journal.sanjesh.orgjournal.sanjesh.org/article_29986_61693cac9483b3c22b53d... · 2021. 1. 17. ·...

23
Higher Education Letter 1396 %& 73 - 51 Vol. 10, No. 40, Winter 2018 ! "# $% & ’( ! ) *&+ ,-" Determining the Effective Factors on Graduate Students’ Satisfaction in Higher Education System Using Kano Model :/)0 1 2 14 / 03 / 96 :/)0 *:; 2 08 / 06 / 96 =%> =?" * ,@A % %B C%) ’& * * /! D C@A * * * E F"1 * * * * Mahdi Najari Seyed Hesamoldin Hedayatzadeh Hassan Roshani Ali Benasi Faranak Mokhtarian ’%G : +,- ./0 1 23 4 56789: +; <, 3=7 +> +?@ 3 A3 > BC 7D: .<3 F G3 > 4 A7&: H7I9: 3 C .<3 A3 ;70 J K L;3 7D: 56789: M;3 ./0 73 > 3K: 1435 > +A . H7I9: +> O P3 300 > +A R8: 5& ST3 HI9 4;+0 ./0 3=>3 . 39 3 F <3 U > +C 88T ) JW3 <X7 ( 7Z: 0 +> +F JA P3 [ . \9 ]\ K> J3+> ]\+F JA 89 / 0 J3+> /0 K> ; 91 / 0 > 279: J3+> . < 3 279: F 3 J7Z: 3 A . 3 279: =M: F 3 ; G+: J+D 3 =7L3 53=3 .T> ‘7:+: > 5U 5\ 3 :3 a33 3 b,3 43 KR 7 < J G77K: +7O .I 4 c74D: >3 J J G74d .H7I9: J %78T: > ef 53\3 ;/0 4 RF > g: &3 L ./0 J4> h7D: 27D: > J+7O <R+;70 .0 J3=>3 ‘7:+: 3 J+D 3 =7L3 53=3 G+: .T> . 4 ;/0 5U Abstract: The aim of this study was to identify the effective factors on graduate students’ satisfaction in higher education system using Kano Model. To do this end, a descriptive survey method was used. The statistical population of this research was composed of graduate students of Urmia University (N=1453), out of them 300 students were randomly selected as the research sample using Morgan Table. The research tool was limited to the researcher-made questionnaire whose content validity was confirmed by experts (faculty members). Regarding the reliability of the forenamed questionnaire, it was attempted to make use of Cronbach's Alpha Coefficient. As such, the educational and research dimensions received coefficients of 0.89 and 0.91, respectively. Next, the Kano Model and Confirmatory Factor Analysis were used to analyze the data. The results of data analysis indicated that the most important motivational, fundamental and functional requirements in the educational services sector were as follows: providing clear guidance on learner`s activities, determining the role of trainer and evaluating statistical techniques and research methods. Also, timely allocation of research grants, sufficient familiarity with typing and the principles of research writing, timing the task completion and provision of tools needed to monitor learning progress were considered the most important motivational, fundamental and functional requirements in the research services sector. :=%# HID 7D: 56789: <, J Key words: Satisfaction, graduate studies, higher education. iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii ([email protected] <+ J+F JM;3 :X 4) 73 L;3 * * * 3 73 L;3 <+ 8f3 D;3 * * * <+ J+F JM;3 73 L;3 * * * * <+ J+F JM;3 3+: L;3

Transcript of journal.sanjesh.orgjournal.sanjesh.org/article_29986_61693cac9483b3c22b53d... · 2021. 1. 17. ·...

  • ���� ���� �� ����� ���� Higher Education Letter ��� ���� ��� ���� � ��� ��1396%& �73- 51 Vol. 10, No. 40, Winter 2018

    ����� ������� �� ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� !�"# $%� &� '�(�� ! �)� *&��+ ,-"

    Determining the Effective Factors on Graduate Students’ Satisfaction in Higher Education System Using Kano Model

    :/)0� �1��� 2��� 14/03/96 :/)0� *�:; 2��� 08/06/96 =%>� =�?"∗

    ,@A %����%B C�%)�'��&∗∗ /�! ��� ���D� C@A�∗∗∗

    ����E� F"�1∗∗∗∗

    Mahdi Naj ari Seyed Hesamoldin Hedayatzadeh Hassan Roshani Ali Benasi Faranak Mokhtarian

    '%��G :+,�- .��/0 1��� 2�3�� �����4� 56789: ���+�;� +?@� ��� �3

    �A��3 �> ���� ���� B�C� � ��7�D:

    .4�A7&�: H7I9: ��� �3 ��C . 3�K: �1435 �> +A�. H7I9: �����+>

    ��O��� ���� P��3300 �> +A� �R�8: 5��&�� S�T��3

    ��HI9� ���4;�+0 �.��/0 �3=>3 .

