2010 Annual Report July 2011 Prepared By Missouri ... · July 2011 Prepared By ... enforcement...

2010 Annual Report

July 2011

Prepared By

Missouri Department of Natural Resources Division of Environmental Quality

Air Pollution Control Program

1

Reports and Data Required by Federal Rule Reports below are in the order of federal regulation. Federal requirements are in bold type and the Missouri Department of Natural Resources response follows each requirement. Responses that are data tables are found in the Attachments.

TITLE 40--PROTECTION OF ENVIRONMENT

CHAPTER I--ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

SUBCHAPTER C--AIR PROGRAMS

PART 51--REQUIREMENTS FOR PREPARATION, ADOPTION, AND SUBMITTAL OF IMPLEMENTATION PLANS

SUBPART S--INSPECTION/MAINTENANCE PROGRAM REQUIREMENTS

§ 51.366 Data analysis and reporting. Data analysis and reporting are required to allow for monitoring and evaluation of the program by program management and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and shall provide information regarding the types of program activities performed and their final outcomes, including summary statistics and effectiveness evaluations of the enforcement mechanism, the quality assurance system, the quality control program, and the testing element. Initial submission of the following annual reports shall commence within 18 months of initial implementation of the program as required by Sec. 51.373 of this subpart. The biennial report shall commence within 30 months of initial implementation of the program as required by Sec. 51.373 of this subpart. (a) Test data report. The program shall submit to EPA by July of each year a report providing basic statistics on the testing program for January through December of the previous year, including:

The following responses cover data gathered from January through December 2010. See Attachment 1 for a Summary of information from Attachments 2-16.

(1) The number of vehicles tested by model year and vehicle type;

See Attachment 2 – (1) The number of vehicles tested by model year and vehicle type

(2) By model year and vehicle type, the number and percentage of vehicles:

2

(i) Failing initially, per test type;

See Attachment 3 – (2i) Vehicles Failing Initially

(ii) Failing the first retest per test type;

See Attachment 4 – (2ii) Vehicles Failing the First Retest

(iii) Passing the first retest per test type;

See Attachment 5 – (2iii) Vehicles Passing the First Retest (iv) Initially failed vehicles passing the second or subsequent retest per test

type;

See Attachment 6 – (2iv) Vehicles Passing the Second or Subsequent Retest

(v) Initially failed vehicles receiving a waiver; and

See Attachment 7 – (2v) Initially Failed Vehicles Receiving a Waiver

(vi) Vehicles with no known final outcome (regardless of reason).

See Attachment 8 – (2vi) Vehicles with No Known Final Outcome

(vii) -(x) [Reserved]

(xi) Passing the on-board diagnostic check; See Attachment 9 – (2xi-xii) Vehicles Passing/Failing the On-Board Diagnostic Test

(xii) Failing the on-board diagnostic check; See Attachment 9 – (2xi-xii) Vehicles Passing/Failing the On-Board Diagnostic Test (xiii) Failing the on-board diagnostic check and passing the tailpipe test (if

applicable); N/A

(xiv) Failing the on-board diagnostic check and failing the tailpipe test (if

applicable); N/A

3

(xv) Passing the on-board diagnostic check and failing the I/M gas cap evaporative system test (if applicable);

N/A

(xvi) Failing the on-board diagnostic check and passing the I/M gas cap evaporative system test (if applicable);

N/A

(xvii) Passing both the on-board diagnostic check and I/M gas cap evaporative system test (if applicable);

N/A

(xviii) Failing both the on-board diagnostic check and I/M gas cap evaporative system test (if applicable);

N/A

(xix) MIL is commanded on and no codes are stored; See Attachment 10 – (2xix) MIL is Commanded On and No Codes Are Stored

(xx) MIL is not commanded on and codes are stored; See Attachment 11 – (2xx) MIL is Not Commanded On and Codes Are Stored

(xxi) MIL is commanded on and codes are stored; See Attachment 12 – (2xxi) MIL is Commanded On and Codes Are Stored

(xxii) MIL is not commanded on and codes are not stored; See Attachment 13 – (2xxii) MIL is Not Commanded On and Codes Are Not Stored

(xxiii) Readiness status indicates that the evaluation is not complete for any

module supported by on-board diagnostic systems;

See Attachment 14 – (2xxiii) Vehicles Failing the Readiness Status

(3) The initial test volume by model year and test station;

See Attachment 15 – (3) Initial Test Volume by Model Year and Test Station

(4) The initial test failure rate by model year and test station; and

See Attachment 16 – (4) Initial Test Failure Rate by Model Year and Test Station

4

(5) The average increase or decrease in tailpipe emission levels for HC, CO, and

NOx (if applicable) after repairs by model year and vehicle type for vehicles receiving a mass emissions test.

N/A

(b) Quality assurance report. The program shall submit to EPA by July of each year a

report providing basic statistics on the quality assurance program for January through December of the previous year, including:

(1) The number of inspection stations and lanes:

(i) Operating throughout the year; There were 700 GVIP licensed stations with 709 lanes in operation for the entire year of 2010. This includes both public and private stations but does not include Systech International (STI), Missouri State Highway Patrol (MSHP) or Missouri Department of Natural Resources (Department) stations/lanes. These would account for an additional 5 stations and 49 lanes. (ii) Operating for only part of the year; In addition to the stations noted above there were 150 GVIP licensed stations with 152 lanes that operated less than 12 months out of the year.

(2) The number of inspection stations and lanes operating throughout the year:

(i) Receiving overt performance audits in the year;

9,958 overt audits of GVIP stations were performed in 2010. Of these, the Department performed 5,019 (which included 1,737 lanes) and the MSHP performed 4,935 (which included audits of all lanes at the station). This indicates that every station and every lane received at least one overt performance audit during the year. These numbers include audits of those stations that operated both greater than ten months of 2010 and less than 10 months of 2010.

(ii) Not receiving overt performance audits in the year;

All stations received at least one overt performance audit during this period, many received multiple audits.

5

(iii) Receiving covert performance audits in the year;

265 in-station covert audits of licensed stations were performed in 2010. The Department performed 155 of these and MSHP performed 110. In addition to the above, the Department conducted data investigations regarding various aspects of the GVIP, such as Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) mismatches, OBD “fingerprint” mismatches, multiple 'readiness monitor fails' on the same vehicle, and 'Repair Verification' action regarding problem waivers. In 2010, the Department conducted 17 such audits. Because the station is unaware of this type of audit, we consider them covert audits as well. Finally, the Department conducts a ‘repair audit’ with each waiver application to ensure the repairs made are appropriate and well-documented. Again, as the station is unaware of these audits, we consider them an additional type of covert audit. The Department conducted 582 repair audits on 324 stations in 2010. Each station received at least one covert audit during the year via one of these methods. (iv) Not receiving covert performance audits in the year; and 645 stations did not receive a physical covert audit by Department staff. As mentioned above, the Department conducted repair audits of 324 stations in 2010. In addition, the Department and the MSHP routinely conduct data audits also mentioned above. Each time they are conducted, these data audits pull information from all stations. Therefore, through the various types of covert audits, every station was subjected to a covert audit at least once throughout the year.

(v) That have been shut down as a result of overt performance audits;

3 inspection stations had licenses suspended or revoked as a result of overt audits by the MSHP.

(3) The number of covert audits:

As noted in previous reports, the MSHP does not have a vehicle with “set to fail” capabilities.

(i) Conducted with the vehicle set to fail per test type; The Department performed 155 covert audits in 2010. Each vehicle is set up:

6

1) with a Diagnostic Trouble Code (DTC) embedded in it by a technical service center. This ensures that every covert vehicle will fail, at a minimum, the OBD test for DTC reasons

2) with the ability for the Department auditor to allow the Malfunction Indicator Lamp (MIL) to illuminate as it should or to be turned off.

