2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

download 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

of 59

Transcript of 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    1/59

    *49 JURISPRUDENCE OF SUCCESSFUL TREASON: COUP D'ETAT &

    COMMON LAW

    Tayyab Mahmud FNa!"

    C#$y% h( ) + !994 by (h, C#%-,.. U- /,%0 (y1 Tayyab Mahmud

    I-(%#du ( #-

    O%d,%.y (%a-02,% #2 $#3,% #-(,m$.a(,d by (h, #-0( (u( #-a. #%d,% 0 (h,, ,$( #- %a(h,% (ha- (h, -#%m - m#0( $#0(5 #.#- a. 0# ,( ,06 A ha- , #2#/,%-m,-( #2(,- 00u,0 2%#m (h, (h%,a( #% u0, #2 2#% , a a -0( (h, - umb,-(%, m,7 a $h,-#m,-#- d,0 -a(,d a0 a #u$ d',(a(6 FN8" C#u$ d',(a( 0 (h,m#0( / 0 b., a-d %, u%%,-( ha%a (,% 0( FN4" #2 (h, $#. ( a. , $,% ,- ,

    #2 $#0(5 #.#- a. 0# ,( ,07 a-d (0 ,-d,m (y 0h#30 -# 0 - #2 2#%,0,,ab.,aba(,m,-(6 FN " S - , a- - umb,-( %, m, 2#%m0 $a%( #2 (h, #-0( (u( #-a.#%d,%7 (0 , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. #/,%(h%#3 0 -#( #-.y .., a. bu( am#u-(0 (#(h, h h % m, #2 (%,a0#-6 FN;"

    A 0u ,002u. #u$ d',(a( %a 0,0 0#m, #m$., ., a.

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    2/59

    @ud a. %,0$#-0, (# #-0( (u( #-a. %u$(u%,07 #(h,% $#00 b., %,0$#-0,0 a%, -#(, $.#%,d a-d ,/a.ua(,d6 Th 0 a%( ., a m0 (# %,m,dy (h,0, 0h#%( #m - 0 by0u%/,y - a.. $#0(5 #.#- a. #mm#- .a3 a0,0 d,a. - 3 (h (h, a2(,%ma(h #2#u$0 d',(a( a-d ,/a.ua( - a.. #$( #-0 a/a .ab., (# a #u%( 3h,- #-2%#-(,d3 (h a 0u ,002u. #u$6

    Th, 2 %0( $a%( #2 (h 0 a%( ., 0 a 0u%/,y #2 a.. ?-#3- @ud a. %,0$#-0,0(# #u$0 d',(a( - $#0(5 #.#- a. #mm#- .a3 0,(( - 06 Th, a0,0 - .ud,d * 8a%, 2%#m Pa? 0(a-7 ha-a7 S#u(h,%- Rh#d,0 a )-#3 mbab3,+7 U a-da7 N ,% a7Cy$%u07 S,y h,..,07 %,-ada7 L,0#(h#7 T%a-0?, 7 a-d #$hu(ha(03a-a6 I- ,a ha0,7 (h, a%( ., d,-( 2 ,0 (h, #-(, ( #2 (h, #-0( (u( #-a. % 0 0 a-d, am -,0 (h, @ud a. %,0$#-0,7 - .ud - (h, d# (% -a. $#0(u%,7 %h,(#% a.0(y.,7 a-d ,/ d,-( a%y ba0,0 #2 (h, @ud a. $%#-#u- ,m,-(06

    A.(h#u h (h,0, d 22,%,-( #u$0 u-2#.d,d - d /,%0, #-(, (0 a-d %,0u.(,d -%, m,0 3 (h /a% ,d $#. ( a. a ,-da07 (h, #u%(0 /a. da(,d a.. - umb,-(

    u0u%$,% %, m,0 3 (h #-, , ,$( #-6 a-0 G,.0,-'0 (h,#%y #2 %,/#.u( #-a%y., a. (y 2u%- 0h,d (h, $% ma%y d# (% -a. /,h ., (# %,a h (h 0 %,0u.(6 Wh .,(h,%, 3a0 , (,-0 /, d# (% -a. %#005$#.. -a( #- am#- (h, d 22,%,-(

    @u% 0d ( #-07 ,-u- a( #- #2 (h, d# (% -, .a ?,d u- 2#%m (y6 Wh ., 0#m,#u%(0 ad#$(,d G,.0,-'0 $%#$#0 ( #- (ha( ,22 a y #2 a #u$ b,0(#30 /a. d (y- a- u-adu.(,%a(,d 2#%m7 #(h,%0 m#d 2 ,d (h 0 3 (h #% 0ub0( (u(,d ( byd# (% -,0 #2 0(a(, -, ,00 (y7 m$. ,d ma-da(,7 a-d $ub. $#. y6 G,.0,-'0.a- ua , $,%m,a(,0 (h, @ud a. $%#-#u- ,m,-(01 (h, #u%(0 -0 0( (ha( (h, %d, 0 #-0 a%, %#u-d,d - ., a. $% - $.,0 a-d -#( - $#. ( a. a-d $,%0#-a., $,d ,- ,6 F#..#3 - G,.0,-7 (h,y 2a . (# d 0( - u 0h b,(3,,- ., ( ma y a-d/a. d (y #2 a ., a. #%d,%7 u0 - (h, (,%m0 -(,% ha- ,ab.y6 Th, ,/ d,- ,-/#?,d (# @u0( 2y 2 -d - 0 #2 ,22 a y #2 #u$0 d',(a( by d 22,%,-( #u%(0 0%,ma%?ab., 2#% (0 $au (y a-d d /,%0 (y7 3 (h (h, ,/ d,- , #2 h# , b, -0,.250,%/ - a22 da/ (0 by $ub. #22 a.0 u-d,% (h, #-(%#. #2 u0u%$,%0 a-d

    @ud a. -#( , #2 2a (0 d,0 -a(,d a0 b, - -#(#% #u06

    Th, 0, #-d $a%( #2 (h, a%( ., ,/a.ua(,0 a.. (h, #$( #-0 a/a .ab., (# a#mm#- .a3 #u%( 3h,- #-2%#-(,d 3 (h a 0u ,002u. u0u%$a( #- #2 $#. ( a.

    $#3,% (h%#u h a #u$ d',(a(6 F %0(7 (h, a%( ., d,-( 2 ,0 0a. ,-( 2,a(u%,0 #2 (h, -#-5., a. #-(, ( 3 (h - 3h h #u%(0 a%, 2#% ,d (# 2a0h #- %,0$#-0,0 (#0u ,002u. #u$06 Th, a%( ., (h,- ,/a.ua(,0 (h, 2#u% $#00 b., @ud a.%,0$#-0,0: /a. da( #- a-d ., ( ma( #- #2 u0u%$a( #-7 0(% (#-0( (u( #-a. 0m7 %,0 -a( #- #2 #22 ,7 a-d d, .a%a( #- #2 (h, 00u, (# b, a-#-@u0( ab., $#. ( a.

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    3/59

    m,(a5., a. 7 !9 B7 P%,0 d,-( I0?a-da% M % a 00u,d a

    $%# .ama( #- - 3h h h, ab%# a(,d (h, C#-0( (u( #-7 d 00#./,d (h, Na( #-a.a-d P%#/ - a. A00,mb. ,07 d, .a%,d ma%( a. .a37 a-d a$$# -(,d (h,C#mma-d,%5 -5Ch ,2 #2 (h, a%my a0 (h, Ch ,2 Ma%( a. La3 Adm - 0(%a(#%6 FN! "Th, P%,0 d,-( (h,- 00u,d (h, La30 )C#-( -ua- , - F#% ,+ O%d,%7 3h,%,by a...a30 3,%, (# %,ma - - 2#% , a-d (h, #u-(%y 3a0 (# b, #/,%-,d a0 -,a%.y a0may b, - a #%da- , 3 (h (h, .a(, C#-0( (u( #- 0ub@, ( (# (h, u-2,((,%,d., 0.a( /, a$a (y #2 (h, ma%( a. .a3 %, m,6 FN!8" Wh ., (h, d, .a%,d#b@, ( /, #2 (h, #u$ 3a0 (# d,/ 0, a C#-0( (u( #- m#%, 0u (ab., (# (h,,- u0 #2 (h, Mu0. m $,#$., FN!4" a-d %,(u%- (# d,m# %a y bu( #2 a (y$,(ha( $,#$., a- u-d,%0(a-d a-d 3#%?7 FN! " (h, %,a. m#( /, 3a0 (# 2#%,0(a..- ( a( #- #2 %,$%,0,-(a( /, d,m# %a( #/,%-a- ,6 FN!;"

    6 Th, Jud a. R,0$#-0,: T% um$h #2 G,.0,-

    F#u% #-0#. da(,d % m -a. a$$,a.0 a22#%d,d (h, Su$%,m, C#u%( #2 Pa? 0(a-(h, #$$#%(u- (y (# , am -, (h, /a. d (y #2 (h, #u$ d',(a( - S(a(, /6 *D#00#6 FN!>" Th, Ch ,2 Ju0( ,7 au(h#% #2 (h, ma - #$ - #-7 #-0 d,%,d (-, ,00a%y (# a$$%a 0, (h, , 0( - #-0( (u( #-a. $#0 ( #- - (h, . h( #2(h, @u% 0( $% - $.,0 3h h d,(,%m -, (h, /a. d (y #% #(h,%3 0, #2.a35 %,a( - #% a-0 - m#d,%- S(a(,06 FN!B" Th, C#u%( (u%-,d (# a-0G,.0,-'0 (h,#%y #2 %,/#.u( #-a%y ., a. (y7 3h h ( (,%m,d #-, #2 (h, ba0d# (% -,0 #2 ., a. $#0 ( / 0m7 #- 3h h (h, 3h#., 0 ,- , #2 m#d,%-

    @u% 0$%ud,- , %,0(07 FN!9" a-d ad#$(,d (h, $%#$#0 ( #- (ha( (h, ,22 a y #2a #u$ d',(a( 0 (h, ba0 0 #2 (0 /a. d (y6 FN H" Th, C#u%( h,.d (ha( (h,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    4/59

    #u$ d',(a(7 ha/ - b,,- 0u ,002u. 7" 6 6 6 0a( 02 ,0 (h, (,0( #2 ,22 a y7a-d ha0 b, #m, a ba0 .a3 %,a( - 2a (6 FN !" Th,%,2#%,7 (h, La30)C#-( -ua- , - F#% ,+ O%d,%7 h#3,/,% (%a-* ; 0 (#%y #% m$,%2, ( ( may b,70 a -,3 ., a. #%d,% a-d ( 0 - a #%da- , 3 (h (ha( O%d,% (ha( (h, /a. d (y#2 (h, .a30 a-d (h, #%%, (-,00 #2 @ud a. d, 0 #-0 ha0 (# b, d,(,%m -,d6

    FN " I- (h, a2(,%ma(h #2 a 0u ,002u. #u$7 (h, -a( #-a. ., a. #%d,% mu0(2#% (0 /a. d (y d,$,-d u$#- (h, -,3 .a35 %,a( - #% a-7 FN 8" a-d ,"/,-C#u%(0 .#0, (h, % , 0( - @u% 0d ( #-07 a-d a- 2u- ( #- #-.y (# (h, , (,-(a-d - (h, ma--,% d,(,%m -,d by (h, -,3 #-0( (u( #-6 FN 4" Th,%,2#%,7

    u"-d,% (h, -,3 ., a. O%d,% a-y .a3 may a( a-y ( m, b, ha- ,d 6 6 6 a-d6 6 (h,%, b, - -# %,0(% ( #- #- (h, #u$ ma?,%0'" .a35ma? - $#3,% 6 6 6(h, 2u-dam,-(a. % h(0" (,0( (# d,(,%m -, (h, /a. d (y #2 (h, .a30 a-d2,((,%0 #- (h, $#3,% #2 (h, ., 0.a(u%, (# ma?, .a30 ha/, b#(h d 0a$$,a%,d6FN "

    I( 0 m$#%(a-( (# -#(, (ha( (h, C#u%(7 d, d - (h, a0, #-.y (3,-(y day0

    a2(,% (h, #u$7 d d -#( %,2,% (# a-y ,/ d,- , 3h h 2#%m,d (h, ba0 0 #2 (0d,(,%m -a( #- (ha( (h, #u$ 3a0 ,22 a #u06

    Th, D#00# @ud m,-(7 (,%m,d a a%(, b.a- h, 2#% (%,a0#-ab., #-du (FN ;" by #-, #mm,-(a(#%7 0 a .a-dma%? - #mm#- .a3 @u% 0$%ud,- , %, a%d -(h, /a. d (y7 ., ( ma y7 a-d ., 0.a( /, a$a (y #2 , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a.%, m,06 I( $%#/ d,d (h, 2 %0( , $%,00 (%a-02#%ma( #- #2 G,.0,-'0 (h,#% ,0 #2#-0( (u( #- a-d %,/#.u( #- -(# a @ud a..y $%#-#u- ,d #mm#- .a3 d# (% -,#2 %,/#.u( #-a%y ., a. (y6 ,2#%, D#00#7 (h, d# (% -, #2 0(a(, -, ,00 (y had2u%- 0h,d #mm#- .a3 #u%(0 3 (h (h, 2%am,3#%? (# /a. da(,, (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. a (0 #2 .a32u. %, m,06 FN >" u( (h, %, # - ( #- * > #2 u0u%$a( #- #2 , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. $#3,% by (h, d# (% -, #2 0(a(, -, ,00 (yam, 3 (h -a%%#3.y % um0 % b,d . m (0 %, a%d - 3h# #u.d , ,% 0, 0u h

    $#3,%07 (# 3ha( ,-d07 a-d 2#% h#3 .#- 6 I- (h, #/,%-#%5 ,-,%a.'0 Ca0,7 (h,Pa? 0(a- #u%( had (0,.2 . m (,d (h, d# (% -, (# a (0 (a?,- by (h, , 0( -.a32u. 0#/,%, -7 FN B" #-2 -,d (h, 0 #$, #2 , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. $#3,% (#a (0 mm,d a(,.y -, ,00a%y 2#% (h, $%,0,%/a( #- #2 (h, 0(a(,7 FN 9" a-d. m (,d (0 du%a( #- (# (h, $,% #d -, ,00a%y (# %, %,a(, a$$%#$% a(,#-0( (u( #-a. ., 0.a( /, #% a-06 FN8H"

    A0 d 0 u00,d b,.#37 #mm#- .a3 #u%(0 %,. ,d u$#- D#00# 3h,-,/,% (h,y 2,.((h, -,,d (# b,0(#3 @ud a..y $%#-#u- ,d ., ( ma y u$#- #u$0 d',(a(6 Th,d# (% -, #2 %,/#.u( #-a%y ., a. (y 0 a((%a ( /, (# b#(h #u$ -0( a(#%0 a-d0ym$a(h,( #u%(0 b, au0, ( u-2,((,%0 (h, ., 0.a( /, a$a (y #2, (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. %, m,0 a-d .#a?0 0u h %, m,0 3 (h ., ( ma y 0 m$.y #-(h, ba0 0 #2 (h, 0u ,00 #2 (h, u-d,%.y - (%,a0#-6

    6 Th, Ma(#/u Ca0,: U a-da !9;;

    !6 Th, C#-(, (

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    5/59

    U a-da'0 2 %0( #-0( (u( #-a. % 0 0 %,3 #u( #2 (h, ,(h- d /,%0 (y a-d#-2. ( (ha( 3a0 #m$#u-d,d by (h, #.#- a. ., a y #2 ,-(%a. a( #- a-du-d,%d,/,.#$m,-(6 FN8!" A2(,% (h, 2 %0( $#0(5 -d,$,-d,- , ,., ( #-0 - A$% .* B !9; 7 (3# $a%( ,07 (h, U a-da- P,#$.,'0 C#- %,00 .,d by M .(#- Ob#(, a-d

    (h, Gaba?a ,??a .,d by Daub O h,- 7 2#%m,d a #a. ( #- #/,%-m,-(7 bu( (h,#a. ( #- %,ma -,d u-0(ab.,6 FN8 " Th, Gaba?a ,??a m,mb,%0 #2 (h, ab -,(7(h%#u h a m#( #- - (h, Na( #-a. A00,mb.y7 a..,d 2#% -/,0( a( #- #2#%%u$( #- ha% ,0 a a -0( P% m, M - 0(,% Ob#(,7 (h, m - 0(,%0 #2 $.a-- - a-dd,2,-0,7 a-d C#.#-,. Id Am -7 (h, 0, #-d5 -5 #mma-d #2 (h, a%m,d 2#% ,06FN88" I- %,0$#-0,7 #- F,b%ua%y ;7 !9;;7 (h, P% m, M - 0(,%7 3 (h (h, 0u$$#%(#2 (h, m . (a%y7 a00um,d 2u.. $#3,%0 #2 #/,%-m,-(7 0u0$,-d,d (h, Na( #-a.A00,mb.y7 a-d ab%# a(,d (h, !9; C#-0( (u( #-6 FN84" O- A$% . ! 7 !9;;7 (h,