    ��3��9� ��3�� �F � +C���88T�� ) J�W�3 � +F J�A� P��3� [���� .�� �\��9� ]�\� ����� �K> J3+> ]�\��+F J�A�89/0 J3+> �

    �/0 �K> �;�91/0 �> 27�9: J3+> .�� � `7:+: �> ����� 5���U5��\���3 :�3 �a3�3

    �3 b,3� ����4�3���KR7����3 � J��� J��

    ��� � G74d�� .H7I9: J��%78T: �>ef�� 53��\��3 ��;��/0���4� �R�F �> g��: � ��&3 ���L� .��/0 �����J�4> � h7��D: 27�D:

    �> J+7O�� 3 `7:+: �3��� J+D��� � ����3 ���=7L�3 5��3=�3 G�+: �

    .T>.���� �����4� �;��/0 5���U

    Abstract: The aim of this study was to identify the effective factors on graduate students’ satisfaction in higher education system using Kano Model. To do this end, a descriptive survey method was used. The statistical population of this research was composed of graduate students of Urmia University (N=1453), out of them 300 students were randomly selected as the research sample using Morgan Table. The research tool was limited to the researcher-made questionnaire whose content validity was confirmed by experts (faculty members). Regarding the reliability of the forenamed questionnaire, it was attempted to make use of Cronbach's Alpha Coefficient. As such, the educational and research dimensions received coefficients of 0.89 and 0.91, respectively. Next, the Kano Model and Confirmatory Factor Analysis were used to analyze the data. The results of data analysis indicated that the most important motivational, fundamental and functional requirements in the educational services sector were as follows: providing clear guidance on learner`s activities, determining the role of trainer and evaluating statistical techniques and research methods. Also, timely allocation of research grants, sufficient familiarity with typing and the principles of research writing, timing the task completion and provision of tools needed to monitor learning progress were considered the most important motivational, fundamental and functional requirements in the research services sector.

    :=%��# �HI�D ��7�D: 56789: �

  • 52 �)� *&��+ M�"

    /�%0� � ���� �j6:+0 �J��+�3 ���+�;� .I� ��7 > �:�7- 3� � �I> �> � � ��� ��7 > J+\�3� l6�� ������ �3 J��7 > J3+> ��

    �>�� ������ +��j)J��7F �J���m � �����TR 1389 .( G�3+>�4>������J�� J�7��: � �:���U �> n� G�3 � �o�,�� +7 � �����4� ����7� � ���3�U ���+�;� B�O

    ���3+>��3 �: �> �a3�3 5���U �>ef�� `��4� � �> G�+��> �9� J�LT��0 ��7�J�� ���+�;� �U �4��> )�D 4����3 � ��+O ������F ��7�M�2� 2014 .(� ���J�� +7U3�

    � .��/0J��

    +� OJ3 �>p9> br� ���� J�+7� ��� �3 .��/0 � 3�J3+> ��;FJ�� �K��:��R�� � � ��- �K��: ��3+R

    �� 3 � B�C� ����� ���� )���� �3��D�� �� 2009(. �3 .��/0 G�3+>�4>���+:G� �a� �� �3=�� �L;�3�� ���> �> � ���:

    ��3� �4��> )�7�+> � st7�7R �3 �2004( . ���� �+O � 1�� G�3 �F ��� J���>�7���3 �

  • 53 ����... ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� ! ��� �����

    I:�3J� 53��C��3 J����7� � ����M;�3 �4��> )P���:1� 2011� 183.( �3 ����M;�3 ��F�3 ��&3 � J���> ��3+�3 ��:�� � �F+9� .��/0 � �L;�3��

    �4� � ���3��) �2002 .( H�+j ��� J��+> ������ �> J+�;� J�4\��0 � J�3�R��3yO )m���� � ���>33 �2007 �145 .(

    ��d�� ��3+L;��/0 5�K��r� [���� �D��4�J+>4 )0120 � (3�4���� �3��D�� �5 )2005 =7� (��;��4� Z:�f +7? 5���U +> ��� ���+�;� 5��3=�3 � �� H\r4�6U +DR �M7�� ����> z� l3+j ����4���> ���� ����

    �:��\�J+�;� � �> {\:+� 5��7�8: �3�3a� 5���U � �7��:� �\��4� �L������j ��7� �R�8:

    �> |�>+� ��+R � �>���3��> �3+���350 �47�� � ��KR � �4� �F48 � �>���3��> �3+��� �3 �&�30 ��+R �3+��� �3 �&�

    3 ���

    ��� }U� ���� �:�I7I9: J���3� �����4�@� 2�3�� �3 ���+�;� +?���� ����� .��/0 G�3 �+��f ��7���3 �L;�3 �� 3+�3.�� ��X � G�3 .��/0 �� �F

  • 54 �)� *&��+ M�"

    �7�8: �T:3J�� `��4� J�� �3�m�X � �L;�3� � 5���U �7���3 �L;�3 .��/0 � ����.���>

    OBDP; /����; D =-" �"Q� ��F �>����3 5���U �7���3 �> ����� � G����3��02������1 )1998( c� P�7I�J�K>�4� J3+> �3��3U +�� �3�F�F �4�U�� � ���+�;� n3�3 [40 � 3 �3��3�� J+7OF4 .� �K>3 G�32���: P���� ��>� ���LT��0 ���47�j3� . ���� 13��3�a3�3��O�4� ��- G�3 �> q ���� ���� 5���U�

    �;� ����M;�3 n3�3 �3 �A�+K: �3 2&�- [���� � 2�3�� G74d�� J�K> [40 P�7I� c� ��3��3�� �a3�3 5���U |�>+� 2a� � ����L;�3 +7 � ���L;�3 5���U J�����: �� �a3�3 ��O���O 5���U �3 �F h��T� ��KA�@� {� ���� 5� � ����+�>�4� ����3 �L� > � .3�������j ��&3 ����M;�3 �F�+:J G eA�

    2��� ����� 5���U +M:� ��U �> 2��K:��� ��j � �� �a3�3 ��O���O 5� �U ���M;�3 J���=��5� 2013 �320(. >+F�= � ����36 )2007( br� 5���U � =F3+� +7 ���A��3 �3 �O�� ����� 3� ���+> � ���� J3+> �3��3J+7O 5���U �> 3+�� [���� �a3�3

    iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii 1. Berry, Parasuraman & Zeithaml 2. Narang 3. Sultan & Yin Wong 4. Abdullah 5. Jancey & Burns 6. Brooks & Ondrich

  • 55 ����... ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� ! ��� �����

    +F��3 >)+F�= � ����3� 2007 �130.( �0�+7R3� �I��3 �>P�� ��3�� �1 )2007( ���� �����>��j ��=R3���� m�&3 +�3 G�3 .�r�3� G�3�F �>�3�4� �J����7K� �3 �D �>����3�7FZ: ���44F )�+7R3��0 � P������3� 2007 �213 .( J+�;� P��3 h���K:

    +M: �4��� ��7��A� h��T��3 5���Un� ���3 �53��C��3 � �7�� �>����3 � � 5���U �3 �M�8U �: e��4& 5��A: 27� �>� J�7� 3�3 �> ��7� ��:���U �a

    ���J�� �� P� -3 5���U e��4& �> `��4���� . 5m�89� �3 3� 5���U �d��� 3��m�3 �F P����� �f� ����LT��0 ��L� ��� ���\��3 �|�\:�3 ���+�� 3� ���K> �F J+�;� )���� �312.( �> ���: J����>� +?@� 2�3��+> ���� J+L���> ��;F +� J����7� �

  • 56 �)� *&��+ M�"

    2013 �47(. ��C4� G7�� �> J� � �����)2013 (+> ��47�j3 J3+> �F �4� � +C� G�3 �����M;�3 ���> ���� ����� 5���U ������� 2��� �

    �44F ���: J+R � �J� � �����) 2013 �145.( [���� � �3���1 )1998 (J3+>

    �3��3J+7O + P��3 ������4� �3�F�+� �3=>3 .M4� ��� �� �����3 J+D��� � ��=7L�3 �7 I: ���44F � ���F) �3��D��2� 1984 �33.( ���F � ��� �U

    J�4���7�J�� ���+�;� � �� �> 5��\� �+L� 5�7&�8U �A7F 5m�89� 3� �> �� �7 I: ��� +F � +� �� o�� J�4���7� 3� � c� �3��� �K>�J ��;� 3. ��9�

    �J��� �3=7� � G7��0�rI� G�+: �3 ��9� J��� �3��� �>

    `7:+: +L��7> ���+�;�

  • 57 ����... ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� ! ��� �����

    �x �3��D�� �1 )2010( �;��/0 �3�4� �>» �3

    �A��3 �> ���+�;� J����7� ���+> ������F« �F � �� ��-+� � �> 330 ����� J��� �3 �3+>��F G7>�� ���7M� 3+�3��+F .��� 3��>3 J����7� ���+�;� 3� �> ��7�� ��� �I\j ���FJ�4> � st� �3 ��=M: � 27�9: ����3

    �A��3 �3 ��� ���F« 2�3�� +?@� +> �3 ��� ���F 3� �����4� � ��+F .��� � H7I9: G�3� 21 2��� +?@� +> 3� P��3 ��� ���F �I\jJ�4>

    +F � ��+> |�\4��3 ���+�;� �3 �r� �> ���U��

    �L;�3��J ��3+�3 � �>

    �A��3 �3 �����J h��T� J��� �F �f ��47�j3 � 3� G7�W: ��4F ���+> +F [���� .��;� 3

    �F

    �A��3 �3 G�3 ��� �> �����4� ����3 � +F.

    J+> )2001� �( �;��/0 �F �> ��\� %T;� �+F B�I: 3� �3 � �f �C-6�3J +>

    3� J�f G7>

  • 58 �)� *&��+ M�"

    L�7>7�� �3����1 )2008�> �I7I9: ( �3�4� »+>��F ��� ���F J3+> �I\j�4>J �7��J�� �L;�3 ����M;�3« 3+�3 +F��. ��� � G�3 H7I9: �&� �����4� J����7�

    ����M;�3 �3 5���U �a3�3 ��� �L;�3 n��:�: H7I9: [���� .���> ��;� ���� �F35 @� ����M;�3 ��j �&6U� �F 3 ��;� J+C� ���\� ���+> ��+�3���+�;� � `��4� ��� �F +�;�

  • 59 ����... ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� ! ��� �����

    *D���� OBDP; .��/0.��F 5�I7I9: o�� �3 1�� J�4\� +> +,�- ���: �> H7I9: o��> �

    3 J��+O �7���� �A7&�:- �;���70� J�4\� +>

    3 27�9:3 �� � o��\�� �L� 3�K:1435 �> +A�. 3�K: G�3 �31184 erI� � +A� ���4���F � ���3251 ���� �3 ����� �M- G77K: J3+> .���> 2789: ��- � J+�F erI� � +A�

    3�K: �F ��

    �A��3 ��O���300 ����� ��� �> +A� �R�8: J+7O�� S�T��3

    ���� .J3+> ;�+0 �3 �L;�3 5���U �3 ���+�;� � 2��� ���4;�+0 G�3 . ) (�;��/0 �������A�@� +�� .� 2��� ����� 5���U .�7���3 � J3�3 �19 . ��3��9� ��3�� . �3=>3 )J�W�3

    ����� �K> J3+> ]�\��+F J�A� [���� .��

    �A��3 ]�\��+F J�A� ���89/0 J3+> � �;��/0 �K>91/0 �>

    3 27�9: .�� ���F ��� . P��3 ��� G�+�;7> ��3�3+R 2D� ��R+O ����� 27�9: ��� �3J�7�Z: B+� � B� �\:+� �3=R38.5lisrel ������� 3��>3 ��C4� G�3 J3+>.70+RJ�� B�m )(����� ���+� > J3+ ����� 27�9:J�7�Z: .�4�R+O �3+f ���� ���

    /�1�OBDP; =B

    O�; ��!U1���� *D� =B� ����=%��V� > ��1��+7��3 1�+O����F J��� ���� �3

    �A��3 �> 3��>3 �J��� ��� J+7O ��F�

    �> ���+� �

    3�� ������ . [���� �> ���: �>�> ��J��+7u�� .��/0v�=>+: �305/0 �4>

    3�� ��+7u�� �3 c�+� ���� J3+> �

  • 60 �)� *&��+ M�"

    ����� 27�9: J3+> �� S�T��3 ����� �M- �� �D4�3 ���+> J3+>J�7�Z: F �R�) ����� [���� �> ���: �> ���� G�3 �3��3 +,�- .��/0 � �86/0 �f �3=7� �F �

    G�3.�+0 �3

    3 ��3�3+R %U���� � [���� �F ��

    �A��3� .T> �S � h�3 �> �> ���:������ J���3��� � )1 � 2( �� ��

    ��.

