2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955...

71
Report School Survey to Collect Data on Material Performance Research Project No: 2005-003-B-08 The research described in this report was carried out by: Project Leader Penny Corrigan Researchers Angela Bradbury Ivan Cole Robin Drogemuller Stephen Egan Wayne Ganther Tim Muster David Paterson Gerry Trinidad Natalie Sherman Andrew Martin Wan Yee Chan Richi Nayak Esther Ge Project Affiliates Peter Hope Michael Ball Frank Turvey Lee Wade Wayne Muller Lex Vanderstaay Research Program: B Sustainable Built Assets Project: 2005-2003-B Learning System for Life Prediction of Infrastructure Date: June 2007

Transcript of 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955...

Page 1: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

Report School Survey to Collect Data on

Material Performance

Research Project No: 2005-003-B-08

The research described in this report was carried out by:

Project Leader Penny Corrigan Researchers Angela Bradbury Ivan Cole Robin Drogemuller Stephen Egan Wayne Ganther Tim Muster David Paterson Gerry Trinidad Natalie Sherman Andrew Martin Wan Yee Chan Richi Nayak Esther Ge Project Affiliates Peter Hope Michael Ball Frank Turvey Lee Wade Wayne Muller Lex Vanderstaay Research Program: B Sustainable Built Assets Project: 2005-2003-B Learning System for Life Prediction of Infrastructure Date: June 2007

Page 2: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

Distribution List Cooperative Research Centre for Construction Innovation Authors

Disclaimer The Client makes use of this Report or any information provided by the Cooperative Research Centre for Construction Innovation in relation to the Consultancy Services at its own risk. Construction Innovation will not be responsible for the results of any actions taken by the Client or third parties on the basis of the information in this Report or other information provided by Construction Innovation nor for any errors or omissions that may be contained in this Report. Construction Innovation expressly disclaims any liability or responsibility to any person in respect of any thing done or omitted to be done by any person in reliance on this Report or any information provided. © 2007 Icon.Net Pty Ltd

To the extent permitted by law, all rights are reserved and no part of this publication covered by copyright may be reproduced or copied in any form or by any means except with the written permission of Icon.Net Pty Ltd.

Please direct all enquiries to:

Chief Executive Officer Cooperative Research Centre for Construction Innovation 9th Floor, L Block, QUT, 2 George St Brisbane Qld 4000 AUSTRALIA T: 61 7 3138 9291 F: 61 7 3138 9151 E: [email protected] W: www.construction-innovation.info

Page 3: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

i

Table of Contents Page

List of Tables .............................................................................................................. ii

List of Figures ........................................................................................................... iii

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................. 1

1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 2

2 SURVEY METHODOLOGY ................................................................................. 2

2.1 Material Rating Used in Survey .................................................................. 10

3 SURVEY RESULTS ........................................................................................... 10

3.1 Analysis of Data ......................................................................................... 25

APPENDIX I-XXIV School Photograph Files………………………………………….28

APPENDIX XXV School Survey Data…………………………………………………..29

Page 4: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

ii

List of Tables Page

Table 1. Queensland School Details ............................................................................................ 6

Table 2. Victorian School Details .................................................................................................. 7 Table 3. Definition of Rating used for Components ...................................................................... 8 Table 4. Survey data for downpipes ........................................................................................... 17

Table 5. Survey data for flashing ................................................................................................ 18 Table 6. Survey data for gutters ................................................................................................. 19 Table 7. Survey data for ridge capping...................................................................................... 20

Table 8. Survey data for roofs .................................................................................................... 21

Table 9. Survey data for roof fasteners ...................................................................................... 22

Table 10. Survey data for steel supports .................................................................................... 23

Table 11. Survey data for windows ............................................................................................ 24

Table 12. Parameter Values for Colorbond® components ........................................................ 25

Table 13. Parameters for Zincalume components ..................................................................... 25

Table 14. Parameters for Galvanised components .................................................................... 26

Table 15. Parameters for Galvanised components .................................................................... 26

Table 16. Database of Service life determined from Survey data. ............................................. 27

Page 5: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

iii

List of Figures Page

Figure 1. Locations of the different areas surveyed, chosen to give a range of climates ............ 3

Figure 2. Locations of Sunshine Coast schools surveyed in 2007 and 2005 .............................. 4

Figure 3. Locations of the Townsville schools .............................................................................. 5 Figure 4. Locations of the Victorian schools, in Melbourne and on the surf coast ....................... 5

Figure 5: Photographs depicting the various rating categories for the different components and materials ............................................................................................................................. 11

Figure 6. The Colorbond data for roofs in graphical form .......................................................... 12

Page 6: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

1

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY A survey of a number of schools in a number of different climates was carried out to determine the condition of building components of interest in the project. Schools in Melbourne, the Victorian Surf Coast, Brisbane, Townsville and the Sunshine Coast were inspected. A rating system was devised to categorise the components and the results collated in tables. Analysis of the data (where sufficient examples permitted) resulted in formulae to predict the service of the components and a database was derived.

Page 7: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

2

1 INTRODUCTION This project is developing a program to access a number of sources of data on service lifetimes of metallic building components. Originally it was planned to utilise the Queensland Department of Public Works database of maintenance activities to develop a lifetime database giving information based on current usage and updating as more events were entered by the actual maintainers reflecting ongoing upkeep of the schools’ infrastructure. Maintenance information is seen as being a particularly useful source of data about service life of building components as it relates to actual performance of materials in the working environment. Access was granted to a number of databases recording maintenance activities in Queensland Government Housing. However, analysis of the information indicated that entries did not give information in fine enough detail to enable extraction of data for the individual building components being considered in the current work. An alternative approach was devised to estimate the performance of materials in the field. This involved a survey of a range of schools with inspection of the building components of relevance to the current work. These were given a rating indicating the current condition of the structure and the age of the buildings was also ascertained. This data collected was also used to validate the modifications made to the holistic model for the different building components.

2 SURVEY METHODOLOGY Schools were chosen to give a wide range of climates and corrosivity levels (related to salt levels). At least three schools in each category were chosen, where possible with different ages. Three climates were looked at:

• Tropical (Townsville) • Subtropical (Brisbane and Sunshine Coast) • Temperate (Melbourne and southern coast of Victoria)

Figure 1 shows the locations of the school areas surveyed in the Eastern part of Australia. Within these climates corrosive severity levels can be classified as

• Severe marine (within 3km of the coast) • Coastal (3-10km from coast) • Inland (>10km from coast)

Ideally all three corrosivity levels in each of the three climate types would be surveyed, but this was not possible. The categories looked at are:

• Tropical Coastal • Subtropical Marine • Subtropical inland • Temperate Marine

Page 8: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

3

• Temperate Inland

Figure 1. Locations of the different areas surveyed, chosen to give a range of climates

The Sunshine Coast schools surveyed are shown in more detail in Figure 2. A number of schools were looked at in 2005 as part of the earlier phase of this project and they are indicated in the map as well. The locations of the Townsville schools are shown in Figure 3 and those of the Victorian schools surveyed in Figure 4. A list of all the Queensland schools surveyed is given in Table 1 along with details such as longitude and latitude and distance from the ocean. In some cases two figures are given indicating the distance from a sheltered beach on an inlet and the actual distance from the nearest ocean beach. Similar details are given for the Victorian schools visited in Table 2. Not all the schools visited had the full array of metal components of interest. In particular it was difficult to gain information for the sub-floor components, as many schools had wooden and concrete footings rather than metal. These were more prevalent on portable classrooms but they were not included in the survey as their location history is unknown and the condition of metal components may have been affected by previous environments. At each school, the relevant building components on a number of buildings were identified as to material and the condition rated, noting the orientation and degree of sheltering etc. Photographs taken are documented in a series of appendices (I –XXVII) in separate files (due to the size).

Melbourne

Surf Coast

Brisbane

Sunshine Coast

Townsville

Page 9: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

4

Figure 2. Locations of Sunshine Coast schools surveyed in 2007 and 2005.

Surveyed in 2005 ~2km

Page 10: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

5

Figure 3. Locations of the Townsville schools

Figure 4. Locations of the Victorian schools, in Melbourne and on the surf coast.

Page 11: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

6

Table 1. Queensland School Details School Code

School Name Year opened

Address Line 1 Address Line 2 Post Code

Longitude Latitude Distance from Coast

Sunshine Coast (Degrees) (Degrees) (KM) 1888 Buddina State School 1979 Cnr Tumut Street and Iluka Avenue Buddina 4575 153.1329 -26.7018 0.3 2165 Coolum State High School Havana Road Coolum 4573 153.0856 -26.5005 1.0 1571 Coolum State School 1917 School Road Coolum Beach 4573 153.0771 -26.5349 1.6 1818 Mooloolaba State School 1930 Cnr Meta & Douglas Streets Mooloolaba 4557 153.1146 -26.6782 0.3** 2190 Mountain Creek State High School 1995 Lady Musgrave Drive Mountain Creek 4557 153.1031 -26.6867 2-3* 1999 Mountain Creek State School 1994 Lady Musgrave Drive Mountain Creek 4557 153.1027 -26.6903 2-3* 1991 Pacific Paradise State School 1992 14-24 Menzies Drive Pacific Paradise 4564 153.0810 -26.6126 2.0 2108 Sunshine Beach State High School 1992 45 Ben Lexcen Drive Sunshine Beach 4567 153.0996 -26.4085 1.2 1917 Sunshine Beach State School 1982 David Low Way Sunshine Beach 4567 153.1011 -26.4018 1.2 Townsville 2186 William Ross State High School 1991 Mervyn Crossman Drive Annandale 4814 146.7999 -19.3174 7 2120 Heatley Secondary College 1968 Cnr Hanlon Street and Fulham Road Heatley 4814 146.7557 -19.2899 7 305 Heatley State School 1971 410 Fulham Road Heatley 4814 146.7557 -19.2899 7 1862 Kirwan State School 1977 21 Burnda Street Kirwan 4817 146.7335 -19.2990 9 2146 Kirwan State High School 1979 Hudson Street Kirwan 4817 146.7321 -19.3086 10 287 The Willows State School 1997 Bilberry Street Kirwan 4817 146.7241 -19.3066 10 Brisbane 923 Kenmore State School 2052 Moggill Road Kenmore 4069 152.9394 -27.5093 25-53* 1872 Chapel Hill State School 1978 Ironbark Road Chapel Hill 4069 152.9435 -27.5006 25-53* 16 Brookfield State School Boscombe Road Brookfield 4069 152.9136 -27.4962 25-53* 2053 The Gap State High School 1020 Waterworks Road The Gap 4061 152.9502 -27.4461 20-50* 1302 The Gap State School 1912 Cnr Waterworks & Settlement Roads The Gap 4061 152.9443 -27.4427 20-50* 286 Payne Road State School 1970 171 Payne Road The Gap 4061 152.9516 -27.4483 20-50* 1887 Hilder Road State School 1980 Cnr Kaloma and Hilder Roads The Gap 4061 152.9378 -27.4382 20-50*

* near sheltered beach and open ocean ie. 25-53 is 25KM to sheltered beach and 53KM to open ocean ** slightly sheltered beach

Page 12: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

7

Table 2., Victorian School Details School Code

School Name Year opened

Address Line 1 Address Line 2 Post Code

Longitude Latitude Distance from Coast

Surf Coast (Degrees) (Degrees) (KM) 4332 Anglesea Primary School Camp Rd Anglesea 3230 144.1771 -38.4188 1 1574 Barwon Heads Primary School 1950 Golf Links Rd Barwon Heads 3227 144.4868 -38.2812 1 3368 Torquay Primary School 2000 P O Box 51 Torquay 3228 144.3242 -38.3327 1.5 2162 Lorne - Aireys Inlet P-12 School 1879 Grove Road Lorne 3232 143.9750 -38.5419 0.4 Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary School 1889 185 Whitehorse Rd Blackburn 3130 145.1581 -37.8172 16-70* 4860 Blackburn Lake Primary School 1964 Florence St Blackburn 3130 145.1656 -37.8272 16-70* 4863 Laburnum Primary School 1964 Janet St Blackburn 3130 145.1396 -37.8268 16-70*

* near sheltered beach and open ocean ie. 25-53 is 25KM to sheltered beach and 53KM to open ocean ** slightly sheltered beach

