670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f...

13
) : / / : / / ( ! " ) $ % & $ ( () *+ ,- . /0 1 2 *34 * 5 670 8 8 9 : ! "#$ $ #%&’ ()" *&’ (#+ , "$- ./0 ! 1234 #%&’ ()" *&’ ); : 5#$$" 6)7" (0 0’ &8 #- 9:’ ;’’ ()"- 8< =2$> =2$> "8 2 ?@$ =2B (>/" #2- . D$" E2 22’! 2EF’2G H- >8 )"I ?@$ 2>2 6J2K 6L /’! #’ . M$ )"I 6 D$" 8 N4 D$" O 6J2K 6L #P’ 2P> )/"’2 Q/GF 8 &K&FI O- 6L . PG P42RS 6L#PT’ .P’ 6PL D$" 8 ?@$ .’ "$- 8& 3G 2@ #’ . G PG EF’2PU 0NU2PF’ 0NG2VNW /F2/8 X2O/KI 6L PR+ 6PL X2 M$ G (’E/ 42RS L YKF G #’ "L . "8 D$" ’BZ 6L ![ 6* "8 2 ?@$ /R/-2\V 6L (& R/3G Q/GF 6’’ L 6R! G #L P"’ P//]F HZT ^8 F _"2) ‘/")W 8 /3: . P% P%E 8& 0 ![ (28 D$" W2FE’ /R/-2\V 6L M$ L 6L M8’ 0’ GT "8 2 6 6#&27 %/)V 6 D$" (I 6L (I (% *)"7 L "L . HR)B D$" 6R! *)"7 .F =J PM$ L 6#/\2)/’! 6L )"2W /2O/KI Q/GF 8 )BF 6 /3W) 8 ’RL M$ 6L 2F .’ H/%&F a48 G "’ *)"7 6 bP/ P8 >8 L )! ‘G ‘ST 8 F M$ 0’ F "’ #- )"I 6 . 7= : D$" >8 )"I R/3G ./2I) )7$- W2FE’ /3: $ 2 ?@ "8 8 cP4 ]> 6PL dP/’ ef PF º g X2P@ RP- 6PL dP/’]> g g dPF eh g :P- #- #B # ) Hi- ( . $ .’ ?@ (0 6PL 2P!! jkP)7’ 27 8 =2$> #- 7 b!’0 XR- - # 2F (I L 6#/\2)/’! 6 (2PR$7 )P"I P>8 #’ . P"8 ./’ PL P$ .P’ HPU l/FR)P/" 6 ?@ _"2F ] [ " Q: (’2$4 BF 6)U 6 » $/p "$- 17 q2!p l/2)iF 6V2)W 8I « P"’ )! 1S’ ] s [ XPP" ett QPP: ?@PP$ .PP’ 82PP$> uPP8 (PW P (’2P$4 PBF #P-’ P"$-U 6 » P"8 6PL ./0 )W P"$- D$P" 6V2P P/T 6#P/\2)/’! 6PL 6 )"I -2! « "’ ’: "8 2 . ./P$vRL ] [ P" PS’ FPS 2P!! 3wP 2P7 6P)U 6 /FR*W P"’ ’: "8 2 ?@$ .’ 6L . ] g [ (W " #-’ "$-U P"8 8 27 6)U 6 ! ./0 D$" 6R- 8 "$- 2F "$- 6J2K 6L * .K3F X2w #$2 : hxtetx,yx W %/)%’ : [email protected] X" SL R- ‘L# 6 g ()0 BKZ 0’ 6 zg{ F z Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 16:09 +0330 on Friday February 7th 2020

Transcript of 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f...

Page 1: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

)����� ����:�/��/������� ���� :��/�/��(

����� �� �� ������ �������� ����������� ����� ��������� ����� ��! ���� �" )� $���%��&$� ��� (()� � �*���+ ,�- ������� .���� �/ ��0 ������ ���

1�� 2����

�*���34 ����*5�670 ���8� ��8� 9:

��� �� ! ��"#$�� � �$ �#%&�'� �(�)" � ��*&�'�(#+ ,��"�$- ./�0 �� ! �1234 �#%&�'� �(�)" � ��*&�'�

��);:5#$$" 6��)7�" (�0 0' �&�8 � �#- 9:'� ;'�' (�)" �- �8 < =2$> � =2$> �� �"� 8 ��2� ?@�$� –=2�B� (�> /" ��#�2- .D$" E�2� � ��2�2�' ! ���2�EF�'2G H��- � >� 8 � ���)"I ?@�$� �� �2>2� 6J2K� 6�L�/�' !�#�' .��M$� �� ���)"I 6

D$" 8 ��N4 D$" ��� O��� 6J2K� 6�L #P��'� �2P>� �)/"'�2� Q/G F �8 ���&K&FI �O- 6�L .���PG �P42RS� 6�L#PT'� .P' 6�PLD$" �8 ?@�$� .' �� �"�$- �8�&� �3G �2@#�' .���G ���PG EF�'2PU � 0NU2PF�' �0NG2VNW ��/F2/8 �X2O/K�I 6�L PR+� 6�PL �� �� X2��M$� ���G ('E/� �� �42RS� L Y��KF �G #�'�"�L .�"� 8 D$" ��' BZ 6�L �![� � 6��*� �"� 8 ��2� ?@�$� ��/R/-2\V 6�L

�� (�&� �R/�3G Q/G F 6'�'� �� L ���� 6�R!�� �G #L���P"' P//]F HZ�T � ^�8 �F _"2)� `/"�)W �8 ��/3: .����P%� �P%�E� �8�&� � ����0 �![� (�28 D$" �W2F�E' � ��/R/-2\V 6�L ��M$� �� L 6�L �M8'� 0' �G�T �"� 8 ��2� 66#���&27 � �%/)�V 6

D$" (I 6�L (I (��% ��*)"�7 ���� �� � �L�"�L .HR)B�D$" ���� 6�R!�� ��*)"�7 . F =�J ��P�M$� �� L 6#/\2)/�' ! 6�L�)"2W �/�2O/K�I Q/G F �8 ���)BF 6�/3W�)� �8 �' RL ��M$� 6�L ��2F .' H/%&F a4�8 �G �"' ��*)"�7 6b�P/�� �P8 � >� 8 �� �L

�� )�!`G `ST �8 � F��M$� 0' F�"' �#- ���)"I 6.

��������7=�:D$" �� >� 8 ����)"I�R/�3G �./�2�I�)� ��)7�$-��W2F�E' ���/3:

����� $����2� ?@�"� 8 �8c P4 ]> 6�PL d��P/' ef˚�� �PF º�g

X2PP@ � ���RPP-6�PPLd��PP/' ]> g�˚g�d�PPF eh˚g� �: PP- �#- ��#B�'#�)Hi-�(.$� .'�?@(�0 6�PL �2P! !� ��� '�

��'� j�kP)7' �27 �8 =2$> �� '� �#- � 7 b !'0 � X�R--'#���2F (I �� ��L6#/\2)/�' ! 6(2PR$7� ���)P"I � � P>� 8

#��'�.�P"� 8 ./��' PL P$� .P' �� HP��U � l/F�R)�P/" 6��?@

_"2F]�[���"� Q��: �� ('2$4 �BF 6 )U� 6»�$/p ��"�$-

1 7 q2!���p l/�2)iF � 6V2�� )W ��8I «� �P"' �) ! 1�S�']s[X�PP" �� �ett QPP��: �� '� ?@�PP$� .PP' �82PP$> uPP�8

(�PP�W �PP��� ('2PP$4 �PPBF #PP-�' �PP"�$-��U 6»�PP"� 8 6�PPL./�0 � )W � �P"�$- D$P" 6V2P� �P/T�� 6#P/\2)/�' ! 6�PL 6���)"I–�-2! «�"' ��'� �' : �"� 8 ��2� ../P$vRL]�[�����PP"� ��PPS' � �F���PPS� ��2PP! !� �3w�PP� �2PP7 6 PP)U� 6

�/F�R*W �P"' ��'� �' : �"� 8 ��2� '� ?@�$� .' 6�L .]g��[(��W �� ���"� � #-�' �"�$-��U ���� �P"� 8 �8 �27 6 )U� 6! ./�0 D$" �6��R- �� ��8 � �"�$- ��2F �"�$- 6J2K� 6�L

*.K3F �X2w�� �#$�2� :hx�tetx,�yx �W�%/�� )%�' �� :[email protected]

