: Uswat: 15421
getahuan, sa ilmiah say
M STUDY MILE IN S
kan (bila adSanata Dhamengelolandan mempu
tanpa perlua selama te
at dengan se
vi
UAN PUBLGAN AKA
hasiswa Uni
tun Khasana14104
saya membya yang berju
ON PERSMITH’S
da). Denganarma hak unnya dalamublikasikannu meminta etap menca
ebenarnya
LIKASI KAADEMIS
iversitas San
ah
berikan kepudul
RSONIFICS “YONOS
n demikian ntuk menyimm bentuk nya di intern
ijin kepaantumkan n
ARYA ILM
nata Dharm
pada Perpus
CATION, SA HOUS
saya membmpan, meng
pangkalannet atau med
ada saya mnama saya s
MIAH
ma
stakaan
SE”
berikan alihkan
n data, dia lain maupun sebagai
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
vii
The more you like yourself,
the less you are like anyone else,
which makes you unique.
- Walt Disney -
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
viii
For
my beloved parents, my dear husband,
my fabulous best friends, and for all
who never get tired of supporting me
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
ix
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
First of all, I want to send my gratitude to Allah SWT for giving me grace and
guidance so that I can finish writing this undergraduate thesis well. I also want to
send my gratitude to my father and mother who tirelessly encouraged me. I dedicate
the results of this effort to my beloved father and mother. I would also say thank you
to my husband, Bang Olliz, who always accompanied me staying up while snacking
late at night working on this undergraduate thesis. I also say thank you to my brothers
and sister, Mas Esan, Oman, Okim, 'Ayni, and Dauz, for their greatest support in my
life.
Furthermore, I want to send my gratitude to my academic advisors, FX.
Risang Baskara, M.Hum. and Dr. Bernardine Ria Lestari for giving me
encouragement to be a better person. Then, I also want to send my gratitude to my
thesis advisor, A.B. Sri Mulyani, M.A., Ph.D., for her patience in giving guidance
and assisting in writing this undergraduate thesis, so I can finish it well. I would
thank my co-advisor, Drs. Hirmawan Wijanarka, M.Hum., for all corrections and
suggestions given to me in order to improve the writing of my undergraduate thesis.
Last but not least, I want to say thank you to my friends of Geng Micin:
Vatma, Putri, Ayu, Mitha, and Widi who always brighten my days during my college
life. Without you, my college life feels boring. Finally, I also thank the parties that I
cannot mention one by one who have helped me in the process of completing this
undergraduate thesis. May Allah SWT repay all of your kindness.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
x
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TITLE PAGE ........................................................................................... ii APPROVAL PAGE ................................................................................. iii ACCEPTANCE PAGE ............................................................................ iv STATEMENT OF ORIGINALITY ....................................................... v LEMBAR PERNYATAAN PERSETUJUAN PUBLIKASI KARYA ILMIAH ....................................................................................... vi MOTTO PAGE ........................................................................................ vii DEDICATION PAGE .............................................................................. viii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ....................................................................... ix TABLE OF CONTENTS ......................................................................... x LIST OF TABLES ................................................................................... xii ABSTRACT .............................................................................................. xiii ABSTRAK .................................................................................................. xiv CHAPTER I: INTRODUCTION ........................................................... 1
A. Background of the Study ................................................................ 1 B. Problem Formulation ..................................................................... 3 C. Objectives of the Study .................................................................. 3 D. Definition Terms ............................................................................ 3
CHAPTER II: REVIEW OF LITERATURE ....................................... 4 A. Review of Related Studies ............................................................. 4 B. Review of Related Theories ........................................................... 7
1. Personification ......................................................................... 7 2. Metaphor .................................................................................. 8 3. Simile ....................................................................................... 9 4. Denotative and Connotative Meaning ...................................... 10 5. New Criticism Study ................................................................ 11
C. Theoretical Framework .................................................................. 14
CHAPTER III: METHODOLOGY ....................................................... 17 A. Object of the Study ........................................................................ 17 B. Approach of the Study ................................................................... 19 C. Method of the Study ....................................................................... 19
CHAPTER IV: ANALYSIS RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS ......................................................................................... 22
A. The Explication of Smith’s “Yonosa House” ................................ 22 1. The Text .................................................................................. 23 2. The Summary .......................................................................... 24
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
xi
3. The Form ................................................................................. 25 4. The Language .......................................................................... 32
B. Uncovering Personification, Metaphor, and Simile Presented in Smith’s “Yonosa House” ............................................ 36 1. Personification ......................................................................... 36 2. Metaphor .................................................................................. 45 3. Simile ....................................................................................... 46
C. The Overall Meaning of Smith’s “Yonosa House” Based on Personification, Metaphor, and Simile Presented in it ................................................................................. 49 1. Meaning by Personification .................................................... 49 2. Meaning by Metaphor ............................................................. 50 3. Meaning by Simile .................................................................. 50 4. Meaning by Personification, Metaphor, and
Simile ....................................................................................... 51
CHAPTER V: CONCLUSION ............................................................... 52
REFERENCES ......................................................................................... 54
APPENDIX ............................................................................................... 57
Smith’s “Yonosa House” Summary Table .......................................... 57
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
xii
LIST OF TABLES
No. Table Page
1. Table 1. List of Alliteration .............................................................. 29 2. Table 2. List of Assonance ................................................................ 29 3. Table 3. List of Consonance ............................................................. 30 4. Table 4. List of Personification ........................................................ 32 5. Table 5. List of Metaphor ................................................................. 33 6. Table 6. List of Simile ...................................................................... 33 7. Table 7. List of Visual Imagery ........................................................ 34 8. Table 8. List of Auditory Imagery .................................................... 34 9. Table 9. List of Olfactory Imagery ................................................... 35 10. Table 10. List of Tactile Imagery ..................................................... 35 11. Table 11. List of Subjective Imagery ............................................... 35 12. Table 12. List of Symbols ................................................................. 35
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
xiii
ABSTRACT
KHASANAH, USWATUN. (2019). A New Criticism Study on Personification, Metaphor, and Simile in Smith’s “Yonosa House”. Yogyakarta: Department of English Letters, Faculty of Letters, Universitas Sanata Dharma.
“Yonosa House” is a poem that tells about the life of an old woman of
Tuscarora (American Indian), Yonosa. It describes Yonosa as a strong woman who keeps the tradition of her ethnic. The researcher’s reason for choosing Smith’s “Yonosa House” is to find personification, metaphor, and simile as shown in the poem. Moreover, it can be used to analyze the overall meaning of the poem.
From the problem formulation of this study, there are two objectives of the study. The first is to find out personification, metaphor, and simile presented in Smith’s “Yonosa House”. The second is to find the overall meaning of Smith’s “Yonosa House” based on personification, metaphor, and simile presented in it.
Furthermore, in the analysis the researcher uses two kinds of resources, the primary and secondary source. The main source is the poem “Yonosa House” written by Smith. The secondary sources are the references from books, articles, and sites from internet that support the analysis. Related to the focus of the study, the researcher uses New Criticism to help the analysis. Thus, the researcher applies four theories to answer the problem formulation such as theory of personification, metaphor, simile, and connotative and denotative meaning.
This study concludes that based on the analysis of the personification, metaphor, and simile in Smith’s “Yonosa House”, the overall meaning of the poem is about the body of Yonosa, a grandmother, that houses all the things worth living for, the values that she shares for her descendants and the people of the tribe: artistry, craftsmanship, loving activity, attunements to nature, living out the mythologies, and being at one with culture and history.
Keywords: personification, metaphor, simile, Yonosa House
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
xiv
ABSTRAK
KHASANAH, USWATUN. (2019). A New Criticism Study on Personification, Metaphor, and Simile in Smith’s “Yonosa House”. Yogyakarta: Program Studi Sastra Inggris, Fakultas Sastra, Universitas Sanata Dharma. "Yonosa House" adalah sebuah puisi yang menceritakan tentang kehidupan seorang wanita tua Tuscarora (Indian Amerika), Puisi tersebut menggambarkan bahwa Yonosa adalah wanita yang kuat yang menjaga tradisi etnisnya. Alasan peneliti untuk memilih "Yonosa House" milik Smith adalah untuk menemukan personifikasi, metafora, dan simile seperti yang ditunjukkan dalam puisi itu. Selain itu, hal tersebut dapat digunakan untuk menganalisis makna puisi secara keseluruhan.
