A History of the Khoja Community

An Outline History of the Khoja Shia Ithna Asheri Community in Eastern Africa (By Mulla Asgherali M.M. Jaffer)

In the name of Allah, the Merciful. Salawat upon the Prophet, Hadhrat Muhammad and hisprogeny, the pure and immaculate.

And upon his companions who were faithfully by his side.

And upon all Muslims who believed in him without ever having sight of him.

Maulana Syed Saeed Akhtar Razavi, in his capacity as a Director of the Preparatory Committeeof the first Conference of World Ahlulbayt League (held in London on 5th August 1983),requested me to prepare an outline of the role of Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris in East Africa.

Brief excerpts from this paper were read before the Conference. Full text was later submitted tothe Secretariat of the League.

1 / 45


As this paper was being sent to Press for publication, additions were made, and some noteswere annexed. This is an outline, which can be given a detailed treatment later. It is hoped thatit will enlighten many who are interested in the history of the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris who livedin Africa.

This work is dedicated to –

a. All the Arab and Irani Missionaries who set foot on the soil of India, and converted manyIndians to ISLAM.

b. All the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris who suffered banishment, deprivation, injuries and death, inIndia and East Africa, for the sake of their Faith. They became a part of ISLAM and its history ,"but most of the people do not comprehend",

Asgharali M. M. Jaffer

London

Arabs, African & Islam

The role of Shia Ithna-Asheris in Eastern Africa is both impressive and interesting. But since it isa part of the major role played by Islam in Africa, it is imperative that we study the history of thefirst contact of Islam with this very important continent. There can be no doubt that the Arabswere the torch bearers of Islamic propagation, and therefore, the first Arab contact with Africa isa subject of our prime attention.

2 / 45


It is commonly assumed that Arabs were drawn to Africa after the advent of Islam. Recordsreveal, however, that Arab influence can be traced as back in time as 84 A.D. ( 1) There is anearly guide to trade and navigation called the "Periplus" compiled by a Greek merchant seaman,which describes in detail the voyage down the Red Sea and the African coast of the IndianOcean. From this 'Periplus' we learn that the people inhabiting the coast were of negroid stock,ruled by chiefs. But it also appears that these chiefs had long been under some kind of Arabsuzerainty and there was already a well-established trade carried by Arab and Indian shipsbetween Africa, Arabia and India. The book says: "The people of Muza (in Southern Arabia)sent thither many large ships, using Arab captains and agents, who are familiar with the nativesand inter-marry with them."

Africa saw the first light of Islam in the days of the Prophet himself, when a group of eleven menand four women took refuge in Abyssinia, escaping the rampant persecution in Mecca. As theyexplained their faith to the King and the priests, reciting Ayahs from the Surah of Maryam, tearsrolled down the cheeks of all who listened, shaking their heads in awe and reverence.

Muslim historians have recorded how the King of Abyssinia decided to send a delegation toMecca, so as to prepare a first hand report on the personality and the message of the Prophet.The description of their first encounter with the Prophet is inspiring and moving. The HolyQur'an, in its unique rendering, describes how the delegation from Negasus responded to themessage of Allah. In Suratul Maeda, Verse 83, Allah says:-

" And when they hear what has been revealed to the Prophet, you will see their eyesoverflowing with tears on account of the Truth that they recognize."

It is interesting to note that while the people near and around the Prophet rallied against him,meting out ill-treatment and persecuting his followers, a group of people from across the sea,with a different ethnic origin, belief and persuasion, should be so receptive and responsive.Here, I wish to make a pertinent observation on this historical event. This brief encounter ofIslam and Africa, in Abyssinia and later in Mecca, is a significant pointer to the African affinity toIslam. The point I wish to stress is that Africa today is still responsive and receptive to the greatmessage of Islam, in that it has a better appeal to the African mind and spirit than any otherreligion known to them. The relevance of Islam in Africa endures, but, it requires a healthy, freshimpetus and stimulus.

3 / 45


The penetration of Islam in the African society continued after the Prophet. The early record ofIslamic impact upon this important continent has been meticulously preserved in the books ofhistory, ethnography and sociology. The interesting admixture of social traditions, theemergence of new races by interbreeding among Arabs and Africans, the effect of Arabic uponthe local African language, the birth of new Arabic dialects in Africa- all bear testimony to thegreat work completed by the Muslim Arabs.

The spread of Islam in Africa is one of the most captivating chapters in the history of thatcontinent. It begins in the seventh century with the conquest of North Africa, onwards tonortheast Africa, the Red Sea islands and the coast of Eritrea. From the eleventh to theeighteenth century, Islam spread through the Sahara Desert to West Africa, and via the Nile tothe Sudanese belt and along the Coast of East Africa. The Northern Sudan IS an example oftotal cultural assimilation by the Arabs. Ibn Khaldun, visiting North and West Africa in the 14thc.describes Mali as the centre of A/moravid Berber empire established in the 11th c. Manyrulers of Mali made pilgrimage to Mecca, maintaining diplomatic, scholarly and commercialrelations with the Islamic world.

The earliest known Arab settlement on the East African coast is Pate, said to have beenfounded in 689 A.D. During the next 600 years, other cities such as Lamu, Malindi, Mombasaand Kilwa were founded and reached a high level of civilization; until eclipsed by thePortuguese conquests in the early 16th c. But the Arabs returned and ousted the Portuguese inthe early 18th c to commence a new era of Islamic influence. (2)

Zanzibar's Kizimkazi mosque dates from 1107 A.D. and the ruins of the 14th-15th c A.D.,Mosques, houses and palaces show that Arab influence was paramount.

The Arabs in East Africa spread Islam, introduced coconut palms, casurinas and bougainvillea;they planted mango trees in their scattered trading stations providing a shade to many a villagein the Tanzanian interior. More important, they intermarried with African people, the outcomebeing the Afro-Arab race, and its famous "Swahili" language. "Swahili", a loan word from ArabicSawahil, means coastal; it is basically Bantu, with many borrowings from Arabic.

4 / 45


They taught the Africans how to read and write, a gift which antedates in origin the Englishroman script. They taught them the Holy Quran, and encouraged them to memorize smallerchapters first. In an interesting account of such one attempt described by Arye Oded in his book'Islam In Uganda', we find a certain Ahmad Bin Ebrahim teaching small suras to the ruler ofBaganda in Uganda. The local historians describe how the King was taught "Kulauzu","Birabinasi" and "Kuluwalulamo", evidently referring to the chapters of AI-Falaq, An-Nas, andAI-Ikhlas.

The Christian evangelists in parts of East Africa made extensive use of Arabic for theirpropagation work. There was a time when they wrote the Ten Commandments in Arabic forAfricans to read, and the Catholic missionaries wrote their sacraments and prayers in Arabic. Intheir letters to their headquarters they pressed for books in Arabic as there was a big demandfor them among the African chiefs. It was in the latter half of the 19th c that they began to applythe roman script to Swahili.

The oldest preserved Swahili literature is in Arabic script, dating from the early 18th c. Amongthe most important Swahili epic poems preserved is the one called "Huseni", containing 1209stanzas, about the life and martyrdom of Imam Husein. Its representation in Swahili literature isof particular interest for the study of Shi'ite school in East Africa. (3)

It must be noted that Arabs did not spread Islam in East Africa by use of force or bycolonization. They were traders, and along their trading routes, they performed their religiousrituals regularly. To an inquisitive African, they inculcated Islam; and with their own actions anddeeds, their civility, their polite demeanour, and with their amazing adaptability to the localculture, they invited Africans to the new fold. This was conversion without coercion. The coastpeople, known as Waswahili,- and also called Wangwana by Christian missionaries, weretaught by Arabs various crafts. They became able artisans, masons, carpenters, gardeners andboat builders. But most important of all, they became zealous and enthusiastic propagators ofIslam.

The Christian missionaries also depended on these coastal people for their services. But they

5 / 45


were specially angry when they discovered that the Wangwana were usually very fanatical intheir Islamic faith much more so than the Arab traders, and that some of them were even tryingto convert their fellow Africans. D.P. Jones of the London Missionary Society, who worked in theinterior of East Africa, wrote to his headquarters on this subject. He said, "You will agree thathowever useful they may have been or may be in assisting us to build our houses etc., the harmthey do in propagating their Moslem ideas and customs more than counterbalances the moreeffective assistance they can render us." (4 )

The early influence of the Post-lslamic Persia has also been traced. It may well be true that thetown of Kilwa on the coast of Tanzania was founded by migrants from Shiraz in Persia; duringthe 10 c A.D. (5) A political party in Zanzibar formed under the name and style of Afro-ShiraziParty was suggestive. Further, a new year day is traditionally celebrated by Swahili Communitywith great funfare. This day is termed "Niruz", a persian word meaning "a new day." This 'Niruz'was celebrated last month (July-1983) in Mombasa, Kenya, as usual. The name of the head ofthe Community was given as Sheikh Mohamed Salim Shirazi. Besides, inspirations drawn fromPersian Islamic literature can easily be traced from the early Swahili poetry.

