2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The...
Transcript of 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The...
BrookLynk Youth Employment Program
2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Luis Salado-Herrera BrookLynk Youth Employment Coordinator Jolene Rotich BrookLynk Youth Outreach Specialist September 29, 2017
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 2
TableofContentsExecutiveSummary……………………………………………………………………………3Introduction………………………………………………………………………………….……7
Background……………………………………………………………………………………7ProgramDescription………………………………………………………………………7ProgramGoals………………………………………………………………………………..8ProjectDescription…………………………………………………………………………8ProjectGoals…………………………………………………………………………………...8ResearchFrameworkforBuildingPathwaystoCollege&Career………9
EvaluationPurpose………………………………………………………………...………….9CoreEvaluationQuestions…………………………………………………………………10EvaluationMethods……………………………………………………………………………10Results………………………………………………………………………………………………..11
YouthParticipation…………………………………………………………………………11 YouthOutreach…………………………………………………………………………12WorkReadinessTraining………………………………………………………..…14InternshipsandCheck-ins…………………………………………………………15YouthJobFair…………………………………………………………………………...15
CommunityParticipation………………………………………………………………..16QualityAssessment……………………………………………………………………….. 19YouthOutcomes……………………………………………………………………………..21
CareerSkills……………………………………………………………………………..22Finances………………………………………………………………………………… 23SocialNetworks……………………………………………………………………… 24InternCustomerSatisfaction…………………………………………………… 24Long-termOutcomes…………………………………………………………………27
BusinessOutcomes…………………………………………………………………………28CapacityBuilding……………………………………………………………………………30
DegreeofSupports……………………………………………………………………30ProgramCost……………………………………………………………………………32PoliticalWill…………………………………………………………………….…….…33
ProcessEvaluation…………………………………………………………………..….… 34ProgramDevelopment………………………………………………………..….…34Outreach…………………………………………………………………………….….…35WorkReadinessTraining……………………………………………………….…37Matching……………………………………………………………………………….…38YouthJobFair…………………………………………………………………………..40InterviewsandOnboarding………………………………………………………43Internships……………………………………………………………………………....45Check-insandEnrichmentOpportunities…………………………………. 47Celebration………………………………………………………………………………49Evaluation……………………………………………………………………………… 50
Discussion………………………………………………………………………………………….51NextEvaluationQuestions…………………………………………………………….. 51RecommendationsforImprovingBrookLynk…………………………………. 52
FurtherInformation………………………………………………………………….……... 54Appendix……………………………………………………………………………………..……. 54
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 3
2017BrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramFinalReportExecutiveSummary
DATE: September29,2017TO: AllianceBoardofDirectorsSteeringCommittee BrookLynkFundingPartnersFROM: RebeccaGilgen–ExecutiveDirector
IvanLui–DataandQualityCoordinatorLuisSalado-Herrera–YouthEmploymentCoordinatorJoleneRotich–BrookLynkSpecialist
ExecutiveSummaryInNovemberof2014theBrooklynBridgeAllianceforYouthBoardofDirectorsapprovedthelaunchofa2-yearprojectwithtwogoals:1)CustomizetheMinneapolisSTEP-UPmodelforthecitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynParkand2)BuildcapacityamongsttheAlliancepartnerstosustainthisprogram.ThefollowingisacomprehensiveinternalevaluationofboththeBrookLynkprogramandcapacitybuildingeffortsfromthissecondyearofimplementation.DataindicatethatinYear3,continuedcustomizationoftheSTEP-UPprogrammodelhasbeensuccessfulandthatlocalcapacityforoperatingtheprogramattheCityofBrooklynParkandCityofBrooklynCenterhasbeenbuilt.Whatfollowsisasummaryofresultsfromthetwomajorgoalareas1)Programimplementationand2)Capacity-buildingactivities.ProgramResultsSummaryThesuccessofBrookLynkhingesonparticipationfromemployersandyouth.Inthethirdyeartheprogramwasclosetoreachingparticipationgoals.Additionaldataonprogramqualityandtheimpactonparticipantssuggestthatwhilethereareareasforprogramqualitytoimprove,bothemployersandyouthwerepositivelyimpacted.YouthParticipationBrookLynkservesyouth14-21wholiveorgotoschoolintheBrooklyns,haveatleastonebarriertoemployment,and/orareOpportunityYouth(outofmainstreamschoolorcountyinvolvedyouth).
• 529youthappliedforGetReady!WorkReadinessTraining• 189youthcompletedtheGetReady!training,whichisa39%increasefrom2015.• 104youthwerematchedtointernshipsand96begansummerinternship
opportunities.Thisyear’sgoalwas100.• 91youthcompletedtheentiresummerinternship(a95%completionrate).
92%ofsupervisorswouldparticipatein
BrookLynkagain
99%ofinternswouldrecommendBrookLynktoa
friend
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 4
CommunityParticipationTherewere14education,business,andcommunitypartnerswhoofferedinternshipsandsupervisors/employmentmentorsforyouth.BusinessPartners
• AllenPropertyServices,LLC• Amplifon,Inc.• BostonScientific• CumminsPowerGeneration• ToplineFederalCreditUnion
EducationPartners
• Anoka-HennepinAreaSchools• BrooklynCenterCommunity
Schools• HennepinTechnicalCollege• NorthHennepinCommunityCollege• OsseoAreaSchools• RobbinsdaleAreaSchools
CommunityPartners
• HennepinCountyo BrooklynParkLibraryo CenterofInnovationand
Excellenceo HumanServicesandPublic
HealthDepartmento PublicWorksDepartment
CommunityPartners(continued)
• CityofBrooklynParko CommunityDevelopment
Departmento CommunityEngagement
Departmento InformationTechnology
Departmento OperationsandMaintenance
Departmento PoliceDepartmento RecreationandParksDepartment,
YouthServices• CityofBrooklynCenter
o AdministrationandOfficeoftheClerk
o BuildingandCommunityStandardsDepartment
o BusinessandDevelopmentDepartment
o CommunityActivities,Recreation&Services
o FinanceDepartmento FireDepartmento PoliceDepartmento PublicWorksDepartment
QualityAssessmentTheYouthProgramQualityAssessment(PQA)®avalidatedyouthprogramqualityinternal-assessmentwascompletedduringoneoftheworkreadinesstrainings.Intheassessmentofthetraining,theprogramscoredhigheralldomainsduetochangesmadetothedesignanddelivery.InternshipswerealsoassessedusinganInternshipQualityAssessment,andscoresremainedhighinallofthedomains.YouthOutcomesParticipatingyouthgainedworkreadinessandsocial-emotionallearningskills,financialbenefits,andsocialconnections.Themajorityofyouthweresatisfiedwiththeirinternshipexperiences.
• 99%ofinternswouldrecommendBrookLynktoafriend• 86%ofinternsagreedthattheyreceivedenoughtrainingandsupportto
successfullycompletetheirinternships• 77%ofinternsstatedthattheirinternshiphelpedthemincreasethenumberof
professionalsintheirsocialnetwork
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 5
• InternsratedtheBrookLynkprogram4.3outof5(1beingpoor,5beingexcellent)
• Internsratedsupervisors4.5outof5(1beingpoor,5beingexcellent)
• 76%ofinternswereratedbytheirsupervisorsashavinggainedall14assessedcareerskills
• Themedianinternshipsalarywas$2400• Alumnifromtheyears2015and2016whoresponded
toourrequestforanupdateontheirlifesuccesswelearnedthat:
o 96%ofeligibleseniorsgraduatedo 88%ofthosethatgraduatedwillbeincollegeo 87%wereemployedthissummer
BusinessOutcomesEmployersweresatisfiedwiththeprogramandtheirintern(s).
• 92%ofsupervisorswouldliketoparticipateintheBrookLynkprogramagain• Over92%ofsupervisorsreportedthattheyweresatisfiedwiththesupportthey
receivedfromBrookLynk• 82%statedthattheirinternsweregoodmatchesfortheirorganizations• 81%ofsupervisorsreportedthattheirinternsmetorexceededtheirexpectations
ofjobresponsibilitiesandworkload• 68%ofsupervisorsrespondedthattheirinternswerethebestpartoftheir
internshipexperiencesCapacityBuildingResultsSummaryCapacitybuildingwasmeasuredbyidentifyingprogramcosts,assessingthedegreeofsuccessincustomizingMinneapolisSTEP-UPandidentifyingthesupportsBrookLynkwillneedtooperatelong-termembeddedwithinourcitypartnersorganizations.ResultsindicatethatthedegreeofsupportforBrookLynkishigh.BrookLynkimplementedtwokeychangestotheSTEP-UPmodelthathadapositiveeffectonprogramoutcomes1)Weeklyinterncheck-insand2)IntegratingMeasuresofHumanAchievement(MHA)asharedframeworkfor21stCenturyskill-building.DegreeofSupports
• Thedegreeofsupportfromemployerswashigh.Therewasincredibleinterestfromthebusinesscommunity:BrookLynkwasabletosecure106internships,whichis6overourgoalof100forYear3.
• Alliancefacilitatedahighdegreeofsupportfromcommunitypartners.Threedozenorganizationsprovided:
o In-kinddonations:useoffacilities,vanandbustransportation,andmarketingandprintingsupport
o Volunteers:financialliteracyandpublictransitworkshops,interviewsforthemockinterview,workreadinessandjobfairworkshoptrainers
o Funding:hiringaBrookLynkSpecialisttomanageReferralPartners,implementtheYouthJobFair,andlaunchanAlumniNetworkandJobBoard
“Sheprovidedneweyesandafreshperspective.Herquestionsledstaff
workingwithhertothinkinanewwayabouthowwedowhatwedo.”
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 6
ProgramCosts• Theprogramcostsnecessarytooperatetheprogramareprimarilyrelatedtostaff
whocoordinatetheprogramandstrategicoversight/dailymanagement.• Astheprogramdoubledinyouthserved,thebudgetalsoexpandedtohirea2ndFTE.• TheBrookLynkmulti-yearbudgethasbeencreatedandwasacriticalstepin
creatingthecooperationagreement.PoliticalWill
• ThecooperationagreementtotransitionBrookLynktotheCitiesin2018isanimportantindicationthatpoliticalwillishighamongourpartners,andthattheprimarygoalofbuildingcapacityhasbeenreached.
• TheAllianceprovidedaplaceforBrookLynktogrowthispoliticalwill.ThisismeasuredbythreeyearsofcontinuousaffirmationfromyouthandemployerswhoexpresscontinuedinterestandneedforBrookLynk.
ProgramCustomization
• BrookLynkdevelopedacustomizedlogicmodel,programprocessmapandacomprehensiveevaluationplanforeachyearoftheincubationprocess.
• TheReferralPartnerprogramwaslaunchedwithschoolandorganizationalpartnerstorecruitandsupportmorestudentsfromtargetpopulations.
• TheGetReady!WorkReadinessTrainingandSupervisorTrainingwerebothredesignedandimprovedthequalityandimpactofboth.
• Thematchingprocesswasscaledandcontinuedtobesuccessfulforover100internsmatchedtointernships.Nearly82%ofthesupervisorsagreedtheirinternwasagoodmatch.
• TheYouthJobFairdidnotmeetthegoalsofgettingyoungeryouthemployedattheevent.Itwillberedesignednextyeartobettermatchjobseekerswithlocaljobs.
• Theweeklycheck-ins,andcollegeandcareersitevisitswerecontinuedduringtheinternship.Throughtheseevents,internsreportedasenseofbelongingandmutualsupport,theopportunitytoshareandreflectontheirexperiences,discusssolutionstoproblemstheywerefacing,andworkonimprovingcareerskills.
SummaryResultsindicatesignificantprogresshasbeenmadeincustomizingSTEP-UPfortheBrooklynsandinbuildingcapacitytosustainBrookLynk,especiallyasevidencedbythetransitionoftheprogramtotheCitiesinJanuaryof2018.Thenextstepsinevaluatingthisprogramincludebetterunderstanding(1)whatspecificcharacteristicsofsupervisorsleadtoahigh-qualityinternship,(2)whatthebenefitsaretoemployersandtheyouthworkforce,and(3)thevalueofthisprogramtotheCitiesanditspartnersingrowingeconomicvitality.Finally,asBrookLynkentersitssecondyearofoperation,staffwillprioritizeandimplementsuggestionsforprogramimprovementidentifiedinthisevaluation.Theseimprovementsrangefrombuildingthecapacityofemployerstoimproveinternalprocessesandsupportsupervisors,tocreatingdeeperengagementwithschoolandcountypartners,tolaunchingtheAlumniNetworkandJobBoardtoredesigningtheYouthJobFair.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 7
INTRODUCTIONBackgroundIn2014,theAlliancestaffwastaskedwithdevelopingayouthemploymentprogramformiddleandhighschoolagedyouthwholivedinorgotoschoolintheBrooklynsthatpreparesthemwithskills,ignitestheirmotivations,andcreatessocialconnectionstoemploymentandcollege.Thisprogramhasthreecomponents:21stcenturyskillbuilding,experientialemploymentopportunities,andlocalcoordination.Initsinauguralsummer,the2015BrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramhad234applicants,80youthcompletedworkreadinesstraining,and29internsininternshipswithemployers.Inyeartwo,the2016BrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramexpandedto399applicants,136completedtraining,and62interns.Thisyeartheprogramcontinuetoexpand.BrookLynkwasdesignedtoprovideopportunitiestoyouthwithbarrierstoemploymentand/orwereatriskofbecomingdisconnected:thoseexperiencinghomelessness,whowerenolongerenrolledinmainstreamhighschools,teenparents,andyouthinvolvedinthecountyfostercare,teenparentingorjuvenilecorrectionssystems.TheAllianceoperatedBrookLynkin2015and2016,andincollaborationwiththecitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynParkin2017.Thiswasanintentionalcollaborationtocreateasmoothtransitiontothecitiestotakeownershipoftheprogramsolelyin2018.Thisevaluationwillhelpanswerkeyquestionsaboutcapacitybuildingandprogramdevelopmenttofacilitatethattransition.ProgramDescriptionTheBrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramhasseveralmaincomponentsthatarealldeliveredwithapositiveyouthdevelopmentpractice:workreadinesstraining,ayouthjobfair,internships,andlocalcoordination.Youthparticipateinworkreadinesstraining,mockinterviews,andinternshippreparationtraining.Someofthosestudentsarethenmatchedwithalocalemployerandsupervisortoparticipateinapaidsummerinternshipprogram.Studentsattendregularcheck-in’storeflectandlearnabouttheirexperiences.Localcoordinationinvolvespromotionofthetrainings,recruitmentofbusinesses,continuousimprovementefforts,anddevelopingpartnershipswithinthecommunity.For2017thegoalsweresetat500youthapplyingfortraining,300attendingworkreadinesstraining,and100internships.TherewereseveraldifferencesforthisthirdyearofBrookLynkcomparedtothelastcoupleofyears.BrookLynklaunchedayouthjobfairinthespringtofollowcloselyaftertheBrookLynkGetReady!WorkReadinessTraining.ThiswouldallowyoungeryouthwhoareineligibleforBrookLynkinternships(onlyforyouthaged16-21)andyouthwhodonotchooseorarenotselectedforinternships,togettheirfirstjob.Thetargetinthefirstyearwastohave50businessesandorganizations,and500youthinattendance.Afull-timeprogramassistantwashiredtohelptheprogramcoordinator.AndanalumninetworkandonlinejobboardwillbedevelopedinFall2017.ThealumninetworkwillallowBrookLynktostayconnectedtoalumni,providesupportandresources(includingLinkedIn
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 8
networking)onyouth’spathwaytocollegeandcareer,andprovideemployerswithadiversetalentpool.Thealumninetworkwillalsocreateausergroupforthejobboardthatwillhelpyouthandbusinessestoconnect.Businesseswillbeabletoaddopenpositions,andyouthwillbeabletosearchavailablepositionsandconnecttojobswhenevertheychoosetoenterthejobmarket.Formoreinformation,pleaserefertotheYouthEmploymentProgramLogicModelandProcessMapintheAppendix.ProgramGoals
1. Short-termOutcomesa. Increaseinschoolpersistenceandcareerawarenessfortargetedyouthb. Increasedincome(wealthcreation)fortargetedyouthc. Increaseintargetedyouthwithworkreadinesstrainingandearlyinternship
experiences(STEM,IT,government,education,manufacturing,service,etc.)d. Increaseinamoreskilledanddiverseworkforcee. Increaseofnewjobsinthecommunity(jobcreation)
2. Long-termOutcomesa. Increasedopportunitiesforemploymentforyouthb. Increaseinyouthgraduatingfromhighschoolc. Increaseinyouthpursuingpost-secondaryeducationtosupportcareer
developmentProjectDescriptionTheBrooklynBridgeAllianceforYouthBoardauthorizedtheAlliancestafftoimplementathree-yearcapacitybuildingprojectthatwouldutilizebestpracticesandtechnicalassistancefromStep-UpinMinneapolistocreateaYouthEmploymentProgram,tobemanagedandfundedbytheAlliancein2015and2016,jointlymanagedandfundedin2017bytheAllianceandCitypartners,andbetransferredtocompletelytoCitypartnerstomanageandfundin2018.ProjectGoals1. CapacityBuildingProject
a. DeterminethedegreeofsupportfromtheprivatesectorandAlliancepartnerswhowillcontributekeyresourcestowardsimplementation.
b. DetermineexactcostsofthisprogramasimplementedintheBrooklynstodeterminefeasibilityfortheCitiesabsorbingtheprogram.
c. Understandtheresults,benefits,andvalue-addtotheCommunityandifthisisdirectionpolicymakersshouldsupport.
d. Alignlocalmunicipalitiesandcountyresources,bothpolicyandpractice,tosupportthiswork.
