5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines,...

13
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555-0001 April 4, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY MEMORANDUM TO FILES FROM: Emile L. Julian DOCKETED USNRC April 5, 2006 (8:40am) OFFICE OF SECRETARY RULEMAKINGS AND ADJUDICATIONS STAFF Assistant for Rulemakings and Adjudications SUBJECT: FORM COMMENTS SUBMITTED IN RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR COMMENTS ON PR-73 (70FR67380) Attached is a representative sample of 360 identical e-mails submitted in response to the Federal Reqister Notice on PR-73, the proposed rule on "Design Basis Threat." Additionally, attached is a list of persons who submitted identical e-mails. Attachments: As stated

Transcript of 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines,...

Page 1: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555-0001

April 4, 2006

OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY

MEMORANDUM TO FILES

FROM: Emile L. Julian

DOCKETED USNRC

April 5, 2006 (8:40am)

OFFICE OF SECRETARY RULEMAKINGS AND

ADJUDICATIONS STAFF

Assistant for Rulemakings and Adjudications

SUBJECT: FORM COMMENTS SUBMITTED IN RESPONSE TO REQUEST FOR COMMENTS ON PR-73 (70FR67380)

Attached is a representative sample of 360 identical e-mails submitted in response to

the Federal Reqister Notice on PR-73, the proposed rule on "Design Basis Threat."

Additionally, attached is a list of persons who submitted identical e-mails.

Attachments: As stated

Page 2: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

-up- FECY - Re: Comments on the NRC's Proposed Rule f or its Design Bass Threat (RIN 31 50-AH60) p a g e 4 - - ~ - - L - p - - ~ - ~ - ~ - ~ - - p ~ - - -

From: Temple Lee Reed <[email protected]> To : <secy@ nrc.gov> Date: Sat, Jan 21,2006 10:18 PM Subject: Re: Comments on the NRC*s Proposed Rule f or its Design Basis Threat (RIN 31 50-AH60)

Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 ATTN: Rulemakings and Adjudications Staff

I am writing to express my alarm about the NRC's proposed rule for amending its Design Basis Threat (DBT), which is the magnitude of threat that a nuclear facility's security systems must be capable of defeating. The NRC's proposed rule makes virtually no substantive upgrades to existing security requirements for nuclear facilities. The proposed rule is insufficient and unacceptable in the face of the current terrorist environment and the potential consequences of a successful attack on a nuclear site.

In section 651 (a) of the Energy Policy Act of 2005, Congress ordered the NRC to consider 12 factors as part of its DBT rulemaking, including the events of September 11, 2001, the potential for attack by large groups, and the potential for air-based threats. Yet, the NRC has failed to consider these critical issues in its proposed rule. In fact, rather than doing the analysis as required by Congress, the NRC asks for comments on "whether or how the 12 factors should be addressed" for the final rule (emphasis added). The NRC is patently disregarding Congress' legislative intent that these issues be fully considered as part of the DBT revision. Deferring the analysis to the final rule is also a violation of rulemaking law, because such vague generalities make genuine comment impossible.

I strongly support the Committee to Bridge the Gap's Petition for Rulemaking to upgrade reactor security to a level that takes into account the terrorist capabilities demonstrated on 911 1. Nuclear plants should be protected against at least 19 attackers-the same number as were involved on 911 1. It is outrageous for NRC not to require explicitly that nuclear power plants be protected against a force including that number of attackers. It is also appalling for the NRC to exempt air attacks from the kinds of threats against which nuclear reactors must be capable of defending. The NRC should require that nuclear reactors be protected by steel I-beams and cabling at specific distances from reactor buildings ("Beamhenge" shields), which would prevent a plane from hitting the reactor or spent fuel pools. Despite receiving over 800 comments in favor of this petition, including from seven state Attorneys General, the NRC continues to defer consideration of the Committee to Bridge the Gap's proposal.

I urge the NRC to withdraw this proposed rule for amending the DBT and to complete a thorough analysis of the 12 factors as required by Congress before reissuing a proposed DBT rule for public comment.