The Khojas (I)

The arrival of Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris and other Shias coincides with the resurgence of Islamicinfluence In the early nineteenth century. Although Arabs had regained their rule in E. Africa bydriving out the Portuguese in the late 17th c their ties with the coast of Africa were weak andnominal. It was only in the reign of Sayyid Said Bin Sultan who transferred his permanentresidence from Oman to Zanzibar 1n 1840, that the control became strong and complete.

The importance of Sayyid Said to the history of East Africa hinges on his energetic developmentof trade between the coastal towns and the interior. In the wake of Muslim traders came Islam tothe interior, followed in turn by the Christian missionaries and the pioneers of the colonialpowers.

The death of Sayyid Said in 1856 signified the beginning of the decline in Arab influence, adecline which continued until the colonial conquest of the region by the British.

6 / 45


The colonial period created conditions which generally were supportive of the Islamic influencein East Africa, such as the opening of communications, the establishment of order and securityalong the transportation routes, and the employment of Muslim clerks and functionaries by thegovernment. (6)

The circumstances in which the Shia settlement began and took roots in E. Africa are indicativeof their courage and enterprising spirit - their ability to make the most of the opportunities and toadopt and assimilate the varying trends.

The Shia Ithna-Asheri population of East Africa comprises chiefly of the Khojas. In a censuscarried out by the Community in late fifties and then repeated during sixties, the Khoja Shias inE. Africa, Somalia, Zaire, (then Congo), Mauritius, Reunion Island, and Madagascar numberedaround 20,000. Besides, there were Shia Ithna-Asheris from the Punjab, who were located inNairobi, the capital city of Kenya; numbering at one time, around 300. In Zanzibar, a smallcommunity of Bahraini Shias, consisting of Sadaat and others existed; and there were IranianSadaat of Shushter extract- commonly- knows as Shushtaries, and few other -all totallingaround 500.

According to the research paper written by Maulana Syed Saeed Akhtar Razavi, in collaborationwith Professor King of Makerere University , Kampala, Uganda, the Khojas arrived on the coastof E. Africa in 1840. (71 The Shia Ithna-Asheris from the Punjab were chiefly those recruited inthe labour force for the railway project in E. Africa, and Bahrainis and Iranians came to serve theSultans of Zanzibar after they had made that island their headquarters from 1832 onwards. Butthe growing number of Sadaat was mainly comprised of the descendants and relatives of theresident Aa!im of Zanzibar , Syed Husain Shushtari. The early Khojas came from Cutch andKathiawad. Their appearance in the East African coast is attributed to several developmentsback at home in India. It is said that these parts of India were stricken with long years of famine,and families lived below the subsistence level. Due to unemployment and scarcity, many ayoung man left this part of India in quest of new opportunities in Bombay. For hundreds ofyears, Indians sailed down to the East African Coast in their sailships during the North EasternMonsoon. The young, adventurous Khojas were probably among these Indians, who stayedbehind in Africa to explore new opportunities and possibilities for their livelihood.

7 / 45


Maulana Syed Saeed Akhtar Razavi in his paper referred to earlier, gives a somewhat detailedchronological and topographical order in which the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris moved forsettlement to every nook and corner of E. Africa, and farther still to Zaire, Mauritius andMadagascar. I quote:

"There appears to be a set pattern to their movements. When any enthusiastic pioneer went intoa new place, other newcomers followed him so that they might benefit from his experience andacquaintance with the local people. It appears that there was no jealousy among them, andwell-established persons helped the inexperienced to stand on their feet. New arrivals fromIndia usually came to Zanzibar and after acquiring some information, ventured out to otherplaces. Sometimes, however, they disembarked at Lamu, Mombasa or Dar-es-Salaam, andwent from there to the interior." (8)

While the new lands offered limitless opportunities to the Khojas, the new environment andprevailing influences called for an orientation. First, Zanzibar was then ruled by the Sultans ofOman who followed Ibadiyya sect; but the majority of the people at the coast remained underthe influence of Shafei Arab merchants who had migrated from Hadramut. .Second, theundeveloped Eastern Africa was totally foreign to the Khojas - they did not know the language,nor did they have any previous cultural contact with the indigenous African. Before them lay thevast, unexplored but inaccessible tracts of lands into which even the adventurous Arabs did notventure. Thirdly, it is a known fact that a number of Khojas converted from Ismailies to ShiaIthna-Asheri faith after their arrival in East Africa. These were perhaps among the few pioneerShia Ithna-Asheris present in East Africa. (9) Thus, one can safely conclude that most of theseKhojas were novices in complete sense of the term: new to the place, and new to the faith. Theatmosphere was undoubtedly conducive to speculative and progressive Khoja society, and it isin this light and vein that an inquiry into their history must be made.

Wherever the Khojas settled, they soon formed themselves into a Khoja Shia Ithna-Ashericommunity, commonly known as the Jamaat, guarded by an understandable sense of territorialjealousy. They advised and assisted each other, and invited their families, friends and fellowmen from India to join the venture. They engaged in religious activities, first with modestyappropriate to their means; but as their fortune grew, they became vigorously activated. Theybuilt Mosques, Imambadas, Madressas, Schools for secular education and created severaltrusts for charity. (10) Under the subsequent German rule in Tanganyika, British rule in otherparts of E. Africa, French rule in Madagascar, Italian rule in Somalia, Belgium rule in the Congoand Portuguese rule in Mozambique, the Khojas were subjected to a variety of influences andexperience. To an inquisitive and objective investigator, it is not difficult to trace a blend of Arab,

8 / 45


African, Persian, Indian and European cultures in the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheri Society inEastern Africa. The thrust of these influence was great, engendering a fear in the minds of theKhoja of losing their identity. It served to drive them farther inwards into the precincts of theirsociety, instead of mobilizing any worthwhile change. Hence the persistent perseverance by theKhojas to remain within a well-knit framework of the Jamaat allowing no intrusion.

During their stay in Africa South of Sahara, now spanning out over nearly two centuries, theKhoja Shia Ithna-Asheris have produced a number of men of note and repute. In the earlierdays, when modern modes of transportation were practically non-existent, they travelled on footor on donkeys, far and wide -establishing business centres, and encouraging distributive trade.Due to their probity and reliability, they were appointed as Agents for various governmentservices during the early period of British rule. (11} They were among the importers ofcommodities, exporters of produce and promoters of agriculture. In short, their contribution todevelopment of the economy and the country at large has been substantial. In the fields ofpolitics, social and cultural services, various professions, and religion, the community producedmen of great abilities, whose services are on record, forming an inalienable part of history.

The Jamaats functioned with a set of laws and bye-laws drawn on democratic principles; It usedto be a democracy which would put British system to shame. For while it provided rights andassigned duties to all, it never had a penal code nor a clause of punishment for the digressersor dissenters. In a later development, one can see a punishment clause in their constitution, butin actual practice this was ineffectual because of the intricate family ties and filial bonds whichhad developed within the Community.

While the services offered by such Jamaats were multiple and multifarious, they werepredominantly religious in nature. And it was in this sphere, that the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheriswere able to produce men of considerable talents and outstanding abilities. In the early dayswhen the Khojas were indeed novices, the influence of Allama Haji Gulamali Haji Ismail ofBhavnagar, India, was great. He authored nearly 300 books, chiefly on the theme of Islamicliturgy and ethics. His translation of "Meraju Ssa'dah", for example, is known to haverevolutionized and transformed many a life in Africa. His book of prayers, "Dua no Majmuo" runsparallel in importance and utility to "Mafatihul Jinan" by Sh. Abbas Qummi. That his servicespromoted and preserved the Shia Ithna-Asheri faith and knowledge in the Khoja society ofAfrica is an undeniable fact. >From among the local people Mullas of considerable abilitiesarose to teach and preach. Prolific writers like Gulamhusein Mohamed Vali Dharsi andMohamedjaffer Sheriff Dewji were acknowledged for their religious scholarship and eruditioneven in India.

