! "!

!

A More Diverse Community:

Does Predator Diversity Maintain Prey Diversity?

!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Washington University in St. Louis Environmental Studies Program

Senior Honors Thesis

Vanessa Schroeder Thesis Advisor: Kevin G. Smith

March 2010!

!

! #!

!

Table of Contents

!

$%&'()*'++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++,-!

./)0'1(!"2!34'(567*'854+++++,,++++++++++++++++++++++++,,,++++++9:;!

./)0'1(!#2!<(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)46!)??(1?)'854!)@@1*'&!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!)*(5&&!&*)A1&+,,+,,B:-#!

./)0'1(!-2!C7A'80A1!0(16)'5(!A)46&*)01&2!'1&'84?!)!'/15(1'8*)A!D561A,+++++,,+++,,,--:EF!

./)0'1(!92!.54*A7&854++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++E;:FG!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! -!

"#$%&'(%)!

! C7A'80A1!0(5*1&&1&!*)4!A1)6!'5!)!A5&&!5@!)!(1?854H&!%85'8*!68&'84*'8=141&&!I61*(1)&16!

J:68=1(&8'>KL!&7*/!)&!6(57?/'L!68&1)&1!5(!0(16)'854,!<(16)'854!/)&!54A>!%114!&/5M4!'5!A1)6!

'5!A5M1(!J:68=1(&8'>!84!'/1!*)&1!5@!)!748@5(D!0(16)'5(,!3!/>05'/1&8N16!'/)'!84*(1)&16!

68=1(&8'>!)'!'/1!0(16)'5(!'(50/8*!A1=1A!I/8?/!0(16)'5(!J:68=1(&8'>K!84!)!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(!

A)46&*)01!M57A6!(1&7A'!84!)!*)&*)684?!84*(1)&1!84!J:68=1(&8'>L!84!M/8*/!84*(1)&16!68=1(&8'>!

)'!'/1!0(16)'5(!'(50/8*!A1=1A!'()4&A)'1&!'5!84*(1)&16!J:68=1(&8'>!)'!'/1!0(1>!'(50/8*!A1=1A,!3!

@8(&'!'/15(1'8*)AA>!1O)D8416!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)46!&0)'8)A!)??(1?)'854!54!

0(1>!*5DD748'>!68=1(&8'>!7&84?!)!*5D%84)'854!5@!D561A&!)46!&8D7A)'854&L!)46!'/14!

1D08(8*)AA>!'1&'!'/1!D8'8?)'84?!1@@1*'&!5@!)!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(!A)46&*)01,!P/1!&8D7A)'854&!

1O)D8416!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>L!614&8'>!)46!)??(1?)'854!?()6814'&L!D1)&7(84?!'/1!A5*)AL!

(1?854)A!)46!β:68=1(&8'>!I&01*81&!'7(4:5=1(K!5@!'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'81&,!3!@5746!'/)'!/8?/!

0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!D168)'1&!'/1!&84?A1!0(16)'5(!1@@1*'!5@!61*(1)&16!β:68=1(&8'>L!%7'!54A>!84!

'/1!*)&1!'/)'!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&!)??(1?)'1!84'()&01*8@8*)AA>L!&7*/!'/)'!'/1>!65!45'!5**7(!

7%8Q78'57&A>!84!)!D1')*5DD748'>,!P/1!&1*546!0)('!5@!'/8&!&'76>!D1)&7(16!A5*)A!IRK!)46!

(1?854)A!ISK!0(1>!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!84!)('8@8*8)A!0546&,!3!@5746!'/)'!0(16)'5(&!)@@1*'16!0(1>!

*5DD748'81&!68@@1(14'A>L!84!541!*)&1!A1)684?!'5!68@@1(14'8)'854,!P/1!D561A!0(168*'854&!M1(1!

45'!&7005('16,!$!A5M1(!'/)4!1O01*'16!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)46!)!/8?/1(!61?(11!5@!0(16)'5(!

681'!5=1(A)0!D8?/'!)**574'!@5(!'/1!68&*(10)4*>!%1'M114!'/1!D561A!)46!1D08(8*)A!(1&7A'&,!

T7'7(1!M5(U!&/57A6!84*A761!)!/8?/!68=1(&8'>!5@!&01*8)A8N16!0(16)'5(&!)46!&/57A6!@5*7&!54!

'/1!(5A1!5@!0(16)'5(&!M8'/!'/1!05'14'8)A!'5!*574'1()*'!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!/5D5?148N)'854!84!)!

0(16)'5(!A)46&*)01,!

!

! 9!

*+',%-&!./!01%&234(%521)!

! 34!'/1!D86&'!5@!84*(1)&84?!?A5%)A8N)'854L!D)&&!1O'84*'854&!)46!'/1!&7%&1Q714'!

D561(4!%8568=1(&8'>!*(8&8&L!'/1!V)('/!8&!A5&84?!45'!54A>!8'&!748Q71!&01*81&L!%7'!)A&5!8'&!

748Q71!A)46&*)01&!I<8DD!"#!$%&!"WWEL!X8'57&1U!"#!$%&!"WWFL!C*Y8441>!)46!Z5*UM556!"WWWK,!

[5D5?148N)'854L!'/1!A5&&!5@!%85'8*!68&'84*'8=141&&!)D54?!A5*)'854&L!(1@1(&!'5!'/1!

(10A)*1D14'!5@!748Q71L!1461D8*!%85')!M8'/!*5DD54L!4544)'8=1!&01*81&,!P/7&L!

/5D5?148N)'854!5**7(&!M/14!*5DD748'81&!%1*5D1!D5(1!&8D8A)(!IC*Y8441>!)46!Z5*UM556!

"WWWK,!$A'/57?/!D7A'80A1!0(5*1&&1&!*)4!A1)6!'5!'/1!A5&&!5@!%85'8*!68&'84*'8=141&&L!I\A614!)46!

<5@@!#GG-KL!&1=1()A!(1*14'!&'7681&!&7??1&'!'/)'!M/14!1*5A5?8*)A!0(5*1&&1&!)(1!&8D8A)(!

)D54?!A5*)'854&L!%85'8*!&8D8A)(8'>!M8AA!%1!/8?/1(!'/)4!1O01*'16!I1,?,L!6(57?/'2!./)&1!#GG;]!

0(16)'8542!./)&1!1'!)A,!#GGW]!68&1)&12!^D8'/!1'!)A,!#GGWK,!!

! P/1!(5A1!5@!0(16)'854!84!84*(1)&84?!0(1>!*5DD748'>!&8D8A)(8'>!8&!45'!)&!M1AA!

7461(&'556!)&!5'/1(!0)''1(4&!5@!0(16)'854,!$A'/57?/!'/1!(5A1!5@!0(16)'5(&!84!&'(7*'7(84?!

0(1>!0507A)'854&!/)&!A54?!%114!U45M4!I^8/!"#!$%&!"WBEKL!)46!0(16)'5(&!/)=1!'/1!)%8A8'>!'5!

61*(1)&1!'/1!A5*)A!IRK!68=1(&8'>!5@!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!I1,?,![8O54!)46!_11'&!"WW-L!^08AA1(!)46!

^*/5141(!"WBBL!"WWBKL!D7*/!5@!'/1!M5(U!1O)D8484?!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854!54!0(1>!

*5DD748'>!*5D05&8'854!/)&!%114!6541!54!)!A5*)A!&*)A1!I1,?,!(1=81M!84!^8/!1'!)A,!"WBEK,!

[5M1=1(L!(1*14'!M5(U!/)&!&/8@'16!'5M)(6&!1O)D8484?!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854!54!0(1>!

68=1(&8'>!)'!A)(?1(!&0)'8)A!&*)A1&!I^/7(84!)46!$AA14!#GG"L!./)&1!1'!)A,!#GGWK,!!

! 34!541!5@!'/1!54A>!&'7681&!54!'/8&!'508*L!./)&1!1'!)A,!I#GGWK!@5746!'/)'!0(16)'5(>!@8&/!

(167*1!45'!54A>!A5*)A!0(1>!68=1(&8'>L!%7'!)A&5!68=1(&8'>!)D54?!0546&!IJ:68=1(&8'>KL!(1&7A'84?!

84!(1?854)A!ISK!&01*81&!A5&&!)46!/5D5?148N)'854,!$!&8D8A)(!&'76>!%>!_18&41(!"#!$%&!#GG-!

61D54&'()'16!'/)'!0(16)'5(>!@8&/!84!'M5!A)U1&!A16!'5!61*(1)&16!J:68=1(&8'>!)'!%5'/!'/1!

! E!

0(16)'5(!'(50/8*!A1=1A!)46!'/1!N550A)4U'54!'(50/8*!A1=1AL!&7??1&'84?!)!J:68=1(&8'>!'(50/8*!

*)&*)61!I8,1,L!%'((!')!*+,-."/(-#0!-1!#2"!#'3!#/'32-4!%"."%!%"$,(!#'!$!%'((!-1!*+,-."/(-#0!-1!#2"!

%'5"/!#/'32-4!%"."%K,!_1*)7&1!'/1!0(16)'5(&!84!'/1&1!&'7681&!M1(1!*5&D505A8')4L!5**7((84?!84!

)AA!`0(16)'5(!/)%8')'&aL!'/1!*54&8&'14*>!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(H&!1@@1*'&!)D54?!A5*)'854&!*)7&16!'/1!

1O'84*'854!5@!&01*81&!'/)'!M1(1!(101)'16A>!(1D5=16!@(5D!8468=867)A!/)%8')'&,![5M1=1(L!

0(16)'5(&!65!45'!)AM)>&!5**7(!748@5(DA>!)*(5&&!)!A)46&*)01,!!P/7&L!`0(16)'5(!/)%8')'&a!)(1!

45'!)AM)>&!748@5(D!)46!D)>!)*'7)AA>!84*A761!)4>!541!5@!)!?(570!5@!'50!0(16)'5(&!M8'/!

*54*5D8')4'!68=1(&8'>!84!0(1>!0(1@1(14*1&!I1,?,L!b1(41(!)46![)AA!"W;;K,!b/8A1!)!&84?A1!

0(16)'5(!84*(1)&1&!&8D8A)(8'>!)D54?!A5*)A!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!'/(57?/!&1A1*'8=1!1O'84*'854!5@!

'/1!&)D1!&01*81&!84!1=1(>!A5*)A8'>L!84*(1)&84?!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)'!)!(1?854)A!&*)A1!M8AA!

84*(1)&1!'/1!68=1(&8'>!5@!'/1!0(1>!'/)'!)(1!&1A1*'8=1A>!1O'8(0)'16,!P/1!(1&7A'84?!1O'84*'854!5@!

68@@1(14'!&01*81&!)'!68@@1(14'!A5*)A8'81&!A1)6&!'5!%85'8*!68@@1(14'8)'854!I84*(1)&16!J:68=1(&8'>K,!

c71!'5!68@@1(14*1&!84!'/1!0(1>!&1A1*'8=8'>!5@!0(16)'5(&L!)!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(!A)46&*)01!M57A6!

0(5=861!)!D5(1!47)4*16!7461(&')4684?!5@!/5M!68=1(&8'>!)'!541!'(50/8*!A1=1A!)@@1*'&!J:!)46!

!:68=1(&8'>!)'!5'/1(!'(50/8*!A1=1A&,!!

! P/15(1'8*)A!D561A&!5@@1(!)!@()D1M5(U!M8'/!M/8*/!'5!7461(&')46!'/1!@746)D14')A!

0)''1(4&!5@!1*5A5?>!)46!)AA5M!@5(!)!M861!1O0A5()'854!5@!0)()D1'1(&!8D05&&8%A1!84!4)'7(1,!_>!

')(?1'84?!&01*8@8*!=)(8)%A1&!'/)'!*)445'!%1!1)&8A>!'1)&16!)0)('!84!1D08(8*)A!&'7681&L!1=14!

&8D0A1!D561A&!*)4!5@@1(!?(1)'!84&8?/'&!84'5!*5D0A1O!Q71&'854&,!P/15(1'8*)A!D561A&!)A&5!

5@@1(!?141()A!0(168*'854&!54!M/8*/!'5!%)&1!1D08(8*)A!&'7681&,![1(1L!3!7&1!)!*5D%84)'854!5@!

D561A&!)46!&8D7A)'854&!'5!'/15(1'8*)AA>!1O0A5(1!/5M!68@@1(14*1&!84!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>L!

614&8'>!)46!)??(1?)'854!84@A714*1!68=1(&8'>!)*(5&&!&*)A1&!84!0(1>!D1')*5DD748'81&,!

$668'854)AA>L!'/1&1!D561A&!/1A0!61'1(D841!8@!'/1!/5D5?148N84?!1@@1*'&!5@!'50!0(16)'5(&!8&!

! F!

D8'8?)'16!%>!J:68=1(&8'>!84!0(16)'5(&!)*(5&&!)!(1?854,!3!*5D0)(1!'/1!0(168*'854&!)46!

*54*A7&854&!5@!'/1!'/15(1'8*)A!D561A!'5!)!D1&5*5&D!1O01(8D14'!84!*)''A1!')4U&!

(10(1&14'84?!&D)AA!@(1&/M)'1(!0546&!84!M/8*/!3!1O)D841!'/1!1@@1*'&!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(&!

)*(5&&!)!A)46&*)01!I/8?/!0(16)'5(!J:68=1(&8'>K!/)=1!54!'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'>,!!

!

65%-&'%4&-!*5%-3)!

_18&41(L!_,V,L!3=1&L!$,d,L!)46!^,d,!.)(014'1(!I#GG-K,!P/1!1@@1*'&!5@!)4!1O5'8*!@8&/!84=)&854!54!

'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!5@!'M5!A)U1&,!e,!$48D,!V*5A,!;#2!--"f-9#,!

./)&1!e,C,!I#GG;K,!c(57?/'!D168)'1&!'/1!8D05(')4*1!5@!&'5*/)&'8*!*5DD748'>!)&&1D%A>,!

<g$^!"G92!";9-G:";9-9,!

./)&1L!e,C,L!_8(5L!V,h,L!d>%1(?L!b,$,L!)46!^D8'/L!Y,h,!I#GGWK,!<(16)'5(&!'1D01(!'/1!(1A)'8=1!

8D05(')4*1!5@!&'5*/)&'8*!0(5*1&&1&!84!'/1!)&&1D%A>!5@!0(1>!D1')*5DD748'81&,!

V*5A5?>!Z1''1(&L!"#2!"#"Gf"#"B,!

[8O54L!C,$,L!)46!e,<,_11'&!I"WW-K,!<(16)'854L!0(1>!(1@7?1&L!)46!'/1!&'(7*'7(1!5@!*5()A:(11@!

! @8&/!)&&1D%A)?1&,!V*5A5?8*)A!C545?()0/&!F-2;;:"G",!

C*Y8441>L!C,Z,!i!Z5*UM556L!e,Z,!I"WWWK,!_85'8*!/5D5?148N)'8542!)!@1M!M8441(&!(10A)*84?!

! D)4>!A5&1(&!84!'/1!41O'!D)&&!1O'84*'854,!P(146&!V*5A,!V=5A,L!"9L!9EGf9E-,!

\A614L!e,!c,L!)46!g,!Z,!<5@@!I#GG-K,!P5M)(6!)!C1*/)48&'8*!j461(&')4684?!)46!<(168*'854!5@!

! _85'8*![5D5?148N)'854,!P/1!$D1(8*)4!g)'7()A8&'L!"F#2!99#:9FG, <8DDL!^,Z,L!d7&&1AAL!h,e,L!h8''A1D)4L!e,Z,!i!_(55U&L!P,C,!I"WWEK,!P/1!@7'7(1!5@!%8568=1(&8'>,!

! ^*814*1L!#FWL!-9;f-EG,!

^/7(84L!e,!_,L!)46!V,!.,!$AA14!I#GG"K,!V@@1*'&!5@!*5D01'8'854L!0(16)'854L!)46!68&01(&)AL!54!

! &01*81&!(8*/41&&L!)'!A5*)A!)46!(1?854)A!&*)A1&,!$D1(8*)4!g)'7()A8&'!"EB2F#9:!F-;,!

^8/L!$,L!<,!.(5MA1>L!C,!C*<11UL!e,!<1'()4U)L!)46!Y,!^'(5/D18(1(!I"WBEK,!<(16)'854L!

! *5D01'8'854L!)46!0(1>!*5DD748'81&2!)!(1=81M!5@!@81A6!1O01(8D14'&,!$447)A!d1=81M!5@!

! V*5A5?>!)46!^>&'1D)'8*&!"F2#FWf-"",!

^D)('L!^,!C,L!Y,!P/5D0&54L!d,![,!C)((&L!C,!h,!Z1!c7*L!Z,!.,!C)&U1AA!)46!Z,!h,!T8(%)4U!I#GGFK,!

! _85'8*!/5D5?148N)'854!)46!*/)4?1&!84!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!)*(5&&!/7D)4:D568@816!

! 1*5&>&'1D&,!<(5*,!d,!^5*,!_!#;-2!#FEW:#FFE,!

! ;!

^D8'/L!Y,h,L!Z80&L!Y,d,L!)46!./)&1L!e,C,!I#GGWK,!^1A1*'84?!@5(!1O'84*'8542!454()465D!68&1)&1:!

)&&5*8)'16!1O'84*'854!/5D5?148N1&!)D0/8%8)4!%85')&,!V*5A5?>!"#2!"GFWf"G;B,!

^08AA1(L!c,$,L!)46!^*/5141(L!P,b,!I"WBBK,!$4!1O01(8D14')A!&'76>!5@!'/1!1@@1*'!5@!A8N)(6&!54!

M1%:&0861(!*5DD748'81&,!V*5A5?8*)A!C545?()0/&!EB2!EB:;;,!

^08AA1(L!c,!$,L!)46!P,b,!^*/5141(!I"WWBK,!Z8N)(6&!d167*1!^0861(!^01*81&!d8*/41&&!%>!

! 1O*A7684?!d)(1!^01*81&,!V*5A5?>!;W2!EG-:E"F,!

X8'57&1UL!<,!C,L!.,!C,!ck$4'5485L!Z,!Z,!Z5501L!)46!d,!b1&'%(55U&!I"WWFK,!_85A5?8*)A!84=)&854&!

)&!?A5%)A!14=8(54D14')A!*/)4?1,!$D1(8*)4^*814'8&'!B929FB:9;B,!

b1(41(L!V,V,L!)46![)AAL!c,e,!I"W;;K,!.5D01'8'854!)46!/)%8')'!&/8@'!84!'M5!&74@8&/1&!

I.14'()(*/86)1K,!V*5A5?>2!EB2!BFW:B;F,!

! B!

*+',%-&!7/!<(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)46!)??(1?)'854!)@@1*'&!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!)*(5&&!&*)A1&!

"89:;"*:)!

$A'/57?/!D7*/!M5(U!/)&!%114!6541!1O)D8484?!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(&!54!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!)'!

68@@1(14'!&0)'8)A!&*)A1&L!45!&'7681&!/)=1!84*A7616!0(1>!&01*81&!8614'8'>!'5!61'1(D841!'/1!

68@@1(14'8)A!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(!)??(1?)'854!54!0(1>!*5DD748'81&,!_78A684?!7054!0(1=857&!

M5(U!6541!'/(57?/!VP3_!I1Q78A8%(87D!'/15(>!5@!8&A)46!%85?15?()0/>K!D568@8*)'854&!)&!M1AA!

)&!*5DD748'>!&8D7A)'854&!84*5(05()'84?!%5'/!0(16)'5(!)46!0(1>!&01*81&!8614'8'81&L!3!

1O)D8416!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)46!)??(1?)'854!A5*)AA>!IR:68=1(&8'>K!)46!

(1?854)AA>!I!:68=1(&8'>K!54!0(1>!*5DD748'81&L!)&!M1AA!)&!'/1!1@@1*'&!54!J:68=1(&8'>!I&01*81&!

'7(45=1(K,!3!*54*A7616!'/)'!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)46!&0)'8)A!)??(1?)'854!)@@1*'!0(1>!

*5DD748'81&!'/(57?/!J:68=1(&8'>!'(50/8*!*)&*)61&!M/1(1!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)@@1*'&!0(1>!

68=1(&8'>,!

!

0<:;=>?*:0=<)!!

! c1'1(D8484?!'/1!@)*'5(&!'/)'!)@@1*'!68=1(&8'>!/)&!A54?!%114!)!?5)A!5@!1*5A5?>!)46!

*54&1(=)'854,!3'!8&!M1AA!U45M4!'/)'!0(16)'5(&!*)4!0A)>!8D05(')4'!(5A1&!84!61'1(D8484?!'/1!

&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!5@!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!I./)&1!"#!$%&L!#GG#]!^8/!"#!$%,L!"WBEK,!C7*/!5@!'/1!

M5(U!1O)D8484?!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854!5@!0(1>!*5DD748'>!*5D05&8'854!/)&!%114!6541!54!

)!A5*)A!&*)A1!I1,?,!(1=81M!84!^8/!"#!$%&!"WBEK,![5M1=1(L!(1*14'!M5(U!/)&!&/8@'16!'5M)(6&!

1O)D8484?!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854!54!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!)'!A)(?1(!&0)'8)A!&*)A1&!I^/7(84!)46!

$AA14!#GG"L!./)&1!"#!$%&!#GGWK,!P/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854!54!0(1>!*5DD748'>!*5D05&8'854!)'!

(1?854)A!&*)A1&!)46!'/1!(1&7A'84?!&8D8A)(8'>!5(!68&&8D8A)(8'>!IA5M!J:68=1(&8'>!5(!/8?/!J:

68=1(&8'>K!(1A81&!7054!0(1>!*5DD748'>!)&&1D%A>,!<(16)'5(&!=)(>!84!'/18(!0(1>!&1A1*'8=8'>!

