3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF...

24
1 3D Systems (DDD) Senior Analyst: Matt Soriento Junior Analysts: Triston Waiss, Jose Grullon, Siqi Xu, Sophia Kryloff, Shubham Koradia

Transcript of 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF...

Page 1: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

Investment Research PresentationMonth Day, 20XX

1

3D  Systems  (DDD)

Senior  Analyst:  Matt  SorientoJunior  Analysts:  Triston  Waiss,  Jose  Grullon,   Siqi Xu,  Sophia  Kryloff,  Shubham Koradia

Page 2: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

2

Recommendation

Slowing  Top  Line  Momentum  of  Diverse  Product  Portfolio

Movement   Into  The  Healthcare  Industry  Will  Offset  Slowing  Revenue

Stronger  Cash  On  Hand  Will  Allow  For  More  Acquisitions

Recommendation Summary

Company (Ticker) DDDCurrent Trading Price (MM-DD-YYYY) 15.28$

Recommendation HoldTarget Price 15.29$ Upside Potential 0.1%

Valuation Summary

Method Price Weight

Discounted Cash FlowPerpetuity Growth Method 10.51$ 15%Exit Multiple Method (0.64)$ 0%

Comparable Company AnalysisP/E 3.54$ 0%EV/EBITDA (0.21)$ 0%EV/Revenue 16.14$ 85%

Target Price 15.29$

Recommendation HOLD

Current  Price $15.28

%  Upside 0.1%

Target Price $15.29

Page 3: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

3

3D  Printing  Industry  OverviewIndustry  Definition§ The  industry   includes  manufacturers  of  3D  printers  and  offer  prototyping  and  printing  services§ The  process  involves  using  digital  data  to  print  three-­‐dimensional  products  using  an  additive  

layering  process§ 3D  printing  has  been  around  since  1984  and  has  been  developed  over  a  30  year  span  § With  the  exception  of  some  household   names,  the  industry   is  fairly  small  and  contains  niche  small  

cap  companies§ Revenue  contribution   is  relatively  small  compared  to  the  overall  tech  industry  but  total  sales  are  set  

to  grow  at  a  CAGR  of  12.55%  into  2021

IBIS  World,  Deloitte,  Bloomberg

Nasdaq:  SYSSMkt  Cap:  $1106.60M

NYSE:  DDDMkt  Cap:  $1647.20M

Nasdaq:  ONVOMkt  Cap:  $295.50M

Nasdaq:  XONEMkt  Cap:  $152.20M

Key  Industry  Drivers§ Material  inputs  are  are  expected  to  increase  at  a  1.62%  CAGR§ The  market  size  of  downstream  buyers  of  3D  printing   products  and  

services  is  projected  to  grow  at  a  CAGR  of  21%

Page 4: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

4

Revenue  Generation

MetalsPlastic/Resin

Organic/Inorganic  Chemicals

Prototyping Manufacturing

Design/Edit  SoftwareOptical  Machinery

Plastic/ResinMetals

Prototyping Manufacturing

ConsumersManufacturing  Companies Healthcare

Construction Aerospace Automobile

IBIS  World

Suppliers

Buyers

3D  Printing

Page 5: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

5

0.00

100.00

200.00

300.00

400.00

500.00

600.00

700.00

800.00

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019

Revenue  ($M)

3D  Systems  Total  Revenue

3D  Systems  Overview

35%

25%

40%

2016  Revenue  Breakdown

Printers  &  Other  Products Materials Services

Company  Background:3D  Systems  is  a  small  cap  tech  company  focused  on  manufacturing  3D  printers,  3D  design  software,  on  demand  product  prototyping,   and  selling  printing  materials§ Founded   in  1986  with  HQ  in  South   Carolina  (2,445  employees)  § Product  and  services  sales  are  done  through  a  direct  sales  force,  

distributors,  and  partner  channels§ Recently  moved  out  of  consumer  3D  printer  space§ Management  predicts  revenue  growth  from  2-­‐8%  in  2017

Key FinancialsMarket  Cap $1,647.2M2016  Sales $632.97M2016 YoY  Sales  Growth (5%)5Y  Sales  Growth 78.99%5Y  Avg. Gross  Margin 48.92%