9 / 45


The great Mujtahid of lucknow, Syed Aqa Hasan Taba Sarah conferred the title of‘Hami-e-lslam' upon Gu/amhusein Mohamed Valli Dharsi in 1910. Along with the symbolicendowment of a turban and a shawl, he wrote:

"In these days of the so called enlightenment, and in the face of the Western inculcations, it ismost gratifying to find men like you who protect and defend the Faith in the most appropriatemanner."(12)

Mohamedjaffer Sheriff Dewji wrote on diverse themes. He covered religious as well as socialsubjects. He has about twenty books to his credit, some of which have been acclaimed as hismasterpieces. He was better known for his preaching which was in simple Gujarati. In a stylepeculiarly his own, he held his audience spellbound and fully engrossed during his discourses.Two books by Mohamedjaffer Sheriff Dewji – “Ruyate Hila/" and "Imame Zaman" weretranslated into Urdu - a first example of Gujarati work to be rendered into a language which wasa principle source of reference by Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris. These locally produced Mullas,because of their voluntary undertakings to travel far and wide on preaching missions, and alsobecause of their common ethnic origin, were able to render unique services. Having grown up inArab and African atmosphere at the coast, and under the influence of Iraqi and Indian Ulemamost of these Mullas spoke Arabic, Persian, Urdu, Kiswahili - apart from their own mothertongues, with great ease, facility and fluency. (13)

The Khojas (II)

The earliest attention paid to the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris dates back to the days, of SheikhZainul Abedeen Mazendarani in Iraq. Those were the formative years, when certain Khojas hadbroken away from the Aga Khan after realizing that their beliefs and practices were not inaccordance with Islamic tenets. It is related that a group of Khojas led by Dewjibhai Jamal cameto Iraq to pay their homage to the shrines of Imam Ali and Imam Hussain. While in the presenceof Sheikh Zainul Abedeen Mazendarani, they were asked if they had already performed Haj. Inan answer which displays the then prevalent attitude, and which remains characteristic of thefollowers of the Aga Khan even today, they said that they believed that the Ziyarats of Imamstook precedence over Haj. A gentle admonition from the Ulama of Iraq awakened the Khojas to

10 / 45


the Truth they did not know, with the result that they made a vehement appeal to Sheikh ZainulAbedeen Mazendarani for a tutor to be sent to Bombay. A certain Indian student, Mulla QadirHusein, was sent by the Sheikh to India in 1873 for the purpose of teaching the Khojas thefundamentals and the obligatory rituals of Islam according to the Shia Ithna-Asheri school. ThisMulla stayed in Bombay and remained in service for 27 years, a period which is historicallyimportant, though tumultuous, in the development of Shia Ithna-Asheri faith among the Khojas.Some of the students of Mulla Qadir Husein then travelled to Zanzibar, and were responsible forthe propagation of faith among the Khojas in East Africa.

The Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris in Eastern Africa will ever remain indebted to the constantattention of Ulema of Iraq and India for their religious training. The Maraje' of Taqleed sent theirrepresentatives to East Africa with a mission to teach Fiqh, to publish the Amaliyyah in locallanguages, to write religious tracts and treatises, and to preach from Mimber. The speed withwhich these representatives adapted themselves to the local surroundings is amazing. Some ofthe Ulema from Iraq are known to have learnt Gujarati and Urdu so as to enable them tocommunicate with the masses with ease and facility. Their command over these languages,though not very impressive, was tolerable. A group from amongst the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris,who formed he majority of Shi'te population in Eastern Africa, soon became able to preach andteach religion to the members of the Community, and to write scholarly works on variousreligious topics in their own language. Apart from this tangible result, there is another influenceof these earlier Ulema, which is subtle and tenuous. They were men of piety, probity and virtue.Their simple living, zeal and dedication and their clean, immaculate and distinctive record ofservices to Islam, all had a tremendous impact upon the minds of the Shias. In this implicitmanner, these Ulema provided a life style and ethical rigorism agreeable to Islamic code ofconduct and behaviour.

Earlier in this century , beginning from the later part of the second decade onwards, theMadrasatul Waezeen of India started sending their missioneries to East Africa. Thesemissionaries were men of profound learning, specially trained for preaching and propagating thefaith. They toured East Africa, visiting various Jamaats of Shia Ithna-Asheris and prepared acomprehensive report of their own activities. But the nature of these visits was expeditious,protracted for a few months during which time some of them extended their visits to as far southas Madagascar, and northwards to Somalia. In early thirties, the need for resident Ulema wasfelt, and Jamaats of East Africa, Madagascar and Somnalia decided to have such services on apermanent basis. The great learning institutions of India, like Nazmia Arabic College andMadaris of Lucknow, Jawadia Arabic College of Benaras and others came to their rescue. Thesympathetic and patronizing regard by the great divines of India, Aqa-e-Najmul Millat SyedNajmul Hasan Saheb, Taba Sarah, Aqa-e-Nasirul Millat Syed Nasir Husein Saheb, Taba Sarah,Aqa-e-Baqirul Millat Syed Mohamed Baqir Saheb, Taba Sarah, and later on, Aqa-e-SyedZafarul Hasan Saheb Taba Sarah, Mufti Syed Ahmad Ali Taba Sarah and Aqa-e-Syed

11 / 45


Muhammed Taba Sarah, has left an indelible imprint upon the developments of ShiaIthna-Asheri school in these parts of Africa.

The earliest record of services by a resident Aalim is to be found in Zanzibar where Agha SyedAbdulhusein and Agha Syed Husein Shushtari were sent by Agha-e-Yazdi and Agha Syed AbulHasan Isfehani from Iraq. Later on, we find Ulema from India serving as resident Molvis incentres like Mombasa in Kenya, Dar-es-Salaam in Tanganyika (now Tanzania), Mogadishu inSomalia and Morondava in Madagascar. Other smaller Jamaats followed in the wake, and by1958, there were more than 25 Ulema stationed in East Africa, Somalia, Mauritius andMadagascar. Needless to say that these men of learning from India and now also fromPakistan, gifted with fluency of Urdu and an eloquent style, equipped with enough of what onemight call ‘a Khoja experience' gained from Bombay and at times Gujarat, enjoyed greatpopularity. Thus, one can safely infer that Shi'ite practice and piety in Africa was a strategycarefully and lovingly managed by Iraq and India, gradually turning it into the spontaneousmovements of the masses.

It is not my intention to pronounce any judgment on the role played by these later Ulema; nor doI feel qualified. In the course of time, however, as the Molvis grew familiar with the localenvironment and attitudes, as their recruitment became centrally controlled, governed by aunified contract, and also due to the human element involved on either side, the Molvis and thelaity, a set, rigid and defined pattern of their role emerged. This was restricted to leading dailyprayers, occasional preaching, solemnizing marriages and divorces, last rituals for the dying orthe dead, exorcising those overtaken by the evil spirits, amulets and divining. The brunt laysquarely on the shoulders of the Khoja Shias who expected nothing more, and upon thoseMolvis who found this a comfortable and convenient vocation.

With the passage of time, some thinking Khoja Shias became aware and conscious of thisdismally monotonous role played by the Ulema, and were rudely awakened to the need forchange. This progressive element began to express itself articulately and persuasively. Thesudden shift of attention occurred chiefly because of two reasons. First, a wind of change hadstarted to blow across the continent of Africa; the indigenous Africans demanding freedom fromthe inhuman yoke of colonization. To a casual observer, this may be a just another politicalmovement. But this was, in fact, a stage set to change the very fabric, structure and attitudes ofthe society, - especially that of non-African origin - and Khoja Shias were no exception. Thenarrow vision of the world, engendered by the jealously guarded bouhds of communal entities,must change to a wider and broader ' perspective. Secondly, and more important, was thedichotomy caused by the limited role of the Ulema. People were religious if they attended the

12 / 45


daily prayers - the preachings during Ramadhan and Moharram, paid handsome donations toone or another religious cause; but beyond the precincts of the Mosque and the Imambada,there was a territory foreign to the Ulema; which by mutual understanding was not to be invadedor trespassed.

Discussing the second reason that I have advanced, mention must be made of the effects of themodern World. And when I refer to the modern world, I speak of the revolution in thought,politics and economics which radically altered the material and social conditions and theconsciousness of people whose way of life was structured by them. The picture of the worldpresented in contrast with the influential development all around, was neither relevant norrecognizable. The dichotomy, therefore, was a dichotomy by contradiction; a disjunction hadbeen created, and people were no longer living their beliefs.

The demands made upon the Ulema and the Community at large were very clear. The handfulthinkers of reform wanted them to recognize that Religion and social order were interwoven, toan extent that it was not clear where one ended and the other began; that modernity had comein a package, not available in its separate components and therefore it called for an appraisaland adoption within the limits of Sheriah; that a detached existence of Ulema among the peoplethey supposedly served was outmoded; that the proper response for any behaviour consideredto be irreligious and undesirable was not for merely impute moral responsibility to the doer, butto locate the cause of action by empirical investigation of the social and psychologicalcircumstances of the individuals; that the message of Ahlul Bayt was not an exclusive preserveof any one community, group or class.

As these novel ideas suffered the pangs of labour, a young Aalim from India set his feet on landin Dar-es-Salaam, Tanzania. With an analytic bent and genius, vast knowledge and readinessto meet with the new challenges, this young Aalim was destined to set the wheels of changemoving. He was Maulana Syed Saeed Akhtar Razavi. Whether he himself was aware of thenew directions to which the Shia Ithna-Asheri Community of Eastern Africa was being led by hisefforts, and , whether his efforts were intentional and thus motivated, is difficult to ascertain. Butthat his arrival heralded a new era in the Shi'ite Society of East Africa is indisputable. Amongthe Ulema who now remained to discharge their set role, he was perhaps the first to walk downbriskly from the elevated pedestal of mere adoration. Maulana set himself to learning Kiswahili,the lingua franca of Tanzania and Kenya, and language of adoption in Uganda, Zaire, Coastalparts of Madagascar, Comore Islands and boundaries of Somalia. With great diligence, heperfected his English. He was now equipped and prepared to meet with the new demands inwhich he himself was a fervent and ardent believer. This was indeed very important; for the new

13 / 45


venue of service was not imposed upon him; it was charted by himself.