! W!

I1,?,!h(5=1(!"WWEKL!)46!?141()A8&'!)46!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&!*)4!/)=1!68@@1(14'!1@@1*'&!54!

*5DD748'>!*5D05&8'854,!P/8&!*)4!5**7(!'/(57?/!*/)4?1&!84!&01*81&!055A!&8N1L!)46!'/1!

&7%&1Q714'!*/)4?1&!84!*5A548N)'854!5(!1O'84*'854!()'1&!M/8*/!*)4!*/)4?1!'/1!8D05(')4*1!5@!

&'5*/)&'8*8'>!)46!61'1(D848&D!84!0(1>!*5DD748'>!)&&1D%A>!I./)&1!1'!)A,!#GGWK,!d)465D!

0(5*1&&1&!*/)()*'1(8N16!%>!*/)4*1!1=14'&!61@841!&'5*/)&'8*8'>,!^'5*/)&'8*!0(5*1&&1&L!&7*/!)&!

1O'84*'854!)46!*5A548N)'854!)46!1*5A5?8*)A!6(8@'L!*)4!&'(7*'7(1!*5DD748'81&!54!'/1!A5*)A!IRK!

&*)A1,!P/1&1!0(5*1&&1&L!84!)!68&01(&)A:)&&1D%A16!&>&'1DL!(1&7A'!84!=)(8)'854!84!*5DD748'>!

*5D05&8'854!)D54?!&8'1&!I[7%%1A!#GG"L!./)=1!#GG9L!./)&1!#GG;K!A1)684?!'5!(1A)'8=1A>!/8?/!

J:68=1(&8'>,!_>!)A'1(84?!A5*)A!1O'84*'854!6>4)D8*&L!0(16)'5(&!*)4!61*(1)&1!'/1!&8N1!5@!A5*)A!

*5DD748'81&!(1A)'8=1!'5!'/1!&01*81&!055AL!84*(1)&84?!'/1!8D05(')4*1!5@!&'5*/)&'8*!0(5*1&&1&!

)46!'/7&!84*(1)&84?!J:68=1(&8'>!I\((5*U!)46!TA1'*/1(!#GGEL!d>%1(?!)46!./)&1!#GG;K,!

34!)668'854!'5!'/1!)%5=1!&'5*/)&'8*!0(5*1&&L!61'1(D848&'8*!0(5*1&&1&L!&7*/!)&!

14=8(54D14')A!*5468'854&L!84'1(&01*8@8*!*5D01'8'854!)46!48*/1!&1A1*'854L!D)>!A1)6!'5!

&D)AA1(!68@@1(14*1&!)D54?&'!14=8(54D14')AA>!&8D8A)(!A5*)A8'81&L!)46!'/7&!A5M1(!J:68=1(&8'>!

I./)&1!)46!Z18%5A6!#GG-K,!b8'/84!'/8&!@()D1M5(UL!0(16)'5(&!*)4!&1A1*'8=1A>!@8A'1(!&01*81&!

@(5D!A5*)A!*5DD748'81&L!'/1(1%>!*54&'()8484?!'/1!(1)A8N16!&01*81&!055AL!84*(1)&84?!'/1!

(1A)'8=1!8D05(')4*1!5@!61'1(D848&'8*!0(5*1&&1&!)46!61*(1)&84?!J:68=1(&8'>!I./)&1!1'!)A,!

#GGWK,!!

! $!(1*14'!&'76>!%>!d>%1(?!)46!./)&1!I#GG;K!*54'(8%7'16!'5!'/1!'/15(1'8*)A!

61=1A50D14'!5@!/5M!0(16)'5(&!*)4!84@A714*1!'/1!*5D05&8'854!5@!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!)D54?!

A5*)'854&!)46!)*(5&&!&0)'8)A!&*)A1&,!_>!1O0)4684?!C)*$('/7(!)46!b8A&54H&!1Q78A8%(87D!

'/15(>!5@!8&A)46!%85?15?()0/>!IVP3_K!'5!84*A761!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854L!'/1!)7'/5(&!

61D54&'()'1!'/)'!)4!84*(1)&1!84!0(16)'854!M8AA!61*(1)&1!'/1!&A501!5@!'/1!&01*81&!)(1)!

! "G!

(1A)'854&/80!IC)*$('/7(!)46!b8A&54!"WF-L!"WF;L!d>%1(?!)46!./)&1!#GG;KL!05'14'8)AA>!

(1&7A'84?!84!61*(1)&16!J:68=1(&8'>,![5M1=1(L!&7*/!)!D561A!07(*/)&1&!?141()A8'>!)'!'/1!*5&'!

5@!(1)A8'>]!%>!1O)D8484?!&7*/!%(5)6!0)''1(4&!'/1!)7'/5(&!D)U1!)4!)&&7D0'854!5@!)!748@5(D!

0(16)'5(L!0(1=14'84?!)!D5(1!47)4*16!7461(&')4684?!5@!0(16)'5(>!1@@1*'&!54!%8568=1(&8'>,!!

! $!41M!0)01(!84!d1=81M!%>!d>%1(?L!^D8'/!)46!./)&1!8D0(5=1&!7054!'/1!0(1=857&!

0(16)'5(!D568@816!VP3_!D561A!Id>%1(?!)46!./)&1!#GG;K!%>!84*A7684?!'/1&1!68@@1(14'8)A!

1@@1*'&!5@!&01*8)A8&'!)46!?141()A8&'!0(16)'5(&,!P/1>!@5746!'/)'!?141()A8&'!0(16)'5(&!84*(1)&1!

J:68=1(&8'>!'/(57?/!(167*'854&!84!A5*)A!0507A)'854!)46!*5DD748'>!&8N1!M/8A1!&01*8)A8&'!

0(16)'5(&!61*(1)&1!J:68=1(&8'>!%>!&1A1*'8=1A>!@8A'1(84?!'/1!(1?854)A!*5DD748'>!055A!

Id>%1(?L!^D8'/!)46!./)&1!84!d1=81MK,!c1&08'1!'/1!68&'84*'854!84!8614'8'>!@5(!0(16)'5(!

&01*81&L!'/8&!8614'8@8*)'854!8&!()'/1(!*5)(&1!?()8416L!0A)*84?!0(16)'5(&!84!54A>!'M5!68&*(1'1!

*)'1?5(81&2!&01*8)A8&'!5(!?141()A8&'L!)46!'/1!8614'8'>!5@!'/1!0(1>!&01*81&!8&!&'8AA!A5&',!<(1=857&!

M5(U!54A>!A55U&!)'!'/1!47D%1(!5@!&01*81&!*54&7D16!%>!'/1!0(16)'5(L!45'!'/1!8614'8'>!5@!

'/1&1!&01*81&!Id>%1(?!)46!./)&1!#GG;L!d>%1(?L!^D8'/!)46!./)&1!84!d1=81MK,!3@!0(16)'5(&H!

1@@1*'&!68@@1(!)46!0(16)'5(!J:68=1(&8'>!8&!/8?/L!1)*/!0(16)'5(!D)>!61*(1)&1!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!84!

)!0)'*/!IR:68=1(&8'>K!M/8A1!14/)4*84?!5(!D)84')8484?!68@@1(14*1&!84!68=1(&8'>!)*(5&&!'/1!

A)46&*)01,!P/7&L!0(1>!(1@7?1&!D)>!1O8&'!1=14!M8'/84!)!A)46&*)01!5@!0(16)'5(&L!84!M/8*/!*)&1!

'/1!41?)'8=1!1@@1*'!5@!0(16)'5(&!54!J:68=1(&8'>!)46!(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>!D)>!%1!D168)'16!%>!

A)46&*)01:&*)A1!68=1(&8'>!84!0(16)'5(&,!

! <)''1(4&!5@!68=1(&8'>!&/57A6!%1!*54&861(16!M8'/84!'/1!*54'1O'!5@!'/1!68&'(8%7'854)A!

0)''1(4&!5@!&01*81&,!P/1!0)''1(4&!5@!&01*81&!68&'(8%7'854!84!&0)*1!/)=1!0(1=857&A>!%114!

61D54&'()'16!'5!0A)>!)4!8D05(')4'!(5A1!84!)@@1*'84?!&01*81&!(8*/41&&L!M8'/!/8?/!&0)'8)A!

)??(1?)'854!(1&7A'84?!84!A5M1(!&01*81&!(8*/41&&!84!*5DD748'81&!I[1!)46!Z1?146(1!#GG#K,!

! ""!

P/7&L!'/1!&0)'8)A!)??(1?)'854!I61?(11!'5!M/8*/!0(16)'5(&!)(1!*A7D016!84!&0)*1K!5@!'/1!

0(16)'5(&!D)>!'1D01(!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!54!0(1>!*5DD748'81&,!

! P/1!A)(?1!)D574'&!5@!=)(8)'854!84!4)'7(1!*)4!D)U1!6()M84?!84@1(14*1&!68@@8*7A'!

M/14!)''1D0'84?!'5!'1)&1!)0)('!*5D0A1O!&>&'1D&L!)46!8'!8&!5@'14!68@@8*7A'!'5!6()M!*A1)(:*7'!

*54*A7&854&!@(5D!1D08(8*)A!&'7681&,!^8D7A)'854&!5@@1(!)4!861)A!M)>!84!M/8*/!'5!68(1*'A>!'1&'!

68@@1(14*1&!45'!1)&8A>!8&5A)'16!84!4)'7(1,!C561A&!5@@1(!&8D0A1!@()D1M5(U&!@5(!%1''1(!

7461(&')4684?!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854!54!68=1(&8'>,!_5'/!D561A&!)46!&8D7A)'854&!*)4!

?141()'1!0(168*'854&!7054!M/8*/!'5!%)&1!1D08(8*)A!M5(U,![1(1L!3!7&1!)!*5D%84)'854!5@!

D561A&!)46!&8D7A)'854&!'5!'/15(1'8*)AA>!1O0A5(1!/5M!68@@1(14*1&!84!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>L!

614&8'>L!)46!)??(1?)'854!84@A714*1!68=1(&8'>!)*(5&&!&*)A1&!84!0(1>!D1')*5DD748'81&,!3!)A&5!

1O)D841!/5M!0(16)'5(!&01*8@8*8'>!I*/)4?1&!84!681'!%(1)6'/K!)46!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!)A'1(!

'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!54!0(1>!*5DD748'81&,!$668'854)AA>L!'/1&1!D561A&!/1A0!

61'1(D841!8@!'/1!/5D5?148N84?!1@@1*'&!5@!'50!0(16)'5(&!*)4!%1!)D1A85()'16!%>!J:68=1(&8'>!84!

0(16)'5(&!)*(5&&!)!(1?854,!

!

@=>A69!"<>!90@?6":0=<9)!

! 3!7&16!)!D568@816!VP3_!D561A!)&!M1AA!)&!D1')*5DD748'>!&8D7A)'854&!'5!'/15(1'8*)AA>!

1O0A5(1!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854L!M8'/84!)!&0)'8)A!*54'1O'L!54!0(1>!*5DD748'>!68=1(&8'>,!3!

1O)D841!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>L!614&8'>!)46!)??(1?)'854!)&!?()6814'&!()'/1(!'/)4!

68*/5'5D57&!68&'84*'854&,!$668'854)AA>L!3!D)4807A)'1!'/1!681'!%(1)6'/!)46!0(16)'854!

84'14&8'>!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(&!)'!'/1!/8?/!146!5@!'/1!68=1(&8'>!?()6814',!P/1!68=1(&8'>!?()6814'!

&0)4&!@(5D!)!&84?A1!0(16)'5(!0(1&14'!84!)!D1')*5DD748'>!I541!0(16)'5(!01(!A5*)A!

*5DD748'>K!'5!)!'5')A!5@!@8=1!68@@1(14'!0(16)'5(&L!1)*/!*54&7D84?!)!748Q71!&1'!5@!'/1!

! "#!

(1?854)A!0(1>!*5DD748'>!IT8?7(1!"K,!P/1!614&8'>!?()6814'!84*(1)&1&!'/1!47D%1(!5@!

0(16)'5(&!)'!'/1!/8?/!146!5@!'/1!68=1(&8'>!'(1)'D14'!@(5D!541!0(16)'5(!'5!@8=1!'5')A!

0(16)'5(&,!P/8&!A1)6&!'5!'/1!@84)A!?()6814'L!84!M/8*/!0(16)'5(&!)(1!)??(1?)'16!

84'1(&01*8@8*)AA>!5(!84'()&01*8@8*)AA>,!$??(1?)'854!(1@1(&!'5!'/1!61?(11!'5!M/8*/!0(16)'5(&!

)(1!*A7D016!84!&0)*1,!34'()&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!5**7(&!M/14!'/1!&01*81&!*A7&'1(16!M8'/84!

'/1!A5*)A!*5DD748'>!)(1!'/1!&)D1!&01*81&L!)46!84'1(&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!5**7(&!M/14!'/1!

/8?/!614&8'81&!5@!0(16)'5(&!*A7&'1(16!)(1!68@@1(14'!&01*81&!IT8?7(1!"K,!P/1!681'!%(1)6'/!

?()6814'!1O)D841&!'/1!68@@1(14'!1@@1*'&!/8?/!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!/)&!54!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!671!'5!

68@@1(14*1&!84!)!0(16)'5(H&!&01*8@8*8'>,!P/1!?()6814'!&0)4&!@(5D!0(16)'5(&!'/)'!*)4!*54&7D1!

54A>!"Gl!5@!'/1!(1?854)A!0(1>!*5DD748'>!'5!WGl!5@!'/1!(1?854)A!0(1>!*5DD748'>,!P/1!@84)A!

?()6814'L!)A&5!D)4807A)'16!)'!/8?/!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>L!1O)D841&!'/1!0(16)'5(H&!0(16)'854!

84'14&8'>,!^01*8@8*)AA>L!54*1!)!0(1>!8'1D!M8'/84!'/)'!0(16)'5(H&!681'!%(1)6'/!8&!14*574'1(16L!

'/1!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!8&!'/1!0(5%)%8A8'>!'/)'!'/1!0(16)'5(!M8AA!D)4)?1!'5!*)0'7(1L!U8AA!)46!

*54&7D1!'/1!0(1>,!

!

@235B5-3!A:08!@23-C)!

! $!D568@816!VP3_!D561A!8&!7&16!'5!D561A!84'1(&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!IT8?7(1!"K!)'!'/1!

(8?/'!146!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(!)??(1?)'854!?()6814',!P/1!D568@816!VP3_!D561A!0(1&14'16!%>!

d>%1(?L!^D8'/!)46!./)&1!0(168*'&!'/)'!'/1!1Q78A8%(87D!47D%1(!5@!&01*81&!I6K!54!)4!8&A)46!8&!

)!@74*'854!5@!'/1!D)O8D7D!1O'84*'854!()'1!I7KL!8DD8?()'854!()'1!I8KL!)46!'/1!'5')A!47D%1(!5@!

&01*81&!84!'/1!(1?854)A!ID)84A)46K!&01*81&!055A!I9K,!6!8&!(1:61@8416!)&!A5*)A!68=1(&8'>!)46!9!

(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>,!P/1!)7'/5(&!0(1&14'!'/1!@5AA5M84?!1Q7)'854!61&*(8%84?!J:68=1(&8'>!7&84?!

'/1!VP3_2!

! "-!

!

I"K!

!

P5!68@@1(14'8)'1!%1'M114!&01*8)A8&'!)46!?141()A8&'!0(16)'5(&L!'/1!)7'/5(&!)&&7D1!)!417'()A!

*54'(8%7'854!%>!?141()A8&'!0(16)'5(&!54!0(1>!*5DD748'>!)&&1D%A>!&7*/!'/)'!)AA!0(1>!)(1!

1Q7)AA>!=7A41()%A1!'5!0(16)'5(&,!P/7&!1O'84*'854!()'1&!)(1!'/1!&7D!5@!'/1!14=8(54D14')A!

1O'84*'854!()'1&!I7K!)46!1O'84*'854!671!'5!0(16)'854!I79KL!(1&7A'84?!84!'/1!1Q7)'8542!

!

I#K!

!

!

34*5(05()'84?!'/1!)&&7D0'854!'/)'!&01*8)A8&'&!61'1(D848&'8*)AA>!@8A'1(!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!

055AL!'/1!)7'/5(&!84'(567*1!9:-%#"/L!M/8*/!61@841&!'/1!47D%1(!5@!&01*81&!'/)'!*)445'!*5:1O8&'!

M8'/!'/1!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(,!P/7&L!'/1!(1?854)A!055AL!9L!8&!A8D8'16!%>!'/5&1!&01*81&!'/)'!*)4!

*5:1O8&'!M8'/!'/1!0(16)'5(!I9!+!9:-%#"/KL!(1&7A'84?!84!'/1!1Q7)'8542!

!

I-K!

!

j461(!'/8&!D561AL!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A!61*(1)&1&!@)&'1(!'/)4!'/1!A5*)A!&01*81&!055AL!

(1&7A'84?!84!)!D5(1!()086!61*(1)&1!84!J:68=1(&8'>,!!

! 34!5(61(!'5!1O)D841!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!&0)'8)A!)??(1?)'854!5@!0(16)'5(&!54!0(1>!

*5DD748'>!68=1(&8'>!)'!D7A'80A1!&*)A1&L!3!D568@>!'/1!)%5=1!D561A!I1Q,!-K!'5!84*5(05()'1!)4!

84*(1)&84?!47D%1(!5@!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&L!^,!P/8&!(10(1&14'&!541!146!5@!'/1!)??(1?)'854!

! "9!

?()6814'!84!M/8*/!0(16)'5(&!)(1!84'1(&01*8@8*)AA>!)??(1?)'16!IT8?7(1!"K,!P/1!5005&8'1!146!5@!

'/8&!?()6814'L!84!M/8*/!0(16)'5(&!)(1!M861A>!68&'(8%7'16!)*(5&&!)!D1')*5DD748'>!8&!

D561A16!7&84?!&8D7A)'854&!)46!M8AA!%1!)66(1&&16!A)'1(,!b8'/!'/1!)668'854!5@!1)*/!&01*8)A8&'!

0(16)'5(L!^!84*(1)&1&L!(1&7A'84?!84!'/1!@5AA5M84?!1Q7)'8542!

!

I9K!

!

b8'/!1)*/!)668'854)A!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(!M8'/84!'/1!&)D1!*5DD748'>L!'/1!&8N1!5@!9:-%#"/!

84*(1)&1&,!9:-%#"/!!84*(1)&1&!671!'5!)!A)*U!84!5=1(A)0!84!'/1!&01*8@8*!0(1>!'/1!&01*8)A8&'!

0(16)'5(&!1)',!V)*/!&01*8)A8&'!*54&7D1&!748Q71!0(1>!&01*81&L!@8A'1(84?!)!748Q71!05('854!5@!

'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'>,!!C7A'80A1!?141()A8&'!0(16)'5(&!'/)'!/)=1!5=1(A)0!84!'/1!0(1>!*54&7D16!

M57A6!D8'8?)'1!)668'854)A!A5&&!5@!J:68=1(&8'>,!34!*54'()&'L!%1*)7&1!1)*/!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(!

/)&!748Q71!1@@1*'&!54!'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'>L!'/1!*7D7A)'8=1!1@@1*'!8&!D5(1!61'(8D14')A!'5!J:

68=1(&8'>!IT8?7(1!#K,!

!

95D4C'%521$)!

! P5!D561A!'/1!?()6814'&!84!68=1(&8'>L!614&8'>!)46!)??(1?)'854!3!@8(&'!*(1)'16!"GG!

`()465Da!*5DD748'81&!'/)'!M1(1!()465DA>!)&&1D%A16!@(5D!)!(1?854)A!055A!5@!"GG!&01*81&!

)**5(684?!'5!)!()4U:)%746)4*1!*7(=1,!3!7&16!1Q7)'854&!0(1&14'16!%>!g17'1%55D!)46!^'(78U!

I#GGEK!'5!0(567*1!)!()465D8N16!()4U:)%746)4*1!*7(=1!@(5D!M/8*/!'5!*(1)'1!'/1!()465D!

*5DD748'81&!@5(!'/1!417'()A!D1')*5DD748'>,!3!'/14!*)A*7A)'16!)=1()?1!R:!IA5*)AKL!J:!

I&8D8A)(8'>L!JmSn!RL!b/8'')U1(!"WFGL!"W;#K!)46!S:!I(1?854)AK!68=1(&8'>!@5(!'/1!

D1')*5DD748'>!)46!8'1()'16!'/8&!0(5*1&&!"GGG!'8D1&!7&84?!<50P55A&!@5(!VO*1A!I[556!

! "E!

#G"GK,!P/1!(1&7A'&!@(5D!'/1&1!&8D7A)'854&!)46!'/1!&7%&1Q714'!WEl!.3&!)(1!68&0A)>16!

?()0/8*)AA>!IT8?7(1&!-:BK,!j&84?!'/8&!`417'()Aa!D1')*5DD748'>!)&!)!*5D0)(8&54L!3!'/14!

)00A816!68@@1(14'!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&L!D)4807A)'84?!'/1!@5AA5M84?!0)()D1'1(&,!

9/",$#'/!;-."/(-#0!</$,-"1#!

! P/1!@8(&'!Q71&'854!3!&57?/'!'5!)4&M1(!M)&!M/1'/1(!*/)4?1&!84!'/1!68=1(&8'>!)'!541!

'(50/8*!A1=1AL!'/)'!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(L!)@@1*'&!68=1(&8'>!)'!)!A5M1(!'(50/8*!A1=1AL!'/)'!5@!'/1!0(1>,!

P5!D561A!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!84*(1)&84?!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!54!0(1>!68=1(&8'>L!3!&')('16!M8'/!'/1!

