OMT  Business  Mee+ng:  2013  Agenda  1.  Welcome  and  Division  Chair  Report  

–  Membership    –  Updates,  sponsorship,  and  thanks  

2.  Conference  Reports  –  PDWs  –  Program  and  Awards  

3.  Dis+nguished  Educator  Award  4.  Best  Published  OMT  Paper  Award  5.  Farewells  6.  Ar+fact  and  Social  Hour    

Welcome  to  Our  New  Officers!!  

                                                         Ann  Langley        PDW  Chair-­‐Elect  

     Mark  Ebers                Brayden  King  – Representa+ves  at  large  

Division  Chair  Report:  Membership  Updates  

•  Membership  –  4000  members  –  25%  of  our  members  are  students  –  OMT  members  con+nue  to  be  recognized  for  best  scholarship  

•  75%  of  AMJ  Best  Paper  Awards  •  88%  of  ASQ  Best  Paper  Awards  

•  Accomplished  OMT  members  recognized  by  Academy  this  year:  – Mike  Tushman,  Dis+nguished  Award  for  Scholarly  Contribu+ons  for  AOM  

–  Jim  Walsh,  Dis+nguished  Award  for  Service  for  AOM  – Mike  Lounsbury,  Pat  Thornton  and  Willie  Ocasio,  AOM  George  R.  Terry  Book  Award  

Division  Chair  Report:  Membership  Updates  

•  We  wanted  to  know  more  about  early  career  OMT  members  

 •  Surveyed  past  4  years  of  doctoral  student  consor+um  par+cipants  (108  respondents)  –  62%  Assistant  Professors  –  15%  Postdocs  or  lecturers  –  21%  S+ll  in  Doctoral  Program  

•  Where  did  they  go?  •  What  do  they  teach?  

Where  is  OMT?  

–   50%  are  currently  outside  the  US      – Jobs  that  were  adver+sed  in:  

• Organiza+on  Theory:  26%  • Management:    35%  • Strategy:  35%  • Organiza+onal  Behavior:  27%  • Entrepreneurship:  15%  

What  do  OMT  members  teach?  –  13%    Organiza+on  Theory  –  47%    Strategy  –  29%    Organiza+onal  Behavior  –  18%    Entrepreneurship  –  13%    Corporate  Social  Responsibility  –  11%    Leadership  –  9%      Introduc+on  to  Management  –  6%      Organiza+onal  Change  –  10%      Innova+on  or  Social  Entrepreneurship  (5%  each)  –  4%        Human  Resources  –  9%    Networks,  Intl  Business,  Ethics  (3%  each)  

We  are  Everywhere!  

•  OMT  is  a  diverse  group  that  spawns  new  ideas  and  new  divisions  and  interest  areas  

•  We  provide  intellectual  thought  leadership  

•  We  support  and  foster  high  quality  research  across  a  range  of  topics  and  areas  

 

Division  Chair  Report:  Updates  

•  Paper  Development  Workshops  – Co-­‐sponsored  with  universi+es  around  the  world  – 4  in  2011-­‐2012:  London,  Paris,  Milan,  Cambridge  – 4  in  2013:    Singapore,  Istanbul,  Sydney,  Montreal  – Planning  stages:    China  

•  EGOS  Collabora+ons  – Meet  OMT  at  EGOS  in  Montreal  – 2013  PDW  Fron+ers  of  Organiza+onal  Scholarship  –  Introduc+ons:  Renate  Meyer,  EGOS  Chair  

Reimagining Rethinking Reshaping

Organizational Scholarship in Unsettled Times 3-5 July, 2014 60 subthemes Deadline for short paper submission: 13 January, 2014

30th EGOS Colloquium, Rotterdam 2014

31th EGOS Colloquium, Athens 2015

Organizational Scholarship in Unsettled Times 2-4 July, 2015 Deadline for subtheme proposals: September 2014

SPECIAL  THANKS  TO  SPONSORS  OF  OMT  ACTIVITIES  

•  Boston  College…………………………  

•  University  of  California,  Irvine....  