2. CustomizetheStep-UpmodeltotheBrooklynsa. Createaclearpathwaytocareerandcollegeandensuretheconnectionbetween
earlyemploymentexperiencesandeducation.b. Buildinternshipswithlocalbusinesses.c. Developpre-employmenttrainingandcoordinatealreadyexistingtrainings.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 9
ResearchFrameworkforBuildingPathwaystoCollege&CareerOneofthegoalsoftheAllianceistoincreaseyoungpeople’spathwaystocollegeandcareer.Usingresearchaboutcollegeandcareerreadinessframeworks,includingthosefromtheEducationalPolicyImprovementCenter(EPIC)andMHALabs(MeansandMeasuresofHumanAchievement),theAlliancedevelopedaPathwaytoCollegeandCareerFramework.Inadditiontothetraditionalacademicbenchmarks(highschoolgraduation,ACT/SAT,collegeprerequisitecourses)ourframeworkincludes3additionalcomponents:
• 21stCenturySkillso PersonalMindseto PlanningforSuccesso SocialAwarenesso VerbalCommunicationo Collaborationo ProblemSolving
• CollegeTransitionalSkillso College-CareerAwarenesso ProceduralIssueso FinancialIssueso CollegeCulturalNormso AcademicSkills
• CareerSpecificTransitionSkillso Career-CollegeAwarenesso ProceduralIssueso WorkNavigationSkillso WorkplaceCulturalNorms
Theseconceptsarelearnedbestbyyoungpeopleusingbothclassroomandexperientiallearningopportunities(e.g.PostsecondaryEnrollmentOptions,internships).ThisframeworkwasusedtoinformthedesignanddevelopmentofBrookLynk.
EVALUATIONPURPOSEThepurposeofthisdocumentistoreportontheevaluationandmeasurementofvariouscomponentsoftheBrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgram.TheresultsofthisevaluationwillbedisseminatedtoAlliancemembersandfunderstoreportparticipationandoutcomeinformation,andsuccessofmodelingourprogramafterSTEP-UPMinneapolis.Theevaluationwillalsobeusedtoimprovetheprogramexperienceforstudents,employers,thecommunity,andstaff.Theevaluationwillemploybothformativeandsummativeevaluationmethodstoanswerthecoreevaluationquestionsinordertoinformtheongoingrefiningandimprovementoftheprogram,aswellasreviewlong-termprogressonmajorprogramgoalsandobjectives.Andfinally,theevaluationwillinformtheAlliance’seffortstohelpthetwocitiestakeownershipoftheprogramin2018.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 10
Thegoalsoftheevaluationareto:• Tracknumber,participation,anddemographicsofyouthserved• Documentprogramactivitiesandprocesses• Establishtoolsandmethods,andcollectdataforprogramcontinuousquality
improvement• Measureprogram,youth,andcommunityoutcomesandimpacts
COREEVALUATIONQUESTIONSThecoreevaluationquestionsweredevelopedwithguidancefromAllianceExecutiveLeadershipTeam’sRecommendationsforYouthEmploymentProgramImplementationandfromstakeholderreportingrequirements.
• YouthParticipation:Didtargetedyouth(liveorattendschoolintheBrooklyns,underserved,withemploymentbarriers,OpportunityYouth)participateintheprogram?
• CommunityParticipation:Dideducation,business,andothercommunitypartnersparticipateintheprogram?
• QualityAssessment:Whatwasthelevelofqualityforourprogramservices?• YouthOutcomes:Inwhatwaysdidtheparticipatingyouthgainthenecessarywork
readinessskills,financialbenefits,andsocialconnectionsasanoutcomeoftheprogramtopreparethemforjobs?Weretheysatisfiedwiththeirinternshipexperiences?
• BusinessOutcomes:Wereemployerssatisfiedwiththeirexperienceswiththeprogramandtheinterns?
• CapacityBuilding:Whatarethedegreeofsupports,programcosts,andpoliticalwillnecessarytooperatethiscustomizedmodeleffectivelyandefficientlyfortheBrooklyns?
• ProcessEvaluation:WhatdidwedotocustomizetheMinneapolisSTEP-UPmodelfortheBrooklyns?Howwelldidthecustomizedprocesswork?
AndsincethisisthelastyearthattheAlliancewilloperateBrookLynktherearetwoadditionalquestionswewillbeanswering:
• Whatimprovementsandlessonslearnedoccurredinthe3yearsbetweenlaunchingBrookLynkandnow?
• Inwhatwayswilltheprogramevaluationchangenextyear?
EVALUATIONMETHODSThefollowingdatacollectionmethodsandassessmentswereusedduringevaluationofeachphaseoftheprogram.
• Applications:ApplicationsfromparticipantswillbeacceptedonlineviaSurveyMonkeyatthebeginningoftheprogramtocollectparticipationanddemographicdata.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 11
• Attendance:AttendanceatGetReady!WorkReadinessTrainings,MockInterviews,InternshipPreparationTrainings,YouthJobFair,InternOrientation,SupervisorTraining,andCheck-Inswillbecollectedbyprogramstaff.
• WorkReadinessTrainingSurveyo YouthSurvey:Programevaluationswillbecompletedbystudentsonthe
trainingstocollectoutcomedataandprogramexperiencedataforqualityandprocessevaluation.
o TrainerSurvey:Programevaluationswillbecompletedbytrainerstocollectprogramexperiencedataforqualityandprocessevaluation.
• YouthJobFairSurveyso Asampleofyouthattendeeswillbesurveyedtocollectoutcomeand
programexperiencedata.o Allemployersandorganizationswillbesurveyedtocollectoutcomeand
programexperiencedata.• CommunityParticipation:BrookLynkparticipationdatabycommunitypartnerswill
becollectedbytheprogramstaff.• InternPerformanceReviews:Attheendoftheprogram,supervisorswillrateinterns
ontheMHALabsCompetenciesandtheresultswillbecollectedforuseinoutcomeevaluation.
• InternshipSurveys:o Internswillbeaskedtocompletesurveysattheendoftheprogramontheir
internshipstotrackoutputandoutcomedata,andprogramexperiencedataforqualityandprocessevaluation.
o Supervisorswillbeaskedtocompletesurveysattheendoftheprogramontheirinternshipstotrackoutputandoutcomedata,andprogramexperiencedataforqualityandprocessevaluation.
• YPQASelf-Assessment:AmodifiedYPQAassessmentwillbecompletedforinternshipsusingdatacollectedduringsitevisitsandinternshipsurveys.
• ProcessEvaluationQuestionnaire:TheprogramstaffwillbeaskedtoanswerprocessevaluationquestionsduringandontheentireBrooklynkProgram.
• CapacityBuildingQuestionnaire:Theprogramstaffwillbeaskedtocompleteacapacitybuildingevaluationquestionnaireonthedegreeofsupport,programcosts,andpoliticalwillnecessarytooperateBrookLynk.
RESULTSThefollowingsectiondetailstheresultsforeachcoreevaluationquestion.YouthParticipationDidtargetedyouth(youthwholiveorgotoschoolintheBrooklyns,withemploymentbarriers,and/orareCountyInvolved/OpportunityYouth)participateintheprogram?InthisthirdyearoftheBrookLynkprogram,529youthappliedtoparticipateintheGetReady!WorkReadinessTraining.Ninety-fourpercent(94%)werestudentsofcolorand39%werefromimmigrantfamilies.Onehundredeighty-nine(189)youthcompletedworkreadinesstraining.Allofthestudentshadaleastonebarriertoemploymentand/orwere
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 12
recruitedthroughourReferralPartnerandBrookLynkAmbassador(alumni)recruiters.BrookLynkhad96studentinternsthisyearanda95%completionrate.
“Ilikedhowmyinternshipwassortoflikeaboosterforme.IsaythisbecausewithoutthisopportunityIwouldn'thaveknownorhowIwouldwanttopursueacareerinthetechnologyfieldorifIevenwantedtogointothecareerinthefirstplace.WorkinginITmademerealizehowmanycareeropportunitiesthereareoutthere.”–BrookLynkIntern
_____________________________YouthOutreach
2015 2016 2017Applicants 234 399 529
BytheendofMarch,529youthappliedtoparticipateintheBrookLynkGetReady!WorkReadinessTraining,whichmetthe2017goal.Theyouthwhoappliedrepresentedatotalof33middle,juniorhigh,andhighschoolsintheNorthwestMetroArea,mostlyinBrooklynCenterandBrooklynPark.Otheroutputdataissummarizedbelow:
Grade 2015 2016 20178th 10% 3% 3%9th 20% 22% 15%10th 28% 27% 24%11th 22% 28% 30%12th 16% 18% 26%Graduated,nocollege 2% 1% 1%Notcurrentlyenrolledinschool 2% 1% 0%Race/Ethnicity 2015 2016 2017Asian 7% 24% 20%HispanicorLatino 6% 14% 10%BlackorAfricanAmerican 56% 45% 40%African 7% 23% 23%AmericanIndianorAlaskanNative 4% 3% 2%WhiteorEuropeanAmerican 13% 13% 8%Other 2% 1% 2%
Notes:Duetoanerrorintheapplicationprocess,applicantsfor2017wereunabletoselectmorethanonerace/ethnicityunlesstheywroteintheirselectionson“Other”.EstimatesfromtheAmericanCommunitySurvey(5-YearEstimates2010-2014)forRace/EthnicityfortheBrooklynsforYouthUnder18:Asian19%,Hispanic/Latino11%,African-American18%,African16%,Other7%,White29%.
CityofResidence 2015 2016 2017BrooklynPark 56% 50% 57%BrooklynCenter 36% 34% 32%Minneapolis 3% 6% 4%Other 5% 10% 7%
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 13
School 2015 2016 2017ParkCenterSeniorHigh 22% 25% 23%BrooklynCenterSecondary 17% 21% 19%OsseoSeniorHighSchool 3% 15% 17%ChamplinParkHighSchool 10% 16% 15%BrooklynCenterAcademy 9% 3% 4%RobbinsdaleCooperHighSchool 2% 4% 3%RobbinsdaleArmstrongHighSchool 0% 1% 3%GatewaytoCollege-HTC 5% 2% 3%Other 32% 14% 15%
Note:Inordertobeinvitedtothetraining,applicantshadtoliveorattendschoolintheBrooklyns.Outofthoseapplicants,35%livedorwenttoschoolinBrooklynCenterand65%livedorwenttoschoolBrooklynPark.Inordertocalculatethosepercentages,applicantswerefirstmatchedtotheircityofresidence.Iftheylivedinneithercity,thentheywerematchedtothecitywheretheyattendedschool.
BarrierstoEmployment 2015 2016 2017QualifyforFree/ReducedLunch 74% 85% 80%Immigrant(FamilyorYouth) 26% 46% 39%FirstinFamilytoAttendCollege 22% 22% 18%HaveanIEPorDisability 9% 15% 12%FirstinFamilytoGraduatefromHighSchool 12% 12% 9%DroppedoutofHighSchool 7% 1% 5%HomelessorHighlyMobile 6% 10% 5%EnglishLanguageLearner 5% 5% 5%JuvenileProbation 5% 3% 4%ParentingTeen 1% 1% 2%FosterCareSystemInvolvement 2% 1% 1%OpportunityYouth 17% 13% 17%
Thedemandfortheworkreadinesstrainingincreasedfromlastyearaccordingtothenumberofapplicants.Thepercentageof8thgradersremainedlowthisyearduetodecreasedoutreachtothatgradelevelsincethereisnotadevelopedinternshippathwayfortheyoungerstudentsatthistime.Therace/ethnicitydemographicsremainedsimilartothepreviousyear,againmirroringtheBrooklynspopulationwearetargeting.Thetoptwobarriersstudentsreportedwerequalificationforfreeorreducedlunch(81%),andimmigrantfamilies(39%)whomayhavelimitedexperienceinnavigatingnewworkcultures.Wehadincreasednumbersofopportunityyouth(disconnectedyouth)andcounty-involvedyouthreachedfrom2016.SuggestionsforImprovement
• Considernewstrategiestomeettheneedsofandattract(Opportunity)youthdisconnectedfromeducationalandcareerpathways,andcounty-involvedyouth.
• Revisitthegoalof30%ofyouthservedbeingOpportunityYouthandreframeitintermsofpercentageofOpportunityYouthintheBrooklynsserved.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 14
Three-YearSummaryThenumberofapplicantsfortheGetReady!Trainingincreasedfrom234youthin2015to399youthin2016andfinally529youthin2017.Thepercentagesof9ththrough12thgradersshiftedmoretowardsthejuniorsandseniorsoverthethreeyears,andtheracialandethnicmake-upoftheapplicantsshowedthediversityrepresentedinourcommunities.ThepercentagesofstudentsfromthevariousschoolsaretobeexpectedconsideringthepopulationsofstudentslivingorgoingtoschoolintheBrooklynsateachlocation.Finally,youthwiththespecificbarrierstoemploymentwerereached,exceptforonegroup:theBrookLynkprogramdidnotreachthegoalofserving30%OpportunityYouth.WorkReadinessTraining 2015 2016 2017Numberofyouthinvitedtoworkreadinesstraining 200 334 430Numberofyouthwhocompletedworkreadinesstraining 80 136 189Retentionratefrominvitationtocompletion 48% 42% 44%Numberofyouthwhoattendedmockinterviews 55 84 116Numberofyouthwhoattendedtheinternshiptraining N/A* 68 102
*Internshiptrainingwasnewfor2016.Lessthan50%oftheyouthwhowereinvitedtothetrainingsattended,eventhoughBrookLynkstaffcontactedeachapplicantbyphonetheweekofthetrainings.AlhtoughBrookLynkdidincreasethenumberofyouthcompletingtrainingfromlastyearby40%,wedidnotreachourgoalof300students.Thisretentionratemaybeduetothefactthatitiseasytosignupfor,isfree,andthereisnopenaltyfornotshowingup.WehavelearnedfromourSTEP-UPpartnersthattheyhaveasimilarretentionrateforthissegment.Aftereachtrainingyouthwhodidnotshowupwerecontactedbyphoneinordertounderstandwhathadoccurredtocausethemtomisstheevent.Somestudentsinformedstaffthattheywerenotinterestedinattendinganymore.Themajorityofstudentsrespondedthatresponsibilitiesathomecameup,transportationtotheeventwasunavailablelastminute,orthattheyhadforgotten.Someofthestudentswhohadmissedthefirstweekendandwerecontactedafterwardswereabletorescheduletoattendthesecondweekend.SuggestionsforImprovement
• Scheduleadditionaltrainings,atalternativestimes.• Workwithschooldistrictstoofferworkreadinesstrainingduringschool-dayor
afterschoolprogramming,andinvestigateofferinghighschoolcredittotakingpart.Three-YearSummaryThenumberofyouthwhowereinvitedtoandcompletedworkreadinesstrainingincreasedeachyear.Similarly,thenumberofyouthparticipatinginthemockinterviewsandinternshippreparationtrainingalsoincreased.Theretentionrateremainedrelativelyconstantoverthe3yearsevenafterattemptstoincreaseitbyremindingyouththeweekoftrainingsviaemails,phonecalls,andtexts.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 15
InternshipsandCheck-Ins
2015 2016 2017Numberofyouthwhoappliedforinternships 39 84 129Numberofinternshipopportunitiespledgedbyemployers 32 65 106Numberofyouthwhowerematchedwithinternships 29 65 104Numberofyouthwaitlisted 10 18 25Numberofyouthwhobeganinternships 29 62 96Numberofyouthwhocompletedinternships 25 58 91Completionrate 86% 94% 95%Percentageofyouthwithnopriorworkexperience 86% 64% 49%Numberofbuspassesprovided 6 24 22Averagepercentageofyouthwhoattendedeachcheck-in 58% 60% 62%Averagenumberofyouthwhoattendedcollege/companyvisits 9 18 23Thenumbersofyouthwhoapplied,internshipspledged,youthmatchedtointernships,youthwaitlisted,andyouthwhobeganinternshipsallincreasedfrom2016’sprogram.Ninety-one(91)internssuccessfullycompletedtheirinternshipfromthe96whostartedforacompletionpercentageof95%.Five(5)internsdidnotcompletetheirinternshipduetofamilychallenges,lifecircumstances,andtermination.Three-YearOutlookTheplannedincrementalgrowthwassuccessful.BrookLynkgrewfrom29internshipsin2015to62internshipsin2016and96thisyear.ThiswasmoreimpressivewiththefactthatBrookLynkmaintainedaveryhighcompletionratewhilestilltargetingyouthwithbarrierstoemployment.Thecompletionrateisstillveryhighandhasslightlyincreasedsince2015.Thepercentageofyouthwithnopriorworkexperiencehasbeendecreasingthepastthreeyears.ThismightbeduetothenumberofBrookLynkthisyearwhoparticipatedininternshipsagain(19%),orthattheprogramisattractingmoreyouththanbeforewhohavesomeworkexperience.Thepercentageofyouthwhoareattendingcheck-insisstillnear60%.ToincreaseBrookLynkmayneedtoconsidernewstrategies.Morestudentsareattendingthecollegeandcompanysitevisitsin2017thaninpreviousyears.YouthJobFair
2017Numberofyouthwhoattendedjobfair 159Numberofemployerswhoattendedjobfair 14Numberoforganizationsofferingservices 4Numberofyouthwhovisitedeachemployerbooth(range) 23to75Numberofapplicationsreceivedbyeachemployer(range) 0to50
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 16
NumberofinterviewsgivenduetoYouthJobFair(total) 11NumberofjoboffersgivenduetoYouthJobFair(total) 1
Aswithanylaunchofanynewprogramelement,severaliterationsareoftenrequiredtoaccomplishgoals.AlthoughBrookLynkaimedhigh,itfellshort.Initialgoalswere500youthattending(159attended)and50employers(18employersandorganizationsattended).AmorecompleteevaluationoftheeventisdetailedintheProcessEvaluationsectionbelow.SuggestionsforImprovement
• Ensuretherearejob,volunteer,andsummeropportunitiesfor14-15yearolds.• Considernewstrategiestorecruitmoreyouthandbusinessestoattend,andto
matchjobseekerstoemployerswithjobopeningsattheevent.
CommunityParticipationDideducation,business,andothercommunitypartnersparticipateintheprogram?Six(6)educationpartners,5businesspartners,and3communitypartners(18departments)offeredBrookLynkinternshipopportunities.ForthefirsttimesinceallAlliancemembersparticipatedinofferinginternships.OurAlliancemembersandcommunitypartnersprovidedin-kinddonationsformanyofourfacility,transportation,andmaterialneeds,andstafforanorganizationalpresenceatourevents.