417'()A!D1')*5DD748'>!61&*(8%16!)%5=1!)46!&8D7A)'16!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!)6684?!541!&01*8)A8&'!

0(16)'5(!)'!)!'8D1!'5!'/1!D1')*5DD748'>!IT8?7(1!"K,!<(16)'5(!614&8'81&!M1(1!U10'!A5M!84!

'/8&!&8D7A)'854]!1)*/!A5*)A!*5DD748'>!M)&!)&&8?416!54A>!541!0(16)'5(,!P/8&!)&&7D0'854!

M8AA!%1!(1A)O16!84!A)'1(!&8D7A)'854&,!P/1!681'!%(1)6'/!5@!'/1!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(!8&!61@8416!)&!

#Gl!5@!'/1!14'8(1!(1?854)A!*5DD748'>L!8&!()465DA>!)&&8?416L!)46!*/)4?1&!M8'/!1)*/!

8'1()'854,!\41!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(!M8'/84!'/1!A5*)A8'>!0(1>&!54!)!748Q71A>!8614'8@816!#Gl!

&7%&1'!5@!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A,!b8'/!1)*/!8'1()'854L!'/1!&)D1!&7%&1'!5@!8614'8@816!0(1>!

&01*81&!8&!=7A41()%A1!'5!0(16)'854!%>!'/1!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(,!34!'/8&!D561A!'/1!0(16)'5(&!

/)=1!)!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!5@!BGlL!D1)484?L!'/1!8468=867)A!0(1>!&01*81&!'/)'!)(1!M8'/84!'/1!

681'!%(1)6'/!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(!1)*/!/)=1!)!0(5%)%A>!5@!G,BG!5@!%184?!U8AA16!%>!'/1!0(16)'5(!

M/14!'/1!0(16)'5(!)46!0(1>!*5:5**7(,!P/8&!A1=1A!5@!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!M)&!7&16!84&'1)6!5@!

"GGl!'5!&8D7A)'1!A5*)A!0(1>!(1@7?8)!84!4)'7()A!*5DD748'81&,![5M1=1(L!'/8&!)&&7D0'854!8&!

(1A)O16!84!'/1!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!?()6814'!%1A5M,!$&!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&!)(1!)6616L!

84*(1)&84?!'/1!J:68=1(&8'>!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(!'(50/8*!A1=1AL!'/1!A5&&!5@!J:)46!!:68=1(&8'>!%1?84&!

'5!%1!D168)'16L!(1&7A'84?!84!68=1(&8'>!=)A71&!*A5&1(!'5!'/5&1!1O01*'16!%>!*5DD748'81&!M8'/!

45!0(16)'5(&!)'!)AA!IT8?7(1!-K,!

! "F!

9/",$#'/!;-"#!=/"$,#2!!

! \@'14!0(16)'5(&!)(1!*A)&&8@816!84'5!'/1&1!'M5!68&*(1'1!*)'1?5(81&!5@!681'!%(1)6'/!@5(!

*54=14814*12!&01*8)A8&'!5(!?141()A8&',![5M1=1(L!)!?()6814'!5@!&01*8)A8N)'854!D)>!%1!D5(1!

(10(1&14')'8=1!5@!(1)A8'>,!P/8&!D561A!&11U&!'5!)4&M1(!'/1!Q71&'8542!7461(!)!/8?/!68=1(&8'>!5@!

0(16)'5(!&01*81&!&0(1)6!)*(5&&!'/1!A)46&*)01L!/5M!651&!)!*/)4?1!84!681'!%(1)6'/!)@@1*'!

68=1(&8'>o![1(1!3!&8D7A)'1!)!()4?1!5@!0(16)'5(!681'!%(1)6'/&!84!)!D1')*5DD748'>,!P/1!

A5M1&'!681'!%(1)6'/!(10(1&14'&!'/1!D5&'!&01*8)A8N16!0(16)'5(,!P/8&!0(16)'5(!*)4!54A>!

*54&7D1!"Gl!5@!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055AL!)46!54*1!14*574'1(16L!'/1!0(1>!8&!54A>!U8AA16!

BGl!5@!'/1!'8D1L!)&!D561A16!)%5=1!84!'/1!68=1(&8'>!?()6814',!P/1!D5&'!?141()A!5@!'/1!

0(16)'5(&!*)4!*54&7D1!WGl!5@!'/1!(1?854)A!0(1>!&01*81&,!b8'/!84*(1)&84?!681'!%(1)6'/!

D5(1!&01*81&!)(1!=7A41()%A1!'5!0(16)'854L!)46!%>!D)84')8484?!'/1!&)D1!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!

)&!)%5=1!IBGl!0(1>!14*574'1(16!U8AA16K!'/1!A5*)A!)46!(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>!61*(1)&1&,!_1*)7&1!

0(16)'5(!&)'7()'854!8&!45'!84*A7616!84!'/8&!D561AL!'/1!)=)8A)%8A8'>!5@!D5(1!0(1>!@5(!'/1!

0(16)'5(!)AA5M&!@5(!?(1)'1(!1@@1*'&!%>!'/1!?141()A8&'!54!'/1!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!IT8?7(1!9K,!!

9/",$#-'1!81#"1(-#0!!

! 3'!8&!74A8U1A>!'/)'L!)&!D561A16!)%5=1L!)AA!0(16)'5(&!/)=1!1Q78=)A14'!*)0'7(1!

1@@8*814*81&,!P/1(1@5(1L!68@@1(14'!0(16)'5(&!D)>!68@@1(!84!'/1!0(5%)%8A8'>!'/)'!'/1>!M8AA!

1A8D84)'1!0(1>!54*1!'/1>!)(1!14*574'1(16,!P5!)**574'!@5(!'/1&1!68@@1(14*1&!84!0(16)'854!

84'14&8'>L!3!(1A)O!'/1!)%5=1!)&&7D0'854!'/)'!)AA!0(16)'5(&!U8AA!BGl!5@!'/1!0(1>!M8'/84!'/18(!

681'!%(1)6'/!'/)'!'/1>!14*574'1(,!$&!'/1!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!84*(1)&1&!@(5D!"Gl!5@!

14*574'1(16!0(1>!U8AA16!'5!"GGl!14*574'1(16!0(1>!U8AA16L!)AA!'/(11!68=1(&8'>!D1)&7(1&!

61*A841L!M8'/!'/1!(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>!61*A8484?!@)&'1(!'/)4!'/1!)A0/)L!(1&7A'84?!84!61*(1)&16!J:

68=1(&8'>!@5(!'/1!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!5@!"GGl,!<(16)'854!84'14&8'>!%1A5M!"GGl!I84!M/8*/!

! ";!

0(1>!*)445'!*5:1O8&'!)'!)AA!M8'/!'/1!0(16)'5(K!)AA5M&!)!&D)AA!01(*14')?1!5@!'/1!0(1>!'5!&'8AA!

1O8&'!A5*)AA>L!D)84')8484?!'/1D!84!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055AL!'/1(1@5(1!0(1=14'84?!)!6()&'8*!

61*A841!84!J:68=1(&8'>,![5M1=1(L!M/14!0(1>!)(1!6(8=14!1O'84*'!A5*)AA>!%>!)!0(16)'5(L!J:

68=1(&8'>!651&!61*A841!IT8?7(1!EK,!

9/",$#'/!;"1(-#0!</$,-"1#!

! <(16)'5(:0(1>!6>4)D8*&!&7??1&'!'/)'!0(16)'5(!614&8'81&!)@@1*'!%5'/!0(1>!614&8'81&!

)46!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!I(1=81M16!84!<1'1(&54!"W;WK,![1(1!3!&8D7A)'1!)4!84*(1)&1!84!0(16)'5(!

614&8'>!54!%5'/!&861&!5@!'/1!68=1(&8'>!?()6814'!IT8?7(1!"K,!3!84*(1)&1!'/1!614&8'>!)'!A5M!

68=1(&8'>!@(5D!541!0(16)'5(!'5!@8=1!0(16)'5(&!5@!'/1!&)D1!&01*81&,!P/1!681'!5@!'/1!&01*8)A8&'!

)46!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!(1D)84!)'!#Gl!)46!BGl!(1&01*'8=1A>L!)&!84!'/1!68=1(&8'>!D561A!

)%5=1,!$4!84*(1)&1!84!0(16)'5(!614&8'>!)'!A5M!68=1(&8'>!A1)6&!'5!)!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!'/)'!

M57A6!%1!41)(A>!1Q78=)A14'!'5!)!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!5@!"GGl,!V)*/!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(!

*)7&16!)!#Gl!61*(1)&1!84!D1)4!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!I.3!0(16!"2!;GL!BF!0(16!#:E!.32!;ELB#K,!3@!'/1!

0(1>!8&!45'!*54&7D16!%>!'/1!@8(&'!8468=867)A!0(16)'5(L!8'!M8AA!%1!*54&7D16!%>!)!&7%&1Q714'!

0(16)'5(!M/14!614&8'81&!)(1!/8?/!1457?/,!!$4!84*(1)&1!84!0(16)'5(!614&8'>!)'!/8?/!68=1(&8'>!

(1&7A'&!84!'M5!05&&8%A1!&0)'8)A!*54@8?7()'854&!IT8?7(1!"K,!$'!/8?/1(!614&8'81&!0(16)'5(&!

18'/1(!*A7&'1(!M8'/!0(16)'5(&!5@!'/1!&)D1!&01*81&!A1)684?!'5!84'()&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854L!5(!

'/1>!68&01(&1!)*(5&&!'/1!D1')*5DD748'>L!(1&7A'84?!84!84'1(&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854,!P/7&L!

84*(1)&16!614&8'>!A1)6&!'5!'/1!@84)A!?()6814'2!0(16)'5(!)??(1?)'854,!

9/",$#-'1!>??/"?$#-'1!</$,-"1#!

! 34!)668'854!'5!'/1!)%5=1!D561A&L!M/8*/!)66(1&&!'/1!1@@1*'&!'/)'!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>L!

681'!%(1)6'/!)46!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!/)=1!54!0(1>!*5DD748'>!68=1(&8'>L!3!&8D7A)'1!'/1!

1@@1*'!5@!84*(1)&84?!0(16)'5(!614&8'>!M8'/84!'/1!*54'1O'!5@!/8?/!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>,!!

! "B!

34'()&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!5**7(&!M/14!0(16)'5(&!*A7&'1(!M8'/84!'/1!&)D1!A5*)A8'>!M8'/!

5'/1(&!5@!'/1!&)D1!&01*81&,!b/14!0(16)'5(!J:68=1(&8'>!8&!/8?/L!)46!'/1(1!)(1!&1=1()A!

0(16)'5(!&01*81&!(10(1&14'16!M8'/84!)!D1')*5DD748'>L!'/1!(1&7A'!8&!&1?(1?)'854!54!)!

(1?854)A!&*)A1!IT8?7(1!"K,!T8=1!0(16)'5(&!)(1!(10(1&14'16!M8'/84!'/1!D1')*5DD748'>L!1)*/!

*54&'()8416!'5!"nE!5@!'/1!A5*)A!*5DD748'81&!84!M/8*/!1)*/!0(16)'5(!*A7&'1(&!54A>!M8'/!8'&!

5M4!&01*81&,!P/1!(1&7A')4'!0(1>!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!8&!45'!&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!@(5D!417'()A!

1O01*')'854&!IT8?7(1!;K,!!P/1!D568@816!VP3_!D561A!(10(1&14'&!'/1!5005&8'1!146!5@!'/1!

)??(1?)'854!&01*'(7D2!84'1(&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!IT8?7(1!#K,![5M1=1(L!'/1!)%5=1!D561A!)46!

&8D7A)'854&!A)*U!(1)A8&D!671!'5!'/1!)('8@8*8)A!68&01(&)A!5@!1O)*'A>!541!&01*8@8*!0(16)'5(!'5!

1)*/!A5*)A!*5DD748'>,!c8&01(&)A!8&!45'!&5!D1'8*7A57&!84!4)'7(1,!P5!)66!(1)A8&D!'5!'/1!

84'1(&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!D561AL!3!*(1)'16!'M5!&01*81&!055A&L!541!5@!0(16)'5(&!)46!'/1!5'/1(!

0(1>,!P/1!0(16)'5(!&01*81&!055A!M)&!'/14!()465DA>!68&01(&16!'5!'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!&5!

'/)'!&5D1!*5DD748'81&!D)>!/)=1!D5(1!'/)4!541!0(16)'5(!M/8A1!5'/1(&!/)=1!4541,!P/8&!

(1A)O1&!'/1!)&&7D0'854!5@!'/1!7%8Q78'>!5@!0(16)'5(&!)*(5&&!)!D1')*5DD748'>,!34*(1)&84?!

'/1!0(16)'5(!&01*81&!055A!84!&8N1!@(5D!"GG!'5!EGG!8468=867)A&!I54!)=1()?1!541!0(16)'5(!'5!

@8=1!0(16)'5(&!01(!A5*)A8'>K!)AA5M&!@5(!'/1!61'1(D84)'854!5@!'/1!1@@1*'&!54!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!

*)7&16!%>!84*(1)&84?!0(16)'854!%>!)!/1'1(5?14157&!D8O!5@!0(16)'5(&!IT8?7(1!FK,!34!4)'7(1!

'/8&!D8?/'!%1!(10(1&14'16!%>!)!M)=1!5@!D7A'80A1!&01*8)A8&'!84=)&8=1!&01*81&!68&'(8%7'16!

()465DA>!)*(5&&!)!A)46&*)01,!P/7&L!)'!/8?/!614&8'81&!84'1(&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!5@!0(16)'5(&!

&8?48@8*)4'A>!61*(1)&16!0(1>!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!M/8A1!84'()&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!686!45'!68@@1(!

@(5D!417'()A!1O01*')'854&!IT8?7(1!;L!T8?7(1!#K,!

!

!

! "W!

>09*?990=<)!

! P/1!(5A1!0(16)'5(&!0A)>!84!&'(7*'7(84?!0(1>!0507A)'854&!/)&!%114!D7*/!68&*7&&16!84!

'/1!A8'1()'7(1!I[5A'!"W;;L!d8*UA1@&!"WB;L!./)&1!"#!$%&!#GGWL!d>%1(?L!^D8'/L!./)&1!84!d1=81MK,!

$A'/57?/!0(1=857&!M5(U!/)&!84*5(05()'16!0(16)'5(!8614'8'>L!68@@1(14*1&!84!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!

0(16)'5(&!54!'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'>L!)46!'/1!8D05(')4*1!5@!84*5(05()'84?!&01*81&H!8614'8'81&!

Ip&'D)4!)46!./)&1!#GG;L!d>%1(?!^D8'/!)46!./)&1!84!d1=81MKL!45!(1&1)(*/!54!0(16)'5(!

1@@1*'&!54!0(1>!D1')*5DD748'81&!/)&!)A&5!&01*8@8*)AA>!84*5(05()'16!'/1!8614'8'>!5@!'/1!0(1>!

0507A)'854,!$!748Q71!0(1>!8614'8'>!8614'8@81&!)!&01*8@8*!0(1>!&01*81&!)&!)!0(16)'5(H&!')(?1'L!

1&')%A8&/84?!748Q71!0(16)'5(:0(1>!(1A)'854&/80&,!P/1&1!(1A)'854&/80&!5@!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&!

M8'/!'/18(!0(1>!)AA5M!@5(!'/1!1O8&'14*1!5@!0(1>!&0)'8)A!(1@7?8)L!6(8=84?!'/1!68@@1(14*1&!84!J:!

)46!S:68=1(&8'>,!V*5A5?8&'&!@(1Q714'A>!61%)'1!'/1!8D05(')4*1!5@!&'5*/)&'8*8'>!)46!

61'1(D848&D!84!&'(7*'7(84?!*5DD748'81&L!)46!(1*14'!M5(U!/)&!&/5M4!'/)'!&01*8)A8&'!

0(16)'5(&!84*(1)&1!'/1!8D05(')4*1!5@!61'1(D848&DL!)*'84?!)&!@8A'1(&L!'/7&!/5D5?148N84?!

*5DD748'81&!Id>%1(?L!^D8'/L!./)&1!84!d1=81ML!./)&1!"#!$%&!#GGWK,!P/1!(1&7A'&!5@!'/1&1!

D561A&!&7??1&'!'/)'!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&L!61D54&'()'84?!61'1(D848&'8*!0(501('81&L!

)D1A85()'1!'/1!61*(1)&1!84!J:68=1(&8'>!*)7&16!%>!541!748@5(D!0(16)'5(!M/14!&0(1)6!)*(5&&!

)!D1')*5DD748'>!IT8?7(1!-LFL;LBK,!^01*8@8*)AA>L!'/1!*7D7A)'8=1!1@@1*'&!5@!454:)??(1?)'16!

&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&!)(1!&8D8A)(!'5!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!)!?141()A8&'!0(16)'5(!)&!0(1&14'16!%>!

d>%1(?L!^D8'/!)46!./)&1,!

! <(1=857&!M5(U!/)&!84*5(05()'16!&5D1!&0)'8)A!*5D05414'&!84'5!)4)A>&1&!54!0(16)'5(!

1@@1*'&!)'!68@@1(14'!&*)A1&,!d>%1(?!^D8'/!)46!./)&1!1O)D8416!*/)4?1&!84!0)'*/!I8&A)46K!&8N1!

)&!M1AA!)&!8&5A)'854!)D54?!0)'*/1&!)46!5=1()AA!D1')*5DD748'>!&8N1,!P/1!D561A&!0(1&14'16!

/1(1!54!&0)'8)A!)??(1?)'854!)46!68=1(&8'>!5@!0(16)'5(&!)66!'5!'/8&!0(1=857&!M5(U,!

! #G!

^01*8@8*)AA>L!3!@5746!'/)'!68@@1(14*1&!84!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)46!)??(1?)'854!/)=1!68@@1(14'8)A!

1@@1*'&!54!68=1(&8'>!)*(5&&!&*)A1&,!34'1(&01*8@8*)AA>!)??(1?)'16!?(570&!5@!0(16)'5(&!14/)4*1!

'/1!61'1(D848&'8*!1@@1*'&!5@!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&!I)&!&114!84!d>%1(?L!^D8'/!)46!./)&1!84!

d1=81MK!IT8?7(1!#L!FL!)46!;K,!.54=1(&1A>L!M/14!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&!)(1!*A7&'1(16!M8'/84!)!

A5*)A8'>L!)46!45'!7%8Q78'57&!)*(5&&!'/1!A)46&*)01!I84'()&01*8@8*)AA>!)??(1?)'16K!&'5*/)&'8*!

1@@1*'&!65D84)'1L!)46!J:68=1(&8'>!8&!D)84')8416!IT8?7(1!;K,!P/1&1!(1&7A'&!&7??1&'!'/)'!45'!

54A>!8&!)!/8?/!68=1(&8'>!)'!'/1!0(16)'5(!'(50/8*!A1=1A!41*1&&)(>!@5(!D)84'14)4*1!5@!0(1>!

68=1(&8'>!IT8?7(1!BKL!%7'!'/1!&0)'8)A!*5D05&8'854!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(&!)'!)!/8?/!68=1(&8'>!)A&5!

61'1(D841&!0(1>!*5DD748'>!68=1(&8'>!IT8?7(1!;K,!P/1(1!M8AA!)AM)>&!%1!&5D1!0(1>!&01*81&!

'/)'!A81!57'&861!5@!'/1!681'!%(1)6'/!5@!*1(')84!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&,!P/1(1@5(1L!/8?/1(!

0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!84*(1)&1&!(1@7?8)!)=)8A)%A1!'5!0(1>!&01*81&!M8'/84!)!A)46&*)01L!

01(D8''84?!'/1!01(&8&'14*1!5@!)!A)(?1(!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A,![5M1=1(L!/8?/!0(16)'5(!

68=1(&8'>!54A>!D)84')84&!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!84!'/1!*)&1!'/)'!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&!)??(1?)'1!

84'()&01*8@8*)AA>L!&5!'/)'!'/1&1!(1@7?8)!1O8&'!&5D1M/1(1!84!'/1!D1')*5DD748'>,!P/1(1@5(1L!

68=1(&8'>!)D54?!0(16)'5(&!8&!8D05(')4'!@5(!'/1!68=1(&8'>!5@!'/1!0(1>,!$!D5(1!68=1(&1!

*5DD748'>!5@!0(16)'5(&!*)4!A1)6!'5!)!D5(1!68=1(&1!*5DD748'>!5@!0(1>L!(1&7A'84?!84!`J:

68=1(&8'>!'(50/8*!*)&*)61&a!84!M/8*/!J:68=1(&8'>!)'!541!'(50/8*!A1=1A!(1&7A'&!84!84*(1)&16!

%1'):68=1(&8'>!)'!'/1!'(50/8*!A1=1A!%1A5M,!![5M1=1(L!'/8&!68=1(&8'>!'(50/8*!*)&*)61!610146&!

54!'/1!'>01!5@!)??(1?)'854!61D54&'()'16!%>!'/1!0(16)'5(,!

! T5(!'/1!&)U1!5@!&8D0A8*8'>L!'/8&!D561A!D)U1&!&1=1()A!)&&7D0'854&!'/)'!A)*U!&5D1!

(1)A8&D,!!T8(&'L!'/1&1!&8D7A)'854&!)&&7D1!0(16)'854!61*(1)&1&!68=1(&8'>!)'!'/1!A5*)A!&*)A1,!

[5M1=1(L!'/8&!651&!45'!)AM)>&!/5A6!'(712!0(16)'854!*)4!84*(1)&1!68=1(&8'>!A5*)AA>!84!*)&1&!5@!

! #"!

U1>&'541!0(16)'854!I1,?,L!<)841!"WFFK,!34*5(05()'84?!U1>&'541!0(16)'854!M57A6!)66!>1'!

