2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
-
Upload
chalcedon-presbyterian-church -
Category
Documents
-
view
217 -
download
0
Transcript of 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
1/25
byJoe Morecraft, III
John Calvin on theWorship of god
Nothing was more important toJohn Calvin than the pure worshipof God in spirit and in truth. SeveralBiblical texts played a role in Calvins
development of his doctrine of the wor-ship of God.
You shall have no other gods
before Me.- Exodus 20:3
Calvin understood that concern of theFirst Commandment was worship. Init God,
enjoins that He alone should
be worshipped, and requires a
worship free from all supersti-
tions.God, therefore calls for
the affections of the hear that
He alone may be spiritually
worshipped.thence we arrive
at the distinction between true
religion and false superstitions;
for since God has prescribed tous how He would be worshipped
by us, whenever we turn away
in the smallest degree from this
rule, we make to ourselves oth-
er gods, and degrade Him from
His right place.CALVINS
Calvin at His Studies
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
2/25
5Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 2010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
COMMENTARIES, Vol. II, p.418, 419
Now Nadab and Abihu, the
sons of Aaron, took their re-
spective firepans, and afterputting fire in them, placed
incense on it and offered
strange fire before the LORD,
which He had not com-
manded them. And fire came
out from the presence of the
LORD and consumed them,
and they died before theLORD. Ten Moses said to
Aaron, It is what the LORD
spoke, saying, By those who
come near Me I will be treat-
ed as holy, and before all the
people I will be honored. So
Aaron, therefore, kept silent.-
Leviticus 10:1-3
is text greatly impressed Calvin. Hespeaks of it as,
a memorable circumstancefrom whence it appears howgreatly God abominates all thesins whereby the purity of reli-
gion is corrupted.Now, Godhad forbidden any other fire to
be used in the ordinances, inorder to exclude all extrane-ous rites, and to show His de-testation of whatever might bederived from elsewhere. Let uslearn, therefore, so to attend toGods command as not to cor-rupt His worship by any strangeinventions. But if He so severely
avenged this error, how hor-rible a punishment awaits the
Papists, who are not ashamedobstinately to defend so many
gross corruptions.- CALVINS
COMMENTARIES, Vol. III, p.
431-432
Terefore, come out from
their midst and be separate,
says the Lord. And do nottouch what is unclean; and I
will welcome you, and I will
be a Father to you, and you
shall be sons and daughters of
Me, says the Lord Almighty.-
II Corinthians 6:17-18
In his comments on this verse, Calvinmakes the point that believers, like
OT priests, are set apart for the spiri-
tual worship of God, as a royal priest-
hood, in the totality of our being, body
and soul. Hence, as we are redeemed
by the grace of God, it is befitting that
we keep ourselves undefiled in respect
of all uncleanness, that we may not pol-
lute the sanctuary of God.- CALVINS
COMMENTARIES, Vol. XX, p. 262
Bibliography
(1). W. Robert Godfrey, Calvin and the Wor-
ship of God, Westminster SeminaryCalifornia faculty, ww w.wscal.edu/faculty/
wscwritings/07.04.php
(2). John Calvin, e Necessity of Reforming the
Church, TRACTS AND TREATIES, Vol. I,
(Grand Rapids, Michigan: Wm. B. Eerdmans
Publishing Co., 1958)
(3). John Calvin, COME OUT FROM AMONG
THEM: ANTI-NICODEMITE WRIT-
INGS, (Dallas, Texas: Protestant Heritage
Press, 2001); (4). Carlos M.N. Eire, WAR
AGAINST IDOLS: THE REFORMATION
OF WORSHIP FROM ERASMUS TO CAL-
VIN, (New York: Cambridge University
Press, 1990).
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
3/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 20106
John Calvin on the Worship of God
the relation ofcalvins conversion
and his struggle forthe purity of worship
Calvins war against the idolatry ofRome was the logical consequence ofhis conversion. After being devoutlyRoman Catholic, by a sudden act ofconversion, God subdued [his] heart toteachableness,and to Protestantism.
According to Calvin, his conversionwas a turning away from what stood be-tween him and Godhis adherence tothe superstition of popery. Like Farel,his conversion focused on the rejectionof Roman Catholic worship.
is is a thoroughly Biblical at-titude. As I essalonians 1:9 says:
For they themselves report about uswhat kind of reception we had withyou, and how you turned to God from
idols to serve [worship] a living andtrue God
the supremeimportance of the
worship of god forcalvin
Public worship was of supreme andcentral importance to Calvin. It wasfar more important to him than it is tomany professed Christians today.
If it be inquired, then, by what
things chiefly the Christian re-
ligion has a standing existence
amongst us, and maintain its
truth, it will be found that the
following two not only occupythe principal place, but com-
prehend under them all the
other parts, and consequently
the whole substance of Christi-
anity, viz., a knowledge, first, of
the mode in which God is duly
worshipped; and, secondly, of
the source from which salvationis to be obtained. When these
are kept out of view, though we
may glory in the name of Chris-
tians, our profession is empty
and vain. After these come the
sacraments and the govern-
ment of the church- John Cal-
vin TRACTS AND TREATIES:ON THE REFORMATION OF
THE CHURCH, Vol. 1, p. 126
In this quote, we see the top prior-
ity worship was to Calvin. He placed,
How to worship God above How to
be saved. His emphasis is that a knowl-
edge of how God wants to be worshipand the knowledge of how God saves
sinners not only occupy the principal
place in Christianity, but they comprise
the whole substance of Christianity.
Following these two priorities, Calvin
ranks a knowledge of the sacraments
and of the government of the church as
third and fourth.