Sincerely,

Temple Lee Reed Box 152 610 S. Adams Rolla. KS 67954

Page 3: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

Mail Envelope Properties (43D2F96C.D98 : 21 : 23960)

Subject: Re: Comments on the NRC% Proposed Rule f o r its Design Basis Threat (RIN 3 150-AH60)

Creation Date: Sat, Jan 21, 2006 9:37 PM From: Temple Lee Reed [email protected]>

Created By: [email protected]

Recipients nrc.gov

owf.5-po.OWFN-DO SECY (SECY)

Post Office owf5-po.OWFN-DO

Files MESSAGE Mime.832

Size 2732 371 1

Options Expiration Date: None Priority: Standard Reply Requested: No Return Notification: None

Route nrc. go v

Date & Time Saturday, January 21.2006 9:37 PM

Concealed Subject: No Security: Standard

Page 4: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

PR-073 (70FR67380) Form Letters No. 3 re Design Basis Threat

Temple Lee Reed Box 152 61 0 S. Adams Rolla, KS 67954

Richard Cooper 5631 Castle Drive Oakland, CA 9461 1

Donna Hyatt Robert Pancer 9040 Keith Avenue 7936 Redondo Court West Hollywood, CA 90069 Darien, IL 60561

Art Hanson 181 5 Briarwood Drive Lansin, MI 4891 7

Kris Sands 200 Harvest Bend Drive Wylie, TX 75098

William Hudgins 31 5 Andanada Los Alamos, NM 87544

Cal Cogburn P 0 Box 425 Oak Harbor, WA 98277

Donna Mummery 67 Village Trail Honeoye Falls, NY 14472

Dave Ladd 200 Beth Street McEwen, TN 371 01

James & Cynthia Enlow 1460 NW Ashley Drive Albany, OR 97321

Delfina Velasco 350 Highland Court La Habra, CA 90631

Elizabeth Hammond 2927 Keswick Road Baltimore, MD 2121 1

Fred Lifton 1824 Eastwood Highland Park, IL 60035

Penny LaDeur 298 Turtle Rock Drive Floyd, VA 24091

D. Jackie Handel 1951 8 Whitewood Drive Spring, TX 77373

Michael J Murray Ill 2800 Postal Way #D-6 Juneau, AK 99801

Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320

Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351

Justin Brown 3 Lienau Place Jersey City, NJ 07306

John Riddell 13549 Frady Avenue Chino, CA 91 71 0

Paula Bogle 532 Matheson Street Healdsburg, CA 95448

Cynthia Glentzes 1665 Dogwood Road Charleston, SC 2941 4

Joe Dale 4249 N. Greenview Chicago, IL 6061 3

Melissa Freeman 2738 63rd Street Fennville, MI 49408

Laura Juozunas 441 6 S. Artesian Avenue Chicago, IL 60632

Todd Boldt 2908 1 45th Street Urbandale, IA 50323

Kevin McDonald P 0 Box 198 62 Lakeshore Drive Belgrade Lakes, ME 0491 8

Susan L D Shamblin Biff Michael Appia 1230 Kinglet Drive 108 East Bridgeport Avenue Morganton, NC 28655 Spokane, WA 99207

Lee Loshak Gary Thaler 160 West End Ave., Apt. 8N 84 Bradstreet Avenue New York, NY 10023 Revere, MA 021 51

James Harper 5620 S. Sheridan Road Tampa, FL 3361 1

Richard Linsenberg 1901 Walnut Street Philadelhia, PA 191 03

Vincent Petta 308 Oak Track Crse Ocala, FL 34472

Michael Merenda 15 East Haley #325 Santa Barbara, CA 931 01

Page 5: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

Rachel Buckley 135 Cedar Hill Avenue Nyack, NY 10960

Alicia Rubi P 0 Box #83 Bronx, NY 10463

Elizabeth Bell Friou 21 Beech Lane Tarrytown, NY 10591

Melissa Daigle 17498 Old Scenic Hwy Zachary, LA 70791

Estela Dimas 1501 E Watson Drive Tempe, AZ 85283

Diane Allred 1 101 1 Banner Road Olalla, WA 98359

-

Melinda Alden Leonard Meltzer 129 Vines Drive 47-14 Little Neck Parway Jonesborough, TN 37659 Little Neck, NY 1 1362