“IlovedandreallyenjoyedtheworkIdidthissummer.Initially,whenIfirstreceivedtheemailaboutwhereIwouldbeworkingIwasquestioningitinregardstoifitwastherightmatchforme.Iwasn'tsureifitwaswhereIwantedtobe,butIendeduplovingitsomuch.IwasexposedtothingsIneverthoughtI'dseeandexperience.Ilearnedalotandlearnedthatthereisreallyaproblemoutthereinourcommunitiesinregardstohowthegovernmentworksandequityforourunderrepresentedcommunities.MyinternshipthissummerhelpedmefindsomethingI'mpassionateabout.”–BrookLynkintern
_____________________________
Alliancemembersandcommunitypartnersprovidedin-kinddonationsforfacility,transportation,andmaterialneeds,andstafforanorganizationalpresenceatourevents.FundingfortheprogramwasalsoprovidedbygrantsfromtheBremerFoundation,theUnitedWay,PohladFoundation,andHennepinCountyStateEquityfunds.Inadditiontotheinternships,BostonScientificandCumminsPowerGenerationprovidedtransportation(viaSafeTreeTransportation)totheirinternsintheArdenHillsandShoreviewlocations.
Specifically,ourcommunitypartnersprovidedthefollowingsupportsduringtheprogram:
GetReady!WorkReadinessTrainings,MockInterviews,andInternshipPreparationTraining:HennepinTechnicalCollegeprovidedthespaceforthetrainingsandtheYMCA
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 17
TwinCitiesprovidedoneofthetrainers.TheCityofBrooklynParkprovidedaroomattheCommunityActivityCenterforthemockinterviews.Representativesfrommanycommunitypartnersvolunteeredasinterviewers,includingToplineFederalCreditUnion,YellowTreeTheatre,Nilfisk,CumminsPowerGeneration,BostonScientific,theCityofBrooklynPark,theCityofBrooklynCenter,OsseoAreaSchools,Anoka-HennepinSchoolDistrict,HennepinCounty,theLionsClub,andtheRotaryClubofBrooklynPark.YouthJobFair:AgrantfromtheBremerFoundationfundedtheYouthJobFair.TheAlliancemembersprovidedstafftoparticipateintheplanningcommittee.NorthHennepinCommunityCollegeprovidedtheirfacilitiesfortheYouthJobFair.OsseoAreaSchoolsprovidedbustransportationandfoodandbeverages.Hy-Veeprovidedfinancialsupport.BrooklynParkRec-on-the-Gocametoproviderecreationactivitiesforyoungersiblings.Participatingemployersandorganizationsprovidingjobsandsupportsincluded:HennepinCounty,Anoka-HennepinSchools,MinnesotaUnitedFC,McDonald’s,UPS,Fed-Ex,theUSArmy,OsseoAreaSchools,theYMCATwinCities,MinnesotaDepartmentofEducationandEconomicDevelopment,JobCorps,EnglishRoseSuites,TreeTrust,BrooklynParkFireExplorers,HennepinTechnicalCollege,NorthHennepinCommunityCollege,BrooklynsYouthCouncil,andComunidadesLatinasUnidasServicio(CLUES).TheYMCATwinCitiesstaffedthecomputerlabtohelpstudentscreatearesumeandapplyforjobsonline.InternandParentOrientation:TheCityofBrooklynParkprovidedaroomattheCommunityActivityCenterfortheorientation.MetroTransitandFireflyCreditUnionledworkshopsonhowtotakepublictransportationandfinancialliteracy,respectively.SupervisorTraining:NorthHennepinCommunityCollegeprovidedtheirfacilitiesfortheSupervisorTraining.TheYMCATwinCitiesprovidedstafftohelptrainthesupervisors.Check-insandEnrichmentOpportunities:NorthHennepinCommunityCollegeprovidedtheirfacilitiesfortheweeklyinterncheck-ins.CollegevisitswerehostedbyConcordiaUniversityandtheUniversityofMinnesota,TwinCities.AcompanysitevisitwashostedbyGeneralMills.Internships:Thefollowing14employersprovidedinternshipopportunitiesthisyear(includingnumberofinternships):
EducationPartners
• Anoka-HennepinAreaSchools(5)• BrooklynCenterCommunitySchools(8)• HennepinTechnicalCollege(5)• NorthHennepinCommunityCollege(6)• OsseoAreaSchools(15)• RobbinsdaleAreaSchools(3)
BusinessPartners• AllenPropertyServices,LLC(2)• Amplifon,Inc.(2)• BostonScientific(8)• CumminsPowerGeneration(6)
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 18
• ToplineFederalCreditUnion(1)CommunityPartners
• CityofBrooklynCenter(17)o AdministrationandOfficeoftheClerko BuildingandCommunityStandardsDepartmento BusinessandDevelopmentDepartmento CommunityActivities,Recreation&Serviceso FinanceDepartmento FireDepartmento PoliceDepartmento PublicWorksDepartment
• CityofBrooklynPark(13)o CommunityDevelopmentDepartmento CommunityEngagementDepartmento InformationTechnologyDepartmento OperationsandMaintenanceDepartmento PoliceDepartmento RecreationandParksDepartment,YouthServices
• HennepinCounty(5)o BrooklynParkLibraryo CenterofInnovationandExcellenceo HumanServicesandPublicHealthDepartmento PublicWorksDepartment
Year-EndCelebration:NorthHennepinCommunityCollegeprovidedtheirfacilitiesforthecelebration.
SuggestionsforImprovement
• Createan“engagementladder”forcommunitypartnerstogetinvolvedwithincreasingprogressionofcommitment,e.g.donatingfinancialorin-kindsupport,participatinginatrainingorevent,providinginternships,orjoiningabusinessadvisory.
Three-YearSummaryIn2015,BrookLynkhad8partnersprovide29internships,andafewAlliancemembersandotherpartnerscontributedin-kinddonationsandstaffforthemockinterviews.In2016,therewere16partnersproviding62internships,andaboutadozenAlliancemembersandotherpartnerswhoparticipatedinmockinterviews,providingworkshopsandenrichmentopportunities,andin-kinddonations.Andin2017,therewere14partners(includingallofourAlliancemembers)providing96internships,and36organizationscontributedfundingandin-kinddonations,andparticipatedinBrookLynktrainingsandevents.BrookLynkhasgrowninthenumberandbreadthofpartnershipswithorganizationsinthecommunity.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 19
QualityAssessmentWhatwasthelevelofqualityforourprogramservices?TheYouthProgramQualityAssessment(YPQA)®self-assessmentwascompletedduringoneoftheWorkReadinessTrainings.Significantchangesweremadetothedesignofthetrainingtoaddressthelowerscoresfrompreviousyears,andthescoresshoweddramaticimprovement.Theinternshipswereagainassessedthisyearusingamodifiedqualityassessment,andtheyscoredhighforqualityacrosstheboard.
“IlikehowIwasbeingchallengedbydoingthingsIusuallydon'tdo.I'velearnedhowtotalktostrangersandcomeoutofmycomfortzone.Ilikegoingtomeetingsandhearinghoweachsituationwillbesolvedandthebestpossiblesolution.SometimesIlikeputtingpaperworktogetheranddoingregistrationforpeopleeventhoughI'mnotgoodatit.Ilikerunningsmallerrands.Ilikegoingalongwithmyco-workerandseehowtheygiveatourtotheroom.Ilikeguidingwheretheroomsareandhavingsmallconversationswiththestaffsandpeople.”–BrookLynkintern
_____________________________TheYPQAisavalidatedinstrument(grades4-12)designedtomeasurethequalityofyouthprogramsandidentifystafftrainingneeds.TheYouthPQAevaluatedthequalityofyouthexperiencesasyouthattendworkshopsandclasses,completegroupprojects,andparticipateinmeetingsandregularprogramactivities.Domaincategoriesarebrokendownintoindividualscales,whicharerated1,3,or5(1beingthelowestand5beingthehighest).TheYPQASelf-AssessmentwascompletedduringthesecondweekendoftheGetReady!WorkReadinessTrainingsessions.Asummaryoftheresultscomparingtheassessmentontheworkreadinesstrainingsfromall3yearsispresentedbelow.
YOUTHPQASCORES2015
GetReady!Training
2016GetReady!Training
2017GetReady!Training
SafeEnvironment 4.7 4.7 4.8EmotionalSafety 5.0 5.0 5.0HealthyEnvironment 5.0 5.0 5.0EmergencyPreparedness 4.0 4.0 4.0AccommodatingEnvironment 5.0 5.0 5.0Nourishment 4.3 4.3 5.0
SupportiveEnvironment 3.4 4.1 4.8WarmWelcome 4.3 5.0 5.0SessionFlow 4.6 4.6 4.6ActiveEngagement 3.0 3.0 5.0Skill-Building 2.0 3.5 5.0Encouragement 3.7 4.3 4.3ReframingConflict 2.5 4.0 N/A
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 20
Interaction 2.7 2.5 4.4Belonging 4.0 4.0 4.5Collaboration 2.3 2.3 5.0Leadership 2.3 1.7 3.0AdultPartners 2.0 2.0 5.0
Engagement 1.8 1.8 4.0Planning 1.0 1.0 4.0Choice 1.0 2.0 4.0Reflection 3.5 2.5 4.0
ThebiggestimprovementswereintheInteractionandEngagementdomains.Thoseareasscoredlowestforthetraininginpreviousyears,consideringthelecture-styleclassesusedintheWorkReadinessTraining,andthelackofchoiceforyouth.BrookLynkstaffaddedthreenewaspectstothetrainingthisyear.First,studentsweregivenachoiceofthreetracks:beginner,intermediate,andadvanced.Thesetrackswerestructuredforstudentswithnopreviousworkexperience,studentswithsomeexposure,andstudentswithextensiveworkexperienceoralumnioftheinternshipprogram.Second,someoftheinternshipalumniwereaskedtoco-teachthetrainingwiththeadulttrainers.Thisofferedmoreopportunitiesfor(some)youthtoleadinpartnershipwithadults.Finally,innotingthatpreviousyears’trainingslackedofopportunitiesforyouthtoreflectontheirlearningaswellasanactivecomponentintheclass,staffspecificallyprovidedoptionsforhowtheycouldincorporatemorereflectionquestionsandactivities.SincetheinternshipsareacorepartofprogramtheevaluationteamcreatedanInternshipQualityAssessmentthatwasinformedbytheYouthPQA.OfthefourdomainsintheYouthPQAseveralwereassessedduringthesitevisitswhiletheremainingareaswereratedbysurveyinginternsattheendoftheirsummerexperience.
INTERNSHIPQUALITYASSESSMENTSCORES
2016Internships
2017Internships
SafeEnvironment 5.0 4.8EmotionalSafety 5.0 4.5HealthyEnvironment 5.0 5.0EmergencyPreparedness 5.0 4.4AccommodatingEnvironment 4.7 5.0Nourishment 5.0 5.0
SupportiveEnvironment 4.5 4.5WarmWelcome N/A 4.6SessionFlow 4.1 4.4ActiveEngagement 4.5 N/ASkill-Building 4.5 4.4Encouragement 4.6 4.6ReframingConflict N/A N/A
Interaction 4.6 4.6Belonging 4.6 4.4Collaboration 4.6 4.5
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 21
Leadership N/A N/AAdultPartners N/A 4.8
Engagement 4.3 4.3Planning 4.3 4.4Choice 3.9 4.3Reflection 4.6 4.2
Thescoreswereverysimilartothepreviousyear.Cautionshouldbeusedintryingtomakeanydirectcomparisonsbetweenyears,sincethemodifiedassessmentthisyearwastweakedtoaddslightlydifferentquestionstotrytoimproveonlastyearassessmenttool.SuggestionforImprovement
• Fine-tunethedifferenttracksofferedduringthetrainingtobetterfittheworkreadinessneedsofthestudentsattending.
• Continuetoimproveandvalidatetheprocessofassessingqualityintheinternshipexperiencesatemployerlocations.
Three-YearSummaryEachyear,theGetReady!WorkReadinessTraininghasbeenassessedandanactionplanhasbeenputintoplacetoimprovethequality(specificallywiththeInteractionandEngagementdomains),withhigherscoresthefollowingyears.Theinternshipmodifiedqualityassessmentwasaddedin2016,andhasbeenusefulinourunderstandingofwhataqualityinternshiplookslikeandhowtotrainsupervisorsaccordingly,butitvalidityisstillunclear.
YouthOutcomesInwhatwaysdidtheparticipatingyouthgainthenecessaryworkreadinessandsocial-emotionallearningskills,financialbenefits,andsocialconnectionsasanoutcomeoftheprogramtopreparethemforjobs?Weretheysatisfiedwiththeirinternshipexperiences?Attheendoftheinternship,76%ofinternswereratedbytheirsupervisorsashavinggainedall13workreadinessskillstheywereassessedon.Seventy-sixpercent(76%)ofsupervisorssaidtheywouldhiretheirinterniftheyhadajobopening.Themedianamountofnetsalaryearnedduringthesummerwas$2400.Seventy-sevenpercent(77%)ofinternsthoughtthattheinternshipshelpedthemincreasethenumberofprofessionalsintheirsocialnetwork.Onaverage,theinternsratedtheirinternshipexperiencea4.3outof5,andtheirsupervisorsa4.5outof5.Eighty-sixpercent(86%)oftheinternsagreedthattheyreceivedenoughtrainingandsupporttosuccessfullycompletetheirinternships,98%saidtheywouldparticipateinBrookLynkagainnextyear,and99%respondedthattheywouldrecommendBrookLynktoafriend.
“(Ilikedgettingtheopportunitytoexperience)helpingotherinternswiththeirjobslikecollectingattendance,doingsnacktable,helpingteachers,helpingstudents,respondingtocompanies,andorderingfoodonline.ItreallyhelpedmeexploremypossiblecareeroptionslikeIcanbeateacher,aleader,acompanyowner,andetc.Thisisbyfarthebestaspectsoftheinternship.AlsoIdoenjoythecompanyofotherinternsbecauseitreallyhelpedmebondwith
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 22
themandgetthingsdonequickerinateam.IdowishIcanhaveTHISexactinternshipnextyear.”–BrookLynkAmbassador
_____________________________CareerSkillsBrookLynkisusingtheMeasuresofHumanAchievement(http://mhalabs.org)asatooltogaugeworkreadiness.TheMHAframeworkisanexcellentframeworkthatgivesbothadultsandyouthsharedlanguageabout21stcenturyworkreadinessskills.Staffhaveinvestedsignificanttimetolearn,research,andintegrateMHAtoolsintoourprogramdesign.Thishashelpedtoensurethatsupervisorsprovidinginternshipsareusingastrengthsapproachforinternspersonalandskilldevelopment.TheMHALabs’HireabilitySkillsPerformanceReviewaskedthesupervisorsattheendoftheinternshipstoratetheirinterns’competencyin13basicskillsin5separateskillsetslistedbelow:
• ProfessionalAttitudeo Bringsenergyandenthusiasmtotheworkplaceo Takesresponsibilityforhisorheractionsanddoesnotblameotherso Stayscalm,clearheadedandunflappableunderstresso Graciouslyacceptscriticism
• TeamWorkEthico Activelylooksforadditionaltaskswhenownworkisdoneo Activelylooksforwaystohelpotherpeople
• ProblemSolvingo Unpacksproblemsintomanageablepartso Generatesmultiplepotentialsolutionstoproblemso Identifiesnewandmoreeffectivewaystosolveproblems
• TimeManagemento Managestimeanddoesnotprocrastinateo Getsworkdoneontimeo Arrivesontimeandisrarelyabsentwithoutcause
• VerbalCommunicationo Communicatesprofessionally
TheHireabilitySkillsframeworkincludesbasicworkreadinessskillsthatwillallowyoungpeopletogethiredandmaintainanentry-levelposition.InternswhoscoredStandard,Skilled,orExpertinaskillareaweredeemedcompetent.ThescoringoptionsbelowStandardareNovice(lowest)andEmerging.
NumberofMHALabsWorkCoreSkillsInternsRatedCompetentIn
%ofInternsRatedCompetentWithThoseNumberofSkills
2016 2017
Under10CareerSkills 8% 5%10-12CareerSkills 23% 18%13CareerSkills 70% 76%
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 23
Overall,76%ofinternsratedcompetentinall13outof13careerskillsbytheirsupervisors.Theinternsseemedtoagreewiththoseassessmentsas82%answeredMostlyTrueorCompletelyTruetothestatement“Myinternshipexperiencetaughtmevaluablecareerskills.”Relatedmeasuresofwhetherinternsarework-readyincludethreestatementsalsoonthePerformanceReviews(CompletelyTrueorMostlyTrue).
2016 2017 IfIhadajobopening,Iwouldhirethisperson 70% 76% Iwouldrecommendthispersontoacolleague,forasimilarposition 73% 82%
Iwouldseekoutthispersontobeonmynextproject 68% 73%
Three-YearReviewThepercentageofinternswhowereratedbytheirsupervisorstobecompetentinall13oftheCareerSkillsincreasedfrom2016to2017.Onepossibleexplanationfortheseimprovementswasimprovedtraining.Inboththeyouthandsupervisortrainings,therehasbeenincreasedtimespentonlearningabouttheMHALabsframeworkandhowtogaintherelevantskills.Andthenthisisrefreshedduringthecheck-insandinemailstosupervisorsduringthesummer.FinancesStudentsreportedtheirnetearningsaftertheirpaidinternshipsthissummer.
