90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared...

112
1 NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected] 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative Political Science – Paper 2 Question and Model Answers from Subject Experts

Transcript of 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared...

Page 1: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

1

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing

Initiative

Political Science – Paper 2

Question and Model Answers from Subject Experts

Page 2: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

2

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

11-Dec-2017 – Question 1

Explain the Political-Sociological Approach in the field of comparative politics

and discuss its limitations.(2017)

Model Answer

The branch of learning which examines political institutions, processes, and

ideologies in the light of corresponding social structures, processes, and modes of

thought is called political sociology. It examines the impact of political domination

and decisions on social life. It emerged as an approach but later got developed as

a discipline itself.

The complex societies include within their domain, almost every aspect of human

behavior. Thus, the approach wanted to incorporate not only political behavior

but also analysis of bureaucratic structure for the study of institutions like political

parties, trade unions, and even economic institutions. The practice of politics

involves taking public decisions and ipso facto must take into account various

social motivations of involved stakeholders. The study of politics extends beyond

formal procedures and institutions in the contemporary era so incorporation of

sociology into political inquiry becomes essential.

The roots of the approach can be traced back to Aristotle and Machiavelli where

their work on the theory of revolution and type of government depending on the

nature of people in society respectively hints at the combination of political

science and sociology. However, Marx and Weber gave solid foundations to this

perspective. They turned to political analysis as a part of their social inquiry. Later

on, their thesis became the foundation pillar for two different schools of thought

Page 3: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

3

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

in political sociology. The debates and disagreements between these two schools

have enriched the political sociology approach and helped it emerge as a

discipline in itself. While the focus of Marx was to study basic structure of society

and class relations, Weber delved into concepts like authority, legitimacy, ideal

type etc.

Political sociology sought to achieve a synthesis between normative analysis and

research. It focuses on the intersection between politics and society, for example,

political organization, political culture, political participation, political ideologies,

political consensus, and cleavage etc. They use mathematical and statistical

models, field questionnaires to provide data collection and also provide analytical

insights. Prominent work done in the field of political sociology includes Caste as

Politics in India by Rajni Kothari, Role of Caste in Tamilnadu by Andre Baitelle etc.

The main inhibition of this approach was, losing the identity of political science as

a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was

to be the case, political science would become a sub-discipline under sociology. It

was also thought that this approach is not suitable for post-colonial societies

where the state is still very powerful and shapes society to a significant extent.

Theda Skacpol, thus, called for ‘bringing the state back in’. Also, the social

stratification view of politics has been described as a form of sociological

reductionism that has inherent limitations because of the institutional and

cultural factors which are excluded. However, from the very nature of the

discipline, no approach can be a panacea and can provide only a perspective to

deal with various concepts. The political sociology approach provides vital insights

in that context.

Page 4: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

4

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

11-Dec-2017 – Question 2

Do interest groups help to promote democracy or to undermine it? Give your

opinion.(2016)

Model Answer

Interests groups are the association of people formed to articulate their interests.

It performs the role of interest articulation of their members. They are generally a

monolith entity having similar interests and their underlying objective is the

welfare of their constituents. It is seen where ideological differences among

political parties are less significant, interest groups tend to be more active. For

example, United States of America.

The Indian polity has a historical legacy of interest groups and they emerged as a

result of our fight for independence. The earlier Congress party, when

representing the interest of the elites, was demanding more representation of

Indians within the larger framework of British Raj. After independence, the state,

being very powerful and overarching, saw the bureaucratic associations as

institutionalized and strong interest groups.

Interest groups hold a lot of power without any direct accountability, so they are

considered to undermine democracy. The interest groups which don’t have the

national interest in mind, lobbies for policies and decisions which are not in the

larger interest of our country and undermine the representative democratic

nature, by incorporating undemocratic elements in decision making.

Page 5: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

5

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Corporate class has started playing important role in policymaking. Now they are

part of the official Indian delegation to foreign countries. India has been called

deformed polyarchy because of the relatively stronger influence of corporate

interest groups.The threat of an elite takeover of democracy is evident in this

case, undermining the democratic nature of our polity. Recently, the Indian

capitalist class was seen directly participating in the electoral process with

election and representation in Rajyasabha, giving this phenomenon an interesting

turn.

However, there are scholars who believe that interest groups, in turn,

strengthens democracy. Rajni Kothari notes that interest group in India are

different from their western counterparts as it has multigroup character. In this

sense, they mobilize a section of society which is legitimate for any democratic

structure. According to Robert Hardgrave, they increase the political

consciousness and act as an agent of modernization. Anand Chakravarti,

therefore, wants greater accommodation of interest groups so that conflictual

situations can be avoided and political stability can be strengthened.

Indian polity doesn’t recognize lobbying as legitimate means of getting across

one’s interest, putting the entire feedback mechanism of a section of society as

illegitimate. The legislative representatives can’t incorporate many vital inputs

due to a vast constituency of their representation and the structural defects of

FPTP. In this case, interest groups can strengthen democracy too.

Thus, Indian polity has always been a false binary, where association with one

group is portrayed as their being against another one, even when both don’t

Page 6: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

6

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

necessarily have mutually antagonistic relations. There is a need to synthesize this

thought process, while strongly taking a stand against conflict of interest and

nexus, we can devise mechanism and institutions whereby each interest group

can represent their interests in a legitimate way. For example, FICCI.

Page 7: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

7

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

13-Dec-2017 – Question 1

Comment on the decline of political parties and examine whether new social

movements shall be alternative strategy for establishing link between

government and society.(2016)

Model Answer

The great motors of the modern party system—class and ideology—have ceased

to function in the way they once did. The result is a problem of party funding, as

big donors displace mass memberships; but even more crucially a problem of

representation, as party politicians increasingly become a political class without a

popular base. This has resulted into a decline of political parties.

The phenomenon has worldwide resonance. The decline in political party

membership in the UK is a recipe for a crisis of legitimacy. The parties continue as

the monopolists of access to political careers and to political office, but in a

context in which 99 percent of citizens now do not belong to a political party.

Parties can re-invent themselves and open up, or we need to recognize that the

age of the mass party is simply over and that new structures of representation

and participation have to be embraced instead.

It is perfectly possible for parties to continue to structure political life and offer

accountable political choice without also being the monopolists of political power.

In America, the “50-50” nation is more like a 30-30-30 nation, a Pew survey

recently found that “independents” at 37% outnumbered either Democrats or

Republicans.

Page 8: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

8

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

In the Indian context, Yogendra Yadav has commented on the decline of political

parties in terms of the decline of dedicated cadre and erosion of loyalty.

According to him, parties which boost high number of members are not realizing

that their base is essentially eroding. Political parties are, therefore, suffering

from the crisis of legitimacy. They are not able to challenge popular issues in a

systematic way, so the trust of people is decreasing in them.

Rajni Kothari gives the period of the 1970s as defining decade of Indian polity.

According to him, political parties have given up their ‘movement’ type of

activities and became content with only being electioneering machine, working

on grassroot level every five years, to get votes. The recent formation of Aam

Aadmi Party tried to change that concept through dedicated grassroots

volunteers, it also became a casualty to the underlying structure of Indian party

system.

New Social Movements on the other hands are acquiring legitimacy as a popular

vehicle of protest. The wide-ranging issues from environmentalism, human rights,

disarmament etc and powered with middle and upper-middle class ethics, it is

giving voice to different sections of society. The spectacular success of India

against corruption movement, the recent ‘Muk morcha’ of Maharashtra farmers

etc are symbols of new ways and arena of mobilization.

Social movements used to be on disparate issues where marginalized and

excluded population were at the centre of the activity. The micro movements

expanded the arena of politics much beyond representational institutions of

elections. The new social movement saw the coalition of this localized

Page 9: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

9

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

movements to create a global alliance against the certain minimum agreed

programme. This alliance is against nation-states on the issue of globalization. The

long aim of the social movement is democratizing development and transforming

society. The lack of credible opposition also helped some addressal of grievances

through social movements.

However, political parties have certain systemic characteristics, which makes

them irreplaceable even when the contours of the concepts of democracy and

representations are changing.

Page 10: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

10

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

13-Dec-2017 – Question 2

Critically examine the Marxist aspect of political economy approach to the study

of Comparative Poliics.(2016)

Model Answer

Political economy stands for study and practice of the management of the

government and the nation. It deals with political aspects of economic policy-

making so that a social policy should prove not only economically efficient but

also politically acceptable. A closer analysis reveals that most of the economic

decisions are influenced by non-economic factors like cultural values, personality,

political needs and consideration of status. This approach aims to combine

disciplines for a holistic understanding of any concept. Political economy

combines mathematical techniques with normative theories to have a better

understanding of poverty, inequality, underdevelopment and suggesting

measures to improve these situations.

A Marxist aspect of the political economy is a critic of the liberal political

economy. Adam Smith, known as the father of modern-day political economy,

gave the theory of the wealth of nations. The laissez-faire doctrine showed that

the unrestrained economic system can lead to socially disastrous consequences.

Politics cannot deliver goods until it is able to tackle the economic problem

effectively. Therefore, according to Marx, all politics is shaped by economic

forces. He criticized Smith and said that his policies will not result in ‘wealth of

nation’ but ‘wealth of few at the cost of many’. The Marxist aspect was later

developed into two schools, namely, dependency school and structural school.

Page 11: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

11

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Immanuel Wallerstein in his work ‘World system theory’ held that the world

works like a system where there are ‘core countries’ which are in the center,

‘peripheries’ which are on the outside, and ‘semi-peripheries’ which are in

between the two. The liberal political economy doesn’t result in the

empowerment of peripheries, but the ‘development of underdevelopment’ in the

peripheries. The relative inequality and wealth of peripheries increase and the

core countries get wealth at the cost of peripheries. There is a development of

‘dependency’ by which peripheries become a supplier of raw materials and

consumer of manufactured goods. The semi-peripheries are the face of this

system whereby they were given access to outdated technologies and work as a

source of cheap labor. Semi-peripheries are projected as beneficiaries of the

world system to provide legitimacy to the policies of the core countries.

Hamza Alavi in his seminal work ‘The State in Post-Colonial Societies: Pakistan and

Bangladesh’, gives the ‘theory of overdeveloped state’. He states that in the

western countries the growth of capitalism and democracy has been

simultaneous and organic. The nation-states of South Asia, on the other hand,

saw independent democratic states where the capitalism was still in its infancy.

The state took reins of the economy and established itself at the commanding

heights of the economy. The state is a power center and defining institution

which directed the growth of the nation. In the west, where the state is said to be

the instrument in the hands of the capitalist, the same can’t be said for post-

colonial nations. Here, the state is ‘overdeveloped’ compared to other

institutions, and thus, relatively autonomous.

Page 12: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

12

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

However, there are limitations of this approach like its narrow focus, ideological

orientations, neglect of institutions etc. It is helpful, none the less, to study

relations between mode of production and various historical social formations.

Page 13: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

13

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

15-Dec-2017 – Question 1

Party system in India is neither western nor indigenous. Explain.(2014)

Model Answer

Party system in India displays numerical paradoxical features, which reveal the

western and traditional institutions. Indian National Congress, even after being

the grand old party of India couldn’t institutionalize the party system that could

be fitted in the west. The influence of Congress due to historical legacy and

legitimacy was so great to allow it to dominate the national party discourse much

of the independent history. Many of India’s several parties have overshadowed all

others by having dominated the political scene ever since independence.

That is why the observers of Indian politics like Morris Jones described the Indian

Party system as a system of “one-party dominance” While Rajni Kothari went to

the extent of calling “One Party Dominance System” or “The Congress System”.

The success of strong Marxist and communist trend in Europe and later in Asia

was not replicated in India. While there were considerable awareness and debate

around socialist ideas, the vigor was never great enough to overthrow the state.

Communism in the Indian context, therefore, is not very successful and has been

mostly an academic discipline. Communism has not threatened the stability of the

Indian state or the physical extinction of nation-state like Indonesia. Instead, it

was amalgamated as a part of the reformist parliamentary system of India.

While the FPTP system, has produced a two-party system in most of the liberal

democracies, India has been an exception to that law. The diversities and social

Page 14: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

14

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

fragmentation of Indian polity on the basis of statewise regional parties in the

larger framework of imperfect ‘national party system is unique. Some

characteristic features like factionalism, dynastic succession, and the presence of

ideological differences without ideological cleavages are seen in almost all

national parties of India.

The Indian democracy was introduced as a gamble and it has paid off. While the

contemporary independent nations have seen coup, authoritarianism plagued

their democratic process, India is largely untouched by it barring a brief period of

emergency. The paradoxical feature of high voter turnout even with low literacy

rates since independence has baffled many western commentators who have

traditionally associated democracy with educational awareness. We have

introduced the special representation for Scheduled Caste, as a measure of

affirmative action, before many western countries could do it. We adopted

universal adult franchise and voting rights to women before western democracies

like Sweden.

Western countries like USA where the parties aggregate multiple private

interests, the Indian context has substantial differences. Apart from the formal

representation which is few and far in between, the informal movements, caste-

based association, and mobilization, revivalist movements etc also hold

substantial weight. In recent years, the proliferation of non-party movements is

rising, mostly representative, often violent gave it a unique character.

The tension between authoritarian and centralizing tendencies and decentralizing

tendencies are evident in the party and associational sectors Indian political life.

Page 15: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

15

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

The traditional features like personality cult are also present wherein Indian

politics has produced many charismatic leaders. Many of the above features,

however, are visible in the post-colonial societies and therefore not strictly

indigenous.

Page 16: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

16

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

15-Dec-2017 – Question 2

Which are the major approaches to comparative politics? Explain in brief, the

political economy approach to the study of comparative enquiry.(2015)

Model Answer

Comparative politics is the study of the domestic politics, political institutions, and

conflicts of countries. It is not defined by the object of its study, but rather by the

method it applies to study political phenomena. Aristotle is known as the father

of comparative politics.He has studied more than 160 constitutions to give his

‘Theory of Revolutions’ and classification of government. Earlier it was sufficient

to study constitutions because social, economic, cultural variable do not give any

contrasting features in western societies. However, in spite of parliamentary

system in both, United Kingdom and India, the socio-cultural variable cannot be

overlooked. We can, therefore, divide the evolution of comparative politics into

two phases.

1. Until Second World War (Traditional Approach): Study of European or

western countries.

Philosophical Approach: It is the oldest approach where the objective is to

understand the philosophy behind the observed reality. Plato is known as

the father of political philosophy. The approach is based on Plato’s theory

of ideas, thus focuses on ‘what ought to be’ rather than ‘what is’. The

objective is not only to understand reality but also transform it.

Page 17: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

17

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Historical Approach: It means an understanding of political ideas,

institutions, dynamics in the context of the situations which give rise to

them. Historical ideas have their origin in crisis phase of history. It is also

said that history is past politics and politics is present history. It is a simple

and widely used approach but suffers from chances of historicism.

Legal/Constitutional Approach: Politics was primarily studied as the study

of constitutional provisions. However, this has lost relevance with the

emergence of the 3rd world. Now there is a consensus that law is text and

politics is context.

Institutional Approach: It is closely related to legal/constitutional approach

but we go beyond to understand the emergence of political institutions.

1. Since the end of Cold War (Contemporary Approach): Research shifted to

the political system of non-western countries.