Shirley Garland 828 W. George Street Chicago, lL 60657

Richard Berghofer 1308A E Randolph Ct Milwaukee, W l 5321 2

Laura Marie Flynn 2 Vail Landing, NJ 07850

Bryce Smith 3 Hurd Pt. Road Dedham, ME 04429

Lillian Hanahan David & Judith Laws 25 Arroyo Lane 171 8 Valencia Street Novato, CA 94947 Bellingham, WA 98229

Susan Emge Milliner Fred Morrison 102 S. Kings Canyon Drive 3121 1 Faircliff Street Cedar Park, TX 7861 3 Hayward, CA 94544

A. Joan Gravel 2038 Trevino Avenue Oceanside, CA 92056

Sherman Feller 198 Tillotson Road Fanwood, NJ 07023

Daniel Robbins Luella Corbin P 0 Box 101 2980 W Farm Road 164 Mackinaw City, MI 49701 #I -1 7

Springfield, MO 65807

Geraldine Dimondstein 749 S. Longwood Avenue Los Angeles, CA 90005

Linda Zager 1051 Central Avenue Deerfield, I L 6001 5

David Dene Casa De La Realidad Sorbas, OT 04270

Clark Mleynek 201 3 West 47th Terrace Westwood, KS 66205

Sandor Shapiro 100 Evans Lane Haverford, PA 19041

Richard Mackin 2704 SE Belmont Portland, OR 9721 4

Maurita Bernet 9229 N. 14th Street Phoenix, AZ 85020

Laura English 61 01 River Rock Court Raleigh, NC 27604

Maryann St. John 603 Jefferson Bennignton, VT 05201

Janet Strouse P 0 Box 96 Wardensville, WV 26851

Ben Rall 1081 8 Wauna Park Rd SW Lakewood, WA 98498

Ray Thatcher 2849 # 2oth Street Tucson, AZ 8571 6

-

Alicia Dickson 1 185 So. Country Club Drive Niskayuna, NY 12309

Nancy Sossner 21 85 S. Finley Road #I 606 Lombard, lL 601 48

Sue Gray Al-Salam 5 Christopher Newport Drive Newport News, VA 23601

Kristen Zehner 11 8 Blue Spruce Marshall, W I 53559

Suzanne Baker 41 41 N. Paseo De Los Rancheros Tucson, AZ 85745

-

Marilina Imperati 20 Alexander Drive North Haven, CT 06473

--- -

Rena Kaplowitz P 0 Box 767 La Veta, CO 81 055

Page 6: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

Ben Demar 72321"Avenue Seattle, WA 98122

Frances Taylor 2239-23rd Avenue Sacramento, CA 95822

Mary Miller 69 Village Drive Nazareth, KY 40048

Frank Harte 38 High Street Kennebunk, ME 04043

Lise Horton 321 Lansdowne Avenue Carle Place, NY 1 151 4

Calvin Konno 275 Kalihi Street, Apt. A6 Honolulu, HI 9681 9

Joan Breiding P 0 Box 170625 San Francisco, CA 941 17

Pam Hopper P 0 Box 1315 Lake Oswego, OR 97035

Mike Caffrey 1631 Poplar Street Greensburg, PA 15601

Rosalie Hewitt 13 Brown Street, Apt. 12A Norwich, NY 13815

lsabella Lacki 5941 Hickory Hollow Ct. Harrisburg, NC 28075

Bettie Reina P 0 Box 191 570 High Street Milmay, NJ 08340

Louise Brown 533 E. 87th St., Apt. 3-W New York, NY 101 28

Marie Webster Pamela McAllister 176 Saxon Woods Road 6 Mitchell Court Scarsdale, NY 10583 Bluffton, SC 2991 0

Robert Leghart 123 Ramage Road Pittsburgh, PA 15214

Louis G. Albano 31 4 - 1 3th Street Brooklyn, NY 1 121 5

Dorothy & Richard Chamberlin 201 0 Parkview Blvd. Colorado Springs, CO 80906

Jody Wolfe 3931 Warrendale Road South Euclid, OH 441 18

Stephens & Robin Newberg 146 Granville Road North Granby, CT 06060

William Dabby 191 5 Maravilla Avenue 6 Ft. Myers, FL 33901

Julie Machado 22248 Main Street

Monica Romero 1855-47th Avenue San Francisco, CA 94122

Eric Bottomly P 0 Box 1773 Socorro, NM 87801

Loretta Bober 17 S Bay Court Brightwaters, NY 1 171 8

Faith Roseberry 303 W Flores # I 5 Tucson, AZ 85705

Caroline Getz 909 Harrison Street Hollywood, FL 3301 9

Rodney Hoover, M.S.Ed. 21 04 Kimberley Drive Arlington, TX 7601 0

Sally Simpson 31 6 Crooked Creek Garland, TX 75043

F.J. Pappas 1791 Hague Avenue St. Paul, MN 551 04

Ron Dutra Lynn Coffey-Edelman 1 127 Munich Street 27 Foxwood Drive San Francisco, CA 941 12 Huntington Station, NY