)45'/1(!68@@1(14*1!84!0(16)'5(!8614'8'>!)46!*57A6!D5(1!(1)A8&'8*)AA>!D561A!4)'7()A!&>&'1D&,!!

! ^1*546L!'/1&1!&8D7A)'854&!8?45(1!0(16)'5(:0(1>!6>4)D8*&!%>!)&&7D84?!'/)'!

0(16)'5(!0507A)'854&!)(1!8461014614'!5@!0(1>!0507A)'854&,!VO'84*'854!()'1&!)(1!

84*5(05()'16!84'5!'/8&!D561AL!%7'!8DD8?()'854!8&!74)@@1*'16!%>!'/1!0(1&14*1!5@!0(16)'5(&,!

P/8&!D)>!45'!(1@A1*'!(1)A8'>!84!)AA!*)&1&,!T5(!84&')4*1L!D)4>!&01*81&!5@!)D0/8%8)4&!)(1!

U45M4!'5!&1A1*'8=1A>!5=805&8'!84!0546&!M8'/!45!0(16)'5(&L!)=58684?!0)'*/1&!M8'/!'/5&1!

0(1&14'!I1,?,!Y)'N!)46!^8/!"WW#K,!$A'/57?/!84*5(05()'84?!Z5'U):X5A'1(()!0(16)'5(:0(1>!

6>4)D8*&!84'5!'/8&!D561A!M57A6!)66!D5(1!(1)A8&DL!?141()A!'(146&!D)>!%1*5D1!5%&*7(16!

%>!'/1!)6616!*5D0A1O8'>!)46!)(1!'/7&!%1>546!'/1!&*501!5@!'/8&!&'76>,!!

! $668'854)AA>L!'/8&!D561A!651&!45'!84*A761!*/)4?1&!84!0(16)'5(!&)'7()'854,!P/1!

47D%1(!5@!0(1>!&01*81&!A5*)AA>!0(1&14'!M)&!*54'(5AA16!@5(!M/14!D)4807A)'84?!0(16)'5(!681'!

%(1)6'/!)&!)!0(5O>!@5(!0(16)'5(!&)'7()'854L!%7'!8'!8&!45'!68(1*'A>!D561A16!IT8?7(1!9K,!

h141()A8&'!0(16)'5(&!/)=1!D5(1!0(1>!50'854&L!'/7&!A)(?1(!47D%1(&!5@!0(1>!84!1)*/!A5*)A8'>,!

b8'/57'!*54'(5AA84?!@5(!A5*)A!0507A)'854!&8N1!5(!84*5(05()'84?!0(16)'5(!*54&7D0'8=1!

&)'7()'854L!'/1!?141()A8&'!&01*81&!*54'847)AA>!*54&7D1&!0(1>L!74(1)A8&'8*)AA>!61*(1)&84?!

&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!)*(5&&!&*)A1&,!$!%1''1(!D1*/)48&D!@5(!D561A84?!0(16)'5(!*54&7D0'8=1!

&)'7()'854!M57A6!%141@8'!'/8&!D561A,!T84)AA>L!@7'7(1!M5(U!D)4807A)'84?!'/1!&8N1!5@!

D1')*5DD748'>!D)>!)A'1(!'/1!1@@1*'!&8N1&!&114!84!'/8&!&'76>L!)A'/57?/!'/1!?141()A!'(146&!

&/57A6!(1D)84!'/1!&)D1,!P/1&1!D561A&!7&16!)!D1')*5DD748'>!&8N1!1Q78=)A14'!'5!'/1!

(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A,!^7*/!)!A)(?1!D1')*5DD748'>!D)>!%1!0(5=8684?!'/1!()(1!&01*81&!M8'/!

`&'5*/)&'8*!(1@7?1&La!)AA5M84?!'/1D!'5!1O8&'!84!=1(>!@1M!A5*)A8'81&!671!'5!()465D!*/)4*1!

! ##!

61&08'1!0(16)'854,!$!&D)AA1(!D1')*5DD748'>!D8?/'!%1''1(!8AA7&'()'1!&1A1*'8=1!1O'84*'854!

671!'5!0(16)'854!)46!'/7&!61D54&'()'1!)!&'(54?1(!D7A'80(16)'5(!1@@1*',!!

! b/14!1O)D8484?!0)''1(4&!5@!%8568=1(&8'>L!D)4>!0)''1(4&!D7&'!%1!*54&861(16!84!

*54*1(',!P/1!8D05(')4*1!5@!&0)'8)A!&*)A1!/)&!A54?!%114!(1*5?48N16L!)46!'/1(1!/)&!%114!D7*/!

M5(U!54!'/1!(1A)'854&/80!%1'M114!&01*81&!(8*/41&&!)46!)(1)!I^*/5141(!"W;FK,!b/8A1!8'!/)&!

A54?!%114!U45M4!'/)'!68=1(&8'>!0)''1(4&!*/)4?1!)*(5&&!&0)'8)A!&*)A1&L!8'!8&!A1&&!7461(&'556!

/5M!0(16)'854!)@@1*'&!'/1&1!0)''1(4&,!_>!%78A684?!54!(1*14'!0(16)'5(:61014614'!&0)'8)A!

D561A&L!'/8&!&'76>!0(5=861&!)!@()D1M5(U!'5!1O)D841!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)46!

)??(1?)'854!54!%8568=1(&8'>,!P/1&1!(1&7A'&!8468*)'1!'/)'!0)''1(4&!5@!&*)A1L!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!

)46!0(16)'5(!)??(1?)'854!*)445'!%1!=81M16!8461014614'A>,!b/8A1!'/1!D561A!61D54&'()'1&!

'/)'!/8?/!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!*)4!D168)'1!'/1!/5D5?148N84?!1@@1*'&!5@!)!&84?A1!&01*8)A8&'!

0(16)'5(L!84'1(&01*8@8*!&0)'8)A!)??(1?)'854!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(&!*574'1()*'&!'/8&!D168)'8=1!

1@@1*',!P/7&L!M/14!1O)D8484?!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(&!54!0(1>!%8568=1(&8'>L!8'!8&!*(8'8*)A!'5!

*54&861(!45'!54A>!&0)'8)A!&*)A1L!%7'!)A&5!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)46!&0)'8)A!)??(1?)'854,!

!

"*E<=F6A>GA@A<:9!

This work was done for a senior honors thesis in Environmental Studies at Washington

University in St. Louis. I would like to thank my advisor, Kevin G. Smith, for providing ideas,

comments and guidance. 3!M57A6!)A&5!A8U1!'5!'/)4U!$,!./74?L!$,!^'()7&&L!V,!C5()4L!C,!V=)4&L!

Y,!<5M1AA!)46!e,!./)&1!@5(!/1A0@7A!68&*7&&854!54!'/1!861)&!@5(!'/8&!0)01(,!$668'854)AA>!3!

M57A6!A8U1!'5!'/)4U!'/1!14'8(1!.5DD748'>!V*5A5?>!.A)&&!5@!#G"G!@5(!/1A0@7A!68&*7&&854,!

!

!

!

! #-!

65%-&'%4&-!*5%-3!

./)&1L!e,!C,L!<,!$,!$%()D&L!e,!<,!h(5=1(L!^,!c81/AL!<,!./1&&54L!d,!c,![5A'L!d,!C,!g8&%1'L!)46!P,!e,!

.)&1,!#GG#,!P/1!84'1()*'854!%1'M114!0(16)'854!)46!*5D01'8'8542!)!(1=81M!)46!

&>4'/1&8&,!V*5A5?>!Z1''1(&!E2-G#:-"E,!

./)&1L!e,!C,L!)46!C,!$,!Z18%5A6,!#GG-,!V*5A5?8*)A!g8*/1&2!Z84U84?!.A)&&8*)A!)46!.54'1D05()(>!

$00(5)*/1&,!j48=1(&8'>!5@!./8*)?5!<(1&&L!./8*)?5,!

./)&1!eC,!#GG;,!c(57?/'!D168)'1&!'/1!8D05(')4*1!5@!&'5*/)&'8*!*5DD748'>!)&&1D%A>,!<g$^!

"G92!";9-G:";9-9,!

./)&1L!e,!C,L!V,!h,!_8(5L!b,!$,!d>%1(?L!)46!Y,!h,!^D8'/,!#GGW,!<(16)'5(&!'1D01(!'/1!(1A)'8=1!

8D05(')4*1!5@!&'5*/)&'8*!0(5*1&&1&!84!'/1!)&&1D%A>!5@!0(1>!D1')*5DD748'81&,!

V*5A5?>!Z1''1(&!"#2"#"G:"#"B,!

./)=1!e,!#GG9,!g17'()A!P/15(>!)46!*5DD748'>!1*5A5?>,!V*5A5?>!Z1''1(&!;2!#9":#E-,!

h(5=1(L!e,!<,!"WWE,!.5D01'8'854L!/1(%8=5(>L!)46!14(8*/D14'2!47'(814':%)&16!D561A&!@5(!

168%A1!)46!84168%A1!0A)4'&,!$D1(8*)4!g)'7()A8&'!"9-2;9F:;;9,!

[1L!T,!)46!<,!Z1?146(1,!#GG#,!^01*81&!c8=1(&8'>!<)''1(4&!c1(8=16!@(5D!^01*81&:$(1)!C561A&,!

! V*5A5?>!B-2!""BE:""WB,!

[5A'L!d,!c,!"W;;,!<(16)'854L!)00)(14'!*5D01'8'854L!)46!'/1!&'(7*'7(1!5@!0(1>!*5DD748'81&,!

P/15(,<50,!_85A,!"#2"W;:!##W,!

[556L!h,!C,!,#G"G,!<50P55A&!=1(&854!-,#,-,!$=)8A)%A1!54!'/1!84'1(41',!jdZ!

! /''02nnMMM,050'55A&,5(?!

[7%%1AA!^<,!#GG"!P/1!j48@816!g17'()A!P/15(>!5@!^01*81&!$%746)4*1!)46!c8=1(&8'>,!

<(84*1'54!j48=!<(1&&L!<(84*1'54,!

Y)'&!Z,!_,!)46!$!^8/,!"WW#,!\=805&8'854!^8'1!^1A1*'854!)46!$=586)4*1!5@!T8&/!%>!^'(1)D&861!

^)A)D)461(&!I$D%>&'5D)!%)(%57(8K,!.5018)!"WW#2!9FB:9;-,!

C)*$('/7(L!d,![,L!)46!V,!\,!b8A&54,!"WF-,!$4!1Q78A8%(87D!'/15(>!5@!84&7A)(!N55?15?()0/>,!

V=5A7'854!";2-;-f-B;,!

C)*$('/7(L!d,![,L!)46!V,!\,!b8A&54,!"WF;,!P/1!'/15(>!5@!8&A)46!%85?15?()0/>,!<(84*1'54!

j48=1(&8'>!<(1&&,!

g17'1%55DL!e,[,!!)46!<,.!^'(78U,!#GGE,!X)(8)'854!84!()4U!)%746)4*1!(10A8*)'1!&)D0A1&!)46!

8D0)*'!5@!*A7&'1(84?,!ge$^!E-2!"WW:###,!

! #9!

\((5*U!eZ!)46!de!TA1'*/1(!e(,!#GGE,!./)4?1&!84!*5DD748'>!&8N1!)@@1*'!'/1!57'*5D1!5@!

*5D01'8'854,!P/1!$D1(8*)4!g)'7()A8&',!"FF2!"G;:""",!

\&'D)4L!\L!eC!Y418'1A!)46!eC!./)&1,!#GGF,!c8&'7(%)4*1!)A'1(&!/)%8')'!8&5A)'854H&!1@@1*'!54!

%8568=1(&8'>!84!)Q7)'8*!D8*(5*5&D&,!\8U5&!""92!-FG:-FF,!

<)841L!d,!P,!"WFF,!T556!M1%!*5D0A1O8'>!)46!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>,!$D1(8*)4!g)'7()A8&'!"GG2FE:

;E,!

<1'1(&54L!.,![,!"W;W,!<(16)'854L!*5D01'8'8=1!1O*A7&854L!)46!68=1(&8'>!84!'/1!&5@'!&168D14'!

%14'/8*!*5DD748'81&!5@!1&'7)(81&!)46!A)?554&,!<)?1&!#--:#F9!84!d,!e,!Z8=84?&'54L!

168'5(,!V*5A5?8*)A!0(5*1&&1&!84!*5)&')A!)46!D)(841!&>&'1D&,!<A147DL!g1M!q5(UL!g1M!

q5(UL!j^$,!

d8*UA1@&L!d,!V,!"WB;,!.5DD748'>!c8=1(&8'>2!d1A)'8=1!(5A1&!5@!A5*)A!)46!(1?854)A!0(5*1&&1&,!

^*814*1!#-E2!"F;:";",!

d>%1(?L!b,!$,L!)46!e,!C,!./)&1,!#GG;,!<(16)'5(:61014614'!&01*81&:)(1)!(1A)'854&/80&,!

$D1(8*)4!g)'7()A8&'!";G2F-F:F9#,!

d>%1(?!b,!$,L!Y,!h,!^D8'/L!)46!e,!C,!./)&1,!<(16)'5(&!)A'1(!'/1!&*)A84?!5@!68=1(&8'>!84!0(1>!

! D1')*5DD748'81&,!34!<(1&&,!

^*/5141(L!P,!b,!"W;F,!P/1!&01*81&:)(1)!(1A)'854!M8'/84!)(*/801A)?51&2!D561A&!)46!

! 1=8614*1!@(5D!8&A)46!A)46!%8(6&,!<(5*11684?&!5@!'/1!34'1(4)'854)A!\(48'/5A5?8*)A!

! .54?(1&&!"W;F2!F#WfF9#,!

^/7(84L!e,!_,L!)46!V,!.,!$AA14,!#GG",!V@@1*'&!5@!*5D01'8'854L!0(16)'854L!)46!68&01(&)AL!54!

&01*81&!(8*/41&&L!)'!A5*)A!)46!(1?854)A!&*)A1&,!$D1(8*)4!g)'7()A8&'!"EB2F#9:!F-;,!

^8/L!$,L!<,!.(5MA1>L!C,!C*<11UL!e,!<1'()4U)L!)46!Y,!^'(5/D181(,!"WBE,!<(16)'854L!*5D01'8'854L!

)46!0(1>!*5DD748'81&2!)!(1=81M!5@!@81A6!1O01(8D14'&,!$447)A!d1=81M!5@!V*5A5?>!)46!

^>&'1D)'8*&!"F2#FW:-"",!

b/8'')U1(L!d,[,!"WFG,!X1?1')'854!5@!'/1!^8&U8>57!D574')84&L!\(1?54!)46!.)A8@5(48),!

V*5A5?8*)A!C545?()0/&L!-GL!#;Wf--B,!!

b/8'')U1(L!d,[,!"W;#,!V=5A7'854!)46!D1)&7(1D14'!5@!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>,!P)O54L!#"L!#"-f#E",!!

!

!

!

!

! #E!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

T8?7(1!",!.54*10'7)A!D561A!(10(1&14'84?!'/1!'/(11!D)r5(!?()6814'&!&8D7A)'16,!

P/1!68=1(&8'>!?()6814'!&0)4&!@(5D!A5M!68=1(&8'>L!541!0(16)'5(!&01*81&L!

(10(1&14'16!%>!)!A1''1(!$L!I'50!A1@'K!'5!/8?/!68=1(&8'>L!E!0(16)'5(!&01*81&!I$:VK!

I'50!(8?/'K,!c81'!%(1)6'/!)46!0(16)'854!84'14&8'>!&8D7A)'854&!)(1!D561A16!)'!'/1!

/8?/!68=1(&8'>!146!5@!'/8&!?()6814',!P/1!614&8'>!?()6814'!()4?1&!@(5D!A5M!

0(16)'5(!614&8'81&!)'!A5M!68=1(&8'>!I'50!A1@'K!'5!/8?/!0(16)'5(!614&8'81&!)'!A5M!

68=1(&8'>!I45'!08*'7(16K,!C5=1D14'!)A54?!'/1!614&8'>!?()6814'!)'!/8?/!68=1(&8'>!

A1)6&!'5!'/1!)??(1?)'854!?()6814'!84!M/8*/!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!(1D)84&!*54&')4'!84!

'/1!D1')*5DD748'>!)'!E!0(16)'5(&L!%7'!'/1!&0)'8)A!)??(1?)'854!*/)4?1&,!

34'1(&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!(10(1&14'&!)AA!E!0(16)'5(&!0(1&14'!84!1=1(>!A5*)A8'>L!

7%8Q78'57&!)*(5&&!'/1!A)46&*)01!I%5''5D!(8?/'K,!34'()&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!

(10(1&14'&!*A7&'1(&!5@!0(16)'5(&!%>!&01*81&!M8'/84!)!A5*)A!*5DD748'>!I%5''5D!

A1@'K,!

! #F!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

H5I4&-!7)!"2!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!)!&84?A1!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(!54!0(1>!*5DD748'>!)&&1D%A>!'/(57?/!&1A1*'8=1!@8A'1(84?!I61'1(D848&'8*!0(5*1&&1&K!5@!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A!@9+9:-%#"/K,!!:)46!":68=1(&8'>!%5'/!61*(1)&1!%7'!":68=1(&8'>!61*(1)&1&!)'!)!@)&'1(!()'1!I1Q,!-K,!82!'/1!*7D7A)'8=1!1@@1*'&!5@!D7A'80A1!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&!54!0(1>!*5DD748'>!)&&1D%A>!'/(57?/!&1A1*'8=1!@8A'1(84?!I61'1(D848&'8*!0(5*1&&1&K!

5@!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A!@9+9:-%#"/K,!.7D7A)'8=1!@8A'1(&!*)7&1!)!6()&'8*!61*(1)&1!84!β:68=1(&8'>!I1Q,!9K,!_A71!65''16!A841m!"!&01*8)A8&'L!(16!65''16!A841m!#!&01*8)A8&'&L!?(114!65''16!A841m-!&01*8)A8&'&L!07(0A1!

65''16!A841m!9!&01*8)A8&'&L!)46!'1)A!65''16!A841m!E!&01*8)A8&'&,!!

! #;!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

H5I4&-!J)!d1&7A'&!5@!'/1!68=1(&8'>!?()6814'!0(16)'5(!&8D7A)'854&,!$668'854!5@!1)*/!0(16)'5(!(10(1&14'&!)!D5=1D14'!)A54?!'/1!A841!5@!'/1!68=1(&8'>!?()6814'!IT8?7(1!"K,!$!61*A841!84!":!)46!J:68=1(&8'>!8&!&114!671!'5!'/1!0(1&14*1!5@!)!&84?A1!0(16)'5(!&01*81&!I(16!A841K!01(!

D1')*5DD748'>L!M8'/!'/1!0(16)'5(!%184?!0(1&14'!84!1)*/!A5*)A!*5DD748'>,!P/1!)668'854!5@!

D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(&!84!)!D1')*5DD748'>!I/8?/!68=1(&8'>K!8AA7&'()'1&!)!(167*'854!84!J:!)46!S:!

68=1(&8'>!A5&&,!PM5!I%(5M4!A841KL!'/(11!I07(0A1!A841KL!@57(!I)Q7)!A841K!)46!@8=1!I?5A6!A841K!

0(16)'5(&!M1(1!45'!&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!@(5D!'/1!417'()A!1O01*')'854&!I?(114!A841K,!!

! #B!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

H5I4&-!K)!d1&7A'&!5@!'/1!681'!%(1)6'/!&8D7A)'854&!01(@5(D16!)'!/8?/!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>,!34*(1)&84?!681'!%(1)6'/!/)&!A8''A1!'5!45!1@@1*'!54!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>,!"Gl!&01*8)A8&'!I(16KL!#Gl!

&01*8)A8&'!I%(5M4K!-Gl!I=85A1'K!&01*8)A8&'!9Gl!I)Q7)KL!EGl!?141()A8&'!I?5A6KL!FGl!?141()A8&'!

IA8?/'!%A71KL!;Gl!?141()A8&'!I>1AA5MKL!BGl!?141()A8&'!I')4K!)46!WGl!?141()A8&'!I%A71K!M1(1!45'!

&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!@(5D!417'()A!1O01*')'854&!I07(0A1K,!

! #W!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

H5I4&-!L)!d1&7A'&!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(!84'14&8'>!&8D7A)'854&!)'!/8?/!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>,!./)4?1&!84!01(*14'!14*574'1(16!0(1>!U8AA16!/)=1!45!1@@1*'!54!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!74'8A!"GGl!

5@!)AA!0(1>!'/)'!)(1!14*574'1(16!)(1!U8AA16!IA5M1&'!A8?/'!%A71!A841K,!<(16)'5(!84'14&8'81&!5@!

"Gl!I%A71KL!#Gl!I')4KL!-Gl!I>1AA5MKL!9Gl!IA8?/'!%A71KL!EGl!I?5A6KL!FGl!I'1)AKL!;Gl!

I?(114KL!BGl!I%(5M4K!)46!WGl!I(16K!M1(1!45'!&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!@(5D!417'()A!

1O01*')'854&!I07(0A1!A841K,!

! -G!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

H5I4&-!M)!d1&7A'&!5@!'/1!84'1(&01*8@8*!0(16)'5(!)??(1?)'854!&8D7A)'854&!(10(1&14'84?!'/1!@)(!(8?/'!5@!'/1!)??(1?)'854!?()6814'!)'!/8?/!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!IT8?7(1!"K,!b8'/!84*(1)&84?!84'1(&01*8@8*!

0(16)'5(!)??(1?)'854!I0(16)'5(!&01*81&!055A!84*(1)&84?!@(5D!"GG!0(16)'5(&L!5(!)4!)=1()?1!5@!541!