DDD  10K,  S&P  CapIQ

Page 6: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

6

Slowing  Top  Line  Momentum  of  Diverse  Product  Portfolio

Movement   Into  The  Healthcare  Industry  Will  Offset  Slowing  Revenue

Stronger  Cash  On  Hand  Will  Allow  For  More  Acquisitions

Trends  and  Drivers

Page 7: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

7

§ Product  revenue  peaked  in  2014  at  $284M  and  was  $223  through  2016– Weaker  demand  for  production  printers  and  

on-­‐demand  services  § 3D  Systems  cut  its  consumer  printer   segment,  

which  accounted  for  ~3%  of  the  decrease  in  revenue  for  2016

§ Increasing  exposure  to  new  geographical   segments  allows  an  opportunity  to  increase  growth– 3D  has  seen  increasing  growth  in  Europe  (excl.  

Germany)– European  sales  as  a  %  of  total  revenue  will  

decrease  offset  by  an  increase   in  Asian  sales  § Rising  rates  and  a  strengthening  dollar  will   create  a  

FX  headwind  with  more  exposure   to  Asian  markets§ 3D  Systems  did  not  hedge  with  any  currency  

contracts  abroad  in  2015  and  2016

Slowing  Top  Line  Momentum  of  Diverse  Product  Portfolio

Sources:  Goldman,   DDD  10k

Weakening  sales  will  pick  up  in  the  coming  quarters  and  FX  headwinds  may  have  a  small,  negative  impact  on  revenues

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019

%  of  S

ales

%  of  Sales  By  Geographical  Region

United  States Asia  Pacific Europe  

0.00

50.00

100.00

150.00

200.00

250.00

300.00

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019

Revenue  ($M)

Revenue  Breakdown  ($millions)

Printers  &  Other  Products Materials Services

Page 8: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

8

Slowing  Top  Line  Momentum  of  Diverse  Product  Portfolio

Movement  Into  The  Healthcare  Industry  Will  Offset  Slowing  Revenue

Stronger  Cash  On  Hand  Will  Allow  For  More  Acquisitions

Trends  and  Drivers

Page 9: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

9

§ 3D  Systems  recently  acquired  Vertex  Global  Holdings   -­‐ Next  Dent

§ Management  expects  this  acquisition  to  increase  revenue  by  ~2%

§ In  2016,  they  opened  a  facility  in  Denver  to  focus  solely  on  healthcare  operations

§ Acquired  Symbionix in  2014  for  $120M– Symbionix develops   surgical  simulators   and  

training  programs  for  medical  professionals§ YoY  healthcare  revenue  has  increased  5%  

since  2015  and  is  projected  to  grow  with  recent  acquisitions

§ 3D  Systems  reduced  the  price  of  its  ProXSLS  500  – This  move  will  allow  them  to  gain  market  

share  among  manufacturers§ New  introduction  of  Figure  4  technology  

to   increase  market  share  on  assembly  line

Movement  Into  Healthcare  Industry  And  Strengthening  Product  Pipeline

0.00%

5.00%

10.00%

15.00%

20.00%

25.00%

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

Healthcare  Solutions   Revenue  ($millions)

Total  Healthcare  Solutions  Revenue Percentage  Of  Revenue

Sources:  Goldman,   S&P  CapIQ

Healthcare  solutions  and  new  product  developments  have  the  potential  to  drive  revenue  in  the  next  few  years  and  offset  weakening  sales

PwC  ManufacturerSurvey

Not  Implementing

Prototyping +  Production

2015 28.9% 13.2%

2014 33.3% 9.6%

Page 10: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

10

Trends  and  Drivers

Slowing  Top  Line  Momentum  of  Diverse  Product  Portfolio

Movement   Into  The  Healthcare  Industry  Will  Offset  Slowing  Revenue

Stronger  Cash  On  Hand  Will  Allow  For  More  Acquisitions

Page 11: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

11

-­‐40

-­‐20

0

20

40

60

80

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019Free  Cash  Flow

 ($M)