The impressive performance by Maulana Razavi received a great impetus from the societywhich was now becoming fully aware of the creeping changes all around. Whether the EastAfrican Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris contributed to the making of Maulana what he became is amatter of meticulous study. One thing is certain. No great and substantial change is wrought in avacuum. While some of the members of the Khoja Shia society remained wary and scrupulousabout the missionary undertakings beyond the community, the impact of the protagonists andtheir influence had a distinct effect on the majority. From this group of thinkers and enthusedmen, Maulana gleaned enough support to proceed. It is safe, perhaps, to assume that theexercise was reciprocal. Society was preparing to countenance the demands of the changingtimes, viewing the role of Ulema in a different perspective and becoming alive to itsresponsibilities towards Allah and His message. This was undoubtedly conducive to anunforeseen situation. Maulana Razavi set out to meet the challenge, and in so doing,demonstrated his talent and genius which made him famous throughout the Shia world as adedicated missionary and a scholar of great repute. It is for this reason that in certain thinkingquarters of the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris of East Africa, it is firmly held that they must be giventhe due credit for having discovered Maulana Razavi .

The Federation

As the community grew in size and number, at the East African Coast, and at the remoteinterior, a need to obviate the difficulties caused by dispersion became a focus of attention.From early thirties of this century and onwards, writers and thinkers began to promulgate anidea of forming a central organisation to which these Jamaats would be affiliated, thus instillinga sense of common belonging and creating a social interaction.

Among the first thinkers who wrote about the need of a common platform was MarhumAbdulhusein Sachedina "AZAD", editor of the Gujarati monthly, "MUNADEE". "MUNADEE"means 'a herald'. In 1932, this reticent but profound thinker wrote an editorial in his monthly,appealing to leaders of major Jamaats to awaken and rise to the changing times. He can besafely called the first visionary who saw the ailing society, and suggested a remedy with clarity.His powerful pen heralded a new era. (14)

14 / 45


Marhum Azad had a style which was quite appealing. With almost complete command over hissubject, he wrote poetically, gracefully and with enviable coherence. In this editorial which hepenned in 1932, he says:

"lthna-Asheri Society today is overwhelmed by layers of backwardness and retrogression.These layers have been building up for the last several years, and continues even today. Thehorizon is bleak and dark, and nowhere is a ray of light to be seen. The ship of our community isdrifting aimlessly and helplessly in a vast ocean, and none can predict when it will perish againstthe rocks. This is not a figment of imagination by a poet, or empty, fictional verbiage by a writer.Those who care to spare a moment or two to make an appraisal, will agree that our wordsportray an exact and accurate picture of the prevailing situation."

And then he proceeded to enumerate the ills of our society, condemning the time worn,sometimes outlandish, traditions and social norms which he believed must be shunned. Hedescribed how the community was scattered in the remote parts of East Africa, graduallybecoming disorganized, losing contact with the mainstream of the Ithna-Asheri society. Mincingno words, he held the leaders of the major Jamaats responsible for the pathetic state of affairs,"Progress without reform and organization is difficult. We need a strong, fortified set of lawswhich should bring about order and discipline in all our Jamaats, big and small, and should openup the stifled path of progress and advancement. This has got to be our goal, and the easiestway to achieve this is to form a Central Council of the Shia Ithna-Asheri Community in EastAfrica",

he wrote. In response to this editorial, Marhum Abdulhusein Nurmohamed wrote a letter whichwas published in "MUNADEE" in January 1933.

He supported the editorial, and gave a detailed programme for such a Central Council, should itever be established. The letter shows that he clearly saw the use of such an organized, centralbody, and that he was gifted with a sense of direction to which, he thought, the community couldbe led. No wonder he was elected the first President of the Central Council when it was finallyformed twelve years later .

15 / 45


Marhum A. H. Nurmohamed was a public figure, his services extending beyond the precincts ofour community. Amiable, soft- spoken, polite and affable, he was a master of his temperament,in every sense a gentleman, who could keep his head while others around him lost theirs. Helaid the foundation masterfully, and left his marks as a farsighted and dedicated leader. Tributemust be paid to his able Honorary Secretary, Marhum Haji Gulamhusein Nasser Lakha whostood by his side through all the teething troubles of the early days. Marhum G. N. Lakha,despite his tendency to act as one in a secondary position, was the hub of the wheel.

In 1945, the leaders of the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheri Jamaats of East Africa met InDar-es-Salaam to approve the idea, and form an adhoc committee for a ConstitutionalConference which was convened in the ensuing year, again at Dar-es-Salaam. In 1961,Jamaats in Somalia, Madagascar, Mauritius, Zaire and Mozambique were brought under thewings of this Federation, and the central organization , metamorphosed from East African intoAfrican Federation.

The second President of the Federation was Marhum Haji Abdulrasul Haji Nasser Virjee.Though he hailed from a pioneer family which had once established its trade branches all overEast Africa, he was little known outside Mwanza where he lived. Behind the veil of reticence andaloofness, was a man gifted with the philosophical attitude, staid habits and clear, incisivethinking. He was a man of few words. In his inaugural Presidential address delivered at thesecond Conference held in Mombasa in 1949, the values in his life emerge clearly defined andhis words show him as a figure towering high, a lone traveler, a detached spectator. His term ofoffice was short and uneventful. History may judge him as a right man in the wrong place.

The most vigorous and active President of the Federation was Marhum Haji Ebrahim HuseinSheriff Dewji. He hailed from a family which is known for its religious services, and for itsdevotion as well as brilliance.

At the end of 1958, the Federation needed a redeemer. Marhum Haji Ebrahim then provided aleadership which has remained unequalled till today. Unfortunately, he was also one of the mostmisunderstood leaders of our community. Or was it all because of envy which he evoked ?There was hardly any challenge he could not meet, hardly any hostile strategem he could notsurround, hardly any difficulty he could not surmount. He died in 1964 at the age of 41, whilestill in office.

16 / 45


The path blazed by Haji Ebrahim needed a sustainer. Marhum Haji Mohamedali Meghji, whosucceeded Haji Ebrahim as a President, was a man of matchless calm and composure. Despitehis advancing age and frail health, he proceeded to work for the Community with devotion anddiligence. He jealously guarded the seeds sown by his predecessors, nursed them and sawthem bloom before he died in 1973 while still in office.

The ability to create an effective unified organization of nearly 72 Jamaats, further enabled theKhoja Shia Ithna-Asheris of Africa to grow from a conceptually static and arid society into theone more vigorous and discursive. Anew hierarchy placed greater responsibilities upon theleaders, giving them a wider perspective. New paths were blazed, and new venues of serviceswere explored and adopted. Among the pronounced features are the centralization of Funds,controlled movements of Molvis, unified syllabus for all Madressas, providing assistance to theneedy, planning economic upliftment of the less fortunate members, and giving educational aidto those intending to go overseas for religious as well as secular higher studies. The growth ofcloser ties between the individual members of the constituent Jamaats, commercial as well associal, was, of course, a natural outcome of the increasing interaction, acquaintance andcontact brought about by frequent meeting of the Federation. The Federation works through theinstrumentality of the Supreme Council which meets every year , and the tri-annual Conference.The administrative ability and discipline generally displayed by this community has been lookedupon with great admiration by the sister communities in Africa. Of particular interest is theappreciation shown by the Maraie' Taqleed like Ayatullah Syed Muhsin Et-Hakirn Taba Sarah,and Ayatullah Syed Abut Qasim El-Khui in diverse manners. The Khoia Shia Ithna-Asheris werefrequent visitors to the holy shrines in Iraq and Iran, and to the great Mujtahedeen there.However, it was quite apparent that this acquaintance was peripheral and very formal. The firstintimate relationship between the Marja' of Taqleed and the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheri Communityof Africa and their recognition as an active and united Shia people were visible during the timesof Ayatullah El-Hakim, when the then President of the Federation, Late Haji Ebrahim HuseinSheriff Dewji made a detailed representation. The Community will ever remain grateful toAyatullah El-Hakim and Ayatullah El-Khui for their spiritual guidance and for their continued careand concern.

Whether the establishment of the Federation was a sign of far-sightedness of the leaders, or amere fear of decadence, or result of a sense of insecurity felt in an adopted land, is a very finepoint of scholastic sociology; especially so, one would think, in contrast with the parent Jamaats.of Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris in the sub-continent of India who, in spite of their greater numberand dispersal, never federated. One thing, however, is certain. The Federation prepared,inadvertently though, the Khoja Shias of Africa to find a new role in the World which was rapidly

17 / 45


changing with the technological advance, scientific outlook, and political upheavals.

Beginning from 1964 with the revolution in Zanzibar, the demands upon the Federation becamegreater. It had to undertake the unprecedented task of rehabilitating the displaced and uprootedmembers, caused by political changes. And so, in 1972, when Asians in Uganda were asked toleave the country for good, the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheri settlement in Uganda disappeared. Thisdismemberment, besides causing untold miseries to the affected families, placed the Federationface to face with a hitherto unconceived situation. The great one-third limb was now amputated,and while World agencies and governments came to the rescue of the Ugandan refugees onhumanitarian basis, the Federation set itself busily to assist its Community members dutifully.

