7th Circuit Same Sex Marriage

8/11/2019 7th Circuit Same Sex Marriage

1/40

!" $%&

'"($&) *$+$&, -./0$ .1 233&+4,5.0 $%& *&6&"$% -(07/($

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,

/01234# 105 60782#9!" $%&9

'%$()"(**+,-..!%%!!+9

/&

:5##4 6;


2/40

* #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

01 :;7#519 U23320/79 ?FH X0/23Q;#9 2(785(" 4516!+&

:;7#519 2(785(" 4516!& 2FHG?F? ?FH UG%J$F%GF ?B> ?C$FY

.D> %DBGFZGFY C?[$BG.\ $A %.?.>% .D?. H$ F$. B>J$YFG]> .D> M?)

@GHG.\ $A %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>%9 _D>.D>B J$F.B?J.>H GF .D>%>

%.?.>% $B GF %.?.>% `$B A$B>GYF J$LF.BG>%a _D>B> .D>\ ?B> @?_)

AL@& QD> %.?.>% D?M> ?==>?@>H AB$C HG%.BGJ. J$LB. H>JG%G$F%

GFM?@GH?.GFY .D> %.?.>%b @?_% .D?. $BH?GF %LJD B>AL%?@&

V$BC?@@\ .D>%> J?%>% ?B> ?W$L. HG%JBGCGF?.G$F ?Y?GF%. .D>

%C?@@ D$C$%>^L?@ CGF$BG.\ GF .D> EFG.>H 7.?.>%& 6L. ?. ?

H>>=>B @>M>@9 ?% _> %D?@@ %>>9 .D>\ ?B> ?W$L. .D> _>@A?B> $A

0C>BGJ?F JDG@HB>F& QD> ?BYLC>F. .D?. .D> %.?.>% =B>%% D?BH)

>%. GF H>A>F%> $A .D>GB =B$DGWG.G$F $A %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> G%

.D?. .D> $F@\ B>?%$F Y$M>BFC>F. >FJ$LB?Y>% C?BBG?Y> G% .$

GFHLJ> D>.>B$%>^L?@% .$ C?BB\ %$ .D?. .D>B> _G@@ W> A>_>B

c?JJGH>F.?@ WGB.D%9d _DGJD _D>F .D>\ $JJLB $L.%GH> $A C?B)

BG?Y> $A.>F @>?H .$ ?W?FH$FC>F. $A .D> JDG@H .$ .D> C$.D>B

`LF?GH>H W\ .D> A?.D>Ba $B .$ A$%.>B J?B>& ;M>B@$$Z>H W\ .DG%?BYLC>F. G% .D?. C?F\ $A .D$%> ?W?FH$F>H JDG@HB>F ?B>

?H$=.>H W\ D$C$%>^L?@ J$L=@>%9 ?FH .D$%> JDG@HB>F _$L@H

W> W>..>B $AA W$.D >C$.G$F?@@\ ?FH >J$F$CGJ?@@\ GA .D>GB

?H$=.GM> =?B>F.% _>B> C?BBG>H&

U> ?B> CGFHAL@ $A .D> 7L=B>C> K$LB.b% GF%G%.>FJ> .D?.

c_D>.D>B >CW$HG>H GF .D> V$LB.>>F.D 0C>FHC>F. $B GF)

A>BB>H AB$C .D> VGA.D9 >eL?@ =B$.>J.G$F G% F$. ? @GJ>F%> A$B

J$LB.% .$ [LHY> .D> _G%H$C9 A?GBF>%%9 $B @$YGJ $A @>YG%@?.GM>

JD$GJ>%& 2F ?B>?% $A %$JG?@ ?FH >J$F$CGJ =$@GJ\9 ? %.?.L.$B\J@?%%GAGJ?.G$F .D?. F>G.D>B =B$J>>H% $%9)6 +5+.!8" %()!+F$B GF)

ABGFY>% ALFH?C>F.?@ J$F%.G.L.G$F?@ BGYD.% CL%. W> L=D>@H

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


3/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- +

?Y?GF%. >eL?@ =B$.>J.G$F JD?@@>FY> GA .D>B> G% ?F\ B>?%$F?W@\

J$FJ>GM?W@> %.?.> $A A?J.% .D?. J$L@H =B$MGH> ? B?.G$F?@ W?%G%

A$B .D> J@?%%GAGJ?.G$F&d :22 /& ;!$83 29


4/40

( #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

9* 2$%(*97)($ /& ;$CC!9 (+, E&7& *-P9 +-Oi-* `'gf,ah J"& 493)K+

I)("!1 235783 9* 237(+" /& 2("E 9* 23(8$699 PO* V&+H -'-9 -+,

`f.D KGB& *OOfah @(%C()+ /& G$11E9 f+( V&+H +((9 +(, `(.D KGB&

*O'+ah G$%%$63!7 /& 2("E 9* 2%$E"9)9 -gg V&+H 'O'+9 'O',i'g `,.D

KGB& *O'*a& QD>%> JGBJLC%.?FJ>% JB>?.> ? =B>%LC=.G$F .D?.

.D> HG%JBGCGF?.G$F G% ? H>FG?@ $A .D> >eL?@ =B$.>J.G$F $A .D>

@?_% `G. C?\ MG$@?.> $.D>B =B$MG%G$F% $A .D> K$F%.G.L.G$F ?%

_>@@9 WL. _> _$Fb. D?M> .$ J$F%GH>B .D?. =$%%GWG@G.\a& QD>

=B>%LC=.G$F G% B>WL..?W@>9 GA ?. ?@@9 $F@\ W\ ? J$C=>@@GFY

%D$_GFY .D?. .D> W>F>AG.% $A .D> HG%JBGCGF?.G$F .$ %$JG>.\ ?% ?

_D$@> J@>?B@\ $L._>GYD .D> D?BC% .$ G.% MGJ.GC%& 7>>9 >&Y&9G75""!7 /& ;9%%()6!79 P+g E&7& +O-9 +*-i*f `*OO+ah I)("!1 J"$"!+

/& ?(76()($9 P', E&7& P'P9 P+'i++ `'gg-a&

QD> ?==B$?JD G% %.B?GYD.A$B_?BH WL. J$C>% _B?==>H9 GF

C?F\ $A .D> H>JG%G$F% ?==@\GFY G.9 GF ? A$BCGH?W@> H$J.BGF?@

.>BCGF$@$Y\S.D> .>BCGF$@$Y\ $A B?.G$F?@ W?%G%9 $A %.BGJ.9

D>GYD.>F>H9 ?FH GF.>BC>HG?.> %JBL.GF\9 $A F?BB$_ .?G@$BGFY9

ALFH?C>F.?@ BGYD.%9 ?FH .D> B>%.& U>b@@ W> GFM$ZGFY GF =@?J>%

.D> J$FJ>=.L?@ ?==?B?.L% .D?. D?% YB$_F L= ?B$LFH .DG%

.>BCGF$@$Y\9 WL. $LB C?GF A$JL% _G@@ W> $F .D> %.?.>%b ?BYL)C>F.%9 _DGJD ?B> W?%>H @?BY>@\ $F .D> ?%%>B.G$F .D?. W?FFGFY

%?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> G% [L%.GAG>H W\ .D> %.?.>b% GF.>B>%. GF JD?F)

F>@GFY =B$JB>?.GM> %>^ GF.$ `F>J>%%?BG@\ D>.>B$%>^L?@a C?B)

BG?Y>& U> _G@@ >FY?Y> .D> %.?.>%b ?BYLC>F.% $F .D>GB $_F

.>BC%9 >F?W@GFY L% .$ H>JGH> $LB WB?J> $A J?%>% $F .D> W?%G%

$A ? %>eL>FJ> $A A$LB eL>%.G$F%N

'& I$>% .D> JD?@@>FY>H =B?J.GJ> GFM$@M> HG%JBGCGF?.G$F9

B$$.>H GF ? DG%.$B\ $A =B>[LHGJ>9 ?Y?GF%. %$C> GH>F.GAG?W@>

YB$L= $A =>B%$F%9 B>%[email protected] GF LF>eL?@ .B>?.C>F. D?BCAL@ .$.D>Cj

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


5/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- P

*& 2% .D> LF>eL?@ .B>?.C>F. W?%>H $F %$C> GCCL.?W@> $B

?. @>?%. .>F?JG$L% JD?B?J.>BG%.GJ $A .D> =>$=@> HG%JBGCGF?.>H

?Y?GF%. `WG$@$YGJ?@9 %LJD ?% %ZGF J$@$B9 $B ? H>>= =%\JD$@$YG)

J?@ J$CCG.C>F.9 ?% B>@GYG$L% W>@G>A $A.>F G%9 W$.D .\=>% W>GFY

HG%.GFJ. AB$C JD?B?J.>BG%.GJ% .D?. ?B> >?%\ A$B ? =>B%$F .$

JD?FY>9 %LJD ?% .D> @>FY.D $A DG% $B D>B AGFY>BF?G@%aj QD>

JD?B?J.>BG%.GJ CL%. W> $F> .D?. G%Fb. B>@>M?F. .$ ? =>B%$Fb%

?WG@G.\ .$ =?B.GJG=?.> GF %$JG>.\& 2F.>@@>J.9 A$B >^?C=@>9 D?% ?

@?BY> GCCL.?W@> J$C=$F>F. WL. ?@%$ ? HGB>J. ?FH %LW%.?F.G?@

W>?BGFY $F eL?@GAGJ?.G$F% A$B J>B.?GF .\=>% $A >C=@$\C>F.

?FH A$B @>Y?@ =BGMG@>Y>% %LJD ?% >F.G.@>C>F. .$ ? HBGM>Bb% @G)J>F%>9 ?FH .D>B> C?\ W> F$ B>?%$F .$ W> =?B.GJL@?B@\ %L%=G)

JG$L% $A ? %.?.L.> .D?. J@?%%GAG>% $F .D?. W?%G%&

+& I$>% .D> HG%JBGCGF?.G$F9 >M>F GA W?%>H $F ?F GCCL.?)

W@> JD?B?J.>BG%.GJ9 F>M>B.D>@>%% J$FA>B ?F GC=$B.?F. $AA%>..GFY

W>F>AG. $F %$JG>.\ ?% ? _D$@>j 0Y> G% ?F GCCL.?W@> JD?B?J)

.>BG%.GJ9 WL. ? BL@> =B$DGWG.GFY =>B%$F% $M>B fO .$ =G@$. ?GB@GF)

>B% CGYD. B>?%$F?W@\ W> .D$LYD. .$ J$FA>B ?F >%%>F.G?@ W>F>)

AG. GF .D> A$BC $A GC=B$M>H ?GB@GF> %?A>.\&

(& QD$LYD G. H$>% J$FA>B ?F $AA%>..GFY W>F>AG.9 G% .D> HG%)JBGCGF?.$B\ =$@GJ\ $M>BGFJ@L%GM> W>J?L%> .D> W>F>AG. G. J$F)

A>B% $F %$JG>.\ J$L@H W> ?JDG>M>H GF ? _?\ @>%% D?BCAL@ .$

.D> HG%JBGCGF?.>H)?Y?GF%. YB$L=9 $B LFH>BGFJ@L%GM> W>J?L%>

.D> Y$M>BFC>F.b% =LB=$B.>H B?.G$F?@> A$B .D> =$@GJ\ GC=@G>%

.D?. G. %D$L@H >eL?@@\ ?==@\ .$ $.D>B YB$L=% ?% _>@@j ;F>

_?\ .$ H>JGH> _D>.D>B ? =$@GJ\ G% $M>BGFJ@L%GM> G% .$ ?%Z

_D>.D>B LF>eL?@ .B>?.C>F. G% !++!)"($% .$ ?..?GFGFY .D> H>)

%GB>H W>F>AG.& 2C?YGF> ? %.?.L.> .D?. GC=$%>% ? k* .?^ $F

_$C>F WL. F$. C>F& QD> =B$J>>H% AB$C .D?. .?^ ?B>9 @>.b%?%%LC>9 >%%>F.G?@ .$ .D> >AAGJG>F. $=>B?.G$F $A Y$M>BFC>F.&

QD> .?^ G% .D>B>A$B> %$JG?@@\ >AAGJG>F.9 ?FH .D> W>F>AG.% J@>?B@\

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


6/40

- #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

$L._>GYD .D> J$%.%& 6L. .D?.b% F$. .D> >FH $A .D> GFeLGB\& 7.G@@

.$ W> H>.>BCGF>H G% _D>.D>B .D> W>F>AG.% AB$C GC=$%GFY .D>

.?^ 9)%E 9) A9GYD .D> J$%.%& 0FH @GZ>_G%> GF ?

%?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> J?%> .D> G%%L> G% F$. _D>.D>B D>.>B$%>^L?@

C?BBG?Y> G% ? %$JG?@@\ W>F>AGJG?@ GF%.G.L.G$F WL. _D>.D>B .D>

W>F>AG.% .$ .D> %.?.> AB$C HG%JBGCGF?.GFY ?Y?GF%. %?C>)%>^

J$L=@>% J@>?B@\ $L._>GYD .D> D?BC% .D?. .DG% HG%JBGCGF?.G$F

GC=$%>%&

;LB eL>%.G$F% Y$ .$ .D> D>?B. $A >eL?@ =B$.>J.G$F H$J)

.BGF>& lL>%.G$F% ' ?FH * ?B> J$F%G%.>F. _G.D .D> M?BG$L% A$B)

CL@?% A$B _D?. >F.G.@>% ? HG%JBGCGF?.>H)?Y?GF%. YB$L= .$

D>GYD.>F>H %JBL.GF\ $A .D> HG%JBGCGF?.G$F9 ?FH eL>%.G$F% +

?FH ( J?=.LB> .D> >%%>FJ> $A .D> 7L=B>C> K$LB.b% ?==B$?JD

GF D>GYD.>F>H)%JBL.GF\ J?%>%N cQ$ %LJJ>>H9 .D> H>A>FH>B $A

.D> JD?@@>FY>H ?J.G$F CL%. %D$_ m?. @>?%. .D?. .D> J@?%%GAGJ?)

.G$F %>BM>% GC=$B.?F. Y$M>BFC>F.?@ $W[>J.GM>% ?FH .D?. .D>

HG%JBGCGF?.$B\ C>?F% >C=@$\>H ?B> %LW%.?F.G?@@\ B>@?.>H .$

.D> ?JDG>M>C>F. $A .D$%> $W[>J.GM>%&bd I)("!1 J"$"!+ /& ?(76(),

($9 +5.7$9 P', E&7& ?. P*( `'gg-a9 eL$.GFYL(++(++(..( I)(/!7+("E

*97 @9 HGAA>B>FJ> W>._>>F .D> ?==B$?JD _> .?Z> GF .D>%>

._$ J?%>% ?FH .D> C$B> J$FM>F.G$F?@ ?==B$?JD G% %>C?F.GJ

B?.D>B .D?F %LW%.?F.GM>& QD> J$FM>F.G$F?@ ?==B$?JD H$>%Fb.