Page 13: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

8

Table 3. Definition of Rating used for Components

Damage Rating 0 1 2 3 4 5

Component Material As New Shows signs of Age

Needs maintenance Significant Maintenance required

Planning for replacement

Needs replacement

Roof Sheeting Ridge Cap Flashings Gang Nails Steel Supports

Coated Steel

No Damage

Some loss of paint gloss/coating (Top coat only on multi-coat systems), dulling of surface

Loss of paint (chips lost, peeling, undercoat may still be intact), White corrosion product less than 50%, red rust on cut edges

Some red rust present, less than 50% of a particular area, White corrosion product greater than 50%

50- 100% red rust

Perforation

Aluminium No Damage

Dulling of Surface White and/or Grey Corrosion Product <50% coverage and/or signs of pitting

Pitting/Black Corrosion Product <50% coverage, No perforation

Significant pitting >50% coverage, No perforation

Perforation

Fasteners No Damage

Some loss of paint coating (if applied), often mechanical damage during installation

White corrosion product (more than 25%) on less than 50% of fasteners

Red rust present, on any fasteners but more than spotting

Red rust (>25%) present on all fasteners

100% Red rust, on more than 50% of fasteners

Gutters Down Pipes

Coated Steel (For Al see above)

No Damage

Some loss of paint gloss/coating (Top coat only on multi-coat systems), dulling of surface

Loss of paint (chips lost, peeling, undercoat may still be intact), White corrosion product less than 50%, red rust on cut edges or spotting

Some red rust present, less than 50% of a particular area, White corrosion product greater than 50%

Red Rust >50% of Inside bottom of Gutter or Downpipe

Perforation

Page 14: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

9

Table 3. (cont) Definition of Rating used for Components

Damage Rating 0 1 2 3 4 5

Component Material As New Shows signs of Age

Needs maintenance Significant Maintenance required

Planning for replacement

Needs replacement

Windows Bare and Anodised

No Damage

Loss of new look, loss of gloss or staining

Corrosion Product present <10%, at joins or other

White corrosion product less than 50%,

> 50% WCP Perforation or loss of window

Painted No Damage

Some loss of paint gloss/coating (Top coat only on multi

Undercutting of paint, White Corrosion Product present <10%, at joins or other

Loss of paint (chips lost, peeling), White corrosion product less than 50%,

>50% paint loss and > 50% WCP

function, Jamming etc.

Page 15: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

10

2.1 Material Rating Used in Survey The components in the survey were rated using the following scheme:

0. As new 1. Shows signs of age 2. Needs maintenance 3. Significant maintenance required 4. Planning for replacement 5. Needs replacement

How these different categories relate to the conditions of the components is detailed in Table 3. Indicative photos depicting the condition of the components are shown in Figure 5 (on the following pages). Not all ratings for each component were found or photographed in the survey.

3 SURVEY RESULTS The raw data for all the schools surveyed is presented in Appendix XXVIII. The data has been reformatted in Tables 4 -11 which show the ratings for the different components categorised for the different environments. The information for Colorbond roofs is graphed in Figure 6.

Colorbond Roofs

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

Years

Rat

ing

TropicalSub-TropicalTemperateSub-Tropical MarineTemperate Marine

Figure 6. The Colorbond data for roofs in graphical form.

Page 16: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

11

Roof rating a) Colorbond

0 1 2

b) Zincalume 1 2 3

Figure 5: Photographs depicting the various rating categories for the different components and materials

Page 17: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

12

c) Galvanised steel

3 4 5

Gutters

a) Colorbond

1 2 3

Figure 5(cont): Photographs depicting the various rating categories for the different components and materials

Page 18: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

13

b) Zincalume (painted outside)

3 4 5

c) Galvanised (painted outside)

2 4 5

Figure 5(cont): Photographs depicting the various rating categories for the different components and materials

Page 19: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

14

Gangnails 3 4

Flashings 3 (Aluminium) 5 (Galvanised)

Figure 5(cont): Photographs depicting the various rating categories for the different components and materials

Page 20: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

15

Downpipes Colorbond 1 2.5 3

Windows anodized Al 1 2. 3

Figure 5(cont): Photographs depicting the various rating categories for the different components and materials

Page 21: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

16

Steel supports - Galvanised 0 1 2

Fasteners – galvanised 0 1 3 5

Figure 5(cont): Photographs depicting the various rating categories for the different components and materials

Page 22: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

17

Table 4. Survey data for downpipes

Tropical Sub-tropical inland Temperate Inland Sub-tropical Marine Temperate Marine

Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R CB 10 2 CB 10 1 CB 3 2 CB 9 1.5 CB 2 1Painted steel 37 5 CB 27 2.5 CB 3 1 CB 13 3 CB 7 2Painted ZA 7 1.5 CB 3 2 CB 15 2.5 CB 7 2CB 10 1 CB 5 1.5 CB 22 1 CB 15

CB

CB 8 1

Inbuilt structural, steel 22 2 CB 15 5

Gal 8 3 CB 12 2 Painted ZA 21 3 Gal 20 3Painted steel 27 5

Gal painted 12 1 Plastic 2 0 Painted gal 20 5

Painted ZA 16 2

Gal painted 12 1

Painted Heavy section Gal 10 2

Gal painted 25 3 ZA 6 2.5 Painted 12 2 ZA 6 2.5 ZA 3 1 ZA 6 2

ZA 5 1.5 ZA painted

outside 10 2

ZA 20 1.5 ZA painted

outside 1

ZA painted outside 15 2

Page 23: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

18

Table 5. Survey data for flashing

Tropical Sub-tropical inland Temperate Inland Sub-tropical Marine Temperate Marine

Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R CB 8 2.5 Gal 18 2.5 CB 3 1 Al 16 3 CB 2 0CB 2 Gal 27 2.5 CB 3 1 Al 17 2.5 CB 6 1.5Gal 27 4.5 Gal 27 2 CB 3 1 CB 5 2 Gal 15 2.5 Gal 37 2 CB 3 1 CB 12 1.5 CB 5 1.5 CB 13 1.5 CB 12 1 CB 15 2.5 Gal 12 3 ZA Painted 15 2 Gal 15 2.5 Gal 25 4 ZA 10 2

Page 24: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

19

Table 6. Survey data for gutters

Tropical Sub-tropical inland Temperate Inland Sub-tropical Marine Temperate Marine Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R

CB 0 CB 4 2 3 1 75 Al 16 3 gal 20 5CB 1 1 CB 6 2 3 1 75 Al 25 2.5 ZA 1CB 7 2 CB 6 2 3 1 75 Al 30 1 Gal 7 2CB 10 2.5 CB 9 2 5 2 75 CB 2 0 Gal 15 2CB 10 2 CB 9 1.5 5 1 75 CB 12 1 Gal 20 2.5CB 2 CB 10 3 5 1 75 CB 12 1 Gal 20 2.5CB Single Top Coat 16 2 CB 27 2 8 2 80 CB 15 1 CB 2 0CB Single Top Coat 16 2 CB 27 2 8 0 50 CB 22 1 CB 6 1

CB XRW 8 2.5 CB 37 1 8 1 75CB double sided 5 1.5 CB 6 1

Painted Gal or ZA 27 5 CB 2 12 1 75

CB double sided 9 2 CB 6 1

Painted ZA 27 3 Painted Gal 37 4 15 1.5 80

CB Double Sided 13 1 CB 7 2

Painted ZA 3 Painted Gal 47 5 20 2 75

CB Galvanised inside 22 5 CB 7 2

Painted ZA 5 Stainless Steel 7 0 12 1 50 Painted Al 28 2 CB 10 1.5

Stainless Steel 1

Stainless Steel 7 0 12 1 75

ZA Painted outside 15 2 CB 15 2

Painted Gal 3 2 ZA 18 3 25 3.5 50ZA Painted outside 21 5 CB 15 2

ZA 27 2 3 1 75

ZA Painted outside 30 3 CB 15 2

ZA 31 2.5 15 1 50 CB 20 2

Page 25: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

20

Table 6 (cont). Survey data for gutters

Tropical Sub-tropical inland Temperate Inland Sub-tropical Marine Temperate Marine Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R

ZA painted outside 27 5 10 1.5 25

CB 20 2 ZA

painted outside 27 3 20 4 75

Painted Gal 20 5

ZA painted outside 27 4 15 4 50

Painted Gal 20 5

ZA painted outside 31 4

ZA painted outside 37 3

ZA painted outside 47 4

Table 7. Survey data for ridge capping

Tropical Sub-tropical inland Temperate Inland Sub-tropical Marine Temperate Marine

Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R CB 10 1 CB 6 0 CB 8 1.5 CB 15 1 CB 2 0ZA 27 2.5 CB 9 2 CB 15 1 CB 22 1 CB 10 1 ZA 27 1 Gal 12 4 CB 15 1 ZA 31 4 Gal 20 3 CB 20 2 ZA 31 3 ZA 10 2 CB 20 2 ZA 15 1 Gal 20 3

Page 26: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

21

Table 8. Survey data for roofs

Tropical Sub-tropical inland Temperate Inland Sub-tropical Marine Temperate Marine

Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R CB 1 0 CB 4 1.5 CB 3 1 Al 16 1 CB 2 0CB 3 2 CB 6 0 CB 3 1 Al 17 2.5 CB 6 1CB 7 2.5 CB 6 1.5 CB 3 1 Al 22 2 CB 7 1CB 8 2.5 CB 9 2 CB 5 1.5 Al 25 1.5 CB 7 1CB 8 1.5 CB 9 2 CB 5 1.5 Al 25 3 CB 7 1CB 10 1 CB 10 3 CB 7 1 Al 28 4 CB 10 1CB 10 1 CB 27 2.5 CB 8 1 CB 2 0 CB 10 1Gal 36 5 CB 27 2 CB 12 1 CB 5 1.5 CB 10 1Gal 37 3 CB 37 3 CB 15 2 CB 9 2.5 CB 15 2Gal Kliplock 27 3 CB 2.5 Gal 5 1.5 CB 9 3 CB 15 2

Painted Gal 37 5

Kliplock deck, top painted

3

Gal 12 2 CB 12 1 CB 20 2ZA 9 2.5 Gal 27 3 Gal 12 3 CB 12 1 CB 20 2

ZA 16 3.5

Galv sheet corrugated top painted

4

Gal 12 2 CB 13 1.5 Gal 20 5

ZA 16 2.5 Painted Gal 37 2 Gal 12 2.5 CB 15 2 Gal 20 3.5

ZA 27 2.5 ZA 18 2.5 Gal 12 2.5 CB 15 1 Gal 35 2.5

ZA 27 3 ZA 27 1 Gal 20 3 CB 15 2Gal painted 20 1

ZA 27 3 Gal 25 3 CB 22 2.5 ZA 27 3 Gal 51 3.5 CB 22 1 ZA 27 3 Gal 3 CB 28 3 ZA 27 3 Gal 3 Gal Kliplock 36 3.5 ZA 27 3 ZA 3 1.5 ZA 10 1.5 ZA 31 3 ZA 5 1 ZA 21 3

Page 27: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

22

Table 8 (cont) Survey data for roofs Tropical Sub-tropical inland Temperate Inland Sub-tropical Marine Temperate Marine

Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R ZA 31 1 ZA 8 2 ZA 25 3 ZA 31 2 ZA 8 0.5 ZA 30 2.5 ZA 31 3 ZA 10 2 ZA 37 2 ZA 12 2 ZA 47 2 ZA 15 1.5 ZA 2 ZA 15 1.5 ZA 1 ZA 20 0 ZA 1 ZA 2

Table 9. Survey data for roof fasteners Tropical Sub-tropical inland Temperate Inland Sub-tropical Marine Temperate Marine

Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R B1 non cyclone 16 3 Gal 18 2 Gal 3 0 Painted 2 0 Gal 10 3B4 1 1 Gal 27 2 Gal 3 1 Painted 12 1 gal 20 2.5Buildex class4 Zinc 9 2 Gal 31 2 Gal 8 0 Painted 12 4 Gal nails 20 2Buildex Painted 8 1 Gal 31 5 Gal 12 1 Painted 15 1 Nails 20 4Bx 10 3 Gal 37 5 Gal 12 4 Painted 22 2.5 Painted 2 0Bx Cyclone 16 2 Painted 4 1.5 Gal 12 1.5 Painted 28 4 Painted 6 2.5

