2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment...

27
A-1 Western Area Power Administration Sierra Nevada Region 2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information or questions regarding this Transmission Assessment Report, please contact Larry Tobias via (916) 353-4766 or email at [email protected]

Transcript of 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment...

Page 1: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-1

Western Area Power Administration Sierra Nevada Region

2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment

Report

Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002

November 1, 2010

For information or questions regarding this Transmission Assessment Report, please contact Larry Tobias via (916) 353-4766 or email at [email protected]

Page 2: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-2

Attachment 4: Category B (NERC Planning Standard TPL-002): Single Element Outage, (N-1) Includes Power Flow, Post-Transient and Dynamic Stability Plots)

Page 3: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-3

Figure 4-1 2011 Summer Peak Load Normal System

Page 4: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-4

Figure 4-2 2011 Summer Peak Load – Pre-SVS Project

Page 5: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-5

Figure 4-3 2011 Summer Peak Load – Pre-SVS Project O’Banion-Elverta 230 kV Line Outage – Drop Sutter Power Plant

Page 6: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-6

Figure 4-4 2011 Summer Peak Load – Post-SVS Project O’Banion-Elverta 230 kV Line Outage

Page 7: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-7

Figure 4-5 2011 Summer Peak Load

Shasta-Cottonwood 230 kV Line Outage

Page 8: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-8

Figure 4-6 2011 Summer Peak Load Shasta Split 230 kV Bus

Page 9: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-9

Figure 4-7 2011 Summer Peak Load Shasta-Flanagan 230 kV Line Outage

Page 10: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-10

Figure 4-8 2011 Summer Peak Load Shasta-Flanagan 230 kV Line Outage, Shasta-Cottonwood 230 kV Lines Uprated

Wave Trap and line jumpers into Cottonwood Substation Replaced

Page 11: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-11

Figure 4-9 2011 Summer Peak Load Captain Jack-Olinda 500 kV Line Outage

Page 12: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-12

Figure 4-10 2011 Summer Peak Load Captain Jack-Olinda 500 kV Line Outage

60% Northern California Hydro Generation

Page 13: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-13

Figure 4-11 2011 Summer Peak Load

Page 14: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-14

Figure 4-12 2015 Summer Peak Load

Page 15: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-15

Figure 4-13 2020 Summer Peak Load

Page 16: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-16

Figure 4-14 2015 Summer Peak Load

NERC TPL-002 Category B1 Sutter Power Plant Outage

Page 17: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-17

Figure 4-15 2015 Summer Peak Load NERC TPL-002 Category B2

O’Banion-Elverta 230 kV Line Outage

Page 18: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-18

Figure 4-16 2015 Summer Peak Load NERC TPL-002 Category B3

Tracy 500/230 kV Transformer bank Outage

Page 19: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-19

Figure 4-17 2015 Summer Peak Load NERC TPL-002 Category B1 Sutter Power Plant Outage

Page 20: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-20

Figure 4-18 2015 Summer Peak Load NERC TPL-002 Category B2

O’Banion-Elverta 230 kV Line Outage

Page 21: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-21

Figure 4-19 2015 Summer Peak Load NERC TPL-002 Category B3

Tracy 500/230 kV Transformer Bank Outage

Page 22: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-22

Figure 4-20 2020 Summer Peak Load

NERC TPL-002 Category B2 Sutter Power Plant Outage

An Outage of the Sutter Combined-Cycle Power Plant could not be taken for the year 2020 under summer peak load conditions due to apparent insufficient reactive voltage support within the Sacramento Area. This deficiency is associated with load growth in the Sacramento Area as the

scheduled power transfer over WASN’s transmission system has not increased from 2015 to 2020. This will be followed up with the utility companies (load serving entities) in this area (Sacramento Municipal Utility District and the City of Roseville) to more accurately identify the

deficiency and best location to add additional reactive voltage support and if it should be static and/or dynamic type reactive voltage support. This outage is identified with NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 and a category B1 outage.

Page 23: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-23

Figure 4-21 2020 Summer Peak Load NERC TPL-002 Category B2

O’Banion-Elverta 230 kV Line Outage

Page 24: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-24

Figure 4-22 2020 Summer Peak Load NERC TPL-002 Category B3

Tracy 500/230 kV Transformer bank Outage

Page 25: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-25

Figure 4-23 2020 Summer Peak Load NERC TPL-002 Category B1 Sutter Power Plant Outage

Page 26: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-26

Figure 4-24 2020 Summer Peak Load NERC TPL-002 Category B2

O’Banion-Elverta 230 kV Line Outage

Page 27: 2010 WAPA SNR Study Report Attachment4-rev...2010 Annual Ten-Year Transmission Plan Assessment Report Report Attachment 4 NERC Planning Standard TPL-002 November 1, 2010 For information

A-27

Figure 4-25 2020 Summer Peak Load NERC TPL-002 Category B3

Tracy 500/230 kV Transformer Bank Outage