0(16)'5(!01(!A5*)A!*5DD748'>!I(16!A841K!'5!EGG!0(16)'5(&L!)4!)=1()?1!5@!@8=1!0(16)'5(&!01(!A5*)A!

*5DD748'>!I?5A6!A841KK!":!)46!J:68=1(&8'>!61*(1)&1,!#GG!0(16)'5(&!I%(5M4!A841K!(10(1&14'!)4!)=1()?1!5@!'M5!0(16)'5(&!01(!*5DD748'>L!-GG!0(16)'5(&!I07(0A1!A841K!)4!)=1()?1!5@!-!0(16)'5(&!

01(!A5*)A8'>L!)46!9GG!0(16)'5(&!I)Q7)!A841K!)4!)=1()?1!5@!9!0(16)'5(&!01(!A5*)A!*5DD748'>,!

! -"!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

T8?7(1!;,!d10(1&14'84?!%5'/!146&!5@!'/1!&01*'(7D!5@!'/1!)??(1?)'854!?()6814'!IT8?7(1!"K,!<(16)'5(!

84'1(&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!I%(5M4K!84!M/8*/!)!/8?/!614&8'>!5@!0(16)'5(&!5@!68@@1(14'!&01*81&!1O8&'&!M8'/84!)!

1)*/!A5*)A!*5DD748'>!I@8=1!0(16)'5(&!84!541!A5*)A8'>K!&8?48@8*)4'A>!(167*1&!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!*5D0)(16!'5!

417'()A!1O01*')'854&!I?(114K!34'()&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!I?5A6KL!84!M/8*/!)!/8?/!614&8'>!I@8=1K!5@!0(16)'5(&!5@!

'/1!&)D1!&01*81&!M8'/84!)!A5*)A!*5DD748'>L!M8'/!)!/8?/!68=1(&8'>!5@!0(16)'5(&!84!'/1!D1')*5DD748'>!IEK!

651&!45'!&8?48@8*)4'A>!(167*1!'/1!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!)'!'/1!(1?854)A!&*)A1!I"K!%7'!651&!)'!'/1!A5*)A!&*)A1!IRK,!!

! -#!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

H5I4&-!N)!.5D0)(8&54!5@!&8D7A)'854!(1&7A'&,!P50!A841!I07(0A1Km417'()A!1O01*')'854&!M8'/!45!0(16)'5(&!0(1&14',![8?/!68=1(&8'>!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&!*)7&1!45!&8?48@8*)4'!*/)4?1!84!S:!)46!J:!

68=1(&8'>!@(5D!'/1!417'()A!1O01*')'854&!I(16!A841m!/8?/!68=1(&8'>L!A5M!614&8'>L!&01*8)A8&'!IEK!

0(16)'5(!&8D7A)'854L!?(114!A841m!()465D8N16L!I/8?/!68=1(&8'>KL!84'1(&01*8@8*!)??(1?)'854!

?()6814'!)'!A5M!614&8'>!Is"!0(16)'5(!01(!A5*)A8'>K,!$!&84?A1!0(16)'5(L!18'/1(!&01*8)A8&'!I07(0A1K!

5(!?141()A8&'!I%A71K!61*(1)&1&!%5'/!J:!)46!S:68=1(&8'>!*5D0)(16!'5!()465D!1O01*')'854&,!

! --!

*+',%-&!J/!C7A'80A1!0(16)'5(!A)46&*)01&2!'1&'84?!)!'/15(1'8*)A!D561A!

"#$%&'(%)!

! <(16)'5(&!0A)>!)4!8D05(')4'!(5A1!84!'/1!&'(7*'7(84?!5@!0(1>!*5DD748'81&,!<(16)'854!

/)&!%114!&/5M4!'5!A1)6!'5!84*(1)&1!*5DD748'>!&8D8A)(8'>!IA5M1(!J:68=1(&8'>KL!%7'!54A>!84!

'/1!*)&1!5@!)!7%8Q78'57&!0(16)'5(,!j&84?!)4!)('8@8*8)A!0546!1O01(8D14'!3!1O)D8416!'/1!

1@@1*'&!5@!)!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(!A)46&*)01!54!0(1>!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>,!3!@5746!'/)'!)!(1?854)A!

*5DD748'>!*54&8&'84?!5@!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(&!*)4!A1)6!'5!68@@1(14'8)'854!)D54?!A5*)A!

*5DD748'81&L!%7'!651&!45'!D168)'1!'/1!A5&&!5@!(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>!)&!0(168*'16,!j461(A>84?!

'/8&!(1&7A'!M)&!)!A5M1(!'/)4!1O01*'16!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)46!/8?/!61?(11!5@!681'!5=1(A)0,!

T7'7(1!M5(U!&/57A6!@5*7&!54!'/1!(5A1!5@!0(16)'5(&!M8'/!'/1!05'14'8)A!'5!*574'1()*'!'/1!

1@@1*'&!5@!/5D5?148N)'854!84!)!0(16)'5(!A)46&*)01,!

!

01%&234(%521)!

$!@746)D14')A!?5)A!5@!1*5A5?>!8&!'5!61'1(D841!0)''1(4&!5@!%8568=1(&8'>!)46!@)*'5(&!

)@@1*'84?!%85A5?8*)A!*5DD748'>!*5D05&8'854,!C)4>!&'7681&!/)=1!61D54&'()'16!'/1!(5A1!5@!

0(16)'854!84!&'(7*'7(84?!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!I1,?,!(1=81M!84!^8/!"#!$%&!"WBEK,!P/1!(5A1!5@!

0(16)'854!8&!0)('8*7A)(A>!M1AA!&'76816!84!@(1&/M)'1(!/)%8')'&!I(1=81M2!b1A%5(4!"#!$%&!"WWFKL!

)46!'/1!(5A1!5@!0(16)'5(>!@8&/!84!61'1(D8484?!*5DD748'>!&'(7*'7(1!8&!M1AA!65*7D14'16!

Ih8A84&U>!"WB9L!c81/A!"WW#L!./(8&'5@@1(&14!"#!$%&!"WW-K,![5M1=1(L!D5&'!&'7681&!1O)D8484?!

'/1!*5DD748'>!A1=1A!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854!5**7(!)'!'/1!A5*)A!IRK!&*)A1!I^8/!"#!$%&!"WBEK,!d1*14'!

M5(U!%>!./)&1!"#!$%&!#GGW!1O0)4616!'/1!&0)'8)A!&*)A1!5@!&'76>!'5!)!(1?854)A!&*)A1!)46!@5746!

'/)'!0(16)'5(>!@8&/!(167*1!45'!54A>!A5*)A!0(1>!68=1(&8'>L!%7'!)A&5!68=1(&8'>!)D54?!0546&!IJ:

68=1(&8'>KL!(1&7A'84?!84!)!A)(?1!A5&&!5@!&01*81&!@(5D!'/1!(1?854!IS!68=1(&8'>KL!61D54&'()'84?!)!

! -9!

/5D5?148N84?!1@@1*'!5@!0(16)'5(>!@8&/,![5D5?148N)'854L!'/1!A5&&!5@!%85'8*!68&'84*'8=141&&!

)D54?!A5*)'854&L!8&!()086A>!)**1A1()'84?!671!'5!/7D)4!)*'8=8'81&L!A1)684?!'5!'/1!A5&&!5@!

748Q71!%85?15?()0/8*!A)46&*)01&!IX8'57&1U!"#!$%&!"WWFL!C8*U8441>!)46!Z5*UM556!"WWWK,!$!

(1*14'!&'76>!%>!_18&41(!"#!$%&!#GG-!&7??1&'16!'/)'!/5D5?148N)'854!/)&!'/1!05'14'8)A!'5!

*)&*)61!)*(5&&!'(50/8*!A1=1A&,!P/1!(1&1)(*/1(&!61D54&'()'16!'/)'!0(16)'5(>!@8&/!84!'M5!

A)U1&!A16!'5!/5D5?148N)'854!)'!%5'/!'/1!0(16)'5(!'(50/8*!A1=1A!)46!'/1!N550A)4U'54!'(50/8*!

A1=1AL!&7??1&'84?!)!*)&*)684?!1@@1*'!5@!0(16)'5(!/5D5?148N)'854!IA5M!J:68=1(&8'>K,!!P/1!

1O01(8D14')A!(1&1)(*/!8468*)'84?!/5D5?148N)'854!671!'5!@8&/!0(16)'854!/)&!)AA!)&&7D16!)!

7%8Q78'57&!0(16)'5(!748@5(DA>!68&'(8%7'16!84!&0)*1!I./)&1!"#!$%&!#GGWKL!%7'!84!4)'7(1!'/1(1!

8&!()(1A>!54A>!)!&84?A1!0(16)'5(!&01*81&!748@5(DA>!68&'(8%7'16!'/(57?/57'!)!

D1')*5DD748'>,!\@'14!0(16)'5(&!A8=84?!84!)!&8D8A)(!(1?854!/)=1!1=5A=16!'5!&01*8)A8N1!84!

68@@1(14'!0(1>!681'&!'5!)=586!*5D01'8'854!I(1=81M16!84!T7'7>D)!)46!C5(145!"WBBK,!

c8@@1(14*1&!84!681'!%(1)6'/!*57A6!05'14'8)AA>!0(5=861!(1@7?8)!@5(!*1(')84!0(1>!&01*81&L!

)AA5M84?!D5(1!&01*81&!'5!1O8&'!84!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A!84!'/1!0(1&14*1!5@!D7A'80A1!

&01*8)A8N16!0(16)'5(&,!$!D5(1!(1)A8&'8*!68&'(8%7'854!5@!0(16)'5(&!%5'/!84!&0)*1!)46!84!681'!

&01*8)A8N)'854!*57A6!'/1(1@5(1!A1)6!'5!A1&&!6()D)'8*!1@@1*'&!54!68=1(&8'>!)'!A)(?1(!&0)'8)A!

&*)A1&L!5@@1(84?!41M!84&8?/'&!84'5!/5M!0(16)'5(&!D568@>!%8568=1(&8'>!)46!*54'(8%7'1!'5!

/5D5?148N)'854,!

! $('8@8*8)A!0546&!D)U1!@5(!1O*1AA14'!&>&'1D&!'5!&'76>!%8568=1(&8'>!)*(5&&!&*)A1&!671!'5!

'/1!1)&1!M8'/!M/8*/!'/1>!*)4!%1!(10A8*)'16!)46!D)4807A)'16,!3!61&8?416!)4!)('8@8*8)A!0546!

1O01(8D14'!'5!1O)D841!/5M!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(&!54!0(1>!D1')*5DD748'81&!68@@1(!)*(5&&!

&84?A1:0(16)'5(!&>&'1D&!I45!J:68=1(&8'>!5@!0(16)'5(&K!)46!D7A'80A1:0(16)'5(!A)46&*)01&!IJ:

68=1(&8'>!)'!'/1!0(16)'5(!'(50/8*!A1=1AK,!!P/1!)('8@8*8)A!0546&!M1(1!*5D05&16!5@!*)''A1!')4U!

! -E!

D1&5*5&D&!(10(1&14'84?!&D)AA!@(1&/M)'1(!0546&,!b/8A1!8'!8&!U45M4!'/)'!)!&84?A1!0(16)'5(!

61*(1)&1&!68=1(&8'>!%5'/!A5*)AA>!)46!(1?854)AA>L!/5D5?148N84?!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!I./)&1!"#!

$%&!#GGWKL!3!/>05'/1&8N1!'/)'!84*(1)&84?!J:68=1(&8'>!)'!541!'(50/8*!A1=1A!I1,?,!)D54?!'50!

0(16)'5(&K!M8AA!*)&*)61!65M4!'5!'/1!14'8(1!D1')*5DD748'>L!)46!'/)'!(1A)'8=1A>!@1M!

(1?854)A!1O'84*'854&!M8AA!5**7(!61&08'1!'/1!748=1(&)A!0(1&14*1!5@!'50!0(16)'5(&,!

!

@A:O=>9!

7A3"/-B"1#$%!,"(-?1!

! P/8&!1O01(8D14'!7'8A8N16!0(1:1O8&'84?!)('8@8*8)A!0546!*5DD748'81&!84!*)''A1!')4U&!)'!

P>&54!d1&1)(*/!.14'1(!IV7(1U)L!C\!j^$K,!P/1&1!*)''A1!')4U&!M1(1!1&')%A8&/16!%>!0(1=857&!

(1&1)(*/1(&!I&11![)4A>!"#!$%&!&7%D8''16K!'M5!>1)(&!0(85(!'5!'/8&!1O01(8D14',!g5!&8?48@8*)4'!

68@@1(14*1&!M1(1!@5746!)D54?!'(1)'D14'&!84!'/1!0(1=857&!1O01(8D14']!'/1(1@5(1!'/1(1!

&/57A6!%1!45!*54@574684?!1@@1*'&!@5(!'/8&!&'76>,!

! T5('>:18?/'!"#GG!Z!1O01(8D14')A!D1&5*5&D&!M1(1!1&')%A8&/16!84!C)>!#GGB!)46!

@8AA16!M8'/!sE!*D!5@!&58A!)46!'/14!@8AA16!M8'/!M1AA!M)'1(,!P/1!D1&5*5&D!*5DD748'81&!M1(1!

848'8)'16!'M5!6)>&!A)'1(!M8'/!&1=1()A!68&01(&)A:A8D8'16!&01*81&,!c8&01(&)A!A8D8'16!&01*81&!

M1(1!*5AA1*'16!@(5D!18?/'!A5*)A!0546&!)46!5'/1(!1&')%A8&/16!D1&5*5&D!1O01(8D14'&,!V)*/!

D1&5*5&D!(1*18=16!)!EGGDA!)A8Q75'!&)D0A1!*54')8484?!N550A)4U'54L!0/>'50A)4U'54!)46!

5'/1(!D8*(55(?)48&D&!)&&5*8)'16!M8'/!'/1!A5*)A!0546!M)'1(,!\41!M11U!)@'1(!'/1!)A8Q75'!M)&!

61A8=1(16L!18?/'!D)*(50/>'1!&01*81&!)46!'/18(!)&&5*8)'16!@8A)D14'57&!)A?)1!)&!M1AA!)&!

68&01(&)A!A8D8'16!D)*(584=1('1%()'1&!I@5(!1O)D0A1!&4)8A!&01*81&!&7*/!)&!920($!?0/-1$!)46!

C"%-('B$!$14"3(!$14"3(K!M1(1!1&')%A8&/16!84!1)*/!*)''A1!')4U,!P/1!D1&5*5&D&!M1(1!5014!

! -F!

&>&'1D&!@(11!'5!68&01(&)A!)46!M1(1!)AA5M16!'5!&1A@:)&&1D%A1!%1>546!'/1!&01*81&!'/)'!M1(1!

84'(567*16!)'!848'8)'854,!

! $(()>&!M1(1!()465DA>!)&&8?416!'5!541!5@!&8O!'(1)'D14'&2!)!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'L!M8'/!

45!0(16)'5(!0(1&14'L!5(!541!5@!'/1!@8=1!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&!84!M/8*/!18'/1(!C5&Q78'5@8&/!

I<$BDE(-$!$))-1-(KL!h(114!^74@8&/!IF"3'B-(!40$1"%%E(KL!h5A614!^/841(&!IG'#"B-?'1E(!

4/0('%"E4$(KL!T)'/1)6!D8445M&!I9-B"32$%"(!3/'B"%$(KL!5(!V)&'1(4!g1M'&!IG'#'32#2$%BE(!

.-/-,"(4"1(K!M1(1!0(1&14',!P/1!@8=1!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&!M1(1!84'(567*16!'5!'/18(!(1&01*'8=1!

')4U&!84!C)>!#G"G,!j&84?!6)')!@(5D!)!0(1=857&!@8&/!(1D5=)A!1O01(8D14'L!3!1&'8D)'16!'/1!

*)((>84?!*)0)*8'>!5@!)!&8D8A)(!&8N16!*)''A1!')4U!@5(!C5&Q78'5@8&/!I<&!$))-1-(K!)46!h(114!

^74@8&/!IF&!40$1"%%E(K,!P5!)**574'!@5(!'/1!68@@1(14*1&!84!'/1!D)&&!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(&L!)46!'/7&!

'/1!*)((>84?!*)0)*8'>!5@!'/1!D1&5*5&D&!@5(!'/1!68@@1(14'!@8&/!&01*81&L!3!M18?/16!)!

&7%&)D0A1!5@!'/1!@8&/!)46!*)A*7A)'16!)!%85D)&&!0(5O>,!\4!)=1()?1!"GG!?()D&!5@!<&!$))-1-(!

)46!-GG!?()D&!5@!F&!40$1"%%E(!M1(1!(1D5=16!@(5D!)!0(1=857&!@8&/!(1D5=)A!1O01(8D14'L!

8468*)'84?!68@@1(14*1&!84!*)((>84?!*)0)*8'>,!c71!'5!'/1&1!68@@1(14*1&!84!*)((>84?!*)0)*8'>!)46!

'/1!&D)AA!&8N1!5@!<&!$))-1-(L!3!84'(567*16!"GG!?()D&!5@!<&!$))-1-(H!)46!*/5&1!'5!84'(567*1!'/1!

&)D1!%85D)&&!)&!F&!40$1"%%E(!54!)**574'!5@!)!*A5&1(!)=1()?1!8468=867)A!&8N1!%1'M114!

&01*81&,!P/7&L!3!84'(567*16!-GG!?()D&!5@!%85D)&&!5@!F&!40$1"%%E(L!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!)46!9&!

3/'B"%$(&!\41!D)A1!)46!541!@1D)A1!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!M1(1!0A)*16!84!1)*/!41M'!*)''A1!')4U!84!

)**5(6)4*1!M8'/!41M'!614&8'81&!7&16!84!&8D8A)(!&'7681&!IC5(84!"#!$%&!"WB-K,!

! P/1!1O01(8D14'!()4!@5(!"B!M11U&!)46!'/1!D1&5*5&D&!M1(1!&)D0A16!67(84?!'/1!A)&'!

'M5!M11U&!84!^10'1D%1(!5@!#G"G,!P5!*14&7&!)D0/8%8)4&!)46!D)*(584=1('1%()'1&!3!7&16!'/1!

t&'5=1:0801H!&)D0A84?!D1'/56!I1,?,!P7(41(!)46!P(1OA1(!"WW;K!84!M/8*/!)!-F!*D!68)D1'1(!O!"!

D!')AA!0A)&'8*!*>A8461(!8&!0A)*16!=1('8*)AA>!84!'/1!M)'1(!*5A7D4L!M8'/!541!146!&1)A16!84!'/1!

! -;!

D1&5*5&D!&58A!)46!'/1!5'/1(!)%5=1!M)'1(,!$!"E!*D!(1?7A)(!)Q7)(87D!41'!M8'/!G,--!DD!

41''84?!8&!'/14!7&16!'5!&*550!57'!)AA!A8=84?!5(?)48&D&!@(5D!'/1!M)'1(!*5A7D4!&)D0A16!

M8'/84!'/1!0A)&'8*!*>A8461(!I./)&1!"#!$%&!#GGWK,!PM5!&'5=1:0801!&)D0A1(&!M1(1!7&16!@5(!1)*/!

8468=867)A!*)''A1!')4U,!$AA!)D0/8%8)4&!M1(1!8614'8@816!M/8A1!&)D0A84?!)46!(1A1)&16!7054!'/1!

*5D0A1'854!5@!&)D0A84?!)46!'/1!D)*(584=1('1%()'1&!M1(1!0(1&1(=16!84!;Gl!1'/)45A!@5(!

A)'1(!8614'8@8*)'854!7461(!)!68&&1*'84?!D8*(5&*501,!P5!*)0'7(1!&861:6M1AA84?!&01*81&!I&7*/!

)&!&4)8A&!)46!)D0/8%8)4!A)(=)1KL!9!1Q7868&')4'!&M110&!M1(1!01(@5(D16!@(5D!'/1!%)&1!5@!'/1!

')4U!'5!'/1!'50!5@!'/1!M)'1(!*5A7D4!M8'/!)!#E!*D!M861!G,--!DD!)Q7)(87D!41'!@A7&/!'5!'/1!

84&861!5@!'/1!*)''A1!')4U,!$D0/8%8)4&!M1(1!8614'8@816L!*574'16!)46!(1A1)&16!)46!

D)*(584=1('1%()'1&!M1(1!0(1&1(=16!@5(!A)'1(!8614'8@8*)'854,!P5!*)0'7(1!()(1!&01*81&L!3!7&16!

)!-G!*D!M861!c!41'!M8'/!"!DD!D1&/!'5!D)U1!-!&M110&!)'!=)(>84?!610'/&!)*(5&&!'/1!A14?'/&!

5@!'/1!0546,!$4>!&01*81&!45'!@5746!84!'/1!&'5=1:0801!M1(1!0(1&1(=16!84!1'/)45A!@5(!@7'7(1!

8614'8@8*)'854,!P5!*14&7&!'/1!N550A)4U'54!3!7&16!)!D568@816!84'1?()'16!'7%1!&)D0A1(!IE:*D!

68)D1'1(!<X.!0801!O!"!D!')AAK!I<)??8!1'!)A,!#GG"K!&)D0A84?!()465DA>!@8=1!'8D1&!'/(57?/57'!

'/1!D1&5*5&D,!P/1!&)D0A16!M)'1(!M)&!'/14!@5(*16!'/(57?/!)!BG!uD!D1&/!N550A)4U'54!41'!

)46!*54*14'()'16!84'5!)!EGDA!)A8Q75'!)46!0(1&1(=16!M8'/!$*86!Z7?5A&!&5A7'854!@5(!A)'1(!

8614'8@8*)'854!M8'/!)!*5D05746!D8*(5&*501!7&84?!1&')%A8&/16!D1'/56&!IP/5(0!)46!.5=8*/!