Gal 27 Painted 6 0 Gal 15 3Stainless Steel 22 2 Painted 6 5

Gal 1 Painted 6 1.5 Gal 15 3.5 Painted 6 2Gal Bx 16 2 Painted 9 1 Painted 3 0 Painted 6 2Painted 7 1.5 Painted 10 3 Painted 7 1 Painted 7 2Painted 10 3 Painted 27 2 Painted 8 1 painted 7 2Painted Bx 3 1 Painted 27 1.5 painted 10 3 Painted 15 3Painted Bx 8 3 Painted 31 4 Painted 12 1.5 Painted 15 3 Painted 1 Painted 15 1.5 Painted 20 5 Painted 20 5

Page 28: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

23

Table 10. Survey data for steel supports

Tropical Sub-tropical inland Temperate Inland Sub-tropical Marine Temperate Marine

Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Gal 8 1 Painted 27 2 Gal 3 1 Gal 2 0 Gal 6 2Galvaspan G92075P11 4.195 1

Painted Gal 10 1 Gal 7 1 Gal steel 15 2 Gal 7 1

Painted 10 1 Painted Gal 17 2 Painted 5 1 Gal steel 17 1 Gal 15 2

Painted (Gal?) 3 0

Painted Gal 37 3 Painted 8 2 Gal steel 25 2

Painted steel 10 1

Painted steel 16 1

Painted steel 9 2 Painted 12 1

Painted Gal steel 12 1

Painted steel 16 2

Painted Steel 18 3 Painted 12 1 Painted steel 9 2

Painted steel 27 2

Painted steel 27 2 Painted steel 21 2

Painted steel 27 1

Painted Steel 27 3 Painted steel 21 2

Painted steel 1

Painted steel 31 1 Painted Steel 22 2

Uprights Painted gal

Painted steel 31 2 Painted steel 36 3

Painted steel 37 3

Painted Steel 47 2

Painted steel 2

Painted steel 1

Page 29: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

24

Table 11. Survey data for windows

Tropical Sub-tropical inland Temperate Inland Sub-tropical Marine Temperate Marine

Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Type Age R Al mesh screens 2.5 Al 10 1 Al 5 1 Al 22 1.5 Al 2 0

Anodised Al 3 1.5 Al anodised 37 2 Al 12 1 Aluminium 15

Powdercoated Al 6 2

Anodised Al 8 1 Anodised Al 18 3

Powdercoated Al 0 0 Anodised Al 9 1

Powdercoated Al 6 2

Anodised Al 16 1.5 Anodised Al 27 3

Powdercoated Al 3 1 Anodised Al 12 1

Powdercoated Al 7 1

Anodised Al 16 2 Painted Al 9 2

Powdercoated Al 5 1 Anodised Al 15 1.5

Powdercoated Al 7 1

Powdercoated Al 7 2

Powdercoated Al 12 1 Anodised Al 21 1

Powdercoated Al 10 2

Anodised Al 28 2.5Powdercoated Al 15 2

Anodised painted 13 2

Powdercoated Al 20 1

Page 30: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

25

3.1 Analysis of Data The data for the different components were graphed separately for each material and environment type. In some cases there were very limited data points, but the points were used to estimate an exponential line of best fit using the equation: Damage = A * ln(life) – B …Eqn (1) Where Damage is the rating system (from 0-5) life is the age of the component in years A, B are constants In some cases there appeared to be two rates of material aging so these were separated in two sets of data: “normal” and “accelerated”. Equation 1 was used to estimate the service life of all the components surveyed. A and B were determined for the different materials and environments. 3.1.1 Colorbond® Components For Colorbond® the formula was used to estimate the time to reach Rating 3 and then 10 years was added. Table 12 shows the values estimated for A and B from the survey data. Table 12. Parameter Values for Colorbond® components Component Environment A BRoof Normal 1.27 -1.84 Roof Accelerated 1.30 -0.38 Roof Tropical 1.18 -1.5 Roof Tropical acclerated 1.3 0 Downpipes normal 1.13 -0.95 Down pipes accelerated 1.39 0 Gutters normal 1.2 -1.9 Gutters tropical 0.99 -0.043 Gutters acclerated 1.30 -0.67 3.1.2 Zincalume Components Equation (1) was used to calculate the years to reach Rating 3 and then D was added to give service life. Values for A, B and D are given in Table 13. Table 13. Parameters for Zincalume components Component Environment A B D Roof Sub tropical normal 1.28 -1.80 9 Roof accelerated 1.28 -0.50 9 Roof tropical 1.28 -1.43 9 Roof temperate 1.28 -1.43 9 Downpipes normal 1.25 -2.2 9 Down pipes accelerated 1.31 -0.37 6 Gutters normal 1.26 -1.29 9 Gutters accelerated 1.31 -0.075 6 Ridge cap normal 1.18 -1.2 9

Page 31: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

26

3.1.3 Galvanised Components Equation (1) was used to calculate the years to reach Rating 3 and then D was added to give service life. Values for A, B and D are given in Table 14. Table 14. Parameters for Galvanised components Component Environment A B D Roof normal 1.1 -0.64 8 Roof accelerated 1.3 -0.48 8 Downpipes normal 1.1 -1.58 8 Down pipes accelerated 1.31 -0.37 5 Gutters normal 2.52 -4.9 8 Flashing normal 1.1 -1.1 8 Flashing accelerated 1.22 -0.18 8 Fasteners normal 1.36 -1.1 * Fasteners accelerated 1.38 -0.06 * * For fasteners the formulae were used to calculate the time to reach Rating 5 to give the predicted service life. Therefore D is not applicable 3.1.4 Aluminium Components Equation (1) was used to calculate the years to reach Rating 3 and then D was added to give service life. Values for A, B and D are given in Table 15. Table 15. Parameters for Galvanised components Component Environment A B D Windows normal 0.92 -0.68 10 Windows accelerated 1.0 -0.04 10 Powder coated normal 0.53 -0.05 10 Powder coated accelerated 0.89 -0.14 10 Fasteners normal 1.36 -1.1 5 Fasteners accelerated 1.36 -0.06 5 3.1.5 Database The results of applying these formulae to the components surveyed to estimate the remaining life is consolidated into Table 16. Service life determined to be more the 50 years is quoted as >50 in all cases.

Page 32: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

27

Table 16. Database of Service life determined from Survey data. Component Material Environment Severity Life (years)roof galvanised All normal 35 roof galvanised All accelerated 23 downpipes galvanised All normal >50 downpipes galvanised All accelerated 18 gutters galvanised All normal 31 flashing galvanised All normal 50 flashing galvanised All accelerated 19 roof zincalume Sub-tropical normal >50 roof zincalume Tropical Normal 41 roof zincalume Temperate Normal 41 roof zincalume All accelerated 24 downpipes zincalume All normal >50 downpipes zincalume All accelerated 18 gutters zincalume All normal 39 gutters zincalume All accelerated 15 ridge cap zincalume All normal 44 window Al anodized All normal >50 window Al anodized All accelerated 31 window Powder coated All normal >50 window Powder coated All accelerated 48 roof Colorbond Temperate and

Sub-tropical normal >50

roof Colorbond Temperate and Sub-tropical

accelerated 25

roof Colorbond Tropical normal >50 roof Colorbond Tropical accelerated 22 gutters Colorbond Temperate and

Sub-tropical normal >50

gutters Colorbond Tropical normal 34 gutters Colorbond All accelerated 29 downpipes Colorbond All normal 45 downpipes Colorbond All accelerated 21 fasteners galvanised All accelerated 38 fasteners galvanised All normal >50

Page 33: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

28

APPENDIX I – XXVII School Photograph Files The plans and photographs taken at the various schools are collated into a series of separate files. I Anglesea Primary School II Barwon Heads Primary School III Blackburn Primary School IV Brookfield State School V Buddina State School VI Chapel Hill State School VII Coolum High School VIII Coolum State School IX Heatley High School X Heatley State School XI Hilder Road State School XII Kenmore State School XIII Kirwan High School XIV Laburnum Primary School XV Lorne P-12 College XVI Mooloolaba State School XVII Mountain Creek High School XVIII Mountain Creek State School XIX Pacific Paradise State School XX Payne Road State School XXI Sunshine Beach Secondary School XXII Sunshine Beach State School XXIII The Gap High School XXIV The Gap State School XXV The Willows State School XXVI Torquay Primary School XXVII William Ross High School

Page 34: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

29

APPENDIX XXVIII School Survey Data The raw data from the schools survey is presented in the following table. RR = red rust WCP = white corrosion product

Page 35: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

30

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating William Ross HS Townsville GB Roof CB 3 Dirty but Glossy RR at defects only 2 William Ross HS Townsville GB Roof Fasteners Painted Bx 3 perfect except Mech Damage 1 William Ross HS Townsville GB Gutters inside Painted Gal 3 50% Black 50% White Wall has RR spots 2 William Ross HS Townsville GB Gutters outside Painted Gal 3 Fine 1 William Ross HS Townsville GB Windows Anodised Al 3 Small Pits on Frame base 1.5 William Ross HS Townsville GB Steel Supports Painted (Gal?) 3 Good 0

William Ross HS Townsville GA Roof ZA 16

Dull & Dirty but mostly shiny, edge corrosion up to 2mm, grey spots up to 1inch with 50%RR 3.5

William Ross HS Townsville GA Roof Underside ZA 16 >50% Coating Loss, WCP&BCP, spots of RR 3

William Ross HS Townsville GA Roof Fasteners Gal Bx 16 Significant WCP around some 2

William Ross HS Townsville GA Windows Anodised Al 16 Fine pits on bottom surface ~500µm dia, spaced ~3mm Apart 1.5

William Ross HS Townsville GA Steel Supports Painted steel 16 Maintained with Thick paint 1

William Ross HS Townsville GA Gutters outside CB Single Top Coat 16 Hangers have undercutting up to 50mm, average 20mm Top coat is chalking 2

William Ross HS Townsville GA Gutters inside CB Single Top Coat 16 Dirty, RR spotting at internal bends, also on side walls 2

William Ross HS Townsville Canteen Gutters outside CB Single Top Coat 16 Hangers have undercutting up to 50mm, average 20mm Top coat is chalking 2

William Ross HS Townsville Canteen Gutters inside CB Single Top Coat 16 Dirty, RR spotting at internal bends, also on side walls 2

William Ross HS Townsville Canteen Roof ZA 16 Black Spots, RR in some grooves and folds 2.5

William Ross HS Townsville Canteen Roof Fasteners B1 non cyclone 16 All 20%RR 3 William Ross HS Townsville Canteen Roof Fasteners Bx Cyclone 16 Plates ZA grey,10%wcp rr spots on some 2

William Ross HS Townsville Canteen Downpipes Painted ZA 16

Delamination of paint at both ends up to 3inches, RR damage also up to 3 inches from base & large RR spots at top cut end ~5mm in dia 2

William Ross HS Townsville Canteen Windows Anodised Al 16

Damage at bottom panels; WCP spots up to 3mm Dia. Maybe associated with concrete splashing. No other damage 2

Page 36: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

31

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating William Ross HS Townsville Canteen Steel Supports Painted steel 16 Railings have rr where paint is damaged 2

Heatley Sec Townsville K Manual Arts Bldng Roof ZA 27

Dull Clean but not cleaned, Dull, Grey-black spots in places, more prevalent at bottom of roof sheeting, some red streaks, appear to be from small red spotting 2.5

Heatley Sec Townsville K Manual Arts Bldng Roof Fasteners Gal 27

50% of fasteners have 100% rr, remainder have some rr and wcp

Heatley Sec Townsville K Manual Arts Bldng Gutters CB 0

Heatley Sec Townsville K Manual Arts Bldng Gutter North side Painted Gal or ZA 27 Totally Rusted out 5

Heatley Sec Townsville K Manual Arts Bldng Flashings Gal 27

Zinc almost gone, some Black spots, 1005 WCP in pustules, RR at joins severe in places up to 30-40mm, some has rusted away 4.5

Heatley Sec Townsville ICT centre Roof CB 7 North facing, dull & dirty, clean, shine has gone, RR spots mainly in crevices 2.5

Heatley Sec Townsville ICT centre Roof Fasteners Painted 7 Mechanical damage with some WCP 1.5

Heatley Sec Townsville ICT centre Gutter CB 7 Damage where gutter is pushed into downpipe, RR spots 2

Heatley Sec Townsville ICT centre Down pipes Painted ZA 7 Outside good, inside OK except where water drips into it inside 1.5

Heatley Sec Townsville ICT centre Windows Powdercoated Al 7

Louvre's corroding in btn seals & paint Al- presumably where moisture is trapped. General Damage of some powder coated windows 2