    Na( #-a. A00,mb.y 3a0 %, #-/,-,d ha0( .y (# a$$%#/, a -,3 #-0( (u( #- (ha( $%#/ d,d 2#% a- , , u( /, $%,0 d,- y a-d a u- (a%y 0(a(,6 O$$#0 ( #- (# (h,0,d,/,.#$m,-(0 $%#m$(,d Ob#(, (# d, .a%, ma%( a. .a3 #- May H7 !9;;6 FN8 "

    6 Th, Jud a. R,0$#-0,: G,.0,- a-d D#00# F#u-d I%%,0 0( b., a-dU-a00a .ab.,

    O- Au u0( !!7 !9;;7 M ha,. Ma(#/u7 a u a-da #u-(y h ,27 3a0 0,%/,d 3 (ha d,(,-( #- #%d,% u-d,% $%#/ 0 #-0 #2 A%( ., 8!)I+ #2 (h, !9;; C#-0( (u( #-6Ma(#/# 2 .,d a hab,a0 #%$u0 a$$. a( #-7 a% u - (ha( (h, d,(,-( #- #%d,%/ #.a(,d (h, 2u-dam,-(a. % h(0 $%#/ 0 #-0 #2 0, ( #- B #2 (h, !9;C#-0( (u( #-7 3h h %,ma -,d (h, 0u$%,m, .a3 #2 (h, .a-d6 Th 0 2u%- 0h,d (h,

    h C#u%( #2 U a-da 3 (h (h, #$$#%(u- (y (# , am -, (h, /a. d (y #2 (h, -,3%, m, - U a-da /6 Ma(#/u6 FN8;"

    I- a u-a- m#u0 d, 0 #-7 (h, C#u%( 2 %0( %,@, (,d (h, %, m,'0 $.,a (ha( (h,-,3 #a(h #2 a.., a- , adm - 0(,%,d u-d,% (h, -,3 C#-0( (u( #- $%, .ud,d (h,C#u%( 2%#m -" Th, C#u%(a.0# %,@, (,d (h, $.,a (ha( (h, #u%( had -# @u% 0d ( #- (# ,-

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    6/59

    C#-0( (u( #- ha/ - b,,- ab#. 0h,d a0 a %,0u.( #2 a / (#% #u0 %,/#.u( #- -.a3 d#,0 -# .#- ,% , 0( -#% d#,0 ( -#3 2#%m $a%( #2 (h, La30 #2 U a-da7 (ha/ - b,,- d,$% /,d #2 (0 d, 2a (# a-d d, @u%, /a. d (y6 Th, !9;;C#-0( (u( #-7 3, h#.d7 0 a -,3 ., a. #%d,% a-d ha0 b,,- ,22, ( /, 0 - , A$% .!47 !9;;7 3h,- ( 2 %0( am, -(# 2#% ,6 FN4 "

    Wh ., (h, D#00# #u%( d d -#( 2,,. #b. ,d (# %,2,% (# a-y ,/ d,- , (#0u$$#%( (0 h#.d - #2 ,22 a y #2 (h, #u$7 (h, Ma(#/u C#u%( %,2,%%,d (# a.a% , -umb,% #2 a22 da/ (0 03#%- (# by a .a% , -umb,% #2 #22 a.07 (h,

    $u%$#0, #2 3h h 0 (# $%#/, (# (h, 0a( 02a ( #- #2 (h, #u%( (ha( (h, -,3C#-0( (u( #- 0 ,22 a #u0 a-d (ha( ( ha0 b,,- a ,$(,d by (h, $,#$., 0 - ,( am, -(# 2#% ,6 FN48" Th, C#u%( a.0# %,. ,d u$#- (0 , (%a$#.a( #- #2-(,%-a( #-a. .a3 $% - $.,0 (# , am -, (h, /a. d (y #2 a-, (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. %, m,6 Th, C#u%( h,.d (ha( a".(h#u h (h, $%#du ( #2 a%,/#.u( #-7 (h, !9;;" C#-0( (u( #- 0 -#-,5(h,5.,00 /a. d - .a3 b, au0, --(,%-a( #-a. .a3 %,/#.u( #-0 a-d #u$0 d',(a( a%, (h, %, # - ,d m,(h#d0 #2

    ha- - #/,%-m,-(0 a-d #-0( (u( #-0 - 0#/,%, - 0(a(,06 FN44" D#00# had0a d (h 0 mu h7 bu( Ma(#/u ,m$ha0 ,d (ha( b, au0, U a-da 3a0 a3,..5,0(ab. 0h,d -d,$,-d,-( 0(a(,7 (h,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    7/59

    Rh#d,0 a6 FN49" A( (h, ( m,7 Rh#d,0 a 3a0 #/,%-,d u-d,% (h, !9;!C#-0( (u( #- 3h,%,by ( %,ma -,d a % ( 0h #.#-y bu( ,-@#y,d , (,-0 /,0,.25%u., u-d,% a 3h (, m -#% (y %, m,6 I-d,$,-d,- , %,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    8/59

    a-d (h, #/,%-m,-( #2 (h 0 #u-(%y 0,( u$ u-d,% ( 0 -#( (h, .a32u.#/,%-m,-(6 FN;;" #3,/,%7 (h, C#u%( u$h,.d (h, a ( #-0 #2 (h,, (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. %, m, #- (h, ba0 0 #2 (h, d# (% -, #2 0(a(, -, ,00 (y by#-, @ud , FN;>" a-d #- (h, ba0 0 #2 (h, d# (% -, #2 $ub. $#. y by (h,#(h,%6 FN;B"

    O- a$$,a.7 2 /, @ud ,0 #2 (h, A$$,..a(, D / 0 #- d,. /,%,d (h, % @ud m,-(0#- Ja-ua%y 97 !9;B6 FN;9" T3# #2 (h, @ud ,0 h,.d (ha( (h, %, m, 3a0 a d,2a (# #/,%-m,-( 3h h #u.d .a32u..y d# a-y(h - 3h h (0 $%,d, ,00#% #u.d.a32u..y ha/, d#-, u-d,% (h, !9;! C#-0( (u( #-6 FN>H" T3# #2 (h,m h,.d (ha((h, %, m, had a !" Th, 2 2(h @ud , h,.d(ha( (h, %, m, had -, (h,% d, 2a (# -#% d, @u%, 0(a(u0 b, au0, ( had -#(u0u%$,d (h, 2u- ( #-0 #2 (h, @ud a%y7 a-d (h, h C#u%( %,ma -,d a #u%(#-0( (u(,d u-d,% a-d d,% / - (0 au(h#% (y 2%#m (h, !9;! C#-0( (u( #-6 O-%#u-d0 #2 -, ,00 (y7 h#3,/,%7 h, h,.d (ha( a- *;8 a ( #2 (h, %, m, may b,

    u$h,.d a0 .#- a0 ( d d -#( d,2,a( (h, % h(0 ua%a-(,,d by (h, !9;!C#-0( (u( #-6 FN> "

    Ch ,2 Ju0( , ,ad.,7 3h# d, .a%,d h m0,.2 (# b, a $#0 ( / 0(7 FN>8"%,/ ,3,d (h, 0(a(u0 #2 (h, $%,0,-( #/,%-m,-(7 FN>4" u d,d by G,.0,-7D#00#7 a-d Ma(#/u7 3h h 0h#3 .,a%.y ,-#u h (ha( 0u ,00 a.#-, 0 (h,d,(,%m - - 2a (#%6 FN> " M -d2u. #2 (h, ,22#%(0 #2 % (a - (# u-d,%m -, (h,UDI7 h, #- .ud,d (ha( 3h ., (h, UDI %, m, 3a0 a 2u..y d, 2a (# #/,%-m,-(- (h, 0,-0, (ha( ( 0 - 2a ( - ,22, ( /, #-(%#. #2 (h, S(a(,'0"(,%% (#%y a-d (h 0 #-(%#. 0,,m0 . ?,.y (# #-( -u,7 FN>;" ( 3a0 .,a% (ha(a"( (h 0 0(a , 6 6 6 ( a--#( b, 0a d (ha( ( 0 y,( 0# 2 %m.y ,0(ab. 0h,d

    a0 (# @u0( 2y a 2 -d - (ha( (0 0(a(u0 0 (ha( #2 a d, @u%, #/,%-m,-(6FN>>" , d, . -,d (# a$$.y (h, d# (% -, #2 0(a(, -, ,00 (y #- (h, %#u-d0(ha( ( 0 0# m$%, 0, - (0 a$$. a( #-7 FN>B" a-d h, %,2u0,d (# a$$.y(h, 2u-dam,-(a. $% - $., (ha( -#b#dy may (a?, ad/a-(a , #2 a -, ,00 (y #2h 0 #3- ma? - 6 FN>9" Th, d 0( - ( #- b,(3,,- d, @u%, a-d d, 2a (# %, m,0.,d (h, Ch ,2 Ju0( , (#7 - E,?,.aa%'0 $h%a0,7 0$. ( " (h, %u-d-#%m:FNBH"

    Th, $%,0,-( #/,%-m,-( ha0 ,22, ( /,.y u0u%$,d a.. (h, #/,%-m,-(a. $#3,%0u-d,% (h, #.d %u-d-#%m7 bu( ha0 -#( y,( 0u ,,d,d - 0,(( - u$ a -,3%u-d-#%m - (0 $.a , 6 6 6 u-( . (h, $%,0,-( #/,%-m,-( ha0 a h ,/,d (h,0(a(u0 #2 a d, @u%, #/,%-m,-(7 a-d (h, %,/#.u( #-a%y %u-d-#%m b, #m,0 (h,-,3 %u-d-#%m7 ( mu0( #/,%- - (,%m0 #2 (h, #.d %u-d-#%m 6 6 6 6 T"h,%,2#%, 6 6 6 (h, $%,0,-( #/,%-m,-( 6 6 6 a- -#3 .a32u..y d# a-y(h - 3h h(0 $%,d, ,00#% #u.d .a32u..y ha/, d#-,7 bu( u-( . (0 -,3 #-0( (u( #- 02 %m.y ,0(ab. 0h,d7 a-d ha0 (hu0 b, #m, (h, d, @u%, #-0( (u( #- #2 (h,(,%% (#%y7 (0 adm - 0(%a( /, a-d ., 0.a( /, a (0 mu0( #-2#%m (# (h, !9;!C#-0( (u( #-6 FNB!"

    Ju0( , Ku,-,( 3a0 m#%, 2#%(h% h( - h 0 a ,$(a- , #2 G,.0,-'0 (h,#%y *;4

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    9/59

    a0 a$$. ,d - (h, Pa? 0(a- a-d U a-da- a0,07 FNB " a-d #- .ud,d (ha( (h, $%,0,-( #/,%-m,-( 0 (h, #u-(%y'0 d, 2a (# #/,%-m,-(1 ( ha07 a.0#7a

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    10/59

    O- F,b%ua%y 47 !9;;7 (h, a%m,d 2#% ,0 #2 ha-a 0(a ,d a #u$ d',(a( a-d(#$$.,d (h, #/,%-m,-( #2 P%,0 d,-( N?%umah6 FN9B" T3# day0 .a(,%7 (h,m . (a%y7 by $%# .ama( #-7 0u0$,-d,d (h, !9;H C#-0( (u( #-7 d 0m 00,d (h,P%,0 d,-(7 d 00#./,d (h, -a( #-a. a00,mb.y7 a-d ,0(ab. 0h,d (h, Na( #-a.L b,%a( #- C#u- . a0 (h, -,3 0#/,%, - au(h#% (y 3 (h $#3,% (# ., 0.a(, *;;

    by d, %,,6 FN99" Th, $%# .ama( #- #-(a -,d a #-( -ua( #- - 2#% , $%#/ 0 #-6 FN!HH" I- !9;97 (h, m . (a%y %u., 3a0 (,%m -a(,d a-d / . a- %u.,3a0 ,0(ab. 0h,d u-d,% a -,3 C#-0( (u( #-6 Th, (%a-0 ( #-a. $%#/ 0 #-0 #2 (h,-,3 C#-0( (u( #- $%#/ d,d 2#%7 am#- #(h,% (h - 07 (h, (,%m -a( #- #2 a-y#22 , ,0(ab. 0h,d by (h, Na( #-a. L b,%a( #- C#u- .6 FN!H!"

    E6G6 Sa..ah 3a0 a$$# -(,d - O (#b,% !9;> (# a ma-a ,% a. $#0( a( (h, ha-a Na( #-a. T%ad - C#%$#%a( #- ) NTC+7 a #%$#%a( #- ,0(ab. 0h,d u-d,% (h,S(a(u(#%y C#%$#%a( #-0 A ( #2 !9;!7 a-d %,5,0(ab. 0h,d u-d,% (h, -,3 S(a(u(#%yC#%$#%a( #-0 A ( #2 !9;46 O- F,b%ua%y !7 !9>H7 (h, -,3 / . a- #/,%-m,-(d 0m 00,d Sa..ah7 u-d,% (h, (%a-0 ( #-a. $%#/ 0 #-0 #2 (h, !9;9 C#-0( (u( #-6

    , ha..,- ,d (h, /a. d (y #2 h 0 d 0m 00a. b,2#%, (h, ha-a C#u%( #2 A$$,a.0- Sa..ah /6 A((#%-,y5 ,-,%a.6 FN!H "

    6 Th, Jud a. R,0$#-0,: R,m#(, a-d D# (% -a %, G,.0,- R,@, (,d

    I( 0 0 - 2 a-( (# -#(, (ha( (h 0 3a0 (h, 2 %0( -0(a- , #2 @ud a.d,(,%m -a( #- #2 (h, /a. d (y #2 a #u$ d',(a( u-d,%(a?,- a2(,% (h,, (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. %, m, had , $ %,d6 Th, A((#%-,y5 ,-,%a.7 %,.y - #-G,.0,-7 a% u,d (ha( (h, !9;; #u$ d',(a(7 du, (# (0 0u ,007 had d,0(%#y,d-#( #-.y (h, , 0( - C#-0( (u( #- bu( a.0# (h, ,-( %, ., a. #%d,% a-d,0(ab. 0h,d a -,3 ., a. #%d,%6 FN!H8" , a% u,d (ha(7 3 (h (h, 0u0$,-0 #- #2(h, !9;H C#-0( (u( #-7 (h, A ( (ha( ,0(ab. 0h,d (h, NTC a.0# .#0( (0/a. d (y a-d .a$0,d6 FN!H4" I( %, a -,d (0 /a. d (y #-.y by / %(u, #2 (h,P%# .ama( #- #2 F,b%ua%y ;7 !9;;6 FN!H " S m .a%.y7 a.. $ub. #22 ,0 -ha-a 0(##d ab#. 0h,d by / %(u, #2 (h, 0u ,002u. #u$ d',(a(7 a-d 3,%,,0(ab. 0h,d a-,3 by (h, P%# .ama( #- #2 F,b%ua%y ;7 !9;;6 FN!H;"C#-0,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    11/59

    C#-0( (u( #- 3h h a--u..,d #% %,/#?,d (h, !9;H C#-0( (u( #-6 FN!!H" A% h,%7J6A67 %,0(,d h 0 %,@, ( #- #2 G,.0,- - (h, d 22 u.(y #2 .# a( - (h, -,3%u-d-#%m:

    Su$$#0, 3, a$$.y (h 0 G,.0,-'0" @u% 0( %,a0#- - (# (h, $%,0,-( a0,7( 2#..#30 (ha( 3h,- (h, $%# .ama( #- 0u0$,-d,d (h, C#-0( (u( #- #2 !9;H7 (h,

    #.d a0 N#%m d 0a$$,a%,d6 Wha( 3a0 (h, -,3 a0 N#%m= Wa0 ( (h, $%# .ama( #-= I( 3a0 -#( b, au0, ( 3a0 -#( a #-0( (u( #-6 #3 (h,- d# 3,(%a , (h, a0 N#%m= I0 (h, a0 N#%m (h, $,#$., #2 ha-a 3h# 0u$$#%(,d (h,a%m,d 2#% ,0 a-d (h, $#. , #% 0 (h, a0 N#%m (# b, d,(, (,d 2%#m (h,a%m#u%,d a%0 a( u%ma Cam$= FN!!!"