Of these audits: - 155 were conducted on a vehicle set to fail for OBD DTC; - 155 were conducted on a vehicle set to fail OBD MIL Test; - 0 were conducted on a vehicle set to fail for OBD Readiness; - 26 were conducted on a vehicle set to fail for Safety (One of the covert vehicles is set to fail Safety inspections due to a missing catalytic converter.) (ii) Conducted with the vehicle set to fail any combination of two or more test

types; The Department performed 155 covert audits with the vehicle set to fail any combination of two or more test types in 2010. - 129 were conducted on a vehicle set to fail both OBD MIL & OBD DTC. - 26 were conducted on a vehicle set to fail OBD MIL, OBD DTC and Safety.

(iii) Resulting in a false pass per test type; All covert audits in 2010 resulted in an overall failure for the vehicle’s emission inspection. However, 48 covert audits resulted in a false pass for the MIL Verification Test as a result of the Inspector/Mechanic passing this test although the MIL was mechanically set to not illuminate by the Department auditor. The Department plans to begin enforcement on these false passes, though they did not result in a “Pass” for the vehicle’s emissions inspection in 2011. No false passes were recorded for OBD DTC or Readiness. There were 18 false results for the vehicle’s safety inspection. All of these false results were in relation to the vehicle with a missing catalytic converter and resulted in a “Pass” for the missing catalytic converter. (iv) Resulting in a false pass for any combination of two or more test types; None of the covert audits for a vehicle set to fail resulted in a false pass in 2010. In addition, none had false passes for more than one test type.

(v) - (viii) [Reserved]

7

(4) The number of inspectors and stations:

(i) That were suspended, fired, or otherwise prohibited from testing as a result of covert audits;

All suspensions and revocations (described below) were the result of overt audits. (ii) That were suspended, fired, or otherwise prohibited from testing for

other causes; and The MSHP suspended or revoked 3 station and 7 Inspector/Mechanic licenses in 2010.

(iii) That received fines; The APCP established a penalty matrix including provisions for civil and criminal enforcement of the requirements of the GVIP. Please see Attachment 17 for a copy of this matrix. In 2010, the APCP began enforcement based on this matrix. In October 2010, the Air Program initiated negotiations for civil penalties with a GVIP facility in Hazelwood, MO, to settle violations for multiple fraudulent emissions inspections. Negotiations are on-going.

(5) The number of inspectors licensed or certified to conduct testing;

There were approximately 5,806 Inspector/Mechanics licensed to conduct testing under the GVIP in 2010.

(6) The number of hearings:

(i) Held to consider adverse actions against inspectors and stations; and The MSHP conducted one hearing with an Inspector/Mechanic under the GVIP.

(ii) Resulting in adverse actions against inspectors and stations; The MSHP hearing resulted in a suspension of the Inspector/Mechanic’s license and a “Written Warning” for the inspection station. In August 2010, the Department of Justice announced the federal indictment of three licensed emissions inspectors employed by Clark Tire Wholesale in Imperial, MO. Sentences are scheduled to be given in early 2011.

8

(7) The total amount collected in fines from inspectors and stations by type of violation;

The APCP began their first GVIP enforcement case in October 2010 and expects fines to be collected from both the station and the inspectors. Negotiations are ongoing; therefore, amounts will be reported in the 2011 Annual Report. In addition, the U.S. Attorney’s Office indicted three inspectors from a GVIP station located in Imperial, MO. Each received one felony violation of the Clean Air Act. Final judgments and fines will be reported in the 2011 Annual Report.

(8) The total number of covert vehicles available for undercover audits over the

year; and

There were 6 Department owned vehicles and 5 MSHP vehicle used to perform covert audits during this reporting period. (9) The number of covert auditors available for undercover audits.

During this reporting period, the Department had 6 staff members available for covert audits. The MSHP had 12 staff available to perform covert audits.

(c) Quality control report. The program shall submit to EPA by July of each year a report providing basic statistics on the quality control program for January through December of the previous year, including:

(1) The number of emission testing sites and lanes in use in the program;

In 2010, there were 841 GVIP licensed stations and 867 lanes in operation (as noted above, this excludes STI, Department, and MSHP stations and lanes).

(2) The number of equipment audits by station and lane;

The Department’s staff conducted 1,711 station equipment audits, which included 1,737 lanes. This indicates that each station received at least one audit by Department staff, and some received two. All overt audits conducted by the MSHP are also equipment audits. MSHP conducted 4,935 station audits. In addition, Department auditors routinely audit software. They assist in development of acceptance test procedures and also participate in acceptance testing on all software versions released during the calendar year. They provide approval or request additional modifications as appropriate.

9

(3) The number and percentage of stations that have failed equipment audits;

and 84 stations failed inspections for equipment violations. This equates to approximately 9.9% of stations.

(4) Number and percentage of stations and lanes shut down as a result of

equipment audits. 128 stations were locked down until the equipment was fixed as a result of equipment audits.

(d) Enforcement report.

(1) All varieties of enforcement programs shall, at a minimum, submit to EPA by July of each year a report providing basic statistics on the enforcement program for January through December of the previous year, including:

(i) An estimate of the number of vehicles subject to the inspection program,

including the results of an analysis of the registration database;

According to the Missouri Department of Revenue’s (DOR) vehicle registration database, 1,313,419 vehicles were subject to the Gateway Vehicle Inspection Program in 2010. (ii) The percentage of motorist compliance based upon a comparison of the

number of valid final tests with the number of subject vehicles;

For the reporting year, GVIP inspection stations performed 706,075 initial emission tests. These tests include vehicle transfers (used vehicles sold and required to be reinspected) and some federal, state and local government fleet vehicles that are not on the registration database (fewer than 3,000). Assuming that roughly half of the 1,313,419 vehicles should be emission inspected during each year of the GVIP, then 656,710 vehicles should have received an emission test. However, as noted in last year’s Annual Report, a more accurate measure of compliance may be found in Attachment 8 (2vi-Vehicles with No Known Final Outcome) which indicates that out of 27,525 emissions failures, 4,271 vehicles never passed an emission inspection. This indicates a non-compliance rate of 16% and in turn a compliance rate of 84%.

10

(iii) The total number of compliance documents issued to inspection stations;

All compliance documents are stored on the Missouri Decentralized Analyzer System (MDAS) unit in the inspection lane. Because of this feature, they are printed on an as required basis so the number issued would correlate directly to the number of inspections performed or passed as appropriate.

(iv) The number of missing compliance documents;

As noted above, a complete set of compliance documents are stored on the MDAS unit in each lane and are available to be printed on an as needed basis. (v) The number of time extensions and other exemptions granted to

motorists; and Cost-based emissions waivers are available if a motorist has spent more than $450 on emissions-related repairs and labor if a Missouri Recognized Repair Technician performs the repairs. If the vehicle owner performs the repairs, the owner must spend at least $400 in qualified emissions-control parts, as determined by the EPA, toward the waiver amount. If vehicle owners are financially dependent solely on state and federal disability, benefits or other public assistance programs and anticipate failing the emissions test, they may receive a waiver if they spend at least $200 on emissions-related repairs and labor. The Department granted 675 cost based waivers in 2010. Out-of-area waivers are also available. If a vehicle is registered in the St. Louis ozone nonattainment area, but operating outside of that area for the following 24 consecutive months, owners may apply to the Department for an out-of-area waiver. Examples include vehicles used by family members away at college or on farm property outside of the St. Louis area. Out of Area Waivers, valid for the period of registration, are given to motorists of such vehicles. The Department granted 486 Out-of-area waivers in 2010. Reciprocity waivers are also available. If a vehicle is in a state other than Missouri and that state conducts pass/fail OBD testing, the motorist may choose to have the vehicle emissions inspected in that state and submit a reciprocity waiver application to the department. The Department also uses these as “Technical Waivers.” The Department granted 101 Reciprocity waivers in 2010. Mileage-Based Exemptions are also available. There are 3 categories of motor vehicles eligible for mileage-based exemptions:

11

1.) New motor vehicles, of model years of the current calendar year and within two (2) years of the current calendar year that have an odometer reading of fewer than 6,000 miles at the time of original sale by a motor vehicle manufacturer or licensed motor vehicle dealer to the first user,

2.) New motor vehicles that have not been previously titled and registered, for the 4-year period following their model year of manufacture, that have an odometer reading of fewer than 40,000 miles showing at the first required biennial safety inspection

3.) Motor vehicles that are driven fewer than 12,000 miles between biennial safety inspections.