=LB=$B. .$ W?@?FJ> .D> J$%.% ?FH W>F>AG.% $A .D> JD?@@>FY>H

HG%JBGCGF?.$B\ @?_& 2F%.>?H G. >M?@L?.>% .D> GC=$B.?FJ> $A

.D> %.?.>b% $W[>J.GM> GF >F?J.GFY .D> @?_ ?FH .D> >^.>F. .$

_DGJD .D> @?_ G% %LG.>H `c.?G@$B>Hda .$ ?JDG>MGFY .D?. $W[>J)

.GM>& 2. ?%Z% _D>.D>B .D> %.?.L.> ?J.L?@@\ ALB.D>B% .D> GF.>B>%.

.D?. .D> %.?.> ?%%>B.% ?FH _D>.D>B .D>B> CGYD. W> %$C> @>%%WLBH>F%$C> ?@.>BF?.GM>& QD> ?F?@\%G% .DL% A$JL%>% F$. $F

cJ$%.%d ?FH cW>F>AG.%d ?% %LJD9 WL. $F cAG.&d QD?. G% _D\ .D>

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


7/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- f

WBG>A% GF .D>%> ._$ J?%>% $M>BA@$_ _G.D H>W?.> $M>B _D>.D>B

=B$DGWG.GFY %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> G% c$M>B) $B LFH>BGFJ@L)

%GM>dSA$B >^?C=@>9 $M>BGFJ@L%GM> GF GYF$BGFY .D> >AA>J. $A

.D> W?F $F .D> JDG@HB>F ?H$=.>H W\ %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>%9 LFH>B)

GFJ@L%GM> GF >^.>FHGFY C?BBG?Y> BGYD.% .$ $.D>B F$F)

=B$JB>?.GM> J$L=@>%& 6L. .$ %?\ .D?. ? HG%JBGCGF?.$B\ =$@GJ\

G% $M>BGFJ@L%GM> G% .$ %?\ .D?. .D> =$@GJ\ H$>% C$B> D?BC .$

.D> C>CW>B% $A .D> HG%JBGCGF?.>H)?Y?GF%. YB$L= .D?F F>J>%)

%?B\ .$ ?..?GF .D> @>YG.GC?.> Y$?@% $A .D> =$@GJ\9 ?FH .$ %?\

.D?. .D> =$@GJ\ G% LFH>BGFJ@L%GM> G% .$ %?\ .D?. G.% >^J@L%G$F $A

$.D>B9 M>B\ %GCG@?B YB$L=% G% GFHGJ?.GM> $A ?BWG.B?BGF>%%&

[email protected]$LYD .D> J?%>% HG%JL%%9 ?% _> %D?@@ W> H$GFY GF .DG%

$=GFG$F9 .D> D?BC% .D?. ? JD?@@>FY>H %.?.L.> C?\ MG%G. L=$F

.D> HG%JBGCGF?.>H)?Y?GF%. YB$L=9 .D$%> D?BC% H$Fb. A$BC?@@\

>F.>B GF.$ .D> J$FM>F.G$F?@ ?F?@\%G%& UD>F ? %.?.L.> HG%JBGC)

GF?.>% ?Y?GF%. ? =B$.>J.>H J@?%% `?% H>AGF>H A$B >^?C=@> GF

$LB eL>%.G$F *a9 G. H$>%Fb. C?..>B _D>.D>B .D> D?BC GFA@GJ.>H

W\ .D> HG%JBGCGF?.G$F G% ? YB?M> D?BC& 0% _> %?GH9 ? %.?.L.>

.D?. GC=$%>H ? k* .?^ $F _$C>F WL. F$. C>F _$L@H W>

%.BLJZ H$_F LF@>%% .D>B> _>B> ? J$C=>@@GFY B>?%$F A$B .D>HG%JBGCGF?.G$F& 2. _$L@HFb. C?..>B .D?. .D> D?BC .$ >?JD =>B)

%$F HG%JBGCGF?.>H ?Y?GF%. _?% %@GYD. GA .D> W>F>AG. $A GC=$%)

GFY .D> .?^ $F@\ $F _$C>F _?% >M>F %@GYD.>B&

;LB =?GB $A J?%>% G% BGJD GF H>.?G@ WL. [email protected]?.>@\ %.B?GYD.)

A$B_?BH .$ H>JGH>& QD> JD?@@>FY>H @?_% HG%JBGCGF?.> ?Y?GF%.

? CGF$BG.\ H>AGF>H W\ ?F GCCL.?W@> JD?B?J.>BG%.GJ9 ?FH .D>

$F@\ B?.G$F?@> .D?. .D> %.?.>% =L. A$B.D _G.D ?F\ J$FMGJ.G$FS

.D?. %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% ?FH .D>GB JDG@HB>F H$Fb. )!!1 C?BBG?Y>

W>J?L%> %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% J?Fb..79158!JDG@HB>F9 GF.>FH>H $BLFGF.>FH>HSG% %$ AL@@ $A D$@>% .D?. G. J?FF$. W> .?Z>F %>BG)

$L%@\& Q$ .D> >^.>F. .D?. JDG@HB>F ?B> W>..>B $AA GF A?CG@G>% GF

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


8/40

, #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

_DGJD .D> =?B>F.% ?B> C?BBG>H9 .D>\ ?B> W>..>B $AA _D>.D>B

.D>\ ?B> B?G%>H W\ .D>GB WG$@$YGJ?@ =?B>F.% $B W\ ?H$=.GM>

=?B>F.%& QD> HG%JBGCGF?.G$F ?Y?GF%. %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% G% GBB?)

.G$F?@9 ?FH .D>B>A$B> LFJ$F%.G.L.G$F?@ >M>F GA .D> HG%JBGCGF?)

.G$F G% F$. %LW[>J.>H .$ D>GYD.>F>H %JBL.GF\9 _DGJD G% _D\

_> J?F @?BY>@\ >@GH> .D> C$B> J$C=@>^ ?F?@\%G% A$LFH GF

C$B> J@$%>@\ W?@?FJ>H >eL?@)=B$.>J.G$F J?%>%&

2. G% ?@%$ _D\ _> J?F ?M$GH >FY?YGFY _G.D .D> =@?GF.GAA%b

ALB.D>B ?BYLC>F. .D?. .D> %.?.>%b =B$DGWG.G$F $A %?C>)%>^

C?BBG?Y> MG$@?.>% ? ALFH?C>F.?@ BGYD. =B$.>J.>H W\ .D> HL>

=B$J>%% J@?L%> $A .D> V$LB.>>F.D 0C>FHC>F.& QD> =@?GF.GAA%

B>@\ $F J?%>% %LJD ?% M916+9) /& L())!+9"$= (gf E&7& ('f9 (+P

`'ggOa9 ?FH N$B%98C( /& H!13$(%9 (+( E&7& +f(9 +,+i,- `'gf,a9

.D?. D$@H .D?. .D> BGYD. .$ JD$$%> _D$C .$ C?BB\ G% GFH>>H ?

ALFH?C>F.?@ BGYD.& QD> %.?.>% B>=@\ .D?. .D> BGYD. B>J$YFG]>H

GF %LJD J?%>% G% .D> BGYD. .$ JD$$%> AB$C _G.DGF .D> J@?%% $A

=>B%$F% >@GYGW@> .$ C?BB\9 .DL% >^J@LHGFY JDG@HB>F9 J@$%> B>@?)

.GM>%9 ?FH =>B%$F% ?@B>?H\ C?BBG>HS?FH9 .D> %.?.>% J$F.>FH9

=>B%$F% $A .D> %?C> %>^& QD> =@?GF.GAA% BG=$%.> .D?. .D>B> ?B>

Y$$H B>?%$F% A$B GF>@GYGWG@G.\ .$ C?BB\ JDG@HB>F9 J@$%> B>@?).GM>%9 ?FH .D> ?@B>?H\ C?BBG>H9 WL. F$. A$B GF>@GYGWG@G.\ .$

C?BB\ =>B%$F% $A .D> %?C> %>^& 2F @GYD. $A .D> J$C=>@@GFY ?@)

.>BF?.GM> YB$LFH% .D?. _>b@@ W> >^=@$BGFY A$B ?@@$_GFY %?C>)

%>^ C?BBG?Y>9 _> _$Fb. D?M> .$ >FY?Y> _G.D .D> =?B.G>%b

cALFH?C>F.?@ BGYD.d H>W?.>h _> J?F J$FAGF> $LB ?..>F.G$F .$

>eL?@ =B$.>J.G$F&

U> W>YGF $LB H>.?G@>H ?F?@\%G% $A _D>.D>B =B$DGWG.GFY

%?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> H>FG>% >eL?@ =B$.>J.G$F $A .D> @?_% W\

F$.GFY .D?. 2FHG?F? ?FH UG%J$F%GF9 GF B>AL%GFY .$ ?L.D$BG]>%LJD C?BBG?Y> $B `_G.D @GCG.>H >^J>=.G$F% HG%JL%%>H @?.>Ba .$

B>J$YFG]> %LJD C?BBG?Y>% C?H> GF $.D>B %.?.>% W\ B>%GH>F.%

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


9/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- g

$A 2FHG?F? $B UG%J$F%GF9 ?B> HG%JBGCGF?.GFY ?Y?GF%. D$C$)

%>^L?@% W\ H>F\GFY .D>C ? BGYD. .D?. .D>%> %.?.>% YB?F. .$

D>.>B$%>^L?@%9 F?C>@\ .D> BGYD. .$ C?BB\ ?F LFC?BBG>H ?HL@.

$A .D>GB JD$GJ>& 0FH .D>B> G% @G..@> H$LW. .D?. %>^L?@ $BG>F.?)

.G$F9 .D> YB$LFH $A .D> HG%JBGCGF?.G$F9 G% ?F GCCL.?W@> `?FH

=B$W?W@\ ?F GFF?.>9 GF .D> %>F%> $A GF)W$BFa JD?B?J.>BG%.GJ B?)

.D>B .D?F ? JD$GJ>& UG%>@\9 F>G.D>B 2FHG?F? F$B UG%J$F%GF ?B)

YL>% $.D>B_G%>& QD> 0C>BGJ?F :%\JD$@$YGJ?@ 0%%$JG?.G$F D?%

%?GH .D?. cC$%. =>$=@> >^=>BG>FJ> @G..@> $B F$ %>F%> $A JD$GJ>

?W$L. .D>GB %>^L?@ $BG>F.?.G$F&d 0:09 c0F%_>B% .$ 4$LB

lL>%.G$F%N V$B ? 6>..>B EFH>B%.?FHGFY $A 7>^L?@ ;BG>F.?.G$Fn X$C$%>^L?@G.\d * `*OO,a9 ___&?=?&$BYo.$=GJ%[email protected]$BG>F

.?.G$F&=HA `MG%G.>H 7>=.& *9 *O'(9 ?% _>B> .D> $.D>B _>W%G.>%

JG.>H GF .DG% $=GFG$Fah %>> ?@%$ Y$B\ /& X>B>Z >. ?@&9 cI>)

C$YB?=DGJ9 :%\JD$@$YGJ?@9 ?FH 7$JG?@ KD?B?J.>BG%.GJ% $A 7>@A)

2H>F.GAG>H 3>%WG?F9


10/40

'O #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

=$%LB> .$ J>B.?GF D$BC$F>%& 7>>9 >&Y&9 R& /GJD?>@ 6?G@>\9 c6G$)

@$YGJ?@ :>B%=>J.GM>% $F 7>^L?@ ;BG>F.?.G$F9d GF F!+B($)= G$E=

$)1 ;(+!O5$% >1!)"("(!+ D/!7 "3! F(*!+.$)Q '+E839%96(8$% '!7+.!8,

"(/!+ 'O*i+O `0F.D$F\ 1& Ib0LY>@@G ?FH KD?B@$..> R& :?..>B)

%$F >H%& 'ggPah 6?BW?B? 3& VB?FZ$_%ZG9 c7>^L?@ ;BG>F.?.G$F

?FH 0H$@>%J>F.%=R ''+'!1($"7(8+ ',*f9 ',*, `*OO(a& [email protected]$LYD

G. %>>C% =?B?H$^GJ?@ .$ %LYY>%. .D?. D$C$%>^L?@G.\ J$L@H

D?M> ? Y>F>.GJ $BGYGF9 YGM>F .D?. D$C$%>^L?@ %>^ G% F$F)

=B$JB>?.GM>9 D$C$%>^L?@G.\ C?\9 @GZ> C>F$=?L%>9 W\ B>HLJ)

GFY =B$JB>?.G$F W\ %$C> C>CW>B% $A %$JG>.\ AB>> .D>C .$

=B$MGH> JDG@H)J?BGFY ?%%G%.?FJ> .$ .D>GB =B$JB>?.GM> B>@?.GM>%9.DL% GFJB>?%GFY .D> %LBMGM?@ ?FH D>FJ> =B$JB>?.GM> =B$%=>J.%

$A .D>%> B>@?.GM>%& QDG% G% J?@@>H .D> cZGF %>@>J.G$F D\=$.D>)

%G%d $B .D> cD>@=>B GF .D> F>%. .D>$B\&d 7>>9 >&Y&9 0%%$JG?.G$F

A$B :%\JD$@$YGJ?@ 7JG>FJ>9 d7.LH\ 1>M>?@% :$.>F.G?@ 5M$@L)

.G$F?B\ 1$@> A$B 7?C>)7>^ 0..B?J.G$F9d V>W& (9 *O'O9

___&=%\JD$@$YGJ?@%JG>FJ>&$BYoC>HG?oB>@>?%>%o*O'OoM?%>\&JA

C& QD>B> ?B> $.D>B Y>F>.GJ .D>$BG>% $A %LJD ?..B?J.G$F ?% _>@@&

7>>9 >&Y&9 #?.D?F U& 6?G@>\ ?FH /?B@>F> qLZ9 c7?C>)7>^

7>^L?@ 6>D?MG$B ?FH [email protected]$F9d A$B.DJ$CGFY GF P7!)1+ ()

S89%96E $)1 S/9%5"(9)9 ___&A?JL@.\&LJB&>HLorC]LZo6?G

@>\p*O?FHp*OqLZp*O*OOgp*O7?C>p*O%>^p*OW>D?MG$LB&

=HA&V$B ? B>%=$F%GW@> =$=L@?B .B>?.C>F. $A .D> %LW[>J. %>>

UG@@G?C 8B>C>B9 cQD> [email protected]$F?B\ :L]]@> $A X$C$%>^L?@G)

.\9d ;;2 T!A+ L$6$U()!9 V>W& 'f9 *O'(9 ___&WWJ

&J$CoF>_%oC?Y?]GF>)*-O,g(,-&

QD> D?BC .$ D$C$%>^L?@% `?FH9 ?% _>b@@ >C=D?%G]>9 .$

.D>GB ?H$=.>H JDG@HB>Fa $A W>GFY H>FG>H .D> BGYD. .$ C?BB\ G%

J$F%GH>B?W@>& /?BBG?Y> J$FA>B% B>%=>J.?WG@G.\ $F ? %>^L?@ B>)

@?.G$F%DG=h .$ >^J@LH> ? J$L=@> AB$C C?BBG?Y> G% .DL% .$ H>F\

G. ? J$M>.>H %.?.L%& 6>J?L%> D$C$%>^L?@G.\ G% F$. ? M$@LF.?B\

J$FHG.G$F ?FH D$C$%>^L?@% ?B> ?C$FY .D> C$%. %.GYC?.G]>H9

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


11/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- ''

CG%LFH>B%.$$H9 ?FH HG%JBGCGF?.>H)?Y?GF%. CGF$BG.G>% GF .D>

DG%.$B\ $A .D> _$B@H9 .D> HG%=?B?Y>C>F. $A .D>GB %>^L?@ $BG>F)

.?.G$F9 GC=@GJG. GF .D> H>FG?@ $A C?BBG?Y> BGYD.% .$ %?C>)%>^

J$L=@>%9 G% ? %$LBJ> $A J$F.GFLGFY =?GF .$ .D> D$C$%>^L?@

J$CCLFG.\& #$. .D?. ?@@$_GFY %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> _G@@

JD?FY> GF .D> %D$B. BLF .D> F>Y?.GM> MG>_% .D?. C?F\ 0C>B)

GJ?F% D$@H $A %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>& 6L. G. _G@@ >FD?FJ> .D> %.?)