Systems Approach: Based on a system which is a set of elements in a state

of interaction. It was developed by David Easton in his search for a scientific

model of inquiry. He wrote a book called ‘the political system’ in 1953.

However, it couldn’t explain the institutions and functions within the

system and was criticized as just a conceptual framework with limited

utility.

Structural-Functional Approach: This approach was designed to address

some limitations of the systems approach. Gabriel Almond in his work,

Comparative Politics: A developmental approach, worked upon it. He

incorporated the concept of function, where different systems are designed

to perform certain functions that are universal. It suggested that political

Page 18: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

18

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

systems are evolving and different societies are at different stages of

evolution.

Political Sociology Approach: The branch of learning which examines

political institutions, processes, and ideologies in the light of corresponding

social structures, processes, and modes of thought is called political

sociology. It examines the impact of political domination and decisions on

social life. Political sociology sought to achieve a synthesis between

normative analysis and research. It focuses on the intersection between

politics and society, for example, political organization, political culture,

political participation, political ideologies, political consensus, and cleavage

etc.

Political Economy Approach: Political economy stands for study and

practice of the management of the government and the nation. It deals

with political aspects of economic policy-making so that a social policy

should prove not only economically efficient but also politically acceptable.

A closer analysis reveals that most of the economic decisions are influenced by

non-economic factors like cultural values, personality, political needs and

consideration of status. This approach aims to combine disciplines for a holistic

understanding of any concept. Political economy combines mathematical

techniques with normative theories to have a better understanding of poverty,

inequality, underdevelopment and suggesting measures to improve these

situations.

Adam Smith, known as the father of modern-day political economy, gave the

theory of the wealth of nations. The laissez-faire doctrine showed that the

Page 19: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

19

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

unrestrained economic system can lead to socially disastrous consequences.

Politics cannot deliver goods until it is able to tackle the economic problem

effectively. A Marxist aspect of the political economy, ipso facto emerged as a

critic of the liberal political economy.

However, there are limitations of this approach like its narrow focus, ideological

orientations, neglect of institutions etc. It is helpful, none the less, to study

relations between mode of production and various historical social formations. It

is also helpful to understand issues like demands, cost, allocation of resources,

utility, optimization etc.

Page 20: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

20

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

25-Dec-2017 – Question 1

Discuss the impact of globalization on the internal functioning of the state. 2016

(200)

Model Answer

Globalization is widening, deepening and speeding up of worldwide

interconnectedness. While the predictions of the demise of nation-states and the

sceptics who question the existence of this change, will be futile, a

transformationalist would agree with the changes while accepting the

continuation of old structure to study the impact of globalization on the internal

functioning of the state. It is true that over the last three decades the scale and

scope of globalization have become increasingly evident. The 2008 GFC has

proved that no economy, however, insulate it would be, could claim to be

immune from global change.

Every day over 4 trillion dollars flow across foreign exchange markets, no

government even the most powerful ones can resist the sustained speculation of

its currency. Transnational corporations account for 25-33 percent of world

output, making them key players of the global economy. New modes of

communication have made it easier for like-minded people to mobilize resources

in virtually real-time basis. The Arab spring has shown that the most stringent

structures are all the more vulnerable.

The impact of forces has been such that a terrorist bombing in Bali has policy

repercussions in Europe or USA, while agricultural subsidies in USA have

significant consequences for the livelihood of farmers in Africa, Latin America and

Page 21: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

21

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Asia. Rather than growing interdependence between discrete, bounded nation

states or the internationalization, globalization seeks to capture the dramatic shift

in the organization of human affairs and from the world from the discrete

interdependent nation states to the world as a shared social space.

The once drawn lines of domestic and foreign policy of Westphalian world order is

blurring, the debate is more about economic policy, environmental policy or

security policy. Globalization has in this sense, has identified headers and

removed horizontal distinction of authorities.

Globalization has changed the role of the state in many ways: politically through

interdependence and independence of states, socially through the problems and

threats of terrorism and deadly diseases, technologically through the media and

internet and economically through the change from national to global economies.

The state has moved from a controlling to a protecting role internally in facing the

problems that globalization has caused, but also from an authoritative to a

dependent figure externally between the sovereign state age to current unfailing

interdependence.

Globalization is often seen to have lowered the importance of the state, but in the

end, the states that will remain the most successful in the face of globalization is

those who adapt to the changes their role makes. In the words attributed to

Charles Darwin, ‘It is not the strongest of the species that survives, nor the most

intelligent, but rather the one most responsive to change.

Page 22: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

22

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

25-Dec-2017 – Question 2

Transnational actors have become driving force of global politics. 2013 (200)

Model Answer

Transnational actors are part of civil society and have operations beyond the

boundary of the single nation. Multinational companies, terrorist organizations,

international NGOs are some of the transnational actors. All schools including

Marxist, realist, liberal and communitarians give recognition to transnational

actors in some form or the other.

The 3D chess model given by Joseph Nye gives enormous social and political

power enjoyed by non-sovereign entities. Globalization, the proliferation of

democracy, economic interdependence and technological revolution have

strengthened the capability and reach of these actors. In this era of complex

interdependence, the power of nation-states have been ceded to many of these

organizations and they are important stakeholders in global decision making.

They are at the centre of global cleavages and also part of the solution

framework.

The MNCs have long been criticized as a vehicle of Capitalism by Marxist scholars.

They have wide reach and power. Many of MNCs have a greater turnover than

most of the nation states. They are criticized for their exploitative labour policies,

their interference in domestic politics. In cold war era also, they have been

alleged to have been serving the foreign policy interests of USA. They have said to

have funded private armies and engineered coups in Latin American countries.

Page 23: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

23

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Even today, they are more important than ever in shifting global alliances. In the

aftermath of the Nuclear test by India, MNCs were the instrumental interest

group in a paradigm shift in USA foreign policy towards India. The nature of

influence has been changing since then. Indian and Chinese MNCs are dominating

the oil trade, which takes stand often against the foreign policy interest of USA.

For example, trade with sanctioned countries like Iran, Myanmar etc. The recent

controversies regarding Chinese policies in Africa, the debate and lobbying

around net neutrality have brought their role into focus again in the contours of

world politics.

NGOs, on the other hand, have been emphasised as a prime mover for

development and advocacy by liberals. They have been said to be the vehicle to

diffuse the power on grassroots levels, raise consciousness regarding rights in

general and human rights in particular. They form a close association with MNCs

to achieve their objective. Emerging countries have a distrust of NGOs as they feel

it is western intervention to maintain status quo in power of world politics. They

have often taken positions which goes against the developmental administration

and have face policy reversals. NGOs like Amnesty International with presence

over 162 countries create parallel structures and authorities of power with

respect to nation-state and UN world order. Developing countries have grudges

against NGOs as they became the vehicle to impose conditionalities by World

Bank and other aid by western countries.

Terrorist actors have been at the centre of the debate over the last few years in a

way in which they have altered priorities. They have been at the centre of

attention and reported about extensively. The asymmetric advantage, the

Page 24: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

24

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

element of surprise have forced defence and security analyst to find new ways to

cope up with it. The lack of consensus to deal with them, the use of terrorism as

an instrument of state policy and the ulterior motives in altering the balance of

power with the use of terrorist actors have questioned the rationale or utility of

conventional wisdom. They are considered the biggest threat of 21st century.

The system exists at all levels of world politics and transnational actors are the

manifestations of the same. International organizations form systems would also

imply that global politics can’t be reduced to just ‘inter-state’ relations.

Page 25: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

25

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

27-Dec-2017 – Question 1

Critically access the changing nature of the concept of national security. 2014

(250)

Model Answer

Security is taken to be about the pursuit of freedom from threat and the ability of

states and societies to maintain their independent identity and their functional

integrity against forces of change, which they see as hostile. The bottom line of

security is survival, but it also reasonably includes a substantial range of concerns

about the conditions of existence. Quite where this range of concerns ceases to

merit the urgency of the “security” label (which identifies threats as significant

enough to warrant emergency action and exceptional measures including the use

of force) and becomes part of everyday uncertainties of life is one of the

difficulties of the concept.

The question of security has long since preoccupied the minds of International

Relationists. The traditional concept of security with the state as the main

referent has been up for extensive debate. The realist view of security where it is

seen as a “derivative of power” reduces the complex concept of security to a

mere “synonym for power”. This view could be considered relevant during the

period of the World Wars, where states seemed to be in a constant struggle for

power.

However, in the post-Cold War era, the concept of Security has become much

more multifaceted and complex. In his book, People, States and Fear, Barry Buzan

points out that the concept of security was “too narrowly founded”, his goal was

Page 26: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

26

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

to, therefore, offer a “broader framework of security” incorporating concepts that

were not previously considered to be part of the security puzzle such as regional

security, or the societal and environmental sectors of security. Buzan’s approach

is more holistic; and while he primes his analysis with neorealist beliefs such as

anarchy, the depth of his analysis is constructivist in that he does not accept the

given, but rather explores each element of what he considers to be the security

package one by one in order to arrive at a more informed conclusion.

Buzan’s approach is an interesting one as he looks at security from all angles

going from micro to macro, also addressing the social aspects of security and how

people or societies construct or “securitize” threats. Buzan is somewhat of an

independent thinker and a reformer. This allowed him to broaden the analysis

that existed and give his audience a more complete understanding of the

complexities of security with the ability to then apply these concepts to current

issues, for example, the war on terrorism. This constructivist approach allows to

not only discover Buzan’s reading of security, but also the breakdown of every

aspect that contributes to or affects security, from the individual and society to

the main referent, which, for Buzan is the state.

Along similar lines to that of addressing the levels essential to understanding

security, Buzan also addresses the different sectors of security. In his article “New

Patterns of Global Security in the Twenty-First Century”, Buzan analyses how five

sectors of security (Political, Military, Economic, Societal, and Environmental)

might affect the “periphery” based on changes in the “center”.

Page 27: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

27

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

The ‘national’ security problem turns out to be a systemic security problem in

which individuals, states and the system all play a part, and in which economic,

societal and environmental factors are as important as political and military ones.

From this integrative perspective, the levels and sectors appear more useful as

viewing platforms from which one can observe the problem from different angles,

than as self-contained areas for policy or analysis.

Page 28: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

28

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

27-Dec-2017 – Question 2

Write a note on intellectual precursors of Realism. 2013 (250)

Model Answer

Realism, as its name suggests, claims to be an approach to international relations

theory that captures the real essence of politics. It has been the dominant IR

theory over the past several decades, and its proponents like to speak of ‘the

timeless wisdom of realism’. By looking at some of its intellectual precursors we

can try to see why realists make such bold claims.

Thucydides was an Athenian historian and general. His History of the

Peloponnesian War recounts the 5th-century BC war between Sparta and Athens

until the year 411 BC. Thucydides has been dubbed the father of “scientific

history” by those who accept his claims to have applied strict standards of

impartiality and evidence-gathering and analysis of cause and effect, without

reference to intervention by the gods, as outlined in his introduction to his

work.He has also been called the father of the school of political realism, which

views the political behavior of individuals and the subsequent outcomes of

relations between states as ultimately mediated by and constructed upon the

emotions of fear and self-interest.His text is still studied at universities and

military colleges worldwide.The Melian dialogue is regarded as a seminal work of

international relations theory, while his version of Pericles’ Funeral Oration is

widely studied by political theorists, historians, and students of the classics.

More generally, Thucydides developed an understanding of human nature to

explain behaviour in such crises as plagues, massacres, and civil war.

Page 29: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

29

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Scholars traditionally view Thucydides as recognizing and teaching the lesson that

democracies need leadership, but that leadership can be dangerous to

democracy. Leo Strauss (in The City and Man) locates the problem in the nature of

Athenian democracy itself, about which, he argued, Thucydides had a deeply

ambivalent view: on one hand, Thucydides’s own “wisdom was made possible” by

the Periclean democracy, which had the effect of liberating individual daring,

enterprise and questioning spirit; but this same liberation, by permitting the

growth of limitless political ambition, led to imperialism and, eventually, civic

strife.

Machiavelli has often been called the father of modern political science. He was

for many years a senior official in the Florentine Republic, with responsibilities in

diplomatic and military affairs. He wrote his most renowned work The Prince in

1513. Machiavelli is sometimes seen as the prototype of a modern empirical

scientist, building generalizations from experience and historical facts, and

emphasizing the uselessness of theorizing with the imagination. He emancipated

politics from theology and moral philosophy. He undertook to describe simply

what rulers actually did and thus anticipated what was later called the scientific

spirit in which questions of good and bad are ignored, and the observer attempts

to discover only what really happens.

He advocated intensive study of the past, particularly regarding the founding of a

city. For example, Machiavelli denies that living virtuously necessarily leads to

happiness. A related and more controversial proposal often made is that he

described how to do things in politics in a way which seemed neutral concerning

who used the advice—tyrants or good rulers. That Machiavelli strove for realism

Page 30: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

30

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

is not doubted, but for four centuries scholars have debated how best to describe

his morality. The Prince made the word “Machiavellian” a byword for deceit,

despotism, and political manipulation. Even if Machiavelli was not himself evil,

Leo Strauss declared himself inclined toward the traditional view that Machiavelli

was self-consciously a “teacher of evil,” since he counsels the princes to avoid the

values of justice, mercy, temperance, wisdom, and love of their people in

preference to the use of cruelty, violence, fear, and deception. Italian anti-fascist

philosopher Benedetto Croce concludes Machiavelli is simply a “realist” or

“pragmatist” who accurately states that moral values in reality do not greatly

affect the decisions that political leaders make. German philosopher Ernst

Cassirer held that Machiavelli simply adopts the stance of a political scientist—a

Galileo of politics—in distinguishing between the “facts” of political life and the

“values” of moral judgment.

Thomas Hobbes was an English philosopher who is considered one of the

founders of modern political philosophy. Hobbes is best known for his 1651 book

Leviathan, which established the social contract theory that has served as the

foundation for most later Western political philosophy.

Though on rational grounds a champion of absolutism for the sovereign, Hobbes

also developed some of the fundamentals of European liberal thought: the right

of the individual; the natural equality of all men; the artificial character of the

political order; the view that all legitimate political power must be

“representative” and based on the consent of the people; and a liberal

interpretation of law that leaves people free to do whatever the law does not

explicitly forbid. His understanding of humans as being matter and motion,

Page 31: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

31

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

obeying the same physical laws as other matter and motion, remains influential;

and his account of human nature as self-interested cooperation, and of political

communities as being based upon a “social contract” remains one of the major

topics of political philosophy.

Page 32: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

32

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

29-Dec-2017 – Question 1

Who was Mr X in international politics? Elaborate his approach to foreign policy.

2014 (250)

Model Answer

After the end of second world war, as Pax Britannica got over, USA and USSR

emerged as two super-powers. These two have little similarities but their aim of

domination of the world. While the USA was a manifestation of Capitalism, USSR

was the first successful experiment of the laboratory of Communism. Both had

not only competitive aims to get dominant pole position, but were also

ideologically opposite and incompatible with each other. This realist worldview

had dominated the discourse of cold war.

USSR became a nuclear state in 1949, ending the American monopoly and

challenging its claim to represent the world. Mr.X in international politics was an

ambassador of USA to Russia, named George Kennan. He published an article

entitled “The Sources of Soviet Conduct” in the Foreign Affairs magazine in 1947.

The article focused on Kennan’s call for a policy of containment toward the Soviet

Union and established the foundation for much of America’s early Cold War

foreign policy.

