26093770 the Truth About Bihar

8/13/2019 26093770 the Truth About Bihar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/26093770-the-truth-about-bihar 1/10

The Truth About Bihar

From Tehelka Magazine, Vol 7, Issue 05, Dated February 06, 20 0

CURRENT AFFAIRS cover story

BIHARTry Me Now Society

!V!"#$%! I& '())I%* %ITI&+ -M(" T+! D!'(D!.& /I**!&TT"(%&F$"M!" VIJAY SIMHA (%D 1+$T$*"(1+!" VIJAY PANDEY M$T$"

('"$&& T+! "-**!D &T(T! T$ &%IFF (T T+! I%D& $F '+(%*!

BY THE time Omer Hejazeenwalked into the secretariat at

Patna, he was already cursingthe day he agreed to return toBihar. Months ago, he metBihar hie! Minister "itish#umar, who was $y thensearching !or %eo%le o! Bihariorigin to hel% him sa&e Bihar.

's Omer recalled, "itish #umarwas kind during the meetingand asked him to ha&e a look atBihar. (e%uty hie! Minister)ushil Modi too was in theroom. )omething a$out themanner in which they s%okeand looked at him made Omeragree to the tri%. *rom (u$ai hetook his + nd !light !or the year, and reached Patna.

The !irst sight o! Patna can hit hard. The city is a$out,- years old and had nurtured human thought and

%rogress !or se&eral centuries. /t was called Patali%utra then. "ow, there are !ar too many %eo%le onthe roads, and too much jostling and yelling. There are cycle0rickshaws e&erywhere, with %eo%le$ent low as they %ull the load in a mighty e!!ort. There is a musty smell. There1s a sense that the cityis straining. Too much has $een taken !rom them. Too little gi&en $ack. 2ood lord, thought Omer,nothing has changed. He had le!t Patna years ago and it was still the same.

He ste%%ed into the secretariat in dee% $lue trousers and jacket, shining $lack shoes, white shirt andred tie. He was sur%rised when he was sto%%ed and asked !or the %ur%ose o! his &isit. 34ow, /thought. They were controlling the crowds. /t was the !irst sign o! %ro!essionalism !or me. / lookedaround and saw no white or khadi,5 says Omer. He walked into the chie! minister1s cham$ers. 3/ toldhim / didn1t !ind any change in Bihar. "itish #umar looked at me and said he had not told the %eo%leo! Bihar anything. But, he said, he had made a commitment to himsel!. He would change Bihar. /twas the second time "itish #umar im%ressed me. / thought the man had guts,5 says Omer.

"/T/)H #6M'7 asked Omer what he could do !or Bihar. The chie! minister said there werethousands o! Bihari workers in the 2ul!. 3He asked me to think a$out what / could o!!er. He told meto %ick a sector and in&est,5 recalls Omer. ' day later, Omer had a %lan. There are a$out + ,Biharis who work as unskilled la$our in the 2ul! regiona!ter ha&ing com%leted school education. Omer thoughthe could %ro&ide &ocational training to such %eo%le8o!!er degrees in technical courses, so they could earnmore and li&e $etter.

Style guru Nitish Kumar held aCabinet meeting on this launch on theGanga

THE */7)T )/2HT O* P'T"' '"H/T H'7(. THE7E /) ' M6)TY)ME99. THE7E /) ' )E")E TH'TTHE /TY /) )T7'/"/"2

9'96 4') ' M'" O* THE PEOP9E, 'P7 (7E'M. HE 769E( BY /")T/" T.

"/T/)H /) ' B67E'6 7'T1) (7E'M.HE 769E) BY 7E')O"



Ha&ing a %lan in Bihar may mean little. *or it to $e acted u%on, you need land. 'nd land in Bihar is atale. /n +:;<, 9ord ornwallis was a%%ointed the 2o&ernor02eneral o! /ndia and ommander0 in0

hie! o! Bengal. He set a$out changing the judicial and re&enue systems in /ndia. Bihar, as %art o!eastern /ndia, was among the !irst areas ornwallis looked at. He introduced the Permanent)ettlement system, essentially retaining the then e=isting ownershi% o! land. He ga&e the owners, orzamindars, the right to collect ta= !rom the tenants on the land and %ass it on to the East /ndia

om%any.

The amount o! ta= was !i=ed.*or instance, a zamindar mayha&e %aid 7s + lakh !or anagreed num$er o! &illages ordistricts, !or decades. Thisresulted in a %ermanentsettlement $etween thezamindars and the East /ndia

om%any. O&er time, the land azamindar owned was di&ided

$etween his children and so itcarried on !or generations. Thestate $arely inter&ened.

