21 - Antifreezing admixturesdownload.xuebalib.com/xuebalib.com.45704.pdfadmixture, it was possible...

7
Antifreezing admixtures 21 P.-C. Aïtcin Université de Sherbrooke, QC, Canada 21.1 Introduction Despite the fact that antifreeze admixtures are currently used in Russia, Finland, Poland and China for placing concrete without any special protection under temperature as low as 15 C, antifreeze admixtures are not used in Canada, Alaska and the northern parts of the United States, or elsewhere in Europe (besides Finland and Poland). Presently in Finland, it is possible to buy on the market prepacked sacks of concrete and mortars in which an appropriate dosage of calcium nitrite has been included. These prepacked mix- tures can be used under temperatures as low as 10 C without any special protection against such a very low temperature. Very little English literature can be found on the subject except one comprehensive article written by Ratinov and Rozenberg in Rama- chandrans book on concrete admixtures (Ramachandran, 1995). The basic idea of using an antifreeze admixture is very simple: it consists of incor- porating in the mixer a soluble salt that lowers the freezing temperature of water. Lowering the freezing temperature of water by adding a soluble salt is a well- known phenomenon. Fahrenheit used it when he selected the origin of his temperature scale: The temperature 0 F corresponds to the minimum temperature at which a satu- rated solution of calcium chloride freezes. Seawater freezes around 1.8 C according to its salinity. 21.2 Winter concreting in North America When facing the rst low temperature at the beginning of winter season, Canadian concrete producers start to heat the mixing water in order to increase the temperature of the fresh concrete. As the temperature continues to decrease, they start heating the coarse aggregates and the sand with steam. In the eld, when night temperature is decreasing close to 0 C, contractors protect the freshly poured concrete with insulating blankets. When it freezes harder, they build temporary polyethylene heated shelters to protect concrete against freezing. Of course, there is a price associated to the application of all these measures: on average, they charge 25% more for winter concreting. When the ambient temperature is lower than 10 C in Canada, concrete is deliv- ered only for inside applications. At 15 C, ready-mix plants stop producing concrete until the ambient temperature goes up. Currently, antifreeze admixtures are not used at all in Canada. Science and Technology of Concrete Admixtures. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-100693-1.00021-7 Copyright © 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Transcript of 21 - Antifreezing admixturesdownload.xuebalib.com/xuebalib.com.45704.pdfadmixture, it was possible...

  • Antifreezing admixtures 21P.-C. AïtcinUniversité de Sherbrooke, QC, Canada

    21.1 Introduction

    Despite the fact that antifreeze admixtures are currently used in Russia, Finland, Polandand China for placing concrete without any special protection under temperature as lowas �15 �C, antifreeze admixtures are not used in Canada, Alaska and the northern partsof the United States, or elsewhere in Europe (besides Finland and Poland). Presently inFinland, it is possible to buy on the market prepacked sacks of concrete and mortars inwhich an appropriate dosage of calcium nitrite has been included. These prepacked mix-tures can be used under temperatures as low as �10 �C without any special protectionagainst such a very low temperature. Very little English literature can be found on thesubject except one comprehensive article written by Ratinov and Rozenberg in Rama-chandran’s book on concrete admixtures (Ramachandran, 1995).

    The basic idea of using an antifreeze admixture is very simple: it consists of incor-porating in the mixer a soluble salt that lowers the freezing temperature of water.Lowering the freezing temperature of water by adding a soluble salt is a well-known phenomenon. Fahrenheit used it when he selected the origin of his temperaturescale: The temperature 0 �F corresponds to the minimum temperature at which a satu-rated solution of calcium chloride freezes. Seawater freezes around�1.8 �C accordingto its salinity.

    21.2 Winter concreting in North America

    When facing the first low temperature at the beginning of winter season, Canadianconcrete producers start to heat the mixing water in order to increase the temperatureof the fresh concrete. As the temperature continues to decrease, they start heating thecoarse aggregates and the sand with steam.