Dari rumusan masalah penelitian ini, ada dua tujuan dilaksanakannya penelitian ini. Yang pertama adalah untuk menemukan personifikasi, metafora, dan perumpamaan yang disajikan dalam “Yonosa House” Smith. Yang kedua adalah menemukan makna keseluruhan "Yonosa House" milik Smith berdasarkan personifikasi, metafora, dan perumpamaan yang disajikan di dalamnya.
Selanjutnya, dalam analisisnya peneliti menggunakan dua jenis sumber, sumber primer dan sekunder. Sumber utamanya adalah puisi “Yonosa House" yang ditulis oleh Smith. Sumber sekundernya adalah referensi dari buku, artikel, dan situs dari internet yang mendukung analisis. Terkait dengan fokus penelitian, peneliti menggunakan pendekatan New Criticism untuk membantu analisis. Dengan demikian, peneliti menerapkan empat teori untuk menjawab rumusan masalah seperti teori personifikasi, metafora, simile, dan makna konotatif dan denotatif.
Studi ini menyimpulkan bahwa berdasarkan analisis personifikasi, metafora, dan simile dalam “Yonosa House” milik Smith, makna keseluruhan puisi itu adalah tentang tubuh Yonosa, seorang nenek, yang menampung semua hal yang layak untuk dijalani, nilai-nilai yang ia ajarkan kepada keturunan serta orang-orang di sukunya: kesenian, keahlian, aktivitas penuh kasih, penyesuaian dengan alam, menghayati mitologi, dan menyatu dengan budaya dan sejarah. Kata kunci: personifikasi, metafora, simile, Yonosa House
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
1
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
A. Background of the Study
Literature is something in printed-form that people can read, enjoy,
appreciate, and even criticize it (Wellek & Warren, 1992, p. 20). Literature is usually
the product of a mysterious inner compulsion combined with fully conscious
discipline (Hogins, 1975, p. 28). Literature has form, beauty in expression, and
intellectual as well as emotional appeal (Hogins, 1975, p. 28). Therefore, literature
can be described as works that contain aesthetic qualities.
The genre of literature is enormously varied. One of examples of literature is
poetry. Poetry is the process of creating a literary work by using imagery, figurative
language, and forms (Parini, 1987, p. 2). Moreover, the result of the process is called
poem.
To read a poem well, to enjoy it, and to judge its worth fairly is no mean feat. Poetry is demanding, and those who would learn to read it well must pay close attention to the words on the page, their full meaning and context (Parini, 1987, p. 2) A poem entitled “Yonosa House” is a poem that tells about the life of an old
woman of Tuscarora (American Indian), Yonosa. Yonosa is illustrated as a strong
woman who keeps the tradition of her ethnic.
The researcher’s reason for choosing Smith’s “Yonosa House” is to find
personification, metaphor, and simile as shown in the poem. The personification,
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
2
metaphor, and simile are parts of figurative language. Figurative language relies on
the coexistence of meanings, that is, the incongruity of meaning in two layers, one is
literal, and the other is pretense (Jay, 2003, p. 325). Personification allows physical
object to be specified as being a human (Lakoff & Johnson, 2003, p. 33). Parini
(1987) explains that metaphor is a comparison that suggests that one thing is similar
to another (p. 36). Moreover, if the word like is actually used, the comparison is
called simile (Parini, 1987, p. 36).
In this study, the researcher uses New Criticism to do the analysis of Smith’s
“Yonosa House”. New Criticism focuses only to the literary work itself to find its
meaning. According to New Criticism, people should look at the ways in which a
text’s literary language operates to create a complex meaning that can stand on its
own as an object of art (Tyson, 2011, p. 39). In New Criticism, unity is considered as
the prominent quality of a literary text. When a text has unity, what it means cannot
be separated from how it means (Tyson, 2011, p. 43). By selecting New Criticism to
study on personification, metaphor, and simile as the main topic, the researcher
believes that this research can be used not only by readers but also all learners in
understanding the meanings and messages of the poem. Furthermore, by
understanding every line of the poem, readers will get the meaning of the poem
easier. This research also can be helpful for other researchers who have similar
interest, especially in analyzing personification, metaphor, and simile.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
3
B. Problem Formulation
Based on the aims of the study, the problem formulation is formulated as
follows:
1. What are personification, metaphor, and simile presented in Smith’s “Yonosa
House”?
2. What is the poem’s overall meaning based on personification, metaphor, and
simile presented in Smith’s “Yonosa House”?
C. Objectives of the Study
The aim of the study is to find out personification, simile, and metaphors in
Smith's “Yonosa House”. Moreover, it helps to find the overall meaning of the poem
as the personification, simile, and metaphor found.
D. Definition of Terms
There are some terms need to be explained in analyzing Smith's “Yonosa
House” to avoid misunderstanding and give clear explanation. The terms are
personification, metaphor, and simile.
A personification allows physical object to be specified as being a human
(Lakoff & Johnson, 2003, p. 33). Parini (1987) describes metaphor as a comparison
that suggests that one thing is similar to another (p. 36). Moreover, if the word like is
actually used, the comparison is called simile (Parini, 1987, p. 36).
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
4
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
A. Review of Related Studies
The present study discusses about a poem entitled “Yonosa House” written by
Smith. Since there is no single study that discuss about the work of Smith’s “Yonosa
House”, therefore the researcher chooses related studies that have similarities with the
present study in the matter of the topic and approach used. In this chapter, the
researcher uses three previous studies that apply the theory of figurative language,
denotative meaning, and connotative meaning in finding the meaning of particular
literary work. All the studies have different object of studies, but similar aims with
the present study, which are analyze a literary work and find the meaning of the
literary work. Thus, the three related studies are an undergraduate thesis conducted by
Listiani, a journal article conducted by Hayani, and a journal article conducted by
Yazdani.
The first related study is an undergraduate thesis conducted by Listiani in
2015. The title of the study is “An Analysis of Figurative Language Found on the
Song Lyric by Taylor Swift’s “Speak Now” Album”. The research problems of the
study are about the application of figurative language and its meaning in Taylor
Swift’s Speak Now album which contains 14 songs. The researcher uses two
approaches such as descriptive qualitative approach and the theory of figurative
language by Potter and Kennedy. The researcher finds 11 types of figurative
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
5
language. The most used type in the album based on her study is hyperbole. The
second type that is used the most is simile. Furthermore, the researcher finds 10
symbols, 8 personifications, 4 metaphors, 2 synecdoches, and 2 oxynomorons in her
analysis of Taylor Swift’s Speak Now album.
The second related study is a journal article conducted by Hayani. The title of
the study is ”Figurative Language on Maya Angelou Selected Poetries” compiled in
Script Journal Volume 1, Issue 2, October 2016. This study aimed to find out the
kinds of figurative language in the five selected poetries of Maya Angelou, the titles
are: Alone, Caged Bird, Old Folks Laugh, Phenomenal Woman, Still I Rise. The focus
of this study is figurative language which involves metaphor, personification,
hyperbole, simile, metonymy, synecdoche, irony, antithesis, symbolism, and paradox.
Qualitative approach with design of content analysis was used in this study.
The result of her study showed there were 40 sentences containing figurative
language in five selected poetries of Maya Angelou. They were: metaphor (13
sentences), personification (9 sentences), hyperbole (1 sentence), simile (8 sentences),
synecdoche (1 sentence), antithesis (1 sentence), symbolism (5 sentences), and
paradox (2 sentences). The researcher conclude, if the figurative language used by
Angelou to compare, or even symbolize the sentences to bring the meaning come up
with beautiful language. Mostly of her poetries told about her experience in the past
that rooted to history of the discrimination of American-African.
The third related study is a journal article conducted by Yazdani in 2011. The
title of the study is “The Use of Metaphors in Poetry and Organization Theory”
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
6
compiled in Iranian Journal of Management Studies, 4(2),63-78. The article
reinforces the views of contemporary writers of organization theory that the field
draws from multiple and diverse disciplines by highlighting the link between
organization theory and poetry through employing metaphoricity. The language of
poetry according to P. B. Shelley “is vitally metaphorical; that is, it marks the before
unapprehended relations of things and perpetuates their apprehensions”. This means
metaphors create new meanings and insights. They are used as a tool for revitalizing
the language. By recreating through employing metaphors the poet also restores
something old, ancient and lost (Hirsch as cited in Yazdani, 1999, p.14).