"itish #umar tends to stay o!!land as well. )o, the state o!Bihar does not ac>uire land !or%ri&ate in&estors. /! Omer hadto set u% a technical educationhu$, he needed to $uy land.3"itish #umar had suggested /take o&er an /T/ ?/ndustrialTraining /nstitute@ and run it%ro!ita$ly. 4e went to

(ar$hanga ?north0central Bihar@and !ound that the teacherswere not %aid !or months. Themachines were e=%ensi&e andunused. /t looked like therewould $e %lenty o! hiccu%s inrunning an /T/. )o we thought,why don1t we set u% somethingon our ownA 4e registered a!amily trust and $egan to $uyland in (ar$hanga,5 says Omer.

9and holdings are not huge inthis %art o! Bihar. Thus, an

entre%reneur may need toengage with se&eral owners. /tis a tiresome %rocess and caneasily go wrong. 3One o! the!armers wanted 7s lakh more.He said he had to %ay hisdaughter1s dowry. This camea!ter we %aid him the agreedamount !or his land. /t washolding us u%. *inally, we ga&ehim the money,5 says Omer.E&entually, Omer says, his trust$ought acres at 7s +- lakh

an acre. This, in turn, createdcom%lications.

Phoenix rises Once a pariah forbusiness, Patna is now awash withconstruction

DIPANKARBHATTACHARYA, '1I 3M) *eneral &e4retary LALU’S 1 YEARS!ERE SYN"NYM"US!ITH STA#NATI"N$N"! THERE IS A

DECLINE IN BI# CRIME’



3Things are e=aggerated in small towns. There were two immediate e!!ects o! our $uying the land.*irst, %eo%le thought / ha&e a money tree. My %arents warned that / was now a %rime kidna%%ingtarget. 't !irst, we hired local security guards. But this caused me discom!ort. / hated the culture o!walking around with gun0toting guards. / ha&e seen %eo%le do this in '!rica and )ri 9anka. / ne&erliked it. / also had no %ri&acy. The guards heard e&erything / discussed. / got rid o! them and a%%lied!or a licence to carry a gun. The second e!!ect was an increase in land %rice. )oon a!ter we $oughtland, the %rice went u% to 7s +; lakh an acre,5 says Omer.

(ar$hanga is a des%erately %oor town. The lanes are !ilthy, the drains o&er!low, the roads arerickety, the uni&ersities are the size o! small go&ernment o!!ices and the jo$s are !ew. To reach his%ro%osed college o! technical education, Omer needed roads. /t is one thing to make %eo%le enrol ina college. To make them get there is another thing altogether. Omer has used his years outside/ndia well. He does %roductionin !ilms, tele&ision and radio. Hedoes %u$lic relations. He dealsin arms. /n (ar$hanga, he gotinto construction.

3/! / ha&e to come here, / ha&eto !eel com!orta$le. The roadsin (ar$hanga are &ery $ad. )owe registered a com%any againand started working on roadsand $uildings.5 Ok%et

onstruction C )er&ices P&t.9td., the new com%any, islaying + km o! road in a %art o!(ar$hanga with e=tremely %ooraccess. /t will cost Omer 7s +crore. He ho%es to make a%ro!it o! 7s crore !rom thisroad.

Portions o! (ar$hanga are$uzzing with acti&ity, o! whichOmer1s com%any is only a %art.The )tate is $uilding $ridgesand laying roads inside(ar$hanga, the entre is layingnational highways, and the %oorha&e something to do. *inally, ita%%ears, at least a %ortion o!Bihar is awake. Omer has gotso much at ease that he is alsogetting into !ood %rocessing. Heis e&en com!orta$le with ha&ing

to %ay what are &ariously called$ri$es or o!!ice e=%enses. 3/tworks out to +. - %er cent o!my e=%enses. /! it !acilitates my$illing and my work, / don1tmind. /n the 6'E, / ha&e to %aya huge testing !ee !or the roads.Here, an engineer comes e&enat night and does the testing. /tis only !air that he getssomething,5 says Omer. /n all,he says he has in&ested 7s crore o&er three years. /n time,

he ho%es to get it all $ack andsome.

Abandoned Kunwa Devi gets twokilos of coarse rice as daily wage,which she feeds her children !erhusband died of hunger last year

New & old " spanking new policestation built with private money

while policemen continue to live inhovels in old police stations



This is new Bihar, where the chie! minister talks to a $usinessman and things get started. learing%ro%osals !aster is one %art o! "itish #umar1s re!orm. The other $ig im%act is on law and order. Theroads in Patna are noisy and crowded till at least ;. %m most days. Many ignore the tra!!ic%oliceman or %olicewoman. Men tend to drink at roadside sho%s and kiosks, at times e&en during theday. Peo%le gather in grou%s to gossi% and discuss. The roads ha&e $ecome a %lace to just $e. Thisenrages dri&ers who ha&e to s>ueeze through narrower%aths, honking their way through. *or the momentthough, they are not com%laining. They are just ha%%yto $e there. The locals say the roads used to em%ty atsunset in the %ast. 'nyone out a!ter that was !air game!or looting, snatching and kidna%%ing. They say %eo%lereturning to Patna $y train or $us would s%end the nightat the railway station or $us station i! they arri&ed a!ter+ %m and reach home the ne=t morning.

