4of4 dtruran ebbf imsd - social media for social innovators

116
Using social media to communicate, learn and co-create social innovation IMSD PROFESSOR Daniel Truran IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship
  • date post

    17-Sep-2014
  • Category

    Business

  • view

    159
  • download

    3

description

how can social innovators use social media, not to - sell - their product but to learn, engage, promote and dialogue with their stakeholders?

Transcript of 4of4 dtruran ebbf imsd - social media for social innovators

Page 1: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

Using social media to communicate, learn and co-create social innovation

IMSD

PROFESSOR Daniel Truran

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 2: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.esebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.esebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.esebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

What can you expect from this course?

An introduction to social entrepreneurship (DT) !Social Entrepreneurship through the lenses of Ashoka 35 years’ experience (MZ) !Social Scaling and Hybrid Value Chains (MZ) !Creating your own social enterprise and social impact (DT) !Inspiring, managing, motivating your team and stakeholders (DT) !how can social innovators use social media to learn, engage and co-create? (DT)

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 3: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

how can social innovators use social media to learn, engage and co-create?

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 4: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 5: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social EntrepreneurshipLack of experience?

Page 6: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

this is the era of collaboration of the connected society

co-working spaces

crowd-sourcing

crowd-funding

co-creation …

Page 7: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

… collaborating and sharing is a natural attitude you live daily…

… and you have (at least) twice as much experience in social media as any of your “experienced” colleagues

Page 8: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

What are two of the main differences between web 1.0 (before social media) and 2.0 (after social media) ?

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

website social platforms e.g. Facebook / Instagram / Twitter

> from promotion to interaction !> it hands over your enterprise to the “crowd”

> where should you be present? attracting to your magic website?

be where the crowd is

how often do you go to your - favourite - company’s website?

Page 9: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

how can social innovators use social media to learn, engage and co-create?

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

how can social innovators use social media to promote their social enterprise?

Page 10: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

we (not companies) are in control

increased democracy and trust

trust reigns - fake likes but we only TRUST people we know

buying becomes even more socially motivated: great products that consumers love will sell themselves

to make people become your evangelists have them co-create with you - have them FEEL and BE PART of your enterprise

the great connector is the EMOTIONAL connection

http://feeds.harvardbusiness.org/~r/harvardbusiness/daily-idea/~3/0Du3CFdcEsM/what-marketing-may-look-like-i.html

Page 12: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Attitude Message Channel

Page 13: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Attitude

Page 14: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

the times of “hard selling” are over ...

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 15: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

the times of “hard selling” are over ...

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

tempting but not right

have a great social enterprise idea?

want to convince everyone to “buy” it?

Page 16: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 17: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 18: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 19: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

EVERY TIME you are about to post something ask yourself:

am I selling !or am I opening an opportunity for engagement

and allowing my target audience to - fall in love - (love brand)?

!and am I being useful to my target audience?

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 20: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

Blue Move Car Sharing example

being humourous !being human !being useful !creating partnerships with shops that can

bring in “responsible” clients

https://www.facebook.com/BluemoveCarsharing

after seeing their FB wall how did they use it ?

Page 21: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 22: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 23: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

where an “evangelist” tells their friends about your social enterprise

Page 24: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 25: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

what posts would make you

useful? !!Interesting? !!allow you to learn?

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 26: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

The good, the bad and the ugly

search - # - to be aware

Page 27: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

BE SOCIAL!

Listen

Social media

Dialogue Learn React

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 28: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 29: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 30: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

Should I then avoid Social Platforms?

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 31: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 32: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

HUB Madrid practical example: attitude and TIMING

Page 33: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

using social media to communicate your values?

Alamo cinemas have a small passionate audience of movie lovers. They don’t allow sms texting in the movie theater.

A person did sms text in the movie theater and she was “thrown out”

what would you have done? “kick them out” of your movie theatre?

Page 34: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

carefully “using” customer feedback

Page 36: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

AttitudeMessage

Channel

Page 37: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

think of your social enterprise

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 38: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

How to !attract?

Create Action

Who

WhAT

In YOUR enterprise / projectIMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 39: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

How to !make your message!move?

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 40: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

http://www.business2community.com/marketing/emotion-necessary-make-sales-0708440

how do you make it go viral?

Page 41: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 42: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 43: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

... as long as you have something “good” to offer

use as market research

Others doing the marketing for you...

Page 44: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

how do you make it go viral?