Free  Cash  Flow  Growth

201311 Acquisitions

$162.3M

201410  

Acquisitions$345.4M

20154  Acquisitions

$91.8M

20160 Acquisitions

2017Vertex  -­‐ Next  

Dent

Stronger  Cash  On  Hand  Will  Allow  For  More  Acquisitions

§ Management  and  analysts  expect  increasing  GM  and  stronger  NWC

§ More  cash  for  acquisitions  has  potential  to  drive  top  line  growth

§ 3D  Systems  acquired  no  companies  in  2016  due  to  a  $565.2M  impairment  of  goodwill  in  2015– We  expect  this  to  negatively  

impact  revenue  growth  in  coming  years

§ FCF  is  expected  to  reach  $70M  by  2019  and  grow  

Sources:  DDD  10k,  DDD  Earnings  Call,  Needham

Acquisitions  will  drive  business  growth  in  the  coming  years  and  increase  market  share  in  diverse  markets  but  weak  acquisition  volume  in  past  quarters  

will  hurt  revenue

Page 12: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

12

Risks  to  3D  Systems

• HP  is  planning   to  invest  in  the  3D  printing   industry• Room  to  undercut  costs  and  operate at  a  loss  

HP’s  3D  printing  business is  successful

• Stratasys currently  holds  more  market  share  • Similar products  and  services

Increasing  competition from  Stratasys and  smaller  printer  

companies

• Healthcare is  representing  a  larger  amount  of  revenue  and  can  cripple  growth  if  not  adopted

Slower than  expected  adoption  of  healthcare  

products

• Management  expects  better  margins  in  coming  quarters  and  stronger  cost control

Smaller than  expected  margins

These  risks  can  be  detrimental  to  3D  System’s  performance.  Each  risk  isn’t  fully  priced  in  and  is  a  main  reason  for  our  hold  recommendation.  

Page 13: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

13

Comparable  Companies

Comparable Company Analysis

LTM data (12-31-2016)Company Ticker EV Market Cap Revenue EBITDA Net Income P/E EV/EBITDA EV/Revenue

3D Systems DDD 1,574.2 1,729.1 633.0 27.9 (38.4) -45.0x 56.4x 2.5x

1 Stratasys SYSS 815.4 1,067.6 672.5 27.2 (77.2) -13.8x 30.0x 1.2x

2 ExOne XONE 126.2 152.2 47.8 (8.5) (14.6) -10.4x -14.8x 2.6x

3 Organovo ONVO 225.5 295.5 4.0 (35.2) (36.2) -8.2x -6.4x 56.4x

High 815.4 1,067.6 672.5 27.2 (14.6) -8.2x 30.0x 56.4x

Mean 389.0 505.1 241.4 (5.5) (42.7) -10.8x 2.9x 20.1x

Median 225.5 295.5 47.8 (8.5) (36.2) -10.4x -6.4x 2.6x

Low 126.2 152.2 4.0 (35.2) (77.2) -13.8x -14.8x 1.2x

Analysts  primarily  use  EV/Sales  to  value  3D  Systems

EV/RevenueLTM Revenue 633.00$ Implied Price Target $16.14Upside (Downside) % 5.6%

Page 14: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

14

DCF  Valuation

Forecasted2017 2018 2019 2020 2021

EBIT 83.28$ 94.62$ 103.50$ 113.23$ 119.46$ - Taxes (7.66)$ (8.70)$ (9.52)$ (10.42)$ (10.99)$

75.62$ 85.92$ 93.98$ 102.82$ 108.47$ + D&A 18.25 19.34 20.40 21.53 22.71 - CAPEX (14.21) (23.90) (24.83) (26.20) (27.64) - Δ in NWC 3.60 (5.00) (5.25) (5.92) (7.18) Unlevered FCF 83.26$ 76.36$ 84.31$ 92.23$ 96.36$ Net Present Value $318.43

ForecastedWACC Calculation:

Cost of Debt 4.21%% Weight 2%

Cost of Equity 10.89%% Weight 98%

WACC 10.77%

Perpetuity Growth Method

Growth Rate 2.50%Undiscounted TEV 1,193.74$ Discounted TEV 715.68$ DCF Value 1,034.11$ Equity Value 1,189.06$ Share Price 10.51$ Implied Exit Multple 8.40x

Page 15: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

15

Valuation  and  Recommendation

HOLDSlowing  Top  Line  Momentum  of  Diverse  Product  Portfolio

Movement  Into  The  Healthcare  Industry  Will  Offset  Slowing  Revenue

Stronger  Cash  On  Hand  Will   Allow  For  More  Acquisitions

Trends  Driving  Valuation

Recommendation Summary

Company (Ticker) DDDCurrent Trading Price (MM-DD-YYYY) 15.28$

Recommendation HoldTarget Price 15.29$ Upside Potential 0.1%

Valuation Summary

Method Price Weight

Discounted Cash FlowPerpetuity Growth Method 10.51$ 15%Exit Multiple Method (0.64)$ 0%