NetEarnings 2015 2016 2017NotSure 9% 7% 5%$0-$999 41% 16% 15%
$1000-$1999 50% 57% 20%$2000-$2999 0% 22% 25%$3000-$3999 0% 9% 25%$4000+ 0% 0% 11%
2015 2016 2017Mediannetearnings $1000 $1500 $2400Putmoneyinbankorcreditunionaccount 82% 84% 92%Hadpaychecksdepositedbydirectdeposit 64% 68% 72%
ThemediannetearningamountforBrookLynkinternsin2017was$2400(thisdoesnotincludeanytaxesorotherdeductions,orbenefitsoffered).Thisnumberissubstantiallyhigherthanpreviousyearsmostlylikelyforseveralreasons.Inthepast,wesurveyedinternsattheendofthesummertoaskthemtoself-reportthetotalamountearned,whichwesuspectwasunderreported.Thisyear,weaskedinternstoreporthowmanyweekstheyworked,howmanyhoursperweektheyaveraged,andwhattheirhourlysalarywas(whichwewereabletoconfirmwiththeemployers).Wethencalculatedforthemwhattheirtotalearningswere,whichisprobablymoreaccurate.Second,sinceseveralofourinternships
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 24
werefundedorsubsidizedviaaHennepinCountygrantwhichrequiredsalariestobe$15/hr.,thosesalarieswerehigherthantheywouldhavebeennormally.Lastly,althoughtheinternshipswereoriginallyintendedtobefor6-8weekslong,someorganizationshostedtheirinternsforupto10weeks,whichincreasedthehoursworked.Wealsosurveyedthestudentsabouttheirfinancialpracticesandfoundoutthat92%oftheinternsputtheirsavingsintoabankorcreditunionaccount,and72%hadtheirpaycheckssubmittedviadirectdeposit.Thesenumberswerehigherthanpreviousyears’.Three-YearReviewThemediannetearningamounthasincreasedoverthethreeyearsoftheprogram.Asexplainedabove,partofthismightbeduetomoreaccuratedatacollection,butinternsareearningmoreintheprogramnowthantheyhaveinpreviousyears.Alsomoreinternsaredepositingtheirpaychecksintoabankorcreditunionandareusingdirectdeposittodoso.SocialNetworksResearchshowsthathavingaccesstoprofessionalsocialnetworksincreasesthechancesoflandingajob.Manyofourinternshavelimitedprofessionalsocialnetworks.OneofBrookLynk’sgoalsthroughtheinternshipswastoincreasethenumberofprofessionalsintheyoungperson’snetwork.
2015 2016 2017Myinternshiphelpedmeincreasethenumberofprofessionalsinmysocialnetwork 96% 82% 77%
Seventy-sevenpercent(77%)ofinternsreported(CompletelytrueorMostlytrue)thattheinternshipshelpedthemincreasethenumberofprofessionalsintheirsocialnetwork.SuggestionsforImprovement
• Designadditionalprogramactivitiestoengageyouthindevelopingtheirsocialnetworks,e.g.theAlumniNetwork
Three-YearReviewThedatashowthatsocialnetworkdevelopmenthasdecreasedovertime.Staffreportthatotherprogramimprovementprioritieshaveneglectedtheimplementationofintentionalactivitiesthatwouldsupportthedevelopmentofsocialnetworks.InternCustomerSatisfaction 2015 2016 2017RatingforBrookLynkinternship(onascalefrom1to5) 4.4 4.3 4.3Ratingfortheirsupervisors(onascalefrom1to5) 4.4 4.5 4.5WouldparticipateinBrookLynkagain,ifpossible 86% 95% 98%WouldrecommendBrookLynktoafriend 100% 100% 99%ReceivedenoughsupportfromBrookLynkstaff 100% 95% 86%
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 25
WhenaskedabouthowtheywouldratetheirBrookLynkinternships,theinternssurveyedratedtheirexperiencesanaverageof4.3outof5.0.Ninety-eightpercent(98%)ofinternsreportedthattheywouldparticipateintheBrookLynkprogramagainifpossible.And99%ofinternssaidthattheywouldrecommendBrookLynktoafriend.WhenaskedaboutthesupporttheyreceivedfromBrookLynkstaff,86%ofrespondentsstatedthattheyreceivedenoughsupportduringtheinternship,13%answered“Somewhat”,and1%saidtheydidnotreceiveenoughsupport.Astheprogramhasscaledupinsizeeachyear,theamountofsupportthatinternsreceivefromstaffalsodecreased,althoughthisdidnotimpactcompletionrates.Suggestingthatwhilesupportmaybehelpfulitisnottheprimaryreasoninternscompletetheirsummerinternship.Internsratedtheirsupervisorsanaverageof4.5outof5.0(with1beingpoorand5beingexcellent).Theyalsoratedtheirsupervisorsinthesespecificareasbelow.
Mysupervisor:%ofInternsAnswering“MostlyTrue”
or“CompletelyTrue”2015 2016 2017*
Tookmeseriouslyandtreatedmefairly 78% 76% 90%MademefeeltheworkIdidwasimportanttotheorganization 65% 80% 76%
Askedforandlistenedtomyopinions 70% 71% 82%Gavemefeedbackonmyworkthathelpedmedobetter. 61% 67% 78%
Genuinelycaredaboutmeasaperson. 70% 73% 84%Introducedmetopeoplewhocanhelpmegrow 61% 62% 69%
IssomeoneIcantrust 83% 69% 80%Introducedmetonewideas,experiences,and/orplaces. 65% 69% 71%
Helpedmeseefuturepossibilitiesformyself. 52% 56% 75%
Helpedmesetandachievegoals. 44% 47% 64%*For2015and2016,internswereaskedtoratehowtruevariousstatementsabouttheirsupervisorswereona5-pointscale(NotTrue,ALittleTrue,SomewhatTrue,MostlyTrue,CompletelyTrue).For2017,itwaschangedtoa3-pointscaletobemoreconsistentwithourqualitymeasures(NotTrue,SomewhatTrue,MostlyTrue).Thepercentagesfrom2015and2016wereadjustedtobecomparedto2017results.BrookLynkwasselectedtoparticipateinaregionalfellowshipwithMHALabs.Stafffocusedtheirfellowshipdiscoveryprojectonlearningwhatimpactsupervisorswouldhaveonthequalityoftheinternshipexperience.TheSupervisorTrainingwasrevampedtobettersupporttheneedsofsupervisor’s.Newcontentwasdevelopedtoteachadultshowtoworkwithandrelatetohighschoolinterns,howtobeagoodsupervisor,andhowtoprovidefeedback.Datashowthatthereisarelationshipbetweenchangestothesupervisortrainingandincreasesinhowinternsratedtheirsupervisors.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 26
BrookLynkstaffarefundamentallyinterestedintwoongoingresearchquestions:WhatmakesagoodsupervisorinaBrookLynkinternship?AndhowcanBrookLynkstaffsupportsupervisorstobepreparedtoofferhigh-qualityinternships?Higherresponseratesuponcompletionprovidedenoughdatatobeginuncoveringtheanswers.Someoftheinternshipqualityratingsweredisaggregatedbywhetherornottheintern’ssupervisorattendedtheSupervisorTrainingornot.(Ratingsareona5-pointscalewith1beingNotatAllTrueand5beingCompletelyTrue.)
AverageRating(SupervisorAttendedTraining)
AverageRating(SupervisorDidNotAttendTraining)
Ifeelasenseofbelongingtomyworkplace 4.5 4.0
IfeelthattheworkIdoisimportanttotheorganization 4.7 4.0
Thereisanappropriate(+/-)amountotimeforallofmywork 4.5 4.0
Mysupervisorengagesmeinanintentionalprocessofreflection 4.1 3.8
OverallSupervisorRating 4.5 4.3
OverallBrookLynkRating 4.4 4.1Seventy-threepercent(73%)ofinternshadsupervisorswhoattendedthetraining,27%didnotattendthetraining.Itseemsthatsupervisorsattendingtrainingincreasedtheinterns’ratingofthesupervisors,andalsoincreasedtheratingoftheinternshipexperienceingeneral.Atthispoint,nocorrelationcanbedrawnbutthisquestiondoesmeritmorestudy.Theaspectoftheinternshipsthatinternslikedthebestwastheworkenvironmentthattheyexperienced.Internslikedbeingapartofdoingmeaningfulwork(andbeingpaidforit).Theytalkedabouthowtheirinternshipshelpedpreparethemforthefutureworkincludingtheopportunitytolearnandpracticenewskills,networking,andbeingexposedtodifferentcareers.Internsalsobenefitedfromthenewrelationshipstheydevelopedwithco-workers,mentors,supervisors,andotherinterns.Manyoftheinternswhoworkedinschoolsettingslovedtointeractwiththechildrenundertheircare.Theaspectoftheinternshipsthatinternslikedtheleastwasnothavingenoughtodo.Otheraspectstheyreportedwerehavingtodoworktheydidn’tlikeorthoughtwasboring,havingtodopaperwork,workinginacubicle,havingtogetupearly,dealingwithunrulychildrenanddisagreeableco-workers,workingbythemselves,andspecificjobresponsibilitiestheydidn’tenjoy.Somestudentsweredisappointedthattheycouldnotworkmorehoursduringtheweekormoreweeksduringtheinternship.Anotherleastfavoriteaspectoftheprogramwasrelatedtocheck-insandenrichmentopportunities.Somestudentswerenotinterestedbeinginthecheck-insorhavingtotaketimeoffofworktogotothefieldtrips.SuggestionsforImprovement
• Considerwhatotherdatashouldbecollectedandanalyzedthatmayhelptounderstandthecharacteristicsofahigh-qualitysupervisor.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 27
• Considertoanalyzeandstudythe2017datasettounderstandthecorrelationsbetweenqualityandsupervisortrainingandbehavior.
Three-YearReviewInterns’satisfactionwithBrookLynkhasalwaysbeenhigh,asindicatedbytheratingstheygivefortheprogramandsupervisors,andthefactthatcloseto100%wouldparticipateintheprogramagainandrecommendittotheirfriends.Therehasbeenaslightdecreaseinsatisfactionofsupportsfromprogramstaffandthelevelofsupervisionprovided.Whilesatisfactioninsomeaspectdecreased,itdidnotdecreaseoverallsatisfactionorcompletionrates.AstheprogramhasscaledBrookLynkhasfoundtherightmixofeffortstoensureyouthsuccess.Long-TermOutcomesEighty-three(83)internsparticipatedinthefirsttwoyearsoftheBrookLynkprogram.BrookLynkstaffreachedouttoallofthealumnitotracktheiracademicandjoboutcomesandwereabletofollow-upwith74ofthem.Theremaining9eitherdidnotrespondtoemailsandphonecalls,ortheircontactinformationwasout-of-date.Forthealumniwhoshouldhavegraduatedafter4yearsofhighschool,96%hadearnedtheirdiplomaorGED,and4%werecontinuingwithschool.Oftheremainingalumniwhoshouldstillbeinhighschool,all(100%)areinschoolforFall2017.TheaveragehighschoolgraduationrateforBrooklynshighschoolsin2016was85%,sothegraduationrateforBrookLynkalumni(96%)isexcellent,especiallyforourtargetedpopulationofyouthwhohavebarrierstopathwaystocollegeandcareer.Ofthe51studentswhohadgraduatedfromhighschoolorreceivedtheirGED,45(88%)wereattendingcollegeduringthe2017-2018schoolyear.Additionally,2studentswereenrolledinthePost-SecondaryEnrollmentOptions(PSEO)programtotakecollegeclasseswhilestillinhighschool.TheaveragecollegeenrollmentrateforBrooklynshighschoolsin2015was78%,sotheenrollmentrateforBrookLynkalumniwhograduatedhighschool(88%)ismuchhigher.Seventy-fivepercent(87%)ofthealumniwhowereinthelaborforcewereemployedthissummer.Twenty-twopercent(22%)ofalumniparticipatedinBrookLynkagainin2017.Ofthoseworking,55%workedsummerjobs,19%workedyear-roundfulltimejobs,17%workedpart-timeyear-roundjobs,and2%wereinschoolinternships.WhenaskedhowBrookLynkcouldcontinuetosupportthem,thealumniwantedtobekeptinformedaboutinternshipandjobopportunitiesavailablelocally,toreceivecontinuedsupportandguidancetheirpathwaystoacareer,andnetworkingevents.Notethatmanyofthealumniwhodidnotrespondtousorhadchangedtheircontactinformationwereopportunityyouth.Ifwehadincludedtheirdata,thereportedoutcomespotentiallywouldbedifferent.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 28
SuggestionsforImprovement• Developandlaunchanalumninetworktokeepincontactwithalumniandprovide
ongoingsupportandnetworkingopportunities.• Developandlaunchajobboardprovideinformationaboutlocalinternshipandjob
opportunitiesforyouth.• Inthefuture,oncethereisalargeenoughsampleofyouthwhorespond,considera
morerigorousresearchdesigntocomparealumniwithyouthofsimilarbackgroundstodetermineifBrookLynkmadeadifferenceintheirlifeoutcomes.
BusinessOutcomesWereemployerssatisfiedwiththeirexperienceswiththeprogramandtheinterns?Ninety-twopercent(92%)ofsupervisorssaidthattheywouldliketoparticipateintheBrookLynkprogramagainnextyearwithanotherstudent.Over90%ofsupervisorsreportedthattheyweresatisfiedwiththesupporttheyreceivedfromBrookLynktobeeffectivesupervisorsfortheinterns.Inresponsetofeedbackwereceivedlastyearfromsupervisors,thisyearweinformedthemearlieroftheirmatchessotherewouldbeenoughtimeforthehiringandonboardingprocesses.Eighty-eightpercent(88%)saidtheyhadenoughtimethisyear.And85%believedthattheirinternsweregoodmatchesfortheirorganizations.
“Theinternshipprogramisagreatwayforareabusinessesandorganizationstocollaborateforthegoodofthecommunityandprovideyoungadultswiththeopportunitytolearnandnetworkwithprofessionals,andlearnabitaboutvariouseducationandcareeroptions.Theinternwasvaluabletoourorganizationasshefilledagapwhereweneededhelponvariousprojects,insightsgleamedfromthecapstoneproject(greataddition)andotherbeneficialfeedbackfromayoungadult’spointofview.”
_____________________________ 2015 2016 2017SupervisorTrainingwashelpful 70% 85% 89%Therewasenoughtimetoprepareforanintern N/A 88% 80%Receivedtherightsupportfromcompany/organization N/A N/A 79%ReceivedtherightsupportfromBrookLynk 90% 92% 92%Expectationsofinternshipmatchedwhathappened N/A 77% 81%Internwasagoodmatchformycompany/organization 85% 85% 82%WouldparticipateinBrookLynkagainnextyear 100% 92% 92%
Aboutaquarter(23%)ofthesupervisorssurveyeddidnotattendtheSupervisorTraining.Eighty-ninepercent(89%)ofthesupervisorsthatdidattendtheSupervisorTrainingthoughtitwashelpfulbecausetheylearnedhowtounderstand,setexpectations,andworkwithyouthasinterns,learnedaboutBrookLynkbasics,andpickeduptipsandtoolsonhow
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 29
tobebettersupervisorsthroughtheworkshops.Somesupervisorsthoughtthetrainingwastoobasicorrepeatedinformationtheywerealreadyfamiliarwithasanexperiencedmanager.Thepasttwoyears,manysupervisorsexpressedthattheywishedtheyhadmoretimetopreparefortheirinterns,mostlybecauseofHRhiringprocesses.Theapplication,training,andmatchingwascompletedearlierinordertoaccommodatethem.Weaskedsupervisorsiftheyhadenoughtimethisyearand80%respondedCompletelyTrueorMostlyTrue.Seventy-ninepercent(79%)ofthesupervisorsrespondedthattheyfelttheyreceivedtherightsupportfromtheircompanies/organizationstobeaneffectivesupervisor.Ninety-twopercent(92%)ofthesupervisorssaidthattheyfelttheyreceivedtherightsupportandresourcestobeeffectivesupervisorsfromBrookLynk.Whenaskedaboutsupervision,24%ofsupervisorsprovideddirectsupervision,10%delegatedthatresponsibilitytosomeoneelse,and66%respondedthatacombinationofthemselvesandothersprovidedsupervision.Whenaskedhowmuchhoursofsupervisionwereprovidedperweek,3%said0hours,16%said1-2hours,24%said3-4hours,10%said5-6hours,and47%said7+hours.Eighty-onepercent(81%)ofsupervisorssaidthattheirexpectationsofinternjobresponsibilitiesandworkloadmatchedorwereexceededbywhatactuallyhappened.Eighty-twopercent(82%)ofthesupervisorsansweredthatatleastoneoftheirinternswasagoodmatchfortheirorganizationsandpositions.Sixty-eightpercent(68%)ofsupervisorssaidthattheinternswerethebestpartoftheinternships.Supervisorssaidthatinternswerepreparedtoworkwithvaluableskillsandprofessionalattitudes,gainedvaluableworkexperience,madesignificantcontributionstothecompany,workedhard,andweregreattoworkwith.Alsomentionedby27%ofsupervisorswashowBrookLynkwasoverallwellorganized,matchedinternswell,andprovidedgoodsupportfromtheprogramcoordinator.Finally,7%ofsupervisorssaidthatthebestpartoftheinternshipforthemwashowmuchtheylearnedandbenefitedfrommentoringtheinterns.Whenaskedaboutproblemstheyfaced,30%ofsupervisorssaidthatthelevelofskillsthatthehighschoolinternshadwaslowerthantheyhadexpected.Seventeenpercent(17%)saidthattheircompanyororganization’sinternalpoliciesorproceduresneededtobeadjustedtobetteronboardorworkwithstudentinterns.Fifteenpercent(15%)wishedtheirinternswerewiththemforalongerperiod.Another13%reportedthattheydidn’thavethetimetheyhadhopedtoproperlysupervisetheintern.Afew(9%)supervisorsmentionedthathadproblemswiththeinternsnotbeingmotivatedorwithnotshowingupforwork.And9%wouldhavelikedbettercommunicationwithBrookLynk.SupervisorssuggestedthatweprovideassistancetotheircompaniesororganizationstoimprovetheirinternalstructuresorproceduresaroundhiringandworkingwithaBrookLynkintern.Supervisorswouldalsolikemoreassistancearoundtheinternshipitself(suchasthecapstoneproject,expectationsofmentors,toolstousewithinterns,etc.).Somesupervisorswouldliketobemoreinvolvedwithselectingtheirinterns.Providinginternswithmoretrainingaroundbasicofficeskills(Outlook,Excel,preparingformeetings,etc.)