Heatley Sec Townsville Walkways Roof top ZA 27 Moderately dirty, not much edge damage, flat, some black spots, spots of RR 2.5

Heatley Sec Townsville Walkways Roof Underside ZA 27 >50% black and grey spots 3

Heatley Sec Townsville Walkways Gutters Painted ZA outside 27

New sections added in 2006, wcp on edges 100%, RR up to 20mm in spots and on edge, no perforations 3

Heatley Sec Townsville Walkways Painted ZA inside 27 Maintained paint Heatley Sec Townsville Walkways Steel Supports Painted steel 27 Condition OK 1

Heatley State Townsville Bldng B Roof Gal 37 Flat no cleaning, 80% WCP pustules, 10% RR 3

Page 37: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

32

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Heatley State Townsville Bldng B Roof Underside Gal Almost totally covered with a fine film of WCP, some larger pustules of WCP 3

Heatley State Townsville Bldng B Roof Fasteners Gal Not as old as roof sheets, in good condition 1

Heatley State Townsville Bldng B Gutters inside Painted ZA Not clean inch of leaves and mud, 30% RR 3

Heatley State Townsville Bldng B Gutters edges Painted ZA 50% WCP, spots of RR 3 Heatley State Townsville Bldng B Gutters outside Painted ZA dull & dirty , damage around holes 2 Heatley State Townsville Bldng B Windows AL mesh screens Widespread small pits 2.5 Heatley State Townsville Bldng B Steel Supports Painted steel Look fine particularly the uprights 1

Heatley State Townsville Bldng J Roof Gal Kliplock 27 Flat no cleaning, 80% WCP pustules, 10% RR 3

Heatley State Townsville Bldng J Ridge Cap Zincalume 27 Black & grey spotting all over 2.5 Heatley State Townsville Bldng J Gutters Stainless Steel Fine 1 Heatley State Townsville Bldng J Downpipes Painted steel 27 Perforated in spots 5 Heatley State Townsville Bldng J Steel Supports Painted steel 27 Surface rust 2

Heatley State Townsville Covered play area Roof CB XRW 1999 8

Top is Dull & Dirty Underneath mechanically damaged, no signs of Corrosion 1.5

Heatley State Townsville Covered play area Roof Fasteners Buildex Painted 8 Look fine 1

Heatley State Townsville Covered play area Other Fasteners Bx gal Some rr around rim of Fastener 2

Heatley State Townsville Covered play area Gutters CB

Fine at bottom, on inside edge small blisters starting 2

Heatley State Townsville Covered play area Downpipes CB

Heatley State Townsville Covered play area Flashings CB Dull, couple of rr spots 2

Heatley State Townsville Covered play area Steel Supports

Galvaspan G92075P11 4.195

Significant mechanical damage, no signs of corrosion, although grain structure obvious 1

Heatley State Townsville Covered play area Steel Supports Uprights Painted gal

Page 38: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

33

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Heatley State Townsville Bldng D Roof Painted Gal 37

Not Maintained, Coating cracked, loss of coating due to Blistering, RR at Perforations, Perforations at sheet joints 5

Heatley State Townsville Bldng D Gutters Painted ZA Totally perforated nearest edge to bldng 5 Heatley State Townsville Bldng D Down pipes Painted steel 37 Perforated red rust 5

Heatley State Townsville Walkways Roof Gal 36 Up to 70% WCP, RR and perforations at depressions 5

Heatley State Townsville Walkways Roof Underside Gal 36 Thin Film WCP on underside 3 Kirwan Sec Townsville ZA shelter Roof ZA 9 Dull & Dirty, RR at sheet join in crevices 2.5

Kirwan Sec Townsville ZA shelter Roof Underside ZA 9 Black spots/pitting on underside up to 20% black 2

Kirwan Sec Townsville ZA shelter Roof Fasteners Buildex class4 Zinc 9 Dull, covered totally with WCP, more heavy on ~15% of area 2

The Willows Townsville Multicovered PlayArea Roof CB 10 Dull & Dirty 1

The Willows State Townsville

Multicovered PlayArea Roof Underside AL Foil & Gal mesh 10 Gal Mesh has WCP and RR 3

The Willows Townsville Multicovered PlayArea Ridge Cap CB 10 Dull & Dirty 1

The Willows Townsville Multicovered PlayArea Roof Fasteners Painted 10 10% Have RR <25% 3

The Willows Townsville Multicovered PlayArea Gutters CB 10

RR on CB hangers, some RR spots(sparse) more regular with leaf coverage 2.5

The Willows Townsville Multicovered PlayArea Down Pipes CB 10 Some damage at bottom edge 2

The Willows Townsville Multicovered PlayArea Steel Supports Painted 10 Good Condition 1

The Willows Townsville Admin Roof CB 8 No damage to top coat except for some chalking 1.5

The Willows Townsville Walkway from Admin Roof Underside CB 8

Significant pin hole red rusting in places (up to 30% damage) Also edge damage up to 3 mm 2.5

The Willows Townsville Admin Roof Fasteners Painted Bx 8 Most have retained paint, some (5-10%) have red rust >50% 3

The Willows Townsville Admin Gutters Exterior CB XRW 8 Good 1

Page 39: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

34

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

The Willows Townsville Admin Gutters Interior CB XRW 8 RR spots in the outside bend, some also on inner edge. 2.5

The Willows Townsville Admin Downpipes Gal 8 up to 60% WCP 3 The Willows Townsville Admin Flashings CB 8 Spots of WCP and RR also chalking 2.5 The Willows Townsville Admin Windows Anodised Al 8 Damage from water cleaning solution 1

The Willows Townsville Walkway from Admin Steel Supports Gal 8 Look ok, grain obvious 1

The Willows Townsville Walkway from Admin Purlins

CB or powder coated steel 8 Paint flaking off at edges, RR at edges 2

The Willows Townsville

Library / resource centre Roof CB 10 West facing 20°, Dull & Dirty 1

The Willows Townsville

Library / resource centre Roof CB 1 West facing 20° 0

The Willows Townsville

Library / resource centre Roof Fasteners Bx 10

third have > 20% RR, some paint damage due to installation 3

The Willows Townsville

Library / resource centre Roof Fasteners B4 1 all good 1

The Willows Townsville

Library / resource centre Gutters CB 10

Dull, loss of shine possible staining underneath on outside, inside red rust spots 2

The Willows Townsville

Library / resource centre Gutters CB 1

shiny on outside, dirty inside no obvious damage 1

The Willows Townsville

Library / resource centre Downpipes CB 10 no obvious damage 1

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Staff room Sheltered area Roof CB 5

10°, moderately maintained, some leaves and sticks, Morning shading, no coating loss, no WCP, Slight RR on cut edge, no perforations 1.5

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Staff room Sheltered area Fasteners Painted Buildex 5

Loss of paint due to mechanical damage, localised WCP where paint lost, sparsely spotted with RR 2

Page 40: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

35

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Staff room Sheltered area Gutters CB double sided 5

no damage except WCP on hangers on sheltered edges 1-5mm 1.5

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Staff room Sheltered area Flashings CB 5

Dull & Dirty some undercutting at cut edges with roof sheeting up to 2mm 2

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Staff room Sheltered area Post holders Gal 5 some WCP at ground level 2

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Admin / staff room Roof Old Al 25

Could not get close but much duller than newer section 1.5

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Admin / staff room Roof Newer Al 16

Textured aluminium sheet, no noticeable pitting, Dull and dirty 1

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Admin / staff room Gutter Al 16 noticeable pitting but no perforations 3

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Admin / staff room Flashings newer Al 16 Flat smooth with noticeable pitting 3

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Walkway junction btn Admin & Under covered area Roof Top Al 25

Textured aluminium sheet, very dirty stained from leaf litter. Pitting not obvious 1.5

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Walkway junction btn Admin & Under covered area Roof Underside Al 25

Btn 25 and 50% large grey spots, with large white pustules in the centre of the larger grey spots, no noticeable perforations 3

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Walkway junction btn Admin & Under covered area Steel Supports Galvanised steel 25 WCP present on <25% 2

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Walkway junction btn Admin & Under covered area Beams Galvanised steel 25

Significant WCP 25-50%, some red rust spots <10% 3

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Walkway junction btn Admin & Under covered area Fasteners Stainless Steel 25 Look fine but are very dirty 1

Page 41: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

36

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Walkway junction btn Admin & Under covered area Gutters Al 25

Textured Al, Outside Side looks good, Outside underneath shows WCP, Outside top edge shows black spot inside the texture and looks pitted, Inside side walls Ok, Inside bottom is very stained and possibly pitted, no noticeable perforations 2.5

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Undercovered area btn B1 & B12 Roof Top Al 17

Textured aluminium sheet, very dirty stained from leaf litter. Pitting not obvious 1.5

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Undercovered area btn B1 & B12 Roof Underside Al 17

Around 25 % grey spots not as big and not as much coverage as Walkways 2.5

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Undercovered area btn B1 & B12 Steel Supports Galvanised steel 17

Slight WCP grain structure pronounced more towards top 1

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Undercovered area btn B1 & B12 Beams Galvanised steel 17

Large Spots of WCP and Some RR Mainly in crevices at connections 3

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Undercovered area btn B1 & B12 Fasteners Stainless Steel 17 Good Condition although dirty and stained 1

Sunshine Beach Sunshine Coast

Undercovered area btn B1 & B12 Flashings newer Al 17 Flat smooth very dirty with some pitting 2.5

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast Student Centre Roof CB 13

North facing, 25°, not maintained, no shading, Dull&Dirty, no WCP or RR, undercutting from cut edge at gutter 1- 10mm 1.5

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast Student Centre Fasteners Painted 13

Some paint damage and Slight WCP where paint damaged, no RR 2

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast Student Centre Gutters CB Double Sided 13

Full of leaf litter and mud, but in good condition 1

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast Student Centre Flashings CB 13 1.5

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast Student Centre Windows Anodised painted 13 Minor damage at cut edge 2

Page 42: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

37

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast Student Centre Air Grills Aluminium Anodised 13 Insignificant corrosion in crevices 2

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast Student Centre Rain Head CB Double Sided 13 Rusted out from inside 5

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast Student Centre Gutter hangers Gal 13 Red rust on cut edges 3

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast Student Centre Down pipes CB 13

Mostly looks good except where it is in Rain head. Here there is `20mm of undercutting from cut edge and red rust 3

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast Student Centre Beams 13

Steel beams on lower roof section have red rust present and upper roof section has significant RR at join btn two beams as well as flaking rust. 4

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast

General studies Roof CB 9

North facing, 10°, mild dust & dirt, some chalking, some blistering and undercutting up to 20mm, reasonably significant at edge at gutter 2.5

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast

General studies Fasteners Painted 9

40% have > 80% RR, spots of RR on all fasteners 3.5

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast

General studies Gutters CB double sided 9

Reasonably clean, dry dirt coverage, minor RR at cut edges including overflow cutouts 2

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast

General studies Windows Anodised 9 Look fine 1

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast

General studies Gutter hangers Gal 9 RR on cut edges 2

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast

General studies Purlins / beams ? Painted gal 9

Bolts have RR, WCP is on purlins in sheltered areas 2.5

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast

General studies Downpipes CB 9

look good except for WCP at pop rivets at join to gutters 1.5

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast

Walkway near General Studies Roof top CB 9

OK in general, Dull& Dirty, no shading, some loss of gloss, Some undercutting at edges <10mm, some blistering 2.5

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast

Walkway near General Studies Roof Underside CB 9

Performing poorly, <25% WCP, RR in places up to 30mm in places 3

Page 43: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

38

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast

Walkway near General Studies Fasteners Painted 9

<20% have >50% RR, all show some RR spots too. 3.5

Sunshine Beach High

Sunshine Coast

Walkway near General Studies Steel supports Painted steel 9

Blistering of paint, 15-20% blistering breaking, worst on sheltered cross members than uprights 2

Coolum High Sunshine Coast

Walkway Btn Bldng F and Amenities Roof top Al 22 Moderate shading, dirty, no WCP 1

Coolum High Sunshine Coast

Walkway Btn Bldng F and Amenities Roof Underside Al 22 15% WCP 2

Coolum High Sunshine Coast

Walkway Btn Amenities and Admin (position 2) Roof Top CB 22

Clean, no shading, significant coating loss on North side up to 50% of top coat 2

