5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
-
Upload
giles-slade -
Category
Documents
-
view
215 -
download
0
Transcript of 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
1/48
108
108
5. Mexicos Environmental Collapse and America.
Padres Unidosand Community in Actionmarked a radical change of mind for SouthGate residents from Mexico. In Mexico working with the police had been
unthinkable. Cops were corrupt exploiters of the vulnerable. Supportingthemwas a bizarre idea. So when Mexican immigrants marched with the policeor called city workers to have an abandoned mattress removed, these were hugecivic moments. Years after coming here, immigrants in South Gate were warmingto a fuller participation in American life
Sam Quinones.Antonios Gun and Delfinos Dream: True Tales of Mexican Migration
In the 1980s, a great migration caused by Mexicos economic collapse,
initiated profound changes in the ethnic composition of the United States. In
addition to this demographic transformation, the Mexican crisis provides a
model for what could soon happen in those half-dozen or American states that
now face similar economic collapse. Few people would describe Californias
current fiscal crisis as an environmental implosion, and yetjust as there was in
Mexico thirty years ago- there is a pressing environmental dimension to
Californias predicament. The volume of water available to the Golden State is
shrinking on all fronts due to the same climate changes that dried out northern
Mexico. As the earths tropics expand towards the poles, previously fertile
regions become increasingly arid. Californias dense population, advanced
industry and huge agribusiness already require more water than is available, and
because its financial crisis has lasted decades, this populous American state can
no longer afford to buy increasing amounts of expensive water from other
regions. Despite the efforts of Governor Arnold, little is being done to resolve
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
2/48
109
109
this potentially catastrophic lack. Today, California stands on the brink of
becoming a failed state because of a devastating financial crisis that will soon be
compounded by a disastrous reduction in available water and the loss of its
vital agribusiness.
Outmigration is the obvious long-term solution to the life-theatening
scarcity of such a vital resource as water. Already, at 270,000, California has the
second highest number of moving vans leaving the state annually. 1 But this
number represents only the number of middle class families leaving. After the
2010 census, California might soon lose one of its 53 congressional seats
because outmigration has depleted the states wage-dependent urbanites in
both the lower and middle classes.2 Of course, these migrants are not
environmental refugees and their decision is not a climate migration. But if
climate change occurs during the kind of financial downturn that already causes
people to leave a region, its crushing expense will then tip the economic scales
into financial ruin. The migration this ruin then brings about will have powerful
joint causes :In the past, it was this same combination of financial chaos and
ecological devastation that initiated every known example of failed state status.
So environmental collapse is like the aggrieved drunk who brings a gun to a last
stages of a wild party. No one agrees about when exactly things began to turn
sour, but no good can possibly come of it. Anyone who is still sober leaves.
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
3/48
110
110
California is only repeating what already happened in Mexico. In the
1980s, Mexico experenced la crisis, the first round of a spiraling tail -spin of
economic woes that really never ended. If crushing poverty exposed Mexico to
the stupid, savage rule of the drug cartels, Mexico first began to plumb the
depths of poverty when its economy collapsed in 1982. There had been
warnings as early as 1976 when the peso was first devalued, but at that time the
country anticipated tremendous revenue from seemingly endless offshore oil
deposits. El boom petrolero (1976-1982) was an excessive period of infrastructure
megaprojects, widespread importation of foreign goods and expensive
government subsidy programs that supplied fertilizers or pesticides to farmers,
while also guaranteeing basic nutrition to all Mexicans. Using borrowed money,
the oil boom financed a half dozen years of false prosperity, but then
the Arab led oil cartel disintegrated and world petroleum suppliesrose causing the price of oil to drop precipitouslyA financialcrisis in the summer of 1982forced a devaluation of the peso andunleashed successive rounds of hyperinflation that persistedthrough the 1980s which came to be called the lost decade (la decada
perdida)3
By 1989, Mexico was again staggering to its feet, but in 1994 the Chiapas
revolution ended the countrys economic prospects by driving out all foreign
investment. So by 9/11, the crisis that began in Mexico as the lost decade had
lasted 20 years with only a short recess. From the beginning, this crisis
completely dissolved any elements of economic security for ordinary Mexicans.
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
4/48
111
111
In February 1982, personal savings disappeared into an abyss of devaluation
when -overnight- the peso lost 30 percent of its purchasing power. Mexicans
with any financial resources left quickly invested them outside the country.
Banks closed. Inflation soared. Food prices, especially those of tortillas and
bread, doubled and then doubled again. Manufacturing and retail sales faltered
when many small businessmen unable to pay foreign dollars for their imported
inventories or materials went bankrupt. Across the nation jobs evaporated.
1,000,000 Mexicans suddenly found themselves out of work. As a result, the
national index of poverty doubled.
With devaluation, the countrys foreign debt skyrocketed: Mexico owed
234 billion pesos at 1981 rates, but 405 billion at the 1982 rate of exchange. 4
In April, Pemex (Mexicos nationalized petroleum company) determined that
oil revenues for 1982 would amount to less than half the amount projected in
the national budget: Already poor, Mexico was suddenly destitute.
Infrastructure projects and social subsidies around the country ended
immediately. Simple food security became an everyday issue for ordinary
Mexicans. The social impacts were so complete that the crisis was personified
as a tangible villain demonizing the lives of ordinary Mexicans:
The darkness lingered on. Assassinations, corruption, street crime.In everyday conversation, Mexicans referred to the phenomenon as,simply, la crisis. People said that la crisis was responsible forevery malady that afflicted them, a deus ex machina that was cause,
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
5/48
112
112
not effect. Because of la crisisyou borrowed a thousand dollarsand risked your life sneaking acorss the U.S.-Mexico border.5
In the countryside, the Green Revolution which had transformed
Mexican agriculture in the 1950s and 1960s had begun to have an unforeseen
impact on ordinary small holdings farmers by the 1970s. Before the oil boom,
peasants were given fertilizers, pesticides and special seed stocks that made
their land magically produce many tons more corn, beans, wheat, sorghum,
soybeans and cotton. The Green Revolution made Mexican agribusiness
possible because it created an agricultural surplus in the semi-arid nothern and
northeastern zones of Mexico. But it was accompanied by huge water
management projects that transformed the national model of subsistence
agriculture into a modern export business that grew
major commercial crops including sugar cane, vegetables, alfalfa,
soybeans, cotton and wheatin irrigation districts in northernMexico. Of the 6.2 million hectares of irrigated land, 2.8 millionare irrigated by 27,000 small producers with private or communal
water and land. 6
Unfortunately, most of Mexicos farmers were campesinos or e jidatarios
who grew personal crops on small privately or cooperatively owned plots of
land. They didnt have the benefit of irrigation megaprojects. In fact, with the
exception of ancient middle eastern hydrological technologies like qanats or
shadufs, mexican pesants werent really involved in irrigated agriculture at all:
Instead they plant[ed] during the rainy season and stretch[ed] theirmeager water resources over the dry months. The governments
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
6/48
113
113
core agricultural and irrigation investmentspassed theseproducers by, leaving them vulnerable to climatic fluctuations andto pricesset incommodity markets.7
Moreover, although the Green Revolution radically increased Mexicos
food production, not all regions became self-sufficient. In some areas, the
situation was desperate long before the economic crisis broke. During the
1960s, despite the billions spent developing an indigenous agribusiness, hunger
was widespread in the south where 83 percent of all the farmerscould
maintain their families only at a subsistancelevel.8For this reason, a national
system of food subsidies was instituted in the 1960s. Perhaps the best social
program ever created in Mexico, it guaranteed basic nutrition to all Mexicans.
Its abandonment in the early days of la crisis, left the poorest of Mexicos 90
million citizens without food to feed themselves or their children.