"WW"L![)((8&!"#!$%&!#GGGK,!

I#$#-(#-4$%!$1$%0("(!

! P5!61'1(D841!'/1!68@@1(14*1&!84!)A0/)!68=1(&8'>!)D54?!'/1!*54'(5A!)46!'/(11!

0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&L!3!7&16!)!541:M)>!$g\X$,!C>!1O01(8D14')A!61&8?4!651&!45'!)AA5M!@5(!

(10A8*)'854!5@!(1?854)A!ISK!68=1(&8'>]!'/1(1@5(1L!3!01(@5(D16!r)*UU48@1!(1:&)D0A84?!M8'/57'!

(10A)*1D14'!84!5(61(!'5!*(1)'1!(10A8*)'854!@5(!(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>!IC8AA1(!"W;9K,!d1?854)A!

! -B!

68=1(&8'>!M)&!*)A*7A)'16!%>!(1D5=84?!541!(10A8*)'1!)'!)!'8D1!'5!*(1)'1!)!(1?854)A!

*5DD748'>!5@!&1=14!A5*)A!*5DD748'81&,!P/1!(1D5=)A!5@!)!68@@1(14'!A5*)A!*5DD748'>!

M8'/57'!(10A)*1D14'!>81A6&!B!68@@1(14'!?)DD)!=)A71&,!$4!$g\X$!M)&!01(@5(D16!84!<$^P!

7&84?!'/1&1!r)*UU48@16!?)DD)!=)A71&!I[556!#G"GK,!!

! P5!61'1(D841!'/1!1@@1*'!5@!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(&!54!(1?854)A!ISK!)46!J:!I*5DD748'>!

&8D8A)(8'>K!68=1(&8'>L!3!*(1)'16!)!@8@'/L!&')'8&'8*)A!'(1)'D14'L!M/8*/!3!M8AA!(1@1(!'5!)&!

`D7A'80(16,a!P/8&!'(1)'D14'!M)&!*(1)'16!%>!()465DA>!6()M84?!'M5!41M'!(10A8*)'1&L!'M5!G&!

4/0('%"E4$(!)46!#!F&!40$1"%%E(!*)''A1!')4U&!'5!*(1)'1!)!`D7A'80(16a!(1?854)A!*5DD748'>!

*54&8&'84?!5@!F!A5*)A!*5DD748'81&,!P/1!*(1)'854!5@!'/8&!D7A'80(16!(1?854)A!*5DD748'>!8&!

8'1()'16!"GGG!'8D1&!7&84?!'/1!%55'&'()0084?!'55A!84!'/1!<50'55A&!)66:84!@5(!VO*1A!I[556!

#G"GK,!3!'1&'16!'/1!D1)4!?)DD)!68=1(&8'>!5@!'/1!5'/1(!'(1)'D14'&!7&84?!'/1!'1&'=)A71!

@74*'854!M8'/84!'/1!%55'&'()0084?!'55A!'5!*)A*7A)'1!)!0:=)A71!'5!'1&'!8@!'/1!D7A'80(16!

'(1)'D14'!68@@1(&!&8?48@8*)4'A>!@(5D!5'/1(!'(1)'D14'&,!3!*)A*7A)'16!'/1!0:=)A71!)&!'/1!

47D%1(!5@!8'1()'854&!'/)'!@1AA!57'&861!5@!'/1!'1&'=)A71!68=8616!%>!'/1!'5')A!47D%1(!5@!

8'1()'854&!I"GGGK,!!

! P/1!d)70:.(8*U!Id)70!)46!.(8*U!"W;WK!68&')4*1!I&8D8A)(8'>K!D)'(8O!M)&!*)A*7A)'16!84!

<)^P!I[)DD1(!1'!)A,!#GG"K!@5(!)AA!'(1)'D14'&,!C)4>!*5DD54!&8D8A)(8'>!8468*1&L!&7*/!)&!

e)**)(6H&!8461O!*)4!*/)4?1!%1*)7&1!5@!(8*/41&&!8461014614'!5@!&8D8A)(8'>!I.5445(!)46!

^8D%1(A5@@!"W;BL!d)70!)46!.(8*U!"W;WKL!M/1(1)&!'/1!d)70:.(8*U!D1'(8*!8&!A1&&!61014614'!

54!=)(8)'854&!84!A5*)A!68=1(&8'>,!j&84?!<$^PL!3!01(@5(D16!)!g<C$g\X$!I454:0)()D1'(8*!

C$g\X$L!)A&5!U45M4!)&!)!01(D7')'854)A!D7A'8=)(8)'1!)4)A>&8&!5@!=)(8)4*1K!'5!*)A*7A)'1!

68@@1(14*1&!%)&16!54!*14'(586!D5=1D14'!I68@@1(14*1!84!'>01&!5@!&01*81&!@5746!84!1)*/!

'(1)'D14'K!%1'M114!%5'/!'(1)'D14'&!)&!M1AA!)&!'/1!68@@1(14*1&!84!68&01(&854!)D54?!

! -W!

A5*)A8'81&!IJ:68=1(&8'>K!%1'M114!%5'/!'(1)'D14'&!I$461(&54!#GG"K,!g<C$g\X$!8468*)'1&!8@!

'/1!A5*)A8'81&!M8'/84!1)*/!'(1)'D14'!)(1!&')'8&'8*)AA>!68@@1(14'!671!'5!'/1!0(16)'854!

'(1)'D14'&,!<$^P!)AA5M&!@5(!'/1!*/58*1!5@!68@@1(14'!&8D8A)(8'>!D1'(8*&L!)46!3!*/5&1!d)70:

.(8*U!@5(!'/1!(1)&54&!&')'16!)%5=1,!_1*)7&1!g<C$g\X$!651&!45'!68&'84?78&/!M/1'/1(!'/1!

68@@1(14*1!84!'/1!*5DD748'81&!8&!*)7&16!%>!I18'/1(!'/1!*14'(586!D5=1D14'!5(!'/1!*/)4?1!84!

68&01(&854!)D54?!0584'&!M8'/84!'/1!'(1)'D14'KL!3!)A&5!7&16!'/1!0(5?()D!<VdCc3^<!

I01(D7')'854)A!)4)A>&8&!5@!D7A'8=)(8)'1!68&01(&854&K!'5!*)A*7A)'1!'/1!&8D8A)(8'81&!)D54?!

A5*)A8'81&!IJ:68=1(&8'>K!I$461(&54!#GG9K,!P/8&!68&01(&854!)D54?!0584'&!(10(1&14'&!/5M!

'8?/'A>!5(!A55&1A>!*A7&'1(16!'/1!0584'&!I(10(1&14'84?!A5*)A!*5DD748'81&K!M8'/84!'/1!

'(1)'D14'!)(1,!$!*/)4?1!84!'/1!*A7&'1(84?!5@!A5*)A8'81&!8468*)'1&!)!*/)4?1!84!%85'8*!&8D8A)(8'>!

)D54?!5'/1(M8&1!14=8(54D14')AA>!&8D8A)(!A5*)A8'81&L!)46!'/7&!8&!1O01*'16!'5!*5((1A)'1!M8'/!

J:68=1(&8'>,!$!68&')4*1!D)'(8O!M)&!@8(&'!*)A*7A)'16!84!<$^P!7&84?!'/1!d)70:.(8*U!D1'(8*L!

'/14!8407'!84'5!$461(&54H&!<VdCc3^<!0(5?()D,!P/1!D7A'80(16!'(1)'D14'!(10(1&14'&!)!

*5DD748'>!5@!&8O!(10A8*)'1&!8'1()'16!D7A'80A1!'8D1&]!'/1(1@5(1L!541!D7A'80(16!*5DD748'>!5@!

&8O!/)&!45!(10A8*)'854!)46!8&!45'!(10(1&14')'8=1!5@!'/1!'(1)'D14'!8'&1A@,!P/8&!D)U1&!

*5D0)(8&54!M8'/!'/1!5'/1(!'(1)'D14'&!M8'/84!gCc^!)46!g<C$g\X$!)46!<VdCc3^<!

68@@8*7A',!P5!61)A!M8'/!'/8&!8&&71!3!8'1()'16!'/1!D7A'80(16!'(1)'D14'!B!'8D1&L!)46!7&84?!'/1!

)=1()?1!)%746)4*1&!5@!'/1!F!*)''A1!')4U&!D)U84?!70!'/1!D7A'80(16!'(1)'D14'L!*(1)'16!B!

(10A8*)'1&!@5(!'/1!D7A'80(16!'(1)'D14',!P/1&1!6)')L!)A54?!M8'/!'/1!5'/1(!9!'(1)'D14'&L!M1(1!

7&16!'5!*(1)'1!)!d)70:.(8*U!68&')4*1!D)'(8O!84!<$^P,!P14!68&')4*1!D)'(8*1&!M1(1!*(1)'16!

)46!)=1()?16,!P/1!)=1()?1!68&')4*1!D)'(8O!M)&!'/14!8407''16!84'5!$461(&54H&!<VdCc3^<!

0(5?()D!'5!61'1(D841!8@!'/1!)=1()?1!68@@1(14*1&!84!'/1!D7A'80(16!'(1)'D14'!68@@1(16!@(5D!

'/1!5'/1(!'(1)'D14'&,!g54:D1'(8*!68D14&854)A!&*)A84?!IgCc^K!0A5'&!7&84?!'/1!d)70:.(8*U!

! 9G!

D1'(8*!M1(1!)A&5!*)A*7A)'16!7&84?!<$^P!&5@'M)(1,!

!

;A9?6:9)!

! \@!'/1!@8=1!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&!'M5!1O01(814*16!*5D0A1'1!0(16)'5(!1O'8(0)'854&,!

P/1!'M5!&01*81&!'/)'!M1(1!1O'8(0)'16L!<&!$))-1-(!I1O'8(0)'16!84!;!57'!5@!B!(10A8*)'1&K!)46!9&!

3/'B"%$(!I1O'8(0)'16!84!F!57'!5@!B!(10A8*)'1&K!)(1!1O*A7616!84!)AA!5@!'/1!@5AA5M84?!)4)A>&1&!

5M84?!'5!'/1!A)*U!5@!(10A8*)'854,!

F'4$%!;-."/(-#0!

! \4!)=1()?1L!#"!&01*81&!5**7((16!A5*)AA>!84!'/1!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'&L!"B!84!G&!

.-/-,"(4"1(!'(1)'D14'&L!"E!84!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!)46!"-!84!F&!40$1"%%E(,!!3!@5746!'/)'!'/1!R:

68=1(&8'81&!5@!1)*/!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!)(1!45'!&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!@(5D!'/1!*54'(5A!

'(1)'D14'!IP)%A1!"L!T8?7(1!"K,!P/1!681'!%(1)6'/!5@!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!)46!F&!40$1"%%E(!5=1(A)0016!

84!-G!&01*81&,!F&!40$1"%%E(!1O*A7616!EG!0(1>!&01*81&!@(5D!'/1!*5DD748'81&!M/8A1!G&!

4/0('%"E4$(!1O*A7616!-F!&01*81&,!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!54A>!1O*A7616!F!748Q71!0(1>!&01*81&!'/)'!F&!

40$1"%%E(!686!45'!1O*A761,!3!@5746!?556!1=8614*1!'/)'!F&!40$1"%%E(!(167*16!'/1!&01*81&!

68=1(&8'>!)'!'/1!A5*)A!&*)A1]!/5M1=1(L!45!5'/1(!0(16)'5(&!&8?48@8*)4'A>!(167*16!R:68=1(&8'>!

IP)%A1!"L!T8?7(1!"K,!!

J"?-'1$%!;-."/(-#0!

! P/1(1!M1(1!B#!0(1>!&01*81&!0(1&14'!)*(5&&!)AA!D1&5*5&D&,!P/1!)=1()?1!r)*UU48@16!

(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>!@5(!'/1!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!M)&!EG!&01*81&L!E"!@5(!'/1!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!

'(1)'D14'L!9#,;E!@5(!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!)46!-#,#E!&01*81&!@5(!F&!40$1"%%E(,!d1?854)A!68=1(&8'>!

68@@1(16!@(5D!'/1!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!1O*10'!84!'/1!*)&1!5@!'/1!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!0(16)'5(!

'(1)'D14'L!)46!)AA!'/1!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&!68@@1(16!@(5D!541!)45'/1(!IP)%A1!#L!T8?7(1!"K,!

! 9"!

P/1!(1?854)A!I!K!68=1(&8'>!5@!'/1!D7A'80(16!'(1)'D14'!M)&!&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!@(5D!'/1!

*54'(5A!I0mG,GGFKL!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!I0mG,GG#K!)46!F&!40$1"%%E(!'(1)'D14'!I0m!G,G#-KL!%7'!686!

45'!68@@1(!@(5D!'/1!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!'(1)'D14'!I0mG,9F"K,!

K'BBE1-#0!I-B-%$/-#0!

! \=1()AAL!*5DD748'>!&8D8A)(8'81&!IJ:68=1(&8'>K!68@@1(16!%1'M114!'(1)'D14'&!IP)%A1!-L!

P)%A1!9K,!P/1(1!M)&!45!*/)4?1!84!*5DD748'>!&8D8A)(8'>!%1'M114!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!)46!F&!

40$1"%%E(!)&!8468*)'16!%>!'/1!%1'M114!'(1)'D14'!*5D0)(8&54&!IP)%A1!-K,!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!M)&!

&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!@(5D!'/1!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!M/8A1!G&!4/0('%"E4$(H!F&!40$1"%%E(!)46!'/1!

D7A'80(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!M1(1!45'!IP)%A1!9!K,!P/1!D7A'80(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!686!45'!68@@1(!

&8?48@8*)4'A>!@(5D!)4>!5@!'/1!5'/1(!'(1)'D14'&!IP)%A1!9K,!P/1!*5DD748'>!&8D8A)(8'>!5@!'/1!G&!

.-/-,"(4"1(!'(1)'D14'!68@@1(&!&8?48@8*)4'A>!54A>!@(5D!'/1!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!'(1)'D14'!IP)%A1!9K,!

e7&'!)&!M8'/!g<C$g\X$L!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!)46!F&!40$1"%%E(!/)=1!45!*/)4?1!84!&8D8A)(8'>!M8'/!

(1?)(6&!'5!1)*/!5'/1(!M8'/84!<VdCc3^<!IP)%A1!9K,!P/1!gCc^!I454:D1'(8*!

D7A'868D14&854)A!&*)A84?K!0A5'!8468*)'16!'/)'!*5DD748'81&!*A7&'1(16!84!0(16)'5(>!@8&/!

'(1)'D14'&!IG&!4/0('%"E4$(!)46!F&!40$1"%%E(K!)46!*5DD748'81&!68&01(&16!84!'/1!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!

0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&!(1A)'8=1!'5!'/1!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!IT8?7(1!#K,!P/1!gCc^!*54')8484?!'/1!

D7A'80(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!8AA7&'()'1&!54A>!541!(10A8*)'1L!'/7&!8&!45'!(10(1&14')'8=1,![5M1=1(L!

'M5!gCc^!0A5'&!5@!'M5!8468=867)A!(10A8*)'1&!)(1!0(1&14'16!'5!?8=1!)4!861)!5@!68&01(&854!

68(1*'854,!P/1!gCc^!0A5'!8468*)'1&!'/)'!'/1!D7A'80(16!'(1)'D14'!68&01(&16!(1A)'8=1!'5!'/1!

*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!IT8?7(1!-K,!

!

!

!

! 9#!

>09*?990=<)!

! <(16)'5(&!()(1A>!5**7(!748@5(DA>!)*(5&&!A)46&*)01&,!P/8&!&'76>!8&!'/1!@8(&'!'5!

)66(1&&!'/1!*5D0A1O8'>!84!0(16)'5(!68=1(&8'>!)46!681'!%(1)6'/L!)46!'5!1O0A5(1!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!

'/1&1!0)''1(4&!54!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!)*(5&&!)!A)46&*)01,!<(16)'5(&!/)=1!%114!&/5M4!'5!

/)=1!&'(54?!1@@1*'&!54!D7A'80A1!&0)'8)A!&*)A1&!I^08AA1(!)46!^*/5141(!"WBBL!"WWBL!./)&1!"#!$%&!

#GGWK,!P/8&!&'76>!61D54&'()'1&!'/)'!68@@1(14'!0(16)'5(&!A1)6!'5!68@@1(14*1&!84!68=1(&8'>!)'!

D7A'80A1!&*)A1&,!$!(1?854)A!*5DD748'>!*54&8&'84?!5@!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(&!*)4!A1)6!'5!

68@@1(14'8)'854!)D54?!*5DD748'81&L!%7'!651&!45'!D168)'1!'/1!A5&&!5@!(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>!)&!

0(168*'16,!

9/",$#'/!7))"4#(L!F'4$%!I3$#-$%!I4$%"!

! <(16)'5(&!/)=1!%114!&/5M4!'5!61*(1)&1!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!)'!'/1!A5*)A!&*)A1!I[8O54!

)46!_11'&!"WW-L!^08AA1(!)46!^*/5141(!"WBBL!"WWBK,!3!@5746!'/)'!'/1!0(16)'5(!1@@1*'!5@!F&!

40$1"%%E(!M)&!&8?48@8*)4'!)'!'/1!A5*)A!&0)'8)A!&*)A1L!)&!M)&!@5746!84!0(1=857&!&'7681&!IP)%A1!"L!

T8?7(1!"K!I./)&1!"#!$%&!#GGWK,![5M1=1(L!'/1!5'/1(!0(16)'5(&!686!45'!(167*1!A5*)A!68=1(&8'>!)&!

1O01*'16,!P/8&!D)>!%1!671!'5!'/1!4)'7(1!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(!8'&1A@]!'/1!*5DD748'81&!D)>!%1!

D5(1!'5A1()4'!'5!0(16)'5(&!&7*/!)&!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!)46!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!'/)4!F&!40$1"%%E(!84!'/1!

&/5('!'1(DL!5(!'/1!0(16)'5(!614&8'81&!M1(1!45'!Q78'1!1Q78=)A14',!^1=1()A!&'7681&!/)=1!@5746!

45!1@@1*'!5@!0(16)'854!54!@(1&/M)'1(!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!I(1=81M16!84!P/5(0!"WBFK,!

<(16)'854!/)&!)A&5!%114!&/5M4!'5!)@@1*'!R:68=1(&8'>!41?)'8=1A>!'/(57?/!&01*81&!1O'8(0)'854&!

5(!05&8'8=1A>!'/(57?/!@)*8A8')'854!)46!U1>&'541!0(16)'854,!P/1!41'!1@@1*'!5@!0(16)'854!8&!'/1!

*5D%84)'854!5@!'/1!&01*81&!'/)'!)(1!@)*8A8')'16!%>!'/1!0(16)'5(!)46!'/5&1!'/)'!)(1!1O'8(0)'16!

I1O*A7616K!A5*)AA>!I^*/5141(!)46!^08AA1(!"WWFK,!<(16)'5(&!*)4!61*(1)&1!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!)'!

'/1!A5*)A!&*)A1!M/14!'/1>!0(1>!54!)!&01*81&!74'8A!8'!8&!18'/1(!0(1&14'!)'!1O'(1D1A>!A5M!

! 9-!

614&8'81&!5(!1O'8(0)'16!*5D0A1'1A>,!X1(>!A5M!0(16)'5(!614&8'81&!*57A6!)AA5M!@5(!'/1!

D)84'14)4*1!5@!0(1>!&01*81&!)'!)61Q7)'1!614&8'81&!'5!D)84')84!0(1>:&01*81&!68=1(&8'>,!

<(16)'5(!614&8'81&!)'!'/1!'8D1!5@!&)D0A84?!M1(1!45'!)**574'16!@5(!Q7)4'8')'8=1A>L!)46!

(1A)'8=1A>!A5M!0(16)'5(!614&8'81&!*57A6!1O0A)84!'/1!745%&1(=16!61*(1)&1!84!A5*)A!68=1(&8'>,!!

9/",$#'/!7))"4#(L!J"?-'1$%!I3$#-$%!I4$%"!

! <(16)'854!/)&!%114!61D54&'()'16!'5!/)=1!&'(54?!/5D5?148N84?!1@@1*'&!)'!(1?854)A!

&0)'8)A!&*)A1&!I./)&1!"#!$%&!#GGWK,!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!)46!F&!40$1"%%E(!61*(1)&16!'/1!5=1()AA!

(1?854)A!&01*81&!055AL!&7005('84?!0(1=857&!M5(U!M/8A1!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!/)6!45!1@@1*'!54!

(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>,!$!61*(1)&1!84!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A!8468*)'1&!'/)'!'/1!0(16)'5(&!

&1A1*'8=1A>!0(1>!54!'/1!&)D1!&01*81&!)*(5&&!A5*)A8'81&,!b8'/!45!A5*)A!(1@7?8)!'5!)AA5M!'/1!

0(1>!&01*81&!'5!1O8&'L!'/1>!)(1!1O*A7616!@(5D!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A,!!

ME%#-3%"!9/",$#'/!7))"4#(!

! P/1!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(!1@@1*'!686!45'!)D1A85()'1!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854!54!J:

68=1(&8'>!)&!0(168*'16]!'/1!D7A'80(16!'(1)'D14'!/)6!@1M1(!&01*81&!84!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!

055A!'/)4!%5'/!'/1!*54'(5A!)46!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!'(1)'D14'&!IP)%A1!#L!T8?7(1!#K,!b/14!D7A'80A1!

0(16)'5(&!)(1!0(1&14'!)*(5&&!)!A)46&*)01L!D5(1!&01*81&!*)4!1O8&'!84!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!