    In the field, when night temperature is decreasing close to 0 �C, contractors protectthe freshly poured concrete with insulating blankets. When it freezes harder, they buildtemporary polyethylene heated shelters to protect concrete against freezing. Of course,there is a price associated to the application of all these measures: on average, theycharge 25% more for winter concreting.

    When the ambient temperature is lower than �10 �C in Canada, concrete is deliv-ered only for inside applications. At�15 �C, ready-mix plants stop producing concreteuntil the ambient temperature goes up. Currently, antifreeze admixtures are not used atall in Canada.

    Science and Technology of Concrete Admixtures. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-100693-1.00021-7Copyright © 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-100693-1.00021-7

  • 21.3 Antifreeze admixtures

    According to Ratinov and Rosenberg, nitrites, nitrates, calcium chloride, sodium chlo-ride, ammonia, etc. have been used as antifreeze admixtures in Russia (Ramachandran,1995). Usually, a combination of some of these chemicals is used. In practice, the mostpopular formulations are the ones based on nitrites. In China and Finland, a mixture ofsodium nitrite (NaNO2) and sodium sulphate (Na2 SO4) is used, as well as a mixture ofsodium nitrate and calcium nitrite, Ca(NO2)2. Pedro Hernandez (1989), during hismaster’s thesis, used essentially calcium nitrite as an antifreeze admixture.

    As calcium nitrite is currently available in North America to provide an additionalprotection against the corrosion of reinforcing bars, the use of calcium nitrite as anantifreeze admixture should become an interesting alternative for winter concreting.Of course, the dosage of calcium nitrite that has to be added as an antifreeze admixtureis much higher than the one used as a corrosion inhibitor. A saturated solution ofCa(NO2)2 freezes at a temperature of about �20 �C.

    21.4 The construction of high-voltage power lines in theCanadian North

    The anchors of the power lines erected in the Canadian North could benefit fromthis technology. In the Canadian North, high-voltage power lines are erected inwinter because it is very easy to transport on the snow all the materials neededto erect the lines as well as the personnel. The frozen rivers and lakes are no longerobstacles for the progression of the construction of the lines. The only negativepoint is that the rock in which the anchors have to be fixed is totally or partiallyfrozen, depending on the latitude at which the power line is located. In both cases,it is necessary to heat the rock around the anchorage hole in order to create anunfrozen zone around it before injecting the grout that will fix the anchor.In fact, the rock has to be unfrozen deep enough so that when the heating stopsthere is enough time for the grout to harden and get enough strength before therock comes back to its initial frozen temperature.

    The use of an antifreeze admixture could avoid such a long and complicated pro-cess. In order to prove the feasibility of such an alternative, experimental anchorswere cast in Nanisivik in the extreme north of Baffin Island.

    21.5 The use of calcium nitrite in Nanisivik

    Nanisivik is a village located in the extreme north of Baffin Island at the 73 parallelwhere Nanisivik Mines exploits a zinc mine (Figure 21.1). An airport is connectedto Ottawa twice a week and a harbour facility exists to ship the extracted zinc ore.

    To study the feasibility of using grouts containing calcium nitrite as an antifreezeadmixture, it was possible to take advantage of all of the facilities of the mining

    434 Science and Technology of Concrete Admixtures

  • company (food and dwelling, drills, transportation, etc.) and establish a temporarysmall laboratory inside a garage.

    Two series of experiments were done: the first one in a cap of rock close to the plantas seen in Figure 21.2 and a second one in a gallery of the mine where the rock and theair were all year round at �12 �C (Figure 21.3).

    At 300 mm below its surface, the temperature of the rock was �12 �C for the 12anchors tested. The ambient temperature was �15 �C when the grouting was done.

    The grouts were prepared in a garage using water at 10 �C and transported to thesite immediately to be poured in the anchor holes. They contained some aluminiumpowder in order to create a small expansion of the volume of the grout to improvethe bonding of the grout with the anchor and the rock. Only the first 300 mm of theanchors were grouted and thermocouples installed at the bottom of the anchor tomonitor the temperature of the grout (Figures 21.4 and 21.5). The composition ofthe grout is shown in Table 21.1.