    W)�- ����� 5���U ) ���� �> ���: �>1+?@� 2�3�� ( �L;�3 ����� 5���U �3

    5��\� ���+7O�� :�3 ��3�1���.�>�7���3 � 3+�3 �G���: ��-3+j � ���� H\j )1( �>����3 �> c74D:J�� � J��������H7I9: J |�>+� �> ����

    B3=��3 �> {\:+� �F )188( G�+��F�3�3+R� )25( �> B3=��3��=7L�3

  • 61 ����... ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� ! ��� �����

    $D%X )1( 1'��� �"�D�/0QY D B/��H =%�! ���� Z�� D B=�! '[�"�� ��&��+ ��%\

    /()�� �1 �"�D]\� �HP�D M O A ���)D� Z������

    ,%� Z������

    ��+7

    O��

    Jm�> .�3 � 5������O��+7O��

    01F 96 154 36 O )63/0( )83/0-(

    Jm�> �+L� � �=7L�3����M;�3

    02F 60 47 167 A )71/0( )35/0-(

    5���� Jm�> br� J��.70 ��7���

    03F 152 78 46 M )41/0( )76/0-(

    1��

    ��

    13��3 ��> {\:+��3+7O3+R �> �����

    04F 142 96 33 M )43/0( )79/0-(

    �Z: �3 �� 13��3 �7`-�& 3+R3 1+j+C�

    05F 169 60 51 M )36/0( )76/0-(

    �-3+j

    � �7�K: �A �R G77K: �> `��4�� +:��

    06F 172 52 22 M )24/0( )74/0-(

    ���� .I� G77K:�4� 07F 54 187 25 O )70/0( )80/0-( ��3+R�+F 5���� J��

    ��U�4�3+R 08F 145 51 49 M )33/0( )65/0-(

    G���

    :

    �3 b,3� J��4�3� �a3�3��

    10F 36 189 54 O )81/0( )075/0-(

    3+�3

    ���� � J��D�� J�4>

    ����M;�3 .�+0 �9� 11F 61 74 110 A )61/0( )45/0-(

    �> ����M;�3 H��;:

    �� � ��KR �3 ���3 �7� S�T��3 ��a3�3

    13F 66 33 184 A )72/0( )33/0-(

    �a3�3 �7� � o�� G77K:P���

    14F 107 126 25 M )50/0( )77/0-(

  • 62 �)� *&��+ M�"

    /()�� �1 �"�D]\� �HP�D M O A ���)D� Z������

    ,%� Z������

    �>�7

    ���3

    c74D: �>����3 J����� � J��� J��

    ���� �> |�>+� H7I9: 15F 188 64 38 M )34/0( )84/0-(

    ��a3 J���U�� ��� �L;�3 ��>��C4�

    �> ��7;T> �3+���3����+> �>����3��� J��

    16F 155 75 37 M )37/0( )76/0-(

    �>����3 J��+\�3� �7FZ: +> ����M;�3 +D��� �3

    ��� z�\r�3 �>����3 J��1�� �> ����+> J��

    ���

    17F 61 125 87 O )70/0( )62/0-(

    - ��%\ �"�D�1 $D%X �D&�� C�["�� *D� _� ! �"# $%� �����

    ��&��+ ����� G7L��7� ��� P��3 +> ���F ��� 27�9: [�����3�3+R ���� 5���U �

    ) �3��� � �����1 (�33�a .��� J+D��� � ����3 ���=7L�3 5��3=�3 G�+: .T> ������ 5���U � �a3�3

    �3 b,3� ����4�3���KR7����3 �c��� � J��� J��H7I9: J��

  • 63 ����... ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� ! ��� �����

    �����" )1( ��&��+ ��%\ �D&�� C�["�� *D� _� ! �"# �����

    `- �;��/0 5���U �> ���� �> ���: )2+?@� 2�3�� ( �L;�3 �;��/0 5���U �3

    5��\�:�3 ��3 J�8�f3 �5���D�3 �������3 � �8T� �J����4��3�:. ���� H\j )2( �����4>��+7O�� 3 � h7��D: 27�D: J �F�> |�>+� B3=��3

    )174 ( �> 3� |�>+� ��� {\:+� �F

  • 64 �)� *&��+ M�"