Needless to say that Shia people from Africa thought of migration. This time the reasons werepolitical rather than economical. In the wake of Uganda exodus, Khoja Shias from other parts ofAfrica girded up their loins to pre-empt anything similar happening to them. Within a space offour years after 1972, many Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris of Africa found their new homes inEngland, the U.S.A., Canada, other European countries, the Middle East- with a section of themback home in India or Pakistan. Their ties with the Federation of Africa gradually becameweaker, despite being constantly haunted by the memory of the Sweet and happy days inAfrica.

The Exodus …. and after

The dislocation of Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris from Uganda, coupled with a steady migration fromother parts of Eastern Africa, and Madagascar, had a traumatic effect on the Community. Withinthe society, the tremors were unmistakably felt, and the psychological effects upon the mindsand morals of the people were great and telling. The most remarkable feature of these newsettlements, however, is that no sooner did they settle down in the new lands, than they beganorganizing themselves in the same old fashion as that of Eastern Africa. Here again there wereJamaats, based on nearly the same type of constitution, and religious projects receiving thesame attention as before. Within a very short period, buildings for Mosques, Imambadas andAlim quarters were either purchased or built. The cost of such undertakings had riseninexorably, and the capital investments in Eastern Africa stood in no comparison. Yet, theprojects were completed successfully.

18 / 45


In order to recompense the terrible loss sustained as a result of the expulsion and forcedmigration it was absolutely necessary to re-enact an external surrounding compatible to theacquired living habits. Mosques and Imambades served to mitigate the distress, gave a feelingof having partly recovered what had been lost, and, of course, provided a spiritual comfort sonecessary for the depressed souls. To this end, money poured in copiously. Was it an urge topay any price for spiritual comfort? Or was it a religious zeal whipped up by frenzy? Or both, orperhaps neither? Perhaps it was only a pure intention to remember Allah and submit to His willand pleasure against all odds and adversities.

In 1975, a meeting was convened in London to discuss the need of a central organization, thistime not only for the Community in the West, but for the entire Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheripopulation of the World. In exactly the same fashion as it was done thirty years ago, an ad hoccommittee prepared a draft Constitution for approval and adoption by the Conference c'onvenedfor the purpose in the ensuing year, and thus the World Federation of Khoja Shia Ithna-AsheriMuslim Communities was born.

Compared to the Federation of Africa, the World Federation is still in its infancy. But thecontributions made by the experienced leaders from East Africa has enabled it to acquirestability earlier than expected. Jamaats in proximity of each other and in close regional locationswere advised to form their own Federations, so that the World Federation could be promoted toa status of Confederation. At present, there are three Federations who enjoy representativememberships on the World Federation. First, of course, is the Federation of Africa, and next inline is the Federation of the Jamaats in North America. The third Federation is of the Jamaats inCutch and Kathiawad, known as the Gujarat Federation. Where there are no such Federations,the Jamaats and other constituted Shia organizations have been granted memberships. Theservices of the World Federation are currently streamlined to the projects, as and when they arebrought for consideration. But there are a few original projects like the group marriages in Indiaamong Sadaat and the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris, rehabilitation of Shia people in India, theireconomic upliftment, grants towards capital funds needed for religious buildings, in the East andin the West, housing schemes, and above all, planning and financing such projects which aremeant for maintaining and disseminating religious practices and knowledge with a specialemphasis upon the Jamaats in the West.

In these days of turmoil and upheavals, the World Federation has kept itself abreast of thedevelopments in the Muslim world. Though not politically attuned, it has remained alive to theneeds of the Ummah at large, and has contributed whatever it could to the brothers in need anddistress. There have been instances when this World Federation has raised voice of protest

19 / 45


against the oppressors on behalf of Mustadhafeen from various countries. (15)

The World Federation is currently based in London. There is a much advertised moral questionfacing this organization, mention of which is now absolutely necessary. Should the Khoja ShiaIthna-Asheris remain conscious of their own ethnic origin, faithfully and jealously guarding theirbounds against all encroachments? Is it not high time for them to forget their nomenclature, andjoin the mainstream Islamic organizations? Better still, if they have the fund of experience inorganizational work, would it not serve the Shia Ummah better if they opened their doors to allregardless of their ethnic origin? Is it morally justifiable to remain detached and self complacent,looking at the suffering outsiders with a passive condescention ? To all this, the Khoja ShiaIthna-Asheris are repeatedly invited to answer. They are not more than 100,000 people all theworld over. However, the demands made upon them by the majority of the Shiah brothers toassimilate and accept all into their organizational fold is a pointer to their organizational abilityand their achievements, if nothing else. The patronizing regard by the present Majia'e TaqleedAyatullah Syed Abul Qasim El-Khui towards the World Federation is a matter of great pride ansatisfaction. The preservation and promulgation of Islam according to the teachings of AhlulBayt had become a matter of prime concern for the Maraje' since the times of Ayatullah SyedHusein Burujardi, and Ayatullah Syed Muhsin El-Hakim, and continues to be so in the presenttimes. The World Federation is among those agencies which fulfill desires of the Marja' in thisrespect.

The services of the World Federation are by no means restricted the Khoja Shias. And yet, thefield of service to its own member immeasurably vast. It has just begun to touch the fringes. Letus hope that in the course of time, after attending to the urgent needs, this organization is ableto participate meaningfully in the mainstream Shia organizations and maintain a vocal as well asreciprocal relationship.

Bilal of Africa

With the passage of time, the emergence of new patters, tendencies and values brought aboutby the new social environment, the Federation became gradually aware of its responsibilitytowards propagation of Faith outside the Khoja Community. This awareness was not promptedby any selfish motive. The urge for spreading the mission was now genuinely believed to betheir burden. But at least a decade before the Federation ever thought in this direction, that is inthe mid-fifties, Mulla Husein Alarakhya Rahim wrote in the Zanzibar-based, religious, Gujarati

20 / 45


periodical 'SALSABIL' about the need to spread the message of Ahlul Bayyt among theindigenous inhabitants of the Continent. in 1964, Ayatuullah Syed Muhsin EI-Hakim Taba Sarahgently admonished the leaders of the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris for their self-centred, proprietoryand possessive frame of mind. He directed them to preach the Truth to the African masses, andthus to absolve themselves of their sacred responsibility to Allah Almighty. In the year 1962, andlater in 1964, Maulana Syed Saeed Akhtar Razavi submitted a pilot scheme and a detailedmemorandum on the missionary activities before the Conference of the Federation convened atTanga, Tanzania. The 1964 memorandum was received with mixed feelings, but was ultimatelyadopted as a policy by an appreciable majority. This is how a new field of activity appropriatelynamed BILAL MUSLIM MISSION, after the great African companion of the Prophet, and firstMuazzin of ISlAM, HAZRAT BILAL, may Allah bestow upon him His pleasure, was begun.

Studying the African response to the Shi'ite propagation and its evaluation is a subject requiringan extensive research. But it will not be out of place to record that the previously prevailingimpression that Shi'ite faith was exclusively Indian has now been eradicated. The bias andprejudice with which the Shias were held has now been replaced with a fair and balancedattitude.

The scope of the Bilal Muslim Mission is vast and has many facets. It must be graciouslyadmitted that the people with whom it deals need religious as well as temporal care andattention. In the wake of spreading the teachings of the 'THAQALAIN', the Holy Qur'an and the :Ahlul Bayt, the need for social, educational and economic services could not escape ourperception, and Islam being a complete code of life, demanded explicitly that such acomprehensive programme be instituted. To this end, the late Professor Khwaja Mohamed LatifAnsari of Pakistan, had drawn the attention of the Community in his memorable addressdelivered at Arusha Conference in December 1958.

The Africans have their own rich cultural traditions and ancient history of which they are rightlyproud. At he same time in their search for the Truth, and in their efforts to identify themselveswith the modern world, they are keen and least resistant. When an African embraces a newfaith, he generally does so with absolute conviction and with no ulterior motives. Therefore,when I speak of the scope of the Bilal Muslim Mission, I do not merely speak of theirexpectations; I speak also of our responsibilities.

21 / 45


An African is an avid and voracious reader. He reads whatever comes in his way, so as to learnand know more and more.

The Bilal Muslim Mission started its first Swahili Publication "Sauti Ya Bilal" (The Voice of Bilal)to cater for the Swahili readers. And then there was an English periodical, 'The Light' which nowenjoys global readership. To its credit, the Mission has several Kiswahili and English bookswritten on a wide range of Islamic topics. Apart from two centres in Tanzania and Kenya, it hasnearly 25 Madressas in East Africa, which are managed by the Shia African Muballegheenoriginally trained in the centres. The number of African converts in Tanzania. Kenya, Burundiand Madagascar may safely be estimated at 40,000. Both the centres run a successfulcorrespondence course which has a substantial enrolment of African students some from as faras West Africa. At least one Primary School for secular education of . African boys and girls isknown to have been built by the Bilal Muslim Mission. This school in Kenya, is classed amongthe best primary schools at the Coast. Many African converts were given employment and someof them were trained for various vocations enabling them to become self employed. However,the efforts in this sphere cannot termed satisfactory.