055A!'/)4!8@!541!0)('8*7A)(A>!&'(54?!0(16)'5(L!&7*/!)&!F&!40$1"%%E(H!8&!68&'(8%7'16!748@5(DA>!

)*(5&&!'/1!A)46&*)01,!P/8&!8&!671!'5!'/1!5'/1(!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&!)*'84?!)&!(1@7?8)!@5(!'/1!

0(1>!&01*81&L!)AA5M84?!'/1D!'5!*51O8&'!&5D1M/1(1!A5*)AA>!&5!'/)'!'/1>!)(1!45'!1O*A7616!

@(5D!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A,!^01*8)A8N)'854!5@!0(16)'5(&!14&7(1&!'/)'!68@@1(14'!&01*8)A8&'!

0(16)'5(&!M8AA!A1)6!'5!'/1!1O'84*'854!5@!68@@1(14'!0(1>!&01*81&,!3@!&01*8)A8N)'854!651&!45'!

5**7(L!84!'/1!*)&1!'/)'!'/1!681'!%(1)6'/!5@!0(16)'5(!&01*81&!8&!D7*/!A)(?1(L!14*5D0)&&84?!

'/)'!5@!5'/1(!0(16)'5(!&01*81&L!'/14!)!/8?/!68=1(&8'>!5@!0(16)'5(&!M8AA!45'!41*1&&)(8A>!A1)6!'5!

! 99!

'/1!1O'84*'854!5@!68@@1(14'!0(1>!&01*81&,!$!/8?/!68=1(&8'>!5@!?141()A8&'!0(16)'5(&L!M8'/!)!/8?/!

5=1(A)0!84!681'!%(1)6'/L!M8AA!45'!(1&7A'!84!'/1!&)D1!D)84'14)4*1!5@!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!)&!'/)'!5@!

&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&,!P/1!(1A)'8=1A>!A5M!(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>!@5746!84!'/1!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(!

'(1)'D14'!D)>!/)=1!%114!*)7&16!%>!'/1!A)(?1!5=1(A)0!84!681'!%(1)6'/!%1'M114!'/1!'M5!

&'(54?1&'!0(16)'5(&!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!)46!F&!40$1"%%E(,!!

! 34!'/1!)%&14*1!5@!0(16)'5(&L!61&08'1!&8D8A)(!14=8(54D14')A!*5468'854&L!'/1!0(1>!

*5DD748'81&!61D54&'()'1!&'5*/)&'8*!0(5*1&&1&!1O/8%8'84?!/8?/!=)(8)%8A8'>!)D54?&'!&8'1&!

IT8?7(1!#L!)46!./)&1!#GG-K,!P/8&!/8?/!&8'1!'5!&8'1!=)(8)'854!A1)6&!'5!'M5!&*14)(85&L!541!84!

M/8*/!'/1!0(16)'5(!1O'8(0)'1&!)!0(1>!&01*81&!A5*)AA>!'/)'!M)&!5(8?84)AA>!&/)(16!%>!%5'/!

*5DD748'81&L!5(!671!'5!'/1!=)(8)%8A8'>!)D54?!&8'1&L!'/1!0(1>!&01*81&!D)>!/)=1!%114!()(1!

)46!45'!&/)(16!%>!%5'/!*5DD748'81&,!

! 34!)!(1*14'!&'76>!D561A84?!&1=1()A!68@@1(14'!84=)&854!)46!1O'84*'854!&*14)(85&L!

\A614!)46!<5@@!I#GG-K!0(168*'!M/14!BE%#-3%"!&01*81&!84=)61!)46!6(8=1!68@@1(14'!&01*81&!'5!

1O'84*'854L!'/14!68@@1(14'8)'854!M8AA!5**7(!84!D5&'L!%7'!45'!)AAL!*)&1&,!b/14!0(16)'5(&!6(8=1!

0(1>!&01*81&!1O'84*'!'/)'!)(1!&/)(16!%>!%5'/!*5DD748'81&L!68@@1(14'8)'854!)AM)>&!5**7(&,!3!

)D!74)%A1!'5!'1)&1!)0)('!'/1!'/(11!68@@1(14'!&*14)(85&!84!D>!&'76>!671!'5!'/1!&'5*/)&'8*!

4)'7(1!5@!0(1>!*5DD748'>!)&&1D%A>,!P/18(!0(168*'854&!8468*)'1!'/)'!84!'/1!*)&1!5@!'/1&1!

'/(11!&*14)(85&L!M8'/!D7A'80A1!&01*81&!A1)684?!'5!1O'84*'854&!84=5A=84?!I"K!68@@1(14'!&01*81&!

I#K!&01*81&!&/)(16!%>!'/1!*5DD748'81&!5(!I-K!45'!&/)(16!%>!'/1!*5DD748'81&L!

68@@1(14'8)'854!&/57A6!5**7(!1O*10'!84!*)&1&!I"K!)46!I-K!M/14!'/1!47D%1(!5@!A5&1(&!I47D%1(!

5@!4)'8=1&!?541!1O'84*'K!?(1)'A>!57'M18?/&!'/1!47D%1(!5@!M8441(&!I47D%1(!5@!454:4)'8=1&!

1&')%A8&/16K!I\A614!)46!<5@@!#GG-K,!!

! 9E!

! P/1!A)*U!5@!68@@1(14'8)'854L!)46!A5M!(1?854)A!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!&114!84!'/1!D7A'80(16!

'(1)'D14'!*57A6!/)=1!%114!*)7&16!%>!1O*1&&8=1!0(16)'854!0(1&&7(1!84!M/8*/!'/1!47D%1(!5@!

A5&1(&!I0(1>!1O'84*'854&K!M)&!&8D0A>!'55!?(1)'!'5!1O/8%8'!'/1!0(168*'16!)D574'!5@!

68@@1(14'8)'854,!P/1!A)*U!5@!68=1(&8'>!84!'/1!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!*5D0574616!'/8&!1@@1*'!%>!

A8D8'84?!'/1!47D%1(!5@!`M8441(&,a!!

;-))"/"1#-$#-'1!$1,!C'B'?"1-N$#-'1!

! P/1!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!'(1)'D14'!A16!'5!68@@1(14'8)'854!)D54?!A5*)A!*5DD748'81&!(1A)'8=1!

'5!'/1!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!IT8?7(1!#L!P)%A1!-L!9K,!F&!40$1"%%E(!$1,!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!#/"$#B"1#(!

(1&7A'16!84!68&'84*'!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!IP)%A1!-K!%7'!686!45'!(1&7A'!84!)!*/)4?1!84!&8D8A)(8'>!

)D54?!&8'1&!IP)%A1!9K,!P/1&1!@84684?&!&7005('!'/)'!5@!5'/1(!&'7681&L!84!'/)'!0(16)'854!*)4!

61*(1)&1!68=1(&8'>!)'!%5'/!'/1!A5*)A!)46!(1?854)A!&*)A1!I^*/5141(!)46!^08AA1(!"WWFK,!C)4>!

&'7681&!/)=1!@5*7&16!54!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854!5@!&01*81&!(8*/41&&!IP/5(0!"WBFK!M/8A1!

'/1&1!(1&7A'&!)(1!748Q71!84!'/)'!'/1>!8468*)'1!'/)'!0(16)'854!)@@1*'&!*5DD748'>!*5D05&8'854!

84!)!=)(81'>!5@!M)>&,!<(16)'5(&!*)4!)A'1(!'/1!*5D05&8'854!5@!*5DD748'81&!'/(57?/!

&01*8)A8N16!0(16)'854L!&1A1*'8=1A>!61'1(D8484?!M/8*/!&01*81&!*)4!*5A548N1!84!0)('8*7A)(!A5*)A!

*5DD748'81&L!)&!61D54&'()'16!%>!)AA!5@!'/1&1!0(16)'854!'(1)'D14'&,!$668'854)AA>L!0(16)'854!

*)4!(1&7A'!84!'/1!68@@1(14'8)'854!5@!A5*)A!*5DD748'81&L!*(1)'84?!D5(1!68=1(&1!

D1')*5DD748'81&L!)&!61D54&'()'16!%>!'/1!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!IT8?7(1!#L!

P)%A1&!-L9K,!$A'/57?/!0(16)'854!%>!F&!40$1"%%E(!61*(1)&16!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055AL!8'!686!

45'!84*(1)&1!&8D8A)(8'>!IP)%A1!9KL!84!*54'()&'!'5!)!0(1=857&!&'76>!I./)&1!"#!$%&!#GGWK,!P/1!

(1)&54!@5(!'/8&!68&*(10)4*>!84!(1&7A'&!*57A6!%1!671!'5!)!68@@1(14*1!84!'(1)'D14'!'8D1&,!./)&1!

"#!$%&!I#GGWK!1O05&16!'/1!A5*)A!*5DD748'81&!'5!0(16)'854!%>!F&!40$1"%%E(!@5(!'M5!>1)(&L!

M/8A1!'/1!*5DD748'81&!84!'/8&!&'76>!1O01(814*1!0(16)'854!@5(!54A>!"B!M11U&,!P/1!

! 9F!

*5D%84)'854!5@!'/1&1!748Q71!0(16)'5(!1@@1*'&!>81A616!)!(1&7A'!M8'/!/8?/!=)(8)'854,!P/1!

D7A'80(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!M)&!45'!&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!@(5D!'/1!*54'(5A!45(!'/1!G&!

.-/-,"(4"1(!'(1)'D14'L!&7??1&'84?!'/)'!84!'/1!*)&1!5@!)!68=1(&1!0(16)'5(!A)46&*)01L!D7A'80A1!

(1&7A'&L!84*A7684?!68@@1(14'8)'854L!)(1!05&&8%A1,!

F-B-#$#-'1(!

! P/8&!&'76>!M)&!&1=1(1A>!A8D8'16!%>!'/1!47D%1(!5@!0(16)'5(&!84!'/1!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(!

'(1)'D14'L!)46!@7('/1(!1O)*1(%)'16!%>!'/1!A)(?1!5=1(A)0!84!681'!%(1)6'/!5@!'M5!5@!'/1!

&'(54?1&'!0(16)'5(&,!34*5(05()'854!5@!D5(1!0(16)'5(&!84'5!'/1!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!

M57A6!)AA5M!@5(!D5(1!5005('748'81&!@5(!0(1>!(1@7?8)!@(5D!0(16)'5(&,!P/1&1!(1@7?8)!M57A6!

84!'7(4!84*(1)&1!'/1!A8U1A8/556!5@!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A!%184?!D)84')8416!7461(!

0(16)'854,!P/8&!8&!*54'84?14'!7054!'/1!&01*8)A8N)'854!5@!0(16)'5(&!M8'/!(1A)'8=1A>!748Q71!

681'!%(1)6'/&,!3@!)AA!0(16)'5(&!)*'!)&!?141()A8&'&L!1)'84?!(1A)'8=1A>!'/1!&)D1!'/84?L!'/1!1@@1*'!

54!'/1!0(1>!&01*81&!055A!M8AA!(1D)84!'/1!&)D1!)46!'/1!0(16)'5(!1@@1*'!M8AA!45'!%1!

)D1A85()'16,!T7'7(1!(1&1)(*/!M8'/!)!A)(?1(!0(16)'5(!&01*81&!055A!I/8?/1(!0(16)'5(!J:

68=1(&8'>K!8&!41*1&&)(>!'5!61'1(D841!'/1!05&&8%8A8'>!5@!)!J:68=1(&8'>!'(50/8*!*)&*)61!84!M/8*/!

*/)4?1&!84!J:68=1(&8'>!)D54?&'!0(16)'5(&!'()4&A)'1&!'5!*/)4?1&!84!68=1(&8'>!5@!0(1>,!C7*/!

M5(U!/)&!%114!6541!54!'/1!=)(81'>!84!0(16)'854!1@@1*'&!54!68=1(&8'>!I45!*/)4?1L!84*(1)&16!

68=1(&8'>L!61*(1)&16!68=1(&8'>K!IP/5(0!"WBFL!<)841!"WFWL![8O54!)46!_11'&!"WW-L!^08AA1(!)46!

^*/5141(!"WBBL!"WWBK,!VO)D8484?!'/1&1!1@@1*'&!)*(5&&!)!/1'1(5?1457&!0(16)'5(!A)46&*)01!

*)4!A1)6!'5!)!D5(1!47)4*16!7461(&')4684?!5@!/5M!0(16)'854!)@@1*'&!68=1(&8'>!)*(5&&!&*)A1&,!

P/8&!8&!5@!0)('8*7A)(!8D05(')4*1!84!'56)>H&!84*(1)&84?A>!/5D5?148N16!A)46&*)01,!T7'7(1!

M5(U!&/57A6!@5*7&!54!'/1!(5A1!5@!0(16)'5(&!M8'/!'/1!05'14'8)A!'5!*574'1()*'!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!

/5D5?148N)'854!84!)!0(16)'5(!A)46&*)01,!

! 9;!

"*E<=F6A>GA@A<:9!

This work was done for a senior honors thesis in Environmental Studies at Washington

University in St. Louis. I would like to thank my advisor, Kevin G. Smith for providing ideas,

guidance, field assistance, statistical analysis, comments, and funding for this project. I would

like to thank L. Woods, A. Strauss, and J. Chase for helpful comments and discussion. Thanks to

A. Burgett, E. Biro, L. Woods, A. Strauss, M. Evans, T. Dickson H. Bernardo and the TERF

fellows for field assistance. Finally, I would like to thank the entire Chase Lab for all of the

helpful comments they supplied. This project was partially funded by Tyson Research Center

and the Lennette Fellowship for Undergraduate Research.

60:A;":?;A!*0:A>!

$461(&54L!C,e,!I#GG"K,!$!41M!D1'/56!@5(!454:0)()D1'(8*!D7A'8=)(8)'1!)4)A>&8&!5@!=)(8)4*1,!

$7&'()A!V*5A5?>!#F2!-#:!9F,!!

$461(&54L!C,e,!I#GG9K,!<VdCc3^<2!)!T\dPd$g!*5D07'1(!0(5?()D!@5(!01(D7')'854)A!

)4)A>&8&!5@!D7A'8=)(8)'1!68&01(&854&!I@5(!)4>!'M5:@)*'5(!$g\X$!61&8?4K!7&84?!

01(D7')'854!'1&'&,!c10)('D14'!5@!^')'8&'8*&L!j48=1(&8'>!5@!$7*UA)46L!g1M!v1)A)46,!!

_18&41(L!_,V,L!3=1&L!$,d,L!)46!^,d,!.)(014'1(!I#GG-K,!P/1!1@@1*'&!5@!)4!1O5'8*!@8&/!84=)&854!54!

'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!5@!'M5!A)U1&,!e,!$48D,!V*5A,!;#2!--"f-9#,!

./)&1L!e,C,!I#GG-K,!.5DD748'>!)&&1D%A>2!M/14!&/57A6!/8&'5(>!D)''1(o!\1*5A5?8)L!"-F2!

! 9BWf9WB,!

./)&1L!e,C,L!_8(5L!V,h,L!d>%1(?L!b,$,L!)46!^D8'/L!Y,h,!I#GGWK,!<(16)'5(&!'1D01(!'/1!(1A)'8=1!

8D05(')4*1!5@!&'5*/)&'8*!0(5*1&&1&!84!'/1!)&&1D%A>!5@!0(1>!D1')*5DD748'81&,!

V*5A5?>!Z1''1(&L!"#2!"#"Gf"#"B,!

./(8&'5@@1(&14L!Y,L!d81D)44L!_,L!YA>&41(L!$,L!)46!^5461(?))(6L!C,!I"WW-K,!<5'14'8)A!d5A1!5@!

! T8&/!<(16)'854!)46!g)'7()A!<507A)'854&!5@!v550A)4U'54!84!^'(7*'7(84?!)!<A)4U'54!

! .5DD748'>!84!V7'(50/8*!Z)U1!b)'1(,!Z8D45A5?>!)46!\*1)45?()0/>!-B2!EF":E;-,!

.5441(!VT!)46!c!^8D%1(A5@@!I"W;BK,!^01*81&!47D%1(!)46!*5D05&8'854)A!&8D8A)(8'>!5@!'/1!

h)A)0)?5&!@A5()!)46!)=8@)74),!V*5A5?8*)A!C545?()0/&!9B2!#"W:#9B,!

! 9B!

c81/AL!^,!I"WW#K,!T8&/!<(16)'854!)46!_14'/8*!.5DD748'>!^'(7*'7(12!P/1!d5A1!5@!\D48=5(>!

! )46![)%8')'!.5D0A1O8'>,!V*5A5?>!;-2!"F9F:"FF",!

T7'7>D)L!c,!e,L!)46!h,!C5(145!I"WBBK,!P/1!V=5A7'854!5@!V*5A5?8*)A!^01*8)A8N)'854,!$447)A!

! d1=81M!5@!V*5A5?>!)46!^>&'1D)'8*&!"W2!#G;:#--,!

h8A84&U>L!V!I"WB9K,!P/1!d5A1!5@!T8&/!<(16)'854!)46!^0)'8)A![1'1(5?1418'>!84!c1'1(D8484?!

! _14'/8*!.5DD748'>!^'(7*'7(1,!V*5A5?>!FE2!9EE:9FB,!

[)4A>L!<,!e,L!Y,!h,!^D8'/!)46!e,!C,!./)&1,!.54')D84)'854!5@!0546!*5DD748'81&!%>!)4!/1(%8*861!

! )46!)4!84&1*'8*861!)@@1*'&!&/5(':'1(D!*5D05&8'854!)46!1=1441&&!%7'!45'!(8*/41&&,!34!

! (1=81M,!

[)((8&!dL!b81%1!<L!Z14N!eL!^Ur5A6)A![dL![74'A1>!C!I#GGGK,!3.V^!v550A)4U'54!

! C1'/565A5?>!C)47)A!I$*)61D8*L!^)4!c81?5K!

[8O54L!C,$,L!)46!e,<,!_11'&!I"WW-K,!<(16)'854L!0(1>!(1@7?1&L!)46!'/1!&'(7*'7(1!5@!*5()A:(11@!

! @8&/!)&&1D%A)?1&,!V*5A5?8*)A!C545?()0/&!F-2;;:"G",!

[556L!h,!C,!I#G"GK,!<50P55A&!=1(&854!-,#,-,!$=)8A)%A1!54!'/1!84'1(41',!jdZ!

! /''02nnMMM,050'55A&,5(?!

C*Y8441>L!C,Z,!i!Z5*UM556L!e,Z,!I"WWWK,!_85'8*!/5D5?148N)'8542!)!@1M!M8441(&!(10A)*84?!

! D)4>!A5&1(&!84!'/1!41O'!D)&&!1O'84*'854,!P(146&!V*5A,!V=5A,L!"9L!9EGf9E-,!

C8AA1(L!d,!h,!I"W;9K,!P/1!r)*UU48@1:)!(1=81M,!_85D1'(8U)!F"2!":"F,!

C5541>L![!$!I"WWBK,!P/1!hA5%)A8N)'854!5@!V*5A5?8*)A!P/57?/',!\A661465(@L!h1(D)4>2!

! V*5A5?>!34&'8'7'1,!

C5(84L!<,e,L!b8A%7(L![,!C,L!)46![)((8&L!d,!g,!I"WB-K,!^)A)D)461(!<(16)'854!)46!'/1!^'(7*'7(1!

! 5@!VO01(8D14')A!.5DD748'81&2!d1&054&1&!5@!g5'50/'/)AD7&!)46!C8*(5*(7&')*1),!

! V*5A5?>!F92!"9-G:"9-F,!

<)??8L!e,!.,L!d,!\,!C1465N)L!.,!e,!c1%548&L!)46!^,!_,!e5&w!61!<)??8!I#GG"K,!$!&8D0A1!)46!

! 841O014&8=1!'()0:'7%1!&)D0A1(!@5(!N550A)4U'54!*5AA1*'854!84!&/)AA5M!M)'1(&,!

! [>6(5%85A5?8)!9F929E:9W,!

<)841L!d,!P,!I"WFWK,!P/1!<8&)&'1(:P1?7A)!34'1()*'8542!<(1>!<)'*/1&L!<(16)'5(!T556!

! <(1@1(14*1L!)46!34'1('86)A!.5DD748'>!^'(7*'7(1,!V*5A5?>!EG2!WEG:WF",!

d)70L!c,!C,!)46!d,!V,!.(8*U!I"W;W,K!C1)&7(1D14'!5@!@)74)A!&8D8A)(8'>!84!0)A154'5A5?>,!

e57(4)A!5@!<)A154'5A5?>!E-2!"#"-:"##;,!

! 9W!

^8/L!$,L!<,!.(5MA1>L!C,!C*<11UL!e,!<1'()4U)L!)46!Y,!^'(5/D18(1(!I"WBEK,!<(16)'854L!

! *5D01'8'854L!)46!0(1>!*5DD748'81&2!)!(1=81M!5@!@81A6!1O01(8D14'&,!$447)A!d1=81M!5@!

! V*5A5?>!)46!^>&'1D)'8*&!"F2#FWf-"",!

^*/5141(L!P,!b,!)46!c,!$,!^08AA1(!I"WWFK,!c1=)&')'854!5@!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!%>!1O01(8D14')AA>!

! 84'(567*16!0(16)'5(&!84!'/1!@81A6,!g)'7(1!-B"2!FW":FW9,!

^08AA1(L!c,$,L!)46!^*/5141(L!P,b,!I"WBBK,!$4!1O01(8D14')A!&'76>!5@!'/1!1@@1*'!5@!A8N)(6&!54!

M1%:&0861(!*5DD748'81&,!V*5A5?8*)A!C545?()0/&!EB2!EB:;;,!

^08AA1(L!c,!$,L!)46!P,b,!^*/5141(!I"WWBK,!Z8N)(6&!d167*1!^0861(!^01*81&!d8*/41&&!%>!