X�"SL��R- �`L#�6g�(�)��0��BKZ 0' ��6zg{ �F z��

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 2: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

�S37 6#RT' ��O"�R�@ (' ' �"�$- ���G � �"�$-�238 �3S� zg�

��M$� �F���S� ��2! !� ��P"' �)7'� W � >� 8 6.]z[EP/� ���� (��W �� �![� �27 6 )G� 6" 6�LD$D$P" �)7�$--

�"' ��'� �' : �"� 8 ��2� '� ���)"I .�JI 6�L .�8 X�T .' �8 D$" �3w�� 02$L �i$' �8 �>2F ��2PF ��/R/-2\V � �)7�$--

�PM8'� � ���)"I � � >� 8 6#/\2)/�' ! 6�L (I 6�� `PL �P8 �PL���L ��*)"�7 � |2� ��2� �� �F��K)� 6�L }� � ��28 1��8' 0' 6'

/�' ! .' �"' �#- ~ M� �L#/\2)]���[��)P-2� .P' �� '�P� ��![� �F �#- �+" D$" �3)�� 6�L ��/R/P-2\V � �)7�$P-

��2F �PM8'� �2>� � ��&� ?@�$� .' 6#/\2)/�' ! 6�L �P 6�M8'� 1#4 D$" ���� 6�R!�� 6 *#Pi �P8 ?@�P$� .P' 6�PL

#�2- �"� 8.

2��� ����- ����� $����2� ?@�"� 8 u�8 �� 5#$$" �'2� �8 < X�R-�

�� � (�> /"= <=2$> ��8 < (�)" �- ;'�'�) ! �' : '#�)Hi-�.(�R#: �)&�� . F $� .' �� �2>2� 6�L��8 ?@

b� F�)�8'� =2$> �� �U ��28 ?@�$� .' � #��'� (2R$7� H��-D$"�#- (2! !� ���&K&FI 6�L�^ (��� �8 0' ��L

�F �0�� 6�L � ��^ `/��#�' ]s[��)&�� . F##> �6�L(I�L�� 8I �"' ��T #�4 6�L .$� .' ����42RS� �?@ 6

�/T�� ��2! !� ����7� _' - 0' �K/@ �8 6'6EO" ��/- �F�/�2O/K�I�� �#� ��2F J2K� �@ �� �U �2-�L66#/\2)/�' !

��6�)"'�(I �)02)�/- �M" �42RS� l �L (2! !� 6�F���S�)�3K��2L (�"' �#- HZ�T ]g�z.[p !�]��{[

��M$� �� 6J2K� �/��+ ./��' �U #�#�)+� (��0 �� � >� 8 6. 0 �"�F U)��#TMa �s� (��'� �� �2F � �"'�66J2K�

��'�' �� � ./O�I (��0 �� ���)"I 0' 6 *� 6 " (I 6�/�' ! ����W �"�F U �� � >� 8 6�L�I ."2w��W .0�<)Ma

�s�{�(�U T �@./�0 6�L ��I �)7�")#/�'�^ ��"�F U���:2 (�#- H/i&F." .//+F ��� �#�' �8 �) ! 1�S�' 6�L q��Pb�U��2F .' �3)�� 6�L#T'� .U 0 ���U 6�� ��L

(��i ."Ma �{� ��{� )���/� l/"'��V(�� (�&� '� -H/i&F 0' �U�T �U #$L�(I�L �/��+ QO" �8 �'EL2U 0�

���/� . /R/" �"']z�f��[.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 3: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

#3>�f���R- ���(�)��0 �efx �![� 0' ���K)"'���U 6�L�"�$- ��/R/-2\V �)/�' ! #/\26�L . . .zg�

(>�5&���6./�0 �#- ���" �"�$- ��2� ?@�$� 0' 6' �"� 8 ]�[.

��.�! � .�= ?�. �P/�F � �P"� 8 ��2P� ?@�$� 0' 6�'� 8 ��2R� 0' �W 9@�P�� 6

��2R� .' 0' ;0�� ��L�8�![� �"� 8 �2}$� �/R/P-2\V 6�PL���2F 66#/\2)/�' ! � >� 8��'#+F ��0' ��2R� �3Z' 6�L#T'� (I �PPPPPPP8 q��ICP-AES �ICP-MS �� ��*&PPPPPPPP��0I

ALSChemex ��/R/- E/���I '����U #�#-)��'� 0' �L]��z[(�=�/RG � �3Z' Z�$4 E/���I 6' 8��2F 66#P/\2)/�' ! ����)P"I

�'#+F �y0' ��2R� (I �3PZ' 6�L#PT'� q�� �P8 6�PLXRF �ICP-MS �� 1�PS�' X�' �P��� _P"2F ��/���P"' 6'23L ��*&�'�

� !)X�#>�L6��s(.��2W ���� �3Z' Z�$4 E/���I 6' 8#PP- �PP/�F j PP: ��PP" �.0' �PPW �PP8 =�PP/RG PPZ�$4 6' PP8

�P8 ��P��� � ��#P 3G #/P"' � �P )/� #/P"' �8 �2-#/"'#�#�I �"� �8 }� ��2� Z�$4 j�7 6�L��'#��)"' .

@�� 5���I 6�L D$" =�/RU � �3Z' Z�$4 E/���)"I ��M$� .�JI.��2�EF�'2U ��2�2�' ! �/�' !�E�2� �/"'�2�

samples 24 28 As5 Ch1 K2 Sa14 Sa2 CSa15 33 38 As15 SiO2 �/t� y/t� t, �/t� t/te e/te ,/tx �/yh y/ty ,/ty f/ty

TiO2 �/h t/h �/h �/h �/h t/h e/h e/h �/h �/h �/hAl2O3 �/�t t/�t t/�t x/�� �t �t �/�� y/�� �/�t �/�t ,/�t

Fe2O3T y/t x/t �/t �/t �/t e/t t/e t/e �/e ,/e eFeO �/t ,/t �/� �/� t/� f/� e/e e/e f/, x/, f/,MgO �/e �/e x/, f/, x/, x/, �/� �/� t/� t/� �/�MnO �/h �/h �/h �/h �/h �/h �/h �/h h h hCaO ,/� �/� ,/� � t/� y/� y/, f/, f/, e ,/eNa2O y/, �/, t/, �/, �/, �/, y/, f/, � � �K2O �/, �/, �/, t/, �/, f/, ,/� y/e �/e �/e y/,P2O5 �/h �/h �/h �/h �/h �/h �/h �/h �/h �/h �/hTotal x/�hh y/�hh �/�hh f/�hh t/�hh t/�hh e/�hh t/�hh �/�hh ��� f/�hh

V ,/tf �/xy x/xt y/�hh f/yf �/�ht t/�� e/ef e/e� ,/e� �/e�

Cr y/xh e/yf e/��� e/��� �/��h y/�xx �/��f �/��� x/ff t/th �/xh Co �/�h �g y/�� �/,x �/,� �/�f e/x �/t ,/x y/y e/xNi �/�h ,/�t �/�y �/�x �/�� e/,� e/�� f/y ,/x t/t �/�h

Cu z x/,� �/x �/e� x/� �/�h � x/ey �/��� �/ey� �/eey

Zn x/e� x/�y x/ff �� ,/�h x/t, �/ex y/�x �/,h sz �/e�

Rb y/y� e/ft y/x� f/fx f/f, �/�hf �/�ey t/��y f/x� f/�h� x/��t

Sr �/�,e x/��h �/�th t/�tt t/�ef f/��h �/�hy ,/x� f/,�h �/,he �/,��Y x/�� x/�t y/�y f/,� t/�t t/,� �� �/�� �/f ,/y �/�h

Zr y/y� t/ye x/yy �/�,h �/�h� �/�h� �/�� �/�t e/��x t/��f y/�e�

Nb f/t �/f f/x ,/�� x/f y/�� x/x t/y t/�� t/�h �/�,

Ba x/,he ,/,ft �/,x� �/,�t s�{ y/,fe y/,ee t/�xx �/,x, �/,y� t/eh�

La �/�, �/�� t/,h x/,t ,/�� e/e� e/,t s� �/�, f/�� e/�e Ce sz t/e, �/�� y/�, e/,x t/te �� t/�t ss ,/,h y/,,