Even before the food subsidy program ended, however, the end of other
government subsidies had made small rural farmers vulnerable to increasing
levels of debt. During the Green Revolution, the government gave bags of
chemical fertilizers to small farmers who rejoiced because their yields
immediately multiplied. Farmers soon abandoned traditional agricultural
methods like the planting of the the three sisters corn, beans and squash- that
enriched the soil as they used it. As they did so, they also abandoned or forgot
traditional skills, becoming dependent on the modern methods of inputs
encouraged by the Green Revolution. Increasingly, small farmers relied on
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
7/48
114
114
expensive fertilizers and pesticides to grow their crops and kill insects. What
they produced appeared cost-effective and marketable only because the
governments subsidized these chemicals. When the subsidies ended and were
replace by low interest loans through the governments bank, most small
farmers got into serious debt very quickly:
Three years after they first began to use fertilizers, corn yieldsdropped to their original levels. Not only that, if famers did notadd fertilizers the corn would not grow at all. By the early 1980s,
with their debt continuing to growpeoplewere caught up in a
cycle of dependence. More and more were going to the UnitedStates topay off their debtsthe situation had deteriorated tothe point where the cost of fertilizers required to produce amarginal corn crop often exceeded the value of the corn itself. 9
Long before 1982, rural farmers supplemented their income by exploiting
unsuitable, government owned lands -forests, hills, arroyos, unsettled
countryside- until these gave out due to erosion, salinization or desertification.
By the late 90s about one third (50 million acres or 20 million hectares) of all Mexican
farmland had been severly eroded, while much more (86 percent) was eroded to some
degree. In Tlaxcala, the smallest Mexican state whose economy relies on rain-fed corn
production, half of the states arable land was destroyed by erosion amidst predictions it
will soon desertify completely. In the Mixteco region (of Oxaca state), 70 percent of all
once-arable land is now also ruined. Mexican farmers have a pat-phrase that describes the
exhaustion of their soil. The land, they say, no longer gives.10
As the land gave out, more and more peasants learned to survive by working as
farm laborers for larger growers who had water, who could afford fertilizers, and who
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
8/48
115
115
produced crops for the international market. Often too, unemployed rural farmers
migrated to large cities where they worked seasonally in laboring jobs like construction.
But in 1982, after economic disaster had leveled Mexicos quality of life and eliminated
the availability of city jobs, drought struck the most productive zones of Mexican
agriculture resulting in a 40 percent loss of the corn harvest, and adding to the long list of
push factors now driving peoplemillions of people- out of Mexico.11
The drought that began in 1982, was the vanguard of new climate change
rainfall patterns that present a serious and continuous challenge to local
farmers throughout the Mexican countryside. Drought exacerbates the problem
of radical declines in the levels of Mexicos aquifers so as bad as the current
water crisis is, it can only get worse. (-Unfortunately this is also true for
California.) Already rainfall changes have had disastrous effects in dry states
like Tlaxcala and Zacatecas. A former corn farmer in Zacatecas, describes the
conditions that forced many like him to leave the land and find work elsewhere:
Ordinary peasant farmers found themselves out of work and short of food.In a good year I can grow four tons of corn and maybe three and a half ofbeans. But with the sparse rainfall we had this year, I harvested less than aton of each. Six months of work, plowing, sowing, weeding, fumigating,
and that was all I brought in.12
In the 80s, massive migration to the United States was the only reasonable
course available for rural Mexicans who due to environmental devastation-
would have starved if they stayed in place or who due to economic
devastation- would have done little better in a large Mexican city. In Mexico,
these environmental forces are accepted and widely discussed, but in the U.S.
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
9/48
116
116
the same issues are invariably lost when Americans sound alarms about how an
overwhelming wave of migration might change the ethnic make-up and
demographic predispositions of the United States. Moreover, Mexico was not
the only source of Latin environmental migration. Political upheaval and
economic chaos have already impoverished the citizens of Guatemala, El
Salvador, Honduras, and Nicaraugua, but these countries also share a
geographical rainshadow that is steadily worsening as a result of climate change.
Over 8 million residents of Central Americas drought corridor suffer from
chronic malnourishment, since agriculture in the region fails annually when the
rains stop during the planting months of May to August.
Since the 1980s residents of Guatemala have fled to southern Mexico.
Despite Mexican efforts to repatriate them, between 50 and 100,000
unregistered Guatemalans remained in Mexico in the early 90s before
conditions in central America worsened.13 By 2002, the rate of chronic
malnourishment in Guatemala was 48%, the highest in Central America, and
the U.N. sent emergency relief to feed 6,000 Guatemalan children in mortal
danger from starvation,.
In addition to Guatemalans fleeing famine, even more Salvadorans pass
through southern Mexico.14 A famous song by the popular Norteo band Los
Tigres del Norte, recounts the journey of an undocumented Salvadoran refugee
fleeing 5,000 kilometres through Guatemala and Mexico into the United States.
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
10/48
117
117
Three Times a Wetback (Tres Veces Mojado ) is an anthem for modern Latino
migrants no matter their circumstances or country of origin:
sabia que necesitaria mas que valor
Ya para muchos no hay otra solucion
Que abandonar su patria tal vez para siempre
By the late 80s American response to the massive migration from Mexico
and Latin America turned into alarm. In 1983, Time Magazinewarned that Los
Angeles was being invaded by a staggering influx of foreign settlers. 15 I
remember being disappointed when I read this piece one morning at the juice
bar in the old El Centro market because there was no mention of L.A.s
Canadian community whose population was then double the size of my small
hometown. Apart from a local sitcom writer I knew who referred to L.A.s
expat Canadians as the snowflakes, the 300,000 or so snowbirds in SoCal were
largely ignored because they were dwarfed by the influx of millions of newly-
arrived Latinos. While I enjoyed Mexican food and the festival of accents that
filled the citys public spaces, the rhetoric that targeted these migrants
surprised me. I drove around L.A. in an old car listening to salsa stations,
pretending I was a tourist in Latin America, but others were not charmed by
the Mexican invasion. Latino immigration from 1982 onward was bigger than
any other wave of immigrants in Americas history. It was just too big for
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
11/48
118
118
mainstream Americans to assimilate easily and quickly. At the time, I remember
it was a very emotional topic even in academic circles, and since I was an
uninvited gatecrasher, I stopped talking about it to my American friends
resolving simply to read whatever I could since I sensed that something very
important was happening. Much of California is Latino, of course, but today
7% of its current population are illegal immigrants (most of them from Mexico)
while hundreds of thousands of white and black middle-class Californians now
leave the state every year. These changes began in 1982, but deficit
outmigrationmore people leaving than arriving- did not occur until California
itself experienced an economic downturn in the early 90s.
I left the state in 93. At the time there was very little in print in English
about Mexicos economic and environmental crisis. In the intervening years a
few books have appeared about the assault on Mexicos environment like Joel
Simons excellent Endangered Mexico: An Environment on the Edge. At the same
time, quite a bit has been published about the Mexican migration so Ive
learned more la crisisand about Americas Latinos. The current U.S. population
hovers at around 300 million people while the population of Mexico has
reached about 100 million. In the year 2000, the U.S. census reported there
were 35 million Latinos in the United States. This is more than the entire
population of Canada and, surprisingly, Americas Latinos now outnumber
African Americans whose influence on American culture has been profound.
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
12/48
119
119
Still, official figures describing the size of this emerging minority are inevitably
misleading. Although the known Latino population in the U.S. includes about
18-20 million legally-landed people of Mexican origin, it probably does not
include the six million Mexican immigrants who applied for foreign identity
cards at Mexican consulates between the years 2000 and 2006. 16
Most likely, the people who applied for these documents are illegal aliens
since this form of identification was designed by Mexico to help its foreign
remittance workers remain in the United States: (there is little other reason for
Mexicans in America to need these identity cards). In addition, these six million
are only a fraction of the enormous and fluctuating number of illegal
Mexicans living in the U.S. at any given moment. So, to guesstimate, we might
put the total number of Mexicans in America at the end of the first decade of
the 21st century somewhere below 30 million people: not quite 10% of the U.S.
population. (This number, of course, does not include children born to
Mexican parents in the United States who are sometimes referred to derisively
by native-born Mexicans aspochos, meaning spoiled or rotten fruit).
The fact that, as a matter of their daily routine, between 1/5 th and 1/3rd of
the entire population ofMexico sleeps, eats and works in the United States
disturbs many Americans and has for some time. Because they are immediate
neighbours, Mexicans often return home, and until recently they have not
assimilated readily to American culture any more than do the half-million or so
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
13/48
120
120
seasonal snowbirds who leave Canada to enjoy the warmth of Arizona,
California, Florida, Nevada, or New Mexico for a month or more every winter.