In February 1946, Kennan, then serving as the U.S. charge d’affaires in Moscow,

wrote his famous “long telegram” to the Department of State. He suggested that

Russia views itself at permanent war with Capitalism and is committed to route

out Capitalism. In the missive, he condemned the communist leadership of the

Soviet Union and called on the United States to forcefully resist Russian

Page 33: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

33

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

expansion. Encouraged by friends and colleagues, Kennan refined the telegram

into an article, “The Sources of Soviet Conduct”. Kennan signed the article “Mr X”

to avoid any charge that he was presenting official U.S. government policy. In the

article, Kennan explained that the Soviet Union’s leaders were determined to

spread the communist doctrine around the world, but were also extremely

patient and pragmatic in pursuing such expansion.

In the “face of superior force,” Kennan said, the Russians would retreat and wait

for a more propitious moment. The West, however, should not be lulled into

complacency by temporary Soviet setbacks. Soviet foreign policy, Kennan claimed,

“is a fluid stream which moves constantly, wherever it is permitted to move,

toward a given goal.” In terms of U.S. foreign policy, Kennan’s advice was clear:

“The main element of any United States policy toward the Soviet Union must be

that of a long-term, patient but firm and vigilant containment of Russian

expansive tendencies.”

Kennan’s article created a sensation in the United States, and the term

“containment” instantly entered the Cold War lexicon. The administration of

President Harry S. Truman embraced Kennan’s philosophy, and in the next few

years attempted to “contain” Soviet expansion through a variety of programs,

including the establishment of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) in

1949.The Truman doctrine was based on Kennan’s proposal. President Truman

demanded $ 400 Million from US Congress to stop Greece and Turkey from falling

into Communist designs. It proclaims US’s commitment to assist free people to

work out their destinies in their own way. It is significant as it marked the end of

Monroe doctrine of isolationism of USA into world affairs.

Page 34: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

34

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

However, by the 1960s, with the United States hopelessly mired in the Vietnam

War, Kennan began to question some of his own basic assumptions in the “Mr X”

article and became a vocal critic of U.S. involvement in Vietnam. In particular, he

criticized U.S. policymakers during the 1950s and 1960s for putting too much

emphasis on the military containment of the Soviet Union, rather than on political

and economic programs.

Page 35: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

35

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

29-Dec-2017 – Question 2

Examine in brief the rise and fall of the cold war.

Model Answer

The cold war is a term introduced in international politics to explain the nature of

relations between USA and USSR since the end of World war-2 till 1991. The

relations had a very high level of distrust, antagonism but there was never

actually ‘hot war’ happening between the two parties. Nuclear weapons made it

cold. There were many proxy wars which primarily affected the countries in the

third world.

First Phase(1947-62): The USSR became a military state in 1949 which prompted

the USA to initiate its ‘containment policy’. The Truman doctrine with its

economic arm, the Marshall plan, was trying to save countries from falling into

communist designs. USSR in response formed ‘Cominform’ to support communist

guerillas and assisted the Eastern European countries with Molotov Plan. The

Berlin blockade was the first direct confrontation between the two superpowers

out of which the west emerged victorious. With the formation of NATO and

Warsaw Pact, the military and strategic bipolarity were fully established. The cold

war had its manifestations in Asia, Middle-East and Latin America too.

Second Phase(1962-79): It is also known as the phase of ‘detente’ meaning

relaxation of tensions. It was not symbolic but qualitative change in relations.The

context of detente was Cuban missile crisis which had put the world at the brink

of nuclear war. Both countries were facing domestic challenges. In this phase

only, NPT, SALT-1, PTBT etc treaties came into force. West recognised the Soviet

Page 36: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

36

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

control over Eastern Europe and USSR recognized Human Rights which became

the basis for peace and security in Europe.

Third Phase(1979-89): It is also known as the ‘new cold war’. The immediate

context was the USSR invasion of Afghanistan and the Iranian revolution of 1979.

USA followed dual policy: challenge USSR militarily in Afghanistan and start

nuclear arms race which can give the final blow to USSR economically. The new

phase was more dangerous as it was less ideological and more geopolitical.

After 1989, the Berlin wall collapsed which marked the symbolic end of cold war.

Communism in East Europe fell easily and the USSR was disintegrated. It also

marked the third wave of democracy. Thus, the cold war had formally ended,

however, its legacies still continues, with the manifestation in a different region

from Middle-East to Afghanistan.

Page 37: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

37

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

08-Jan-2018 – Question 1

Sketch the journey of global political economy from washington consensus to

the present. 200 words. 2013

Model Answer

For a quarter of a century, it has been conventional wisdom among policymakers,

academics, and journalists that the neo-liberal policies that have governed the

global economy are a great success. The policy responsible for this is called

Washington Consensus. The Washington Consensus is a set of 10 economic policy

prescriptions considered to constitute the “standard” reform package promoted

for crisis-wracked developing countries by Washington, D.C.–based institutions

such as the International Monetary Fund (IMF), World Bank, and the US Treasury

Department. The term was first used in 1989 by English economist John

Williamson.

The prescriptions encompassed policies in such areas as macroeconomic

stabilization, economic opening with respect to both trade and investment, and

the expansion of market forces within the domestic economy. Subsequent to

Williamson’s use of the terminology, the phrase Washington Consensus has come

to be used fairly widely in a second, broader sense, to refer to a more general

orientation towards a strongly market-based approach (sometimes described as

market fundamentalism or neoliberalism).

As of the 2000s, several Latin American countries were led by socialist or other

left-wing governments, some of which—including Argentina and Venezuela—

have campaigned for policies contrary to the Washington Consensus policies.

Page 38: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

38

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Other Latin American countries with governments of the left, including Brazil,

Chile and Peru, in practice adopted the bulk of the policies included in

Williamson’s list, even though they criticized the market fundamentalism that

these are often associated with. Besides the excessive belief in market

fundamentalism and international economic institutions in attributing the failure

of the Washington consensus, Joseph Stiglitz provided an explanation about why

it failed. In his article “The Post Washington Consensus Consensus”, he claims that

the Washington consensus policies failed to efficiently handle the economic

structures within developing countries. The cases of East Asian countries such as

Korea and Taiwan are known as a success story in which their remarkable

economic growth was attributed to a larger role of the government by

undertaking industrial policies and increasing domestic savings within their

territory.

Some European and Asian economists suggest that “infrastructure-savvy

economies” such as Norway, Singapore, and China have partially rejected the

underlying Neoclassical “financial orthodoxy” that characterizes the Washington

Consensus, instead of initiating a pragmatist development path of their own

based on sustained, large-scale, government-funded investments in strategic

infrastructure projects. Some view the emergence of Trumponomics in the

context of the United States presidential election, 2016 as an unprecedented

challenge to the Washington Consensus, far more important than the “liberal and

New Left” critiques of the past, arguing that the Trump administration has

effectively “repudiated in part the canons of globalization and the neoliberal

economic orthodoxy of the past 36 years”.

Page 39: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

39

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Some scholars have held that the failure of the neoliberal paradigm and the

growing imbalances of the world’s leading economy provides right time for a

rethinking of the politics of the global marketplace. Key to that understanding is

recognition of the class dimension of the global political economy. A major

strategic task before us is the strengthening of the alliance of working people –

North and South, East and West – through a common program. This should rest

on a “grand bargain” in which the interests of developing and developed country

workers are served, they say. Such a grand bargain, however, should also ensure

for labour, raise consciousness among the majority of the world’s citizens of the

need for international solidarity with each other.

Page 40: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

40

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

08-Jan-2018 – Question 2

Argue a case for UN reform in the context of changing global milieu. 250 words.

2014

Model Answer

The United Nations will mark its 70th anniversary when world leaders assemble

next month at its headquarters in New York. the UN is not only as the most

important political innovation of the twentieth century but also as the best

bargain on the planet. But if the UN is to continue to fulfil its unique and vital

global role in the twenty-first century, it must be upgraded. Since the late 1990s,

there have been many calls for reform of the United Nations (UN). However,

there is little clarity or consensus about what reform might mean in practice. Both

those who want the UN to play a greater role in world affairs and those who want

its role confined to humanitarian work or otherwise reduced use the term “UN

reform” to refer to their ideas. The range of opinion extends from those who

want to eliminate the UN entirely, to those who want to make it into a full-

fledged world government.

One of the most crucial reform is spending on all UN bodies and activities – from

the Secretariat and the Security Council to peacekeeping operations, emergency

responses to epidemics, and humanitarian operations for natural disasters,

famines, and refugees – totalled roughly $45 billion in 2013, roughly $6 per

person on the planet. That is not just a bargain; it is a significant

underinvestment. Given the rapidly growing need for global cooperation, the UN

simply cannot get by on its current budget. The second major area of reform is

Page 41: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

41

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

ensuring that the UN is fit for the new age of sustainable development.

Specifically, the UN needs to strengthen its expertise in areas such as ocean

health, renewable energy systems, urban design, disease control, technological

innovation, public-private partnerships, and peaceful cultural cooperation. Some

UN programs should be merged or closed, while other new SDG-related UN

programs should be created.

The third major reform imperative is the UN’s governance, starting with the

Security Council, the composition of which no longer reflects global geopolitical

realities. Indeed, Western Europe and Other Group (WEOG) now account for

three of the five permanent members (France, the United Kingdom, and the US).

That leaves only one permanent position for the Eastern European Group

(Russia), one for the Asia-Pacific Group (China), and none for Africa or Latin

America. UN Security Council reflects the power structure of the world as it was

in 1945. There are several proposed plans, notably by the G4 nations, by the

Uniting of Consensus group, and by former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan. At

another level, calls for reforming the UN demand to make the UN administration

more transparent, more accountable, and more efficient, including direct election

of the Secretary-General by the people as in a presidential system.

India is also spending a lot of resources to actualize UN reforms. The nature of

international relations determines that India’s behaviour will be consistent with

the traditional behaviour of the Security Councils permanent members, with

strategic interests trumping institutional imperatives. While during the Cold War

era, India attempted to make its presence relevant in the international realm by

pragmatically resorting to normative vocabulary, these were typical of the

Page 42: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

42

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

instruments employed by a weak state to secure its interests in the global

hierarchy. India is no longer attempting to set fresh criteria and establish

alternative universalities in reshaping the world. Instead, in tandem with altering

global realities and its emergence as a major player, it is focusing on playing the

game of realpolitik.

Institutions are not a mitigating factor where the interests of great powers are

threatened, and they are only pertinent when there is no conflict between these.

Like the permanent members, India is satisfying its political interests first, while

refusing to act in the face of massive brutality. As Baldev Raj Nayar and T.V. Paul

assert, there is a “behavioural requirement of great power status: a great power

is and becomes what a great power does.”

Page 43: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

43

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

10-Jan-2018 – Question 1

How does regionalism shape the world politics? Explain with examples. 200

words. 2016

Model Answer

Though regional institution building has become a global trend, regionalism has

evolved in different ways. It is therefore imperative to explore the various factors,

be they historical, geopolitical, cultural or other, that have influenced the

development of regionalism around the world. Only by comparing the process of

regionalism around the world can we understand the richness and diversity of this

central trend in global politics.

Regionalism, generally speaking, is a phenomenon in international trade where

states create groups for the purposes of trade and to collectively reduce barriers

of trade among the members of a group. Most of this phenomenon appears in the

form of Regional Trade Agreements (RTA). These groups, like all trade regimes,

vary greatly in terms of the scope of the goods that are covered, the institutional

bylaws and guidelines of these agreements, etc. There is not a universal definition

for regionalism due to disputes over the importance of geographic proximity and

on the relationship between economic flows and policy choices. However, a

region is often defined as a group of countries located in the same geographically

specific area. An example which illustrates this is the African, Caribbean and

Pacific Group of States which includes African, Caribbean, and Latin American

nations.

Page 44: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

44

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

The incidence of regionalism has increased in recent history as the number of

members in the GATT and WTO increased. This has generally been attributed to

problems with the World Trade Organization. Small nations that are not part of

the quad countries may engage in RTAs to enhance their power within the WTO.

RTAs may also serve as alternatives among countries with similar trade policy

goals when they cannot have their goals implemented through WTO negotiations.

There are two camps within the international political economy that see

regionalism as either an aid or an obstacle to global integration. Some decry the

loss of multilateralism and a resulting division of the world into regional trade

alliances. Others believe that regionalism encourages states to reduce trade

barriers in an initially less painful manner, and thus helps states transition to a

position where they are better suited to reduce trade barriers multilaterally.

Louise Fawcett and Andrew Hurrell in their seminal work ‘Regionalism in World

Politics: Regional Organization and International Order argues that the past five

years have witnessed a resurgence of regionalism in world politics. Old regionalist

organizations have been revived, new organizations formed, and regionalism and

the call for strengthened regionalist arrangements have been central to many of

the debates about the nature of the post-Cold War international order.

It is important to reconsider the future of ‘regionalism’ in world politics. Consider,

for example, the UK and the European Union. Brexit has shown the limits of

globalist arguments in regionalism theories: ‘regionalism’ is not simply a product

of states’ rational choice to cooperate with other countries. It is, in fact, a po litical

project that is heavily dependent upon ideological contestation and political

processes at both the domestic and global level. Current developments in ASEAN

Page 45: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

45

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

also provide a useful further example. The recent ASEAN Summit, which was held

in Manila under Philippine’s chairmanship last month, was marked by heated

tensions in the region, for example with the ongoing debate over disputed

territorial rights in the South China Sea. But this year’s Summit was also

particularly significant because of the growing crisis on the Korean Peninsula, and

the appearance of extra-ASEAN states in the regional politics of south-east Asia,

such as China and the United States with their visibly growing interest. For those

who wish to resurrect regionalism in world politics, challenging the global uneven

development would be a crucial agenda in the future.

Page 46: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

46

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

10-Jan-2018 – Question 2

Discuss the theory of nuclear deterrence. Did nuclear deterrence prevent a

superpower war? 200 words. 2015

Model answer

Deterrence theory gained increased prominence as a military strategy during the

Cold War with regard to the use of nuclear weapons. It took on a unique

connotation during this time as an inferior nuclear force, by virtue of its extreme

destructive power, could deter a more powerful adversary, provided that this

force could be protected against destruction by a surprise attack. Deterrence is a

strategy intended to dissuade an adversary from taking an action not yet started,

or to prevent them from doing something that another state desires. A credible

nuclear deterrent, Bernard Brodie wrote in 1959, must be always at the ready, yet

never used. In the 1950s and early 1960s, strategists and policymakers

anticipated the arrival of a technological condition of mutual assured destruction

in which both the United States and the Soviet Union could launch a devastating

nuclear second strike even after absorbing a massive nuclear Ž rst strike. Secure,

second-strike forces would render defense impossible as neither state could

physically protect itself from an attack. Consequently, both states would have to

rely on deterrence to dissuade the other from attacking should it be tempted to

do so.

Besides this general security and stability, the conventional wisdom also holds

that nuclear deterrence provides three specific benefits:

1) protection against attacks with nuclear weapons

Page 47: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

47

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

2) protection against attacks with conventional forces

3) indefinable additional diplomatic clout.

If the conventional wisdom is true, if nuclear deterrence is as well defined and

successful as is sometimes assumed, it is both a powerful argument against

nuclear disarmament and a considerable obstacle to those who wish to prevent

proliferation. These issues matter because nuclear weapons remain dangerous

and powerful and appear to be slowly but steadily spreading.