    F#% (h, ma@#% (y7 (h,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    12/59

    3h# #$$#0,d (h, ma@#% (y (% ba. %#u$ #2 (h, %, m,6 FN!!>" Th,0, 2a (#%0%a 0, H

    !6 Th, C#-(, (

    O- Ja-ua%y ! 7 !9;;7 0#m, a%my #22 ,%0 a((,m$(,d a #u$ d',(a( - N ,% a3h h %,0u.(,d - (h, d,a(h #2 (h, P% m, M - 0(,% a-d 0#m, #(h,% m,mb,%0 #2(h, ab -,(6 FN!!B" Th, %,ma - - 2,d,%a. ab -,( a-d (h, a ( - P%,0 d,-((u%-,d #/,% (h, adm - 0(%a( #- #2 (h, #u-(%y (# (h, ,-,%a. O22 ,%C#mma-d - #2 (h, A%my7 ,-,%a. A u y 5I%#-0 6 Th, m . (a%y %, m, 0u0$,-d,d(h, $%#/ 0 #-0 #2 (h, C#-0( (u( #- d,a. - 3 (h (h, , , u( /, a-d ., 0.a(u%,a-d d, .a%,d (ha(7 3h ., (h, C#-0( (u( #- 0ha.. ha/, (h, 2#% , #2 .a3(h%#u h#u( N ,% a7 FN!!9" (h, m . (a%y #/,%-m,-( 0ha.. ha/, $#3,% (# ma?,

    .a30 6 6 6 3 (h %,0$, ( (# a-y ma((,% 3ha(0#,/,%7 FN! H" a-d (ha( (h 0C#-0( (u( #- 0ha.. -#( $%,/a . #/,% a d, %,,7 a-d -#(h - - (h 0 C#-0( (u( #-0ha.. %,-d,% a-y $%#/ 0 #- #2 a d, %,, /# d (# a-y , (,-( 3ha(0#,/,%6 FN! !"Th, @u% 0d ( #- #2 (h, #u%(0 3a0 #u0(,d 2%#m %,/ ,3 - a-y a ( #% #%d,% #2(h, m . (a%y %, m,6 FN! " O- Ju.y 97 !9;;7 (h,%, 3a0 a-#(h,% #u$ d',(a(- N ,% a a-d (h, -,3 m . (a%y %, m, #-( -u,d (# #/,%- by d, %,,6 FN! 8"

    6 Th, Jud a. R,0$#-0,: U0u%$,%0 D,2 ,d

    ,2#%, !9>H7 (h, N ,% a- Su$%,m, C#u%( had 2a ,d (h, " 3h h -,/,%(h,.,00 ?,,$0 (h, C#-0( (u( #- #2 (h, F,d,%a( #-a. /, 0ub@, ( #2 #u%0, (# (h, 0u0$,-0 #- a-d m#d 2 a( #-0 mad, by (h,D, %,,6 FN! B" Th, C#u%( (##? (h, $#0 ( #- (ha( ( 3a0 -#( -

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    13/59

    #/,%-m,-('0 $#0 ( #- (ha( 3ha( (##? $.a , - Ja-ua%y !9;; 3a0 a %,/#.u( #-a-d (h, F,d,%a. M . (a%y #/,%-m,-( 0 a %,/#.u( #-a%y #/,%-m,-( 6 6 6 6 I(a #%d - .y ha0 a- u-2,((,%,d % h( 6 6 6 (# %u., by 2#% , a-d by m,a-0 #2D, %,,0 6 6 6 6 FN!8 " Th, #/,%-m,-( a% u,d (ha( ( 3a0 %,.y - u$#-G,.0,-'0 (h,#%y #2 %,/#.u( #-a%y ., a. (y a0 ,0$#u0,d by D#00# a-d Ma(#/u6

    FN!88" Th, C#u%( d d -#(

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    14/59

    *> 86 Th, A2(,%ma(h: R,bu?, a-d Ca$ (u.a( #-

    Th, m . (a%y %, m, %,a (,d 0ha%$.y a-d " y 0ay - (ha( (h, -,3 D, %,,3a0 #-.y d, .a%a(#%y - -a(u%,7 (h, C#u%( - ,22, ( 0a d (ha( La?a-m 7 #%#7a-d U- /,%0 (y #2 Ibada- 3,%, a.. 3%#- .y d, d,d6

    Th, a2(,%ma(h #2 La?a-m 0 /,%y -0(%u ( /, 2#% a-y 0(udy (ha( a m0 a(d,-( 2y - 0u (ab., @ud a. %,0$#-0,0 (# 0u ,002u. #u$0 d',(a(6 I( .,a%.yd,m#-0(%a(,d (h, $%a ( a. . m (a( #-0 a #u%( #-2%#-(0 3h,- 2a ,d 3 (h *>8(h, 2a ( a #m$. #2 u0u%$a( #-6 Th, u0u%$,%'0 m#-#$#.y #2 #,% /, $#3,%a..#30 (h,m (# -#%, a-y ad/,%0, $%#-#u- ,m,-( by (h, @ud a%y #% ,/,- (#

    b%#3b,a( ( -(# 0ubm 00 #-6

    F6 Th, J .a- Ca0,: Pa? 0(a- !9>

    !6 Th, C#-(, (

    Th, , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. %, m, - Pa? 0(a- /a. da(,d by D#00# %,ma -,d - $#3,% 2#% ,.,/,- y,a%06 FN!4B" F#..#3 - $%#.#- ,d / . d 0#b,d ,- ,7 (h,P%,0 d,-( %,0 -,d a-d ha-d,d #/,% (h, adm - 0(%a( #- #2 (h, #u-(%y (# (h,m . (a%y #- Ma% h 7 !9;96 FN!49" Tha( 0am, ,/,- - 7 (h, m . (a%y $%# .a m,dma%( a. .a3 a-d ab%# a(,d (h, !9; C#-0( (u( #-6 FN! H" Th, m . (a%y'0%,2u0a. (# %, # - , (h, %,0u.(0 #2 ,-,%a. ,., ( #-0 h,.d - D, ,mb,% !9>H.,d (# a / . 3a% a-d d 0m,mb,%m,-( #2 (h, #u-(%y - D, ,mb,% !9>!6 FN! !"

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    15/59

    O- D, ,mb,% H7 !9>!7 (h, m . (a%y ha-d,d #/,% (h, #/,%-m,-( (# (h, $a%(y3h h had 3#- (h, ,., ( #- - (h, %,ma - - $a%( #2 (h, #u-(%y6 FN! " Du,(# (h, #-0( (u( #-a. /# d7 (h, / . a- #/,%-m,-( (##? #/,% a0 a ma%( a. .a3%, m,6 FN! 8"

    6 Th, Jud a. R,0$#-0,: G,.0,- R,-#u- ,d a-d Sub0( (u(,d by (h, D# (% -, #2Im$. ,d Ma-da(,

    T3# $,-d - % m -a. a$$,a.07 #-0#. da(,d a0 J .a- /6 #/,%-m,-( #2Pu-@ab7 FN! 4" 2u%- 0h,d (h, #$$#%(u- (y (# (,0( (h, /a. d (y #2 (h, !9;9#u$ d',(a(6 Th, Su$%,m, C#u%( h,.d (h, a00um$( #- #2 $#3,% by (h, m . (a%y a-.., a. u0u%$a( #-6 FN! " Th, C#u%(7 a2(,% a- , (,-0 /, a-a.y0 0 #2 G,.0,-a-d D#00#7 %,-#u- ,d (h, d# (% -, #2 %,/#.u( #-a%y ., a. (y a-d , $%,00.y *>4#/,%%u.,d D#00#6 FN! ;" Th, C#u%( ad/a- ,d 0,/,%a. %,a0#-0 3hy ( #-0 d,%,dD#00#'0 ad#$( #- #2 G,.0,- m$%#$,%6 F %0(7 (h, D#00# %u. - #2 ,22 a y #2(h, #u$ 3a0 $%,ma(u%, 3h,- (h, %, m, 2#u-d (# b, ,22, ( /, #-, day 3a0

    #/,%(h%#3- (h, -, (6 FN! >" S, #-d7 G,.0,-'0 0 a d,0 % $( /, (h,#%y #2 .a37-#( a -#%ma( /, $% - $., #2 ad@ud a( #-6 FN! B" Th %d7 /a. d (y #2 a-, (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. %, m, 2.#30 -#( 2%#m 0u ,002u. a00um$( #- #2 $#3,% bu(2%#m hab (ua. #b,d ,- , by (h, ( ,-06 FN! 9" F#u%(h7 0 - , (h, (h,#%y #2%,/#.u( #-a%y ., a. (y $%,0u$$#0,0 (h, $% ma y #2 -(,%-a( #-a. .a3 #/,%mu- $a. .a37 (ha( (h,#%y 0 #2 . ((., u0, (# d#m,0( #u%(06 FN!;H"F -a..y7 (h, C#u%( -#(,d (ha( (h, ma - au(h#% #2 D#00# 3a0 -/#./,d 3 (hd%a2( - (h, /,%y ma%( a. .a3 #%d,% 3h h 3a0 a( 00u, - (h, a0,6 FN!;!"

    Th, C#u%( a ?-#3.,d ,d (h, %#., @ud a. $%#-#u- ,m,-(0 $.ay - b,0(#3 -., ( ma y (# , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. #%d,%0: #3,/,%7 0 " ,22, ( /, (h,#/,%-m,-( #2 a u0u%$,% may b,7 ( d#,0 -#( 3 (h - (h, Na( #-a. L, a. O%d,%a H7 #- 3h h (h, /a. d (y #2 (h, 0u ,,d - ,., (,d #/,%-m,-(%,0(,d7 3,%, h,.d u-d,% a 2%am,3#%? $%#-#u- ,d by (h, m . (a%y %, m,7 (h,C#u%( 2,.( #m$,..,d (# /, ., a. ,22, ( (# ,%(a - a (0 #2 (h, .., a.u0u%$,% %, m,6 FN!;4" Th, C#u%( ,m$.#y,d (h, d# (% -, #2 m$. ,d ma-da(,72 %0( ,-u- a(,d by u # %#( u07 a #%d - (# 3h h #u%(0 may /a. da(,,%(a - -, ,00a%y a (0 #2 a u0u%$,% d#-, - (h, -(,%,0( #2 $%,0,%/ - (h,0(a(, b, au0, (h, .a32u. 0#/,%, - 3#u.d ha/, a.0# 3a-(,d (h,0, a (0 (# b,u-d,%(a?,-6 FN!; " Fu%(h,%m#%,7 %,.y - u$#- L#%d P,a% ,'0 d 00,-( - (h,P% /y C#u- . d, 0 #- - Mad mbamu(# /6 La%d-,%5 u%?,7 FN!;;" (h, C#u%(

    $%#-#u- ,d a a(a.# #2 2#u% -d,$,-d,-( %#u-d0 #2 #-d#-a( #- #2 a (0 #2a- .., a. u0u%$,% %, m,:

    )!+ a.. (%a-0a ( #-0 3h h a%, $a0( a-d .#0,d7 2#%7 0 " -# u0,2u. $u%$#0, a- b, 0,%/,d by %,#$,- - (h,m7 ) + a.. a (0 a-d ., 0.a( /, m,a0u%,03h h a%, - a #%da- , 3 (h7 #% #u.d ha/, b,,- mad, u-d,%7 (h, ab%# a(,d

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    16/59

    C#-0( (u( #- #% (h, $%,/ #u0 ., a. #%d,%7 )8+ a.. a (0 3h h (,-d (# ad/a- ,#% $%#m#(, (h, ##d #2 (h, $,#$.,7 )4+ a.. a (0 %,"

    Th, # ,-(.y a% u,d % ( H" Th, ,., (,d P%,0 d,-( 3a0 2#% ,d (# 2.,,7a-d (h, #u$ ma?,%0 -0(a..,d #-, N #.a#0 Sam$0#- a0 P%,0 d,-( #2 (h,R,$ub. 6 FN!>!" Th, #u$ $%#m$(,d (h, -/a0 #- #2 Cy$%u0 by Tu%?,y #- Ju.yH7 !9>46 FN!> " Th,%, 3a0 a ,a0,52 %, a %,,m,-( #- Ju.y 87 !9>46 FN!>8"Tha( 0am, day7 (h, u0u%$,% P%,0 d,-( %,0 -,d a-d (h, P%,0 d,-( #2 (h, #u0,#2 R,$%,0,-(a( /,0 a00um,d (h, du( ,0 #2 (h, P%,0 d,-(6 Du% - (h, , h( day0(ha( (h, u0u%$,%0 h,.d #22 ,7 a -umb,% #2 $ub. #22 a.0 3,%, %,m#/,d 2%#m(h, % @#b0 a-d #(h,%0 a$$# -(,d - (h, % $.a ,6 FN!>4" S#m, $#. , #-0(ab.,03h#0, 0,%/ , 3a0 (,%m -a(,d by a- #22 ,% a$$# -(,d by (h, u0u%$,%0ha..,- ,d (h, % d 0m 00a. - L a0 /6 A((#%-,y5 ,-,%a.6 FN!> "

    6 Th, Jud a. R,0$#-0,: Su ,00 P.u0 P#$u.a% A ,$(a- , a-d (h, D# (% -, #2D, Fa (# O% a-

    Th, a$$. a-(0' $.,a (ha( (h, % (,%m -a( #- 3a0 a- a ( -#-5, 0(,-( - .a3

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    17/59

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    18/59

    a$$# -(m,-( 6 6 6 a-d d#,0" -#( 0u22,% 2%#m 0u h a- .., a. (y 0# a0 (# b,%,-d,%,d a0 -#-5, 0(,-( - .a36 FN!B " Th, $.au0 b., a$$# -(m,-( 0 (# b,(,0(,d #- a- #b@, ( /, 0(a-da%d #2 3h,(h,% - (h, #$ - #- #2 a %,a0#-ab., a-d

    $%ud,-( ma-7 u-d,% (h, % um0(a- ,07 - 3h h - (h, $a%( u.a% a0, (h,a$$# -(,, 3a0 , ,% 0 - h 0 du( ,07 ( 3a0 $#00 b., a-d %,a0#-ab., (# b,

    (a?,- (ha( h, 3a0 ., a..y $#00,00 - (h, a$a (y #2 (h, #% a-6 FN!B;"

    Th, C#u%( h,.d (ha( (h, ,.,m,-( #2 $.au0 b . (y 3a0 .a ? - b, au0,a$$# -(m,-( #2 (h, P#. , Ch ,2 3h# d 0m 00,d (h, a$$. a-(0 #-0( (u(,d a.# a. , (,-0 #- #2 u0u%$a( #- #2 $#3,% a-d #/,%(h%#3 #2 (h, #-0( (u( #-a.#%d,%6 FN!B>" M#%,#/,%7 b, au0, (h, % um0(a- ,0 #2 (h, .., a. a$$# -(m,-(3,%, ?-#3- (# ,/,%y#-,7 (h, a0, 2a..0 3 (h - a- , ,$( #- (# (h, d, 2a (##% a- d# (% -,7 -am,.y (ha( (h, d# (% -, d#,0 -#( a$$.y 3h,%, (h,% um0(a- ,0 %,0$#-0 b., 2#% (h, ., a. d,2, (7 a%, ?-#3- (# ,/,%yb#dy6FN!BB"

    #(h (h, 2a ( (ha( (h, 0h#%(5. /,d u0u%$,% %, m, had a.%,ady 2a..,- a-d (h,2a ( (ha( (h, -,3 %, m, had a.0# @# -,d (h, $,( ( #-,%'0 $.,a (# d,0 -a(,(h, #u$ d',(a( .., a.7 mad, (h 0 a- ,a0y a0, (# d, d,6 Wh ., J .a- had#-.y m$. ,d 0#m, d,0 %ab., m#d 2 a( #-0 #2 G,.0,-'0 d# (% -,07 L a0-(%#du ,d (h, $#$u.a% a ,$(a- , (,0( 2#% ., a. a( #- #2 a #u$ d',(a(6u(7 a0 d 0 u00,d b,.#37 (h 0 #-.y , a ,%ba(,d (h, ,/ d,-( a%y $%#b.,m0 2#% a#u%( a((,m$( - (# d,(,%m -, (h, 0u ,00 #2 a #u$ d',(a( a-d 2u%(h,%#-2u0,d (h, 0,$a%a(, 00u,0 #2 ., ( ma y a-d /a. d (y #2 a ., a. #%d,%6