.L% $A .D>%> C?BBG?Y>% GF .D> >\>% $A $.D>B 0C>BGJ?F%9 ?FH GF

.D> @$FY BLF G. C?\ J$FM>B. %$C> $A .D> $==$F>F.% $A %LJD

C?BBG?Y> W\ H>C$F%.B?.GFY .D?. D$C$%>^L?@ C?BBG>H J$L)

=@>% ?B> GF >%%>F.G?@ B>%=>J.%9 F$.?W@\ GF .D> J?B> $A .D>GB?H$=.>H JDG@HB>F9 @GZ> $.D>B C?BBG>H J$L=@>%&

QD> .?FYGW@> ?% HG%.GFJ. AB$C .D> =%\JD$@$YGJ?@ W>F>AG.% $A

C?BBG?Y>9 _DGJD `?@$FY _G.D .D> =%\JD$@$YGJ?@ W>F>AG.%a >F)

LB> HGB>J.@\ $B GFHGB>J.@\ .$ .D> JDG@HB>F $A .D> C?BBG?Y>9

_D>.D>B WG$@$YGJ?@ $B ?H$=.>H9 ?B> ?@%$ J$F%GH>B?W@>& 2F 2F)

HG?F? .D>\ GFJ@LH> .D> BGYD. .$ AG@> %.?.> .?^ B>.LBF% [$GF.@\9

2FH& K$H> s -)+)()*`Hah .D> C?BG.?@ .>%.GC$FG?@ =BGMG@>Y>9 s +()

(-)+)'`(ah %=$L%?@)%L==$B. $W@GY?.G$F%9 s +P)(-)')-`?ah %LBMG)

M$B W>F>AG.% A$B .D> %=$L%> $A ? =LW@GJ %?A>.\ $AAGJ>B ZG@@>H GF.D> @GF> $A HL.\9 s +-),),)'+&,`Jah .D> BGYD. .$ GFD>BG. _D>F ?

%=$L%> HG>% GF.>%.?.>9 s *g)')*)'`Wa9 `Jah JL%.$HG?@ BGYD.% .$

?FH JDG@H %L==$B. $W@GY?.G$F% A$B JDG@HB>F $A .D> C?BBG?Y>9

?FH =B$.>J.G$F% A$B C?BG.?@ =B$=>B.\ L=$F .D> H>?.D $A ?

%=$L%>& ss '*)'P),&P)+`'ah '*)*O)*f)'`?a`*a`0a& 6>J?L%> UG%)

J$F%GF ?@@$_% H$C>%.GJ =?B.F>B%DG=%9 %$C> %=$L%?@ W>F>AG.%

?B> ?M?G@?W@> .$ %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% GF .D?. %.?.>& 6L. $.D>B% ?B>

F$.9 %LJD ?% .D> BGYD. .$ ?H$=. JDG@HB>F [$GF.@\9 UG%& 7.?.&

s (,&,*`'ah %=$L%?@)%L==$B. $W@GY?.G$F%9 ss f-P&OO'`*a9

f--&'P`'a9 f--&PPh .D> =B>%LC=.G$F .D?. ?@@ =B$=>B.\ $A C?B)

BG>H J$L=@>% G% C?BG.?@ =B$=>B.\9 s f--&+'`*ah ?FH %.?.>)

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


12/40

'* #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

C?FH?.>H ?JJ>%% .$ >FB$@@C>F. GF ? %=$L%>b% D>[email protected] GF%LB)

?FJ> =@?F9 s -+*&f(-`fa&

;A YB>?. GC=$B.?FJ> ?B> .D> >^.>F%GM> *!1!7$% W>F>AG.% .$

_DGJD C?BBG>H J$L=@>% ?B> >F.G.@>HN .D> BGYD. .$ AG@> GFJ$C>

.?^>% [$GF.@\9 *- E&7&K& s -O'+h %$JG?@ %>JLBG.\ %=$L%?@ ?FH

%LBMGMGFY)%=$L%> W>F>AG.%9 (* E&7&K& s (O*h H>?.D W>F>AG.% A$B

%LBMGMGFY %=$L%> $A ? CG@G.?B\ M>.>B?F9 +, E&7&K& s '+''h .D>

BGYD. .$ .B?F%A>B ?%%>.% .$ $F>b% %=$L%> HLBGFY C?BBG?Y> $B ?.

HGM$BJ> _G.D$L. ?HHG.G$F?@ .?^ @G?WG@G.\9 *- E&7&K& s 'O('h >^)

>C=.G$F AB$C A>H>B?@ >%.?.> .?^ $A =B$=>B.\ .D?. =?%%>% .$ .D>

%LBMGMGFY %=$L%>9 *- E&7&K& s *OP-`?ah .D> .?^ >^>C=.G$F A$B

>C=@$\>B)=B$MGH>H D>[email protected]?B> .$ ? %=$L%>9 *- E&7&K& s 'O-h

QB>?%& 1>Y& s '&'O-i'h ?FH D>[email protected]?B> W>F>AG.% A$B %=$L%>% $A

A>H>B?@ >C=@$\>>%9 P E&7&K& ss ,gO'`Pa9 ,gOP&

QD> H>FG?@ $A .D>%> A>H>B?@ W>F>AG.% .$ %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>%

WBGFY% .$ CGFH .D> 7L=B>C> K$LB.b% $=GFG$F GF I)("!1 J"$"!+

/& @()1+979 '++ 7& K.& *-fP9 *-g(igP `*O'+a9 _DGJD D>@H LF)

J$F%.G.L.G$F?@ .D> H>FG?@ $A ?@@ A>H>B?@ C?BG.?@ W>F>AG.% .$

%?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>% B>J$YFG]>H W\ %.?.> @?_& QD> K$LB.b%

JBG.GJG%C% $A %LJD H>FG?@ ?==@\ _G.D >M>F YB>?.>B A$BJ> .$ 2F)HG?F?b% @?_& QD> H>FG?@ c.>@@% .D$%> J$L=@>%9 ?FH ?@@ .D>

_$B@H9 .D?. .D>GB $.D>B_G%> M?@GH C?BBG?Y>% ?B> LF_$B.D\ $A

A>H>B?@ B>J$YFG.G$F& tT9%?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>% ?B> M?@GH GF 2F)

HG?F?&u QDG% =@?J>% %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% GF ?F LF%.?W@> =$%G.G$F

$A W>GFY GF ? %>J$FH).G>B C?BBG?Y> tGF 2FHG?F?9 GF .D> @$_)

>%.S.D> 5)Bu& QD> HGAA>B>F.G?.G$F H>C>?F% .D>

J$L=@> v t?FHu DLCG@G?.>% .>F% $A .D$L%?FH% $A JDG@HB>F

F$_ W>GFY B?G%>H W\ %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>%& QD> @?_ v C?Z>% G.

>M>F C$B> HGAAGJL@. A$B .D> JDG@HB>F .$ LFH>B%.?FH .D> GF.>Y)BG.\ ?FH J@$%>F>%% $A .D>GB $_F A?CG@\ ?FH G.% J$FJ$BH _G.D

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


13/40


14/40

'( #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

UD>.D>B .D>\ D?M> H$F> %$ G% B>?@@\ .D> $F@\ G%%L> W>A$B> L%9

?FH .D> W?@?FJ> $A .DG% $=GFG$F G% H>M$.>H .$ G.S>^J>=. .D?.

W>A$B> ?HHB>%%GFY G. _> CL%. ?HHB>%% .D> %.?.>%b ?BYLC>F.

.D?. _D?.>M>B .D> C>BG.% $A .D> =@?GF.GAA%b J@?GC%9 _> ?B>

W$LFH W\ ;$C!7 /& T!%+9)9 (Og E&7& ,'O `'gf*a `C>C&a9 .$ B>[>J.

.D>C& V$B .D>B> .D> 7L=B>C> K$LB.9 _G.D$L. G%%LGFY ?F $=GF)

G$F9 HG%CG%%>H cA$B _?F. $A ? %LW%.?F.G?@ A>H>B?@ eL>%.G$Fd

?F ?==>?@ AB$C ? %.?.> J$LB. .D?. D?H D>@H .D?. =B$DGWG.GFY

%?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> HGH F$. MG$@?.> .D> K$F%.G.L.G$F& 0@.)

D$LYD >M>F ? H>JG%G$F _G.D$L. $=GFG$F G% $F .D> C>BG.% ?FH

%$ WGFH% @$_>B J$LB.%9 .D> 7L=B>C> K$LB. J?BM>H ?F >^J>=).G$F .$ .DG% =BGFJG=@> $A [LHGJG?@ DG>B?BJD\ GF M(8C+ /& L(7$)1$9

(** E&7& ++*9 +(( `'gfPa9 A$B c_D>F H$J.BGF?@ H>M>@$=C>F.%

GFHGJ?.> $.D>B_G%>dh %>> ?@%$ I)("!1 J"$"!+ /& ;%$()! 295)"E9

+-+ V&+H ,gf9 gO( `g.D KGB& *OO(ah J9"9,F9.!U /& T!A V97C 2("E

2(/(% J!7/(8! 29?B% ?Y$ ?FH .D> H?BZ ?Y>%

%$ A?B ?% @G.GY?.G$F $M>B HG%JBGCGF?.G$F ?Y?GF%. D$C$%>^L?@%

G% J$FJ>BF>H& 7LW%>eL>F. H>JG%G$F% %LJD ?% H9

fg `*OO+a9 ?FH I)("!1 J"$"!+ /& @()1+97 ?B> HG%.GFYLG%D?W@>

AB$C .D> =B>%>F. ._$ J?%>% WL. C?Z> J@>?B .D?. ;$C!7 G% F$

@$FY>B ?L.D$BG.?.GM>& 0. @>?%. A! .DGFZ .D>\bB> HG%.GFYLG%D?)

W@>& 6L. RL%.GJ> 7J?@G?9 GF ? HG%%>F.GFY $=GFG$F GF F$A7!)8!9

P+g E&7& ?. P,-9 [$GF>H W\ KDG>A RL%.GJ> 1>DFeLG%. ?FH RL%.GJ>

QD$C?%9 .D$LYD. F$.& X> _B$.> .D?. c=BGFJG=@> ?FH @$YGJd

_$L@H 7!W5(7! .D> K$LB.9 YGM>F G.% H>JG%G$F GF F$A7!)8!9 .$

D$@H .D?. .D>B> G% ? J$F%.G.L.G$F?@ BGYD. .$ %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>&

>1& ?. -OP&

VGB%. L= .$ W?. G% 2FHG?F?9 _DGJD H>A>FH% G.% B>AL%?@ .$ ?@)

@$_ %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> $F ? %GFY@> YB$LFH9 F?C>@\ .D?. Y$M)

>BFC>F.b% %$@> =LB=$%> `$B ?. @>?%. 2FHG?F?b% %$@> =LB=$%>a GF

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


15/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- 'P

C?ZGFY C?BBG?Y> ? @>Y?@ B>@?.G$F `LF@GZ> J$D?WG.?.G$F9 _DGJD

G% =LB>@\ J$F.B?J.L?@a G% .$ >FD?FJ> JDG@H _>@A?B>& #$.?W@\

.D> %.?.> H$>% F$. ?BYL> .D?. B>J$YFG]GFY %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>

LFH>BCGF>% J$FM>F.G$F?@ C?BBG?Y>&

UD>F ? JDG@H G% J$FJ>GM>H GF.>F.G$F?@@\9 .D> =?B>F.%

F$BC?@@\ GF.>FH .$ B?G%> .D> JDG@H .$Y>.D>B& 6L. =B>YF?FJ\9

?FH .D> B>%[email protected] WGB.D `GF .D> ?W%>FJ> $A ?W$B.G$Fa9 ?B> %$C>)

.GC>% ?JJGH>F.?@9 LFGF.>FH>Hh ?FH $A.>F GF %LJD JGBJLC%.?FJ)

>% .D> C$.D>B G% %.LJZ _G.D .D> W?W\S.D> A?.D>B9 F$. D?MGFY

_?F.>H .$ W>J$C> ? A?.D>B9 B>AL%>% .$ .?Z> ?F\ B>%=$F%GWG@G.\

A$B .D> JDG@Hb% _>@A?B>& QD> %$@> B>?%$F A$B 2FHG?F?b% C?B)

BG?Y> @?_9 .D> %.?.>b% ?BYLC>F. J$F.GFL>%9 G% .$ .B\ .$ JD?FF>@

LFGF.>F.G$F?@@\ =B$JB>?.GM> %>^ GF.$ ? @>Y?@ B>YGC> GF _DGJD

.D> WG$@$YGJ?@ A?.D>B G% B>eLGB>H .$ ?%%LC> =?B>F.?@ B>%=$F%G)

WG@G.\& QD> %.?.> B>J$YFG]>% .D?. %$C> $B >M>F C?F\ D$C$)

%>^L?@% _?F. .$ >F.>B GF.$ %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>%9 WL. =$GF.%

$L. .D?. C?F\ =>$=@> _?F. .$ >F.>B GF.$ B>@?.G$F% .D?. Y$M)

>BFC>F. B>AL%>% .$ >FA$BJ> $B =B$.>J. `ABG>FH%DG= W>GFY ? F$)

.?W@> >^?C=@>a& BFC>F. D?% F$ GF.>B>%. GF B>J$YFG]GFY

?FH =B$.>J.GFY %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>9 2FHG?F? ?BYL>%9 W>J?L%>D$C$%>^L?@ %>^ J?FF$. B>%L@. GF LFGF.>FH>H WGB.D%&

0% A$B .D> J$F%GH>B?W@> W>F>AG.% .D?. C?BBG?Y> J$FA>B% $F

.D> C?BBG>H J$L=@>9 .D>%> GF .D> %.?.>b% MG>_ ?B> ? =?B. $A .D>

B>YL@?.$B\ B>YGC>N .D> J?BB$. %L==@>C>F.GFY .D> %.GJZ& /?BG)

.?@ W>F>AG.% A$B D$C$%>^L?@ J$L=@>% _$L@H F$. %>BM> .D> B>Y)

L@?.$B\ =LB=$%> $A C?BG.?@ W>F>AG.% A$B D>.>B$%>^L?@ J$L=@>%

W>J?L%> D$C$%>^L?@ J$L=@>% H$Fb. =B$HLJ> W?WG>%&

QD> %.?.>b% ?BYLC>F. J?F W> ?F?@$YG]>H .$ B>eLGBGFY

HBGM>B%b @GJ>F%>% A$B HBGM>B% $A C$.$B M>DGJ@>% WL. F$. A$B WG)J\J@G%.%& /$.$B M>DGJ@>% ?B> C$B> H?FY>B$L% .$ $.D>B L%>B% $A

.D> B$?H% .D?F WGJ\J@>% ?B>9 ?FH .D>B>A$B> ? HBGM>Bb% @GJ>F%> G%

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


16/40

'- #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

B>eLGB>H .$ HBGM> .D> A$BC>B WL. F$. .$ =>H?@ .D> @?..>B& 6GJ\)

J@G%.% H$ F$. ?FH J?FF$. J$C=@?GF ?W$L. F$. D?MGFY .$ D?M> ?

