© 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ......

37
© 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved.

Transcript of © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ......

Page 1: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

© 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved.

Page 2: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Real-Time Modeling BasicsUser Case Studies

Presented by

Saša Tomić, Ph.D., P.E., HDRTarun Gill, P.E., HDR

Asset Management and Prioritization - Innovyze WorkshopNovember 9th, 2016

Page 3: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013)

Modeling Trends§ Level of model detail has increased

§Use of Extended Period Simulation (EPS) has increased

§Models are being used for numerous and new applications

Model Use§ >50% used at least weekly§ ~75% used at least monthly

Page 4: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Most Frequent Models Uses

Fire Flow 24%

Planning 28%

Asset Mngmt

7%

Operational21%

Energy4%

Water Quality

10%Flushing

5%Other

1%

Source: AWWA EMAC Survey 2013

Page 5: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Most Important Technology

Real-Time20%

Mobility6%

GIS32%

Cloud-Computing

5%

Telemetry/Sensors

24%

Computer Speed12%

Other 1%

Source: AWWA EMAC Survey 2013

Page 6: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Features and Trends Ranking

Source: AWWA EMAC Survey 2013

Page 7: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

A Model You Can Trust

Links to SCADA

Access to Results

How to Build

a Real-Time Model

Page 8: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

§ Numerous models developed over 30 yearso SWMMo InfoWorks

§ Combined Models foro Queenso Brooklyno Manhattan

§ Models validationo 12-month recordo GARRo Tides and Snowmelt o Flow and Level Datao SCADA

§ Model needed to predicto Actual Annual Counts of CSOo Actual Annual Duration of CSOo Actual Annual Volume of CSO

NYC DEP, New York City, NY

Model Calibration for CSO

Page 9: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

January 27, 2016 9

Radar Grid and Gage Network for GARR

Page 10: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Tides Data – NOAA Adjusted Atmospherics Tides

January 27, 2016

Page 11: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Flow Monitoring – Regulator R-083Meter Name Method Notes

R-083_M1 MP1: This meter is in 72 inch incoming line.

Depth may be used to measure depth over weir and for model verification

R-083_M1 MP2

Overflow detection sensor. Positive velocity

= overflow

No tidal intrusion expected. Sensor on weir

wall

R-083_M2 MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line.

Depth may be used to measure depth over weir and for model verification

R-083_M2 MP2

Overflow detection sensor. Positive velocity

= overflow

No tidal intrusion expected. Sensor on weir

wall

R-083_M3 CSO Outfall Q=VA for thesingle 192 inch sewer.

Sensors measures all overflow from

structure

CSOFLOW_R-083

Preliminary CSO overflow

= M3 Qc when MP2 sensors detect velocity

Final CSO overflow calculation analyzed

by ADS and modified if

validation methods are valid. Reported

on FlowWorks as QFinal

Page 12: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Statistical Flow Comparison

Page 13: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Model Validation – CSO Event Counts

R-026 R-015 R-083 R-029

CSO

Even

tsCa

ptur

ed S

torm

Ev

ents

ADS Measured: 113 116 114 119Total Storms: 115 116 115 119

Exact Match: 96% 96% 91% 89%CSO: Model/ADS: 89% 113% 96% 85% includes FP

Page 14: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

CSO Volume Comparison R-026

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

Mod

eled

CSO

Vol

ume

(MG

)

ADS CSO Volume (MG)

Rain >1.0'' Rain 0.5-1.0 ''

Rain <0.5 '' Snow Impacted

Basis: 72 Storm Events

4/29/2014 Event

7/2/2014 Event

+20%

-10%

Gold Standard Storms

Page 15: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Model Validation – CSO Volume

Study Period (March 28, 2014 – March 27, 2015) CSO Volume Comparison

Note: volumes shown reflect comparisons for events for which data are available at each location. Do not compare the relative volumes between locations.

ADS DataUpdated Model

R-026 R-015 R-083 R-029

Page 16: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Gold Standard Comparison R-026

Gold Standard Storms Only

Page 17: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

A Model You Can Trust

Links to SCADA

Access to Results

How to Build

a Real-Time Model

Page 18: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

§ Population doubled since 2000§ Water Sourceso Treated Water

• Treatment Plant ~44%• Denver Water ~35%• Reuse ~21%

o Raw Water• Colorado-Bit Thompson (C-BT) Project • Windy Gap System

Broomfield, COModel-Based Decision Support System

Page 19: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

§ A ‘tool’ to balance water supply and demand § Include two sources of raw and two sources of finished water§ Provide output both operational and cost§ Make the ‘tool’ user-friendly, flexible, freely-distributable and § Limited budget

Project Challenge

Page 20: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

System Schematic

Page 21: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

System Schematic

Page 22: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Solution

Page 23: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

§ Description § Simulation length§ Water supply o Water rights limitso Potable treatment targetso Denver Water criteria§ Pump stations§ Storage tanks

Scenario Setup

Page 24: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

§ Treatment costs§ Master meter costs§ Raw water “costs”§ Pumping costs

Cost Data

Page 25: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Demand Allocation

Page 26: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Results

Page 27: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Reporting

Page 28: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

A Model You Can Trust

Links to SCADA

Access to Results

How to Build

a Real-Time Model

Page 29: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

§ NJ DEP require utilities to o Report potential CSOs in real time o Provide monthly report of daily CSO volumes

§ HDR has developed online system to satisfy these requirements

§ http://njcso.hdrgateway.com/

Passaic Valley Sewer Commission, NJ

Online CSO Notification System

Page 30: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

Animated Radar Image(white dots – observation stations)

Page 31: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

CSO Notification Site

Page 32: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

CSO Site Navigation

Page 33: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

CSO reporting

Page 34: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

CSO reporting

Page 35: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

CSO reporting

Page 36: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

A Model You Can Trust

Links to SCADA

Access to Results

How to Build

a Real-Time Model

Page 37: © 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved. - Innovyze · AWWA Modeling Committee Survey (2013) ... R-083_M2. MP1: This meter is in 192” inch incoming line. Depth may be used to measure

© 2015 HDR, Inc., all rights reserved.

Questions?Questions?

Tarun Gill, [email protected], (617) 357-7799 Saša Tomić, Saš[email protected], (212) 545-5430

Thank You