    *>9 6 Th, hu((# Ca0,: Pa? 0(a- !9>>

    !6 Th, C#-(, (

    F#..#3 - (h, %,$ud a( #- #2 %,/#.u( #-a%y ., a. (y by J .a- 7 Pa? 0(a-0(a%(,d (0 2 %0( , $,% m,-( 3 (h %,$%,0,-(a( /, d,m# %a y u-d,% aC#-0( (u( #- ad#$(,d - !9>86 FN!B9" #3,/,%7 (h, , $,% m,-( 3a0 0h#%( . /,d6F#..#3 - ha% ,0 #2 #% a- ,d % - #2 (h, ,-,%a. ,., ( #-0 #2 ,a%.y !9>>7ma00 $%#(,0(0 a-d / . d 0#b,d ,- , ,-0u,d6 O- Ju.y 7 !9>>7 (h, m . (a%yd, .a%,d ma%( a. .a37 %,m#/,d a-d d,(a -,d (h, P% m, M - 0(,% a-d d 00#./,d(h, Pa%. am,-(6 M -d2u. #2 (h, h#.d - #2 J .a- a-d A%( ., ; #2 (h, !9>8C#-0( (u( #-7 3h h d,0 -a(,d 0ub/,%0 #- #2 (h, C#-0( (u( #- a0 (%,a0#-7 (h,m . (a%y %, m, (##? (h, $#0 ( #- (ha( (h, C#-0( (u( #- ha0 -#( b,,-ab%# a(,d6 O-.y (h, #$,%a( #- #2 ,%(a - $a%(0 #2 (h, C#-0( (u( #- ha0 b,,-h,.d - ab,ya- ,6 FN!9H" D,(,-( #- #2 (h, P% m, M - 0(,% u-d,% Ma%( a. La3O%d,% N#6 ! #2 !9>>7 3a0 ha..,- ,d b,2#%, (h, Su$%,m, C#u%( - hu((# /6Ch ,2 #2 A%my S(a22 FN!9!" a0 a / #.a( #- #2 2u-dam,-(a. % h(0 ua%a-(,,d by(h, C#-0( (u( #-6

    6 Th, Jud a. R,0$#-0,: C#-0( (u( #-a. D,/ a( #- D (a(,d by N, ,00 (y

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    19/59

    Th, Su$%,m, C#u%( adm ((,d (h, $,( ( #- 2#% h,a% - - d,2 a- , #2 , $%,00#u0(,% #2 @u% 0d ( #- 2%#m ma%( a. .a3 #%d,%06 A0 a- , $%,00 #- #2 (0d 0a$$%#/a.7 (h, %, m, %,m#/,d (h, Ch ,2 Ju0( , 3 (h - (3# day0 #2 adm 00 #-#2 (h, $,( ( #-6 FN!9 " Th, $,( ( #-,% u% ,d (h, C#u%( (# 2#..#3 J .a- 7 a-d(# d,0 -a(, (h, #u$ a- .., a. u0u%$a( #-6 Th, %, m,7 b,0 d,0 $# -( - (#

    (h, #u0(,% #2 @u% 0d ( #- a-d (h, 0u0$,-0 #- #2 2u-dam,-(a. % h(0 by (h,La30 )C#-( -ua- , - F#% ,+ O%d,%7 !9>>7 FN!98" %,. ,d #- G,.0,- (# a% u,(ha( (h, $%# .ama( #- #2 ma%( a. .a3 had b%#u h( a -,3 ., a. #%d,% -(# b, - 7a-d (h 0 -,3 ., a. #%d,%7 ,/,- 2 ( 3,%, #-.y (,m$#%a%y7 had d 0$.a ,d (h,2#%m,% ., a. #%d,%6 FN!94" Wh ., (h, C#u%( *BH %,2u0,d (# %,0u%%, ( D#00# a-d%,@, (,d (h, a% um,-( (ha( ,22, ( /,-,00 #2 (h, $#. ( a. ha- , 0" (h,0#., #-d ( #- #% % (,% #- #2 (0 ., a. (y7 FN!9 " ( a.0# d, . -,d (#2#..#3 J .a- a-d h#.d (h, #u$ d',(a( a- .., a. u0u%$a( #-6 FN!9;" Wh .,%, # - - (0 #3- -ab . (y (# d,(,%m -, (h, 2a (ua. #%%, (-,00 #%#(h,%3 0, #2 (h, 0,/,%a. a.., a( #-0 a-d #u-(,% a.., a( #-0 mad, by (h,

    $a%( ,0 a a -0( ,a h #(h,%7 FN!9>" (h, C#u%(7 a2(,% #-0 d,% - (h, (#(a.

    m . ,u - 3h h (h, ha- , 3a0" b%#u h( ab#u(7 FN!9B" #- .ud,d (ha( (h,#u$ d',(a( 3a0 a- , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. 0(,$7 bu( #b/ #u0.y d (a(,d by (h,h h,0( #-0 d,%a( #-0 #2 S(a(, -, ,00 (y a-d 3,.2a%, #2 (h, $,#$.,7 FN!99"a-d h% 0(,-,d (h, -,3 ., a. #%d,% a $ha0, #2 #-0( (u( #-a. d,/ a( #-d (a(,d by -, ,00 (y6 FN HH" Wh ., -0 0( - (ha( (h, !9>8 C#-0( (u( #-0( .. %,ma -0 (h, 0u$%,m, .a3 #2 (h, .a-d7 0ub@, ( (# (h, #-d ( #- (ha(,%(a - $a%(0 (h,%,#2 ha/, b,,- h,.d - ab,ya- ,7 FN H!" a-d (ha( (h,0u$,% #% C#u%(0 #-( -u, (# ha/, (h, $#3,% #2 @ud a. %,/ ,37 FN H " (h,C#u%( h,.d (ha( (h, ., 0.a( /, a$a (y #2 (h, m . (a%y %, m, - .ud,d (h,$#3,% (# am,-d (h, !9>8 C#-0( (u( #-"6 FN H8" Th 07 #u$.,d 3 (h (h,/a. da( - a (0 3h h (,-d (# ad/a- , #% $%#m#(, (h, ##d #2 (h, $,#$.,7FN H4" am#u-(,d (# b,0(#3 - u-2,((,%,d ., 0.a( /, $#3,% #- (h,, (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. %, m,7 a-d -#%,d (h, (%ad ( #-a. . m (0 #2 (h,d# (% -, #2 -, ,00 (y 3h h (h, C#u%( .a m,d ( 3a0 a$$.y - 6

    Ka 0a% Gha-7 J67 h#3,/,%7 3a0 #2 (h, / ,3 (ha( du, (# (h, 0u ,00 #2 (h,#u$7 a d, 2a (# -,3 L, a. O%d,% had d 0$.a ,d (h, !9>8 C#-0( (u( #-#m$.,(,.y7 a-d (h, Jud ,0 #2 (h, Su$%,m, C#u%( by (a? - a -,3 #a(h #2 #22 ,

    $%,0 % b,d by (h, m . (a%y %, m, ha/, #- ,d,d (h, d, 2a (# , 0(,- , #2 (h,-,3 L, a. O%d,%6 FN H " Ku#( - G,.0,- a-d Mad mbamu(# *B! , (,-0 /,.y7 h,a% u,d7 Th, mu- $a. C#u%(0 ha/, a.3ay0 (# ,-2#% , (h, .a30 #2 (h, d, 2a (##/,%-m,-( a0 ( 0 0u h a #/,%-m,-( 3h h a- ,-a ( .a37 a- a$$# -( Jud ,0a-d a- ,-2#% , (h, , , u( #- #2 .a36 FN H;" , #- .ud,d (ha( b, au0, (h,C#u%( d,% /,0 (0 @u% 0d ( #- 2%#m (h, -,3 L, a. O%d,%7 ( a--#( a00,%(

    @u% 0d ( #- - d,2 a- , #2 $%#/ 0 #-0 #2 (h, -,3 #%d,%6 FN H>"

    Th, $ha0, #2 #-0( (u( #-a. d,/ a( #- 0a- ( #-,d by hu((# .a0(,d #/,%, h( y,a%01 ma%( a. .a3 3a0 . 2(,d #- D, ,mb,% 8H7 !9B 6 A0 2#% (h, 0u%/ /a.#2 @ud a. %,/ ,37 (h, Su$%,m, C#u%( - hu((# /6 S(a(,7 FN HB" h,.d (ha(#- , a %, m, had b,,- /a. da(,d by (h, d# (% -, #2 -, ,00 (y7 (0 -d / dua.

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    20/59

    a ( #-0 had (# b, #-0(%u,d a0 b, - -, ,00a%y 2 (h,y %,a0#-ab.y 2,.. 3 (h -(h, a(, #% ,0 ,-um,%a(,d - hu((#7 a-d (h, , , u( /, had b%#ad d 0 %,( #- -(h 0 %, a%d6 Th, m . (a%y %, m, mad, a .,a- b%,a? 3 (h ,/,- (h, m - ma.. m (a( #-0 u$#- (0 ., 0.a( /, a$a (y m$. ,d by hu((# by $%#mu. a( -(h, P%#/ 0 #-a. C#-0( (u( #-a. O%d,%7 !9B! PCO"7 3h,%,by (h, ,a%. ,% $%,(,-0,

    #2 ?,,$ - (h, !9>8 C#-0( (u( #- a. /, (h#u h - ab,ya- , 3a0 d 0$,-0,d 3 (h6FN H9" Th 0 3a0 $%#m$(,d by Ku,((a h C#u%('0 -/a. da( #- #2 (h,C#-0( (u( #- )Am,-dm,-(+ O%d,%7 !9BH )P6O6 N#6 ! #2 !9BH+7 3h h #u0(,d

    @u% 0d ( #- #2 0u$,% #% #u%(0 (# >7 0u0$,-d,d (h, C#-0( (u( #- a-d /,0(,d (h, $#3,% (#ma?, .a30 by d, %,, - F%a- , A.b,%( R,-,7 (h, , 5P% m, M - 0(,%7 3h# (h, #u$ma?,%0 -0(a..,d a0 P%,0 d,-(6 A-#(h,% P%# .ama( #- #- Ju-, B7 !9>>7 %,/#?,d(h, #-0( (u( #- a-d %,$.a ,d ( 3 (h #-, (ha( ,. m -a(,d (h, $a%. am,-( a-d(%a-02,%%,d u-2,((,%,d ., 0.a( /, $#3,%0 (# (h, P%,0 d,-(6 Th,, (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. %, m, 2#%mu.a(,d a-#(h,% C#-0( (u( #- - !9>96 Th 0%, m, $u%$#%(,d (# b, #m, (h, #-0( (u( #-a. #/,%-m,-( - !9B! by ,., ( #-0d,,m,d (# ha/, ,-d#%0,d (h, -,3 #-0( (u( #-6 F%,, mu.( 5$a%(y ,., ( #-0 3,%,-#( h,.d u-( . Ju.y !9986 FN !>"

    6 Th, Jud a. R,0$#-0,: G,.0,- R,hab . (a(,d

    a.abha@ /6 C#-(%#..,% #2 Ta ,0 FN !B" 2u%- 0h,d (h, S,y h,..,0 C#u%( #2

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    21/59

    A$$,a. (h, #$$#%(u- (y (# , am -, (h, /a. d (y #2 (h, u0u%$a( #-6 Th,a$$,..a-(7 3h# had b,,- 0,%/,d -#( ,0 #2 am,-d,d a00,00m,-(0 #2 - #m, (au-d,% (h, I- #m, Ta D, %,, #2 !9>B7 a% u,d (ha( (h, D, %,,7 a-d - ,22, ( a..., 0.a( #- ,-a (,d - S,y h,..,0 - !9>> a-d !9>B by (h, P%,0 d,-( a0 (h,0#., ., 0.a( /, au(h#% (y7 3a0 u- #-0( (u( #-a.6 Th, a((#%-,y5 ,-,%a.7

    %,$%,0,-( - (h, S(a(,7 %,. ,d #- (h, a$$. a( #- #2 G,.0,- - D#00# a-dMa(#/u (# $%#$#0,7 Wh,- a #/,%-m,-( - $#3,% ha0 ,22, ( /, #-(%#. 3 (h (h,0u$$#%( #2 a ma@#% (y #2 (h, $,#$., a-d 0 ab., (# #/,%- ,22 ,-(.y (ha(#/,%-m,-( 0h#u.d b, %, # - ,d a0 ., a.6 FN !9" Th, a((#%-,y ,-,%a. a.0#%,m -d,d (h, #u%( #2 d, Sm (h'0 adm#- ( #-7 L, a. (h,#% 0(0 ha/, -# #$( #-

    bu( (# a #mm#da(, (h, % #- ,$(0 (# (h, 2a (0 #2 $#. ( a. . 2,6 Su ,002u.%,/#.u( #- 0##-,% #% .a(,% b, ,(0 (0 #3- ., a. (y6 FN H" *B8 Th, C#u%('00u%/,y #2 @ud a. #-0 d,%a( #- - %, ,-( y,a%0 #2 ab%u$( ha- ,0 -#/,%-m,-(7 d,m#-0(%a(,d (ha( (h,%, 3a0 0#m, /a% ,(y #2 #$ - #-7 bu( (ha(2%,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    22/59

    FN 9" , -#(,d (ha( (h, C#u%( had (h, ad/a-(a , #2 -#( ha/ - (# d, d, (h 0a0, - m,d 0 %,bu07 bu( a2(,% a- -(,%/a. #2 0#m, 2#u% y,a%07 du% -3h h (h, -,3 %,/#.u( #-a%y %, m, ha0 ,-@#y,d u- ha..,- ,d au(h#% (y a-dma -(a -,d 0(ab., a-d ,22, ( /, #/,%-m,-( - (h, S,y h,..,07 3 (h . ((., #%-# -(,%%u$( #- - (h, #%d -a%y . 2, #2 (0 ( ,-06 u(7 ,/,- 2 I d d -#(

    ha/, (h, b,-,2 ( #2 (h 0 h -d0 h( I b,. ,/, I 3#u.d ha/, #m, (# (h,#- .u0 #- 2%#m (h, 0m##(h-,00 a-d ,22 a y #2 (h, %,/#.u( #-a%y (%a-0 ( #-(ha( (h, -,3 %, m, had by (h, B(h Ju-, !9>> %, , /,d 0u h 3 d,0$%,ad a-du-47 3 (h a C#-0( (u( #- (ha( $%#/ d,d 2#% a $a%. am,-(a%y 0y0(,m a-d 2u-dam,-(a. huma- % h(06 FN 8 " Th,C#-0( (u( #- a.0# ,0(ab. 0h,d a Su$%,m, C#u%( #2 %,-ada a-d (h, *B W,0(I-d ,0 A00# a(,d S(a(,0 a-d (h, % h( (# a$$,a. (# (h, P% /y C#u- .6 O-Ma% h !87 !9>97 (h, N,3 J,3,. M#/,m,-(7 a .,2( 0( $#. ( a. $a%(y7 0(a ,d a#u$ d',(a( a a -0( (h, -#(#% #u0.y #%%u$( P% m, M - 0(,% S % E% a %y7 a-da00um,d $#3,% a0 (h, P,#$.,'0 R,/#.u( #-a%y #/,%-m,-( )PR +6 FN 88" Th, PR0u0$,-d,d (h, C#-0( (u( #-7 a.(h#u h (h, Ku,,- %,ma -,d (h, ,ad #2 S(a(,7 a-d(h, #/,%-#%5 ,-,%a. %,ma -,d - #22 ,6 FN 84" Th, PR a.0# (##? a.., , u( /, a-d ., 0.a( /, $#3,% a-d ab#. 0h,d a$$,a.0 (# (h, P% /y C#u- .7a-d ,0(ab. 0h,d -,3 0u$,% #% #u%(06 FN 8 " E 0( - .a30 #-( -u,d - 2#% ,7, ,$( a0 am,-d,d #% %,$,a.,d by (h, PR 6 FN 8;"

    O- O (#b,% !97 !9B87 2#..#3 - d 00,-0 #- 3 (h - (h, PR 7 (h, P% m, M - 0(,% a-d #(h,% M - 0(,%0 3,%, ? ..,d7 a-d ,-,%a. Au0( -7 h,ad #2 (h, a%my7 a00um,d

    $#3,%7 d, .a% - h m0,.2 Cha %ma- #2 a R,/#.u( #-a%y M . (a%y C#u- . )RMC+6FN 8>" S day0 .a(,%7 a%m,d 2#% ,0 #2 (h, U- (,d S(a(,0 a-d 0#m, Ca% bb,a-0(a(,0 -/ad,d %,-ada a-d a%%,0(,d m,mb,%0 #2 (h, RMC6 FN 8B" F#..#3 - (h,,00a( #- #2 h#0( . ( ,0 #- O (#b,% 8!7 !9B87 (h, #/,%-#%5 ,-,%a. 00u,d a

    $%# .ama( #- 3h,%,by h, a00um,d , , u( /, #-(%#. #2 (h, #/,%-m,-( #2%,-ada6 FN 89" y a-#(h,% $%# .ama( #-7 (h, #/,%-#%5 ,-,%a. d, .a%,d a0(a(, #2 ,m,% ,- y7 a00um,d ., 0.a( /, $#3,%07 d, .a%,d #-( -ua( #- #2 a...a30 - 2#% , b,2#%, O (#b,% !97 !9B87 0ub@, ( (# m#d 2 a( #-07 a-d %,(a -,d(h, @ud a. 0y0(,m %,a(,d by PR 6 FN 4H" O- N#/,mb,% 97 !9B47 (h,#/,%-#%5 ,-,%a. $%#mu. a(,d (h, C#-0( (u( #- #2 %,-ada O%d,% !9B47 3h h

    b%#u h( (h, !9>8 C#-0( (u( #- ba ? - 2#% , , ,$( a0 am,-d,d by (h,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    23/59