Coolum High Sunshine Coast

Walkway Btn Amenities and Admin (position 2) Roof Underside CB 22

Clean and is cleaned once a year, small localised red spots, some WCP within 5mm of edges 2.5

Coolum High Sunshine Coast

Walkway Btn Amenities and Admin (position 2) Roof Fasteners Stainless Steel 22 Some red marks but minimal damage 2

Coolum High Sunshine Coast

Walkway Btn Amenities and Admin (position 2) Gutters CB Galvanised inside 22 These are being replaced since original 5

Coolum High Sunshine Coast

Walkway Btn Amenities and Admin (position 2) Downpipes Inbuilt structural, steel 22

Problematic where water collects at bottom 2

Coolum High Sunshine Coast

Walkway Btn Amenities and Admin (position 2) Steel Supports Painted Steel 22

Reasonable condition, Walkways are washed once a year 2

Coolum High Sunshine Coast Bldng ? Windows Al not anodised 22

No serious problems, some damage at bottom (where water collects) 1.5

Page 44: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

39

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Walkway btn block C and toilets (pos 1) Roof top Gal Kliplock 36 No slope, slight shading, >25% RR 3.5

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Walkway btn block C and toilets (pos 1) Roof Underside Gal Kliplock 36 100% WCP, spots of RR < 1% 3

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Walkway btn block C and toilets (pos 1) Roof Fasteners Gal 36 100% RR 4

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Walkway btn block C and toilets (pos 1) Steel Supports Painted steel 36

Where the uprights go into the concrete red rust, where flat plates are welded on to the bottom they have minimal damage. <5% RR on uprights,<10% RR on x-members where blisters have ruptured 3

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Toilet block south of teaching block 4 (B), east of Block C, (marked Position 2) Roof Zincalume 30

Black staining, not maintained, covered with leaf litter, lots of coating loss 2.5

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Toilet block south of teaching block 4 (B), east of Block C, (marked Position 2) Roof Fasteners Buildex gal 30

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Toilet block south of teaching block 4 (B), east of Block C, (marked Position 2) Gutters Zincalume Painted 30 Definite Blisters of RR 3

Coolum State Sunshine Coast Block B (D) Gutters Al 30 Good condition 1

Page 45: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

40

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Library Block G (I) Position 3 Roof CB 22

Facing East, 10°, not maintained, clean, no shading, no Coating loss, no WCP, No RR, Edges are mostly ok, small amount of damage along longitudinal edge 1

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Library Block G (I) Position 3 Ridge Cap CB 22 Good condition 1

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Library Block G (I) Position 3 Roof Fasteners Painted 22

Mechanical damage, WCP up to 50% only where paint removed, some RR spots 20% 2.5

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Library Block G (I) Position 3 Gutter CB 22 Some dirt 1

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Library Block G (I) Position 3 Downpipes CB 22

Slight edge corrosion on mounting brackets 1

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Walkway East of Block 2 (L) position 4 Roof Top Zincalume 25 no angle, not maintained, No WCP 1

Coolum State Sunshine Coast

Walkway East of Block 2 (L) position 4 Roof Underside Zincalume 25

40% WCP and 10% black CP, some RR where ZNAl nodules have been 3

Pacific Paradise Sunshine Coast

Walkway & Bldngs Roof top CB 15

0°, Dull&Dirty losing gloss, RR spots in localised areas 2

Pacific Paradise Sunshine Coast

Walkway & Bldngs Roof Underside CB 15

1 spot with significant RR at a join under flashing, possibly due to moisture trap 2

Pacific Paradise Sunshine Coast

Walkway & Bldngs Roof Fasteners Coated Marked "F" 15 100% RR all have RR 5

Pacific Paradise Sunshine Coast

Walkway & Bldngs Flashings CB 15

0°, Dull&Dirty losing gloss, RR spots in localised areas 2.5

Pacific Paradise Sunshine Coast

Walkway & Bldngs Gutters CB 15 Clean but some dirt ok 1

Pacific Paradise Sunshine Coast

Walkway & Bldngs Gutter hangers CB 15 Several completely destroyed 5

Pacific Paradise Sunshine Coast

Walkway & Bldngs Downpipes CB 15 Blistering at joins but otherwise ok 2.5

Pacific Paradise Sunshine Coast

Walkway & Bldngs Windows Al anodised lightly 15

Good performance in general except where vegetation has brushed against them 1.5

Page 46: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

41

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Pacific Paradise Sunshine Coast

Walkway & Bldngs Gangnail Plates Painted 15 Significant WCP 3

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast

Walkway btn Block D and Undercover eating area Roof Top Zincalume 21

no angle, WCP on ridges, black spotting and tiny amount of RR 2.5

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast

Walkway btn Block D and Undercover eating area Roof Underside Zincalume 21 50% WCP or grey corrosion product 3

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast

Walkway btn Block D and Undercover eating area Gutters Painted Zincalume 21

Rusted through in places, most of gutter displays RR 5

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast

Walkway btn Block D and Undercover eating area Down Pipes Painted Zincalume 21

Some damage due to impact, paint peeling but otherwise ok some signs of RR inside down pipe 3

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast

Walkway btn Block D and Undercover eating area Steel Supports 21

Some paint peeling, not maintained, no RR 2

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast Block D Windows Al anodised 21

OK in general, Dull& Dirty, on veranda so Sheltered from washing, no WCP present 1

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast Block D Beams 21

Painted beams sheltered by veranda, not cleaned, RR present on edges and has eaten away up to 5mm in parts, but insignificant due to size of beams 2

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast Block D Ventilation frames Steel Painted 21 Dirty, rust in bends 3

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast

Under cover eating area Roof Top Zincalume 10 Dull&dirty, no obvious WCP or RR 1

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast

Under cover eating area Roof Underside Zincalume 10

looks good maybe some wcp or staining along edge of trough 1.5

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast

Under cover eating area Purlins Gal 21

Significant WCP all over (100%), Red rust at joins and edges, 3

Page 47: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

42

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast

Under cover eating area Steel Supports painted steel 21

Dirty, not cleaned, in general look ok, paint intact mostly, where it isn't there is RR present but only surface. On some there is paint loss and RR at base above where embedded into concrete 2

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast Block T Roof Top CB 2

Good condition, still glossy, some dirt collecting in valleys and bldng up at edge of sheet into gutter 0

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast

Block T Walkway Roof Underside CB 2 Good condition a little bit dirty 0

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast Block T Roof Fasteners Painted 2

Some mechanical damage from installation but otherwise good, no WCP 0

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast Block T Gutters CB 2 Dirt and leaves present but no damage 0

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast Block T End Cap CB 2 Good condition 0

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast

Block T and Walkway Steel Supports Gal 2

Steel supports on walkway and veranda in good condition, still shiny and little sign of grain structure 0

Mooloolaba State Sunshine Coast Block T Downpipes Plastic 2

Downpipe are painted plastic and held with stainless brackets, in good condition 0

Mountain Creek High

Sunshine Coast

Admin Bldng and Walkway Roof CB 12 facing NE, clean and no shading, Dull 1

Mountain Creek High

Sunshine Coast

Admin Bldng and Walkway Roof Fasteners Painted 12 Paint has faded 1

Mountain Creek High

Sunshine Coast

Admin Bldng and Walkway Fasteners other Painted non standard 12

Incorrect fasteners used to fix flashings to Walkway almost complete loss of paint and >50% red rust 4

Mountain Creek High

Sunshine Coast

Admin Bldng and Walkway Gutters CB 12 A bit of dirt in gutters and paint is dull 1

Mountain Creek High

Sunshine Coast

Admin Bldng and Walkway

Flashings CB 12

No damage apart from loss of gloss, and possible problems around the non standard fasteners 1.5

Mountain Creek High

Sunshine Coast

Admin Bldng and Walkway Windows Anodised Al 12 No Damage 1

Mountain Creek High

Sunshine Coast

Admin Bldng and Walkway Steel Supports

Painted Galvanised steel 12 No damage, No corrosion visible at base 1

Page 48: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

43

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating Mountain Creek High

Sunshine Coast

Admin Bldng and Walkway Gutter clips CB 12 WCP from edges 2

Mountain Creek High

Sunshine Coast Arts Bldng Roof CB 12 Dull & Dirty 1

Mountain Creek High

Sunshine Coast Arts Bldng Roof Fasteners Painted 12 Significant RR on all fasteners >25% 4

Mountain Creek High

Sunshine Coast Arts Bldng Gutters CB 12 Dirt inside but no leaves, outside is dull 1

Mountain Creek State

Sunshine Coast Admin Bldng Roof CB 15 Very Dull & Dirty 1

Mountain Creek State

Sunshine Coast Admin Bldng Ridge Cap CB 15 Dull & Dirty 1

Mountain Creek State

Sunshine Coast Admin Bldng Gutters

Zincalume Painted outside only 15 look ok, some pitting(grey) <10%, no RR 2

Mountain Creek State

Sunshine Coast Admin Bldng Roof Fasteners Painted Buildex 15 no significant wcp, no RR 1

Mountain Creek State

Sunshine Coast Admin Bldng Windows Aluminium 15

Mountain Creek State

Sunshine Coast Admin Bldng Flashings Zincalume Painted 15 Widespread peeling paint 2

Mountain Creek State

Sunshine Coast

Walkway from Admin Bldng Steel Supports Galvanised steel 15

moderately corroded, Grains obvious, all cemented in at expansion joints and corrosion initiating at these points 2

Mountain Creek State

Sunshine Coast

Walkway from Admin Bldng Beams Galvanised steel 15 In bad way in places red rust present 3

Mountain Creek State

Sunshine Coast

Walkway from Admin Bldng Roof Underside CB 15

no damage except where incorrectly specified screw used and have gone rusty and under cut sheeting 2

Buddina State Sunshine Coast

Covered Area & Walkways Roof Aluminium 28

Heavily pitted top and bottom, 40% grey corrosion product 4

Buddina State Sunshine Coast

Covered Area & Walkways Beams Painted Steel 28

Rusting in places where paint damaged, needs maintenance but is not significant 2

Buddina State Sunshine Coast

Covered Area & Walkways Roof CB 28

Significant RR undercutting from edge sheltered by ridge capping Otherwise ok 3

Buddina State Sunshine Coast

Covered Area & Walkways Roof Fasteners Painted 28 Significant red rust >75% coverage 4

Page 49: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

44

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Buddina State Sunshine Coast

Covered Area & Walkways Gutters Painted Al 28 Paint peeling, 2

Buddina State Sunshine Coast

Covered Area & Walkways Windows Al Anodised 28

Some damage mainly confined to windows directly in line with coast 2.5

Buddina State Sunshine Coast

Covered Area & Walkways Gang Nails Painted 28 Significant Red rust, up to 50% 4

Kenmore State Brisbane

Walkway Senior Toilets to B Block Roof top CB 10

0-5° angle, not maintained some dirt, no shading, no coating loss 1

Kenmore State Brisbane

Walkway Senior Toilets to B Block Roof Underside CB Single sided 10

10% blistering under paint, mechanical damage, WCP up to 30%,some red rust 3

Kenmore State Brisbane

Walkway Senior Toilets to B Block Roof Fasteners Painted 10 some damage, red rust in places 3

Kenmore State Brisbane

Walkway Senior Toilets to B Block Gutters CB Single sided 10

Good in general, some RR spots internal, WCP in corner joins and undercutting up to 5mm 3

Kenmore State Brisbane

Walkway Senior Toilets to B Block Downpipes CB 10 OK 1

Kenmore State Brisbane

Walkway Senior Toilets to B Block Flashings CB Single sided 10

Kenmore State Brisbane

Walkway Senior Toilets to B Block Steel Supports Painted Gal 10 Good Condition in general 1

Kenmore State Brisbane Senior covered area Roof Underside Zincalume

Dirty, 50% black & white corrosion product on underside no visible RR, roof angle 0 2

Kenmore State Brisbane Senior covered area Steel Supports Painted steel

In good condition except for footing, concrete has bad adhesion at base and corrosion present, paint loss and red rust present 2

Kenmore State Brisbane Senior covered area Gang Nails Painted Good condition 1

Kenmore State Brisbane Senior covered area Roof top Zincalume Dull & Dirty, no obvious WCP and no RR 1