Nd t/�� t/�� y/�f f/,, x/�, y/,� t/�x �/�x �/f x/t �/fSm �/, �/e f/e x/� x/, � g �/e y/� �/� t/�Eu �/h f/h x/h � y/h � y/h �/h t/h �/h y/hGd ,/, e/e t/e y/� � f/� y/e � y/� �/� y/�Tb �/h t/h t/h x/h t/h x/h f/h �/h e/h e/h e/hDy �/, �/e f/e t/� � y/� t/e �/, y/� �/� f/�Ho �/h y/h f/h �/� y/h �/� f/h �/h �/h e/h �/hEr e/� s s x/, x/� x/, s ,/� � x/h �/�Tm ,/h e/h e/h �/h e/h �/h e/h ,/h ,/h �/h ,/hYb e/� f/� x/� t/, y/� t/, f/� ,/� x/h y/h �/hLu ,/h e/h e/h �/h e/h �/h e/h ,/h ,/h �/h ,/hTa e/e ,/� �/, �/� x/h e/� �/� e/, e/� x/h �/�Pb �/x �/�f t/e� t/e� y/,� �/�� f/,f �/,� f/f z x/t

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 4: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

�S37 6#RT' ��O"�R�@ (' ' �"�$- ���G � �"�$-�238 �3S� z��

Th e/� � e/x y/�� � e/�y t/�� x/�f f/f ,/f ,/��

Eu/Eu* t/h y/h f/h y/h f/h t/h �/h �/h � ,/� ,/�

@�� :��M$� .�JI 6�L D$" =�/RU � �3Z' Z�$4 E/���I � >� 8 6.��2�EF�'2U ��2�2�' ! �/�' !�E�2�

Sample GM25 G12 GM5 G6 G4 B1A55 AKY13 AB6 AG18 G24 GM10

SiO[2] x/�y e/�t ,/ty e/t� f/te t/th �/�f �/y� f/yh y/yh yh TiO[2] t/h x/h �/h t/h t/h y/h �/h ,/h �/h ,/h e/hAl2O3 e/�� �/�y �/�� y/�t x/�t �/�y �f �/�� �/�e t/�� �/��

Fe2O3 t x/t f s �/� t/� �/t f s f/, ,/, �/eMnO �/h ,/h h �/h �/h �/h �/h h �/h �/h �/hMgO �/t �/� x/e t/� t/� f/� �/, ,/� t/h �/h y/hCaO �/t x/t y/h x/e f/e �/� �/� x/h � y/� �/,

Na2O �/, �/, ,/� �/e � x/, �/, ,/� x/e f/e f/,K2O �/, �/, �/� �/e t/e �/e ,/e �/, �/� t/� gP2O5 �/h ,/h ,/h ,/h �/h e/h �/h �/h �/h h �/h

Ni ��� �{� �� �{ �z ss �s �� �� � �s

Cr gs� �z� g� �s� �s� ��� ��� ��� �� �� s�

Co g� f/,y x/�� �s �/�� f/�, t/�f e/e y/�� y/e �/�e

V �{� s�g �� �� �� �{ ��� s� s{ �� s�

Cs �� �/� x/h f/e �/e f/� �/� e/, �/� �/� ,/tRb �/�ht ,/ff e/,x �/�eh �/�ee �/�e� �/�,x f/te �/�,e ��y �/�tt

Sr e�y e�y x/t� e,, e�x eef ,x� ��� �tf �/�,� ,ex

Ba �hy ee� �/�y, �xf �xt yt� yte ,yt te� �hf �h�

Th �� � s� �s �� s �� �z �s �� s�

U �/, �/, t/� �/, e/e �/� x/� �/, e/� �/, y/,Ta x/h x/h ,/� x/h � x/h x/h �/� t/, x/h �/�Nb �� �s �z �g �� �� �� �� s� �� ��

La f/,f ,/,y t/,f �/,x ,/�� �/�x �� �/e, �/�x �/,h y/ex

Ce t/�� t/�y ,/�, x/�x t/x, f/�h �he �/t� �/�h� �/�h �/�y

Pr y/t y/t t �/t e/x �/� �� �/t y/x ,/� e/fNd sg s� ,/,� �/,, e� �/�� ,/ex e/,, t/,x �� y/,f

Sm f/� � x/e � f/� e/, y �/� ,/� e/e ,/�Eu �/� �/h ,/h � �/� e/� e/� y/h �/h �/h �/hGd t/� �/� y/e �/� e/� ,/, f/t ,/� e/� t/e �/�Tb y/h y/h �/h �/h t/h ,/h x/h t/h y/h t/h y/hDy f/e e/� y/, x/, �/e �/� e/� y/e � �/e x/eHo f/h f/h t/h t/h y/h ,/h �/� y/h f/h y/h f/hEr e/, t/, t/� �/, �/, y/h t/e ,/, �/, �/, ,/,Tm e/h �/h ,/h e/h e/h �/h �/h e/h �/h e/h e/hYb e/, �/, �/� , e/, y/h �/e �/, t/, �/, ,/,Lu e/h �/h ,/h e/h �/h �/h �/h e/h �/h e/h e/hY t/,� �/,e ,/�� f/�f ,/,h y/t t/e� ,/,h f/,, e/,h ,� Zr �t� �/�t� ,�h ,he ,he ,e, ,y� �ht ,eh �,f �ey Sn t e , � � , � e � � ,W ,�y f �,h t x f �h f ��t �� �,x

Eu/Eu* y/h ,/h ,/h f/h y/h f/� t/h �/h h �/h e/h(La/Yb)N �/f e/y y/�, f/x x/�, t/�f �h �/x e/�� �/t �/�,

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 5: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

#3>�f���R- ���(�)��0 �efx �![� 0' ���K)"'���U 6�L�"�$- ��/R/-2\V �)/�' ! #/\26�L . . .z��

1�� ����AB C!��. � �.�/� D�.��E+.��= �8��

.'#T'� �P�2�2�' ! #PT'� (��� � ��'� �EP�� 8 Y�2PZ �P8 6#$386�L 6 )�U�7 �� �#�#�2- �P>�� P}� 0' �6./P*��

Y' U�E��"' .D$P" Q/U F �PF �P�2�EF�'2U 0' (I �P"�$- �� //]F �/���2F #$U )Hi-s.(���U D$P" .P' �3Z' 6�L PL�

X2O/K�I ��/F2/8 �0NU2VNW H��- �/�3G |2� 0' �'#P�� �P8 � )RU ���"#3 ��/3: EF�'2U ��"' ..U 0 � �/F�WI . P)R�����U D$" .' �4 6�L �L#$)�L .��2P� �� �P>2F H8�: �)i�

�/F2/8 �� �U �"' .' �L6�)"'� (I �� P8 �/$L W �L�Y�2PZ �"#4 � �8�OT �"' �#- H/i&F .�P/F2/8 �� �#P#W .' 6�PL #T'� �� �2>2� ��2�2�' ! �� �#� E/� �2P-.�P� �PG #P�'2F

�PW �L #/\2)/�' ! 6�� ./�W �>�� ��2! !� l 6�L �' #2� #-�8 �/��' �23OF 0' .�P�2�EF�'2G Y��PKF ��2P� ?@�P$� 6�PL

�� )�! �/@ � �!� )�! �� �"� 8 D$" F �� �#P-�� 6�PL �"' � >� 8 .N412O�� 8 �.' 8 �� QP/G F P}� 0' ���)P"I 6�L

#��'� 6 )&/8 |2$F .12O�� 8 ���RF �$P> 0' ?@�P$� .P' 6�L ��'� E� �/�� � )�P! �� �PO/U F � #�' �PF �P�2� � Pi/� 6

#��'� � 8�!� i/�]��[.12O�� 8 ��� PF 6#/P"' QP/G F �P8 6�L �P�M$� �� ��$F ���2�2�' ! #$��� �#P� � P>� 8 6�#P- #P�' .

���G Y��KFD$" �"�$- �P�M$� �� �� �#P- ��P 6�L ��2P� 6�8 .�G� /W2F��' �2�T ��"� 8 0' �P7 8 �� �� G2$ Y�2Z

��2R� �P�M$� �� �G �"' ���)"I �)�2�EF�'2G 6�L � P>� 8 6#&� �#L�&� ���G .'.