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 30
wasanothersuggestion.Otherimprovementssuggestedincludeallowinglongerinternships,providingmoresupportsforinternswithspecialneeds,helpingtogetinternstorespondtofillingoutpaperworkanddrugscreeningduringtheonboardingphase,andsyncingcommunicationsbetweenBrookLynkandinternalcoordinators.Ninety-twopercent(92%)ofthesupervisorsrespondedthattheywouldliketoparticipateintheBrookLynkprogramnextyearwithanotherstudent.SuggestionsforImprovement
• Communicatetheimportanceofthesupervisor’srole(andtrainingaroundthat)increatingahigh-qualityinternshipexperience;sharethisevaluationwiththem.
• Increaseoptionsforsupervisorstoattendtraining.• Providetechnicalassistancetoemployerstoimprovetheirinternalprocessesfor
hiringyouthandforsupportingsupervisors.• Considerwaystoprovideinternswithmoretrainingaroundjobskillsemployers
need(Outlook,Excel,etc.)includingworkingwithschoolsandhaveemployersprovideOn-The-JobTraining.
Three-YearReviewThepercentageofsupervisorswhothoughttheSupervisorTrainingwasusefulhasincreasedinthe3years.ThehighlevelofsupportthatBrookLynkstaffhasofferedtosupervisors,settingtherightexpectationsforemployers,theperceptionthatinternmatcheshavebeengood,andcompaniesandorganizationswantingtoparticipateinBrookLynkagain,havenotchangedoverthatsametimeperiod.Wehavelearnedthatweneedtokeepmonitoringthetimingbetweenmatchingandthestartofinternshipstoallowforcompanies’andorganizations’internalhiringprocessesenoughtime,tohelpeachemployertoprovidetherightsupportsforsupervisors,andtoimprovethetrainingpotentialinternsreceivetomeettheneedsoftoday’sworkforce.
CapacityBuildingTheevaluationofcapacitybuildingisseparatedintothefollowingthreesections:degreeofsupports,programcostsandpoliticalwill.DegreeofSupportsWhatisthedegreeofsupportsnecessarytooperatethiscustomizedmodeleffectivelyandefficientlyfortheBrooklyns?Wedefinesupportstoincludeourinternshipbusiness(includingeducationalandcommunity)partners,ourAlliancepartnerswhoprovidedin-kinddonations,andorganizationspartneredwithtoimplementvariouscomponentsoftheBrookLynkprogram.Overallwefoundanincreasinglyhighlevelofsupporttooperate,customizeandmanagetheprogram.Therewasincreasedinterestfromourbusinesscommunityevidencedby106pledgedinternships,whichsurpassedthegoalof100forthisyear.FundingpartnersprovidedresourcesneededtohireaBrookLynkSpecialisttoassistinthecoordinatingmoreinternships.Alliancepartnersalsoshowedahighdegreeofsupportinprovidingresources
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 31
tosupportprogramoperations.ThecitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynParkhavetakentheleadinpreparingforthetransitionoftheprogramtotheirorganizations.Withallofthissupport,staffrecognizedthatstrongerpipelinesneedtobeestablishedbetweennon-profitsandpublicagencieswhodirectlyworkwithcounty-involvedyouth(CIY)inordertoconnectthoseyouthtoBrookLynkopportunities.
_____________________________Keyresourcesrequiredforimplementationarepledgedinternshippositions,andfundingthecoordinationwork.Therewasasignificantincreaseinpledgedinternshipsduetothreereasons.First,diligentworkoftheProgramCoordinatorandExecutiveDirectortoengagebusinesses.Second,fundingprovidedbytheHennepinCountyEquityGrantallowedforpartialsubsidiesforinternshipwages.Third,privatesectoremployershaveincreasedtheircommitment.Thereareseveralkeystakeholdersthatinvestincollaborativeworktodevelopandsupporttheprogram.TheBrookLynkSteeringCommitteemetmonthlyandprovidedoversightfortheprogram.Youthwereapartofafewofthesemeetingsandincludedinotherdecision-makingsessions.Programpartnersalsohaveprovidedsignificantin-kindresourcestosupportprogramoperations,whichincludephysicalspacefortrainings,check-ins,jobfair,andmeetings.Andmovingforward,thecitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynParkwillbemakingequalcontributionstothebasebudgetofBrookLynk.BrookLynkstaffhavealsobeenintentionalwithkeepingvariousstakeholdersengagedinthereporting,planninganddecision-makingprocess,forexample,thegroundworkthattheBBAhasdonewithfosteringanongoingrelationshipwithCumminsPowerSystemsandhavingsupportfromBostonScientifictopresenttoCityCouncil’sduringtheco-operationagreementnegotiationswaskey.KeyleadersfromthecitieshavebeendeeplyengagedincreatingacooperationagreementthatprovidesthelegalarrangementneededtotransitionBrookLynkintotheoperationsofthecities.TheirleadershiphasbeenengagedinthemanagementconversationswithcurrentBrookLynkstafftounderstandtheprogrammingelementsandhaveparticipatedinin-depthnegotiationsregardinghowtheprogramwillbemanagedandpaidfor.Staffreflectionsnotethatalthoughpartnershipstoreachcounty-involvedyouth(CIY)youthhaveimproved,wearestillunderourperformancegoalof30%ofyouthservedwillbeopportunityyouthorcountyinvolved.Movingforward,staffrecommendedstrongerpipelinestobeestablishedbetweenBrookLynkandnon-profitsandpublicagencieswhodirectlyworkwiththeseyouth.Additionalprofessionaldevelopmentmaybeneededforstaff,andforemployers,toeffectivelyengageandplacetheseyouthinsuccessfulinternshipandemploymentopportunities.Asonestaffstated,“Ifthisisnotanintentionalaspectofgrowth,itwilleasilybecomeapopulation‘toodifficult’fortheprogramtoeffectivelyserve.”AnotherchallengeinaccessingprivatesectorfundraisingsupporthasbeenthelimitationsinfundraisingcapacitywiththeExecutiveDirector.Moresupportisneededtothoroughlyleverageresourcesasasteptocreatingamoreefficientandeffectiveprocessforbringingresourcestotheprogram.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 32
NextSteps• ContinuewiththeBrookLynkSteeringCommittee,andputenergyintoestablishinga
newadvisoryduringthetransition.• Establishstrongerpipelinestonon-profitsandpublicagencieswhodirectlyworkwith
county-involvedyouth(CIY),torecruitandsupportthemintheirBrookLynkinternship.• Determinehowtostrategicallybuildresourcescollaboratively.Staffidentifiedtheneed
todevelopacollaborativetimeline,expectations,andclarityregardingfundraising.• Explorehowtorecovercostsrelatedforcoordinationefforts.• CreateaBrookLynkoperationsmanualsothatthevariousprogrammingelements,
fundraisingstrategies,marketing/communicationsplans,andstrategicplanningofBrookLynkcanbeeffectivelycommunicatedandtaughttonewstaff/partners.
ProgramCostWhataretheprogramcostsnecessarytooperatethiscustomizedmodeleffectivelyandefficientlyfortheBrooklyns?Insummaryprogramscostsareprimarilyrelatedtostaffwhocoordinateandsupervisetheprogram.Thismodelisdesignedforonefulltimeemployeeforevery60youthmatched.Astheprogramnearlydoubledinyouthserved,thebudgetalsoexpandedtohirea2ndFTE.TheBrookLynkmulti-yearbudgethasbeencreatedandwasacriticalstepincreatingthecooperationagreement.
_____________________________Theexactcostsoftheprogramfluctuatedin2017.Withtheadditionofanewfull-timestaffmemberandasignificantincreaseinthenumberofinternsthatwereserved,thisyear’scostsweregreaterthaninyears’past.Costsarenotlikelytoexpandnextyearsincenosignificantprogramexpansionisplanned.TheBrookLynkmulti-yearbudgethasbeencreatedandwasacriticalstepindevelopingthecooperationagreement.Citypartnershaveagreedtosplitcoreprogramexpenses,aswellasjointlyfundraisefortheprogramwithsupportfromtheAlliance.ThecooperationagreementhadunanimouscitycouncilapprovalfrombothcitiesinAugustof2017.Withthisinagreementinplace,theprogramhasmadeasignificantstepforwardinlong-termfinancialsustainability.Asstaffreported,theexpansionoftheprogram,bothinthenumberofyouthservedandthetypesofservicesbeingoffered,mademanagingthedaytodayexpensesandthebudgetsetbytheboardchallenging.Programstabilitywillmakeitpossibleforstafftobettermanageresources,andmoreimportantly,makeiteasiertobuildpartnerships,in-kindcontribu-tions,anddonationsforvariousaspectsoftheprogram.(e.g.findingsponsorsfortheendofyeareventorbettermanagingexpensesfortraining).DatacollectionfortheBrookLynkevaluationhasundergoneathoroughautomationthankstosupportfromtheBremerFoundation.Theautomationoftheevaluationdatacollection
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 33
hasreducedcollectionandanalysistime.Thiswillsavecostsrelatedtoevaluationworkneededfornextyear.NextSteps
• Programcostsforstaffingaretopfundraisingpriority:thecitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynParkwillimplementthecooperationagreementandtherebyapprovethecityfundingtosupport40%oftheprogramcosts.
• TherewillbeseveralopportunitiesforreportingtoBremer,UnitedWayandothersthatshouldbeseenashighpriorityfundraisingopportunitiesthatbothmanagementandstaffshouldbeengagedin.
PoliticalWillWhatisthepoliticalwillnecessarytooperatethiscustomizedmodeleffectivelyandefficientlyfortheBrooklyns?PoliticalwillisdefinedasbuildingthedesireandinterestinoperatingtheBrookLynkprogram.Itincludesabroadbaseofstakeholderswhosupporttheprogramanddesiretoseeitsuccessful.Insummary,thecooperationagreementtotransitionBrookLynktotheCitiesin2018isanimportantindicationthatpoliticalwillishighamongourpartners.TheAllianceprovidedaplaceforBrookLynktogrowththatbuiltpoliticalwill,primarilythroughhighlightingthatbothyouthandemployersexpresscontinuedinterestandneedforBrookLynk.
_____________________________Staffnotethattheeffortsmadetoincludeabroadsetofstakeholdersindevelopingtheprogramhascreatedsharedownership.Overthelastyearstakeholdersweredirectlyorindirectlyinvolvedinthefollowingprocesses:
• CreatingtheBrookLynkmission,vision,andvalues• DesigningtheAlumniNetworkthroughparticipatoryprocesses• Automatingtheevaluation• Implementingaparticipatoryprocessfortheyouthledjobfair• CreatingagreatBrookLynkwebsite• CraftingformalMemorandumsofUnderstandingwithreferralpartners
Thecommunitysupportforthisprogramwasevidencedbythelettersofsupportprovidedfortheprogramtocitypolicymakers.TheselettersweregatheredbytheAlliancetosharewithcitycouncilmemberspriortoagreeingtothetransitionoftheprogram.Theselettersprovidedtestimonialsfrombusinesses,communityleaders,andyouthwhodescribedthepowerfulimpactBrookLynkhashadontheirlife.TheAlliance,asayouthdevelopmentintermediary,hasplayedakeyroleincreatingtheconditionsforthegrowthandexpansionoftheprogramwhilesupportedwithprogramdesignandsupportforstaffduringchange.RegionaleconomicconditionshavealsobuiltpoliticalwillforBrookLynk.Theincreasedregional,nationalattentionontheworkforceshortagehascreatedaneconomiccontext
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 34
whereeffortslikeBrookLynkarevaluable.ThecitiesofBrooklynParkandBrooklynCenterrecentlycompletedtheirstrategicplanswhichfocusonincreasingeconomicvitalityaswellasyouthengagement.Alsooutlinedintheseplansareeffortstostrengthenthelocalworkforceandbetterconnectresidentstolocalemployers.ThisalignmenthascreatedabroaderandveryimportantopportunityforBrookLynktocontributetothemissionforbothcities.Thecities’capacitytomanagethistypeofprogramhasdevelopedsignificantly.Therehasbeentremendousinvestmentfromleadershipinbothcitiestomeetbi-monthlytolearnthemanagementprocessandtobeapartofdecision-making.CityleadershiphasalsoincreasedtheirparticipationinregionalmeetingsrelatedtoBrookLynkandhasjoinedtheExecutiveDirectorinseveralmeetingswithfunders,includingtheUnitedWayandthePohladFoundation.TheHennepinTechnicalCollegestaffhasbeenamajorsupporttotheprogram,andisnowfullysustainedbyafederalPerkinsgrant.HennepinCountyhasamissionaroundyouthworkforcedevelopmentandthisyearprovidedtheEquityGranttosupportourwork.Thisyear,manyAlliancepartnershaveputBrookLynkinternshipsintheirbudgets.NextSteps
• ContinuetogrowtheBrookLynkprogramtorespondtocommunityneed.• Simplifytheevaluation.• Createauniqueandengagingrecruitmentpiecesforfunders,employers,andpolicy
makers.• Continuetogrowstrategicpartnerships.• Continuetoidentifyandengagenewstakeholders.
ProcessEvaluationWhatdidwedotocustomizetheMinneapolisSTEP-UPmodelfortheBrooklyns?Howwelldidthecustomizedprogramwork?ProgramDevelopmentMinneapolisSTEP-UPprovidedtheirlogicmodelandevaluationsoftheirprogram,whichhelpedBrookLynktorefineourownlogicmodelandcreateourownprocessmap.Acomprehensiveevaluationplanwascreatedtocollectandmeasureprogramoutputs,processes,quality,andoutcomes.
_____________________________TheBrooklynBridgeAllianceforYouthcustomizedtheSTEP-UPSummerJobsProgrammodelfromMinneapolisforthecommunitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynPark.WithtechnicalassistancefromSTEP-UP,weconsideredtheirlogicmodelandevaluationsoftheirprogramtorefineourownlogicmodelandcreateourownprocessmap.Acomprehensiveevaluationplanwascreatedtocollectandmeasureprogramoutputs,processes,quality,andoutcomes.Allthreehavebeenupdatedforthe2017programandcanbefoundintheAppendix.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 35
OutreachAnewoutreachstrategyfor2017,theReferralPartnerprogramrecruitedpointsofcontactsat8differenthighschoolsand5youth-servingorganizationstogetyouthtoapplytoBrookLynkandattendthetrainings.Thisyear’sapplicationwashostedonlinewithSurveyMonkey.Themobilefriendlywebsitemadeoutreacheasierasstaffcouldstudentsregisteronthespot.BrookLynkreacheditsgoalof500applicantstotheprogram.
_____________________________Anewoutreachstrategyfor2017wastheReferralPartnerprogram.BrookLynkstaffrecruitedcontactsat8highschoolswithBrooklynsstudents(BrooklynCenterAcademy,BrooklynCenterSecondary,ChamplinParkHighSchool,OsseoAreaLearningCenter,OsseoSeniorHigh,ParkCenterHighSchool,RobbinsdaleArmstrongHighSchool,andHTCGatewaytoCollege)and5otheryouth-servingorganizations(YMCA,MNWorkforceCenter,AvenuesforHomelessYouth,BrooklynParkZanewoodCommunityCenter,andHennepinCountyJuvenileProbationandExtendedFosterCareServices).MemorandumsofunderstandingwerecreatedbetweenBrookLynkandtheseorganizationstosetgoalsforrecruitment,outreachstrategies,andschedules.Atotalof16BrookLynkAmbassadors(alumni)activelyreachoutattheirownschoolsalsohelpedwithrecruitingefforts.
SchoolReferralPartnersReferralPartnerGoals
Applicant TrainingCompletion
InternshipPlacement
BrooklynCenterAcademy 15 10 6BrooklynCenterSecondary 105 105 16ChamplinParkHighSchool 100 70 16OsseoAreaLearningCenter N/A N/A 3OsseoSeniorHigh 70 35 10ParkCenterHighSchool 125 100 35RobbinsdaleArmstrongHighSchool N/A N/A 3HTCGatewaytoCollege 10 5 3Total 425 325 89TheReferralPartnerswerekeyinhelpingBrookLynkreachthe500applicantsaimedfor.Eachreferralpartnershiphelpedtoinformandmarkettopotentialyouthparticipantsindifferentways.Schoolpartnersallowedstafftouseinternalcommunicationsuchasnewsletters,Schoology(anonlinelearningmanagementsystem),andotheronlineplatformstomarketBrookLynk.Staffwereablecomeoncampusanduseschoolfacilitiestohostinformationalsessionsandtableduringschoolevents,whichoftenresultedinhighernumbersofapplicantsduringthosetimes.Rightbeforethetrainings,thereferralpartnerswouldhelpsetupfollow-upsessionswithBrookLynkstaffandapplicantstoansweranyquestionsandasanotherremindertoattend.InschoolsthatwerelocatedoutsideoftheBrooklynsitwashelpfulwhentheReferralPartnerpointofcontactgottogetherstudentswholivedinBrooklynParkandBrooklynCenter(andthuseligiblefortheprogram)fortheinformationalsessions.AvenuesforHomelessYouthwasonceagainabletorefermanyoftheirresidentstoourprogram.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 36
Thisyear’sapplicationwashostedonlinewithSurveyMonkey.Havinganonlineregistrationthatwasmobilefriendlymadeoutreacheasierasstaffcouldstudentsregisteronthespot.Theapplicationwasdesignedtoweedoutyouthwhoweren’teligiblefortheprogram,butmanyapplicantsdidnotreadtheeligibilityquestionscarefullyandthuswouldapplymultipletimes.ThiscausedmoreworkfortheBrookLynkstafftoclearoutthepartiallyfilledoutapplications.Outreachtoemployerswentwellasstaffwereabletoleverageexistingrelationshipswithemployersandotherpartnerstogetinternshipspledged.TherewasasignificantincreaseinthenumberofinternshipsbeinghostedbylocalemployersbutwealsowelcomednewemployerslikeCumminsPowerSystemsandRobbinsdaleAreaSchools.TheHennepinCountyWorkforceEquityGrantallowedforourpublicsectorpartnerstoincreasethenumberofinternshipstheywereabletohost,allowingBrookLynkstaffcapacitytobemaximized.BrookLynkworkedwithChannel12tocreatevideosaboutregisteringfortraining.Inoneofthevideos,aBrookLynkAmbassadorwasfeatured.BrookLynkalumniwerekeypartnersintheoutreachprocessandingivingpresentationstobothemployersandpotentialyouth.Itwasdifficultgainingtractionwithfaithcommunitiesandcountyserviceproviders.ManyoftheOpportunityYoutharecounty-involved,sothelackofconnectionwiththecountyserviceprovidersmadeitdifficulttorecruitthatpopulation.SuggestionsforImprovement
• CreateatargetedandsupportedoutreachstrategytoengageOpportunityYouth,includingmoreconnectionstocountyserviceprovidersandotherorganizationsservingthatpopulation.