! 1O*A7684?!d)(1!^01*81&,!V*5A5?>!;W2!EG-:E"F,!

P/5(0!e,[,!)46!.5=8*/!$<!I"WW"K,!V*5A5?>!)46!.A)&&8@8*)'854!5@!g5('/!$D1(8*)4!T(1&/M)'1(!

! 34=1('1%()'1&!I$*)61D8*L!^)4!c81?5K,!

P7(41(L!$,!i!P(1OA1(L!e,.,!I"WW;K,!^)D0A84?!84=1('1%()'1&!@(5D!'/1!TA5(86)!V=1(?A)61&2!)!

! *5D0)(8&54!5@!)A'1(4)'8=1!D1'/56&,!e,!g5('/!$D,!_14'/5A,!^5*,L!"FL!FW9f;GW,!

X8'57&1UL!<,!C,L!.,!C,!ck$4'5485L!Z,!Z,!Z5501L!)46!d,!b1&'%(55U&!I"WWFK,!_85A5?8*)A!84=)&854&!

)&!?A5%)A!14=8(54D14')A!*/)4?1,!$D1(8*)4!^*814'8&'!B929FB:9;B,!

b1A%5(4L!h,$,L!c,!Y,!^U1AA>!)46!V,!V,!b1(41(!I"WWFK,!C1*/)48&D&!.(1)'84?!.5DD748'>!

! ^'(7*'7(1!$*(5&&!)!T(1&/M)'1(![)%8')'!h()6814',!$447)A!d1=81M!5@!V*5A5?>!)46!

! ^>&'1D)'8*&!#;2!--;:-F-,!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! EG!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

H5I4&-!.!V@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(L!*54'(5A!)46!D7A'80(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&!54!)=1()?1!R:!IA5*)AK!)46!S!I(1?854)AK!0(1>!&01*81&!68=1(&8'81&!@5(!'/1!*)''A1!')4U!D1&5*5&D!1O01(8D14',!V((5(!

%)(&!(10(1&14'!&')46)(6!1((5(,!F&!40$1"%%E(!I>1AA5MK!61*(1)&16!(1?854)A!)46!A5*)A!

68=1(&8'>!(1A)'8=1!'5!'/1!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!I07(0A1K!IP)%A1!"L!#K,!G!4/0('%"E4$(!61*(1)&16!

(1?854)A!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!IP)%A1!#K,!P/1!D7A'80(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!!I?(114!68)D546K!M)&!

&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!@(5D!)AA!'(1)'D14'&!I050'55A&!'1&'=)A71!(1&7A'&K!1O*10'!G&!

4/0('%"E4$(,!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!/)6!45!1@@1*'!54!418'/1(!R!45(!γ-0(1>!68=1(&8'>,!.)A*7A)'854&!6541!84!<$^P!I[)DD1(!"#!$%&!#GG"K,!

! E"!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

H5I4&-!7)!gCc^!I454:D1'(8*!D7A'868D14&854)A!&*)A84?K!5(684)'854!0A5'!8468*)'84?!'/1!68@@1(14*1&!84!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&!IF&!40$1"%%E(L!07(0A1!65'&L!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!%A71!

65'&!)46!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!)Q7)!65'&K!54!0(1>!*5DD748'>!*5D05&8'854!(1A)'8=1!'5!'/1!

*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!I%A)*U!65'&K,!WEl!1AA80&1&!&/5M4!@5(!1)*/!'(1)'D14'!84!'/1!

*5((1&054684?!*5A5(,!g<C$g\X$!)46!<VdCc3^<!(1&7A'&!8468*)'1!&8?48@8*)4'!

68@@1(14*1!%1'M114!'(1)'D14'&,!$AA!0(16)'5(&!68@@1(16!@(5D!'/1!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!84!

*5DD748'>!*5D05&8'854!)**5(684?!'5!g<C$g\X$!(1&7A'&!IP)%A1!-K,!!P/1!68@@1(14*1!

84!'/1!*5DD748'>!&8D8A)(8'>!%1'M114!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!)46!'/1!*54'(5A!)46!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!!

)46!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!8&!671!'5!68&01(&854L!<VdCc3^<!(1&7A'&!IP)%A1!9K,!$4)A>&1&!(74!84!

<$^P!I[)DD1(!"#!$%&!#GG"K!)46!<VdCc3^<!I$461(&54!#GG9K,!

!

! E#!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

H5I4&-!J)!gCc^!I454:D1'(8*!D7A'868D14&854)A!&*)A84?K!5(684)'854!0A5'!8468*)'84?!'/1!68@@1(14*1&!84!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&!IF&!40$1"%%E(L!07(0A1!65'&L!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!%A71!65'&!)46!G&!

4/0('%"E4$(!)Q7)!65'&K!54!0(1>!*5DD748'>!*5D05&8'854!(1A)'8=1!'5!'/1!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!I%A)*U!

65'&K,!WEl!1AA80&1&!&/5M4!@5(!1)*/!'(1)'D14'!84!'/1!*5((1&054684?!*5A5(,!h(114!65'&!)46!

1AA80&1&!8468*)'1!'M5!8468=867)A!(10A8*)'1&!5@!'/1!D7A'80(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!(1A)'8=1!'5!'/1!*54'(5A!

'(1)'D14',!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!'(1)'D14'!68&01(&16!(1A)'8=1!'5!'/1!*54'(5A!8468*)'84?!)!A1&&!

/5D5?1457&!I/8?/1(!J:68=1(&8'>K!0(1>!*5DD748'>,!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!M)&!&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!

@(5D!%5'/!'/1!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!)46!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!IP)%A1!9K,!$AA!5'/1(!'(1)'D14'&!M1(1!45'!

&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!<VdCc3^<!(1&7A'&!IP)%A1!9K,!!

! E-!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

:'#C-!.)!d1&7A'&!@(5D!$g\X$!'1&'!(74!54!'/1!R!IA5*)AK!0(1>!*5DD748'>!)D54?!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&,!$4)A>&1&!M1(1!(74!84!<$^P!I[)DD1(!"#!$%&!#GG"K,!P/1!

5=1()AA!'1&'!&7??1&'16!?556!1=8614*1!5@!)!0(16)'5(!1@@1*',!x!=)A71&!5@!'/1!P7U1>H&!

0)8(M8&1!*5D0)(8&54&!)(1!&/5M4!84!'/1!%5''5D!'(8)4?A1!5@!'/1!D)'(8O!)46!0:

=)A71&!)(1!&/5M4!84!'/1!'50!'(8)4?A1!5@!'/1!D)'(8O,!F&!40$1"%%E(!8&!'/1!54A>!

0(16)'5(!'/)'!'/)'!&8?48@8*)4'A>!)@@1*'16!)A0/)!68=1(&8'>,!

! E9!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

:'#C-!7)!d1&7A'&!@(5D!$g\X$!'1&'!(74!54!'/1!S:68=1(&8'>!I(1?854)AK!5@!'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'>!)D54?!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&,!$4)A>&1&!M1(1!(74!84!<$^P!I[)DD1(!"#!

$%&!#GG"K,!P/1!5=1()AA!'1&'!8468*)'16!)!&8?48@8*)4'!0(16)'5(!1@@1*',!x!=)A71&!5@!'/1!

P7U1>H&!0)8(M8&1!*5D0)(8&54&!)(1!&/5M4!84!'/1!%5''5D!'(8)4?A1!5@!'/1!D)'(8O!)46!

0:=)A71&!)(1!&/5M4!84!'/1!'50!'(8)4?A1!5@!'/1!D)'(8O,!$AA!0(16)'5(&!1O*10'!@5(!G&!

.-/-,"(4"1(!)@@1*'16!S:68=1(&8'>,!

! EE!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

:'#C-!J)!d1&7A'&!@(5D!)!g<C$g\X$!'1&'!I"GLGGG!01(D7')'854&K!54!'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'>!)D54?!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&,!$4)A>&1&!M1(1!(74!84!<$^P!I[)DD1(!"#!$%&!

#GG"K,!P/1!5=1()AA!'1&'!M)&!&8?48@8*)4'L!8468*)'84?!0(16)'5(!1@@1*'&,!P/1!_54@1((548!

*5((1*'854!8&!&/5M4!84!'/1!A5M1(!'(8)4?A1!5@!'/1!D)'(8O!)46!'/1!0:=)A71&!84!'/1!7001(!

'(8)4?A1!5@!'/1!D)'(8O,!^8?48@8*)4'!0:=)A71&!)(1!%5A616,!$AA!0(16)'5(&!68@@1(16!@(5D!'/1!

*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!84!*5DD748'>!*5D05&8'854,!!

!

! EF!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

:'#C-!K)!d1&7A'&!@(5D!)!<VdCc3^<!'1&'!I9LWWW!01(D7')'854&K!84!<VdCc3^<!0(5?()D!I$461(&54!#GG9K!54!'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'>!)D54?!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&,!

P/1!5=1()AA!'1&'!M)&!&8?48@8*)4'L!8468*)'84?!0(16)'5(!1@@1*'&,!P/1!':=)A71&!)(1!

&/5M4!84!'/1!A5M1(!'(8)4?A1!5@!'/1!D)'(8O!)46!'/1!0:=)A71&!84!'/1!7001(!'(8)4?A1!5@!

'/1!D)'(8O,!^8?48@8*)4'!0:=)A71&!)(1!%5A616,!P/1!*5DD748'>!&8D8A)(8'>!5@!'/1!G&!

.-/-,"(4"1(!'(1)'D14'!68@@1(&!&8?48@8*)4'A>!@(5D!1=1(>!5'/1(!'(1)'D14'!1O*10'!@5(!

'/1!D7A'80(16)'5(!'(1)'D14',!_5'/!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!)46!'/1!D7A'80(16!'(1)'D14'!

&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(16!@(5D!'/1!*54'(5A!'(1)'D14'!M/8A1!'/1!5'/1(!'(1)'D14'&!686!

45',!

!

! E;!

*+',%-&!K/!*21(C4$521!

! P/1!M5(A6M861!?A5%)A8N)'854L!61&'(7*'854!)46!@()?D14')'854!5@!/)%8')'!)(1!A1)684?!

'5!'/1!A5&&!5@!%85?15?()0/8*!68&'84*'41&&!IX8'57&1U!"WWFL!C*Y8441>!)46!Z5*UM556!"WWWK,!

<(16)'5(&!)(1!)D54?!D)4>!5@!'/1!&01*81&!&011684?!)(5746!'/1!V)('/!54!'/1!'861!5@!

?A5%)A8N)'854!I1,?,!T(11D)4!)46!_>1(&!#GGFL!.)7'!"#!$%&!#GG;K,!X1(>!A8''A1!(1&1)(*/!1O8&'&!

1O)D8484?!'/1!/5D5?148N84?!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'5(&,!P/1!54A>!(1&1)(*/!54!'/1!'508*!1O)D841&!

'/1!1@@1*'!5@!)!7%8Q78'57&!0(16)'5(!I./)&1!"#!$%&!#GGWK,!P/8&!0)01(!)''1D0'16!'5!61'1(D841!8@!

68=1(&8'>!)46!&0)'8)A!)??(1?)'854!5@!0(16)'5(&!*57A6!)D1A85()'1!'/1!/5D5?148N84?!1@@1*'!5@!

'50!0(16)'5(,!!!

! P5!65!'/8&!3!@8(&'!%78A'!)!D561A!'5!1O0A5(1!'/15(1'8*)AA>!/5M!*/)4?1&!84!0(16)'5(!

68=1(&8'>!)46!)??(1?)'854!)*(5&&!)!A)46&*)01!M57A6!)@@1*'!0(1>!68=1(&8'>!)*(5&&!&0)'8)A!

&*)A1&,!3!7&16!)!D568@816!VP3_!I1Q78A8%(87D!'/15(>!5@!8&A)46!%85?15?()0/>K!D561A!)&!M1AA!)&!

D1')*5DD748'>!&8D7A)'854&,!3!7&16!'/1!D561A!'5!1O)D841!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!)!&84?A1!0(16)'5(!

&0(1)6!7%8Q78'57&A>!)*(5&&!)!(1?854!=1(&7&!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(&!&0(1)6!748@5(DA>!)*(5&&!)!

A)46&*)01,!P/8&!%)&8*!D561A!0(567*16!0(168*'854&!@5(!'/1!1D08(8*)A!D1')*5DD748'>!&'76>,!

3!@7('/1(!1O0A5(16!'/1!D561A!0(168*'854&!M8'/84!'/1!'/15(1'8*)A!@()D1M5(UL!1O0)4684?!'/1!

D561A!'5!84*A761!0(16)'5(!614&8'>L!)??(1?)'854L!681'!%(1)6'/!)46!84'14&8'>!?()6814'&,!

! 3!'/14!1D08(8*)AA>!'1&'16!'/1!0(168*'854&!5@!'/1!68=1(&8'>!?()6814'!&8D7A)'854&!

05('854!5@!'/1!D561A!84!)!D1&5*5&D!*)''A1!')4U!1O01(8D14',!3!/>05'/1&8N16!'/)'!68=1(&8'>!

)D54?!'50!0(16)'5(&!M57A6!*)&*)61!65M4!'5!'/1!14'8(1!*5DD748'>L!A1)684?!'5!(1A)'8=1A>!

A8''A1!(1?854)A!1O'84*'854!)46!D168)'84?!)!0(16)'854!1@@1*'!54!(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>,!P/1!

/>05'/1&8&!M)&!'1&'16!%>!'(1)'84?!A5*)A!*5DD748'81&!'5!&8O!68@@1(14'!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&L!

! EB!

&)D0A84?!'/1!*5DD748'81&!)@'1(!"B!M11U&!)46!'/14!*)A*7A)'84?!'5')A!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!)'!

A5*)A!IRK!)46!(1?854)A!ISK!&*)A1&,!!

! P/1!(1&7A'&!5@!'/1&1!D561A&!&7??1&'!'/)'!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&L!M/14!&0(1)6!)*(5&&!)!

D1')*5DD748'>!)D1A85()'1!'/1!61*(1)&1!84!J:68=1(&8'>!*)7&16!%>!541!748@5(D!0(16)'5(,!

P/1!*7D7A)'8=1!1@@1*'&!5@!D7A'80A1!&01*8)A8&'!0(16)'5(&!@5746!84!)!(1?854)A!A)46&*)01!)(1!

45'!&8?48@8*)4'A>!68@@1(14'!@(5D!'/1!47AA!1O01*')'854&!M/14!0(16)'5(&!*A7&'1(!

84'()&01*8@8*)AA>!84!A5*)A!/)%8')'&,!P/1!05&8'8=1!1@@1*'&!5@!D7A'80A1!0(16)'5(&!)(1!41?)'16!

M/14!)AA!0(16)'5(&!)(1!@5746!748@5(DA>!)*(5&&!'/1!/)%8')'!I84'1(&01*8@8*)AA>!)??(1?)'16K,!

P/7&L!D>!D561A!0(168*'&!'/)'!)!/8?/!68=1(&8'>!84!0(16)'5(!&01*81&!M8'/!A5M!681'!5=1(A)0L!

84'()&01*8@8*)AA>!)??(1?)'16L!M8AA!D168)'1!'/1!/5D5?148N84?!1@@1*'!5@!)!&84?A1!&01*8)A8&'!

0(16)'5(,!!!

! P/1!1D08(8*)A!&'76>!686!45'!&7005('!'/1!0(168*'854&!5@!'/1!D561A,!P/1!D7A'80A1!

0(16)'5(!1@@1*'!686!45'!D8'8?)'1!'/1!1@@1*'&!5@!0(16)'854!)&!0(168*'16]!8'!/)6!@1M1(!&01*81&!84!

'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A!'/)4!%5'/!'/1!*54'(5A!)46!G&!.-/-,"(4"1(!'(1)'D14'&,![5M1=1(L!'/1!

(1&7A'&!686!8468*)'1!'/)'!*1(')84!0(16)'5(&!*)4!A1)6!'5!68@@1(14'8)'854!)D54?!A5*)A!0(1>!

*5DD748'81&,!

! P/1!68&*(10)4*81&!%1'M114!'/1!D561A!)46!'/1!1D08(8*)A!&'76>!D5&'!A8U1A>!/)=1!

D)4>!*)7&1&]!'/1!@8(&'!5@!M/8*/!8&!'/1!A)(?1!5=1(A)0!84!0(1>!&01*81&!*54&7D16!%>!'/1!'M5!

D5&'!/5D5?148N84?!0(16)'5(!&01*81&!IG&!4/0('%"E4$(!)46!F&!40$1"%%E(K,!P/1!D7A'80A1!

0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'!8&!*54'84?14'!7054!'/1!861)!5@!84*(1)&16!5005('748'81&!@5(!0(1>!(1@7?8)!

@(5D!0(16)'5(&L!A1)684?!'5!)!A)(?1(!A8U1A8/556!5@!'/1!(1?854)A!&01*81&!055A!%184?!D)84')8416!

7461(!0(16)'854,!P/8&!610146&!7054!'/1!0(16)'5(&!/)=84?!(1A)'8=1A>!748Q71!681'!%(1)6'/&,!

P55!D7*/!5=1(A)0!84!'/1!681'!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(&!61*(1)&1&!'/1!0(1>!(1@7?8)L!*)7&84?!'/1!1@@1*'!

! EW!

54!'/1!0(1>!&01*81&!055A!'5!(1D)84!'/1!&)D1,!P/1(1@5(1L!'/1!/8?/!&8D8A)(8'>!84!0(1>!&01*81&!

*54&7D16!%>!G&!4/0('%"E4$(!)46!F&!40$1"%%E(!D)>!)**574'!@5(!M/>!'/1!0(16)'5(!1@@1*'!54!

(1?854)A!68=1(&8'>!M)&!45'!)D1A85()'16,!$668'854)AA>L!'/1!J:68=1(&8'>!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(!

'(1)'D14'!M)&!(1A)'8=1A>!A5M!671!'5!'/1!1O'8(0)'854!5@!'/1!0(16)'5(!&01*81&!84!"-!5@!'/1!

*)''A1!')4U&!A1)684?!'5!'/1!1A8D84)'854!5@!<&!$))-1-(!)46!9&!3/'B"%$(!0(16)'5(!'(1)'D14'&,!

^'7681&!/)=1!61D54&'()'16!'/)'!/5D5?148N)'854!5@!541!'(50/8*!A1=1A!/)&!A16!'5!

/5D5?148N)'854!5@!'/1!541!%1A5M!I_18&41(!"#!$%&!#GG-K]!84*(1)&16!J:68=1(&8'>!D)>!/)=1!'/1!

5005&8'1!1@@1*',!T7'7(1!M5(U!&/57A6!84*A761!/8?/1(!J:68=1(&8'>!M8'/84!'/1!0(16)'5(!

'(1)'D14'!)46!?(1)'1(!&01*8)A8N)'854!84!'/1!0(16)'5(!681',!

! ^01*81&!A5&&!8&!)!?A5%)A!0(5%A1D!)46!&/57A6!%1!1O)D8416!)*(5&&!&0)'8)A!&*)A1&,!_85'8*!

/5D5?148N)'854!8&!()086A>!)**1A1()'84?!)&!'/1!M5(A6!D5=1&!()086A>!@5(M)(6,!b/14!

*54&861(84?!Q71&'854&!5@!&01*81&!68=1(&8'>!)46!/5D5?148N)'854L!&0)'8)A!&*)A1L!0(16)'5(!

68=1(&8'>!)46!&0)'8)A!)??(1?)'854!&/57A6!)AA!%1!*54&861(16,!!

!

60:A;":?;A!*0:A>!

_18&41(L!_,V,L!3=1&L!$,d,L!)46!^,d,!.)(014'1(!I#GG-K,!P/1!1@@1*'&!5@!)4!1O5'8*!@8&/!84=)&854!54!

'/1!0(1>!*5DD748'81&!5@!'M5!A)U1&,!e,!$48D,!V*5A,!;#2!--"f-9#,!

.)7'L!^,L!$4?7A5L!V,!)46!T,!.57(*/)D0!I#GGBK,!c81')(>!&/8@'!5@!)4!84=)&8=1!0(16)'5(2!()'&L!

! &1)%8(6&!)46!&1)!'7('A1&,!e!$00A!V*5A!9E2!9#B:9-;,!

./)&1L!e,C,L!_8(5L!V,h,L!d>%1(?L!b,$,L!)46!^D8'/L!Y,h,!I#GGWK,!<(16)'5(&!'1D01(!'/1!(1A)'8=1!

8D05(')4*1!5@!&'5*/)&'8*!0(5*1&&1&!84!'/1!)&&1D%A>!5@!0(1>!D1')*5DD748'81&,!

V*5A5?>!Z1''1(&L!"#2!"#"Gf"#"B,!

T(11D)4L!$,!^,L!)46!e,!V,!_>1(&!I#GGFK,!c8=1(?14'!3467*16!d1&054&1&!'5!)4!34=)&8=1!<(16)'5(!

! 84!C)(841!C7&&1A!<507A)'854&,!^*814*1!-"-2!B-":B--,!

C*Y8441>L!C,Z,!i!Z5*UM556L!e,Z,!I"WWWK,!_85'8*!/5D5?148N)'8542!)!@1M!M8441(&!(10A)*84?!

! D)4>!A5&1(&!84!'/1!41O'!D)&&!1O'84*'854,!P(146&!V*5A,!V=5A,L!"9L!9EGf9E-,!

! FG!

X8'57&1UL!<,!C,L!.,!C,!ck$4'5485L!Z,!Z,!Z5501L!)46!d,!b1&'%(55U&!I"WWFK,!_85A5?8*)A!84=)&854&!

)&!?A5%)A!14=8(54D14')A!*/)4?1,!$D1(8*)4^*814'8&'!B929FB:9;B,!

!

!