Page 45: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

effects of that video two years later

Page 46: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

THE MESSAGE

Page 47: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

... and here

Page 48: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

The police have issued this warning: "If you are driving after dark and see an oncoming car with no headlights on, DO NOT FLASH YOUR LIGHTS AT THEM!" Why? Because the no-headlights car is being driven by a gang member, and as part of an initiation rite, the first person who flashes him will be hunted down and killed.

Page 49: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

The police have issued this warning: "If you are driving after dark and see an oncoming car with no headlights on, DO NOT FLASH YOUR LIGHTS AT THEM!" Why? Because the no-headlights car is being driven by a gang member, and as part of an initiation rite, the first person who flashes him will be hunted down and killed.

It's emotional

doing a public service

A trigger is an environmental reminder to talk about an idea “when you see flashing lights...”

Page 50: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

other examples of triggers

Page 51: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 52: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 53: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 54: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 55: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

rogier.tumblr.com

Page 56: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

use images …. with a message

Page 57: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

they spread

Page 58: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

what kinds of images would YOU use for your social enterprise?

Page 59: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

look at specific - community impact - https://www.facebook.com/impacthubmadrid

Page 60: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

Don’t sell your product /service

Have people!Resonate!

with your idea

Page 61: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 62: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 63: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 64: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 65: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

where are we?

Page 66: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

making a wall ... talk

Page 67: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

revenues to a good cause

Page 68: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Make the involvement!meaningful and visible:!see you have made a difference

Page 69: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

Attract

Create Action

Page 70: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

Message!!Emotion!!ACTION

Page 71: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 72: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

The ChannelAttitude Message

Page 73: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 74: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

http://www.flickr.com/photos/dbarefoot/1814873464/

Which Channel?

Page 75: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

you want to be where your customers are going - daily - (this is not your website)

WWW.THE-BEST-WEB-SITE-EVER.COM

Page 76: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

you want to be where your customers are going - daily - (this is not your website)

WWW.THE-BEST-WEB-SITE-EVER.COM

Page 77: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

Picking where people - currently - are

Page 78: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

Picking where people - currently - are

Page 79: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

Picking social media that your target uses

Page 80: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

newsletter

WebsitePage

re-tweet

Notes

mailchimp

RSS

BLOGwordpress?

Where to post? … simplifying

Page 81: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 82: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T6MhAwQ64c0

Page 83: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

People Short Good Questions

Page 84: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

How can you position yourself?

Page 85: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

How can you position yourself?

Page 86: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 87: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 88: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

It’s never been easier to find your relevant audience!

!as local or as global as

you wish!!

and engage, influence, impact and learn from !

!specially !

if you have something meaningful and valuable to offer that RESONATES with

people

Page 89: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

ADDITIONAL BONUS MATERIALS

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

Page 90: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

Not for long ...

Use tailored!platforms?

when choosing a social media channel mke sure it is one that will be there next year

Page 91: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

IMSD / Social Entrepreneurship

http://www.guardian.co.uk/sustainable-business/blog/big-business-lose-social-enterprises

Tuesday 15 May 2012

Page 92: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

Your role as “social entrepreneurs”“combines the passion to help society, based on entrepreneurial business principles laced with innovation and new ideas” !“I believe all three principles and ideas are assets I hope will one day make me

a social entrepreneur”

Don’t do it aloneDreaming dreams is often a solitary act, but it often takes a committed band of

people to translate a dream into reality

Page 93: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 94: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

#getmehome

Page 95: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators
Page 96: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

#getmehome

get to know!new contact

What are people saying about @AIESEC

#AIESECeventname

info comes!to you

1st to inform you of Hudson Plane, Chile Quake

Page 97: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Nairobi sends more SMS

messages every day than does New York City.

Page 98: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Page 99: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Page 100: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Total value of all loans made through Kiva: $130,604,210!Number of Kiva Users: 699,219!Number of entrepreneurs that have received a loan through Kiva: 333,125!Current repayment rate (all partners): 98.48%

Page 101: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

05/10/09 21:52Kiva - Community

Page 1 of 2http://www.kiva.org/app.php?page=community&kv_orderBy=amt_loaned&kv_direction=DESC&kv_page=2

Search for a lending team: Search

How do Lending Teams work?

Community

Lending Teams By Category: -- All Categories --

Showing records 11 to 20 from 8903, page 2 of 891

Name Created On Numberof

Members

Numberof

Loans

Total Loaned ↑

NetherlandsLocal Area

Aug 29,2008 611 6214 $183,800.00

You may join this open team.

Kiva Baha'isReligious Congregations

Sep 6,2008 95 1101 $173,000.00

You may join this open team.

Kiva Team GermanyLocal Area

Aug 29,2008 490 6184 $167,050.00

You may join this open team.