Page 50: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

45

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Kenmore State Brisbane

Walkway at Junior Covered area Roof top

Kliplock deck, Painted on top,

Paint wearing, up to 50% loss, Thin even WCP were paint lost. 2

Kenmore State Brisbane

Walkway at Junior Covered area Roof Underside

Kliplock deck, Painted on top, WCP and grey spots covering all 3

Kenmore State Brisbane Junior Covered area Roof top

Galvanised corrugated sheet Painted on top

Paint loss to > 50%, one sheet replace with non painted and large rust spot now present 3

Kenmore State Brisbane Junior Covered area Roof Underside

Galvanised corrugated sheet Painted on top

WCP evenly covered, Heavy WCP and RR at joins extending 10-30mm 4

Kenmore State Brisbane Tuck shop Roof top Zincalume Kliplock Dull & Dirty, No obvious damage 1 Kenmore State Brisbane Bldngs Windows Al 10 Good condition 1

Brookfield State Brisbane

Covered Play Area, End of D Block Roof top CB 6

Not Maintained, Dirty only, No gloss loss or coating loss 0

Brookfield State Brisbane

Covered Play Area, End of D Block Ridge Cap CB 6 Good condition 0

Brookfield State Brisbane

Covered Play Area, End of D Block Roof Fasteners Painted 6

Mechanical damage has deformed but not broken paint, good condition 0

Brookfield State Brisbane

Covered Play Area, End of D Block Gutter CB 6

good condition but there are a few rust spots, EIS done 2

Brookfield State Brisbane N Block Roof CB 6

15°, not maintained, clean, no shading, faded undercutting where dirt collects on edge of roof (5mm) 1.5

Brookfield State Brisbane N Block Roof CB 4

15°, not maintained, clean, no shading, faded undercutting where dirt collects on edge of roof (5mm) 1.5

Brookfield State Brisbane N Block Roof Fasteners Painted 6 Mech damage, light WCP or dulling at damage 1.5

Brookfield State Brisbane N Block Roof Fasteners Painted 4 Mech damage, light WCP or dulling at damage 1.5

Brookfield State Brisbane N Block Gutters CB 6 Blistering and WCP at drip point from roof 2

Page 51: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

46

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating Brookfield State Brisbane N Block Gutters CB 4 Blistering and WCP at drip point from roof 2

Brookfield State Brisbane C Block Walkway Roof top ZA 37

Flat, Not maintained, dirty, Black and Gray CP 10-20%, 1% really black spots 2

Brookfield State Brisbane C Block Walkway Roof Underside ZA 37 Black & Grey CP 50% 2.5

Brookfield State Brisbane C Block Walkway Gutters Painted ZA outside 37 Red rust on hangers, bottom has red rust 3

Brookfield State Brisbane C Block Walkway Flashings Gal 37 Corroded, dull no red rust 2

Brookfield State Brisbane C Block Walkway Steel supports Painted Gal 37

Maintained with thick paint, chipped and flaking in places, some older posts show significant RR, good cementing at base 3

Brookfield State Brisbane C Block Roof CB 37

Flat, dirty, but swept, Paint cracking & susceptible to peeling off in small segments, Paint loss on ridges, no visible WCP, some RR on ridges 3

Brookfield State Brisbane C Block Roof Fasteners Gal 37 All red rust 5 Brookfield State Brisbane C Block Gutters CB Single sided 37 Ok have been changed at some stage 1 Brookfield State Brisbane C Block Windows Al anodised 37 Very few tiny pits, mostly good condition 2

Brookfield State Brisbane C Block Steel supports Painted steel 37

Steel supports on underside of covered walkway show significant red rust. Moisture gets btn steel and cement fibre sheet. 3

Brookfield State Brisbane

Covered are (Shed) south of A block Walkway Roof Painted Gal 37 Pre 1970 50% of paint removed 2

Brookfield State Brisbane

Covered are (Shed) south of A block Roof Gal 27 100% WCP 3

Brookfield State Brisbane

Covered are (Shed) south of A block Gutter Painted ZA 27 Perforated where water collects 5

Page 52: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

47

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Brookfield State Brisbane

Covered are (Shed) south of A block Walkway Gutter Painted Gal 37

100% RR inside (well drained) not perforated due to good drainage 4

Chapel Hill State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Admin & Covered Games Area Roof Top ZA 31

Dull and Dirty <50% black spots, no WCP no RR 2

Chapel Hill State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Admin & Covered Games Area Roof Underside ZA 31 100% WCP, 20% black spots 3

Chapel Hill State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Admin & Covered Games Area Gutter 31

Chapel Hill State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Admin & Covered Games Area Steel Supports Painted steel 31 Good condition 1

Chapel Hill State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Admin & Covered Games Area Roof Fasteners Zinc ? 31 100% RR 5

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Covered Games Area Roof Underside ZA 31 60% WCP, <25% Grey and black spots 3

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Amenities Block Roof top ZA 31

Dull and Dirty, some staining from leaf litter some black spotting <10%, no RR 2

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Amenities Block Gutter Painted ZA 31

Repainted outside a number of times, inside bottom red rust 4

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Amenities Block Roof Fasteners May have been painted 31

some 100% RR, others <25% WCP pustules 4

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Amenities Block Steel Supports Painted steel 31

except for paint flaking in good condition, no Red Rust 2

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Teaching Block 2 Roof ZA 31

Dull & Dirty, some black spotting, no RR or noticeable WCP 1

Page 53: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

48

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Teaching Block 2 Gutter Stainless Steel 7 Good no damage 0

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Teaching Block 2 Ridge Cap ZA 31

Badly pitted lots of Black spotting > 50%, 100% RR under leaf litter 4

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Resource Centre Roof ZA 27

dull but shiny on ridges, no WCP or RR, some dirt 1

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Resource Centre Gutter Stainless Steel 7 No Damage but full of leaves 0

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Resource Centre Ridge cap ZA 27 no damage, only slightly dull 1

Chapel Hill State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Resource & Teaching Block 6 Roof top CB Heavily Stained, no obvious WCP or RR 1

Chapel Hill State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Resource & Teaching Block 6 Roof Underside CB

WCP especially on lower ridge edges, some RR spots 2.5

Chapel Hill State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Resource & Teaching Block 6 Steel Supports Painted steel

Good condition painted many times no Red Rust 1

Chapel Hill State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Resource & Teaching Block 6 Gutter CB

Painted on outside some pitting of paint inside bottom 2

Chapel Hill State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Resource & Teaching Block 6 Roof Fasteners Painted Stained, no obvious WCP or RR 1

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Admin Bldng Roof ZA 31 Dull and some black/grey spotting <25% 2

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Admin Bldng Gutter ZA 31 pitting (black spots) up to 50%, no obvious RR 2.5

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Admin Bldng Roof Fasteners Zinc 31 Dull possible general WCP over all of Fastener, no pustules 2

Chapel Hill State Brisbane Admin Bldng Ridge Cap ZA 31 Black spots and WCP up to 50% 3

Page 54: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

49

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Payne Road State Brisbane Activities Bldng Roof Top CB 9

Very stained, dull & Dirty, staining mainly in trough, lichens growing on roof, Some undercutting at edges where dirt builds up, lichens may be damaging the paint. 2

Payne Road State Brisbane Activities Bldng Roof Lining CB 9

Underneath lined with colorbond sheet. Dull no obvious damage 1

Payne Road State Brisbane Activities Bldng Roof Fasteners Painted 9

BX fasteners, Some mechanical damage no obvious WCP, no RR 1

Payne Road State Brisbane Activities Bldng Ridge Cap CB 9 Same as roof 2

Payne Road State Brisbane Activities Bldng Gutter CB 9

Some undercutting around joins and pop rivets, > 10% coating loss, Gal or ZA hangers some RR 2

Payne Road State Brisbane Activities Bldng Windows Painted Al 9

Some WCP at joins and edges, <1mm of undercutting. Pop rivets WCP 2

Payne Road State Brisbane Activities Bldng Downpipes Plastic 9

Payne Road State Brisbane

Walkway to Activities Bldng Roof top CB 9

Very stained, dull & Dirty, staining mainly in trough, lichens growing on roof, Some undercutting at edges where dirt builds up, lichens may be damaging the paint. 2

Payne Road State Brisbane

Walkway to Activities Bldng Roof Underside CB 9

Paint looks stained which may be the start of some undercutting or blistering 1

Payne Road State Brisbane

Walkway to Activities Bldng Gutter CB 9

Dry and only dirt no leaf litter, no obvious damage inside, some undercutting and RR around some pop rivets 1.5

Payne Road State Brisbane

Walkway to Activities Bldng Steel Supports Painted steel 9

Paint dull but intact, some paint damage but no WCP or RR 2

The Gap High Brisbane Admin Block Gutters Painted Gal 47 Rusted through in places 5

The Gap High Brisbane

Walkway btn Admin and B Block Steel supports Painted Steel 47

Some paint chipped off but no Red rust seen 2

The Gap High Brisbane

Walkway btn Admin and B Block Roof top ZA 47

Dull & Dirty, Leaf litter present near gutters, Pitting and black spots approx 25% 2

Page 55: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

50

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

The Gap High Brisbane

Walkway btn Admin and B Block Roof Underside ZA 47

25% black spotting, Red rust along sheet edges, small WCP pustules 2

The Gap High Brisbane

Walkway btn Admin and B Block Gutters ZA painted outside only 47

Red Rust inside bottom, and up to 50% up side walls, no perforations seen 4

The Gap State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Library and C Block Roof Top CB 27

Flat Dirty& very Dull and Faded, Undercutting at sheet edge at gutter in trough of sheet up to 15mm 2

The Gap State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Library and C Block Roof Underside CB 27

Blistering and WCP and a little RR on Cut edges of joins, some Blistering on sheet 2.5

The Gap State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Library and C Block Roof Fasteners Painted 27

Some mechanical damage from installation, some WCP, colour faded 2

The Gap State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Library and C Block Gutters CB 27

Some small blisters inside no Red Rust, undercutting on outside at joins up to 10mm 2

The Gap State Brisbane

Walkway Btn Library and C Block Steel Supports Painted steel 27 Look ok some paint chips no RR 2

The Gap State Brisbane

Covered area Btn Library, C Block and D Block Roof Top CB 27

Dull & Dirty, curved roof, some leaves and lichens, some undercutting at sheet edge in gutters up to 10mm 2

The Gap State Brisbane

Covered area Btn Library, C Block and D Block Roof Underside CB 27

Some blistering, edge corrosion in places up to 2mm 2

The Gap State Brisbane

Covered area Btn Library, C Block and D Block Roof Fasteners Painted 27 Mechanical damage to most WCP <5% 1.5

The Gap State Brisbane

Covered area Btn Library, C Block and D Block Gutters CB 27

Very dirty full of leaves and water some plants growing, Blistering present some RR on edges 2

Page 56: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

51

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

The Gap State Brisbane

Covered area Btn Library, C Block and D Block

Steel cross members Gal 27

In general good condition except for a couple of places where red rust spots up to 20mm of unknown origin are present under roof 3

The Gap State Brisbane

Covered area Btn Library, C Block and D Block Steel Supports Painted 27

some loss of paint chips, rr at bases with concrete, some rr spots 2

The Gap State Brisbane

Covered area Btn Library, C Block and D Block Downpipes CB 27

CB sheet connected to Steel support RR at bottom 2.5

The Gap State Brisbane Activities covered area Roof Underside ZA 27

Covered with white and grey corrosion product, some black spots 3

The Gap State Brisbane Activities covered area Gang nails Painted 27 Good condition no WCP or RR 1

The Gap State Brisbane

Shade sail in Quadrangle Btn Blocks B, A, and C Steel Supports Painted Gal 17

Paint cracking, no corrosion on uprights, red rust around Welds, some corrosion at joins of heavy structural members 2

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Roof ZA 27

On cleaning still shiny, Flat, some maintenance, clean, slight shading, 10% Black CP, general WCP, 1% RR, some heavy pitting 3

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Gutters ZA 27

Large pits up to 6mm in Dia, leave and dirt present, no obvious RR 2

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Roof Fasteners Gal 27 Buildex, dull, light WCP 2

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Flashings Gal 27

White pustules over top surface (15% of area), black of bottom of pustule 2.5

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Windows Anodised Al 27

Small Black pits (<0.5mm) at base of windows spaced ~4mm apart 3

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Steel Supports Painted Steel 27

Not well maintained, Red Rust showing where paint has been cracking & peeling (most damage is mechanical 3