• Attendprofessionaldevelopmentforprogramstafftoeffectivelyengageandsupportcountyinvolved/opportunityyouththroughouttheBrookLynkexperience.
• OutreachtorecruitsimilarnumbersofyouthfromBrooklynCenterasBrooklynParktomeettheBrookLynkCooperationAgreement’sgoalofequalnumberofyouthfromeachcity.
• Createreferralpartnershipswiththecountyserviceprovidersandfaith-basedcommunityorganizations.
• AllowtheAmbassadorstotakeagreaterleadonmarketingattheirschoolsandhavingtwoAmbassadorsorstudentpointsofcontactforeachschoolifpossible.Ambassadorshavethecapacitytotableatschooleventsandtakeonotheroutreachinitiatives.
• WorkwithBrooklynParkstafftocreatemarketingmaterialinthefallthateachschoolpointofcontactcansendoutwhenrecruitingbegins.
• Createasinglepageapplicationsothatallofastudent’sinformationiscollected.• Haveamorecomprehensivecommunicationsplan/pitchtoemployerswith
supportingmaterialsthatincludebrochures,evaluationsummaries,testimonials,andinfographics.
• HavetheBrookLynkAmbassadorsleadasocialmediacampaignthroughamoreorganicinitiativethatcreatesbuzzearlieron.
• Leveragesocialmediamoretobeontheradarofemployersandyoungpeople,suchasusingLinkedIntopublishsuccessstoriesandnewsaboutBrookLynk.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 37
• Betterusetraditionalmedia(Channel12,theSunPost,andothernewsoutlets)torecruityouthandcommunicatetheworkBrookLynkdoesinthecommunity.
WorkReadinessTrainingBrookLynkadoptedMinneapolisSTEP-UP’sworkreadinesstrainingandmockinterviews,builtupontheirtraininghandbookandaddedtheMHALabsSkillBuildingBlocksandWorkCoreSkills.Onaverage,studentsratedtheworkreadinesstraininga4.3outof5.0.Onlyabout44%oftheyouthwhoappliedfortheprogramattendedtheGetReady!WorkReadinessTrainings,similartothe42%attendanceratefromlastyear.AfterscoringlowintheYPQAfortwoyearsaroundyouthinteractionandengagement,participantsweregivenachoicethreedifferenttracks,andyouthalumniandadulttrainerswereco-trainers.
_____________________________GetReady!WorkReadinessTrainingconsistedof7.5hours(includinglunch)ofinstructiononcommunication,networking,professionalism,emailandphoneetiquette,resumes,applications,andinterviews.StudentsweregiventheoptionofattendingoneoftwoSaturdays(March25thandApril1st).HennepinTechnicalCollegeprovidedtheirfacilitiesforthetraining.TransportationwasofferedtostudentsviaMetroTransitbustokens.OneachoftheWednesdaysfollowingtheGetReady!Training,mockinterviewswerescheduledatBrooklynParkCommunityActivityCenter.VolunteerinterviewerswererecruitedfromAlliancepartnersandthecommunity.Eachstudentwasaskedtobringacurrentresume,andsatthroughashortinterviewfollowedbyfeedbackprovidedbytheinterviewer.Anadditional7-hourtrainingforyouthages16andoverwhowereinterestedinapplyingforinternshipswasheldonApril8thatNorthHennepinCommunityCollege
Year AttendanceRate2015 48%2016 42%2017 45%
Onaverage,studentsratedtheworkreadinesstraininga4.3outof5.0.Whenaskedwhattheylikedmostaboutthetraining,participantsrespondedwithmeetingotherpeople(68%),Learningaboutapplications,resumes,andinterviews(68%),theinstructors(63%),theinformationsharedaboutgettingandkeepingajob(63%),andtheactivities(37%).AfterscoringlowintheYPQAfortwoyearsaroundyouthinteractionandengagement,severalprogramdesignchangesweremadetothetraining.First,therewerethreedifferenttracks(beginning,intermediate,andadvanced)thatstudentscouldchoosefrom.Eachofthelevelsweregearedtothelevelofexperiencethatstudentshadwiththeskillsthatweretaughtduringtraining.Uponfurtherreflection,thetrainingtracksforGetReady!couldhavebeenexecutedbettertoprovideamoreseamlessprocessforparticipants,staff,andtrainers.Whenusing
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 38
HennepinTechnicalCollege,BrookLynkmustcontractwithaspecificcatererfortheeven,whichcausedasignificantstrainonthefoodbudget.Transportationtotrainingcontinuedbeinganissueassomeyoungpeoplewereunabletofindaridethedayof.Someretuningprogramparticipantscomplainedthattheydidnotlearnanythingnewatthetrainings.Thereneedstobefurthertrainingwithadulttrainerstoeffectivelyengageyouthasco-trainers,sincesometrainerswerenotasgoodatitasothers.Attheendofthefirsttraining,thecertificateswerenotreadytohandoutsonoteverystudentsreceivedtheirsatthetraining.SuggestionsforImprovement
• Havingthestudentschoosewhatlevelofworkexperiencetheyconsiderthemselvesinwhentheyregisterinitiallysotheydon'thavetodosopriortotraining.
• RefinetheBrookLynkGetReady!andInternshipTrainingtobereflectiveoftheneedsofyouthanddemandsofemployers.ThisrefinedversionshouldalsoaddressthequestionaboutyouthparticipatingBrookLynkformultipleyearsandtheirneedtotakepartintraining.
• AskMetroTransitorapartneringtransportationcompanytoprovidetransportationservicesforyoungpeople.
• HostGetReady!atamorecentrallylocatedspaceandthatisaccessiblebythevariousbusroutes.
• PilotGetReady!atoneofthealternativelearningcentersintheBrooklynsandgaugethelevelofparticipationandcompletionofBrookLynkbytheparticipatingcohort.
• Completethreeseparatetrain-the-trainersessionswithtrainersthat1)allowthemtounderstandthecurriculumandBrookLynk,2)buildarelationshipwithco-trainers,and3)practicecurriculumimplementationwithfeedbackfrompeers.
MatchingThematchingprocesswassimilartoMinneapolisSTEP-UP’s,althoughwithfarfewerapplicantsandinternshipopportunities.BrookLynkmatchedthestudentsbasedontheirage,transportationoptions,skilllevel,workexperience,careerinterest,andtheirattendanceattrainingevents.Additionally,BrookLynkonlyhadonetierofinternshipscomparedtothethreethatSTEP-UPusestoseparatelevelsofinternships.Thematchingwaseasierthisyearsincethiswasthethirdtimethatstaffhadgonethroughthisprocess.BrookLynkstafftookalmostafullworkdaytomatch104youthtointernships.Eighty-twopercent(82%)ofthesupervisorsansweredthatatleastoneoftheirinternswasagoodmatchfortheirorganizationsandpositions.Sixty-sixpercent(66%)ofinternsexpressedthattheirinternshipshelpedthemfocusonspecificcareerpathwaysthatalignedwiththeirlifegoals.
_____________________________InthemiddleofApril,Alliancestaffmettogethertomatchstudentstointernships.Thiswascompletedaweekearlierthanlastyearsothatemployerswouldhaveextratimetoonboardtheirinternsandalsotoallowforyouthtoknowtheirmatchstatusbeforetheyouthjobfair.Ascorecardforeachinternwascreatedwithdemographicinformation,
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 39
opportunityyouthstatus,transportationoptions,availability,trainingandmockinterviewattendance,trainerevaluations,andpersonalinterests.Similarscorecardswerecreatedforeachpositionusingthejobdescriptionssentinbyemployers.Thesewereallconsidered,alongwithjobrequirementsanddescriptionssubmittedbyemployers.Theprioritiesformatchingwereasfollows:
• OpportunityYouth• Internshipswithagerequirements• Internshipsinlocationswithnopublictransportationoptions• Skill-levelexpectationfromemployersandskill-levelofinterns• Workexperience• Careerinterestsofstudentsmatchedwithcareerfieldsofinternshipsand/or
employers• Attendanceattrainingsandmockinterview,andtrainerandinterviewratings• Overallmixofethnicity,gender,school,andcityofresidencearebalanced
OncematchedInterncandidateswerecontactedbyphonetoexplainthejobstheywerematchedtoandaskediftheywouldaccept.Ifso,thecorrespondingsupervisorsweregiventhecandidate’scontactinfotosetupaninterview.Aftertheinterviewsoccurred,bothinternsandsupervisorsmadeafinalchoiceatwhichtimetheemployerstartedthehiringprocess.Thematchingwaseasierthisyearsincethiswasthethirdtimethatstaffhadgonethroughthisprocess.Knowingsomestudentsandsupervisorsfrompreviousyears,andmeetingthenewstudentsatthetrainingsallowedstafftobemoremindfulabouttheyoungpeoplethatwerebeingmatched.Thisyear,OpportunityYouthwerenotrestrictedonlytospecificinternships,whichallowedthemtobematchedtocareerfieldsthattrulyinterestedthem.Theamountoftimebetweenmatchingandinterviewswasstillanissue.Therewasonlyaone-weekwindowtomatchandcontactallofthestudentsandsupervisors.Andsomeemployersturnedintheirjobdescriptionslatesofinalmatchesforthosepositionsdidn’thappenuntilalmosttheinterviewtime.Callingstudentsindividuallytodoanoverviewoftheirmatchpositionwastimeconsumingandnotalwayseffectiveinexplainingthenecessarynextsteps.Bothinternsandsupervisorswerenotalwaystimelyinrespondingtocommunications,whichmadeitdifficulttobeginthehiringprocess.Youthwhoweren’tmatchedwithaninternshiphadtransportationissues,conflictswiththeirsummerschedule,ordidn’twantthepositionsoffered.Employerswhohadpledgedinternshipsbutwerenotultimatelymatched,decidedlateronthattheyhadnocapacitytoofferaBrookLynkinternship.SuggestionsforImprovement
• Considergivingatwoorthreeweekwindowbetweenmatchingstudentsand
contactingtheemployers,whichwillallowtimeforinternstothinkabouttheirmatchdecision.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 40
• Requirealljobdescriptionstobesubmittedbysupervisorspriortomatching.Also,eachdescriptionformneedstoberevisedbyprogramstafftoensureithassufficientdetailstoensureahigh-qualitymatch.
• Potentiallyhosttheinternshiptrainingafterstudentshavebeenmatchedtotheirinternships.Thiswaytheyknowwhatisneededoftheminordertosuccessfullylandtheinternshipandtoeffectivelycommunicatethenextstepsandwhattheirinternshipwillentail.
• Youthshouldberequiredtoattachacopyoftheirresumetotheinternshipapplicationtostreamlinetheprocesswhensharingcontactinformationandresumesofcandidateswithsupervisors.
YouthJobFairMinneapolisSTEP-UPDiscoverprovidesjobopportunitiesforyoungeryouth(usually14-15yearsold)whoarenewtotheworkforceandlookingfortheirfirstjob.AtthistimeBrookLynkonlyoffersinternshipsforyouth16yearsandolder.Inresponsetothelackofjobopportunitiesforyoungeryouth,aYouthJobFairwasstartedthisyeartotrytoconnectthemwithlocalemployerslookingtohire.AscanofsuccessfulyouthjobfairsaroundthecountryincludedinterviewswiththeorganizationsthatrunsomeofthemoresuccessfuleventsinSanFrancisco(UnitedWay)andBoulder(WorkforceBoulderCounty).BrookLynklearnedthatmakingtheeventsyouth-centerediskeytohavingyouthattend.Totargetyouthmeansfocusingontheirinterests(funandengaging)andspecificemploymentneedswhendesigningtheevent,workingwithschoolstomarket,providingtransportationtotheevent(and/ormakingiteasilyaccessiblebypublictransportation),andprovidingadditionalworkreadinesssupports(includingmockinterviews,resumebuilding,professionalnetworking,applicationlab,etc.)attheevent.Youthwereincludedontheplanningcommitteeofthosejobfairs.Understandingthatmostyouthhavenoideahowajobfairworks,providingon-siteorientationsforyouthastheyfirstarrive,canhelpthemfeelmoreconnected.Gettingtherightemployerstoshowupisalsokey.Bothorganizationswetalkedtotargetedemployerswhohadactualjobopeningsforyouth(andespeciallyforthoseages14-15)andwhowereabletointerviewandhireon-siteatthejobfair.Thishelpeddecreaseahugebarrieringettingdisconnectedyouthconnectedtojobs.Althoughtheyweremarketedasyouthjobfairs,theyalsoincludedvolunteeropportunities,internships,andasmentionedpreviously,workreadinesstrainingsandresources.Finally,inordertogaugesuccess,theysurveyedyouthandemployersaftertheeventstounderstandhowmanyreceivedjobsduetothejobfairs.BrookLynktooktheselearningsandattemptedtoimplementthemforthisfirstYouthJobFaironApril29,2017.AplanningcommitteeconsistingofBrookLynkalumniandrepresentativesfrommanyoftheAllianceandyouth-servingorganizationpartnersmetevery3weeksbeginninginFebruary2017.Threesubcommitteeswereorganized:VolunteersandSponsors,MarketingandYouthEngagement,andLogisticsandEmployers.Asidefromtheplanningcommitteemeetingsthesubcommitteesalsometontheirown.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 41
Themarketingteamcreatedarecruitingvideo.Itwaswellproducedbutunfortunatelynotmanypeopleviewedit.Attheevent,14employersand4organizationsprovidingworkforcedevelopmentrelatedservicesattended.Twoemployersdroppedoutoftheeventatthelastminute.SeveralbusesprovidedbyOsseoAreaSchoolspickedupstudentsatvariousschoolsintheareatobringthemtotheYouthJobFairandreturnthem.WorkshopswereofferedtwiceanhourtoprovideanintroductionforyouthontheJobFair.ThecomputerlabwasavailableforyouthandstaffedbytheYMCAtoprovidesupportinresumebuildingandfillingoutonlineapplications.BrooklynPark’sRec-on-the-Govanwasoutsidetoproviderecreationactivitiesforanyyoungersiblingswhowereattendingwithyouth.RefreshmentswereprovidedbyOsseoAreaSchools.Duringtheevent,therewasmusic,aselfiephotobooth(withalivefeedofpicturesandtweetsprojectedontoascreen),andadrawingforprizeseveryhour.BrookLynksampledyouthandemployersatthejobfairtounderstandwhattheirexperienceswereandtogetpreliminarydataonhowsuccessfulthejobfairwasatmatchingyoungpeoplewithjobopportunities.Youthratedthejobfaira3.5(outof5.0)andemployersgaveita4.6rating.Ninety-sixpercent(96%)ofyouthsaidtheywouldrecommendittoafriendand100%ofemployerssaidtheywouldattendanotheryouthjobfair.Employerssaw23to75visitorstotheirboothsandreceivedupto50applicationsfortheirpositions.However,only5interviews(allattheirbooths)weregivenandonly1jobofferwasactuallyextendedonsite.Staffalsofollowedup6weeksaftertheeventwithemployerstoaskthemhowmanyyouththeyinterviewedandhired.Itwasdifficulttofollow-upwithmostemployersandevenwhenreached,theyhaddifficultyrecallinghowmanyinterviewsandjobofferswereextendedtoyouthcontactedinitiallyattheyouthjobfair.Bestestimatesarethat6interviewsoccurredfromthoseinitialcontacts,butnoneresultedinanactualjob.Althoughhalf(51%)ofyouthfeltthatthejobfairmettheirexpectations,all(100%)employerswhoparticipatedfeltthismettheirexpectations.Duringfollowupwiththeemployersoveramonthlaterthatitwashardforthemtoseparateoutwhichapplicantshadcomefromthejobfairspecifically.Thehopewasthatemployerswouldcomewiththerightstafftointerviewandhireonthespot,butonlyafewinterviewshappenedatthebooths,andnoneintheroomswehaddesignatedforsuch.Thereseemstobeafundamentaldifferenceinhowtheemploymentsystemcurrentlyworks,andwhatwethinkdisconnectedyouthneedinordertogettheirfootinthedoor.Forthemostpart,humanresourcedepartmentstaffsenttojobfairshavenodecision-makingcapacitywhenitcomestohiring.Theyaremostlytheretoraiseawarenessabouttheircompaniesandtheemploymentopportunitiestheyoffer.Theymostlyencourageapplicationthroughonlineportals,oratthemost,collectresumesforwhenthereareopenings.Youngpeoplewhoaren’tconnectedtothejobmarketneedamorestraightforwardpathtogetthatfirstjobonthedayoftheevent.Workingwiththepublicpartnerswasessential.Howeverthereisalsoalearningcurveforeveryonetounderstandhowayouthjobfairisdifferentfromajobfairtargetingadults
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 42
(whichmosthadmoreexperiencewith).BrookLynkwillneedtogetschools,libraries,workforcedevelopmentcenters,andotherpublicinstitutionstothinkdifferentlyabouthowtosupportyoungpeopletogettingtheirfirstjobs,andreachingouttotheyoungpeopletheyareconnectedto.Manyyoungpeoplethinkoftheirnextstepsasafewweeksaway.Companieshiringseveralmonthsoutmeansthatthosejobsarenotevenontheradar.Asemployerswerebeingrecruitedforthejobfair,manywhohireyoungeryouthsaidthatajobfairinAprilwastoolate.Theyhirehundredsofyouthforsummerjobsatschoolsandrecreationprograms,buthiremanyoftheminMarch.Thus,toparticipatetheywouldliketheJobFairtobeheldearlierintheyear.Foryouth,itisclearfromexperiencethatdoingthejobfairinMarch,orApril,wouldbeachallengeforyouthtoplanthatfarahead.Developmentally,youthtakeactiononwhatisneedednow.Theyarelessplanfulthanadults,andoftentimeslifecircumstancesandresponsibilitiesrequiredofthemfromparentschangeplanstheymaymake.Thisisespeciallytrueforyouththathavesignificantbarriers.Structurally,thereweresomelessonslearnedaswell.Theplanningcommitteewasmissingsomekeypartners,includingrepresentativesofculturalgroupsandsomeoftheAlliancepartners.Afeworiginalcommitteemembersleftthegroupmidwaythroughtheplanning.Fewerteammeetingswouldhaveallowedthesubcommitteestomeetseparatelyandgetmoreworkdone.TheVolunteerandSponsorsgroupwaslessclearabouttheirrole,maybewasresponsibleforareasthataretoodifferent,andneededtowaitforothergroupstofinalizetheirpartsfirst.Regardingsponsorshipstwokeyquestionsemerged:Whatistherightwaytoengagesponsorship,whatarethelevels,whataretheneeds?TheBusinessOutreachandLogisticsgroupneededmorepeopletodooutreachthanjusttheProgramCoordinator.CreatingthemarketingmaterialtookupalotofthetimeoftheBrookLynkspecialist.Therewasascramblerightbeforetheeventtoorganizetheworkshopsbecausenoonewasassignedtoitoriginally.Only$1900outofthe$5000budgetedwasspent(notincludingin-kinddonationsforbuses,roomrental,food,etc.).Onthedayoftheeventtherewasadeafstudentwhoattended.Therewerenointerpretersscheduled;thankfully,oneoftheparentsknewASLandcouldinterpret.ThebusdriversdroppedstudentsoffattheotherendoftheNorthHennepinCommunityCollegecampusfromwheretheeventwasheld.Nodatawascollectedonhowmanyyouthtookadvantageofthebuses.Sincethisisthefirstyearoftheevent,thereweremanyshortfallsandlessonslearned.SuggestionsforImprovement
• Recruitemployershiringforpositionsandtrainthemtohireonthespot.• Settleoncertaindetailsbeforemeetingwithplanningcommittee,suchasdates,
budget,andlocation.• Reachouttoemployersandyouthworkforcedevelopmentorganizationsyear-
roundtoplanforthisevent.• Reconfiguresubcommitteesbasedonlessonslearnedfromthisyearaboutwhich
tasksarealigned:VolunteerswithLogistics,andSponsorswithMarketing
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 43
• Createamarketingrolloutprocess,startingwitha“savethedate”or“keepaneyeout”notice.Makesurethemarketingistimedearlyenoughsoeveryonehasenoughadvancenotice.