the reason for thissupreme importance
A. THE NATURE OF WORSHIP AS
GODS MEETING PLACE
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
4/25
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
5/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 20108
John Calvin on the Worship of God
the definition ofworship
C. THE ELEMENTS OF TRUE
WORSHIP ACCORDING TOCALVIN
Let us now see what is meantby the due worship of God. Itschief foundation is to acknowl-edge Him to be, as He is, theonly source of all virtue, justice,
holiness, wisdom, truth, power,goodness, mercy, life and salva-tion; in accordance with this, toascribe and render to Him the
glory of all that is good, to seekall things in Him alone, andin every want have recourse to
Him alone. Hence arises prayer,
hence praise and thanksgiv-ingthese being attestations tothe glory which we attribute to
Him. is is that genuine sanc-tification of His name which He
requires of us above all things.To this is united adoration,
by which we manifest for Him
the reverence due to his great-ness and excellency, and to thisceremonies are subservient, ashelps or instruments, in orderthan, in the performance ofdivine worship, the body maybe exercised at the same timewith the soul. Next after thesecomes self-abasement, when,renouncing the world and the
flesh, we are transformed in therenewing of our mind, and liv-ing no longer to ourselves, sub-mit to be ruled and actuated by
Him. By this self-abasement weare trained to obedience and
devotedness to his will, so that
his fear reigns in our heart, and
regulates all the actions of our
lives. at in these things con-
sist the true and sincere wor-
ship which alone God approves,and in which alone He delights,
is both taught by the Holy Spirit
through the Scriptures, and is
also, antecedent in discussion,
the obvious dictate of piety. Nor
from the beginning was there
any other method of worship-
ping God, the only differencebeing, that this spiritual truth,
which with us is naked and
simple, was under the former
dispensation, wrapt up in fig-
ures.- Calvin, TRACTS AND
TREATIES: ON THE REFOR-
MATION OF THE CHURCH,
Vol. 1, p. 127
In this quote, we see what Calvin con-
sidered the four basic elements of true
worship. (1). Total dependence upon
God for all things spiritual, moral and
material; (2). Grateful rendering to God
the glory due Him, or the sanctification
of His name; (3). Adoration of God; and(4). Self-abasement.
For Calvin worship was not
a means to an end. Worship
was not a means to evangelize
or entertain. Worship was an
end in itself. Worship was not
to be arranged by pragmatic
considerations, but was rather
to be determined by theologi-
cal principles derived from the
Scriptures. e most basic
realities of the Christian life
were involved. In worship God
meets with his people to bless
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
6/25
9Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 2010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
them. What could be more im-portant? What should requiremore care and faithfulness?-
Robert Godfrey, Calvin andthe Worship of God
Calvins reform of worship includedthe reform of the environment of wor-ship. All religious symbols includingcrosses in St. Pierres church in Genevawere removed. e cross on top of thesteeple there was not removed, untilGod removed it by a lightning bolt. Itwas not replaced.
D. THE NATURE OF WORSHIP ASSPIRITUAL WORSHIP
In John 4:24, Jesus said: God is spirit,and those who worship Him must wor-
ship Him in spirit and truth. Because ofverses like this, Calvin believed that theonly correct for of worship approved byGod was spiritual worship, which hadtwo characteristics: (1). Worship devoidof trust in material props and humanlydevised ceremonies, and in Old Testa-ment ceremonies that were fulfilled inChrist; and (2). Worship that has beencommanded by God in the Bible.
Calvins interpretation of the Sec-ond Commandment involves ferventlypraying against our imagining that God
can be expressed in any figure. e Ro-man Catholic Church breaks this com-mandment by its idolatrous innovations;but it tries to evade the label of idolatryby calling their idolatrous sculptures,
paintings, frescoes and rituals, thebooks of the uneducated. Calvins re-sponse to this ploy was as follows:
I still cannot see what benefit
such images can provide for the
unlearnedexcept to make
them into anthropomorphites,
[i.e., people who humanizeGod].Indeed, brothels show
harlots clad more virtuously
and modestly than the church-
es shows those objects which
they wish to be seen as images
of virgins.But then we shall
also answer that this is not the
method of teaching the peopleof God whom the Lord will to be
instructed with a far different
doctrine than this trash. He has
set forth the preaching of His
word as a common doctrine for
all.From this one word they
could have learned more than
from a thousand crosses of ei-
ther wood or stone.erefore,
He will vindicate His majesty
and glory against any who may
transfer it to graven images or
other things. And not once, but
against fathers, the children
and the grandchildren.- 1536
INSTITUTES OF THE CHRIS-
TIAN RELIGION, p. 21
the regulativeprinciple of worship
is is another vitally important issuefor Calvin because ere is nothing
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
7/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 201010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
more perilous to our salvation than apreposterous and perverse worship of
God.- CALVINS REPLY TO CARDI-
NAL SADOLETO
e rule which distinguishesbetween pure and vitiated
worship is of universal applica-
tion, in order that we may not
adopt any devise which seems
fit to ourselves, but look to the
injunctions of Him who alone
is entitled to prescribe. ere-
fore, if we would have Him toapprove our worship, this rule,
which he everywhere enforces
with the upmost strictness,
must be carefully observed.
For there is a twofold reason
why the Lord, in condemn-
ing and prohibiting all ficti-
tious worship, requires us togive obedience only to his own
voice. First, it tends greatly to
establish His authority that we
do not follow our own pleasure,
but depend entirely on his sov-
ereignty; and, secondly, such is
our folly, that when we are left
at liberty, all we are able to dois to go astray. And then when
once we have turned aside from
the right path, there is no end
to our wanderings, until we get
buried under a multitude of
superstitions. Justly, therefore,
does the Lord, in order to as-
sert his full right of dominion,
strictly enjoin what he wishes
us to do, and at once reject all
human devices which are at
variance with his command.
Justly, too, does he, in express
terms, define our limits, that
we may not, by fabricating per-
verse modes of worship, provokeHis anger against us.TRACTSAND TREATIES, Vol. 1, p. 128
e regulative principle of worship by
which we determine what to includeand exclude in the worship of God isthe Biblical injunctions of Him whoalone is entitled to prescribe how Heis to be worshipped. God enforces thisrule with upmost strictness. And, Godgives us two reasons why He requiresus to give obedience to His own voice:
(1). It firmly establishes the true thatGod is sovereign in our consciences,causing us to depend entirely on thatsovereignty; and (2). When left to ourown imaginations and experience, allwe are able to do is to go astray. ere-fore the Lord asserts His dominion bystrictly commanding us, not only to doonly what He commands in worship butalso to reject all rites and rituals of wor-ship that originated in the brain of man.
erefore, we can summarize Cal-vins regulative principle of worship inthree simple statements: (1). WhateverGod commands in His worship is re-
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
8/25
11Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 2010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
quired of us. (2). Whatever God forbidsin His worship is prohibited for us. And,(3). If God has not commanded a rite orritual for worship, it is forbidden be-cause of the truth spelled out in Deuter-
onomy 12:32Whatever I commandyou, you shall be careful to do; you
shall not add to nor take away from it.
So, let us hold to this rule, thatall human inventions whichare set up to corrupt the simple
purity of the word of God, and
to undo the worship which hedemands and approves, are
true sacrileges, in which theChristian man cannot par-ticipate without blasphemingGod and trampling his honorunder foot.- Calvin, COMEOUT FROM AMONG THEM,
p. 141, [Underlining mine.]