The approach that is used in this article is New Criticism approach that
focused on metaphor theory and organization theory. Thus, the discussion highlights
that both in poetry and organization theory, the metaphors have the theoretical and
practical potential to compare and contrast the ‘source’ (abstraction) with the ‘target’
(the actual organizational or social reality).
The present study of Smith’s “Yonosa House” is different from the previous
studies. The first difference is the object of the study. The second one is what the
researcher analyzes after finding the figurative language used in the poem such as
personification, metaphor, and simile. The analysis explains the whole meanings of
the poem based on the personification, metaphor, and simile presented in the poem.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
7
B. Review of Related Theories
There are some theories from some experts, books and journals resources in
the process of conducting this study. The researcher chooses five theories which are
connected to this research such as theory of personification, metaphor, simile,
denotative and connotative meaning, and New Criticism study.
1. Personification
Personification allows objects or things which are nonhuman entities to be
described as if they are alive and acting like human (Lakoff & Johnson, 2003, p. 33).
It is really a subtype of metaphor, an implied comparison in which the figurative term
of the comparison is always a human being (Arp & Johnson, 2009, p. 708). For
example, inflation is eating up our profits – that means the speaker is experiencing a
loss because of the inflation. This shows the inflation that actually is a nonhuman
entity is described as if it is able to do human activity which is eating. That
expression is classified as personification as a nonhuman entity has the ability to do
an activity like a person does (Lakoff & Johnson, 2003, pp. 33-34).
Personification differs in the degree to which it asks the reader actually to
visualize the literal term in human form (Arp & Johnson, 2009, p. 708). Arp and
Johnson (2009) give example autumn is sitting careless on a granary floor (p. 708). It
shows that the season is personified. The readers are asked to make a complete
identification of autumn with a human being (Arp & Johnson, 2009, p. 708). Then, in
the expression the startled little waves, a personification is barely suggested. Arp and
Johnson (2009) explain, the readers would make a mistake if they tried to visualize
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
8
the waves in human form or even, really, to think of them as having human emotions
(p. 708).
Abrams (1999) defines personification as inanimate object or an abstract
concept is spoken as though it were endowed with life or with human attributes or
feelings (compare pathetic fallacy) (p. 99). Abrams (1999) gives examples of
personification such as sky lowered, muttering thunder, and sad drops (p. 99). Those
personification show that the sky, thunder, and drops act as if they are able to do
human activities such as lowering, muttering, and being sad. In such a way, the
expressions are classified as personification.
2. Metaphor
Metaphor is a device of the poetic imagination and the rethorical flourish—a
matter of extraordinary rather than ordinary language (Lakoff & Johnson, 2003, p. 3).
In a metaphor, a word or expression that in literal usage denotes one kind of thing is
applied to a distinctly different kind of thing, without asserting a comparison
(Abrams, 1999, p. 97). Jay (2003) mentions that a metaphor makes an implicit
comparison between two concepts (p. 315). Through metaphor, the abstract and
confusing can be made more concrete and meaningful (Jay, 2003, p. 316). Thus, it
can be said that metaphor facilitates understanding.
One of metaphorical expressions in everyday language is ‘time is money’
(Lakoff & Johnson, 2003, p. 7). Jay (2003) explains that ‘time’ is difficult to be
understood because it has no concrete physical or spatial reality (p. 316). Time is
portrayed as a valuable commodity (Lakoff & Johnson, 2003, p. 8). Lakoff and
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
9
Johnson (2003) also mention that time is a limited resource that people use to
accomplish their goals (p. 8).
In our culture TIME IS MONEY in many ways: telephone message units, hourly wages, hotel room rates, yearly budgets, interest on loans, and paying your debt to society by “serving time”. These practices are relatively new in the history of the human race, and by no means do they exist in all cultures. They have arisen in modern industrialized societies and structure our basic everyday activities in a very profound way. Corresponding to the fact that we act as if time is a valuable commodity—a limited resource, even money—we conceive of time that way. Thus we understand and experience time as kind of thing that can be spent, wasted, budgeted, invested wisely or poorly, saved, or squandered (Lakoff & Johnson, 2003, p. 8).
3. Simile
Jay (2003) mentions that a simile makes an explicit comparison between two
concepts (p. 313). Usually, it uses like or as in comparing the two concepts (Jay,
2003, p. 315). Moreover, Arp and Johnson mention that besides like and as,
sometimes simile also uses word or phrase such as than, similar to, resembles, or
seems to compare things that essentially unlike (Arp & Johnson, 2009, p. 705).
Cigarettes are like a time bombs is one of expressions uses simile (Jay, 2003,
p. 316). The expression relates the understanding of one thing (cigarettes) to another
(time bombs) (Jay, 2003, 316). In fact, both cigarettes and time bombs are unlike
things. Nevertheless, they share certain similarity. Cigarettes are known that it is not
good for health. People who smoke cigarettes in a long period have big risks of lung
disease, heart disease, stroke, asthma, diabetes, and other chronic diseases. Thus,
smoking cigarettes can cause health to decline that leads to chronic diseases easily.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
10
The worse, this can lead to death anytime. It can be said that excessive smoking
cigarettes looks like counting down the coming of death.
This condition is similar with time bombs. Time bombs are equipped with a
countdown device. It will explode when the time is up and it can kill people if it
explodes near the crowd. Thus, cigarettes and time bombs share similarity in
approaching or causing damage that leads to death.
4. Denotative and Connotative Meaning
In communication, people use two ways to interact each other which are
denotative and connotative way. Denotative is the literal meaning that is used when
people write, say, or deliver their messages. People say directly what they actually
want to say. Meanwhile, in connotative way, people do not directly write or say what
they want. There must be messages, implied meanings, or something behind
sentences or utterances. In this research, the researcher analyzes what are the
meanings behind the selected poem, Smith’s “Yonosa House”. Thus, it is important
to understand the difference between denotative and connotative and to understand
definition and how the concepts are used.
Jay (2003) mentions a word’s meaning in terms of its literal meaning or
denotation is actually similar with what people might find in a dictionary (p. 99).
Besides, words also have emotional overtones or connotations (Jay, 2003, p. 99).
Each denotation has a different connotation (Jay, 2003, p. 99).
Furthermore, Arp and Johnson (2009) give example of denotation and
connotation by word home (p. 674). The word home, for instance, by denotation
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
11
means only a place where one lives, but by connotation it suggests security, love,
comfort, and family (Arp & Johnson, 2009, p. 674). Another example, the words
childlike and childish both mean “characteristic of a child”, but childlike suggests
meekness, innocence, and wide-eyed wonder, while childish suggests pettiness,
willfulness, and temper tantrums (Arp & Johnson, 2009, p. 674).
Arp and Johnsons (2003) mention that connotation is very important in
poetry, for it is one of the means by which the poet can concentrate or enrich meaning
–say more in fewer words (p. 674).
5. New Criticism Study
According to New Criticism, we should look at the ways in which a text’s
literary language operates to create a complex meaning that can stand on its own as
an object of art (Tyson, 2011, p. 39). Some notable members who apply New
Criticism are John Crow Ransom, William Empson, T. S. Eliot, Allen Tate, I. A.
Richards, Cleanth Brooks, and Kenneth Burke (Hogins, 1975, p. 889). Hogins (1975)
states that most of these critics have concentrated on the criticism of poetry, but
Kenneth Burke has gone on to construct an entire philosophy of language and usage
(p. 889).
The New Critics sought precision and structural tightness in the literary work; they favored a style and tone that tended toward irony; they insisted on the presence within the work of everything necessary for its analysis; and they called for an end to a concern by critics and teachers of English with matters outside the work itself—the life of the author, the history of her or his times, or the social and economic implications of the literary work. In short, they turned the attention of teachers, students, critics, and readers to the essential matter: what the work says and how it says it as inseparable issues (Guerin et al, 2011, p. 79).