Page 57: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

52

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Roof ZA 18

On cleaning still shiny, Flat, some maintenance, clean, slight shading, general WCP, some pitting less corroded than 1980's roof on same bldng 2.5

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Gutters ZA 18

Large pits, more leaves than older section and dirt present, 30% RR 3

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Roof Fasteners Gal 18 Buildex, dull, light WCP 2

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Flashings Gal 18

White pustules over top surface (15% of area), black of bottom of pustule 2.5

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Windows Anodised Al 18

Small Black pits (<0.5mm) at base of windows spaced ~4mm apart 3

Hilder Road State Brisbane Teaching Block 3 Steel Supports Painted Steel 18

Not well maintained, Red Rust showing where paint has been cracking & peeling (most damage is mechanical 3

Hilder Road State Brisbane

Walkway from Teaching Block 3 Roof top ZA 27

Dull & Dirty, 10% Heavy Black spotting, <1 % RR 2

Hilder Road State Brisbane

Walkway from Teaching Block 3 Roof Underside ZA 27 >50% WCP, >10% Black CP 3

Hilder Road State Brisbane

Walkway from Teaching Block 3 Gutters ZA painted outside only 27

100% White and Black CP, no obvious RR except at joins where there is RR and significant (>10mm) undercutting. 3

Hilder Road State Brisbane

Walkway from Teaching Block 3 Flashings Gal 27 Thin film of WCP, no obvious RR 2

Hilder Road State Brisbane

Walkway from Teaching Block 3 to Amenities 2 Roof Underside ZA 27 >50% WCP, <10% Black CP 3

Hilder Road State Brisbane

Walkway from Teaching Block 3 to Amenities 2 Gutters ZA painted outside only 27 100% RR inside bottom, and 25% of wall 4

Hilder Road State Brisbane Covered Play Area 1 Roof Underside ZA 27 approx. 50% WCP, <25% Black CP 3

Page 58: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

53

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Hilder Road State Brisbane Covered Play Area 1 Gang nails Painted 27 Good condition no WCP or RR 1

Blackburn PS Blackburn Prep Bldng Roof top CB 15

10% coating loss, Dull & Dirty, Chalking, no cut edge corrosion, Some pin pricks which may be corrosion, more damage in valleys at edge of sheet 2

Blackburn PS Blackburn Prep Bldng Roof Fasteners Painted 15 some paint loss, some WCP 1.5 Blackburn PS Blackburn Prep Bldng Ridge Cap CB 15 Very dull & dirty 1

Blackburn PS Blackburn Prep Bldng Gutters CB 15 some maintenance, Faded Dull, similar condition to roof 1.5

Blackburn PS Blackburn Prep Bldng Downpipes ZA painted outside only 15 Extensive RR around joint to gutter, wrong insert? 2

Blackburn PS Blackburn Veranda on Admin Bldng Roof ZA 8

Some cut edge corrosion btn sheets, Condensation marks 2

Blackburn PS Blackburn Admin Bldng Roof CB 8 Very dull & dirty 1 Blackburn PS Blackburn Admin Bldng Ridge Cap CB 8 signs of cut edge corrosion 1.5 Blackburn PS Blackburn Admin Bldng Roof Fasteners Painted 8 no rr 1 Blackburn PS Blackburn Admin Bldng Fasteners other metal 8 on ridge cap, wrong fasteners?, RR 4 Blackburn PS Blackburn Admin Bldng Gutters CB 8 Corrosion around join to downpipe 2 Blackburn PS Blackburn Admin Bldng Steel supports painted 8 RR where paint is chipped from surface 2

Blackburn PS Blackburn Walkway north of Library Roof Top ZA 15

WCPspots<10%, Valleys dirt, ridges clean, not pitted very dull 2

Blackburn PS Blackburn Walkway north of Library Roof Underside ZA 15

RR at panel joins, no RR in middle of sheets, corrosion spots 2

Blackburn PS Blackburn Walkway north of Library Gutter Gal 15

Btn walkway and next roof, 100% RR in bottom 4

Blackburn PS Blackburn Walkway north of Library Roof Fasteners Gal 15 70% have RR 3

Blackburn PS Blackburn Walkway north of Library Flashing Gal 15 covered in light WCP no RR 2.5

Blackburn PS Blackburn Computer Centre Roof Top ZA 15 Dull maybe light CP 1.5

Blackburn PS Blackburn Computer Centre Roof Fasteners Gal 15 70% of Fasteners 100% RR 3.5

Page 59: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

54

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Blackburn PS Blackburn Computer Centre Ridge Cap ZA 15 Shiny 1

Blackburn PS Blackburn Library Roof ZA 8 Bright Shiny 0.5 Blackburn PS Blackburn Library Gutters CB 8 Clean no corrosion 0 Blackburn PS Blackburn Library Roof Fasteners Gal 8 New looking 0 Blackburn PS Blackburn Arts Bldng Roof ZA 15 Very Dull Kliplock 1.5 Blackburn PS Blackburn Arts Bldng Gutters ZA 15 looks new 1 Blackburn Lake Primary Blackburn Main Bldng Roof CB 5

Corrugated, Dull & Dirty, no obvious WCP, but blistering on edges at gutter 1.5

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Main Bldng Gutter CB 5

Good condition some dirt but maintained, cut edge corrosion on gutter hangers and pop rivets have WCP & RR 2

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Main Bldng Downpipes CB 5 good, (except pop rivets 100% RR) 1.5 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Main Bldng Downpipes ZA 5 ZA insert into gutter corroding 1.5 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Main Bldng Flashings CB 5

Corrugated, Dull & Dirty, no obvious WCP, but blistering on edges at gutter 1.5

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Main Bldng Windows Powdercoated Al 5 Good condition 1

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn

Walkway Main Bldng Roof CB 5

Kliplock, <5°, Kliplock, not very dull, Blistering of paint, some deterioration, some WCP in blisters 1.5

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn

Walkway Main Bldng Gutter CB 5 Good 1

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Block B Roof Gal 12 Flat Kliplock Gal, some WCP, <1%RR 2 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Block A Roof CB 12

20-30°, not much debris, no edge corrosion, dull 1

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Block A Roof Fasteners Painted 12

some mechanical damage, light WCP where no paint, no RR 1.5

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Block A Gutters CB 12 OK just dirty but cleaned 1 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Block A Downpipes CB 12

some undercutting, on bent edges and top surface, rivets RR 2

Page 60: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

55

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Block A Windows Powdercoated Al 12 Good condition 1 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn

Walkway West of Block A Roof Gal 12 Kliplock, <5% RR, WCP all over 3

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn

Walkway West of Block A Flashing Gal 12 100% WCP, painted on external side 3

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn

Walkway West of Block A Steel supports Painted 12 OK 1

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn

Walkway West of Block A Downpipes Gal painted 12 OK 1

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Art Room Roof Gal 20

Kliplock, 35°, WCP all over, <5% RR,South and west side 3

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Art Room Ridge Cap gal 20 Some RR, North side worst 3 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Art Room Gutters ZA painted outside only 20 100% Red rust in bottom 4 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Art Room Roof ZA 20

Flat water ponding, good condition still shiny 0

Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Art Room Downpipes ZA 20 corrosion around base 1.5 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Art Room Gutters CB 20 RR spots on inside side walls 2 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Shelter Shed Roof Gal 25 10-15°, WCP all over, <5% RR 3 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Shelter Shed Flashings Gal 25 70-80% RR 4 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Shelter Shed Gutter Gal painted 25 RR inside 50% 3.5 Blackburn Lake PS Blackburn Shelter Shed Downpipes Gal painted 25 RR around joints 3

Box Hill North PS Blackburn

North Wing Porch next to Library Roof Gal 12

south facing, 20-30°, corrugated, general WCP, no RR on roof 2

Box Hill North PS Blackburn

North Wing Porch next to Library Roof Fasteners Gal 12 50% of fasteners have 100% rr, 4

Page 61: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

56

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Box Hill North PS Blackburn

North Wing Porch next to Library Gutters Gal painted 12 no RR 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn

North Wing Porch next to Library Downpipes Gal painted 12 Good 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn North Wing GPC75 Roof Gal 12 WCP 2.5

Box Hill North PS Blackburn North Wing GPC75 Roof Gal 51 Heavy WCP, 20% RR 3.5

Box Hill North PS Blackburn North Wing GPC75 Gutters Gal painted 12 Not maintained, full of water 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn North Wing GPC75 Roof Fasteners Gal 12 ok look new 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn North Wing GPC75 Steel Supports Painted ? 12 ok 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn North Wing GPC75 Downpipes Painted 12 Cut bends 2

Box Hill North PS Blackburn North Wing GPC75 Windows AL 12 OK 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn North Wing GPC72 Roof ZA 12 Very dull & dirty, slightly grey, grey CP 2

Box Hill North PS Blackburn North Wing GPC72 Roof Fasteners Gal 12 Some WCP 1.5

Box Hill North PS Blackburn North Wing GPC72 Flashings CB 12 Some mechanical damage but OK 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn

Newer Bldng on West end of North Wing Roof ZA 3

Tree over hang, Dull & Dirty, some loss of ZN, No WCP or RR 1.5

Box Hill North PS Blackburn

Newer Bldng on West end of North Wing Gutters ZA 3 full of debris, WCP on some hangers 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn

Newer Bldng on West end of North Wing Roof Fasteners Gal 3 Ok no WCP 0

Page 62: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

57

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Box Hill North PS Blackburn

Newer Bldng on West end of North Wing Flashings CB 3 dirty no visible problems 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn

Newer Bldng on West end of North Wing Gang nails ? 3 Shiny 0

Box Hill North PS Blackburn Gym Roof ZA 5 Very dull & dirty, black corrosion spots, 20°, no edge corrosion 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn Gym gutters CB 5 dirty not clean, no corrosion visible, outside ok but scratched 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn Gym Windows AL 5 dirty but ok 1

Box Hill North PS Blackburn Gym foyer Roof Gal 5 kliplock, <5°, WCP where covered, no RR, clean of debris 1.5

Box Hill North PS Blackburn Gym foyer Steel Supports Painted 5 Good 1 Box Hill North PS Blackburn Block A Roof Gal 12 General WCP 2.5 Box Hill North PS Blackburn Block A Ridge Cap Gal 12 Red Rust 4

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Toilet Block East end of Main Bldng Roof Gal

<5°, kliplock, not maintained, but is clean, no obvious WCP but Red Rust on ridges ~50% RR 3

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Toilet Block East end of Main Bldng Gutters CB 8

Not Maintained or clean, External some loss of gloss, inside looks good. 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Toilet Block East end of Main Bldng Downpipes CB 8

a little cut edge corrosion, silicon is weathering, rivets are good. 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Toilet Block East end of Main Bldng Flashings Gal South and SW, <50% RR 3

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Toilet Block East end of Main Bldng Windows Powdercoated Al 0 Good 0

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Music Bldng East of Main Bldng Roof ZA

Not Maintained, ridges clean, valleys very dirty, some debris, very dull & Dirty, some coating loss, small RR spots 2

Page 63: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

58

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Music Bldng East of Main Bldng Roof Fasteners Gal No RR, some WCP ~25% 2

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Music Bldng East of Main Bldng Gutters CB

Exterior repainted, not maintained, very full of leaf litter and wet, looks ok 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Music Bldng East of Main Bldng Downpipes PVC

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Music Bldng East of Main Bldng Flashings ZA Dirty, no RR same as roof. 2

Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Roof CB 3 kliplock, <5°, not maintained, south facing, looks ok 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Gutters CB 3 Not Maintained, not clean, no corrosion 1 Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Downpipes CB 3 cut edge corrosion lots, WCP on brackets 2 Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Flashings CB 3 OK, no cut edge corrosion 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Veranda Roof CB 3

Not maintained or clean, troughs have lots of dirt, roof ok 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Veranda Roof Fasteners Gal & some Painted 3 <1% WCP 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Veranda Gutters CB 3 Very dirty, faded interior ok 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Veranda Flashings CB 3 Ok 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Veranda Strapping Gal 3 some WCP 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Veranda sarking wires Steel 3 some corrosion 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Veranda Gang nails Gal 3 no corrosion 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Veranda Steel supports Gal 3 no corrosion 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Canteen Veranda Downpipes CB 3 ok 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn room 9 & 10 Roof CB 3 not maintained not clean, some dulling 1