@GJ>F%> .$ =>H?@9 W>J?L%> $W.?GFGFY9 B>F>_GFY9 >.J&9 .D> @G)

J>F%> _$L@H GFM$@M> ? J$%. GF .GC> ?FH C$F>\& QD> ?F?@$Y\

G% F$. =>BA>J. `GA G. _>B>9 G. _$L@H W> ?F GH>F.G.\ F$. ?F ?F?@)

$Y\a W>J?L%> C?BBG?Y> J$FA>B% W>F>AG.% ?% _>@@ ?% GC=$%GFY

J$%.%9 ?% _> D?M> >C=D?%G]>H `GFH>>H G. J$FA>B% $F C$%.

J$L=@>% W>F>AG.% YB>?.>B .D?F .D> J$%.%a& 6L. .D$%> W>F>AG.%9 GF

2FHG?F?b% MG>_9 _$L@H %>BM> F$ %.?.> GF.>B>%. GA >^.>FH>H .$

D$C$%>^L?@ J$L=@>%9 _D$ %D$L@H .D>B>A$B> W> J$F.>F. _G.D

.D> W>F>AG.% .D>\ H>BGM> AB$C W>GFY >^J@LH>H AB$C .D> C?B)BG?Y>)@GJ>F%GFY B>YGC>N .D> J$%. $A .D> @GJ>F%> ?FH .D> WLBH>F

$A C?BG.?@ HL.G>%9 %LJD ?% %L==$B.9 ?FH .D> J$%.% ?%%$JG?.>H

_G.D HGM$BJ>& /$B>$M>B9 >M>F GA =$%%>%%G$F $A ? HBGM>Bb% @G)

J>F%> J$FA>BB>H W>F>AG.% F$. ?M?G@?W@> .$ WGJ\J@G%.% `HG%)

J$LF.%9 $B .?^ JB>HG.%9 =>BD?=%a9 .D> %.?.> J$L@H ?BYL> .D?. G.

$AA>B>H .D>%> W>F>AG.% $F@\ .$ GFHLJ> HBGM>B% .$ $W.?GF ? @G)

J>F%> `.D> J?BB$. %L==@>C>F.GFY .D> %.GJZa9 ?FH .D?. WGJ\J@G%.%

H$Fb. JB>?.> .D> %?C> B>YL@?.$B\ J$FJ>BF ?FH %$ H$Fb. H>)

%>BM> ? J?BB$.&

0F$.D>B ?F?@$Y\N QD> A>H>B?@ Y$M>BFC>F. >^.>FH% ?

k*OOO c%?M>Bb% JB>HG.d .$ @$_) ?FH CGHH@>)GFJ$C> _$BZ>B%

_D$ J$F.BGWL.> .$ ? B>.GB>C>F. ?JJ$LF.& [email protected]$LYD >M>B\$F>

_$L@H @GZ> ? k*OOO JB>HG.9 $F@\ @$_>B)GFJ$C> _$BZ>B% ?B>

>F.G.@>H .$ G.& 7D$L@H DGYD>B)GFJ$C> _$BZ>B% J$C=@?GF ?W$L.

W>GFY @>A. $L. $A .D> =B$YB?C9 .D> Y$M>BFC>F. J$L@H B>=@\

.D?. $F@\ @$_>B)GFJ$C> _$BZ>B% JB>?.> ? B>YL@?.$B\ J$F)

J>BFS.D> J$FJ>BF .D?. .D>\bH W> LF?W@> .$ %L==$B. .D>C)

%>@M>% GF B>.GB>C>F. _G.D$L. Y$M>BFC>F. >FJ$LB?Y>C>F. .$

%?M> _DG@> .D>\bB> \$LFY&

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


17/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- 'f

2F %D$B.9 2FHG?F? ?BYL>% .D?. D$C$%>^L?@ B>@?.G$F%DG=%

?B> JB>?.>H ?FH HG%%$@M>H _G.D$L. @>Y?@ J$F%>eL>FJ>% W>)

J?L%> .D>\ H$Fb. JB>?.> A?CG@\)B>@?.>H B>YL@?.$B\ J$FJ>BF%&

4>. >FJ$LB?YGFY C?BBG?Y> G% @>%% ?W$L. A$BJGFY A?.D>B% .$

.?Z> B>%=$F%GWG@G.\ A$B .D>GB LFGF.>FH>H JDG@HB>FS%.?.> @?_

D?% C>JD?FG%C% A$B H>.>BCGFGFY =?.>BFG.\ ?FH B>eLGBGFY .D>

A?.D>B .$ J$F.BGWL.> .$ .D> %L==$B. $A DG% JDG@HB>FS.D?F

?W$L. >FD?FJGFY JDG@H _>@A?B> W\ >FJ$LB?YGFY =?B>F.% .$

J$CCG. .$ ? %.?W@> B>@?.G$F%DG= GF _DGJD .D>\ _G@@ W> B?G%GFY

.D> JDG@H .$Y>.D>B& /$B>$M>B9 GA JD?FF>@GFY =B$JB>?.GM> %>^

GF.$ C?BBG?Y> _>B> .D> $F@\ B>?%$F .D?. 2FHG?F? B>J$YFG]>%C?BBG?Y>9 .D> %.?.> _$L@H F$. ?@@$_ ?F GFA>B.G@> =>B%$F .$

C?BB\& 2FH>>H G. _$L@H C?Z> C?BBG?Y> @GJ>F%>% >^=GB> _D>F

$F> $A .D> %=$L%>% `A>B.G@> L=$F C?BBG?Y>a W>J?C> GFA>B.G@>

W>J?L%> $A ?Y> $B HG%>?%>& QD> %.?.> .B>?.% C?BBG>H D$C$%>^)

L?@% ?% _$L@H)W> cAB>> BGH>B%d $F D>.>B$%>^L?@ C?BBG?Y>9 LF)

B>?%$F?W@\ B>?=GFY W>F>AG.% GF.>FH>H W\ .D> %.?.> A$B A>B.G@>

J$L=@>%& 6L. GFA>B.G@> J$L=@>% ?B> AB>> BGH>B% .$$& UD\ ?B>

.D>\ ?@@$_>H .$ B>?= .D> W>F>AG.% ?JJ$BH>H C?BBG?Y>% $A A>B)

.G@> J$L=@>%9 ?FH D$C$%>^L?@% ?B> F$.j

QD> %.?.> $AA>B% ?F GFM$@L.>H =?GB $A ?F%_>B%9 F>G.D>B $A

_DGJD ?F%_>B% .D> JD?BY> .D?. G.% =$@GJ\ .$_?BH %?C>)%>^

C?BBG?Y> G% LFH>BGFJ@L%GM>& 2. =$GF.% $L. .D?. GF .D> J?%> $A

C$%. GFA>B.G@> D>.>B$%>^L?@ J$L=@>%9 $F@\ $F> %=$L%> G% GFA>B)

.G@>9 ?FH G. ?BYL>% .D?. GA .D>%> J$L=@>% _>B> A$BWGHH>F .$

C?BB\ .D>B> _$L@H W> ? BG%Z $A .D> A>B.G@> %=$L%>b% %>>ZGFY ?

A>B.G@> =>B%$F $A .D> $.D>B %>^ .$ WB>>H _G.D ?FH .D> B>%L@.

_$L@H W> [email protected]=@> B>@?.G$F%DG=% .D?. CGYD. \G>@H LFGF.>F)

.G$F?@ W?WG>%&d QBL>9 .D$LYD .D> A>B.G@> C>CW>B $A ?F GFA>B.G@>

J$L=@> CGYD. H>JGH> GF%.>?H .$ =B$HLJ> ? JDG@H A$B .D> J$L)

=@> W\ %LBB$Y?J\ $B `GA .D> A>B.G@> C>CW>B G% .D> _$C?Fa ?

%=>BC W?FZ9 $B .$ ?H$=.9 $B .$ HGM$BJ>& 6L. _D?. G% C$%. LF)

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


18/40

', #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

@GZ>@\ G% .D?. .D> A>B.G@> C>CW>B9 .D$LYD 1!+(7()6? WG$@$YGJ?@

JDG@H9 _$L@H D?M> =B$JB>?.GM> %>^ _G.D ?F$.D>B =>B%$F ?FH

.D>F $B$)19).D> JDG@HS_DGJD G% .D> %.?.>b% =B$A>%%>H A>?B&

QD> %.?.> .>@@% L% .D?. cF$F)=B$JB>?.GFY $==$%G.>)%>^ J$L)

=@>% _D$ C?BB\ C$H>@ .D> $=.GC?@9 %$JG?@@\ >^=>J.>H W>D?M)

G$B A$B $.D>B $==$%G.>)%>^ J$L=@>% _D$%> %>^L?@ GF.>BJ$LB%>

C?\ _>@@ =B$HLJ> JDG@HB>F&d QD?.b% ? %.B?FY> ?BYLC>F.h A>B)

.G@> J$L=@>% H$Fb. @>?BF ?W$L. JDG@H)B>?BGFY AB$C GFA>B.G@>

J$L=@>%& 0FH _D\ _$L@HFb. %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> %>FH .D>

%?C> C>%%?Y> .D?. .D> %.?.> .DGFZ% C?BBG?Y> $A GFA>B.G@> D>.)

>B$%>^L?@% %>FH%S.D?. C?BBG?Y> G% ? H>%GB?W@> %.?.>j

2.b% .BL> .D?. GFA>B.G@> $B $.D>B_G%> F$F)=B$JB>?.GM> D>.>B)

$%>^L?@ J$L=@>% `%$C> A>B.G@> J$L=@>% H>JGH> F$. .$ D?M>

JDG@HB>Fa HGAA>B AB$C %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% GF .D?. G. G% >?%G>B A$B

.D> %.?.> .$ H>.>BCGF> _D>.D>B ? J$L=@> G% GFA>B.G@> W\ B>?%$F

$A W>GFY $A .D> %?C> %>^& 2. _$L@H W> J$F%GH>B>H ?F GFM?%G$F

$A =BGM?J\ .$ J$FHG.G$F .D> >@GYGWG@G.\ $A ? D>.>B$%>^L?@ J$L)

=@> .$ C?BB\ $F _D>.D>B W$.D =B$%=>J.GM> %=$L%>% _>B> A>B)

.G@> `[email protected]$LYD @?.>B _>b@@ %>> UG%J$F%GF [email protected] _G.D %LJD ?F

?==B$?JD _G.D B>%=>J. .$ ?F$.D>B J@?%% $A GFA>B.G@> J$L=@>%a&0FH $A.>F .D> J$L=@> _$L@HFb. ZF$_ GF ?HM?FJ> $A C?BBG?Y>

_D>.D>B .D>\ _>B> A>B.G@>& 6L. .D>F D$_ .$ >^=@?GF 2FHG?F?b%

H>JG%G$F .$ J?BM> ?F >^J>=.G$F .$ G.% =B$DGWG.G$F ?Y?GF%. C?B)

BG?Y> $A J@$%> B>@?.GM>% A$B AGB%. J$L%GF% -P $B $@H>BS? =$=L)

@?.G$F YL?B?F.>>H .$ W> GFA>B.G@> W>J?L%> _$C>F J?Fb. J$F)

J>GM> ?. .D?. ?Y>j 2FH& K$H> s +')'')')*& 2A .D> %.?.>b% $F@\ GF)

.>B>%. GF ?@@$_GFY C?BBG?Y> G% .$ =B$.>J. JDG@HB>F9 _D\ D?% G.

Y$F> $L. $A G.% _?\ .$ =>BCG. C?BBG?Y> $A AGB%. J$L%GF% 9)%E

$*"!7 .D>\ ?B> =B$M?W@\ GFA>B.G@>j QD> %.?.> CL%. .DGFZ C?B)BG?Y> M?@L?W@> A$B %$C>.DGFY $.D>B .D?F [L%. =B$JB>?.G$FS

.D?. >M>F F$F)=B$JB>?.GM> J$L=@>% W>F>AG. AB$C C?BBG?Y>&

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


19/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- 'g

0FH ?C$FY F$F)=B$JB>?.GM> J$L=@>%9 .D$%> .D?. B?G%> JDG@)

HB>F9 %LJD ?% %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% _G.D ?H$=.>H JDG@HB>F9 Y?GF

C$B> AB$C C?BBG?Y> .D?F .D$%> _D$ H$ F$. B?G%> JDG@HB>F9

%LJD ?% >@H>B@\ J$L%GF%h >@H>B@\ =>B%$F% B?B>@\ ?H$=.&

2FHG?F? D?% .DL% GFM>F.>H ?F GF%GHG$L% A$BC $A HG%JBGCG)

F?.G$FN A?M$BGFY AGB%. J$L%GF%9 =B$MGH>H .D>\ ?B> F$. $A .D>

%?C> %>^9 $M>B D$C$%>^L?@%& 5@H>B@\ AGB%. J$L%GF% ?B> =>BCG.)