Although some Americans in the service industries harbour mild resentments
towards visiting Canadians (mainly because our wintering seniors tip so
grudgingly) the only time I experienced genuine and widespread anti-Canadian
prejudice occurred the day I was changing planes in Atlanta after the Blue Jays
won the 1992 pennant, making it at last, as I was foolish enough to say out
loud, a real World Series. Resentment of Mexicans throughout America, on
the other hand, is quite visible and common.
Usually, American journalists and historians think the great Mexican
migration was caused simply by the economic collapse that began in 1982. But
its more accurate to think of this wave of migrants as the result of a one -two
combination of punches in which first the economy, and then the environment
connected with Mexicos undefended chin. It was at this time that many
Mexicans began to revise their image of the United States. After 1982, for more
and more Mexicans, America came to symbolize the land where the problems
of Mexico [could] be solved, where the benefits of an advanced economy
promised but not delivered by the Mexican development plan [could] be turned
into reality.17
Over the next 20 years, as America gradually became the symbol and the
site of Mexican economic salvation, anti-U.S. sentiment disappeared.
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
14/48
121
121
Apparently, a high percentage of Mexicans now have a favorable opinion of
the institutions of American society. 18In response to national polls conducted
in 1991 and 2002, nearly 60% of Mexicans said they favored a political union
with the United States if that would improve Mexican living standards.19
Cynics will say that Mexicans have only acquired their more appreciative
attitude towards the United States because of Mexicos unrepai rable economic
and environmental chaos. Theyre probably right, but it might still be a good
thing. The radical change in Mexican attitudes is a marked improvement over
the deep suspicion, mistrust and hostility towards the United States that has
accompanied Mexican nationalism since the humiliating (Mexican-American)
war of 1847. What fascinates me most, however, is the knowledge that this
same combination of economic and environmental collapse is usually what
pivots social orders into spirals of decline so severe that they can bring on a
dark ages or critical crisis periods when environmental conditions play a
significant role in determining how societiesare reorganized. 20
In his Trilogy on World Ecological Degradation, economic historian Sing C.
Chew traces connections between the environment and the collapse of
expansive economies immediately prior to the onset of each dark age. In
Chews case studies, economic collapse is always accompanied by the
simultaneous collapse of the natural environment that once sustained its
society. Chew claims and it seems sensible- that all economies are dependent
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
15/48
122
122
on the environments that sustain them, so economic collapse is characterized
by a loss of the environmental carrying capicity for human expansion and
progress. This is as true today in California as it was in 1982 in Mexico:
If, in the 1980s, crisis was the most common adjective used todescribe the Mexican economy, much the same could be said ofits environmental predicament. Forty years of rapidindustialisationhad taken a devastating toll on its naturalresources and the health of its citizensIt is hardly anexaggeration to say that the deterioration of Mexicosenvironment has been comprehensive and on a magnitude withfew rivals.21
Today, Mexico is still engaged in the suicidal destruction of its topsoil
through erosion, deforestation, salinization and desertification. This destruction
threatens the land and it people, but it also threatens Mexicos ancient culture
of corn by initiating more intensive land uses including logging and
overfarming.22 The destruction of Mexicos arable land has worsened
considerably since 1995, when it the following, very dark, description was
written:
by 1988, more than 400,000 hectares had gone out ofproduction because of salinization. This is equal to 1 milliontons of food grainsenough to satisfy the basic needs of 5million peopleanother 100,000 will be fallow by 2005 because
of salinization and waterlogging. This increasing agriculturalcontamination affects the surface water that feeds into lakes andaquifers. 23
The war on topsoil has virtually ended the indigenous production of corn,
beans and squash for small holdings farmers, who are the majority of all
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
16/48
123
123
agricultural producers in Mexico. But the extent of devastation to the Mexican
environment is even greater as a result of the rush towards industrialization in
all potentially commercial fields. With the exception of China, Mexico leads the
world in industrial damage to its environment. This damning overview of the
Mexican environment was published in 1995:
The ecological crisis [is] seen in the net reduction of [Mexicos]forests at a rate exceeding a million acres annually (second only toBrazil)the reduction of the Lacandon forest zone by 70percent since 1950, and the disapperance of thousands of species
of fauna and flora in a nation with one of the worlds highestlevels of biodiversity The threat from environmental pollution [is]evident in the severe degradation of its two most celebratednatural lakes, Lake Chapala and Lake Patzcuaro; thecontamination of over 60 percent of its rivers; severe oil spillsalong the Mexican Gulf coast, damaging national fisheries andaquatic life; inadequate sanitation and sewerage facilities in morethan half of Mexicos municipalities, both large and small; the
virtual absence of hazardous waste disposal facilities throughoutthe nation; and, perhaps most notoriously, the venomous air
pollution blanketing the worlds largest urban area, Mexico City,and one of the highest rates of pulmonary disease on the globe. 24
Mexicos war on its own environment is so great that in 1999, the United
Nations sounded an alarm about the impact its collapse would continue to have
on the countrys population. They warned that the lowest income groups would
continue to experience a decline in their living standards; that the countryside
would continue to become impoverished: that land would become less
productive; and that corn and bean yields, which are the staples of the Mexican
diet, would continue to decline until there is widespread hunger in the
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
17/48
124
124
birthplace of the green revolution.25 What this means for Mexican migrants to
the United States is that there is very little reason -other than family and
friends- to return to Mexico. Those who remain following the financial
devastation of 2009 no longer have the option of fleeing to a healthier
economy. So Mexicans are now trapped in a collapsing society that is
increasingly chaotic and dangerous as well as very short of food and water. So
far, -and it will not remain this way- Mexico has been able to survive the onset
of a Central American dark age or what is now usually called failed state
status- by substantially reducing its population and importing large amounts of
foreign currency to support those who remain. Sending Mexicans north to
work for their wealthy neighbour leaves fewer mouths to feed in Mexico, and
Mexicans working in American send money home to sustain their loved ones.
No wonder the Mexican government does everything it can to encourage
northward migration.
Unfortunately, in the United States, the impact of Mexicos one-two,
economic-environmental punch has been profound. Economically and socially
Mexico may have been knocked down by these punches, but, as it fell, much of
Mexico actually landed inAmerica. The 9 billion or so dollars of remittances
that Mexican-Americans send home every year would go a long way to shoring
up todays broken American economy. Some out-of-work Americans are now
very angry that many jobs in the United States go to Mexican illegals who are
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
18/48
125
125
powerless to prevent ruthless employers from undercutting the minimum wage.
So perhaps it is understandable that first passage of the Sensenbrenner Bill in
the House of Representatives in 2006, was a panicked response to the rising
tide of Mexican migration, an issue which achieved the earmarks of hysteria in
the anxiety and confusion following 9/11. The desperation of the period can be
measured by Sensenbrenners proposal that illegal aliens should actuallyreceive
a prison sentence for remaining in the United States without documents or that
legal American residents should be so imprisoned for helping an
indocumentado. As a former indocumentado in California, who was helped
by so many Americans I cannot count them, I find Sensenbrenners proposal
truly alarming. The only crime I ever knowingly committed in America was
overstaying my visa. According to Jim Sensenbrenner, thats sufficient reason
to send me and others like me to prison.
Of course, not many Americans are bothered by the presence of a few
undocumented Canadians. Many Canadians are white, native English speakers
unhampered by an accent as noticeably foreign as that of Australians, Britons,
New Zealanders or South Africans, so Canadians generally move invisibly and
effortlessly through the United States. The circularity of their seasonal
migration goes unnoticed and their unwillingness to assimilate isnt
accompanied by any resentment Ive noticed. This is not true for Mexicans,
who come to the United States not as tourists but as workers, and whose
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
19/48
126
126
visible differences have always invited prejudice. Friends in the States welcome
me and tolerate my odd opinions even though they think Im slightly more
midguided than the average Democrat. A recent survey described the opinion
held by 55% of Americans that Canada has a special economic relationship
with the United States to which no form of protectionism should apply.
Mexicans, however, experience a very different welcome. An anthropology
professor, Leo Chavez, believes that something similar to what was once called
the Yellow Peril (the early 20th
century fear that America would be
overwhelmed by Chinese immigration) is at work here. Chavez traces the
historical development of what he calls a Latino Threat Narrative directed
mainly against Mexicans. It is often used, Chavez says, by politicians or the
popular press to deny Latinos the right to live and work in the United States.