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
12
Perharps the most important recent school of criticism—and the one that has
produced the greatest number of influential critics—is New Criticism (Hogins, 1975,
p. 888). By the 1950s, New Criticism had become the dominant critical system in
such influential journals as Sewanee Review, The Kenyon Review, The Southern
Review, and The Hudson Review and in college and university English departments
(Guerin et al, 2011, p. 79). Furthermore, Hogins (1975) states that New Criticism
believes in appraising each work without regard to its origin or social value (p. 888).
It means that New Criticism is concerned only with the intrinsic worth of the work
itself such as style, language, structure, meter, and metaphor; they discuss the purpose
and effectiveness of the devices used and the levels of meaning and symbolism
(Hogins, 1975, pp. 888-889).
Just as a great painting is a complex art object made of a unique combination
of paints on canvas, a literary text is a complex art object made of language (Tyson,
2011, p. 39). Therefore, in order to understand a literary text, we need to understand
the complex workings of the unique combination of words—and other literary
devices, or techniques—of which it is made (Tyson, 2011, p. 39). We can begin to
apply New Criticism by asking such question as: What reality or experience does the
selection try to communicate? What methods or devices are used? Are they effective?
How well does the work succeed in communicating the experience? (Hogins, 1975, p.
889). In fact, New Criticism insists on textual evidence (Tyson, 2011, p. 40). Thus, an
effective way to deepen our appreciation of literature and improve our ability to
interpret it is by gaining a more thorough knowledge of how to analyze textual
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
13
evidence—of how to analyze the language of which a literary text is made (Tyson,
2011, p. 39).
Moreover, New Criticism has four basic concepts to support the literary
interpretation such as theme, formal elements, unity, and close reading and textual
evidence. New Criticism believes that a great literary work has a theme that
contributes to our understanding of what it means to be human (Tyson, 2011, p. 41).
Theme refers to the content of a literary work—what the work means, while form
refers to the literary devices and language, or formal elements, used to get that
meaning across (Tyson, 2011, p. 41). The literary devices are important to get the
understanding of how literary work communicates its theme (Tyson, 2011, p. 41).
Later on, Tyson (2011) states that some of the literary devices that can be found in a
literary text are tension, ambiguity, imagery, symbol, metaphor, and simile (pp. 41-
43).
New Criticism considered unity, or what they called organic unity, the most
important quality of literary text (Tyson, 2011, p. 43). A text has unity when its
theme and formal elements work together as an inseparable whole (Tyson, 2011, p.
41). Then, the last basic concept of New Criticism as mentioned by Tyson is close
reading and textual evidence. Close reading consists of careful attention to every
aspect of a literary work, including and especially to the text’s formal elements
(Tyson, 2011, p. 44). It is done to accurately and meaningfully interpret the text: to
determine the text’s theme, as we see it, and to show how all the characters, plot
events, settings, images, and other formal elements contribute to that theme (Tyson,
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
14
2011, p. 44). Moreover, close reading is how people provide thorough, detailed
textual evidence to support the interpretation of a literary text (Tyson, 2011, p. 44).
In the final analysis by applying New Criticism, people will have to learn to
make their own judgments. As Auden says:
The one thing I most emphatically do not ask of a critic is that he tell me what. I ought to approve of or condemn. I have no objection to his telling me what works and authors he likes and dislikes; indeed, it is useful to know this for, from his expressed preferences about works which I have read, I learn how likely I am to agree or disagree with his verdicts on works which I have not. But let him not dare to lay down the law to me. The responsibility for what I choose to read is mean, and nobody else on earth can do it for me (Hogins, 1975, p. 891).
C. Theoretical Framework
The focus of the study is to uncover personification, simile, and metaphors in
Smith's “Yonosa House”. Moreover, it helps to find the overall meaning of the poem
as the personification, simile, and metaphor found. In this section, the researcher
discusses the theories that have been mentioned previously and their contribution in
answering the research questions in the previous chapter. The first question concerns
on personification, metaphor and simile that presented in Smith’s “Yonosa House”.
The second question concerns on the poem’s overall meaning based on
personification, metaphor, and simile as presented in the poem. Moreover, the
researcher applies the theory of personification, metaphor, and simile to answer the
first research question.
The theory of personification used is taken from Lakoff and Johnson. The
theory of personification is required to determine which one of the expressions in the
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
15
poem that convey connotative meaning about nonhuman objects are described as if it
has human characteristics. Furthermore, the theory of metaphor used is also taken
from Lakoff and Johnson. The theory of metaphor is required to determine which one
of expressions in the poem that convey connotative meaning about the comparison
between two things. Meanwhile, the theory of simile used is taken from Jay. Simile
is part of metaphor. Thus, the theory of simile is almost similar with the theory of
metaphor. The theory of simile is required to determine which one of expressions in
the poem that convey connotative meaning about the comparison between two things
by using the word ‘like’ or ‘as’. New Criticism taken from Tyson is applied in finding
the all personification, metaphor, and simile in the poem.
After that, the researcher answers the second research question about the
poem’s overall meaning of Smith’s “Yonosa House”. The researcher applies the
theory of denotative and connotative meaning by Arp and Johnson to find the
meaning of the poem. The theories of denotative and connotative meaning are
required to find the actual meaning of the expressions in the poem.
The theoretical framework to study based on the review in the proceeding
sections is synthesized and displayed in the following figure:ons is synthesized
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
16
The theoretical framework to study based on the review in the proceeding
sections is synthesized and displayed in the following figure:ons is synthesized and
displayed in the following figure:
Figure 1. The Theoretical Framework
Types of figurative
language:
Personification
Metaphor
Simile
Theories from Lakoff and
Johnson (1980)
Theories from Jay (2003)
Poem
Smith’s
“Yonosa
House”
Denotative and
connotative meaning
Theories from Arp and
Johnson (2003)
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
17
CHAPTER III
METHODOLOGY
A. Object of the Study
Smith’s “Yonosa House” is the object of the present study. The poet, Smith,
wrote “Yonosa House” when he was in graduate school, on a wintry Saturday
evening in Boone, N. C., in 1975, before he rode his little Yamaha to sit in the sound
booth of the local theater and eat popcorn while talking about Chaucer with the
projectionist as a congregation of costumers watched the late night movie. It was
published shortly afterward by Sanskrit, the magazine at UNCC, where he had taken
his undergraduate degree in philosophy in 1969, little thinking of his Native
American lineage or of the fairly folksy ways he had adopted as near-feral child in
Griffin, Georgia. Joe Bruchac republished it in his anthology Songs from the Turtle’s
Back, and before long it had weaseled its way into Norton’s New Worlds of Literature
and then into their Literature of the American South.
Smith included “Yonosa House” in his initial volume, Waking Under Snow
which is basically his M. A. thesis from Appalachian State University, but he has also
included it in The Cardinal Heart (Livingston University, 1991) and Split the Lark:
Selected Poems (Salmon Publishing/ Ireland, 1999). Smith’s “Yonosa House” is a
poem about a grandmother called “Yonosa House” who teaches her grandchild,
phrases which represent or address what people enthusiastically call “the natural
world”, which owes not a little romantic constructions and literary projections, but
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
18
which still insists on thingness, on beings whose beauty, at least, is linked to their
capacity to surprise people. Yonosa, like so many of her survival skills (and naming
things correctly is not the least of these), resists absorption into a culture that would
declare her woodcraft obsolete. And yet the grandchild embraces the carving, the
litany, the seemingly secular communion. The grandchild accepts the premise that
“the mountain is holy”, perharps that is “holier” than the Baptist churchyard.
R. T. Smith was born in Washington, D. C., in 1947, and he was raised in
Georgia and North Carolina. He is the author of numerous poetry collections,
including In the Night Orchard: New and Selected Poems (Texas Review Press,
2014) and Outlaw Style (University of Arkansas Press, 2007) and Messenger
(Louisiana State University Press, 2001), which both received a Library of Virginia
Annual Literary Award. He is also the author of the short story collection Faith
(River City Publishing, 1995), and he co-edited Common Wealth: Contemporary
Poets of Virginia (University of Virginia Press, 2003) with Sarah Kennedy.
Smith has received fellowships and grants from Arts International, the
National Endowment for the Arts, and the Virginia Commission for the Arts, and in
2013 he received the Carole Weinstein Prize in Poetry from the Library of Virginia.