.>H .$ C?BB\ W>J?L%> .D>\ J?Fb. =B$HLJ> JDG@HB>Fh D$C$%>^)

L?@% ?B> A$BWGHH>F .$ C?BB\ W>J?L%> .D>\ J?Fb. =B$HLJ> JDG@)

HB>F& QD> %.?.>b% ?BYLC>F. .D?. ? C?BBG?Y> $A AGB%. J$L%GF%

_D$ ?B> =?%. JDG@H)W>?BGFY ?Y> =B$MGH>% ? cC$H>@ t$Au A?CG)

@\ @GA> A$B \$LFY>B9 =$.>F.G?@@\ =B$JB>?.GM> C>F ?FH _$C>Fd

G% GC=$%%GW@> .$ .?Z> %>BG$L%@\&

0. $B?@ ?BYLC>F. .D> %.?.>m% @?_\>B _?% ?%Z>H _D>.D>B

c2FHG?F?b% @?_ G% ?W$L. %LJJ>%%AL@@\ B?G%GFY JDG@HB>F9d ?FH

%GFJ> c\$L ?YB>> %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% J?F %LJJ>%%AL@@\ B?G%>

JDG@HB>F9 _D\ %D$L@HFb. .D> W?F W> @GA.>H ?% .$ .D>Cjd QD>

@?_\>B ?F%_>B>H .D?. c.D> ?%%LC=.G$F G% .D?. _G.D $==$%G.>)

%>^ J$L=@>% .D>B> G% M>B\ @G..@> .D$LYD. YGM>F HLBGFY .D> %>^)

L?@ ?J.9 %$C>.GC>%9 .$ _D>.D>B W?WG>% C?\ W> ? J$F%>)eL>FJ>&d 2F $.D>B _$BH%9 2FHG?F?b% Y$M>BFC>F. .DGFZ% .D?.

%.B?GYD. J$L=@>% .>FH .$ W> %>^L?@@\ GBB>%=$F%GW@>9 =B$HLJGFY

LF_?F.>H JDG@HB>F W\ .D> J?B@$?H9 ?FH %$ CL%. W> =B>%%LB>H

`GF .D> A$BC $A Y$M>BFC>F.?@ >FJ$LB?Y>C>F. $A C?BBG?Y>

.DB$LYD ? J$CWGF?.G$F $A %.GJZ% ?FH J?BB$.%a .$ C?BB\9 WL.

.D?. Y?\ J$L=@>%9 LF?W@> ?% .D>\ ?B> .$ =B$HLJ> JDG@HB>F

_?F.>H $B LF_?F.>H9 ?B> C$H>@ =?B>F.%SC$H>@ JG.G]>F% B>)

?@@\S%$ D?M> F$ F>>H A$B C?BBG?Y>& X>.>B$%>^L?@% Y>. HBLFZ

?FH =B>YF?F.9 =B$HLJGFY LF_?F.>H JDG@HB>Fh .D>GB B>_?BH G%.$ W> ?@@$_>H .$ C?BB\& X$C$%>^L?@ J$L=@>% H$ F$. =B$HLJ>

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


20/40

*O #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

LF_?F.>H JDG@HB>Fh .D>GB B>_?BH G% .$ W> H>FG>H .D> BGYD. .$

C?BB\& &

UDGJD WBGFY% L% .$ 2FHG?F?b% _>?Z>%. H>A>F%> $A G.% HG%)

.GFJ.G$F ?C$FY HGAA>B>F. .\=>% $A GFA>B.G@> J$L=@>N G.% ?%)

%LC=.G$F .D?. %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> J?FF$. J$F.BGWL.> .$ ?@@>)

MG?.GFY .D> =B$W@>C $A c?JJGH>F.?@ WGB.D%9d _DGJD .D> %.?.>

J$F.>FH% G% .D> %$@> Y$M>BFC>F.?@ GF.>B>%. GF C?BBG?Y>& 7L=)

=$%> .D> J$F%>eL>FJ>% $A ?JJGH>F.?@ WGB.D% ?B> GFH>>H .D>

%.?.>b% %$@> B>?%$F A$B YGMGFY C?BBG?Y> ? @>Y?@ %.?.L%& 2F ?H)

M?FJGFY .DG% ?% "3!B>?%$F .$ A$BWGH %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>9 2FHG)

?F? D?% GYF$B>H ?H$=.G$FS?F >^.B?$BHGF?B\ $M>B%GYD.& EF)

GF.>F.G$F?@ $AA%=BGFY ?B> .D> JDG@HB>F C$%. @GZ>@\ .$ W> =L.

L= A$B ?H$=.G$F9 ?FH GA F$. ?H$=.>H9 .$ >FH L= GF ? A$%.>B

D$C>& 0JJGH>F.?@ =B>YF?FJG>% ?B> .D> C?[$B %$LBJ> $A LF)

_?F.>H JDG@HB>F9 ?FH LF_?F.>H JDG@HB>F ?B> ? C?[$B =B$W)

@>C A$B %$JG>.\9 _DGJD G% H$LW.@>%% .D> B>?%$F D$C$%>^L?@%

?B> =>BCG..>H .$ ?H$=. GF C$%. %.?.>%SGFJ@LHGFY 2FHG?F?

?FH UG%J$F%GF&

2.b% W>>F >%.GC?.>H .D?. C$B> .D?F *OO9OOO 0C>BGJ?F

JDG@HB>F `%$C> +OOO GF 2FHG?F? ?FH ?W$L. .D> %?C> FLCW>BGF UG%J$F%GFa ?B> W>GFY B?G%>H W\ D$C$%>^L?@%9 C?GF@\ D$)

C$%>^L?@ J$L=@>%&


21/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- *'

F.oL=@$?H%oU2)%?C>)%>^)J$L=@>%)H>C$)?LY)*O'(&=HA&


22/40


23/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- *+

M>B%>@\9 GC?YGF> .D> =?B>F.% D?MGFY .$ .>@@ .D>GB JDG@H .D?.

%?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% J?Fb. C?BB\9 ?FH %$ .D> JDG@H G% F$. .D>

JDG@H $A ? C?BBG>H J$L=@>9 LF@GZ> DG% J@?%%C?.>%&

2FHG?F? =>BCG.% [$GF. ?H$=.G$F W\ D$C$%>^L?@% `UG%J$F)

%GF H$>% F$.a& 6L. ?F LFC?BBG>H D$C$%>^L?@ J$L=@> G% @>%%

%.?W@> .D?F ? C?BBG>H $F>9 $B %$ ?. @>?%. .D> %.?.>b% GF%G%.>FJ>

.D?. C?BBG?Y> G% W>..>B A$B JDG@HB>F GC=@G>%& 2A C?BBG?Y> G%

W>..>B A$B JDG@HB>F _D$ ?B> W>GFY WB$LYD. L= W\ .D>GB WG$@$Y)

GJ?@ =?B>F.%9 G. CL%. W> W>..>B A$B JDG@HB>F _D$ ?B> W>GFY

WB$LYD. L= W\ .D>GB ?H$=.GM> =?B>F.%& QD> %.?.> %D$L@H A$)"

D$C$%>^L?@ J$L=@>% _D$ ?H$=. JDG@HB>FS?%9 .$ B>=>?.9 .D>\

?B> =>BCG..>H .$ H$S.$ W> C?BBG>H9 GA G. G% %>BG$L% GF ?BYLGFY

.D?. .D> $F@\ Y$M>BFC>F.?@ GF.>B>%. GF C?BBG?Y> H>BGM>% AB$C

.D> =B$W@>C $A ?JJGH>F.?@ WGB.D%& `U> H$LW. .D?. G. G% %>BG)

$L%&a

QD> %.?.>b% J@?GC .D?. J$FM>F.G$F?@ C?BBG?Y> G% .D> %$@L)

.G$F .$ .D?. =B$W@>C G% W>@G>H W\ .D> %.?.>b% >^=>BG>FJ> _G.D

WGB.D% $L. $A _>H@$JZ& 0JJGH>F.?@ =B>YF?FJG>% ?B> A$LFH

?C$FY C?BBG>H J$L=@>% ?% _>@@ ?% LFC?BBG>H J$L=@>%9 ?FH

?C$FY GFHGMGHL?@% _D$ ?B> F$. GF ? J$CCG..>H B>@?.G$F%DG=?FH D?M> %>^L?@ GF.>BJ$LB%> .D?. B>%L@.% GF ?F LFGF.>FH>H

=B>YF?FJ\& 6L. .D> %.?.> W>@G>M>% .D?. C?BBG>H J$L=@>% ?B>

@>%% @GZ>@\ .$ ?W?FH$F ? JDG@H $A .D> C?BBG?Y> >M>F GA .D>

JDG@Hb% WGB.D _?% LFGF.>FH>H& 7$ GA .D> %.?.>b% =$@GJ\ $A .B\GFY

.$ JD?FF>@ =B$JB>?.GM> %>^ GF.$ C?BBG?Y> _>B> %LJJ>>HGFY9

_> _$L@H >^=>J. ? HB$= GF .D> =>BJ>F.?Y> $A JDG@HB>F W$BF

.$ ?F LFC?BBG>H _$C?F9 $B ?. @>?%. F$. ?F GFJB>?%> GF .D?.

=>BJ>F.?Y>& 4>. GF A?J. .D?. =>BJ>F.?Y> D?% W>>F BG%GFY >M>F

%GFJ> 2FHG?F? GF 'ggf B>>F?J.>H G.% =B$DGWG.G$F $A %?C>)%>^C?BBG?Y> `.DL% LFH>B%J$BGFY G.% H>.>BCGF>H $==$%G.G$F .$

%LJD C?BBG?Y>a ?FH A$B .D> AGB%. .GC> H>J@?B>H .D?. G. _$L@H

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


24/40

*( #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

F$. B>J$YFG]> %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>% J$F.B?J.>H GF $.D>B %.?.>%

$B ?WB$?H& QD> @>YG%@?.LB> _?% A>?BAL@ .D?. X$$%G>B D$C$)

%>^L?@% _$L@H A@$JZ .$ X?_?GG .$ Y>. C?BBG>H9 A$B GF 'gg- .D>

X?_?GG J$LB.% ?==>?B>H .$ W> C$MGFY .$_?BH GFM?@GH?.GFY

.D> %.?.>b% W?F $F %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>9 .D$LYD ?% .DGFY%

.LBF>H $L. X?_?GG HGH F$. ?L.D$BG]> %LJD C?BBG?Y> LF.G@

*O'+&

2F 'ggf9 .D> \>?B $A .D> >F?J.C>F.9 ++ =>BJ>F. $A WGB.D% GF

2FHG?F? _>B> .$ LFC?BBG>H _$C>Fh GF *O'* `.D> @?.>%. \>?B

A$B _DGJD _> D?M> %.?.G%.GJ%a .D> =>BJ>F.?Y> _?% (+ =>BJ>F.&

QD> J$BB>%=$FHGFY AGYLB>% A$B UG%J$F%GF ?B> *, =>BJ>F. ?FH

+f =>BJ>F. ?FH A$B .D> F?.G$F ?% ? _D$@> +* =>BJ>F. ?FH ('

=>BJ>F.& `QD> %$LBJ> $A ?@@ .D>%> H?.? G% 8GH% K$LF. I?.?

K>F.>B9 c6GB.D% .$ EFC?BBG>H U$C>F9d D..=NooH?.?J>F.>B&

ZGH%J$LF.&$BYoH?.?o.?W@>%of)WGB.D%).$)LFC?BBG>H)_$C>FwH>.

?G@>Ho*o'-9P'oA?@%>o,-,9,-f9'++9+,9+Po?F\o*Pf9*P,&a QD>B> G% F$

GFHGJ?.G$F .D?. .D>%> %.?.>%b @?_%9 $%.>F%GW@\ ?GC>H ?. JD?F)

F>@GFY =B$JB>?.G$F GF.$ C?BBG?Y>9 D?M> D?H ?F\ %LJD >AA>J.&

0 H>YB>> $A ?BWG.B?BGF>%% G% GFD>B>F. GF Y$M>BFC>F. B>YL)

@?.G$F9 WL. _D>F .D>B> G% F$ [L%.GAGJ?.G$F A$B Y$M>BFC>F.b%.B>?.GFY ? .B?HG.G$F?@@\ HG%JBGCGF?.>H)?Y?GF%. YB$L= %GYFGAG)

J?F.@\ _$B%> .D?F .D> H$CGF?F. YB$L= GF .D> %$JG>.\9 H$GFY

%$ H>FG>% >eL?@ =B$.>J.G$F $A .D> @?_%& ;F> _$L@HFb. ZF$_9

B>?HGFY UG%J$F%GFb% WBG>A9 .D?. .D>B> G% $B >M>B D?% W>>F HG%)

JBGCGF?.G$F ?Y?GF%. D$C$%>^L?@% ?F\_D>B> GF .D> EFG.>H

7.?.>%& QD> %.?.> >G.D>B G% $W@GMG$L% .$9 $B .DGFZ% GBB>@>M?F.9

.D?. LF.G@ eLG.> B>J>F.@\ D$C$%>^L?@G.\ _?% ?F?.D>C?.G]>H

W\ .D> M?%. C?[$BG.\ $A D>.>B$%>^L?@% `_DGJD C>?F%9 .D> M?%.

C?[$BG.\ $A .D> 0C>BGJ?F =>$=@>a9 GFJ@LHGFY W\ C$%. 0C>BG)J?F% _D$ _>B> $.D>B_G%> eLG.> @GW>B?@& X$C$%>^L?@% D?H9 ?%

D$C$%>^L?@%9 F$ BGYD.%h D$C$%>^L?@ %>^ _?% JBGCGF?@

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


25/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- *P

`.D$LYD B?B>@\ =B$%>JL.>Hah D$C$%>^L?@% _>B> A$BC?@@\

W?FF>H AB$C .D> ?BC>H A$BJ>% ?FH C?F\ $.D>B .\=>% $A Y$M)

>BFC>F. _$BZ `.D$LYD ?Y?GF >FA$BJ>C>F. _?% %=$B?HGJah

?FH .D>B> _>B> F$ @?_% =B$DGWG.GFY >C=@$\C>F. HG%JBGCGF?)

.G$F ?Y?GF%. D$C$%>^L?@%& 6>J?L%> D$C$%>^L?@G.\ G% C$B>

>?%G@\ J$FJ>?@>H .D?F B?J>9 D$C$%>^L?@% HGH F$. >^=>BG>FJ>

.D> %?C> >J$F$CGJ ?FH >HLJ?.G$F?@ HG%JBGCGF?.G$F9 ?FH =LW)

@GJ DLCG@G?.G$F9 .D?. 0ABGJ?F)0C>BGJ?F% >^=>BG>FJ>H& 6L. .$

?M$GH HG%JBGCGF?.G$F ?FH $%.B?JG%C .D>\ D?H .$ J$FJ>?@ .D>GB

D$C$%>^L?@G.\ ?FH %$ _>B> B>@LJ.?F. .$ =?B.GJG=?.> $=>F@\ GF

D$C$%>^L?@ B>@?.G$F%DG=% $B B>M>?@ .D>GB D$C$%>^L?@G.\ .$.D> D>.>B$%>^L?@% _G.D _D$C .D>\ ?%%$JG?.>H& /$%. $A .D>C

%.?\>H cGF .D> J@$%>.&d 7?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> _?% $L. $A .D>

eL>%.G$F9 >M>F .D$LYD GF.>BB?JG?@ C?BBG?Y> _?% @>Y?@ GF C$%.