Calvin: Only when we followwhat God has commanded usdo we truly worship Him, and
render obedience to His Word.-CALVINS COMMENTARIES,THE EPISTLE OF PAUL THE
APOSTLE TO THE ROMANS
AND TO THESSALONIANS,ed. D.W. Torrance et all, (Grand
Rapids, MI, Wm. B. EerdmansPub. Co), pl 118
It is obvious that Calvins view of theregulative principle of worship influ-enced the authors of the WestminsterConfession of Faith1, 21.1
e acceptable way of worship-ping the true God is institutedby Himself, and so limited by
1. John Knox was more consistent with applying
Calvins regulative principle of worship than
was Calvin.
His own revealed will, that He
may not be worshipped ac-
cording to the imaginations
and devices of men, or the sug-
gestions of Satan, under any
visible representation, or anyother way not prescribed in the
Holy Scripture.
Godfrey informs us correctly that Cal-
vin knew the human tendency to think
that sincerity and fervor can substitute
for truth and faithfulness, but he reject-
ed any such notion absolutely. P. 2-10
every one of us is, even from
his mothers womb, a master
craftsman of idols.- Carlos
M.N. Eire, WAR AGAINST
THE IDOLS: THE REFORMA-
TION OF WORSHIP FROM
ERASMUS TO CALVIN, Cam-bridge, Cambridge Univer-
sity Press, 1986, p. 208, citing
Calvins COMMENTARY ON
THE ACTS OF THE APOS-
TLES, CR, 48.562
Calvins cautious concern about wor-
ship reflected his belief that even Chris-tians often want to please themselves in
worship rather than please God, God-
frey, 2-10. Calvin wrote:
Nor can it be doubted but that
under the pretense of holy zeal,
superstitious men give way to
the indulgence of the flesh; and
Satan baits his fictious modes
of worship with such attrac-
tions, that they are willingly
and eagerly caught hold of and
obstinately retained. COM-
MENTARIES ON THE FOUR
LAST BOOKS OF MOSES,
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
9/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 201012
John Calvin on the Worship of God
Grand Rapids, Baker Book
Hous, 1983, Vol. 3, p. 346.
And undoubtedly this is the
origin of all superstitions, that
men are delighted with theirown inventions and choose to
be wise in their own eyes rather
than restrain their senses in
obedience to God.- COMMEN-
TARY ON THE BOOK OF THE
PROPHET ISAIAH, Baker Book
House, 1979, Vol. 4, p. 381.
e more it (worship) delights
human nature, the more it is to
be suspected by believers.- Cal-
vin, INSTITUTES, IV, x, 11.
Nothing is more abominable in
the sight of God than pretended
worship, which proceeds from
human contrivance.- COMM.ON ISAIAH, vol. 4, p. 385
the difficulty withpersuading the world
of the regulativeprinciple
A. THE HUMAN TENDENCY TO
WARD IDOLATRY
I know how difficult it is to per-
suade the world that God dis-approves of all modes of wor-
ship and expressly sanctioned
by His Word. e opposite per-
suasion which cleaves to them,
being seated, as it were, in their
very bones and marrow, is, that
whatever they do has in itself a
sufficient sanction, provided it
exhibits some kind of zeal for
the honor of God. But since Godnot only regards as fruitless, butalso plainly abominates, what-ever we undertake from zealto His worship, if at variance
with His command, what dowe gain by a contrary course?e words of God are clear anddistinct, Obedience is bet-ter than sacrifice. In vain dothey worship me, teaching fordoctrine the commandments ofmen, I Sam. 15:22; Mat. 15:9.
Every addition to His word, es-pecially in this matter, is a lie.Mere will worship is vanity.is is the decision, and whenonce the judge has decided, it isno longer time to debate. Cal-vin, TRACTS AND TREATIES:Vol. 1, p. 129
is quote by Calvin condemns allRoman Catholic worship and much ofProtestant worship in the 21stCentury.
B. THE ORIGIN OF IDOLATRY
Calvin traces the origin of idolatry notto the inferiority of the spiritual to thematerial, but to the fallen human mind.
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
10/25
13Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 2010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
For this is the origin of idolatry,
that when the genuine simplic-
ity of Gods worship is known,
people begin to be dissatisfied
with it, and curiously to inquire
whether there is anything wor-
thy of belief in the figments of
men; for mens minds are soon
attracted by the snares of nov-
elty so as to pollute, with vari-
ous kinds of leaven, what has
been delivered in Gods word.-
quoted by Eire, p. 209
C. THE DANGER OF THE BEGIN
NINGS OF IDOLATRY
Calvin not only believed that idolatry
progressed gradually, but that once the
process of idolatry has begun there can
be no turning back.- Eire, p. 225. Cal-vin gives us his reason for this:
Experience teaches us how
fertile is the field of falsehood
in the human mind, and that
the smallest grains, when
sown there, will grow to yield
an immense harvest.- quoted
by Eire, p. 225
e amazing speed with which
idolatry propagates is due to
the fertility of the soil in which
its seed is planted. It is also due
to the punishment inflicted by
God on man. e more men
persist in worshipping God intheir own way, the more He
abandons them to their own
desires and the greater the
number of false ceremonies be-
comes.Idolatry, then, is also
its own punishment.
Taking these factors into con-sideration, Calvin warns thatit is necessary to keep the seed
from ever coming into contactwith the soil; in other words,
that every effort must be madeto ensure that worship remainsspiritual.
e image of idolatry as fertileis accompanied by that of idol-atry as highly inflammable.Calvin cautions that when men
begin to accept objects such asimages into worship, they areplaying with fire.- Eire, p. 225
So innate in us is superstition,that the least occasion willinfect us with contagion. Drywood will not so easily burnwhen coals are put under it,
as idolatry will seize and oc-cupy the minds of men, whenthe opportunity presents itselfto them. And so does not seethat images are sparks? What!Sparks do I say? Nay, rather,torches, which are sufficient
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
11/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 201014
John Calvin on the Worship of God
to set the whole world on fire.-Calvin quoted by Eire, p. 225
Calvins argument is that thereis no such thing as an innocent
religious image [or innovationin worship not commanded byGod]. eir acceptance aloneis an act of idolatry, so that as
soon as the images appear, reli-gion is corrupted and adulter-ated.By divine law, therefore,all believers are prohibited from
taking the first step toward idol-atry.- Eire, p. 226
As the apostle concluded his epistle ofI John: Little children, guard your-selves from idols.
the six basic principles
of worship flowingfrom calvinstheology
A. THE CENTRALITY OF THE
WORD OF GOD.
e word of God directs worship and
is largely the content of worship. eword is read, preached, sung, prayed,confessed and seen in communion. eworshiper meets God through the word.