    $D%X )2( 1'��� �"�D�/0QY D B/��H =%�! ���� Z�� D B=�! '[�"�� ��BDP; ��%\

    /()�� ]\� �"�D�1 �HP�D M O A ���)D� Z������

    ,%� Z������

    J

    �8

    �f3

    %78T:�>ef�� ��\��3 53�;��/0

    01F ٧٩ ۶۴ ١۴٢ A )68/0( )48/0-(

    � .��/0 �R�F ���>B���

    02F 57 122 87 O )69/0( )59/0-(

    5���

    D�3

    c��> ��� �:��6j3 J����U3

    03F 163 68 58 M )42/0( )77/0-(

    J�4�0 04F 154 60 71 M )43/0( )71/0-( ���� e>�4� ���

    �4�3 ��88T: 56M�)(n�3�� �

    05F 84 120 71 O )63/0( )68/0-(

    ���

    ���3

    � �

    8T�

    {� : �R�F J3+> A��3

    � �3 e>�4� ����U

    06F 78 87 123 A )70/0( )55/0-(

    ��� � m�X �� �L;�3

    08F 83 81 105 A )62/0( )54/0-(

    B3�T��3 �7 ���: �>

    �3�: �;��/0 ��� 09F 152 63 69 M )44/0( )71/0-(

    J��

    ��4�

    �3�:

    ���� h7��D: 27�D: J�4>

    3 �

    ��+7O��

    10F 174 54 62 M )38/0( )76/0-(

    � g��: �> �R�F ���4� � .��/0 ���L� ��&3

    ���I� 11F 95 109 63 O )57/0( )68/0-(

    B+� �> ���4� J���3=R3�;��/0

    12F 152 54 61 M )38/0( )68/0-(

  • 65 ����... ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� ! ��� �����

    - $%� ������"�D�1 $D%X �D&�� C�["�� *D� _� ! �"# ��%\��BDP;

    5���U ��3�3+R ���� ����� G7L��7� ��� P��3 +> ���F ��� 27�9: [����) �3��� � �;��/02 (�33�a .ef��

    53��\��3 ��;��/0���4� �R�F �> g��: � ��&3 ���L� .��/0 �����J�4> : 27�D `7:+: �> J+7O�� 3 � h7��D:���=7L�3 5��3=�3 G�+: ���

    J+D��� � ����3 .T> � 5���U

  • 66 �)� *&��+ M�"

    $D%X )3 (/�E��B����� ���� $%� *&�! ����" =

    /�E�� ��D+!

    `�+I: J�rU s����3� ��+> �y�)RMSEA( 078/0

    ��3+> ���D� �;�3=R3 %U��)IFI( 91/0

    ��3+> ���D� �I7\r: %U��)(CFI 91/0

    %U��NFI 93/0

    ��R�� ���� J��)3( �� ��;� �� ���� ��� J3+> � �U %U�� �F ���4K��U %U�� �3�I� . �J13 �3) S��r� �3�I�3( +��F �F �U ��3+> �3 ���G�3 +> �6�� �3�I� %U��RMSEA =7� �3 ) S��r� �3�I�08/0 ( +��F ��� S�U ��3+> +L��;�

    3J��+O J�� . � `7:+:91/0 �91/0 �93/0 (� ��� J��+O J�� ��. �>�U ��3+> �3

  • 67 ����... ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� ! ��� �����

    ���)1( ���� �����=%��V� OBDP; $%� ,D� /Q��

    %U�� �> ���: �>��3=O �O���3+> J�� +> J+�;� ���F ���O �3 J3�K: . ����� 2D� 5��&)1( �7�Z: .

  • 68 �)� *&��+ M�"

    �;��/05��\� ��-3+j �13��3 ���+7O�� :����� 5���U �3 ��3 � 3+�3 �G���:� �>�7���3 5���U J����4��3�: � 5���D�3 �J�8�f3 �������3 � �8T� :�;��/0. �3 c� +� G�3�A�@� ���O �4� �����3

    �A��3 �> �F �33 +> ���F 27�9:�3+R P��� ��3 ����+> � �3+���3 � �L���70 �> +� � . =7�

    .��/0 ������3 J��|�>+� � G74d�� ���: � ���� �>)3( 2D� �)1( ��� ��� �- � ����3 � J+D��� ���=7L�3 �K>3 � +C�

    >�f\f 2��� ��7�Z: ��. +L;��/0 �3 J��7 >5���U J3

    �3 � J�4����,� �� J��+> ������ �> J+�;� J�4\��0 � J�3�R� +> H�+j �O�3y )�m���� � ���>3 2007.( B�M�3 5�K��r� �� ��;� ���R+O ���F ��d�� ���3��

    5�97�+: ���O��+7O�� 5���� � .�3 br� ���O��+7O�� ��U�4� 1��J�� ��3+7O3+R �> �� ������7�Z: 1��J�� �3 ��J�� 3+R3

    `-�&@� +C� ��> 2��F �� �1���� � �> ��+7O�� h7��D: J��O���1��J�� �3+7O3+R 3� J�f G7> +?3 3+����� ����4�3�

    � �3+���3 � �L���70 ��� �3 ��-+� +� � � �������� � �� ���U�� ��> ��D� ��U J+C� �7� P��3 +> ����� 3�� ��

    iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii 1. Nancy

  • 69 ����... ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� ! ��� �����

    �+O ��> .T>+?3�3��:) 3� ����� 3�� J�4>1� 2006.( G�3+>�4> ���: �>) �3��: +C� �>2006 (�> ��3+R�+F �3 G��� ����4�3�R�����

    G77\: 3�q+F 3+���> ���: �3��� �> )1�� ( �F ������� ��� ���=7L�3 �O/�� G�+: J��4�3� �a3�3G��� �3��KR7+?3 �

    P� �a3�3������ 3�� �� �> ���3 ���U��> �a3�3 �����M;�3 � �3 ����>� >����3 �3=>3 ��d�� �3+���3 ��>����3�U J���3=>3 ���>����3 � �L���70 � � .3� �>����3 o3��3 �>����� ����3 ���>

    �>�a3 ��j� �> � ��I� � 3� ������ � ���� ���+�1���� ��>��j �> ��F���� J��+\�3�� +F ���+> )�:+��3� 2006.(

    5���U +L� .T> ��� .��/0 �> |�>+� ���� ��� �>�U �4��4>� .�3=R3 p��> �F ���3�� �> ���:

    �� A��3

    � �3

    e>�4� ����U��� � � m�X �� B3�T��3 ��L;�3 ���: �> �3�: �;��/0 ��� �3� ���: �4���7� �3�� /�

    ��4� �. � ����3 5��3=�3 �����3 ���� e>�4� G7�Z: �;��/0 �� �M�3 � .��/0 �=7L�3 �M�3 � �R�F .��/0� ��� �R�F 2&�- �3 �F ��� ��� .��+7O �3+f ���: c��>J�� �:��6j3 ��U3 J�4�0 �����U �

    iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii 1. Taran 2. Archibald 3. Doherty

  • 70 �)� *&��+ M�"

    Jm�> ��� ��4� ���� )56M� ��88T: �4�3 � n�3��( e>�4� �M�3 ������3 2�3�� �47�� G�3 � ���: �4���7��4� �. ����3�: �> ���: G74d�� 5���� �

    ���� . 27�D: h7��D: � J���3=>3 .��0 g��: � ��&3 ���L� .��/0 � ���4� ����I� �> B+�J���3=R3 0 �;��/

    �M�3 � ��+?@� J+7O �3 ̀ ��4��� ����+�J�� J+DR �K��� � . �-3+j J�3=>3 ����F J3+> �>����3 � 27�9:

  • 71 ����... ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� ! ��� �����

    b!�� ��R=7: ��D:��3 J��� )1384 .(�����4� � �\:�J�4> 2�3�� +?@� +> 53+7?Z:�7I� � � �7I� �+7 �>���3��> �r>3�J3 +> J�3�R� ����M;�3. ���4�8R .��/0 �����+>J=�� � ���� ����� 22 )3�( 129-143. ����,� �3+��Fq ���7��G7 - �q � �,���9� ���7��� �J+��� ��9� )1384 .(

    J+�;� J+D��� �3�� �> l+jJ=�� � �\�> ��89� �� P�\� �J��M- ���3 )1385 .(���J�� H7I9: � B���

    J���R�. +;� :�3+�: .�O \�7�J+ �7� ��9� )1394 .(��3�>�� ����+>J�� ���� �< ��r79� � ���� ����

    �>

    �A��3 �3 ���. SWOT l+j ;��/0� �L;�3 07B� ���. J+��j =7\��iF ����i��F)1381 .(�ia3�3 �i���3 J3+> �>�����

    ���+�;i� �3=7�

  • 72 �)� *&��+ M�"

    Aldridge, S. & Rowley, J. (1998). Measuring customer satisfaction in

    higher education. Journal Quality Assurance in Education, (6) 4, 197-204.

    Ali, F. & Amin, M. (2014). The influence of physical environment on emotions, customer satisfaction and behavioral intentions in Chinese resort hotel industry. Journal for Global Business Advancement, (7) 3, 249-266.

    Alves, H. & Raposo, M. (2010). The influence of university image on student behaviour. International Journal of Educational Management, (1) 24, 73-85.

    Angilella, S.; Corrente, S.; Greco, S. & Słowiński, R. (2014). MUSA-INT: Multicriteria customer satisfaction analysis with interacting criteria. Omega, 42 (1), 189-200. DOI: 10.1016/j.omega

    Archibald, D. (2005). Rapid e-learning: A growing trend. Learning circuits. www.elearningguild.com/pdf/1/apr05-rapid.pdf.