D�.������� �8�� u�8 #T'� .'`�� ��2F �L�� �2>2� 6J2K� 6?@�$� � >� 8

���)"I ��� H/i&F '� ��2P8 ��2" � ��0'2L Y#- �8 �U #L� �����)7�$- (I �3U �8��F Y�2Z |�PKF�' `PU ��2" 6�L

�"' .D$" X�T .' �8 �PESF P)RU �PU QP/U F .P' �8 ��L�#- 0' 6�'#�� � #�'6#$38�L��'� H/i&PF '� �#L�&P� EP/� #P�'�� �2- .D$" Q/U F � .' 6�L ���2F �F ��2�2�' ! 0' #T' P/ �

�� //]F #$U.D$" .' �P�2R� �� �L DP�� �P8 ��PO��< �)P"� 6�� �#� 6 )�U�7 ���U 0' �$*RL Q/U F � #�2- �EF�'2PU 6�L

� �/F2/8 �0NU2VNW ���"#3 ���/3: � �/�3G |2� 0' X2O/K�I �/�2� F�'� �/�2$/)G' #��'�.���PU �P4 6�PL(I�PL H��P-

�/�^I � .U 0 ��/F�WI � #�'>��6 /*R&Pp 6 P/! 0' �P-����>6 /! ���U �L)8��P/F2/8 �[P�(��PBF �PU ��@�P$� ��

(�0 /��F �' : �- 8 6�L !�) �#�'(I �� �L�P� �#� �PU �2P-�� #P-�8 �P�M$� �� �i/��$� ��2! !� l 0' �U�T #�'2F .��

u�8 �/-�T 6�L D$" .' �6' I 6��PT �PL #$)�PL �02�'#P� .�� �02�'#P�I 6�L�238 ��'�' ��P�� � �P"' Y��PK)� �P3)��

��> 6 /! �R� (�&� '� �Z�7 #P$L�.�� �02�'#P�I 6�PL�238 D$" .' (2*8I �8 u$U'� �' �� �L ̀ /P"�)W ��R!�� 6�L �PF �'�

�#- (�" !� �/� " � ��2i�� �8 6��0 #T (�&P� �U #�'�#$L� #�� �W ��2! !� 6D$" �� �(I �7�$- � ��"�L �� �L

(�PPi�' ���PP"I �PP8 �2iPP"� i/� PP0 ��PP/� �PPW.Y��PPKF ��M$� �� �� ��2�2�' ! .P' )&P/8 `PST ��P"� 8 ��2� 6

D$" � P@ 0' �P"' ���)P"I �8 �O�� � >� 8 6 ��M$� �� �L �� )�P! �P/@ *� �P�2�2�' ! 0' 6 PF ('EP/� �P8 �PLSiO2

��M$� 0' �� )�! >� 8 6�� �#L�&� ��2-.

�E��� �8��D����� D$" .' �8 �L ��2F Y�2Z 'ES� � lp2U 6�L � ! u/8 � `U�

��2F �82$> u�8 �� 6#P��'� �E�� 8 � >� 8 �3Z' )HiP-�(.��M$� �� 6#T'� E/� ���)"I)�2�2�' ! �u�8 ��6�L �82$>

�)/�' !�E�2� �"' �#- �� �8 �>2F �8 �.-�� D F���P�2R� 6�)"��0'��� ��"' �/�&F H8�: #T'� .' X�PT .P' �8 P�0

#$)�/� u'#> H8�: � #��'#� �k�&�..P' �� �P/F2/8 �'#�� D$" �P�> � �P"' P)RU �PL 6 P/! (�&P� �2P7 0' �K/+P� �� #$L�.���U H/i&F �3Z' 6�L #P$L��6(I��P/F2/8 H��P-

� EF�'2U �0NU2VNW ���"#3F��' |2� 0' ��/3: 0NU2�"' .

$�F�F+" �*����.����� �D$" .' �8 �L Y�2Z��#\'06(��� lp2U ��/�8 � H�)��

#T'� ��2�2�' ! ��M$� ���)"I 6#��'� �' : .D$P" 6�PL ��P�#- �8 � ��'� E�#$)�L .-�� D�� .���U H/i&PF �3PZ' 6�L

�#$L� D$" .' 6EF�'2U �0NU2VNW H��- �L ����"#3 ��P/3: �/F2/8 � .#/��" |2� 0'#�'���U 0' �(I �4 6�L �P� �L ('2PF

�8 �U � U ���-' �/F�WI � .U 0 �8 ���PU �� X�7�' Y�2Z 6�PL �� �#� *� #�2- .�![� 0' �% D$" .' `�� 6�L 1#P4 �PL

�"' X2O/K�I �2�T .��M$� �� ./$vRL D$" � >� 8 66�PL �#&� �#L�&� Q/G F .' �8#�' .12O�� 8 D$" .' �� 9:'� 6�L-

0' �3%P- �2P7 6�L �� G2$ 6��T � ��28 �/"'� |2� 0' �L ^�P8 �P/F�2�I �P8 0NG2VNW � �0�!��W X2O/K�I(An 86-92)��

�$/�0 � �P/F2/8 � 0NG2PVNW �$P> 0' �P�'� EP� 6�PU #P�'

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 6: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

�S37 6#RT' ��O"�R�@ (' ' �"�$- ���G � �"�$-�238 �3S� z�s

D$P" .P' H/i&PF � �23OF *��&� �P"' )&P/8 ?PR4 �� �PL]z���[.

(>�G��' (�'�2R�SiO2�8 �O�� |2RS� ��/3: ]�s[�#$$U '#> _7�6� )�! �%LI 0' ��/3: 6�0' H�� �8 ��/3: ]�g[=(��� 6#$8]��[.

. � �.�H/��� 1�� ������� ���! .�� ,4��� 2�.I" �����.�!

D$" 6�'�*��� 6' 8 _"2F �G ��L�'�2R� 0' �"� 8 ��2� 6�LL�[W #P- ���K)P"' ��P"' �#- �\'�' �3)�� (' *& .b�P"' P8

��P/3: Z�$4 |2RS� �8 �O�� �/3/" �'�2R�]�s[H%P- �s��'(D$" �� )�! �� ���)"I � � >� 8 ?@�$� 6�L ��P�2� 6

��2�EF�'2G��� �' : �/�' ! � ��2�2�' ! #� /! . P8 ��NP4�PP42RS�D$PP" ^�PP8 6)/PP"'�2� ���&PPK&FI �OPP- 6�PPL �� �

��M$� �P� �#P� EP/� ���)"I 6#�2P-.����� 6#P$8 � P*� �P8 �U ���� 0' ���K)"'F6�L )�'��W 0' � Z�$4 ��2/P�Q���K)"'

�� �2-]��[.�� �i��$p Hi-,=�� �#� �2-�D$P" 6�PL ��2� �P"� 8 �� � )�P! 6�P/3�'�I ��P�2�2�' ! 0' �P7 8 �D$" ��M$� 6�L � )�P! �� � P>� 8 6�P�2��E�2�EF�'2G 6

#��'� �' :.

E���� J � ������� �#$L� H/%&F 6�R!�� |2� �7�$- �/RL' �8 �>2F �8D$" 6-

����� � ���)"I � � >� 8 ?@�$� .�JI 6�L�![� 6 PL 6�L �L�O- �8 (� 8 �W 6' 8 ��R!�� |2� ��Y��KF � �L 6�PR!�� 6�L

#> j�P7 6�L�'�2R� 0' ��M$� |2� �� L ���� ./P/+F � �&P' #- ���K)"' �R!�� |2� .�'�2PR� 0' ���� �2}$� ./RL �8]�g[

SiO2�8 �O�� Na2O + K2O`� G ���K)"' �)H%-���'.(��2R� b�"' .' 8 � )�P! �� �P�M$� �� L 6�L 6 P" 66�PL

�#- 9:'� ���&K&FI �O- #P�' .� �PR!�� ��*)P"�7 ./P/+F 6' P8 �)"2W ���7� ('E/� ���: 6� 6' D$" H/%&F ����M$� �� 6�L

�'�2R� 0'A/CNK �8 �O�� A/NK `� PG ���K)"')H%P-�=.(]�{���[�PP�2R� ��'�2PPR� .PP' �� �� �PP"� 8 ��2PP� 6�PPL

� )�PP! �PP�2R� �PP7 8 � ./�2�I�PP)� 6� �)�2PP�2�' ! 6�PPL � )�! �� �)/�' !�E�2� �P� �' : ./�2�I W 6#P� /! ../P$vRL

��2R� � �)�2P�EF�'2U 6�L �P�2R� QP3<' � �)�2P�2�' ! 6�PL � )�PP! �� �)/�' !�E�2PP��PP/�' ! 6|2PP� 6�PPLI]��[�' PP:

�PP) ! #PP�' .�PP�2R� 0' �PP7 8 HPP�RF � �)�2PP�2�' ! 6�PPL � )�! �8 �)/�' !�E�2� �� ./�2�I W 6�PK3)�� H^� �8 #�'2F �/�' ! |2� �8 �U #-�8 �P8 #-�O� �)�8'� X�P�� ('2P$4 :u'#P>

�� )�! 6���PU lP 0' �P/F2/8 � #P$3O��2L �0NU2PVNW 6�PL �%LI 6�R!�����/3: ]��[�P8 ���P� D$P" 6�PR!�� uP^I

#� /! 8 �� D$"�6�/3W�)� /}� ./�2�I 0' �$< �)/� " ��L �P/�2F� W =I ('EP/� Y' P//]F �P � �)/3W� W � ���� !�]s�[

�PPP"' .�PPP�2R� 0' �PPP7 8 6 PPP/!�' : � �)�2PPP�2�' ! 6�PPPL2� � )�! �� �)/�' !�E� �/�' ! 6|2� 6�LS�� E/� *��/8 #�'2F

|2� �)/�' ! 6�R!�� ##- u'#>I�� �!�2P�I 0' �P-�� � �D$P" �P8 �#P- ��P 6�PR!�� u$U'� �' �� (2P*8I �PR/� 6�PL

#-�8 �#� /! 8.�'�2R� ��]s�[)Hi-��(�P�2R� 0' �P"� 8 ��2P� 6�PL

'#> `L 0' `/"�)W �'#�� }��#- #�' .��$p �� �}TN� �i ��2P- )&/8D$" ��2� 6�L�"� 8 �� � )�! ̀ /P"�)W 6�PF _P"2)�

^�8�� �' : #� /!�'#�� 6��!0�"�� �U K2O�P8SiO2�P7 8 �� ��2R� 0' �� �L (I (�28 6���� !� H/�� �8 #�'2F �L#-�8.

�K$� #���P2O5u'EP' �P8 �O�� SiO2�P�2R� �� 6�PL �"� 8 ��2�)Hi-eY(�P![� �P8 �P/�' ! 6�PL |2P� 6�PLI�"' ��!0�" .���)4' �8]ss[|2P� �P)/�' ! 6�L�R!�� �� K� I

�8 �/F�WI �&�8 �23OF H/�� �8 ��P)� ��!0�P" k$4 l Y�2Z�� �P)/�' ! 6�L�R!�� �� �U �F�2Z �� �#$G |2P� SHP/�� �P8

KL� M

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 7: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

#3>�f���R- ���(�)��0 �efx �![� 0' ���K)"'���U 6�L�"�$- ��/R/-2\V �)/�' ! #/\26�L . . .z��

�P"' ��!0�P"�� kP$4 lP uP�� 6'�'� ���G .' �23OF 1#4 ��� u'E' u'#> X2@ �� �0'#! �� (I �}3< #8�.

()�N��'('�2R� �6 " �&'#> 6�L ���/3: �O- � ��/3:]�g[.=(�'�2R�A/NK �8 �O�� A/CNK 6' 8 ./�2P�I W 6�PL�R!�� �/�&F�.��i�I W � ./�2�I�)� ]����{[�(�'�2R� K2O�8 �O��SiO2],�[Y(�'�2R�P2O5��P8 �O�SiO2�P�2R� �PU #P��� 0' �P"� 8 ��2P� 6�PL |2� 6�L#/\2)/�' !I6���$&/W ]ss[�� 6� /W #$$U.

#$' u�� �"� 8 6' 8 0' u'#> �3PZ' PZ�$4 Y' //]F �8 �O�� SiO2) U��PL 6�PL�'�2R�(#P- ���K)P"' )HiP- g.(

�� �}TN� �%��$p �2- ' �8u'E SiO2�P�0� #Z��Fe2O3�Al2O3�CaO �TiO2�MnO �MgO �P2O5�� uL�U #8� .uL�PUTiO2,�MnO�MgO �Fe2O3�P� #PP�'2F �PP34 �P8

6�> 6 /! �L #/�G' .' ���U ��)7�" �� 6�L ̀ E/$� � .LI�'� )�/F2/8 � X2O/K�I (���P/��' HT' �6�2P3OF �&P'#> �PR!��

#P-�8.uL�PU CaO �Al2O3�P2O5EP/� �P8 QP/F F P8 �HP/���G - � �PL0NU2VNW ��)7�P" �� PZ�$4 .P' QP/U F P//]F

�8 )RU �/F�2�I 0' �L0NU2VNW uL�PU � )&P/8 �/O�I �R"�'#PP�� �2PP3OF ��PP�� HPPT' � �� �PP/F�WI �PP"'.� PP@ 0' PP*�

Y' //]FP2O5Y' //]F 98�F CaO �"' ��� K�P kP$4 ' 0 M8'� �R!���6��'� `/�P3U kP$4 �P8 �Pi�E� ]ss[.]FY' P//

Na2O�8 �O�� SiO2)O�����8�� ��2R� �7 8 �� ��&'E' �L �K2O�8 �O��SiO2�� (�&� �&'E' 6#��� L�$#�' 0 �P8

� &/Wu'#> (I �'#P�� ��� �PL �0'#P!6u'EP' �#P��R/:�8 �� � #8��)7�" ��'� ���� �� �0NU2F�' ���2-.

��2R� 6 /!�' : Q/G F ./8 ���)"I 6�L �2P>� � � >� 8 6�L �PRL 6�L#P��� 6��!0�" � �*)"2/W ��P�M$� �� �� PZ�$4 6

�M8'� *��/8 �P�M$� �� .P' ���P� 6�PR!�� ./8 6#���&27 6�"' .�K$� 6�L#���V�Ti �P8 �O�� SiO2�&P'#> �2P3OF

6�L#/�G'Fe-Ti �P� (�&� '� #PL� . PZ�$4LILE ��!0�P"�� �H��Ba �Rb �La �Hf �Zr W #���O �F � �#$G'��(�&P� �O�� ��#$L� .�8 `#/8�� � `��8 �!#$G' W �8 Q/F F u'#P> HP/��

�"' ���� 6�R!�� �� X2O/K�I � 0NG2VNW . PZ�$4 �!#P$G' W ��&P'#> �23OF #$' 8 ��N4 6 *� #$' 0' �-�� ��!0�"�� uP^I �P � =�J Y��PK)� 98�P$� �=�J Y��PK)� Y�>�� #$���

�)"2W �"' 6' .��&P'#> �2P3OF P8 ��NP4 �P%$' �"� 8 6' 8 H%- �� 6 )&/8 /��F ^�8 H�'24 0' � 1'#G �� 6�R!�� 6 /!

D$" H\��� HT � �)-'� ��M$� D$P" �� �P�M$� �P'0 6�PL ���K)"' �F2O%$4 6�L�'�2R� 0' �6J2K� �#- �P"' .D$P" 6�PL ��#$G �8 �O�� �"� 8 ��2� ?@�$�]s�[D$" �: 6�L b2

5#$$" ��R!�� _(�> /"]sg[�#P- 60�" 6��4 #P�')HiP-�.(� �P�M$� �� PL �*$" �3)�� 6�L#T'� ��L�'�2R� .' ��

�/"'�2� ��M$� 6�L �8 ���)"I 6�#- `/" F ���!'#> �2@ #P�' . Z�$4 62*�'REE �![� PZ�$4 0' �!#P- �P$< H�� '� 6�L

LILE)Ba �Rb �Th �U(��F � Z�$4 0' �!#- HFSE)Nb

KL� M

O P

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 8: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

�S37 6#RT' ��O"�R�@ (' ' �"�$- ���G � �"�$-�238 �3S� z�g

�Ti ( Q/- (�28 �M�� �HREE �� (�&� ��)P�� �G #L��%LI 6�R!����"' ��/3: .

(>� Q��2R� �/+:2� �8 �O�� �3Z' Z�$4 Y' //]F �'�2R� 6�� 8 �"� 8 ��2� 6�LSiO2.H%- �8�&� `\N4e#$)�L .