    #/,%-#%5 ,-,%a.6 FN 4!" F#..#3 - -,3 ,., ( #-07 (h, -,3 ., 0.a(u%, ,-a (,dA ( N#6 ! #2 !9B 7 (# #-2 %m (h, /a. d (y #2 .a30 mad, du% - (h, $,% #d

    b,(3,,- Ma% h !9>9 a-d N#/,mb,% !9B4 3h,- (h, C#-0( (u( #- #2 %,-ada 3a00u0$,-d,d"6 FN 4 "

    I- Au u0( !9B47 !9 .,ad,%0 #2 (h, RMC 3,%, ha% ,d 3 (h mu%d,% a-d 3,%, b#u-d #/,% (# 0(a-d (% a. b,2#%, (h, h C#u%( #2 %,-ada6 I- a $%,(% a.m#( #-7 (h, d,2,-da-(0 ha..,- ,d (h, ., a. , 0(,- ,7 #-0( (u( #-a. (y7 a-d/a. d (y #2 (h, h C#u%(6 Th,y .a m,d (ha( (h, h C#u%( 2#%m,d $a%( #2(h, @ud a. 0y0(,m 3h h (h, PR had %,a(,d - a *B; ma--,% #-(%a%y (# (h,!9>8 C#-0( (u( #- a-d 3a0 h,- , -/a. d6 Fu%(h,%m#%,7 (h,y .a m,d (h,#/,%-#%5 ,-,%a.'0 #-2 %ma( #- #2 (h, PR @ud a. 0y0(,m 3a0 a.0# a-u- #-0( (u( #-a. u0u%$a( #- #2 ., 0.a( /, $#3,%6 F -a..y7 -0#2a% a0 A ( N#6! #2 !9B $u%$#%(,d (# a #%d /a. d (y (# PR '0 @ud a. 0y0(,m ., 0.a( #-a-d (h, #/,%-#%5 ,-,%a.'0 .a(,% #-2 %ma( #- #2 (h, 0am,7 ( #-0( (u(,d a-am,-dm,-( #2 d,,$.y ,-(%,- h,d $%#/ 0 #-0 #2 (h, C#-0( (u( #- by 3ay #2

    #%d -a%y ., 0.a( #-6 FN 48"6 Th, Jud a. R,0$#-0,: G,.0,- M#d 2 ,d5E22, ( /, C#-(%#. P.u0 P#$u.a%Su$$#%(

    I- (h, h C#u%(7 Ch ,2 Ju0( , S % A% h ba.d N,dd 0(a%(,d 3 (h (h,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    24/59

    h C#u%( 3a0 (,m$#%a% .y /a. d #- %#u-d0 #2 0(a(, -, ,00 (y7 u-( . 0u h( m, a0 (h, u%%,-( #/,%-m,-( (##? a$$%#$% a(, 0(,$0 (# %, -0(a(, (h, C#u%(#-(,m$.a(,d by (h, !9>8 C#-0( (u( #-6 FN " P,(,%? -7 J67 #- u%%,d 3 (h

    b#(h #- .u0 #-06 FN 8" L /,%$##.7 J67 #- u%%,d 3 (h /a. da( #- #2 (h, hC#u%( #- %#u-d0 #2 -, ,00 (y7 FN 4" bu( a.0# h,.d (ha( (h, PR had b, #m,

    ., ( ma(, #% .a32u. #/,%-m,-(6 FN "

    *BB T# d,(,%m -, (h, (3 - " Th, a$$,a.3a0 -,/,%(h,.,00 d 0m 00,d b, au0, (h, h C#u%( 3a0 2#u-d (# b, (,m$#%a% .y/a. d #- %#u-d0 #2 0(a(, -, ,00 (y6 FN ;B"

    *9H G6 Th, M#?#(0# Ca0,: L,0#(h# !9BB

    !6 Th, C#-(, (

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    25/59

    L,0#(h# a -,d -d,$,-d,-( 0(a(u0 - !9;;7 by / %(u, #2 (h, L,0#(h#I-d,$,-d,- , A ( !9;;7 ,-a (,d by (h, % ( 0h Pa%. am,-(6 FN ;9" AW,0(m -0(,% m#d,. C#-0( (u( #- (##? ,22, ( #- O (#b,% 47 !9;;7 3h h $%#/ d,d2#% a 0#/,%, - d,m# %a( ? - d#m7 a b am,%a. $a%. am,-(a%y 0y0(,m7 a-d

    $%#(, ( #- #2 2u-dam,-(a. huma- % h(0 3h h 2#%m,d $a%( #2 (h, ,-(%,- h,d $%#/ 0 #-0 #2 (h, C#-0( (u( #-6 Th, 2 %0( ,-,%a. ,., ( #-0 3,%, h,.d #-Ja-ua%y >7 !9>H7 3h h %,0u.(,d - (h, d,2,a( #2 (h, - umb,-( P% m,M - 0(,%7 Ch ,2 J#-a(ha-6 Ch ,2 J#-a(ha-'0 %,0$#-0, 3a0 (# -u.. 2y (h,,., ( #-07 0u0$,-d (h, C#-0( (u( #-7 $%# .a m a 0(a(, #2 ,m,% ,- y a-d a00um,d (a(#% a. $#3,%0 3h ., %,(a - - (h, G - a0 a 2 u%,h,ad6 FN >H" F#% (h,-, ( !; y,a%0 (h 0 , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. %, m, %,ma -,d - $#3,% a-d b, am,-#(#% #u0 2#% abu0,0 #2 $#. ( a. a-d -d / dua. 2%,,d#m06 O- Ja-ua%y7 H7!9B;7 (h, L,0#(h# Pa%am . (a%y F#% , )LDF+ 0(a ,d a #u$ d',(a(6 Wh ., (h,G - %,ma -,d - #22 ,7 (h, LDF ,0(ab. 0h,d a M . (a%y C#u- .6 Th, G - 7a ( - #- (h, ad/ , #2 (h, M . (a%y C#u- .7 a00um,d a.. , , u( /, a-d

    ., 0.a( /, au(h#% (y6 E 0( - .a30 3,%, (# %,ma - - 2#% , u-.,00- #-0 0(,-( 3 (h O%d,%0 #2 (h, M . (a%y #/,%-m,-( a-d (h, #u%(0 3,%, (#%,(a - (h, % @u% 0d ( #-6 FN >!"

    I- M#?#(0#7 (h, $.a -( 2207 3h# a.., ,d (ha( (h, m . (a%y %, m, had d,- ,d(h, % 2%,,d#m #2 a00# a( #- ua%a-(,,d by (h, !9;; C#-0( (u( #-7 ha..,- ,d(h, /a. d (y #2 (h, m . (a%y %, m, a-d 0#u h( a d, .a%a( #- (ha( %, m,0,0(ab. 0h,d by b#(h (h, !9>H a-d !9B; #u$0 3,%, u-.a32u.6 FN > "

    6 Th, Jud a. R,0$#-0,: Pu%, G,.0,- R,hab . (a(,d

    Th, h C#u%( #2 L,0#(h#7 - a !;B5$a , #$ - #- by Cu.. -a-7 C6J67 0(a%(,d3 (h a- a ?-#3.,d m,-( (ha( b#(h (h, !9>H a-d !9B; #u$0 3,%,, (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. a-d $%# ,,d,d (# -8" Th, C#u%( 2 %0( , am -,d G,.0,-'0 (h,#%y#2 %,/#.u( #-a%y /a. d (y a-d 0umma% ,d ( a0 (h, #.d (%u 0m7 -#(h - *9!0u ,,d0 . ?, 0u ,006 FN >4" Th, C#u%( (h,- 0u%/,y,d (h, a$$. a( #- #2G,.0,-7 FN > " a-d (h, d# (% -, #2 S(a(, N, ,00 (y7 FN >;" - d 22,%,-(

    @u% 0d ( #-06 Th, C#u%( #- .ud,d (ha(7 3h ., (h, d# (% -, #2 0(a(, -, ,00 (y3a0 3,..,0(ab. 0h,d7 (0 a$$. a( #- -d a(,0 #-2u0 #- a0 (# d,-( 2y -3h,%, (h, -, ,00 (y . ,0 - ,a h a0,6 FN >>" Th, ma@#% $%#b.,m d,-( 2 ,d3a0 (ha(7 a.(h#u h 0#m, #u%(0 $# -( (# (h, -, ,00 (y 2a - (h, C#u%(7%a(h,% (ha- (h, -, ,00 (y7 2 a-y7 3h h a/, % 0, (# (h, u- #-0( (u( #-a.a ( #- - (h, 2 %0( a0, 6 6 6 #(h,%0" 0,,m 6 6 6 (# $.a , m#%, ,m$ha0 0 u$#-(h, -, ,00 (y / - % 0, (# (h, u- #-0( (u( #-a. a ( #-6 FN >B" F -d -(ha( (h, (%u, (,0( 0 (ha( #2 (h, -, ,00 (y7 2 a-y7 3h h 2a ,0 (h, #u%(7FN >9" 6,67 (ha( #2 a/# d - a ., a. /a uum a-d ha#0 a-d $%,0,%/ - (h,2ab% #2 0# ,(y7 (h, d# (% -, 3a0 h,.d (# b, a$$%#$% a(, (# (h, a0, #2 a-a( #-a. ,m,% ,- y du% - (h, adm - 0(%a( #- #2 a .a32u. #/,%-m,-(6 FN BH"Wh ., (h, d# (% -, a$$. ,0 (# (h, u- #-0( (u( #-a. a00um$( #- #2 $#3,% by a

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    26/59

    #-0( (u( #-a. au(h#% (y7 3h,%, 0u h a ( #- 0 (a?,- (# $%,0,%/, %a(h,% (ha-(# d,0(%#y (h, #.d ., a. #%d,%7 a2(,% a 0u ,002u. %,/#.u( #- (" h,. ?,. h##d 0 (h,%,7 a0 (h, .a0h #2 a%m0 (h%#u h#u( (h, #u%0, #2 h 0(#%y,0(ab. 0h,07 (ha( (h,%, -,/,% 3 .. b, a-y %,(u%-7 a( .,a0( -#( (# (h, #.d., a. #%d,% a0 0u h6 FN B!" Th, C#u%( #- .ud,d:

    I- b% ,2 (h, "

    Th, C#u%( (h,- #-0 d,%,d (h,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    27/59

    D, d, h, mu0(6 FN B9"

    A$$.y - (h, (,0( #2 ., ( ma( #- 2 %0( (# (h, !9>H #u$ d',(a(7 (h, C#u%((##? @ud a. -#( , #2 (h, -#(#% #u0 2a ( (ha( (h, #u$ 3a0 0u ,002u.6FN 9H" Th, C#u%( (,d a-d H #u$ had $%#/,d (# b, a 0u ,002u. %,/#.u( #- ,0(ab. 0h -a .a32u. #/,%-m,-(6 FN 9!" I- / ,3 #2 (h 0 $% #% @ud a. %, # - ( #-7 *98a-d (h, #$,%a( #- #2 0(a%, d, 0 07 (h, C#u%( d d -#( #-0 d,% a-y 2u%(h,%d 0 u00 #- -, ,00a%y6

    Tu%- - (# (h, !9B; #u$7 (h, C#u%( 2#u-d (ha( 0 - , (h, #/,%-m,-( 3a02 %m.y ,0(ab. 0h,d a-d 2u- ( #- - ,22, ( /,.y7 ( 3a0 (h, .a32u. #/,%-m,-(6FN 9 " Th, C#u%( 2 %0( -0 0(,d (ha( "( 0 (h, $,#$.,7 -#( (h 0 C#u%(7 3h#- %,a. (y by (h, % a ,$(a- , ha/, #-2,%%,d ., a. (y u$#- (h, #/,%-m,-(6FN 98" I- ma? - (h, d,(,%m -a( #- #2 (h, ,22 a y #2 (h, #u$ d',(a(7 (h,C#u%( %,. ,d #- a- a22 da/ ( by (h, A((#%-,y5 ,-,%a. 0(a( - (ha( (h,

    #/,%-m,-( ha0 ,22, ( /, #-(%#.7 (0 .a30 a%, ,-2#% ,d a-d #b,y,d7 a-dd, 0 #-0 #2 C#u%(0 a%, ,-2#% ,d6 FN 94" Th, C#u%( $%# ,,d,d (# (a?,@ud a. -#( , #2 -#(#% #u0 2a (07 3h h - .ud,d (h, 2a ( (ha( (h,#/,%-m,-( 0 - ,22, ( /, #-(%#.1 (ha( ( ha0 ad#$(,d a 2#%m dab., b#dy #2., 0.a( #-1 (ha( ( ha0 2a . (a(,d ,22, ( /, 2u- ( #- - #2 (h, @ud a%y1(ha( (h, %u., #2 .a3 0 2 %m.y ,0(ab. 0h,d1 (ha( (h, /a0( ma@#% (y #2 (h,

    $,#$., a%, b,ha/ - - #-2#%m (y 3 (h (h, #/,%-m,-('0 adm - 0(%a( #-1 a-d(ha( $,a , a-d 0(ab . (y -#3 %, -6 FN 9 "

    Th, C#u%( (h,- a00,00,d (h, $#$u.a% (y #2 (h, %,/#.u( #-6 FN 9;" I( a a -(##? @ud a. -#( , #2 2a (0 3h h - .ud,d: (h, #/,%-m,-('0 $%#m#( #- #2h,a.(h a-d ,du a( #-7 ,0(ab. 0hm,-( #2 $,a , a-d 0(ab . (y a-d @ub .a( #- -(h, 0(%,,(0 a2(,% (h, $,#$., had h,a%d -,30 #2 (h, #u$ d',(a(6 FN 9>"

    L6 Th, Ma(a- ma Ca0,: T%a-0?, !9BB

    !6 Th, C#-(, (

    P% #% (# !9>;7 T%a-0?, 2#%m,d $a%( #2 (h, R,$ub. #2 S#u(h A2% a6FN 9B" I- !9>;7 ( 3a0 %a-(,d -d,$,-d,- , by (h, S(a(u0 #2 T%a-0?, A ( !HH#2 !9>;6 FN 99" Th, A ( a/, (h, ., 0.a( /, a00,mb.y #2 T%a-0?, (h, $#3,%(# ad#$( a C#-0( (u( #- 2#% (h, -,3 0(a(,6 Su h a C#-0( (u( #- 3a0 ad#$(,d a-dam, -(# ,22, ( #- (h, day #2 -d,$,-d,- ,7 O (#b,% ;7 !9>;6 FN8HH" Th,C#-0( (u( #-7 3h h ,-/ 0a ,d a $a%. am,-(a%y 2#%m #2 #/,%-m,-(7 $%#/ d,d 2#% a -#-5, , u( /, P%,0 d,-(7 ,., (,d 2#% 0,/,- y,a%0 by (h, Na( #-a. A00,mb.y73h# a (,d #- (h, ad/ , #2 (h, E , u( /, C#u- . 3h h #-0 0(,d #2 (h,M - 0(,%0 #2 S(a(,6 FN8H!" Pa%. am,-(7 #-0 0( - #2 (h, *94 P%,0 d,-( a-d(h, Na( #-a. A00,mb.y7 3a0 (h, 0#/,%, - ., 0.a( /, au(h#% (y6 FN8H " Th,

    Na( #-a. A00,mb.y #-0 0(,d #2 (h, 2 /, Pa%am#u-( Ch ,207 0,/,-(y Ch ,20%,$%,0,-( - ,-um,%a(,d d 0(% (07 a-d 0,/,-(y52 /, ,., (,d m,mb,%06 FN8H8"

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    28/59

    Th, @ud a. $#3,% 3a0 /,0(,d - a- -d,$,-d,-( @ud a%y6 FN8H4"

    O- S,$(,mb,% 47 !9B>7 (h, m . (a%y 2#% ,d (h, %,0 -a( #- #2 , h( ab -,(m - 0(,%07 a--#u- ,d (ha( P% m, M - 0(,% ,#% , Ma(a- ma had 2.,d (h,#u-(%y7 a-d 2#%m,d a a%,(a?,% #/,%-m,-(6 FN8H " Th, T%a-0?, Na( #-a.