%.?.>%& [email protected]$LYD HG%JBGCGF?.G$F ?Y?GF%. D$C$%>^L?@% D?%

HGCGFG%D>H YB>?.@\9 G. B>C?GF% _GH>%=B>?H& 2. =>B%G%.% GF

%.?.L.$B\ A$BC GF 2FHG?F? ?FH GF UG%J$F%GFb% J$F%.G.L.G$F&

0. .D> M>B\ @>?%.9 c? tHG%JBGCGF?.$B\u @?_ CL%. W>?B ? B?)

.G$F?@ B>@?.G$F%DG= .$ ? @>YG.GC?.> Y$M>BFC>F.?@ =LB=$%>&d

H9%N

c;F@\ ? C?BBG?Y> W>._>>F $F> C?F ?FH $F> _$C?F %D?@@ W>

M?@GH $B B>J$YFG]>H ?% ? C?BBG?Y> GF .DG% %.?.>& 0 @>Y?@ %.?.L%

GH>F.GJ?@ $B %LW%.?F.G?@@\ %GCG@?B .$ .D?. $A C?BBG?Y> A$B LF)

C?BBG>H GFHGMGHL?@% %D?@@ F$. W> M?@GH $B B>J$YFG]>H GF .DG%

%.?.>&d ;==$F>F.% $A %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> GF 2FHG?F? D?M>.BG>H A$B ? FLCW>B $A \>?B% .$ GF%>B. ? =B$DGWG.G$F $A %LJD

C?BBG?Y>% GF.$ .D> %.?.>b% J$F%.G.L.G$F9 ?% \>. _G.D$L. %LJ)

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


26/40


27/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- *f

B>%.BGJ.G$F% $F %LJD C?BBG?Y>%& 7>> Q>FF& K$H> 0FF& s +-)+)

'O'h L$+9) /& L$+9)9 ffP #&5&*H fO-9 fOg `2FH& 0==& *OO*a&

2FHG?F? D?% F$. .BG>H .$ >^=@?GF .$ L% .D> @$YGJ $A B>J$YFG]GFY

C?BBG?Y>% $A A>B.G@> AGB%. J$L%GF% `=B$DGWG.>H GF 2FHG?F?a .D?.

D?==>F .$ W> J$F.B?J.>H GF %.?.>% .D?. =>BCG. %LJD C?BBG?Y>%9

WL. $A B>AL%GFY9 W\ MGB.L> $A .D> 'ggf ?C>FHC>F.9 .$ B>J$Y)

FG]> %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>% `?@%$ =B$DGWG.>H GF 2FHG?F?a J$F)

.B?J.>H GF %.?.>% .D?. =>BCG. .D>C& QDG% %LYY>%.% ?FGCL%

?Y?GF%. %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>9 ?% G% ALB.D>B %LYY>%.>H W\ .D>

%.?.>b% GF?WG@G.\ .$ C?Z> ? =@?L%GW@> ?BYLC>F. A$B G.% B>AL%?@

.$ B>J$YFG]> %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>&

6L. W?JZ .$ UG%J$F%GF9 _DGJD C?Z>% A$LB ?BYLC>F.% $A

G.% $_F ?Y?GF%. %LJD C?BBG?Y>N VGB%.9 @GCG.GFY C?BBG?Y> .$

D>.>B$%>^L?@% G% .B?HG.G$F?@ ?FH .B?HG.G$F G% ? M?@GH W?%G% A$B

@GCG.GFY @>Y?@ BGYD.%& 7>J$FH9 .D> J$F%>eL>FJ>% $A ?@@$_GFY

%?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> J?FF$. W> A$B>%>>F ?FH .D>B>A$B> ? %.?.>

%D$L@H W> =>BCG..>H .$ C$M> J?L.G$L%@\S.D?. G%9 .$ H$ F$.D)

GFY9 A$B UG%J$F%GF H$>% F$. %LYY>%. .D?. G. =@?F% .$ .?Z> ?F\

%.>=% GF .D> HGB>J.G$F $A >M>F.L?@@\ ?L.D$BG]GFY %LJD C?B)

BG?Y>& QDGBH9 .D> H>JG%G$F _D>.D>B .$ =>BCG. $B A$BWGH %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> %D$L@H W> @>A. .$ .D> H>C$JB?.GJ =B$J>%%9 .D?. G%9

.$ .D> @>YG%@?.LB> ?FH .D> >@>J.$B?.>& 0FH A$LB.D9 %?C>)%>^

C?BBG?Y> G% ?F?@$Y$L% GF G.% >AA>J.% .$ F$)A?L@. HGM$BJ>9

_DGJD9 .D> %.?.> ?BYL>%9 C?Z>% C?BBG?Y> AB?YG@> ?FH LFB>@G?)

W@>S.D$LYD $A J$LB%> UG%J$F%GF 3$+ F$)A?L@. HGM$BJ>9 ?FH

G.b% %LB=BG%GFY .D?. .D> %.?.>b% ?%%G%.?F. ?..$BF>\ Y>F>B?@9 _D$

?BYL>H .D> %.?.>b% ?==>?@9 _$L@H .B?%D DG% $_F %.?.>b% @?_&

QD> J$F.>F.G$F9 WLG@. $F .D> ?F?@$Y\ .$ F$)A?L@. HGM$BJ> ?FH

%>F%GW@\ HB$==>H GF .D> %.?.>b% WBG>A% GF .DG% J$LB.SWL. .D>

?%%G%.?F. ?..$BF>\ Y>F>B?@ J$L@H F$. B>%G%. B>%L%JG.?.GFY G. ?.

.D> $B?@ ?BYLC>F.SG% .D?.9 ?% .D> %.?.> D?H =L. G. GF %LWCG%)

%G$F% .$ .D> HG%.BGJ. J$LB.9 ?@@$_GFY %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> JB>)

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


28/40

*, #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

?.>% ? H?FY>B $A c%DGA.GFY .D> =LW@GJ LFH>B%.?FHGFY $A C?B)

BG?Y> ?_?\ AB$C ? @?BY>@\ JDG@H)J>F.BGJ GF%.G.L.G$F .$ ?F

?HL@.)J>F.BGJ GF%.G.L.G$F A$JL%>H $F >C$.G$F&d #$ >MGH>FJ> G%

=B>%>F.>H .D?. %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> G% $F ?M>B?Y> @>%% cJDG@H)

J>F.BGJd ?FH C$B> >C$.G$F?@ .D?F ?F GFA>B.G@> C?BBG?Y> $A

D>.>B$%>^L?@%9 $B A$B .D?. C?..>B .D?. F$)A?L@. HGM$BJ> D?%

B>FH>B>H C?BBG?Y> @>%% cJDG@H)J>F.BGJ&d

QD> %.?.>b% ?BYLC>F. AB$C .B?HG.G$F BLF% D>?H $F GF.$

F9/()6 /& ?(76()($9 +,, E&7& ' `'g-fa9 %GFJ> .D> @GCG.?.G$F $A

C?BBG?Y> .$ =>B%$F% $A .D> %?C> B?J> _?% .B?HG.G$F?@ GF ?

FLCW>B $A %.?.>% _D>F .D> 7L=B>C> K$LB. GFM?@GH?.>H G.&

3?_% A$BWGHHGFY W@?JZ)_DG.> C?BBG?Y> H?.>H W?JZ .$ J$@$FG)

?@ .GC>% ?FH _>B> A$LFH GF F$B.D>BF ?% _>@@ ?% %$L.D>BF J$@)

$FG>% ?FH %.?.>%& 7>> :>YY\ :?%J$>9 @3$" 29


29/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- *g

QD> @GCG.?.G$F $F GF.>BB?JG?@ C?BBG?Y> GFM?@GH?.>H GF F9/,

()6 _?% GF $F> B>%=>J. @>%% %>M>B> .D?F UG%J$F%GFb% @?_& 2.

HGH F$. A$BWGH C>CW>B% $A ?F\ B?JG?@ YB$L= .$ C?BB\9 [L%. .$

C?BB\ ? C>CW>B $A ? HGAA>B>F. B?J>& />CW>B% $A HGAA>B>F.

B?J>% D?H GF 'g-f9 ?% W>A$B> ?FH %GFJ>9 ?WLFH?F. =$%%[email protected]>%

A$B AGFHGFY ? %LG.?W@> C?BBG?Y> =?B.F>B $A .D> %?C> B?J>& 2F

J$F.B?%.9 UG%J$F%GFb% @?_9 @GZ> 2FHG?F?b%9 =B>M>F.% ? D$C$)

%>^L?@ AB$C C?BB\GFY ?F\ =>B%$F _G.D .D> %?C> %>^L?@ $BG)

>F.?.G$F9 _DGJD G% .$ %?\ `_G.D $JJ?%G$F?@ >^J>=.G$F%a ?F\

=>B%$F ? D$C$%>^L?@ _$L@H _?F. $B W> _G@@GFY .$ C?BB\&

UG%J$F%GF =$GF.% $L. .D?. C?F\ M>F>B?W@> JL%.$C% ?=)

=>?B .$ B>%. $F F$.DGFY C$B> .D?F .B?HG.G$FS$F> CGYD. >M>F

%?\ $F CGFH@>%% .B?HG.G$F& UD\ H$ C>F _>?B .G>%j UD\ H$

=>$=@> %D?Z> D?FH% `.DL% %=B>?HGFY Y>BC%a $B YGM> ? =>JZ

$F .D> JD>>Z `HG..$a _D>F YB>>.GFY ? ABG>FHj UD\ H$>% .D>

:B>%GH>F. ?. QD?FZ%YGMGFY %=?B> ? WB?J> $A .LBZ>\% `._$ $L.

$A .D> C$B> .D?F (O CG@@G$F .LBZ>\% ZG@@>H A$B QD?FZ%YGMGFY

HGFF>B%a AB$C .D> WL.JD>Bb% ZFGA>j 6L. .D>%> .B?HG.G$F%9 _DG@>

.$ .D> A?%.GHG$L% .D>\ C?\ %>>C %G@@\9 ?B> ?. @>?%. D?BC@>%%& 2A

F$ %$JG?@ W>F>AG. G% J$FA>BB>H W\ ? .B?HG.G$F $)1G. G% _BG..>FGF.$ @?_ $)1G. HG%JBGCGF?.>% ?Y?GF%. ? FLCW>B $A =>$=@> ?FH

H$>% .D>C D?BC W>\$FH [L%. $AA>FHGFY .D>C9 G. G% F$. [L%. ?

D?BC@>%% ?F?JDB$FG%Ch G. G% ? MG$@?.G$F $A .D> >eL?@ =B$.>J)

.G$F J@?L%>9 ?% GF F9/()6& 7>> +,, E&7& ?. ,i'*&

0Y?GF%. .DG% .D> %.?.> ?BYL>% GF G.% $=>FGFY WBG>A .D?. F9/,

()6 c%D$L@H W> B>?H ?% B>J$YFG]GFY .D> J$F%.G.L.G$F?@ B>)

%.BGJ.G$F% $F .D> Y$M>BFC>F.b% ?WG@G.\ .$ GFABGFY> .D> AB>>H$C

$A GFHGMGHL?@% .$ H>JGH> A$B .D>C%>@M>% D$_ .$ ?BB?FY> .D>GB

$_F =BGM?.> ?FH H$C>%.GJ ?AA?GB%&d 6L. .D?. %$LFH% [L%. @GZ>_D?. .D> Y$M>BFC>F. $A UG%J$F%GF D?% H$F>N .$@H D$C$%>^)

L?@% .D?. .D>\ ?B> A$BWGHH>F .$ H>JGH> A$B .D>C%>@M>% D$_ .$

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


30/40

+O #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

?BB?FY> .D>GB =BGM?.> ?FH H$C>%.GJ ?AA?GB%& 2A .D>\ _?F. .$

C?BB\9 .D>\ D?M> .$ C?BB\ ? =>B%$F $A .D> $==$%G.> %>^&

QD> %.?.> >@?W$B?.>% G.% ?BYLC>F. AB$C .D> _$FH>B% $A

.B?HG.G$F W\ ?%%>B.GFY9 ?Y?GF GF G.% $=>FGFY WBG>A9 .D?. c.D$L)

%?FH% $A \>?B% $A J$@@>J.GM> >^=>BG>FJ> D?% t+(8u >%.?W@G%D>H

.B?HG.G$F?@ C?BBG?Y>9 W>._>>F $F> C?F ?FH $F> _$C?F9 ?%

$=.GC?@ A$B .D> A?CG@\9 %$JG>.\9 ?FH JGMG@G]?.G$F&d #$ >MG)

H>FJ> GF %L==$B. $A .D> J@?GC $A $=.GC?@G.\ G% $AA>B>H9 ?FH

.D>B> G% F$ ?JZF$_@>HYC>F. .D?. ? FLCW>B $A J$LF.BG>%

=>BCG. =$@\Y?C\S7\BG?9 4>C>F9 2B?e9 2B?F9 5Y\=.9 7LH?F9

/$B$JJ$9 ?FH 0@Y>BG?S?FH .D?. G. A@$LBG%D>% GF C?F\ 0ABG)

J?F J$LF.BG>% .D?. H$ F$. ?J.L?@@\ ?L.D$BG]> G.9 ?% _>@@ ?% GF

=?B.% $A E.?D& `2FH>>H G.b% W>>F %?GH .D?. c=$@\Y\F\9 _D>B>)

W\ ? C?F J?F D?M> [email protected]=@> _GM>%9 G% .D> C?BBG?Y> A$BC

A$LFH GF C$B> =@?J>% ?FH ?. C$B> .GC>% .D?F ?F\ $.D>B&d

7.>=D?FG> K$$F.]9 L$77($6!= $ M(+"97EQ M9A F9/! 29)W5!7!1

L$77($6! 'O `*OO-a&a 6L. %L==$%> .D> ?%%>B.G$F G% J$BB>J.&

X$_ H$>% .D?. W>?B $F %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>j I$>% UG%J$F%GF

_?F. .$ =L%D D$C$%>^L?@% .$ C?BB\ =>B%$F% $A .D> $==$%G.>

%>^ W>J?L%> $==$%G.>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> G% c$=.GC?@dj I$>% G..DGFZ .D?. ?@@$_GFY %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> _G@@ J?L%> D>.>B$%>^)

L?@% .$ J$FM>B. .$ D$C$%>^L?@G.\j 5AA$B.% .$ J$FM>B. D$C$)

%>^L?@% .$ D>.>B$%>^L?@G.\ D?M> W>>F ? WL%.h G% .D> $==$%G.>

J$FM>B%G$F C$B> A>?%GW@>j

0BYLC>F.% AB$C .B?HG.G$F CL%. W> HG%.GFYLG%D>H AB$C

?BYLC>F.% W?%>H $F C$B?@%& /?F\ LFeL>%.G$F>H @?_% ?B>

A$LFH>H $F C$B?@ =BGFJG=@>% .D?. J?FF$. W> B>HLJ>H .$ J$%.)