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 9: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

#3>�f���R- ���(�)��0 �efx �![� 0' ���K)"'���U 6�L�"�$- ��/R/-2\V �)/�' ! #/\26�L . . .z��

(>�R6�L2*�'REEs ��#$U �8 �#- 6��4 ]s�[.��M$� �G�7 6�/�' ! 6 ) 5#$$" ��R!�� 6�L�#$)�PL (�> /" ]sg[.�P/�' ! �� 6�PL � )�! �� ��M$� 5#$$" 6��#- 9:'� (�> /" �%LI 6�R!�� ��/R/-2\V 62*�' 0' � #�'��� 6� /W ��/3: #$$G .)O�� 6��S$L�����O�� Eu �Sr

62*�' �HREE�/"'�2� ��*)"�7 (�28 F ?/R4 *��/8 �"' ���)"I 6�L.�86��S$L �K$� 6�LEu �Sr HP8�: 0NG2PVNW u'#> �8

�"' �/>2F .��2R� �� �P�M$� ���&PK&FI �OP- 6�PL ���)P"I 6�8 �2>� �O�� 6��S$LSr ���&� 6�PR!�� .) P! ��*)P"�7 6

�#$L� H/%&F D$" .' 6�)P-2! 98�P$� 0' �L �P"' 6' .(2Pp �)"2W =�J 0' �G ��L�R!�� ��: 6��P� �&� 6' #P� /! .6'�'�

�8 �K$� 6��S$LSr #$)�PL ],�[.aP4�8 0NG2PVNW �'#P>�PP8 ./�PPW 6��PPS$LBa �Sr�Eu PPZ�$4 62PP*�' �� REE �

u'EP' �8 S$� #$3O��2L u'#>LREE/HREE �0'#P! �� ���2- .

�O�PP�La/Yb ./PP8 f���#PP$L� (�&PP� ��2PP3OF /��PPF 6�P%LI 6�L�R!�� �� �&'#>�?@�P$� �� �P�� ��P"' ��P/3:

��2R� )&/8 �� �O�� .' ���)"I � � >� 8 0' u/P8 �Lf�P"' �#$L� (�&� �G �&P'#> �23OF 0' /< 6 *� H�'24 � i3R4 6

��#-�8.� �P�M$� �� L 6�R!�� H/%&F ?R4 .//+F � �"� 8 6' 8

�'�2R� 0' �R!�� H/%&F �� �)-2! /��FCaO/Al2O3�8 �O��FeOtot /MgO)H%-t��'(�P"' �#P- ���K)"' .�!#P$G' W

��2R� Q3<' 0' �P-�� ��P0 X�PR)T' �P8 6�2R4 #��� X2@ �� �L�PP"' 0NG2PPVNW u'#PP> .�' PP: �PP�2R� 0' �PP7 8 6 PP/! 6�PPL

*��P/8 #P��'� X2O/K�I �8 60'2� #��� �G � >� 8 �)�2�EF�'2G D$"���� 6�R!�� .) ! �&� �! �� � >� 8 .�JI 6�L� ) 6

X2PPO/K�I 6�'#PP�W)�)"2W )&PP/8 ?PPR4 (6�PPR!�� �PP8 �O�PP��#�0�" D$" 6� )�! 0' �G �"' ���)"I .�JI 6�L 6�'#�W 6

0NG2VNW)�)"2W )RG ?R4 (�"' �) ! �&� .�!#- �$< �� Y' //]FLILE �[P� �P8 �L U�Th �� ��

�J �'#P�� �P � ��*)P"�7 QP/G F �� P//]F 0' �P-�� ��M$� =�"' �&�8 .(�0 �� �P%$' �P8 �>2F �8 u�'�� P 6�PL���f%

�� Y�2Z �&�8 =�J � P/!]sz�s{[�P }� '�P� �Y��PK)� 6�P� �>'2� 6#> #� F �8 �&�8 =�J ('E/� (�28 �2P- .6' P8

�W �8 (� 8 �P }� �'�2PR� 0' =�J Y��PK)� ��*)P"�7 6Th/La �P8 �O��Sm/La)HiP-t=(�P"' �#P- ���K)P"']s�[. P8

D$P" ���P� 6�PR!�� ��*)"�7 �'�2R� .' b�"' ?@�P$� 6�PL

� )�! �� � >� 8 � ���)"I �P$�W �OP- � �)-2! ./8 66'6�PL�)"2W �� �' : ��*)"�7 �� L ���7� � � 6' Y��PKF ��� #� /!

�PP�M$� �� .PP' �� �O�PP� (�2PP8 F^�PP8Sm/La 0' �PP7 8 �PP�2�EF�'2G� )�PP! �PP8 �PP�E� �PPG �PP"' � PP>� 8 6�PPL 6

M)�)-2! (�� �' :#� /! .b�P"' P8]ss[�P$< 6' P8 ��!#P- Z�$4 0' �R!��LILE��F � Z�$4 �7 8 �!#-HFSE (Ti ,

Nb) �PP%LI 6�PPR!�� �� �/3/PP" 0' �PPR!�� �!#PP- �PP$< ��H:'#PPT �PP��7� ��PP/3:�h%=2PP"�)�PP$�W �OPP- �PP � 6'

�2 !�)� (�P }� �8 �>2F �8 �G �"' 10^ =�J .R� 6]s�[=2"� �� =�J u�'�� �8 (��ERL 6�L#�2- . P}� �P8 .' 8�$8

�� �)P"2W uP^I #"� �P$�W �OP- �P��7� 6�P$+� �P8 6'6'�#P-�8 �+�2� � �3B� #$' ��R!�� H/%&F 0' �W �2 !�)� .

�PW 6' P8 ^�P8 ��'2P� 8 ��N4 �PM8'� �P8 (� P8 6#���&P27 6�'2R� 0' ��M$� �� ���� 6�R!�� Ni �P8 �O�P� Mg#��'�2PR�

Th/Co�8 �O�� La/Th �P"' �#- ���K)"' )HiP-Y � �(.��2R� `EP/$� �#P4 � HP%/� ('EP/� � >� 8 �)�2�EF�'2G 6�L

�#$L� (�&� �G#��'� F^�8 �P�M$� �� �P/�� 6�R!�� ./��' 6��'� �*)"2/W � �"' ��*)P"�7 `L 0' �G�T ��M$� �� L 6�L

(I 6�R!�� (�28�"�L .�'�2R� ��Th/Co�8 �O�� La/Th �P�2R� � � P>� 8 6�PL

.) P! �&P� ����P� 6�PR!�� �&P'#> #P��� 8 ��N4 ���)"I �)"2W ��*)"�7 � 0' ���� 6�R!�� �� (�&� E/� '� 6'#$L� .�P8

u'E'SiO2�'#�� Yb �P� `G �P� �PG �2P- ���&P� #P�'2F 6�&� �#�0�" 6�R!�� 6 /! D$" 6�&P�8 =�J 0' ��M$� 6�L2O/K�I#-�8 �/�]eh[.

�)"2W _"2)� ./*��/� �8 �O�� Z�$4 �7 8 (�28 F^�8-���PP: 66')e�h >Ba �t/�>Th ��,Nb> �],x[EPP/�

�"' ���:2 �)"2W �'2� �8 �R!�� u^I 0' �-��]����s[.D$" ('#� �8 �>2F �8 �� PL �� �)�'0�P8 QP/G F �P8 6�PL

�PP�M$�(SiO2> 52%)D$PP" (�2PP8 `/PPST �PPL .PP�JI 6� ?@�P$� �P)/�' ! 6�PR!�� .) P! �&� ��M$� �� �� �/�3

�)-2! �/�� 6�R!�� � u'#> 0' �"� 8 ��2� Q/G F �8 6'

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 10: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

�S37 6#RT' ��O"�R�@ (' ' �"�$- ���G � �"�$-�238 �3S� z�z

�� }� �8 HR)B��� ��)�'0�8 Q��< �8 �>2F �8 � #"��$< �!#P- ��!0�P"�� PZ�$4)K�Th �Rb �La�Ce �Nd (�6��PS$�/8

�PPK$�Ti �Nb �Eu �Ba �Sr .PP' �� ��PP�M$� ��)HiPP- �(

D$" H/i&F �P"� 8 ��2P� ?@�$� l/�3 .�JI 6�L )&P/8 �� �23OF HZ�T #�'2F �0'#! �)"2W0' HZ�T 6�L 6. P0 #P-�8

]ss�����g[.

()�S��'(CaO/Al2O3�8 �O�� FeOtot/MgO �P"' �P�M$� �� PL ���� 6�R!�� 0NG2VNW � X2O/K�I u'#> *��/8 .=('�2PR� �Th/La �8 �O��Sm/La ]s�[ *��/8 �)"2W 0' ��M$� �� L ���� 6�R!�� .) ! �&� D$" 0' 6� /W � ���)BF 65#$$P" ��R!�� b2: 6�L�(�> /P"(SSMA],�[�"' .�(Mg#�8 �O�� Ni .Y(La/Th �8 �O�� Th/Co . � �P"� 8 ��2� ?@�$� �*$" �3)�� 6�L#T'� u'#> �'�2R� �� .'