"O4, THE7E is a sense o! relie!. )ome !amilies e&encatch the D%m mo&ie show. Mona inema, considered the $est theatre in Bihar at the moment,draws a$out a hundred %eo%le !or the late night show e&en on some weekdays. )ome o! them are

!amilies. The !ilm world is, there!ore, ha%%y. Prakash ha, !ilmmaker and entre%reneur, is making $igmo&es. ha has esta$lished his credentials with !ilms like Damul, *angaa al and ( aharan He is%utting together what he says is Bihar1s !irst multi%le= mall, the PCM Mall, in the heart o! Patna1sPatali%utra industrial estate. The mall is coming u% where sick units lay earlier. /t is e=%ected to $eready $y March this year, well in time the %remiere o! ha1s new !ilm "a neeti

THE M'99 has !i&e !loors with -D sho%s. /t will ha&e !our cinemas, each seating a$out a thousand.4hen o%erational, the multi%le= mall could ha&e +, %eo%le going home !rom the mo&ies e&erymidnight. /t should $e >uite a sight on the roads o! Patna. 't the moment, - la$ourers work here aday. 4hen ready, the mall could em%loy many more and trigger a $uzz in Patna. /n size, the PCMMall is roughly the same as the %arking lot in south (elhi1s )elect itywalk Mall. But !or Patna, it is$ig.

)ays haF 3/t has taken !our and a hal! years to re&erse the regression o! se&eral years. "ow, we aregetting a $etter en&ironment !or in&estment. But, %ri&ate industry will not ha%%en o&ernight when youha&e $etter o%%ortunities in Maharashtra, 'ndhra Pradesh, 2ujarat or Tamil "adu.3The mindset must change. /! Biharis don1t $uy $ack into Bihar, why will othersA My idea o! %olitics islinked strongly with the economy. 4ealth generation is the only thing that can iron out caste andclass. / am doing my $it. '%art !rom the mall, / am starting Bihar1s !irst !ully indigenous tele&isionchannel, Maurya TG, with %roduction entirely in Patna.5

The !ilmmaker comes !rom Bettiah, the head>uarters o! 4est ham%aran district near the $orderwith "e%al. Bettiah was notorious as the kidna%%ing ca%ital o! Bihar. 3"ow,5 he says, 3kidna%%ing isgone8 !inished. The law is getting a!ter the $ig cul%rits. "itish has done a great clean0u% jo$.5

Bhoj%uri !ilmstars 7a&i #ishanand Manoj Tiwari are ha%%y aswell. #ishan, who has acted in++ !ilms, many in Hindi, isworking on the cultclassic De das in Bhoj%uri, setin Patna. He is also lo$$ying !ora !ilm city close to Patna. 34ecouldn1t tra&el !or shooting atnight in the %ast in Bihar. /tused to scare %eo%le. "ow, thestate is $reathing. /t waschoked !or a long time. You cansee cou%les at the mo&ies a!ter;%m. There is a %ositi&e energynow. Earlier, Biharis were seen as criminals and du!!ers. "ow, it is our turn. The in&estors arecoming. 9ocal actors !rom Patna and elsewhere are $ooked with me in Bhoj%uri !ilms e&ery year. 4eused to o%erate !rom Mum$ai $ut now / can assure the state o! $usiness i! they gi&e us a !ilm city. '

MCH""NEE, Mauritian+igh 'ommissioner MAURITIUS IS ANE%TENDED LE# "&BIHAR$ PE"PLE&R"M BIHAR ANDUTTAR PRADESH ARE RUNNIN#MAURITIUS’

Night out Once deserted aftersundown, Patna now has crowds atlate night movie shows



hundred Bhoj%uri !ilms will $e made a year,5 says#ishan.

Tiwari, who also sings, says the Bihar go&ernment didnot res%ect artistes in the %ast. 3/ used to get calls !rom

ministers in the %re&ious go&ernment to %er!orm. Theywould terrorise us. riminals associated with %olitical%arties and the go&ernment also used to call. / wasa!raid o! getting hurt. )o, / used to %er!orm !or them."ow, i! the secretariat calls, they ask us !or our !ee and re>uirements. 'lso, location is now grantedon %riority !or shooting and the %olice %ro&ide security,5 says Tiwari.