Comparable Company AnalysisP/E 3.54$ 0%EV/EBITDA (0.21)$ 0%EV/Revenue 16.14$ 85%

Target Price 15.29$

§ High  growth  is  expected,  but  unclear  due  to  industry  uncertainties  and  volatility

§ EV/Revenue  is  the  strongest  way  to  value  

§ Price  jumped   6%  since  Monday  § We  expect  stronger  strategic  moves  

to  follow    

Page 16: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

16

THANK  YOU

Page 17: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

17

APPENDIX

Page 18: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

18

Income  StatementHistorical Forecasted

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021

Revenue 353.63 513.40 653.65 666.16 632.97 670.95 711.21 750.32 791.59 835.13 % growth 0.45 0.27 0.02 (0.05) 0.06 0.06 0.05 0.06 0.06

COGS (excl. D&A) (151.21) (215.37) (281.03) (291.28) (262.67) (268.38) (284.48) (296.45) (316.64) (334.05) % of Revenue 0.43 0.42 0.43 0.44 0.41 0.40 0.40 0.40 0.40 0.40

Gross Profit 202.42 298.03 372.62 374.88 370.30 402.57 426.73 453.87 474.95 501.08

% Margin 0.57 0.58 0.57 0.56 0.59 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60

R&D (23.20) (43.49) (75.40) (92.77) (88.40) (73.08) (71.12) (75.03) (71.24) (75.16) % of Revenue 0.07 0.08 0.12 0.14 0.14 0.11 0.10 0.10 0.09 0.09

SG&A (97.42) (143.24) (207.73) (283.23) (254.04) (227.96) (241.64) (254.93) (268.95) (283.74) % of Revenue 0.28 0.28 0.32 0.43 0.40 0.34 0.34 0.34 0.34 0.34

EBITDA 81.80 111.30 89.50 (1.11) 27.87 101.53 113.96 123.91 134.76 142.17

% Margin 0.23 0.22 0.14 (0.00) 0.04 0.15 0.16 0.17 0.17 0.17

Depreciation (8.66) (10.00) (14.73) (20.98) (24.33) (18.25) (19.34) (20.40) (21.53) (22.71) Amort. of Intangibles (12.57) (20.45) (40.46) (62.09) (36.20) - - - - -

Total D&A (21.23) (30.45) (55.19) (83.07) (60.53) (18.25) (19.34) (20.40) (21.53) (22.71) Other Operating Expenses - - - - - - - - - -

Total Operating Expenses (141.86) (217.18) (338.32) (459.07) (402.96) (319.29) (332.10) (350.37) (361.72) (381.62) Operating Income (EBIT) 60.57 80.85 34.31 (84.18) (32.67) 83.28 94.62 103.50 113.23 119.46

% Margin 0.17 0.16 0.05 (0.13) (0.05) 0.12 0.13 0.14 0.14 0.14

Interest Expense (12.50) (3.40) (1.20) (2.00) (1.30) (1.28) (1.28) (1.28) (1.28) (1.28) Interest Income 0.17 1.26 0.48 0.52 0.81 0.65 0.65 0.65 0.65 0.65

Net Interest Inc. (Exp) (12.33) (2.14) (0.72) (1.48) (0.49) (0.63) (0.63) (0.63) (0.63) (0.63)

Other Non-Operating Income 0.70 (1.00) (6.40) (4.10) 0.30 - - - - - EBT Excl. Unusual Items 48.94 77.71 27.19 (89.76) (32.86) 82.65 93.99 102.87 112.60 118.83

% Margin 0.14 0.15 0.04 (0.13) (0.05) 0.12 0.13 0.14 0.14 0.14

Unusual Items (5.70) (13.80) (9.80) (565.20) (6.90) - - - - - EBT Incl. Unusual Items 43.24 63.91 17.39 (654.96) (39.76) 82.65 93.99 102.87 112.60 118.83

Income Tax Expense (4.34) (19.89) (5.44) (8.97) 0.50 7.60 8.65 9.46 10.36 10.93 Earnings from Cont. Ops 38.90 44.02 11.95 (663.94) (39.26) 90.25 102.63 112.33 122.96 129.76

Earnings from Discounted Ops. - - - - - - - - - - Extraord Item & Acct. Change - - - - - - - - - -