However, it is not taking brinkmanship of states into account. Brinkmanship is

fundamentally a contest of resolve in which states bid up the risk of events

spiraling out of control until one of the states Ž nds this risk intolerably high and

backs down. there are no crises if there is little or no uncertainty about the states´

levels of resolve. In this case, the less resolute state does not challenge the more

resolute state. Crises arise only if there is substantial uncertainty about the

balance of resolve, and in this case, the dynamics of escalation depend on a

complex interaction between the states´ levels of resolve and their uncertainty

about each other´s resolve.

The closer inspection calls the fundamental soundness of nuclear deterrence

theory into question. In addition, three practical arguments put the efficacy of

nuclear deterrence into doubt:

1) the characteristic attack threatened in most nuclear deterrence scenarios city

attack is not militarily effective or likely to be decisive

Page 48: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

48

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

2) the psychology of terror that is supposed to work in nuclear favor of

deterrence actually creates the circumstances for unremitting resistance

3) even though the field is mostly conjectural, what little unambiguous evidence

does exist contradicts the claim that nuclear deterrence works.

There are also reasons, however, for doubting how much this doctrine might

determine the shape of an actual war. First, a nation’s declaratory policy is likely

to be different from its actual plans for nuclear war. Second, city attacks, even if

they are absent from the early stages of nuclear war scenarios, usually loom large

in any later stages. Descriptions of nuclear war always include the possibility of

the war getting out of control. Getting out of control means using nuclear

weapons against civilian populations. City attacks exist, therefore, as an inherent

possibility in virtually every nuclear war scenario. Third, it seems doubtful that the

choices made by the United States in its targeting doctrine necessarily control the

choices other nuclear nations make in their targeting doctrine. Certainly when

nuclear war is discussed between India and Pakistan, for example, there seems to

be an emphasis on the possibility of attacks against cities. Fourth, ‘‘no cities’’ is a

doctrine for states with many nuclear weapons. It seems likely that states with

smaller nuclear arsenals (and the majority are believed to have fewer than 200)

would not emphasize ‘‘no cities’’ targeting policies.

Thus, nuclear deterrence may have prevented superpower war and ensured ‘long

peace’ according to conventional wisdom but the contemporary rethinking in

political theory suggests that the theory was deeply flawed and in the increasing

Page 49: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

49

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

proliferation and asymmetric balancing, it may not work. We need to debate

about alternatives to ensure that ‘long peace’ is not short lived.

Page 50: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

50

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

12-Jan-2018 – Question 1

State the place of gender justice in global political agenda. 200 words. 2013

Model Answer

Gender justice is a cry to secure parity among world largely dominated by men.

Women forms a vulnerable group and have been victim of exploitation across

cultures and time. There have been efforts by different waves of feminism to

address the issue and create awareness against the structural inequality in the

institutions, however, it has not been adopted by a majority polity. Gender

exploitation is still common. Women in many parts of the world are recognised as

second class citizens, leading what is called ‘a private and personal life’ away from

the ‘public’. According to an estimate, in 2001-02, the number of women and

children trafficked out of SE Asia was 2,25,000. For South Asia, the figure is

1,50,000.

Women fall behind man in almost every indicator and parameter. They possess

roughly one percent land in the world. The World march for Women says that in

the last 100 years, only 24 heads of state have been women. Around 80 percent

of 27 million refugees are women. Only six countries can boast to achieve near

complete sexual equality in secondary education, 30 percent representation in

elected government and 50 percent non-agricultural job occupied by women. The

International Labour Organization reveals that seventy percent of world’s poor

are women, living less than 1 $ per day. In European union, 83 percent of part-

time workers are women. Women on average earn two thirds of what men earn.

Page 51: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

51

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

In this context there have been demands to increase participation of women in

the labour force, decision making etc. In USA, Hillary Clinton has advocated

female empathetic foreign policy. She has criticised rape as weapon of war and

have been critical of the traditional USA allies like Saudi Arabia for their

differential and discriminatory treatment of women. Sweden became the first

country to adopt feminist foreign policy, and they wanted to secure women’s

security as a fundamental goal to achieve human security.

There are many international foras where the issue of gender justice is taken up

and debated. At the recent ten-year review conference of the International

Criminal Court (ICC), one of the side events was a Women’s Court: a space for

women to ‘testify’ about their experiences during and after armed conflict in their

countries. The idea is to provide a platform for women directly affected by armed

conflict to provide testimonies about their own experiences and those of their

communities. Women speak of the widespread gender-based violence

committed by militias and national armies, the aggression of their governments

against their own citizens, the political interests supporting these conflicts, and

the need for justice and a permanent end to the fighting.

The role of the United Nations in delivering gender justice through its various

institutions, instruments and processes, has been under the spotlight. Another

important space for gender justice work was convened by the Women’s Initiatives

for Gender Justice in collaboration with the Nobel Women’s Initiative, in April

2010, in Puerto Vallarta, Mexico. At this forum, diversity of actors came together

to contribute to conceptualization and action towards a global gender justice

plan. The participants at the International Gender Justice Dialogue discussed how

Page 52: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

52

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

to pursue gender justice through formal mechanisms such as the ICC and by

influencing the frameworks and methodologies of peace talks so as to infuse

them with feminist analysis.

Systematic and effective achievement of gender equality and gender justice

requires moving away from viewing gender inequality and injustice as a sort of

“second grade” inequality and injustice, forced to take a “back-seat” to other

“more important” forms of inequality and injustice. It is time for a better

understanding that gender inequality and injustice are inextricably linked to other

forms of inequality and injustice. Gender inequality and injustice are both part of

the causes and consequences of all other inequalities and injustices. Effective

work with gender equality and gender justice requires full understanding of the

interlinkages with other inequalities and injustices. Similarly, effective efforts to

reduce other inequalities and injustices, such as poverty, require explicit attention

to gender inequalities and injustice.

Page 53: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

53

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

12-Jan-2018 – Question 2

Explain the concept of North-South divide and suggest how structural

inequalities between high wage, high investment industrial North and low

wage, low investment predomintly rural south can be reduced? 200 words. 2016

Model Answer

The North–South divide is broadly considered a socio-economic and political

divide. Generally, definitions of the Global North include the United States,

Canada, Western Europe, and developed parts of Asia (the Four Asian Tigers,

Japan, and Israel), as well as Australia and New Zealand. The Global South is made

up of Africa, Latin America, and developing Asia including the Middle East. The

North is home to all the members of the G8 and to four of the five permanent

members of the United Nations Security Council.

The Brandt Line is a visual depiction of the north–south divide, proposed by West

German Chancellor Willy Brandt in the 1980s. It encircles the world at a latitude

of approximately 30° North, passing between North and Central America, north of

Africa and the Middle East, climbing north over China and Mongolia, but dipping

south so as to include Australia and New Zealand in the “Rich North”. The North

mostly covers the West and the First World, along with much of the Second

World, while the South largely corresponds with the Third World. While the North

may be defined as the richer, more developed region and the South as the

poorer, less developed region, many more factors differentiate between the two

global areas. 95% of the North has enough food and shelter. The Global South

“lacks appropriate technology, it has no political stability, the economies are

Page 54: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

54

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

disarticulated, and their foreign exchange earnings depend on primary product

exports.” Nevertheless, the divide between the North and the South increasingly

“corresponds less and less to reality and is increasingly challenged.”

The gap between the industrialised, relatively rich countries of the global north,

and the relatively poor countries of the global south is huge. The North contains

only 20% of the world population, yet consumes 60% of world production. The

South has 80% of the world population, but consumes only 40% of world

production. Many argue that the divide is growing, as the North continues to

absorb more and more of global production, yet the South remains stuck in a

poverty trap of low income, leading to low levels of saving, which restricts

investment. Low levels of investment in turn restrict the development and

progress of firms, thereby restricting income growth, and therefore savings etc.

There are a number of reasons for the lack of development in the South, which

candidates should be able to describe and illustrate. These include: political

leadership (ineffective policy making, wasteful government spending and

corruption), political instability (including civil war and violence), debt, lack of

resources, restricted access to western markets, economic dumping (EU food),

and natural disasters (earthquakes, famines, floods etc).

There’s a solution to address the inequality between global north and global

south : A global minimum wage. If capitalism is going to be globalised, it makes

sense that we should globalise the rules and standards that protect people from it

as well. Economist Thomas Palley recommends a floor set at 50% of each

country’s median wage, so it would be tailored to local economic conditions and

cause minimum disruption to comparative advantage. The International Labour

Page 55: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

55

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Organization has already proven that they have the capacity to manage such a

system. And it would make good sense to couple it with a universal basic income.

By allowing people to opt out of exploitative jobs, a basic income would force

employers to raise wages – and would provide a crucial cushion for the workers

who will soon be displaced by the rising tide of automation. These ideas are not

only feasible, they are quickly gaining traction. Implementing them will require a

political struggle, to be sure. But if we want to stop the global inequality machine,

it’s a battle we’ll have to fight.

Page 56: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

56

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

22-Jan-2018 – Question 1

Identify the elements of change in India’s foreign policy. 200 words 2013

Model Answer

A country’s foreign policy consists of self-interest strategies chosen by the state to

safeguard its national interests and to achieve its own goals through relations

with other countries. The approaches are strategically employed to interact with

other countries. India’s Foreign Policy is not just to secure National Interest, but

also to shape world order based on toleration, non-violence, cosmopolitanism.

India’s worldview has never been entirely realist, always there is a strong

ideational element.

Arvind Virmani in his article “Recalibrating India’s foreign policy” says that every

country’s foreign policy has elements of continuity and change following a change

in government. The changes have not necessarily been explicitly articulated, but

are implicit in the government’s actions and view of the world. There are five

areas of the emerging change according to Dr Virmani: The centrality given to

economic and technological development; the orientation of domestic and

foreign policies toward this objective; the emphasis on national power including

military power; and stress on soft power; and a reduction in self-imposed

constraints on actions that other countries may construe as inimical to their

interests.

Hon. Foreign Secretary Dr S Jaishankar talks of five “innovations” in the way India

was using the tools of statecraft to further this proactive foreign policy –

narratives; lexicon and imagery; soft power; the Indian diaspora; and the link

Page 57: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

57

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

between foreign policy and national development. First, the Modi government

was developing a narrative as part of a transition to making India a leading power.

Second, the creation of a new lexicon and imagery – whether it is from a “Look

East” to “Act East” policy or the image of a “first responder” in humanitarian

assistance and disaster relief – has been critical in signalling and driving foreign

policy change. Third, the Modi government has emphasized the use of soft power

in Indian foreign policy, as evidenced by the International Day of Yoga and its links

with the country’s culture and heritage. The fourth “innovation” is related to the

Indian diaspora. While their achievements have long been broadly appreciated,

the Modi government has been more direct thus far in engaging with overseas

Indians, as evidenced by the turnout at Madison Square Garden during his visit to

the United States earlier this year. Fifth and finally, there has also been a more

explicit link made between diplomacy and national development efforts, with

India working hard to leverage its international relationships to bring resources,

technology and best practices to further its own development such as through the

Make in India initiative.

However, as Teresita Schaffer in her book “India at the Global High Table” says

that between Narendra Modi and J L Nehru, only ends have remained same but

means have changed. Earlier Non-Alignment, 3rd world solidarity and soft power

were the key essentials. Now strategic autonomy, alignment with USA and Russia,

use of smart power has become the key pillars of India’s foreign policy. The four

concepts woven together throughout the book offer an exploration of India

today: its exceptionalism; its nonalignment and drive for “strategic autonomy;” its

determination to maintain regional primacy; and, more recently, its surging

economy.

Page 58: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

58

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Amb. Jitendra Nath Misra in his lecture “Continuity and change in India’s Foreign

Policy” argues that India’s foreign and security policies are ‘enablers’ in the

transformation of India is now well understood among thinking Indians. In that

sense, by getting tied to domestic policy, which receives greater public attention,

foreign policy has woven itself into the people’s consciousness. India is being

recast. Today India is at the centre of the international security architecture, and

a key to the economic and technological debates of the age. By virtue of its

economic growth, its world-class space programme, and its contributions from

medicine to IT, India has become indispensable to global needs and a shaper of

the world economy, not just as a market, but also as an engine of growth and

ideas.

It would thus not be far-fetched to say that what India does will profoundly affect

the future of the world. Terrorism is an example. With swathes of embittered

humanity on the boil, terrorism is at the centre of international discourse. The

world now speaks of 9/11 and 26/11 in the same breath, and, as a major victim,

India becomes a natural partner in fighting terrorism. Similarly, on the emission of

greenhouse gases and climate change, what India does affects the world. This is

the foundation for India’s new foreign policy.

Page 59: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

59

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

22-Jan-2018 – Question 2

Discuss the foreign policy initiatives taken by India to balance its relations

between Israel and the Arab world. 250 words. 2015

Model Answer

Amid the turmoil of the Middle East, India has conventionally adhered to a policy

of equivalence in dealing with Israel and neighbouring Arab countries. Israel is a

major defence and strategic partner for India while Arab state are leading trade

partners, mainly fulfilling India’s energy needs and serving as a destination for

India’s food exports. To maintain a friendly relationship with both sides, India

prefers to avoid the Arab-Israeli conflict and advocates a dialogue-driven,

peaceful, two-state solution.

Delhi’s interests in Israel have grown rapidly in the last quarter of a century. So

have those with the 400 million Arabs. The Arab Middle East is the main source of

India’s energy, the home to nearly seven million expatriate workers, and a big

market for Indian goods. As we look to India’s growing stakes in the Middle East,

Delhi’s problem is not about fidelity to one domestic ideological position or the

other.

C Raja Mohan therefore, argues that the challenge for India lies in finding the

right balance between competing imperatives in a volatile region amidst the

pursuit of enlightened self-interest. The Israelis and Arabs alike have a strong

tradition of realpolitik. They might be happier with an open, predictable and

interest-based Indian policy towards the region than the one trapped in political

posturing for domestic audiences. Israeli and Arab leaders also, view India from

Page 60: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

60

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

the perspective of regional balance, rather than an ideological framework. India’s

exceptional political warmth certainly does not beget uncritical Israeli support for

India in its territorial disputes with Pakistan or China. Similarly, the Arab nations

don’t back India on Kashmir, just because India extends formal solidarity with the

Palestinians. Like all nations, Israelis and Arabs want to maximise possibilities with

India but would want to limit its impact on the relations with Pakistan.

India’s volume of trade with Arab countries stands at $121 billion, which includes

$50 billion in exports and imports of $71 billion. That constitutes around 18.25

percent of India’s total trade while India’s trade with Israel, at $5 billion, accounts

for less than one percent of total trade. As per the latest SIPRI release for 2016,

India’s arms trade with Israel has increased 117 percent, from $276 million in

2015 to $599 million in 2016. India imports 48 percent of Israel’s total arms

exports. Russia is still the largest exporter of arms to India, contributing 62

percent of total imports, but Israel has emerged as the second largest at 24

percent. Nicholas Blarel in her work “Evolution of India’s Israel Policy: Continuity,

Change and Compromise since 1992” says that New Delhi no longer sees the

India-Israel relationship in a zero-sum manner.