"itish #umar is too canny to miss the signs. He senses that the mood could $e in his !a&our and it is$eginning to show in his walk and talk. He is Mr Bihar now and he lo&es it. He calls a ca$inetmeeting on $oard a shi% in the 2anga, and the local media la%s it u%. He holds cam%s in &arious%arts o! the state, during which time he also chairs a ca$inet meeting on site, and the %eo%lea%%laud. He $elie&es he is heading the $iggest reconstruction story in /ndia. He also $elie&es he isright. He is $eginning to ac>uire the same sel!0righteousness that 9alu Prasad Yada& once had. /tled 9alu into a world o! his own where he did no wrong. Bihar went into the dark ages $ut 9alu sawthe re&erse in his mind.E&eryone in Bihar has an o%inion on e&erything. They are asserti&e and di!!icult to dislodge !rom the%ositions they hold. /t is a curious trait o! Bihar, %ossi$ly /ndia1s most %olitically conscious state. Yet,when it comes to go&ernance, Bihar tends to idolise a man at the to% and make him think he isa$o&e the crowd. 9alu was king once. "itish is now. 9alu was a man o! the %eo%le, a P7 man1sdream. He could connect. He ruled $y instinct. He knew the &alue o! gesture. "itish is a $ureaucrat1sdream. He can %er!orm. He rules $y reason. He knows the &alue o! deli&ery.

/T /) not all hunky dory, howe&er. Most o! the $uzz is $eing generated !rom a km $elt aroundPatna. Beyond that, li!e can $e cruel. "iranjan Paswan is the 2aya district secretary o! the P/0M9?9i$eration@, a 9e!t %arty that once o%erated as a guerrilla unit. 2aya is Bihar1s second $iggest towna!ter Patna. /t also has an air%ort, which largely caters to the tourists who !lock to Bodh 2aya, wherethe Buddha is $elie&ed to ha&e attained enlightenment. Paswan sits in an o!!ice co&ered $y as$estos

sheets. ' tele&ision set sits on $ricks. 4ooden %oles su%%ort the entire structure. Paswan1s wi!e andson also work in the same o!!ice !or the %arty. He deals mostly with the rural %oor, argua$ly the worsto!! in Bihar. 4orking among the de%ri&ed, Paswan sees little change in Bihar. 3/t is a routine with us.4e hear o! %eo%le dying o! hunger, we &isit them, we make a noise, and the administration saysthey died o! disease. Please tell me where the change is,5 he says.

2ajichak &illage in 2aya1s (o$hi $lock seems to $e a century $ehind Patna. /t is a$out noon on a)unday and a $oy is stu!!ing what a%%ears to $e the hind %ortion o! a dead goat. Only the skinremains, with the hind legs dangling. There is no !lesh. The $oy care!ully stu!!s the carcass with hay.He then gets a !ire going. He is joined $y a !ew other children. 3He will cook it now,5 says Paswan.

'%%arently, the !ire will $urn the hair on the goat skinand roast it !rom the outside. The hay inside, used !orthe stu!!ing, will catch !ire and cook the skin !rom theinside. This will $e the )unday meal. 'nywhere else,

the skin would $e chucked as waste. Here, it is adelicacy.

#unwa (e&i, who li&es in the same &illage, has !our childrenF three girls and a $oy. )he says she is- years old. Her hus$and used to work in a near$y !arm. /n May D he died, a%%arently o!

hunger. #unwa (e&i says her hus$and de&elo%ed a !e&er, which the local >uack said was malaria.There was no money !or medicines, so some o! the &illage !olk %ooled money !or the medicines.They ran out o! the medicine e&entually. 'lso, there was &ery little !ood in the house when herhus$and couldn1t work $ecause he was ill. )he says her hus$and sto%%ed eating so that the childrencould eat. 34e used to get grass !rom the jungle to !eed him. /t was not enough,5 she says.

"MERHEJA'EEN, %on3"esident /ihari I& I HAVE T" C"MET" BIHAR, I HAVET" &EELC"M&"RTABLE$

S", I STARTED A C"MPANY T"BUILD R"ADS’

/T /) "OO" /" 2'Y'. ' BOY )T6**) ' (E'( 2O'T 4/TH H'Y '"(B67") /T. THE7E /) O"9Y )#/", "O

*9E)H. YET *O7 H/M, /T1) '(E9/ ' Y



Paswan says #unwa (e&i1shus$and died o! hunger. Theadministration says he died o!illness. The !amily li&es in ahutment with three small rooms.There are just the walls and a!ew &essels. There is a small$ag o! coarse rice, which shesays she gets as daily wageswhen she works in a !arm. )hegets no money, she says. )hehas just !ed the children withthe rice and the gruel that!ormed while the rice wascooked. )he cannot see withher le!t eye. )he says a $ranch%ierced her eye. "o one in her !amily uses !ootwear. The children1s hair is matted. They ha&en1t hada $ath !or days.

Paswan1s $oss, (i%ankar Bhattacharya, 2eneral )ecretary o! the P/M9 ?9i$eration@, is in his Patnao!!ice. Most %olitical %arties in Bihar ha&e their head>uarters on the same road, Gir hand PatelPath, and the P/0M9 is a neigh$our o! the Bharatiya anata Party. There is a maze o! wireshanging !rom a %lug %oint, a la%to% waits on the ta$le and there is a $on!ire going. There is a suddenshar% drizzle $e!ore Bhattacharya comes. His wi!e and daughter are in 9ondon, and he s%ends hisli!e !ighting !or $etterment in the li&es o! the rural %oor and the most economically $ackward o! Bihar.He has $een general secretary !or ++ years. His %arty has !i&e mem$ers in the legislati&e assem$ly.