Net Income to Company 38.90 44.02 11.95 (663.94) (39.26) 90.25 102.63 112.33 122.96 129.76

Minority Int. in Earnings - (0.30) 8.43 0.85 (1.94) (2.21) (2.42) (2.65) (2.80) Net Income 38.90 44.02 11.65 (655.50) (38.41) 88.31 100.42 109.91 120.31 126.96

% Margin 0.11 0.09 0.02 (0.98) (0.06) 0.13 0.14 0.15 0.15 0.15

EPS 0.42 0.43 0.10 (5.84) (0.34) 0.78 0.89 0.97 1.06 1.12

Page 19: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

19

Balance  SheetHistorical Forecasted

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021

Cash And Equivalents 155.96 306.32 284.86 155.64 184.95 280.9 371.8 472.0 581.7 696.6 Accounts Receivable 79.87 132.12 168.44 157.41 127.11 158.1 167.6 176.8 186.5 196.8 Other Recievables - - - - - - - - - -

Total Receivables 79.9 132.1 168.4 157.4 127.1 158.1 167.6 176.8 186.5 196.8 Inventory 41.82 75.15 96.65 105.88 103.33 92.7 98.2 102.4 109.3 115.3 Prepaid Exp. 4.01 7.20 15.77 13.54 17.56 12.3 13.1 13.6 14.5 15.3 Other Current Assets 5.87 6.07 14.97 - - 6.5 6.8 7.1 7.6 8.0

Total Current Assets 287.5 526.9 580.7 432.5 433.0 550.4 657.4 771.8 899.7 1,032.0

Gross Property, Plant & Equipment 71.38 87.69 134.61 156.99 164.82 179.0 202.9 227.8 253.9 281.6 Accumulated Depreciation (37.03) (42.48) (52.73) (71.00) (84.84) (103.1) (122.4) (142.8) (164.4) (187.1)

Net Property, Plant & Equipment 34.4 45.2 81.9 86.0 80.0 75.9 80.5 84.9 89.6 94.5

Long-term Investments - - 11.97 10.69 9.12 9.1 9.1 9.1 9.1 9.1 Goodwill 240.31 370.07 589.54 187.88 181.23 181.2 181.2 181.2 181.2 181.2 Other Intangibles 108.38 141.71 251.56 157.47 121.50 121.5 121.5 121.5 121.5 121.5 Deferred Tax Assets, Current & LT 0.11 0.55 0.82 1.90 8.12 8.1 8.1 8.1 8.1 8.1 Deferred Charges, LT - - - - - - - - - - Other Long-Term Assets 6.85 13.47 13.85 15.57 16.26 16.3 16.3 16.3 16.3 16.3

Total Assets 677.5 1,097.9 1,530.3 892.0 849.2 962.6 1,074.2 1,193.0 1,325.5 1,462.8

Accounts Payable 32.10 51.73 64.38 46.87 40.51 53.5 56.7 59.1 63.1 66.6 Accrued Exp. 18.75 20.72 34.79 43.22 36.90 36.6 38.8 40.9 43.2 45.5 Curr. Income Taxes Payable 3.38 1.83 8.58 11.32 9.83 24.3 27.6 30.2 33.0 34.9 ST Debt - - 0.16 - -Other Current Liabilities 20.80 36.00 39.40 43.50 42.60 40.6 43.0 44.8 47.9 50.5

Total Current Liabilities 75.0 110.3 147.3 144.9 129.8 154.9 166.1 175.0 187.2 197.5

Long Term Debt 80.53 11.42 - - - - - - - -Capital Leases & Current Portion 7.62 7.46 9.43 8.72 8.16 8.2 8.2 8.2 8.2 8.2 Unearned Revenue, Non-Current 2.79 4.22 7.63 7.96 7.46 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 Def. Tax Liability, Non-Curr. 23.14 19.71 30.68 17.94 17.60 17.6 17.6 17.6 17.6 17.6 Other Non-Current Liabilities 8.05 10.98 32.28 48.88 50.52 50.5 50.5 50.5 50.5 50.5