The Department granted 1,563 mileage-based exemptions in 2010. (vi) The number of compliance surveys conducted, number of vehicles

surveyed in each, and the compliance rates found.

The Department conducted three compliance surveys in 2010 regarding vehicles that applied, and received, out-of-area waivers. In all three instances, the vehicles were found inside the nonattainment area. Warning letters were issued to all three owners.

(2) Registration denial based enforcement programs shall provide the following

additional information:

(i) A report of the program’s efforts and actions to prevent motorists from falsely registering vehicles out of the program area or falsely changing fuel type or weight class on the vehicle registration, and the results of special studies to investigate the frequency of such activity; and

Real Time Inspection Data/Paperless Inspection Verification Each lane is connected to the VID using a dedicated Internet connection at the inspection station. At the completion of each vehicle inspection, the lane software automatically uploads the inspection data to the VID, where it then becomes immediately available to the DOR contract license offices and online registration system for inspection verification. As a result of this real time paperless inspection verification system, GVIP has simplified registration verification and increased registration integrity for St. Louis area DOR contract license offices. Contract license offices now have the ability to quickly identify fraudulent vehicle inspection reports (VIRs) that motorists attempt to use to bypass the vehicle inspection requirements. Contract license offices now contact the Department as soon as such attempts have been prevented so that the Department and MSHP can initiate immediate investigation of the source of these fraudulent VIRs.

12

In addition to the ability to use real time inspection data and paperless verification, the GVIP program utilizes the Sierra Look-Up Table data and POLK VIN Decode data to define the vehicle for the Inspector/Mechanic, including the GVWR and fuel type. The DOR also has a data sheet with information regarding manufacturer types and weight classifications based on VIN. (ii) The number of registration file audits, number of registrations reviewed,

and compliance rates found in such audits.

The Department did not audit or review any registration files during this reporting period. However, the Department and DOR have updated the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with regard to this data sharing. The Department submitted the official request to DOR in late 2009 and we should begin receiving data shortly. Once we begin receiving data, the Department plans to utilize this information to determine fraudulent registrations and pursue enforcement action.

(3) Computer-matching based enforcement programs shall provide the following

additional information:

The Gateway Vehicle Inspection Program is primarily enforced with a registration denial based program rather than a computer-matching system. However, we do have the ability to implement some computer-matching based measures as well. As noted in Section (b)(2)(iii), the Department does conduct data investigation using various reporting tools, for example, reports which show VIN mismatches, OBD “fingerprint” mismatches, vehicles with multiple ‘readiness monitor fails’ and ‘Repair Verification’ action regarding problem waivers.

(i) The number and percentage of subject vehicles that were tested by the

initial deadline, and by other milestones in the cycle; Vehicles may be inspected, and if passing, renew their registration up to 6 months prior to their registration renewal deadline. The Department will begin tracking this information as soon as we begin receiving DOR registration data

(ii) A report on the program’s efforts to detect and enforce against motorists

falsely changing vehicle classifications to circumvent program requirements, and the frequency of this type of activity; and

The system utilizes the Sierra Look-Up Table and POLK to decode the VIN and define the vehicle. Changes to GVWR or fuel type require station management approval.

13

In addition, Department and MSHP staff are able to compare vehicle information entered in the VIR to the Inspector/Mechanic’s photographs of the vehicle’s VIN, rear license plate and odometer attached to the electronic VIR. As noted above, the Department and MSHP also frequently conduct data investigation using various reports including those which show VIN mismatches and OBD “fingerprint” mismatches to identify and address attempts to circumvent program requirements.

(iii) The number of enforcement system audits and the error rate found

during those audits. The Department anticipates beginning these types of audits as soon as transmittal of DOR registration data begins.

(4) Sticker-based enforcement systems shall provide the following additional

information:

The Gateway Vehicle Inspection Program is not enforced with a sticker-based system. Although a windshield sticker is issued to any vehicle that passes an emissions test or receives a waiver, the stickers are not currently used as an enforcement tool.

(i) A report on the program’s efforts to prevent, detect, and enforce against

sticker theft and counterfeiting, and the frequency of this type of activity; (ii) A report on the program’s efforts to detect and enforce against motorists

falsely changing vehicle classifications to circumvent program requirements, and the frequency of this type of activity; and

(iii) The number of parking lot sticker audits conducted, the number of vehicles surveyed in each, and the noncompliance rate found during those audits.

(e) Additional reporting requirements. In addition to the annual reports in

paragraphs (a) through (d) of this section, programs shall submit to EPA by July of every other year, biennial reports addressing:

(1) Any changes made in program design, funding, personnel levels, procedures,

regulations, and legal authority, with detailed discussion and evaluation of the impact on the program of all such changes; and

Established in 2007, the decentralized Gateway Vehicle Inspection Program is still in place with no major structural changes. In 2010, the APCP focused on increasing the number of covert audits. In 2008, inspectors conducted 23 covert audits compared to 155 in 2010. In addition to physical station audits, the APCP began to conduct “data audits” which consist of running an array of reports focused on revealing fraudulent inspections. The APCP conducted 17 such audits in 2010. These “data audits” have proved to be very successful in identifying stations as well as individual inspectors that are non-compliant.

14

In addition, the APCP began official enforcement through the GVIP in October 2010. The APCP initiated negotiations with one station for conducting fraudulent emissions inspection and has another one ready to begin in early 2011. The first two enforcement cases will be with stations as a whole; however, the APCP hopes to begin enforcement against the individual inspectors as well in 2011. (2) Any weaknesses or problems identified in the program within the two-year

reporting period, what steps have already been taken to correct those problems, the results of those steps, and any future efforts planned.

The Department and Highway Patrol continually strive to improve our ability to detect fraud and ensure data integrity. We continue to move forward by identifying areas of improvement to the GVIP, including:

· Increase efforts to seek out and prevent fraudulent inspection procedures in

addition to clean scanning violations. With ongoing improvements to the reporting system, we can more efficiently identify improper inspections.

· Continue working with DOR to identify and prevent invalid registration due to counterfeit inspection reports.

· Develop measures along with the Missouri Attorney General’s Office Consumer Protection Division and DOR to bring enforcement action against used car dealers who fail to meet the requirements of the statute. RSMo. 643.315.4 requires a dealer to obtain a passing emissions test before sale or clearly state in the sales contract that the purchaser may return the vehicle to the dealer for retest and repair within ten days of sale should the vehicle fail an emissions test.

· Develop a more stringent and comprehensive schedule of covert audits to identify and prevent fraudulent emissions inspection activity.

(f) SIP requirements. The SIP shall describe the types of data to be collected.