•  U  of  Alberta…………………..………...  •  Wharton  School……...……..………  •  Harvard  Business  School….………  •  USC  Marshall  School………………..  •  Emerald…………………………………..  •  Florida  State  University  and                Warwick  Business  School  ………  

Dis+nguished    Scholar  Breakfast  Meet  OMT  at  EGOS  Winter  Execu+ve  Mee+ng  Business  Mee+ng  Junior  Faculty  Consor+um    Junior  Faculty  Consor+um  

Doctoral  Consor+um  

Doctoral  Consor+um  

Behavioral  Theory  Anniversary  Symposium  

     

Commigee  Thanks  Yous    

Communica+ons  Commigee:  Joel  Gehman,  Chair  Thank  you  to  commigee  members  –  stand  up  and  take  a  bow!      

•  Evelyn  Micelo:a,  PhD  Candidate,  University  of  Alberta,  former  blogging  commigee  member  since  2010  

•  Mia  Raynard,  PhD  Candidate,  University  of  Alberta,  former  blogging  commigee  member  since  2010  

•  Vern  Glaser,  PhD  Candidate,  University  of  Southern  California,  former  blogging  commigee  member  since  2011    

•  Derek  Harmon,  PhD  Candidate,  University  of  Southern  California,  former  blogging  commigee  member  since  2011  

•  Diane-­‐Laure  Arjaliès,  Assistant  Professor,  HEC  Paris,  commigee  member  since  2012  

•  Marco  Clemente,  PhD  Candidate,  HEC  Paris,  commigee  member  since  2012  

•  Rebecca  Henn,  Assistant  Professor,  Penn  State  University,  commigee  member  since  2013  

•  Michael  Mauskapf,  PhD  Candidate,  Northwestern  University,  commigee  member  since  2013  

Name   University   Name   University  

Mona Al-Amin Suffolk University Dali Ma Drexel University

Felix Arndt University of Nottingham Yuri Mishina Imperial College London

Prasad Balkundi SUNY Buffalo Tom Moliterno University of Massachusetts at Amherst

Roxana Barbulescu McGill University Hongseok Oh Yonsei University

Sekou Bermiss University of Texas at Austin Amalya Oliver Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Daniel Beunza London School of Economics Antoaneta Petkova San Francisco State University

Lyda Bigelow University of Utah Greg Robbins Southern Connecticut State University

Emily Block Notre Dame University Gokce Sargut Governors State University

Gianluca Carnabuci University of Lugano Bruce Skaggs University of Massachusetts at Amherst

David Chandler University of Colorado at Denver Paul Skilton Washington State University, Tricities campus

Niki den Nieuwenboer Santa Clara University Ned Smith University of Michigan

Micki Eisenman Hebrew University of Jerusalem Giuseppe Soda University of Bocconi

Luca Gnan Università degli Studi di Roma Tor Vergata Maxim Sytch, University of Michigan

Scott Graffin University of Georgia Adam Tatarynowicz Tilburg University

Nina Granqvist Helsinki School of Economics Balagopal Vissa INSEAD

Peter Groenewegen Vrije University Klaus Weber Northwestern University

Dan Halgin University of Kentucky Jennifer Woolley Santa Clara University

Kate Kellogg MIT April Wright University of Queensland

Tomi Laamanen University of St. Gallen Eric Zhao University of Alberta

Elizabeth Lim University of Texas at Dallas David Zhu Arizona State University

Research Committee Members Chair: Joe Broschak – University of Arizona Talk to Joe!

Stand up, take a bow!

OMT  PDWs:  2013  

OMT  PDWs  Summary  •  9  sessions  solo  sponsored  by  OMT  •  10  sessions  Led  by  OMT  •  26  sessions  co-­‐sponsored  by  OMT    Of  the  36  jointly  sponsored  sessions  •  53%  with  BPS      •  39%  with  OB  •  33%  with  RM  •  22%  with  MOC  •  19%  with  TIM  •  14%  with  SAP      

OMT  Program:  2013  

Submissions  to  OMT  

0  

100  

200  

300  

400  

500  

600  

700  

2003   2004   2005   2006   2007   2008   2009   2010   2011   2012   2013  

Symposia  

Papers  

Program  Summary  •  1017  people  agreed  to  review  for  OMT  from  50  countries.  

THANK  YOU!  

