9 - 2014 ITL Problem Class #9 Lawyer Lynn.docx

1
Problem Class #9 “Lawyer Lynn” Lawyer Lynn is representing Plaintiff in a civil jury trail. During the trial, Lynn has reacted with eye-rolling, grimaces, and other negative facial expressions and gestures whenever the judge rules adversely to her. These expressions and gestures are visible to the jury, disrespectful, and disruptive. The judge has, on his own initiative, and upon motion of opposing counsel, admonished Lynn both in camera and in front of the jury, to stop. After these admonishments, Lynn will temporarily comply, but will then begin gesturing again when a ruling by the judge provokes her. You represent Defendant in this case. 1. What should you do? A. File an appropriate motion with the Court asking that more serious sanctions be imposed on Lawyer Lynn. B. Have a private conversation with Lawyer Lynn and try to convince her to stop. C. Report Lynn to the local Bar panel that reviews charges of unprofessional conduct. D. File a Florida Bar grievance seeking formal disciplinary sanction against Lynn. E. None of the above. If you choose this option, you must indicate what you would do.

Transcript of 9 - 2014 ITL Problem Class #9 Lawyer Lynn.docx

ProblemClass #9 Lawyer Lynn

Lawyer Lynn is representing Plaintiff in a civil jury trail. During the trial, Lynn has reacted with eye-rolling, grimaces, and other negative facial expressions and gestures whenever the judge rules adversely to her. These expressions and gestures are visible to the jury, disrespectful, and disruptive. The judge has, on his own initiative, and upon motion of opposing counsel, admonished Lynn both in camera and in front of the jury, to stop. After these admonishments, Lynn will temporarily comply, but will then begin gesturing again when a ruling by the judge provokes her. You represent Defendant in this case.

1.What should you do?

A.File an appropriate motion with the Court asking that more serious sanctions be imposed on Lawyer Lynn.B.Have a private conversation with Lawyer Lynn and try to convince her to stop.C.Report Lynn to the local Bar panel that reviews charges of unprofessional conduct. D.File a Florida Bar grievance seeking formal disciplinary sanction against Lynn.E.None of the above. If you choose this option, you must indicate what you would do.