For example, in 1985, when the Mexican migration was already well underway,
U.S. News and World Report ran a piece called The Disappearing Border: Will the
Mexican Migration Create a New Nation? which sounded the following alarm:
By might of numbers and strength of culture, Hispanics arechanging the politics, economy and language in the U.S. statesthat border Mexico. Their movement is, despite its quite andlargely peaceful nature, both an invasion and a revolt. At the
vanguard are those born herewho are ascending within the U.S.systemBehind them comes an unstoppable masswhoclaimancestral homelands in the southwest, which was the norther halfof Mexico unti the U.S. took it awayLikeconquistadorsAmericas riches are pulling people all along thecontinents Hispanic horn in a great migration26
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
20/48
127
127
Chavez identifies the anxiety that United States will be reconquered by
disgruntled and dispossessed Latinos as a constant theme underlying the
stereotypes that characterize all statements opposed to Mexican immigration
since the 1920s. The most powerful motif of this ideology is the claim that
Mexicans are reluctant or unable to assimilate into American culture. Allegedly,
this is the main difference that sets Mexicans apart from earlier immigrant
groups and warrants less tolerance towards them. Simply put
The Latino Threat Narrative characterizes Latinos as unable orunwilling to intergrate into the social and cultural life of theUnited States.27
Although, as Chavez demonstrates, this claim is very widespread throughout
the extensive literature of the Latino Threat Narrative, the simple truth is that
many previous immigrant groups were also simply birds of passage who
arrived in the United States with the intention of making money and then
returning home wihtout assimilating. In the nineteenth and early twentieth
centuries these temporary Americans included many immigrants from the
Balkan and Slavic states; but in addition, 66 percent of all Romanians returned
to their European homes as did 45 percent of all Italian immigrants to America.
Only Jews, Germans and Irish people seemed to have been universally satisfied
with their new lives in the United States. Perhaps this is because they were
fleeing pogroms, famines and deeply divisive political unrest.28
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
21/48
128
128
But to be completely fair, descriptions of Mexicans unwillingness to
assimilate to Anglo culture are difficult to deny. Until the beginning of the
twenty-first century, there was considerable truth to them. Even Jorge
Castenada, Vincente Foxs former foreign minister (from 2000 to 2003) admits
thatwith good reason- Mexican migration to America is generally described in
terms of its circularity.29 Mexicans come to America to work and earn money
which they then send or take home. Although they frequently stay longer, when
they come to America, they comeas I once did- with a limited time-period in
mind. Where my goals were a beach (Malibu), sunshine and a Ph.D., the
intention of most Mexican migrants has been to return to their homeland after
collecting a saddelbag full of dollars. But at the end of the first decade of this
new century, this is no longer completely true. The disappearance of
productivity among Mexicos small farms is the first reason immigrants no
longer return. But then there are the changes that America itself effects inside
all visitors. I was changed radically by my years in California: people who come
from Mexico are also changed.
Women in particular experience an enormous personal transformation.
Although during the twentieth century Mexican immigrants to the United
States were predominantly male, many Mexican women who ventured into the
north became reluctant to return to Mexico. Second generation journalist,
Joseph Contreras describes the reaction of one womanhis own mother- to his
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
22/48
129
129
familys return to Mexico from Los Angeles. Born in Chihuahua in 1924, Olga
Contreras was three years old when she immigrated to El Paso. Although a
naturalized American, she returned to Mexico with her husband and their
American-born children in the mid-6os. But there, according to Contreras, she
became very discontent:
My mom announced in the late spring of 1968 that she was fedup with life in Guadalajara and the sexist attitudes of my fathersnewfound buddies and was taking me back to Los Angeles.30
The difficulty Mexican-born women have in returning to Mexico is well-
documented, and often accounts for the protracted stays in the United States of
their entire families. Although American women have probably not yet
achieved absolute parity with men in terms of civil liberties, equal pay and equal
opportunity, they are much further ahead than rural Latino women. Latinas
resistence to returning south often has, at a bedrock level, an understandable
reluctance to lose the personal liberties cherished by Americans. Sara, a highly
articulate entrepreneur who came from San Rafael in Zacatecas to Los Angeles,
first cast her reasons for wanting to stay in the United States in an economic
light:
The men are always talking about when we return, but I cant see thattheres anything left to return toYou cant live from cultivating theland any more and there are no jobsWhats more, who will send the
money down for the others to live if we abandon Los Angeles and returnhome? I keep telling Pablo that we should save our money to buy a littlehouse here since the eight of us are paying almost $18,000 a year in rentfor this four bedroom bungalow.31
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
23/48
130
130
As she continued, however, the deeper reasons emerge for Saras (and many other
Latinas) desire to stay in America:
San Rafael is a great place to live when youre a young girl. But onceyoure married youre expected to live with your husbands parents, and
youre not free to walk about on the streetpeople will gossip aboutyoucriticize you. Its just crazy. Im a woman of thirty and I wouldnt
have the freedom of a thirteen year old. Im not kidding.I canremember how I felt totally asphyxiated in my in-laws homeCan youimagine someone like me, who has her ownearnings, a woman whodrives a minivan, who goes here and there in Los Angeles visiting herfriends can you imagine me shut away like a prisoner in Pablosparents house in San Rafael?32
Another wonderful illustration of how America changes the Latinos who visit
begins with a demonstration of Latinas resistence to returning home and how
this hampers that of their husbands and children. But I include it here because
remarkably- it morphs into a powerful example of how and why more
Mexicans are now actually assimilating into American culture.
In the Chicago suburbs during the 1980s and 1990s, Mexican-Americans
perfected the art of establishing small business partnerships among families and
friends in order to build taquerias, small take-out Mexican food restaurants that
freed them from the rotten jobs as day-laborers that had once greeted the
arrival of most Mexicans seeking their fortune in the United States.
A pioneer of this movement into the entrepreneurial middle-class was
Carlos Ascencion (Chon) Salinas, who made his way to Michigan from
Atolinga at age 15. A small town of 2,700 people north of Guadalajara in
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
24/48
131
131
Zacatecas, Atolinga has been sending its citizens north to Chicago for nearly 50
years. Like many other Atolingans in Chicago, Chon got his first job washing
dishes at a Golden Nugget Pancake House. Two years later he became their night-
shift manager. In 1976, at age eighteen, he was hired to manage a prestigious
local jazz dinner club. Then, 10 years later, he put together a group of investors
to buy a really nice sit-down restaurant in Lincoln Park where he had been
manager for several years. He lost the deal, but since he had the investors
assembled, he bought a faltering taqueria and twisted its concept a bit in order
to serve American versions of Mexican food, geared to gringo tasteIt was
Mexican fast food for Americans, and for Chicago it was new. 33
Through hard work, native intelligence and an extremely positive attitude,
Salinas soon had six taquerias around Chicago and two more in Nebraska
where his sister lived. Despite his success, he missed Mexico and believed that
he would one day return to Atolinga to live so, after a few years, he began
pressing his Anna, his wife, to return. She
balked. Womens lives in the village were brutish. She liked Chicagosservicesthe diswasher and refrigerators and supermarkets. The kids weregowing up. She didnt want to go back to Atolinga to live.[Still,] Chon insisted. What would it take to get her to return? he asked. A
house, big and luxurious she said finally, built in the American style, witha driveway, and a lawn and set back from the property line. She found aphotograph of a house in a magazine and gave it to her husband. He gaveit to an architect. Build me something like that, he said.
34
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
25/48
132
132
A devoted husband and father, Chon Salinas spent several years building
Annas house. But meanwhile he and other
Atolingan immigrants had to admit that their village had become less a
hometown than a place to spend a couple of quiet weeks a year. Atolingasresidentsgenerally viewed them as wealthy and arrogantA party Chon
Salinas and a friend attended in Atolinga emptied when they arrived. Onvillage streets, poor menwhod never left town hit [Chon] up for money
and scolded him if he didnt recognize them immediately.