1 1746

Anthony Martin Dambrosi Marcia Cohen 19 Broad Street 243 Broadway Middletown, NY 10940 Hastings-on-Hudson, NY

10706

Lori Blauwet Ryan Danzinger 121 6 -gth Avenue NW 1536 N. Hickory Avenue Rochester, MN 55901 I Arlington ~ e i ~ h t s , IL 60004

Page 7: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

Jenny Heinz 21 5 West 88 Street New York, NY 10024

Chip Phillips 41 -35 45th Street, 5A Sunnyside, NY 1 11 04

Joel Berner P 0 Box 1275 Champlain, NY 1291 9

William Larson 20 Webster Street Dunkirk, NY 14048

Lorne Beatty 573 N. Maxfield Road Brighton, MI 481 14

- -

Tim Martin 485 Mountatin Home Road Woodside, CA 94062

Linda Walsh N4693 440th Street Menomonie, W I 54751

Seanna Blake 1 14 W. 1 Oth Avenue Ellensburg, WA 98926

Krista Culp 11 100 S. Country Rd.,800 W Daleville, IN 47334

Patricia McHugh 7008 Amherest Avenue St. Louis, MO 631 30

Nancy McNamara 4634 Jessica Drive Los Angeles, CA 90065

John Walker 61 2 Los Arbolitos Blvd., Apt. 35 Oceanside, CA 92054

Gilbert Buccola 6282 Palm Vista Port Orange, FL 321 28

Francis Horton 160 River Ridge Lane Statesville, NC 28677

Linda Pompa 57 Tram Drive Oxford, CT 06478

Jason Artero 371 98 Manchester Drive Apt. 42 Sterling Heights, MI 48312

Mary Xakellis-Chapman 6B Ridge Road Greenbelt, MD 20770

Gloria J. O'Reilly 1045 Worthington Spring Drive Melbourne, FL 32940

Vlad Catalin Oltenitei 73 Bucuresti, OT 41299

Jackie Murdock 6281 Still House Road Blairsville, GA 3051 2

Lawrence Brick 301 7 Midvale Avenue Philadelphia, PA 191 29

Machelle Smith 112 S. Bowser Rd. #7 Richardson, TX 75081

-- -

Nadine Lauru 1243 N. Kraemer Llvd. Placentia, CA 92870

Wendie Stauffer P 0 Box 19716 Colorado City, CO 81 01 9

Deborah Clifton 1 101 1 Banner Road Olalla, WA 98359

Bill Stokes 301 - 2"d Street N. #18 St. Petersburg, FL 33701

Steven Langer 309 Herndon Street Park Forest, IL 60466

Steven Culp 11 100 S. Country Rd. 800 W Daleville, IN 47334

Jerry W ikon 401 2 Maryland Avenue Finleyville, PA 1 5332

Joe Dale 4249 N. Greenview Chicago, IL 6061 3

Roy Henock 121 4 G Street Eureka, CA 95501

Linda Decker 6 Fourth of July Road Truro, MA 02666

G. Konecky 350 Plaza Road North Fair Lawn, NJ 07410

Richard Parmett 120 Elm Street Shelburne Falls, MA 01 370

Linda Rising 11 09 E. Tapatio Drive Phoenix, A285020

Rudolph Korbler 51 6 Woodford Avenue Endicott, NY 13760

Page 8: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

Jay Rozner 74 Ventnor D Deerfield Beach, FL 33442

Steven Strode 104 Charter Court Sherwood. AR 721 20

Marian Schwarzenbach 4542 Stanford Avenue NE Seattle, WA 981 05

Jeremy Start 1403 Grand Avenue Kalamazoo, MI 49006

Daphe T. Stevens 15 Arnold Road Fiskdale, MA 01 51 8

Dave Fenimore 302 Bent Lane Newark, DE 1971 1