    Resolute Nanisivik

    Groenland

    Cercl

    e arct

    ique

    Frobisher bay

    Baie D’Hudson

    WinnipegMontreal

    Quebec

    Ottawa

    Toronto

    Figure 21.1 Location of Nanisivik in Baffin Island.

    Antifreezing admixtures 435

  • Dosages are given in proportion of the cement mass. In the case of the superplasti-cizer and the calcium nitrite, the dosage corresponds to that of their solid content.

    On the cap of rock, the anchors were pull out after 14 days. In the frozen gallery ofthe mine, the anchored bars were supposed to be pulled out 1 year later. A small rect-angular base was built around each anchor to support the base of the hollow jack usedto pull out the anchors (Figure 21.5).

    Figure 21.2 The selected rock cap for the testing outside the mine.

    Figure 21.3 Grouting the anchors in the mine gallery.

    436 Science and Technology of Concrete Admixtures

  • Figure 21.4 Installation of the 12 anchors.

    Table 21.1 Composition of the grout

    High early strength cement (O) 1

    Water (W) 0.44

    Silica fume (FS) 0.10

    Aluminium powder 0.7 � 10�4

    Superplasticizer 0.03

    Sodium nitrite (N) 0.12

    N/(N þ E) ratio 0.21W/(C þ FS) ratio 0.40

    Figure 21.5 The small rectangular base built around each anchor to support the base of thehollow jack used to pull out the anchors. The temperature of each grout was monitored by athermocouple.

    Antifreezing admixtures 437

  • The results obtained on the cap of rock were compared to those obtained in an un-frozen rock in Sherbrooke; they were excellent (Benmokrane et al., 1987). However, inthe case of the anchors grouted in the frozen gallery, after a year at �12 �C it wasimpossible to pull them out because by error the grouted length was too long; theload that had to be developed to extract them was well over the capacity of thejack. It was necessary to cut the anchors with acetylene torches and seal the anchoringhole with a grout to avoid any accident in the gallery.

    21.6 Conclusion

    This experience of the Université de Sherbrooke in the Canadian Arctic has shown thegreat potential of using antifreeze admixture in concrete or grouts, as is currently donein Finland, Russia and China. The use of this technology could result in importantsavings when erecting power lines. Antifreeze admixtures can also be used to increasethe length of the concrete season in the Canadian North by adding 2 months to theusual concreting season. Concreting could start 1 month earlier and stop 1 month later,which would be a great advantage in the short concreting seasons of the north.

    References

    Benmokrane, B., Aïtcin, P.C., Ballivy, G., 1987. Injection d’ancrages �a base de ciment Portlanddans l’Arctique, Revue Canadienne de Génie Civil 14 (5), 690e693.

    Hernandez, P., 1989. Master Degree Thesis No 556, Université de Sherbrooke.Ramachandran, V.S., 1995. Concrete Admixtures Handbook, second ed. Noyes Publications,

    Park Ridge, NJ, USA, pp. 740e799.

    438 Science and Technology of Concrete Admixtures

  • 本文献由“学霸图书馆-文献云下载”收集自网络,仅供学习交流使用。

    学霸图书馆(www.xuebalib.com)是一个“整合众多图书馆数据库资源,

    提供一站式文献检索和下载服务”的24 小时在线不限IP

    图书馆。

    图书馆致力于便利、促进学习与科研,提供最强文献下载服务。

    图书馆导航:

    图书馆首页 文献云下载 图书馆入口 外文数据库大全 疑难文献辅助工具

    http://www.xuebalib.com/cloud/http://www.xuebalib.com/http://www.xuebalib.com/cloud/http://www.xuebalib.com/http://www.xuebalib.com/vip.htmlhttp://www.xuebalib.com/db.phphttp://www.xuebalib.com/zixun/2014-08-15/44.htmlhttp://www.xuebalib.com/

    21. Antifreezing admixtures21.1 Introduction21.2 Winter concreting in North America21.3 Antifreeze admixtures21.4 The construction of high-voltage power lines in the Canadian North21.5 The use of calcium nitrite in Nanisivik21.6 ConclusionReferences