Criticism of Calvins approachto worship often focuses on his
stress upon the Bible. One suchcriticism is that Calvin is bib-licistic in his approach to wor-
ship. Such a criticism declaresthat there is no Book of Leviti-cus in the NT and so the churchhas great freedom in worshipas it sees best. Calvins responsewould be that the absence of
a Levitical book in the NT re-
flects more the simplicity of the
churchs worship in Christ than
creative freedom. For Calvin,
the teaching of the NT is full
and complete as a guide and
warrant for the simple wor-
ship of the chidren of God in
the Spirit. No more freedom is
given in the NT to invent forms
of worship than was given in
the Old. Godfrey, 3-10
Calvin recognized that circumstancessurrounding the worship of God are not
specified in the Bible, viz. the time of
worship on Sunday, the location of the
worship service, and the language used
in worship. In such issues the church
has some discretionary authority, as the
Westminster Confession of Faith in-
forms us, 1.6. e church has no discre-
tionary authority inthe worship of God;
but it does have some discretionary
authority regarding the circumstances
surrounding (circa) the worship service.
Another criticism is that Calvins
stress on the word makes worship be-
come too intellectual or didactic be-cause of an excessive concentration on
the Bible. Calvins defenders would re-
spond that the Bible itself points to the
importance of preaching and teaching,
although Calvin would not have the
service overly or exclusively intellectual.
Worship includes the whole person.
B. THE SIMPLICITY OF WORSHIP.
We are not dependent on the childish
props of the old covenant. ey were
temporary shadows that have passed
away not that Christ, the substance,
as come, Colossians 2:17. Calvin wrote:
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
12/25
15Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 2010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
What shall I say of ceremonies
which, with Christ half buried,
cause us to return to Jewish
symbols? Our Lord Christ,
says Augustine, has bound the
fellowship of the new peopletogether with sacrments, very
few in number, very excellent in
meaning, very easy to observe.
How far from this simplicity
is the multitude and variety
of rites, with which we see the
church entangled today, cnnot
be fully told.-INST. IV,x, 14
Simplicity did not mean the
absence of liturgical structure.
Calvins service with its move-
ment from confession to praise
to preaching to intercessions
to communion shows that.
Simplicity meant the removalof physical symbolism and
ceremonies that were not insti-
tuted in the Bible. Simplicity
is closely linked to spirituality.
In the simplicity of the Spirits
power, Christ is present among
his people in the preaching and
sacrament. Nothing may beadded to that divine arrange-
ment.- Godfrey, 4-10
e following was the normal order of
worship used by Calvin in Geneva, and
by:
Call to worship: Psalm 124:8
Confession of sins
Prayer for Pardon
Singing a Psalm
Prayer for Illumination
Scripture reading
Sermon
Collection of Offerings
Prayers of Intercession and a long
paraphrase of the Lords Prayer
Singing of the Apostles Creed (whileLords Supper is prepared)
Words of Institution
Instruction and Exhortation
Communion (while a Psalm is sung
or Scripture read)
Prayer of anksgiving
Benediction: Numbers 6:24,25
Calvins influence once again can beseen on the Westminster Confession of
Faith. In 7.5, the Westminster fathersdescribe the complex and ornate liturgyof Temple worship with all its messianictypes and figures. And, in 7:6, they de-scribe the worship of the church of theNew Covenant:
Martin Bucer
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
13/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 201016
John Calvin on the Worship of GodWhere Has All the Worship Gone?
Under the gospel, when Christ,
the substance, was exhibited,
the ordinances in which this
covenant is dispensed are the
preaching of the Word, and
the administration of the sac-raments of baptism and the
Lords Supper, which, though
fewer in number, and adminis-
tered with more simplicity, and
less outward glory; yet, in them,
it is held forth in more fullness,
evidence and spiritual efficacy,
to all nations, both Jews andGentiles, and is called the New
Testament. ere are not there-
fore two covenants of grace,
differing in substance, but one
and the same, under various
dispensations.
In other words, in this one covenantof grace that is the unifying structure
and theme of both testaments, there are
two modes of administrating the bless-
ings of that covenant. e Old Testa-
ment dispensation was highly complex
and ornate in its messianic symbols
expressed in rites and rituals. e New
Testament dispensation of those sameblessings is simpler than the Old Testa-
ment, but far more spiritually effective
in transmitting them. e Covenant
of God is held forth in more fullness,
evidence and spiritual efficacy. Hence,
simplicity of worship has reference to
the spirituality of worship.
C. THE SPIRITUAL ASCENT OF
WORSHIP
A mystical element pervades Calvins
understanding of the worship of God.
According to him, when believers are
worshipping God, they ascend into
heaven. Worship draws the Christianinto heaven in communion with the
ascended Christ. is ascent in wor-
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
14/25
17Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 2010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
ship is mysterious even for Calvin but
a foundational current in his thought.
is idea of ascent is part of the pattern
of Christian experience flowing from
Christs saving work. Christ descended
in his incarnation to lift us to heaven.-Godfrey, 4-10. Calvins own words are:
Now that the Mosaic ceremo-
nies are abolished we worship
at the footstool of God, when
we yield a reverential submis-
sion to his word, and rise from
the sacraments to a true spiri-tual service of him. Knowing
that God has not descended
from heaven directly or in his
absolute character, but that
his feet are withdrawn from
us, being placed on a footstool,
we should be careful to rise
to him by the intermediatesteps. Christ is he not only on
whom the feet of God rest, but
in whom the whole fullness of
Gods essence and glory re-
sides, and in him therefore, we
should seek the Father. With
this view he descended, that
we might rise heavenward.-COMMENTARY ON THE
PSALMS, Vol. 5, p. 150
Robert Godfreys summary of Calvin
is this: Christ continues to help us
heavenward as his Spirit descends to
empower the Word and sacraments of
the church.- Godfrey, 4-10
It is thus that the Holy Spirit
condescends for our profit, and
in accommodation to our in-
firmity, raising our thought to
heavenly and divine things by
these worldly elements.- John
Calvin, COMMENTARY ONTHE PSALMS, Vol. 5, p. 150
Calvin spoke of the ordinances of wor-ship as ladders God has provided for
believers to help in this ascent to heav-en in worship.