Jenn Yeh 25 Barton Way Mount Laurel, NJ 08054

Victoria Mosse 71 08 N. lvanhoe Street Portland, OR 97203

Andrew Joens 5399 Chaison Gladstone, MI 49837

Judi Fonsh 45 Long Hill Road Leverett, MA 01 054

Rosemary Moser 69 Garron Road Middletown Springs, VT 05757

Laura Ann K Bernstein 1 160 Greacen Poitn Road Mamaroneck, NY 10543

Bill Hartig 45 Montangue Avenue Ewing, NJ 08628

Rosemarie Sawdon P 0 Box 125

Blacksburg, VA 24063

Penny LaDeur 298 Turtle Rock Drive Floyd, VA 24091

Edwin Davis 91 07 Molly Woods Avenue La Mesa, CA 91 941

Randy Pottinger 11 0 Hemlock Drive Latrobe, PA 15650

Pierre-Paul Villafafila 5727 N. Eight Street Fresno, CA 9371 0

Michael Miller 1225 S. Carlisle Street Philadelphia, PA 191 46

James Corcoran 30877 Lee Frank Madison Heights, MI 48071

Tonia Jauch 5820 Encina Road #2 Goleta, CA 931 17

Laura Juozunas 441 6 S. Artesian Avenue Chicago, IL 60632

James & Susan Sherry 806 Spring Street Conneaut, OH 44030

Anita Das 9533 - 4gth Avenue NE Seattle, WA 981 14

Charles Shumate 11 1 North Ozark Street Prarie Grove, AR 72753

Natalie Hanson 181 5 Briarwood Drive Lansing, MI 4891 7

Donna Noe-Murdock 1 463 Rose Avenue Santa Rosa, CA 95407

Nicole Avedon 20 Merle Place Apt. 3M Staten Island, NY 10305

Bailey Moore 1720 Wells Branch Parkway Apt. 8204 Austin, TX 78728

Elvira Mastro 2642 Manning Avenue Los Angeles, CA 90064

Gloria Hoffman 7034 Greene Street Philadelphia, PA 191 19

Cornel Crabtree 185 W. Houston New York, NY 10014

Rovert Van Wyk 1334 Egolf Road Bedford, PA 15522

Jane Dubrin 109 Ridge Circle Fort Pierce, FL 34882

Dana Ludeking 5941 N. Lima Center Road W hitewater, W I 531 90

Jill Armentrout 706 N. Maine Street Lake Mills, WI 53551

Robert Wagner 10349 Kingsport Drive Cincinnati, OH 45241

Eleanor Brucken 8088 Long Forest Drive Becksville, OH 441 41

Steven Goldman 250 East 63 Street New York, NY 10021

Page 9: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

Roberta Mayer 400 Lafayette Road Harrington Park, NY 07640

- - --

Mary Harte 1 180 Cragmont Avenue Berkeley, CA 94708

E.C. Petruzziello 1200 SW 1 24th Terr., 0-201 Pembroke Pines, FL 33027

Terry Azzarello 302 Kemman Avenue La Grange Park, IL 60526

Sarah Jane Hall 51 0 South Lake Street, #215 Burbank, CA 91 502

JeanneLong 1842 Columbia Road Westlake, OH 44145

Harold Piggott 21 1 N. Meridan Road Glen Carbon, IL 62034

Kathy Riggle 2405 La Rochelle Court Seabrook, TX 77586

Paul Stien 532 Laguardia Place New York, NY 1001 2

P T McGrath P 0 Box 118 Rockaway, OR 971 36

Jonathan Boyne 201 3 Kakela Drive Honolulu, HI 96822

Mark Burwinkel 4686 Hamilton Avenue # I Cincinnati, OH 45223

Barbara A. Stone 836 Stumpville Road Jefferson, OH 44047

Dale LaCognata 6244 Dover Court Fishers, IN 46038

Donna Butler 8438 Mississippi Blvd. NW Coon Rapids, MN 55433