"2W ���7�(I 6�R!�� E�V �� �)�� (�&� '� �L H%- �8�&� `\N4 �#$L�e#$)�L .

�8 �K$� 6��S$LEu �/�' ! �� �P�M$� 6�PL � � P>� 8 6�"' �/>2F H8�: Y�2Z �� �8 ���)"I :�8�2PO� 0' �-�� 6��S$L

�2P>� ��*)"�7 �� 0NG2VNW � � �"' ��*)"�7 �� 0NG2VNW � H/%&F _' - ��� ��)-'� �P�2! �P8 �PR!� �PG �P"' ��2P8 6'

�PP"' �#PP��� �:�PP8 �/)PP"� 0�PP �� 0NU2PPVNW .�PP8 �PP>2F �PP8 (�/� �O�� �*)�ORLEu/Eu* �P8 �O�P�Sr �� 0NG2PVNW �

X2P@ �� 0NU2VNW �G .' H/�� �8 ��� ��-'� �2>� ��*)"�7 �)"2W �� �&�8 =�J 6�L#$' �P"' 1��P�� �)O�� ���)BF 6

�:�8 �/)"� 0� �� �"' �#��� ]e�[)H%-�(�2P>� .' 8�P$8 ��P8 aP4�8 �/)"� �� (I �PK$� 6��PS$L Eu �Sr 6�PR!�� ��

�� �)/�' !�2-]et[.�#/�4 8 �$86]�y[ 8=�J 0' HPZ�T �P8 SF ��)� b�"'

D$" �&�8 �)"2W 6�L 6#/\2)/�' ! 6�L�R!�� �U 6' �P%LI���/3: |2� ^�8 `/"�)W I�� &P�8 =�J 0' #P$�'2F D$P" �6�PL �/�� #T �F (2! !� �)P"2W �� �'#8I _"'� . P0 6�2P>28

#$I.�� Q/F F .#8?@�$� ��2� �"� 8 �P8 �>2F �8 �P"� 8-6�L���U D$P" ��"�$- �P![� � �\�/R/P-2\V ��P"�$- 6�PL./�0 �"�$-��� }$8 ./$p ��2PF �U #"� �PL 6#P/\2)/�' ! 6

� � >� 8I���)P" �' �� 6�PR!�� �2P3OF 0' HPZ�T �&P�8 =�J �PP/�2F� W �)PP"2W 6�PPL . PP0 6)IO/K�2�PP/� +�PP/3W�)���2 !�)� (�2P3OF � �P"' �#P�I �2>28 �0'#P! �&P'#> �� �PL

��)PP"2W F^�PP8 ~2MPP" D$PP" |'2PP�' �PP/@ ��2PPF 6�PPL �PPL 6QO" '� 6#/\2)/�' !-�"' �#��)"2W u^I 6uP�� ���P:2

��2F .' H/i&F �� �R�� �L � �P"' �)-'� �)�'0�P8 6�PL�R!�� �)P"2W �� �PU �)P-2! 0' HZ�T6�#P- .E*�P> . P0 #P�'

HR)B� . F��*)"�7��28 �&�8 =�J 6' 8 ��� ! #�'.

D���! ���G ��' BZ #L'2- ��'� ��"�$- �W2F�E' � ��/R/-2\V 6�L

�� (�&� D$" �G #L� � P>� 8 ��M$� �� L 6#/\2)/�' ! 6�L

KL� M

O P

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 11: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

#3>�f���R- ���(�)��0 �efx �![� 0' ���K)"'���U 6�L�"�$- ��/R/-2\V �)/�' ! #/\26�L . . .z�{

0' H%&)� ���)"I ��/�' ! �E�2� � ��2�2�' ! ���2�EF�'2G�"' .Q/G F ���G 6�L PO �F �P�M$� �� �� #PT'� PL �"�$-��

D$" ��/R/- Q/G F � �8�&� �R/� |2� 0' �L �R/�3G � ��/3:��"' ��/3: .�P$< }� 0' �̂ 2PR+� `/P"�)W 0' �!#P- �PRL 6

��2R� � )�! �� �L #$)�PL ^�P8 �PF _P"2)� `/P"�)W 6.P>� �2 �![� (�28 �8�&� �����0 � ���%� �%�E� ���PG 6�PL ��P"�$-

� )�PP! 6 PP/!�' : � G��PPL 6�PPL�'�2R� �� �*)PP"2/W�� 1#PP4 6� )�PP! ./PP8 ���)PP"I 6�L#PP/\2)/�' ! �L�OPP- � � PP>� 8 6

�P3^� u�'�� ?@�$� 6�R!�� �8 ��!0�" �F2O%$4 6�L�'�2R� �PM8'� �2P>� � (�2P8 �&� `L 0' �G�T �G #$)�L �P%/)�V 6

�"' �42RS� �� .' ./8 . L =�/RG � �G�7���� Z�$4 62*�' O �F ��M$� �� �� #T'����P%LI 6�PR!�� �P8 ��!0�P" � �8�&� �

Y��KF � �"' ��/3: �P$< ('E/� �� �\E> 6�L �P�F � �!#P--6�R!�� ��*)"�7 Y��K)� ?R4 0' �-�� � Z�$4 0' �7 8 �!#-

(I �)"2W �'2� �8 u^I � �L6'�"' .D$P" �X�PT .P' �8 6�PL �P�M$� �� _� �)/"'�2� Q/G F �8 ���&K&FI �O- ���)P"I 6

�� �#� ��M$� �� � �2- D$P" |2P� .P' � >� 8 6�#P� �PL�R�#�2- .D$P" .P' ." .)��'#� H/�� �8 �� P}� ��P��' �PL

(I ��2� Z �L�����G #L'2- �8 �>2F �8 ��/R/P-2\V � �P"�$-�"' ./- Q/G F D$" .' ��/R �P�2�2�' ! �8 �/O- �L 6�PL

�![� � ��8 �� Y��KF � �"' ��M$� �� L ��/R/P-2\V 6�L �"' �#- u'#> .' a4�8 .�8 (2p 6#L'2- �PO�� 6��S$L

Sr �Eu D$" �� PO �F 62*�' E/� � �)/"'�2� 6�L��Y��PK)� HREE D$" �8 �O�� 0' �G�PT �P�M$� �� PL 6J2PK� 6�PL?/R4 FD$" .' �&� ���� 6�R!�� (�28 D$" �8 �O�� �L-

�"' 6J2K� 6�L .���PG H^� X2PO/K�I �2P>� #P$��� �P"�$- 12O�� 8 �� �0�!��W D$" .' �)/"'� 6�L �P8 0NG2PVNW � �PL

�P"' 6 *� #L'2- �3R> 0' �� G2$ Y�2Z �8 ^�8 �/F�2�I ?/R4 �G �#$L� H/i&F 6�R!�� ��*)"�7 (�28 F $" 6D6�L

�� #/�F '� �)/"'�2�#$G]��[.

���.�T �� �2PP7 ���&PP� � �PPR$L'� #/F�PP"' �PP/3G 0' �PP���� (�!#$�PP2�

��*&�'��� ��'��#: � %&F (��KZ' � (' �F 6�L#$$G .

U ��� [1] Berthier F., Billiaul H.P., Halbroronn B., Marizot P., "Etude Stratigraphique, petrologique et structural de La region de Khorramabad

(Zagros, Iran)"., These De 3e cycle, Grenoble, (1974) 282p.

]s[5 �'�.�"�"� 8 ./�0 6�L D$" 6V2�� )W � �"�$- 6�PL ���)"I �/T�� 6#/\2)/�' !–�-2! "(��W ��#-�' �"�$-��U ����

�1234 �� W �#i&�'�./�0 �"�$-� �F ��*&�'�(') .�ett.([3] Masoudi F., "Contact metamorphism and pegmatite development in the region SW of Arak, Iran", PhD Thesis, Leeds University, ( 1997) UK.