He does not enjoin us to as-cend forthwith into heaven,but, consulting our weaknesshe descends to usis maywell suffice to put to shame thearrogance of those who withoutconcern can bear to be deprivedof those means, or rather, who
proudly despise them, as if itwere in their power to ascend toheaven in a moments flightWemust not however imagine thatthe prophet suffered himself torest in earthly elements, but
only that he made use of themas a ladder, by which he mightascend to God, finding that hehad not wings with which to
fly.- COMMENTARY ON THEPSALMS, Vol. 2, p. 129f
D. THE REVERENCE OF WORSHIP
Here indeed is pure and realreligion: faith so joined withan earnest fear of God thatthis fear also embraces will-ing reverence, and carries withit such legitimate worship asis prescribed in the law. And
we ought to note this fact evenmore diligently: all men havea vague general veneration ofGod, but very few really rever-ence him; and wherever thereis great ostentation in ceremo-
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
15/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 201018
John Calvin on the Worship of GodWhere Has All the Worship Gone?
nies, sincerity of heart is rareindeed.- INSTITUTES, I, ii, 2
Today people would criticize Calvinsconcern for reverence in worship. ey
say that this encourages coldness ofworship, with little emotion and little
joy. Calvin, of course, was not opposedto emotion, believing that the full rangeof human emotions would be expressedin worship, just as they are expressedin the Psalms. However this expressionof emotion must be moderate and self-
controlled. As Calvin himself wrote:
For the principle which theStoics assume, that all the pas-
sions are perturbations and like
diseases, is false, and has itsorigin in ignorance; for either to
grieve, or to fear, or to rejoice,or to hope, is by no means re-
pugnant to reason, nor does itinterfere with tranquility andmoderation of mind; it is onlyexcess or intemperance whichcorrupts what would else be
pure. And surely grief, anger,desire, hope, fear are affectionsof our unfallen nature, im-
planted in us by God, and suchas we may not find fault with,without insulting God himself.-
INSTITUTES, III, xvii, 6
Godfrey also explains that part of thereverence of Reformed worship is foundin the role of the minister. He speaksfor God to the people and for the peopleto God. Some criticize this practice aslimiting the participation of the peoplein worship. Calvins response would betwofold. First, such a criticism missesthe importance of the ministry inChrists church: For neither the lightand heat of the sun, nor food and drink,
are so necessary to nourish and sustainthe present life as the apostolic and pas-toral office is necessary to preserve thechurch on earth. (INSTITUTES, IV, iii,2) e ministers as they preach faith-
fully speak for God: he (God) provesour obedience by a very good test whenwe hear his ministers speaking just as ifhe himself spoke. (INSTITUTES IV, I,5) Second, Calvin would argue that thecongregation does participate activelyin worship. ey must listen actively infaith to the preaching of the word. ey
must join in the sung praise of God.ey must pray with the minister liftingup their hearts and minds to God. Suchactivities are the reverent participationto which God calls his people.- 5-10
E. THE PLACE OF MUSIC INWORSHIP
Congregational singing play only aminiscule role in medieval worship.e Reformation restored congrega-tional singing to its rightful place, sothat it has been said that Europe waspsalm-sung into Reformation.
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
16/25
19Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 2010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
Calvin gave music an importantplace in worship. He even wrote mu-sic, e.g., he probably composed, I greetee whom my sure Redeemer art. His
view of music grows out of his theology.
we find by experience that ithas a sacred and almost incred-ible power to move hearts in oneway or another. erefore weought to be even more diligent inregulating it in such a way thatit shall be useful to us and in no
way pernicious. Preface tothe GENEVAN PSALTER, p. 3(See Godfrey, p. 6-10
And in truth we know by ex-perience that singing has greatforce and vigor to move andinflame the hearts of men toinvoke and praise God with
a more vehement and ardentzeal. Care must always betaken that the song be neitherlight nor frivolous; but that ithave weight and majesty (asSt. Augustine says), and also,there is a great difference be-tween music which one makes
to entertain men at table andin their houses, and the Psalmswhich are sung in the Churchin the presence of God and hisangels.- Preface to the GENE-VAN PSALTER, p. 3
Although Calvin appreciated music inworship, he did not allow for musicalinstruments in public worship.2
2. Calvin simplified congregational worship in
comparison with the complex liturgies of the
Roman Catholic Church. He also eliminated
choirs. Congregational music was a capella
and psalms were sung in unison.
But when they [believers] fre-quent their sacred assemblies,musical instruments in cel-ebrating the praises of Godwould be no more suitable than
the burning of incense, the light-ing up of lamps, and the resto-
ration of the other shadows ofthe law. e Papists therefore,have foolishly borrowed this,as well as many other things
from the Jewsbut we shouldalways take care that no cor-
ruption creep in which mightboth defile the pure worship ofGod and involve men in super-
stition.- COMMENTARY ONTHE PSALMS, Vol. 1, p. 539
Calvin thought that the Psalms werethe best songs to be sung in publicworship, although he was not an ex-clusive psalmist, as his singing of theApostles Creed in his Geneva order ofworship shows.
I have been accustomed to call
this book [Psalms], I think notinappropriately, An Anatomyof the Parts of the Soul; for
there is not an emotion ofwhich any one can be consciousthat is not here represented asin a mirrorin short, there isno other book in which we are
more perfectly taught the rightmanner of praising God, or inwhich we are more powerfully
stirred up to the performance ofthis religious exercise.- COM-
MENTARY ON THE PSALMS,Vol. 1, p. xxxvi-xxxix
At this point, we would ask Calvin: Howand in what sense was orchestral musicin the Temple typological? e church
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
17/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 201020
John Calvin on the Worship of God
of the New Testament continued to use
musical instruments in the worship of
God as the book of Revelation shows.3
Godfrey also points out that Cal-
vins concern for proper worship ex-
tended also to the tunes to be used for
the Psalms. He carefully supervised the
preparation of the Genevan Psalter over
the years to insure the composition of
appropriate music and in the provi-
dence of God was blessed with compos-
ers of extraordinary talent like Louis
Bourgeois. Calvin expressed his basic
position on tunes in these words:
Touching the melody, it has
seemed best that it be moder-
ated in the manner we have
adopted to carry the weight
and majesty appropriate to the
subject, and even to be proper
for singing in the church-Preface to the GENEVAN
PSALTER, p. 4
F. THE WEDDING OF INWARD
SINCERITY AND OUTWARD
FAITHFULNESS TO GODS WORD
1. THE VAIN WORSHIP OF GODEXTERNALLY WITHOUT HEART
it is not sufficient to utter the
praises of God with our tongues,
if they do not proceed from the
heart - COMMENTARY ON
THE PSALMS, Vol. I, p. 126
e prophet Isaiah could not make this
point any stronger, in Isaiah 1:10-15
Hear the word of the Lord,
You rulers of Sodom;
3. See my book, HOW GOD WANTS US TO
WORSHIP HIM, p. 165-180.