The pursuit of balance is an essential feature of international life; how it gets

expressed or couched in a specific context is a matter of diplomatic detail. Israel’s

dispute with Palestine is not the only one that India confronts in the Middle East.

Delhi, for example, is constantly trying to balance between Israel and Iran, Riyadh

and Tehran, the Sunni and Shia, Saudis and Qataris, and between the Kurds and

everyone else. The Middle East long ceased to be defined by the Arab-Israeli

Page 61: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

61

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

conflict. There are new faultlines and raging conflicts and the new partnership is

about surviving the coming storms.

Page 62: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

62

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

24-Jan-2018 – Question 1

“Indian policy of non-alignment has been guided by the genius of the Inian

people and their interests.” Explain. 250 words. 2014

Model Answer

The word ‘non-aligned’ is used for the foreign policy of those nations which are

not aligned to Anglo-American Bloc and Communist bloc and independently

frame and follow their foreign policies. According to Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru, “ Non-

Alignment means an attempt by a nation to keep itself aloof from military blocs. It

means trying to view the thing as far as possible not from the military point of

view though that has to come in sometimes, but we must have an independent

viewpoint and must have friendly relations with all countries.” The primary of

objectives of the non-aligned countries focused on the support of self-

determination, national independence and the sovereignty and territorial

integrity of States; opposition to apartheid; non-adherence to multilateral military

pacts and the independence of non-aligned countries from great power or block

influences and rivalries; the struggle against imperialism in all its forms and

manifestations; the struggle against colonialism, neocolonialism, racism, foreign

occupation and domination; disarmament; non-interference into the internal

affairs of States and peaceful coexistence among all nations; rejection of the use

or threat of use of force in international relations; the strengthening of the United

Nations; the democratization of international relations; socioeconomic

development and the restructuring of the international economic system; as well

as international cooperation on an equal footing.

Page 63: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

63

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

The Movement of Non-Aligned Countries could not spare itself difficulties to act

effectively in an adverse international political situation marked by hegemonic

positions and unipolarity as well as by internal difficulties and conflicts given the

heterogeneity of its membership and, thus, its diverse interests. Nevertheless,

and in spite of such setbacks, the principles and objectives of non-alignment

retain their full validity and force at the present international juncture. The

primary condition that led to the emergence of the Movement of Non-Aligned

Countries, that is, non-alignment from antagonistic blocks, has not lost its validity

with the end of the Cold War. The demise of one of the blocks has not done away

with the pressing problems of the world. On the contrary, renewed strategic

interests bent on domination grow stronger and, even, acquire new and more

dangerous dimensions for underdeveloped countries.

India adopted policy of non-alignment as it was need of the time, it was good for

the all-round development of the country, the military alliance could have proven

harmful to developing countries, geographical Position of India didn’t allow us so

many options, it was necessary for the formulation of independent Foreign

Policy, India acted as a mediator to many disputes, India had the freedom to

manoeuvre. Advantages we had because of NAM were, India has been able to

maintain its independence in Policy Making. The policy of Non-Alignment is in

accordance with the national interests of India. India has been able to maintain

neutral status. India’s role in the solution of international Conflicts. India has been

able to get the support of both the blocs.

India continues to practice a policy of non-alignment in an attempt to maintain

sovereignty and oppose imperialism. Since its inception, the movement

Page 64: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

64

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

attempted to create an independent path in world politics that would not result

in lesser states becoming pawns in the struggles between major world powers.

Today, India has a working security relationship with the United States. Over the

course of history, these two countries have inherently forged a deeper sense for

each other’s motivations and aspirations while never establishing a formal

alliance. India continues to serve as an example of a country that is overcoming

the continuum gap and advancing its policies to better fit an emerging world

power. India’s non-alignment policy has made the free development of the

individual as well as the economic and social progress of society and of nations its

central focus in its strategic objectives. This strategy combines the goals of peace

and economic development within the country with the emancipation of peoples

from all forms of subordination and exploitation. As a result, India’s non-

alignment stance functions as a benchmark for the positive development of

international relations on a global scale.

Page 65: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

65

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

24-Jan-2018 – Question 2

The Ministry of external affairs is loosing its importance in the making of India’s

foreign policy with the parallel rise of PMO. Explain. 250 words. 2014

Model Answer

The emergence of globalization and the cosmopolitaization of statecraft have

redefined the concept and scope of Foreign Policy. In the borderless global village

when the gap between internal and external affairs is gradually narrowing down,

the matter of external relation no longer remains the isolated business of foreign

office only. Though the Ministry of External Affairs is the pivotal player in India‘s

external relation, other important agencies such as the Cabinet, Ministry of

Defence, Ministry of Commerce and Industry, National Security Council, Prime

Minister‘s Office and Parliament also are contributing significantly for the

planning and formulation of India‘s Foreign Policy. Apart from these core agencies

various other peripheral agencies also are involved in Foreign Policy decision-

making process, which is a highly complex and multi-stage process.

With the emergence of India as one of the aspiring global power and

transformation of the Indian economy, the role and function of MEA have been

multiplied gradually. To deal with these emerging challenges, the role and

function of the ministry have undergone numerous changes to facilitate India‘s

emerging role in the international sphere. Like any other foreign office, the prime

function of MEA is to plan, formulate and manage India‘s external relations with

other nations as well as protect and promote India‘s national interest at the

global stage. Besides, the ministry is also responsible to set up and manage India‘s

Page 66: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

66

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

foreign missions and diplomatic institutions and extend consular activities to

Indian and foreign nationals. Similarly, matters related to India‘s representatives

at UN and other specialized agencies, Issues and cancellation passports and visas

and protection of Indian nationals and institutions abode also come under the

jurisdiction of MEA. The ministry receives reports from its foreign missions and

gives the necessary inputs to the government during the Foreign Policymaking.

Since the attachment of External Publicity Division (XP) to the MEA, in 1948, the

ministry also is responsible to publicise India‘s positive image among world

communities.

It is true that the PMO is at the commanding heights of foreign policy-making due

to increasingly integrated nature of the economy, polity and the globalized world,

the distribution of power is not a zero-sum game in this case. This has been

proven by the strong cadre of foreign service and the useful intervention by Hon.

Minister of External Affairs in her response to the humanitarian crisis and

important foreign policy matters like recent UN speech. By the very structure of

the international system, the role of head of government is increasing, and India

is not an exception to the same.

Page 67: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

67

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

26-Jan-2018 – Question 1

How does Parliament determine and influence the making of India’s foreign

policy? 200 words. 2015

Model Answer

Foreign Policy Decision Making is a complex process which involves multiple

actors, agencies and institutions. Though the Ministry of External Affairs plays a

pivotal role in shaping India’s Foreign Policy behaviour, the Cabinet, Ministry of

Defence, Ministry of Trade and Commerce, Prime Minister’s Office and National

Security Council also are extensively involved in determining India’s external

policy. Apart from this, the Parliament, in any democratic setup is considered as

one of the important institutions in Foreign Policy decision making. Being the

centre of world’s largest democracy, Indian Parliament is also playing an

important role in determining India’s Foreign Policy behaviour.

The parliament enjoys complete authority in making laws, for both domestic and

foreign affairs, of this country. Thus, the part influences Foreign Policy activities in

many ways. Though, some believe that the Parliament enjoys limited and minimal

inputs in foreign affairs as compared to domestic affairs, it has been well

established that domestic policies too can influence the foreign policies

significantly. Article 246 of the Indian Constitution which distributes powers to

the Union Government and the states authorize the Parliament to legislate on all

aspects of external affairs of this country. Item 10 of the Union List under the

Seventh Scheduled of the Constitution specifically empowers the Parliament to

formulate appropriate laws regarding foreign affairs. 269 In addition, items listed

Page 68: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

68

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

from serial number 9 to 21 of the Union List include war and peace, diplomacy,

matters regarding UN, and international treaties and agreements under the

supervision of the Parliament.

Apart from the policy formulation, the Parliament is influencing the Foreign Policy

decision in many ways using various tools. Using its budgetary control, it can slash

down various allocations on

military, Defence, foreign aid and other such peripherals as well. Similarly by

opening of new offices and branches and neutralizing the performance through

resource control of such agencies that deal with the Foreign Policy activities, the

Parliament can indirectly control the external policy of the country. Thus, one can

agree that the Parliament plays a vital role in Foreign Policy making in India. Its

role can be divided into three broad categories – Policy formulation, policy

shaping, and policy alternation.

It can also legislate or enhance or curtail the executive power that is used to have

larger role to play. Legislation regarding military forces and war and peace

similarly places the Parliament at the decisive stage on Foreign Policymaking

mechanism. It can direct the force to go for war or legislate on maintaining peace

by ending war. Further, trade and commerce and economic affairs remain on the

preview area of the Centre on which the Parliament can pass any law in favour or

against certain trade policies. Starting from the border settlement to the UN

affairs the Parliament is awarded with immense power to make a law that

influence, guide or change the Foreign Policy of the Country. Along with the

Page 69: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

69

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

domestic issues, a significant amount of Foreign Policy related matters also has

been the subject of the parliamentary debate and discussion.

As the parliamentary debate has been an important instrument of influence and

control of the policymaking in India, a large number of issues make into the floor

of the house for discussion. The subjects of the debate on Foreign Policy issues

happens to be the matter related to strategic relations, CTBT and NPT, India-

Pakistan war, an incursion into Indian Territory, problems of Tibet, India’s

neighbourhood policies and India’s relations with major powers. The present

milieu is said to be one of which a shift is underway from what commentators call

centralized decision-making process- arguably visible during the single-party rule

of the Congress- to a decentralized process of foreign policy formulations.

Page 70: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

70

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

26-Jan-2018 – Question 2

Comment on India’s contribution to Non-alignment movement and its

contemporary relevance. 200 words. 2016

Model Answer

The Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) was created and founded during the collapse

of the colonial system and the independence struggles of the peoples of Africa,

Asia, Latin America and other regions of the world and at the height of the Cold

War. During the early days of the Movement, its actions were a key factor in the

decolonization process, which led later to the attainment of freedom and

independence by many countries and peoples and to the founding of tens of new

sovereign States. Throughout its history, the Movement of Non-Aligned Countries

has played a fundamental role in the preservation of world peace and

security. The principles that would govern relations among large and small

nations, known as the “Ten Principles of Bandung”, were proclaimed at that

Conference.

A champion of human freedom, Nehru opposed colonialism in his foreign policy

and it received high praise from many of the newly independent countries though

it was viewed with scepticism by the US. American Secretary of State John Foster

Dulles characterized the non-aligned ideal as immoral and opportunistic. Under

Nehru’s guidance, India became the first country to begin a policy that was new in

the history of international relations – the policy of Non-Alignment, which was

founded in 1961 in Belgrade and was ably supported by Gamal Abdel Nasser of

Egypt, President Sukarno of Indonesia and Joseph Broz Tito of Yugoslavia. Nehru’s

Page 71: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

71

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

policy of principled distance paved the way for the establishment of the Non-

Aligned Movement (NAM). India facilitated the involvement of former colonies

and newly independent countries into the organization which aimed to protect

the interests of undeveloped nations in international politics. The policy of

nonalignment meant the acceptance of the inevitability of war but on the

conviction that it could be avoided. Non-alignment entailed a position to judge

each issue without bias or prejudice. The secret of this policy was that India was

never permanently pro-west or pro-east.

The policy of non-alignment was based on the five principles of Panchasheel,

which directed international conduct. These principles which were envisaged and

formulated in 1954, were mutual respect for each other’s territorial integrity and

sovereignty; non-interference in each other’s military and internal affairs; mutual

non-aggression; equality and mutual benefit and finally, peaceful coexistence and

economic cooperation. By 1955, a number of countries including Burma, China,

Laos, Nepal, Vietnam, Yugoslavia and Cambodia had accepted the principles of

Panchasheel. The technique of maintaining world peace through non-alignment

was to make sure that each nation pursued its own interest without disturbing

other nations.

The buzzword or mantra amongst the Indian strategic establishment of recent

times has been ‘strategic autonomy’. India will not be cajoled, enticed or coerced

into actions that would jeopardize its standing as a responsible and restrained

regional power with the potential of emerging as a major power to reckon with in

the years to come. NAM 2.0 policy would be used by India to fulfil its national

interests in changing security scenario. It would be used by India to counter

Page 72: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

72

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

regional and global challenges of 21st century. India will refine its foreign policy

with the mixture of ‘soft power’ and ‘hard power’ to combat new challenges of

21st century.

‘‘Non-alignment has been responsible to ever-changing international relations

and that it has been permissive of diversity and multiplicity of approaches

consistent with a hard-core unity on same irreducible, minimum principles.’’ Since

the end of the Cold War and the formal end of colonialism, the Non-aligned

Movement has been forced to redefine itself and reinvent its purpose in the

current world order. A major question has been whether any of its foundational

ideologies, principles can be applied to the contemporary issues. The NAM has

emphasized its principles of multilateralism, equality and mutual understanding in

attempting to become a stronger voice of developing and third world countries as

well as an instrument that can be utilized and promote the needs of member

countries.

The concern of NAM since the beginning has been with the world peace in view of

the nuclear arms race and the dangers of nuclear war, instead of solving the

problem, it has been mostly aggravated them. In the initial years, concern for

international peace so overshadowed their politics, that their other efforts for

development were virtually ignored. The NAM had always opposed the

disarmament and nuclear expansion. We cannot ignore the role of NAM in recent

time. They represent nearly two-third of the UN members and comprise 55% of

the world population. Many of US and USSR former ally partner are became a

member of NAM. All these factors indicated the importance and relevance of

NAM in post-Cold War era. The NAM is an international platform of developing

Page 73: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

73

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

and under developing countries. The NAM produce a platform as ‘dialogue table’

for developing the world and it has done a lot of for United these countries. These

countries discuss their mutual problem and find a way to resolve these problems.

The Nonalignment platform could play a meaningful role in developing countries.

This platform is the common voice of third world countries. It is considered as a

positive and constructive movement in across the world. India’s efforts for non-

aligned countries have appraised by everyone. Therefore, we can say that Non-

aligned agenda has immense importance for future.

Page 74: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

74

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

05-Feb-2018 – Question 1

Identify the constraints/challenges to the regional cooperation in South Asia.

200 words. 2015

Model Answer

The South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation was formed under Article

52 of the United Nations’ Charter providing existence of regional arrangements or

agencies for dealing with such matters, relating to the maintenance of

international peace and security with the purpose and principles of UN charter.

India since her freedom from foreign rule has always been keenly interested and

deeply committed to regional cooperation for the solution of common problems

in various fields viz. the cultural, economic political ones. The SAARC member

countries include Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri

Lanka. Afghanistan is the eight member of the SAARC. The region is of strategic

importance between the east and west with respect to defence, trade, transport

population growth and economic development particular for India directly and

indirectly. The Indian Ocean plays a vital role in defence, trade and water

transport is in the proximity of the majority of South Asia Countries.

SAARC has long had to deal with an imbalance within it: one very large country

surrounded by a number of very small ones. As a result, in the region, there has

been no compelling economic force to push towards regional integration, unlike

East Asia or Europe for instance. Even in North America, access to the vast pool of

cheap labor in Mexico did a lot to create a constituency for free trade and

investment. This structural fact of life in South Asia — the sheer asymmetry in the

Page 75: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

75

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

economic weight between one country versus all the rest — has done more to

inhibit regional integration than any territorial disputes and geopolitics.