• Attendotherjobfairsduringtheyeartomeetrecruitersandorganizations.• ConsiderpartneringwiththeCityofMinneapolis’TeenJobFair.• Scheduleinterpreters(includingASL)foryouthwhoneedlanguageservicesand
considerotherwaystoensureaninclusiveevent.• Havevolunteersonthebusestocounthowmanyyouthusethem,andtoprovide
supportoranswerquestions.• Askforcontactinformationofbusdriverstomakesurethatstudentsgetpickedup
anddroppedoffatthecorrecttimesandlocations.• Createanevaluationplantobetterassessthejobfair.
InterviewsandOnboardingTheinterviewingandonboardingprocesswasadoptedfromtheMinneapolisSTEP-UPmodel.BrookLynkalsoprovidedamorecomprehensivesupervisor’strainingtoincludeMHALabsSkillBuildingBlocksandparentswereinvitedtotheinternorientation.For66%ofsupervisors,itwastheirfirsttimeemployingahighschoolstudent.Eighty-ninepercent(89%)ofthesupervisorsthoughttheSupervisorTrainingwashelpful,especiallyinhelpingthemunderstandhowtoworkwithandrelatetohighschoolstudents.However,someemployersstillhadissueswithonboardingtheirinterns.
_____________________________Employersandstudentswerenotifiedofthestaff’smatchesattheendofApril,afterwhichinterviewswereconducted.Employersweregivenafewweeksfortheirinternalhiringprocessestoonboardtheirinterns.OnMay26th,supervisorsgatheredatNorthHennepinCommunityCentertoreceiveSupervisorTrainingonwhattoexpectwiththestudentstheywouldbeworkingwith,theMeasuresofHumanAchievement(MHA)tooltheywouldbeusingtoprovidecareerskillfeedbackwith,andotherlogisticalissuesrelatedtothesummerinternships.AnInternOrientationwasheldatBrooklynParkCommunityActivityCenteronJune9thasafinalpreparationforstudentsandparents.ForthoseinternswhoneededhelpwithtransportationMetroTransitprovidedaworkshoponhowtotakepublictransit.FireflyCreditUniongaveanotherworkshoponfinancialliteracy.Oneofthebigchangestothisyear’sprogramwashavinghiringcoordinators(atemployerswith4ormoreinterns:Cummins,BostonScientific,CityofBrooklynCenter,CityofBrooklynPark,OsseoAreaSchools,BrooklynCenterSecondary,RobbinsdaleAreaSchools,HennepinTechnicalCollege,NorthHennepinCommunityCollege,andAnokaHennepinSchoolDistrict)playakeyroleinprovidinginformation,relayingcommunications,andmakingsuretheonboardingprocesswasgoingsmoothlyasasupportfortheirorganization’sinternsandsupervisors.For66%ofsupervisors,itwastheirfirsttimeemployingahighschoolstudent,sotheyneededsomesupportbeforestartingtheinternships.Eighty-ninepercent(89%)ofthesupervisorsthoughttheSupervisorTrainingwashelpful.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 44
Therewasfeedbackfromsupervisorsthattheywereimpressedbythelevelofpreparednessthatinternsdisplayedduringtheirinterviews.Contactingtheinternspriortotheirinterviewstogivetheminformationthattheywouldneedfortheirinterviewandonboardingprocess.Forthemostpart,studentsandsupervisorswereresponsivetothecommunicationsbeingsenttooneanother.MostoftheinterviewsandonboardingtookplaceinthetimeframethatBrookLynksuggested.However,someinterviewstookplaceclosetothestartingdatesoftheinternships,sotherewasalonggapforstudentswaitingtohearbackforaninterview.Somesupervisorsandinternswerenotresponsivetoemailandphonecommunications,ortheybothhadconflictingschedulesthatmadeitdifficulttoorganizeatimetomeet,whichcausedsomeinterviewstobeconductedmuchlaterintheprocess.Afewstudentsdidn’thaveproperdocumentationforworkingortheywereintheprocessoforderingthem,whichsloweddowntheonboardingprocess.Somestudentshaddifficultywithhavingaccesstotransportationtotheirinterviewsiteduringbusinesshourswhileothersfacedchallengeswithsettingupabankaccount.Asignificantpercentageofopportunityyouththatwerematchedtoaninternshipdidnotcompletetheinterviewing/hiringprocess.Afterschoolwasletouttheseyouthnolongerhadsupportfromschoolstafftoencouragethemtoparticipate.SomestudentsdidnotrespondtocommunicationsfromsupervisorsandBrookLynkstaff.Thereseemedtobealotofuncertaintyandquestionsfromsupervisorsabouttheinternalhiringpracticesatvariousemployers,forexample,wherewillinternsbeofficed,dotheygetaccesstotechnology,whenaretheyexpectedtostartandfinishtheirinternships,andiftheyareeligibleforbenefitsandvacation.Forthoseemployersthathadmappedoutanonboardingandhiringprocess,theprocessitselfwasefficientandeffective.Itallowedfortheemployerandtheinterntounderstandwhattheyneededtocompleteandbywhenanditprovidedatrackerforprogress.TheconsistentcommunicationbetweenBrookLynkstaff,studentsandsupervisorsprovedtobeeffectiveinsupportingeachthroughtheinterviewingandonboardingprocess.InternsandsupervisorscontactedtheBrooklynkstaffiftheyneededadditionalsupportorhadquestions.Withtheexceptionofa5-7students,theinitialmatchesprovidedtosupervisorsweresuccessful.Eighty-twopercent(82%)ofsupervisorsagreedthattheirinternswereagoodmatchfortheircompanies.SuggestionsforImprovement
• MeetingalloftheworksitehiringcoordinatorspriortomatchingandinterviewingtogothroughBrookLynkinternshipprogrammingsteps.Thecoordinatorswouldthenrelaythisinformationtothesupervisorsattheirworksite
• Lookintowaysthatstudentscanaccessfreebankingapps.• Askinternsintheinternshipapplicationwhethertheyhavetheproperwork
documents.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 45
• Scheduleaninterviewdateaheadoftimeforsupervisorsandinternsatthevariousemploymentlocationstoreduceconfusionastowhentheinterviewswillbetakingplaceandhowtocoordinate.
• Haveeveryinternshipcandidatesubmitacopyofhisorherresumepriorwhencompletingtheinternshipapplication;thiswillhelpstreamlinetheinterviewingprocess.
• HaveprogramstaffworkwiththevariousinternshiplocationstooutlineanddetailtheinternalhiringprocessofBrookLynkinterns.Andthen,coordinateamandatoryworksessionwitheverysupervisorattheirlocationthatwilloutlinetheprocess,policies,andanswerlogisticalquestionsthattheymayhave.
• Keepacopyoftheonboardingproceduresforeveryemployerworksitesothatjobcoachescanfollowupwithstudentsasnecessary.
InternshipsAsmentionedpreviously,BrookLynkdiffersfromMinneapolisSTEP-UPinthatBrookLynkinternshipsarenotseparatedintothreetiers(Achieve,Discover,andExplore).Otherwise,theinternshipsaremodeledoffoftheSTEP-UPprogram:theyarepaid,supervisorsfromtheemployersmentortheinterns,therearesitevisits,andemployersandinternsreceiveweeklyupdatesfromBrookLynkstafftosupportlearning.Ninety-one(91)outoftheoriginal96internssuccessfullycompletedtheirinternships.Averyhighpercentage(93%)ofsupervisorsexpressedthattheirinternprovidedgreatvaluetotheirorganization,department,andwork.Trainingandprovidingongoingsupportforboththeinternsandthesupervisorswaskeytoasuccessfulinternship.Internsbelievedtheylearnedimportantworkskillsthroughtheirinternshipexperiences(with84%answeredCompletelyTrueorMostlyTrue).
_____________________________Internshipsbeganmid-Juneandwerecompleted8-11weekslater,dependingontheemployer.Supervisors,orsomeonetheydelegatedto,wereresponsibleformentoringthestudentsandhelpingthemlearnaboutcareerpathsandworkskills.TheinternshipswerethecoreexperientiallearningopportunityoftheBrookLynkprogram.Allinternshipsbeganasplanned.Ninety-one(91)internssuccessfullycompletedtheirinternship.Fiveinternsdidnotcompletetheirinternshipbecausetheywereterminatedforjobperformancerelatedissues,familychallenges,andlifecircumstances.Internswereplacedinavarietyofdifferentindustriesandpositionsintheircompanies.Theworksitesvisitedwerewelcomingandaccommodatingspaces.Newforthisyear,eachinternhadacapstoneprojectthattheyworkedonduringthesummer.Thisprovideddirectionfortasksthattheycouldcompleteduringtheirinternship.SomeinternshiplocationssuchasCumminsPowerSystems,BostonScientific,CityofBrooklynCenter,andOsseoAreaSchoolsorganizedtheirsupervisorstoworkcollaborativelyontheirintern’scapstoneprojects.Internsbelievedtheylearnedimportantworkskillsthroughtheirinternshipexperiences(with84%answeredCompletelyTrueorMostlyTrue).Internswereabletohaveabetter
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 46
understandingoftheirinterestsandhaveexposuretodifferentrolesandpositionswithinandoutsidetheirworksite.However,someinternsexpressedthattheydidn’tfeelchallengedattheirinternshiporthattherewasnotenoughtodo.Andsomeinternshipsdidn’tseemtobemeaningfulorimpactfulfortheintern.Eighty-onepercent(81%)ofsupervisorssaidthattheirexpectationsofinternjobresponsibilitiesandworkloadmatchedorwereexceededbywhatactuallyhappened.Almosthalf(47%)ofthesupervisorsrespondedthattheyspentover7hoursaweeksupervisingtheirinterns.Sixteenpercent(16%)spentonly1-2hoursinsupervision.Somesupervisorsexpressedchallengesinfindingtimetoadequatelysupervisetheirinternsastheyjuggledotherworkresponsibilities.Therewereseveralreturningsupervisorsthatwereabletosupporttheirpeersandbeon-sitementors.Supervisorswereintentionalaboutcoordinatingopportunitiesfortheirinternstomeetnewindividualsandexpandtheirexperiences(growtheirsocialcapital)On-siteinternshipcoordinatorsplayedakeyroleinsupportingBrookLynkstaff,youth,andsupervisorswithissuesandquestionsrelatedtotheorganization.Supervisorsdidnotalwayscommunicateearlywhentherewereconcernsabouttheirinterns.Thisinformationgenerallycameupduringthesitevisitswhenitwasalmostattheendoftheinternships.Afewoftheinternsalsodidn'texpresstheirconcernsuntiltheendoftheirinternships.Someworksitesdidnothaveenoughtasksfortheirinterns,consideringtheamountoftimethatwasavailable.ThiswasmosttrueinworksitesthatwereparticipatinginBrookLynkforthefirsttime.Someinternalprocessesandculturesoforganizationslimitedinternsexperience.Itappearedasifsomeinternshippositionswerenotcreatedoroutlinedbythedirectsupervisor,butbysomeoneelse,andthiscausedsupervisorstonotbeclearonwhattheirintern’sscopeofworkentailedorwhattheirspecificresponsibilitywas.Thereprovedtoberacial,religious,andotherformsofinequitiesatsomeemployersthatdirectlyimpactedyoungpeople.TheHennepinWorkforceGrantdatareportingrequirementswerenottimely,noradequatelycommunicated.ThismadeitdifficultforBrookLynkstafftocommunicatedetailstoemployers,collectWorkforceOneinformationfrominterns,andtoultimatelyexecutethegrantrequirementsinatimelyandeffectivemanner.HavingtwoJobCoachesallowedforstafftoallocatemoretimetomeetwithyouthandprovidesupport.Staffcapacitiestocheck-inwitheveryinternandsupervisorwerestillstretchedthinandcompromisedthedepthofengagementwitheach.Thereweresomeinternsandsupervisorsthatfeltdisconnected.SuggestionsforImprovement
• Createreferralpartnershipswithserviceprovidersthatcanofferresourcesforstudentsthroughoutthesummer.
• Targetnewsupervisorsandinternswithhigherneedsformoregreatersupport.Establishongoingcommunicationbyemailingorcallingbothinternsandtheirsupervisorstocheck-inshortlyaftertheon-boardingphase.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 47
• Encouragesupervisorstohavealeastoneweeklycheck-inwiththeirinterntogoovertasks,discusschallenges,andestablishsummergoals.
• Providemoreclarityforsupervisorsabouthowtoplancapstoneprojects.• Hireapart-time,seasonaljobcoachwhocanprovidesupportsforinternsand
supervisorsduringthemonthsofMay–August,includingsendingoutandmanagingcommunicationswithinternsandsupervisors,conductingsitevisitsandfacilitatingweeklycheck-inswithacohortofinterns.
• Whenreviewinginternshipdescriptionforms,confirmtheaccuracyoftheinformationwiththesupervisorsandmentors.Thiswillallowfortheretobelessconfusionaboutwhattheinternshipentailsandwhattheyarecommittedto.
• MakeitclearduringsupervisortrainingthatBrookLynkshouldbeinformedassoonaspossibleaboutupdatesaroundchangedenddates,changedsupervisorroles,andanyotherrelevantinformation.
• Facilitategroupcheck-insforBrookLynksupervisorsandmentors.Thiswillallowforstafftohavemorefrequenttouchpointswiththemandtohelpmediateanyissuesandprovidesupportswhereneeded.
• Ifsupervisorscannotallocateenoughtimetoactuallysupervisetheintern,ortocoordinateameaningfulinternship,BrookLynkshouldstronglysuggestthatanothersupervisorbeassignedtotheintern.
Check-insandEnrichmentOpportunitiesMinneapolisSTEP-UPofferssomeadditionaltrainingopportunities(e.g.financialliteracy).BrookLynkStaffwantedtoaddamoreinvolvedcomponentwhichallowedtheinternstomeettogetherregularly,developasenseofbelonging,allowforreflectionontheinternshipexperience,andworkoncareerdevelopmentandskills,andpostsecondaryawareness.Aweeklycheck-induringtheinternshipperiodwasaddedtotheBrookLynkprogram,similartowhatwasdevelopedintheCityofSt.PaulRightTrackyouthemploymentprogram.Sixty-twopercent(62%)ofinternsonaverageshowedupfortheweeklycheck-ins.Internswhoattendedreportedthattheydevelopedasenseofbelongingandmutualsupport,wereabletoshareandreflectontheirexperiences,discusssolutionstoproblemstheywerefacing,andworkonimprovingcareerskills.Stafffoundthecheck-insavaluableplacetoconnectwithinternstobettersupportthem.Theinternswhoparticipatedinenrichmentopportunitieswereabletobetterunderstandtheirowncollegeandcareergoalsafterthevisits.