3/t will $e wrong to say there has $een no change in !i&e years. 9alu1s +-0year reign wassynonymous with a$solute stagnation. There is a decline in $ig crime. )ome sort o! a nationalisationo! crime has taken %lace. The $ig criminals are earningas much through trans%ort. /! you ha&e the state1sco!!ers o%en to you, why would you loot and kidna%A

'lso, the discourse has changed. /t has mo&ed !romsocial justice and dignity to good go&ernance andgrowth,5 says Bhattacharya.

3But, there is a $ig %ro$lem. *eudal Bihar is a stu$$ornsur&i&or. The go&ernment will %retend to do land re!orm$ut will sit on actual re!orm. )ocially, there is &ery little%rogress. hange is not !ree. You ha&e to %ay a $ig %rice. *or a small change, there has to $e a $ig!ight.5

) HO9'7) '"( academics !ind the hy%e o&er Bihar1s growth $a!!ling. "# haudhary, Pro!essor inPatna 6ni&ersity1s (e%artment o! Economics, is gra%%ling with a sudden teacher1s strike in theuni&ersity. 3 an you imagine a strike anywhere whose sole demand is %ayment o! salaries on timeA5he says. 9ike many in Bihar, haudhary is %er%le=ed at the ++. %er cent growth !igure !or Biharreleased $y the entral )tatistical Organisation in "ew (elhi early anuary. The !igures made%eo%le look at Bihar anew and generated a $ig $uzz. Peo%le $egan to com%are Bihar with 2ujarat,which haudhary says is ingenious.

3The growth may not $e real $ecause Bihar is not a miracle economy. The $asis o! the !igures isalso weakened a!ter Prona$ )en, hie! )tatistician o! /ndia, said it was wrong to attri$ute the !iguresto the )O. Much o! the hy%e created $y "itish then !alls !lat. /t is too good to $elie&e. 'll o! asudden you tell a $eggar you are a rich man. /! your $ase is low, e&en a little !orward mo&ement will$e $ig,5 says haudhary.

haudhary says Bihar may $e shining !or a !ew, $ut !or the rest, Bihar is sinking. He lists theim%ro&ementsF in health, law and order, and roads. He lists the non0im%ro&ementsF a $ureaucracythat has su%reme %ower in a democracy, no rule o! law, no land re!orm, no water resourcemanagement, no %ro%er !aculty in higher education, increase in scale o! corru%tion $ecause o! more

!unds !low, no action against $ureaucrats !or gra!t, and distress migration.

Selling roots Nitish Kumar alsowants to boost religious tourism andethnic pride

/* 26 '7'T H'( )T'7TE( *7OMTHE )'ME B')E ') B/H'7, /T4O69( H'GE PE7 E"T27O4TH. B6T "O4, THE7E /)OPT/M/)M



B/H'7 H') not !ound %anacea. /! 2ujarat were to start!rom the same $ase as Bihar, it would %ro$a$ly register

%er cent growth. /t is di!!icult to s%ot a !unctioningstate in Bihar o&er the %ast < years. "ot a single newarea has $een de&elo%ed !rom the %re0/nde%endence%eriod in Bihar. There is no history o! entre%reneurshi%!or at least three generations. There is no renaissancein Bihar, now or in the %ast. There is no nan%ith 'wardwinner in Bihar. There is &irtually no cor%orate %resence. The e=tent o! ine>uity is high. 'nd yet,there is a sense o! o%timism. /t raises the %ossi$ility that Bihar may attem%t the long haul honestlythis time.

)hai$al 2u%ta, Mem$er0)ecretary o! the 'sian (e&elo%ment 7esearch /nstitute, a leading think0tankin Patna, thinks there is signi!icance in recent e&ents. 34hy is "itish #umar im%ortantA He is the !irstchie! minister o! Bihar to take cognisance o! the a$sence o! the state in the state. He has succeededmarginally in the mammoth task o! $uilding state structures. He was the !irst to set u% an

'dministrati&e 7e!orms ommission. He was the !irst to set u% a 9and 7e!orms ommission. He isstarting !rom scratch. He is creating an atmos%here where the Prakash has can !lourish,5 says2u%ta. He says what ha%%ens in Bihar now is critical $ecause in two years, 3Each o! the < districtsin /ndia will ha&e a Bihari (istrict Magistrate or )u%erintendent o! Police5. 3Bihar has mo&ed !rom aItouch0me0not1 society to a Itry0me0now1 society. This is a $enchmark !or a resistant state.5

Brand Bihar is also getting noticed $ecause o! the Bihar *oundation. O%erating under the statego&ernment, the *oundation works on a sim%le $rie! o! I$onding and $randing1. /t $onds $y creatingcha%ters in &arious cities in /ndia and outside. The newest cha%ter is in Bengaluru and there arecha%ters in Mum$ai, (elhi, hennai and #olkata, andin (u$ai, (oha and )outh #orea outside /ndia. Thecha%ters think a$out what a!!ects Biharis in their areas,and hel%s non0resident Biharis trace their roots and dosomething !or where they came !rom.