Total Liabilities 197.2 164.1 227.3 228.4 213.6 238.7 249.9 258.8 271.0 281.3

Common Stock 0.06 0.10 0.11 0.11 0.12 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 Additional Paid In Capital 460.24 866.55 ####### ####### ####### 1,307.4 1,307.4 1,307.4 1,307.4 1,307.4 Retained Earnings 16.41 60.49 72.12 (583.40) (621.80) (533.5) (433.1) (323.2) (202.9) (75.9) Treasury Stock (0.20) (0.30) (0.40) (1.00) (2.70) (2.7) (2.7) (2.7) (2.7) (2.7) Comprehensive Inc. and Other 3.87 5.79 (24.40) (39.50) (53.20) (53.2) (53.2) (53.2) (53.2) (53.2)

Total Common Equity 480.4 932.6 1,292.9 656.0 629.8 718.2 818.6 928.5 1,048.8 1,175.8

Minority Interest - 1.15 10.08 7.61 5.70 5.7 5.7 5.7 5.7 5.7 Total Equity 480.4 933.8 1,303.0 663.6 635.5 723.8 824.3 934.2 1,054.5 1,181.4

Total Liabilities and Equity 677.5 1,097.9 1,530.3 892.0 849.1 962.5 1,074.1 1,193.0 1,325.5 1,462.7

Balance Check OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK

Page 20: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

20

Capital Asset Pricing Model

Beta 1.04Risk-free Rate 2.18%Base Risk Premium 6.70%Market Cap 1,729.14$ Size Premium 1.74%

CAPM 10.89%

Debt  – $150M  Revolving  Credit  from  PNC  Bank

Page 21: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

21

Porter’s  Five  Forces

§ Low  =  § Medium  =  § High  =  

Rivalry• Products  don’t   have  too  much  

differentiation• Potential  for  a  company  to  

break  through  to  new  markets  (High  R&D  necessary)

• Prototyping  services   are  spread  across  the  industry

Threat  of  New  Entrants• Cost  of  capital  to  enter  is  high• High  R&D  costs  to  keep  high  

with  rapid  innovation• Brand  recognition  is  high• Matured  companies  with  

larger  capex  potential  could  step  in  at  any  moment

Threat  of  Substitution• Prototyping  still  is  not  

perfected  but  is  time  effective• Traditional  manufacturers  still  

have  a  foothold   but  are  losing  market  share  as  3DPs  become  more  available

Buyer  Power• High  buyer  concentration  and  

diversified   buyers• No  single  major  buyers  that  

supply   the  industry• Not  many  companies  buying

Supplier  Power• Input  materials  are  on  the  rise  

and  creating  more  difficulties  for  3DP  companies

IBIS  World,  PwC

Page 22: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

22

Decreasing  costs  of  3D  printers  and  more  accessibility  will  be  offset  by  increasing  input  prices

§ Desktop  3D  printers  are  predicted  to  be  or  demanded  in  15%  of  homes  – Several  printers  are  below  $1,000  and  have  decreased  hundreds   of  dollars   from  past  years

§ Consumer   printers  are  still  too  expensive   and  consumers  will  look  to  prototyping   for  a  cost  effective  option§ Input  prices  to  manufacture  systems   and  build  material  prices

– Plastic,  resin,   steel  and  aluminum  are  set  increase  at  an  average  CAGR  of  1.62%  from  2017  to  2022§ Resin  and  plastic  are  heavily   correlated  to  the  price  of  oil§ The  input   prices  account  for  47.1%  of  prototyping  costs  and  29.5%  of  3D  manufacturer’s  costs

Deloitte,  3D  Hubs,  Makerbot,   IBIS  World

0.00

500.00

1,000.00

1,500.00

2,000.00

2,500.00

3,000.00

1980

1983

1986

1989

1992

1995

1998

2001

2004

2007

2010

2013

2016

2019

2022

World  Price  of  Aluminum  Per  Ton   ($)

0.00

50.00

100.00

150.00

200.00

250.00

300.00

350.00

1980

1983

1986

1989

1992

1995

1998

2001

2004

2007

2010

2013

2016

2019

2022

World  Price  of  Steel  Index  ($)

0.00

50.00

100.00

150.00

200.00

250.00

300.00

1980

1983

1986

1989

1992

1995

1998

2001

2004

2007

2010

2013

2016

2019

2022

Price  of  Plastic  and  Resin  ($)

Increasing  input  prices  can  hurt  the  trend  of  3D  printers  a  slowly  becoming  more  affordable