W>F>AG. ?F?@\%G%& 3?_% A$BWGHHGFY YB?.LG.$L% JBL>@.\ .$ ?FG)

C?@%9 ?FH @?_% =B$MGHGFY =LW@GJ ?%%G%.?FJ> A$B =$$B ?FH HG%)?W@>H =>B%$F%9 ?B> >^?C=@>%& QD>B> G% _GH>%=B>?H C$B?@ $=)

=$%G.G$F .$ D$C$%>^L?@G.\& QD> $==$F>F.% ?B> >F.G.@>H .$

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


31/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- +'

.D>GB $=GFG$F& 6L. F>G.D>B 2FHG?F? F$B UG%J$F%GF C?Z> ?

C$B?@ ?BYLC>F. ?Y?GF%. =>BCG..GFY %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>&

QD> %.?.>b% %>J$FH ?BYLC>F. G%N cY$ %@$_dN C?GF.?GFGFY

.D> =B$DGWG.G$F $A %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> G% .D> c=BLH>F.9 J?L)

.G$L% ?==B$?JD9d ?FH .D> %.?.> %D$L@H .D>B>A$B> W> ?@@$_>H

c.$ ?J. H>@GW>B?.>@\ ?FH _G.D =BLH>FJ>S$B9 ?. .D> M>B\ @>?%.9

.$ Y?.D>B %LAAGJG>F. GFA$BC?.G$FSW>A$B> .B?F%A$BCGFY .DG%

J$BF>B%.$F> $A JGMG@G]?.G$F ?FH %$JG>.\&d QD>B> G% F$ %LYY>%)

.G$F .D?. .D> %.?.> D?% ?F\ GF.>B>%. GF Y?.D>BGFY GFA$BC?.G$F9

A$B F$.GJ> .D> ?%%LC=.G$F GF .D> eL$.>H =?%%?Y> .D?. .D>

%.?.> ?@B>?H\ C)9A+ .D?. ?@@$_GFY %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> _$L@H

.B?F%A$BC ? cJ$BF>B%.$F> $A JGMG@G]?.G$F ?FH %$JG>.\9d F?C>@\

C$F$Y?C$L% D>.>B$%>^L?@ C?BBG?Y>& ;F> _$L@H >^=>J. .D>

%.?.> .$ D?M> =B$MGH>H +9MGH>FJ>9 +9?%$F .$ W>@G>M>9

D$_>M>B %=>JL@?.GM> ?FH .>FL$L%9 .D?. ?@@$_GFY %?C>)%>^

C?BBG?Y> _G@@ $B C?\ c.B?F%A$BCd C?BBG?Y>& 0. .D> $B?@ ?B)

YLC>F. .D> %.?.>b% @?_\>B J$FJ>H>H .D?. D> D?H F$

ZF$_@>HY> $A ?F\ %.LH\ LFH>B_?\ .$ H>.>BCGF> .D> =$%%GW@>

>AA>J.% $F D>.>B$%>^L?@ C?BBG?Y> GF UG%J$F%GF $A ?@@$_GFY

%?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>& X> HGH %?\ .D?. %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> CGYD.%$C>D$_ H>M?@L> C?BBG?Y>9 .DL% C?ZGFY G. @>%% ?..B?J.GM> .$

$==$%G.>)%>^ J$L=@>%& 6L. D> eLGJZ@\ ?JZF$_@>HY>H .D?. D>

D?HFb. %.LHG>H D$_ %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> CGYD. D?BC C?BBG?Y>

A$B D>.>B$%>^L?@% ?FH _?%Fb. =B>=?B>H .$ ?BYL> .D> =$GF.&

/?%%?JDL%>..%9 .D> AGB%. %.?.> .$ @>Y?@G]> %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>9

HGH %$ ? H>J?H> ?Y$& X?% D>.>B$%>^L?@ C?BBG?Y> GF /?%%?)

JDL%>..% W>>F c.B?F%A$BC>Hdj UG%J$F%GFb% @?_\>B HGHFb.

%LYY>%. G. D?% W>>F&

X> C?\ D?M> W>>F Y>%.LBGFY .$_?BH .D> J$FJ>BF >^)=B>%%>H W\ %$C> .D?. %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> G% @GZ>@\ .$ J?L%>

.D> D>.>B$%>^L?@ C?BBG?Y> B?.> .$ H>J@GF> W>J?L%> D>.>B$%>^)

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


32/40

+* #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

L?@% _D$ ?B> D$%.G@> .$ D$C$%>^L?@%9 $B _D$ _D>.D>B D$%.G@>

.$ .D>C $B F$. .DGFZ .D?. ?@@$_GFY .D>C .$ C?BB\ H>YB?H>%

.D> GF%.G.L.G$F $A C?BBG?Y> `?% CGYD. D?==>F GA =>$=@> _>B>

?@@$_>H .$ C?BB\ .D>GB =>.% $B .D>GB %=$B.% J?B%a9 CGYD. H>)

JGH> F$. .$ C?BB\& 4>. .D> $F@\ %.LH\ .D?. _>bM> HG%J$M>B>H9

? B>=L.?W@> %.?.G%.GJ?@ %.LH\9 AGFH% .D?. ?@@$_GFY %?C>)%>^

C?BBG?Y> D?% F$ >AA>J. $F .D> D>.>B$%>^L?@ C?BBG?Y> B?.>&

/?BJL% IG@@>FH>B9 cQD> I>?.D $A /?BBG?Y>j QD> 5AA>J.% $A

#>_ V$BC% $A 3>Y?@ 1>J$YFG.G$F $F /?BBG?Y> 1?.>% GF .D>

EFG.>H 7.?.>%9d P' 0!BJ>F. .$ ?W$L. ( =>B)

J>F.& QD> >%.GC?.> A$B UG%J$F%GF G% *&, =>BJ>F.9 _DGJD GF)

J@LH>% WG%>^L?@ ?FH .B?F%Y>FH>B>H =>B%$F%&


33/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- ++

?FH DG%.$BG?F%SJ?F =B>HGJ. _G.D ?F\ J>B.?GF.\ _D?. .D>

@$FY).>BC B?CGAGJ?.G$F% $A _GH>%=B>?H ?JJ>=.?FJ> $A %?C>)

%>^ C?BBG?Y> _G@@ W>& 0FH [LHY>% ?B> J>B.?GF@\ F$. >eLG==>H

.$ C?Z> %LJD ?F ?%%>%%C>F.&d UD?. A$@@$_%9 GA =B>HGJ.G$F G%

GC=$%%GW@>j RL%.GJ> 0@G.$ .D$LYD. _D?. A$@@$_% G% .D?. .D>

7L=B>C> K$LB. %D$L@H F$. GF.>BA>B> _G.D K$FYB>%%b% H>.>B)

CGF?.G$F GF .D> I>A>F%> $A /?BBG?Y> 0J. .D?. cC?BBG?Y>9d A$B

=LB=$%>% $A >F.G.@>C>F. .$ A>H>B?@ C?BG.?@ W>F>AG.%9 >^J@LH>%

%?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> >M>F GA @?_AL@ LFH>B %.?.> @?_& 6L. J?F

.D> c@$FY).>BC B?CGAGJ?.G$F%d $A $)EJ$F%.G.L.G$F?@ H>JG%G$F

W> =B>HGJ.>H _G.D J>B.?GF.\ ?. .D> .GC> .D> H>JG%G$F G% B>F)H>B>Hj

QD> %.?.> H$>% F$. C>F.G$F RL%.GJ> 0@G.$b% GFM$J?.G$F $A ?

C$B?@ J?%> ?Y?GF%. %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>9 _D>F D> %.?.>% GF DG%

HG%%>F. .D?. c$.D>B% >^=@?GF .D> W?%G% A$B .D> GF%.G.L.G$F GF

C$B> =DG@$%$=DGJ?@ .>BC%& QD>\ ?BYL> .D?. C?BBG?Y> G% >%%>F)

.G?@@\ .D> %$@>CFG]GFY $A ? J$C=B>D>F%GM>9 >^J@L%GM>9 =>BC?)

F>F. LFG$F .D?. G% GF.BGF%GJ?@@\ $BH>B>H .$ =B$HLJGFY F>_

@GA>9 >M>F GA G. H$>% F$. ?@_?\% H$ %$&d >1& ?. *f',& QD?. G% ?

C$B?@ ?BYLC>F. A$B @GCG.GFY C?BBG?Y> .$ D>.>B$%>^L?@%& QD>%.?.> H$>% F$. C>F.G$F .D> ?BYLC>F. W>J?L%> ?% _> %?GH G.

C$LF.% F$ C$B?@ ?BYLC>F.% ?Y?GF%. %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>&

U> ZF$_ .D?. C?F\ =>$=@> _?F. .$ >F.>B GF.$ ? %?C>)%>^

C?BBG?Y> `.D>B> ?B> CG@@G$F% $A D$C$%>^L?@ 0C>BGJ?F%9

.D$LYD $A J$LB%> F$. ?@@ $A .D>C _?F. .$ C?BB\a9 ?FH .D?.

A$BWGHHGFY .D>C .$ H$ %$ GC=$%>% ? D>?M\ J$%.9 AGF?FJG?@ ?FH

>C$.G$F?@9 $F .D>C ?FH .D>GB JDG@HB>F& UD?. UG%J$F%GF D?%

F$. .$@H L% G% _D>.D>B ?F\ D>.>B$%>^L?@% D?M> W>>F D?BC>H

W\ %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>& ;WMG$L%@\ C?F\ =>$=@> ?B> HG%).B>%%>H W\ .D> GH>? $B B>?@G.\ $A %LJD C?BBG?Y>h $.D>B_G%>

.D>%> ._$ J?%>% _$L@HFb. W> D>B>& 6L. .D>B> G% ? HGAA>B>FJ>9

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


34/40

+( #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

A?C$L%@\ >C=D?%G]>H W\ R$DF 7.L?B. /G@@ GF D) F(B!7"E

`',-ga9 W>._>>F .D> HG%.B>%% .D?. G% J?L%>H W\ ?F ?%%[email protected] $B ?

.D>A. $A =B$=>B.\9 $B ?F GFM?%G$F $A =BGM?J\9 $B A$B .D?. C?..>B

HG%JBGCGF?.G$F9 ?FH .D> HG%.B>%% .D?. G% J?L%>H W\ W>D?MG$B

.D?. HG%YL%.% %$C> =>$=@> WL. H$>% F$ `$.D>Ba D?BC .$ .D>C&

/G@@ ?BYL>H .D?. F>G.D>B @?_ `Y$M>BFC>F. B>YL@?.G$Fa F$B

C$B?@G.\ `J$FH>CF?.G$F W\ =LW@GJ $=GFG$Fa D?% ?F\ =B$=>B

J$FJ>BF _G.D ?J.% .D?.9 LF@GZ> ? =LFJD GF .D> F$%>9 GFA@GJ. F$

.>C=$B?@ D?BC $F ?F$.D>B =>B%$F _G.D$L. J$F%>F. $B [L%.GAG)

J?.G$F& QD> eL?@GAGJ?.G$F "!\& Q$ W> .D> W?%G% $A

@>Y?@ $B C$B?@ J$FJ>BF9 /G@@ ?BYL>H9 .D> D?BC CL%. W> .?FYG)W@>9 %>JL@?B9 C?.>BG?@S=D\%GJ?@ $B AGF?FJG?@9 $B9 GA >C$.G$F?@9

A$JL%>H ?FH HGB>J.SB?.D>B .D?F C$B?@ $B %=GBG.L?@& /G@@ G@@L%)

.B?.>H F$F.>C=$B?@ D?BC _G.D B>ML@%G$F ?Y?GF%. =$@\Y?C\

GF E.?D `D> _?% _BG.GFY W>A$B> E.?D ?YB>>H9 ?% ? J$FHG.G$F $A

W>GFY ?HCG..>H .$ .D> LFG$F ?% ? %.?.>9 .$ ?C>FH G.% J$F%.G.L)

.G$F .$ =B$DGWG. =$@\Y?C\a& QD> 5FY@G%D =>$=@> _>B> AG>BJ>@\

JBG.GJ?@ $A =$@\Y?C\ _D>B>M>B G. $JJLBB>H& 0% .D>\ _>B> >F.G)

.@>H .$ W>& 6L. .D>B> _?% F$ _?\ =$@\Y?C\ GF E.?D J$L@H

D?M> ?HM>B%> >AA>J.% GF 5FY@?FH9 (OOO CG@>% ?_?\& /G@@

HGHFb. .DGFZ .D?. =$@\Y?C\9 D$_>M>B $AA>F%GM>9 _?% ? =B$=>B

[email protected]?@ J$FJ>BF $A 5FY@?FH&

7GCG@?B@\9 _DG@> C?F\ D>.>B$%>^L?@% `.D$LYD GF 0C>BGJ?

? B?=GH@\ HGCGFG%DGFY FLCW>Ba HG%?==B$M> $A %?C>)%>^ C?B)

BG?Y>9 .D>B> G% F$ _?\ .D>\ ?B> Y$GFY .$ W> DLB. W\ G. GF ? _?\

.D?. .D> @?_ _$L@H .?Z> J$YFG]?FJ> $A& UG%J$F%GF H$>%Fb.

?BYL> $.D>B_G%>& /?F\ =>$=@> %.B$FY@\ HG%?==B$M>H $A GF)

.>BB?JG?@ C?BBG?Y>9 ?FH9 C$B> .$ .D> =$GF.9 C?F\ =>$=@>

%.B$FY@\ HG%?==B$M>H `?FH %.G@@ %.B$FY@\ HG%?==B$M>a $A D$)

C$%>^L?@ %>^9 \>. F9/()6 /& ?(76()($ GFM?@GH?.>H %.?.> @?_%

W?FFGFY GF.>BB?JG?@ C?BBG?Y>9 ?FH F$A7!)8! /& P!O$+ GFM?@G)

H?.>H %.?.> @?_% W?FFGFY D$C$%>^L?@ %>^ ?J.%&

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


35/40


36/40

+- #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

FG]>H&d UG%& K$F%.& 0B.& x2229 s '+& I$C>%.GJ =?B.F>B%DG= GF

UG%J$F%GF G% F$. ?FH J?FF$. W> C?BBG?Y> W\ ?F$.D>B F?C>&

2. G% .BL> .D?. W>J?L%> .D> %.?.> H$>% F$. B>Y?BH %?C>)%>^

C?BBG?Y>% J$F.B?J.>H GF $.D>B %.?.>% ?% _D$@@\ M$GH `.D$LYD

.D>\ ?B> F$. cB>J$YFG]>Hd GF UG%J$F%GFa9 JG.G]>F% $A UG%J$F)

%GF _D$ J$F.B?J. %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>% GF %.?.>% GF _DGJD %LJD

C?BBG?Y>% ?B> @>Y?@ ?B> F$. H>W?BB>H AB$C B>J>GMGFY %$C> $A

.D> A>H>B?@ W>F>AG.% .$ _DGJD @>Y?@@\ C?BBG>H =>B%$F% `GF)

J@LHGFY =?B.G>% .$ ? %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>a ?B> >F.G.@>H& #$. .$

?@@ .D$%> W>F>AG.%9 D$_>M>B9 W>J?L%> ? FLCW>B $A .D>C ?B>

@GCG.>H W\ A>H>B?@ @?_ .$ =>B%$F% _D$ B>%GH> GF ? %.?.> GF

_DGJD .D>GB C?BBG?Y>% ?B> B>J$YFG]>H& QD>%> GFJ@LH> W>F>AG.%

LFH>B .D> V?CG@\ n />HGJ?@ 3>?M> 0J.9 %>> *g K&V&1&

s ,*P&'**`Wa9 ?FH ?JJ>%% .$ ? %=$L%>b% %$JG?@ %>JLBG.\ W>F>AG.%&

7>> (* E&7&K& s ('-`Da`'a`0a`Ga&

7$ @$$Z _D?. .D> %.?.> D?% H$F>N G. D?% .DB$_F ? JBLCW .$

%?C>)%>^ J$L=@>%9 H>F\GFY .D>C F$. $F@\ C?F\ $A .D> BGYD.%

?FH C?F\ $A .D> W>F>AG.% $A C?BBG?Y> WL. ?@%$ $A J$LB%> .D>

F?C>& 2C?YGF> GA GF .D> 'g-O% .D> %.?.>% .D?. A$BW?H> GF.>BB?)