Pakistan is not alone in holding up regional cooperation. India’s own domestic

politics and the security establishment’s conservatism have often undermined the

possibilities for regional cooperation. Opposition from West Bengal and Tamil

Nadu, for example, has prevented the advancement of India’s engagement with

Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, respectively. If West Bengal and Tamil Nadu point to

the negative side of the equation, many others have been enthusiastic

proponents of regionalism. Punjab, for example, has been an active champion of

transborder cooperation. The bipartisan sentiment in Amritsar has been marked

by the active pursuit of an opening to Lahore. Sikkim has long been an active

champion of deeper economic cooperation with Tibet in China. But it is Delhi’s

security establishment that appears to be resisting the case for full-fledged trade

across the Sikkim-Tibet border. The northeastern states see connectivity with

Southeast Asia as critical to their economic prosperity. While Delhi talks of the

Northeast as the gateway to Asia, it has done precious little to improve transport

infrastructure within the region over the decades. In any case, if India signs

bilateral agreements with its neighbors on connectivity and offers overland transit

to all of them, a large part of the subcontinent will automatically get integrated.

The threats to India’s peace and security environment have multiplied

enormously, just as the threat to world peace is far more somber and sinister

now. The regional and international balance

Page 76: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

76

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

of forces is menacingly hostile. The most ominous problem, the most agonizing

issue, facing India today is the nuclear option. The South Asian region was beset

by many political problems, besides the massive economic difficulties. The

legacies of suspicion, often bitterness, loomed too large to be easily dismissed.

Clearly regional cooperation could not take the form of political cooperation

forthwith. Yet, the lesson of history was equally clear. Either cooperate and

advance together or suffer separately and individually. South Asia had to find its

road towards regional cooperation that would not ignore regional realities and

would not, therefore, die premature death.

The SAARC strength and progress is determined by the member states.

Cooperation and friendly relations would bring a change develop the region. It is

very interesting that international politics is always awake for SAARC blends.

Prejudice, suspicion, hatred and discrimination in its role would destroy and

defeat all objectives. Technology sharing, facilitation of trade amongst the nation

states for economic and political development will enhance development towards

global growth. Population explosion should be controlled to speed up the process

of development. Culture, religion, social and race commonality would keep the

essence of attachment in every sphere. Any disharmony and social turbulence

would defeat any positive development. The future is in the hand of the SAARC

nations. The choice is development or to harbour anti social activities with

different ideologies.

Page 77: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

77

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

05-Feb-2018 – Question 2

River water disputes are emerging as a major source of irritation between India

and its neighbours. Identify the sources of conflicts and suggest remedial

measures. 250 words. 2015

Model Answer

India along with some other countries of Asia, are not very far from being

classified as „water scarce‟ nations, with less than 1,000 cubic metres per persons

per year being available. The situation is more or less similar for other emerging

economies of Bangladesh, China and Pakistan, who are also in a precarious

situation, and are highly susceptible to water stress in the near future. As a result,

it is often argued by many that there is a serious possibility that present water

interests/disputes and scarcity, if not resolved, could one day transform or lead

into a potential flashpoint/security risk within the Asian subcontinent.

India and Pakistan Water Conflicts/Flashpoints:

Both countries signed an accord called the Indus Waters Treaty in 1960, which

clearly determined how the region’s rivers are to be divided. In this treaty, control

over three eastern rivers of the Beas, Ravi and Sutlej was given to India, while

Pakistan got the control over western rivers of the Indus, Chenab and Jhelum.

Climate change also has begun to have a serious impact on the outflow of water

resources in Pakistan, which has more or less crippled the economy and the

society of the nation as a whole. The source or flow of all of the Pakistan’s rivers

passes through India first, so this naturally provides India with an upper hand in

controlling the outflow of these rivers. This in turn makes Pakistan more

Page 78: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

78

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

suspicious of any dam project or any activity that is carried out by India upstream

of the western rivers. Pakistan is further considering arbitration to clear out the

differences with India over dam projects which are underway on the Indus and

Jhelum River. Although, it is difficult to predict if India and Pakistan will actually

go to a war to settle their water disputes, however one thing is for certain, the

differences between the two nations related to water resources, are ultimately

making it harder for long-time rivals to put their enmity behind them.

India and China Water Conflicts/Flashpoints

China is the world‟s most prolific builders of hydropower dams, and is further the

source of ten major rivers flowing to eleven countries. Therefore, it is not

surprising that its neighbours downstream live in the constant fear that Beijing

has a tight grip on “Asia’s tight water tap”. both the countries are rapidly growing

economies, and are competing for the access to the same yet limited water

resources within the Asian subcontinent. China’s lack of usable water resources is

already causing a significant shortfall in the annual GDP, and the situation could

further worsen with the persistent economic growth, and through the negative

effects that are related to climate change within China. India on the other hand,

with a projected population of 1.4 billion by 2050, is also predicted to be “water-

scarce” roughly during the same time. With both China and India having their own

reasons to fear the increasing water shortages, conflicts in the near future

can/may take place, if such issues are not resolved at the earliest.

Page 79: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

79

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

India and Bangladesh Water Conflicts/Flashpoints

India and Bangladesh share 54 rivers between them. Despite the setting up of a

Joint River Commission for water management as early as 1972, tensions

between both the countries on how to share resources has always been a matter

of concern. The construction of the Farakka barrage in 1975 in West Bengal (close

to Indo- Bangladesh border) led to serious frictions between both the nations.

Tensions between India and Bangladesh have resurfaced once again on how to

share the water resources over the Teesta River in 2012. The Teesta River which

has its source in Sikkim, flows through the northern part of West Bengal in India,

before it enters into Bangladesh, from where it merges with the Brahmaputra

River. In 1983, an ad-hoc water sharing agreement was reached between India

and Bangladesh, whereby both countries were allocated 39 percent and 36

percent of the water flow respectively.

India and Nepal Water Conflicts/Flashpoints

The 2008 Bihar floods when the Kosi embankment near the Indo-Nepal border

broke on August 18, 2008, causing the river to change its course. It affected over

2.3 million people, destroyed 300,000 homes and 800,000 acres of cropland in

north Bihar. Going by the experts’ opinion, this tragedy was allowed to happen.

Since 1954, when the Kosi Agreement was signed between India and Nepal, talks

between the two governments have stalled and water rights issues have not been

addressed. As a result, the first dam had remained neglected for decades and a

proposed partnership for a second dam didn’t take off. Nepal, which is reeling

under poor sanitation and power blackouts every day, intends to find a place as a

Page 80: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

80

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

hydropower hub of Asia. The country is exploring opportunities to provide for its

own power needs as well as those of its neighbours.

Recommendations: Water Scarcity Situation

The United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) Water Convention

that came up in 1992 that intends to strengthen national measures for the

protection and ecologically sound management of the trans boundary surface

waters and ground waters, till 2007, has only been ratified by fifteen countries

around the world. The rest of the countries have either not taken a stand, or have

rejected this proposal completely. During the time of water scarcity, countries

around the world should instead cooperate and share, rather than compete with

each other which will benefit no one in particular. Therefore, more and more

countries ratifying this convention and becoming part of the global community in

the near future, would ultimately help everyone in their task of preserving the

limited water resources around the world. Joint programmes of water linking

projects should be launched with the cooperation of countries, which will require

minimum input of resources to be incorporated with the project, while the final

output and gains will be substantial for everyone to enjoy.

Page 81: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

81

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

07-Feb-2018 – Question 1

What are the hopes and aspirations of ‘Look East Policy’ of India? Explain. 250

words. 2016

Model Answer

India’s Look East policy is an effort to cultivate extensive economic and strategic

relations with the nations of Southeast Asia in order to bolster its standing as a

regional power. Initiated in 1991, it marked a strategic shift in India’s perspective

of the world. It was developed and enacted during the government of Prime

Minister P.V. Narasimha Rao and I K Gujral and rigorously pursued by the

successive administrations of Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Manmohan Singh.

According to Rejaul Laskar, the ‘Look East’ policy has strengthened India’s

political, economic and cultural relations with the countries of Southeast Asia and

the Pacific and has ensured that India becomes an important part of the emerging

economic and security architecture of the region.

Economic synergy

Economically, the India-ASEAN relations have acquired an unstoppable

momentum. The India-ASEAN trade has crossed $80 billion. The signing of a Free

Trade Area in goods in 2009 was a game-changer of sorts, and now the two sides

are looking to sign the India-ASEAN Free Trade Agreement on Services and

Investment. With the institutional framework in place, the two sides are now

confident of scaling the India-ASEAN trade to $200 billion by 2022.

Page 82: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

82

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Strategic Depth

India set up of an Indian mission to the ASEAN in Jakarta, and the ASEAN-India

Centre for Trade and Investment. While trade and investment remain the core of

the India-ASEAN engagement, the two sides have opened new vistas of

cooperation on cross-cutting security issues and imbued bilateral ties with the

much-needed strategic depth. The festering tensions in the South China Sea have

lent an added urgency to the strategic dimension of the relationship. With the

economies of India and the ASEAN growing and their energy needs going up,

another area that is bringing the two sides closer is the pursuit of maritime

security and enhanced cooperation in combating terrorism and piracy. India has

consistently pitched for freedom of navigation, which has received across-the-

board endorsement from ASEAN nations and East Asia. India sees the 27-member

ARF as a key regional platform for forging consensus on security issues and

evolving an inclusive regional architecture. New Delhi sees the ASEAN-India

strategic partnership as “an anchor for peace, stability and prosperity in the

region as also globally.” India has also underlined the centrality of ASEAN to

regional fora such as the East Asia Summit, the ASEAN Regional Forum, the ASEAN

Defence Ministers’ Meeting Plus and the Expanded ASEAN Maritime Forum. India

has robustly backed the creation of an ASEAN Community by 2015, the precursor

to an unfolding Asian century, the Initiative for ASEAN Integration (IAI) and the

Narrowing of the Development Gap. India has also offered more than 1100

scholarships to ASEAN countries under the Indian Technical and Economic

Cooperation (ITEC) programme.

Page 83: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

83

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Only Connect

Connectivity is the reigning mantra as India deepens its diplomatic, economic and

cultural ties with its extended neighbourhood. India has vigorously backed fast-

tracking a host of connectivity projects that will quicken regional integration and

has supported the Master Plan on ASEAN Plus Connectivity (MPAC). The Tamu-

Kalewa-Kalemyo sector of the India-Myanmar-Thailand Trilateral Highway is

progressing well. India has backed the extension of this highway to Laos,

Cambodia and Vietnam, its further linkage with ports in ASEAN countries and its

integration with models like Special Economic Zones. Enhancing connectivity to

Southeast Asia is critical to unlocking the economic energies and enterprise of

India’s north-eastern states, which border the region.

Connectivity is not just geographical and physical; what animates India’s

engagement with the region are cultural and spiritual connections, grounded in

history and a shared civilizational space. It is from India Buddhism flowed to

Southeast Asian countries, as Buddhists from all over the region flock for

pilgrimage to revered shrines Mahabodhi Temple in Bodh Gaya, the sacred place

where Lord Buddha attained enlightenment under the Bodhi tree. The revival of

Nalanda University, the ancient seat of learning, has now become a showpiece

project of ASEAN and epitomises age-old cultural and spiritual linkages between

India and Southeast Asia region. India has signed pacts with several ASEAN and

East Asian countries to make Nalanda University an international knowledge hub.

Page 84: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

84

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

The Asian Dream

Underpinning this cultural alchemy and an intricate web of rail, road and

maritime links is a soaring vision of an Asian century that is becoming increasingly

real with the ongoing shift of economic gravity from the north to the south and

the west to the east. There is a lot at stake in the flowering of the Asian dream; in

the end, it’s about surging hopes and aspirations of around 1.8 billion peop le of

India and the ASEAN region who are itching to carve their place in a changing

world. The world is in a flux, and many equations may change, but the India-

ASEAN ties will not only endure, but looks set to cross new milestones in days to

come.

Thus, India has achieved notable success in securing institutional integration with

ASEAN countries, under its Look East policy. With these regional initiatives India is

trying to penetrate the ASEAN markets by enhancing the mutual economic

benefits, transportation and infrastructural development, space science,

agriculture, information and communication technology, telecommunication,

transport, tourism and culture.

Page 85: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

85

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

07-Feb-2018 – Question 2

Discuss the factors for the decline of India’s presence in Latin America. 250

words. 2015

Model Answer

India’s relations with Latin America and the Caribbean are more recent than with

any other region of the world, for geographical and historical reasons, without

carrying any political baggage. It is a region often described as the last frontier for

India’s diplomacy, which is open for greater business with India. During the Cold

War era, the world tended to look at Latin American countries in the context of

the United States, and many countries based their policies towards the region on

that perspective. Latin America is important for India as the region boasts a

combined GDP of $4.9 trillion and is home to 600 million inhabitants, nearly half

the population of India, but with a landmass five times that of India. The region’s

economic resurgence is an unfolding story, which has made it a powerful magnet

for foreign investment from near and far. Latin America, according to a report by

Economic Commission for Latin America and Caribbean of the United Nations,

netted 179 billion dollars of FDI in 2013, the highest record for any region in the

world.

Ash Narain Roy says that the reasons for India’s limited engagements with Latin

America in the 1950s through the 1980s are not far to seek. Indira Gandhi visit in

1968 to the region was a voyage of discovery. She described her visit as an effort

to establish a ‘concord with people who are strangers to us’. Until the 1980s, the

attitude of the Indian government and private entrepreneurs was lacklustre.

Page 86: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

86

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Unfortunately, the situation was the same in Latin America if one substitutes India

for Latin America. Geographical distance, information gap and the lack of air and

shipping links were often cited as factors that came in the way of greater

economic interaction between India and Latin America.

The changes of the 1990s facilitated better interaction between the two in trade-

related matters – both sides eventually came to hype the importance of their

trade ties. Added to this, political ties also made the Indo-Latin America

relationship significant. In that context, formation of BRICS and IBSA, irrespective

of their impediments, was an appreciated effort. Ever since they were formed,

critics have questioned the achievements and projected the subsequent demise

of these ambitious initiatives. It is sufficient to note, however, that if the countries

involved achieved less than expected under BRICS and IBSA, at least they were

not harmed by being under such a grouping.

At the political level, interactions between India and LAC countries have dropped

to an all-time low. It seems evident there is an absence of real interest; the

exchange of visits has become low-profile or all but disappeared. While India’s

prime ministerial visits have gradually and substantially increased to other regions

of the world, LAC countries are the exception. Prime Minister Narendra Modi did

not undertake an official visit to any country in LAC, aside from a working visit to

Mexico in June 2016. His state visit to Fortaleza, Brazil was primarily aimed at

attending the 2014 BRICS Summit. PM Modi’s non-attendance at the Non-Aligned

Movement Summit at Venezuela last year in particular has been much discussed

in the Indian media — especially as the decision came at a time when Venezuela

needed India the most. India’s future interactions with LAC countries must

Page 87: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

87

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

downplay the differences and look into how much these far-off countries can

interact. In the past few years, there has been total neglect of the continent as a

whole — which is a huge mistake on India’s part. Even India’s trade with LAC

countries has marginally fallen, and the list of top trading countries has been

reshuffled. There has been decrease in trade volume, not only with the region as

a whole but also with the individual countries. India’s trade relations even with

regional economic groupings paints a gloomy picture.