    I-d,$,-d,- , Pa%(y7 3h#0, #/,%-m,-( had b,,- %,m#/,d a-d 3h h 0( ..#mma-d,d a 0ub0(a-( a. ma@#% (y - (h, Na( #-a. A00,mb.y7 ,., (,d M 00 S(,..aS au a0 (0 .,ad,%6 FN8H;" O- O (#b,% B7 !9B>7 0h, b, am, P% m, M - 0(,%a-d a -,3 ab -,( 3a0 a$$# -(,d6 FN8H>" O- D, ,mb,% 8H7 !9B> (h, C#mma-d,% #2 (h, T%a-0?, D,2,-0, F#% ,0 d, .a%,d ma%( a. .a37 0u0$,-d,d (h, C#-0( (u( #-a-d %,m#/,d (h, #/,%-m,-(6 FN8HB" , a--#u- ,d (ha( (h, #u-(%y 3#u.d b, %u-

    by a- -(,% m #/,%-m,-( #-0 0( - #2 a M . (a%y C#u- . 0u$$#%(,d by a-a$$# -(,d C#u- . #2 M - 0(,%06 FN8H9" Th, -, ( day ma%( a. .a3 3a0 . 2(,d6FN8!H" O- Ja-ua%y 7 !9BB7 a d, %,, 3a0 $ub. 0h,d - (h, #/,%-m,-( a ,((,3h h $%#/ d,d7 am#- #(h,% (h - 07 (ha(

    (h, , , u( /, a-d ., 0.a( /, au(h#% (y 6 6 6 0 /,0(,d - (h, P%,0 d,-(

    a-d h, 0ha.. , ,% 0, 0u h au(h#% (y #- (h, ad/ , #2 (h, M . (a%y C#u- . 6 6 6 E"/,%y -0(%um,-( 0 -,d by (h, P%,0 d,-( 0ha.. b, #u-(,%50 -,d by am,mb,% #2 (h, M . (a%y C#u- . 6 6 6 6 Th, P%,0 d,-( 0ha.. by d, %,, ma?, .a30 6 6 a-d may am,-d #% %,$,a. a-y .a36 6 6 6 N# #u%( #2 .a3 0ha.. b,#m$,(,-( (# -

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    29/59

    2#%mu.a(, (h, M#?#(0# (,0(" - 3ha( 0 $,%ha$0 a m#%, $#0 ( /, ma--,% 6 6 6 6 FN8!>" Th, C#u%( (h,- 0(a(,d:

    A %,/#.u( #-a%y #/,%-m,-( b, #m,0 .a32u. a-d (0 ., 0.a( #-0 ., ( ma(,dab - ( # 3h,- )a+ ( 0 2 %m.y ,0(ab. 0h,d7 (h,%, b, - -# %,a. da- ,% (ha(( 3 .. (0,.2 b, #u0(,d 2%#m $#3,%7 a-d )b+ (0 adm - 0(%a( #- 0 ,22, ( /,7

    - (ha( (h, $,#$.,7 by a-d .a% ,7 ha/, a

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    30/59

    !6 Th, C#-(, (

    O- F,b%ua%y !H7 !9BB7 0, ( #-0 #2 (h, m . (a%y #2 #$hu(ha(03a-a a((,m$(,d a#u$ d',(a(6 FN8 B" Th, P%,0 d,-( a-d Cab -,( 3,%, (a?,- -(# u0(#dy a-d

    2#% ,d (# %,0 - (h, % $#0(06 S#m, m . (a%y ba0,0 a-d (h, b%#ad a0( - ,-(,%3,%, # u$ ,d a-d a -,3 P%,0 d,-( a-d Cab -,( 3,%, *9> a$$# -(,d6 FN8 9" Th,S#u(h A2% a- m . (a%y -(,%/,-,d7 0ubdu,d (h, #u$ ma?,%07 a-d %, -0(a(,d (h,d,$#0,d #/,%-m,-(6 FN88H" Sa-d# J#ha--,0 a-da7 (h, .,ad,% #2 (h, a((,m$(,d#u$7 a-d !94 #(h,%0 3,%, b%#u h( (# (% a. #- (h, ha% , #2 h h (%,a0#-6FN88!" Th, d,2,-0, #b@, (,d #- (h, %#u-d0 (ha( (h, -d (m,-( d 0 .#0,d -##22,-0, a a -0( (h, a u0,d6 FN88 " P%#2,00#% J#h- Du a%d7 a$$,a% - 2#% (h,d,2,-da-(0 b,2#%, (h, Su$%,m, C#u%( #2 #$hu(ha(03a-a7 a% u,d (ha( (h, % m,#2 h h (%,a0#- by d,2 - ( #- a- #-.y b, #mm ((,d a a -0( a 0(a(, $#00,00 -ma@,0(a0 )0#/,%, -(y+6 FN888" S - , #$hu(ha(03a-a 3a0 a %,a( #- #2 (h,S#u(h A2% a- ., 0.a(u%, a0 $a%( #2 (h, P%,(#% a %, m,'0 $#. y 2#% (h,

    0,$a%a(, d,/,.#$m,-( #2 %a a..y d,2 -,d 0, ( #-0 #2 (h, S#u(h A2% a- $#$u.a( #- )a$a%(h, d+7 ( .a ?,d (h, a$a (y #2 0(a(,h##d - -(,%-a( #-a..a3 a-d #-0," a-d /a% #u0 S#u(h W,0( A2% a- )Nam b a+ a0,0FN88B" 2#% (h 0 $#0 ( #-6

    Th, C#u%( 2 %0( %,/ ,3,d (h, #-0( (u( #-a. h 0(#%y #2 (h, %,a( #- #2#$hu(ha(03a-a6 I( -#(,d (ha( #$hu(ha(03a-a b, am, a 0#/,%, - -d,$,-d,-(0(a(, #- D, ,mb,% ;7 !9>>7 by a- a ( #2 (h, ., 0.a(u%, #2 S#u(h A2% a6FN889" O- (h, 0am, day (h, ., 0.a( /, a00,mb.y #2 #$hu(ha(03a-a $%#mu. a(,d(h, R,$ub. #2 #$hu(ha(03a-a C#-0( (u( #- A ( !B #2 !9>>6 FN84H" Thu07#$hu(ha(03a-a b, am, 0#/,%, - a-d -d,$,-d,-(1 *9B (0 $a%. am,-( ha/ -u-2,((,%,d ., 0.a( /, $#3,%0 a-d #/,% 3h h (h, R,$ub. #2 S#u(h A2% a,a0, d" (# , ,% 0, a-y au(h#% (y6 FN84!" Fu%(h,%m#%,7 0, ( #- !)!+ #2 (h,

    C#-0( (u( #- $%#/ d,d (ha( #$hu(ha(03a-a 0 a 0#/,%, - -d,$,-d,-( S(a(, 66 6 FN84 " F -a..y7 (h, C#u%( (,d a0 3, h(y $,%m 00 /, au(h#% (y7FN848" S /6 Ma%3a-,7 FN844" - 3h h (h, A$$,..a(, D / 0 #- #2 S#u(h A2% a%, # - ,d7 a ,$(,d7 a-d a$$. ,d (h, $% - $., #2 0#/,%, - -d,$,-d,- , #2#$hu(ha(03a-a6 Th 0 C#u%( #- .ud,d (ha( a #%d - (# .a3 #2 (h 0 #u-(%y

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    31/59

    a-d (ha( #2 S#u(h A2% a7 #$hu(ha(03a-a 0 a- -d,$,-d,-( 0#/,%, - S(a(,ha/ - ma@,0(a06 FN84 "

    Cu% #u0.y7 (h, C#u%( d d -#( 0(#$ (h, -

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    32/59

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    33/59

    d',(a( - $#0(5 #.#- a. 0# ,( ,06 ,2#%, (h 0 , am -a( #-7 ( 0 m$#%(a-( (#(a?, -#(, #2 (h, #-(, ( 3 (h - 3h h (h, ,- #u-(,%0 b,(3,,- #u$0 d',(a( a-d

    @ud a% ,0 u-2#.d6 Th, a%( ., $%# ,,d0 3 (h (h, $%,m 0, (ha( a..#-0( (u( #-a. ad@ud a( #- 0 a$$. ,d $#. ( 06 FN8; " Th 0 $%,m 0, 0 a

    ba0 #-, 3h,- #-, 2# u0,0 u$#- #-0( (u( #-a. ad@ud a( #- - (h, m d0( #2

    a-d $,%(a - - (# $#. ( a. u$h,a/a. -#( #-(,m$.a(,d by (h, #-0( (u( #-a.#%d,%6Th, . 2, #2 (h, .a3 ha0 -#( b,,- .# : I( ha0 b,,- , $,% ,- ,6 Th, 2,.(

    -, ,00 ( ,0 #2 (h, ( m,7 (h, $%,/a.,-( m#%a. a-d $#. ( a. (h,#% ,07 ,/,- (h, $%,@ud ,0 3h h @ud ,0 0ha%, 3 (h (h, % 2,..#3m,-7 ha/, had a ##d d,a. m#%,(# d# (ha- (h, 0y..# 0m - d,(,%m - - (h, %u.,0 by 3h h m,- 0h#u.d b,#/,%-,d6 FN8;8"

    C#-0,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    34/59

    A.. (h,0, 2a (#%0 #-(% bu(, (# a .a ? #2 #-0,-0u0 ab#u( (h, #-0( (u( #-a.2%am,3#%?06 Thu07 (h, ., ( ma y #2 (h, $#. ( a. #%d,% %,ma -0 ,.u0 /,6 Th,

    @ud a. -0( (u( #-07 .# a(,d a0 (h,y a%, - (h, m d0( #2 (h 0 #-(, (7a--#( , 0( 3 (h#u( b, - a22, (,d by (6

    I( 0 m$#%(a-( 2#% (h 0 -H"

    *!H8 A #u$ d',(a(7 #- (h, #(h,% ha-d7 (y$ a..y a m0 #-.y a( a$(u% - $#. ( a. $#3,% , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a..y6 O-.y (ha( $a%( #2 (h, C#-0( (u( #-3h h b,a%0 #- (h, 2#%ma( #- #2 $#. ( a. #% a-0 #2 (h, 0(a(, 0 0ub/,%(,d6FN8>!" Th, 2u- ( #-a. 2%am,3#%? #2 (h, 0(a(,7 (h, @ud a. b%a- h7 a-d (h,3 d,% ., a. #%d,% a%, (y$ a..y ?,$( - $.a ,6 FN8> " A0 a %,0u.(7 (h,., ( ma y #2 (h, -,3 %, m, 0 -#( #m$.,(,.y au(#-#m#u0 #2 (h, $%,5, 0( -

    $%# ,00,0 a-d -0( (u( #-06 I- a.. (h, a0,0 , am -,d ab#/,7 (h, @ud a%y0u%/ /,d (h, #u$0 d',(a( (ha( d,0(%#y,d (h, , , u( /, a-d ., 0.a( /, #% a-0#2 (h, 0(a(,6 ,y#-d .,(( - ( 0u%/ /, -0( (u( #-a..y7 (h, @ud a%y 3a0a..#3,d (# d,(,%m -, (h, /a. d (y #2 (h, -,3 %, m,7 ,/,- - (h, 2a , #2, $%,00 $%, .u0 #- #2 0u h %,/ ,3 #-(a -,d - $%# .ama( #-0 a-d d, %,,0 #2u0u%$,% %, m,06 FN8>8" U0u%$,%0 a$$,a% (# %, # - , (ha( @ud a.

    $%#-#u- ,m,-(0 ab#u( (h, -a(u%, a-d m,% (0 #2 (h, ha- , a-d 4"a-d - #mm#-5.a3 0,(( - 07 F#% a.. $%a ( a. $u%$#0,0 a ., a. 0y0(,m #% a#-0( (u( #- 0 /a. d 3h,- (h, @ud ,0 ha/, u-amb u#u0.y a ,$(,d ( a0 /a. d6T# (h 0 , (,-( (h, #-0( (u( #- 0 3ha( (h, @ud ,0 0ay ( 06 FN8> "S, u% - @ud a. %, # - ( #- a$$,a%0 (# b, (h, ?,y (# a - - $#. ( a.., ( ma y6 /,- (h, 0# a. %,0$, ( ,-@#y,d by (h, @ud a%y7 %, # - ( #- by#u%(0 #2 (h, #.d #%d,% 2u%- 0h,0 a 0#u% , #2 %,d b . (y 2#% u0u%$,% %, m,06Th#0, - $#3,% ?-#3 #-.y (## 3,.. (h, ad/a-(a , 3h h (h, 0,a. #2 ., a. (ya%% ,06 FN8>;" Th, u0u%$,%'0 -,,d 2#% ., ( ma y a-d @ud a. %, # - ( #-m$. ,0 (ha( (h, #u%(0 may -#( b, ,-( %,.y $#3,%.,00 3h,- #-2%#-(,d 3 (h a#u$ d',(a( a-d may b, - a $#0 ( #- (# 0, u%, #- ,00 #-0 - , ha- , 2#%

    @ud a. %, # - ( #-6

    Th 07 h#3,/,%7 mu0( b, (,m$,%,d by (h, 2a ( (ha( - (h, a2(,%ma(h #2 a0u ,002u. #u$ d',(a(7 @ud ,0 3h# ha/, b,,- u0,d (# $.a - a ' h, ?' #-

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    35/59

    ., 0.a( /, , ,00,0 a-d a @ud a%y (ha( had a.3ay0 0,,- (0,.2 a0 a $#(,-(a-d ,22, ( /, ' #-(%#.' #- (h, #(h,% #% a-0 #2 #/,%-m,-( a%, -#3 #-2%#-(,d3 (h a 2a ( a #m$. , $%,00,d - D, %,,0 a-d Ed (06 FN8>>" C#u$0 a%,(y$ a..y a%% ,d #u( by7 #% 3 (h (h, 0u$$#%( #27 (h, m . (a%y ,0(ab. 0hm,-(#2 (h, 0(a(,6 , au0, (h, m . (a%y ,-@#y0 a $%,$#-d,%a- ,7 ,/,- a m#-#$#.y7 #2

    #,% /, $#3,% - (h, 0# ,(y7 ( a- ,-2#% , (0 3 .. #- a-y 0, ( #- #2 (h,0(a(, #% / . 0# ,(y 3h ., ( %,ma -0 %,.a( /,.y mmu-, 2%#m #u-(,%/a . - $%,00u%, 2%#m a-y #(h,%

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    36/59

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    37/59

    b, au0, (h, -d / dua.0 3h#0, b,ha/ #% (h, -,3 #%d,% %, u.a(,0 a (ua..y b,ha/,7 by a-d .a% ,7 - #-2#%m (y 3 (h (h, -,3 #%d,%7 (h,- (h 0 #%d,% 0#-0 d,%,d a0 a /a. d #%d,%6 FN89 " I- h 0 a((,m$( (# ma?, , $. ( (h,

    $%,0u$$#0 ( #- #- 3h h (h,0, @u% 0( #-0 d,%a( #-0 %,0(7 G,.0,- 2 -d0 (ha(

    (h, -#%m0 #2 (h, #.d #%d,% a%, %, a%d,d a0 d,/# d #2 /a. d (y b, au0, (h,#.d #-0( (u( #- a-d7 (h,%,2#%,7 (h, ., a. -#%m0 ba0,d #- (h 0 #-0( (u( #-7(h, #.d ., a. #%d,% a0 a 3h#.,7 ha0 .#0( (0 ,22 a y1 b, au0, (h, a (ua.

    b,ha/ #% #2 m,- d#,0 -# .#- ,% #-2#%m (# (h 0 #.d ., a. #%d,%6 6 6 6 Th, $% - $., #2 ., ( ma y 0 %,0(% (,d by (h, $% - $., #2 ,22, ( /,-,006FN89;"

    G,.0,-'0 (h,#%y a00um,0 (h, d,-( 2 a( #- #2 (h, 0(a(, 3 (h (h, ., a.#%d,%7 3 (h (h, % 2#u-da( #-0 %##(,d - (h, #-0( (u( #-6 A0 h 0 (h,#%y %,0(0u$#- (h, #$,%a( /, $%,m 0, 6 6 6 (ha( (h, $#0 ( /, a-d d,. b,%a(, d,0(%u ( #-#2 (h, 2#u-da( #- #2 (h, ., a. #%d,% $%,0um,0 (h, -(,-( #- (# 2#u-d a -,3

    0(a(,7 a -,3 0#/,%, -(y7 FN89>" ( $%, .ud,0 a-y d 0( - ( #- b,(3,,- a%,/#.u( #- a-d a #u$ d',(a(6 Wh ., h, %, # - ,0 (ha( #u$0 d',(a( d# -#(%,0u.( - a (ua. %,$.a ,m,-( #2 (h, ., a. 0y0(,m7 a-d #-.y (h, #-0( (u( #-a-d ,%(a - .a30 #2 $a%am#u-( $#. ( a. 0 - 2 a- , a%, 0u$$%,00,d7 3h .,a" %,a( $a%( #2 (h, #.d ., a. #%d,% '%,ma -0' /a. d7 FN89B" h, 0#-0(%a -,d (# (%,a( (h, % ., a. m$. a( #- a0 b, - (h, 0am, a0 (h#0, #2 a%,/#.u( #-6 Th 0 $.a ,0 h 0 (h,#%y #u( #2 0(,$ 3 (h (h, %,a. (y #2 #u$0 -

    $#0(5 #.#- a. 0# ,( ,0 (ha( d# -#( a m a( d,0(%u ( #- #2 (h, ,-( %, ., a.#%d,%7 bu( #-.y a( u0u%$a( #- #2 $#. ( a. #22 ,06

    a6 G,.0,-'0 2#%ma. @u% d a. #- ,$( #- #2 (h, 0(a(, 0 2a..a #u0

    G,.0,-'0 $#0(u.a(,0 %,0( #- a -a%%#37 2#%ma. 0( 7 a-d @u% d a. #- ,$( #-#2 (h, 0(a(,7 3h,%,by #- ,$(0 #2 0(a(,7 ., a. #%d,%7 a-d #-0( (u( #-

    b, #m, 2u0,d6 I( 0 (h 0 2u0 #- 3h h .,ad0 (# 0(a(,m,-(0 (ha( (h, 0(a(, a-d(0 ., a. #%d,% %,ma - (h, 0am, #-.y a0 .#- a0 (h, #-0( (u( #- 0 -(a ( #%ha- ,d a #%d - (# (0 #3- $%#/ 0 #-06 FN899" G,.0,-'0 0 a h h.y%,0(% ( /, *!HB / ,3 #2 (h, S(a(, a0 (h, , $%,00 #- #2 (h, .# a.#m$.,(,-,00 a-d --,% #-0 0(,- y #2 (h, 0y0(,m #2 ., a. -#%m06 FN4HH" Th 0#- ,$( #- #2 (h, 0(a(, a0 a 0(%u (u%, #2 ., a. -#%m0 0 a $u%,.y @u% 0( a-d2#%ma. #-,6 I( 2a .0 (# (a?, a #u-( #2 (h#0, 0# a. 2a (#%0 (ha( #-d ( #-(h, -a(u%, #2 $a%( u.a% 0(a(,0 a-d ., a. #%d,%0 - 0$, 2 0,(( - 07 a-d%,2., (0 ., a. $#0 ( / 0m'0 .a ? #2 $h .#0#$h a. #- ,%- 3 (h m#%a.