The theory o! roots is a %ower!ul conce%t. /t can make strong men and women yearn !or memories

as children. O!ten, this yearning can take the sha%e o! catharsis. Mookhesswur hoonee isMauritius1 High ommissioner to /ndia. He gets astonishingly sentimental when it comes to Bihar. Hedescri$es Mauritius as an 3e=tended leg o! Bihar5. He says he is %roud to see how Bihar has%rogressed. 3Peo%le o!ten ask me are you the high commissioner o! Bihar,5 he says. hoonee saysthe %rime minister o! Mauritius 3$elongs to Bihar5 and that 3%eo%le !rom Bihar and 6ttar Pradesh arerunning Mauritius5.

'nil #umar Bachoo, Mauritius1 Minister o! Pu$lic /n!rastructure, 9and Trans%ort, and )hi%%ing, canget touchier a$out Bihar. 3/n the +D: s, / was a student in (elhi. My seniors told me not to interactwith anyone !rom Bihar $ecause they are $ackward and cannot rise in li!e. 4ell, a !ew weeks ago,my %rime minister told me to go and get some Biharis to Mauritius. 4e ha&e retained in Mauritiuswhat they ha&e lost in Bihar. Mauritius is a little Bihar. 4hen they catch cold in Bihar, we sneeze inMauritius. 4e are %roud o! our roots. Bihar was the !ount o! ci&ilisation. /t is the torch$earer o! /ndiain !uture,5 says Bachoo.

That may take some doing, $ut there are nuggets that suggest that res%ect !or honesty and hardwork may yet sa&e Bihar. 7akesh )harma is a $usinessman who rents out a community centre indowntown Patna !or marriages and runs a cooking gas agency. The community centre can host ama=imum o! a thousand guests in com!ort. 3/n "o&em$er0 (ecem$er D, we used litres diesel!or the generator during %ower cuts. /n ;, we needed litres.5

These are the %arts o! the whole that "itish #umar ho%es to $uild o! a new Bihar. *or too long, thestate o! Bihar has not deli&ered. This is rock $ottom. /t1s a good %lace to start.

!RITER’S EMAIL&ijsimhaJgmail.com


PRAKASHJHA, Filmmaker andentre reneur THE MINDSET MUSTCHAN#E$ I& BIHARISD"N’T BUY BACK

INT" BIHAR, !HY!ILL THE "THERS(’

B7'"( B/H'7 /) 2ETT/"2 "OT/ E(BE '6)E O* THE B/H'7*O6"('T/O". /T BO"() TH7O62H

H'PTE7) /" /"(/' '"( O6T)/(E

mailto:[email protected]

mailto:[email protected]




CURRENT AFFAIRS cover story

)I Do*’t H+ e A Switc- T-+t I C+* Pre.. A*/ M+0eT-i* . H+22e*’It is ele4tion year 8or /ihar and 'hie8 Minister %itish umar is 8eeling 4om8ortable The big it4h 8orhim is the 9ork ethi4 he brings to /ihar and its e88e4t +ere, he e: lains ho9 /ihar is going about thebig three ; in estment, edu4ation and hunger ; and 9hy he thinks the 'entre may not be toohel 8ul

H3* er i* Bi-+r i. too 4+.ic +* i..3e to 4e 0e2t +.i/e$ !e .+w + 5+6i7ycoo0i* +*/ e+ti* t-e .0i* o5 + o+t$ How 7o* wi77 yo3 t+0e to re+c-t-i. Bi-+r( There is great %o&erty in Bihar. More %eo%le li&e $elow the %o&erty line here

than what the entral go&ernment claims. 4e ha&e made our assessmentand it shows +. crore destitute in Bihar. The entre says there are <- lakh%eo%le $elow the %o&erty line in Bihar. /! we ha&e to reach the hungry, the$iggest thing is to ha&e clarity on %o&erty.

So, -ow 7o* 4e5ore t-e .t+r i* et 5oo/(9et me e=%lain how it works. Our teams go $y names in the list o! !amilies$elow the %o&erty line. 4e say +. crore names must $e on the list. The

entre says there are <- lakh %eo%le. How can / reach these %eo%le whenwe cannot agree on how many destitute there areA The states don1t run theP(). /t all de%ends on the entral go&ernment. /! the %oor are to getsu$sidised !ood so they don1t eat animal skin, we must agree on who toreach. 4e are the su!!erers. / wrote to the entre on a !ood security law.