The St. Louis area I/M SIP was initially approved by the EPA on May 18, 2000, and revisions approved on May 12, 2003 and on May 13, 2004. The Department submitted the most recent I/M SIP amendment to the EPA on December 7, 2007. On April 15, 2008, the EPA found the I/M SIP submittal to be both administratively and technically complete. A technical support document for the most recent rule revision was submitted on June 10, 2009.

Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:47:10 PM V10.01 /OBD/EPA New/EPA_Summary_Report

(2) By model year and vehicle type, the number and percentage of vehicles

27,525 3.86 % OBD

27,525 (2i) Failing Initially per test type

Subtotals % Program

3.86 % of Total Vehicles Tested

1,567 5.69 % OBD

1,567 (2ii) Failing the first retest per test type

Subtotals % Program

5.69 % of Failing Initially

20,640 74.99 % OBD

20,640 (2iii) Passing the first retest per test type

Subtotals % Program


977 3.55 % OBD

977 (2iv) Initially failed vehicles passing the second or greater retest

Subtotals % Program


99.17 % of Total OBD Vehicles Tested

707,037 (2xi) Passing the OBD test


5,908 (2xii) Failing the On-Board Diagnostic check


2,241 (2xix) MIL On and No DTCs stored


51,847 (2xx) MIL Off and DTCs stored


16,291 (2xxi) MIL On and DTCs stored


642,199 (2xxii) MIL Off and No DTCs stored


0 (2xxiii) Not Ready for the OBD test

Tests Report Period : From Date 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

712,945 100.00 % OBD

712,945 (1) The number of vehicles tested by model year and vehicle type

712,945 Vehicles tested Subtotals % of Total Vehicle Tested

Program

Total Vehicles Tested

4,271 15.52 % OBD

4,271 (2vi) Vehicles with no known final outcome (regardless of reason)

Subtotals % Program


741 0.10 % OBD

741 (2v) Initially Failed Vehicles Receiving a Waiver

Subtotals % Program


From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(1) The number of vehicles tested by model year and vehicle type

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:49:45 PM V10.01 /OBD/EPA New/EPA1_Vehicles_Tested_by_Model_Year_and_Vehicle_Type

562712945110124492452588453

0184040180

08206074007466

01957701384018193

897927112934784993

22866204119224543

18997643149171584847

41944703065416382

351023926190452983347

1318700332251015475

859968115185737081108

3518699430803115619

1118056419165229264042

1817080431931413887

935577625129186842858

241221132518219693

116340752782558925820

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

WaivedTest CountWaivedTest CountWaivedTest Count

TotalTruckPassenger CarModel Year

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2i) Vehicles Failing Initially

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:50:15 PM V10.02 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2i_Vehicles_Failing_Initially

OBD Tests

4 %275257129454 %55691244924 %21956588453

1 %21840 %041 %2180

0 %3182060 %37400 %287466

0 %80195770 %313840 %7718193

1 %506979271 %79129341 %42784993

1 %229286621 %3541191 %19424543

2 %1536997642 %276149171 %126084847

2 %401194472 %6030652 %34116382

3 %28451023923 %640190453 %220583347

4 %696187005 %14732254 %54915475

5 %5139996815 %975185735 %416481108

6 %1166186996 %17030806 %99615619

6 %4663805645 %827165226 %383664042

7 %1128170806 %19831937 %93013887

8 %4299557768 %1042129188 %325742858

10 %12791221110 %264251810 %10159693

10 %35253407510 %850825510 %267525820

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% Total Fails

Total Failed

Test Count

% Total Fails

Total Failed

Test Count

% Total Fails

Total Failed

Test Count

Total Initial TestsTruckPassenger CarModel Year

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2ii) Vehicles Failing the First retest

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:50:40 PM V10.02 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2ii_Vehicles_Failing_the_First_Retest

OBD Tests

7 %1567222077 %32646797 %124117528

0 %010 %01

0 %0300 %030 %027

1 %17350 %120 %071

1 %44860 %0761 %4410

3 %51916 %2322 %3159

4 %5413983 %92674 %451131

4 %123160 %0484 %12268

4 %9724993 %155734 %821926

5 %255173 %31155 %22402

5 %22343915 %448625 %1793529

9 %748135 %611910 %68694

8 %28938257 %477058 %2423120

11 %877698 %1114212 %76627

8 %27533709 %798488 %1962522

14 %11786413 %2519914 %92665

11 %304266412 %8468811 %2201976

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% Total Fails

Total Failed

Test Count

% Total Fails

Total Failed

Test Count

% Total Fails

Total Failed

Test Count

Total First RetestTruckPassenger CarModel Year

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2iii) Vehicles Passing the First retest

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:51:05 PM V10.02 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2iii_Vehicles_Passing_the_First_Retest

OBD Tests

93 %206402220793 %4353467993 %1628717528

100 %11100 %11

100 %3030100 %33100 %2727

99 %727350 %12100 %7171

99 %482486100 %767699 %406410

97 %18619194 %303298 %156159

96 %1344139897 %25826796 %10861131

96 %304316100 %484896 %256268

96 %2402249997 %55857396 %18441926

95 %49251797 %11211595 %380402

95 %4168439195 %81886295 %33503529

91 %73981395 %11311990 %626694

92 %3536382593 %65870592 %28783120

89 %68276992 %13114288 %551627

92 %3095337091 %76984892 %23262522

86 %74786487 %17419986 %573665

89 %2360266488 %60468889 %17561976

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% Passed

Test Passed

Test Count

% Passed

Test Passed

Test Count

% Passed

Test Passed

Test Count

Total First RetestTruckPassenger CarModel Year

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2iv) Vehicles Passing the second or subsequent retest

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:52:15 PM V10.02 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2iv_Vehicles_Passing_the_Second_or_Subsequent_Retest

OBD Tests

75 %977131073 %21028975 %7671021

100 %44100 %44

83 %5650 %12100 %44

88 %374286 %6789 %3135

82 %91182 %911

86 %6980100 %101084 %5970

62 %162640 %2567 %1421

82 %16720383 %384682 %129157

84 %475625 %1488 %4652

75 %17723678 %314074 %146196

81 %485990 %91080 %3949

75 %17523473 %496775 %126167

53 %5811070 %142049 %4490

68 %16524363 %497870 %116165

Total

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% Passed

Test Passed

Test Count

% Passed

Test Passed

Test Count

% Passed

Test Passed

Test Count

Total Subsequent RetestTruckPassenger CarModel Year

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2v) Initially Failed Vehicles Receiving a Waiver

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:52:38 PM V10.02 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2v_Initially_Failed_Vehicles_Receiving_a_Waiver

OBD Tests

0.10 %7417130470.11 %1341245070.10 %607588540

0.00 %01840.00 %040.00 %0180

0.00 %082060.00 %07400.00 %07466

0.02 %4195770.00 %013840.02 %418193

0.01 %8979270.01 %1129340.01 %784993

0.01 %4286620.00 %041190.02 %424543

0.02 %19997650.02 %3149170.02 %1684848

0.05 %9194490.03 %130650.05 %816384

0.04 %431023980.03 %6190450.04 %3783353

0.12 %23187020.12 %432250.12 %1915477

0.10 %101996900.10 %18185750.10 %8381115

0.29 %54187090.16 %530810.31 %4915628

0.19 %151805900.16 %26165270.20 %12564063

0.12 %20170800.13 %431930.12 %1613887

0.20 %112557880.21 %27129200.20 %8542868

0.27 %33122140.16 %425180.30 %299696

0.47 %160341060.42 %3582600.48 %12525846

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% Waivers

WaiversTest Count

% Waivers

WaiversTest Count

% Waivers

WaiversTest Count

Total Initially TestedTruckPassenger CarModel Year

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2vi) Vehicles with no known final outcome