He has previously taught at Appalachian State University and Auburn University,
where he co-edited Southern Humanities Review. He currently serves as the writer-in-
residence at Washington and Lee University, where he edits Shenandoah.
In this research, the book where the poem “Yonosa House” compiled that the
researcher uses is R.T. Smith Greatest Hits: 1975—2001 written by R.T. Smith,
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
19
published in 2002. The researcher reason in choosing this book is because it is the
latest poetry collections written and compiled by Smith that republish “Yonosa
House”. The book consists of 37 pages. Moreover, the poem “Yonosa House” is in
the page 13. The poem consists of 30 lines of 5 stanzas.
B. Approach of the Study
In analyzing Smith’s “Yonosa House”, the researcher applies New Criticism
as the basis of the analysis. New Criticism is used to find the intrinsic elements of
literary work without any influence outside the literary work itself. This approach
leads to find the interpretation towards the intricacy of a literary work. The researcher
uses New Criticism to find out certain figurative languages presented in Smith’s
“Yonosa House” that later on it helps the researcher find the overall meaning of the
poem.
By using this approach, the researcher finds out how New Criticism becomes
the most suitable approach for the study, because New Criticism makes the researcher
focus only to the poem in order to make a detail analysis towards the poem. Thus,
New Criticism helps the development of the analysis reveal the unity of meaning of
Smith’s “Yonosa House” based on figurative languages presented in it.
C. Method of the Study
This study is based on library research for the sources of this study are books,
journals, and articles in the form either printed or not printed from library and
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
20
internet. The data is combined to help the analysis of the study that finally it is
written into an undergraduate thesis. The primary source of the study is the poem
Smith’s “Yonosa House” compiled in R.T. Smith Greatest Hits: 1975—2001 written
by R.T. Smith. Moreover, the secondary sources that become the most important
sources in this study are Lakoff and Johnson’s Methapors We Live By, Jay’s The
Psychology of Language, Arp and Johnson’s Literature Structure, Sound, and Sense,
Tyson’s Using Critical Theory, Guerin et al’s A Handbook of Critical Approaches to
Literature, and Parini’s An Invitation to Poetry.
Furthermore, there are some steps taken in the analysis. The first step was
close reading towards the poem of Smith’s “Yonosa House” as the primary object of
the study for several times to gain understanding about the poem and to find the main
data that related with the research. In analyzing the problem of the study, the
researcher focused in figurative languages presented in the poem. The second step,
the researcher formulated some questions based on the part that the writer interested
most. To help providing the answer of the problem formulation, the researcher used
some theories from several books after collecting the data from the primary source.
The third step was answer the first problem formulation, what are
personification, metaphor, and simile presented in Smith’s “Yonosa House” by using
the theory of figurative language. Then, from the evidences of all data that the
researcher had to answer the first problem formulation, the researcher found the key
point to answer the last problem formulation. The researcher analyzed the overall
meaning of Smith’s “Yonosa House” based on figurative languages found in the
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
21
poem. The last step of the analysis, the researcher draw a conclusion based on the
result of the research from the chapter one until chapter four.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
22
CHAPTER IV
ANALYSIS
Before analyzing the two questions in problem formulation, the researcher
provides the explication of the poem Smith’s “Yonosa House” in the first subchapter.
The explication consists of the text, summary, the form, and language used in the
poem in order to get insightful thought about the unity of the poem that later on it
helps to facilitate answering the two questions of problem formulation. In the second
subchapter, it is about the analysis of personification, metaphor, and simile found in
Smith’s “Yonosa House”. Then, in the third subchapter, it is about the analysis of the
overall meaning of Smith’s “Yonosa House” in relation with personification,
metaphor, and simile presented in the poem.
A. The Explication of Smith’s “Yonosa House”
This part is divided into four subparts. The first subpart aims to reveal the text
of the poem Smith’s “Yonosa House”. The poem consists of 5 stanzas. There are 6
lines in the first stanza, 10 lines in the second stanza, 4 lines in the third stanza, 8
lines in the forth stanza, and 2 lines in the fifth stanza. Overall, the poem has 30 lines
from the first stanza until the last stanza. The second subpart aims to summarize the
poem as a whole. The summary is useful to gain well-understanding about the matters
mentioned in the poem. The third subpart aims to reveal the form of the poem. Then,
the forth subpart aims to reveal the language of the poem.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
23
1. The Text
Yonosa House
She stroked molten tones From the heart-carved dulcimer And sat like a stately sack of bones Withered within coarse skin, Rocking to corn chants, snake 5 Songs, the music of passing seasons.
Her old woman’s Tuscarora hair Hung like waxed flax ready to spin Till she wove and knotted it To lie like ropes on her shoulders. 10 Through my young mind she wove The myths of her race In fevered patterns, feather colors: Sound of snow, kiss of rock, The feel of bruised birch bark, 15 The call of the circling hawk.
Her knotted hands showing slow blue rivers Trembled through cornbread frying, Pressed fern patterns on butter pats, Brewed sassafras tea in the hearth. 20
They buried Yonosa in a deerskin skirt, Ribbons and braids, but featherless. I cut hearts in her coffin lid, Wind-slain maple like the dulcimer. The mountain was holy enough for her. 25 We kept our word and raised no stone. She sank like a root into Georgia clay. No Baptist chruchyard caught her bones.
I thank her hands when the maples turn. I hear her voice in the thrush’s song. 30
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
24
2. The Summary
The poem of Smith’s “Yonosa House” dramatizes the conflict between
appearance and reality, particularly as this conflict relates to what the speaker (I)
seems to say and what I really says. The speaker looks at his or her grandma named
Yonosa and explains that she is such an inspiring person. In the first stanza, the
speaker notes that Yonosa loves music, and then points to several specific objects
such as “tones, dulcimer, chants, songs, and music” (1-6). After describing one of
Yonosa’s favorite things, in the second stanza he asserts that Yonosa likes to share
the mythologies of the tribe who lives close to nature by mentioning several natural
objects like “feather, snow, rock, birch bark, and hawk” (13-16).
Moreover, in the third stanza, the speaker illustrates that Yonosa likes doing
activities in the kitchen, and he mentions several things in the kitchen such as
“cornbread frying, butter pats, and sassafras tea” (18-20). After describing of all
Yonosa does, that actually reveals the speaker’s deep feeling of loving his grandma,
in the forth stanza, the speaker notes the burial of Yonosa after her death. Finally, in
the fifth stanza, the speaker sends his gratitude for Yonosa at last for everything she
taught for the speaker during her lifetime. The speaker seems to say simply that
Yonosa houses anything the speaker needs for life, especially her lore and exemplary.
However, the poem begins with several oddities that suggest the speaker is
saying more than what he seems to say initially. For example, the poem has no rhyme
(free verse). Thus, Smith’s “Yonosa House” can be classified into modern poetry for
it does not follow the strict requirements of traditional meter and rhyme that makes
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
25
the poem has no regular or predictable rhyme. Usually, something that has regular
pattern is intentionally made to create balance or beauty. Meanwhile, something that
has irregular pattern is usually naturally formed. Thus, the irregularity emphasizes the
idea of nature. Hence, the irregular rhyme of the poem actually shows that it has
strong relation to nature. Meaning to say, the poem mostly illustrates about nature.
Besides, the odd syntax continues when the natural objects are personified such as
“sound of snow, kiss of rock, the feel of bruised birch bark, and the call of the
circling hawk” (14-16).
Then, the poem reveals such a farewell statement: “she sank like a root into
Georgia clay” (27). In this line, Yonosa is portrayed like a root after the burial. In this
way, it reinforces the conflict between the appearance of Yonosa and what such a
scene and the speaker’s words actually reveal.
In short, the speaker notes about the memory about the grandma, Yonosa,
someone who inspires the speaker’s life. The speaker mentions several loving
activities as Yonosa does that shows the speaker’s deep feeling towards her. The
speaker sends gratitude to Yonosa for her lore and exemplary given. Moreover, as the
choice of words, the poem dramatizes the appearance of Yonosa beyond the reality.