The things I used to feel returning to Atolinga I dont feel hereanymore, Chon said.35
Chon began finding reasons for not returning to Mexico. The decisive inner voice
that guided his complex business decisions told him that his kids were in private schools
and were still growing up. Soon theyd be in college. He should return the n. Since his
business was doing so well, it was a shame to leave it. Make hay while the sun shines,
he thought, using a newly-learned American expression.36
Meanwhile his wifes parents
died, His own mother became naturalized and went to live in Nebraska . His wifes
beautiful and expensive new house stood empty on a hill overlooking Atolinga. As the
appeal of life in the gossipy small town of his birth diminished, Chicago seemed
increasingly like his lifes biggest adventure. Every day there was less and less to return
to in Mexico. Finally, Chon came to the realization that he was no longer entirely
Mexican:
After thirty years in ChicagoI found myself, he said ashe drove his SUV through the citys north side one winter
afternoonAll that time I thought I was going backImaginethe energy it uses up all that time youre thinking that youregoing back. It keeps you from growing and involving yourself inlife here. It takes over part of your brain. Its not so much whatyou spend in money. Its that it uses up all your energyA lot ofimmigrants spend most of their lives doing that. 37
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
26/48
133
133
If Chons self-knowledge and self-realization led to an awakening about
how America had changed him, he is not alone. Many other Mexican
Americans experience similar transformations during their time in the United
States. This transformation has a direct bearing on the central claims of the
Latino Threat Narrativesince although it may once have been true that Mexicans
cycled through the United States before returning homeward, it is no longer
very true at all.
In 1982, in South Gate near Los Angeles, there was a changing of the
guard. GM, Firestone and three other local plants closed that year and the town
lost nearly 12, 000 jobs. There was a sudden burst of white flight from South
Gate and other middle-class suburbs that had Anglo names like Lynwood,
Downey, Bellflower, Lakewood, Norwalk, and Cypress. White residents were
only too happy to sell. So Latinos eagerly picked up these homes on the cheap.
La Crisishad just begun, and Mexico was in such a mess that everyone knew it
would take years for change to happen. In 1982, returning home seemed like
economic suicide. As a result, South Gate
went from 80 percent Anglo in 1980, to 80 percent Latino in1990the city grew from sixty-six thousand to eighty-six
thousand people in that decadeBy 2000, 92 percent of thepopulation was Latino[But] in the early 1990s, South Gate
was [still] a town with a Latino population governed by a whitecity council, which a dwindling group of white seniorselectedPlaying soccer was prohibited in South Gate parks, as
were pinata parties.38
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
27/48
134
134
The story of how South Gate achieved a more representative municipal
government is not as straightforward as you might think. Mexicans living in the
United States traditionally have been quite politically apathetic. Of course, they
often feel uncomfortable in their new land and want to keep a low profile. But
there is also the issue of circularity. Migrants from Mexico have been busy
making money to send home. America has been just a factory dormitory to
them. No one has much interest in contributing to a place that they intend to
leave. South Gate, however, provides us with an illustration of how that is
changing. The gradual acculturation of Mexicans in South Gate also offers
Americans an explanation for the overwhelming demonstrations by Latinos
across the United States in the spring of 2006 when a Republican from
Wisconsin, Jim Sensenbrenner, threatened many of their brothers and sisters by
passing a new bill that would make illegal immigration a criminal offense
punishable by imprisonment.
What happened in South Gate, happened gradually. In 1982, South Gate
elected the first Latino City Councilman, Henry Gonzalez a local UAW
representative. Car dealerships around the city responded by inviting Latino
business: Se habla espanol signs were displayed prominently in the plate glass
windows. A few years later, the state electoral district that included South Gate
became the only such district in the state to become predominantly Latino.
Then, in 1994 the Chiapas Revolution compounded Mexicos economic woes
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
28/48
135
135
by driving all investment and many more migrants out of the countrys serially
dysfunctional ecomony. Of course many ran to California, but that same year,
Californians overwhelmingly approved Proposition 187 denying costly state
education and health care benefits to the swelling numbers of illegal aliens. This
happened just as millions of illegal immigrants finally became eligible for
citizenship under the federal amnesty program passed by congress in 1986.
Across the country, Californias Proposition 187 scared Latinos witless. Fearing
that the conservative backlash in California might go national, millions rushed
to become U.S. Citizens.
In South Gate, after citizenship became widespread, the city became much
more settled and comfortable. The number of gorgeous Latina contestants in
the citys annual beauty queen contest increased. Pinata parties were made legal
in the citys parks. The Chamber of Commerce began publishing a bilingual
version of its newsletter. Older Latinas who had been unable to join the
Womens Club of South Gate formed their own Multicultural Club which had
much better parties, better music, more dancing, and much better food. People
also started painting their houses, a sure sign of civic pride. At last, Mexican
migrants were putting down roots in a town theyd once intended to pass
through. 39
The demographic changes in South Gate attracted the attention of Albert
Robles an ambitious political science major from UCLA whod once been a
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
29/48
136
136
state assemblywomans aide. Aged 27 in 1992, he won a seat on South Gates
City Council and then proceeded to ravage the towns trust and finances for the
next 11 years.
1992 was also the year that riots burned throughout L.A. in response to
the acquittal of the four LAPD officers charged with beating Rodney King, a
black former felon caught speeding one night on a lonely highway. During the
riots, the fires expanded every day. They crept northward from Watts towards
Hollywood and then into Pasadena where I lived, and also into the Valley.
Black people were very unhappy, and suburbs that had their own black
neighbourhoods had their own fires. Carjackings multiplied. Freeways were
safe to drive, buteven in daylight- the surface streets were very unsafe so the
small number of people who drove through the city -out of necessity or
madness- no longer stopped for lights or for street signs. For me, it was a rare
glimpse at anarchy. Television and furniture stores were emptied by gangs of
looters who formed mosh pits in front of the broken windows to empty them
of their inventory. Helpless to stop it, I took careful note. No one except the
looters or the courageous members of the Los Angeles Fire Department went
out at night, unless it was to climb up to your own roof to learn how close you
were to the fires. Throughout the day you often heard the pock-pock of small
arms fire in the distance. This became closer and much more frequent at night.
You considered buying weapons. Neighbours offered to lend you some. You
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
30/48
137
137
stayed awake at night while your family slept, sitting near the door in the
darkness while your asthmatic son coughed from the smoke that smelled of
burning wood and old tires. Gladys Knight sang Midnight Train low on the
stereo. After a dozen wonderful years, you realized it was time to leave, and
even though it was not your fault you felt defeated as Gladys sang:
L.A. proved too much for the man.
Down in South Gate, the riots had a different and very positive impact,
one that would eventually defeat Albert Robles and unite the citys Latino
population in what would become their first American political involvement. It
was April, but it was very hot. The curbside Jacarandas, which require
considerable encouragement from the sun, were already blooming. Watts and
South Central L.A. have window-bars and graffiti instead of decorative trees. In
these neighbourhoods, the city began burning as soon as the policemens
acquittal was announced. There were plumes of black smoke on the southern
horizon as you drove west on the 101. If you tried to count them, about a
dozen were always visible. But you had always missed this one or that one so
you started counting again. -After a while you gave up.
The hostility towards LAPD was palpable and because they were
ridiculously outnumbered, the police retreated to their station houses. There
was a brief lull as city residents registered this power vacuum, and what was
about to fill it. Agitated people began hunkering down or throwing bags and
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
31/48
138
138
bedclothes into their cars and leaving. Right around this time, South Gates
Police Chief, George Toxcil, had an inspiration. Using a small army of city
officers supplemented by hastily positioned railroad cars, he was able more or
less completely- to seal off South Gate from its northern neighbor Compton.
This prevented anyone from from entering the town. So while the curved
beltway of surrounding suburbs burned for days in the fires, South Gates
Latino children played safely in the citys parks, no doubt wondering where all
the smoke was coming from.40
During the riots, Toxcil gained substantial political capital. But he didnt
use it to run for office. Instead, he instituted a community-oriented policing
program called Community-In-Action (CIA) that organized police officers and
citizens in public clean-up campaigns emptying junk out of alleys and vacant
lots, fixing broken windows and chain link fences, painting over graffiti. During
the next decade, lasting long after Toxcils tenure, crime nearly disappeared
from South Gate. It worked so well, that the police opened a separate
substation where officers volunteered to tutor and coach neighbourhood kids
after school hours. -For very good, but for very different reasons, Mexican kids
are usually afraid of both the Mexican and the American police. But the latch-
key kids of South Gate didnt run in the opposite direction towards drugs,
tagging or gangbanging. Instead, they were doing homework, and working on
their jumpshots while also getting ready to participate in el sueo americano (the
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
32/48
139
139
American dream). The relationship between the community and the police
solidified over the next few years. It is still in place today. More than one parent
has marvelled at the unique character of South Gate:
In what town in Mexico have you seen any kind of relationshipbetween the police and the community?It doesnt happen veryoften in the United States either.41
Albert Robles didnt have kids, so he may have missed the vital political
information that if Chief Toxcils successors ever stumbled in South Gate,
there were thousands of willing hands to catch them and set them upright.