•  1008  people  received  papers  to  review:  –  Avg  of  2.51  submissions/reviewer  –  4  reviews/  submission  –  Very  few  emergency  reviews  

•  Reviewers  and  AoM  Membership:  –  62%  not  AoM  Members  or  less  than  FIVE  years  –  23%  FIVE  to  TEN  years  –  15%  TEN  plus  years  –  62%  are  FACULTY  and  37%  PhD  STUDENTS  

•  49%  (303)  paper  acceptances;  74%  (45)  symposium  acceptances  

•  Concnuing  to  improve  paper  matching  process  

0  

50  

100  

150  

200  

250  

300  

350  

400  

Not  AoM   1  to  5   5  to  10   10+  

Not  OMT  

OMT  Member  

Reviewers  and  OMT  Membership  

Please tell your doctoral students to sign up for OMT!

Submissions  and  Reviewers  by  Concnent  (last  year  in  parens)  

Region Number  of  Papers  

Submi:ed

%  Papers  (last  year)

%  Symposia  

%  Reviewers  (last  year)

North  America 243  (253)  39  (39)% 72%   49  (44)%

Europe 243  (266) 39  (43)% 21%   34  (36)%

Asia* 99  (~91)  16  (~15)% 3%   12  (~11)%

Oceana 21 (?) 3 (?)% 3%   3 (?)

South  America 7  (7)  1  (1)% 0%   .02  (2)%

Africa** 0% (?) 0 (?)% 0%     .004 (?)% * China, So. Korea, Israel, Turkey etc. ** Botswana, Egypt, Nigeria, South Africa, Uganda

Popular  Submission  Keywords/Trends  Keyword  -­‐  theories     Papers  (Last  Yr)   Reviewers  Ins+tu+onal  Theory   160  (160)   499  (599)  ~  50%  Networks  &  Embeddedness   79  (93)   251  (301)  Learning,  Adapta+on  &  Rou+nes   70  (68)   200  (?)  Behavioral  Theory/Decision  Making   39  (61)   225  (?)  

Keyword  -­‐  topics    Corporate  Governance  &  Strategy   60  (63)   148  (?)  Ins+tu+onal  Logics  &  Complexity   59  (56  )    285  (321)  Iden+ty  &  Categoriza+on   55  (55)   223  (?)    Organiza+onal  Form   44  (?  )   179  (?)  Innova+on  and  Crea+vity   41  (50)   231  (?)  Entrepreneurship   41  (?  )   186  (?)  Performance  &  Effec+veness   37  (39)   200  Keyword-­‐level-­‐  Organiza+on   99  (?)   623  (?)  

**Note  that  submigers  chose  3  keywords  and  that  keywords  overlap  

Most  Popular  Theories  by  Concnent  (last  year  in  parens)  

Region   Insctuconal  Theory  

Networks  &  Embedded-­‐

ness  

Learning,  Adaptacon,  Roucnes  

Behavioral  Theory  &  Dec.  

Making  

Europe 49  (40)  27  (50) 30 (?) 10  (44)

North  America 63  (47) 23  (36) 27 (?)    14  (32)

Asia   24  (~11) 12  (~14) 16 (?)  5  (~21)

Oceana 7 (?) 1 (?) 2 (?) 1 (?)

South  America 1  (1) 1  (0) 0 (?)  0  (4)

Africa 0 0 0 0

Most  Popular  Topics  by  Concnent  (last  year  in  parens)  

Region   Governance  &  Strategy  

Insctuconal  Logics  /

Complexity  

Idencty  &  Categorizacon  

Organizaconal  Forms  

Europe 14  (28) 27  (52) 21  (30) 17 (?)

North  America  23  (38) 15  (43)  19  (59) 14 (?)

Asia    19  (29)  8  (4) 7  (11) 6 (?)

Oceana 2 (?) 1 (?) 1 (?) 0 (?)

South  America 1  (0) 2  (2) 0  (?) 2 (?)

Africa 0 0 0 0

AWARDS  

Louis  R.  Pondy  Award    for  Best  Paper  Based  on  a  Dissertacon  

 "The  Illusions  of  Power"  

 Murad  Mithani  -­‐  Stevens  Ins+tute  of  

Technology    

OMT  Division  Best  Paper  Award  

"Social  Distancing  from  Journalists  Who  Engage  in  Nega+ve  Coverage  of  Firm  

Leadership  "      

James  Westphal  -­‐  University  of  Michigan  Guy  Shani  -­‐  University  of  Michigan  

 

   

OMT  Division  Best  Internaconal  Paper    

"The  Diffusion  of  Contested  Prac+ces  across  Environments:  Social  Movements'  

Boundary-­‐Bridging  Role"    