Give ear to the instruction of
the God,
You people of Gomorrah.
What are your multiplied
sacrifices to Me?
Says the Lord.
I have had enough of burnt
offerings of rams,
And the fat of fed cattle.
And I take no pleasure in the
blood of bulls, lambs or goats.
When you come to appear be-
fore Me,Who requires of you this
trampling of My courts?
Bring your worthless offer-
ings no longer,
Teir incense is an abomina-
tion to Me.
New moon and Sabbath, the
calling of assembliesI cannot endure iniquity and
the solemn assembly.
I hate your new moon fes-
tivals and your appointed
feasts,
Tey have become a burden
to Me.
I am weary of bearing themSo when you spread out your
hands in prayer,
I will hide my eyes from you,
Yes, even though you multiply
prayers,
I will not listen.
Your hands are full of blood-
shed.
is inseparable bond between sincer-
ity of heart and outward faithfulness to
the demands of Gods word flows out of
Calvins theology. A human person is
an integrated whole.
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
18/25
21Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 2010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
2. THE DISOBEDIENT WORSHIP
OF THE NICODEMITES
a. HE IDENIY OF HE
NICODEMIES
e Nicodemites were primarily Prot-
estants in France, who did not want
to separate from the Roman Catholic
Church, but who wanted to reform it
from within. Consequently, although
they knew the worship and theology of
the Roman Catholic Church was false
and unbiblical, they continued to attendmass and go through the motions of the
mass, largely for their own safetys sake,
while knowing that these outward ac-
tions were wrong. ey believed they
could truly worship God in their hearts,
even as they were participating in rites
and rituals they knew to be out of ac-
cord with the Word of God.ey took the name Nicodemites
after a man of the Pharisees, named
Nicodemus, a ruler of the Jews; this
man came to Him [Jesus] by nightfor
fear of what the Jews might do to him
if they found out his relationship to Je-
sus, John 3:1. However, Calvin did not
appreciate them calling themselves asNicodemites, because Nicodemus was
never really the prototype of the reli-
gious dissembler [those who disguise
their true feelings, ideas, and motives.].
When Nicodemus was still in igno-
rance, he went to Jesus by night, but
later he openly displayed his faith as
a disciple at Jesus burial. As a Chris-
tian, Nicodemus did not fear persecu-
tion. (Calvin)- COME OUT FROM
AMONG THEM, p. 18
More particularly, Calvin identi-
fied four kinds of Nicodemites, or dis-
semblers:
First, false preachers of the
gospel, who adopt some evan-
gelical doctrinesnext, worldly
people, courtiers and refined
ladies, who are used to flat-
tery and hate austerity; then,scholars and literary men, wholove their ease and hope for
gradual improvement with the
spread of education and intel-
ligence; lastly, merchants and
citizens, who do not wish to be
interrupted in their avocation.-
quoted in COME OUT FROMAMONG THEM, p. 19
b. HE CHOICES CALVIN GAVE
HE NICODEMIES
Calvin did not give the Nicodemitesthe choice of compromise and pretense.Rather, he told them, although it was
difficult to do so, because he knew thatsuch choices would lead to hardship,exile or martyrdom, that they had twobiblical choices before them: (1). Leavethe Roman Catholic Church and beginProtestant Churches with pure worshipin private homes; or (2). Migrate to anation or province where true liberty of
worship for Protestants could be found.
c. HE REFUAION OF HE
NICODEMIES BY CALVIN
it is agreed by all that the
Christian man must honor
God, not only in his heart by
spiritual affection, but also
by outward witness. Since the
Lord has redeemed our body
and soul from death, he has
bought both the one and the
other, in order to be master
and governor of them. Since,
therefore both the mans body
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
19/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 201022
John Calvin on the Worship of God
and his soul are concentratedand dedicated to God, his glorymust shine in both the oneand the other, as St. Paul says(I Cor. 6:20)- Calvin, COME
OUT FROM AMONG THEM:ANTI-NICODEMITE WRIT-
INGS OF JOHN CALVIN, p. 36
us it is a mockery to say thatit is enough for man to glorifyGod within his heart, without
concerning himself about exter-
nal things, for which God hasno concern. For, if the heart isgood, it will produce its outwardfruit.- Calvin, COME OUTFROM AMONG THEM, p. 36
when we have the privilegeof hearing the word of God
preached purely, of calling
upon his name and enjoyingthe sacraments,this is amplerecompense for all the trials,troubles and hindrances thatSatan may stir up against us.
Calvin, COME OUT FROMAMONG THEM, p. 131
e sum of the matter is, thatonce we have come to know the
living God as our Father, andJesus Christ as our Redeemer,we must dedicate body and
soul to him, who by his infi-nite goodness has adopted usas his children; and we musttake care to do homage to this
good Savior for what cost himso dearly. We must likewise not
only renounce every sort of un-faithfulness, but also distanceourselves from all superstitions,which are contrary both to the
service of God and to the honor
of his Son, and which cannot bereconciled with the pure doc-trine of the gospel and a trueconfession of faith.- Calvin,COME OUT FROM AMONG
THEM, p. 132
Question: If a person merely goesthrough the motions of idolatrous wor-ship with full knowledge of its false-hoods, why would God mind? Calvinanswers:
ere is a real kind of idolatrywhen one performs an externalact that is contrary to the true
service of God, even if it is doneonly for deception.- quoted by
Eire, p. 257
Carlos Eire goes on to explain Calvinswords: ose who insist on payingexternal honor to idolatrous servicesare harming themselves and denyingGod His glory, says Calvin, becausethe physical act of participation in false
Carlos Eire
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
20/25
23Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 2010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
worship is objectively misdirected and
evil regardless of the intentions of the
worshipper. One is not to use ones body
incorrectly, he adds, because external
acts of reverence are objective signs of
spiritual honor and as such carry withthem the full intent of the reverential
act. Bodily gestures cannot be sepa-
rated from the honor they outwardly
effect. Calvin will not admit a separa-
tion of internal belief and external con-
fession; to him faith entails an honest
outward profession.- p. 257
is is in accord with Pauls com-
ments in Romans 10:9If you confess
with your mouth that Jesus is Lord,
and believe in your heart that God
has raised Him from the dead, you
will be saved.
Eire continues: Calvin argues that
although the service of God is primar-
ily located in the heart, one still needs
to make a public confession of faith
through external actions.It is a meta-
physical inversion that denies that there
is any real, concrete connection be-
tween the material and the spiritual.