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    38/59

    (3#6 Th, -a(u%, #2 (h, / . 0# ,(y #-d ( #-0 (h, 2#%m0 (ha( (h, 0(a(,a00um,0 3 (h - (0 m d0(7 a-d (h, 0(a(,7 - (u%-7 #-d ( #-0 (h, / . 0# ,(y

    by (0 /,%y , 0(,- ,7 0(%u (u%,7 a-d 2u- ( #-06 Fu%(h,%m#%,7 (h, 2u- ( #- #2(h, 0(a(, 0 -#( , .u0 /,.y a #,% /, #-,6 Id,#.# a. a-d -#%ma. -2u- ( #-0 a%, (h, $% ma%y 2u- ( #-0 #2 a m#d,%- 0(a(,7 3h,%,by (h, 0(a(, a-d

    / . 0# ,(y -, ,00a% .y #/,%.a$6 Th, #- ,$( #2 (h, 0(a(, 0 #$,-5(, (u%,d7ma? - ( 0u0 ,$( b., (# a mu.( $. (y #2 u0a ,06 FN4H " A-y $u%,.y @u% 0(, $.a-a( #- #2 (h, 0(a(, 07 (h,%,2#%,7 a- u-a/# dab.y ab0(%a ( $#0(u.a( #- #2 (h,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    39/59

    %,a0#-ab.,-,007 (h#0, 0( $u.a( #-0 a.(# ,(h,% .a ? (h, au(h#% (y (h,y 3#u.d#(h,%3 0, ha/, by / %(u, #2 b, - h 06 FN4!!"

    Wh ., 2#% G,.0,- (h, .a3 0 a.3ay0 #- ,%-,d 3 (h #,% #-7 FN4! " 2#%F -- 0 ( 0 $% ma% .y a m,d a( 2a . (a( - (h, %,a. a( #- #2 (h, #mm#-

    ##d6 FN4!8" Th, ,-(%a. d 22,%,- , b,(3,,- (h, (3# 0 (ha(7 3h ., G,.0,-,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    40/59

    a$$. ab., (# (h, 0(a(u0 #2 (h, #-0( (u( #-6

    I- G,.0,-'0 (h,#%y7 h#3,/,%7 (h,%, 0 a 0ha%$ d 0( - ( #- b,(3,,- (h, (3#6Th, %u-d-#%m 0 (h, %,a0#- 2#% (h, /a. d (y #2 (h, #-0( (u( #- a0 0,,- by., a. 0 ,- ,1 ( 0 -#( (h, #-0( (u( #- (0,.26 Th, %u-d-#%m . ,0 #u(0 d,

    $#0 ( /, .a30 a-d (h, % -#%m01 ( 0 a $%,0u$$#0 ( #- #2 (h,m mad, - (h,-(,%,0( #2 ., a. 0 ,- ,6 A-d ,/,- (h#u h $%,0u$$#0,d7 (h, %u-d-#%m ha0 -#-d,$,-d,-( 0(a(u01 ( a.3ay0 %,2,%0 (# a 0$, 2 #-0( (u( #-6 Fu%(h,%m#%,7(h, %u-d-#%m 0 -#( $%,0 % b,d by G,.0,-'0 $u%, (h,#%y6 T# $%,0 % b, (3#u.d b, (# ma?, .a307 a-d $u%, (h,#%y a--#( %,a(, a .a3 #- (0 #3-a #u-(1 #-.y (h#0, au(h#% ,d (# d# 0# by (h, ., a. 0y0(,m a- d# (ha(6G,.0,-'0 $u%, (h,#%y 0 #- ,%-,d #-.y 3 (h -(,.., (ua. #h,%,- , - ., a.a-a.y0 06 I( 0 a d,0 % $( /, (h,#%y7 -#( a $%,0 % $( /, $% - $., #2 .a36FN4 " G,.0,- %,2,%0 (# (h, %u-d-#%m a0 (h, #-0( (u( #- *!! - (h,., a.5.# a. 0,-0, a0 #$$#0,d (# (h, #-0( (u( #- - (h, $#0 ( /, ., a.0,-0,7 FN4 ;" a-d -0 0(0 (ha( (h,0, a%, d 0( - ( #- ,$(07 a-d a-y

    -(,%$%,(a( #- (ha( 3#u.d #..a$0, (h, (3# 0 3 (h#u( a-y 2#u-da( #- - my3% ( - 06 FN4 >"

    Th, #-2u0 #- #2 %u-d-#%m a-d #-0( (u( #- $,%m ((,d @ud ,0 - (h, a0,0%,/ ,3,d ab#/, (# $%,0,-( (h,m0,./,0 a0 m$a%( a.7 ,/,- 0 ,-( 2 72a (52 -d,%07 #b@, ( /,.y d 0 #/,% - a-d $%,d ( - ,22 a y6 Su h a ( / (y7h#3,/,%7 0 a. ,- (# (h, ,-(,%$% 0, #2 $u%, (h,#%y7 3h h a m0 (# d,0 % b,(h, $#0(5d, 0 #- 0 (ua( #- a-d (hu0 a--#( (a?, $a%( - ma? - (ha( d, 0 #-6A d, 0 #- 2 -d - ,22 a y a0 a ba0 0 #2 /a. d (y 0 a- a ( #2 -#%m %,a( #-7-#( a $%,0u$$#0 ( #- #2 ., a. 0 ,- ,6 A (0 #2 -#%m5 %,a( #-7 a0 G,.0,- -#(,07may

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    41/59

    #-0( (u( #-7 3% ((,- #% u-3% ((,-7 0 %, # - ,d a0 (h, h h,0( .,/,. #2 $#0 ( /, .a37 ( 0 (0,.2 /a. da(,d by (h, $%,0u$$#0,d %u-d-#%m6 FN488"Th, (%#ub. - m$. a( #- 0 (ha( 2 (h, #-0( (u( #-7 (h#u h (h, h h,0(.,/,. #2 $#0 ( /, .a37 0 -#( - 2a ( (h, h h,0( -#%m7 (h,- (h,#-0( (u( #-'0 /a. d (y may b,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    42/59

    /,-(u% - $%,d ( #-0 #2 2u(u%, b,ha/ #%7 FN448" a (a0? 3,.. b,y#-d @ud a.#m$,(,- ,6

    Th,%, 0 a.0# (h, $%#b.,m #2 , .u0 #- #2 %,a0#-0 a-d "Wh ., (h, ,a%.y a0,07 2#..#3 - G,.0,-7 had #-0 d,%,d m#( /a( #- #2

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    43/59

    u0u%$a( #- %%,.,/a-(7 .a(,% a0,0 (##? (h, $#0 ( #- (ha( ("h, ., a.#-0, (0.a00 2#%mu.a( #-7 (h, d# (% -, may b, -/#?,d #-.y by (h, .a32u. 0#/,%, -7FN4;4" a-d /a. da(,d a (0 mu0( b, d %, (,d (# a-d %,a0#-ab.y %,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    44/59

    - (h, -(,%,0( #2 $%,0,%/ - (h, 0(a(,6 FN4;;" Th, d# (% -, #2 m$. ,dma-da(, 3a0 $%#22,%,d a( a ( m, #2 ab0#.u(, m#-a% h ,07 b,2#%, (h, ,%a #2#-0( (u( #-a. #/,%-a- ,7 0,$a%a( #- #2 $#3,%07 a-d -d,$,-d,-( #u%(07FN4;>" a-d a0 0u h 0 -#( 3#%(hy #2 @ud a. %, # - ( #- by a-y0,.25%,0$, ( - m#d,%- #u%(6 T%a/,. - 2u%(h,% a.#- (h 0 %#ad7 hu((#

    %,-d,%,d m,a- - .,00 a-y d 0( - ( #- b,(3,,- (h, d# (% -, #2 -, ,00 (y a-d (h,(h,#%y #2 %,/#.u( #-a%y ., a. (y 3h,- ( u0,d (h, d# (% -, (# /a. da(,u-2,((,%,d ., 0.a( /, a$a (y #2 (h, u0u%$,% %, m,7 - .ud - (h, $#3,% (#am,-d (h, C#-0( (u( #-6 FN4;B" A-#(h,% d,/ , u0,d by (h, #u%(0 (# d# a3ay3 (h (h, (%ad ( #-a. . m (a( #-0 #- (h, a$$. a( #- #2 (h, d# (% -, 0 (#2# u0 -#( #- (h, -, ,00 (y 3h h $%#m$(,d (h, , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. a ( #-7 bu(#- (h, -, ,00 (y (ha( 2a ,0 (h, #u%( a2(,% (h, 2a ( (# /a. da(, 0u h a ( #-- (h, $ub. -(,%,0(7 -d,,d a0 a ma((,% #2 $ub. $#. y6 FN4;9" S %J# ,.y- S m#-'0 #b0,%/a( #- (ha( $ub. $#. y 0 (h, /,%y ,00,- , #2 (h,d# (% -,7 3h,(h,% #-, a..0 ( '-, ,00 (y' #% ' m$. ,d ma-da(,' #% a-y(h -,.0,7 FN4>H" 0 .#0,% (# (h, a (ua. $%a ( ,6 Th 0 - (u%- %a 0,0 (3#

    % ( a. $%#b.,m06 O-,7 0u h d .u( #- #2 (h, d# (% -, ma?,0 @ud a. $%a ( ,/u.-,%ab., (# (h, ha% , (ha( m$%, 0 #- #2 (h, d# (% -, .,ad0 (# @ud a.u0u%$a( #- #2 ., 0.a( /, 2u- ( #-06 FN4>!" T3#7 (h 0 $,%m (0 (h, @ud ,0 (#

    b% - -(# $.ay7 3 (h#u( a ?-#3.,d - (7 (h, % $,%0#-a. b a0,0 a-d *!!B $%,2,%,- ,06 FN4> "

    P,% ,$( /, % ( 0 ha/, .#- h,.d (ha( a$$. a( #- #2 (h, d# (% -, #2-, ,00 (y %,8" E/,- 3h,%,a @ud , $,%0#-a..y 2 -d0 (h, m#( /a( #-0 #2 u0u%$a( #- .audab.,7 h 0 ., a.#b. a( #- (# ,-2#% , (h, #-0( (u( #- %,ma -06 FN4>4" T# $,%m ( @ud ,0 (#d, d, 0u h ba0 ;" (0 u0,0 b,0( . m (,d (# , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. a ( #-0 by a .a32u. #/,%-m,-( (a?,-- %,0$#-0, (# ,m,% ,- ,0 a-d d,0 -,d (# $%#(, ( %a(h,% (ha- 0ub/,%( (h,#-0( (u( #-a. #%d,%6

    86 I-(,%-a( #-a. La3 D#,0 N#( a. da(, C#u$0 d'E(a(

    O-, . -, #2 %,a0#- - ad#$(,d by 0#m, #2 (h, #u%(0 (# /a. da(, u0u%$a( #-(h%#u h #u$ d',(a( 0 (# %,2,% (# (h, $% - $.,0 #2 0(a(, %, # - ( #- --(,%-a( #-a. .a3 a-d 2 -d mu- $a. #u%(0 #b. a(,d (# 2#..#3 d (a(,0 #2-(,%-a( #-a. .a36 FN4>>" Th 0 . -, #2 %,a0#- - m$. ,0 a- u- % ( a.ad#$( #- *!!9 #2 (h, , (%,m, m#- 0( / ,3 #2 (h, $% ma y #2 -(,%-a( #-a. .a3, $#u-d,d by G,.0,-6 FN4>B" Th 0 / ,3 #2 G,.0,- 0 .# a..y -d,$,-d,-( 2%#mh 0 a-a.y0 0 #2 d#m,0( ., a. 0y0(,m07 FN4>9" a-d -/#./,0 (h, $%#$#0 ( #-

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    45/59

    (ha( a.. -#%m0 #2 a d#m,0( ., a. 0y0(,m a%, 0ub#%d -a(, (# (h#0, #2-(,%-a( #-a. .a36 Th, /a. d (y #2 (h, %u-d-#%m (0,.2 0 (h,%,2#%, -# .#- ,%

    $%,0u$$#0,d7 bu( 0 d,(,%m -,d by a $#0 ( /, -#%m #2 -(,%-a( #-a. .a3 3h ha"u(h#% ,0 a- -d / dua. #% %#u$ #2 -d / dua.07 #- (h, ba0 0 #2 a-

    ,22, ( /, #-0( (u( #-7 (# %,a(, a-d a$$.y a0 a ., ( ma(, #/,%-m,-( a

    -#%ma( /, #,% /, #%d,%6 Tha( -#%m7 (hu07 ., ( m ,0 (h 0 #,% /, #%d,%6 6a0 a /a. d ., a. #%d,% 6 6 6 %, a%d.,00 #2 3h,(h,% (h, #/,%-m,-( am, (# $#3,% - a '., ( ma(,' 3ay 6 6 6 #% by %,/#.u( #-6 FN4BH"

    Th,%, a%, -um,%#u0 $%#b.,m0 3 (h u0 - (h 0 $%#$#0 ( #- a0 a %u., #2d, 0 #-6 I%%,0$, ( /, #2 (0 m,% (07 ( 0 a (h,#%y #2 .a3 a-d (h,-(,%%,.a( #-0h $ b,(3,,- 0y0(,m0 #2 .a37 a-d -#( a $% - $., #2 .a3 (ha(#u.d 0,%/, a0 a %a( # d, d,-d 6 Th, (h,#%y 0 , (%,m, b, au0, ( 0 $#00 b.,(# u$h#.d (h, $% ma y #2 -(,%-a( #-a. .a3 - a ,-,%a. 0,-0, FN4B!" 3 (h#u(#b. a( - d#m,0( #u%(0 (# /a. da(, u0u%$a( #- #2 0(a(, $#3,%6 Th, (h,#%y0 m#%a..y %,$u -a-( b, au0, ( ,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    46/59

    y 2a . - (# d 0( - u 0h 2#% , 2%#m .a37 (h 0 #$( #- ,%#d,0 (h, d,a. #2 (h,%u., #2 .a3 a-d d m - 0h,0 (h, $%,0( , #2 (h, #u%(06

    C6 O$( #- T3#: S(% ( C#-0( (u( #-a. 0m

    C#-2%#-(,d 3 (h a #u$ d',(a(7 #-, #$( #- a/a .ab., (# a #u%( 0 (# (a?,(h, %#ad #2 0(% ( #-0( (u( #-a. 0m7 6,67 2#..#3 (h, $% - $., (ha( a #u%(3h h d,% /,0 (0 , 0(,- , 2%#m a 3% ((,- #-0( (u( #- a--#( /, ,22, ( (#a-y(h - 3h h 0 -#( .a3 3h,- @ud ,d by (ha( #-0( (u( #-6 FN4B>" Th,ad/a-(a ,0 #2 (h 0 h# , a%, -um,%#u06 ,0 d,0 b, - d# (% -a..y 0a2,7 0(% (2 d,. (y (# (h, #-0( (u( #- 3 .. 2u%- 0h #-0 0(,- y (# @ud a. %,0$#-0,0 (#(h,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    47/59

    2u(u%, $a%. am,-(07 FN49 " a-d (h,%,2#%,7 a-y 0(a(u(, 0 by d,2 - ( #-%,/# ab.,6 FN49;" L# a..y (h,-7 (h, #%%, ( ., a. $#0 ( #- 0 (ha( (h,S(a(u(, #2 W,0(m -0(,% a- b, %,/#?,d by (h, % ( 0h Pa%. am,-(7 %,0(#% - (h,Pa%. am,-('0 ., 0.a( /, a$a (y #/,% (h, , 5 #.#- ,07 a-d (hu0 -u.. 2y -(h, % -d,$,-d,-( 0#/,%, - 0(a(u06 FN49>" D#,0 %, #u%0, (# .# a-d 2#%ma.