Daniel  Waeger  –  HEC,  Lausanne    Sébas+en  Mena  -­‐  University  of  Alberta  

 

OMT  Division  Best  Symposium  Award  

"Organiza+onally  Diverse  Capitalism:  Exploring  Alterna+ves  to  20th  Century  

Corpora+ons"    

Suntae  Kim  -­‐  University  of  Michigan    

OMT  Division  Best  Empirical  Paper  on  Social  &  Environmental  Praccces*  

"Be  Fair  or  Care?  Fairtrade  and  the  Standardiza+on  of  Ethical  Prac+ces"  

 Juliane  Reinecke  -­‐  University  of  Warwick  Shahzad  Ansari  -­‐  University  of  Cambridge    

 1992-­‐2010  

* Sponsored by http://wA special thanks to BCCC Executive Director Katherine V. Smith!

ABCD  Reviewer  Awards  (Above  and  Beyond  the  Call  of  Duty)  

Reviewer   Affiliacon   Reviewer   Affiliacon  

Marcos Barros, HEC Montreal Suntae Kim, U. of Michigan

Hans Berends, VU U. Amsterdam Sheen S. Levine, Columbia U.

Amelie Boutinot, Inst.Supérieur de Gestion Pablo Martin de Holan, EM Lyon

Andrea Casey, George Washington U. Thomas P. Moliterno, U. of Mass., Amherst

Gino Cattani, New York U. Vanessa Pouthier, Northwestern U.

David Chandler, U. of Colorado, Denver Ryan Raffaelli, Harvard Bus. School

Elena Dalpiaz, Imperial Coll. London Wendy K. Smith, U. of Delaware

Maria B Gondo, U. of New Mexico Norbert Steigenberger, U. of Cologne Jennifer Howard-Grenville, U. of Oregon Maxim Sytch, U. of Michigan

Julien Jourdan, Bocconi U. Madeline Toubiana, Schulich School of Bus.

Arvind Karunakaran, M.I.T Paul Tracey, U. of Cambridge

Patricia Klarner, U. of Munich Maciej Workiewicz, INSEAD

Massimo Maoret, IESE Anastasiya Zavyalova, Rice U.

Other  People  Who  Went  Far  Above  and  Beyond…  

•  Advise  &  guidance:  Mike  Lounsbury  and  Chriscne  Beckman  who  helped  me  tremendously!  

•  Technical  support:  Massimo  Maoret    •  Pulng  the  program  together:    

Lily  Crosina,  Doug  Lepisto,  Massimo  Maoret,  Shelley  McArdle,  Ryan  Raffaelli,  Erika  Steckler,  Lee  Watkiss  

   

•  Everyone  that  signed  up  to  review  and  came  through  on  their  commitment!!!  

OMT Distinguished Educator

2013 Winner

W. Richard Scott

Name   University   Name   University  

Diane Burton Cornell University Brayden King Northwestern University

Kim Elsbach University of California - Davis David Ravasi Cass Business School

Martha Feldman University of California - Irvine Claus Rerup Western University

Teppo Felin University of Oxford Majken Schultz Copenhagen Business School

Royston Greenwood University of Alberta Maureen Scully University of Massachusetts, Boston

Heinrich Greve INSEAD Maxim Sytch University of Michigan

Paul Hirsch Northwestern University Mike Tushman Harvard Business School

Jennifer Howard-Grenville University of Oregon Hugh Wilmott Cardiff University

Kate Kellogg MIT

2012-13 OMT Best Published Paper Committee Members

Co-Chair: Jane Dutton – University of Michigan Co-Chair: Mary Ann Glynn – Boston College

OMT  Best  Published    Paper  Award    •  Ethan  S.  Bernstein  

– Harvard  University  

The  Transparency  Paradox:  A  Role  for  Privacy  in  Organiza+onal  Learning  and  Opera+onal  Control.  Administra>ve  Science  Quarterly,  

57:181-­‐216.  

Farewell  and  Thanks                    

Eva Boxenbaum Rodney Lacey

Klaus Weber

Special  Thanks  to  Our  Outgoing  Chair  

             Mag  Kraatz  

•  Brought  us  through  a  technology  transi+on  in  his  program  chair  year  

•  Improvements  to  Disserta+on  Proposal  workshop  

Ar+fact  and  Social  Hour  

Revealed  by  …    Nelson  Phillips      Social  Hour      in  Grand  Harbor  North  7:30  –  9:00