2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

42
Gaming or Sharing at Lan-Parties What is going on? Fredrik Wallenberg, Marc Fetscherin, Charis Kaskiris University of California, Berkeley School of Information AxMedis Conference December 2, 2005

Transcript of 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Page 1: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Gaming or Sharing at Lan-PartiesWhat is going on?

Fredrik Wallenberg, Marc Fetscherin, Charis KaskirisUniversity of California, Berkeley

School of Information

AxMedis ConferenceDecember 2, 2005

Page 2: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Agenda

Introduction

Research Approach

Analyses and Results

Conclusion and Discussion

2

Page 3: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Why do we care?

3

Page 4: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Popular with Users

4

Page 5: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Piracy is costlyThe Software and Information Industry Association (SIIA) estimates these losses at about 12 billion USD per year across the world.

The International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI) came up with a figure of about 4.3 billion USD per year.

The Motion Picture Association (MPA) arrived at a value of about 3 billion USD per year.

5

Page 6: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Piracy is risky

6

Page 7: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Why Lan-Parties are Interesting

“right” demographics

high bandwidth

low risk of detection

7

Page 8: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

What is a Lan Party?

8

Page 9: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Big!

9

Page 10: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

High Performance Networks

10

Page 11: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Young males

11

Page 12: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Tournaments

12

Page 13: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Multi-Player Games

13

Page 14: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Social Event

14

Page 15: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Lots of them!

15

Page 16: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Agenda

Introduction

Research Approach

Analyses and Results

Conclusion and Discussion

16

Page 17: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

HypothesesH1: Gaming is the primary motivation for going to LAN-parties

H2: There is a unique group of “sharers” different than the “gamers.”

H3: Free-riding is less common at LAN-parties than...

H4: Greater bandwidth means larger files.

17

Page 18: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Methodology & Data Collection

LAN-Party # 1 2 3 4

Participants 400 50 300 500

Duration (days) 3 3 4 3

# Respondents 22 22 51 62

18

Page 19: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Agenda

Introduction

Research Approach

Analyses and Results

Conclusion and Discussion

19

Page 20: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

H1

Gaming is the primary motivation for going to LAN-parties

20

Page 21: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Why go to a LAN-Party?To participate in playing multi-user games

To share digital content files

To meet friends

To learn about new hacking/cracking

To attain information about regarding DRM

21

Page 22: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Are you here to game?

14.4

30.1

11.614.4

26.0

No!Yes!

22

Page 23: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Are you here to share?

16.4

32.2

10.3

26.7

12.3No!

Yes!

23

Page 24: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Many share files...Median # files Made Available Downloaded

Music 200 50

Movies 10 10

Software 5 5

24

Page 25: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

H2

There is a unique group of “sharers” different than the “gamers.”

25

Page 26: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Are “sharers” different from “gamers”?

26

Page 27: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

38 21 17 44 21 5 146

1 0 1 0 1 0 3

6 1 4 5 7 1 24

13 7 4 16 5 2 47

4 1 2 5 3 0 15

6 9 4 16 3 1 39

8 3 2 2 2 1 18

Pearson χ2 (25) = 24.50 Pr = 0.491Cramér's V = 0.18

gamma = 0.12 ASE = 0.090Kendall's τ-b = 0.09 ASE = 0.071

Are “sharers” different from “gamers”?

27

Page 28: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

26 27

23 33

Sharers

Non-Sharers

GamerNon-Gamer

28

Are “sharers” different from “gamers”?

Page 29: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Do Gamers Share?

axes: number of files shared/downloadedplot: quantiles

Quantile-Quantile Plot29

Page 30: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

H3

Free-riding is less common at LAN-parties than on P2P networks.

30

Page 31: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Free Riding

Free riding on P2P networks: Connect to the network without sharing any files.

Free riding at Lan-Parties: Download at least one file while sharing none.

We care because the value of a sharing network goes up the more content is being shared.

31

Page 32: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Sharing v. Downloading

32

Page 33: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Sharing v. Downloading

33

Page 34: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Free-Riding?

34

Page 35: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Free-Riding?

35

Page 36: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Comparison to P2P

36

Music Movies Software Total

Free Riders 28% 29% 28%

Adar /Huberman 70%

43%21%

E. Adar and B. A. Huberman. Free Riding on Gnutella. Technical report, Xerox PARC, August 2000.

Page 37: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

H4

Greater bandwidth leads to download of larger files.

37

Page 38: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

D/L: LAN-Parties v. P2P?

P2P Networks LAN-Parties

Music 69% 71%

Movies 25% 94%

Software 46% 73%

38

Page 39: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

D/L: Music/Movies Mix

P2P Networks LAN-PartiesFetscherin/Zaugg 13 : 1

5:1Film Distributers Association 13.6 : 1

M. Fetscherin and S. Zaugg. Music piracy on peer-to-peer networks. In IEEE International Conference on e-Technology, e-Commerce, and e-Service, Taipei, 2004. IEEE Computer Society.

F.  D. Association. Downloading danger. Technical report, Film Distributors’ Association, 2004.

39

Page 40: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

Agenda

Introduction

Research Approach

Analyses and Results

Conclusion and Discussion

40

Page 41: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

ConclusionWhile Lan-Parties officially caters to gamers, there is a lot of sharing going on.

Everybody shares.

There is less free-riding at the Lan-Parties than on P2P networks.

Features of Lan-Party networks promotes sharing of larger files.

This could predict sharing behavior on a higher bandwidth internet.

41

Page 42: 2005-Gaming or Sharing at Lan Parties: What is going on?

42

?