Beth Call 102 Otis Walla Walla, WV 99362

JoAnn W itt 9237 Wyandotte Street Kansas City, MO 641 14

Barry Spielvogel 435 E. 79 Street, Apt. 11-0 New York, NY 10021

Bruce Cohen 7 Ware Street Worcester, MA 01 602

Sue Miller 31 42 Yorshire Road Cleveland Heights, OH 441 18

Kim Kauffman 4037 McClain Way #61 Carmichael, CA 95608

Philip DeMaertelaere 1455 N. Sandburg Terrace #807 Chicago, IL 6061 0

Mary Bradshaw 23920 North Line Camp St. San Antonio, TX 78255

Demetri Wagner 65 Mingus Mountain Road Sedona, AZ 86336

Beverly Williams 141 N. Chestnut Ave. #301 Green Bay, WI 54303

Richard Haberstroh 1001 Meadow Lane Cody, WY 8241 4

Lorna Smith P 0 Box 966 Placitas, NM 87043

Pat Johnson 864 Lakefield Drive Galloway, OH 431 19

Susan Grieder 361 9 Ocean View Avenue Los Angeles, CA 90066

Don McKelvey 591 5 Gardenia Avenue Long Beach, CA 90805

Victor Goldin 440 West End Ave. #9B

Dorene Eisentrager 7501 W hitestone Drive

New York, NY 10024

Ken Irwin 348 Custer Avenue, Apt. 2 Evanston, IL 60202

Robert Blumenthal 281 2 NE 62" Street Seattle, WA 981 15

Lincoln, NE 68506

Kirk Rhoades 301 Cooper Street Mountain Home, AR 72653

Patti Wright 105 Thunderbird Hutchinson, KS 67502

Page 10: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

Barbara Stamp 1821 8 Ginavale Lane Eden Prarie, MN 55346

Marc Pilisuk 494 Cragmont Avenue Berkeley, CA 94708

Linda McLain 105 N. 25th Avenue Hattiesburg, MS 39401

Deidra Kahn 601 Van Ness Avenue #725 San Francisco, CA 941 02

Frank ane Dee Lawton 2160 Brown Road NE Salem, OR 97305

Jehre Holtzclaw 1 1797 Hondo Heights Dewey, AZ 86327

Helene Soule 7 Bestor Lane Apt. 59 Bloomfield, CT 06002

Angie Hughes HC 63 Box 256 Re House, WV 251 68

Floyd Edwards 1521 Pueblo Midland, TX 79705

Susan Gould P 0 Box 865 Land O'Lakes, FL 34639

Shena Kieval 230 Moores Gulch Road Soquel, CA 95073

William Howald 731 9 - 227th Street, SE Woodinville, WA 98072

Gary Scmidt 4456 Martin's Chapel Road Springfield, TN 371 72

Frank and Rhonda Kingman 701 Minnesota St. #226 San Francisco, CA 941 07

Philip Lipari 28 N. Lincoln Avenue Colonia, NJ 07067

Emily Dale P 0 Box 501 Franklin, NC 28744

Ken Herren 6480 Greene 721 Rd. Paragould, AR 72450

Janis Watkins 14050 Miramar Avenue Madeira Beach, FL 33708

Nathan Blyveis 361 6 SW 2"d Street Cape Coral, FL 33991

Mark Deats 21 0 Treetop Circle Nanuet, NY 10954

Rosel Pine 3040 Oak Road Orange Park, FL 32065

Jim Berger 5041 Galen Road Wolcott, NY 14590

Leonard & Zeace Nadler 331 0 N. Leisure World Blvd. Silver Spring, MD 20906

Diane Zimmer Fascione 528 Woodbine Avenue Oak Park, IL 60302

Hannah King 6061 Village Bend # I 31 4 Dallas, TX 75206

Annemarie Askwith 1300 Ryan Avenue Sault Ste. Marie, MI 49783

