2015-03-01 State of Israel v Alenkari (37961-05-12) in the Tel-Aviv District Court – Presided by...

Human Rights Alert (NGO) Joseph Zernik, PhD ד"ר יוסף צרניק PO Box 33407, Tel-Aviv, Israel 6133301, ת"א 33407ת"ד

Fax: 077-3179186 Email: [email protected]

2015-03-01 State of Israel v Alenkari (37961-05-12) in the Tel-Aviv District Court – Presided by Judge David Rosen: Net Hamishpat records – public access, remote terminal //

) בבית המשפט המחוזי ת"א: כתבים37961-05-12 מדינת ישראל נ אלנקרי (עציר) ואח' (בתיק מנט המשפט – מסוף מרוחק, גישת הציבור

The records in the electronic court file include valid, invalid, inaccessible andmissing records... Access to the entire court file is arbitrary and capricious.

Judge David Rosen of the Tel-Aviv District Court

a) 2013-03-13 “Sentencing of Defendant #2” • The record shows a typical signature box with a graphic signature, below which his name

appears “David Rosen, Judge”.• The record shows the date at the top left of the face page, typical of records that show a

siganture.• The record was docketed under “Decisions” as, “Sentencing of March 13, 2013 by Judge

David Rosen, and likewise under “Judgments.

1/6

Top of the face page of the 2013-03-13 “Sentencing of Defendant #2” - a typical valid appearing Net Hamishpat record: a) Israel Coat of Arms appears in blue, b) the first line includes the court file name and date, in font (Times) which is different than the rest of the record (David)

Signature box and page number of ultimate page of the 2013-03-13 “Sentencing of Defendant #2” - a typical valid appearing Net Hamishpat record: a) graphic signature (no evidence of e-signature above a signature line, b) “David Rosen, Judge”, appears below the signture line, c) page number and page count appear at the bottom of the page.

b) 2012-02-12 “Protocol”• The record is unsigned• The record is docketed under “Decisions” as “Instruction for Prosecutor to file an amended

indictment.”

2/6

Top of the 2012-10-17 “Protocol”: • Israel Coat of Arms in blue at top of the page. • File caption and number and date appear here in same font (David) as rest of the record.• Three Defendants are listed, but only for one of them a judgment record appears in the file.

Signature box and page number of 2012-10-17 “Protocol”:

• The record is unsigned

• Page number without page count.

PageDocument #

22012-10-17 “Protocol” by Judge David Rosen - unsigned1.

32012-10-17 “Protocol” by Judge David Rosen - unavailable2.

2013-03-13 “Sentencing” by Judge David Rosen - signed3.

3/6

Some of the records in this case were downloaded from Net HaMishpat on March 1, 2015.On March 3, 2015, attempt was made to recover the missing data.Access was denied:

The user is not permitted to view this file.

4/6

1) Calendar

Notice: The list includes 7 hearings for which protocols were generated, but most of them are missing from the “Decisions” list.

2) Decisions

5/6

4. Judgments

Notice: The title of the record itself is “Sentencing for Defendant #2”. The decision record list three (3) Defendants. For two of them there is no judgment record.

6/6

of 5

22/02/2015http://breader.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

2012-10-17 Hearing Protocol Judge Rosen

“The record is inaccessible now”.

of 6

22/02/2015http://breader.court.gov.il/EPDefault/FlashReader/print.asp

2015-03-01 State of Israel v Alenkari (37961-05-12) in the Tel-Aviv District Court – Presided by...

Documents

Transcript of 2015-03-01 State of Israel v Alenkari (37961-05-12) in the Tel-Aviv District Court – Presided by...