    ., a. *! 8 d# (% -, ,-d (h, -

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    48/59

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    49/59

    P% /y C#u- .'0 $#0 ( #-6 I- R, -a /6 Ndh.#/u7 FN !!" (h, C#u%( d, .a%,d(ha( (h, d, 0 #- #2 (h, Jud a. C#mm ((,, 3a0 -#( b -d - #- (h, #u%(0 #2S#u(h,%- Rh#d,0 a1 (ha( (h, !9; C#-0( (u( #- had b, #m, (h, d, @u%,C#-0( (u( #-1 a-d (ha( (h, UDI #/,%-m,-( had b, #m, (h, .a32u. #/,%-m,-(6FN ! " I- J .a- 7 by (h, ( m, (h, 0u ,002u. #u$ d',(a( 3a0 d, .a%,d a-

    u-.a32u. u0u%$a( #- #- A$% . H7 !9> 7 (h, u0u%$,% %, m, had a.%,ady 2a..,-2#u% m#-(h0 ,a%. ,%6 FN !8" N,/,%(h,.,007 (h, C#u%(7 #mb - - (h, d# (% -,#2 m$. ,d ma-da(, 3 (h (h, d# (% -, #2 0(a(, -, ,00 (y7 a-d a.. - ( a

    $% - $., #2 #-d#-a( #- a-d -#( ., ( ma( #-7 /a. da(,d ma-y a (0 #2 (h,u0u%$,% %, m, -#(3 (h0(a-d - (h, % .., a. (y - (h, 3 d,% $ub.-(,%,0(6 FN !4" I- L a0 7 (h, Cy$% #( #u%( d, . -,d (# /a. da(, (h, !9>4#u$ d',(a(7 bu( #-.y a2(,% (h, 0h#%(5. /,d #u$ had b,,- 0u$$%,00,d6 FN ! "M#%,#/,%7 (h, %,0(#%,d #-0( (u( #-a. #/,%-m,-(7 3h h had by ., 0.a( #-ha%a (,% ,d (h, #u$ a0 b, - 3 (h#u( ., a. ba0 07 @# -,d (h, $,( ( #-,% -0,,? - a @ud a. d, .a%a( #- #2 -/a. d (y #2 (h, #u$6 S m .a%.y7 (h,M ( h,.. C#u%( %,2u0,d (# /a. da(, a u0u%$,% %, m, (ha( had a.%,ady 2a..,-6

    FN !;" S( .. (h, #u%(7 (0,.2 a $%#du ( #2 (h, u0u%$,% %, m,7 -/#?,d (h,d# (% -, #2 -, ,00 (y (# /a. da(, b#(h (0 #3- , 0(,- , a-d (0 @u% 0d ( #-6

    Th, #-.y a0, 3h,%, a- - umb,-( u0u%$,% %, m, 3a0 %,2u0,d /a. da( #- by(h, #u%(0 3a0 (h, La?a-m a0, #2 N ,% a6 FN !>" Th, %,0$#-0, #2 (h, %, m,3a0 03 2( a-d u-,-#(3 (h0(a-d - (0 $a00 #-a(, ,0$#u0a. #2 (h, $% - $.,0 #2 0,$a%a( #- #2

    $#3,%0 a-d -h,%,-( au(#-#my a-d $#3,% #2 (h, @ud a%y - La?a-m 6

    Th, #(h,% , am$., #2 a d, 0 /, %,bu?, by u0u%$,% %, m,0 #2 a- a00,%( /, @ud a%y 0 (h, P%#/ 0 #-a. C#-0( (u( #-a. O%d,% )PCO+ #2 Pa? 0(a- - !9B!6FN H" Th 0 O%d,% , $%,00.y %,$%#/,d a00,%( #-0 #2 -d,$,-d,- , by (h,0u$,% #% #u%(07 mmu- ,d (h, a ( #-0 #2 (h, u0u%$,%0 2%#m @ud a. %,/ ,37a-d %,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    50/59

    2 (h,y #-( -u, - #22 , (h, % %,a. #% a$$a%,-( a ?-#3.,d m,-( #2 (h,au(h#% (y #2 (h, -,3 %, m, 3 .. .#(h, ( 3 (h (h, /a.u,d $% , #2., ( ma y6 FN >" Wh,- 2a ,d 3 (h u0u%$a( #- #2 $#3,%7 3h,(h,% a @ud ,0h#u.d 0(ay #% %,0 - 0 a ma((,% #2 $,%0#-a. h# , 6 6 6 a ma((,% #2

    @ud a. #-0 ,- ,6 FN B" Ju0( ,0 F ,.d0,-d a-d #u- - Rh#d,0 a7

    FN 9" Ju0( ,0 *! B A-3a%u. a< a-d Ma%% - Pa? 0(a-7 FN 8H" a-d (h,,-( %, Su$%,m, C#u%( #2 F @ - !9B> FN 8!" , ,% 0,d (h 0 #$( #-6

    I- . h( #2 (h, 2u( . (y #2 a %u. - ad/,%0, (# (h, u0u%$,%07 (h, #$( #- #2%,0 - - ha0 0#m, ad/a-(a ,06 F %0(7 ( 0 -a.0 (h, 2 d,. (y #2 (h, @ud ,0 (#(h, #-0( (u( #- u-d,% 3h h (h,y h,.d #22 , a-d %, -2#% ,0 (h, (, h- a..yu-a00a .ab., $% - $., (ha( a #u%( 3h h d,% /,0 (0 , 0(,- , 2%#m a3% ((,- #-0( (u( #- a--#( /, ,22, ( (# a-y(h - (ha( 0 -#( .a3 3h,-

    @ud ,d by (ha( #-0( (u( #-6 FN 8 " S, #-d7 %,0 -a( #-0 3#u.d d,-y (h,u0u%$,%0 @ud a..y $%#-#u- ,d /a. d (y a-d ., ( ma y6 F -a..y7 %,0 -a( #-0a- 0,%/, a0 a- u-m 0(a?ab., 0 -a. (# (h, b#dy $#. ( (ha( (h, u0u%$,%0 ha/,

    #-, b,y#-d (h, .a3 a-d (ha( (h, $%,(,-0, #2 $%,0,%/ - (h, ., a. #%d,% 0 @u0( (ha(7 a-d #-, (# 3h h (h, @ud a%y 3 .. -#( b, a $a%(y6 FN 88"

    Th,0, ad/a-(a ,07 h#3,/,%7 a%, (,m$,%,d by 0#m, #-(%a%y #-0 d,%a( #-06F %0(7 %,0 -a( #- #2 #22 , 0 a h,a/y $,%0#-a. bu%d,- (# b, $.a ,d #- (h,

    @ud ,0 0 m$.y b, au0, (h, u0u%$,%0 ha/, -du. ,d - , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a.#-du (6 S, #-d7 ( 0 d#ub(2u. (ha( (h, b#dy $#. ( -,,d0 a d%a0( a ( . ?,%,0 -a( #- #2 @ud ,0 (# a.,%( (h,m (# (h, 2a ( (ha( (h, #u$ d',(a( 0, (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a.6 Th, %,0 -a( #-0 may 3,.. ,- #u%a , #(h,%0 (# d,2y (h,u0u%$,% %, m,7 bu( (h 0 2a ( 0h#u.d -#( #b. a(, @ud ,0 (# %,0 -7 *! 9 0 - ,,- #u%a - $#. ( a. a ( #- 0 -#( a $a%( #2 (h, @ud a. 2u- ( #-6 Th %d7%,0 -a( #- by @ud ,0 may add (# -0(ab . (y7 - %,a0, (h, . ?,. h##d #2d,/,.#$ - a-a% h a. ha#07 FN 84" a-d $%,@ud , (h, % $,a ,2u. (a0?0 #2

    $%#(, ( - (h, 2ab% #2 0# ,(y - ma -(a - - .a3 a-d #%d,%6 FN 8 "F#u%(h7 %,ma - - - #22 , 3 .. $%,/,-( (h, u0u%$,%0 2%#m $a ? - (h, #u%(03 (h 0ym$a(h,( a-d #% - #m$,(,-( @ud ,06 FN 8;" T# a..#3 (h, u0u%$,%0 a-#$$#%(u- (y (# a$$# -( @ud ,0 0ub0,%/ ,-( (# (h,m 3#u.d ha/, (3# -, a( /,%,0u.(0: )!+ a-y #-( -u - h, ? #- (h, #-du ( #2 (h, %, m, 3 .. b,,. m -a(,d1 a-d ) + #-2 d,- , #2 (h, ( ,-0 - (h, @ud a. 0y0(,m 3 ..,%#d,7 a-d #%d,%.y adm - 0(%a( #- #2 @u0( , 3 .. b, @,#$a%d ,d6

    Wh ., (h, ., ( ma y a-d /a. d (y #2 a %, m, b#%- #2 a 0u ,002u. #u$d',(a( 0 #u(0 d, (h, $u%/ ,3 #2 @ud a. d,(,%m -a( #-7 (h, @ud a%y %,(a -0(h, m$#%(a-( %#., #2 %,/ ,3 - (h, 2u- ( #- - #2 a u0u%$,% %, m,6 A#-0( (u( #-a. %u$(u%, d#,0 -#( m,a-7 $0# 2a (#7 u-2,((,%,d ., 0.a( /,a$a (y 2#% (h, , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. %, m,6 ,%,7 ( 0 ,00,-( a. (#d 0( - u 0h a #-0( (u( #-a. %u$(u%, 2%#m d 0 #-( -u (y #2 .a36 FN 8>"

    A #u$ d',(a( (y$ a..y 0u$$%,00,0 #-.y (ha( $a%( #2 a #-0( (u( #- (ha(d,a.0 3 (h $#. ( a. #% a-0 #2 (h, 0(a(,1 (h, %,0( #2 (h, #-0( (u( #- a-d (h,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    51/59

    .a% ,% ., a. 0y0(,m 0 , $%,00.y .,2( - $.a ,6 Wh,%, #u$0 d',(a( d# -#(d %, (.y a22, ( (h, @u% 0d ( #- #2 (h, #u%(07 #% 3h,- (h, #-( -ua( #- #2*!8H (h, -a(u%, a-d 0 #$, #2 @u% 0d ( #- 0 #-2 %m,d7 (h, #u%(0 (h,- %,ma -%,a(u%,0 #2 (h, $%,5%u$(u%, ., a. #%d,%7 a-d a-y 2#%ma. #-( -ua( #- -2#% , $%#/ 0 #-7 b, - m,%,.y d, .a%a(#%y - ha%a (,%7 d#,0 -#( ha- , (h,

    d,-( (y #% (h, @u% 0d ( #- #2 (h, #u%(06 FN 8B" Thu07 0 - , (h, @ud a%yma -(a -0 0#m, $#3,% (# #-(%#. (h, -,3 %, m,7 ( 0 m$#%(a-( (ha( (h, @ud ,0 %,ma - - #22 ,6

    E/,- 3h,%, (h, u0u%$,%0 %, #-0( (u(, (h, #u%(07 %,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    52/59

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    53/59

    ,., (#%a..y %%,0$#-0 b., a-d ha0 -# ,a%(h (# d%a3 0(%,- (h 2%#m6 FN "

    I- (h, a2(,%ma(h #2 a 0u ,002u. #u$7 a.. (h,0, #-0 d,%a( #-0 #m, -(# $.ay6 F %0(7 (h,%, 0 (h, 0(%a- ,-,00 #2 (h, 00u, a-d (0 -(%a (ab . (y (# $% - $.,d %,0#.u( #-6 A #u$ d',(a(7 by d,2 - ( #-7 0 a $#. ( a. ,/,-( -#(

    #-(,m$.a(,d by (h, #-0( (u( #- 3h h d,0(%#y0 (h, $%,5, 0( -#-0( (u( #-a. #%d,%6 I2 a #u%( d, d,0 (# $%# ,,d 3 (h ad@ud a( #- #2 (h,., a. (y #2 a #u$ d',(a(7 ( may , (h,% a$$.y (h, .a3 #2 (h, $%,5, 0( -#-0( (u( #- #% 0,,? , (%a5 #-0( (u( #-a. %u.,0 #2 d, 0 #-6 A-y a((,m$( (#

    @ud , (h, #u$ by (h, d (a(,0 #2 (h, d,0(%#y,d #-0( (u( #- %a 0,0-0( (u( #-a.7 (h,#%,( a.7 d# (% -a.7 a-d $%a ( a. $%#b.,m0 a0 d 0 u00,d -

    $a%( II6C6 I-0( (u( #-a..y7 (h, #u%( 0 2a ,d 3 (h a d .,mma 3h,(h,% ( 0 a#u%( u-d,% (h, #.d #-0( (u( #- #% #-, u-d,% (h, -,3 d, 2a (# ., a.#%d,%6 Th,#%,( a..y7 (h, #u%( 0 2a ,d 3 (h (h, m,(a5., a.

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    54/59

    h# , %,ma -0 @ud a. -#( , #2 -#(#% #u0 2a (06 D,(,%m - - 2a (0 - (h,m d0( #2 $#. ( a. u$h,a/a.0 a-d ha%a (,% - 0# #5$#. ( a. 0 (ua( #-0 a-dhuma- b,ha/ #% $a((,%-0 u-a00 0(,d by #$ - #-0 #2 d 0 -(,%,0(,d a-d (%a -,da-a.y0(0 0 a ha a%d#u0 (a0? - a-y #-(, (6 Th 0 b, #m,0 -, u0ab., 3h,-#u%(0 /,-(u%, a.#- (h 0 $a(h7 ?-#3 -

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    55/59

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    56/59

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    57/59

    ,22, ( /,-,00 a-d /a. d (y b, d 0( - u 0h,d6 FN >!" Th 0 0 a m,(a5., a.a00um$( #- ab#u( (h, %,.a( #-0h $ b,(3,,- 0# a. %,a. (y ),22 a y+ a-d/a. d (y )., a. (y+ #2 -#%m06 A0 a m,(a5., a. a00um$( #-7 ( 0 a/a .ab., (#(h, ., a. 0 h#.a%7 -#( (# a #u%( #2 .a36

    La0(.y7 (h,

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    58/59

  • 8/11/2019 2(II) Tayyab Mahmud. Jurisprudence of Successful Treason (2)

    59/59

    FNa!"6 A00 0(a-( P%#2,00#% #2 La37 C.,/,.a-d5Ma%0ha.. C#.., , #2 La36 6A6!9>87 U- /,%0 (y #2 Pu-@ab1 M6S 6 !9> 7 U- /,%0 (y #2 I0.amabad1 Ph6D6 !9B!7U- /,%0 (y #2 a3a 1 J6D6 !9B>7 U- /,%0 (y #2 Ca. 2#%- a7 a0( - 0 C#.., , #2 (h, La36 Th, %,0,a% h 2#% (h 0 A%( ., 3a0 0u$$#%(,d by a %a-( 2%#m (h,

    C.,/,.a-d5Ma%0ha.. Fu-d6 I 3 0h (# (ha-? my #..,a u,0 Da/ d R6 a%-h ,%7Pa(% a J6 Fa.?7 a-d Da/ d F6 F#%(, 2#% (h, % (h#u h(2u. #mm,-(0 #- a-,a%. ,% d%a2(6 R,ma - - 3,a?-,00,0 a%,7 #2 #u%0,7 my 0#., %,0$#-0 b . (y6