3. The Form
In terms of form, Smith’s “Yonosa House” can be considered as a free verse
poem for it has no exact pattern of rhyme and the lines vary greatly in the number of
syllables, ranging from 5 (in the 1st line) to 11 (in the 21st line). The form contributes
to gain well understanding to the overall meaning because it reveals the meter and the
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
26
pattern of sound of the poem. As the meter is revealed, the speaker gets the image of
certain stressed pattern that leads to help the speaker to intonate the poem and avoid
misinterpretation. Then, the pattern of sound shows the artistic quality of the poem
through the rhyming words used. Furthermore, the next part will locate the meter and
the pattern of sound of Smith’s “Yonosa House”.
a. Meter
The meter pattern of Smith’s “Yonosa House” is trochee (one stressed
syllable is followed by one unstressed syllable). Some of lines have three feet
(trochee trimeter), four feet (trochee tetrameter), five feet (trochee pentameter), but
most of them do not have exact feet for they have odd number of syllables. In the
poem there are 5 lines of trochee trimeter, 8 lines of trochee tetrameter, 5 lines of
trochee pentameter, and 12 lines of no pattern. The meter of the poem can be seen as
follows.
She stroked molten tones
From the heart-carved dulcimer
And sat like a stately sack of bones
Withered within coarse skin,
Rocking to corn chants, snake 5
Songs, the music of passing seasons.
Her old woman’s Tuscarora hair
Hung like waxed flax ready to spin
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
27
Till she wove and knotted it
To lie like ropes on her shoulders. 10
Through my young mind she wove
The myths of her race
In fevered patterns, feather colors:
Sound of snow, kiss of rock,
The feel of bruised birch bark, 15
The call of the circling hawk.
Her knotted hands showing slow blue rivers
Trembled through cornbread frying,
Pressed fern patterns on butter pats,
Brewed sassafras tea in the hearth. 20
They buried Yonosa in a deerskin skirt,
Ribbons and braids, but featherless.
I cut hearts in her coffin lid,
Wind-slain maple like the dulcimer.
The mountain was holy enough for her. 25
We kept our word and raised no stone.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
28
She sank like a root into Georgia clay.
No Baptist chruchyard caught her bones.
I thank her hands when the maples turn.
I hear her voice in the thrush’s song. 30
b. Pattern of Sound
In terms of pattern of sound, Smith’s “Yonosa House” applies aural repetition
such as alliteration, assonance, and consonance. The consonance dominates the
pattern of sound in the poem instead of the alliteration and assonance. Moreover, the
alliteration, assonance, and consonance are identified as in the tables below.
No. Word/ Phrase of Alliteration Stanza Line 1 She stroked… 1 1 2 And sat like a stately sack… 1 3 3 Withered within… 1 4 4 Songs…seasons 1 6 5 Her…hair 2 7 6 To lie like… 2 10 7 Through my young mind… 2 11 8 In fevered…, feather… 2 13 9 Sound of snow… 2 14 10 …bruised birch bark 2 15 11 Her knotted hands… 3 17 12 Trembled trough… 3 18 13 Pressed fern patterns on butter pats 3 19 14 …braids, but… 4 22
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
29
No. Word/ Phrase of Alliteration Stanza Line 15 I cut…coffin lid 4 23 16 …holy…her 4 25 17 She sank… 4 27 18 …her hands… 4 28 19 I hear her… 5 30 Table 1. List of Alliteration Presented in “Yonosa House”
Table 2. List of Assonance Presented in “Yonosa House”
No. Word/ Phrase of Assonance Stanza Line 1 molten—tones 1 1 2 heart—carved 1 2 3 withered—within—skin 1 4 4 music—passing 1 6 5 lie—like 2 10 6 her—shoulders 2 10 7 my—mind 2 11 8 fevered—feather 2 13 9 call—hawk 2 16 10 her—knotted 3 17 11 showing—rivers 3 17 12 trembled—cornbread 3 18 13 patterns—pats 3 19 14 sassafras—hearth 3 20 15 in—deerskin 4 21 16 ribbons—featherless 4 22 17 in—coffin—lid 4 23 18 the—her 4 25 19 no—stone 4 26 20 root—into 4 27
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
30
No. Word/ Phrase of Consonance Stanza Line 1 stroked—molten—tones 1 1 2 molten—tones 1 1 3 from—dulcimer 1 2 4 heart—carved 1 2 5 and—bones 1 3 6 like—sack 1 3 7 sat—stately 1 3 8 withered—within 1 4 9 within—skin 1 4
10 withered—coarse 1 4 11 coarse—skin 1 4 12 rocking—corn—snake 1 5 13 rocking—corn 1 5 14 to—chants 1 5 15 corn—chants—snake 1 5 16 songs—music—passing—seasons 1 6 17 songs—passing 1 6 18 her—Tuscarora—hair 2 7 19 woman’s—Tuscarora 2 7 20 waxed—flax 2 8 21 and—knotted 2 9 22 knotted—it 2 9 23 ropes—her—shoulders 2 10 24 ropes—shoulders 2 10 25 myths—race 2 12 26 her—race 2 12 27 in—patterns 2 13 28 fevered—patterns—feather—colors 2 13 29 patterns—colors 2 13 30 sound—snow 2 14 31 sound—snow—kiss 2 14 32 kiss—rock 2 14 33 bruised—birch—bark 2 15
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
31
No. Word/ Phrase of Consonance Stanza Line 34 call—circling—hawk 2 16 35 call—circling 2 16 36 her—rivers 3 17 37 knotted—hands 3 17 38 hands—rivers 3 17 39 trembled—cornbread 3 18 40 trembled—through—cornbread—frying 3 18 41 pressed—patterns—pats 3 19 42 fern—patterns—on 3 19 43 patterns—butter—pats 3 19 44 brewed—sassafras—hearth 3 20 45 buried—deerskin 4 21 46 buried—deerskin—skirt 4 21 47 Yonosa—in—deerskin 4 21 48 Yonosa—deerskin—skirt 4 21 49 ribbons—braids—featherless 4 22 50 ribbons—braids—but 4 22 51 ribbons—and 4 22 52 ribbons—braids—featherless 4 22 53 cut—hearts 4 23 54 hearts—her 4 23 55 in—coffin 4 23 56 wind—slain 4 24 57 slain—maple—like—dulcimer 4 24 58 slain—dulcimer 4 24 59 maple—dulcimer 4 24 60 wind—dulcimer 4 24 61 mountain—enough 4 25 62 enough—for 4 25 63 our—word—raised 4 26 64 and—no—stone 4 26 65 raised—stone 4 26 66 word—and—raised 4 26 67 sank—like—clay 4 27 68 like—clay 4 27
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
32
Table 3. List of Consonance Presented in “Yonosa House”
4. The Language
The language used in Smith’s “Yonosa House” is everyday choice of words.
Nevertheless, those words convey connotative meaning. It means that the poem tends
to apply figurative language. There are three types of figurative language used in the
poem, such as personification, metaphor, and simile. The personification dominates
the language in the poem instead of the metaphor and simile. The personification,
metaphor, and simile presented in the poem can be seen in the tables as follows.
No. Sentence/ Phrase of Personification Stanza Line 1 She stroked molten tones 1 1 2 Sound of snow 2 14 3 kiss of rock 2 14 4 the feel of bruised birch bark 2 15 5 the call of the circling hawk 2 16
No. Word/ Phrase of Consonance Stanza Line 69 root—Georgia 4 27 70 root—into 4 27 71 no—bones 4 28 72 Baptist—caught 4 28 73 churchyard—her 4 28 74 Baptist—bones 4 28 75 hands—when—turn 5 29 76 hands—maples 5 29 77 her—turn 5 29 78 hear—her—thrush’s 5 30 79 voice—thrush’s—song 5 30
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
33
No. Sentence/ Phrase of Personification Stanza Line 6 No Baptist churchyard caught her bones 4 28 7 the maples turn 5 29 8 the thrush's song 5 30
Table 4. List of Personification Presented in “Yonosa House”
Table 5. List of Metaphor Presented in “Yonosa House”
Table 6. List of Simile Presented in “Yonosa House”
Furthermore, those figurative languages are discussed critically and
elaborately in the analysis. Then, still related to the language used, Smith’s “Yonosa
House” applies imagery and symbols. The identification of it is explained as follows.
a. Imagery
The imagery presents in Smith’s “Yonosa House” are visual, auditory,
olfactory, tactile, and subjective imagery. In the poem, the visual imagery dominates
the language used. Furthermore, those imageries are identified as in the tables below.