Page 64: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

59

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating Laburnum PS Blackburn room 9 & 10 Roof Fasteners Painted 3 no corrosion 0 Laburnum PS Blackburn room 9 & 10 gutters CB 3 ok 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn room 9 & 10 Downpipes CB 3 cut edge corrosion mainly at elbow and join 2

Laburnum PS Blackburn room 9 & 10 Downpipes ZA 3 Insert into gutter and down pipe 1 Laburnum PS Blackburn room 9 & 10 Capping CB 3 Some undercutting 1 Laburnum PS Blackburn room 9 & 10 Windows Powdercoated Al 3 very dirty but ok 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Walkway Btn main bldngs Roof CB 7

not maintained, no corrosion, no cut edge corrosion, not too dirty. 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Walkway Btn main bldngs Roof Fasteners Painted 7 Mechanical damage, no WCP or RR 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn Walkway Btn main bldngs Steel supports Gal 7 Dull but ok 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn North side of Main bldng Roof ZA 10

Dull & Dirty, some Zn loss, small amount of WCP, no cut edge corrosion 2

Laburnum PS Blackburn North side of Main bldng Roof Fasteners painted 10

most paint gone (25% left), one fastener 50% RR(50%WCP), rest none but some WCP 3

Laburnum PS Blackburn North side of Main bldng Ridge Cap ZA 10

Dull & Dirty, some Zn loss, small amount of WCP, no cut edge corrosion 2

Laburnum PS Blackburn North side of Main bldng Flashing ZA 10

Dull & Dirty, some Zn loss, small amount of WCP, no cut edge corrosion 2

Laburnum PS Blackburn North side of Main bldng Gutter ZA painted outside only 10

no RR on inside but Black spotting(Zn loss) outside ok 1.5

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Veradah on north of Main Bldng Roof Gal 100% WCP, 25% RR, flat 3

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Veradah on north of Main Bldng Flashing ZA No RR 1

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Veradah on north of Main Bldng Gutter ZA painted outside only

Dirty, losing Zn ie Black spots, pitting obvious inside 2

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Veradah on north of Main Bldng Downpipes Painted ZA paint blistering, RR at sheltered joint. 3

Page 65: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

60

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Laburnum PS Blackburn

Music Room West end of Mani bldng Gangnail Plates Gal 10

Grain structure pronounced, sub floor, bldng moved 1997 and sub floor structure built 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Admin Bldng Roof CB 15

45-50°, maintained, not clean, very dull, 20% paint coating loss, no RR, White discolouration near edge of sheets, thinner paint at edges top coat loss. 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Admin Bldng Ridge caps CB 15 ok 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Admin Bldng Roof Fasteners Painted 15

20% have significant RR, SE corner all fasteners have RR 3

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Admin Bldng Gutters CB 15

Cut edge corrosion at joins, RR on edge where water drips, inside and out ok 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Admin Bldng Gutter Hangers Gal 15 WCP on gal hangers 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Admin Bldng Downpipes CB 15

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Admin Bldng Gang nails Painted 15

Painted generally ok but south facing ones were rusting 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Admin Bldng Windows Powdercoated Al 15

Some paint blistering, on south facing, but not a great deal. 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads

Admin Bldng West side Roof CB 15

45-50°, maintained, not clean, very dull, 20% paint coating loss, no RR, White discolouration near edge of sheets, thinner paint at edges top coat loss. Some undercutting around fasteners 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads

Admin Bldng West side Roof Fasteners Painted 15

all WCP,10% have 50% RR, 20% have some RR 3

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads

Admin Bldng West side Gutters CB 15

Inside OK, WCP on exterior, RR on Rain head 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SE Roof CB 7 OK 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SE Roof Fasteners Painted 7 Some RR on mechanical damage 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SE Gutters CB 7

Some blistering due to corrosion of gal hangers 2

Page 66: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

61

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SE Gutter Hangers Gal 7 WCP 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SE Downpipes CB 7 WCP at edges of joins, rivets ok 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SE Windows Powdercoated Al 7 good 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SE Door Hinges Stainless Steel 7 Tea Staining 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SW Roof CB 7 Ok 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SW Roof Fasteners painted 7 some paint loss, WCP, no RR 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SW Gutters CB 7 OK, some corrosion on Gal hangers 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SW Downpipes CB 7 Edge corrosion on joins 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SW Windows Powdercoated Al 7 ok 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 1 SW Lintel Painted 7 Some corrosion

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 3 South Roof CB 20

dull & Dirty, undercutting around fasteners, no blistering 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 3 South Roof Fasteners Painted 20 all 100% RR 5

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 3 South Ridge Cap CB 20

dull & Dirty, undercutting around fasteners, no blistering 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 3 South Gutters CB 20 ok except for joins 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 3 South Gutter Hangers Gal 20

WCP all over RR where water drips on to hangers 2.5

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads

Bldng 3 East, West and North Roof CB 20

dull & Dirty, undercutting around fasteners, no blistering 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads

Bldng 3 East, West and North Roof Fasteners Painted 20 most 100% red rust but some only 85% 5

Page 67: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

62

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads

Bldng 3 East, West and North Ridge Cap CB 20

dull & Dirty, undercutting around fasteners, no blistering 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads

Bldng 3 East, West and North Gutters CB 20 ok except for joins 2

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads

Bldng 3 East, West and North Gutter Hangers Gal 20

WCP all over RR where water drips on to hangers 2.5

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads

Walkway outside Bldng 3 Steel Supports Gal 7

ok on beams some WCP and cut edge corrosion 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads

Walkway outside Bldng 3 Roof CB 7 ok 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 13 S Roof CB 2 Dirty but not dull 0

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 13 S Ridge cap CB 2 Looks ok 0

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 13 S Flashing CB 2 A bit dirty 0

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 13 S Gutters CB 2 Fine 0

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 13 S Windows Al 2 Not painted look fine 0

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 13 S Downpipes CB 2 Cut edge corrosion especially on brackets 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 13 S Roof Fasteners Painted 2 no undercutting, no WCP, look good 0

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 2 Roof ZA

Dull & Dirty, some ZN loss, ie grey CP, no WCP or RR 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 2 Gutter ZA Box gutter, some coating loss 1

Barwon Heads PS

Barwon Heads Bldng 2 Downpipes ZA painted outside only OK 1

Torquay PS Torquay Walkways Roof CB 6 Dirty not very dull 1

Page 68: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

63

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating

Torquay PS Torquay Walkways Roof Fasteners Painted 6 Paint loss, some WCP and red rust spotting, shanks also show red rust 2.5

Torquay PS Torquay Walkways Gutters CB 6 Look ok, dull and dirty but clean 1

Torquay PS Torquay Walkways beams Gal 6 Circular beams red rust at all weld joints, WCP up to 50% on rest 3.5

Torquay PS Torquay Walkways Steel Supports Gal 6

WCP generally on sheltered areas, exposed area are clean and grain structure is noticeable 2

Torquay PS Torquay D Block Roof Fasteners Painted 6 Shanks of some fasteners are corroded through, all red rust, heads not seen 5

Torquay PS Torquay D Block Beams Gal 6

Sheltered areas have WCP and Red Rust in areas, some large areas of Red rust, beams are exposed but sheltered 3.5

Torquay PS Torquay D Block Roof Underside CB 6 Dull & Dirty some red rust blisters 3 Torquay PS Torquay D Block Windows Powdercoated Al 6 WCP at most joints 2

Torquay PS Torquay D Block Downpipes ZA 6 Loss of coating in sheltered areas, WCP at joints 2.5

Torquay PS Torquay D Block Door Hinges Stainless Steel 6 1 in 4 screws have red rust, generally dull& dirty 2

Torquay PS Torquay A Block North Downpipes ZA 6

WCP at top and joins, under eaves significant corrosion on top of bends and at joins 2.5

Torquay PS Torquay A Block North Roof Underside CB 6 Wave shaped roof, some WCP, some <10% undercutting 2

Torquay PS Torquay A Block North Roof Top CB 6 Wave shaped roof, Dull & Dirty 1 Torquay PS Torquay A Block North Windows Powdercoated Al 6 WCP at joins, undercutting up to ~2mm 2

Torquay PS Torquay A Block North Roof Fasteners Painted 6 Some loss of paint and WCP, no RR, Underside of fasteners show WCP 2

Torquay PS Torquay A Block North Flashing CB 6 Wave shaped roof, Dull & Dirty, some cut edge corrosion 1.5

Torquay PS Torquay A Block North Beams Gal 6 Some light WCP and Red Rust spots, few mm in diameter, 3

Torquay PS Torquay A Block North Gutters CB 6 Dull & Dirty 1 Torquay PS Torquay A Block South Roof Top CB 6 Dull & Dirty only 1 Torquay PS Torquay A Block South Roof Underside CB 6 Undercutting at fasteners 2

Page 69: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

64

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating Torquay PS Torquay A Block South Roof Fasteners Painted 6 WCP and red rust spots 2

Torquay PS Torquay A Block South Downpipes ZA 6

Significant loss of coating, on sheltered areas, areas that are sheltered and liable for deposition have ~25% black CP 2

Torquay PS Torquay A Block South Gutters CB 6 Hangers have significant RR, dull & dirty 1

Lorne Lorne Bldng 8 Roof Gal painted 20 Could be Gal CB, Dull & Dirty, some paint lifted 1

Lorne Lorne Bldng 8 Roof Fasteners Gal nails 20 WCP no RR 2 Lorne Lorne Bldng 8 Downpipes Painted gal 20 Perforated 5 Lorne Lorne Bldng 8 Gutters Painted Gal 20 Perforated 5

Lorne Lorne Bldng 9 Roof Gal 20

not maintained, clean, no shading, heavy WCP, red rust under eaves, some perforations 5

Lorne Lorne Bldng 9 Roof Fasteners gal 20 general wcp no RR 2.5 Lorne Lorne Bldng 9 Gutter gal 20 Perforated 5

Lorne Lorne Bldng 5 Roof CB 10 Dull & Dirty, slight coating loss, no WCP, no RR 1

Lorne Lorne Bldng 5 Gutters CB 10 Dull & Dirty, slight coating loss, no WCP, no RR 1.5

Lorne Lorne Bldng 5 Downpipes ZA painted outside only 10 Some blistering, cut edge WCP 2 Lorne Lorne Bldng 1 Roof CB 10 Dull & Dirty only 1 Lorne Lorne Bldng 1 Ridge Cap CB 10 Flat Dull & Dirty only 1

Lorne Lorne Bldng 1 Roof Fasteners Painted BX 10 Flat, 25% coating loss, WCP where paint lost 2

Lorne Lorne Bldng 1 Roof Fasteners Gal 10 10% have 100% RR other have spots 3 Lorne Lorne Bldng 1 Windows Powdercoated Al 10 Slight Blistering 2 Lorne Lorne Walkways Roof CB 10 Not maintained but clean, Dull& Dirty 1

Lorne Lorne Walkways Downpipes Painted Heavy section Gal 10 Some WCP coming through paint 2

Lorne Lorne Walkways Steel supports Painted steel 10 good 1

Lorne Lorne Original Bldng Roof Gal 20 100% Wcp, some RR spots, RR near Ridge Cap 3.5

Lorne Lorne Original Bldng Ridge Cap Gal 20 WCP 3

Page 70: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary

65

School Zone Building Component Type Age Condition Rating Lorne Lorne Original Bldng Roof Fasteners Nails 20 Red Rust 4 Lorne Lorne Original Bldng Gutters Painted Gal 20 RR outside Perforations 5 Lorne Lorne Original Bldng Downpipes Gal 20 RR at top and bottom 3 Lorne Lorne Original Bldng Windows Powdercoated Al 20 Slight Blistering at joins 1 Anglesea PS Anglesea Main Bldng Roof Gal 35 Even WCP 2.5 Anglesea PS Anglesea Main Bldng Gutters CB 15 Undercutting at joints, and RR at Joints 2 Anglesea PS Anglesea Main Bldng Downpipes CB 15 WCP, RR and perforations 5 Anglesea PS Anglesea Main Bldng Flashings Gal 15 even WCP, no RR 2.5 Anglesea PS Anglesea Main Bldng Steel Supports Gal 15 2

Page 71: 2005-003-B-08 School Survey Report · Melbourne (Blackburn) 4717 Box Hill North Primary School 1955 Elizabeth St Box Hill North 3129 145.1228 -37.8003 16-70* 2923 Blackburn Primary