Jim Elias 58 Greenwood Drive Turnersville, NJ 08012

Alan Wojtalik 3723 Green Oak Court Parkville, MD 21 234

Pater Lundell 95 Rockport, MA 01 966

-- -

Sali Dutra 251 California Avenue Providence, RI 02905

Lee Jankowski P 0 Box 144 Griggsville, IL 62340

Art Hanson 181 5 Briarwood Drive Lansing, MI 48917

Barry Kuhlik 773 Lee Lane Fincastle, VA 24090

Roxana Kaferly 1029 Parker Drive Schaumburg, IL 601 94

Peter G. Cohen 11 16 N. Milpas Street Santa Barbara, CA 931 03

Peter Smith 320 S. Ardmore Ave., #304 Los Angeles, CA 90020

Robert Strebeck 509 Aransas Euless, TX 76039

Lori Mulvey 1084 - 10 Mile NE Cornstock Park, MI 49321

William Torrey 800 Richmond Hill Drive Marietta, GA 30068

Page 11: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

Arnie Welber 5349 NW 90th Avenue Sunrise, FL 33351

Tracey Ahring 51 2 Tracewood Drive Dennard, AR 72629

Marjorie Lamoreaux 30 Topaz Way Sequim, WA 98382

Melanie Buccola 6282 Palm Vista Port Orange, FL 321 28

David Saperia 901 - 1 oth Street #207 Santa Moncia, CA 90403

Heather Mitchell 121 Edgerton Street Rochester, NY 14607

Cindy Risvold N7807 Lakeshore Drive Fond du Lac, WI 54937

Robert Ellis 191 9 Market Street Oakland, CA 94607

-

Renate Brown 21 32 Marengo Street New Orleans, LA 701 15

Carl Cording Carlene Petty 30 South Clement Avenue 51 1 South Fifth Street Ravena, NY 121 43 New Kentucky Towers

# I 91 8 Louisville, KY 40202

James Busemeyer 5592 Pleasantview Drive Milford, OH 451 50

D. Rex Miller 268 Appalachian Drive Boone, NC 28607

Mary Lebert 7401 Valley Forge Brighton, MI 481 16

Erik Wood 68 Carroll Street Basement Brooklyn, NY 1 1231

Lisa Dodds Barbara Fitzpatrick Peter Gunther 4820 Higel Avenue 2500 W. Valley Drive 231 8 W. Sunnyside, #3 Sarasota, FL 34242 Fayetteville, AR.72703 Chicago, IL 60625

Stephen Gliva Adriel lppolito John Earl 3660 N Lake Shore Drive 2031 Hood Street 1802 Seventh Street #614 Springfield, IL 62703 Tuscaloosa, AL 35401 Chicago, IL 6061 3

Amre Klimchak 644 Driggs Avenue #6 Brooklyn, NY 1121 1

Edward Shafer 3961 Beethoven Street Los Angeles, CA 90066

Leslie Jacobs 407 S. Guadalupe Redondo Beach, CA

90277

Kelly Leibold Darryl Cox 1058 Valley Road 821 Congress #2 Mertztown, PA 19539 Emporia, KS 66801

Ken W ikon Ernest Beetz 35 Liberty Lane 6803 Phillips Rd. SE Petaluma, CA 94952 Port Orchard, WA 98367

Sharon Alexander Amelia Trevelyan 751 7 W. 102 Street 1 Maybeck Place Overland Park, KS 6621 2 Elsah, IL 62028

Tara Schwenker 80 Crescent Avenue Waldwick, NJ 07463

Ronald J. Galieti 51 74 Long Branch Avenue San Diego, CA 921 07

Deborah Clifton 11 01 1 Banner Road Olalla, WA 98359

David Cayford Anne Hammond Gabriel Gardner 912 W. 8Ih Street 5091 Neptune Drive 161 5 Dodge Avenue Santa Rosa, CA 95401 Solon, OHG 44139 Fort Wayne, IN 46805

