8 Shades of Truth

3/13/2015 Eight shades of truth | Inquirer Opinion

http://opinion.inquirer.net/83262/eight-shades-of-truth 1/6

SHARES

PUBLIC LIVES

Eight shades of truth12:09 AM | Thursday, March 12th, 2015Randy David

@inquirerdotnetPhilippine Daily Inquirer

A+AA-

Eight separate investigations have been launched to determine the truth behind the Mamasapano

incident. They are likely to produce eight shades of truth, rather than one. This should not pose

any problemexcept to those who think of the truth as if it were something out there, waiting to

be ferreted out. As I said in a previous column, I favor the pragmatist concept of truth as

something that is made or constructed for a specific purpose.

There is only one Mamasapano incident, but many ways of looking at it. Some investigations, in

their aspiration to produce the definitive account of what happened, may attempt to be as

comprehensive as they can by focusing on a broad range of topics. But, rather than create a more

complete picture, this attempt to aggregate different observational standpoints into a single vision

may only bring out more blind spots.

So much expectation, for instance, has attended the much-awaited report on Mamasapano by the

Philippine National Polices board of inquiry (BOI). This heightens the temptation to cover all the

questions that have been raised by various sectors of the public. The BOI would be well advised to

avoid this pitfall by not thinking of itself as a truth commission. Its task, to my mind, is far

narrower in scope: to review what happened from the perspective of the PNPs mandate, norms,

procedures and tactical protocols. It may draw lessons and recommend sanctions specific to the

work of the police as an organization. But it is not its business to pronounce itself on political,

legal, or policy questions that are outside its area of competence.

March 1

Bail n

Therepeace



Legal questions properly belong to the Department of Justice, which is conducting a separate

investigation. It is the DOJs function to determine the facts from a legal perspective, to ask what

laws have been violated and by whom, and to file the appropriate charges. On the other hand, the

investigation by the Commission on Human Rights looks specifically at possible violations of

human rights standards and protocols that may have been committed by both state and nonstate

actors. Apart from recommending the filing of charges, its main interest would be to formulate

measures aimed at preventing the future occurrence of such abuses.

On top of these, the two chambers of Congress, as we know, initiated their own separate inquiries

into this incident. The Senate completed its hearings, but the House, probably sensing its inability

to rationalize its deliberations after one hearing, decided to suspend its investigation. These are

supposed to be hearings in aid of legislationmeaning, their conduct is meant to guide the

crafting or revision of laws and existing policies, not to determine guilt or assign culpability. But,

given that the Senate and the House are autonomous political bodies, with a pronounced

inclination to liberally interpret their oversight function, it is not easy in practice to delimit the

scope of their inquiries. Not surprisingly, these sessions often take on the character of police

investigations or of courtroom trials.

Interestingly, the Moro Islamic Liberation Front launched its own investigation of the

Mamasapano encounter in the light of the fact that a large number of its troops had participated

in that firefight. The MILF is struggling to maintain its credibility as a partner in a protracted peace

process that is about to bear fruit. Its main interest, I imagine, would be to determine how the

misencounter happened, which of its local commands were drawn into it, why, and what

violations, if any, were committed by the various combatants in that unfortunate encounter. The

results of the investigation may lead the MILF to sanction some of its warriors if only to show that

it is in control of its troops. But, I dont think it will agree to hand them over to the Philippine

government for prosecution.

Separate reports, we are told, are also being prepared by the Armed Forces of the Philippines and

the International Monitoring Team (IMT) on the Peace Process. The AFP investigation will surely

highlight the circumstances surrounding its inability to respond in a timely manner to the

desperate pleas for reinforcement from the beleaguered Special Action Force troops. It will likely

focus on the protocols governing the conduct of various types of military operations, as a way of

showing the impossibility of acceding to the SAF request without the benefit of prior coordination.

Finally, the IMT report will probably zero in on the existing ceasefire agreement, how it was

broken, and why it took time to restore it once it was breached at Mamasapano. It may focus on

the complexities of managing the fragile conditions of peace in conflict situations, and draw

lessons on what it would take to prevent more bloodshed from endangering the ongoing peace

process. This kind of truth is no less important, but it may not merit much attention from those

who are far from the field of battle.

To these eight shades of truth, one may now add President Aquinos ownstill a shade of gray to

many, even after three speeches, because of its ambivalences and glosses. His third speech on

the matter (which came as a lengthy reply to a question from the audience at a gathering of

Christian evangelical church leaders in Malacaang), adds the least clarity to what has remained

very much a clouded issue. The President seemed torn between taking ultimate responsibility for

Pinoy Kasi

March 12, 2015

Role model

Eight shades of truth



what government does or fails to do, and protecting himself from criminal liability. In any event, itwas awkward to hear the Commander in Chief heap all the blame on a single police officer forlapses committed in a mission that he, the President himself, had reviewed and authorized.

* * *

[email protected]

More Stories

Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Tags: board of inquiry Department of Justice Mamasapano

Moro Islamic Liberation Front Philippine National Police

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management

and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our

editorial standards.

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro

Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic

ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati

City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94

March 10, 2015

2014S MOST-PLAYED RADIOARTIST JASON DERULORETURNS WITH NEW SINGLE,WANT TO WANT ME

February 23, 2015

Jazz Festival features RoseFostanes

February 11, 2015

Dine in style and win aromantic getaway withBuddha-Bar ManilasValentines Special 2015 Promo

Aide betrayedMarwan

George Clooneyswife urges UN to act...

Ampatuan out on bail Binay, son face graftraps



February 04, 2015

New Short FROZEN FEVER To

Open In Theaters in Front of

CINDERELLA on March 13,

2015

MY SUNSHINE BY REUBY

DEBUT SINGLE FROM

SINGAPORES BRIGHTEST NEW

SINGER-SONGWRITER

DOMINATES ITUNES

SINGAPORES #1 SPOT ON

NATIONAL DAY



THE INQUIRER SERVICES THE INQUIRER FOLLOW PARTNERS



CHANNELS

News

Sports

Entertainment

Lifestyle

Technology

Business

Opinion

Global Nation

Sitemap

Mobile

RSS

Wireless

Archive

Movies

Contact Us

Advertise

News Letter

Job Openings

COMPANY

About INQUIRER.net

About the INQUIRER

User Agreement

Link Policy

Privacy Policy

Article Index

Copyright 1997-2015 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved

8 Shades of Truth

Documents

Transcript of 8 Shades of Truth