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:52:59 PM V10.01 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2vi_Vehicles_with_no_Known_Final_Outcome

OBD Tests

16 %42712752514 %755556916 %351621956

0 %020 %02

3 %1310 %034 %128

3 %28033 %131 %177

2 %115064 %3792 %8427

10 %232296 %23511 %21194

7 %10415365 %132767 %911260

12 %504018 %56013 %45341

8 %21828457 %436408 %1752205

18 %12369615 %2214718 %101549

10 %53251399 %8897511 %4444164

24 %280116619 %3317025 %247996

15 %696466312 %10382715 %5933836

27 %306112824 %4819828 %258930

18 %794429917 %179104219 %6153257

28 %355127920 %5226430 %3031015

22 %776352519 %16385023 %6132675

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% Never Passed

Never Passed

Failed% Never Passed

Never Passed

Failed% Never Passed

Never Passed

Failed


From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2xi-xii) Vehicles Passing/Failing the On-Board Diagnostic Test

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:54:07 PM V10.01 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2xi_xii_Vehicles_passing_or_failing_the_on-

1 %590899 %7070377129451 %109999 %1234861245851 %480999 %583551588360

1 %199 %1831840 %0100 %441 %199 %179180

0 %1100 %820582060 %0100 %7407400 %1100 %74657466

0 %8100 %19569195770 %2100 %138213840 %6100 %1818718193

0 %20100 %97907979270 %4100 %12931129350 %16100 %8497684992

0 %38100 %28624286620 %3100 %411541180 %35100 %2450924544

0 %156100 %99609997650 %23100 %14905149280 %133100 %8470484837

0 %87100 %19359194460 %11100 %305330640 %76100 %1630616382

0 %373100 %1020181023910 %77100 %18973190500 %296100 %8304583341

1 %18999 %18512187011 %3699 %319232281 %15399 %1532015473

1 %80599 %98877996821 %14299 %18454185961 %66399 %8042381086

2 %37898 %18319186972 %5398 %302430772 %32598 %1529515620

1 %95199 %79614805651 %15099 %16384165341 %80199 %6323064031

2 %39798 %16682170792 %6598 %313532002 %33298 %1354713879

2 %103098 %54747557772 %24398 %12694129372 %78798 %4205342840

4 %47396 %11737122103 %7997 %244225214 %39496 %92959689

3 %100197 %33075340763 %21197 %805882693 %79097 %2501725807

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% Failed

Failed% Passed

PassedTest Count

% Failed

Failed% Passed

PassedTest Count

% Failed

Failed% Passed

PassedTest Count

TotalModel Year

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2xix) MIL is commanded on and no codes are stored

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:54:36 PM V10.01 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2xix_MIL_is_commanded_on_and_no_codes_are_stored

0 %22417129450 %4771244920 %1764588453

1 %11840 %041 %1180

0 %2682060 %27400 %247466

0 %48195770 %013840 %4818193

0 %238979270 %39129340 %19984993

0 %72286620 %1441190 %5824543

0 %269997640 %40149170 %22984847

0 %49194470 %330650 %4616382

0 %2991023920 %56190450 %24383347

0 %60187001 %1732250 %4315475

0 %315996810 %71185730 %24481108

0 %75186990 %1530800 %6015619

0 %277805640 %59165220 %21864042

0 %77170801 %2231930 %5513887

0 %211557760 %63129180 %14842858

0 %57122111 %1625180 %419693

0 %167340751 %6082550 %10725820

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% MIL On &

No Codes

MIL On &

No Codes

Test Count

% MIL On &

No Codes

MIL On &

No Codes

Test Count

% MIL On &

No Codes

MIL On &

No Codes

Test Count


From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2xx) MIL is not commanded on and codes are stored

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:55:04 PM V10.01 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2xx_MIL_is_not_commanded_on_and_codes_are_stored

7 %518477129458 %94961244927 %42351588453

1 %11840 %041 %1180

1 %6882061 %107401 %587466

1 %288195772 %2613841 %26218193

1 %1340979272 %216129341 %112484993

3 %796286622 %9641193 %70024543

4 %4068997645 %738149174 %333084847

5 %1018194475 %14330655 %87516382

7 %68261023926 %1117190457 %570983347

8 %1442187008 %25032258 %119215475

9 %9198996817 %13891857310 %780981108

11 %1983186998 %241308011 %174215619

10 %8372805649 %14751652211 %689764042

12 %1991170809 %286319312 %170513887

13 %71645577614 %17801291813 %538442858

16 %20101221115 %376251817 %16349693

16 %52823407516 %1353825515 %392925820

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% MIL Off &

Stored Codes

MIL Off &

Stored Codes

Test Count

% MIL Off &

Stored Codes

MIL Off &

Stored Codes

Test Count

% MIL Off &

Stored Codes

MIL Off &

Stored Codes

Test Count


From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2xxi) MIL is commanded on and codes are stored

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:32:31 PM V10.01 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2xxi_MIL_is_commanded_on_and_codes_are_stored

2 %162917129453 %31351244922 %13156588453

1 %11840 %041 %1180

0 %182060 %07400 %17466

0 %19195770 %213840 %1718193

0 %173979270 %21129340 %15284993

0 %87286620 %1341190 %7424543

1 %773997641 %147149171 %62684847

1 %227194471 %3830651 %18916382

2 %17321023922 %407190452 %132583347

2 %452187003 %8632252 %36615475

3 %3281996813 %620185733 %266181108

4 %711186993 %10130804 %61015619

4 %2924805643 %474165224 %245064042

4 %654170803 %10931934 %54513887

5 %2618557765 %586129185 %203242858

5 %619122114 %10925185 %5109693

6 %2019340755 %42282556 %159725820

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% MIL On &

Stored Codes

MIL On &

Stored Codes

Test Count

% MIL On &

Stored Codes

MIL On &

Stored Codes

Test Count

% MIL On &

Stored Codes

MIL On &

Stored Codes

Test Count


From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2xxii) MIL is not commanded on and codes are not stored

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:33:07 PM V10.01 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2xxii_MIL_is_not_commanded_on_and_codes_are_not_stored

90 %64219971294589 %11127112449290 %530928588453

98 %181184100 %4498 %177180

99 %8104820698 %72774099 %73777466

98 %192091957798 %1356138498 %1785318193

98 %961129792798 %126451293498 %8346784993

96 %276332866296 %3960411996 %2367324543

95 %945309976493 %139401491795 %8059084847

93 %181251944794 %2874306593 %1525116382

91 %9349810239292 %174631904591 %7603583347

90 %167431870089 %2871322590 %1387215475

87 %868809968189 %164921857387 %7038881108

85 %159291869988 %2723308085 %1320615619

86 %689848056488 %145141652285 %5447064042

84 %143581708087 %2776319383 %1158213887

82 %457825577681 %104891291882 %3529342858

78 %95241221180 %2017251877 %75079693

78 %266073407578 %6420825578 %2018725820

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% MIL Off &

No Codes

MIL Off &

No Codes

Test Count

% MIL Off &

No Codes

MIL Off &

No Codes

Test Count

% MIL Off &

No Codes

MIL Off &

No Codes

Test Count


From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(2xxiii) Vehicles Failing the Readiness Status

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:33:46 PM V10.02 /OBD/EPA New/EPA2xxiii_Readiness_Status