Instead of kids, Robles had ambition and he understood Mexican political
culture very well. Mexican elections are quite different from their American
counterparts. Sleaze, of course, is a common element in any electoral process,
but in Mexican elections it takes a different form, just as Mexican lucha libre
differs from American professional wrestling by preferring masks and aerial
maneuvers over bashing people with folding chairs. During his political career,
Albert Robles became a master of Mexican electoral sleaze. The trouble started
in 1994, when Albert together with South Gates first Latino councilman,
Henry Gonzalez, were joined by two other Latinos to form the first Latino
majority on city council. At the time the mayorality was an honorary and
rotating position lasting one year. Albert became mayor first. Henry became
vice-mayor. When it was Henrys turn in 1995, Albert found two councilmen to
veto the transition and he remained on as South Gates mayor. Then he
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
33/48
140
140
approved a city funded home loan program to encourage first-time
homebuyers:
He applied for and received a forty-thousand-dollar loan from theprogram, with which he bought a house, Albert [also] took aspeed reading class and tried to get the city to pay for [that]. 42
This was the first time he tapped into municipal funds for personal gain,
but it would not be the last. Robles hung onto the mayoralty throughout 1996,
and before he was ousted in 1997 he hired himself as City Treasurer at a salary
of $75,000 per annum. City Council made him sit in the public seats, but he
was not at all cowed. He regularly shouted abuse and threats at Mayor
Gonzalez and the other council members. He was a very strange, Nixonian
politician whose unpersonable tactics were mainly intimidation, greed and slimy
manipulation of others self-interest. In 1999, he seems to have realized that
Mexican style politics would work very well in South Gate so he began a
compaign of free gifts and anonymous mailers to manipulate the council
election in order to win himself a controlling three-seat majority. Although he
personally would not sit on city council again, he had already managed to install
one proxy, Raul Moriel, a local landlord who always voted his way. In 1999, he
installed another, Xochilt Ruvalcaba, the former city hall switchboard operator.
It was a very dirty election in which anonymous mailers accused the
Mayor, Henry Gonzalez, of being a drunk and of becoming a millionaire at
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
34/48
141
141
municipal expense. Another council member, Joe Ruiz, had the worst of it
however. Mailers falsely accused him of being a child molester, and this
reputation would dog him for years. In 1999, both men lost their races and
Robles tools, Moriel and Ruvalcaba, were handily elected. Robles was now
only one council seat away from controlling city hall and in the newly Latino
South Gate, he had left himself with a very easy last mark.
Bill de Whitt was a white, Republican businessman whose door factory
had remained in South Gate despite the economic downturn. He was a civic
minded, square-dealing Californian on the model of Gregory Peck. When
South Gates population changed, de Whitt had pushed for Spanish language
interpreters at City Council meetings. But that didnt matter to Robles. In 2000,
he engineered a recall election for de Whitt. During the campaign anonymous
mailers flooded South Gate and accused de Whitt of being anti-Latino. De
Whitt lost to Xochilt Ruvalcabas cousin, a beautician named Maria Benavides,
who didnt even live in South Gate.
Suddenly, Robles had his council majority.
The new council got to work by giving itself a 500 percent pay raise. They
created a Community Development Corporation of which they became
directors at a monthly salary of $1600. They also formed a Finance Committee
that met for 5 minutes before each council meeting. Each time they met, they
paid themselves $150. Council seats that had previous paid a maximum of
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
35/48
142
142
$7,200 including all perks and bennies now paid $36,000. In addition they
created a Community Services Department whose start-up involved 100
employees at a cost of $3.2 million. This was an old, Tammany Hall style
maneuver that put friends and relatives onto the municipal pad. Maria
Benavides brother, for example, was made a managernoone knew of what- at
an annual salary of $53,000.
Around this time, Albert Robles began attracting a lot of attention. A new
district attorney, Steve Cooley established a task force on integrity that focused
on South Gate politics and Californias Secretary of State, Bill Jones,
announced that in future, his office would oversee elections in South Gate.
Suddenly too, Robles was arrested for threatening the lives of state legislators
Marth Escuitai and Marco Antonio Firebaugh. City Council responded to this
news by quickly creating the position of deputy city manager for which they
hired Robles at an annual salary of $111,000. If his position was terminated as a
result of criminal charges, he would receive a severance package of $180,000.
Stupidly, Robles then approached the police union asking them for criminal
immunity and offering to cut them into his lucrative municipal operation.
Together they would control South Gate.
What Robles was suggesting has been such a common scenario in
American municipal politics that it is sometimes wonderfully satirized in films
like the Coen brothersMillers Crossing. But unlike movie police, the South Gate
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
36/48
143
143
force wouldnt play. Perhaps, this was because Robles was just far too dirty for
them. In any case, theyd enjoyed a decade of building good community
relations in South Gate. The little suburb south of Watts and Compton had
become famous for its community policing programs and, since the time of
chief Toxcil, local officers had been hired with that set of values in mind. In
pitching his sleazy deal to them, Robles encountered a culture he didnt
understand. The South Gate police were as popular and had as much job
satisfaction as firefighters. They were quite happy serving and protecting their
special community. They were welcomed at civic events by parents and
children alike. People from different races mixed at the public events without
giving it a second thought. The police knew they would damage their own
credibility and effectiveness if they got into bed with a politician universally
regarded as the Latino Joe McCarthy. Around South Gate, Latinos already
called him the cucuy, Spanish for boogeyman. What white people called him
is unprintable.
When the police rejected his overtures in 2002, Robles got truly nasty. He
hired a new police chief and then began plans to shut down the municipal force
intending to replace them with contract workers from the L.A. County
Sherriffs department. This was too much for South Gate residents. White
seniors, second and third generation Latinos and Mexican immigrants all rallied
behind Joe Ruiz who engineered a recall election for city council. At a series of
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
37/48
144
144
municipal meetings, the Police Union, the Community In Action, Padres
Unidos, The Womans Multicultural Club and the Womens Club of South
Gate achieved remarkable solidarity that saw the city through the two
municipal electionsof 2003: the recall, (which Robles postponed until the last
minute), and the regularly scheduled election 6 weeks later. In the face of a
common enemy, South Gates Mexicans and Whites unified and Mexican
immigrants learned the strengths of U.S. civics. The American ability to
participate effectively in government is quite different from the Mexican system
of power cliques and interest groups. It is for this reason that a high percentage
of Mexicans appear to have changed their minds about the United States and
now have a favorable opinion of the institutions of American society. 43
All this happened two years before the Sensenbrenner bill. It happened
first because Mexican immigrants began buying homes in America when it
became clear that life in Mexico was no longer feasible and they needed to hang
onto their American jobs and American lives indefinitely. A second reason that
Mexican immigrants became involved in their American community was that
proposition 187 in 1994 scared them into accepting American citizenship in
order to protect the right to social services for themselves and their children.
Nationally, Mexican American and Latino activism began to coalesce in
resistance to proposition 187. The decade following 187 and immediately
preceding Sensenbrenners bill, (1994-2005) saw something completely new as
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
38/48
145
145
Latinos increasingly postponed the traditional circularity of their migration and
began integrating into American society as never before. In 2002, New Mexico
elected Americas first Latino Governor, Bill Richardson, who had formerly
served as President Clintons Energy Secretary. But most acts of integration did
not occur on the national stage. Instead they took place in small communities
throughout the country when Latinos began to seek an active role in their
communities. A truly wonderful book documenting the variety and breadth of
this integration is Sam Quinones, Antonios Gun and Delfinos Dream:True Tales of
Mexican Migration, from which I draw the complex story of Albert Roblesrise
and fall in South Gate.44 Because this decade of acculturation and activism
preceded the passage of Sensenbrenners bill (HR 4437) by Congress in 2006,
Mexican and other Latino Americans were in place, organized, active and
prepared to react to the next manifestation of the Latino Threat Narrative in a
very new and different way. Just as a influx of exoduster migrants changed
Californian politics in the 1930s, so the Mexican migration would change
America in the first decade of the 21st century.