]g[6#RT' ' �S37.�"��2F l 8�� )W � 6V2�� )W �"� 8 6�PL � PP>� 8 �PP�M$� �F���PPS� ��2PP! !� � 6J2PPK�"(�PP�W �PP��� �

�1234 �� W �#-�' �"�$-��U �#i&�'�./�0 �"�$-���*&P�'� �(' �F���) .�eyf(

]�[6#RT' ' �S37.�"��2F 6V2�� )W 66#P/\2)/�' ! � P>� 8 "��' )U� ���"� �12P34 �� W �#i&P�'� ./P�0 �P"�$-���*&P�'�

�(' �F�fy �)�ef�.(]z[�0 �OPP"�R�@ "#PP/\2)/�' ! ��2PPF �R/PP-2\V � 6V2PP�� )W 6

���)"I"j �(��KPZ' ��*&P�'� �12P34 �#i&P�'� �6 )G� ���"� ��{� �)���� .(

[7] Masoudi F., Yardley B.W.D., Cliff R.A., "Rb-Sr geochronology of pegmatites, plutonic rocks and a hornfels in the region southwest of Arak, Iran", Islamic Republic of Iran. Journal of Science 13 (2002) 249-254. [8] Ahmadi-Khalaji A., Esmaeily D., Valizadeh M.V., Rahimpour-Bonab H., "Petrology and Geochemistry of the Granitoid Complex of Boroujerd, Sanandaj-Sirjan Zone, Western Iran", Journal of Asian. Earth Science 29 (2007) 859-877.

]�[6���PP: 1.5 ����PP�� �.�PP�� �1 ��'0.�..� PP �0 �PP"��.�6#RT' ' �S37.�"`/�'��' ." .//+F�6J2PK� �i3�PRU = "

��2PPF � � PP>� 8 l/PP"'��V 6�PPL 5#$$PP" (�0 �� �)�PP8'�–(�> /""�12P34 ��PRL� ! ./�2P" � ��/8 Y^��� �42RS�

./�0�./�0 (��0�" �2&U ��#+� Y��&)U'� �"�$-)�efe.([10] Tahmasbi Z., Khalili M., Castro A., Ahmadi Khalaji A., "Petrography and Geochemistry characteristic of enclaves in Astaneh pluton ( Sanandaj-Sirjan zone, Western Iran)", Journal of Applied Sciences 8(23) (2008) 4251-4262.

]��[0 �OPP"�R�@ .1 �PP3/37 �.' �' 6#PPRT.1 ��'0 �PP%� �.|.�"���)P"I 6J2PK� ��2PF 6 )����82� F2\V � X2O/K�I |'2�' �����)(�> /" 5#$$" (�0"(��(' ' �"�$- ���G� �"�$-�238 �3S�

���R-s�)���� (js{��s�� .

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 12: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

�S37 6#RT' ��O"�R�@ (' ' �"�$- ���G � �"�$-�238 �3S� z��

[12] Cox K. G., Bell J.D., Pankhurst R.J., "The interpretation of igneous rocks", George Allen and Unwin. (1979) 450p. [13] Debon F., Lefort P., "A chemical – mineralogical classification of common plutonic rocks and associations", Transcend Royal of Society. Edinburgh (1983) 135 –149. [14] Irvine T.N., Baragar W.R.A., "A guide to the chemical classification of the common volcanic rocks", Canadian Journal of Earth Science 8 (1971) 523-484. [15] Shand S.J., "Eruptive Rocks", D. Van Nostrand Company, New York (1927) 360pp. [16] Maniar P.D., Piccoli P.M., "Tectonic discrimination of granitoids. Geological Society American Bulletin", 101 (1989) 635–643. [17] Pitcher W.S., "The nature and origin of granite". Chapman and Hall, Pub (1993) 321pp. [18] Chappell B.W., White A.J.R., "Two contrasting granite types", Pacific Geology 8 (1974) 173-174. [19] Zen E.an., "Aluminum enrichment in silicate melts by fractional crystallization: some mineralogical and petrographic constraints",Journal of Petrology 27 (1986) 1095–1118. [20] Waight T.E., Weaver S.D., Muir R. J., " The Hohonu Batholith of North Westland, New Zeland: granitoids compositions controlled by source H2Ocontents and generated during tectonic transition",Canadian Mineralogy and Petrology 130 (1998) 225-239. [21] Rickwood P.C., "Boundary lines within petrologic diagrams which use of major and minor elements", Lithos 22 (1989) 247–263. [22] Chappell B.W., White A.J.R., " I and S-type granites in the Lachlan Fold Belt", Transcend Royal of Society Edinburgh Earth Science 83 (1992) 1–26. [23] Sun S.S., McDonough W. F., "Chemical and isotopic systematics of ocean basalt: implication for mantle composition and processes. In: Saundersand, A. D., Norry, M. J. Magmarisems in the Ocean basins". Geological Society of London, Special Publication42 (1989) 313–345. [24] Omrani J., Agard P., Whitechurch H., Benoite M., Prouteav G., Jolivet L., "Arc-magmatism and subduction history beneath the Zagros Mountains, Iran: A new report of adakites and geodynamic consequences", Lithos 106(3-4) (2009) 380-398. [25] Wang Q., Wyman D. A., Xu J. F., Zhao Z. H., Jian P., Xiong X. L., Bao Z. W., Li C. F., Bai Z. H., "Petrogenesis of Cretaceous adakitic and shoshonitic igneous rocks in the Luzong area,

Anhui Province (eastern China): Implications for geodynamics and Cu-Au mineralization", Lithos 89 (3-4) (2006) 424-446. [26] Pearce J.A., Parkinson I.J., "Trace element models for mantle melting: application to volcanic arc petrogenesis. In: Prichard, H.M., Alabaster, T., Harris, N.B.W., Neary, C.R. (Eds.), Magmatic Processes in Plate Tectonics". Geological Society of London (1993) 373–404. [27] Hirose K., "Melting experiments on lherzolite KLB-1 under hydrous conditions and generation of high-magnesian andesitic melts", Geology 25 (1997) 42–44 [28] Plank T., "Constraints from Thorium/ Lanthanum on sediment recycling at subduction zones and the evolution of the continents.", Journal of Petrology 46 (2005) 921–944. [29] Castro A., Gerya T. V., "Magmatic implications of mantle wedge plumes: Experimental study", Lithos 103 (2007) (1-2) 138-148.[30] Dokuz A., Tanyolu E., Genc S., "A mantle and a lower crust derived bimodal suite in the Yusufeli (Artvin) area, NE Turkey: trace element and REE evidence for subduction- related rift origin of Early Jurassic Demirkent intrusive complex", International Journal of Earth. Science 25 (2005) 112-134. [31] Rudnick R. L., Fountain D. M., "Nature and composition of the continental crust: a lower crustal perspective", Rev. Geophysics 33 (1995) 267-309. [32] DePaolo D. J., "Trace element and isotopic effects of combined wall rock assimilation and fractional crystallization.", Earth Planetary Science Letters 53 (1981) 189-202. [33] Harris N.B.W., Pearce J.A., Tindle A.G., "Geochemical characteristics of collision-zone magmatism. In: Coward, M.P., Ries, A.C. (Eds.), Collision Tectonics", Geological Society of London Special Publication 19 (1986) 67–81. [34] Searele M.P., Fryer B.J., "Garnet- tourmaline- and muscovite-bearing leucogranites, gneisses and migmatites of the higher Himalayas from Zanska, Kulu, Lahoul and Kashmir. In: Coward, M.P., Ries, A.C. (Eds.), Collision Tectonics", Geological Society of London Special Publication 19 (1986) 185–202.[35] Carprarelli G, Leitch E. C., "Magmatic changes during the stabilization of a cordilleran fold belt: the late Carboniferous –Triassic igneous history of eastern New South Wales, Australia",Lithos 45 (1998) 413-430.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020

Page 13: 670 8 8 9 * 34ijcm.ir/article-1-495-fa.pdf · Pb x/ˆ ˝f /‰ e˝/t e‰/t ,ˆ /y ˝‰ /ˆ ,f /f ,˝ /ˆ f/f z t/x Downloaded from ijcm.ir at 14:12 +0330 on Saturday December 14th

#3>�f���R- ���(�)��0 �efx �![� 0' ���K)"'���U 6�L�"�$- ��/R/-2\V �)/�' ! #/\26�L . . .z��

[36] Schleicher H., "Collision –type granitic melts in the context of thrust tectonics and uplift history (Triberg granite complex", Schwarzwald, Germany). N. Jahrb. Mineral. Abh. 162(2) (1994) 211-232. [37] Roberts M.P., Clemens J.D., "Origin of high-potassium, calc-alkaline, I-type granitites",Geology 21 (1993) 825–828.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

ijcm

.ir a

t 16:

09 +

0330

on

Frid

ay F

ebru

ary

7th

2020