0 %07129450 %01244920 %0588453

0 %01840 %040 %0180

0 %082060 %07400 %07466

0 %0195770 %013840 %018193

0 %0979270 %0129340 %084993

0 %0286620 %041190 %024543

0 %0997640 %0149170 %084847

0 %0194470 %030650 %016382

0 %01023920 %0190450 %083347

0 %0187000 %032250 %015475

0 %0996810 %0185730 %081108

0 %0186990 %030800 %015619

0 %0805640 %0165220 %064042

0 %0170800 %031930 %013887

0 %0557760 %0129180 %042858

0 %0122110 %025180 %09693

0 %0340750 %082550 %025820

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

% Failed

Test Failed

Test Count

% Failed

Test Failed

Test Count

% Failed

Test Failed

Test Count


From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010

(3) Initial Test Volume by Model Year and Test Station

Page 1Print Date: 5/4/2011 2:34:22 PM V10.01 /OBD/EPA New/EPA3_Initial_Test_Volume

6736176635826951993844063495049757811221549329758627542708

411821121

41685675237157183412

49104107485826141741842955972081573512939

12311714726311434211172919686

84109926676252719017048511432392391645954

1118141811106213316112639713101619

104991171211083643582153728717324248951068180

19111820216143271011203233916231515

101709385120165367312789692022255210410668100

15151923418231911132726301127161621

966670699518525827774851741915512010292112

25715222133321612241944113991538

6944495071115267058746211213852797172100

26819161721752314161818221128171430

581524254344254430505175903461405592

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

036055036054036045036041036037036035036033036032036030036028036026036025036020036019036015036010036005036002036001Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



1667126236138149948274957953409121148775666149392235567834

13

12622617242121

97091234128385241134

1712331113297945416383106498251111186075

1984128239218337173121172198

212197216547677321514114374103317392074114

2938299251623419137191575248

260161418758539231194016661109917554372127

3036129131618131142679131111710

25613751988951118711734187731391313753980145

44304432312272247261510252361811

2601135224803512097231189881141033633769130

4423357301330617936141531572220

1847251626823899621215742751019442764104

328133145374822517912991715

11634410236145873715113355692032202662

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

036132036119036117036115036113036109036106036105036096036095036092036088036073036071036070036066036064036062036059Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



3371612851371635304416242356290102822720087551484640101012301471

1114122525401

92326210962750251019

271419381919818619125161792022576495262132

316124384911417529103916226623

3221571212779487267351272317511724777119187145

62416161712337953843287215832

291701718765310429845144342548125193131176203

71347101212658527463232315212938

6411942525613184369491293728565198113146106230

7137910112196011261172192117192343

50218117274812773354815337286221429315673213

1335391214211947395102132011361752

5721411719331062316231122527519786613246178

1014063698513378835161412852

31388716183442332472151611137629538120

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

050030050029050027050026050023050021050018050016050014050012050006050002036151036149036148036147036143036137036135Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



242411154858671414138725687322341643844858656873652013091310

1

133355114125

11732816275248172216

2711396811145144208839917174611299292539135

513121361911265679211433628

342187771235719536103294212662111106352346188

52181218719412106269201396830

412183981226921029127182214058117107582467199

5218358418623465138191853338

485175123877422032166120205272131102503641231

442637915341321401713171181224

2451441147943205431016224588712190492742170

5736508122953023430122215166529

23310112858371443398322354548455492026112

33243241034616782382010104339

17483722733105286827103738653942192076

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

050068050067050066050062050061050060050059050057050056050055050054050052050050050046050043050041050040050039050036Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



7003675471544669100664887155359785250744944230844017871019673

1

12331911428

513121573213244238522

9033411718122672823939636264471734286102171

12642428118102261047541361230

100476422796166642261581098655523145311129119

15994020682143481387573282027

10656902279010559128386133866468315033915593

1151245173241829131271071010301613

95589920790691612427284149827468436727616886

1010125221161432618118851015352914

99708021680497142156103149705762487619714440

211014431212612619238129281621339

793554155662291491078398524356355812711325

13318411394462523145916121519195

4324478240731165155632536393250707211

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

050115050114050113050107050105050104050103050102050101050097050095050091050090050079050078050077050076050072050070Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



8781044880895579457730126717253550939047813752231715284243

12343613

3326412784116084111

8814131054745391671964283697120181763321

114315108230211777222524012

71185691186364471591863486064149292424322

3151116141010486919519471114735

141387491189279821942495625348199353004231

1415125109195351134108344115410

151308314124113681191782877716749201272653931

22114528141317436143713943885711

13116481311984551401341465895231181341564430

2410134710483751222137531342819

137352995554911112075143401716922664120

21512737191026281112112233316218

94724755473668666422721911213511623

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

050156050155050152050150050145050144050143050141050140050137050136050135050129050126050124050123050122050118050116Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



78212321782619805971455601258024249877863810971408204453

1311411127131

411743113224661074

95223233025462265684315182123130747

141126482333214468211045

98203833652572274188456143751651491260

20629685987211422132620213

959461362107829100219296961071761972071

222356831631011222172430110

121133223941195208115174191106971761922873

352327851061951012182137137

102427133281061177171157251701172133568

341336882041542185283349177

743153261871115015114502751971852747

17246831711431184212760147

51678148106744114103512044781282434

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

050207050205050202050199050193050191050190050188050187050183050180050175050174050168050167050161050160050159050158Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



1661478832191761911082967096392288457172322568561785584321087

82462833153561422

2323951114632151527641221210

13206983533017218122712058129633759288439103

2814109104114187512150306204114415

2421411430448188291289144112334227582267373147

424133826361917542525110213314311

26271119243751923712594291422279206121324547175

52824383239910115343468233514723

252531732789415249104120391522521421122701139173

425153542232321117243540323722926

2419411918496110338610836123166731292051025155

61982228251210106173016383821128

1910372997165193963188611429115127814116

414121317203392916625301129

1059466037232220371245641674747674

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

092014092013092012092011092010092008092007092005092004092003092002092000G

050257050245050244050239050213050211050209Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



302210119243572705441481690397106646810521364584118111861512452926

210

2671163241157148

1981661461511418783827225

1054031040271181604910618049136286562782451755055

21138657347575731614844674320611

223633454230145162768117355144231642432382295780

61003241034241519413196764413526733

30282374643742234912913784176160861381762977696

8924362122013162162755433234331138

4617229555382626712331114831931256512015526780160

1136319552427518122746223218241364

57882125845122251191984731284338949019352136

161524109329163561418211918321748

46521123434516572104349942221516213344117

16721412229192731597169121529

331964242161015722941549141933662459

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

092043092042092040092039092038092037092036092035092032092031092030092029092027092025092024092022092018092016092015Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



1696130255127774298781427414135911706069641456164418087441275889730

312

73265178111102419441821

19523195411188176415129412351953

24230552599631163803210810913599210323395882389578

427282681637140821233010321201961531158

285227644284712018155182199911332152593259224712899

4537121621240848173712262445711726169

29114278306781521325420118282173251251213134157160123

4517169312273293423162327453518421410

2651368225041141846727118665165246173163120157143132

323314901332205444092536361419422111

196110801536098596620715749145185115111105123136101

4418233591911143539718232561647128

120556281424518441171013386123956266808390

1719112113531122148671141418137

46474628182813399254184861334434404650

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

092076092074092071092069092068092065092064092063092058092057092056092055092054092052092049092048092047092046092045Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



55483637507374761909248525332559659180821431426823161575539

1

59161651121

32131151152552322222866

254633747523282544488529935119703828760

54451021851480541574821029

108193506803182255145812634740820713127489

21656591053146712456621446116

977107597832244378340997287419231124523681

16111531639104175721484449113026

910112880584120341077382101241311251025521280

19182211528413745184942425142314

8707778244774156026467179207141085312372

159231414512240263432214142020

63862761413726863140541191091381256231

2271289811833142718215477

4165144222221862895276352751173128

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

092114092113092111092110092109092108092107092097092096092095092092092088092085092083092081092080092079092078092077Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