Kiva FranceLocal Area

Aug 29,2008 342 5999 $159,625.00

You may join this open team.

NorwayLocal Area

Aug 29,2008 685 5607 $155,550.00

You may join this open team.

You may join this open team.

One of the most powerful things about Kiva is our community of lenders. You now have theoption to connect with other lenders and make an impact as a team.

Start Your Own Lending Team!

Don't see a team for you? It's easy to start a new one.

How to grow your team using the Lending Team Playbook

Home | Kiva Gifts | Login | Register | Do More | My Basket | Help Center

Page 102: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

05/10/09 21:58Kiva - Wahed Group

Page 1 of 3http://www.kiva.org/app.php?page=businesses&action=about&id=136015&_tpos=5&_tpg=1

Make a loan

$1,475.00 Loan Request$1,350.00 Raised so far$125.00 Still needed $25.00

25 days left

Subscribe

About the Group

GroupName:

Wahed Group

GroupMembers:

Wahed Abdull Hady Nekena Rastam Khoja Mohammad KhojaSardaraqa Faryba Mohammd Sarowar Gullaly Abdull Qodos

Location: Kabul, AfghanistanActivity: Services

About the Loan

Loan Amount: $1,475.00Loan Use: their improve for their busineeRepaymentTerm:

11 months - View details below

LendersRepaid:

Monthly

CurrencyExchangeLoss:

Covered

Date Listed: Oct 1, 2009

DateDisbursed:

Sep 10, 2009

About the Field Partner

Field Partner: Ariana Financial ServicesJoint Stock Company (AFS),a partner of Mercy Corps

Field PartnerRisk Rating:

(Learn more)

FundraisingStatus:

Active

Time On Kiva: 32 months

KivaEntrepreneurs:

2140

Total Loans: $995,950

DelinquencyRate:

0.00%

Sean Howell Seattle, WA United States

Elizabeth Albany, NY

United States

peter Pettendorf, Germany

Kashia Fort Collins, CO

United States

Barbara Maple, Ontario

Canada

Dinar Fremont, CA United States

Emily's Family Santa Barbara,

CA United States

Mike and Mim Sitka, AK

United States

Elisabeth London,

United Kingdom

AnonymousNewton, MA United States

Scott Long Beach, CA

United States

Emily & Curtis poughkeepsie, NY

United States

Dave Palo Alto, CA United States

Joseph Neutral Bay, NSW

Australia

Brian Kanata, Ontario

Canada

Wahed Group

Wahed is the group leader of Ahmad Wahed group. There are five members in thisgroup and each of them is taking a loan to expand her or his business.Wahed wants to take a loan to for his business of DVD shop.Nekena wants to takea loan for her husband, who has small electric materials.Nekena husband wants topurchase a new electric materials for his shop.Khoja Mohammad wants to take aloan for the photo shop business and he wants buy new camera for his shopbecause he has lots of problems and help with families. Faryba and Gullaly want totake a loan for the business of tailoring. Their want to buy new machine for theirbusiness. They requested a group loan of 70000 Afghani. They are very thankful to Kivalenders that support the entrepreneurs in the progress of their business.

About Group Loans In a group loan, each member of the group receives an individual loan but is part ofa group of individuals bound by a group guarantee. Under this arrangement, eachmember of the group supports one another and is responsible for paying back theloans of their fellow group members if someone is delinquent or defaults. Learnmore

Lenders to this group

Home | Kiva Gifts | Logout Daniel Truran | Do More | My Basket | Help Center

Page 103: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

USING !API

Page 104: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Page 105: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Page 106: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

How would!you use it!in your project?

What if it was people!you could meet?

Page 107: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Page 108: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Page 109: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Page 110: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Page 111: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Talk to a few... ... or to many?

What do!you think?

Page 112: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Other Projects ?

Page 113: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

Talk to a few... ... or to many?

Higher level of trust Deeper conversations More alignment

Larger Impact Scale of influence World reach Widening contacts and knowledge

Jammer Wiki

Page 114: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.orghttp://www.slideshare.net/jaggeree/social-networks-for-grand-challenges

small !vs !

large!groups

Page 115: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

www.ebbf.org

V.I.B.s!!> 1,000 friends!!ALIGNED

Who are the key influencers in your project area?

Page 116: 4of4 dtruran ebbf   imsd - social media for social innovators

ebbf.org / Daniel Truran www.eoi.es

You are on a path, your path

“a path invites participation, it beckons to new horizons, it demands effort and movement, it accommodates different paces and strides, it is structured and defined”

“crucially, one walks the path in the company of others” !

Universal House of Justice