If PM Modi’s statement at the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum is to

be believed, however South-South interactions seem to be gaining ground again.

However, there is nothing to substantiate that India will get close to latin

American countries. The BRICS joint statement did not contain any point strongly

acknowledging that India and Brazil would become close to each other — and as

we have seen, the BRICS gathering is essentially the only high-level

communication India has had with Brazil or any LAC country in the past three

years. In the past few years, both Indian and Latin American economies have

undergone a paradigm shift. If India has emerged as a global player with its

impressive economic performance, Latin America too has come out of the boom

and bust cycles in its economy and the pendulum swings in power between

civilian and military regimes. India’s growing global footprints now find place in

Latin America’s policy discussions as well. That says a lot for the future of India’s

engagement with the region. Good foreign policy requires prudence. But it also

requires boldness and imagination. That moment is knocking at India’s doors.

Page 88: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

88

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

09-Feb-2018 – Question 1

Discuss the shift of India’s foreign policy towards Pakistan in light of Pathankot

incident. 250 words. 2016

Model Answer

India’s policy towards neighbouring countries has always been that of friendship

and regional cooperation. However, response from different countries has varied.

South Asia has never been so actively engaged with the outside world, it remains

woefully disengaged internally. The central relationship of the region, between

India and Pakistan, continues to be oppressed by the weight of the past. History,

ideology, and domestic politics have fostered divisiveness. And the geopolitics has

sharpened the fault lines. Old disputes like Kashmir lurk in the background and

overlap with the new ones, raising the ever present potential for conflict.

The contours of the relationship changed dramatically with the terrorist attack on

Pathankot in January 2016 and later on the Indian Army base in Uri in Jammu and

Kashmir in September, 2016. The terrorists are believed to have infiltrated from

Pakistan. After this, boycott of the SAARC conference was followed, by news that

the Indian military had carried out a series of ‘surgical strikes’ across the Line of

Control. This was a serious departure from India’s policy of strategic restraint,

putting it in uncharted territory. The ties between the two countries never

improved since then. Cross-border fatalities and repeated violation of the

ceasefire by Pakistan have also contributed to the failure of talks between the

two sides. The dialogue of the peace process remains suspended as of now. The

pattern — first, the announcement of holding talks; next, the collapse of the

Page 89: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

89

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

initiative; and third, renewal of the initiative after an interregnum — has been all

too frequent not to realise that there is more to it than mere caprice.

The structural conditions for India-Pakistan engagement were already sub-

optimal. Weak civilian leadership in Islamabad will only add to the adverse

circumstances. New Delhi will have little choice then but to bide its time, and wait

for more propitious conditions and a stronger interlocutor in Islamabad. The

dismissal now creates further space for the Army to continue its self-defeating

policy of supporting terrorist groups against Afghanistan and India, while

becoming more dependent on political and economic support from China, to the

detriment of Pakistan’s economic potential, security, and autonomy.

In retrospect, India’s responses like boycotting the SAARC summit which was to

be held in Pakistan greatly added to India’s prestige, instead of the country being

equated with a ‘rogue state’ like Pakistan. India also won the ‘perception war’,

gaining international support and sympathy, while Pakistan was consigned to the

position of an ‘international outcast’. What is most needed today is new thinking,

rather than a mere change in style. Conventional wisdom stipulates that

conflicting nations hold talks to settle their differences. This has been the dictum

that has driven leaders of India and Pakistan till now. New thinking should begin

by reviewing and revising the current code of conduct for relations with Pakistan.

This must involve adoption of a ‘minimalist’ approach, including limiting trade

relations and restricting movement of people between the two countries. More

importantly, India must evolve a new ‘Counter Force Doctrine’. Once the situation

improves, India could consider resorting to a step-by-step normalisation process,

Page 90: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

90

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

beginning with the resumption of Track II and Track 1 1/2 dialogues, followed by a

resumption of backchannel negotiations, before proceeding to full-scale talks.

Page 91: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

91

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

09-Feb-2018 – Question 2

Sketch the leadership role of India in WTO negotiations. 200 words. 2013

Model Answer

The World Trade Organization (WTO) is the only global international organization

dealing with the rules of trade between nations. Essentially, the WTO is a place

where member governments go, to try to sort out the trade problems they face

with each other. India has consistently taken the stand that the launch of any new

round of talks depends on a full convergence of views amongst the entire WTO

membership on the scope and framework for such negotiations. Our more urgent

task is to resolve the concerns of developing countries on implementation of the

Uruguay Round agreements. We are against calls for new commitments from the

developing world for achieving symmetry and equity in the existing agreements. It

is in favour of ‘non-trade’ issues be permanently kept off the negotiating table.

Ensuring food and livelihood security is critical, particularly for a large agrarian

economy like India. India’s proposal in ongoing negotiations includes suggestions

like allowing developing countries to maintain appropriate level of tariff bindings,

commensurate with their developmental needs and the prevailing distortions in

international markets.

We are also seeking a separate safeguard mechanism including provision for

imposition of quantitative restrictions under specified circumstances, particularly

in case of a surge in imports or decline in prices; exemptions for developing

countries from obligations to provide minimum market access; exemptions of all

measures taken by developing countries for poverty alleviation, rural

Page 92: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

92

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

development and rural employment. Our immediate priority is that the

agreements reached earlier with the developing countries should be

implemented so as to correct inherent imbalances in some of the Uruguay Round

agreements. Sincere and meaningful implementation of commitments

undertaken by developed countries and operationalization of all special and

differential treatment clauses for developing countries in the various agreements

be made. We also strongly favour extension of higher levels of protection to the

geographical indications for products like Basmati rice, Darjeeling tea, and

Alphonso mangoes at par with that provided to wines and spirits under the Trade-

related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) agreement. In the TRIMS

(Agreement on Trade-Related Investment Measures) review we want flexibility

for developing countries in adopting appropriate domestic policy while permitting

foreign investment.

Developed countries are pushing for a comprehensive agenda like rules on

investment, environment, competition policy, trade facilitation, transparency in

government procurement, labour standards etc also known as the Singapore

issues. They are pressing for incorporating non-trade issues of environment and

labour standards. Using as an excuse that production of products in developing

countries are not being done under proper environment and labour standards

they can ban the imports of their products or impose other non-tariff restrictions.

The developing countries are opposed to these non-trade issues. Indian farmers

need to take advantage of the opportunity provided by the AoA, by addressing

productivity issues and making their products more competitive globally.

Page 93: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

93

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

In its negotiating proposal, India has demanded substantial reduction in tariffs,

elimination of trade-distorting domestic support and export subsidies in

developed countries. The movement of professionals {i.e., labour) from

developing countries is constrained by a number of factors such as lack of specific

sectoral commitments, lack of mutual recognition of qualifications, lack of

transparency in administration of visa regimes, discriminatory practices in use of

Economic Needs Test and social security contributions. India has, therefore,

sought liberalisation of movement of professionals through removal of these

constraints and submitted a paper for discussion at the ongoing negotiations.

To further optimize our negotiating power, the Department of Commerce should

consult all relevant stakeholders in order to make a comprehensive and balanced

assessment of the implications for India of the likely outcomes of negotiating

binding rules on the three issues. This assessment must be objective, based on

hard facts and not on merely on subjective impressions of a few influential

individuals. If the assessment so warrants, India should carefully consider re-

calibrating its position on the some issues. At the WTO India should work

assiduously to enlarge the coalition of countries that share its concerns on the

new issues. This would provide it further strength ahead.

Page 94: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

94

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

19-Feb-2018 – Question 1

Comment on India’s growing relationship with USA in the background of

constrained relations between India and China. 250 words. 2016

Model Answer

The People’s Republic of China has shaped the U.S.-India relationship since it

came into existence in 1949. Today, both India and the U.S. have relationships

with China that have elements of cooperation, competition and, potentially,

conflict—though in different degrees. Each country has a blended approach of

engaging China, while preparing for a turn for the worse in Chinese behavior. Each

sees a role for the other in its China strategy. Each thinks a good relationship with

the other sends a signal to China, but neither wants to provoke Beijing or be

forced to choose between the other and China. Each also recognizes that China—

especially uncertainty about its behavior—is partly what is driving the India-U.S.

partnership. Arguably, there have been three imperatives in the U.S. for a more

robust relationship with India and for supporting its rise: strategic interest,

especially in the context of the rise of China; economic interest; and shared

democratic values. Indian policymakers recognize that American concerns about

the nature of China’s rise are responsible for some of the interest in India. New

Delhi’s own China strategy involves strengthening India both security-wise and

economically (internal balancing) and building a range of partnerships (external

balancing)—and it envisions a key role for the U.S. in both. Some Indian

policymakers highlight another benefit of the U.S. relationship: Beijing takes Delhi

more seriously because Washington does.

Page 95: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

95

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

Power shifts have brought into sharp focus the significance of the U.S.–China–

India triangular relationship in the early twenty-first century. As China reaches out

for trade, investment, resources, markets, and bases, Beijing is also using its

burgeoning military-industrial complex to court, arm, and aid its friends and allies

to protect its overseas interests, assets, and nationals. The fact that countries

with resources, markets, and strategically located naval bases usually tend to be

the largest recipients of Chinese largesse is indicative of Beijing’s search for

potential allies. Beijing’s long-term strategy is to re-establish its dominance in Asia

and regain territories it claims as its own. Post-2008 global financial crisis, China

has turned up the volume, transitioning from “hide and bide” to “seize and lead.”

Rhetoric aside, Beijing’s “New Type of Great Power Relations” concept seeks U.S.

recognition of China’s primacy in Asia in a geopolitical deal that limits

Washington’s regional role and presence, relegates traditional U.S. allies

(especially Japan) to the sidelines, and settles disputes on China’s terms.

While Chinese leaders and diplomats still chant the mantra of “peaceful rise,”

their body language makes it clear that they expect everyone to get out of their

way. China is as determined to change the U.S.-led liberal international order as

the United States seeks to preserve it. President Xi Jinping’s “One Belt One Road”

strategy seeks to secure China’s continental and maritime interests by

simultaneously dominating the Eurasian Heartland and exploiting natural

resources for future economic growth and naval development. The South China

Sea, through which more than $5.3 trillion of maritime trade passes each year, is

now the arena of a geopolitical poker game that will determine whether the

regional future is a Pax Sinica or Pax Americana. The long-term growth of Chinese

supremacy in Asia is also contingent on having weaker and pliant states on

Page 96: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

96

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

China’s periphery. These goals invariably pit China not only against the United

States and Japan, but also against India.

When it comes to China, however, India and the U.S. must have realistic

expectations about the other. Every decision each country makes vis-à-vis China

should not be seen as a zero-sum game. India shouldn’t expect to be treated as an

ally (with all the assurances that come with that) if it isn’t one. And the U.S. has to

recognize that India is likely to maintain other partnerships in its attempt to

balance China—including one with Russia—that Washington might not like.

Finally, it is important for policymakers and analysts in both countries to keep in

mind that an India-U.S. strategic partnership solely based on China is neither

desirable nor sustainable.

Page 97: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

97

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

19-Feb-2018 – Question 2

‘EU-India relations have a long way to go before they can purposely be termed

strategic.” Discuss. 200 words. 2014

Model Answer

India-EU relations date to the early 1960s, with India being amongst the first

countries to establish diplomatic relations with the European Economic

Community. A cooperation agreement signed in 1994 took the bilateral

relationship beyond trade and economic cooperation. At the 5th India-EU Summit

at The Hague in 2004, the relationship was upgraded to a ‘Strategic Partnership’.

The two sides adopted a Joint Action Plan in 2005 (which was reviewed in 2008)

that provided for strengthening dialogue and consultation mechanisms in the

political and economic spheres, enhancing trade and investment, and bringing

peoples and cultures together. India’s past neglect of Europe was in part due to a

lack of attention and capacity. New Delhi neither understood the significance of

the European project nor mastered the technique of navigating Brussels for its

national benefit. India found it easier to focus on bilateral partnerships with key

European actors like the UK, Germany, and France with which it had historic

relations. If Europe had no powerful champion in New Delhi, Brussels too found it

rather hard to deal with the ponderous Indian bureaucratic system.

New Delhi is acutely conscious of Europe’s pole position in India’s international

economic relations as the country’s largest trading partner and biggest foreign

investor. India is also aware of Europe as a repository of scientific knowledge and

advanced technologies. The mobilization for a stronger European participation in

Page 98: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

98

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

major domestic initiatives like Make in India, Clean India, Smart Cities, and Digital

India is sought. It is to bring in European technologies to develop innovative

solutions to India’s developmental challenges. At the top of India’s priorities in

Brussels is the revival of stalled talks on an EU-India bilateral trade and

investment agreement that began in 2007. There is no great enthusiasm for trade

liberalization in India, but amid the continuing decline in the country’s absolute

trade figures since 2014, India wants to shore up its commercial relations with key

partners.

India and EU were due to resume the trade talks in 2015. But New Delhi pulled

out at the last minute when Brussels banned the sale of 700-odd pharmaceuticals

from India. Now, India is also eager to have some of the current European

restrictions on the movement of Indian professionals lifted. And he wants

Brussels to give India’s IT sector data security status, which is critical for

expanding the sector’s business in Europe. Brussels too needs Indian

professionals to boost Europe’s economic competitiveness. The EU is also seeking

better market access in India for a number of its goods, including wines and

automotive parts. There is much room here for some give-and-take. A broad

understanding between PM Modi and his European interlocutors on mutual

concessions would signal a new political commitment in both India and the EU for

a deeper commercial relationship.

Beyond the commercial arena, India will want to generate a deeper political

understanding of how to cope with the rapid breakdown of the old order on the

Eurasian landmass and the adjacent waters of the Pacific and Indian Oceans. Since

the end of the Cold War, both India and Europe have largely focused on

Page 99: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

99

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

reconstituting their domestic political economies. In terms of their regional

interests, Brussels would hardly look beyond Europe, and New Delhi was tied

down by developments in the subcontinent. The rise of China, the assertiveness

of Russia, and the temptations of retrenchment in the United States make it a lot

harder for New Delhi and Brussels to cope with the rapid change in the Middle

East and the Far East. Both India and the EU are under some compulsion to take

on larger security responsibilities in Eurasia and the Indo-Pacific. As middling

powers, New Delhi and Brussels have a greater chance of success if they

strengthen their partnership and improve bilateral strategic coordination on

regional affairs.

Page 100: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

100

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

21-Feb-2018 – Question 1

Illustrate the main causes of tension between India and China. Suggest the

possibilities of improving relationship. 200 words. 2016

Model Answer

The present relation between China and India has great uncertainty and

ambiguity as both the countries have adopted different attitude of methodology

and way of sorting the differences to emerge as regional powers mainly due to

the mutual suspicion and distrust rather due to the inheritance of issues. China

and India, the two largest developing countries in the world, share a number of

interests especially in the field of domestic development, and economic reform.

They are experiencing a period of rapid economic growth. However, both the

states are also struggling to define their role in the world given their new

profound influence on the global economy. Both promote the notion of a multi-

polar world in which they may serve as bigger players alongside the United States.

China’s strategic interests in India follows from its desire to maintain a peaceful

international environment create friendly relations with all the states and

especially with neighbors, prevent any attempt towards the formation of anti-

China blocs and finally develop new markets, investment opportunities and

resources to stimulate its economic growth. It also wants to resolve its domestic

problems in a coherent manner.