JG?@ C?BBG?Y> D?H %?GH .$ GF.>BB?JG?@ J$L=@>%N c\$L J?F D?M>H$C>%.GJ =?B.F>B%DG=% .D?. JB>?.> .D> GH>F.GJ?@ BGYD.% ?FH $W)

@GY?.G$F% $A C?BBG?Y>9 WL. \$L J?F J?@@ .D>C $F@\ mJGMG@ LF)

G$F%b $B mH$C>%.GJ =?B.F>B%DG=%&b QD> .>BC mC?BBG?Y>b G% B>)

%>BM>H A$B %?C>)B?J> LFG$F%&d QDG% _$L@H YGM> GF.>BB?JG?@

J$L=@>% CLJD C$B> .D?F UG%J$F%GFb% H$C>%.GJ =?B.F>B%DG=

%.?.L.> YGM>% %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>%& 4>. _G.DD$@HGFY .D> .>BC

cC?BBG?Y>d _$L@H W> J$F%GH>B>H H>>=@\ $AA>F%GM>9 ?FH9 D?M)

GFY F$ [L%.GAGJ?.G$F $.D>B .D?F WGY$.B\9 _$L@H W> GFM?@GH?.>H

?% ? H>FG?@ $A >eL?@ =B$.>J.G$F&QD> C$%. ?BWG.B?B\ A>?.LB> $A UG%J$F%GFb% .B>?.C>F. $A

%?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% G% G.% B>AL%?@ .$ ?@@$_ J$L=@>% GF H$C>%.GJ

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


37/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- +f

=?B.F>B%DG=% .$ ?H$=. [$GF.@\9 ?% C?BBG>H D>.>B$%>^L?@ J$L)

=@>% ?B> ?@@$_>H .$ H$ `?FH GF 2FHG?F?9 >M>F LFC?BBG>H

$F>%a& QD> B>AL%?@ D?BC% .D> JDG@HB>F9 W\ .>@@GFY .D>C .D>\

H$Fb. D?M> ._$ =?B>F.%9 @GZ> $.D>B JDG@HB>F9 ?FH D?BC% .D>

=?B>F. _D$ G% F$. .D> ?H$=.GM> =?B>F. W\ H>=BGMGFY DGC $B

D>B $A .D> @>Y?@ %.?.L% $A ? =?B>F.& QD> %.?.> $AA>B% F$ [L%.GAG)

J?.G$F&

UG%J$F%GFb% B>C?GFGFY ?BYLC>F. G% .D?. .D> W?F $F %?C>)

%>^ C?BBG?Y> G% .D> $L.J$C> $A ? H>C$JB?.GJ =B$J>%%S.D>

>F?J.C>F. $A ? J$F%.G.L.G$F?@ W?F W\ =$=L@?B M$.>& 6L. D$)

C$%>^L?@% ?B> $F@\ ? %C?@@ =?B. $A .D> %.?.>b% =$=L@?.G$FS

*&, =>BJ>F.9 _> %?GH9 YB$L=GFY .B?F%Y>FH>B>H ?FH WG%>^L?@

=>B%$F% _G.D D$C$%>^L?@%& /GF$BG.G>% .B?C=@>H $F W\ .D>

H>C$JB?.GJ =B$J>%% D?M> B>J$LB%> .$ .D> J$LB.%h .D> B>J$LB%>

G% J?@@>H J$F%.G.L.G$F?@ @?_&

2F G.% B>=@\ WBG>A 2FHG?F? ?H$=.% UG%J$F%GFb% H>C$JB?J\

?BYLC>F.9 ?HHGFY .D?. cD$C$%>^L?@% ?B> [email protected]?@@\ =$_>B)

AL@ $L. $A =B$=$B.G$F .$ .D>GB FLCW>B%&d #$ >MGH>FJ> G% =B>)

%>F.>H W\ .D> %.?.> .$ %L==$B. .DG% J$F.>F.G$F& 2. G% .BL> .D?.

?F GFJB>?%GFY FLCW>B $A D>.>B$%>^L?@% %L==$B. %?C>)%>^C?BBG?Y>h $.D>B_G%> '' %.?.>% _$L@H F$. D?M> JD?FY>H .D>GB

@?_% .$ =>BCG. %LJD C?BBG?Y> `.D> $.D>B , %.?.>% .D?. ?@@$_

%?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> H$ %$ ?% ? B>%L@. $A [LHGJG?@ H>JG%G$F% GF)

M?@GH?.GFY .D> %.?.>%b W?F%a& #$ GFA>B>FJ> $A C?FG=L@?.G$F $A

.D> H>C$JB?.GJ =B$J>%% W\ D$C$%>^L?@% J?F W> HB?_F9 D$_)

>M>B9 ?F\ C$B> .D?F G. J$L@H W> GFA>BB>H AB$C .D> >F?J.C>F.

$A JGMG@ BGYD.% @?_% .D?. 0ABGJ?F)0C>BGJ?F% c?B> [email protected]?@@\

=$_>BAL@ $L. $A =B$=$B.G$F .$ .D>GB FLCW>B%&d 2. G% .$ .D>

JB>HG. $A 0C>BGJ?F M$.>B% .D?. .D>\ H$ F$. %L==$B. $F@\ @?_%.D?. ?B> GF .D>GB =?@=?W@> %>@A)GF.>B>%.& QD>\ %L==$B. @?_%

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


38/40

+, #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

=LFG%DGFY JBL>@.\ .$ ?FGC?@%9 >M>F .D$LYD F$. ? %GFY@> ?FG)

C?@ D?% ? M$.>&

Q$ B>.LBF .$ _D>B> _> %.?B.>H GF .DG% $=GFG$F9 C$B> .D?F

LF%L==$B.>H J$F[>J.LB> .D?. %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> _G@@ D?BC

D>.>B$%>^L?@ C?BBG?Y> $B JDG@HB>F $B ?F\ $.D>B M?@GH ?FH

GC=$B.?F. GF.>B>%. $A ? %.?.> G% F>J>%%?B\ .$ [L%.GA\ HG%JBGCG)

F?.G$F $F .D> W?%G% $A %>^L?@ $BG>F.?.G$F& 0% _> D?M> W>>F ?.

=?GF% .$ >^=@?GF9 .D> YB$LFH% ?HM?FJ>H W\ 2FHG?F? ?FH UG%)

J$F%GF A$B .D>GB HG%JBGCGF?.$B\ =$@GJG>% ?B> F$. $F@\ J$F[>J)

.LB?@h .D>\ ?B> .$.?@@\ GC=@?L%GW@>&

V$B J$C=@>.>F>%% _> F$.> .D> [email protected]?.> J$FM>BY>FJ> $A

$LB %GC=@GAG>H A$LB)%.>= ?F?@\%G% _G.D .D> C$B> A?CG@G?B9 WL.

?@%$ C$B> J$C=@>^9 ?==B$?JD A$LFH GF C?F\ J?%>%& 2F

J #GF.D KGBJLG. J$FJ@LH>H9 W?%>H $F ?

B>?HGFY $A .D> 7L=B>C> K$LB.b% H>JG%G$F% GF F$A7!)8! ?FH

@()1+979 .D?. %.?.L.>% .D?. HG%JBGCGF?.> $F .D> W?%G% $A %>^L?@

$BG>F.?.G$F ?B> %LW[>J. .$ cD>GYD.>F>H %JBL.GF\dS?FH GF H$)

GFY %$ F$.>H .D?. @()1+979 GF GFM?@GH?.GFY .D> I>A>F%> $A

/?BBG?Y> 0J.9 D?H W?@?FJ>H .D> 0J.b% D?BC% ?FH $AA%>..GFYW>F>AG.%N c#$.?W@\ ?W%>F. AB$C @()1+97b% B>MG>_ $A I;/0

?B> .D> m%.B$FY =B>%LC=.G$Fb GF A?M$B $A .D> J$F%.G.L.G$F?@G.\

$A @?_% ?FH .D> m>^.B>C>@\ H>A>B>F.G?@b =$%.LB> .$_?BH Y$M)

>BFC>F. ?J.G$F .D?. ?B> .D> C?BZ% $A B?.G$F?@ W?%G% B>MG>_& v

2F G.% =?B.GFY %>F.>FJ>%9 @()1+97>^=@GJG.@\ ?FF$LFJ>% G.% W?@)

?FJGFY $A .D> Y$M>BFC>F.b% GF.>B>%. ?Y?GF%. .D> D?BC $B GF[L)

B\ .$ Y?\% ?FH @>%WG?F%N mQD> A>H>B?@ %.?.L.> G% GFM?@GH9 A$B F$

@>YG.GC?.> =LB=$%> 9/!789 =LB=$%> ?FH >AA>J. .$ HG%)

=?B?Y> ?FH GF[LB> .D$%> _D$C .D> 7.?.>9 W\ G.% C?BBG?Y>@?_%9 %$LYD. .$ =B$.>J. GF =>B%$FD$$H ?FH HGYFG.\&b '++ 7&

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


39/40

#$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*- +g

K.& ?. *-g- `>C=D?%G% ?HH>Ha& @()1+97b% W?@?FJGFY G% F$. .D>

_$BZ $A B?.G$F?@ W?%G% B>MG>_&d

QD> 7L=B>C> K$LB. ?@%$ %?GH GF @()1+97 .D?. c.D> 0J.b%

H>C$F%.B?.>H =LB=$%> G% .$ >F%LB> .D?. GA ?F\ 7.?.> H>JGH>%

.$ B>J$YFG]> %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y>%9 .D$%> LFG$F% _G@@ W> .B>?.)

>H ?% %>J$FH)J@?%% C?BBG?Y>% A$B =LB=$%>% $A A>H>B?@ @?_&d

'++ 7& K.& ?. *-g+ig(& 0 %>J$FH)J@?%% C?BBG?Y> _$L@H W> ? @$.

W>..>B .D?F .D> J$D?WG.?.G$F .$ _DGJD 2FHG?F? ?FH UG%J$F%GF

D?M> J$F%GYF>H %?C>)%>^ J$L=@>%&

QD> %.?.>%b J$FJ>BF _G.D .D> =B$W@>C $A LF_?F.>H JDG@)HB>F G% M?@GH ?FH GC=$B.?F.9 WL. .D>GB %[email protected]$F G% F$. c.?G)

@$B>Hd .$ .D> =B$W@>C9 W>J?L%> W\ H>F\GFY C?BG.?@ BGYD.% .$

%?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% G. B>HLJ>% .D> GFJ>F.GM> $A %LJD J$L=@>% .$

?H$=. LF_?F.>H JDG@HB>F ?FH GC=?GB% .D> _>@A?B> $A .D$%>

JDG@HB>F _D$ ?B> ?H$=.>H W\ %LJD J$L=@>%& QD> %.?.>%b %$@L)

.G$F G% .DL%9 GF .D> A?CG@G?B .>BCGF$@$Y\ $A J$F%.G.L.G$F?@ HG%)

JBGCGF?.G$F @?_9 c$M>BGFJ@L%GM>&d 2. G% ?@%$ LFH>BGFJ@L%GM>9 GF

?@@$_GFY GFA>B.G@> D>.>B$%>^L?@ J$L=@>% .$ C?BB\9 WL. F$.

%?C>)%>^ J$L=@>%&

6>A$B> >FHGFY .DG% @$FY $=GFG$F _> F>>H .$ ?HHB>%%9

.D$LYD $F@\ M>B\ WBG>A@\9 UG%J$F%GFb% J$C=@?GF. ?W$L. .D>

_$BHGFY $A .D> GF[LFJ.G$F >F.>B>H W\ .D> HG%.BGJ. [LHY>& 2.%

@?_\>B% J@?GC .$ A>?B .D> %.?.>b% W>GFY D>@H GF J$F.>C=. W>)

J?L%> G. H$>%Fb. ZF$_ _D?. C>?%LB>% _$L@H %?.G%A\ .D> GF)

[LFJ.G$Fb% J$CC?FH .D?. ?@@ B>@>M?F. %.?.> $AAGJG?@% c.B>?.

%?C>)%>^ J$L=@>% .D> %?C> ?% HGAA>B>F. %>^ J$L=@>% GF .D>

J$F.>^. $A =B$J>%%GFY ? C?BBG?Y> @GJ>F%> $B H>.>BCGFGFY .D>

BGYD.%9 =B$.>J.G$F%9 $W@GY?.G$F% $B W>F>AG.% $A C?BBG?Y>&d 2A

.D> %.?.>b% @?_\>B% B>?@@\ AGFH .DG% J$CC?FH LFJ@>?B9 .D>\%D$L@H ?%Z .D> HG%.BGJ. [LHY> A$B J@?BGAGJ?.G$F& `QD>\ %D$L@H

D?M> H$F> %$ ?@B>?H\h .D>\ D?M>Fb.&a 6>..>B \>.9 .D>\ %D$L@H

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(


40/40

(O #$%& '()*+,- .$ '()*+,,9 '()*P*-

HB?_ L= ? =@?F $A J$C=@G?FJ> ?FH %LWCG. G. .$ .D> [LHY> A$B

?==B$M?@&

QD> HG%.BGJ. J$LB. [LHYC>F.% GFM?@GH?.GFY ?FH >F[$GFGFY

.D>%> ._$ %.?.>%b =B$DGWG.G$F% $A %?C>)%>^ C?BBG?Y> ?B>

0VV21/5I&

!"#$% '()*+,- ./012$34% *'* 567$8% 9:;9(;*9'(

7th Circuit Same Sex Marriage

Documents

Transcript of 7th Circuit Same Sex Marriage