As Leo Chavez puts it: The immigrant marches of 2006 were not one
event but many.45 For the first time, Mexican and Latino activists were
galvanized into action in the United States. Their ad hoc coalition spread
across the country via the internet, radio and other mass media that catered to
immigrants and Latinos. All of these prompted Latino participation in peaceful
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
39/48
146
146
demonstrations across the country. There were calls for work and school
boycotts and for moratoriums on buying and selling in order to demonstrate
the size of Americas Latin minority and its collective financial muscle. The
response was remarkable. In 2006. civic demonstrations against the
Sensenbrenner by Mexicans and Latinos crisscrossed the country from March
until May. Other ethnic groups soon joined in. Many were American Catholics
from large urban centers of Catholicism. Cardinal Mahoney of L.A. and Mayor
Richard Daly of Chicago spoke forcefully, favorably and often about the role of
immigrants in America and the rights they should be accorded. There was also
participation by Korean and Chinese Americans. These demonstrations were
larger and more frequent than the historic civil rights march on Washington in
1963 or even the very largest of the anti-Vietnam demonstrations in the late
sixties. They included a march and demonstration in Chicago on March 10 th
later estimated to involve 300,000 people; a march and demonstration on
March 25th, involving 500,000 people in downtown Los Angeles and similar
marches in Phoenix AZ and Charlotte NC; marches on April 26 th in Oakland,
San Francisco, Fresno, Yakima, Washington DC, Phoenix, Detroit, Columbus,
Ohio, Houston, Woodbridge VA, Norwood MA, and Longmont CO;
demonstrations on April 9th of about 400,000 people in Dallas with similar but
smaller marches in San Diego, Miami, St. Paul, Birmingham, Des Moines, St.
Louis, Salem and Boise; on April 10 th, rallies in Washington DC and Los
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
40/48
147
147
Angeles with about 500,000 marchers each and other large rallies in Phoenix,
Houston, Omaha, Boston, Atlanta and many other cities; and, on May Day,
there were demonstrations in most large cities across the country, the largest
being those of Los Angeles and Chicago with about million demonstrators
each.
The symbolism at these events is fascinating. A large number of Mexican
flags were noticeable and, of course, these indicated many of the marchers
heritage. But in a remarkable show of solidarity, Latino demonstrators also
sported white shirts and tops that gave viewers impression of an enormous
army united in a common and decent cause. Many, many people also carried
American flags that were clearly intended to send the message that these
demonstrators no longer saw themselves as foreign workers. They were
claiming their rights and status as taxpayers, integral to the United States
economy. As one marcher put it A lot of usbroke the law to get here. That
doesnt mean we dont love America. 46Or as another protestor said:
Im legal. But if I try to help someone who has no papers[according to HR 4437] Im a criminal. For years, I was veryquiet. I only worked and paid taxes. Now its necessary toprotest.47
In Washington, the political reaction to this overwhelming display of
solidarity was abrupt and immediate. Republicans in the House of
Representatives started to back away from the most extreme measures of HR
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
41/48
148
148
4437, including the those that would make it a felony to be in the United States
without documentation or that would make it a felony to help an
indocumentado. Some Republicans tried to shift the blame onto their
opponents, claiming that the Democrats had somehow been responsible for
removing the offensive criminal provisions from the bill.48 But 10 years of
activism and integration had left the demonstrators with greater political acuity
than the busy residents of South Gate who had been buffaloed for so many
years by Albert Robles anonymous mailers. There was a realization that their
greater participation in the process of America would result in improved
conditions and greater respect. So the spring of 2006 should be understood as a
turning point in American electoral politics. It was the moment when
Americas Mexican minority came of age becoming an important voting block
in American national and state level politics. This transition underlies Sonia
Sotomayors ability to win GOP approval for a seat on the Supreme Court in
2009: very few senior Republicans are willing to risk opposing her nomination.
The arrival of a Latin voting block, and the beginning of their voice in
national politics, of course, has great significance for Americas future.
Demographic projections have it that by 2050 a majority of all Americans will
be Latin and most of these will be of Mexican ancestry. But in addition to
changes in the complexion of America, there is a much more vital lesson to be
learned from the great Mexican migration and the integration of Latinos into
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
42/48
149
149
American culture. It is this: when economic collapse is accompanied by environmental
collapse the resulting destruction of any regions carrying capacty initiates massive human
migrations.Thesemigration can only be measured in the tens of millions.This is
relevant, of course, because todayin the late summer of 2009- California
stares into an abyss similar in kind and cause to the double-barreled catastrophe
that has assailed Mexico since 1982. Since 2003, the outmigration from
Californias urban centers that began among low-skilled workers across all
ethnicities in the mid 90s, now extends to its middle classes.49
Los Angeleo
journalist and author, Candice Reed, is only one of these. But she is one of the
most vocal. In late summer 2009, Reed published a farewell to California as
Dear California, Im dumping you in the Los Angeles Times:
Dear California
Youve totally lost perspectiveIm sinking into depression! Wecant pay our billsthe phone is ringing off the hook withcreditors...Childrenare losing healthcare, more than 766,300Californians lost their jobslast yearwere at the top of theforeclosure charts. You need to change and you refuse to admit it.For the first timeIm embarrassed to saywe are together.
Theres no doubt I still have feelings for you butI lost my job inthe newspaper industry and my house is being sold under duress.I want out. Im leaving youand you might as well know the
truth; theres another stateIm fallingfor. 50
In plainer terms, the quality of life that once made California synonmous
with paradise is in decline. Like Candice Reed, lower and middle class
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
43/48
150
150
Americans are finding opportunities for employment and more affordable lives
with better quality elsewhere. Reed has moved to Chelan, WA where she now
works for a small local paper while her retired husband has taken a job laboring
in a local vinyard. The growing exodus from California in which the Reeds are
participating is the result of an economic crisis that was brought on by
attempting to sustain a high quality of life without levying additional tax. Peter
Schrag, the author ofParadise Lost,the book that first warned Californias about
the states nearly inevitable decline, writes:
Californiahad been coasting on the capital investment of the1950s and 1960s and hadbeen disinvesting by letting thatinfrastructure deteriorateIn 1960 California spent nearly $1.50per person for infrastructure. In the 1980s and 1990s, it spentroughly $0.25. Californias backlog on infrastructure theschools and other public buildings, roads, water and sewersystems that needed to be built, repaired or modernized- wasconservatively priced by the California Buisness Roundtable in
the late 1990s at $90 billion, by a state commission in 2002 at$100 billion, and by others at considerably more. 51
In addition to the rapid downturn of Californias infrastructure, there is
in store an environmental crisis of proportions unequalled before in any of the
United States. Water, of course, is already a major challenge to the 38 million
people who live in the state. There is little more to be had elsewhere and,
anyway, California can no longer afford to buy it. In addition to the problem
of a general lack of potable water that will already squeeze millions of people
out of the state, there is also the problem water quality. In recent decades
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
44/48
151
151
salinity has became a serious threat. Most Californian water comes from the
aquifers or from the lower Colorado River. In the past decade, because of
aquifer depletion and evaporation at reservoirs, the concentration of salts has
increased in both sources (since the same amount of minerals are now
dissolved in much less water). Californias famers are forced to irrigate fewer
acres with the same volume of water, to switch to more salt-tolerant crops, to
install expensive tile drains., or to somehow obtain more water simply in order
to produce a dwindling volume of crops. In 2001, the problem became
especially obvious for farmers in the Imperial Valley, the centerpiece of
Californian agribusiness. In The Big Thirst, a book about the history and future
of water crises in California, Norris Hudley describes whats in store:
The Imperial Valley has been especially hard hit, pouring millions ofdollars into a struggle to control salts that, baring some unexpected
technological breakthrough or infusion of new water, will inevitably belost. If that happens the valley will be abandoned, thus following a pattenestablished by many earlier civilizations stretching as far back as Sumer inthe third millenium B.C. 52
In the coming years, droughts, heat waves and increasingly large forest mega-fires
(like the ones now beginning near Bishop, Lake Naciemento, San Bernardino, Ventura
and Sta Cruz) will increase the state's irreparable economic devastation while reducing its
carrying capacity and making California -- especially southern California -- a truly
miserable place to live. The dream is genuinely over. This is the beginning of the end. As
I write this, I am very sad because I have postponed returning to California for 16 years,
and in the meantime it has been ruined by greed and mismanagement. Without any help
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
45/48
152
152
in sight, California is now unable to cope with any major crisis -- a mega-fire, an
earthquake, a drought -- so climate change can only continue to kick the state, and keep it
down in the coming years. I remember my first day on the beach in Santa Monica in late
August 1980. It was so beautiful I thought that I would stay in SoCal forever. But we had
kids and no health insurance. We left for a more affordable life in my native Canada.