The Maraje' Taq/eed, Ayatullah Syed El-Hakim and Ayatullah,Syed El~Khui have attached greatimportance to the activities of the Mission, and have expressed their full support; blessing theFederation with their earnest prayers. In 1968, Ayatullah El-Hakim graciously admitted Africanstudents from East Africa to the Hawza in Najaf but due to the fast deteriorating conditions, theywere transferred to Lebanon - some of them under the care of Syed Mohamedhusein Fazlullah-and later on to Qom, Iran. Among the African students in Iran; we have some who are fromBurundi, Uganda, Madagascar and Comore Islands.

It is not possible, within the limited time at my disposal, to enumerate all the activities of the BilalMuslim Mission in detail. Among the great changes it has wrought in the Khoja ShiaIthna-Asheri Community is a fact that it spurred and prompted the Khoja boys and girls toengage in the advanced religious studies. With the African boys and girls in Iran today, we havea number of Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheri students - all busily pursuing higher religious education.

As I have mentioned earlier, the incessant and untiring efforts and contributions by MaulanaSyed Saeed Akhtar Razavi in this direction have been decisive and of great import. Hisknowledge of Swahili and English enabled him to offer his services without any undue

22 / 45


hesitation. He was appointed Chief Missionary of Bilal Muslim Mission - an apellation signifyingthe new role of an Aalim among the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris. For the first time in its history, theCommunity lent its credence to this new appointment and realized that the function of an Aalimcould be much more beneficial, varied and discursive.

To this August Conference (16) attended by the Ulema and intellectuals of ISLAM, I venture twosubmissions. First, that the Shia Ithna-Asheri Community of Africa has undergone a dispersal,and is now widely scattered in the West. The influence of ISlAM has got to be compatible withthe inroads of anti-ISLAMIC influence, and the pace has got to be equal if not greater. I hopeand earnestly pray that this Ahlul Bayt League, with its high aims and noble objects will, with theaid of modern amenities and new approach, attend to this dire need, giving it a preferentialdispensation. The programme need not be for Shias of Africa alone, for the problem faces allMuslims, and is expected to endure if not remedied in time.

The idea of leadership by Ulema is not a novel one. One can see such leadership provided bythem in the history of Iraq, Iran, Syria, Lebanon and India. In modern times, we have seen itfunction in the Islamic Republic of Iran. With the establishment of this League, a new era hasdawned, with our expectations running high. I hope that this leadership will not be restricted toleading of the daily prayers, occasional preaching, solemnizing marriages and divorce, lastrituals for the dying or the dead, exorcising of those overtaken by the so-called evil spirits,amulets and divining. We hope that this leadership will conjoin the Islamic hope of heaven withjustice on earth. Secondly, please do not forget Africa. Africa needs your prime attention. Thefaint but reasonant recitation from the Holy Our'an in the court of Negasus reverberates evento-day. Every African can become a replica of BILAL who once told the Prophet:

"And when virtue is mentioned in our mids, we cite you as an example"

And the Ayah of Our'an, I recited earlier,

“And when they hear what has been revealed to the apostle, you will see their eyes overflowingwith teachers on account of the truth that they recognize” Al-Maedah (5:83)

23 / 45


holds good even today.

Wassalaam.

Notes & References

(1.) Encyclopaedia Britannica1972. Vol. I P.300 (a!so Vol. 21 p.476)

(2) Ibid 1972 Vol. 21 p.476

(3) Dr. Jan Knappert's article "AL-HUSAIN IBN ALl IN THE EPIC TRADITION OF THESWAHILI"

published among the selected articles in "ALSERAT" (1975-83) by the Muhammadi Trust ofGreat Britain and Northern Ireland, London. It discusses Hemedi b. Abdallah al-BUHRY'SUTENZI wa Sayyidna HUSENI bin ALl, (edited and translated by J.W. T. Allen) Dar es Salaam,1965. Relying upon the information on names and dates given by Mr. J.W. T. Allen, Dr.Knappert says:

"The poet of the Swahili epic about al-Husain's tragic death was called Hemedi (the Swahili formof Ahmad) bin Abdallah al-BUHRY whose family settled in Tanga in the 1820s … Some of theseepics were in fact actually composed by his grandfather, Sai'd b. Abdallah who died c.1875. Theal-Buhry family is known throughout Tanzania for their scholarship and saintly lives."

24 / 45


Quoting from the epic, which seems to be a different composition from the one referred to as'HUSENI', Dr. Knappert provides examples of the Swahili Utenzi.

Describing the lax morals of Ibn Ziyad, the poet says:- "Mwenye mke si mkewe mwenye mwanasi mwanawe ni kama kuku na mwewe."

(He that has a wife- not his wife, he that has a daughter- not his daughter -it is like the chickenand the kite).

Dr. Knappert explains:

"This is a perfect example of classical Swahili style: compact and expressive. The poet meansthat anyone in the city who has a beautiful wife and daughter is in danger of seeing her rapedby the tyrant, who will behave just as the kite behaves with the chicken. The kite is a commonimage in Swahili for the adulterer, the rapist; the chicken is the metaphor for a virtuous woman,full of fear of being attacked."

On Muslim b. Aqeel when he was deserted by the people of Kufa:

"Akatizama yamini asimuone awini

akiola shimalini asione nusurani. "

25 / 45


(When he looked South he saw no helper;

when he looked North he saw no rescue).

Imam Husein (A.S.) bidding farewell to the ladies of the family:

"Kamkalia Farasi Kinga umeme wa Kusi,

na wingu kubwa jeusi , lenye kiza na baridi. "

(He sat on his horse, like the lightning that accompanies the South wind

with a big black cloud, dark and cool) .

"Akasimama Huseni Kawaaga nisiwani

kwa herini, kwa herini, nenda zangu sitarudi. "

(Husein stopped and said goodbye to the women

“Adieu, adieu, I go and shall not return)

26 / 45


"Wakalia na majini na nyama wote yakini

wa bara na baharini hata ndege na asadi. "

(Even the jinn cried and all the animals indeed,

of the land and (the fish) of the sea, even the birds and the lions).

(4) Islam in Uganda by Arye Oded. Printed by Israel Universities Press, Jerusalem, 1974. (Page232).

(5) Encyclopaedia Britannica 1972 Vol. I p. 301.

(6) Islam in Uganda by Arye Oded.

(7) A footnote from this paper reads as follows:-

" White Noel King was Professor of Religious studies at Makerere University College, Kampala,they (Razavi and King) met at Bukoba in 1963, and collaborated in study throughcorrespondence with yearly meetings at Kampala.

27 / 45


The earlier limit (1840) relates to the commencement of new Indian activity in East Africa withthe settling of Sultan Seyyid Said at Zanzibar. The authors gratefully acknowledge assistance ingathering material from Ahmad Jetha and Mohsin M.R. Alidina."

(8) After describing further inroads of the Community into the interiors of Tanganyika andUganda Maulana Razavi adds the following at the footnote:-

"The topographical details given are mainly based on visits to many of the places mentionedand the Ithna-Asheri Trade Directory (in Gujarati) (Arusha and Dar es Salaam: Shia Ithna-Asheri Supreme Council, 1960)".

(9) Some Iranian individuals ventured into Uganda from as early as the dawn of this century.The Directory and History published by the Federation of Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheri Jamaats ofAfrica (1960) gives this interesting account as narrated by Marhum Laljibhai Rawji of MBALE:

"in those days (i.e. 1922) there was an Iranian gentleman named Muhammed Baqir living here.He was a good hunter, and he traded in ivory and other produce. He built two rooms annexed tohis house, where majlises were held regularly. He died in 1925.

Mr. Muhammed Baqir Irani was truly a religious person, and had infused profound religiousfervour into our brothers. He was also a great social worker. In 1919, during the famousepidemic of Influenza, people were very much frightened. But Muhammed Baqir continued toserve bravely, and distributed free medicines to all."

(Directory and History referred to earlier -p.75)

28 / 45


Another reference to the presence of an Irani in Uganda is found in the article by Maulana SyedSaeed Akhtar Razavi published in the 'LIGHT' magazine, (BILAL MUSLIM MISSION,TANZANIA) Vol. VII Nos. 5-6 1973, under the title: " A Chapter Closed - Shia Ithna-Asheriya otUganda." He says:-

"In those early days (the year 1900) there came (to Kampala) an Irani Mirza Asadullah Khanwhose name was still remembered by the Community for his valuable social services and goodnature. He started a transport business using ox carts in partnership with an African chief. Hewas very popular among African and married a Muganda lady with all due tribal ceremonies."

(10) Various waqfs and endowments by the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris of East Africa reveal theirprime concern about perpetuation of their faith. They also show that enough importance wasattached to the secular needs of the Community. Many Trusts and Awqaf were made possibleby general gifts and donation received from the members. In certain cases, the Trusts andendowments have been given the names in memory of those who gave a generous measure oftheir wealth. The Alibhai Panju Jaffery Primary School in Mombasa, Kenya, is an example.