/ told them to identi!y the BP9 !amilies i! they are not satis!ied with our sur&eys. But, it cannot $e thatthe entre takes the credit !or a !ood security law and we get the a$uses $ecause %eo%le say theirnames are not on the list o! BP9 !amilies.

&re.- i* e.t6e*t c+* i*53.e 7i5e i*to +* 3*/er/e e7o2e/ eco*o6y$ Bi-+r i. 6+0i* + .erio3.2itc- 43t t-e 4i i* e.tor. /o*’t .ee6 to 4e co6i* $ !-y i. t-i. .o( Big in&estors are interested in two areas in BiharF thermal %ower and ethanol. Thermal %ower %lantscannot come u% without coal. oal needs water and water is a state issue. But now, they ha&estarted a new system o! seeking clearance !rom the central water resources ministry. This ministryhas said that the 2anga $asin water will not $e a&aila$le !or coal. /n Bihar, there is only the 2anga$asin. 4hat else is thereA

/! they o$ject to water !or thermal %lants, how can in&estments comeA 9ikewise, the %ro%osal tomake ethanol !rom sugarcane is %ending with the entre since :. Things are not mo&ing$ecause o! the entre.

I* e.tor. .+y 7+*/ i. + 2ro47e6 i* Bi-+r$ T-ey +7.o .+y yo3 +re too c+3tio3. + c-ie5 6i*i.terto -e72$4hy should / ac>uire land !or themA 4e are ac>uiring land !or roads, railways and $ridges. 4e areo!!ering hea&y com%ensation !or that. 4e are ac>uiring !ar more land now than in the %ast !or %u$lic%ur%oses. 's !ar as %ri&ate in&estors are concerned, we ask them to negotiate on their own. /! weget into the %icture, there will $e two issues. One, the land cost will $e more $ecause we ac>uirea!ter %aying a he!ty com%ensation. There!ore, our land will include the charges we %ay !or ac>uiringand the de&elo%ment cost. )econdly, we can only o!!er land on lease. /! the %ri&ate in&estorsnegotiate on their own, they can get the land title on their name. Besides, K4estL Bengal is ne=t door.Ha&en1t "andigram and )ingur ha%%ened thereA You may ha&e met the window sho%%ers, who arenot really interested. They look !or ali$is. "o real in&estor has asked us to ac>uire land. Only thenon0serious in&estors are com%laining.

E/3c+tio* i. +*ot-er 2ri6+ry i..3e$ Yo3 rew 32 +. + c-i7/ i* Bi-+r$ How i. it /i55ere*t 5orc-i7/re* *ow( The $iggest change is that we are sending children to school. There were - lakh children out o!



school when we came to %ower. "ow, that !igure has come down to less than eight lakh. The secondchange is that we are trying to o!!er them >uality education once they are in school so thatattendance im%ro&es. 4e must ha&e good midday meals and good teachers to im%ro&e attendance.)o, we are !ocusing on teacher training and management o! midday meals. 4e ha&e just $eguntraining , teachers with the hel% o! /2"O6. You must remem$er that / don1t ha&e a switch that/ can %ress and make things ha%%en. 4e can only tackle things one $y one.

Things are $etter than in the %ast, $ut we ha&e to do !ar more. 4e ha&e $een success!ul in gettinggirls into schools $y gi&ing them school dresses and money. 4e $egan gi&ing $icycles to highschool students, $oys and girls. 'll students $etween lasses and - are gi&en 7s - a year,whiche&er community they come !rom, !or school uni!orm.

"*ce i* .c-oo7, t-e i*te77i e*ce 7e e7. o5 c-i7/re* 4eco6e + 5+ctor$ T-ere +22e+r. to 4e + 7+c0o5 i*te77ect3+7 c+2+city i* Bi-+r to/+y$ This is not a Bihar0centric %ro$lem. You will !ind it elsewhere also. The whole country lacksintellectual de%th. But, the children o! Bihar are ahead o! others in learning languages and math. /1dlike to remind you that we ha&e only now $egun to work in Bihar. Peo%le had lost the ha$it o!working. "ow, they are starting to work again. )o, don1t look !or solutions e&erywhere. You can1t dothird and !ourth stage e&aluation now.

Our %riority was to see that no children stay out o! school. 4e ha&e o%ened +-, new schools andrecruited two lakh teachers. Yet, there are eight lakh children still out o! school. 4e !ound that !i&elakh are either !rom Maha (alit !amilies or !rom the Muslim community. They need s%ecial care.

4e ha&e o%ened centres where we kee% these children and %re%are them !or school. 'll thisre>uires constant e!!ort. There was no e!!ort all these years. /t has only $egun now.