No. Sentence/ Phrase of Metaphor Stanza Line 1 Her knotted hands showing slow blue rivers 3 17
No. Sentence/ Phrase of Simile Stanza Line 1 She…sat like a stately sack 1 1-3 2 Her…hair hung like waxed flax 2 7-8 3 She wove and knotted it…like ropes 2 9-10 4 I cut hearts…like the dulcimer 4 23-24 5 She sank like a root 5 27
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
34
Table 7. List of Visual Imagery Presented in “Yonosa House”
No. Sentence/ Phrase of Auditory Imagery Stanza Line 1 tones 1 1 2 chants 1 5 3 Songs 1 6 4 music 1 6 5 Sound of snow 2 14 6 The call of the circling hawk 2 16 7 I hear her voice 5 30
Table 8. List of Auditory Imagery Presented in “Yonosa House”
No. Sentence/ Phrase of Visual Imagery Stanza Line 1 She stroked molten tones 1 1 2 And sat like a stately sack of bones 1 3 3 Rocking to corn chants 1 5 4 Her old woman’s Tuscarora hair 2 7 5 In fevered patterns, feather colors 2 13 6 snow 2 14 7 rock 2 14 8 bruised birch bark 2 15 9 the circling hawk 2 16
10 Her knotted hands showing slow blue rivers 3 17 11 Trembled through cornbread frying 3 18 12 Pressed fern patterns on butter pats 3 19 13 Brewed sassafras tea in the hearth 3 20 14 They buried Yonosa in a deerskin skirt 4 21 15 I cut hearts in her coffin lid 4 23 16 She sank like a root into Georgia clay 4 27 17 No Baptist chruchyard caught her bones 4 28 18 when the maples turn 5 29
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
35
No. Sentence/ Phrase of Olfactory Imagery Stanza Line 1 Brewed sassafras tea in the hearth 3 20
Table 9. List of Olfactory Imagery Presented in “Yonosa House”
No. Sentence/ Phrase of Tactile Imagery Stanza Line 1 She stroked molten tones 1 1 2 Pressed fern patterns on butter pats 3 19 3 Brewed sassafras tea in the hearth 3 20 4 They buried Yonosa in a deerskin skirt 4 21 5 I cut hearts in her coffin lid 4 23
Table 10. List of Tactile Imagery Presented in “Yonosa House”
No. Sentence/ Phrase of Subjective Imagery Stanza Line 1 Through my young mind 2 11 2 The feel of bruised birch bark 2 15 3 The mountain was holy enough for her 4 25 4 We kept our word and raised no stone 4 26 5 I thank her hands when the maples turn. 5 29
Table 11. List of Subjective Imagery Presented in “Yonosa House”
b. Symbol
In terms of symbol, Smith’s “Yonosa House” uses some words that can be
considered as symbols. The symbols used are listed in the table below.
No. Word Stanza Line 1 house (in the title) - - 2 dulcimer 1, 2 2, 24 3 Tuscarora 2 7 4 snow 2 14 5 rock 2 14
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
36
No. Word Stanza Line 6 birch 2 15 7 hawk 2 16 8 rivers 3 17 9 wind 4 24
10 mountain 4 25 11 stone 4 26 12 root 4 27 13 maples 5 29 14 thrush 5 30
Table 12. List of Symbols Presented in “Yonosa House”
Those symbols are mostly natural objects. Thus, it can be said that the poem
tends to use natural symbols. Furthermore, those symbols are discussed critically and
elaborately in the next subchapter along with the analysis of personification,
metaphor, and simile used in Smith’s “Yonosa House”.
B. Uncovering Personification, Metaphor, and Simile Presented in Smith’s
“Yonosa House”
This subchapter is divided into three parts. The first part aims to analyze
personification presented in Smith’s “Yonosa House” as well as find its implied
meaning. In the second part, it is about the analysis of metaphor found in the poem.
Then, the third part is about the analysis of simile presented in the poem.
1. Personification
As listed in the table 4.4, there are 8 personifications presented in Smith’s
“Yonosa House”. Each of them is analyzed as follows.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
37
a. She stroked molten tones
In the phrase ‘She stroked molten tones’, tones are personified. The tones
which are nonhuman entity and abstract thing defined as if it is alive and can be
stroked.
Literally, tone is a musical sound with reference to its pitch, quality, and
strength (Hasa, 2016, para. 1). In fact, tones cannot be touched, even caught. It is only
can be heard. In the poem, it is illustrated that Yonosa treats the tones as if she can
touch it for it is molten from her dulcimer. It can be considered that Yonosa has
strong relationship with the tones for the speaker notes she can interact with the tones
produces by the dulcimer. Due to the relation image between Yonosa and the tones, it
can be said that Yonosa really likes music. She enjoys playing her dulcimer until it
looks that the tones are molten from the dulcimer, then stroked by Yonosa, produces
beautiful ethnical music.
b. Sound of snow
In the phrase ‘sound of snow’, snow is personified. The snow which is
nonhuman entity (inanimate object) is defined as if it has human ability to produce
sounds. In fact, human can produce various sounds, for example in the act of
laughing, singing, yawning, whispering, screaming, and so on. Here, snow is
described that it sounds. The matter is that which of human’s sound that represents
the characteristic of snow is. Moreover, it can be related by finding the overtones
meaning of snow.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
38
Literally, snow is atmospheric water vapor frozen into ice crystals and falling
in light white flakes or lying on the ground as a bright white layer (Schantz, 2012, p.
224). Nevertheless, snow has overtones meaning instead of its literal meaning that
merely show the physical appearance. In literature, snow can be interpreted in both
optimistic and pessimistic manner (reference.com, 2019, para. 1-4). Optimistically,
snow is often compared to innocence, tranquility, and beauty for it looks so clean and
it has white color. From those comparisons, tranquility is the closest one in relation
with sound which is calm or silent. On the other hand, snow signifies winter and the
end of the growing season. Due to its relation to the end of growth in the natural
world, snow is often linked to death and hardships. Here, the death has the closer
relation with sound, that is silence (no sound). Evidently, in both optimistically and
pessimistically, snow represents calmness or silence.
Furthermore, if ‘sound of snow’ is referred to the three lines before, regarding
to Yonosa’s tribe tradition, it can be interpreted that Yonosa’s tribe prefers to live in
calmness, keep the harmony with nature. Besides, they also live in silence. Meaning
to say, they keep away from the crowd of modern living with its advanced
technology.
c. Kiss of rock
In the phrase ‘kiss of rock’, rock is personified. The rock which is nonhuman
entity (inanimate object) is defined as if it has human ability to kiss someone or
something. Kiss itself is the act of touching somebody or something with the lips to
show love, affection, respect, or as a greeting (Hornby, 2017, p. 652). In fact, rock
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
39
has no lips but the speaker portrays that it can give a kiss. Furthermore, the meaning
of the rock’s kiss can be found by relating the actual and the implied meaning of
rock. Literally, rock is a natural substance made from the solid combination of one or
more minerals (softschool.com, 2019, para. 2). It is the Earth’s outer solid layer.
Then, in literature rock is often associated with eternity for it is naturally powerful
and long last (Kraus, 2012, para. 5). Due to the predicate of ‘eternity’, rock is
considered that it can keep the relation between humans and their ancestors. Thus,
rock in this poem represents the existence of the ancestors.
Moreover, if ‘kiss of rock’ is referred to the three lines before, regarding to
Yonosa’s tribe tradition, it can be interpreted that Yonosa’s tribe always keeps in
touch with the ancestors. Death is not a barrier between the living and the spirit of
the ancestors to communicate. The living can do certain rite to call the ancestors.
They believe that the ancestors have a prominent role in guiding the tribe
everlastingly.
d. The feel of bruised birch bark
In the phrase ‘the feel of bruised birch bark’, birch is personified. The birch
which is nonhuman entity (inanimate object) is defined as if it has human ability to
feel something. Human, indeed, can express various feelings such as happy, sad,
exhausted, furious, shy, disgusted, surprised, depressed, and so on. Here, birch is
described that it has feelings. The matter is that which of human’s feeling that
represents the characteristic of birch is. Moreover, it can be related by finding the
overtones meaning of birch.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
40
Literally, birch is a kind of tree. A birch has smooth, resinous, white bark
(Britannica.com, 2019, para. 2). The bark is marked by horizontal pores (lenticels).