Human beings are spiritual-physical
(material) entities. God has created
both natures and demands that worship
be returned by the whole person.
To deny this, argues Calvin, is
to deny Gods sovereignty over
the physical world. [at is the
heresy of the Manichaeans who
deny that God is the creator
of the total person.]Idolatrymust be shunned at all costs,
even at the risk of ones life, for
the first lesson one should learn
in the school of Jesus Christ is
the renunciation of self.- p.
258-259
the relation ofworship and the
church
Calvins opposition to the Nicodemite
compromise and his call to leave the
Roman Church or migrate to another
nation are not based only on his fear of
contagion of idolatry. ey also grow
out of Calvins doctrine of the church.
e visible church, bearing the marks
of a true church, played a central role in
Christian worship. Christians not only
adhere to a certain kind of worship, butalso to a certain social group: the true
church of Christ, where that worship is
to be found.
Great benefits come to those who
belong to a church devoted to the pure
and unmixed worship of God accord-
ing to His Word. Calvin insisted that it
is very beneficial to be able to worshipfreely, openly confess ones faith, pray,
hear the Word preached, and partici-
pate in the sacraments commanded byGod. Calvin stresses the importance of
the worshipping community against
the dissemblers who scoff at his call to
exile. ose who think they can do with
the true church, he says, know very lit-tle about the faith they claim to follow.
Although God has done away
with the earthly temple of the
Jews and the organized priest-
hood of Aaron, there is still a
divinely ordained need for or-
ganized worship. is need ismet by the church.
For Calvin, there is no choice in
the matterChristians are re-
quired by God to use the means
of grace which God has given
the church is means, of
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
21/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 201024
John Calvin on the Worship of God
course, that in cases where onehas to choose between member-
ship in the visible New Israelof the church, and citizenship
in an idolatrous nation, pref-
erence is to be given to Godskingdom. To this extent, then,
the visible church becomes anation for Calvin. In that the
ultimate allegiance requiredof all Christians (regardless of
their place of birth) lies withGod and his commandments,
not with princes and theirlaws.- Eire, p. 262-263
the duty of allchristians to despise
idolatry
Calvin exhorted believers to constant
commitment to true worship, not toviolent, lawless iconoclastic crusades.However, he did believe that everyChristian has the duty, in the placesGod has assigned them, to despise andoppose idolatry in worship. He did notbelieve in the use of unlawful violence,such as the Peasants Revolt in Germa-
ny; but he believed that it is right for allChristians to burn with the zeal withwhich Christ was animated when He
vindicated the glory of the Father [inthe cleansing of the Temple].- Calvin,quoted by Eire, p. 266.
Calvins message could not helpbut be disruptive to society.
Calvins call upon Christians tobe burn with zeal for the pure
worship of God. By calling onhis followers to withdraw from
the customs of their society,
and to abhor these practiceswith zeal. Calvin helped create
an explosive situation. Calvin
would admit no separation
separation between private
belief and public behavior,
and this principle of confes-
sional integrity went beyond
mere passivity. It also called for
an aggressive public rejection
of the man social norms that
supported idolatry: to accept
the Calvinist (credo), body and
soul, was to become an agent of
change.- Eire, p. 267
is quote by Carlos Eire gives us in-
sight into the explosive and transform-
ing effect those who burn with zeal for
the pure worship of God, can have on a
society. Because Christian beliefs nec-
essarily manifest themselves in public
behavior, and because our commitment
to Christ and His demand to separate
ourselves from and oppose all in a cul-
ture that is opposed to God and His
Word, our confession of Christs lord-
ship will be more than individualistic, it
will be comprehensive. It will be heard
in the individuals and the institutions
of human society. is means that all
faithful Christians must see themselves
as agents of social change, not in a vio-
lent or revolutionary way, but in a Bibli-
cal and reformational manner.
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
22/25
25Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 2010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
the civil magistrateand the purity of
worship
Calvin also believed that it was the duty
of civil magistrates to prevent offenses
to God by obeying and enforcing both
tables of the Decalogue. He believed
that God put them in places of authority
and power to be the guardians of pure
worship and defenders of the Christian
Faith, and that they should govern in
the name of Jesus. Isaiah 49:23 says con-
cerning the church: And kings will beyour guardians, and their princesses
your nurses. ey will bow down to
you with their faces to the earth, and
lick the dust of your feet; and you will
know that I am the Lord; those who
hopefully wait for Me will not be put
to shame.
I admit that it is good to show
moderation, and that not too
much rigor is neither good nor
useful because it is necessary
to accommodate ceremonies
to the simplicity of the people.
But one must not let that which
comes from Satan and the An-tichrist [the Roman Catholic
Church] be accepted under
this principle. is is why Holy
Writ, when praising those kings
who had attacked idolatry but
failed to wipe it out altogether
notes it as a shame that never-
theless they had not cast downthe small temples and places of
deranged devotion. quoted by
Eire, p. 269
In 1544, Calvin gave similar advise to
the King of Poland. In this letter, Cal-
vin says that kings should not hesitate
to wipe out idolatry in their land, be-cause God has set them on high for thispurpose of enlightening their people.Calvin further warns the Polish kingthat unless he calls his subjects away
from the filthy dissipation of Popery tothe obedience of Christ, he shall incurserious blame before God.- Eire, p. 269
In another letter to the same king,Calvin wrote that: if such concern foran outward form of worship was un-dertaken by this ancient Jewish king[David], then how much more should
not the spiritual worship of God absorba Christian monarch in the presentday?- quoted by Eire, p. 269-270
e Westminster Confession ofFaith reflects this Calvinistic emphasison the duty of the civil magistrate re-garding the purity of worship in 23.3
e civil magistrate may notassume to himself the adminis-tration of the Word and sacra-ments, or the power of the keysof the kingdom of heaven; yethe hath authority, and it is hisduty, to take order, that unityand peace be preserved in theChurch, that the truth of God
be kept pure and entire, thatall blasphemies and heresiesbe suppressed, all corruptionsand abuses in worship and dis-cipline prevented or reformed,and all the ordinances of Godduly settled, administered, andobserved [underlining mine]
is view of Calvin is politically in-correct in 21st America. e majorityof Christians, having bought into thepluralistic and humanistic view of lib-erty for all religions, would completelydisagree with him. And yet he bases his
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
23/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 201026
John Calvin on the Worship of God
view on the righteous practice of thekings of the OT Hebrew republic in-sofar as God created it to be model forthe nations.4 Modern and post-modern
Christians do not agree with Calvin
because they do not agree with his viewof the Old Testament. However, it is inthe whole Bible, in both testaments, thatGod has revealed His moral law for indi-
viduals, families, churches and nations.5
the agenda of johncalvin in his struggle
for the purity ofworship (against the
nicodemites)
(e following is largely a paraphraseof Carlos Eire from his book, WARAGAINST IDOLS.)