111741617072512062327991438738829958814651269549406393648465229

11

2341202228112126

126258589133905112825292

12851405277496437061911434108177673236748823

5816481681418781019714291317610485

16245346813846102205811071659172205423742935936

35821239221751510215402817201017386

1985536118185511211691021401363211235666154925436

261332238417371418244483334291029257

17064191182242614312913515714372442057271651005436

27115263632325142026557241926819145

13163910518512119671211161142233140754155922533

26102244282513212024140151915101999

76396931189813083727221539749245562918

1113201931791614147322117107613

5522554812431062494041074829203528510

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

092145092141092136092135092134092132092131092130092129092126092125092123092122092121092120092119092118092116092115Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



4337107466188348059616715017251117831704108097712271161170851

171624225542

35743115126133155207311

23851035781166110121837019230245582091531082063

612171211241831965612431330297351

47103101901261471281322410119610281741752181492304

3111115101720222103433438361522413

611021371121271521701126111915892811131432371982445

1216111923162063112333427539281641

8611112792165111163125115116532811641312432402796

1218182412192623310243186291529496

789994791165811792031271111201146751321762307

1519152715162114291322268231021442

5468584681438921295770314511840911101766

1019131215211125691239101114252

23423429481662370393926978123468956

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

092184092180092179092178092177092175092173092171092169092166092164092162092159092157092156092154092151092148092146Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



744611980790208467149326927242317671704214053401077829402569

2

231257412329

5193128111291131825726

612711473113616252640370241531261114667351

9122211452762240318372141166

675815199105320353153254289321571914691439

15141219862343511338214316171348

915617412326712371347531993699454213149129461

283427204142593109523129263232461

14290161123378825828528310729756312495164409

403123189114132313521934203223166

1069512213735702015243717018415821984146300

35402014819403859222528112122739

748189872960159463440271134311838126179

26241212651627251011145281529

454842482026919173820492023208786

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

092227092220092218092217092216092215092212092208092204092203092202092201092200P

092198092197092196092192092190092186Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



838798924720668114551722268101277234436916428372401175484926

3

11165541911191122111

6111611212461031907112536

793614289021918495192945852349100261279393

223371236734566137615425294215

812472625993142736310911064611991262916182131

124256152941385015101155243292418

141552038251262812630010112459591981384718053152

235448132267840197653277411924

13127133423105205301599511949631351153518152158

427212710268632819453138441828

141121341161001361872751014445951183515617126

42421188209282613281823331727

970113315569973955772126385430981386

118411271461051913715632217

44051493943612274272029261255544

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

092286092281092280092272092270092269092264092261092259092258092256092251092246092245092240092237092236092234092232Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



13382067147150476629137549140903238260164210161235171283776038

32

4041181139166438422

21244352534114164528826

19635773621615139481364796613776132488611044

4785115261491211305133997222307101

200322172614614816411635084691371822481011293

384224346316414655139515611683

158348211573812456515723588821221801211171351

30571397331017492097618341720

20229431318086206021711628582113221731761222

353936751914192214946371217132

15624025397066213131161211034472163361311026

343116124631210181582727624193

10514421234851121467625626421251897496

241955161918113135122141293

5261121229171116522837123384757324

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096044096043096041096039096037096036096033096032096030096028096025096024096022096020096014096013096008096002096001GStation

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



1120490474759253127983299337351191342304322741812222628280591

65125216916

7221152824663111172129112

116276971263430399979982613412941884961781

1346105686121610184711140256428

1253673103349412511511141354218362762124963574

15137115051918121444969192615

171567213337242449154118187454252751604543669

3419512615091710281069106365615

171746814344345048163142191645450661002645493

4124515545013191632127663136332

15075601133633684011999200666541232631263764

4724131054547141339787320251029

1206050782622352790731343444321437673544

3220129482679832799391347

78563250135129166034751833221615403122

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096091096084096076096072096071096069096068096066096064096061096058096055096054096053P

096052096050096048096046096045Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



26178444875262931842371180575420929228907241639291280052375

11

1317221291101

231912212111082632611

9183696399644292804224111611243400245371026

11544410327730368520927623

132151113448248134281682571401347325436480327

2491144116735838281712716803

2760130488116293071063171461509527439414549

11163720123712451919103476511

24891664351415429914338915215313215536385171

21110473025269622617302210645

1287414131213756213132301951151186342278164

371635441619185122143911105019

2643881951064916510819065808534441882051

6101516332114203113172479338

18366697623473791275245561225114747

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096127P

096125096124096122096121096120P

096119096116096115096114096112096111096108096106096102096097096094096093P

096092Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



71848756487409186886486557658417471734089291615745303847930

21

2581200214911340217

18516091611822225108961718

75486783641513074166105231714421532709320106281

10721272521912543445356221531371889

74558817501471291301071082412759516525712029141181

671764415171191254916831011523

11449896585213413089762313259613127314052127138

18111481910125134205024541651621

1355782216535136173489129615851541631255614673

2010113109171214865651037981517

975477166332123141346021454229199854710451

18151812621656112461120158116

89583994626768133282027288784364407716

81491946101444331111144113

51362743716456082012414450233325526

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096164096163096162096161096160096159096157096156096151096150096149096145096144096143096142096140096139096138096128Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



2461534121141615231951262129170560052465510943751173190371509724

3

544312201561131

1501719710224252297472

162592053111110136734042750571842822421274757

220364445231132149826128673710

19287219341820914723714673921964211222324886

670371256516611414514111612451011

34169200432036419718202717811119256112244883107

7482514599282414121116149310713

4111317466284272311115295741121745594415497105

7351813717937233581415227511828

46671286124532187108610473110131528031628096

71420314223332322313191693111436

292879441343111673971626178304715585887

94121921832017228117113210226

2516374011318822753453840192211353859

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096221096218096214096213096209096207096204096198G

096195096190096186096183096181096180096177096174096172096168096167Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



6291124932905533559431737166434831516182010578583591056911904

2

13383291333149

11135118311024112931532517

1710014513265415160338295513045688275980179

5287615610374583244111195101327

3117512212150495410330344550331999434105124159

42541206163454261627161516142121

691511491616175551053006479336512811545114155140

1131381718126293051529272316241920

761638016095116891082396128328518713148159170126

3331321414147193161834472118491519

1251573310289926677150504871851361345518511993

4230172111148171471927562317861013

1141111785546049417444358104147884013710651

31323121316616122112183912103498

707643141413333402628381057722776122

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096265096263096262096261096259096258096256096249096247096244096241096239096238096235096233096232096231096229096223Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



11983129413125791721370491206868811111135392404763175041384163

2

6122152115111117

276616211442725333274122

203212109644111262844084109554163623682586

3031131274198248222515463211333

187311408387171724934713215210602649417622919

3453896532109320334566246301

18945122428323176592029415412903379397724323

2934041012321650122031479226324

177568225110322288413610717515764969347222620

31922128392231192641291924112714

13659592922319288748415523902768238013931

14993107482612144341791895182

773912367151515027501001961225718528821

14321955018418373135147466

44284140989291526781038244313323611

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096315096314096313096311096310096303096297096296096295096293096290096287096286096285096279096271096269096267096266Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