T-e 4r+*/i* o5 Bi-+r +22e+r. to 4e etti* .tro* er o3t.i/e I*/i+$ Are yo3 o2e*i* 32 Bi-+rto M+3riti3.( I. t-i. + *ew tre*/ 5or Bi-+r, tyi* 32 wit- + 5orei * co3*try(4e are doing a lot with Mauritius. They will ha&e a consulate here. 4e are willing to %ro&ide landand they are willing to o%en an o!!ice. lose to hal! the %eo%le in Mauritius are o! Bihari origin. / ha&etold the central go&ernment all this. The E=ternal '!!airs Ministry now has to take the initiati&e with%rotocol.

How wi77 it 27+y o3t(Peo%le !rom Mauritius want to trace their roots. 4e are ready to hel% them. The Mauritius PrimeMinister came here and o%ened schools and hos%itals.

&+6i7y 27+y. + /i.2ro2ortio*+te ro7e i* I*/i+* 2o7itic.$ T-e w+y yo3 /e+7 wit- 5+6i7y i./i55ere*t 5ro6 6+*y ot-er 2o7itici+*.$ How /oe. it wor0 wit- yo3(E&eryone has their way o! looking at !amily and %olitics. / am also a %er!ect !amily man $ut what hasthat got to do with anythingA 4hen you get into %olitics, you must treat e&eryone as a !amilymem$er. There isn1t a human $eing on earth without a !amily. But how does that matterA 4e ha&e to$e !aith!ul to the duty and the o%%ortunity we ha&e got. / think many %eo%le ha&e a sense o!insecurity. They !eel they will $e secure only i! their !amily gets em%owered. / ha&e no insecurity. /know death is imminent in e&ery$ody1s li!e. 4hy get insecureA


)Di/ I E+t U2 Bi-+r Li0e Ter6ite(’%ight 8alls early in 1atna these days and there.s a biting 9ind as 9ell )alu 1rasad, the man 9hosaid he 9ould be rime minister one day, is 9earing thermals and a heran This is the o88i4ialresiden4e o8 the )eader o8 the $ osition o8 /ihar (ssembly and the name late sho9s his 9i8e,"abri De i.s name There.s a bon8ire going in the 4ourtyard and an attendant is busy gi ing )alu a

edi4ure <The 8eet get hard,= he says

(nother attendant is busy rubbing toba44o on his alm 8or )alu.s ne:t 8i: ( third attendant is4lut4hing a hand8ul o8 a ers, hoto4o ies o8 data to rubbish %itish umar.s 4laims o8 gro9th )aluis still a natural, trans8orming the moment he sees a 4ro9d

/ut, there.s a sense that this year.s /ihar ele4tion may be a huge test There 9ere about >00



eo le 8or his Makar &ankranti lun4h o8 4urd, 8lattened ri4e, otato 4urry and a s9eet made o8sesame seeds and sugar That is 8ar 8e9er than 9hen he lorded o er /ihar +e ans9ers a 8e9?uestions

!-+t’. yo3r t+0e o* t-e rowt- o5 Bi-+r 3*/er Niti.- K36+r(The )O ? entral )tatistical Organisation@ has retracted the growth!igures that you re!er to. How can you com%are Bihar to 2ujaratwhen the agriculture sector, the %rinci%al acti&ity in Bihar, has $een%er!orming negati&ely !or three o! the %ast !i&e yearsA an yougrow o&ernightA / am not a child. / ha&e $een in %ower !or +- years.(on1t / know how things are doneA

I. it +* i773.io* t-e*((oes "itish #umar ha&e a magic wand that he can wa&e andtrans!orm e&erythingA /t seems that Manmohan )ingh and BarackO$ama should learn !rom "itish #umar. "itish must $e gi&en the"o$el Prize, it a%%ears. The growth story is an illusion created $ymedia and go&ernment hy%e. /t will take a long time in Bihar. 4eare not dealing with !airytales.

!-+t +4o3t yo3( Yo3 -+/ 1 ye+r.$Bihar is a com%le= state where you ha&e to know how to takee&eryone along. / tolerated humiliation. / went to %rison. They said / had swallowed !odder. (id / eatu% Bihar like a termiteA / ga&e dignity to the des%erately %oor. / did all that / could as railwayminister. "ow, they want to run down e&erything / did. 9et them...

Niti.- +22e+r. to -+ e 7e+r*e/ 5ro6 yo3r e82erie*ce$ "itish #umar is a toy in the hands o! the u%%er castes. /t takes a lot to run Bihar. "itish will alsolearn. / am the &oice o! the $roken and the destitute. You ha&e seen, at the lunch, the kind o!%eo%le who come to me. 4ho else will treat them with res%ectA 9alu is not done.

!-+t *ow(4e will hit the streets. 4e will hold the go&ernment, $oth at the state and the entre, accounta$le!or the %rice rise. You will see what 9alu is made o!. You will see how hollow the claims o! growthare.


26093770 the Truth About Bihar

Documents

Transcript of 26093770 the Truth About Bihar