_____________________________Weeklyinterncheck-insoccurredonsevenFridaysduringtheinternshipatNorthHennepinCommunityCollege.Internswereassignedtooneofthree1.5hourlongsessionsdesignedtoprovideadditionalsupportforinterns.Internshadtimetoreflectontheirexperiences,discussproblemstheyfacedandpossiblesolutions,learnmoreaboutMHALabsBuildingBlockskills,andbuildcommunityamongeachcohortthroughactivitiesandcollaborativework.Check-insprovidedanopportunityforyouthtobuildacommunitywithoneanotherandalsoforstudentsmeetnewpeople.Thecheck-insincludedopportunitiesformultiplecommunicationstyles:internshadtheir
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 48
ownpersonalreflectiontime,discussedtopicswithinsmallgroups,andsharedoutwiththelargergroup.Planningwasmadeeasierbystaffcompilinganongoinglistofactivitiestododuringcheck-inssothatitwasonhandeachweektoeasilyputintotheagenda.Separatingintothreeinterncohortscreatedagoodgroupsizethatwaslargeenoughtodoavarietyofactivitieswhilealsosmallenoughwhereeachinternhadachancetoshareabouttheirexperience.Havingtwostafftocoordinatetransportationandfacilitatethecheck-insprovedtobemuchmoreeffectivethaninyearspast.Onecouldset-upwhiletheotherwouldtransportthestudents.However,coordinatingandfacilitatingthreeback-to-back-to-backcheck-insonFridaysalongwithprovidingvantransportation,wasdrainingforBrookLynkstaffandmadeforlongdays.Onaverage62%ofinternsshowedupfortheweeklycheck-ins.Internsatfirststruggledwiththeaccountabilityandresponsibilitythemethatstaffhadexpressedatthebeginningofthesummer.But,theybecamebetteratbeingresponsiblewithcommunication.Newandyoungerstudentsattendedcheck-insmorefrequentlyandparticipatedmorewillingly.Manyreturningandolderstudentsattendedwithlessfrequencyandstatedthattheyweren’tfindinganyvalueinthecheck-ins.Therewerefewerinattendanceatcheck-inseachweek.ThisisespeciallytrueofstudentsthatmighthaveneededmoresupportfromBrookLynkstaff.SomemovedoutoftheBrooklynsareasduetounforeseencircumstancesandhaddifficultycomingtocheck-ins.Eighty-one(81%)ofstudentswhoattendedrespondedthattheythoughtthecheck-inswerevaluable.Theyreportedthattheydevelopedasenseofbelongingandmutualsupport,wereabletoshareandreflectontheirexperiences,discusssolutionstoproblemstheywerefacing,andworkonimprovingcareerskills.Studentsfeltcomfortablesharinginthelargegroupandprivatelywithstafftheissuesthattheymayhavebeenfacing.Thisallowedstafftobeawareofwhatsupportstheymayneedtoprovideeithertotheinternorthesupervisor.Inadditiontothecheck-ins,BrookLynkofferedenrichmentopportunities,includingvisitstotheUniversityofMinnesota—TwinCities,ConcordiaUniversity,andGeneralMills.Anaverageof23youthattendedtheenrichmentopportunities.Studentswererespectfulandengagedinthediscussionsandactivitiesonallthreeenrichmentevents.TheUniversityofMinnesotavisitwasparticularlynotableasstudentswereabletohearabouthowtoprepareforcollege,atypicalcollegeschedule,andresourcesthattheycanuseoncampus.TheGeneralMillssitevisitallowedthestudentstotourthefacilityandhearfromdifferentemployeesontheirpathwaytotheirparticularroles.Theemployeeswerefromdiversebackgroundswhichallowedthestudentstoseerepresentationamongthepanelists.Byfar,theGeneralMillssitevisitwasthemostpopulareventforthoseinternswhotookadvantageoftheenrichmentopportunities.Theyvaluedseeinghowalargecorporationfunctionedandtheinsightthevisitprovidedtotheirowncareergoals.Eventbritewasusedtosigninternsupforenrichmentopportunities.Sincethewebsiteisopentothepublic,therewereafewnon-BrookLynkparticipantsthatsignedup.The
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 49
campusvisittoConcordiaUniversitywasgenericandmaybedidn’thavetheimpactitcouldhaveifitwerecoordinatedwithastudentgrouporotherofficeatthecollege.SuggestionsforImprovement
• DividethegroupincohortsbasedonBrookLynkexperiencelevel.Thiswaycontentcanbetailoredtotheneedsoftheinterns.
• Createtheagendaitemsforcheck-inbeforetheinternshipbeginssothatthereisgreaterdepthofthoughttowardshowlessonswillbecommunicatedandwhatactivitieswilltakeplace.
• Makecheck-insmandatoryforeveryonesothatinternsmakethemostoftheirinternshipexperiencebygainingprofessionaldevelopmentskills.Jobcoacheswouldalsohavegreaterawarenessofhowinternshipsarefairingandcouldaddressissuesmorereadily.
• Engageyouthtofreshen-upthecheck-incurriculumaroundtheirownneeds.Forexample:hostanetworkingsession,aLinkedInsession,MicrosoftOutlook101,orothertechnicalsessionsthatallowthemtowalkawaywithimmediateskills.
• Incorporatemorechallengingsessionswhereeachsessionbuildsoffoftheprevious.Identifysomethingthatstudentsshouldhavewalkedawaywithafterattendingeachcheck-insession.
• Useanelectronicsign-upsheetonGoogleDrive,whereinternscansign-upforvanpick-upanddrop-offfromcheck-in.
• Sendingoutaweeklyupdatestosupervisorsaboutthecontentthatisgoingtobediscussedatcheck-inandprovidingwaysthattheycanengagetheirinternindiscussingaboutit.
• Coordinatesitevisitstonon-traditionalemployerslikegovernmentagencies,non-profits,orcommunity/technicalschools.
• Requirethateachattendeecomepreparedwithanotecardthathasquestionstheywouldliketoasktheschoolortheemployerduringsitevisits.
CelebrationBrookLynkendedthesummerprogramwithacelebrationfortheinternsandsupervisors,andtheirfamilies.Internssharedamazingstoriesabouthowtheirexperiencesimpactedtheirlives.SomeBrookLynkstakeholderswerepresent,butweweren’tabletogetmembersofthemediatoattend.
_____________________________OnAugust11th,interns,theirfamilies,andsupervisorsgatheredattheGrandHallatNorthHennepinCommunityCollege(NHCC)tocelebratetheendoftheinternships.Theeventstartedoffwithdinner,followedbyareviewofthehistoryofBrookLynkandalookintothefutureoftheprogram,presentationsfrominternsandsupervisorsabouttheirexperiencesandtheimpactBrookLynkhad.InternswhohadparticipatedinBrookLynkfor3yearswererecognizedalongwiththoseadultswhohavebeenchampionsoftheprogram.Aportionofthetimewasalsodedicatedtorecognizealltheinternsandsupervisorsfortheirwork.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 50
Agroupof8BrookLynkinternsmetduringthecourseofthesummertocreatethevision,organize,decorate,andspearheadtheevent.Thedatewasselectedbecausemostinternshipshadbeencompleted,yetbeforestudentsstartingcollegeouttownhadtoleave.Unfortunatelywiththeincreasednumberofinternsthisyear,themaximumsizecapacityoftheroomlimitedthenumberofguestsallowed.Similartolastyear,therewasnomediapresenceattheevent.Thefoodandawardexpenseswentoverbudget.SuggestionsforImprovement
• Findalocalbusinessororganizationwhowouldbewillingtofundtheevent.• Sendoutcalendarinvitestobothstudentsandsupervisorsatthebeginningofthe
programaboutthecelebration.• Sendapressreleasetomediaoutletsatleastonemonthpriortotheevent.• Findaneventspacewhereweareabletohostalargereventwithmoreattendees.
EvaluationMinneapolisSTEP-UPusesMHALabsSkillBuildingBlockstoassesstheirinterns’skilldevelopment,buttheframeworkisnotasembeddedintheprogrammingaswithBrookLynk.STEP-UPmeasuressomelong-termoutcomes(e.g.highschoolattendance,graduationrate,behaviorandgradesandtestscores,andcollegeenrollment/persistence).Surveysaregivenouttostudentsbeforeandafterworkreadinesstraining,andthereisanformalprogramevaluationprocess(asevidencedbythisreport).Mostoftheevaluationframeworkwasalreadyinplacefromlastyear.However,significantworkwasdonetoautomatethedatacollectionandanalysistodecreasetheamountofworkrequiredtoevaluatetheprogram.Thisyear,100%ofsupervisorsfilledoutaperformancereview(comparedto65%lastyear.)
_____________________________ForthethirdyearofBrookLynk,mostoftheevaluationframeworkwasalreadyinplacefromlastyear.However,effortwasputintoautomatingthedatacollectionandanalysisinanticipationthetransitiontotheCitiesnextyearandadecreaseinthehoursscopedfortheevaluation.Alloftheapplicationsandsurveysweremovedtoanonlineplatform(SurveyMonkey),whichallowedustotrackandidentifywhereapplicationsandsurveyswerecomingfrom.Thenumberofqualitativequestionswasdecreased,sincetheyrequiremoretime-intensiveanalysis.Towardstheendoftheinternships,supervisorswereaskedtoevaluateandprovidefeedbacktotheinternsoncareerskillsviaanMHALabsassessmenttool.Thisyear,100%ofsupervisorsfilledoutaperformancereview(comparedto65%lastyear.)Yet,performancereviewswerenotalwaysbeingcompletedpriortotheinterns’enddates.Thismaymeanthatsupervisorswerenotusingthefinalperformancereviewtohaveaclosingconversationwithinterns,whichisconsideredacriticalpieceofahigh-qualityinternshipexperience.Youthandsupervisorsprovidedhonestandtransparentfeedbackintheirsurveysandperformancereviews.However,collectingsurveysandperformancereviewsfrom
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 51
supervisorswaschallenging.Thiswaspartiallyduetothefactthatsomesupervisorsthatwerelistedonthepositiondescriptionwereactuallynotthesupervisorsduringtheinternships.BrookLynkstaffwereonleavewhileafewinternshipswrappedup,whichmadecollectingyear-endsurveysandperformancereviewsdifficultfortheevaluator.SuggestionsforImprovement
• IncludeperformancereviewandsurveydeadlinesonthesheetdetailingimportantBrookLynkdatesthatispassedoutatthebeginningoftheprogram.
• Communicatemid-Julywithsupervisorsonhowtocompletetheperformancereviewandprovidealinktothesupervisorsurvey.Makesuretotalkaboutperformancereviewsandsurveysduringsitevisits.
• Havethestudentstaketheirinternsurveyatthelastcheck-intoensureagreaternumberofresponses.
• CreateprofilesontheBrookLynkwebsitewhereinternsandsupervisorscantracktheprogressoftheirperformancereviewsandsurveys.
DISCUSSIONNextevaluationquestionsandrecommendationsforimprovingtheBrookLynkprogramarediscussedbelow.NextEvaluationAsBrookLynktransitionsfromincubationtooperationattheCities,theevaluationwillchangeaswell.Thisthirdyearevaluationuncoveredadditionalquestionsforfurtherstudy.
• Whatspecificcharacteristics(program,staff,supervisor,employer,orintern)leadtoahigh-qualityinternship?
• WhatarethebenefitsoftheBrookLynkprogramtoemployers?• WhatarethebenefitsoftheBrookLynkprogramtotheyouthworkforce?• Whatisthevalueofthisprogramtothecityanditspartnersingrowingvitalityinthe
community?Thescopeoftheevaluationwilldecreasebytwo-thirdsnextyear.Astheprogrammaturestheevaluationwillshifttowardsprimarilyperformancemeasurement.Theevaluationwillstillincludereportonoutputstotrackyouthandcommunitypartnerparticipation.Thequalityassessmentwillonlyfocusontheinternships.Ashasbeendiscussed,thequalitymeasureswillbecross-tabbedwithotherdatatoidentifywhatleadstoahigh-qualityinternship.Performancereviewswillbeusedtomeasureyouthoutcomesregardingcareerskills.Theend-of-the-yearsurveysforinternsandsupervisorswillbeusedtomeasureyouthoutcomesandbusinessoutcomesaroundqualityandsatisfactionofthosestakeholders.Thecapacitybuildingandprocessevaluationswillbereplacedbypost-eventdebriefsthatwillcapturewhatworked,didn’tworkandsuggestionsforimprovements.Thiswillbereportedminimally.Forexample,fornextyear,thismayspecificallyincludethealumninetwork,thejobboard,andthejobfair.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 52
RecommendationsforImprovingBrookLynkTheevaluationreportgeneratedover100suggestionstoimprovetheBrookLynkProgram.Theserecommendationsaresummarizedbelow.
1. LaunchtheAlumniNetworkandJobBoard.DeveloptheAlumniNetworktokeepincontactwithalumniandprovideongoingsupportandnetworkingopportunities.Designprofessionaldevelopmentaroundsocialnetworks.Developthejobboardtoprovideinformationaboutlocalinternshipandjobopportunitiesforyouth.
2. ConsidernewstrategiestomeetwithneedsofandattractOpportunityYouth.
CreateatargetedandsupportedoutreachstrategytoengageOpportunityYouth.Establishstrongerpipelinestonon-profitsandpublicagenciesthatdirectlyworkwithcounty-involvedyouth(CIY),torecruitandsupportthemintheirBrookLynkinternship.Attendprofessionaldevelopmentforprogramstafftoeffectivelyengageandsupportcountyinvolved/opportunityyouththroughouttheBrookLynkexperience.CreatereferralpartnershipswithserviceprovidersthatcanofferresourcesforstudentsthatmayhavefurtherneedsthanwhatBrookLynkcanprovide.
3. Buildthecapacityofemployerstoimproveinternalprocessesandsupport
supervisordevelopment.Providetechnicalassistancetoemployerstoimprovetheirinternalprocessesforhiringyouthandforsupportingsupervisors.MeetingalloftheworksitehiringcoordinatorspriortomatchingandinterviewingtogothroughBrookLynkinternshipprogrammingsteps.
4. Continuetoengageyouthinco-creatingtheBrookLynkprogram.Refinethe
BrookLynkGetReady!andInternshipTrainingtobereflectiveoftheneedsofyouthanddemandsofemployers.ThisrefinedversionshouldalsoaddressthequestionaboutyouthparticipatingBrookLynkformultipleyearsandtheirneedtotakepartintraining.Engageyouthtofreshen-upthecheck-incurriculumaroundtheirownneeds,forexample:hostanetworkingsession,aLinkedInsession,MicrosoftOutlook101,orothertechnicalsessionsthatallowthemtowalkawaywithimmediateskills.
5. RedesigntheYouthJobFair.Considernewstrategiestorecruitmoreyouthand
businessestoattend,andtomatchjobseekerstoemployerswithjobopeningsattheevent.Recruitemployershiringforpositionsandtrainthemtohireonthespot.Outreachforemployersandyouthworkforcedevelopmentorganizationsyear-round.
6. Createdeeperengagementwithschoolpartnersasstrategicpartners.Consider
newstrategiestoimprovethepercentageofinvitedyouthwhoattendworkreadinesstraining,includingworkingwithschooltoofferworkreadinesstrainingduringschool-dayorafterschoolprogramming.Considerwaystoprovideinternswithmoretrainingaroundjobskillsemployersneed(Outlook,Excel,etc.)includingworkingwithschoolsandhaveemployersprovideOn-The-JobTraining.
7. ContinuetorefinetheyouthoutreachstrategywiththeReferralPartners.Create
referralpartnershipswiththecountyserviceprovidersandfaith-basedcommunity
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 53
organizations.AllowtheAmbassadorstotakeagreaterleadonmarketingattheirschools.WorkwithBrooklynParkstafftocreatemarketingmaterialinthefallthateachschoolpointofcontactcansendoutwhenrecruitingbegins.HavetheBrookLynkAmbassadorsleadasocialmediacampaignthroughamoreorganicinitiativethatcreatesbuzzearlieron.Betterusetraditionalmedia(Channel12,theSunPost,andothernewsoutlets)torecruityouthandcommunicatetheworkBrookLynkdoesinthecommunity.
8. CompletethetransitionofBrookLynkfromtheAlliancetotheCities.Continue
withtheBrookLynkSteeringCommittee,andputenergyintoestablishinganewadvisoryduringthetransitiontoensurepositiveyouthoutcomesduringthischange.
9. Continuetoexpandbusinessoutreachtoengagemoreemployers,andinmore
typesofcareerfieldsandopportunitiesfor2018.Createauniqueandengagingrecruitmentpiecesforfunders,employers,andpolicymakers.Continuetogrowstrategicpartnerships.Continuetoidentifyandengagenewstakeholders.Haveamorecomprehensivecommunicationsplan/pitchtoemployerswithsupportingmaterialsthatincludebrochures,evaluationsummaries,testimonials,andinfographics.
10. EngagemorecommunitypartnerstosupportBrookLynk.Createan“engagementladder”forcommunitypartnerstogetinvolved,fromdonatingfinancialorin-kindsupport,toparticipatinginatrainingorevent,toprovidinginternships,tojoiningabusinessadvisory.FindalocalbusinessororganizationthatwouldbewillingtofundtheBrookLynkcelebration.
11. Determinehowtostrategicallybuildresourcescollaboratively.Staffidentified
theneedtodevelopacollaborativetimeline,expectations,andclarityregardingfundraising.Refinetheunderstandingofthebudget,andbuildadetailedplanforfundraising,partnership,andwaystomanageexpenses.
12. Simplifytheevaluationfurtherfocusonthedatapointsthatmostdirectly
answerthepoliticalandperformancemeasurequestionsthatwillarise.Createasinglepageapplicationsothatallofastudent’sinformationiscollected.Havethestudentstaketheirinternsurveyatthelastcheck-intoensureagreaternumberofresponses.Sendearlierandmoreconsistentcommunicationstosupervisorsandhiringcoordinatorstoensurethattheycompletethesurveysandperformancereviews.Continuetoimproveandvalidatetheprocessofassessingqualityintheinternshipexperiencesatemployerlocations.Considerwhatotherdatashouldbecollectedandanalyzedthatmayhelptounderstandthecharacteristicsofahigh-qualitysupervisor.
BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 54
FURTHERINFORMATIONForfurtherinformationontopicsanddatadiscussedinthisreport,pleaserefertotheYouthEmploymentProgramwikisiteatthefollowingaddress:
https://sites.google.com/site/bbayouthemploymentprogram/APPENDIX
• BrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramLogicModel
• BrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramProcessChart
• 2017BrookLynkEvaluationPlan
• 2017BrookLynkOutputs