**other  materials  include  biomaterials  and  ceramics

Page 23: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

23

Risks - Sensitivity Analysis

DCF - Perpetuity Growth SensitivityWACC

– 9% 10% 10% 11% 11% 12% 12% 13%3.5% 13.98$ 13.00$ 12.16$ 11.45$ 10.83$ 10.29$ 9.81$ 9.39$ 3.0% 13.16$ 12.31$ 11.58$ 10.95$ 10.40$ 9.91$ 9.48$ 9.10$ 2.5% 12.45$ 11.71$ 11.07$ 10.51$ 10.01$ 9.58$ 9.19$ 8.84$ 2.0% 11.85$ 11.19$ 10.62$ 10.12$ 9.67$ 9.28$ 8.92$ 8.60$ 1.5% 11.32$ 10.74$ 10.22$ 9.77$ 9.37$ 9.01$ 8.68$ 8.39$ 1.0% 10.85$ 10.33$ 9.87$ 9.46$ 9.09$ 8.76$ 8.46$ 8.19$

DCF - EV/EBITDA Exit Multiple SensitivityWACC

– 9% 10% 10% 11% 11% 12% 12% 13%-4.4 x 0.64$ 0.72$ 0.79$ 0.87$ 0.94$ 1.01$ 1.08$ 1.15$ -5.4 x (0.17)$ (0.07)$ 0.02$ 0.12$ 0.21$ 0.29$ 0.38$ 0.46$ -6.4 x (0.98)$ (0.86)$ (0.75)$ (0.64)$ (0.53)$ (0.43)$ (0.32)$ (0.22)$ -7.4 x (1.78)$ (1.65)$ (1.52)$ (1.39)$ (1.27)$ (1.15)$ (1.03)$ (0.91)$ -8.4 x (2.59)$ (2.44)$ (2.29)$ (2.14)$ (2.00)$ (1.87)$ (1.73)$ (1.60)$ -9.4 x (3.40)$ (3.23)$ (3.06)$ (2.90)$ (2.74)$ (2.59)$ (2.44)$ (2.29)$

CompCo - Price/Earnings SensitivityImplied Share Price

$3.54 #REF!($8.42) 2.86$ ($9.42) 3.20$

($10.42) 3.54$ ($11.42) 3.88$ ($12.42) 4.22$ ($13.42) 4.56$

CompCo - EV/EBITDA SensitivityImplied Share Price

($0.21) ($0.21)($4.41) 0.28$ ($5.41) 0.04$ ($6.41) (0.21)$ ($7.41) (0.46)$ ($8.41) (0.70)$ ($9.41) (0.95)$

CompCo - EV/Revenue SensitivityImplied Share Price$16.14 #REF!

$4.64 27.32$ $3.64 21.73$ $2.64 16.14$ $1.64 10.54$ $0.64 4.95$

($0.36) (0.64)$

Term

inal

Gr

owth

Rat

e

Term

inal

EB

ITDA

M

ultip

le

Pric

e/Ea

rnin

gs

Mul

tiple

EV/E

BITD

A M

ultip

leEV

/Rev

enue

M

ultip

le

Page 24: 3D#Systems#(DDD) Investment Research Presentation · PDF fileSlowing’Top’Line’Momentum’of’Diverse’Product’Portfolio ... Plastic/Resin Organic/Inorganic ... Global) Holdings)

24

Types  of  Printing§ Stereolithography  (SLA)

– Uses  layers  of  liquefied   resin  and  UV  lasers  to  build  models,   prototypes   and  patterns– Uses  a  support   structure  and  elevator  platform  to  hold  the  structure  in  place– Accounts  for  the  least  amount  of  revenue  and  has  been  slowly   decreasing  in  popularity   compared  to  other  

techniques

§ Selective  Laser  Sintering  (SLS)– Uses  high  power  laser  to  combine   small  particles  of  plastic,  metals,  ceramic  and  glass  to  form  3D  shapes– The  printer  bases  off  of  a  scan  of  a  Computer  Aided  Design  (CAD)  – Can  use  a  wide  range  of  materials  relative  to  other  techniques– Accounts  for  40.4%  of  revenue  and  has  grown  over  the  past  5  years

§ Fused  Deposition  Modeling  (FDM)– Additive  manufacturing  technique  that  uses  a  software  process  to  slice  and  orient  a  model  for  building– Uses  a  support   structure  and  melts  thermoplastics   that  are  deposited  based  on  a  CAD– Fastest  growing  segment  and  the  technique  name  is  trademarked  by  Stratasys

IBIS  World,  3DP  IndustryFDMSLSSLA

**not  including   less  popular  techniques