Here I give the names of those benefactors who gave away their wealth in the name of Allah, atthe time when the Shia settlement in East Africa had just begun.

(i) Dewjibhai Jamal. The tracts of land given away as WAQF for Mosques, Imambadas andQabrastan (Mombasa, Nairobi, Lamu) and some investment properties for related Trusts bearthe name of Dewjibhai Jamal, and his illustrious sons, Sheriff Dewji, Jaffer Dewji, NazeraliDewji, Nasser Dewji and others. In fact, there is hardly a name among his descendents who hasnot made a minor or major contribution to one or the other religious cause. This can rightly becalled a family of benefactors.

Their contributions can be seen in India as well. In East Africa, they also attended to thereligious needs of the Community in Zanzibar, and in what is today Tanzania.

29 / 45


.

(ii) Satchu Peera: A great benefactor of Dar es Salaam who tried his best to secure a piece .ofland for the Mosques arid then personally supervised its construction. He gave away his land forthe Qabrastan.

(iii) Jaffer Khimji: He was one of the donors of the plots for Mosque and Imambada in Tanga.The others were his brother Haji Abdulla Khimji and Haji Nasser Virji. Jaffer Khimji built theMosque in Tanga in 1925. He had a famous MEHMAN KHANA (guest house) where visitorscould come at any time for respite. It was a common sight to witness several guests at hisdinner table, most of whom were not even acquainted with him.

(iv) Ladhabhai Meghji: He gave his plot for the Mosque in MWANZA.

(v) Datu Hemani: He left enough money for a Girls' school in Zanzibar. It was known as DatuHemani KANYA SHARA.

(vi) Nasser Nurmohamed: He left a legacy to be utilized for a charitable Dispensary in Zanzibar.

(vii) Haji Mohamed Jaffer of Lindi: whose name is foremost among the great philanthropists ofKhoja Shia Ithna-Asheri Community. The great Boarding House for students, built in Dar esSalaam, stands as a monument to his generosity.

(viii) Haji Jeevrajbhai Meghji: whose outstanding religious charities stand till today in Mombasa

30 / 45


and Lamu. Together with Haji Jeevrajbhai Khatau and Haji Dharamsibhai Khatau, they settledsubstantial endowments for Mosques, Imambadas and Qabrastans.

(ix) Haji Abdulla Kanji and Fazal Ladak Sivji waqfed a Musafirkhana in Mombasa.

(x) Khimji Bhanji: who gave the first Imambada to Kampala Jamaat. In the interiors of Uganda,names like Kassam Mohamed (Hoima), Ahmad Bhimji (Fort Portal), G.R. Hansraj (Soroti),Allarakhya Kassam, Jamal Ramji, Karabhai Valli (Kampala), Haji Gulamhusein Ladha andHasanali Salemohamed (Kaberamaedo), Haji Merali, H.K. Jaffer and Suleman Esmail (Jinja)and many others rank among the selfless and dedicated benefactors.

This list is not in anyway exhaustive. Many great names can be added to it. However, this issufficient to give a fair idea of how the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris of East Africa adhered to theirfaith and practice, how they sacrificed for upholding what they believed in and how they walkedacross the borders into the remotest part of the Continent as torch bearers of their religion andculture.

.

(11) Haji Karim Alarakhya, a senior member of Khoja Shia IthnaAsheri Community in Zanzibar,in his statement to the editor of the 'Trade Directory and History of Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris inEast Africa and Congo' gave an interesting account of one such incident which took placeduring the Arab Sultanate in Zanzibar. He said:

"In the days of Seyyid Majid, the Sultan of Zanzibar, the Customs Authority was controlled byJeraj Shivji and Tharia Topan. After his death, Syed Barghash ascended the throne. Syed8arghash sent for Lakhabhai Kanji and asked him to take over the management of Customs,but Lakhabhai politely declined. The Sultan insisted, but Lakhabhai remained adamant. Thenthe ruler asked him to recommend someone reliable and experienced who would accept theresponsibilities. Lakhabhai recommended Haji Nasser Lilani, who was then entrusted with the

31 / 45


management of both the Zanzibar Customs, and other Government services. When SyedBarghash died, Haji Nasser Lilani himself organized the Coronation ceremony of the Sultan'sbrother, Syed Khalid"

(See Federation Directory or History - page 187)

(12) 'Salsabil' (Memorial issue for Hami-e-lslam, Marhum Gulamhusein MohamedVali Dharsi).Issue 3-4 {of the 19th year of publication) Zilqad, Zilhaj, 1380, April-May, 1961).

The late Mulla Husein A Rahim then first class Magistrate, High Court Zanzibar) in his glowingtribute to Marhum Gulamhusein M.V. Dharsi said

"If religious propensities, deep love for Ahlul Bayt, propagation of the teaching of Imam Husain{A.S.) coupled with humility, generosity, fear of God, profound religious knowledge andwhole-hearted adoption of its principles can bestow any greatness on a man, then one mustacknowledge that Gulamhuseinbhai was a great Shiah of this era." Gulamhuseinbhai died on11th March 1961 {23rd Ramadhan 1380 Hijri) at Zanzibar.

(14) 'Salsabil' (Conference Issue) February 1946 (Rabi-ul-AwwaI 1365). Furtheracknowledgement of Marhum Abdulhusein Sachedina (AZAD) as the first visionary of a unitedand central organization can be found in the Trade Directory and History of the Khoja ShiaIthna-Asheris in East Africa and the Congo, published by the Federation of Khoja ShiaIthna-Asheri Jamaats of Africa in 1960.

In a separate article under the title "Federation na Sacha Pita" (The true patriarch of Federation)

32 / 45


the editors write

"When the Community lay scattered and disunited, with grudges being nursed in practicallyevery bosom, this young mind passionately and articulately spoke of the 'Conference'. He gavey this dream to the Community and left no stone unturned to see that the dream was realized.His name will ever remain glitteringly m engraved on the pages of the history of the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheris in East Africa.

"This famous pen and lucid mind went into oblivion while still on the ascendant. Before the worldcould truly recognise and acknowledge his worth, 'AZAD' was gone while still in the prime of hislife The impact and effect of his thoughts will remain forever .

"It is difficult for one to forget this composed, reticent but brilliant personality. O 'Azad', like'ASEER ' of India, you are a source of perennial inspiration for this Community. Our MyriadSalutations!"

(Page 166. Trade Directory and History of the Community published by the Federation of K.S.I.Jamaats of Africa, ARUSHA 30th December 1960).

(13) The institution of MAJLIS of Imam Husain (A.S.) created several Zakirs. These wereordinarily known as the Mullas. In earlier days, these Mullas read from the books speciallycompiled for the MAJLIS. Some of them had the ability of preparing their own discourses byselecting passages from various reliable sources. Here again, .the books of MAJALIS publishedby Marhum Allama Haji Gulamali Haji Esmail of Bhavnagar, India, had proved of considerableassistance. In Uganda, for example, his regular monthly “Rahe Najat” provided enough materialto a Mulla for preparing an occasional sermon.

Among these Mullas, there were some who knew Urdu. For them, magazines like "AL BURHAN

33 / 45


" from Ludhiana, Punjab, India, was a rich source of reference. And then there were Mullas whoknew Persian as well. In Zanzibar, because of a steady but constant contact with IRANISADAAT and the Ulema from IRAQ, Mullas were able to read and speak Persian withconsiderable ease. In fact, there was a group of men who, despite not being Mullas themselves,knew this language extremely well. Persian helped the Mullas to delve deeper into the originalworks of our great Ulema .

Here, I give names of few Mullas whose contribution cannot be ignored. Again, it must beobserved that this list iS in no way a complete one. An exhaustive research is indeed necessaryfor preparing a full list of the Mullas who rendered the sacred services, most of the time onvoluntary and honorary basis.

1. Mulla Abdulrasul Dewji. He lived in Zanzibar, and later on migrated to Mombasa where hedied at an advanced age in 1976. A man of profound erudition, he can be singled out as a Mullawho, beside his knowledge of Urdu and Persian, studied Arabic language as well. His Majliseswere highly successful. People hastened to hear his erudite discourses which he wrote himself .His principle subjects were Islamic History, Tafsir of Qur'an, Irfan and Fadhail of Ahlul Bayt(peace be upon them all). A voracious reader, he had numerous original books in his personallibrary. Mulla Saheb was also extremely helpful to the budding Zakirs. His written tracts are inthe hands of many new Mullas who use them till today. In late fifties, Mulla Abdulrasul Dewjibegan oral Majlises. In these later years, despite his infirm state of health, he travelled toNairobi, and Jinja (Uganda) during the first ten days of Muharram to give the benefit of hisorations.

2. Mulla Kassamali Ladha. He lived in Mombasa. In an effort to reach the members of theCommunity, he decided to give discourses in Cutchi language. No doubt, this was a correctdecision he had taken, for people flocked to hear him whenever he went on Mimber. Ladies andchildren enjoyed his preachings better because they could understand him thoroughly. Hespoke their own language. And Mulla Saheb took the maximum advantage of this languagethrough which he had become so lovingly accessible. He chose community welfare, reform andstrong bond of fraternity as his principle themes of MAJLISES. His conversational and modeststyle of rendering is still being remembered.