The main problem between the two countries is the Border question, which is a

historical one. The Border issue is rooted in the disputed status of the McMahon

Line, which defines the border between India and Tibet. India recognizes this

Page 101: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

101

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

agreement as the basis for its territorial claim while China objected the validity of

McMahon Line which was drawn in 1914 Simla convention because China

believes that it was not a party to Simla Convention so it is not bound to accept

the boundary demarcated by Simla convention. After the 1962 war, relationship

between China and India remained hostile for several decades. India’s grant of

statehood to Arunachal Pradesh in the late eighties (February 1987) which China

claims as a part of South Tibet caused the hostility on the bilateral relations to

such an extent that another border war seemed about to happen. China claimed

the major territorial concessions in populated areas of Arunachal Pradesh

particularly Twang because Chinese claim it to be central to Tibetan Buddhism

given that the sixth Dalai Lama was born there.

In all the times, water was regarded as a precious commodity and is essential for

human existence. That is why, its possession bestows power. The preciousness

and possession in geopolitical mechanics makes water a strategic commodity and

its role as a strategic asset or vulnerability cannot be overestimated. Thus, seen in

this context, water can become a source of both contention and cooperation in

the context of contemporary world. In case of China and India, water issues are

becoming major area of concern between two states. In fact, many strategic

thinkers are arguing that disputes relating to water will be major source of

conflict between the two countries in the future. China’s plan of constructing big

dams and diverting the water of rivers to its own advantage has discontented in

India. As there are four rivers that flow from China to India, the two countries

must have a better understanding relating to water sharing and other attending

benefits out of these rivers. However, China’s strategic advantage over these

rivers makes it possible for her to counterbalance India on many other issues.

Page 102: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

102

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

China views that India is treating Dalai Lama in India as government in exile in

Dharmsala which is just 200 miles away from China’s border. Further, the

presence of more than 1,00,000 Tibetans refugees in India and India’s continued

willingness to provide shelter to the Dalai Lama is a continued source of irritation

in China-India relations. Also China alleged that the Dalai Lama and his associates

are provoking the suicides by publicizing a “self-immolation guide” on the internet

and “openly encouraging Tibetans within Chinese border to carry out self-

immolations” against the China. China accused the Dalai Lama of being behind a

self-immolation protest by a Tibetan exile in India during the visit of Chinese

president in March 2012 and Chinese Primer in 21 May 2013.

It can be concluded that India’s long standing border dispute with China

particularly China’s claims on Arunachal Pradesh through which the river

Brahmaputra flows, comes in the way of meaningful cooperation on the water

issues. Here it can be said that border issue and water issues between both the

two states is closely interlinked with each other. In future, China is likely to use

water as a tool to pressurize India and to exact concessions on boundary

question. Thus, water will be the prime issue, apart from the border issues, that

will determine the future relations between the two largest states of the world

India and China. Besides, there life sustaining rivers coming from Tibet region of

China into India will be the major stimulant of co-operating or conflict between

the two.

Page 103: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

103

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

21-Feb-2018 – Question 2

Evaluate India’s participation in United Nations peace-keeping operations over

the years. 250 words. 2014

Model Answer

As one of the founding members of the UN, India’s contribution to the

maintenance of international peace and security has been second to none. In no

other field of activity has this been manifested more than in UN operations

commencing with our participation in the operations in Korea in 1950. The

operation in Korea, led by the USA, was a major military undertaking. India

participated militarily with a medical unit and later provided a Custodian Force for

the Neutral Nations Repatriation Commission. India also contributed significantly

to the Indo-China Supervisory Commission deployed in Cambodia, Laos and

Vietnam from 1954 to 1970. India has provided eleven force commanders and

five deputy commanders to date, and three military advisers at the Department

of Peacekeeping Operations including the first one Major General I J Rikhye; later

Lt Gen RS Mehta, and most recently, Lt Gen Guha.

India’s spontaneous and unreserved participation in UN peacekeeping operations

over the years has been a clear demonstration of the country’s commitment to

the objectives set out in the UN Charter. Not in terms of rhetoric and symbolism,

but in real and practical terms, even to the extent of accepting casualties to

personnel (about 150 fatalities to date). This commitment has been

acknowledged by the international community, successive Secretaries General

and the United Nations Secretariat. But even more significantly, the effectiveness

Page 104: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

104

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

of such participation and commitment to United Nations peacekeeping efforts has

drawn respect and praise from fellow professionals of other countries and many

others that have served jointly with our commanders, observers, police monitors

and contingents, in various parts of the world. Hence, the image of the Indian

forces in the international arena is that of highly competent and well-trained

professionals.

In preparing ourselves for continued participation in United Nations peacekeeping

operations, it would be appropriate to take stock of the changes that have taken

place in the environment in which such operations are being increasingly

mounted in recent years, and the manner in which they are being executed and

take into account the radical changes in the nature of the peacekeeping

commitment. UN peacekeepers are increasingly being sent to regions where civil-

war type situations prevail; where there are no agreements, or if there are, these

are rather tenuous, or broken without compunction; where the consent or

cooperation of the belligerent parties cannot be relied upon; where constitutional

authority does not exist in many cases, or if it does, has limited authority. In such

situations, today’s peacekeepers are not only required to keep the warring parties

apart to the extent they can, but are increasingly called upon to safeguard

humanitarian relief operations, monitor human rights violations, assist in mine

clearance, monitor state boundaries or borders, provide civilian police support,

assist in rebuilding logistics infrastructure like roads, railways, bridges, and to

support electoral processes. In much of this the Indian Armed Forces have

practical experience based on the conduct of counter insurgency operations in

some parts of our own country and thus have a marked advantage over most

other forces from other parts of the world. This was more than amply

Page 105: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

105

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

demonstrated by the performance of our contingents in Cambodia, Somalia,

Mozambique, Angola, Rwanda and Sierra Leone. And continues to be

demonstrated by the contingents deployed in the Congo, South Sudan, and in

Lebanon.

It was therefore most appropriate that in order to exploit our expertise and

experience in this arena, a Centre for United Nations Peacekeeping was set up in

September 2000 under the aegis of the United Service Institution of India in New

Delhi, with the support of the Ministry of External Affairs of the Government of

India. This Centre besides overseeing the training of contingents earmarked for

peacekeeping operations, has undertaken conduct of training courses for our sub-

unit commanders, military observers, officers earmarked for deputation on staff

appointments, and police personnel. These courses, now formally endorsed by

the Department of Peacekeeping Operations at UN HQ, are also being attended

by officers from a number of friendly foreign countries. In addition, the Centre

conducts national and international seminars and conferences on the subject of

peacekeeping. As it matures, the Centre will also be a repository of our

experiences in United Nations peacekeeping.

Page 106: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

106

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

23-Feb-2018 – Question 1

Critically analyze India’s nuclear policy. 200 words. 2016

Model Answer

India’s nuclear doctrine is an important variable determining nuclear stability in

South Asia, especially because the doctrine is generally considered to be

restrained. So any indication of change in the doctrine is a cause for concern.

Though there continue to be significant disagreements within the Indian strategic

community about many elements of nuclear doctrine, the debate has stagnated,

and no longer produces new ideas about how to deal with the most pressing

dilemma that New Delhi faces: countering Pakistan’s tactical nuclear weapons

(TNWs). India might need to shift its massive retaliation nuclear strategy to some

form of modulated retaliation to deal with this challenge.

India released its Draft Nuclear Doctrine (DND) in August 1999. The DND was

prepared by the semi-official National Security Advisory Board (NSAB) and was

quickly disowned by the Indian government, though many details of the DND

faithfully followed previous government statements, including authoritative

statements in parliament regarding credible minimum deterrence and NFU. In

January 2003, New Delhi released its official nuclear doctrine. The official doctrine

itself was based on the DND, though there were also some differences. These

included suggesting that India might use nuclear weapons to retaliate against

attacks using chemical and biological weapons (CBW), and that Indian retaliation

to any nuclear attack would be massive. In a speech in 2010, the then national

security adviser, Shivshankar Menon, stated that India’s doctrine is “no first use

Page 107: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

107

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

against non-nuclear weapon states,” implying that NFU does not apply to nuclear-

armed powers. Though Menon’s remarks created some controversy, they appear

to have been an inadvertent error—such a formulation has not been reiterated

subsequently. In April 2013, a few additional details about the nuclear doctrine

were outlined in a speech by Shyam Saran, the head of the NSAB, in a speech in

New Delhi. Saran explicitly stated that the “views” he was sharing were his own

and not those of the government, but he did reveal details about the

management of India’s nuclear forces that were not in the public realm, so his

speech can be considered an unofficial elaboration of the details of India’s nuclear

doctrine. He outlined the makeup of the Strategic Programme Staff, which carries

out the general staff work of the NCA, and of the Strategic Armament Safety

Authority, which looks after the safety and security aspects of nuclear weapons.

In March 2012, a nonofficial task force of strategic analysts, put together by the

Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies in New Delhi, also produced an alternate

nuclear doctrine for India, which largely stuck to the principles of the official

doctrine, with the exception of rejecting the characterization of “massive” to refer

to retaliation to any nuclear attack on India, preferring the characterization of

“punitive” that was used in the DND.

There is a near consensus in the Indian strategic community that India’s nuclear

doctrine needs to be periodically reexamined. There is also a consensus that the

Indian government needs to release more information about its nuclear doctrine

and policy, both in order to deter adversaries and so that Indian public debate is

better informed. This does not mean, however, that everyone in the strategic

community agrees that the doctrine needs to be revised. At the least, there is no

consensus about the direction any revision would take. Though there has been

Page 108: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

108

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

significant debate and disagreement about the advisability of India’s NFU policy,

the dominant opinion is still that India should maintain it. To the extent that there

is a desire to change the NFU, moderates would like to reorient the doctrine more

in the direction of the DND and abandon some of the expansion that the official

doctrine introduced, such as nuclear retaliation for CBW attacks and references to

massive retaliation. Expansionists, on the other hand, would prefer abandoning

the NFU altogether and retaining a much more flexible approach toward nuclear

force expansion.

On the issue of tactical weapons, though there has been disquiet about Pakistan’s

TNWs and their impact on India’s conventional war options, the predominant

opinion appears to be that there is no need for India to consider any change to its

doctrine. This reflects the fact that New Delhi has few realistic alternatives

available for dealing with Pakistan’s TNWs. Ultimately, these public doctrinal

debates might not be particularly important in keying changes to India’s nuclear

doctrine. As Vipin Narang has pointed out, India might drift toward a much more

aggressive nuclear doctrine simply because the country’s political leadership does

not pay sufficient attention to the military and defense scientific bureaucracies.

The effect of these debates on India’s official policy is difficult to predict. On one

hand, it appears as if the Indian government was indeed responding to public

criticism when it released the official doctrine in 2003. On the other hand, despite

several years of vigorous debate, there is little public indication that there is any

effort at the official level to respond to criticisms from either the moderates or

the expansionists. While it is unlikely that the Indian government will radically

alter its existing nuclear doctrine, it is possible that it might release a new edition

of the nuclear doctrine, given the strong consensus among India’s strategic elite

Page 109: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

109

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

about the need for periodic review and the need for the release of more

information about the nuclear doctrine. If a new edition of the doctrine does

come out, it will hopefully correct some of the errors and contradictions in the

previous edition, thereby strengthening the doctrine as a whole.

Page 110: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

110

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

23-Feb-2018 – Question 2

Explain the socio-economic impacts of arms race and identify the obstacles in

the way of disarmament. 250 words. 2016

Model Answer

Today the social and economic problems of disarmament assume special

topicality. Not only the increased material resources annually used for non-

productive aims, but also the growing acuteness of food, raw material and energy

problems, the aggravation of the world ecological situation, the unsatisfied social

and economic needs of the majority of the world population, the prospects of

development of new, more formidable types of mass destruction weapons, etc.

On the other hand, encouraging prospects have opened up in connection with the

development of the process of detente, which has already led to considerable

changes in the entire system of international relations. Within the process of the

deepening of detente new opportunities appear for arriving at agreements

limiting armaments and leading to disarmament. The treatment of the problems

of stopping the nuclear arms race, nuclear disarmament, the limitation of the use

of science for military purposes and particularly the banning of the development

of new weapons of mass destruction, regional measures of military detente, the

reduction of conventional armaments, armed forces and military budgets reflects

conviction in the necessity of carrying out effective disarmament measures.

Effects of the arms race can be divided into several subcategories. An

indispensable correlate of the arms race is the emergence of military- industrial

complexes (MIC) with considerable power in society. Extensive literature dealing

Page 111: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

111

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

with the MICs was to a large extent a counter-reaction to earlier Western

literature that had devoted scant attention to the structural preconditions and

consequences of the armaments race, and was by character rather individualizing.

The impact of disarmament measures has usually been considered from the

conversion perspective which, in turn, is connected with the problem of

opportunity costs. The possibilities of converting resources used for military

purposes to civilian uses has been analysed, not only by the input-output method,

but also in case studies on either specific industries strongly dependent on

military contracts, or communities affected by such events as the closure of

military bases. The doctrine that military spending is necessary for the growth,

stability and continued functioning of these economies gains no strong support

nowadays. Economic and Social Consequences of Disarmament submitted to the

General Assembly in 1962, for example, concluded that “all the problems and

difficulties of transition connected with disarmament could be met by appropriate

national and international measures. There should thus be no doubt that the

diversion to peaceful purposes of the resources now in military use could be

accomplished to the benefit of all countries and lead to the improvement of world

economic and social conditions. The achievement of general and complete

disarmament would be an unqualified blessing to all mankind”.

Thus, the conversion of resources used for military purposes is believed to be a

feasible option, although some reservations to this generalization have been

made. process not working in certain firms, mostly United States based, which are

very dependent on military production – especially aircraft companies which

have attempted the transition to civilian production. This underlines the need for

governmental subsidy in such cases, but also in the conversion process in general.

Page 112: 90 Days UPSC Mains Optional Answer Writing Initiative · 2019-02-28 · a discipline. It appeared as if politics is a dependent variable of society. If that was to be the case, political

112

NeoStencil – Live Online Classes - IAS/IES/GATE/SSC/PSC | +91 95990 75552 | [email protected]

This support, however, is a controversial issue, as it would mean increasing State

interference in economic life; this is not universally favoured in market economy

countries.

Furthermore, there are significant differences between the phases in which

military spending was a predominantly domestic phenomenon and those in which

the activities of the military establishment and military industries have become

trans-nationalized. These broad examples indicate, firstly, that a dynamic view of

the economic and social consequences of the arms race and disarmament is

needed and, secondly, that these two different, but related aspects of

militarization must be explored in close connection to each other. Thirdly, the

approach to the economic and social consequences of the arms race and

disarmament should be sufficiently comprehensive. More emphasis has been

placed on the strategic, political and legal factors affecting the future of

disarmament and arms control. also involves linking the future military order of

the world (by implication one of disarmament) with the New International

Economic Order (NIEO). It is no exaggeration to say that the present military order

of the world is a considerable obstacle to the realization of NIEO. In the same vein

we would say that disarmament would contribute, in some cases, perhaps only

marginally, to carrying out, e. g. Unesco’s tasks in the NIEO context. These tasks

are, according to the Director-General of Unesco, autonomy in science and

technology, the promotion of cultural identity and the fight against poverty.