Therefore, the phrase ‘bruised birch bark’ is applied in the poem due to the physical
appearance of the birch tree. In the poem, the birch tree is illustrated that it has
bruises. Actually, it is not because the tree got injured, but it is because the pattern of
the bark’s pores that looks like bruises. Nevertheless, birch has overtones meaning
instead of its literal meaning that merely show the physical appearance. In literature,
birch is interpreted as a new beginning and protection (sweep away negative energy)
(Venefica, 2008, para. 1-4). It is called as a new beginning because a tree, naturally,
grows continuously from its tiny-sized become maximum-sized. The growth process
from the start represents a new beginning. Related to the feeling, a new beginning
shows passionate, enthusiasm, and excitement. Then, birch is also called as
protection because one of its innate functions is to prevent natural disasters such as
flood and landslide. Related to the feeling, protection shows alertness of negative or
bad things.
Furthermore, if ‘the feel of bruised birch bark’ is referred to the three lines
before, regarding to Yonosa’s tribe tradition, it can be interpreted that Yonosa’s tribe
always does anything good for the tribe with full of passion, enthusiasm, and
excitement. On the other hand, they keep the people of the tribe from bad things with
their alertness.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
41
e. The call of the circling hawk
In the phrase ‘the call of the circling hawk’, hawk is personified. The hawk
which is nonhuman entity is defined as if it has human ability to call someone. Call
itself can be defined as an act of crying out to summon or to attract someone’s
attention (Hornby, 2017, p. 158). Here, hawk is described that it calls. Actually,
hawk has no ability to speak, even make a call like human does, but the speaker
portrays that it can call. Furthermore, the meaning of the hawk’s call can be found by
relating the actual and the implied meaning of hawk.
Literally, hawk is a strong fast bird of prey (softschools.com, 2019, para. 1-3).
Hawk has sharp talon, large-curved bill, and muscular legs. It also has excellent
eyesight to ease the hunt. Then, in literature hawk is often associated with aura of
power and leadership (Venefica, 2007, para. 3). Due to the predicate of ‘having aura
of power and leadership’, hawk is considered that it gives example for human to
have leadership spirit. The leadership spirit, indeed, is owned by the leader of a
group or tribe. Thus, hawk in this poem represents the existence of the leader of the
tribe.
Furthermore, the hawk is described that it is circling. Hawk flies in circle
pattern to stay aloft in the air while looking for prey or just look around the land. If
this act is addressed to the leader of the tribe, it means that the leader should be a
watchful person. He or she should not be lazy on the throne, but it is an obligation
for a leader to look around the tribe, convincing that people of the tribe in an
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
42
adequate life. If there is problem in the tribe, the leader is expected to solve it fast
before the problem become bigger.
Then, by relating the implied meaning of hawk, the hawk’s call means that it
is the call from the leader of the tribe. In any occasion in the tribe, the leader
summons the people of the tribe to gather in one place, for example, in traditional
ceremonies or even just giving announcement. This call cannot be neglected by the
people for they should honor their leader. Thus, the leader’s call is a prominent thing
for the people of the tribe that they should conform.
Moreover, if ‘the call of the circling hawk’ is referred to the three lines before,
regarding to Yonosa’s tribe tradition, it can be interpreted that Yonosa’s leader of
tribe always protects every member of the tribe. Her or his summons is guidance for
the people of Yonosa’s tribe in doing any tribal occasions. It means that Yonosa’s
tribe believes in the power of their leader to lead them in a good way of life and
protect them from enemy or any bad things.
f. No Baptist churchyard caught her bones
In the phrase ‘No Baptist churchyard caught her bones’, Baptist churchyard is
personified. The Baptist churchyard which is nonhuman entity (inanimate object) is
defined as if it has human ability to hold something which is thrown, propelled, or
dropped. A Baptist churchyard is an area of land that immediately adjacent to the
Baptist church and it is open to the sky (merriam-webster.com, 2019, para. 1).
Usually, it is a grassy area and surrounded by a fence. In some Baptist churches, its
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
43
yards are used for cemeteries. Thus, Baptist churchyard here means cemetery for
Christians. Then, it is mentioned that not any Baptist churchyard—a Christians’
cemetery—caught Yonosa’s bones. Here, caught means being the place for Yonosa’s
bones. The speaker uses ‘bones’ instead of ‘body’ in order to emphasize that Yonosa
is already dead in her old age. Furthermore, from the phrase ‘No Baptist churchyard
caught her bones’, it implicitly infers that Yonosa is a Christian but she is not buried
in the cemetery of Baptist church.
Moreover, if the phrase ‘No Baptist churchyard caught her bones’ is related to
the some lines before, in line 25 and 26 of stanza 4, it is clearly mentioned that
Yonosa is buried in a mountain and there is no any mark of her burial ground. It is
Yonosa’s own will to be buried in that way. By this, her grandchild and her tribe
honor her last will and they do not bury her dead body in the cemetery of Baptist
church. Since she is buried in the mountain without any mark, it shows that Yonosa
wants to unite with the nature.
It is also can be said that Yonosa considers death is not the end of everything.
If she prefers to be buried in the Baptist churchyard, it means that she will be
remembered that she is really gone from this mortal world. Yonosa does not want to
be remembered that way and she refuses to surrender that easy to death. She believes
that death is not the end of everything, yet it is the new beginning for her another
journey. Life and death are like in the same circle. Life is ended by death, but death
starts another life. By her will, Yonosa hopes that after her death, she will still alive
by uniting with nature.
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
44
g. The maples turn
In the phrase ‘the maples turn’, maple is personified. The maple which is
nonhuman entity (inanimate object) is defined as if it has human ability to turn.
Literally, maple is a kind of tree that is known for its vibrant leaf (fiery red, electric
orange, and calming yellow) in autumn (treecanada.ca, 2019, para. 2). Maple in
literature is considered that it represents strength and endurance because maple tree
is a strong tree that able to survive in any seasons (urnabios.com, 2014, para.2).
Related to a person told in the poem, maple can be considered as the manifestation of
Yonosa. This manifestation illustrates that Yonosa owns characteristics of strength
and endurance.
Moreover, in fact, a tree cannot make a movement like human does. Here, it is
mentioned that the maple can turn. Thus, the phrase ‘the maples turn’ has meaning
that Yonosa makes a turn, leaving the life and facing the death. Due to her death,
physically she leaves her family and her tribe.
h. The thrush's song
In the phrase ‘the thrush's song’, thrush is personified. The thrush which is
nonhuman entity is defined as if it has human ability to sing a song. Literally, thrush
is a kind of bird that can produce beautiful chirps (wildlifetrusts.org, 2019, para. 4).
Due to the beautiful chirps, the bird is illustrated that actually it sings like human
does. Thrush in literature is considered that it conveys spiritual symbolism. This bird
symbolizes a good companion in times of loneliness. It has the ability to absorb
sorrow and heal sad person (auntyflo.com, 2018, para. 12).
PLAGIAT MERUPAKAN TINDAKAN TIDAK TERPUJI
-
45
Moreover, if ‘the thrush's song’ is referred to its full line ’I hear her voice in
the thrush’s song’, it can be interpreted that the speaker hears Yonosa’s voice
through the thrush’s chirps. It can be said that Yonosa’s spirit still exists even though
she has already passed away. Her spirit changes into a thrush bird. Then, she tries to
communicate with the speaker to make him realize that she is not really leaving far
away. She wants the speaker know that it is no need of sorrow for her absence.
Instead, he has to believe that death is not the end of a journey. Death is a path
heading another life.
2. Metaphor
There is only one metaphor presented in Smith’s “Yonosa House”. It is in the
line ‘Her knotted hands showing slow blue rivers’ (stanza 3, line 17). In this line,
Yonosa is mentioned that she has knotted hands. Knotted hands (fingers) has
meaning that it is twisted because of old age or too much work (Hamedso, 2017, para.
2). By this, it implies that even though Yonosa is an old woman, a grandmother, she
still does many activities, one of them is house chores. It is explained clearer in the
next lines (stanza 3, line 18-20) that Yonosa cooks cornbread, cookies, and she