3. Mulla Moledina Jaffer. He delivered his sermons in Cutchi , and travelled far and wide to

34 / 45


remote Jamaats during Muharram. He also authored a handbook for Zakirs, known as "NASIRUZZAKIREEN" (The Helper of Zakirs). This book is in Urdu, using the Gujarati script. Perhaps hechose to do this because Urdu was the commonly adopted medium in MAJALIS. He lived inTanga.

4. Mulla Ahmad A. Lakha Kanji. A great orator of the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheri Community, wellknown for his lucidity, and masterful style of delivery. He is, in fact, a linguist. Apart from Englishand Gujarati, Mulla Saheb speaks Urdu and Persian with great ease and facility. He is amongthe best Zakirs. The contents of his MAJAliS have always emphasized the moral values inhuman life, Fadhail of Ahlul Bayt (peace be upon them) and social reform. He travelled far andwide, sometimes upto Madagascar, to give the benefit of his useful sermons. A man ofimpeccable manners and modest disposition, Mulla Ahmad lakha evokes affection andreverence together at the very first contact. As I write, he is in the decline of his life, ailingbecause of infirmities brought about by the advanced age. So is the divine design for everymortal. May Allah keep him.

5. Mulla Husein A. Rahim. He read his Urdu discourses prepared and written by himself. In spiteof his multifarious social and professional duties, he always found time to serve the cause ofIslam and Imam Husein (peace be upon him). Mulla Saheb was also a prolific writer. Severaltracts, essays and commentaries of DUAS, written in English, exist to his credit. Principalamong these is the commentary and apt translation of DUA-E-KUMAIL. He used to be invitedby various Jamaats for delivering speeches on the occasion of Husein Day. Because of hismodern approach to religious topics, especially when he made a comparative study of variousideologies and Islam, Mulla Saheb was extremely popular as a Zakir. He died in London at anadvanced age. He is remembered as a Zakir of great repute, and also as a great social workerwho served the Community in various capacities for years on end.

6. Mulla Mohamed Mulla Jaffer. Born in Zanzibar, he migrated to Mombasa after his brief stay inLucknow, India. He was a preacher and a teacher as well. In fact, in the latter field, he remainsa Mulla of unsurpassed excellence. like his father Mulla Jaffer, he taught FIQH and Urdulanguage. An appreciable section of the Community in Mombasa, most of them in their middleages, would remember Mulla Mohamed as a beloved religious tutor. He spoke Urdu andPersian with considerable fluency. In his earlier days, he read from the books when on Mimber.later, he developed his singular style for orations. He will a1so be remembered as the one whopromoted AZADARI of Imam Husein (peace be upon him) among the youths who had steadily'begun to show signs of indifference. He died in Mombasa at the age of 52, in 1960.

35 / 45


As mentioned earlier, an extensive research is necessary for treatinng the subject justifiably.Names like Mulla Nanji Bhanji, Mulla Faateh Ali, Mulla Jaffer Pardhan, Mulla Ali MohamedNanji, Mulla Mohamedjaffer Nazerali, Mulla Rashid Nurmohamed, Mulla Gulamhusein A.D.Musa, Mulla Ali Khaku Rajpar, Mulla Hasanali Rashid Kermalf, Mulla H.M. Rashid, Mulla H.M.Nasser, Mulla Gulamlhusein Kanji, Mulla Abdulrasul Hassanali G. Khaki and many others willever remain glittering in the history of Khoja Shia Ithhna-Asheri Community. I hope to carry outthis exercise at a later date, compiling a full list of the Mullas, giving detailed accounts of theircontributions which form an inalienable part of Khoja Shia history in East Africa.

(15) The following excerpt from Mr. U Maung Maung Ta's speech is sugges1tive:

"This Conference is being held at a time when sad accounts of our Ulama is emerging daily, atthe hands of an adamant despot I am aware that the events I am referring to have not beengiven the publicity it deserves -Silence maintained by the news media is amazing. I wish toquote an extract from a circular issued recently by the World Federation of Khoja ShiaIthna-Asheria Muslim Communities in London. I quote:

'There comes in peoples' lives when we can no longer sit on the fence or in a corner. This is thetime of action so that we may be successful in stopping the spilling of the blood of Aal-e-Rasool.A concerted effort is required by each one of us.’

The World Federation has done a commendable job during this crisis. As a matter of fact, wewere in the dark and we would not have known about the persecution of our Ulama had it notbeen for one such circular of the World Khojas."

36 / 45


(U Maung Maung Ta, President, The All Burma Shia Muslim Organization, Rangoon - at theInaugural Conference of World Ahlul Bayt (A.S.) League held in London on 5th August, 1983.He was referring to the persecution of El-Hakim family in Iraq, and the execution of six amongthem.)

(16) The World Ahlul Bayt (A.S.) League convened its first conference in London from 5th to 7thAugust 1983. Among the participants were renowned Shia scholars from nearly every country;prominent among them were the following:

Syed Mahdi El-Hakim, son of Ayatullah Syed Muhsin El-Hakim Taba Sarah.

Syed Muhammad Bahrul Uloom, a scholar of high repute, an author of several tracts of highlearning.

Syed Muhammad Husain Fadhlullah, the great advocate of Islamic unity in Lebanon.

Shaikh Muhammad Mahdi Shamsuddeen, the second in command of Shia affairs in Lebanonafter Imam Musa Sadr. His masterly works on various religious topics are read throughout theArabic speaking world.

Syed Jawad Gulpaygani, son of the great Mujtahed of our times, Ayatullah Syed MohammadRedha Gulpaygani. ,

Syed Saeed Akhtar Razavi, whose contributions have been adequately discussed in this book.

37 / 45


Syed Muhammad El-Musavi, the Wakil of Ayatullah El-Khui in India. He is a devoted Aalim,renowned for his learning and piety.

Dr. Saeed Rajai, Ambassador of Islamic Republic of Iran to the United Nations.

Ayatullah Sheikh Jawad Al-Ameli, representing Islamic Republic of Iran. A man of greaterudition and piety.

Syed Safdar Husein, Principal of Jameul Muntazar, Lahore, Pakistan.

Syed Hameedul Hasan, Principal of Nazmia Arabic College, Lucknow. He is the grandson ofAqa-e-Najmul Millat Syed Najmul Hasan Saheb, Taba Sarah.

Hujjatul Islam Sheikh Muhammad Ali Taskheeri from Qum, Iran.

Abyssinia 2

Africa 2

Afro Shirazi 5

38 / 45


Agha Khan 11

Ahmad b. Ebrahim 4

Allama Haji G,ulamali 9, 34

Al-Falaq 4

America, North 22

Ansari, Khwaja Muhammad Latif 25

Arabia 2

Arusha 25

Arye Oded 4

Azad, Abdulhusein Sachedina 16

Baganda 4

39 / 45


Bantu 4

Bilal 24

Burujardi, Syed Husein 23

Chief Missionary 26

Christian 4, 5 ,.

Cutch 7

Dar es Salaam 17

Dharsi, Gulamhusein M.V. 9, 10, 23

Dichotomy 14

Ebrahim H. Sheriff 18

Epic 5, 28

40 / 45


Fazlullah, Syed Muhammad Husein 26

Federation 16

Gujarat Federation 22

Hadramut 8

Hakim, Syed Muhsin 19, 23

Hami-e-IslaIm 10, 33

Hasan, Syed Aqa 10

Husein, Imam 5, 29

Ibn Khaldun 3

ImameZaman 10

Isfehani, Syed Abul Hasan 12

41 / 45


Jamal, Dewjibhai 11, 31

Jones, D.P. 5

Kathiawad 7

Khoja 6

Khlui, Syed Abul Qasim 19, 23, 26

Kilwa 4, 5 ,

Lakha, G.N. 17

'Light', The 25, 31

Madrasatul Waezeen 12

M,eghji, Mohamedali 18

Mohamedjaffer Sheriff Dewji 9, 10

42 / 45


Munadee 16

Nazmia Arabic College 12

Negasus 3, 27

Niruz 5

Nurmohamed, A.H. 17

Periplus 2

Persian 5, 10, 34

Qadir Husein, Mulla 11

Qummi, Sh. Abbas 9

Rahim, Husein A. 24, 33, 36

Razavi, Syed Saeed Akhtar 1, 7, 14, 26

43 / 45


Sauti ya Bilal 25

Sayyid Said B. Sultan 6

Shushtari, Syed Husein 7, 12

Sultanul Madaris 12

Swahili 4, 5, 28

Tanzania 14. 28, 31

Ten Commandments 4

Uganda 4

Virjee, Abdulrasul Nasser 18

Wangwana 5

44 / 45


World Federation 21, 22. 23. 37

Zanzibar 4. 6. 7. 8, 31.32

45 / 45

A History of the Khoja Community

Documents

Transcript of A History of the Khoja Community