    Aydemir, S. D. & Gerni, C. (2011). Measuring service quality of export credit agency in Turkey by using Servqual. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, (1) 24, 321-284.

    Berry, L. L.; Parasuraman, A. & Zeithaml, V. A. (1988). SERVQUAL: A multiple-item scale for measuring consumer perceptions of service quality. Journal of Retailing, (1) 64, 12-40.

    Bilgili, B. & Unal, S. (2008). Kano Model Application for Classifying the Requirements of University Students. In 7th Annual MIBES International Conference, Greece.122-112.

    Brooks, A. C. & Ondrich, J. I. (2007). Quality, service level, or empire: which is the objective of the nonprofit arts firm? Journal of Cultural Economics, (1) 31, 129-142.

    Chahal, H. & Devi, P. (2013). Identifying satisfied/dissatisfied service encounters in higher education. Journal of Quality Assurance in Education, (2) 21, 211-222.

    Cronbach, L. J. (1951). Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests. Psychometrika, (3) 16, 297-334.

    Davies, M.; Hirschberg, J.; Lye, J. & Johnston, C. (2010). A systematic analysis of quality of teaching surveys. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, (1) 35, 83.

    Doherty, W. (2006). An analysis of multiple factors affecting retention in web-based community college courses. The Internet and Higher Education, (4) 9, 245-255.

    Eboli, L. & Mazzulla, G. (2007). Service quality attributes affecting customer satisfaction for bus transit. Journal of public transportation, (3) 10, 2-13.

    Fornell, C.; Johnson, M. D.; Anderson, E. W.; Cha, J. & Bryant, B. E. (1996). The American customer satisfaction index: nature, purpose, and findings. The Journal of Marketing, 7-18.

  • 73 ����... ������ ������ ����� ���� �� �� ! ��� �����

    Gillis, W. & Castrogiovanni, G. J. (2012). The franchising business model: an entrepreneurial growth alternative. International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal, (1) 8, 75-88.

    Jancey, J., & Burns, S. (2013). Institutional factors and the postgraduate student experience. Quality Assurance in Education, (3) 21, 311-322.

    Javadian, Y. (2002). Medical students' attitudes towards the importance of research. Qazvin University of Medical Sciences, 22 (1), 64-67.

    Kano, N.; Tsuji, S.; Seraku, N. & Takerhashi, F. (1984). Miryokuteki Hinshitsu to Atarimae Hinshitsu. Attractive Quality and Must-Be Quality. Quality, JSQC, (2) 14, 33-46.

    Lloyd, T.; Phillips, B. R., & Aber, R. C. (2004) Factors that influene doctors participation in clinical research. Med Educ, (8) 38, 848-851.

    Narang, R. (2012). How do management students perceive the quality of education in public institutions? Quality Assurance in Education, (4) 20, 357-371.

    Salem safi, R.; Ashrafrezaei, N.; Moshiri, Z.; Shaykhi, N. & Baniadam, A. (2009). Study of views of faculty members about research barriers in Urmea University of Medical Sciences. Journal of faculty Nursing and Midwifery of Urmia University, (3) 7,142-150.

    Schneider, B.; Ehrhart, M. G.; Mayer, D. M.; Saltz, J. L., & Niles-Jolly, K. (2005). Understanding organization-customer links in service settings. Academy of Management Journal, (6) 48, 110-119.

    Sultan, P. & Yin Wong, H. (2013). Antecedents and consequences of service quality in a higher education context: a qualitative research approach. Quality Assurance in Education, (1) 21, 70-95.

    Sumsion, J. (2011). Capacity building in early childhood education research in a regional Australian university. British Journal of Educational Studies, (3) 59, 265-274.

    Taran, C. (2006). Enabling SMEs to deliver synchronous online training-practical guidelines. Campus-Wide Information Systems, (3) 23, 182-195.

    Thomas, S. (2011). What drives student loyalty in universities: an empirical model from India? International Business Research, (2) 4, 183.

    Zafiropoulos, C. & Vrana, V. (2008). Service quality assessment in a Greek higher education institute. Journal of business economics and management, (1) 9, 33-45.

    Zhu, Daue-Song; Lin, Chin-Te; Tsai, Chung- Hung & Wu, Ji- Fu (2010). A Study on the evaluation of customers’ satisfaction- The perspective of quality. International Journal for Quality research, 4 (2), 105 – 116.