Page 12: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

Melissa Freeman 2738 -63rd Street Fennville, MI 49408

Louise Sherman 1 15 Oak Tree Place Leonia, NJ 07605

Barbara Henderson 907 W. Branch Street Lantana, FL 33462

Rachel M. Hervey 921 5 Tassajara Cr. Road. Santa Margarita, CA 93453

Robert Wolf 1705 Gordon Drive Naples, FL 341 02

Robert French 83 Durfee Street New Bedford, MA 02740

Harris Hochberg 43 Emerson Wakefield, MA 01 880

Maria Butler 231 1 E. Division St. Apt. 39 Mount Vernon, WA 98274

Virginia Wolter 2724 Kendale #I01 Toledo, OH 43606

Allen Keltner 22336 Applewood Lane South Bend, IN 46628

Dale Nesbitt 171 2 Marin Avenue Berkeley, CA 94707

James Pandaru 60 Laurel West Haven, CT 0651 6

Paul & Ruth Leack 2760 Eldorado Street Torrance, CA 90503

-- - -

Zinaida Pelkey 32 West 96 Street New York, NY 10025

Kenneth Grueschow, Jr. P 0 Box 250309 Milwaukee, W I 53225

Nancy Rutigliano 88 Hess Road Valley Cottage, NY 10989

Lisa Marshall 15023 Rain Shadow Court Houston, TX 77070

Michael West 24 East 23rd Street Huntington Station, NY 1 1746

Joanne Bartlett 530 Longmeadow Road Amherest, NY 14226

Elena Day 151 Buckingham Circle Charlottesville, VA 22903

Katherine R. Parisi 23 W harfside Drive Monmouth Beach, NJ 07750

Andrea Miller 521 East 1 3th Street Okmulgee, OK 74447

Patricia Hubley 1 1 Cross Street # I 0 N. Chelmsford, MA 01 863

Ellen Bryant 3545 M Street Eureka, CA 95503

Raquel Zaputil 1032 W. 5th Street Waterloo, IA 50702

Cecily Bauer 151 0 Francis Street Albany, CA 94706

Don Gentry 15373 lsabella Court Corpus Christi, TX 7841 8

Edward Bonse S. Makaleha Place Makawano, HI 96768

Gregory Linn 40 Walnut Avenue Berwyn, PA 1931 2

Shaun O'Connell I268 Amsterdam Avenue New York, NY 10027

Judy W. Soffler 8 Termakay Drive New York, NY 10956

David Sonneborn 1 183 Navarro Place Orange, CA 92869

Monica Gilman 25525 S. Laura Lane Estacada, OR 97023

Wendi Schnaufer 1728 Dublin Drive Silver Spring, MD 20902

Amy Harlib 21 2 West 22nd St. #2N New York, NY 1001 1

Virginia Levasseur 357 New London Turnpike Norweich, CT 06360

S. White 21 1 1-1 80th Street SE Bothell, WA 98012

Nancy Paquette 601 Sanderson Way Fort Bragg, CA 95437

James Scurrah P 0 Box 395 Hollis, NH 03049

Page 13: 5, 2006 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OFFICE OF SECRETARY ... · Traci Rodiguez 2070 King #8 Des Moines, IA 50320 Anne Niccoli 571 Roode Road Griswold, CT 06351 Justin Brown ... Melissa

Kim Norts 1400 Madrone Avenue Cotati, CA 94931

Ellen E. Barfield 81 4 Powers Street Baltimore, MD 21 21 1

Byron Kibourne 125 Marina View Rockford, MN 55373

--

George White Jr. 581 4 Sunset Road Knoxville, TN 3791 4

Martha Bushnell 502 Ord Drive Boulder, CO 80303

Tim Duda 340 Queen Anne Court San Antonio, TX 78209

Sue Christiansen 41 Valley Iowa City, IA 52246

Dr. Mary Brown & Mr. Ed Rutherford 3987 Bennett Road Morrow, OH 451 52

Lawrence McKay 1201 NW 1 9gth Street Edmond, OK 73003

Christine Gyovai 1 122 Broad Avenue Charlottesville, VA 22903

Nikki Wojtalik 3723 Green Oak Court Parkville, MD 21 234

Leslie Scott P 0 Box 391 8 Palmer, AK 99645

Kathleen Dickerson 32 Oak Street Johnson City, NY 13790

Jim Head 2279 Thomas Berkley, MI 48072

Karen Schiller 1 1247 Cimarron Street Firestone, CO 80504

Marlowe Steege 2630 - 280th Street

235 Wionna Drive Henderson, NV 8901 5

Joan Poss 4061 N. Wilson Fresno. CA 93704

Juan Marchini 1 0475 S.W . 96 Terrace Miami, FL 331 76

Carl Polley MSC 598 171 1 1 East-West Road Honolulu. HI 96848

Bill Copeland 207 S. Somerset Court Sanford, FL 32773

Barbara Grant 360 Bunker Hill Circle Plainfield, VT 05667

Jeffrey Dickemann 2901 Humphrey Avenue Richmond, CA 94804

Shelley Carroll 21 9 Brannan Street #1 H San Francisco, CA 941 07