180114834426441062863764179671211081151387120124841314001373941969

12

756134229245442112829

124941316121025461104125378171262

46416661282261119130862290196231651436383157143197

234218474722185281113013025156393362

3212064985178115106307105173207231892548181220175132

97287584011154620442252636429332433

185242588520013910831611312623152190636454231129114

37231253282114371723228263149422636

127248616212715412925813310418251196407932213130127

153772619192742131930193012107312235

5518769587810610318789581107013617691716711389

1033182916131423158101726394311717

3415440525686751217223635779113691048641

72214129111012145913211112363

16101333318414253451825484217221632512

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096347096343096342096340096339096337096336096335096333096332096330096329096327096326096324096321096318096317096316Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



61063003091107538631710192810041168869909607122330080843811985041398

511

1165245931221152240814213

1442301231203180178665417824175214

556977181575843803791371927192156247129784718925246

1413050331801271962331171249256191158438

749204351956512642391622121131168818465947212549239

3520813429784776212311725185219221228

11180829615759923324219220812415572153251218015356294

42234110329337571621181618361259291134

11293622914560114716917118513316061158281147112773195

24264842282103420171417538156331126

45769135122453861131181121431442012413128679890159

262492518641621112427102241232262724

5054584843054460637111491911399733726055

81431917602411191292291196162815

12337375017716353140647254985221335528

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096392096391096386096385096383096377096375096374096373096372096369096368096366096363G

096361096359096358096354096351Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



585965737529130312841629169513741613974248611517442371031591238

32239

114768386721197121

1652119163511764626544178

65941053123320928332639461277161482671005224

7292361182313617519881529215216166

8213611059211231162255208417883414769221447534

102616106528388020119155820917114

8614913386131216135225140120895712862341668740

91917144929246118420234531429102

1131509881130201118128761211148012397391728634

1132181733342124135252427441231189

671259692711361117180323948387134501448729

10348182318211254271824471130136

74995353338683424011685627310229867231

91912187122295125211437715112

41474241303939232055750345610734316

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096436096435096432096429096428096425096423096422096420096419096415096407096405096404096402096400096396096395096394Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



10141436974305924953228176673123722573911352103812533956552421523823

1132

14346174413122421122

91001428781277142219419348225

153280142493404634879130452551557115233764884280

201163362229360516294713231729212203711

148218158533391583189315340256183136181509538457110

14531953679619245562328441095455

17019117657038849221114216353442151361675712341571140

1432224979607933481023355681254725

182159132540311329271152383125326914715470105262104132

152319395340912284353035581014341627

126105103308219217339816123145186159140549920681124

111019473720511333713223258711231218

97737718713914416701071374812913810755581266169

9813301121116122711103133911211025

452543113715815335679297169532626554850

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096469096467096466096463096459096458096456096455096454096453096451096450096449096448096447096443096442096441096437Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



1317153577779722791328881140095282098618861561123484222817721942032

12311

325454340411171273071763

1368137377101472462968093219188

19037793915911809431716062231414298143613127718349

432296734429172646786714220024114472105

20229313310933721513822211989177294243179722333426233

323822148446199627142550631912931197

2252011401543692211441241711101321821811811063433228243

232516212630264218161936502719632489

21812917012722920913773861241031571672001352528035264

29189152140251419301929293827828369

157678110683152109487513180721131711402918240153

1612141311361114115058203243621237

9031517545939122691012846511059830962283

20368422177624109821281011216

56193554174443153458242427788710751142

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096516096514096509096507096505096504096501096498096497096493096491096489096487096485096484096479096474096473096471Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



7408371595326565371976626199619268141016101120491070991423879547

11

1414861233374318

7131461419731014661356615

5114732282553248330149075154981211201357013067

7231111210641357192172930382734671310

871207661383333973462941031651542191531955912880

81827111114712539015245947184539285

1091511844810963351033772211261981562841591622413976

12185494153617376019154076193617188

11813125950998278933271491561791363301951272099104

18759728431039391815466423232248

120932914512642078420161125106113283164941310272

20199613263012251316173198172321512

9768226194471465213437846074247954756957

18273102815161431510217814191129

74292061433390286319403136158573142234

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096567096566096559096558096556096553096551096550096548096547096546096545096544096541096537096536096526096523096522Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



1883294616671701620797509991961559229632410331025472119269754

2

112351315010324619

1221024104121217412131644467

194141432638116019430270439712418841763121

57921312021123132574192293122065

193351663111037881802914040363155140401356108

21042133152171821235153143591534

384477862718313911773211040763153105751323107

3761331144171446833372423103530

335597100265941911214726893313115010878241188

671131471351716254352422141437

23506687192801212399315824010133495318750

410731251312211322345318133310

174558761345510916222181184110417028727

6341312512374816312610138

11152744573427336876436727479313

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096609096608096607096605096604096600096599096597096596096595096593096591096589096586096585096584096579096575096573Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



10701452283844110316992471864135049411533969564701041775406722619

1224

1511422445482111331112

51744353319139322531028796328

3101776403612256502052423418231825743143935279

12519855916124019679393263421950918

15519056454136864225224974210551066222211628689

27207961616440832632829252017911

11420447869172109342621301001705513059232273710396

412153102413461641828124730519916

80250357751641033632282481505016349227519143101

2229381420203523014311635246331013

6523125766142113292413929129531305222471012172

9202411262124414721112991753128

40155131471046916183171178557421221619852

427189162224131201123365414

11101563673506986113632711615146330

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096652096648096645096644096643096641096636096635096634096633096632096630096628096627096625P

096624096621096614096612Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



91132292564142119001568622264451569629120916620614826126145

14

12321813215112313

548361161416145290124

892445439314496839252146122018181426357

2225371454371588371679512681

11833768236245171374738267881401521933499

201136955222115301850421293

136323741972852914831612967512029242235314

262181247646113113427297353101

132413106107306261434164238729128343036355

22372461223411312915665342

1325109462253221232187177873117322439347

352514962617215332225561181

1043273291931777146211873820221526163

231685271241116143311281

46524115120559830594149261330142

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096703096701096699096693096689096688096685096678096675096674096673096669096667096666096665096664096659096656096654Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



421179732317854541694137146191414772091437026669484950

3

2511414222

433832482982324413

21373027143433986813056592553546926

17134144101931510651081037

5162614215360571115802258173494111141004

11094522981112314937165134

7202121381576589109941282727141951413510

223599271217118516628113102

6192106551091051094125110572113126109201567

19481216154321216411310122231

8176674893841273104928641131168971335

42428519113611611132210313171

6123423554706863592321766647915

152012111033119111325672

1734022234956137362301244333603

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096747096745096741096736096732096731096726096725096724096723096721096720096718P

096717096716096715096711096710096706Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



230010331110447620143134690629620519838341508955147473

2322311

156414351522286

158533634207266313162528340134160

38291232123933151321

3796444522463110814262237366155361

6128356209636728310

371821259225854144362825627761691164

11301223462723146721715614

139195682325249124524143616811511376

17292281258332594717251921

5016822969316052142461821596841062760

15151131992716431911151710

351201116119540104371723421066792237

11214119112112644620189199

22725351484969178122813547623

Total

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

1997

1996

096797096789096786096782P

096780P

096779096774096772096770096767096765096764096763096762096758096753096751096750096749Station

From 1/1/2010 To 12/31/2010



9271745578464919333229929873935136063312151142921075173800629

2624

35199922336181571252

13935325219715813273311258393

131190644917529440512106258491839332442115657

2636108879165141641549311201627

156226566365303221010133232771783331512712667

2550109126692129364092256333513

14726694573439329131214123488262539713011194

2347911373710322274546253253317

17424810974396124928614418572105954353085116

2010 Annual Report July 2011 Prepared By Missouri ... · July 2011 Prepared By ... enforcement...

Documents

Transcript of 2010 Annual Report July 2011 Prepared By Missouri ... · July 2011 Prepared By ... enforcement...