Now, the Paradise I loved is gone. It's like that song-of-a-girl you were going to find the
nerve to dance with before the party ended. For the rest of your life you'll feel the
disappointment of not following through.
1Don Poulson. Daily News. The Way I See It: The Not-So-Great Business of California. Retrieved online on 08/17/2009at http://www.redbluffdailynews.com/fdcp?1250606957991
2Richard Simon. Los Angeles Times. California Could Lose A House Seat After 2010 Census. Retrieved online on 08/17/2009 athttp://articles.latimes.com/2009/jul/15/local/me-california-delegation15
3Marcela Cerruta, Douglas Massey. Trends in Mexican Migration to the Untied States: 1965 -1995, inJorge Durand, Douglas Massey, eds. Crossing the Border: Research from the Mexican Migration Project.
(New York, Russell Sage, 2004): p 21.
4 Judith Adler Hellman.Mexico In Crisis, second edition (New York, Holme and Meir, 1983):pp 223-4.
5 Ruben Martinez. Crossing Over: A Mexican Family on the Migrant Trail. (New York, Henry Holt,2001): p 10.
6Introduction, in Scott Whiteford and Roberto Melville, eds. Protecting a Sacred Gift: Water And SocialChange in Mexico. (San Diego, CA, Center for U.S.Mexican Studies, 2002): p 8.
7 Ibid.
8 Cynthia Hewitt de Alcantara.Modernizing Mexican Agriculture: Socioeconomic Implications OfTechnological Change 1940-1970. (Geneva, UN Research Institute for Social Development, 1976) p 310.
9 Joel Simon.Endangered Mexico: An Environment on the Edge. (San Francisco, Sierra Club Books,1997): p 37.
10 Ibid.
11Judith Adler Hellman.Mexico In Crisis, second edition (New York, Holme and Meir, 1983): p 230.
http://www.redbluffdailynews.com/fdcp?1250606957991http://articles.latimes.com/2009/jul/15/local/me-california-delegation15http://articles.latimes.com/2009/jul/15/local/me-california-delegation15http://www.redbluffdailynews.com/fdcp?1250606957991 -
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
46/48
153
153
12Judith Adler Hellman. The World of Mexican Migrants: The Rock and the Hard Place. (New York, The New Press,2008): p 38.
13 Matthew J. Gibney, et al.Immigration and Asylum: from 1900 to the Present.(Sta Barbara, CA; ABC-
Clio, 2005): p 77.14 Maria Cristina Garcia. Seeking Refuge: Central American Migration to Mexico, the United States andCanada. (Berkeley, University of California Press, 2006): p 45
15The New Ellis Island. Time Magazine. June 13, 1983. pp 18-20.
16 Jorge Castenada,Ex Mex; From Migrants to Immigrants. (New York, The New Press, 2007); p 125.
17 Alejandro Portes, Robert L. Bach.Latin Journey: Cuban and Mexican Immigrants in the United States.(Berkeley, CA, University of California Press, 1985): p 114.
18 Joseph Contreras.In the Shadow of the Giant: The Americanization of Modern Mexico. (New Brunswick,NJ, Rutgers University Press, 2009): p 61.
19 Ibid, p 79.
20 Sing C. Chew. Ecological Futures: What History Can Teach Us. (Lanham MD, Altamira Press, 2008): p45.
21Stephen Mumme. Mexicos New Environmental Policy: An Assessment. In Donald Schulz et al eds.Mexico Faces the 21stCentury. (Westport CT, Praeger, 1995): p 98.
22 Joel Simon.Endangered Mexico: An Environment on the Edge. (San Francisco, Sierra Club Books,1997): p 36.
23Introduction, in Scott Whiteford and Roberto Melville, eds. Protecting a Sacred Gift: Water And SocialChange in Mexico. (San Diego, CA, Center for U.S.Mexican Studies, 2002): p 9.
24 Ibid.
25 Cynthia Hewitt de Alcantara.Modernizing Mexican Agriculture: Socioeconomic Implications OfTechnological Change 1940-1970. (Geneva, UN Research Institute for Social Development, 1976): p 310.
26 Leo R. Chavez. The Latino Threat: Constructing Immigrants, Citizens and the Nation. (Stanford, CA,Stanford University Press, 2008): p 30..
27 Ibid, p 177.
28James Lincoln Collier. The Rise of Selfishness in America. (New York, Oxford University Press, 1981): p 27
29
Jorge Castenada,Ex Mex; From Migrants to Immigrants. (New York, The New Press, 2007): p 135-6.
30 Joseph Contreras. In the Shadow of the Giant: The Americanization of Modern Mexico . (New Brunswick, NJ,Rutgers University Press, 2009): 23.
31 Judith Adler Hellman. The World of Mexican Migrants: The Rock and the Hard Place. (New York, TheNew Press, 2008); pp143-3.
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
47/48
154
154
32 Ibid. p 143.
33 Sam Quinones.Antonios Gun and Delfinos Dream: True Tales of Mexican Migration (AlbuquerqueNM, University of New Mexico Press, 2007): p 209.
34
Ibid, p 213.35 Ibid, p 215
36 Ibid, p 213.
37 Ibid, p 218.
38 Sam Quinones.Antonios Gun and Delfinos Dream: True Tales of Mexican Migration (AlbuquerqueNM, University of New Mexico Press, 2007): p 70.
39 Ibid, p p 70-73.
40 Ibid, p 100.
41 Ibid.
42 Ibid, p 75.
43 Joseph Contreras.In the Shadow of the Giant: The Americanization of Modern Mexico. (New Brunswick,NJ, Rutgers University Press, 2009): p 61.
44 Sam Quinones.Antonios Gun and Delfinos Dream: True Tales of Mexican Migration. (Albuquerque,University of New Mexico Press, 2007): All material concerning the corruption scandal of Albert Robles inSouth Gate is taken from Quinones pages 65-116.
45 Leo R. Chavez. The Latino Threat: Constructing Immigrants, Citizens and the Nation. (Stanford, CA,
Stanford University Press, 2008): p 154.
46 Ibid, p 160.
47 Ibid, p 164.
48 Ibid, p 165.
49 This is a pretty well documented fact. See for example William Freys Metropolitcan Magnets forInternational and Domestic Migrants in Bruce Katz et al, eds.,Redefining Urban and Suburban America:
Evidence from Census 2000, Vol 1, (Washington DC, Brookings Institute, 2005): p 9, 17; Arthur Laffer etal,eds. The End of Prosperity: How Higher Taxes will Doom the Economy-If we let it happen. (New York,
Simon and Schuster, 2008): p 161; Frank Bean, et al eds. Immigration and Opportunty: Race Ethnicity andEmployement in the United States. (New York, Russell Sage, 2003): p 324.
50This is a pretty well documented fact. See for example William Freys Metropolitcan Magnets forInternational and Domestic Migrants in Bruce Katz et al, eds.,Redefining Urban and Suburban America:
Evidence from Census 2000, Vol 1, (Washington DC, Brookings Institute, 2005): p 9, 17; Arthur Laffer etal,eds. The End of Prosperity: How Higher Taxes will Doom the Economy-If we let it happen. (New York,Simon and Schuster, 2008): p 161; Frank Bean, et al eds. Immigration and Opportunty: Race Ethnicity andEmployement in the United States. (New York, Russell Sage, 2003): p 324.
-
8/14/2019 5. Mexico's Environmental Collapse and America
48/48
155
51 Peter Schrag. California: Americas High Stakes Experiment. (Berkeley, Univeristy of California Press,2006): p 109.52 Norris Hundley. The Great Thirst: Californians and Water: a history. (Berkeley, University of CaliforniaPress, 2001): p 44.