Calvins opposition to Nicodemit-ism grew out of his struggle for thesurvival of the Reformation and of Re-formed churches in France. His opposi-
tion was based on theological principles,but it was anything but an irrelevant,academic dispute. It was an attempt tosalvage the Reformed cause from confu-sion and to mold it into a vibrant faith
distinct from Roman Catholicism.e Nicodemite comprise was re-
pugnant to Calvin, not only because itwas a compromise with idolatry, butalso because it denied the need for a
pure and true church in France whollydedicated to Reformation principles.He knew that Nicodemitism could eas-
ily paralyze the Reformed attempt atsocial reform and the establishment of
Reformed institutions, viz., churches,schools, publishing houses. erefore,
4. See THE HEBREW REPUBLIC by E.C. Wines.
5. See BY THIS STANDARD and NO OTHER
STANDARD by Greg Bahnsen.
he saw Nicodemitism as a serious threatto the Reformation because it sought areconciliation between the corruptionof Romes idolatrous worship and thepurity of the gospel of grace taught by
the Reformers. So then, Calvin saw thedoctrinal and liturgical corruption ofthe Roman Catholicism as an immenseevil that had to be shunned and, whenpossible, eradicated.
Calvin not only resisted any kind ofcompromise or negotiation in his waragainst idols, he also bravely asserted
the necessity of separation from the Ro-man Catholic Church, and he laid a sol-id Biblical base for the establishment ofReformed churches throughout Franceand Europe. In opposing any compro-mise with the idolatry of Rome, Calvindrew a blueprint for social, politicaland ecclesiastical change and conflict.
Hence, the implications of Calvinsposition were obviously disruptive tochurch, state and society.
People had to make a choice be-tween Rome and the gospel of the Re-
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
24/25
27Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 2010
John Calvin on the Worship of God
formers. Either one belonged to the truechurch of God, untainted by idolatry,or one belonged to the unreformedchurch, the false church of the pope.To call for such a choice in 16thcentury
Europe was to call for revolution. Inan age when religion and nationalitywere closely intertwined, any religiousschism could not help but also be politi-cal.- Carlos Eire, p. 272
e war in France in the 16thcen-tury was between the Roman Catholicgovernment and the Calvinistic French
people. Calvin insisted that there couldbe no compromise with the faith theking was trying to force by law on thepeople of France. is war, which hadbeen brewing in the 1540s and 1550s,finally erupted in 1562, which waslargely the result of Calvins refusal tocompromise with the Nicodemites.
Similar conclusions can be drawnabout Calvinist-inspired strife in Eng-land, Scotland, and the Netherlandsduring the second half of the 16thcen-tury.- Eire, p. 272
Although Calvins primary goalwas the necessity of true, and uncor-rupted worship in the visible church,based on Biblical and theological prin-ciples, the application of these princi-ples in 16thcentury society necessarilyinvolved a very concrete kind of politi-cal challenge. By calling for separationand exile, and the creation of a puri-fied church, Calvin was striking deepat the heart of the body politic; he was,in fact, calling into question the Chris-
tians national identity and sense of al-legiance.- Eire, p. 272
In his battle against Nicodemit-ism, Calvin had no hidden agenda, al-though he was motivated by a clear vi-sion of the reformation and Christian-ization of the social and political order.
His theology was far from speculative.In fact, in Calvins Christian vision itis impossible to separate political mo-tivations from theological reasons.ey were in no way mutually exclu-
sive. His theology informed his poli-tics. is comprehensive worldviewencouraged the development of moreclearly defined political ambitionsamong his followers, viz. the author ofVINDICIAE CONTRA TYRANNIS.
By attacking Nicodemitism andruling out compromise, Calvin devel-oped the basis and framework, not onlyfor purity of worship, but for a politicsof purity based on the Word of God,much as English Puritanism sought todo. He saw that Christians were exemptfrom obeying civil laws that requireddisobedience to God, that demandedpollution through idolatrous behav-ior. ishelped many to take theirfirst step away from total allegiance to
their rulers, and also made it easier forothers to develop a more active ideologyof resistance against idolatry and thepolitical order that supported it, viz.John Knox.- Eire, p. 275
It can also be said that the Britishsettlement of North America, Americas
-
8/12/2019 2010 Issue 3 - John Calvin on the Worship of God - Counsel of Chalcedon
25/25
Counsel of Chalcedon Issue 3 201028
War for Independence in 1776, and theU.S. Constitution all have their roots inCalvins call for the purity of worship.
Conclusion
e purity of worship is at the heart ofthe Christian Faith. e Christian Faithis most clearly defined in Reformedterms, for the Reformed Faith is Bibli-cal Christianity in its purest humanexpression.
Purity of worship is impossible to
maintain apart from Reformed andCalvinistic theological principles andpresuppositions.
Striving for the purity of worship,church and society without compromisedemands striving to end idolatrous wor-ship and all the institutions and customsof a society that support them.
erefore, those who are strivingfor the purity of worship and the res-toration of the Reformed Faith will bedisruptive agents of social change. And,in reaction to these Christians, thosewho defiantly cling to their idolatrousworship and idolatrous culture will usepolitical and ecclesiastical power to si-lence those who know that the state isnot God. is means that until we con-
vert the American culture to compre-hensive purity, some of will be burnedat the stake, whatever that will mean inthe 21stcentury.
However, as Jesus said to His dis-ciples in Matthew 5:10-16:
Blessed are those who havebeen persecuted for the sake of
righteousness, for theirs is the
kingdom of heaven. Blessed
are you when men revile you,
and persecution you, and say
all kinds of evil against you
falsely, on account of Me. Re-
joice and be glad, for your re-
ward in heaven is great, for so
they persecuted the prophets
who were before you.
You are the salt of the earth;
but if the salt has become
tasteless, how will it be made
salty again? It is good for
nothing any more, except to
be thrown out and trampled
under foot by men.
You are the light of the world.
A city set on a hill cannot be
hidden. Nor do men light a
lamp, and put it under the
peck-measure, but on the
lampstand; and it gives light
to all who are in the house.
Let your light shine beforemen in such a way that they
may see your good works, and
glorify your Father who is in
heaven.